disput from Scripture against a Christian who receaveth and beleeveth the Scripture to be the word of God but hee must needs take himself to consequentiall prooffs for no Christian will deny what is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 literally and syllabically in Scripture but all the controversies of Faith or Religion in the Christian world were and are concerning the sense of Scripture and consequences drawne from Scripture 6. Argument If wee do not admit necessary consequences from Sripture to prove a jus divinum wee shall deny to the great God that which is a priviledge of the little Gods or Magistrates Take but one instance in our own age When the Earle of Strafford was impeached for high treason one of his defences was that no Law of the Land had determined any of those particulars which were proved against him to be high treason Which defence of his was not confuted by any Law which literally and syllabically made many of those particulars to be high treason but by comparing together of severall Lawes and severall matters of fact and by drawing of necessary consequences from one thing to another which made up against him a constructive treason If there be a constructive or consequentiall jus humanum there must be much more for the considerations before mentioned a constructive or consequentiall jus divinum CHAP. XXI Of an assurance of an interest in Christ by the marks and fruits of sanctification and namely by love to the Brethren Also how this agreeth with or differeth from assurance by the Testimony of the Spirit and whether there can bee any well grounded assurance without marks of grace T Is a right a safe a sure way to seek after and to enjoy assurance of our interest in Christ and in the Covenant of grace by the marks and fruits of Sanctification Which before I come to the proof of it that it may not be mistaken but understood aright take these three cautions first our best marks can contribute nothing to our justification but onely to our consolation cannot availe to peace with God but to peace with our selves gracious marks can prove our justification and peace with God but cannot be instrumentall towards it that is proper to faith Faith cannot lodge in the soule alone and without other graces yet faith alone justifies before God Secondly beware that marks of grace doe not lead us from Christ or make us looke upon our selves as any thing at all out of Christ. Thou bearest not the root but the root beares thee Christ is made unto us of God sanctification as well as righteousnesse Thy very inherent grace and sanctification is in Christ as light in the sunne as water in the fountaine as sap in the roote as money in the treasure 'T is thine onely by irradiation effluence diffusion and debursement from Jesus Christ. 'T is Christs by propriety thine onely by participation 'T is thy Union with Christ which conveighs the habits of grace to thy soule 'T is thy communion with Christ which stirs up actuateth and putteth forth those habits into holy dueties and operations 'T is no acceptable duetie no good fruit which flowes not from the inward acting and exerciseing of grace in the soule 'T is no right acting of grace in the soule which floweth not from habituall grace and a new nature 'T is no new nature which floweth not from Christ. Thirdly all thy markes will leave thee in the darke if the spirit of grace do not open thine eyes that thou mayest know the things which are freely given thee of God Hagar could not see the well though she was beside it till her eyes were opened Markes of grace are uselesse undiscernable and unsatisfactory to the deserted and overclouded soule These cautions being in our eye that we may not separat our markes either from the free grace of God or from Christ or from the spirit I proceed to the proof of that point which I propounded in the beginning First It may bee aboundantly proved from these Texts Psal 17. 3. and 119. 6. 2 Cor 1. 12. 1 John 1. 6 7. and 2. 3. and 3. 9 10 14. Secondly our passing from the state of nature and wrath into the state of grace and to bee in Christ is compared in Scripture to such things as are most decernable and perceptible by their proper markes 'T is called a passing from death to life from darknesse to light from being farre off to be near c. all which things are known by manifest and certaine evidences The spirit of grace is compared to fire water winde which are known by sensible signes Conversion is a returning of one who had turned away and is not returning discernable by certaine tokens The new creature is a good tree and is not a good tree known by good fruits Matth. 7. 17 18. Thirdly both in Philosophy and Divinity yea in common sense 't is allowed to reason from the effects to the causes here is burning therefore here is fire here is the blossoming of trees and flowers therefore it is spring and the Sunne is turning again in his course here is perfect day light therefore the Sunne is risen here is good fruit growing therefore here is a good tree 'T is a consequence no lesse sure and infallible here is unfeigned love to the brethen therefore here is regeneration here are spirituall motions affections desires acts and operations therefore here is spirituall life Fourthly the markes of grace have so much evidence in them as formeth in others of the Saints and servants of God a well grounded judgement yea perswasion of charity that those in whom they behold these markes are in the state of grace and regeneration If they could see into the hearts of others to bee sure of the sincerity and soundnesse of their graces they could have a judgement of certainty concerning them But this they cannot for who knowes the things of a man save the spirit of a man which is in him Sure a Saint may know more of himselfe then another Saint can know of him for hee is conscious to the sincerity of his owne heart in in those things whereof another Saint sees but the outside And unlesse one will say that a Saint can know no more of himself by marks then another Saint can know of him by the same markes it must needs be yeelded that a Saint may certainly and assuredly know himselfe by the marks of grace which are in him Fifthly without a tryall by markes wee cannot distinguish between a well grounded and an ill grounded assurance between a true and a false peace between the consolation of the Spirit of God and a delusion How many times doth a soule take Sathan for Samuell and how shall the soul in such a case be undeceived without a tryall by markes But it may bee objected that this remedy may prove and doth often prove no remedy for may not Sathan deceive the soule in the way of markes as well as without
or strengthning of the Soule in such a Testimony or assurance as it hath setled upon contrary to the Scripture And here is a great difference between these Antinomian principles and ours We hold the assurance or evidence of marks to be privative they yeeld no more but that it is at most cumulative to the evidence of the Spirit of God and of Faith For my part I dare not think otherwise but that person is deluded who thinks himlseffully assured of his interest in Christ by the voice of the Spirit of the Lord and by the evidence of Faith when in the mean time his Conscience cannot beare him witnesse of the least mark of true grace or Sanctification in him And I must needs hold that whatsoever voice in man speaking peace to him is antecedaneus unto and separated or disjoyned from all or any evidence of the marks of true although very imperfect Sanctification is not the voice of the Spirit of the Lord neither speaketh according but contrary to the written Word of God I heartily yeeld that the Spirit of the Lord is a Spirit of Revelation and it is by the Spirit of God that we know the things which are freely given us of God so that without the Comforter the Holy Ghost himself bearing witnesse with our Spirit all our marks cannot give us a plerophory or comfortable assurance But this I say that which we have seen described by the Antinomians as the Testimony of the Spirit of the Lord is a very unsafe and unsure evidence and speaks beside yea contrary to the written Word The Word speaks no peace to the wicked to the ungodly to hypocrits to morall Christians to the presumptuous to the self confident to the unmortified carnall professours to temporary believers Christ and his benefits are indeed offered and held foorth unto all that are in the Church and all cal'd upon to come unto Christ that they may have life in him and whoever cometh shall not be cast out this is certain but yet the Word speaks no peace nor assurance save to the humble and contrite to those that tremble at his word to those that are convinced of sin to those that do not regard iniquity in their hearts but hate sin with sincere hatred to those that believe on the Son of God that love the Brethren c. Now therefore the Spirit of the Lord which speaks not to the soul but according to the word of grace as is confessed doth not speak comfort or assurance to any others but these only And if a man would know certainly whether the voice or Testimony which speaks to his Spirit be a delusion or not he must to the Law and to the Testimony and search whether it speak according to this Word T is granted to us that if the voice which speaks peace in man be not according to the written word of God it is not the Spirit of the Lord. But withall t is cautiously declined by these men that the voice which speaks in the soul be tryed by the written word They tell us it is not the Word that maks us believe the Spirit But it is the Spirit that makes us give credit to the Word That it is only the Spirit of God that can truely satisfie the spirit of a man that it is his own testimony and not the spirit of Delusion That as in all Arts and Sciences there are some Principles beyond which there must be no inquiry so also in divine things Is there any thing in the world of better credit or that may rather be believed with men then the Spirit himself Nay can any believe but by this Spirit If not then nothing else is able satisfyingly to bear witnesse to the Spirit but it self This is as if we should receive the Testimony of the Spirit upon the credit of some other thing Whereunto I answer first T is to be remembred The question is not whether the Word of the Lord can satisfie or pacifie a sinners conscience without the Spirit for we say plainly that as the best marks of grace so the richest and sweetest promises and comforts of the word cannot make the soule sit down satisfied till the spirit of the Lord himself speak peace and comfort within us Whence it was that after Nathan had said to David in the name of the Lord The Lord hath put away thy sin thou shalt not die yet even then David prayed Make me to hear joy and gladnesse that the bones which thou hast broken may rejoice Restore unto me the joy of thy Salvation and uphold me with thy free Spirit Psal. 51 8 12. with 2 Sam. 12 13 But t is another thing which is here in question for clearing whereof observe that the efficient cause or revealing evidence which maks us believe and be assured is one thing The objectum fomale fidei or that for which we believe and are assured is another thing In humane sciences a Teacher is necessary to a young Student yet the Student doth not believe the conclusions because his Teacher teacheth him so but because these conclusions follow necessarily from the known and received principles of the Sciences and although he had never understood either the principles or the conclusions without the help of a Teacher yet he were an ill scholler who cannot give an accompt of his knowledge from demonstration but only from this that he was taught so In seeking a legall assurance or security we consult our Lawyers who peradventure will give us light aud knowledge of that which we little imagined yet a man cannot build a wel grounded assurance nor be secure because of the Testimony of Lawyers but because of the deeds themselves Charters Contracts or the like So we cannot be assured of our interest in Christ without the work of the holy Ghost and his revealing evidence in our hearts yet the ground and reason of our assurance or that for which we are assured is not his act of revealing but the truth of the thing it self which he doth reveal unto us from the word of God Secondly this is not to receive the Testimony of the Spirit upon the credit of some other thing for the Spirit that speaketh in the Word is not another thing from the Spirit that speaketh in our hearts and saith we are the Children of God when we receive the Testimony or evidence in our hearts upon the credit of the Word we receive it upon the Holy Ghosts own credit comparing spirituall things with spirituall as the Apostle saith The holy Scripture is called a more sure word then that voice of God which came from heaven concerning his welbeloved Sonne 2 Pet. 1. 17 18 19. and so by parity of Reason if not a fortiori the written word of God is surer then any voice which can speak in the soule of a man and an inward Testimony may sooner deceive us then the written word can which being so we may and ought to try the voice
2. 8. 1 Ioh 2. 23. 2 Epis vers 9. or holy Ghost Ioh 14. 17. Thirdly as the infection of sinne spreadeth it self throughout the whole soule and all the faculties and powers thereof so doth the worke of the Spirit of God Wee finde light and holinesse 1 Pet. 2. 9. joyned together like the Vrim and Thummim See also 1 Thes 5. 23. here is both Soul and Spirit sanctified which two are plainly distinguished Heb. 4. 12. The word of God is so quick and powerfull as that it pierceth even to the dividing asunder of the Soul and Spirit if either the intellectuals be not sound or if the vitals and animals bee not right the word will finde it out A well meaning pious soul a good heart and affection which perhaps a person may sit down satisfied with will not excuse a corrupt minde an erroneous spirit neither will a sound and orthodox judgement excuse a corrupt heart and inordinat affections Aristotle himself could distinguish Art and knowledge from vertue because the most excellent intellectuals cannot make a man so much as morally vertuous without the practise and exercise of vertue Both soul and spirit both the inferior and superior part of the soule must be sanctified Reason is as the helme the affections as the sailes let the helme bee stirred never so right if the winde either blow not at all or blow crosse in the sailes the ship makes no speed in her way let the winde blow never so faire and fill all the sailes yet if the helme be off ' its hingers or be not rightly stirred the ship may quickly run upon a rock or run a shore where 't is not saife so he that hath a sound judgement without good affections cannot move heaven ward He that hath good affections without a sound judgement will make more haste than good speed Reason is as the rider affections as a nimble horse a man is but in an ill taking if either this rider mistake his way or the horse run away with him out of the way having no raines to governe him or if the horse be lame and cannot ride Fourthly consider what the Apostle saith 2 Tim. 3. 16. 17. He tels us of foure ends and uses of Scripture the first two are commonly referred to doctrinals the last two to practicalls the Scripture is profitable for Doctrine for reproof for correction for instruction in righteousnesse that the man of God may bee perfect throughly furnished unto ali good works If any of these be wanting a Christian is not perfect so much as in the perfection of parts He is but halfe a Christian who is an orthodox beleever if he be not practicall also and he is but halfe a Christian who is practicall if he bee not an orthodox beleever These ends of Scripture do not consist nor stand sure one without another Fifthly to bee led into all truth and preserved from error is a work of the spirit of truth and this spirit of the truth is the Comforter and the spirit of sanctification which spirit the Mediator prayeth the Father to give unto those that are his Ioh 14. 16 17. and 16. 13 14. 1 Ioh 2. 27. no promise of being led into all truth but to those that receave the anoynting of the holy Ghost Isa. 54. 13 Psal 25. 12. Sixthly by how much a man falls from the truth by so much he falls from grace and by how much a man falls from grace by so much he falls from the truth for stability in the statâ—… of grace dependeth in a manner upon stability in the truth for proof whereof mark three Ifs Christs Ioh. 8. 31. Pauls Col 1. 23. Iohnes 1 Ioh. 2. 34. Again stability in the truth dependeth upon stability in grace For proof whereof marke a fourth If 1 Ioh. 2. 19. These Scripturall Ifs have much in them and should make us very cautious and headfull that we do not so farre deceave our selves as to divide what God hath joyned together a sound head and a sound heart Chrysostome exhorteth his hearers to joyn Christian vertues and purity of doctrines together for saith he it profiteth us nothing to be orthodox if the life be vitiated as upon the other part a uncorrupt life profiteth nothing without soundnesse of faith licentiousnesse of judgement in Doctrines will certainly introduce licentiousnesse of heart and life in practicalls Arminius himself although many of his followers have cryed up Septicisme in Religion could say that different doctrines produce in a people a dubitation or hesitation concerning Religion that this doubting of the truth produceth despairing to finde the truth and thence followes Atheisme and Epicurisme yet when Heresies and false Doctrines introduce Atheisme Epicurisme they do but discover those roots of bitternes which were before in the heart Therefore as Christ tells those Jews that beleeved on him if they continue not in his word they are not his disciples indeed Ioh 8. 31. so the Apostle Iohâ—… gives this reason why Simon Magâ—…s Hymeneus Alexander Philetus Meâ—…ander Carpocrates Basilides Ebion Cerinthus and such like went out and separated from the Church and from the profession of the truth because saith he they were not of us meaning in respect of lively faith true grace and regeneration therefore they went out from us 1 Ioh 2. 19. which Text in Iohn Hierome in the close of his first book upon Ieremiah applyes to Hereticks in this respect when they fall away openly they doe but shew those very idols of their hearts which in their in ward parts they worshipped before I will adde a seventh reason look how the Scripture distinguisheth the Elect from those who are of an ungodly life in the same manner it distinguisheth them who are of an erroneous beleif 1 Cor 11. 19 the Apostle 2 Thes 2. 10 11. tells us that these who perish beleeve a lie i. e. an error pretending to be a truth but vers 13. he gives thanks for the beleeving Thessalonians because God had chosen them to saâ—…vation through sanctification of the spirit and beleif of the truth so that they who beleeve not the truth are no more elected then the unsâ—…nctified Our Saviour Mat 24. 24. intimateth that it is impossible that the Elect should be deceaved by false prophets that is in the same sense as he that is borne of God doth not commit sin 1 Ioh 3. 9. Christ characterizeth his true disciples and distinguisheth them from others not onely by obedience and a good life Mat 7. 17. 24. and 25. 35. Ioh 13. 35. but also by light in the eye of the understanding Matth 6. 22. 23. with Ephes 1. 17. 18. by continuing in his word Ioh 8. 31. by knowing his voice and fleeing from a stranger Ioh 10. 4. 5. I hope I have aboundantly proved what I undertook and so I conclude that he said right who compared truth to the teacher holinesse and righteousnesse to the ruling Elders I adde where Heresie is the teacher
it Can hee not deceive the soule syllogistically by false reasonings as well as positively by false suggestions I answer no doubt he can and often doth yet the mistaking of marks may be rectified in the Children of God Wisdome is justified of her children but the rejecting and slighting of all markes cannot bee rectified but is a certain and unavoidable snare to the soule If marks of grace become snares to the Reprobate that proves nothing against the use of markes The word of God is a snare and a gin to the Reprobate that they may goe and fall backward and bee broken and snared and taken yet the word is in it self the power of God to salvation So the way of markes is a sure and safe way in it selfe and to every well informed conscience When any conscience through errour or presumption mistakes the marke that is the fault of the person not of the way of markes and the personall errour may be helped by personall light and Information if the partie wil receave it Whereas to make no tryall by markes and to trust an inward testimony under the notion of the holy Ghosts testimony when it is without the least evidence of any true gracious marke this way of its own nature and intrinsecally or in it self is a deluding and insnaring of the conscience But it may be asked and 't is a question worthie to bee looked into though I must confesse I have not read it nor heard it handled before how doth this assurance by marks agree with or differ from assurance by the testimony of the holy Ghost May the soule have assurance either way or must there be a concurrence of both for I suppose they are not one and the same thing to make up the assurance For answere whereunto I shall first of all distinguish a twofold certainty even in reference to the minde of man or in his conscience for I speak not heare de â—…ertitudine entis but mentis the one may be called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 when the conscience is in tuto may be secure needeth not feare and be troubled The Graecians have used the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 when they were speaking of giving security and assurance by safe conducts or by pledges or by sureties or the like The other is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a full perswasion when the soule doth not onely stirre a right and safe course and needeth not feare danger but saile before the winde and with all it's sailes full So there is answerably a double uncertainty the one may be called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 when a man is in himselfe perplexed and difficulted and not without cause having no grounds of assurance when a man doth doubt and hesitate concerning a conclusion because hee hath no reasons or arguments to prove it when a man is in a wildernesse where he can have no way or shut up where hee can have no safe escaping The other is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which is a doubting that ariseth not from want of arguments or from the inextricable difficultie of the grounds but from a disease of the minde which makes it suspend or retaine it's assent even when it hath sufficient grounds upon which it may be assured Now 't is the evidence of signes or markes of grace which giveth that first kinde of certainty and removeth that first kinde of uncertainty But 't is the testimony of the Spirit of the Lord which giveth the second kinde of certainty and removeth the second kinde of uncertainty Take a simile two or three for illustration The Scripture is known to bee indeed the word of God by the beames of divine auctority which it hath in it selfe and by certaine distinguishing Characters which doe infallibly prove it to be the word of God such as the heavenlynesse of the matter the Majesty of the style the irresistible power over the conscience the generall scope to a base man and to exalt God nothing driven at but Gods glory and mans salvation The extraordinary holinesse of the Penmen of the holy Ghost without any respect to particular interests of their owne or of others of their nearest relations which is manifest by their writings the supernaturall mysteries revealed therein which could never have entered inthe reason of men the marvailous consent of all parts and passages though written by diverse and severall Penmen even where there is some appearance of difference the fulfilling of prophesies the miracles wrought by Christ by the Prophets and Apostles the conservation of the Scripture against the malice of Sathan and fury of persecuters These and the like are characters and markes which evidence the Scriptures to be the word of God yet all these cannot beget in the soule a full perswasion of faith that the Scriptures are the word this perswasion is from the holy Ghost in our hearts And it hath been the common resolution of soâ—…nd Protestant writers though now called in question by the Scepticks of this age that these arguments and infallible characters in the Scripture it selfe which most certainly prove it to be the word of God cannot produce a certainty of perswasion in our hearts but this is done by the Spirit of God within us according to these Scriptures 1 Cor 2. 10 11 14 15. 1 Thes 1. 5. 1 Iohn 2. 27. and 5. 6 7 8 10. Ioh 6. 45. In like manner a Scholler or a young disputant may argue and dispute be it in Philosophie or Divinity upon very right and sure principles yet perdventure not without great feare and doubting in his own thoughts till he be put out of that feare by the approbation and testimony of his learned Master who presideth in the dispute The evidence of good markes while it is opened unto us may make our hearts to burne within us as those Disciples said which were going to Emmaus but yet our eyes are held as it was with them that wee doe not know Christ in us or talking with us untill our eyes be opened by the Spirit No doubt they had much light breaking in upon their understandings while Christ expounded unto them the Scriptures by the way and this light was with life and heat in their hearts But after they knew Christ in breaking of bread then and not till then came the fulnesse of perswasion and then they could say The Lord is risen indeed Luke 24. 15 16 30 31 32 34. Our inward evidence of graces or use of signes may bring the Children to the birth I mean in point of assurance but 't is the evidence of the Spirit of God which giveth strength to come forth Without this evidence of the Spirit of God the soule doth but grope after a full assurance as it were in the dark but when the holy Ghost commeth to do the office of a Comforter then there is light and liberty Our assurance of justification adoption grace and salvation is virtually in a syllogisticall way Whoever beleeves on
love and if I cannot have any solid or safe comfort from this that I love the Brethren how much lesse can this comfort me that others judge me to be a lover of the brethren And how do I know them to be the brethren who judge so of me For by their rule no man can say such a one is a brother so that they do but tye themselves with their own knots and must therefore either quite their sense of the Text and take ours or else hold that this text hath no comfort at all in it which yet is most full of comfort and sweet as the honey and the honey combe But secondly will you see these men falling yet more foully in the ditch they have digged for others While they object so much against a believers examining or assuring his conscience by fruits of sanctification sincerity of heart hatred of sin respect to all the commandements love to the Brethren while they tell us that none of these can be sure evidences to the soule and while they pretend to shew other soule satisfying evidences which can resolve quiet comfort and assure the conscience they do but more and more lead the soule into a labyrinth and make the spirits of men to wander from mountain to hill and to forget their resting place I might here take notice of the six remedies against doubting which one of them offereth as an antidote and preservative against all objections whatsoever yet all the six put together cannot resolve nor clear the conscience in the point of a personall or particular interest in Christ I heare much will the perplexed soule say of the nature of faith of free justification of the things sealed in Baptisme c. But oh I cannot see that I have any interest for my part in these things Not to insist upon these six remedies which are indeed most insufficient as to this point my present work shall be to speak unto those personall and particular evidences of an interest in Christ which are held foorth by their chief writers Do but observe their way and you shall see that either they fall in at last into our way of gracious marks and qualifications or otherwise leave the Conscience much more perplexed and unsatisfied then they found it They tell us of two evidences a revealing evidence and a receiving evidence that by the spirits testimony this by faith The revealing evidence of interest in the priviledges of Christ which will put an end to all objections is the voice of the Spirit of God to a mans own spirit This is the great evidence indeed and the evidence which at last doth determine the question and put an end to all objections Well But doth the Spirit of God give testimony to the soule any otherwise then according to the word of God No saith the same writer by no means for it is most certainly true saith he that every voice in man speaking peace being contrary to the word of grace that voice is not the voice of the spirit of the Lord it is the voice of the spirit of delusion Immediatly he moves this doubt But how shall I know that this voice though it be according to the word of grace is indeed the voice of the spirit of the Lord and be satisfied that it is so He might have moved this doubt which is greater how shall I know that this voice or this testimony doth indeed speak according to the word or whether it speak contrary to the word so be the voice of the spirit of delusion Peradventure he had found it difficult and even impossible to answer this doubt without making use of and having recourse unto the way of signes or marks such as the word holds foorth And this agreeth to that twofold joint witnessing Rom 8. 16. the spirit of God is not simply 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a witnesse but 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 qui simul testimonium dicit he bears witness not only to but with our spirit that is with our conscience So that if the witnesse of our Conscience be blank and can testifie nothing of sincerity hatred of sin love to the Brethren or the like then the spirit of God witnesseth no peace nor comfort to that soul and the voice which speaketh peace to a person who hath no gracious mark or qualification in him doth not speak according to the word but contrary to the word and is therefore a spirit of Delusion I shall not contend about the precedence or order between these two Testimonies in the soul so that we hold them together and do not separat them in our assuring or comforting of our hearts before God And here I must take notice of another Passage where he whose principles I now examine saith I do not determine peremptorily that a man cannot by way of evidence receive any comfort from his sanctification which he thus cleareth The spirit of the Lord must first reveal the gracious minde of the Lord to our spirits and give to us Faith to receive that Testimony of the Spirit and to sit down as satisfied with his Testimony before ever any work of Sanctification can possibly give any evidence But when the Testimony of the Spirit of the Lord is received by Faith and the soule sits down satisfied with that Testimony of the Lord then also all the gifts of Gods Spirit do bear witnesse together with the Spirit of the Lord and the Faith of a Believer Surely such a Testimony or voice in the soul as the soul sits down satisfied with before ever any work of sanctification can possibly give any evidence is not an evidence according to the word but contrary to the word and therefore not the revealing evidence of the spirit of God so that in this I must needs dissent from him for he casts the soule upon a most dangerous precipice neither is the danger helped but rather increased by that posteriour evidence or after comfort of sanctification which he speaks of for the soule being before set down satisfied with the Testimony of the spirit of the Lord and Faith receiving that Testimony so he supposeth it cannot now examin whether its sanctification be sound or not sound whether its graces be common or speciall seeming or real It implyes a contradiction if I say that I am assured by the evidence of the spirit of God and by the evidence of Faith that I am in Christ and in Covenant with God and that notwithstanding I sit down satisfied with this assurance yet I am not sure of the soundnesse of my Sanctification Therefore to put the soule upon a looking after the evidence of graces and the comfort of sanctification when the soule is before hand fully assured and satisfied against all objections and doubtings is not onely to lay no weight at all upon these marks of Sanctification in the point of resolving or clearing the Conscience but it is much worse then so it is a confirming
which speaks in the soule by the voice of the Lord which speaks in the Scripture If it agree not then we have not losed but have made a right discovery and found out a depth of Sathan and so gained by the tryall If it do agree so likewise we are gainers being confirmed in the assurance not upon the Testimony of another but upon the surest and best known Testimony of the holy Ghost himself Thirdly if these things be not admitted and if the Antinomian argument which now I speak to stand good then it shall be easie for any deluded person to repell the most searching convictions which can be offered to him from Scripture for he shal still think with himself though unhumbled and unregenerat it is the voice of the spirit of the Lord which speaks peace to my soule and this voice I know is according to the word because I am assured by the same spirit that it is indeed according to the Word and other evidence I will not look after because I am to receive the Testimony of the Spirit upon his own credit and not upon the credit of some other thing The voice of the spirit which speaks in my soul is that beyond which there must be no inquiry I ask now how shall the Antinomians convince such a one from Scriptur Nay how can they choose but according to their principles confirme him in his delusory imaginary assurance Fourthly the very same Antinomian Author who speaks of the Testimony of the spirit of God in the soul as that beyond which there must be no inquirie and which puts an end to all objections even he himself doth by and by tell us of aliquid ultra and puts the soul upon a further inquiry which as I said before shal either resolve into our way of assurance by marks or otherwise leave the soul overclouded more in the dark then at the beginning And so I come to his secōd evidence which he cals the receiving evidēce Though the spirit of the Lord saith he doe reveal the minde of the Lord to men yet they are not fully resolved concerning this mind of the Lord to their own spirits till by Faith they do receive it Now till men do receive this Testimony and believe it they are never resolved but when men do receive it and believe it that it is a true Testimony then they sit down satisfied Again Faith is an evidence as it doth take possession of that which the spirit of the Lord reveals and manifests and gives to a person The spirit indeed makes the title good but faith maks good the entry and possession and so clears the title to us though good in it self before Is there a voice behind thee or within thee saying particularly to thee in thy self thy sins are forgiven thee Doest thou see this voice agree with the word of Grace If thou doest receive the Testimony of the Spirit according to that word If thou doest indeed receive it here is thy evidence Thereafter he moves this objection But you will say if there be not fruits of faith following that faith is a dead faith and therefore there must be something to evidence with it For answer whereunto first he rejects this as a great indignity to Faith If faith be not able of it self to give Testimony or must not be credited when it doth give Testimony except something will come and testifie for it to give credit unto it Next he answereth thus that which hath the whole essence of faith is not a dead but a living faith Now the whole essence of faith is nothing else but the Eccho of the heart answering the foregoing voice of the spirit and word of Grace thy sins are forgiven thee saith the spirit and word of Grace my sins are forgiven me saith Faith If therefore the Eccho to the voice of Spirit and word of Grace be the essence nay be the whole essence of believing this is certain where there is receiving or beleiving there cannot be a dead faith Now behold him at a losse all resolves into this issue no assurance by the Testimony of the spirit and word of grace unlesse this testimony be received by faith no entry and possession no clearing of the title to the soule no resolution or satisfaction to the conscience till it beleive But then while the soule examines it self whether it have a true lively faith or only a dead faith he dare not admit the tryall of faith by the fruits of it as if it were an indignity to the tree to be knowen by the fruit or to the fire to be knowen by the heat Faith purifieth the h◅art saith the Scripture Faith workes by love Faith shewes it self by works This Antinomian durst not adventure upon this tryall by the Scripture markes of faith yea to avoid this he runnes into a great and dangerous errour that the whole essence of faith is nothing else but the Eccho of the heart answering the voice of the spirit and saying my sinnes are forgiven me as if there were no faith where there is no assurance of the forgivenesse of sinnes and as if faith were quite lost as often and as long as the soule cannot say with assurance my sinnes are forgiven me Again may there not bee a false Eccho in the heart may not a temporary beleever who receaves the word of grace with joy say within himself my sinnes are forgiven me Where is the clearing of the conscience now Is it in that last word where there is receaving or beleeving there cannot be a dead faith But how shall I know that there is indeed a receving and beleving The essence of faith is the receaving of Christ in the word of grace and a ◅esting upon him for righteousnesse and life Now another Antinomian tells us that to receave Christ and his benefites truely doth necessarily include in it these foure particular points 1 To know our lost state by the least sinne our misery without Christ and what need we have of him 2. To see the excellency and worth of Christ and his benefites 3. A taking and having of Christ and his benefites to ones owne self in particular 4. To be filled with great joy and thankfull zeal If these things be so then I am sure many doe imagine they have receaved Christ and his benefites by faith who have not truely and really receaved him so that the soul searching it self in this point whether have I any more then a dead faith or a counterfeit faith dare not acquiesce nor sit down satisfied with that resolution where there is receaving or beleeving there cannot be a dead faith For the soule must still enquire whether is my receaving or beleeving true reall sound lively and such as cannot agree to a dead faith The same Author whom I last cited where he putteth a difference between a counterfeit faith and a true faith he saith that the counterfeit faith neither reneweth nor
as well as 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 pag. 72. How the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is often used for the new Testament pag. 72. Prophesie is a speciall gift of an Apostle pag. 73. Prophesie and the gift of tongues of the same kinde ibid. Even Prophetesses were not allowed to speak in the Church pag. 75 76. That place 1 Cor. 14. 26. exponed and vindicated pag. 77 78 79. How Prophesie might be desired pag 81. How Prophets were subject to tryall pag 82. How the word Bretbren is sometimes taken pag. 84. CAP. VI. Whether any but a Minister lawfully called and ordained may administer the Sacraments Baptisme and the Lords Supper p. 86. The Negative is justly held by reformed Churches against Erastians and Socinians and is proven by eight arguments Much of the feeding of the flock confists in the dispensation of the Sacraments pag. 87 What Ezekiels vision concerning the new Temple means pag. 88. None without a calling should make bold with Christs broad Seals pag 89. Whom the commission to Teach and Baptize is given to ibid. Christ hath distinguished between Magistracy and Ministery between Sacred and Civile vocations ibid. What comfort it is for Minister and People if the Minister be lawfully ordained pag. 90. That one Text Eph. 4. 11 12 13. is enough to put to silence these gainsayers pag. 90. 91. CAP. VII Of Prophets and Evangelists in what sense their work and vocation might be called extraordinary and in what sense ordinary p. 91 Their work and Vocation is mixed pag 92 The higher degrees Eph 4. 11. are comprehensive of the lower not contrarywise ibid. What is the proper work of a Prophet ibid. VVhat is the proper and distinguishing work of an Evangelist pag. 93. How the word Evangelist is taken ibid. Their works how and in what sense extraordinary pag. 94. VVhat kinde of Vocation and Mission they had pag. 95. 96. Timothie had a vocation partly Ordinary partly extraordinary ibid. CAP. VIII That the Primitive Apostolicall Pattern holds foorth unto us for our imitation a Presbyterie i. e. an Assembly of Elders having power of Ordination with laying on of hands pag 97. How 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 1 Tim 4. 14. is to be taken and that place vindicated from false glosses pag. 97 98 99 100. The change of the Phrase in that place is observeable pag. 101. Imposition of hands is in Scripture an authoritative act pag. 102. How Timothie might be ordained both Presbyter and Evangelist at one time in one action pag. 103. How Timothie might be ordained Evangelist by the Presbyterie ibid. In what sense Peter calls himself 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 1 Pet 5. 1 2. pag. 104 105 106 107. How imposition of hands is necessary for Ordination and what kinde of rite it is pag. 108. 109. CAP. IX What is meant in Scripture by the word Heresies and how we are to understand that there must be Heresies for making manifest the Godly partie or those that are approved 1 Cor. 11. 19. p. 110 Heresie is more nor Divisions and Schismes pag. 111. VVhat Heresie is not answered in two things pag. 111 112 113 Six things do concurre to make a Heresie pag. 113 114 115. A description of Heresie pag. 115. VVhy Heresie must bee and how ibid. VVho are the approved 1 Cor 11. 19. and who not pag. 117. 118. How we should look upon Gods suffering Heresies in the Church p. 119 How a Child of God may be drawn over to Heresie pag 120. 121. How Heresies makes manifest them who are approved pag. 122. CHAP. X. Of New Lights and how to keep off from splitting either upon the Charybdis of pertinacy and tenaciousnesse or upon the Scylla of Levity Wavering and Scepticisme pag. 123. Five Concessions for clearing the Question pag. 124. 125. The greatest deceits of Satan have come under the name of new Light pag. 125 Many things cried up as new Lights which are neither Lights nor New pag 126. It s a false new Light that expelleth much good old Light pag. 127 128. Balaam seeks a new Light and gets it in wrath pag. 128. Many of our New lights bring in Egyptian darknesse pag. 129. It s not good Light that makes certain truths uncertain ibid. Scepticisme is no good New light pag. 130. Beware of New Lights which come not from the Sun of righteousnesse pag. 131. The VVeigelians wilde fancy ibid. Take heed of proud and self-conceited New lights ibid. Beware of separating new Lights pag. 132. Beware of New lights that dare not be seen ibid. Refuse such Lights as have fellowship with the works of darknes p 133. They are no new Lights which bring no edification pag. 134. Take good heed of New Lights which follow new interests ibid. CAP. XI Of Stability and firmnesse in the Truth pag. 134 Scepticisme is a sin and stability in the truth a dutie proved from Natures light and Scripture pag. 134. 135 Seven reasons confirmed with Scripture proved pag. 136. 137. Some Errours in their own nature damnable pag. 138. Nine Preservatives against wavering and Helps to stability in the truth pag 138. 139. 140. Pertinacy and levitie both to be shunned pag. 141. The Sectaries word is yea and nay ibid. Seekers should be called Atheists because Nullifidians ibid. CAP. XII Whether a sound heart and an unsound head can consist together vice versa or whether Truth and Holines be not inseparable Companions pag. 142. Every Error is not inconsistent with holynesse yet pro tanto it retards and hinders it ibid. Dangerous errours can no other wayes consist with true Grace noâ—… dangerous sins ibid. What are the roots of Heresies and Errors in the hearts of corrupt men pag. 143. 144. All opinions and practises in the world are reduced to three heads 1 John 2. 16. ibid. There is a Reciprocall influence of the will and understanding and how it is pag. 145 As the Infection of sin is universall so is the work of Gods spirit in the soule pag. 146. Soule and Spirit Reasons and affections compared together ibid. Both Doctrinals and Practicalls make up a perfect Christian pag. 147 To be led in all Truth is a work of the Spirit of Truth ibid. Truth and Grace compared ibid. How Erroneous men are distinguished from the Elect pag 148. A holy Heretick is a Chymaera and a prophane believer is another pag. 149. An ungodly mans knowledge is but a forme of knowledge ibid. No sin in the will without some Error in the understanding pag 150. All professed and mantained Errors are but manifestos of the corrupt principles secretly lurking in the judgements of all unrenewed men pag. 150 151. Many hold fast the Truth because not yet tempted ibid. Eleven practicall conclusions drawn from the former Principles pag. 152 153 154 155 156 157. 158. Every Religion and Faith will not save men pag. 152. How Heresies are damnable pag. 153. 154. Church censures should strike both against Hereticks and profane men pag.
proves it ibid. CAP. XIX That there was among the Iews a jurisdiction and government Ecclesiasticall distinct from the civill pag. 231. The Jews had Ecclesiasticall Elders or Church governours which proves the point ibid. Even under the Roman Emperour they had their Presbyteri and Arcbisynagogi It s proved out of Mr. Selden that their Elders received a judiciall degree and were not civil Magistrats ibid. 232. The Jewish ordination of Elders with imposition of hands proves it also pag. 233. 234. A third argument is taken fâ—…om the Synagâ—…ga Magna pag. 235. The Hebrews triple Crown proves it ibid. The Jews exercised Ecclesiastical discipline since their dispersion which is a fifth reason pag. 236. 237. CAP. XX. That necessary consequences from the written word of God do sufficiently and strongly prove the consequent or conclusion if Hereticall to be a certain divine Truth which ought to be believed and if practicall to be a necessary dutie which we are obliged unto jure divino pag 238 The assertion is cleared by some premisses ibid Humane reason drawing the consequence is not the ground of our beliefe pa. 239. There is a difference between corrupt and renewed Reason ibid. Two sorts of consequences distinguished pag. 240 The Assertion is proved First by the example of Christ and his Apostles ibid. In the old Testament as well as in the new some necessary things were left to be drawn by necessary consequence from the Law of Moses pag. 241. Two sorts of necessary consequences from the Law a sortiori and a pari pag. ibid 242 A third reason from the infinite wisedome of God who must foresee all things that followes upon his words pag. 243. Diverse absurdities will follow if this truth be not admitted pag. 244. These who most cry down this assertion yet themselves can bring no other but consequentiall proffes to proove their tenents pag. 245. If this be denied we deny to the great God what is granted to the litle Gods or Magistrats ibid. CAP. XXI Of an assurance of an interest in Christ by the marks or fruits of sanctification and namely by love to the Brethren Also how this agreeth with or differeth from assurance by the Testimony of the spirit and whether there can be any wel grounded assurance without marks of grace pag. 246. Three Cautions for right understanding the question that is Marks are not to be separated either from the free grace or from Christ or from the spirit ibid. It s a sure way to seek after assurance of our interest in Jesus by the marks of Sanctification proved by five reasons p. 247. 248 A twofold certainty of the mind distinguished 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and a twofold uncertainty opposed 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 pag. 249. 250 The evidence of marks gives the first kinde of certainty the testimony of the spirit gives the second ibid. This is illustrat by a simile of believing the Scriptures p. ibid. 251. And by another of the disciples going to Emmaâ—…s ibid. The assurance of Justification is virtually done in a Syllogistical way 252 The spirit works the firme belief of the proposition a twofold testimony concurre to the assumption pag. 252. None should divide these testimonies they are joyned in three Texts of scripture pag. 253. D. Crisps objection against assurance from the love of the Brethren propounded pag. 254 For answer three things are demonstrat ibid. This objection militateth as much against their own interpretatioÌ„ p. 255. The Antinomian way of setling assurance is an inextricable labyrinth pag. 256. The testimony of the spirit must be an evidence according to the word of God pag. 257. 258. Wee say the evidence of marks is privative they say it is at most cumulative pag 259. The spirit of God is a spirit of Revelation but not beside or contrary to the Word ibid. Another objection of Crispe removed pag. 260. 261. How the spirit and word concurre to this assurance ibid. The word is more sure nor any voice within or without pag. 262. Crispe his way of assurance by the testimony of the spirit received by faith resuted pag. 263 264. He grosly mistakes faith ibid. Mr. Eton brought against him pag. 265. A sad lamentation of a poor soul holding foorth what miserable comforters these antinomians are pag. 266 267 268. The love of the Brethren is a sure and clear mark of one being past from death to life ibid Four things observed touching the Brethren pag. 269. It s not necessar to have a infallible knowledge of their regeneration 270 How far particular saints may be known by their fruits pag. 271. Antinomians expone 1 Cor 13. legally pag. 272 5. Marks and tokens of true and sincere love of the brethren p. 273 274 No marks hâ—…eraway without some mixture of contrary corruption p. 275 There is alwayes bellum though not alwayes proelium between the flesh and the spirit pag. 276. CAP. XXII Of the true real and safe grounds of incouragement to believe in Iesus Christ Or Upon what warrands a sinner may adventure to rest and rely upon Christ for Salvation pag 277. To say Christ died for all men conditionally is not the way to ease troubled consciences pag. ibid 278 The true and saâ—…e grounds of incouragement to believe in Christ are First Christ his alsufficiency pag. 279. It s a great part of true faith to believe Christ is able to save to the uttermost ibid. 2. Christs intention to die for all men 1. all sorts of sins or sinners of any kinde pag. 280. All men exponed ibid. To pray for all men and to pray in every place exponed pag. 281. 282. Every man Heb. 9. â—… hath the same sense pag 283. All men can only be all men who are in Christ. ibid 284 The whole world 2 Ioh. 2 2. exponed ibid. 285. The world 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Ioh. 3. 16. is no larger nor 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ibid. 3 Iesus Christ hath died for expiation of all forts and all manner of sins pag. 286. The sin against the holy Ghost only excepted what it is ibid How a blasphemer against the holy Ghost may repent pag 287. 4 Christ receives all who come unto him and excluds none but such as by their unbelief excludes themselves pag. 288. CHAP. I. That the Ministery is a perpetuall Ordinance of Christ in the Church and that Ministers are to bee received as the Embassadours of Christ now aswell as in the Primitive times THat which hath long lurked in the hearts of many Atheists is now professed and argued for by that sierce furious Erastiane whose book was published the last year at Franeker He cryes out that the world is abused with that notion of a pretended sacred ministerial calling that though the Apostles and others who first preached the Gospel were indeed sent and set apart for that holy calling which was also confirmed by signes and miracles and
ungodlynesse and unrighteousnesse are the ruling Elders a holy Hereticke is a Chimera and a prophane person beleeving a right is another But here peradventure some will think that the great objection lyes may not a prophane person have a sound or orthodox judgement in all controverted truthes May not a man understand all mysteries and all knowledge who yet hath no love nor true sanctification 1 Cor 13. 2. May not a person hold fast the profession of the true faith without wavering whose heart not withstanding is not right with God nor stedfast in his Covenant I answer first where there is but a forme of godlynesse there is but aforme of knowledge 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is a word no where used by the holy Ghost but in two places a forme of knowledge Rom 2. 20. and a forme of godlinesse 2 Tim. 3. 5. It is not the true and reall forme either of knowledge or godlinesse which as they have a true matter so a true forme He saith not 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which had been the proper word for a true forme but 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 speciem scientiae speciem pietatis If wee have respect to the notation of the word 't is a formation or forming I may call it a forming without mattering so that the forme of knowledge more then which an ungodly man hath not bee hee never so learned hath not the truth substance and reality of knowledge Theophilact saith some understand it to be the image and false resemblance of knowledge so Hesychius and Suydas understand 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 to be 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 an image of a thing Secondly there is no sinfullnesse in the will and affections without some error in the understanding all lusts which a naturall man lives in are lusts of Ignorance 1 Pet 1. 14. the sins of the people are called the errors of the people Heb 9 7 and the wicked person is the foole in the Proverbs the naturall man receives not the things of the Spirit of God and what is the reason because they are foolishnesse unto him neither can he know them because they are spiritually discerned 1 Cor 2 14. the world cannot receive the spirit of Truth because it knoweth him not Ioh 14 17. The â—…opish Doctrines of free will of Justification by works of meat of implicite Faith of believing the Scriptures because the Church receiveth them what marvel that they do so whose eyes are not opened to see the Sun beame of Divine light in the Scripture it self which is Spiritually discerned Of the Sacraments conferring of Grace and the like also the Soâ—…inian tenents that a man is noâ—… bound to believe any Artiâ—…le of Faith nor any interpretation of Scripture except it agree with his reason that Pastors and Ministers of the word have not now any distinguishing sacred vocation authorizing them to be the Ambassadours of Christ to preach and minister the Sacraments more nor other Christians which is also maintained by a late Erastian writer in the Netherlands These and the like errors professed and maintained by them what are they but so many legible commentaries and manifest interpretations of those corrupt and erroneous principles which are lurking and secretly seated in the judgements and understandings of naturall and unregenerated persons al 's well learned as uulearned these Hereticks do but bring foorth to the light of the Sun what is hid within the mynds of other unregenerat persons as in so many dark dungeons The like I say of tâ—…e Arminian Doctrine of universall grace and universall atonement by Christs death And of Originall sin that it is not properly sin which doctrines are common to many Anabaptists with the Arminians the like I say also of the Antinomian doctrines that Christ hath abolished not only the curse and rigour and compulsion but the very rule it self of the morall Law so that they who are under the Covenant of Grace are not bound to walk by that rule that they ought not to repent and mourn for sin that God doth not affâ—…ict them for sin that Faith without the evidence of any marks or fruits of Sanctification doth assure the soul of its interest in Christ and what is that scientia media which the Iesuits glory of as a new Light but the very old error of naturall men which looks upon things contingent as not decreed and determined by the will of God and what is the Erastian way which oppugneth suspension from the Lords Table Excommunication and all Church government 5. What is it but a declaration or manifesto of the proud imaginations of mens corruptions which say within themselves Let us break their bands asunder and cast away their cords from us And y e take too much upon you Moses and Aaron seeing all the congregation are holy every one of them and the Lord is among them I conclude this point every naturall man hath in his heart somewhat of Popery somewhat of Socinianisme somewhat of Arminianisme somewhat of Anabaptisme somewhat of Antinomianisme somewhat of Erastianisme and I cannot buâ—… adde somewhat of Independency too so farre as it pleadeth for more liberty then Christ hath allowed and if every man hath a Pope in his belly as Luther said then every man hath an Independent in his belly for the Pope is the greatest Independent in the world and t is naturall I think to every man to desire to be judged by no man Thirdly when an unregenerat or unsanctified person holds last the profession of the Faith take heed it be not because he is not yet tempted nor put to it in that thing which is the idol of his heart let him bee brought to this either to quite the truth and the faith or to quite what is dearest to him in the world and see what he will doe in that case His fruit is but such aâ—… growes upon the stony ground but stay till the Sun of persecution arise and scorch him I have the more fully and strongly asserted the inconsistencie of Heresie and holinesse as likewise of sound beleeving and prophane living and have shewed the joynt fading or flourishing of true grace and true holynesse that this being demonstrated and laid down for a sure principle may lead us to many practicall and usefull conclusions and corrolaries which I will onely here point at First it cuts off the exception of those who cry out against the censuring suppressing and punishing of Hereticks by the Christian Magistrate as if this were a persecuting of pietie or pious persons when it is indeed a suppressing of a work of the flesh â—…for Heresie is no other Gal 5. 20. and of that which is either the cause or effect either the usher or page of someimpiety Secondly it confuteth that most pernicâ—…ous and cursed opinion that if a man live well he may be saved in any Religion or any Faith Socinus did hold that all whether Lutherans or Calvinists or Anabaptists or Arians so that they live
well shall be saved as hath been observed he was a follower of Mahomet for Machomet having compyled his Alcoran partly out of the Jewish and partly out of the Christian Tenents and made it an hotch potch out of both that he might conciliâ—…t favour unto it among both hee held that every one who lives well whether Jew or Christian shal be saved he that holds a man may be saved what ever he beleeve may with as much truth hold that a man may be saved what ever he doe or howevâ—…r helive Thirdly it stoppeth the mouthes of Hereticks and Sectaries who call themselves the godly party Arrius Photinus Socinus Arminius and generally the chief Heresiarches which ever rose up in the Church have been cryed up by their followers for men of extraordinary piety as well as parts all are not sheep that comes in sheeps cloathing a false Prophet is a wolfe in sheeps cloathing Math. 7. 15. but it is added ye shall know them by their fruits mark by their fruits not by their green leaves nor faire flourishes let them pretend what they will we must beleeve the word of the Lord that one of the marks of those who are approved is to hold fast Gospell truths against Heresies 1 Cor. 11. 19. and by the rules of contraries those infected with Heresie are made manifest not to be approved If that which I have formerly asserted and cleared from Scripture be a truth as most certainly it is then it is no truth but a most dangerous and grace-destroying doctrine which some hold 1. viz. That it is to be much questioned whether any opinions or Heresies as they are called be absolutly inconsistent with beleeving in Jesus Christ and so damnable that is accompanied with eternall damnation but only that which is formerlie contradictorie to such a beleeving This writer who is one of the fomenters of the Scepticisme of this time makes much question whether any error or Heresie be damnable which doth not formally contradict this proposition that whosoever beleeves in Jesus Christ shall not perish but have everlasting life but I have shewed elsewhere that Heresies denying the God-head of Jesus Christ are accompanied with damnation and no marvell for whosoever beleeveth in Christ and yet beleeveth not him to be eternall God doth but believe in a creature and no creature can redeem us from hell nor satisfie infinite justice so are the Heresies concerning justification which hold that something besides Christs righteousnesse whither our faith or works is imputed to us to justification damnable if continued in Gal. 5. 4. that if by damnable Heresies we mean such errours as are of dangerous consequence and in this respect justly and deeply condemnable or censurable by men many who hold and publicklie maintaine damnable Heresies in this sense may have yea and some as farre as men are able to discerne de facto have true grace and goodnesse If he mean that such have true grace and goodnesse in that sense as David during the time of his continuing in the sinne of adultery or Peter during the time of his denying Christ had true grace and goodnesse that is that such doe not totally fall away from true grace but have the seed of God abidiâ—…g in them then hee pleadeth no better then as if one should say the sin of adultery the sin of denying of Christ are not damnable sinnes at least not inconsistent with true grace and goodnesse but if he will yeeld that errours of dangerous consequence which are justly and deeply condemnable are inconsistent with true grace and goodnesse in the same sense as grosse sinnes are inconsistent therewith that is that grosse and condemnable errors are inconsistent with the soules growing thriving prospering flourishing yea with any lively acting and putting foorth of true grace yea that grosse errors doe greatly and dangerously impare abate diminish weaken wound hurt and blast true grace and goodnesse and doe extremly grieve and in a great measure quench the spirit of grace Then he must also grant that to bear with or wink at grosse erâ—…ors is to bear with or wink at such things as are extremly prejudiciall obstructive and impeditive to true grace and goodnes 4. It is but an ignorant mistake and a dangerous soul deceaving presumption for a prophane loose-liver or for a close immortified and rotten hearted hypocrite to thinke or promise that he will stand fast in the faith and hold fast the truth without wavering Whosoever maketh ship wracke of a good conscience cannot but make shipwracke of faith too Hee that is overcome of a sinne may be overcome of an error too when he is tempted in that which is the idol of his heart Therefore let him who would have light from Christ awake from his sinnes Eph. 5. 14. Hee that hath not pious affections and thinkes his orthodoxe judgement will make him stedfast in the faith is as great a fool as he that thinkes to ride without a horse or a Captain that thinks to fight the enemy without souldiers or a Mariner that thinks to make out his voyage when his ship wants sailes 5. They that would have Church censures put forth only upon Hereticks Apostats or such as are unsound in the faith but not upon prophane livers in the Church which was the error of Erastus and before him of the Princes and States of Germany in the 100. Grievances the Originall of which error so farre as I can finde was from the darknesse of Popery for there was an opinion that the Pope might be deposed for Heresie but not for a scandalous life which opinion Aeneus Sylvius deâ—…gest is concilii Basil lib 1. confuteth they also upon the other hand that would have the censure of excommunication put forth upon loose and scandalous livers within the Church but not for those things which the reformed Churches call Heresies So Grotius annot on Luke 6. 22. and diverse Arminians diverse also of the Sectaries in England These I say both of the one and of the other opinion do but separat those things which ought not cannot be separated 6. There is cause to set a part dayes of fasting and prayers when Heresies and errors abound as well as when prophannesse and grosse wickednesse aboundeth in the lives of people Christ doth in five of his Epistles to the Churches of Asia to Ephesus Smyrna Pergamos Thyatyra Philadelphia take notice of false Teachers Sects and erroneous Doctrines commending the zeal in Ephesus against them blaming those in Pergamos and Thyatira for tollerating such amongst them incouraging those in Smyrna and Philadelphia by expressing his displeasure against those Sects No mention of loose and scandalous livers distinguished from the Sects in those Churches Either there were such scandalous livers in those Churches at that time or not If there were then observe Christ mentions not them but the false Teachers and Sectaries for although both are condemnable yet he takes speciall notice of scandals in Doctrine and
changeth the heart it maketh not a new man but leaveth him in the vanity of his former opinion and conversation Whence I infâ—…r that he who wil throughly rightly examine himself in this particular have I true faith yea or no Must needs before he have a solid resolution be put upon this further inquiry is there any heart-renewing or heart-changing work in me or am I still in the vanity of my former opinion and conversation yea or no I shall now after all this appeall to any tender conscience which is sadly and seriously searching it self whether it be in the faith whether Christ be in the soul and the soul in Christ let any poor wearied soul which is longing and seeking after rest refreshment ease peace comfort and assurance judge and say whether it can possibly or dare sit down satisfied with the Antinomian way of assurance before largely declared which yet hath been held foorth by those of that stamp as the only way to satisfie and assure the conscience and to put an end to all objections I begin to hear as it were sounding in mine ears the sad lamentation of a poor soule which hath gone along with their way of comfort and assurance and hath followed it to the utmost as far as it will go Oh saith the soul I have applyed my self to search and find out and to be clearly resolved in this great and tender point whether I bee in Christ or not whether I have passed from death to life from the state of nature into the state of grace or not whether I be acquit from the curse and condemnation of the Law and my sins pardoned or not when O when shall I be truly clearly and certainly resolved in this thing T is as darknesse and death to me to be unresolved and unsatisfied in it I refused to be comforted without this comfort Is id go to now and prove see this Antinomian way and when I had proved it I communed with mine own heart and my spirit made diligent search Then said I of it thou art madnesse and folly Their doctrine pretendeth to drop as the honey comb yet at the last it byteth like a serpent and stingeth like an Adder I find their words at first to be soft as oyle and butter yet I find them at last as swords and spears to my perplexed heart I am forbidden to try my spirituall condition or to seek after assurance of my interest in Christ by any mark or fruit of sanctification be it sincerity of heart hatred of sin love to the Brethren or be what it will be I am told it is unsafe and dangerous for me to adventure upon any such marks I do not mean as causes conditions or any way instrumentall in my justification for in that consideration I have ever disclaimed my graces nay I do not mean of any comfort or assurance by my sanctification otherwise then as it flowes from Christ who is made unto me of God sanctification al 's well as righteousnes But I am told by these Antinomians that even in the point of consolation and assurance t is not safe for me to reason and conclud from the fruit to the tree from the light to the sun from the heat to the fire from the effect to the cause I love the brethren with true and unfeigned love therefore I have passed from death to life They say I dare not I cannot have any true comfort or assurance grounded upon this or any such mark They promised me a shorter an easier a surer a sweeter way to come by the assurance which I so much long after They put me upon the revealing evidence or Testimony of the holy Ghost which I know indeed to be so necessary that without it all my marks will leave me in the dark But as they open and explain it unto me I must not try by the written word whether the voice or Testimony that speaks in my heart be indeed the voice of the Spirit of the Lord yet they themselves tell me that every voice in man which speaketh peace to him and speaketh not according to the word of grace is a spirit of delusion Again they tel me this Testimony of the Spirit of the Lord will put an end to all objections and is that beyond which there must be no inquiry yet by and by they tell mee there must there must be more then this there must be a receiving evidence of faith and till I believe I do not possesse Christ or his benefits neither can sit down satisfied and assured Oh then said I how shall I know that I have true faith Shall I try faith by the fruits of faith No say they by no means but try it by the eccho in the heart which answers the voice of the spirit as face answers to face in water But what if there be no such Eccho in my heart What if I cannot say with assurance my sins are forgiven me must I then conclude I have no faith And what if there be such an Eccho in mine heart how shall I know whether it be the voice of a true faith or whether it be a delusion Hath every one a true faith whose heart suggesteth and singeth my sins are forgiven me But where there is a receiving and believing said they there cannot be a dead faith Alas said I they leave me where I was How shall I know whether there be a believing or receiving Doe not themselves tell me there is a great difference between a true faith and a counterfeit faith are not these miserable comforteâ—…s who tell mee that true faith hath fruits and yet will not give me leave to try it by its fruits They teach me that Iustification is like the fire so that he that is not Zealous in holynes and righteousnes by Sanctification t is to be feared that he never had the fire of Iustification Another of them sâ—…ith doth not love manifested as truly and infallibly kindle love again a fire kindleth fire Sure then if I doe not love God and his children the Eccho in my heart which saith my sinnes are forgiven me is but a delusion Oh how have these men been charming and cheating me out of the right way They have unsetled mee and frighted me out of all my marks of grace or fruits of faith and when they have promised me a clear resolution behold they leave me much more unsatisfied They have deceived me and I was deceived When all comes to all in their way I must either conclude which I dare not that I have true faith because my heart suggesteth and saith my sins are forgiven mee without any tryall of faith by the fruits thereof or otherwise I am left in a labyrinth believe I must and they will allow me no markes to know whether I believe or not Wherefore I will not come into their secret I will come out of their paths which lead downe to the Chambers of death I
will return to the good old way the Scripture way Christs way the Apostles way in which I shall finde rest to my soule The third point now remains viz. that there is no such inextricable difficulty darknesse or mist in this mark the love of the brethren but that the children of God may and sometimes do clearly and safely assure their hearts by this mark that they have passed from death to life Which that it may appeare I shall speak first to the Object the Brethren then to the Act which is love Touching the Object let foure things be observed First this we certainly know that there are Saints on earth we believe the holy universall Church Now all who have passed from death to life those and none but those have a true and sincere love to the saints in generall praying heartily for them sympathizing with their suffering and rejoycing at their felicity None but a Saint can say in truth and with a sincere selfe-denying affection If I forget thee O Ierusalem let my right hand forget her cunning If I do not remember thee let my tongue cleave to theroof of my mouth If I preferre not Ierusalem above my chief joy Ps. 137. 5. 6. The Apostle commends praying for all Saints Eph 6. 18. and love to all the Saints Col 1. 4. I conceive he means not only all the Saints known to us but the whole invisible Church of Saints on earth That prayer and protestation Psal. 122. 7 8. when uttered in Spirit and Truth can proceed from no other but a gracious renewed heart peace be within thy walls and prosperity within thy Palaces For my brethren and companions sake I will now say peace be within thee This very love to the Saints in generall as to the excellent and precious ones of the earth is a fruit of Sanctification and a mark of a renewed and gracious estate even as contrary wise they that have no love to the Saints in their species or kind that love and esteem men only for some earthly respect and consideration the Rich the Honourable the Mighty c. or for some particular humane relation Parents Wives Children Kindred Friends Benefactors c. much more they that delight in the company and fellowship of the prophane and ungodly prove themselves to be such as have not yet passed from death to life Secondly t is neither necessary nor possible that we have a a certain and infallible knowledge of the true Saintship and regeneration of these particular persons whom we love under the notion of Brethren and Saints The Apostles themselves did once look upon and love some as Saints who were no Saints Iudas Simon Magus Ananias and Saphyra and others of that kind It is Gods own prerogative to know certainly the hearts of men To require a certain knowledge of the Saintship of others before we can say we love the Brethren doth not only strike at the mark of love but at the duty of love and makes the yoke of Christ heavy yea unsupportable and the very Evangelicall commandment of love to be most grievous yea impossible And if the Antinomian objection hold good no man on earth can performe acceptably this duety of Love except he know the hearts of those whom he loves under the notion of Saints If it be replyed that the commandement of Christ is acceptably performed when to my best knowledge and observation and according to the best tryall which one Christian is allowed by Christ to take of another they are Saints whom I love under that notion and that tiâ—… not necessary to the acceptable pâ—…rformance of the duty of love that I know infallibly such a one to be a true Saint Then it will follow by the like rule and by parity of reason that comfort and assurance may be had from this mark I love the Brethren although I cannot certainly and infallibly say these whom I love are true Saints For if I can be cleare in point of the duety and that my obedience to the new commandement of Christ love one another is acceptable to God then may I also be clear in point of the mark or signe this proposition I love the Brethren being a necessary consequent from that proposition I have through the grace of Christ so far performed the duty of Love as that it is acceptable to God in point of new obedience and this leads me to a third answer 3. Particular or individuall Saints may be so farre known by their fruits and are so farre discernable and visible as that our love to them under that notion may be known to be an acceptable service to God and so a comfortable mark or evidence to our selves Which plainly appears from what Christ saith Math 10. 41. 42. He that receiveth a Prophet in the name of a Prophet shall receive a Prophets reward And he that receiveth a righteous man in the name of a righteous man shall receive a righteous mans reward And whoever shall give to drink unto one of these little ones a cup of cold water onely in the name of a Disciple verily I say unto you he shall in no wise lose his reward Before verse 11. Into whatsoever City or Town ye shall enter enquire who in it is worthy and there abide till ye goe thence Heb 6. 20. For God is not unrighteous to forget your work and labour of Love which ye have shewed towards his name in that ye have ministred to the Saints and do minister These believing Hebrews did not infallibly know that they were Saints to whom they ministred yet the Apostle tels them their worke was acceptable to God and made himself to be perswaded of them things that accompany Salvation They to whom he writes being conscious to themselves of the truth and sincerity of their love might much more be perswaded of themselves things that accompany Salvation from this mark of Love although they could not know infallibly the hearts of those whom they loved as Saints We may without either revelation or infallibility of judgement by the marks which the word gives us for judging and discerning of others so farre be perswaded in a judgement of Charity that this or that person is a Saint a Brother a Sister one in Christ as that our love to the person under that notion is according to the rules of Christ flowes from faith which worketh by love and is acceptable to God as a part of our new obedience If it were not so this absurdity would also follow there could be no communion of Saints one with another at least no such thing done in faith Do not Believers act in Faith and not doubtingly when they have communion one with another when they exhort and comfort one another when they pray one with another when they sympathize one with another If they do not act these things in Faith they sinne for whatsoever is not of Faith is sin 4. It is to be observed that he who objects to others