of means to the neglect of another Because there are so many Arguments which may sufficiently satisfy any of their Authority because some are convinced by some others by others We are encouraged in our Church to receive the Holy Scriptures as the word of God both from inward and outward motives both of divine and moral consideration But for our greater certainty and safety in a matter of so great concern our Church doth not lay the weight of so great a cause on slight or uncertain Foundations as the infallibility of the Church much less demonstration from the evidence of oral tradition or the testimony only of the Divine Spirit held by some so absolutely necessary to convince every one of the Divine Authority of Scriptures that without such an inward testimony there can be no kind of certainty whatsoever The Moderation of our Church excellently governs her judgment herein neither refusing the just Authority of Gods true Church nor denying any necessary influence of the Holy Spirit of God according to which Moderation guiding our selves we shall have occasion elsewhere to justify the real certainty of our Faith ch 6. § 8. In convincing also those of the Authority of Holy Scripture who do deny the same the wisdom and temper of our Church prudently hath omitted a twofold medium as improper to confute obstinate Adversaries The one is of proving the Divine Authority of the Scriptures by Scriptures themselves which though it be a sufficient proof among them who have received them as divine yet to others it can never stop the objection from returning infinitely if the objector please to be dissatisfied The other method is alledging the Testimony of the Spirit for though the Church of God hath the Holy Spirit yet those that dispute this point may not have the Spirit neither can any ones saying so be a proper Argument to convince another Thirdly Our Church avoids the Circle of proving the Scripture by the Church and the Church by the Scriptures again because our Church doth first acknowledge the Holy Scriptures as superiour to it self o Article 6. 20. as one of the first principles of its Doctrine and against those who deny that principle of the Holy Scriptures veracity it doth dispute no otherwise than by reasons convincing the certainty of Tradition But as Archbishop Laud in his Preface against Fisher takes notice While one Faction cries up the Church above the Scripture and the other the Scripture to the neglect of the Church According to Christs Institution the Scripture where it is plain should guide the Church and the Church where there is doubt should expound the Scripture § 9. Whereas many run into very immoderate extravagancies concerning the interpretation of Holy Scripture our Church contains it self within very wise and just proportions in its judgment and practice concerning this matter 1. Concerning Holy Scripture it doth own what the Ancient Fathers p S. Chrys Hom. 3. in â— Thess S. Aug. in Ps 8. V. Second Part of the Homily of the knowledge of H. Scrip. have testified That what is absolutely necessary unto Salvation of all either for knowledge or practice is so fair and intelligible and plain to be understood of any that there needs no interpreter of the meaning of the sense to them who understand the words 2. For the understanding other places in Holy Scripture which are more obscure our Church doth suppose and acknowledge plentiful means allowed of God both to the Church and by and in the Church to all particular persons as much as is necessary that such places be understood For those which are mysterious and intricate are for the curious and wise to enquire into They are not the repositories of Salvation but instances of labour and occasions of humility and arguments of mutual forbearance and an endearment of reverence and adoration as the Archbishop of Spalato and our Bishop Taylor use to speak Such means for the interpretation of Scripture are the ordinary assistances of the Holy Spirit of God The instructions of the Church the use of our Reason especially in comparing one Scripture with another which excellent means of finding out the sense of Holy Writ our Church her self doth often use and recommends the same to those of her Communion according to the ancient practice of the Church Yet if we speak properly we do not call the Scripture the interpreter of it self nor properly a Judge of matter of Faith q S. Scripturam Judicem qui sentiunt rectè sentiunt sed siguratè â—oquuntur Gro. de Impâ—rio sum pot Though it be the Rule according to which the judgment which is of Doctrines is made and in Analogy with which Interpretations of Scripture also are to be govern'd But because of the danger of the vulgars being misled our Church doth send them frequently to their Pastors and Ministers for publick instruction and private advice and counsel and inferiour Ministers it refers to their Bishop r Exhortation to the Holy Communion Canon 53. The same method our Church directs for resolution of doubts which may arise referring to the Liturgy Preface concerning the Service of the Church Forasmuch as nothing can be so plainly set forth but doubts may arise in the use and practice of the same to appease all such diversity if any arise and for the resolution of all doubts concerning the manner how to understand do and execute the things contained in this Book the parties that so doubt shall alway resort to the Bishop of the Diocess who by his discretion shall take order for the quieting and appeasing of the same And if the Bishop be in doubt he may send for the resolution thereof to the Archbishop 3. Our Church doth not attribute more or less authority to the means of interpreting Scripture or any part thereof than God hath given it for that purpose and here the Moderation of the Church might be illustrated from the manifold extravagancies others have run into in this matter on all sides 1. Some make the Holy Spirit of God the only immediate interpreter of Scripture unto all persons whatsoever that at any time understand any thing thereof Others run into another extreme of slighting the illumination and assistance of the Holy Spirit 2. Some assert the Church of Rome only to have an infallible and absolute Authority herein others deny both the Church Universal and all parts thereof all authority to teach those under her Discipline or interpret any Scripture to them 3. Some have maintained that the publick Magistrate is the only interpreter of Scripture others deny him any kind of authority over or about the Church 4. There are those who make humane reason the only interpreter of Scripture Others reject all use of reason in divine matters Among these and many more extravagancies of men The Moderation of our Church keeps on one hand from the Tyranny of those who make such Authorities the Rule of interpreting Scripture which
never were so appointed And on the other from the wild inordinacy of them who make their own private principle whatsoever it be the rule of Scripture interpretation Among all wisely making use of and asserting and recommending such means as are given for the conveyance or interpretation or both for the conveying and interpreting of Divine Writ Something further of which will more distinctly appear in the next Chapter CHAP. V. Of the Moderation of the Church in applying the Rule of Faith to it self § 1. Avoiding extremes on either hand in relation to the authority of the Vniversal Church § 2. The Decrees of Councils § 3. The Testimony of the Fathers § 4. Other Traditions § 5. Our Churches own Testimony § 6. The use of Reason § 7. The Testimony of the Spirit § 8. Of the testimony and operation of the Holy Spirit the judgment of our Church according to great Moderation more largely declared § 1. THE Moderation of the Church of England appears very great in her due applying this Rule of Faith to her self wisely and fitly making use of all those Instruments which are most proper and useful in conveying to us that Rule or which are most subservient to the right understanding our Rule avoiding either extreme of those who attribute too much or too little to those instruments of conveyance and interpretation Such as the Authority of the Universal Church The Decrees of Councils The Testimony of the Fathers Other Traditions The Witness of our own particular Church Right Reason alone The Testimony of the Spirit To all and every of these enumerated instruments either of certain conveyance or interpretation of Scripture our Church gives their due place and esteem according to their influence and use and no more which must needs demonstrate a great deal of Wisdom and Moderation in the judgment of the Church 1. The Universal Church it self is no where by the Church of England made the Rule of her Faith but a Witness and Keeper of Holy Writ Art 20. Yet the judgment of the Catholick Church of Christ was always by the Church of England held in greatest veneration next unto the testimony of the Spirit of God himself because of those famous Promises made by Christ himself to the Church which we read of in the New Testament Yea in the Old Testament The Prophecies concerning the Messias and concerning the Church and the Ministers of the Church always are join'd together as I have sometime heard a great Prelate of our Church teach us And because whatever Arguments we have for the truth of Holy Scriptures as thanks be to God we have many beside yet also from the witness and keeping of the Church a Ecclesia non discernit sed niâ—a traditioni legitimae testatur quae sint Canonicae Scripturae Spalatens l. 7. ch 1. we receive the Holy Scriptures themselves and in the sixth Article In the name of Holy Scriptures the Church doth understand those Canonical Books of the Old and New Testament of whose Authority there was never any doubt in the Church So that as the Archbishop of Spalato hath it we have recourse to the Church not as to an Authoritative Judge but as to a Treasure and Repository b Haec sunt quae Patres intra Canonem concluserunt Haec nobis à Patribus tradita S. Hieron Ruffinus in which the Canonical Books and all things necessary to Salvation are preserved by faithful Tradition Wherefore the Catholick Church it self is called not a Judge nor a Rule c Credo Ecclisiam credo Ecclesiae per Eâ—clesiam Non diâ—imus credo in Ecclesiam â—â—t credo in Ecclesiâ— Ep-Esâ—enâ— but more truly a Witness and Keeper of Holy Writ and for interpretation of Scripture and for our help in judging of Doctrines according to our Rule the Church of England values above all others the Judgment of the Catholick Church so far forth as we can attain the testimony of the Catholick Church by such instruments as are approved and undoubted For though d Second Diâ—â—native against Popery l. 1. â— 1. If by Catholick you mean all particular Churches in the World then though truth doth infallibly dwell amongst them yet you can never go to School to them all to learn it in such questions as are curious and unnecessary and by which the Salvation of Souls is not promoted Yet we know that in the Primitive Time the Christian Church was in a less compass and more undivided Wherefore if such matters which are most essential to the being and well-being of the Church are both delivered from that time and with their conveyance have been approved by the Church in common ever since If the Church may be a sure instrument of conveyance of the Books of Holy Scripture why not also of such matters wherein all so well agree from the first and do in no sort thwart the Tradition of the Holy Scripture it self Wherefore in the Canon set forth in our Church with the Articles of Religion 1571. it is caution'd That nothing be at any time taught either to be held or believed upon the account of Religion but what is agreeable to the Doctrine of the Old and New Testament which the Catholick Fathers and antient Bishops have gathered from thence Which Golden Rule of our Church I find twice extoll'd by the Illustrious Grotius once e De imp sum potesta c. 6. §. 9. p. 181. in these words I cannot but commend that famous Canon of the Church of England That c. And again in one of his Epistles f Apologiâ— Eccl. Anglicanae Accessimus verò ad illam Ecclesiam in quâ omnia castè reverenter quantum nos assequâ— potâ—imus proximè ad priscorum temporum rationem §. 118. Inde enim putavimus restaurationem petendâ—m esse unde prima Religionis initia ducta essent §. 150. He takes occasion from this Canon of the Church to say He wonders any should deny In England they attribute more to the ancient Church than they do in France The form also of profession in the admission of Professors in Divinity in the University because it doth very fully express the sense of the Church of England I repeat the tenour thereof I from my heart do embrace and receive all the Holy Canonical Scripture in the Old and New Testament comprehended and all those things which the true Church of Christ Holy and Apostolick subject to the word of God and governed by the same doth reject I reject whatsoever it holds I hold Concerning the Church of England in this matter hear we what the Learned Casaubon hath declared in an Epistle to Heinsius g Ep. Ecclesiasticae p. 345. This saith he is my judgment Whereas there will and can be but one true Church we are not hastily to recede from those Doctrines of Faith which the consent of all the ancient Catholick Church hath approved and whereas I own no other Foundation of true
different Judgments and Interests of the divided World are now a Reconciliation is thought impossible and generally impracticable but because the very speculation of Peace is delightful we make in the Idea this Supposition § 8. Admit which is a case possible some few Families of well-bred and better disposed Persons but of as different Persuasions in the Extreams as any are among us were to settle together in some remote Island and had a singular inclination to compass a Communion with each other in what they might in Spiritual Matters The means to bring this about one would think must be the same which all wise Persons would take to convince another of a different Persuasion namely by moving upon such Principles as both agree in which being improv'd to the utmost they are capable of must be between them the common foundation of a possibility of agreement Suppose then upon this score a Romanist and an extream Dissenter should yet agree in the most Fundamental Articles of Faith contained in the received Creeds and in acknowledging the Holy Scriptures in their Original or admitting the Vulgar Version or the like and if they admit the four first General Councils so much the better Upon this Stock an accommodation must be negotiated amongst them 1. Neither pretending to be Dictators one to the other for that will spoil all but to acquiesce as these Principles and their best Reasons shall govern them to a fair entercourse in common For Union in Practice 2. No unjust condition of Communion must be enjoyned on either hand Nor any thing but what is very necessary and clear as well as they can agreed on according to those first Rules 3. Both must sincerely bear with one another in what they appear to differ and to forbear all occasions of giving mutual distast that may be 4. Sufficient security must be mutually given against such Principles the professing and pursuing of which necessarily destroys all Civil and Spiritual Communion As for Instance That Faith is not to be kept with those whom one part calls Hereticks Or that right of Dominion one over the other is founded in Saint-ship c. 5. For accommodation in Peace-sake if these and the like Principles and Doctrines be publickly and sufficiently renounced then they must mutually take care that the evil Consequence of either shall not be imputed to those particular Persons who do detest them and acknowledg them most impious This being the proper Foundation for Communion together in Doctrine Sacraments and Discipline the consequent business is to convince such as will admit of the Debate That those Doctrines and Practices which are received above and beside what are mutually agreed in do really contradict the clear Contents of the Scripture or the Judgment of the Universal Church and are not of safe influence on the Christian Religion It may do well to be shewn by Instances of Fact and the light of concurrent Tradition when the particular Innovations entred in by what occasions and degrees and the evil Consequences of them all Which will more effectually be performed if it can be demonstrated That most of this is acknowledged by the many of the sincere amongst themselves at quiet Intervals And if they can distinguish between what might be of Original good intent or had at least a plausible pretence and what is of manifest corruption So much of all this as was proper and belonging to the Church of England to perform that She may acquit her self from the Imputations of those who deny her Communion let the whole Church of God judg how carefully and how peaceably She hath done her part But those of the Church of Rome who have appeared desirous of Reconciliation have done it either for civility of Conversation or out of Design or without leave of their Superiors For admit Protestants could open a Door to the Peace of Christendom the Romanists * Num verò spem aliquam ostendunt Pontificii Moderationis leâ—ationis emendationis nihil profecto minùs quin execrandum Anathema dicunt c. Chemn ex Cone Trid. Sess 7. Can. 13. set a Bolt on their side by their Doctrine of Infallibility however they place it whereby they seem to think it unlawful to correct themselves of such Errors as most grievously divide the Church Therefore as the case stands the Learned Thorndike †Forbearance of Penalties Ch. 8. p. 38. professeth himself freely to be without any manner of hope that ever the See of Rome will abate any thing of their Rigour tho the Reformation should content themselves with these terms for I find by the proceeding of former Times that it is their Maxim To stand to that which they have once done And to mark those Popes to posterity that have abated any thing from the rigour of their Predecessors For being arrived at this greatness by this rigour and obstinacy in all pretences right or wrong they will always think themselves obliged in reason of State not to yeeld so much as the Cup in the Eucharist Not considering all this while that this rigour is the cause of Division The Remedy therefore must begin from those Parties which have given cause of the breach if they shall remit of their undue height and rigour and be content with those moderate bounds which God hath set them both for Doctrine and Government and yield themselves but capable of Error there may be a possibility of Vnion and Peace but while they persist to challeng an Infallibility of Judgment and uncontroulableness of Practice they do wilfully block up the way to all Reconciliation and Concord and stand guilty of all that grievous Schism under which the Church of God thus long and miserably suffers * Bp. Halls Remains p. 410. †Casaubon of Reformation p. 147. But This is the grand Mystery of Jesuitism and Politic Popery at this day to look upon all moderate Counsels as pernicious and destructive § 9. The design of Peace is generally applauded by all and indeed it is so excellent an undertaking it seems a great pity that any endeavours for it should at any time be blasted with suspicion misconstruction and ill success And whereas some have Objected against us that we are ready to chuse Pacisication with the Romish rather than with the Protestant Dissenter We Answer 1. in general with respect to both That true Christianity requires us to be Enemies to no one If any will be to us and to Truth the blame must lie at their Door who give the just cause If any require plainly sinful conditions indispensable to hold Communion with them in such a case the Command holds good Come out from among them and be ye separate The reason why in Disputation Reconciliation with the Romanists hath upon such terms mentioned bin spoken of is because They are they who have laid the Obstruction to all Union by their enormous Corruptions and it lies upon them to remove the Obstruction and no
of the Holy Scripture our Church rather doth take for granted than prove too laboriously or uncertainly § 9. All immoderate extravagancies concerning interpretation of Holy Scripture avoided by our Church § 1. WHereas Moderation hath its name and being from the equal measures observed by it the first instance of the Moderation of our Church is most properly to be taken from the right rule and measure in Religion which this Church of ours constantly receives and holds close to by which she is safely preserved from all undue extremes having to her self the same rule and measure of her Moderation which the universal Church of Christ in all Ages hath had such a rule as is beyond all exception and is of undeniable Authority namely the Holy Scriptures which are the same right and just measure by which she measures out to others and desires to be measured by her self in whatever she receives and delivers out as matter of Faith and required practice in the necessary parts of Religion and the worship of God Whereas next to the extreme of them who have no Religion nor no Rule the vanity and extravagance of those is very notorious who set up themselves to be their own Rule which is done in the pretences of infallibility on one hand and enthusiasm on the other between that Rock and this Gulf the Moderation of our Church doth safely conduct its own judgment and practice and all that follow her In the Sixth Article of Religion see how our Church doth own the perfection of Holy Scripture as a Rule Holy Scripture containeth all things necessary to Salvation so that whatsoever is not read therein nor may be proved thereby is not required of any man that it should be believed as an Article of Faith or be thought requisite or necessary to salvation and the reason why the Church of England doth require her self to be acknowledged of her own a Canon 3. 1603. as a true and Apostolical Church is because she teacheth and maintains the Doctrine of the Apostles and in the fourth Canon the Church censures all Impugners of the worship of God and whosoever shall affirm her Form containeth any thing in it repugnant to the Scriptures In the 36. Canon Article 2. All who are to subscribe are willingly and ex animo to affirm That the Book of Common-Prayer and of ordering Bishops Priests and Deacons containeth in it nothing contrary to the word of God and Article 3. That he acknowledgeth all and every of the 39. Articles to be agreeable to the word of God In the 19th Article of Religion The visible Church of Christ is defined a Congregation of faithful men in the which the pure word of God is Preached and the Sacraments be duly administred according to Christs Ordinance And in the ordering of Bishops and Priests it is asked Be you perswaded that the Holy Scriptures contain sufficiently all Doctrine required of necessity for eternal Salvation through Faith in Jesu Christ And are you determined with the said Scriptures to instruct the people committed to your Charge and to teach nothing as required of necessity to eternal Salvation but that you shall be perswaded may be concluded and proved by the Scriptures The Answer is I am so perswaded and have so determined by Gods grace In the 20th Article of Religion it is declared It is not lawful for the Church to ordain any thing contrary to Gods word written neither to expound one place that it be repugnant to another From all which passages and many more which might be repeated out of the Monuments of our Church it is evident that as our Church is formed in her whole Constitution with an uniform respect to this Rule and hath framed her Articles Liturgy Homilies and Orders thereby so it doth require her self to be acknowledged in those but in subordination to this Rule and measure as before and superiour to it self which doth manifest the exceptions of many of the Separation to be very unreasonable who seem to give such deference to the Holy Scriptures and at the same time renounce Communion with the Church of England which doth so religiously hold to the Sacred Scriptures of which our Church in union with the whole Church of God is a sure Keeper a faithful Witness a zealous Defender and a most sober Interpreter § 2. The Moderation of the Church of England further appears in avoiding the extremes of those who take away from the true perfection of Scripture and of others who seem officiously to add thereunto Of the first sort of those who detract from the true perfection of Scripture are they who frame an additional Canon of their own as the Church of Rome doth who declares that the Apocryphal Writings and Traditions of men are nothing inferiour nor less Canonical than the Sovereign dictates of God as well for the Confirmation of doctrinal points pertaining to Faith as for ordering of Life and Manners and that both the one and the other ought to be embraced with the same affection of Piety and received with the like religious Reverence b Concil Trid. Sess 4. Decr. 1. not making any difference between them Thus as it is in the second part of the Homily of good works Christ reproved the Laws and Traditions of the Scribes and Pharisees because they were set up so high as though they had been equal with Gods Laws and above them They worship Me in vain that teach for Doctrines the Commandments of men For you leave the Commandments of God to keep your own Traditions Yet He meant not thereby to overthrow Mens Commandments for He Himself was obedient to the Princes and their Laws made for good order On the other extreme They of the Separation among us are busy to attribute to the Holy Scriptures such a perfection as God never intended them namely particularly to determine of all actions of Mankind and every matter of order and decency in Religion Between these two see by how even a thred our Church divides the controversy first asserting the real perfection of Scriptures as a Rule to be as much as need to be to be as great a perfection as God hath given it in order to its end namely to guide our belief and practice in things needful to Salvation Article 20. Besides the same namely Gods word written ought not the Church to enforce any thing to be believed for necessity of salvation and in the same Article It is not lawful for the Church to ordain any thing contrary to Gods word written Yet the Article begins thus The Church hath power to Decree Rites and Ceremonies and hath Authority in controversies of Faith Wherein according to an accurate Moderation the Church doth behave itself in attributing to the Holy Scriptures their just and full perfection On the other hand our Church doth thankfully accept of that Christian Liberty which God hath left her and indeed which he hath given all particular Christians according to their
Council where alone those men are heard which are determined for ever in all points to defend the Popish party and to arm themselves to fight in the Bishop of Romes quarrel though it were against God and the Holy Scriptures It is no general Council neither ought it to be called general where the same men be only Advocates and Adversaries defending his Primacy born by the ignorance of the World nourished by the ambition of the Bishops of Rome defended by places of Scripture falsly understood Neither secondly is our Churches honour to general Councils lessened because she declares they are not infallible as in our 21. Article of Religion When they be gathered together Forasmuch as they be an Assembly of Men whereof all be not governed with the spirit and word of God they may erre and sometime have erred even in things pertaining to God wherefore things ordained by them as necessary to Salvation have neither strength nor authority unless it be declared that they be taken out of Holy Scripture t Itaque legantur Concilia quidem Cum honore sed interim ad scripturam piam certam rectamque regulam examinentur Reform leg Eccl. c. 14. Notwithstanding they are not infallible yet for the establishing consent King James may be presumed to declare the sense of our Church of the use of such Councils lawfully assembled Come saith He u Rex Jacobus ad Card. Perr put it to the Issue allow a free general Council which may not depend upon the arbitrary will of one man and the Church of England is prepared to give a Reason of its Faith For even anciently it was a great complaint in the Church as the Fond of all their mischiefs x Nilus Archiep Thesâ—al l. 1. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 That Controversies were not determined after the Primitive Rite and manner § 3. Concerning the Testimony of the Fathers the Church of England hath observed the same wise Moderation in her judgment and use of them also no where judging of them as unliable to error according to the arguing of the 21. Article Because they are but men and sometimes have erred in things pertaining to God neither hath our Church any where swallowed their errors through the Veneration of their Piety and Antiquity Yet because of their Proximity to the Apostolick times and the just authority in the Church which for their Learning and Piety they have obtained and all along hath been given them Our Church in her Monuments gives a great deference to their judgment testimony and practice In the 31. Canon Forasmuch as the ancient Fathers of the Church led by the example of the Apostles appointed c. We following their Holy and Religious Example do Constitute and Decree Canon 32. According to the judgment of the ancient Fathers and the practice of the Primitive Church We do Ordain Canon 33. It hath been long since provided by many Decrees of ancient Fathers That c. According to which Examples we do Ordain Canon 60. Forasmnch as it hath been a solemn ancient and laudable Custom in the Church of God continued from the Apostles time That c. We will and appoint So in the 30. Canon The lawful use of the Cross in Baptism is explained from the practice of the Primitive Times And in King Edw. VI. Proclamation before the Common Prayer Book the reason for our Forms and Rites is justified from the practice of the Primitive Church and in the Preface concerning the Service of the Church Here you have an Order for Prayer and reading the Holy Scripture much agreeable to the mind and purpose of the old Fathers and in many other places where they are named and where they are not named The footsteps of their ancient Piety have very discernable impressions throughout the whole Constitution of our Church Wherefore as it is in the Reformation of the Ecclesiastical Laws of England as was intended y Reform leg Eccles Angl. c. 15. Let the Authority and Reverence be continued to the Ancient and Orthodox Fathers but such as may be subject to the determination truth and authority of the Holy Scriptures For always the ancient Fathers z Neque enim quorumlibet disputationes quamvis Catholicorum laudatorum hominum velut seripturas Canonicas habere debemus ut nobis non liceat salvâ Honorificentiâ quae illis debetur hominibus aliquid in eorum seriptis improbare Talis ego sum in scriptis aliorum Tales volo esse intellectores meorum S. Aug. Ep. 3. V. Ep. 19. ad S. Hier. Chilingw Pref. §. 25. themselves refused any other kind of honour or respect frequently admonishing the Reader that he admit their opinions or interpretations but so far as he sees them agree with the Holy Writings So that since Protestants are bound by Canon to follow the ancient Fathers whosoever doth so with sincerity it is utterly impossible he should be a Papist And indeed the Reverence of the Church of England to the ancient Fathers as it is most regular and well govern'd so it is most uniform and constant whereas nothing is more ordinary with the Romanists than when they are prest and urg'd by the authority of the ancient Fathers against them to depreciate their testimonies and add some scurvy false insinuations concerning them as hath been often observed of C. Baronius Bellarmine Stapleton and others Whereas the constant Reverence of the Church of England to the ancient Fathers is such that the Romanists cannot but acknowledge it very often as De Cressy a Exomolog p. 102. 135. saith Indeed the Protestants in England make honourable mention of the Fathers They profess greater Reverence to Antiquity than any other Sect whatsoever § 4. There are many things of excellent use in themselves which come to be suspected and reproached because of the abuse they have had in the Roman Church Of which Tradition may be a great instance Because the Church of Rome hath made Tradition equal if not superiour to Holy Scripture therefore others run to the other extreme of undervaluing all kind of good and lawful Tradition not considering that Holy Scripture is Tradition Recorded And forgeting that in the Church of God one great proof of the integrity of the Canon of Holy Scripture it self hath been always Tradition which these men so confidently despise There are also some Traditions not contrary to the Holy Scripture which if they be rightly qualify'd have and ought to have great authority with us Wherefore upon all occasions is celebrated among us that famous passage of Vincentius Lirinensis b Vinc. Lir. adv Haer. c. 3. Whatsoever is universally delivered which every where which always which of all is believed that is accounted as indubitable and certain We receive not saith Bishop Bramhall to M. Militiere your upstart Traditions nor unwritten Fundamentals but we admit genuine universal Apostolical Traditions And we are so far from believing Tradition without allowing the Papacy That one of the
nearer are they coming to them sundry ways as in opposite Errors the Causes may be commonly the same Thus Arch-Bishop Laud * Pref. of the Conference against Fisher observed The Rigid Professors on either side have quite leaped over the Mean and have bin rigid the other way as Extremity it self and is a very natural motion For a Man is apt to think he can never run far enough from that which he once begins to hate Of which sort the several Factions and Interests among us have bin continually like the Friars at the Council of Trent who were always watchful and zealous to maintain their peculiar Doctrines among which extremes our Church if she might be listened to would reduce all to a due temper upon surer and more reasonable Foundations than the Bishops at that Council laboured to do 3. As our Laws by one name call both sorts of Separatists Recusants so our Romanists and Sectaries behave themselves much alike The one have their private Masses the other their Conventicles both contrary to the Laws of our Kingdom and our Church Both the Romanists and the Separatists join in requiring a License for the Exercise of their Religion in private Houses 4. Both our Romanists and Sectaries by encreasing our Divisions help with joint force to make a general Toleration necessary which would give the Romanists the greatest advantage they can desire They both supplicate with equal earnestness to be tolerated whereas the Principles of each lead them not to tolerate others 5. Their pretences to all mildness and gentleness are equally supple and assuring but how mild they are when they are uppermost odious experience testifies so that Instances of their extreme Rigors which are most known need not be enumerated We need not call on the Inquisition to testify to the Rigors of the Romanists nor look into all the Severities of the Disciplinarians who have bin known to inflict Censures for a suspicion of Covetousness a superfluity in Raiment for dancing at a Wedding for using their Liberty in their Recreations and have kept others as well as themselves from the Sacrament of the Lord's Supper upon uncharitable Accounts It hath bin observed where the Discipline in Scotland was established the People had a high Commission in every Parish and groan'd under the Arbitrary Decrees of Ignorant Governors If there arose a private Jar between the Parent and the Child the Husband and the Wife these Domestical Judges must know it Formerly and lately among some they have bin scarce allowed in Conscience to marry without the consent of the Teacher or when they have it hath bin matter of complaint 6. It hath bin already observed at large Chap. 13. § 58. how both the Romanists and the Separatists agree in their groundless and unjust accusing the Government of Persecution like the Donatists of old who cried out Persecution when they most of all had afflicted the Catholics The Romanists have their dire Anathema's and heavy Censures the Separatists their cruel Maranatha's and preach Damnation most of all against them that differ from them especially if they be of the Church's side 7. Nevertheless both sorts can very easily give out Indulgences to their own Parties God sees no sin in his Children say some Sectaries Which is a greater Bribe to be of their Party than any can be found in the Penitentiary Tax for Sins as they are sold at Rome 8. When the Papists and the Separatists have bin at a loss that they cannot justify their Proceedings by the Laws of God or Man then they meet in one common Sanctuary whereby they are bold to sanctify the most extravagant Practices pretending Providence for their Warrant Thus Pope Pius 5. in his Speech in the Consistory of Cardinals at Rome after the murder of King Hen. 3. of France sundry times in one Oration he magnifies the Exploit of that wretched Zealot as brought about by the special Providence of God * Non nisi Dei opt Max. particulari Providentiâ dispositione perpetratum The same impudence or ignorance others have used to defend such Practices as no Laws Divine or Humane could justify sheltring them under the wide pretence of Providence which hath bin well call'd †Answer to Mr. Jenkins p. 16. Regiment politicum fundatur in extraordinarià Dei Providentiâ Ibid. p. 15. A fine pliable Principle it will lap about your finger like Barbary Gold 9. The Romanists enlarge their Creed in sundry Articles without belief of which there is no Salvation and very many Separatists deliver their peculiar Doctrines as absolutely necessary to a state of Salvation tho among the divided Sects many of them are contrary one to another They both often stuff their Prayers and their Chatechisms with Matters of doubtful Controversy and in maintaining the same they are alike too dogmatical 10. We need not here prove what is so well known namely the mean Opinion which the Romanists have of Holy Scriptures supposing they receive their Authority from the Pope yet receiving their own Traditions with equal affection and reverence The Separatists by casting off to another extreme the real Authority and Testimony of God's Church which hath bin all along the Keeper the Witness the Defender the Interpreter of Holy Scriptures by degrees many of our Separatists have come to throw off the Holy Scriptures as a Rule of Faith and Manners The Romanists they add their own Traditions to the Word of God and many Sectaries call their Teaching and their Impulses the Word of God which often is quite contrary thereunto The Romanists set up the Pope for an Infallible Interpreter many of the Separatists account the Private Spirit an Infallible Interpreter V. Ch. 4. § 3. 11. The Romanists pretend that Miracles and extraordinary Gifts have not ceased but are still necessary Signs of a true Church It is also the very height of Enthusiam to hold as many of our Separatists do That Immediate Revelations from God and extraordinary Illapses from the Holy Spirit are necessary and common among all the Faithful Which Pretences lying obvious to an easy Confidence cannot easily be wrested from such as will hold them to their own destruction 12. The Romanists assert an implicit Faith which is determinately resolved into the authority of their Leaders Whether the like is ever required by the Leaders generally of Factions among us I do not now enquire But however that the same is granted by their Followers appears most evident For when many can give no reason for what they hold they keep close to their Ring-leaders and move and change with them generally and how much the Authority of the Persons they have in admiration governs them more than any sway of Argument is daily experienced And whereas a due regard on this side the implicit Faith of the Romanists is due to Governors V. Ch. 6. § 9 10. toward such how scrupulous delicate and wary are they not to say disregardful but in following their Masters of
5. In her Orders also for dispensing the Holy Scripture to all within her Communion § 6. In governing the reading of the Scripture and communing on the same § 7. In her judgment of the Canonical and Apocryphal Books § 8. The Divine Authority of the Holy Scripture our Church rather doth take for granted than prove too laboriously or uncertainly § 9. All immoderate extravagancies concerning interpretation of Holy Scripture avoided by our Church p. 48 Chap. V. Of the Moderation of the Church in applying the Rule of Faith to it self § 1. Avoiding extremes on either hand in relation to the authority of the Vniversal Church § 2. The Decrees of Councils § 3. The Testimony of the Fathers § 4. Other Traditions § 5. Our Churches own Testimony § 6. The use of Reason § 7. The Testimony of the Spirit § 8. Of the testimony and operation of the Holy Spirit the judgment of our Church according to great Moderation more largely declared p. 77 Chap. VI. The Moderation of the Church in its judgment of Doctrines § 1. Our Church doth wisely distinguish between what is necessary for Salvation and what is not § 2. Her Articles are few § 3. Which are generally exhibited not as Articles of Faith but consent Concerning subscription § 4. Our Articles are propounded so as to avoid unnecessary controversy § 5. The wise Moderation of the Kings of England in their Injunctions to Preachers and Orders taken to preserve Truth Vnity and Charity § 6. The Controversies of the late Age are well moderated by the determinations of our Church § 7. As our Church requires our consent in nothing contrary to sense or reason so it hath also contain'd it self from immoderate curiosity in treating of venerable mysteries § 8. Our Church doth not insist upon such kinds of certainty as others without just cause do exact § 9. Doctrines are so propounded to those in our Churches Communion as not to render useless their own reasons and judgments The reasonableness of which is proved and the Objections answered § 10. The use which we are all allowed of our private judgments is requir'd to be menag'd with a due submission to the Church The duty of which submission is laid down in sundry Propositions p. 114 Chap. VII Of the Moderation of our Church in what relates to the worship of God § 1. Our Prayers are not mingled with controversy § 2. They are framed according to a most grave and serious manner with moderate variety and proper length § 3. In the zeal of Reformation our Church did not cast off what was good in it self § 4. In all our Churches there are the same Rules § 5. Common Prayers for the vulgar required in English To Ministers and Scholars a just and moderate liberty allowed § 6. The obligation of the Church leaves the method of private Devotions to a general liberty § 7. Of the Moderation of the Church in appointing her hours and times of Prayer § 8. In her use and judgment of Sermons § 9. In what is required of people with reference to their Parish Church § 10. The excellent Moderation of the Church in her Orders for the reverent reading of Divine Service and Consecrating the Sacraments in such a voice as may be heard § 11. In her Form and use of Catechizing § 12. The interest of inward and outward worship are both secured according to an excellent Moderation in our Church § 13. The Moderation of the Church in what relates to Oaths p. 166 Chap. VIII Of the Moderation of the Church in relation to Ceremonies § 1. In the Ceremonies of our Church which are very few and those of great antiquity simplicity clear signification and use our Church avoids either sort of superstition § 2. They have constantly been declared to be in themselves indifferent and alterable but in that our Church avoids variableness is a further proof of its Moderation § 3. They are professed by the Church to be no part of Religion much less the chief nor to have any supernatural effect belonging to them § 4. Abundant care is taken to give plain and frequent reasons and interpretations of what in this nature is enjoined to prevent mistakes § 5. The Moderation of our Church even in point of Ceremonies compar'd with those who have raised so great a dust in this Controversy § 6. Many innocent Rites and usages our Church never went about to introduce and why § 7. The Obligation of our Church in this matter is very mild § 8. The Moderation of our Church in her appointment of Vestments § 9. The Benedictions of our Church are according to great Piety and Wisdom ordered § 10. The Moderation of our Church in her appointments of Gestures § 11. Of the respect which is held due to places and things distinguished to Gods Service our Church judgeth and practiseth according to an excellent Moderation p. 201 Chap. IX Of the Moderation of our Church with respect to Holy-Days namely both the Feasts and Fasts of the Church § 1. The Feasts of the Church are few and those for great reason chose with care to avoid the excesses of the Romanists § 2. The further behaviour of the Church in her Feasts most useful and prudent § 3. We celebrate the memory of Saints but of none whose existence or sanctity is uncertain § 4. The excellent ends of our Churches honour to Saints are set down § 5. That they are Festivally Commemorated not out of opinion of worship or merit or absolute necessity thereof to Religion § 6. Our Church runs not into any excess in any Prayer to Saints § 7. Nor with reference to Images § 8. Whether our Church in any of these practices be justly charged of Popery by those who Canonize among themselves those who are of uncertain sanctity § 9. The Moderation of our Church in its honour given to Angels § 10. And to the Blessed Virgin § 11. Our Church hath taken great care that a special honour be had to the Lords Day and that the Lords Day nor any other Festival be abused to Luxury and Impiety § 12. The Moderation of the Church with reference to its Musick and Psalmody § 13. The Moderation of our appointed Fast The Lenten or Paschal Fast how far Religious by the Precept of the Church p. 234 Chap. X. Of the Moderation of the Church in reference to the Holy Sacraments § 1. The Moderation of our Church raiseth no strife about words relating thereunto § 2. Her Moderation in what is asserted of the number of Sacraments § 3. In that her Orders for the Administration of the Sacraments are most suitable to the ends of their appointments § 4. In that our Church doth not make the benefit of the Sacraments to depend upon unrequired conditions In reference to Holy Baptism § 1. Our Church doth make nothing of the essence of Baptism but the use of the invariable Form § 2. The Moderation of our Church toward Infants unbaptized
measures namely leave to determine their particular actions according to the general Rule of Holy Scriptures and sometimes of Prudence where other Laws are not given to determine their Liberty And indeed this Article of the sufficiency of the Scriptures and the use of them as a Rule is the very dividing point at which those of the Separation on either hand leave our Church and her Moderation at once For those who are ready on one hand to receive all Traditions which the Church of Rome can offer with affection and reverence equal to the written word of God so that as it is in our Homily c Homily of good works 3 d. Part. The Laws of Rome as they said were to be received of all men as the four Evangelists No Moderation can contain the extravagancies such belief leads them to On the other hand to accept of no appointment for outward order and government in the Church or Kingdom but what is set out in the express word of God for the direction of every particular action under pretence of defending Christian Liberty is verily so gross and unreasonable a Pharisaical confining it that this principle is the first Sanctuary of ignorance and disobedience in most of our Separatists who under an immoderate pretence to Religion and the honour of Scriptures really offer great abuse and disservice to both as it is a real abuse to a person though of honour to give him Titles which do not belong to him so it is an occasion to Atheists and prophane persons captiously to detract from the true perfection of Holy Writings when they find attributed to them such Titles as are false and imaginary We must take heed saith the judicious Hooker d Eccles Pol. l. 3. §. 8. lest in attributing to Scripture more than it can have the incredibility of that do cause even those things which it hath most abundantly to be less reverently esteemed On this foundation of our Churches Moderation in what she judgeth concerning the perfection of Holy Scripture both the Protestant and the Christian Religion is established For as Bishop Sanderson saith e Pref. to his Sermons The main Article of the Protestant Religion is The Holy Scriptures are a perfect Rule of Faith and manners so the very mystery of Puritanism is That no man may with a safe Conscience do any thing for which there may not be produced either command or example in Scripture § 3. We are to note the Moderation of the Church in her judgment of the letter and sense of Holy Scripture and in the use of such consequences as are duly drawn from thence Whereas the Romanists 1. look on the letter of Holy Scripture but as so many dead and unsensed Characters f Richworth's Dialogues J. S. Sure-footing of variable and uncertain signification g Niâ— Cusâ—nus Card. Ep. 7. ad â—â—hem 2. They make the sense of Scripture entirely depend on the Authority of their Church h V. Concil Trid. Sess 4. Decret de usu S. Scr. 3. They presume the Church of Rome only can make authentick all the Books of Holy Scripture i Nullum Capitulum nullusque liber Canonicus habetur absque illius authoritate Greg. 7. Dict. 16. in Concil Rom. and by her sole Authority is to determine which are to be Canonical 4. They will not allow the clear consequences of Scripture to prove any matter of doctrine k V. Discourse upon a Conference Apr. 3. 1676. In these as in many other instances our Sectaries generally agree with the Romanists 1. They also make the Holy Scripture a dead Letter without their interpretation 2. In making the sense which they vouch to be the Word of God 3. Such Scriptures as seem to serve their turn they allow others they reject 4. The clear consequences from Holy Scriptures against them they cast by as only the results of carnal reason Between these two opposers of Holy Scripture at present there appears this difference instead of an external infallible Interpreter on one side the other sets up the witness of their own private spirit for an infallible interpreter also When time serves They that make the difference can compromise it Amidst these extremes observe we the Wisdom and Moderation of the Church of England 1. It gives all due honour to the Letter of Holy Writ referring her self and her Sons chiefly to the Originals l V. B. of Homilies passim Caeterùm in lectione D. Scripturarum si quae occurrerint ambigua vel obscura in V. Test earum interpretatio ex fonte Hebraicae veritatis petatur in N. autem Graeci codices consulantur Reform Leg. Eccles de fide Cathol c. 12. using all care in keeping the Letter of Holy Scripture and preserving the Originals and setting them forth correctly and translating them as faithfully as may be 2. The sense of Scripture our Church accounteth chiefly as Scripture viz. The Word of God therein The mind of God being thought by our Church to consist not in words but in sense For is the Kingdom of God words and syllables m Translators of the Bible Pres 3. The clear consequences in Scripture are in our Church accounted a good proof in matters of doubtful Doctrine Whatsoever is not read therein nor proved thereby is not to be required saith our sixth Article Wherefore Mr Chillingworth n Chillingworth 's Pref. § 28. did not without reason thus declare I profess sincerely I believe all those Books of Scripture which the Church of England accounts Canonical to be the infallible word of God I believe all things evidently contained in them or even probably deducible from them o Simpliciter necessaria Rex appellat quae vel expressè Verbum Dei praecipit vel ex verbo Dei necessaria Consequentiâ vetus Ecclesia elicuit Rex Jacobus ad Card. Perr § 4. In our Church no one Version nor more are made equal much less superiour to the original Nothing is declared authentick but what is judged truly and originally so Although the Church of Rome hath declared the vulgar Translation to be only the authentick Scripture p Conc. Trid. Sess 4. Decr. 2. according to which all points in Question are to be decided and though the same in our Church hath been convinced by sundry learned men of some imperfections yet wherein it is most faithfully performed the innovations of Popery even from thence may be sufficiently manifested Other ancient Versions and Translations which have been of Holy Scripture our Church is so far from rejecting or undervaluing that it hath made great use of them and doth constantly acknowledge their usefulness and doth esteem them according to their antiquity and the approbation they have had in the Church of God Yea in the worst of our late times when the true Church of England was most of all accused of Popery and opposition to the Scriptures then were sundry learned and religious Sons of the Church diligently
Religion than the Holy and Divine inspired Scriptures with Melancthon and the Church of England I wish all Doctrines of Faith were brought to us derived from the Fountain of Scripture by the Channels of Antiquity otherwise what end will there be of innovation And thus our King James of Happy Memory did declare in the words of St Austin That what could be proved the Church held and observed from its first beginning to those Times That to reject He did not doubt to pronounce to be an insolent piece of madness So that the counsel and judgment of the Church of England seems to be moderated according to the Sentence of St Hierom in his Epistle to Minerva My purpose is to read the Ancients to prove all to hold fast what is good and never to depart from the Faith of the Catholick Church and conformably King Charles I. h His Majesties fifth Paper to Mr. Henders My Conclusion is That albeit I never esteemed any Authority equal to the Scriptures yet I do think the unanimous consent of the Fathers and the universal practice of the Primitive Church to be the best and most authentical Interpreters of Gods word For who can be presumed to understand the Doctrine and practice of the Christian Religion better than those who lived in the first and purest times Wherefore i Of Heresy §. 14. Dr Hammond reckons it among the piè Credibilia that a truly general Council cannot erre § 3. And because the Catholick Church is and hath been so much divided and the Monuments of the ancient Church Universally accepted do contain but a few determinations Therefore the Church of England moderately remits her Sons to the first four general Councils as in the 28th year of K. Henry 8. k Fullers Eccl. Hist ad An. 1536. it was Decreed That all ought and must utterly refuse and condemn all those opinions contrary to the said Articles contained in the three Creeds contained in the four Holy Councils that is to say in the Council of Nice Constantinople Ephesus and Chalcedon and all other since that time in any point consonant to the same So in the Institution of a Christian Man set forth 1537. and approved by the Convocation 1543. 't is there said A true Christian man ought and must condemn all those opinions contrary to the twelve Articles of the Creed which were of a long time past condemned in the four Holy Councils that is to say c. Isaac Casaubon also in the name of King James to Cardinal Perron saith l Primo R. Eliz. c. 1 The King and the Church of England do admit the four first Oecumenical Councils and following the judgment of the Church the Law of the Kingdom doth declare m Dicimus Ecclesiam Britannicam adeò venerari Concilia generalia ut speciali statuto caverit nè quisquam spirituali jurisdictione praeditus praesumat censuras suas Ecclesiasticas aliter distringere vel administrare aut quicquam Haereticum pronunciare quod non à scripturis Canonicis quatuor Conciliis generalibus aut alio quocunque Concilio pro tali judicatum fuerit J. B. de antiq libertate Eccl. Brit. Thes 4. That none however Commission'd shall in any wise have authority or power to order or determine or adjudge any matter or cause to be Heresy but only such as heretofore have been determin'd ordered or adjudged to be Heresy by the authority of the Canonical Scriptures or by the first four general Councils or any of them or by any other general Council wherein the same was declared Heresy by the express and plain words of the said Canonical Scriptures or such as hereafter shall be ordered judged or determined to be Heresy by the Court of Parliament of this Realm with the Clergy in their Convocation Thus the authority of the four first general Councils are placed by our Church in the superiour order of Tradition forasmuch as Spalatensis according to St Austin n A plenariis Conciliis tradita Quarum est in Ecclesiâ salubrâ—â—ima authoritas S. Aug. Ep. 118. speaks of such Councils they have obtained a wholsom authority because from the Apostolick Declarations faithfully received they have explained the Holy Scriptures and beside because they have been approved by the Universal Church which with great reason contradicts what Curcellaeus p Curcell Rel. Christianae Instit l. 1. c. 15. hath delivered to depreciate the honour even of the first four Oecumenical Councils So that Mr Cressy in Answer to Dr Pierce might very well cite the Protestant acknowledgments of the Authority of Councils as that of Ridley Acts and Mon. p. 1288. Councils indeed represent the Vniversal Church and being so gathered together in the name of Christ they have the promise of the gift and guiding of the Spirit into all truth To the same purpose are named Bishop Bilson Hooker Potter c. Instead of all these he might have owned if he had pleased the judgment of our Church it self giving all due honour to general and Provincial Councils whose wholsome Decrees she hath accepted and imitated Yea our Church maintains the right of Provincial Synods taken away by the See of Rome q Tertullianus veneratur Provinciale Concilium quasi esset Oecumenicam assentiente sc universali vel iis decernentibus secundùm universale quomodo fit repraesentatio totius nominis Christiani virtualiter tota Ecclesia Neither is this honour diminisht by the further Moderation which our Church hath shown in not taking those for Councils or general Councils which are not such as neither the Council of Florence nor Lateran nor of Trent and we know that our Articles though they are very moderately framed are many of them directly oppos'd to those of Trent being in those points of Doctrine wherein the Church of Rome hath departed from the Catholick Church and made her Doctrines of design more than truth the unjust conditions of Communion A truly free and general Council we look upon as the best expedient on Earth for composing the differences of the Christian World if it might be had but we cannot endure to be abused by meer names of Titular Patriarchs but real Servants and Pensioners of the Popes with Combinations of interested parties instead of general Councils r Dr. Stillingfleet's first Part of an Answer c. 284. When Pope Paul III. call'd a Council then to be held at Mantua and King Henry VIII refusing thither to send He defended his Protestation in a Letter to the Emperour and other Christian Princes 1538. In which the King declares t Acts and Monuments p. 11â—2 Truly as our Forefathers invented nothing more holy than general Councils used as they ought to be so there is almost nothing that may do more hurt to the Christian Faith and Religion than general Councils if they be abused to lucre to gains to the establishment of errors And verily we suppose that it ought not to be called a General
Churches Moderation The Ceremonies of our Church are but very few and those of great antiquity simplicity decency and clear signification hardly to be wrested to the prejudice of inward piety wherefore they are neither unprofitable nor burdensome of which they are charged in the Preface to the Directory Our Church avoiding extreams on one hand of the Church of Rome a Concil Trid. Sess 7. Can. 13. whose Ceremonies are so cumbersome for their number b Quia ad aures ipsorum totius sermè orbis justissimae querelae pervenerint de moderandâ corrigendâ onerosâ multitudine quorundam rituum Chemnit Examen ib. p. 34. that they make no end of commanding and forbidding till they come to the other extremity of moroseness of which humour St Austin c S. Aug. Ep. 118. in express words complains Religion which God in his mercy hath made free with few and clear Sacraments is made more burdensome than ever was the Jewish Wherefore our Church is most careful lest by any excess of Ceremonies Religion should be any wise obscured and by outward and sensible things the minds of people should be diverted to the neglect of what is inward and spiritual Therefore our Church in its Preface of Ceremonies why some be abolished complains That the excessive number of Ceremonies was so great and many of them so dark that they did more confound and darken than declare and set forth Christs benefits unto us On the other hand our Church avoids that other kind of superstition of those that consider not the frame of men nor the use and experience of having some Rites for comeliness and edification d V. Pref. to the Liturgy and for exciting Piety and Devotion in the publick worship of God Let me for the sake of those who rather will accept such a truth from Mr Perkins e Reformed Catholick 7. §. of Traditions repeat his words We hold that the Church of God hath power to prescribe Ordinances Rules or Traditions touching time and place of Gods worship and touching order and comliness to be used in the same and in this regard Paul 1 Cor. 11. 2. commendeth the Church of Corinth for keeping his Traditions and Acts 15. 29. the Council at Jerusalem decreed that the Churches of the Gentiles should abstain from blood and from things strangled this Decree is termed a Tradition and this kind of Traditions whether made by general or particular Synods we have a care to maintain and observe these Caveats being remembred f Ritus pauci numero sine sumptu minimè graves Grot. in Cassand Artic. 15. 1. That they prescribe nothing childish or absurd to be done 2. That they be not imposed as any part of Gods worship 3. That they be severed from superstition or opinion of merit Lastly That the Church of God be not burdened with the multitude of them And indeed a worthy instance of the prudent Moderation of the Church of England is that in her reformation from Rome she hath delivered her self from such an Endless g Europae Speculum p. 3. multitude of Superstitions and Ceremonies enough to take up a great part of a mans life to gaze on and peruse a huge sort of which are so childish and unsavoury that as they argue great silliness and rawness in their inventors so can they naturally bring no other than disgrace and contempt to those exercises of Religion wherein they are stirring Yet after the fashion of a modest and prudent Matron though our Church doth not appear tawdry drest with too great a variety of ill placed cost yet doth she endeavour always to appear discreet and comely in her attire On purpose retaining some Rites in respect to the practice of the antient Church and to vindicate her self from the imputation of moroseness and not to side with the other extreme of those who in the exercise of their Religion affect carelessness and neglect of any good Form The Church of England doth retain some Ceremonies in her Offices thereby also to vindicate real Christian Liberty namely the publick liberty of Gods Church one part of which as Bucer in the beginning of the Reformation well noted is for the Church to chuse its own Rites and also to vindicate the Liberty of private Christians who by the Orders of the Church have their choice directed for their own edification and the better order of Divine things For Diversity of Ceremonies in divers Churches do serve to testify the Christian Liberty and doth greatly conduce to teach the true judgment of Ceremonies namely that all men by this diversity may understand That those things which are not delivered in Holy Scripture are not necessary to Salvation but may be altered as the time and circumstance of edification doth require h Sprint's Necessity of Conformity in case of Deprivation p. 115. It a Forbesius in Irenico l. 1. c. 7. Harmon Confess p 194. Which reason of them though it hath been frequently repeated yet hath not sufficiently been taken notice of by those who pretend to be such Assertors of Christian Liberty who fall foul into another servile and unquiet sort of Superstition Yet when we consider the horrid stiff superstition of such Precisians whom the Moderation of the Church of England in point of Ceremonies doth affright We cannot think them so moped but others appear to have run into a greater excess of madness when we behold the exceeding number of Ceremonies and observances which the Roman Rubricks appoint in their Rituals Missals and Pontifical c. We may bless our selves who within the Communion of our Church are freed from such a bondage more grievous than the Jewish especially since their Rites many of which are so ridiculous and trifling i Vi. Pontificale Rom. de Ecclesiae Dedicatione p. 237. Vi. Rituale Rom. in absolvendo excommunicatum jam mortuum c. k Quando primò Clericis barbae tondentur dici debet Pontifice sedente cum mitrâ Antiphona Sicut Ros Hermon c. Pontificale p. 550. are not only approved but required by the Council of Trent under the pain of Anathema l Conc. Trid. Sess 7. Can. 13. and that for surer notice repeated in the first page of their Ritual Wherefore as Plutarch well saith of Religion it hath its place between contempt of divine things on one hand and superstition on the other So the Moderation of our Church is excellently tempered to keep Christians from Enthusiasm in one extreme and from what some call Rituality on the other m D. H. Mori Ethic. c. 5. p. 105. Of our Churches care in this last particular Bishop Taylor thus endeavours to satisfie some Consciences There is reason saith he to celebrate and honour the wisdom and prudence of the Church of England which hath in all her Offices retained but one Ritual or Ceremony that is not of Divine Ordinance or Apostolical practice and that is the Cross in Baptism which
wonder if they be called on so to do And who will not consent to that however hopeless desire if they will lay aside their Corruptions we may be all one Sheepfold under one Shephard Christ Jesus Concerning such Projects of Reconciliation with the Church of Rome which have been made long since by some of the most moderate of their own Communion and some other Learned Men amongst Protestants Of which Cassander's Consultation * Ergo istipii pacifici viri sunt omnes ficti simulati C. Bellarm. Tom. 2. l. 3. c. 19. with Grotius's Annotations also thereon are most common and famous Of these this may safely be said whether and to what degrees their Designs be approved or condemned however they have given abundant Proofs wherein the Church of Rome at present appears the more irreconcileable the more she is opposite to all such terms of Reconciliation which they have discoursed If some other Discourses have bin at any time made by any of our Communion referring to such Reconciliation with some Romanists they may be lookt upon only as such Suppositions as have bin among Learned Men generally discoursed thereby the more clearly to show the unreasonableness of the Romish Rigours But what-ever may be proposed as a meer Speculation the vanity of concluding upon any such Union as likely may appear from the Principles of the Church of Rome which are such if we take away her Corruptions we take away Popery it self Yet it must be acknowledged the Art of the Romanist even in such seeming Concessions is very notorious to gain such Points for themselves as may serve their present turns and may make afterwarward for the confirmation of their own Rigours But whatsoever some few among them promise what should be consented to by them is like an Agreement made by a Minor which is void as the Tutor and Governour shall please for we know not only what the nature of their Gifts are but also how they receive and return Concessions and Indulgences Wherefore such Proposals from any of our Communion are the more needless because the Principles of our Reformation are already so prudent and moderate As to some who have suspected an inclination in those of our Communion to pacification rather with the Romanists than with them We Answer 1. This is the nature of Aemulous Parties to be always thus jealous of any sorts of Communication with their Adversaries but so long as the Romanists and Sectaries have had the same kind of jealousy of the same sorts of Persons it is but a good proof of the real Moderation of our Church and of those of her Communion in opposition to all undue extreams Neither ought it to be interpreted Indifference Neutrality and Lukewarmness but impartial constancy to such Truth as is espoused for her own sake Sometime that jealousy hath bin raised of design to make the indiscreet sort of Men among us the more out of charity with our Church Notwithstanding it will be made out Ch. 17. § 7. that those who conform to the Church of England do not agree with the Papists so really as our Dissenters do Our dissenting Brethren often forget what hath bin performed by our Church in opposition to the Romish Corruptions and Errors and also for the sake of themselves They forget how often their Jealousies have proved groundless and untrue And it would do well for the time to come if the sincere among them would set down in some place by it self such jealousies of theirs and in the next Column over against would remark their own frequent mistakes Such forget also or seem never to have known how our Reformation hath bin approved of by the best Protestants And whereas they seem to pity the first Reformers as Men but half so much enlightned as themselves who look upon the Moderation of our Church but proportionable to the first crepuscular and duskish Light of those Times in this Matter they speak like those who have received some Traditions at second-hand from Cartwright but never compar'd his Writings with Arch-Bishop Whitgift and as they do not seem to consider the full knowledg and consideration which our Reformers had of the Principles and Abuses of Popery and the diligent eye they had also to such other Reformations as before ours had their perfection so they do not consider that our present Establishment was constituted with respect to our Protestants of the greatest aversation from Rome It is much to be feared that those that clamour most of us for pacification with the Romanists so little understand what they would have that because the Romanists hold as Mr. Perkins sheweth Reformed Catholic the same necessary Heads of Religion with us they seem willing and contented we should renounce sundry Articles of our Creed that we may be sure not to agree with them And this is spoken upon good grounds for many of our Protestant Dissenters as they are called do as it is too well known not by Consequence only but in direct terms deny many I may say of these few first Fundamental Verities of Common Christianity as 't is a sad thing to say it may be shewn at large and yet nevertheless what kindness what friendship what Correspondence is practised and encouraged by them daily with these Friends who are less suspected or reviled than the true and firm Protestants of the Church of England And whereas they commonly say That the Church of England and the chief of Her Communion are unwilling to allow any Pacification with or Concessions to Protestant Dissenters as may be reasonable for public Concord We Answer 1. They are utterly mistaken in saying so for beside that the conditions of Communion with our Church are very equal and just We may presume to say also from what our Church hath done and hath declared She is willing to do and from the disposition of Her Communion there is no doubt but our Church would gladly in such things as she might remit of what she judgeth otherwise expedient for the ends of Peace and Universal Concord if she could be assured any reasonable Concessions should have that effect as might suit with the true Honour of God and the real good of the Church Uniformity in Religious and Ecclesiastical Matters sure is so excellent and desirable a gain that certainly an establishment somewhat less perfect with being of the same mind so far as we have attained and with a regular and effectual observation of good Laws is more expetible than an appointment in some Circumstances more perfect without the same uniform order and peace therewith But how unequal is it that they should be the only Arbiters and Judges of Union who not only are great Authors of our Dissention but are at such great disagreements among themselves V. Ch. 18. § 2. Rule 10. and are so imperious and tyrannical in their disobedience as some of them are CHAP. XV. Of the Moderation of the Church toward other Churches and Professions
of Men. § 1. In that Vniversal Concord which our Church hath maintained with all so far as lawfully and usefully it may § 2. Her protesting against unsufferable Abuses well consisting with her Moderation and Charity § 3. Our Church leaveth other Churches to the use of their liberty and vindicateth that use mutually § 4. Her especial Moderation and Charity toward the Greek Church § 5. Our Church's Modesty and well-becoming Behaviour toward other Churches and their mutual affection unto Ours § 1. THe excellent temper of our Church is abundantly justified in that Universal Concord and Friendship it desires to maintain with all so far as may be done lawfully Our Church separates indeed as far as is possible from all that is vile and impure making her self as is the Church a Society distinct from Jews and Gentiles and by her Censures doth separate from those that are inordinate and in her own defence keeps her self from complying with sinful and unjust conditions of Communion Yet with the whole Church throughout the World and every part thereof to whom her Communion is not displeasing Our Church in desire and endeavour doth maintain all inward and outward agreement she can * Odia restringi favores convenit ampliari Reg. juris in affections and behaviour also so approving her self that it is manifest she unwillingly differs from any and no more than needs must Thus the 30 Canon of our Church Nay so far was it from the purpose of the Church of England to forsake reject the Church of Italy France Spain Germany or any such-like Churches in all things which they held and practised that as the Apologie of the Church of England confesseth it doth with reverence retain those Ceremonies which do neither endamage the Church of God nor offend the minds of sober Men and only departed from them in those points wherein they were fallen both from themselves in their Ancient Integrity and from the Apostolical Churches which were their first Founders Episcopal Divines saith Bishop Bramhall * Vindication p. 30. do not deny those to be true Churches where Salvation may be had § 2. Neither did our Church of England ever yet oppose it self to any lawful Ecclesiastical Authority which yet is inseparably of the Essence of Schism but on the contrary according to a singular Moderation * Ecclesia Britannica quâ est perpetuò in omnes Christianos singulari moderatione Christianâ dilectiene c. De Antiq. lib. Eccl. Brit. Thes 4. and Charity it doth open its Bosom to every genuine Son of the true Catholic Church of what denomination soever For it is one thing for any to frame to themselves a diverse Congregation and Religion separate from and opposite to the Universal Church as anciently did the Donatists and another thing not to communicate with some particular Persons and Places in some unwarrantable usages and that under express protestation from whence was occasion'd the moderate and innocent Title of Protestants †V. Cluverium Calvisii Chron. ad An. 1529. for protesting against the Edict at Worms which was for restoring all things as they were without Reformation By which Protestation all scandal of Schism is taken away and desire of reconciliation is publicly testify'd not as of absolute necessity but for the sake of Catholic Unity by which Protestation a right is vindicated from the usurpation of the Church of Rome who fondly calls her self not only Catholic but the Mother and Mistress of all other Churches by which she makes her self a public invader of common Ecclesiastical Right § 3. In Matters of Ecclesiastical Freedom The Church of England leaves always other Churches to their liberty and vindicates their right to the same * V. D Durell's View of the Reformed Churches As other Reformed Churches leave us to our liberty and vindicate the same Article 34. It is not necessary that Traditions and Ceremonies be in all places one V. Homily of Fasting or utterly like for at all times they have bin diverse and may be changed according to the diversities of Countries * Distant inter se linguae sed linguarum distantiae non sunt Schismata omnes linguâ ad uâ—am fidem S. Aug. in Joan. Times and Manners Every particular National Church hath Authority to ordain change and abolish Ceremonies or Rites †Pref. of of the Church the Cerem In these our doings we condemn no other Nations nor prescribe any thing but to our own People only According to the practice of S. Cyprian clearing himself to the African Bishops Judging none nor removing any from the right of Communion if they think somewhat diverse from us For which S. Austin * Cujus charitas non solâ—nt illius temporis Christianis sed etiam posteris ad medicinalem notitiam signatur S. Aug. de bapt l. 1. c. 18. commends S. Cyprian And as Tully †Ita dissensi ab illo ut in disjunctione sententiae conjuncti tamen amicitiâ maneremus Orat. pro provinc Consul spake of himself with relation to Caesar I so dissented from him that in the difference of our Opinion however we remained entire in our Friendship Of this mind also was St. Austin in matters of different Observances as to Times of Fasting and Days of Communicating All this saith he is matter of liberty and no practice is more worthy a grave and prudent Christian than to act so as he sees the Church doth unto which it happens he comes and as the Society doth in which he lives * S. Aug. Ep. 118. Ep. 86. And in these Matters of which the Holy Scripture appoints nothing expresly the Custom of the People of God and the Institutes of our Superiors are to be held for a Law Of which if we have a list to dispute and to disprove others for their different Custom there will arise endless Contests M. Amyrald * Galli Anglorum câ—tibuâ— libentissimè intersunt Eucharistiam ex eorum more participant Episcopis sese subjiciunt Angli pariter c. Amyraldi Irenicum p. 351. well observes the friendly moderation of the English and French Protestants when they are in each other Countries they readily join themselves with the Communion of the Churches they are in Yet such is the abundant Moderation of our Church That to Merchants and Strangers of other Churches are permitmitted their several Congregations and Churches And all Aliens of the Reformation have by Act of Uniformity an express provision made for their enjoyment of their own way of worship at the pleasure of his Majesty which is real proof that Conformity doth not prejudice Trade * V. Mod. Pleas for Comprehen answerd p. 210. ¶ Omnibus notum est quà m elementèr patiantur peregrinorum Ecclesias Ceremoniis ritibus uti diversis ab Anglicanâ Ecclesiâ Saravia de div grad Min. c. 24. And this tender care of other Churches Liberty which the Church
Factions how prone are they and sequacious 13. Both the Romanists and Sectaries to serve their turn upon occasion cast off the use of Reason wherein God hath made it a Guide Therefore they both reproach our Faith as a humane probable natural fallible Faith the one because we will not receive Oral Tradition and the like Uncertainties the other because we do not think an immediate extraordinary testimony of the Spirit necessary to assure us of the certainty we have of our Faith of the Truth of Holy Scriptures to afford us also our words in Prayer and the assurance of our Salvation 14. The Superstitions of the Papists are notorious and also of our Sectaries and so many they are not here to be numbred If Superstition be going beyond all measure their humour is to keep no Measure nor order but to heap one superfluous thing upon another and then they think God is pleased because they are Many of them account it a sign of Grace and the favour of God and matter of greatest Conscience not to hear or use Common Prayers nor any decent Rite or Practice required by the Church The Romanists invoke Saints of uncertain Sanctity Many of the Separatists call those of their own Party the only Saints and judg them to have the right to judg the World and in the mean time to rule it if they cannot do that they must censure what is done by others 15. The Romanists and our Enthusiasts are very much the same in their Pharisaical Humour described at large and reprehended by our Saviour Mat. 23. 4. To name only Their binding heavy Burdens and grievous to be born and laying them on Mens shoulders As the Romanists add twelve Articles to their Creed a wondrous number of Ceremonies to their seven Sacraments Not to mention more of their loads of Injunctions their Festivals their Auricular Confession their Vows their Scourgings and Fastings and Penances which they lay upon the Poor when the Imposers do not touch them with one of their fingers or with wetting the least of them they can get themselves an easy Dispensation Doth not the same Pharisaical Spirit possess many who make the Peace of the World and the Church depend upon their peculiar Doctrines Who make all they can think it a sin to come to Common-Prayer to kneel at the Sacrament to be Baptized according to Order of the Church to pray in a Form to wear a Surplice Instead of making broad their Philacteries and enlarging the Fringes of their Garments they have had another sort of Superstition in wearing their Hair in a precise cut somewhat like the tonsures of the Romanists some will not wear a Riband Others not Starch in their Bands nor pull off their Hat 16. The Council of Trent makes the Intention of the Priest necessary to the Sacraments Many of the Separation make the Spiritual Grace of the Minister absolutely necessary for the Peoples receiving benefit from the same 17. Both the Romanists and the Separatists use much the same kind of Arts to blast their Adversaries The Romanists have their Legends and Fables just so our Separatists love to pick up Stories of Bishops and the Clergy and to patch them together in enmity to our Church with these they keep up the humour of the People who entertain them with good things I wish such would remember what in Levit. 19. 16. the command is Thou shalt not go up and down a Tale-bearer among thy People which the Ghaldee Paraphrase interprets Non comedes Placentas in Populo tuo Thou shalt not go up and down among the People pacifying thy Appetite eating of their Delicates and to please them again tell tales of Governors * Apud Anglos est simile genus Hominum quoscirculatores Itali vocant qui irrumpunt in Convivia c. Erasm Eccles l. 3. 18. Most of our * Ineptè nobis tribuis Catharorum nomen cùm Cathari suos habuerint Episcopos quos nos omnes sublatos ex omnibus Ecclesiis optamus Altar Damasc p. 367. Separatists are highly against the Government in the Church by Bishops and in the Covenant the same is ranked with Superstition Heresy and Schism Even so the Jesuits who are the great Exalters of the Pope's Supremacy declare commonly against Bishops as if the source of all Disorders came from Bishops contending for their Jurisdiction which say they makes so many small Popes thus the Jesuits argue †V. C. Palavicini Hist Conc. Trid. l. 1. c. 25. Then it will follow that the Pope cannot dispose of things belonging to their Jurisdictions and then the Pope may be opposed by these Bishops which may be a ready way to overthrow the Papacy So that the Controversy who hath the Jurisdiction which belongs to Bishops in common nay who have such Jurisdiction by Divine Right is driven between the Court of Rome who challeng it to the Pope and other Consistories among us in Division from our Church Wherefore in opposition to Bishops the highest Papalins talk most of the Sovereign Power of the People because they hold the Interest of the Pope to be upheld by their veneration And by the Interest of the Jesuits for many years of late the Popish Faction in England have bin with-held from having any Titular Bishops And most of our Separatists would be glad there were no other thus in their opposition to Bishops they agree 19. Both the Romanists and Separatists extreamly agree in their Principles against the Civil Magistrate According to that of Bishop Lany * Serm. on 1 Thess 4. 11. The Papists and Presbyterians hunt in couples against the King's Power and Supremacy 'T is admirable to see how the Common-Wealths Men in the times of the late Rebellion received their Principles from the Ancient and Modern Writers of the Jesuits and other Papists and still agree with them in most of the Republican Doctrines and Tendencies of them to the like Practices Both the Papists and the others infringe the Authority of the King in Ecclesiastical Matters within his own Dominions Both deny the Right of Kings to call Synods and Ecclesiastical Convocations Both hold that Kings may be put out of all Ecclesiastical Communion Both deny the Supremacy of the King one attributes it to the Pope originally the other to the People And the same Arguments which the Pope useth for his Supremacy over Kings the Disciplinarians use for establishing their Soveraignty the one exempts all the Clergy from the Jurisdiction of the Supreme Magistrate and the other Disciplinarians in Scotland have now a long time endeavoured to have their Ministers exempted from the Punishments of the Civil Governour The pretence of the King's Authority against his Person was hatched under the Roman Territories and was made use of in the Holy League of France * Chr. Loyalty l. 2. c. 1. V. Fowlis of Pop. Treason◠c. The Rules for making a King become a Tyrant and then ceasing to be a King that it may