follows that no Minister can be made but hee must have the Authority of the Holy Ghost Secondly It is necessary also that hee receive the Holy Ghost it self in the gifts and abilities of it for the discharge of this calling For no man can say that is effectually teach that Jesus is the Lord but by the Holy Ghost saith the Apostle 1 Cor. 12. And every spirit that confesseth that is soundly preacheth that Jesus is the Christ is of God 1 John 4.1 2. John 16. For it is the Holy Ghost onely that leadeth into all Truth concerning Christ Thirdly The conveyance of the Holy Ghost in all publick Ordinances is by some Ministerial hand as in Baptism and the Lords Supper wherein at least unto the faithful the Holy Ghost is conveyed So as in respect of the thing it self the Holy Ghost is necessary to bee conveyed to every Minister that is to bee ordained Sense of the words 2. Next for the meaning of the phrase First wee must observe That the word Holy Ghost here may be either taken for his person and gifts or for his Authority or both by a Metonymy It is taken for his gifts where it is said John 7. that the Holy Ghost was not yet because Christ was not yet glorified It is taken for his Authority when the Apostle saith that the Holy Ghost had made the Ministers of Ephesus the overseers of the flock Act. 20. Secondly wee may expound the words by way of declaration and solemn pronouncing as well as imparative or communicative bidding And the other words may bee so expounded also according as in absolution it is in one place in the Common Prayer-Book pronounced authoritatively yet it is expounded to bee onely a declaring and pronouncing Now to apply the former The word Holy Ghost here seems to bee taken for the Authority especially of the Holy Ghost to the exercise of the Ministerial function As if it were said Take thou the Authority of the Holy Ghost which hee hath appointed his Church to communicate and dispense to persons worthy for the Ministry of the Word in binding and loosing and of the Sacraments 3. To their exceptions First To the exception general it self that this form hath no warrant No warrant It is answered Answ That in other things they urge the Letter of the Scripture And surely where there is no incongruity in the thing nor impediment from some other cause from using the very words of Institution there cannot bee desired a better warrant Now that there is no such incongruity nor impediment shall bee shewn in answering unto the Reasons of the former exception whereof the first is that Proof none but God himself hath power to give the Holy Ghost But it hindreth not but that what none but a superiour Authority can have power to give originally may yet bee given ministerially Answ and by delegation from that superiour power Neither Moses had power to consecrate Aaron nor Samuel to confer the Kingdome unto David nor the Apostles themselves to give the Holy Ghost but by delegation and commission Which power if as to that right of the conferring the power and authority of the Holy Ghost to the ordaining of a Minister the Church ministerially hath not for without that power it cannot bee done then must every Minister receive his authority and outward call immediately from Heaven Neither is repugnant hereunto Lib. 1. dist 14. cap. 1. Hic quaeritur Aug. de Trin. l. 15. c. 26. either that of the Master of the sentences nor of Austin himself whence hee hath it viz. Neque enim aliquis discipulorum ejus dedit spiritum sanctum Orabant quippe ut veniret in eos quibus manum imponebant non eum ipsi dabant Quem morem in suis propositis etiam nunc servat Ecclesia Object For neither saith hee any of the Disc ples gave the Holy Ghost but they prayed that hee might come on those upon whom they laid their hands but gave him not themselves which custome the Church even now retaineth in her Bishops For our Church doth pray in laying on of hands and with and under the words Answ 1 of Institution asketh also before and after What form of words the Apostles used in laying on of hands and conferring the Holy Ghost is not expressed but unlikely it is that they used none Now those they used whether they were those used by our Saviour or others in form of praying cannot be determined nor therefore their example urged in that which our Church pretendeth not unto But the former will bee more evident in other ministrations also In Absolution the form is in the Liturgy in the visitation of the sick Imperative and authoritative as I may so speak and in a good sense so it is by his authority committed unto mee I absolve thee from all thy sin c. yet in the general absolution after the general confession at morning-prayer by which the former must bee expounded it is expressed to bee but declaratory by way of solemn and authoritative pronouncing and with the concurrence of prayer for efficacy of such declaration Almighty God who hast given power and commandment to declare and pronounce to his people being penitent the absolution and remission of their sins c. In Baptism the Holy Ghost and remission of sins is given and that by the ministration and the words spoken by the Minister So also in the Lords Supper the body and blood of Christ sacramentally is conferred by the words and action of the Minister none of which is in the power of any to bestow but God onely Shall wee therefore except against the fruits of those Ordinances or against the Minister for pronouncing such words and doing such actions Again as in the Absolution there goeth with the Pronounciation prayer also and so likewise in Baptism and the Lords Supper what hindereth but that the words may be taken under a precatory sense also and as including prayer which more expresly goeth both before and after The words therefore take thou the Holy Ghost do not argue an original or an inherent power but Ministerial onely and so as not excluding a precatory vertue also This to the first Reason The second is because they were the words of Christ himself to his Apostles what Proof 2 then were all Christs words to his Apostles peculiar to them Answ It was to his Apostles that hee gave the command of baptizing and teaching and of giving his last Supper Have none therefore power since to administer these Ordinances Again if no Minister can be made but by the Holy Ghost and his Authority and this Authority were proper onely to the Apostles because the words were spoken to them then is the Church deprived of the Holy Ghost ever since the Apostles nor hath power to ordain a Ministry The third reason is taken from the parallel of other administrations Proof wherein the words of institution in
and for some of our selves likewise if whilst we had such principles we had been silenc'd and asleep also To the last vâ—z That conscientious men are 3. Conscientientious men troubled for their unconformity unto these things molested and troubled I answer And well they may both for their own good and others whom by their example or perswasion they might mislead For if God may justly plague his people for neglecting his good and wholsome Law Act for the uniformity of Common-prayer in these cases provided as the Queen and Parliament imply he will It is as good service done to men by penalties to compel them to their duty in theâ—e particulars as to scourge a child to keep him from the fire St. Austin being once of the mind that Schismaticks and Hereticks should not be punished on better advice acquaintance with the Scripture and by experience Epist 48. and 50. was brought to be of another mind and wrote two large and elaborate Epistles to defend the lawfulness of the use of Laws to that purpose SECT III. Humane Inventions THe third general Exception is against the things we treat of that they are inventions humane and from man onely Answ several of them First The light of natural understanding wit and reason is from God he it is which thereby doth illuminate every man entring into the world Rich. Hook Eccles pol. lib. 3. sect 9. If there proceed from us any thing afterward corrupt and naught the mother therof is our own darkness neither doth it proceed from any such cause whereof God is the Author He is the Author of all that we think or do by vertue of that light which himself hath given And therefore the Laws which the very Heathens did gather to direct their actions by so far forth as they proceeded from the light of nature God himself doth acknowledge to have proceeded even from himself and that he was the writer of them in the table of their hearts In the second place How much more then is he the Author of those Laws which have been made by his Saints c. saith that praise worthy Author When the Disciples would have had our Saviour to put the man to silence who cast out devils in his name Mar. 9.38 and followed him not with them our Saviour rebuking of them gives us this useful Maxim in religious matters viz. That he that is not against us is on our part Things not opposing of the Scripture and intended for and tending to the furtherance of Religion they are not humane notions but the inventions of men directed by Scripture in the general touching such things viz. 1 Cor. 14. That all things be done to decency and edification and guided by the Spirit of God in such particulars Observance whereof rather then opposition thereto would represent a Christs Disciple The Feast of Dedication of the Temple was no injunction from the Lord 1 Maccab. 4.59 Joh. 10.22 But so useful an invention of man that our Lord himself observed it Remarkable also to this purpose is the profession of the Learned Zanchy touching things of this nature viz. Zanch. Observ in confess suam cap. 25. Aph. 10 11. ab initio Credo ea quae â piis patribus in nomine domini Congregatis communi omnium consensu citra ullam sacrarum literarum contradictionem definita recepta fuerunt ea etium quanquam haud ejusdem cum sacris literis authoritatis A SPIRITV SANCTO ESSE Those things saith he which have been concluded and received by the holy Fathers gathered together in the name of God Canons of the Church of what authority agreed on by common consent and without any contradiction to the Scripture although they are not of the same authority with the holy Scriptures yet I believe even those things to be from the HOLY GHOST Thus he Joh. 14. cap. 15. cap. 16. And it is not in vain that Christ hath promised his Spirit to his people to guide them into all truth SECT IV. Of the Apocrypha TO the fourth that many things in the premises are but Apocryphal and so not Scriptural nor obliging Now Touching the Apocrypha and its injunction to be read in some parts in the Church although all the Scripture be not read First which Books in case my self did think as some others do safer and better to be left publickly unread R. Hook Eccles pol. l. 5. sect 20. nevertheless as in other things of like nature even so in this my private judgment I should be loth to oppose against the force of their reverend authority who rather considering the divine excellency of some things in all and of all things in certain of those Apocrypha which we publickly read have thought it better to let them stand as a list or marginal border unto the Old Testament And though with divine yet as humane compositions to grant at the least unto certain of them publick audience in the Church of God And if in them there happen any speech that soundeth towards error should the mixture of a little dross constrain the Church to deprive her self of so much gold rather than learn how by art and judgment to make separation To this effect very fitly from the counsel that St. Jerom giveth unto Laeta of taking heed how she read the Apocrypha as also by the help of other learned mens judgment we may take direction And let me add that without such directions Confer Hamp Court pag. 61. King James said well he would not have all the Canonical Scripture read But because some there are who seem better to relish forreign judgments than those of their own Church Expositio de sacr libr. dignitate praefix ante Biblia Tigurin sive Leon Judae I shall recite first Bullingers opinion of those Books and the publick reading of them one of the Professors of the Church of Tigur his words are Ego verò arbitror salvo aliorum judicio istos libros Apocryphos rectissimè Hagiographa dici posse nimirum a sanctis viris de rebus Scriptos sacris quos quanquam non fint in Canone Hebraeo Ecclesia tamen quia sancta tradunt Canonicis non contradicunt recipit ac in sanctorum coetibus legit I do think saith he saving other mens judgments that these Apocryphal Books may very justly be called holy writings as being written by holy men touching holy things which though they are not in the Hebrew Canon yet because they treat of religious matters and do not contradict the holy Scriptures the Church doth receive them and reads them in the Assemblies of the Saints Then he produceth the judgment and relation of Cyprian Cyprian expos symb or Russinus for the work is ascribed to both in his Exposition of the Creed to the same purpose Where it is by the way to be noted out of the Text of Cyprian or Ruffinus first that he reckons the Books
eyes look right on to the true scope And turn not to the right hand or to the left of unlawful means If thine eye be single thy whole body shall be full of light Matth. 6.22 if thine eye and aim be evil thy whole body of thy actions will be full of darkness and in darkness men do not walk even said our Saviour 8. Cause Negligence in Religious duties Jam. 4. 8. In the next place there was no doubt either neglect of or some other defect in prayer and religious duties For though the thing were not omitted yet it seems there was an asking and not receiving which could not have been for he is faithful who had promised but that there was an asking amiss Heb. 10. Now the promise cannot fail Tâ—t 1. Jam. 1. because God cannot lie and the promise is If any man lack wisdom let him ask of God who giveth it liberally It hath even by the light of nature been discovered that great miscarriages in judgment and practise could not happen but as a punishment for some neglect of God as well as a sin against him When Alexander the Great had in a drunken fit slain Clytus a man both of valor Curtius lib. 8. paulo ab initio and merit towards the King after that he had spent all night in lamenting and repenting Scrutatumque num ira deorum ad tantum nefas actus esset subiit anniversarium sacrificium Libero patri non esse redditum st to tempore itaque inter vinum epulas caede commissa iram Dei fuisse manifestam Upon search it was found that the sacrifice to Bacchus was not performed in its season and therefore in his very benefits wine for so they reckoned the table was made a snare and in drinking and feasting slaughter being committed the anger of god was evident Thus those Heathens Matth. 6. Surely lead us not into temptation as it is a necessary so it should be a daily prayer and that with earnestness 9. Add to this some failing or other 9. Cause Fail in practise either in spirit and sincerity or in practice and walking For Good and upright is the Lord therefore he will teach sinners in the way but so that we be tractable Psal 25.8 9 10. for the meek he will guide in judgment and the meek will he teach his way that is the plain-hearted and those that walk with a right foot and make streight steps unto their feet Heb. 12. And all the paths of the Lord are mercy and truth unto them that keep his Covenant Psal 25. and his testimonies to do them And what man is he that feareth the Lord him shall he teach the way that he shall choose As on the contrary when we know God Rom. 1.28 and glorifie him not as God he often delivers us to an erring and unjudicious spirit 2 Thess 2. And the not receiving the truth in the love of it introduceth frequently strong delusions The close shall be St. Austins Diriget mites In Psal 24. diriges nec perturbabit in judicio eos qui sequuntur voluntatem ejus nec ei resistendo praepenunt suam That is He shall direct the meek nor shall he disturb them in their judgment which follow his will and do not by resisting prefer their own The last of those general causes which I shall name 10. Cause 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of my back-sliding was Being too busie without my sphere 1 Thes 4.11 and in the things did not belong unto me A practice consequent unto the former negligence as is implied by the Apostle whilst he saith Do your own business and work with your hands the thing that is good Psal 131.1 It was one thing that preserved David from sedition that he exercised not himself in things too high for him and above his place but refrained his soul as a weaned child 2 King 11. Not but that Jehoiada the High-prieâ—â— may according to his office and power given him deal in the greatest affairs of a kingdom Yea and not onely Zadoc and Abiather the chief but even also Ahimaaz and Jonathan the inferior Priests when regularly may put their hand to save the Throne as well as the Altar But the case with me was different I need not explain how That Prophesie Take unto thee the instruments of a foolish shepherd Zech. 11.15 c. was applied by one late in power unto the Ministers dealing in affairs of State Lieutenant General Cromwels Letter to the Speaker out of Scotland Sept. 4. 1650. when yet himself and party played their first and best game by their hands in so medling He saith Such means will not be effectual for the setting up the Kingdom of Christ and neglect or not trust to the word of God the sword of the Spirit which alone is powerful and able for the setting up that Kingdom and when trusted to will be found effectually able to that end and will also do it Thus he Oh that so much had been said by him at the beginning of the English as it was at the beginning of the Scotish War But then it would have spoil'd the sport 2 Pet. 1.12 and it seems there is a present truth as some apply those words of Peter not capable of any other moments of time past or to come But to return Johannes Funccius Johan Funccius that notable and good Chronologer a Divine also Chaplain and Chancellor unto the Duke of Borussia having as it seems counsell'd some act that was disgusted vehemently by the State Bucholcer Chronol ad Ann. 1566. they rested not till they had his head that contriv'd it who as he went to execution gave forth this Distich Disce meo exemplo mandato munere fungi Et fuge ceu pestem 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Which I have sometime thus rendred Learn thou by mine example to apply Thy self to thine own studies and do fly As from the plague that folly mine of late Divines too medling in affairs of State Somewhat like was that of Justus Jonas Justus Jonas idem ad Ann. 1567. the year following which he gave forth as he went to the same calamity Quid juvat innumeros scire evolvere casus Si facienda fugis si fugienda facis What doth it boot all cases for to know If duty thou omit and sin thou do But he was of another Trade to wit a Lawyer I conclude this with the Apostles warning 1 Thess 4. that we study to be quiet and to do our own business 1 Pet. 4. lest we suffer as evil doers and busie-bodies in other mens affairs The Causes general are ended CHAP. VI. Particular Causes with their Confutation And first of the War SECT I. Cause General and Privative viz. Resisting of the Spirit of God AS touching particular ones namely those which induced me unto the civil Controversie and those which lead me to
the Ecclesiastical Concerning the first 1. In the Civil Controversie I closed with the one party in the civil contest for these causes whereof the one is General and Privative the other Positive and Particular The former was the grieving or resisting the Spirit of God from whom I received no small concussion about this matter especially at the coming forth of * The resolving of conscience c. Edit Cambr. 1642. Dr. Fearn's first book in opposition to the Lords and Commons in their taking up Arms against the King The authority of Scripture there urged unto which God had given me ever to bear an awful reverence the Spirit setting it on exercised me more than all his arguments But 1 being in heart enclined unto the good things the other side proposed to be contended for and 2 judging his reasons might all be answered and 3 apprehending it much concerned the cause of God and of his servants and 4 my own reputation also being pre-engaged 5 and lastly my place seeming to call for it I holding then the publick Lecture in Cambridge I took all the former reluctancy of spirit to be onely a temptation and accordingly resolved to reply On Judg. 5.23 on which Mr. St. M. had preached before of whose notions that I know of I made no use Mr. J. B. which I did the next Lords day after the publishing of that Book wherein I answered all that seemed material in that Book and so answered it That some who were of the other judgment were pleased to say that so bad a cause could not be better pleaded Upon this I was sollicited to the publishing of my Answer But coming to London and finding another had done it before but especially my spirit working too and fro betwixt resolution and fear I did suppress it But that of Zachary hath been fulfilled in me since In that day the Prophets shall be ashamed Zach. 13.5 every one of his vision when he hath prophesied And blessed be God who hath verified another also towards me viz. Thou shalt hear a voice behind thee saying Isa 30.21 This is the way walk in it when thou turnest to the right-hand and when thou turnest to the left And blessed be his Name that although I have been a rebellious child as it is in the first verse of that chapter that would not take counsel of him nor cover with the covering of his spirit yet he hath not cast me away from his presence Psal 51.11 nor taken his holy Spirit from me Deliver me from bloods O Lord thou God of my salvation A Prayer and my tongue shall sing aloud of thy righteousness The sacrifice of God is a broken spirit a broken and contrite heart O God thou wilt not despise And Vphold me O Lord with thy spirit then will I teach sinners thy ways and transgressors shall be converted unto thee Lastly Do good in thy good pleasure unto Sion build thou the walls of Jerusalem then shall they offer young bullocks upon thine altar Amen Sed irrideant nos fortes potentes Aug. confess l. 4. c. 1. nos autem infirmi inopes confiteamur tibi But let great and oveâ—-grown spirits laugh at this let us that are infirm and poor in heart confess to thee Tota palea areae ipsius irridet eum Aug. in Ps 21. in Prefat in Expos 2. gemit triticum irrideri dominum All the chaff of Christs own floor laughs at him and the good corn laments its Lords derision Thus of the general and privative cause SECT II. Particular Motives 2. THe particular follow and they were such as these 1. 1. Propounded The excellency and necessity of the things held forth to be contended for the Laws namely and the Liberties of the Nation and that which made them both most precious Religion Protestant by them established and secured 2. Next the credit that I gave unto the persons that did propound them both for their ability and for their faithfulness 3. A third was the awful opinion that I conceived of the power and authority of that place from which they seem'd to issue to wit the Parliament 4. That the exigences being such there was a virtual bond by all Laws to use remedies that were not usual 5. and lastly That examples of the like had been in Scripture among the Jews in the Primitive Church the former against Antiochus by the Maccabees the latter of the Christians against Maximinus Also in the Reformed Churches as the French Holland Scottish and owned by our former Princes and then present King defended also by our own Divines and Bishops as Jewel Abbot Bilson c. 2. Replies unto them But all these and such like as applyed to our case being put into the ballance of the Sanctuary in my eye seem much too light As touching the first my opinion and veneration of the Protestant Religion 1. Religion the Laws and Liberties of the Nation I hope is greater now than it was as I know them somewhat better But touching Religion to be defended by Arms especially of Subjects well spake the Dantzikers A notable speech of the Dantzikeâ—s in their material Letter to the Duke of Croy exhorting them to the like May 27. 1656. Evidently it doth appear say they how much the Roman-Catholicks are incensed through this war and that from thence no small persecutions yea the greatest danger may befall the Reformed Churches Vid. Mercurius Politicus Jul. 3. 1656. if God do not prevent it in his mercy We do confidently believe that no body can think or impute it to us as if God took pleasure in Apostates and Hypocrites and as if he would have Religion promoted in casting off the lawful Magistrate Note and in the slender esteem of a well grounded government Call to mind how at all times by Warrs the spirits of men grow more barbarous and inhumane Note and how the wars for Religion use commonly to extinguish Religion Thus they Note Now I call God to witness upon my soul that the sense of the dishonor done unto the Protestant Religion 2 Cor. 1. working upon my heart hath been one main occasion of further examining the grounds of those transactions and of altering my thoughts Homil. of disobedience part 4. pag. 300. And particularly one passage in the doctrine of this Protestant Church expressed in the Homily of disobedience did much affect me of which anon This for Religion 2. Then for the Laws and Liberties seeing first 2. Laws and Liberties that both Houses of Lords and Commons in all their solemn addresses to the King and that in Parliament and as such a Parliamentary body 1. Style of the H. H. do usually style themselves thus Your Majesties most humble and loyal subjects the Lords and Commons in Parliament assembled In that Remonstrance which the King saith Kings Declaration Aug. 12. 1642. Remonstr of the State of
formidable examples in the Ministery of those who not without very probable gâ—ounds and weighty advice have receded from their places provided that they could eat their bread in them though perhaps but course or not over-powered with other temptations or distractions Considerable are the words of Calvin to this purpose Ita respicienda est vocatio tua ut ab omnibus avocamentis sensus tuos omnes avertas In Epist ad Philip. cap. 2. 21. Licet alibi opulentiùs vivere At Deus te alligavit Ecclesiae quae tenuitur modò te alat Alibi plus honoris sed eum tibi locum attribuit Deus in quo humiliter vivas A ibi salubrius coelum aut amoenior Regio sed hîc tibi statio ordinata est Optares tibi cum humaniore populo esse negotium offendit te vel ingratitudo vel ferocitas vel superbia denique cum genio moribus Gentis minimè convenit Atqui luctandum est tibi tecum vis quodammodo contrariis votis est afferenda ut spartam quam nactus es colas Which passage truly I left un-Englished but remembring it may do some good unto the * The Wives of Ministers weaker sex 't is this Thou art so to observe where God hath called thee that thou must shut thine eyes from all enticements thence Elsewhere thou maist live more plentifully but God hath bound thee to a Parish which will but keep thee sparingly There is more credit to be had else where but God hath assigned thee a place whâ—re thou must live obscurely The aire is better at such a place and the Country far more pleasant but here thou are appointed Sentinel Thou couldst wish thou hadst to deal with a better natur'd people thou art troubled at their ingratitude at their rudeness at their pride and insolency in a word thou canst not away with the spirit anâ— disposition of the people But thou must wrastle with thy self and offer a kind of force to all opposite affections that so thou maist adorn that Spouse to which thou art engaged Thâ—s far there But the Sauce is not all Vineger He therâ—fore adds in the same place Idem ibid. Eatenus concedendum est Ecclesiae ministris sua quaerere ut non impediantur à quaerendo Christi Regno sed hoc modo jam non dicentur sua quaerere quoniam à praecipuo scopo aestimatur vita hominis Thus far saith he it must be granted unto Ministers to seek their own so as they may not be hindred from seeking the Kingdom of Christ But on this account they are not now to be said to seâ—k their own because we are to judge of a mans way by the scope and end he aimes at Thus he Conc. Nice Can. 16. And the Council of Nice â—ath this Canon Ne de civitate inferiori ad majorem Ecclesiam transire quis ambiat sive Episcopus sive etiam aliùs Clericus That no man be he Bishop or other Clergy-man should endeavour to go from a meaner to a greater place or people Concil Trid. Sess 3. sub Jul. 3. Can. 5. And there is reason for it seeing it is seldom that he can sine magno suo Eccâ—esiae incommodo gregem sibi concreditum relinquere ac non sine Episcopalis dignitatis diminutions Leave the flock entrusted to him without great inconvenience both to himself and them and without disgrace to his ministerial function Psal 92. as the Council of Trent hath it But to return God hath promised to keep us in all our ways whilst we are in our way 2 Sam. 11.1 2. we are under protection Now as was implyed above this degree of spiritual fornication is occasioned sometime as the other was in David Desidosus erat The hand that is not busie will Object the head to wandring still This for the occasion of my Lapse SECT II. The Causes Privative BUt the Causes were as in the former Controversie partly general and privative partly positive and particular The general was that as I had in the former through zeal without knowlâ—dge resisted the Spirit of God so I committed here the same error upon the same grounds against the Word of â—od For why may I not call it the Word of God which was first in it self a truth and that one of main concernment and then spoken when I was leaving my relation and as it were at Farewell when words use to be of most weight and lastly uttered by Dr. Laud Arch-bish of Cant. my honourable Lord and Master one whose place was in solemn manner to declare it Although his person should have been as bad as his who prophesied being the * Joh. 11.51 High-priest It was this viz. An Admonition to adhere unto the Church of England without turnig unto the right-hand or unto the left To which most Sovereign counsel if the Author's self did not in all things correspond as some have published he had therein no servant of me and yet he did confer upon me no common favours By vertue whereof I enjoyed the benefit of the best part of my education and preparation for the Ministery Unto whom living or dead I have not return'd evil willingly But on the contrary being sollicited and that with some kind of intermination to be and afterward cited as a witness against him I appeared not When the Lord Cromwel in Henry the eighth's time Fox Acts Mon. in the life of Cromwel was glaned at by one for having been servant unto Cardinal Wolsey he not onely did acknowledge it but professed also his grateful memory of the benefits he received from him Because his Lordship may have with some though not meriting the like resentment with the Cardinal This for the occasion and cause privative SECT III. Causes Positive THe Causes Positive First 1. Of Recess from the Church I took offence at some things in the Church in the Assemblies the Worship and the Discipline neither perceiving the beam in my own eye nor the beauty of that Spouse that seemed black Cant. 1.4 14. but was comely in the eye of Christ no nor the deformity of the Concubine that was but painted over An adulterous spirit sees beauty in any but his own wife Next 2. Of Access unto Independency I was taken not undeservedly with the good gifts and preaching that I perceived in certain of the Independent way And I did not well apply then what I had sometime done viz. To mark those that caused divisions and offences Rom. 16.17 contrary to the doctrines which I had received and avoid them because they that are such serve not our Lord Jesus Christ but their own bellies and with sweet preaching so Mr. Tindal and flattering words deceive the hearts of the Innocents But the main was a love to that beauty of holiness in Order and Ordinances which they predicated and spake so much of Now Aug. de utilit cred cap.
〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 high detonations and thundrings Of it what the Antients thought we shall hear from Austin Aug. contr Epist Parm. l. 3. c. 2. Consilia separationis inauia sunt pernitiosa atque sacrilega quia impia superba sunt Thoughts saith he of separation are vain and pestilent yea sacrilegious because they are ungodly and presumptuous Tom. 7. part 1. And one half of a whole Tome of his is on this Argument 2. But more especially Five things in the Church pretended as grounds of separation There are five things in the Church from whence there might be pretended ground of separation viz. the Doctrine the Worship the Assemblies the Discipline and the Government Now there are against them Exceptions both general and particular First generally in no less than seven accusations First that many things in â—hem are unnecessary 1. General exceptions against them Secondly inconvenient and of ill consequence to the Church Thirdly for their rise but human inventions Or fourthly at the best but Apocryphal not Scriptural Yea fifthly Popish superstitions and taken out of the Mass-book Moreover sixthly such as are not established by the Laws of this Church and Nation Seventhly and lastly that there is an engagement for the removing or reforming of them all in the late Solemn League and Covenant I might for answer unto all these as also to the particular exceptions against any of the premises and the matter of them refer the Reader unto that elaborate and in my judgment unanswerable work of the learned Hooker In which Argument I may truly say of him Prefat in Ecles polit n. 2. as he doth of Calvin in reference to his Commentaries and Institutions viz. In which whosoever after him bestowed their labour he gained the advantage of prejudice against them if they gain-said and of glory above them if they consented So fully hath he therein vindicated the Worship and Discipline of this Church Colon. in Compend Calv. Inst in prefat And therefore Quem tu studiosa juventus Nocturnâ versate manu versate diurnâ To be commended to the diligent perusal of all that love the peace of this Jerusalem But because new pens must be apposed to Neoterick Opponents and my Argument engages me I shall speak something SECT I. Unnecessary TO begin with the first viz. That many things in them are unnecessary For answer Answ It should be considered that 't is easie for private men Private men and those in a lower station to mistake in judging of the motions of superior Orbs and Intelligences A man that stands upon the Watch-tower and such are publick persons sees what those should do who are beneath him Ezek. 3.17 and what is necessary better than a wiser man that is below The reason is that men of inferior place are not assisted with the advantage of so much information with the presence and general view of so many things nor ordinarily with that measure of the Spirit as being to act both in a narrower and a lower sphere which God doth usually Publick persons and as it were pro formâ communicate unto men of higher place who for the good of mankind and of his Church doth commonly furnish men according to the places he calleth them unto 1 Sâ—m 10.6 Saul being appointed King was forthwith indued with another spirit So the High Priest that crucified the Lord Jesus Joh. 11.51 uttered a mysterious and most precious Oracle touching the extent of the death of Chrâ—st for all the children of God scattered abroad in all Nations And 't is expressly added Being the High priest that year as representing the cause And a divine sentence saith Solomon is in the mouth of the King Prov. 16.10 his lips do not transgress in judgment Now if he assisted the former and such like How much more then is he the Author of those Laws injoyning what is necessary in his Church which have been made by his Saints indued further with the heavenly grace of his Spirit and directed as much as might be with such instructions R Hook Eccles pol. lib. 3. sect 9. as his sacred Woâ—d doth yield saith my Author And I may add and several of whom have laid down their lives for his truth SECT II. Inconvenient and of ill consequence A Second general Exception against the premises is that they are Inconvenient and of evil consequence first scandalous to the weak occasions of silencing able Ministers and of troubling many good people To the first Answ Scandal what Rom. 14.21 13. 1 Cor. 8.9 scandal is not that which some persons may be offended at but properly that which makes our brother to offend and stumble as it is implicitely described by the Apostle Now the things we speak of are for the keeping of them from falling and in the right way If any will censure before he see and understand the matter we must object unto them the Apostles own practise who did boâ—h circumcise Act. 16.3 with Gal. 2.3 5. and refuse also to circumcise yea and sacrifice too as he saw it made for more general edification Though it could not be without offence to some both Jews and Gentiles Act. 21.26 and seem'd unto them scandalous insomuch that the Apostles at Jerusalem perswaded him to use certain of the legal Ceremonies and to sacrifice for the satisfying of some that were so prejudiced against him To the second 2. Able Ministers silenced That the premises are occasions that some able Ministers not conforming are silenced They must remember that it is not the goodness of the timber nor bigness of the piece that makes it useful for the building but its fitness If it be knotty or crooked or otherwise unproportionable a less and of meaner stuff may do better When the Apostle saith 2 Cor. 11. that certain Ministers were transformed into Angels of light doth he not imply that they were men both of parts great and piety very specious and yet for the rents that they made in the Churches calleth them the ministers of Satan and else-where wisheth Gal. 5. that they were cut off It is not the skill of a soldier nor his courage but his obedience unto government that makes him capable of an Office Metall without breaking makes the Horse to cast hâ—s Rider And St. Austin Contra Parmen l. 1. c. 1. when he commends Tichonius the Donatist as hominem acri ingenio praeditum uberi eloquio himself a man inâ—ued with a sharp wit and fluent eloquence Rom. 16 1â— would not yet have had him his Colleague at Hippo for men by sweet preaching as was noted before may cause such divisions in the Church that the brethren may be warned to beware of them And it will lie at their own and not at the Churches dore if their Talent have been wrapped up in a napkin And it had been better both for this Church and Nation
truly defined by St. Paul to be a departing from the faith it shall be evident that these are no Popery It is prudently uttered by King James Conf. Hamp Court pag. 75. Answ when the like was before him objected of some of these matters That no Church ought further to separate it self from the Church of Rome I may add or from any other Church either in Doctrine or Ceremony than she had departed from her self and from Christ her Lord and head And indeed it is a Popish and superstitious principle to take nothing of those Churches that are opposite to them which is an issue of their pride and arrogance R. Hook Eccles pol. l. 5. §. 68. p. 368. Calv. Epist ad Socinum 1549. vid. Et Instiâ— lib. 4. cap. 2. § 11. which some now imitate on the other side Now it must be noted ' Thot those that hold the head the confession of faith do all joyn in the root though they separate above and in the branches Hence Ecclesiam aliquam manere in Papatu There is some Church remaining in the Papacy saith Calvin Others I might name but take Zanchy's notable word for all Nescio quo singulari beneficio Dei hoc adhuc boni in Romanâ Ecclesia servari nemo non vidit nisi qui videre non vult Quod nimirum sicut semper sic nunc etiam constans firma in verâ de Deo deque personâ Domini nostri Jesu Christi doctrinâ persistit Et Baptizat in nomine Patris Filii Spiritus sancti Christumque agnoscit praedicat pro unico mundi Redemptore futuroque vivorum mortuorum judice qui veros fideles secum in aeternum vitam recepturus incredulos autem impios in aeternum ignem cum diabolo Angelis ejus ejecturus sit Quae causa est cur Ecclesiam HANC pro Ecclesia CHRISTI etiamum agnoscam sed quali Qualis ab Osea aliisque prophetis Ecclesia Israelis sub Jeroboamo deinceps fuisse describitur nunquam enim resipuit à suis fornicationibus That is I know not by what kind of special mercy of God Zanch. ep dedic ante confess suam Tom. 8. but so it is that thus much good remains in the Church of Rome which every man sees but they that will see nothing Namely that as always The Roman Church what remains found in it so now it persists firm and constant in the true doctrine concerning God and concerning the Person of our Lord Jesus Christ And Baptizeth in the Name of the Father and of the Son and of the holy Ghost And doth acknowledge and preach Christ for the onely Redeemer of the world and he that shall be the Judge of the quick and the dead Who also shall receive unto himself all true believers unto eternal life and who shall reject unto everlasting fire with the devil and his angels all unbelievers and wicked men For which reason I do in some sort acknowledge THIS for a Church of CHRIST But what kind of one namely such as the Church of Israel is described to be under Jeroboam and afterwards by Hosea and other Prophets for she never repented of her fornications Thus he Some kind of Church of Christ then it being Hence it follows first that all things in Popery are not superstitious for if a Church there must be somewhat of the Spirit of God and of Christ in them Joh. 1. Joh. 16. to guide and keep it in these truths Else why do these Brethren read the Popish writers the Jesuites and Schoolmen as some of them have the best spoak in their cart from thence and preach much of their matter and notions to their people The superstition may be either in the opinion that they had of them or the abuse they made of them which being removed the thing may be lawful even in individuo As the flesh that had been consecrated to an Idol 1 Cor. 8. even that very flesh might have been bought or eaten by the strong and those that knew the truth As God be praised our people do in the things excepted against no man putting any confidence in them but in Christ alone observing them onely for order edification and decency Secondly Some kind of respect must have been given to that Church as a Church of Christ in some sense by the Reformers both for preventing offence in respect of them abroad and for the regaining of the brethren of this Nation amongst us misled that way as the Apostle saith I become all things to all men 1 Cor. 9. ad fin that I might by all means win some If therefore what could not be thâ—n or cannot be now without danger in those respects left off be retained still the doctrine of the Church in the mean time being fully opened and professed it is charity not Popery and wisdom godly not superstition ' for we must have respect unto the weak 1 Cor. 14. Object Before we leave this If it be objected that the Church of * Homily on Whitsunday part 3. Homily of Rebellion in several places and in other Homilies England doth seem to hold the Church of Rome the seat of Anti-Christ and the Pope to be his very peson It is answered suppose it do so Answ yet doth it not therefore follow but that the Church of Rome hath something in it of a true Church 2 Thess 2. else how should Antichrist sit in the Temple of God which is his Church if the seat of Antichrist were not in some respects a Church And that the Church of England doth acknowledge that Rome hath something of a Church in it it s retaining the Baptism and Ministery of that Church it s not re-baptizing or new-ordaining those that come to it from that 2. The Mass-book doth plainly shew This for Popery and the Church of Rome in general Secondly for the Mass-book in particular Cic. Joh. 1. De Justific lib. 5. cap. 7. sit tertia propositio Missale Rom. edit Paris 1787. The Mass-book against merits Let us see whether any gold be in Ennius dung whether any good thing can come out of Nazareth and whether any truth and piety out of the Mass-book Bellarmine who knew its meaning well and in a cause wherein if any where he should have pass'd it by proves out of the Mass-book that we can have no trust nor confidence in our own work and merits for salvation but onely in the mercy of God In which as in the Master-vein doth run the life-blood of all Religion The words are a] Collectâ in sexagessimâ Deus qui conspicis quia ex nulla nostrâ actione confidimus Item b] Collect. secreta dom Adventus 2. ubi nulla suppetunt suffragia meritorum tuis nobis succurre praesidiis Item c] In canone post consecration in orat prox post comemorat pro defunct de multiâ—udine miserationum tuarum sperantib c.
of Worship in the nerves and sinews of Discipline and in the bones and strength of Government which no true Son of the Church of England can without indignation reflect on Thirdly it striketh at the very beeing and safety of it For first this will both nourish and breed Papists and Separatists when they shall consider that by this Oath we have acknowledged that there is no one part Isa 1. wholly sound in this Church but that from the crown of the head to the sole of the foot there are wounds sores and putrifying corruptions And being the expressions are indefinite they cannot tell what in any part is sound nor know what to cleave unto and so are prepared for apostacy from it 4. Schismaticall illegal oppressive to to the Government of the Church or confirmed therein 4. This Covenant sweareth a Schisme and is an unjust Oath as it is injurious and oppressive to the Government of this Church and the express Law whereby it is established to wit Episcopacy not to insist on the ranking of it with Popery and Superstition The Church of England is founded in Prelacy saith the Luws Of which before And the King in his Oath swears to defend the Rights of this Church Yea this order is by the Laws in force before 17 Car. 11. the very next the King himself in Parliam for so the style runneth the Lords Spiritual and Temporall The right of Episcopacy out of Scripture Antiquity and the late Reformers hath been shewed before and out of the Law of England also Now to swear against a main point of the Law of the Land wherein we have the suffrage of the whole Church and against that order of men both under which Bishops as Cranmer and others special instruments of the Reformation and by influence whereof we first received the Gospel and several whereof sealed it in opposition to Popery and Superstition with their blood Five Bishops being burned viz. Cranmer Arch-Bishop of Cant. Ridley Bishop of London Hooper and Latimer Bishops of Gloucester and Wortester and Ferrar Bishop of St. Davids is such a piece of unchristianity injustice and ingratitude yea and perjury also in those that have subscribed the three Articles and taken the Oath of Canonical obedience that I should wish mine eyes a fountain of tears to bewail it and my quill the pen of a more ready Writer to describe it Pudet haec opprobria nobis c. What shame is it that this should spoken be And nothing to be said to th' contray 5. It is of most dangerous insinuation 5. Of most dangerous insinuation against the dignity person and authority of the King in respect of the Kings Authority Dignity and Person First To his Dignity in putting him after the Parliaments and Kingdoms and yet put the Parliaments before the Kingdoms as if he were inferiour unto both whereas by our Oath of Supremacy we do acknowledge him to be over all persons within these his Realms and Dominions Supreme Governour And have in that and in the Oath of Allegiance and in the Protestation sworn and engaged to maintain his honour and priviledges Secondly It insinuates most imminent danger unto the Kings Person and Authority whilest it engageth to preserve and defend the Kings Majesties Person and Authority in the preservation and defence of the true Religion and Liberties of the Kingdoms Openly implying that both the one and the other may be deserted in case he do not or seems to some not to defend true Religion and the Liberties Thirdly And for his Authority we swear obedience thereunto in the former Oaths indefinitely without such limitations as these are whence these appears to be no less then a treasonable limitation 6. It swears to betray and oppress contrary to Law 6. Is oppressive of the K. faithful subjects and true members of the Church 7. It bettaies the Liberty of the Subject in setting up an Arbitrary power against Law the Kings faithful Subjects and the true sons of the Church because they would keep faith with the one and unity with the other Artic. 4. under the names of Malignants and Hinderers of Reformation 7. It owneth the Houses of Parliament in opposition to the King to be the Supreme Judicatories and acknowledgeth a power in them of punishment to life and estate which is a betraying the Subjects Liberty as also that they may punish as they judge convenient or a Committee from them What is this but to pluck up Magna Charta by the roots which gives this priviledge that no free-born English man shall be punishable in life liberty or estate but by a Jury of his equals c. So that this is an erecting of an Arbitrary Government and destructive to the Fundamental Laws of the Land The same error is committed in the fift Article against those that should any way oppose this kind of union between the two Nations 8. In the sixt and last Article 8. Obliges to a blind a betting of all attempts in the pursuance of it 9. Engages against Repentance it obliges to defend all those that enter into this Covenant in the pursuance thereof which what it infers cannot be foreseen nor how far that clause may be extended 9. It engageth against Repentance which in an Oath of that nature and newness ought not to have been done but that juvat impiis as well as miseris socios habuisse It pleaseth them that have the plague to see That others as themselves infected bee 10. 10. Hypocritical blasphemous towards God scandalous and dangerous to other Churches and Nations Prov. 24. Eccles 10. Matth. 22. Prov. 13. 1 Pet. 2. Lastly In the Epilogue and close of it It is Horridly Hypocritical Blasphemous towards God Scandalous and Dangerous to other Churches and Nations First It is Horridly Hypocritical in acknowledging that we profess before God and the world our unfeigned desire to be humbled for our sins and the sins of these Kingdoms against God and Christ his Son c. And yet at the same time swear to dishonour both and transgress the Gospel which commands obedience of Subjects to their Princes especially in doubtful cases the King holding forth not force but law as well as they and as I am perswaded with better evidence Ezek. 20.27 Secondly It is most blasphemous and a high temptation of Almighty God to pray most humbly unto him to strengthen us by his holy Spirit to live and dye in opposition to the just Laws of the Land in sedition against our natural Prince in schism against the Church and in oppression and violence against our innocent brethren Thirdly It is Scandalous to other Nations and Churches whereby through us the name of God as called upon and professed by the Reformed was blasphemed even among the very Turks Ezek. 36.20 yea our Nation the members of it in peril wheresoever they came as Merchants and Travellers know Lastly Dangerous unto the same Churches First
Three roots of unthankfulness or pride Ignorance when we know not the Author from whom our good cometh Dissimulation when our hands are more open than our eyes upon that we receive Pride when we think our selves worthy of that which meer grace and undeserved mercy bestoweth Again the very silence that our unworthiness putteth us unto doth it self make request for us and that in confidence of his grace With which answer I end my reply unto this point The tenth particular against which they object is in Except 10 the second prayer at Baptism in which we pray Remission by spiritual Regeneration that Infants coming to Baptism may receive remission of their sins by spiritual regeneration The Brethren except That remission of sins is not received by or from spiritual regeneration but by and from the blood of Christ Heb. 9.22 1 Joh. 1.7 But they grant that remission of sins and regeneration flow from one and the same fountain and are both conveyed and sealed in Baptism Answ seminally at least Which words being before have so way-laid the other that they do not onely stop them but destroy them For if regeneration and remission of sins be both conveyed and sealed in Baptism the question onely is which is first and causal one to the other or whether they be both co-ordinate and without dependance one from the other Which doubt is soon answered if we consider first That Baptism of water through the Word is made by our Saviour the instrument of the new-birth Joh. 3. Unless saith he a man be born of water and of the holy Ghost c. And he did sanctifie and clense the Church Eph. 5. with the washing of water by the Word And he saved us by the washing of Regeneration Tit. 3. and renewing of the holy Ghost saith the Apostle Eph. 3. By Baptism we do put on Christ And are by one spirit baptized into one body viz. that of Christ Hence first we partake of the new nature are born to God and become his children whereupon follows the remission of sins by vertue indeed of the blood of Christ but this blood is not communicated out of the body nor to any but those that are members of it and by the operation of the holy Ghost regenerated therein by Baptism Matth. 27. Hence our Saviour before he gave the Cup at his last Supper wherewith he promised remission of sins he premiseth ' This is my Body speaking of the Bread first to be received which the Apostle expounding saith We being many 1 Cor. 10. are one bread and one body And that the bread is the communion of the body of Christ That first then the Cup the communion of his blood for the remission of sins Now we are baptized into this body in this body we have spiritual regeneration or the new birth Remission of sins by spiritual regenerarion and God now reckons us and owns us for his children and being such he confers the blood that is in the body for the forgiveness of sins I am not ignorant that Adoption is made an effect or consequent of our Justification and forgiveness of sins But if we consider that we must have union with Christ before we can have communion and that this communion effects first our regeneration and being born to God we shall see that remission of sin is consequent as an effect thereof We receive it by and from the blood of Christ but by the medium of Regeneration this blood being sprinkled actually on none but those that are regenerate at least sacramentally and in respect of the outward application of the Covenant of grace in which respect all the children of Israel after Circumcision Rom. 4.11 which was the seal of the righteousness of faith were owned by God as regenerate persons were his children and had the priviledge of children the remission of sins And hence it is Communion of Saints forgivness of sins that in the Creed we believe first the holy catholick Church and communion of Saints viz. conjunction into one mystical body of Christ and then the forgiveness of sins Because to this communion and the members thereof namely those that are born again and of sons of Adam are by Baptism and the holy Ghost become the sons of God is this priviledge appropriated that they have the remission of sins But that the Church ascribeth forgivness of sins even in this form of Baptism to the blood of Christ onely appears in the prayer immediately before the act of Baptizing which runs thus Almighty and everliving God whose most dearly beloved Son Jesus Christ Prayer before Baptism for the forgivness of our sins did shed out of his most pretious side both water and blood c. Then the Church shews how this regeneration is wrought Prayer after and what is the consequent of it in the prayer after Baptism namely We yield thee hearty thinks most merciful Father See the Artic. of Relig. 27. of Bapt. that it hath pleased thee to regenerate this Infant with thy holy Spirit Baptism is but the instrument to receive him for thine own child by Adoption see Adoption follows Regeneration and to incorporate him c. Secondly It is usual in Sacramental speech to understand the cause by the name of the effect and contrarily by a Metonymie as Matth. 27. This Cup is the New-Testament Circumcision is the Covenant Gen. 17. This bread is my body So here spiritual Regeneration is Baptism in the meaning of the Prayer by a Metonymie of the effect for the cause because Baptism is the instrumental cause of Regeneration So that the meaning is but this That the child may by Baptism called spiritual Regeneration Tit. 3. as the Apostle calls it the Laver of Regeneration receive forgiveness of sins as in Scripture that benefit is properly affixed first unto Baptism as Be ye baptized for the remission of sins Act. 2. And Arise and be baptised and wash away thy sins And They were baptized Matth. 3. confessing their sins that is in order to their washing away by Baptism But this derogates nothing from the blood of Christ by vertue whereof as being the ordinance and instrument of its application Baptism or spiritual Regeneration doth produce remission of sins As for that reproach the Brethren cast upon this expression as if it were mans falshood rather than Gods truth it savours of an affectation rather not to loose somewhat an elegant expression than to receive the truth in the love of it so pertinently held forth in that expression Now for close let us hear two witnesses onely to the former Doctrine viz. That we receive remission of sins by spiritual regeneration whether taking it for Baptism or for the new birth and that whether taken relatively and as by this Sacrament we are born to God and become his children foederally and by way of Covenant or taken really and as it communicates
est facit quia tota omnes tota singulos paxit Now that holy Spirit which dwells in the Saints of which Saints the Dove that is covered with silver wings is founded by the fire of love doth that which it doth by the ministery and service not onely of those who are simply ignorant but of those who are damnably wicked For children are offered to Baptism and receiving of spiritual grace not so much by them in whose hands they are carried as by the whole society of Saints and Believers For it is truly understood to be done by all who are all desirous that it should be done and by whose holy and undivided charity the children are helped to the participation of the holy Spirit The whole Church therefore which consists of the Saints doth it because she wholly hath brought forth all and every one Thus far he And again in other places more plainly though more briefly as in that vulgar one Credunt infantes Vnde credunt quomodo credunt Aug. de verb. Apost Serm. 14. cap. 19. fide parentum Si fide parentum purgantur peccato parentum polluti sunt Corpus mortis in primis parentibus generavit eos peccatores Spiritus vita in posterioribus parentibus regeneravit eos fideles Tu das fidem non respondenti ego peccatum nihil agenti Even Infants saith he believe Whence do they believe how do they believe Why by the faith of the Parents If they be purged by the faith of the Parents they are polluted by the sin of their parents The body of death in the first parents did generate them sinners The spirit of life in the following parents hath regenerated them faithful and believers Thou givest faith to him that answereth not and I communicate sin to him that acteth not Thus St. Austin Wherein we see that the repentance and faith of one is available for another to the obtaining spiritual benefits for them viz. the faith of the parents and if they fail the faith of the Church and the faith of the Sureties who are always the deputies of one or both the other And that they do perform by them repentance and faith that is the profession of them 3. Proof from recent times I shall add now one or two witnesses of later times as I promised and close this point also Calvin with all the Consistory of Geneva in the Letter above cited makes the faith of the parents or in case they fail the faith of the Church where the child is born to be available for its obtaining the priviledge of Baptism and the spiritual benefits that come thereby Calv. ep Knox. Ann. 1559. ep 285. Promissio Ero Deus tui seminis tui non sobolem tantum cujusque fidelium in primo gradu comprehendit sed in mille generationes extenditur unde ubicunque non prorsus intercidit vel extincta fuit Christianismi professio fraudantur jure suo infantes si à communi symbolo arcentur The promise I will be thy God and the God of thy seed after thee saith he doth comprehend the seed of the faithful not in the first degree onely but to a thousand generations And therefore wheresoever the profession of the Name of Christ is not wholly fallen and extinct there children are defrauded of their right if they be driven from the common obsignation and seal of it Where we see that the repentance and faith of others besides the parents is available and the undertaking of the Sureties doth not give the right but onely for orders sake and the farther engagement of the children when they come to years is superadded thereunto as being continued from the custom first taken up with men that were grown before their Baptism Continued I say both for the more solemnity of that Ordinance Use of answers in Baptism and for the use of the thing it self both as it doth represent to the grown the obligation of their Baptism and as it is an engagement upon the Infants when they come to years I end with the practise of it in the reformed Church of Colen as it is in the Liturgy composed as was said above by Melancthon Lib. Reform Colen in Bapt. Bucer and Pistorius In the form of Baptism the title is Interrogationes ad susceptores parentes ' The Questions to the sureties and the parents that we may see the sureties promised in the name of the Infant Renunciatis igitur vestro Infantis nomine diabolo atque omnibus ejus operibus Respond Renunciamus Q. Etiam mundo concupiscentiis ejus Resp Renunciamus Q. Creditis in Deum Patrem omnipotentem Creatorem coeli terrae Resp Credimus c. Do you therefore in your own and in the INFANTS name renounce the devil and all his works Answ We renounce them Q. Also the world and the lusts of it Answ We renounce them Q. Do you believe in God the Father Almighty Maker of heaven and earth Answ We believe Where you see the word in their own and the Infants name being placed first runs through all the Answers both touching repentance expressed by renouncing and also faith expressed by believing And to clear it further in the same Liturgy in the form of Confirmation in the Questions propounded to the children to be confirmed this is one Ibid. in confirm fol. 80. p. 2. Interrogatio Ergo placet tibi ratumque habes adjutus spiritu domini in eo perseverabis quod tui susceptores nomine tuo ad sacramentum Baptisma promiserunt professi sunt cum pro te renunciarunt Satanae mundo addixerunt te Christo Ecclesiae ejus in solidam evangelii obedientiam Resp Haec rata habeo in eis juvante me domino n. Jesu Christo permanebo usque ad finem That is Question Does it therefore please thee and and dost thou account firm and good and by the help of the Spirit of the Lord wilt thou persevere in that which thy Sureties Godfathers and Godmothers did promise and profess in thy name at the Sacrament of Baptism when they did in thy stead renounce the devil and the world and did consecrate thee to Christ and his Church unto serious obedience Answ These I confirm as good and binding of me and by the help of our Lord Jesus Christ I will continue in them unto the end The doctrine therefore of that Answer in the Catechism of our Liturgy is neither new nor strange but grounded on Scripture and seconded by Antiquity and the practise of the Reformed 4. Proof from civil Contracts I might also for more plainness-sake confirm it by proportion with civil contracts Wherein the undertaking of another is available for one that cannot answer for himself As when an estate doth descend upon a child with such and such conditions without which it cannot enjoy it it being presumed that what is for its good it will consent unto By vertue of anothers
religionem nobiscum profiteantur cum alioqui nihil minus revera sint quà m fratres propter innumerabilia quibus scatent vitia i. e. We do not deny saith he but that there are very many that for this cause onely are counted brethren because they profess the same pure Religion with us whereas otherwise they are indeed nothing less than brethren by reason of the innumerable vices wherewith they swarm Thus he It is then the Profession of the true Faith that makes a Brother from whom then till ejected from and by the Church we may not in matters of Religion and Worship withdraw and separate although in private converse we may because as Austin notes this may be done without danger of Schism but that cannot Nam in domibus suis quique boni fideles ita disciplinam suorum moderantur Aug. contr Parmen l. 3. cap. 2. regunt ut ibi quoque obtemperent Apostoli praecipienti cum ejusmodi nec cibum simul sumere sed non tam facilè malorum multitudo non potest à bonorum commixtione separari i. e. For in their houses all the Faithful do so order the government of those that belong unto them that they obey the Apostles Precept commanding with such a one no not to eat but not so easily a multitude of bad men are separated from the mixture with the good as to wit a bad member of a family may The next shall be Calvin whom some would make a Patron in their way of separating he discoursing of this point among other vehement expressions hath this Instit lib. 4. cap. 1. s 9. Vbi reverenter auditur Evangelii praedicatio neque sacramenta negliguntur illic pro eo tempore neque fallax neque ambigua Ecclesiae apparet facies cujus vel authoritatem spernere vel monita respuere vel consiliis refragari vel castigationes ludere nemini impunè licet multo minus ab ea deficere ac ejus abrumpere unitatem c. i. e. A true Church Wheresoever the preaching of the Gospel is reverently heard and the Sacraments are not neglected there for that time there appears neither a deceitful nor a doubtful face of a Church whose authority they that despise or contemn its counsels or reject its advice or make sport with its chastenings they shall never escape unpunished much less if they fall off from it and rend the Unity of it And afterward Sect. 16. Quanquam autem ex inconsiderato justitiae zelo haec tentatio bonis etiam interdum oboritur hoc tamen recipiemus nimiam morositatem ex superbia magis factu falfâque sanctitatis opinione quà m ex vera sanctitate veroque ejus studio nasci The Cause of separation That is Although this temptation doth arise sometimes even in good men by an inconsiderate zeal of Righteousness yet this we shall finde That too much strictness doth grow rather of pride and height and a false opinion of Holiness than of true Holiness or a true zeal for it Thus he And he doth in that Chapter Sect. 14 15 17 18 19. by examples not onely of the Church of the Jews and in the time of our Saviour Christ but also in the Apostolical Churches demonstrate That greater Vices in Manners and fouler Errors in Doctrine to have been tolerated than are in those Churches that Separation is now made from And adds this memorable Note viz. Quondam autem sacrum unitatis vinculum solvunt nemo justani impii hujus divortii poenam effugit quin se pestiferis erroribus ac teterrimis deliriis fascinet The punishment of separation i. e. But because they dissolve the sacred bond of Unity no man shall escape this just punishment That he shall intoxicate himself with most pestilent Errors and most pernicious fancies Thus he The truth whereof with horror we see at this day in the Anabaptists and Quakers who first began with Separation But the whole discourse in that Chapter is well worth the serious perusal The last Witness from these Churches shall be his Vide Sleid in lib. 15. Ad Ann. 1543. unto whom as the Forreign so our own Church ows much of its Reformation As besides his other Writings appears in that excellent Liturgy of the Church of Colen composed by him Melancthon and Pistemus of which before As also in his censure of our own Common Prayer Book he as I said Bucer Script Anglic. in his Commentary on Zephany Chap. 3. it is at the end of his Exposition on the Evangelists and the Psalms hath a vivide practical and experimental Discourse most effectual to this purpose part whereof is as followeth Indubiè haud temerè factum est Bucer in Zeph. 3.15 c. ut nullum ferè pietatis exemplum scriptura paulo magnificentius praedicet in quo non uno Christo excepto simul insignem lapsum notavit Quà m foede lapsus fuit Aaron David Petrus sed ne Moses quidem perpetuo stetit aut quisquam sanctorum alius Vult enim Deus ex suorum infirmitate bonitatis suae gloriam illustrare Equidem al quot novi qui proximo sexennio quo Evangelium Christi mundus iterum coepit persequi pro Christo mortem fortissime oppetierunt in quibus paulo ante vitam severiorem nemo non desiderabat ita tamen corda eorum timor Dei possederat ut licet plus nimio carni per omnem fere vitam indulsissent ubi eo ventum fuit ut vel negandus illis Christus erat vel semeltota caro igni tradenda alacri vultu confidenti pectore mortis durissimos cruciatus vitae admodum lautae delicataeque quam eis mundus promittebat protulerint That is Doubtless it is not without cause That the Scripture doth not make mention scarce of any great example of piety Christ onely excepted who is not noted for some remarkable failing For how fouly did Aaron David and Peter fall Yea Moses himself did not always stand no nor any other of the Saints For God will by the infirmity of his Saints take occasion to illustrate the glory of his goodness Truly I have known some within these six last years wherein the world hath begun again to persecute the Gospel who have couragiously undergone death for Christ in whom a little before there was no man but could have wished a more sober life But the fear of God had so possessed their hearts that though they had too much indulged the flesh almost all their life yet when it came to that point that they must either deny Christ or else deliver the whole flesh to the fire at once they did with a chearful countenance and a confident spirit prefer the most cruel torments of death before a dainty and delicate life which the world proffered them Thus he And having mentioned others such who at that time of his writing did undergo most grievous sufferings for the Truth he adds Vt enim
Baptism in the administration of the Lords Supper c. are first rehearsed and then at the act of Ministring a prayer is used not a Magisterial use of the very words of Christ himself in the first institution First it is untrue that there is any difference in this Answ between Ordination and Baptism or the Lords Supper for as in these there goeth prayer before and after So also in this of Ordination But in the very act there is used a Magisterial if the Brethren will have it so or an authoritative command precept or imperative expression In Baptism I baptize thee in the name of the Father c. not a praying that hee may be baptized The sense whereof is I wash away thy sins or as Ananias to Paul arise and be baptized and wash away thy sins Act. 22.16 which is Magisterial and commanding At the least it is an using of the very words of Christ himself at the first institution as neer as may bee which the Brethren deny to be lawful So in the Lords Supper It is not in the very act I pray that thou mayest be one for whom Christ died and that thou mayest feed on him by Faith But a peremptory assertion that Christ died for him and an imperative command that hee should feed on him by Faith In neither the one Sacrament nor the other is there a prayer used in the very act of administring Neither were it unlawful if the former were in the Lords Supper Take thou the body of Christ take thou his blood which some have used But that our Church for the avoiding of Superstition hath been forced to use other words The Germane and Dutch Churches use a form not unlike that now named The Dutch Form of the Lords Supper in the Dutch Churches The bread which wee break is the communion of the body of Christ take and eat it where they are commanded to take the body of Christ as peremptorily as the Minister is commanded to take the Holy Ghost So in the Cup. But none can give the body and blood of Christ but himself onely And in the Germane Church of Colen Liber Reform Colen in the Liturgy above mentioned in the form of giving the Lords Supper Accipe manduca ad salutem tuam corpus Domini quod pro te traditum est Take and eat the body of Christ to thy salvation c. But secondly as was said above if the words may bear the fotm of a prayer also there needs no altering unless it bee of the Brethrens spirit unto more charity Again wherein wee differ from the very words of Institution it is partly because it would bee incongruous to use them as to say This is my body which is given for you c. And partly to prevent as was said such superstitions as had grown into the use of that Sacrament for want of a more clear explication of those words But it is not incongruous english to say as a Deputy in the name of the Original Author receive the Holy Ghost So also there hath no Superstition arisen upon these words because by Doctrine prevented elsewhere by reason whereof the Church should be constrained to change the very words of our Saviour Especially seeing they serve more emphatically to confirm the assurance of the Minister in his call as also to beget a greater Authority for his person and office in the hearts of the people both which is very necessary Ac uberrimum h. doctrinae fructum quotidie percipit Ecclesia dum pastores suos intelligit divinitus ordinatos esse aeternae salutis sponsoris Cal. in Joh. 20.23 Whilst the people hereby understand that their Ministers are ordained by God to be his Embassadors If it be replied Object that it nourisheth a Popish opinion of the Episcopal and Priestly power to convey the Holy Ghost Object and to forgive sins Answ It is answered that neither of these opinions are Popish but onely the Application of them to unfit persons and the perverse exposition of them as if they had such power in their sleeve to dispense when and to whom they pleased The danger whereof is not such among us who are better taught as that wee should for it alter the words of institution and form of ordaining of which there is such particular use To their third exception that it countenances a sole Except 3 power of Ordination Answ the very form of Ordination answers which appoints that the Bishops with the Priests or Ministers that are present shall lay on their hands and not the Bishop alone To their last of offence to Except 4 Protestant Churches abroad Vide Harm confess they have not declared any such offence in their publick confessions in reference to our Church that I know of nor will if they consider our Doctrine in this particular Answ If some particular men should not be satisfied if for that wee should alter wee should do it rather for the Brethren who are or have been of our own Church But to satisfie a few we may not by unnecessary change scandalize many more To conclude the sense of our Church in these words and this ceremony might be expressed in that of Austin ' on those words Received yee the Spirit by the works of the Law or by the hearing of Faith Aug. in Gal. 3. 2. Tom. 4. Ab Apostolo praedicata est eis fides in qua praedicatione utique adventum praesentiam spiriti sancti senserant By the Apostle saith hee the Faith was preached unto them in which preaching verily there was felt the coming and presence of the Holy Ghost So doth our Church give the Spirit whilst shee repeating the words of Institution intends and prayes that those to whom her word is directed and for whom her prayers Annot. in Joh. 20.22 in Indic Authoâ—it ap Aug. tanquam ex Serm. 11. de verb. dom Tom. 10 quanquam id ibi non invenio sententia tamen proba est may feel the coming and presence of the Spirit I end all with the words of that Author Insufflavit dixit accipite Sp. S. Ecclesiastica iis verbis poâ—estas coâ—lata esse intelligitur inspiratio ergo haec gratia quaedam est quae per traditionem infunditur ordinatis He breathed on them and said Receive the Holy Ghost in these words wee must understand saith hee an Ecclesiastical power is given This Inspiration therefore is a certain grace or priviledge which by delivery in imposition of hands is infused into the ordained which sentence being it takes in both the power and the gift may not unfitly being expounded as a Ministerial act assisted with prayer close this dissertation SUBSECT IV. Consecration of Bishops and Archbishops c. 3. Gen. Exception against book of Ordination THe last Exception they have against the book of Ordination is about consecration of Bishops and Archbishops Where first that because that the same portion of Scripture is appointed to
Presbyter and Bishop as the Brethren do and that of Paul made him an Evangelist is to make him twice ordained which is not once proved and therefore may as easily be denied This for that they produce out of the Gospel To what they say from Law viz. That the Statute 13. Eliz. 12. binding all men not ordained by the Ordination book to subscribe the Articles before the feast of the nativity then coming and the Brethren thence inferring that the Law did not intend to binde all to this form of Ordination It is easie to see that the Statute refers to those then not ordained by it but by other order or in other places but is no cloak for any since What in the fifth place they add that this affixing the right of Ordination unto Bishops doth unchurch all the Protestant Churches is a cast of their office which is to calumniate For that is law and order in one place which is confusion or Schism in another The Apostles Rule 2 Thes 3. Reformed Churches That every man meddle with his own business may bee in some sense applicable to Churches also Wee know our own duty wee hope charitably they would do theirs had they the liberty wee have or the light They condemn not us wee despise not them but give them the right hand of fellowship and when occasion serves wee declare that wee are with them and they with us one bread and one body SECT IV. Of the book of Ordination SUBSECT I. Bishops imposition of hands on Deacons NExt that they may mark out iniquity and accomplish a diligent search for it and that so the nakedness of their Father and Mother if any were might in no part be covered with the veil of charity or modesty but exposed to the contempt and scorn of those in Gath and Askelon They fall upon the book of Ordination But what Book sure such as is written sententiis vivis The book of Ordination as the Jesuite spake of Savanarola upon the Psalms So composed for strength of Doctrine and piety of expression that there is no religious heart can think but that they were guided in it by the very Spirit of God and which did the Brethren conscionably peruse they would finde as wee say other fish to fry and instead of quarrelling with it fall down and ask God forgiveness for their breach of what they promised when they were ordained by it But to the particulars Omitting their quarrel to the three orders and the word Priest answered before Come wee to their exception against the ordering of Deacons which is P. 45. that the imposition of the hands of the Bishop alone upon them is contrary to Acts the sixth where 't is said that They and not one of them onely laid their hands on them But if it be of necessity that at the ordaining of the Deacon there must be the hands of all the Apostles or Ministers present Then more should be required thereunto than to the making of a Minister or a Bishop for that was done by Pauls hand as himself witnesseth in Timothy or at least it will follow that one Apostle 2 Timothy 2. if the rest were present had not power to make a Deacon Secondly Is it any way probable that all the Twelve laid their hands upon every one May not rather Calvins opinion above cited hee admitted viz. ' that one onely did it in the name of the rest Thirdly How will it follow that if all the Apostles laid on hands that therefore every Minister present with the Bishop must do so too unless they can shew that every private Minister doth come as neer the dignity of an Apostle as a Bishop doth who is a Governour of the Church Fourthly It is well noted in the Articles that some superstitions in the Church though there it speaks in another case have grown Artic. 25. of the Sacrament partly of the corrupt following of the Apostles The Apostles and not one onely might lay on hands because there were several to bee ordained And many occasions did admonish them of expedition Again Their Deacons were not in all points as ours which are admitted into the order of the Ministry Why the sole imposition of the Bishops hands is used in Deacons which because an inferiour one to represent the distinction of it and the dignity of the other viz. The Ministry usually so called or Priesthood it was thought convenient to impose the sole hand of the Bishop in the one But for more solemnity not more efficacies sake to adjoyn other Ministers to the Bishop in the other SUBSECT II. Apostles choose Deacons THey except secondly against that passage in the Except 2 prayer where it is said that God did inspire his Apostles to chuse into this order St. Stephen c. whereas they say Act. 6. the Text saith it was the multitude Now the Brethren say it was by order from the Apostles And it hindreth not but that the Apostles might chuse with them or if not their approbation is their chusing after the multitude had made theirs Where the Brethren say that to say the Apostles chose them directly ' crosseth the Text they give us a taste of their learning and of their Logick With them it seems Except 3 subordinata simul vera are contradictoria and Jonathan and David mortal enemies SUBSECT III. Receive the Holy Ghost BUt that which most offendeth say they is N. 3. Receive the Holy Ghost that in the very act of ordaining Priests or Ministers the Bishop takes upon him to give that which none but God himself hath power to bestow where it saith Receive the Holy Ghost c. which be the words of Christ himself to his Apostles without any warrant from him to bee used by any other Because in other ministrations where the words of Institution in Baptism in the administration of the Lords Supper c. are first rehearsed and then at the Act of ministring a prayer is used not a Magisterial use of the very words of Christ himself in the first institution For answer Answ First the Bishop is not to be laden with this odium alone if any were just but the rest of the Ministers also that impose hands with him the Bishop for orders sake being but their mouth But to the matter First To the thing it self next to their exceptions against it To the former Wee must first remember that the Holy Ghost is Christs Vicar upon earth in the Government of the Church in general Joh. 14. chap. 15. chap. 16. and therefore sent by him for that purpose And particularly assumeth to himself the calling of the Ministry As separate unto mee saith the Holy Ghost Barnabas and Saul for the work that I have appointed them Act. 13.2 And take heed unto your selves and unto the flock over which the Holy Ghost hath made you over-seers Act. 20. saith the Apostle to the Ministers of Ephesus Whence it