disliked by godly and learned men so the generall given for direction in such cases be observed 3 We hold it unlawfull outwardly and but in appearance to joyne with Idolaters in their Idolatry Many words in this matter might well bee spared But wee desire to see your commandement why for every particular act that in a large sense is Idolatrous adjoyned to the true worship of God Calfeb against Mar. art 10. p. 185 186. we should forbeare our presence at the worship it selfe or be said to communicate in the sinne there committed For then no man might present himselfe with good conscience at any publike worship of GOD wherein any thing is done amisse for matter or manner which is in effect to say hee cannot bee present at any at all 4 To communicate in the ordinances of God with the Ministers of the Church of England is not to like approve or reverence the institutions of men in the exercises of religion nor to communicate with the Teacher in his sin nor in ought else that is amisse For the worship is of God both for matter and manner And put case the Minister bee disorderly chosen enter not as he ought be Symoniacall covetous froward corrupt idle scandalous doe the people partake in his sin in that they make use of his Ministery No Scripture teacheth any such thing no reason doth confirm it noe approved authors ever said it That which you alledge for proofe falleth utterly short It appertaineth to the vertue of truth Dav. determ 7. p. 40. that as a man sheweth himselfe by externall signes so he is indeed to be esteemed And such as frequent or repair unto unlawfull assemblies for the publike worship of God by their being there are to be reputed of the same religion or else dissemblers as it were to have no care of religion knowing God Dovvay annot in 4. King 5.19 p. 778. but not glorifying him as God But herein you have misrelated the Doway translators for their words are But in a Christian countrey where all beare the name of Christians especially where men are at controversie about the true Christian Religion all that frequent or repaire unto the same assemblies for publike service of God are to be reputed of the same religion or else dissemblers Bodily presence at false worship by which they shew a liking unto it is unlawfull To eate of meates sacrificed unto Idols in the Idoll Temple Your condemning the worship of God performed in our assemblies as pernicious idolatry vvherein is it a lesser sinne han the Popes prohibition of publike prayer and restraint of the Word and Sacraments throughout the Realm you can neither shevv us warrant for it an the Scriptures nor example of it in the Church of God You that so teach and censure stand guiltie of great impietie and they that hearken unto your persvvasions are partakers of your iniquity in some sort of the vvrong imaginations of Christians Aug. in Tract â—o 19. saith Quae omnia idola cordis sunt T. Caepl 1. art 3. pag. 4. is to communicate with Idolaters These things are evident and freely granted But the Assemblie met to call upon God in the mediation of Jesus Christ alone to heare the doctrine of salvation soundly and purely preached to receive the Sacrament rightly administred is not a false idolatrous assemblie they that repaire unto it be not Idolatrous â—â—false worshippers If you esteem of them as they shew themselves by out ward signes you must esteem them to be of the true religion and the true worshippers of God according to his will The ministerie in that assembly to be true sound and faithfull and of God of substance In this lieth the point of the controversie which you are contented to passe by in silence without any proofe at all But if any humane frailtie or infirmitie cleave to the ministerie or congregation in respect of doctrine manners lawes government or order which concernes not the life and soul but only the safety of the Church or wellfare of Religion In these a Christian doth not partake by his presence at the ordinances as the Scripture reason and the approved practice of the Saints in all ages of the Church do plentifully witnesse This is the judgement and practice of the Nonconformists and therefore they professe they praise God for this reformation so farre forth as it is agreeable to the Word of God they are glad the Word of God is preached that the Sacraments are administred that which is wanting they desire to be added that which is overmuch cut off But that a Christian must separate from the Word and Sacrament by reason of some superfluities or defects is no responsive conclusion that can be gathered soundly from their writings CAN Stay Sect. 5. pag. 66. In preaching of the truths of the Gospell by a false Minister an Idolatrous act is performed For Divine worship is not to be determined by a particular thing howbeit in it selfe good but as the essentiall parts belonging thereto whether they are persons or things are kept and observed The Church of Rome in Baptisme useth water and in the Sacrament of the Lords Supper gives bread and wine otherwhile too doth this cleare their administrations of Idolatry I think all men doe thinke that Vzziah committed an Idolatrous act 2 Chron. 26.16 when he invaded the Priests office But what made it so tooke he unlawfull incense no. Vsed he strange fire no. Offered hee prohibited Sacrifice or upon a wrong Altar No Where then lay the fault the Scripture telleth us Verse 18. it pertained not to him to burne incense unto the Lord but to the sons of Aaron To apply this if his act were Idolatrous because he wanted a calling howbeit observed many truths of the law By the same reason the Church acts of Artichristian Ministers are Idolatrous yea and as for the truths which they preach this cleares their acts no more from Idolatry than Vzziahs true Incense and the Altar quitted him from transgression ANSWER Your great words are of small force CAN. Stag. §. 3. p. 56. for should I speake my conscience it is your phrase They are words without weight of reason For still you presuppose the Ministerie of the Church of England to bee false and idolatrous which is to beg not to conclude the question But that being presupposed let us see how you goe forward In preaching the truth of the Gospell by a false Minister an Idolatrous act is performed you say But doth the Scripture say so Do you read it in the Law or in the Prophets in the Apostles or in the Evangelists The Scribes and Pharisees were false Ministers but it was not an Idolatrous worke in them to expound the Law of Moses or dispence other Church ordinances at that time commanded The popish Priests and Bishops are false Prophets but the simple administration of Baptisme by them is not an idolatrous act The Minister that is prophane and
is bound to separate from that societie wherewith he is not permitted to hold communion in the worship of God without sinne and that a man cannot hold communion with the Church of England in the worship of God without sinne The first of these propositions is most true taught in Scripture which forbiddeth q Rom. 3.7 8. to doe evill that good may come thereof or r Iob 13.9 tell a lie for the glory of God and acknowledged by the learned of all sorts and professions whatsoever If the Church shall deny communion to any member because he will not approve the least sinne or acknowledge the least knowne errour for truth in that case the Church is schismaticall which doth cast out such a member and not the member which doth suffer himselfe injuriously to be cast out For God needs not my lie and by divine precept I am obliged not to allow against conscience what the Lord condemneth You need not therefore take such paines as you doe to prove the corruptions in our Booke of publique service to be so many in number or hainous in quality as you would make the world beleeve much lesse to straine your conscience in misreporting as you have done For if you can shew that by communicating in the ordinances of worship in that or any other societie or Church under Heaven we necessarily partake in sinne of what sort soever great or small either approving what is unlawfull or subscribing to an errour knowne so to be it will easily be granted that it is unlawfull to joyne in that communitie Be the s The good Kings of Judah were favoured and blessed of God for walking in the waies of David their Father and purging the Land from all sacrifices and ceremonies not prescribed by Moses Law Bils Christ subject part 1. p. 32. But if the Princes were remisse the people were not commanded to separate from the ordinances of worship corruptions few or many great or small if by communicating in the ordinances of grace in that societie I must necessarily partake in sinne small or great one or many my communicating is unwarrantable And let the abuses be many and great yet if I may be present at the true worship of God without sinne consent unto or approbation of such abuses or corruptions in voluntary separation I sinne against God his Church and mine owne soule withdrawing my selfe from the ordinances of grace the comfortable presence of Christ and the societie of his Saints without allowance or approbation from God to whom I owe my selfe wholly Your long Catalogue of corruptions to be found in our Liturgie is to small purpose unlesse you could prove some of them to be fundamentall hereticall and really idolatrous which you can never doe or that by communicating in the ordinances of grace we doe t Be the abuses never so palpable if the person be not authorized of God to reforme them or separate it is not Just or lawfull for private persons to attempt them For when Malefactors deserve to die it is not for private men to put them to death without the Magistrate Bilson Christ subject part 3. pa. 97. David committed adultery Salomon erected idolatry both offences being death by Gods law might the people therefore have David and Salomon to death approve such corruptions and then be they one or many great or small wee must not communicate in the ordinances with them Which if any man shall lightly beleeve he may know from whom but not whither to flie For there will be found no societie in the whole world whereunto a Christian might lawfully joyne himselfe and yours much lesse than many others You tell us very confidently that as zealous and judicious Nonconformists as ever held that cause affirme that a man cannot without sinne communicate in that worship where the Ceremonies are used But whether should a man admire more your impudency or vaine confidence herein Must not he mistrust you in every thing that shall consider how notoriously you lavish in this particular Is it not contrary to their profession protestation and practice Doe they not usually frequent the Congregations have they not written in maintenance and defence thereof who have cryed downe by conference preaching writing the neglect of Gods ordinances or the practice of separation more than they And yet you blush not to write that our Assumption is assented unto by as judicious and zealous Nonconformists as ever held that cause and they have brought good reasons for it First You quote Mr u Parker lib. 1. pag. 20 21. Parker That men must flie from Idols and Idolothites but men when they come to worship God in societies where the Ceremonies are used they doe not flie from Idols but draw neere unto them But if a man should have sought out a place of purpose to manifest your fraudulent and unconscionable alledging of mens words and sayings he could scarce have found a second more pregnant The whole passage in Mr Parker to which you send us I will set downe at large because it serves to cleere the matter in many particulars and all men may take the better notice of your fidelitie There is an Idoll more strictly taken saith he and an Idoll of larger sence which will include the Crosse For the better understanding whereof wee must borrow a distinction from the w Tho. Aqui. com in Epist ad Coloss c. 1. sect 4. Schoolmen by which a thing may be guilty of Idolatry Essentialiter participative and causaliter which our doctrine at * Hom. of Idolat par 1. pag. 4 5. home doth backe that is confirmed by act of Parliament affirming that to be an Idoll in Gods service which hath beene or is like to be worshipped What is worshipped by our selves that is an Idoll essentially what hath been worshipped or is now worshipped abroad by others that is an Idoll by participation what is likely to be worshipped that is an x August vet Testam qu. lib. 7. qu. 41. Idoll causing Idolatry in time to come In which sense Gideons Ephod may be termed an Idoll quedam modo and that it may be even before it was adored And hereby are many objections answered Our y Rainold de Idol lib. 2. â—ap 2. sect 2. Bilson Christ subject part 4. p. 321. Call you the Image of Christ an Idoll not unlesse it be worshipped but if it be then it is an Idoll and incense burnt unto it is Idolatrie Writers deny an Image in the Church say some to be an Idoll in case it be not worshipped True an Idoll essentially but as many of them as desire to have Images thrust out of the Church of which sort there be a great number they hold them guilty of Idolatry by participation and by occasioning or els why will they thrust them out A second objection is wont to be made If the signe of the Crosse be an Idol with us then must men separate from our Church and from
CAN stay Epist to the Reader CAN Neces of separation Epist to the Reader wisheth tendernesse of conscience to his Reader ever and anon objecteth to his â—pposites what abominations and vile corruptions they labour to justifie which formerly they condemned beareth in hand that the Scriptures speak expresly for him and the learned of all sorts ancient and moderne who would not expect faire cariage and honest dealing whereas let the whole frame of his writings be looked into with a single heart and unpartiall eye and it will be found wery corrupt loose deceitfull for the matter and stuffed with scorne reproach slander insolency and falsifications for the manner Herein whether I speake the words of truth and sobernesse let the Reader search and then give sentence But for mine owne part I desire to answer in the feare of God and not to strive with him in the like measure of sinning A good cause needs no such tricks of wit but as it is of God so it is able to maintaine and defend it self and the more sincerely it is propounded the more it will prevaile In controversies if men will keepe a good conscience their zeale must be tempered with wisedome truth and meeknesse of spirit they must speake as in Gods presence give the right sense of Scripture and make fit application of it seeke the truth in love and that victorie alone which truth will carrie According to the measure of grace received from God I shall desire to walke within these bounds and with this resolution I come to compare cause with cause and reason with reason Let the Scriptures be the only judge betweene us upon which all a Aug. Epist 48. Audi quid dicit Dominus non quid dicit Donatus c. Et de Pastor ca. 4. Ego vocem Pastoris requirâ— lege de Psalmo c. Hieron in Mat. 23. Quod ex Scriptura non habet authoritatem c. Basil de vera fide Nos omnem a Dominica doctrina alienam vocem sententiam fugiamus Chr. in 2 Cor. hom 13. Obsecro oro omnes vos ut relinquatis quid huic vel illi videatur de his scripturis haec omnia inquirite Ambr. tom 3. lib. 5. epist 31. Caeli mysterium doceat me Deus ipse non homo qui seipsum ignoravit Petrus de Aliaco praec Gerson Nullum principis edictum aut ecclesiae decretum est justum nisi sit Divinae legi consonum Novum Testamentum est malleus qui universas haereses interimit est velut lucerna lumen exhibens recurrendum est ad folas Scripturas ut aeteâ—nam salutem adipiscamur conclusions in Divinitie if sound are grounded whereby all distinctions if true are warranted After the voice of God in Scripture the determinations and practices of our Guides who are no b Mat. 11.8 Luc. 7.14 1 Reg. 14.15 sc calamus arundincus non aromaticus sâ—â— mensorius CAN stay answ sect 1. p. 47. Howsoever we must live by our owne faith notwithstanding wee are not lightly to esteeme of the determinations and practices of our Guides specially when we know they are no reedes but men stable and unchangeable in the truth Bilson Christian subject part 2. pag. 351. Many Bishops have taught lyes and and seduced Princes in the Church of God and therfore not their dignitie but their doctrine is it that princes must regard for neither prince nor people stand bound to the persons of men but unto the truth of God and unto their teachers so long as they swerve not from the truth Id. Absolute judge of truth neither prince nor priest may challenge to be for God is truth and of God I trust no man may bee judge The sonne of God saith of himselfe I am truth c. Angust de nuptiis ad Valentin l. 2. cap. 33. Optat. lib. 5. ad Parmenian And page 351. Only God is to limit and appoint by his word what shalt stand for truth and what for errour c. And as Bishops ought to discerne which is the truth before they teach so must the people discerne who teacheth right before they believe Idem page 355. As the pastors have authoritie from Christ to preach the truth and woe be to them that resist the preachers of truth so have all hearers both libertie to discerne and a charge to beware of seducers given them by the same Lord and woe be to them that doe it not reeds but men stable in the truth shall be produced for they are not lightly to be esteemed though their consent cannot bee the ground of Divine faith and assurance The Lord in mercie give us to know the things which concerne our peace comfort and salvation and make us wise to walke in all pleasing before him CHAP. I. THe Question betwixt us is Whether by the Scriptures and principles of the Nonconformists The state of the Question Separation from the Church of England be necessary or lawfull Those that hold it lawfull to be present at the preaching of the Word but not to partake in the prayers of the Congregations nor to be present at the Sacraments there administred I leave to their owne defence The necessity or lawfullnesse of Separation is that which I deny Neither is it here questioned CAN. Necessit of Separ Epist to the Reader Whether the principles of the Nonconformists be true and justifiable but whether the necessity or lawfulnesse of separation can truly and justly be inferred and concluded from them This Position therefore I lay downe as directly contrary to the other That separation from the prayers Sacraments and preaching of the Word of God in the congregations and assemblies of the Church of England is unlawful by the Scriptures that whatsoever complaints whether just or unjust the Nonconformists judicious learned and holy have made of the corruptions in our Church government Ministerie Worship Prayers Administration of the Sacrament and people received or permitted as externall members they doe not inferre either in their judgements or in truth a necessitie or lawfulnesse of Separation from our Churches as no true Churches of Christ our Ministerie as false and Antichristian our Worship as Idolatry And therefore I shall shall hope such as have separated unadvisedly if men of tender hearts they will repent of their rashnesse seeing the grounds where upon they build are rotten the building ruinous and the practice directly tending to the scandall of Religion and discomfort of their soules And now I proceed in the feare of God by the beames of Truth to try and examine what is objected to shew the necessitie of Separation from the Nonconformists principles SEC I. TO Communicate in a false Ministerie CAN. Neces of Separat ca. 1. S. 3 pag. 26 27. The Church acts of Antichristian Ministers are Idolatious Id. Stay sect 1. pag. 5. s 4. p. 28. Id. Stay Answ s 5 pag. 66. Mat. 24.5.24 Hos 4 17. See Jun. on the the place See
performed was directly contrary to Gods Commandement But they were bound to goe up to Ierusalem though the Priests there Ministering had entred unlawfully and executed their Offices corruptly because God had appointed they should appeare before him in that place and the Service there tendred was of the Lord and by his appointment though the Priests were ignorant proud profane covetous or the like The Faithfull entreate Christ To shew them where he feedeth his flock that they might not turne aside if the words will beare that interpretation to the flocks of his companions that is the Congregations of false Christs and false Prophets That which you adde by his Ministerie with his Spirit Word Seales and Censures And that there they might place themselves for instruction and government is not found in the Text and may be received or refused as it is understood If your meaning be that Christ by these means doth feed or rule his Flock it will easily be granted If it be this That no Christian may lawfully sit downe in any congregation where any one of these is wanting or not executed in all points as it ought you speak of your selfe and not by the warrant of Gods Word For where Christ doth feed his flock there may the Saints of God communicate in the ordinances of Grace and Religion though some be wanting or not so purely performed in all points as they ought though the Minister in some particular enter not as he ought or be not qualified as the Word requireth It is one thing to sacrifice at Bethel Deut. 12.5 Ho. 4.15 â—â—o 4.4 5.5 2 Cron 15.3 11 12 14 15 16. 13.9 10.11 12. which God hath straitly forbidden where is neither God Priest nor Law another to worship God according to his owne appointment though the Minister be not such as he ought I wonder if men doe not tremble thus to abuse and misalledge the holy Scripture Often doe the Prophets Jere. 23.9 Matth 7.15 Christ and his Apostles you say forbid men to heare those which thrust themselves into ministeriall offices not being sent of God and from the Church This last clause And from the Church is your glosse but not found in the Texts of Scripture quoted by you Perhaps you would cunningly insinuate That all Ministers not called by the Church or particular Congregation where they are to administer be false Prophets But this is to begge what you shall never be able to prove not to make proofe of that which is questioned Bilson Christ. Subject part â— p. 367. The Lord when he saith Beware of false Prophets noteth there shall be Prophets by their calling which shall be found false by their reaching as S Peter also witnesseth Pet. 2.1 2. distinguished from Godly Teachers not by office but by doctrine Ier. 21.14 v 26 Iere. 11.14 15. v. 21. Iere 6 14 8.11 Ier. 23.25 v. 26. v. 32. Ezek. 13.2 3.6 7. 2 Pet. 2.1 2. Most certaine it is the Prophets Christ and his Apostles doe all warne us to beware of false Prophets But who are false Prophets They who are not chosen called and ordained by the communitie of the faithfull where they are to Administer No or they whose outward calling in the Church is somewhat defective and disordered nay corrupt and sinfull Not so neither But they are false Prophets who walke with falshood and strengthen the hands of the wicked that they might not returne from their wickednesse who speak the vision of their owne hearts not from the mouth of the Lord. Who say to them that despise the Lord yee shall have peace who run when they were not sent and prophesied when God spake not unto them Who prophesie false things in the Name of the Lord the deceit of their heart and thinke to make the people forget the Name of the Lord and seduce the people with their lies Who prophesie out of their owne hearts and follow their owne spirit The Apostle describes them to be false Prophets who bring in damnable doctrines contrary to the doctrine of salvation which we have received and denying the Lord that bought them But this cannot be applied to them who preach the Truth of the Gospel intirely Of false Bâ—e thren see Gal. 2.4 2 Cor. 11.26 With Hereticks and Apostates be they Princes or pâ—ivate men no Châ—istian Pastor or people may Communicate Bilson Christ Subj part 3 p. 78. Infidells be without the Church of their owne accord and Hereticks be put out Idem 79. Matth 7.15 Bevvare of false Prophets Assentior Chrysostomo qui poshemam voâ—em non de haereti is sed de iit acripit qui vulge 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 noâ—lne dicebantur Tales autem esâ—è ut qui corrupâ—am vitam specie vi 〈◊〉 larva â—egâ—â— Lucas ni sallor eosdem aâ—t innâ—es 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 lâ—â—k 20.20 Hers reâ—â— saâ—◠〈…〉 dispence the holy things of God according as they have received authoritie from God and labour to winne men from sinne unto God though in the entrance into their office or in the execution thereof there be somewhat erroneous faulty and of men Consider then how loosely the Premises of the Scripture and your conclusion hang together Wee must not joyne our selves to Congregations or Assemblies that are without Christ so the Scripture We must forsake Churches and Congregations of Christ this is your conclusion They must be forsaken that refuse the Covenant and worship strange Gods so the Scriptures Wee must forsake them who have received the Covenant and worship the true God in the mediation of Jesus Christ because they observe it imperfectly thus you must conclude or you fay nothing to the purpose If Prophets in the Old Testament had an ordinary outward calling the false Prophets might have a lawfull externall calling as well as the true and then God saith He sent them not because they preached the vision of their own heart lying and deceitfull words to strengthen the hands of the wicked and not the words of Truth to turne men from sinne They were not called of God because the work they went about was not the Lords but their owne But this reacheth not to godly Ministers who preach the Faith of Christ intirely and labour to draw men unto God nor yet unto them who in some sort are called of God according to his Will but not in favour or because he is pleased with their Administration to doe his worke though they be neither qualified as hee requires nor dispence the holy things of God sincerely and purely as they ought When you tell us we must beware of false Prophets you speake the words of Scripture but in your application of it to the Ministers of the Gospel and Congregations in England you robbe and spoile the sense of Scripture which is not the least degree of theft The Priests many times were no better than the false Prophets ut the people is never forbidden to communicate with theâ— in
initiâ— praescripta a Deo non potuit tamen usque adeo in ambulatoriis Israelitarum castris observari an t summo jure ab illis exigi prout ostendit Antithesis Vers 11. vide Num 28.6 The Doway Divines on the place give this observation In the Desart they could not observe the Ceremonies of the Law but comming to rest they were bound to keepe all one set forme of holy rites The conclusion from this Text is That God is pleased to dispence with his people in his owne prescribed Worship untill if he hath appointed determined or appropriated a certaine forme time and place they have opportunitie to serve him at that time in that place and after that forme But thence it followeth not that he hath determined or appropriated a certaine forme of place or that no other Worship may be tendred but what he hath in particular appointed or prescribed This I say cannot be concluded from the Text though I grant it is a truth rightly understood as I said before Such things saith Aaron have befallen me and if I had eaten the sin-offering to day should it have been good in the eyes of the Lord In these words Aaron excuseth himselfe by reason of his sorrow which made him unfit and unworthy to eate of those holy things Deutr. 12.7 26.14 Hos 9.4 The Doway Divines somewhat to the same purpose Naturall griefe of minde made Aaron both unwilling to eate and lesse apt to complete all the ceremonies so without sin he omitted that pertained to his own coÌ„modity offering it unto God The Geneva notes Moses bare with his infirmitie considering his great sorrow but doth not leave an example to forgive them that malitiously transgresse the commandement of God The vulgar reades it Quomodo potui comedore eam aut placere Domino in ceremoniis mente lugubri Vatablus or Leo Iuda Taliaque mihi acciderunt et si comedissem hostiam pro peccato hodiè num hoc benè factum esset in oculis Domini Or Mihi autem acciderunt hujusmodi si igitur comedissem hodie oblationem illam pro peccato an placuisset Deo And the sense of the place he gives thus Mihi tamen mortui sunt filii mei quod certè argumento est illorum sacrificium Deo non placuisse ignorabat enim Aaron causam mortis filiorum Si igitur comedissem quod mibi debebatur ex eâ oblatione quomodo placuissem Deo quum oblatio ipsa non placuerit q. d. Non putavifore Deo gratum quumea victima non fuerit placatus Jun. annot in loc Iun. gives the words another sense Ego quoque non satis attendi ad officium mihi imperatum lege sed per imprudentiam peccavi ut filii mei supersâ—ites â—â—ejusdem negligentiae perturbationis reus sum gratumne ei foret si ego adhut-in peccato haerens peccatum populi expiandum in me transtulissem The conclusions from this Text of Scripture may be such as these That oftentimes the letter of the Law giveth place to great necessities or that Gods worship where he hath prescribed and determined the manner must be performed as he hath appointed But that no other service may be tendered unto God than he hath instituted though that be a Truth or that in every title he hath determined the manner of his Service that cannot be gathered from this Text. All their wickednesse is in Gilgal saith the Lord by the Prophet for there doe I hate them Hos 9.15 Hos 4.15 1â— 11 Amos 4.4 5.5 for the wickednesse of their inventions I will cast them out of mine house I will love them no more all their Princes are rebells The wickednesse of Gilgal was that horrible idolatrie wherewith it was polluted and by their inventions wee must understand their idolatrous Worship set up directly against the Commandement of God And by the house of God neither the land which the Lord gave them to possesse or the family of God is meant but the condition of the people of Israel will not suffer the Sanctuary or Tabernacle to be understood For they set up Altars and sacrificed in Gilgal where was neither the Arke nor Sanctuary of the Lord and when God had expresly forbidden either to multiply Altars or to sacrifice in any other place than that which he had chosen unto himselfe Cypr. Cecilio fratri ep 68. Non hominis corsuetudinem sequi oporteâ— sed Dei veritatem cum per Isaiam Prophetam Deus loquatur dicat sine causa autem colunt me mandata doctrinas hominum docentes iterum Dominus in Evangeâ—o hoc idem repetit dicens Reiicistis c. Matth. 15 3 4. Col. 2.8 Rivet ad Gen. praelect 44 Quiequid ad colendum Deum ab hominibus institu tur sine Dei mandato vanumest rsal 19.13 Math. 15.8 Heb. 11.6 Rom. 10.17 Non camen-negamus posse eos quiecclesium regunt prasâ—ribere aliquid fingulare de circumstantiis ad Dei cul um pertiâ—e tibus ex vâ—râ—â— Dei generâ—libus axioâ—atis ut de leco tempore pabli orum conventuum siâ—dibus quae ad pretatem ecclesiasticam pertinent sed negamus in talibus formaâ—iter cul um Det consistere CAN Stay sect 2. p. 9. Melanâ—th l. 4. c. de distinct Keckerm Thcol. l. 1. p. 59. directly contrary to Gods Commandement is unlawfull therefore it is unlawfull to worship God in any other way or manner than he hath instituted The thing concluded is true but it hangs to the Premises as a rope of sand Two passages of Scripture are rightly alledged by you the rest are mustered up meerely to make a shew and argue your great inconsideratenesse in citing Scripture against will-worship and superstitious rites or emptie shewes of Religion For the soule of Religion is to doe acts with relation to Gods Commandement and where there is no Commandement or Institution there can be no conscience of worship no expectation of a blessing In this sense therefore the proposition is to be admitted But in a matter of such importance so much insisted upon by your selfe it became you to deale distinctly and prove substantially what you affirme and not to confound things that differ confidently to affirme what you can never make good and heape up Scriptures and Authors to no purpose You say it is a certaine rule as Logicians teach Things are really to be distinguished which in themselves are to be separated each from other But the rule is That all things are really distinguished which may be separated each from other as the body is really distinguished from the apparrel because the garment may be separated from the body the body from the garment How truely you understand or fitly apply that Maxime it is needlesse to examine further but what you observe in your Pistoler as you stile him that is most true in your selfe and some others that ignorance or neglect of distinguishing things that differ in this matter
the ordinary way and meanes Id. Sect. 15. p. 132. which the Scripture speakes of to beget men to the faith For as a false forged constitution makes a Church a reall and substantiall Idoll So all that comes from it is touched with the Idolatry of that constitution This is a ruled opinion of many Divines The State makes all the publike actions to be formally good or evill For as the Temple sanctifieth the gold Matth. 23.17 the Altar the offerings so the Ordinances of the Church under the Gospell are sanctified unto us Bucer in Mat. 23.17 That is as Bucer truely speaketh in the use of them made lawfull to us in that they have their rise from a true and right power Seeing therefore the Church in Question wants a right Constitution it must follow that all spirituall actions done in it whether Prayer Preaching Sacraments Censures as they are there done are none of Gods Ordinances though true it is in themselves they are of God If the false Churches of whom we disputed CAN. Stay Sect. 15. p. 131.132 Id. Sect. 2. p. 8. be that spirituall Babylon mentioned in the Revelation cap. 18.4 then it is unlawfull for Gods people to goe unto them to performe any spirituall or religious action and so consequently not to heare theâ—e But the first is true Ergo the later is true also The proposition needs no proofe because our opposites and we herein are of opinion alike The assumption is manifest by these reasons Artopaeus in Rev. 18. pag. 198. Flac. Illyric in Rev. 18.4 Par. com in Hos 4. pag. 506. Bulling in Apoc. ca. 18. con 76. 1. The words in the Text prove it plainely Come out of her my people that is remove your selves from all false assemblies covenant together to walk in all the wayes of God serve the Lord among your selves in spirit and truth and returne not from whence you are come But repent rather that yee have suffered your Consciences to bee wrought upon by any unlawfull Officers And thus doe the Learned interpret the place namely of such a coming out as that we may not be bodily present at any of their worship 2 Cor. 6.1 Ioh. 5.21 Zech. 11.17 Botlac prompt allegoriar cap. 21. de Minist It is like that filthy bird which carryeth this Motto Contactu omnia saedat The publisher and others with him have comitted appatant Idolatry maintained it in the Church and sought thereby to pervert the right wayes of the Lord. Jd. sect 1. p. 7. Id sect 15. p. 133. A false Church state is rightly likened to the leprosie spread in the wals of the houses of the Lepers because of the pollution which it causeth to the persons and things Take for instance a Citie or Towne if the civill State or Corporation which they have be usurped aevised or derived from a false power all their publike administrations are unlawfull and every one partaking thereof offendeth So all administrations done in a false Church whether prayer Preaching Sacraments Censures are uncleane actions and doe defile every receiver J say because of the Idoll State which is devised out of a mans braine and used as a meanes to serve God in it and by it All the Ordinances done after the invention and will of Antichrist can no otherwise be judged than a brood common to the nature of the breeders that is the Devill and the Whore of Rome the Father and Mother that did beget them ANSWER THe Faithfull are commanded to come out of spirituall Babylon and not to communicate with her in false worship or Idolatry Revel 18.4 as the Text doth confirme and your opposites grant And therein it was needlesse to muster up the testimonies of the Learned to give evidence in a case maintained and practised notoriously sc that we must flye from the society of Rome and not be present to behold their worship Your labour herein is superfluous but that the Names of Learned men here numbred up might serve to cover your nakednesse when you come to the point in controversie wherein you prove just nothing at all But our Churches wherein the Gospell of Christ is purely preached and professed in all points fundamentall the seales of the Covenant of Grace rightly administred who are separaced from spirituall Babylon in mind and body and have fled from her worship and Idolatry who are built upon Christ the true and firme foundation of his Church and by Christ himselfe acknowledged for his people and graced with his favourable presence Our Churches I say cannot be deemed or reputed spirituall Babylon without great injurie to Christ his truth his Church and Saints By spirituall Babylon in this booke of the Revelation is meant Rome Christian departed from the faith guilty of the blood of Saints stained with manyfold and fearfull Idolatries the mother of fornications who hath made drunke the Kings of the earth with the cup of her poysons as might bee confirmed by the Scripture it self the joynt consent of learned orthodox Divines and the testimonie of Papists themselves But to brand the Churches of Christ since the reformation who have renounced Antichrists doctrine worship and idolatries and embraced the intire faith of the Lord Jesus with that odious hatefull name is contrary to the truth of God evident reason and the judgement of all approved godly learned men You miserably corrupt and pervert the Text when you give this to be the sense thereof Remove your selves from all false Assemblies covenant together to walke in all the wayes of God serve the Lord among your selves in spirit and truth and returne not from whence you are come This is not to interpret Scripture and learne of them what wee are to thinke but to racke Scriptures to our sense and make them speake according to our fansies which is an high point of Antichristianisme If you will stand to your principles within two hundred yeares after Christ or lesse there was not one true Christian societie in the whole world which did walke together in all the wayes of God and serve God in a Church state among themselves And will you say the faithfull are charged of God in this passage of holy writ to remove and separate from all Christian assemblies that then were in the world and to serve God among themselves If corruption in doctrine manners worship government and orders make a false assembly Rome was a false assembly long before the Lord gave commandement to his people to depart thence and separate themselves Israel for a time continued in Egypt and Babylon viz. untill the Lord sent to bring them forth and the Church lay hid in Babylon and that by the providence and approbation of God long after Rome was miserably corrupted and defiled The matter is notorious and therefore to spend more words about it is needlesse Hee that considereth the state of things long before the faithfull separated from Rome and what is written in defence of that separation which
of God 2. Their qualification for this office their care in execution and other accessories which may be added of man If for substance of office their calling be of God wee are bound to hold communion with them though in the qualification execution and other adhering circumstances some things bee amisse which it is not in our power to redresse This our Saviour Christ hath expressely taught and made knowne unto uâ— both by his Doctrine and example as hath beene shewed already Hereunto this one thing may be added that many Pastors and teachers in the Church of England be called qualified and doe carry themselves in their charges and places according to the direction of IESVS CHRIST the chiefe shepheard of his sheepe and other for substance of Ministery are Pastors and Teachers CAN Stay Sect. 6. pag 79. If to heare Antichristian Ministers bee to serve God in and by an Ordinance If in preaching the truths of the Gospel in a false Church no Idolatry bee done then may a man vvorship God in a vvay of his ovvne devising blamelesse Id. §. 5. page 77. way or institution devised by Idolaters and with Idolaters then it is unlawfull But the first is true Therefore the second The proposition is undeniable by the Treatisers owne confession you should have said the assumption for if the Treatisers words prove ought they must be applyed thereunto As for the proposition they speake not to it at all But forwardnesse here and in many other places hath made you forget your tearmes of Art He that heares the Ministers of the Bishops sending and of the Parishes sent to he heares in the sense of the Scripturs false Prophets Id page 81. Such as hearken to Antichrists Ministers do therein approve of Antichrists unlavvfull povver over the false Church and the Divels donation or his putting of that povver into his eldest sonâ— hâ—nd Id. §. 6. p. 84. But it is not lawfull to heare false Prophets The Major is proved clearly in defencâ— of our twelfth objection The Minor is certaine by these reasons 1. The hearing of false Prophets is forbidden in the word of God c. ANSWER You busie your selfe to weave the Spiders web which is good for little long in weaving but soone swept downe Our Ministers be not Antichristian Ministers nor false Prophets in the Scriptures sense because they preach the whole counsell of God in all points necessary to salvation and rightly dispense the seales of the Covenant by authoritie derived from Jesus Christ the Lord and King oâ— his Church the great Shepheard of his Sheep At least they are set apart to this office which was never deemed Antichristian in the Church of Christ But if we take these words Antichristian Ministers and false Prophets in your sense for you use them in a peculiar dialect then it is not only lawfull but necessary to heare such as you call Antichristian Ministers For it is commanded in the word and acceptable service unto God the meanes to build up the Church It is to hold communion with God to reverence his name to lay hold upon Christ and lodge him in our bosome It sheweth that a man is one of Christs sheep because hee heareth his voice and a member of his sheepfold the servant of the most high God it manifesteth love and zeale to God and is ordinarily blessed to the soul and conscience of the dutifull hearer And in that which you alledge to the contrary you misalledge Scripture speak evill of the truth revile the heritage of the Lord and grievously wound your owne conscience The religion professed and worship performed in our assemblies is true not only in respect of the object but of nature use and end and whatsoever circumstances are necessarilie required to lawfull worship And the false Prophets mentioned in Scripture are of one sort yours of an other even the true Ministers of Jesus Christ But let us turne over to the twelvth objection to heare the cleare proofe of that which here you affirme for thither you send us CAN Stay §. 12. p. 116 117. The Treatiser as you call him propounding this objection of yours that the Scriptures of the old and new Testament warne Gods people of false prophets which the Ministers of that Church are having an unlawfull calling maketh answer 1 By denying that the Scriptures warn men simply not to hear false Prophets i.e. any false prophet whatsoever And then propounds a distinction of fals Prophets that some fals Prophets were in the Church of God and these might be heard as they had place in the Church till they were orderly repressed or at least discovered others were not in the Church but simply without and these were not to be heard This is the plaine and direct answer of the Treatiser as every man may perceive that is not grosly ignorant or wilfully blind But see how you jest and dally with it unconscionably when you had nothing to answer 1. You say he peremptorily denyeth the whole objection and so consequently affirmes that all false Prophets may be heard But what new Logicke is this whereby we may learne to draw such consequences In former times it hath beene thought reasonable to deny an universall negative or affirmative proposition when they hold not true in all Individuals No false prophet is to be heard This proposition may justly be benyed if any false Prophet may be heard though all might not 2 You adde presently and with the same breath He unsaith what hee said before But this is a palpable and grosse calumny For he said not that all false Prophets might be heard by all nor denyeth what hee granted at the first that some may be heard but plainly implyeth a distinction of false Prophets which I can hardly thinke you did not perceive though you be pleased so to pervert his words If there appeare any deep and inextricable riddle in the words you may fitly apply to your selfe what in this very place you report of Marcus Antonius's souldiers who unawares fell upon an hearb that greatly distempered their heads You tell us Id pag. 116. The Treatiser since he lighted upon his Gourd he is not like himselfe in his other writings and I can easily believe it for in his other writings for separation he is insolent censorious scornfull and slighty In this mild Christian and for the most part more substantiall As you deale with your Treatiser to scorne what you cannot answer so you doe with others in this very argument and that much more absurdlie Master Br. in maintenance of the Ministerie of the Church of England The unreasonab of separation p. 2 3 4 7. as it is established by Law distinguisheth betweene the substance of the Ministerie and the execution thereof the essentiall parts of the Ministery and some accidentall circumstances adhering unto them by man For substance saith he the present Ministerie of our Church assemblies is the very Ministerie which Christ hath set in