who shall haue care of the spirituall and eternall life But let the one not encroache vpon the other let both helpe one another and both are stronger as was excellently obserued by NICHOLAS the Pope Nichol. epist ad Michael Imp. cap. Gum ad verum ventum est d. 96. Cum ad verum ventum est neque Imperator Iura Pontificatus arripuit nec Pontifex nomen Imperatoris vsurpauit quoniaem idem Mediator Dei hominum homo CHRISTVS IESVS sic propriis actibus dignitatibus distinctis officia Potestatis vtriusque difcreuit vt Christiani Imperatores pro aeternâ vitâ Pontificibus indigerent Pontifices pro cursu temporalium tantummodo rerum Imperialibus legibus vterentur VVhen it came to the vnderstanding of the truth neither the Emperour did take vnto him the rightes of Bishop-like authorotitie nor the Bishop did vsurp the name of the Emperour because the same Mediatour of God and men man Christ Iesus hath distinguished the offices of both powers by their proper actes and distinct dignities as that Christian Emperours for attaining eternall life should neede Bishops and Bishops should vse the Imperiall lawes for the cause only of temporall thinges 3. But as both are necessarie so both are not equall but the one inferiour to the other the one subordinate to the other else the one would be an hindraÌ„ce to the other and both would cause confusion And certes if we will not preferre the bodie before the soule heauen before earth temporall before eternall life VVe must preferre the spirituall and Ecclesiastieall power before the Temporall and consequentlie the Church before the Common VVealth 4. These two powers and the preemineÌ„ce of the spirituall before the Temporall were prefigured as Turrecremata hath well remarked by the two brazen Pillars in the Porch of Salomons Temple The Porch was a figure of the Church Militant Turrecr lib. 4. cap. 87. 3. Reg. 7. the Inner Temple of the Church Triumphant because as by the Porch the Iewes entred into the Temple so by the Church Militant and by no other way Christians haue entrance into the Church Triumphant The two brazen Pillars that sustained the Porch signified the Power Temporall spirituall which support the Church Militant and the pillar on the right hand signified the spirituall power the Pillar on the left hand the Temporall power whence it is that that must take the precedence of this and this must be subordinate to that 5. And truly that the spirituall and Ecclesiasticall power is superiour to the Temporall and more eminent then it I prooue First by those thinges by which I haue prooued them in the former Chapter to be distinct For the end and finall cause of the temporall power is temporall and naturall to witt temporall peace the end of the spirituall Authoritie is eternall and supernaturall peace the immediat cause efficient of the Temporall is the people the immediat cause of the spirituall is God The matters in which the temporall power is occupied are temporall the affaires which the spirituall gouerneth are Ecclesiasticall and spirituall the functions of the temporall are all temporall the functions of the spirituall power are all spirituall and supernaturall as absoluing from sinnes ministring Sacraments offering of sacrifices enacting lawes for the soules health excommunicating absoluing c. The temporall ruleth especially the bodies the spirituall the soules that ruleth the Kingdome or Common Wealth this the Church To the King the Keyes of Cities are offered to the Priest and Pastour the Keyes of heauen He remitteth temporall Mulctes and paynes no sinnes at all The Priest and Pastour remitteth sinnes and absolueth from all paynes He can cast out of his Kingdome by banishement the Pastour out of the Church by Excommunication And therfore looke how farre eternall felicitie excelleth temporall God the People supernaturall and diuine thinges naturall and humane spirituall functions temporall soules bodies the Church the Common VVealth the Keyes of heauen the Keyes of cities sinnes ciuill penalties eternall temporall punishment excommunication banishement so farre the Ecclesiasticall and spirituall excelleth the Ciuill and Temporall Authoritie By this Argument S. CHRYSOSTOM as alwaies very excellentlie proueth the Priests to be greater then the King Chrysost homil 4. de verbis Isaiae tom 5. Mane intra tuos terminos ô Rex alij sunt termini Regni alij sacerdotij hoc Regnum illo maius est Rex ea quae sunt in terris sortitus est administranda caeterùm ius sacerdotij è supernis descendit Regi corpora commissa sunt sacerdoti animae Maior hic Principatus propterea Rex caput submittit manui sacerdotis vbique in scripturâ sacordotes inungebant Reges Remaine within thy boundes O King others are the limites of the Kingdome others of Priesthood this Kingdome is greater then that The King hath the administration of the things of the earth but the right of Priesthood defcendeth from aboue To the King bodies are coÌ„mitted to the Priest soules greater is this principalitie and therfore the King inclineth his head to the hand of the Priest and euerie where â—n Scripture Priests did anoint Kings Secondlie there is no Christian can denie but that since God hath ordained vs to a supernaturall end to witt the cleate vision and fruition of him selfe as all Scripture witnesseth that he hath all our goods also and states are ordained to the same end and are not well vsed but rather abused when they are vsed to serue our pleasures contrarie to that end whence followeth that all temporall thinges since the former Institution and ordination of God are Media meanes in respect not only of out supernaturall end but also of supernaturall meanes as Sacraments Grace and supernaturall functions which are more proportionate and more neere meanes to that end and consequentlie temporall power which ordaineth of these meanes is subiect to spirituall power which principally considereth the supernaturall meanes and end For as the art of ryding is more noble Arist li. 1. Eth. c. 1. then the art of making bridles as Aristotle to a like purpose reasoneth because this is ordained to that so the spirituall power which disposeth of supernaturall thinges is nobler then the Temporall this being ordained to that and the end being more noble then the meanes 6. Thirdlie Philosophers affirme that all habites and faculties are specified and dignified by their actes obiectes and endes and so Morall Philosophie which hath vertue and manners the health of the soule for its obiect is more noble then the art of Phisicke which teacheth only to cure the diseases of the bodie and to restore corporall health Seeing therefore that the obiects of spirituall power are supernaturall and heauenlie the obiects of Temporall power are naturall and earthlie the end also of spirituall power is eternall beatitude the end of temporall power temporall felicitie the actes also and functions of that power spirituall and supernaturall the actes of this naturall and
examples of the ould and nevv testament it is prooued that the Pope in some case can not only by spirituall censure but also by temporall punishment and euen by depriuation chastice Princes who are rebellious and doe tyrannically persecute and molest the church chap. 8. By Theologicall arguments grounded in principles of faith and the Nature of the church as it is an absolute common wealth the same power of the Supreame Pastour is prooued chap. 9. The same verity is confirmed by the practise of the Church in punnishing heretickes temporally with losse of goods liberty and liues chap. 10. The same power of the Pope ouer Princes is prooued by authority of Generall Councelles out of which are gathered for the same authority â—uident and conuincing arguments chap. 11. By the facts of the holy and learned Bishops of Rome especially Gregorie the seauenth the same power is confirmed chap. 12. By the number of Doctours who haue embraced the opinion that giueth this power to the Pope the same doctrine is prooued betwixt the number grauity and authority of which Doctours and those who staÌ„d for VViddringtons opinion there is no comparison to be made chap. 13. By the doctrine and practise of heretikes the same against them is demonstrated and thence is inferred that the questioÌ„ betwixt vs and them is not so much whether the Pope hath any such authority as whether the Pope or they haue it chap. 14. An explication of the late Oath of pretended Alleageance and of euery clause therof deduced out of the former and some other grounds by which is prooued that it can neither be proposed nor taken without grieuous offence of Almighty God Chap. 15. THE RIGHT AND IVRISDICTION OF THE PRELATE and the PRINCE CHAPTER I. BY WAY OF INTRODVCTION IT IS shewed that there be two powers in the Church the one Ciuill the other Ecclesiasticall which are both necessarie ALMIGHTY God in the first creation of this materiall world Gen. 1. prouided two great lightes to illuminate rule and gouerne it the one he called luminare maius the other luminare minus we commonly call them the SuÌ„ne Moone And no sooner had he created as it were the spirituall world of his Church but he appointed also two great lightes to gouerne it and direct it to the end prefixed The one is the Ecclesiasticall power of the Church residing in her Bishops and Pastours the other is the Temporall power of the CoÌ„mon wealth Magistrate or Prince Both powers are great in their kind both of God both as necessary to humane societie as the SuÌ„ne and Moone to this world Gelas ep ad â—mp Anastas VVherfore GELASIVS Pope saith Duo sunt Imperator Auguste quibus hic muÌ„dus principaliter regitur Autoritas sacra PomificuÌ„ Innoc. 3. Cap. Solitae de maior obed Regalis potestas Two thinges there are O noble Emperour by which this world is principallie gouerned the sacred Authoritie of Bishops and Regal power And Innocentius the Third vsing the former similitude saieth Ad firmamentum Coeli hoc est vniuersalis Ecclesiae fecit Deus duo magna luminaria id est duas instituit dignitates quae sunt Pontificalis Authoritas Regalis Potestas For the FirmameÌ„t of Heauen that is of the vniuersal Church God made two great lights that is he instituted two Dignities which are Pentifical Authoritie and Regal power But because the world now adaies aboundeth and as it were swarmeth with those kind of men whoÌ„ the Apostle calleth Animales homines 1. Cor. 2. quinoÌ„ sapiunt ea quae sunt spiritus sensual men who perceaue not those thinges that are of the spirit of God and therfore preferre the body before the soule this present life before the future time in which they are to liue but for a time before eternitie in which they are to liue eternally and consequently esteeme more of state then of Religion of the Common wealth then the Church and of the Temporall power of Princes then of the spirituall authoritie of Pastours I will by cleare and euident arguments so establish both that I will also sincerely deliuer which of them hath the preeminence and precedence For they who seeke to depriue vs of either of these powers do as if they would take from the world the Sunne or the Moone as though both were not necessary and they who do so admire the Temporall power and dignitie that they debase and misprise the spirituall though that indeede ruleth only the night of TeÌ„porall affaires this the day of the spirituall state are like vnto Owles who are so pleased with the Moone light that they could be contented there were no Sunne at all CHAPTER II. Some Ciuill power floweth immediatly froÌ„ God and nature Regali power proceedeth immediatly from the peoples election and donatioÌ„ mediatly from Gods ordination so that after the election of the people and reception the King is superiour who may command and binde in conscience the people are subiects and bound to obey 1. MAn by a naturall propension which God and Nature hath ingraffed in him desireth to consorte in companie and is prone to frieÌ„dship fellowship and societie And therfore Aristoâ—le saieth that Arist l. 1 Polit. ca. 2. Ciuitas est ex his quae natura sum The citie is one of those things which haue their source from nature and that homo natura ciuile est animal Man by nature is a ciuill liuinge creature And he addeth Ibidem Qui absque ciuitate est per naturam non per fortunam aut nequam est aut potior quam homo He that liueth out of the citie induced therto by inclination of nature not by fortuâ—e is either wicked orbâ—tter then man Ibidem Yea saith he Qui in coÌ„mum societate nequiâ— esse quique nullim indiget propter sufficientiam nulla pars est â—iuitatis quare aut Bestia aut Deus He that can not liue in common societie and needeth no mans hâ—lp by reason that he is sufficient of him selfe is no part of the Citie VVherfore he is either a beast or a God And thence he concludeth that Homo est sociale animal magis quà m Apes quà m omne gregariuÌ„ animal Man is a liuing creature more sociable theÌ„ bees or any consorting liuing creature And we see by experience how all reasonable and liuing Creatures desire societie The Angelles although they haue no familiar conuersation with meÌ„ as being aboue the raÌ„ke of men needing no humane helpe yet they haue Hierarchies and Orders rule and gouernment amongst them selues and the superiour illuminateth the inferiour and all of them speake and confer with one another and in this maÌ„ner they liue together which argueth a societie 〈◊〉 and though they conuerse not visibly and familiarly With vs yet for the charitie they beare vnto vs and for the neede we haue of theÌ„ some of them are our ordinary Guardians others are extraordinary Embassadours sent on diuine messages
indifferent and not otherwise forbidden Fiftlie Mat. 18. Christ gaue authoritie to his Apostles to loose and bynd by excommunications suspensions and interdicts which actes of Iurisdiction are the spirituall bands and Censures which the Church layeth vpon rebellious Christians as Diuines and Fathers interprete Which power Saint Paul in his second Epistle to the Corinthians insinuateth saying If I come againe I will not spare and againe These things I write absent that being present I may not deale hardlie according to the power which our Lord hath giuen me vnto edification and not vnto destruction 1. Cor. 4. 1. Cor. 5. D. Th. in hac loca Gregor Nyssâ—in orat aduersus eos qui agre ferunt reprehens Chrysost hom 60â— ad pop Ant. Hieron ep 53. And in his first Epistle he sayth VVhat will you in rodde that I come to you or in charitie and the spirit of mildnesse And againe he in absence by his letters and mandatum excommunicateth the incestuous person and deliuereth him vp to Satan Out of which wordes Saint Gregorie of Nisse and Saint Chrysostome do gather the power of Excommunication As also doth Saint Hierom who marueileth that the Bishop in whose Diocese Vigilantius liued did not Virga ferrea confringere vas inutile tradere in interitum carnis vt spiritus saluus fiat With an iron rodde breake that vnprofitable vessel and deliuer him to Satan for the destruction of the flesh that the spirit may be saued So S. AVGVSTIN Aug l 1. de pen. cap. 14. so all Fathers so Caluin him selfe vnderstand this place of the power of Excommunication though Caluin will haue onlie the Presbyterie and companie of Seniours not any one alone to excoÌ„municate contrarie to the expresse text which telleth vs that Saint Paul alone absent did excommunicate and deliuer vp to Satan VVhere is to be noted that by excommunication stubbern Christians are saied to be deliuered vp to Satan either because they are cast out of the Church where Satan domineereth or else for that they are depriued of the suffrages and helpes of the Church and so more exposed to Satans tentations or lastely because in the Primatiue Church the Deuil by and by seazed and tooke poslession of the person excommunicated 10. Sixtlie as because the law of Nature could not determine particulerly of all particulers Ciuill power was necessarie to gouerne the Communitie and enact lawes conducing to the Temporall state so because God his law hath not determined all particulers it was necessarie the Church should haue power to call Councelles tomake patticuler lawes according to the times and other circumstances 11. Seuenthlie euerie absolute Common wealth hath power in the Prince and Magistrates to gouerne and defend it self to make lawes to punishe Malefactours c. But the Church is an absolute Common wealth and more absolute then a Kingdome this being subordinate to that not that to this ergo it was to haue all spirituall Authoritie necessarie to gouerne and defend it selfe else Christ had not sufficientlie prouided for it 12. Fightlie we are bound to obey Princes lawes and Authoritie in conscience ergo much more the Churches Authoritie and law this being spirituall that but temporall this being the subordinant that the subordinat power as wee shall see herafter And therfore if the Apostle will haue euerie soule to be subiect to Authoritie and higher powers Rom. 13 he will especiallie that they be subiect if they be members of the Church vnto her spirituall power for as SYMMACHVS Pope sayd once to the Emperour ANASTASIVS Si omnis potestas à Deo est Ep. ad Anastaf Imp. magis ergo quae rebus praestituta est diuinis defer Deo in nobis nos deferemus Deo in te If all power be of God much more therfore that power which gouerneth diuine matters Honour thou God ô Emperour in vs and we will honour him in thee CHAPTER IIII. These two Iurisdictions and powers Ecclesiasticall and Ciuill are compared and conferred and the preeminence is giuen to the Ecclesiasticall 1. AS the little world Man called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 can not consist without bodie and soule nor the great world without the Sunne and Moone so neither can the spirituall world of the Church flourish any time vnlesse it be supported as by two Pillars by the spirituall and Temporall power and Authoritie But as if the Moone should or could contend with the sunne and would or could disdaine to receaue light from the sunne or would or could encroach vpon the sunnes right in the gouernmet of the day all would be out of order so if one of these powers should be at variance with the other and would not receaue light and direction by the more lightsome or would encroach preposterouslie on the others demaines the Church could not long flourish And as if the body should rebell against the soule the flesh against the spirit sensualitie against reason it would perturbe reasons order and breake the Oeconomie of Morall life so if one of these powers should offer iniurie to the other the Mysticall bodie of Christ his Church would be out of frame Wherfore seeing that Christ the Wisdome of God is the Authout of both he no doubt hath disposed them sweetlie Sap. 7. and consequentlie hath setled some order betwixt them because Quae à Deo sunt Rom. 13. ordinata sunt Those thinges that are of God are ordered And for as much as Pluralitas principatuum non est bona Pluralitie of principalities is not good Arist l. 12. Metaph. cap. vlt. to wit Vnlesse one be subordinate to the other no doubt he hath subiected one of these to the other For which cause in this Chapter I will endeauour to shew which of these powers taketh the precedence which hath the preeminence and superioritie wherin and how farre 2. But because Comparisons betwixt so great Powers and Principalities and especiallie in these our corrupted times are odious I protest before hand that I entend not do detract any right or prerogatiue from either but onely to giue to Caesar and his temporall power what belongeth vnto them and to God and his Church Mat. 21. what appertaineth to them For I confesse and haue prooued that both these Authorities are of God both are excellent and eminent in their kinde both to be honoured both to be obeyed within their limites both so necessarie to the Church of God that it can no more stand without them then the world without Sunne and Moone For take away Temporall power and who shall defend the Church and assist her for the execution of her lawes and sentences Take away the spirituall power and who shall direct and correct the Temporall when it is exorbitant Take away the Temporall and who shall drawe the sworde Take away the spirituall and who shall preach the worde Take away the Temporall and who shall haue care of our corporall and temporall life Take away the spirituall and
pleasure not in your enimies crueltie and furie but in your dexteritie in warding constancie in keeping your standing patience in suffering and enduring 5. And truely your afflictions seeme to me neither inferiour nor vnlike to those of IOB and your patience seemeth to match and to aequalize his only the order of your afflictions seeme different For he was assaulted first in his goods theÌ„ in his person you coÌ„trariewise first in your bodies and liues now in your goods and liuings The Sabeians haue rushed in vpon you as well as on IOB and haue spoyled many of you impouerished the rest Irruerunt Sabei tuleruntque omnia Iob. 1. The Sabeians came in violently and haue taken all things from you the fire also of God fell from heauen and striking the sheepe of IOB and the seruants hath consumed theÌ„ Iob. 1. and a fire not from heauen vnlesse by diuine permission but froÌ„ earth yea from hell and the vnquenchable thirst of hauing hath consumed all your substance The Chaldees made three troupes to inuade the Camels of IOB stroke his seruants with the sword Iob 1. So haue they by three troupes to wit Concupiscentia carnis Concupiscence of the flesh 1. Ioan. 2. Concupiscentia oculorum concupiscence of the eyes and Superbia vitae pride of life inuaded you because to satisfie their lust and carnalitie their auarice desire of riches and all that may be seene by the eyes their pride and ambition of greatnesse they haue made hauocke of all you haue A vehement winde blowing boysteroussly from the countrey of the Defert shooke the foure Corners of Iobs house which falling oppressed his Children Iob. 5. The like whirle winde from the North and desert of heresie hath shaken your houses and by their fall hath ruinated your families oppressed your persons your wiues and children 6. And least the deuill should exprobate vnto you as he did to IOB that hetherto your goods haue rather suffered then you and that therefore if God would touch your bodie and corporal life hee should soone see you breake out into impatience because skinne for skinne and all things that a man hath he will giue for his life Iob. 2 God hath permitted Satan by his ministers to haue power ouer your bodies and corporal life also as appeareth by the prisons in which some of you haue rotted some haue statued some haue been choaked with stincking ayres as may easilye bee seene by the rackes in which your ioyntes haue been dissolued by the Tyburnes on which you haue been hanged and vnder which you haue been most butcherlie quartered vnbowelled Yea to augment your affliction many of you haue not wanted a IOBS wife carnal and worldly loue to busse in your eares that Carnall counsell Benedic Deo morere Iob. 2. Curse God and die Doe against thy Conscience frequent hereticall seruice take the oath of pretended Alleageance rather then vndoe thy selfe thy wife and Children Yet you haue not fayled with IOB to reprehend such a wise and tell her that shee hath spoken like one of the foolish woemen Iob. 2. as Sir THOMAS MORE told his wife that she was a foolish marchant to counsell him to sell eternitie for shorte and vncertaine time Many also of you haue not wanted heretickes of your bloud and stocke prefigured by IOBS false and fained friends Iob. 2. who haue gone about to perswade you that these miseries which oppresse you are befallen you for your obstinacie in Religion and yet you haue repelled such deceauing friends yea you haue cast from you such scandalyzing eyes that is you haue shaken off such friends though otherwise as deare and necessarie vnto you as your eyes and haue chosen rather to goe to heauen blinde Matt. 8. then to be directed by such ill-guyding eyes 8. But seeing that God hath not permitted Sathan to haue power ouer your soules but onely ouer your transitorie goods and mortal liues loose ye not either hart or courage Sathan indeede by his Ministers as one telleth you hath broken downe the walles of your house as no maruaile it was but of clay but he could not lay handes on your soule the good man of the house that being forbidden him he hath broken the chest of your bodie and no maruaile it was but of rotten board but he could not finger the treasure of your faith Gods grace and such like Iewels they being locked vp in the Cabinet of your conscience of which God and you onely keepe the key And therefore be yee not dismayed for the losse of your temporal goods liuings and libertie yea corporal life seeing the principal the soule is safe so long as you will But for all temporal losses giue God thankes and say with IOB Dominus dedit Dominus abstulit sit nomen Domini benedictum God gaue all this he hath taken all awaie be he praysed as much for the taking awaie as for the giuing 8. And doe you not imagine that God hath forsaken you in permitting this pillage of your goods and sackage of your estates for such goods are common to the good and bad rather take it for a signe of his fatherâ—ie loue in giuing you patience to beare with alacritie all those oppressions and perswade your selues that necesse erat quia accepti eratis Deo vt tentatio probaret vos Tob. 12. It was necessarie because you were acceptable to God that this tentation should prooue you God hath indeede cast you into a fornace of tribulation but as the Potter doth his earthen vessel to harden it not to breake it or as the Goldsmith doth his golde to purge it not to conâ—ume it He hath indeede chastised you but as his dearest children not as seruants and out of his loue more then out of anger as hee hath dealt with his Apostles his Martyrs yea his Mother yea his Sonne and all his dearest For it is his manner to chastice whom he loueth and to scourge euery childe that hee receaueth As vnto children hee offereth himselfe vnto you For wat sonne is there whoÌ„ the father doth not correct Heb. 12. And when the correction is done he will embrace you and cast the rodde into the fier It is true he hath wounded you but as the Surgeon doth to let out the corrupt matter He woundeth and cureth striketh and his hands shal heale Iob. 5. And the arrowes of our Lord are in you Iob. 6. as they were in IOB but they are as tents which hee will pull out when they haue drawen out all corruptioÌ„ He hath permitted the winde of persecution to beat furiously vpon you but it is to blow away all chasse of imperfection and that the solid wheate of your vertues may be the purer He hath permitted you to be pilled polled and spoyled of your goods but that spoyling is but lopping and pruning that the tree hereafter may beare his fruits more aboundantly 9. Say not there fore God hath forsaken vs hee thinketh no more of vs and if your
against God and his Churches right and honour VVherfore seeing that by this oath the true and lawfull Authoritle of your chiefe visible head and Pallour is abiured as this booke will make plaine vnto you imitate the wise serpent expose bodie liuings libertie and all for the defence of your Head and if your zealous Pastour and Primat S. THOMAS of CANTERBVRIE indured banishment reuilings contumelies iniuries and at length death it self for the defeÌ„ce of the rights of the Church how much more should you constantlie endure for the defence of the Head of the Church 18. And although Widdrington telles you and as he would seeme as a freind and one that hath care of your temporall estates that you are not bound to loose any penny for the Authoritie of the Pope which this oath abiureth yet I desire you to coÌ„pare VViddrington to those Allens Card. Allan in his Answ to the libeller Hardings Sanders Bâ—istowes Stapletons who had as great a care of your temporall and more of your spirituall estates and yet wrote and taught that the Authoritie which this oath abiureth is to be defended with hazard of liuings and life To these I'desire you to adde the CouÌ„cels not only Prouincial but also General which in their decrees haue defined this authoritie the Popes so many so learned so holie who haue exercized it vpon rebellious Princes the Kings and Emperours though most herein interessed who haue acknowledged it the arguments also deducted out of Scripture and Principles of faith and Diuinitie which do conuince it all which this booke will make known vnto you and lastly the fatherlie admonition of your most Holie Father and chiefe visible Pastour PAVL by the Grace of God the fifte of that name who as by office he hath a generall charge and care of all Christian Nations so hath he a particular care not only of the spirituall but also of the temporall estates of all English Catholikes as our Colledges haue and do daiely experience and consequentlie would not expose your temporall estates to the furie of the persecutour by forbidding you this oath if as he telleth you it did not containe thinges which can not be sworne without euident and grieuous wronging of Gods honour and which are flat contrarie to faith and saluation Paulus 5. in Breu. And therfore seeing that hee like a wise and carefull Phisitian hath more care of your health then of contenting your tast and humour and VViddrington contrariewise permitteth you that which is pleasing to flesh and bloud not so much respecting how preiudicious it is to your soules health if you will preferre heauen before a temporall estate and the soule before the bodie you must also preserre your Holie Fathers counsel and admonition especiallie grounded in such authoritie before all the smooth and soothing prescriptions in the world warraÌ„ted by onlie Widdringtons and some few obscure Authors authoritie for although he alleadgeth often the Doctors of Sotbon and all the state of France yet by the late resistance made by the Clergie and nobilitie of France against the like Oath who seeth not how he abuseth his reader and iniureth that noble Monarchie 19. But put the case you should preferre VViddringtons counsel before your chiefe Pastours admonition and all the authoritie alleadged neither so what soeuer he beareth you in hand should you saue your temporall estates or decline persecution For to omitte that if you had at the first iointlie and couragionslie resisted the oath it is like you should neuer haue been so hoatlie pressed with it if now you should all resolue to accept of it neither so should you auoide persecution For as I haue tould you perchaunce your yeelding in this point hath prouoked your heauenlie Fathers wrath and induced him in this his so iustlie conceiued anger to vse or permitt still the rodd of persecution which otherwise he was readie to haue layed aside and the persecutour who proposeth this oath not seeking so much the Princes securitie which rather hereby as I haue shewed in the last chapter of this booke is more endaungered as the molestation of your Consciences and the pillage of your goods would not though you should accept of this oath surcease therfore from persecution but if he could not by this meanes molest your consciences and ruine your estates he would try other meanes as to compell you to their Churches or prophane Communion And this you may gather by his sorrow he shewed when in the beginning so many of you yeelded to take this oath and by this also that many who haue taken this oath can not so free them selues from molestation because nothing but your goods and miseries can satisfie the vnsatiable crueltie of bloudie persecutours And so by yeelding to this oath as you prouoke Gods greater anger so you moue the persecutour to no compassion rather you make him more insolent and redouble your owne miserie But suppose you could thus shake of this hâ—auie yoke of persecution yet it beeing vnlawfull as your chiefe Pastour and â—earnedst Doctours teach you as hetherto rapinam bonorum vestrorum cum gaudio suscepistis cognoscentes vos habere meliorem manentem substantiaÌ„ Heb 10 the spoile of your owne goods you haue taken with ioy knowing that you haue a better and permanent substance so do you perseuere and continue And if God permit the persecutour to prey not only on your goods but also on your liues yet nolite timere eos qui occidunt corpus animam autem non possunt occidere c. Matt 10. feare not them that can kill the bodie and are not able to kill the soule but rather feare him that can destroy both soule and bodie into Hel. 10. Many thinges do make this oath vnlawfull as you will easilie perceaue by the briese examination which the last chapter of this treatise maketh of it but if there were nothing but this that it is an vncouth and vnwonted oath neuer yet proposed by any Prince vnto his subiects and proposed also by the professed Enemies of Gods Church all Catholikes that feare to offend God or to doe iniurie to the Church and her right and authoritie ought to holde it as suspected and as such to shunne it and auoyd it For it is no new thing for heretikes vnder colour of oathes of fidelitie and ciuil alleageance to deceaue the well meaning and nought-suspecting Catholike VVee read in the historie of the persecution of the Wandalles Victor Vticen lib. 3. de pers Vand. how Hunnericus proposed such an oath to the Catholike Bishops assembled together at Carthage preteÌ„ding onely therby to assure him selfe of their sidelitie towards him and his sonne that was to succeede him which if they would take he premised to send them home to their Churches The oath seemed â—â—rie reasonable and was no other then this Iurate si post obitum Domini nostri Regis eius filium Hildericum desideratis esse Regem vel si nullus vestrum ad Regiones
that hateth This I am sure I giue you no other counsell then I would follow my selfe who haue that opinion of the vnlawfulnes of this oath that I would loose liuings libertie and life rather then take it not that I would not giue that to Caesar which is due to Caesar but that I would not take from God which appertaineth to God not that I neglect a temporal life and state but that I preferre the spirituall not that I despise the Prince to whom I acknowledge all tempor all obedience and honour but that I honour the Pastour who hath the rule of my soule not that I regard not the Common wealth but that I desire to liue and dy an obedient sonne of the Church not that I feare not them who can kill the bodie but that I feare God more who can kill the soule Matt. 10. 23. And my intention and proiect I protest of dedicating this Treatise vnto you was not to irritate any Prince but onlie to declare his Authoritie and office not to flatter any Prelate but onlie to defend his right not to increase your persecution but to ridde you of this Anathema which hath prolonged it not to adde affliction to affliction but courage to your fainting and comfort to your griefes to helpe them to rise that are sallen and to confirme them that stand that they may the better keepe their standing And this being my sincere intention I hope not onlie you but all others who shall peruse this booke will make their profit of it and interpret it in that good meaning which the Authour intended Our Lord IESVS for whose cause you endure either ease you of this burden of aduersities vnder which you grone or giue you strength to beare it comfort in bearing and make mee a follower of your rare examples an Imitatour of your patience and partaker of your merits as you shall euer be of my poore prayers and small labours A Preface To the Reader GEntle Reader I did not thinke to haue set out this little booke the second tyme much lesse did I intēd to adde any thing vnto it And although Widdrington in his New-yeares gifte hath of late here and there glanced against some words and speeches of myne where he imagined most aduantage yet I thought as I see other learned writers haue done to haue quite giuen him ouer and not to haue made the least replye as not being desirous to contend with such as are resolued not to yeelde hauing other businesses to many where with to occupie my self But the Printer who first tooke this booke in hād and other friends also īportuning me to let it come forth againe and alleadging that the copies of the first Edition were all spent and yet moe demaunded I was cōtent volens nolens yeelding herein more to importunitie then to myne owne inclination to publishe it once more and vpon this occasion of this new edition to adde here and there something either for a more ample explication or for answer to Widdringtons obiections I was willing I confesse and forward ynough the first tyme to write of this subiect For although as by an accident I was one of the last who wrote in the defence of this the chiefe visible Pastours Authoritie now in Englād impugned so I counted my selfe amongst the least yet as when an house is set on fire some carrie water others ladders and euerie one repayreth thether to shew at least his good will to extinguish it So in this Cōbustion in which not onlie Heretiques but also some of them who make profession of the Catholique name doe endeuoure to put fire euen to the secundarie foundation of God his Church to wit the chiefe vifible Pastours Authoritie I thought it the part of euerie zealous Catholicke to runne to the extinguishing of this fire for though all haue not the like dexteritie yet all may shew the like good will Which I hauing performed in the former Editiō of this little booke according to my abilitie I thought to haue surceased had not importunitie of friendes ouercome mee And therfore after this as I meane not to dispute any more of this point with thē with whōe as I gather by the repulse which greater men then my selfe haue receaued there is little hope to preuaile so I wish all Catholiques seing that they haue hearde their chiefe visible Pastours sentence to leaue of all Disputation touching this his Authoritie and simplie and humblie to obey his commādement and consequentlie to acknowledge the sayd Authoritie to refuse the Oath by him cōdemned and yet to obey the King our Soueraigne and Liege Lord in all ciuil and temporall causes to be faithfull to him and his Royall posteritie and to pray day lie for his maiesties longe and prosperous life that he may liue lōge to vs alwayes to God and so raigne longe in the Kingdome of England as he may raigne for euer in the Kingdome of heauen The Contents of the Chapters BY way of introduction it is shewed that there be two powers in the Church the one Ciuill the other Ecclesiasticall which are both necessary Chap. 1. Some Ciuill povver followeth immediatly from God and nature Regall povver proceedeth immediatly from the peoples election and Donation mediatly from Gods ordination Soe that after the election of the people and reception the king is superiour who may Command and bynde in conscience the people are subiects bound to obey Chap. 2. Ecclesiasticall power is also of God and is distinct from the Ciuill Iurisdiction which also all members of the Church are bound in conscience to obey Chap. 3. These two Iurisdictions and powers Ecclesiasticall and Ciuill are compared and conferred and the preeminence is giuen to the Ecclesiasticall Chap. 4. Ecclesiasticall and temporall Peeres and Princes are compared together and out of the Comparison is gathered that not only priuat laymen but euen temporall Princes though otherwise absolute are subiect to the Pastours of the Church and especially to the Supreme visible Pastour as is prooued by many arguments Chap. 5. That Princes Kings yea emperours haue no authority to gouerne the Church or to make Ecclesiasticall lawes neither are to be accounted heads or Superiours but subiects of the Church though protectours and defendours and therefore are modestly admonished of their duty and office Chap. 6. Although the Pope be not direct temporall Lord and Superiour of the world nor of any part therof by Christs expresse guift and donation but only of the patrimony of Sainct Peter giuen him by Constantine the Great and other Catholicke Princes and confirmed by the consent of the Christian world yet by the spirituall power which Christ gaue him in his predecessour S. Peter 10.21 he may dispose of temporall things and euen of kingdomes for the good of the church and conseruation of her and her faith right and the manner how and in what case he can thus dispose of temporalities is explicated chap. 7. By diuers places and
as God preuented the Iewes and whereas they by lawe of Nature had permission to choose their Kinges yet for their greater good he chose thē one him selue immediatelie so although by the lawe of Nature men otherwise might haue prescribed the manner of worshipping God and the worship had been lawfull so that it had been the worship of the true God and had been free from superstition yet because God hath ordained vs to a supernaturall end and would haue our Ecclesiasticall gouernment free from all superstition he hath himselfe appointed the manner of gouernment and hath giuen the Authoritie So in the lawe of Moyses he chose the Tribe of LEVI to serue in the Tabernacle and Temple and to menage Ecclesiasticall matters he instituted also sacrifices sacramentes and Ceremonies in like sort in the new lawe of Grace vnder which we liue he committed the gouernment of his Church to the Apostles and Disciples only and their successours he instituted seuen Sacramentes and a sacrifice he gaue vs a lawe and beleefe which first he deliuered by preaching then by the written Ghospelles and Epistles of his Apostles and other thinges he committed to the Church which he had instituted and established 5. So that as there is a Ciuill and Temporall Power residing in the Common wealth by which the Prince or Magistrate can gouerne and rule and cōmaund for the conseruation and promotion of the Temporall good of the same so is there a spirituall and Ecclesiasticall Power residing in the Church by which the Pastours haue Authoritie to preach teach administer Sacraments determine of matters of Religion to call Councelles for the better clearing of matters and enacte lawes which shall be thought expedient vnto the honour of God the spirituall good of the Church and euerie ones saluation And this is called Ecclesiasticall power which is distinct from the Temporall in many pointes 6. First in respect of the end and finall cause for Temporall power of it selfe aymeth only at Temporali Iustice peace and conseruation of the Temporall state of the Kingdome or Common wealth Ecclesiasticall power intendeth in this life the spirituall health of the soule and eternall rest and peace in the next Secondlie these powers haue diuers Actes and seing that powers are distinct by their Actes it followeth that Temporall and Ecclesiasticall or spirituall power are distinct That they haue distinct Actes it is manifest for the Temporall power maketh lawes for this corporall life and Temporalle state but the spirituall and Ecclesiasticall power maketh lawes for the soule and her direction the Temporall power remitteth the paines only of sinnes but the spirituall Power remitteth the sinne it self according to that Ioan. 20 Quorum remiseritis peccata c. VVhose sinnes you shall forgiue c. The Temporall power inflicteth and remitteth only Ciuill and Temporall punishments as imprisonment banishment temporall death but the spirituall power as now it is for in the old law there was not Potestas Clauium excommunicateth suspendeth interdicteth which are spiritual punishments and bonds of the soule and remitteth not only these paines but also eternall death and paine of Hell for when the Priest remitteth mortall sinnes he chaūgeth eternall paine into temporall yea some times when the Penitent cometh with a great contrition he remitteth both Eternall and Temporall Thirdly they differ in their obiectes for the spirituall power disposeth not of Temporall thinges but only as they are necessary to the spirituall The Temporall meddleth not with spirituall nor Ecclesiasticall matters according to that of S. AMBROSE S. Ambr. lib. 5. ep 33. ad Marcel soror Ad Impetatorem Palatia pertinent ad sacerdotem Ecclesiae Publicorum tibi maenium ius commissum est non sacrorum To the Emperour Pallaces appertaine to the Priest Churches to thee Emperour the right of common Walles is committed not of Churches And NICHOLAS Pope in an Epistle to MICHAEL the Emperour Ca. Cum ad verū dist 96. Vide etiā ca. Quoniam d. 10. Nec Imperator iura Pontificum arripuit nec Pontifex nomen Imperatoris vsurpauit quoniam Christus sic actibus propriis dignitatibus distinctis officia potestatis vtriusque discreuit Neither hath the Emperour taken to him the rights of Bishops neither hath the Bishop vsurped the name of the Emperour because Christ hath distinguished the offices of both by their distinct actes and dignities Fourthlie they differ in respect of the subiect and materiall cause for although it be not impossible for these two Powers to consort in the same subiect for we see they did in Melchisedech and in the first begotten of the Iewes in the law of Nature and in the Machabees who were Priests and Princes and consequentlie had temporall and spirituall power yet as in other thinges these powers are distinct so God not only in the law of Grace but also in the law written of Moyses would haue these powers placed in distinct subiectes and Persons 2. Paral◠19. For in the law of Moyses AMARIAS menaged matters of the Church law ZABADIAS gouerned the affaires of the Kingdome the Kinges and Princes of the Iewes were of the Tribe of IVDA the Priests of the Tribe of LEVI and those gouerned onely the Common VVealth enacted Temporall lawes waged battaile c. whereas the Priests ruled it matters of the Tabernacle and Temple offered sacrifice and gouerned the Synagogue And now in the law of Grace Christ gaue all spirituall power to the Apostles and their successours and not to Princes for to the Apostles and their successours it was saied VVhatsoeuer you shall bynd vpon earth Mat. 18. shal be bound in heauen and whatsoeuer you shall losse vpon earth shal be loosed in heauen To Princes it was neuer sayd so To the Apostles and their successours it was sayd Ioan. 20. Whose sinnes you shall forgiue they are forgiuen them and whose you shall retaine they are retained To Princes neuer To S. PETER an Apostle and Priest it was sayed Mat. 16 Thou art Peter and vppon this Rock will I build my Church To no Prince was it euer sayd in that sort To Apostles and Priests Christ sayed Matth. vlt. Goinge therefore teach ye all Nations baptising them in the name of the father the sonne and the holy Ghost To Princes neuer To Apostles and Priests Christ said Ioan. 6. As my liuing father hath sent me so I send you that is to preach to minister Sacramentes and to gouerne the Church Ephes 4. To Princes neuer To the Apostles Doctours Pastours Prophets Christ committed his Church to be gouerned Act. 28. to Princes neuer To Priests S. Paul gaue this admonition Attendite vobis vniuerso gregi in quo vos Spiritus Sanctus posuit Episcopos regere Ecclesiam Dei quam acquisiuit sanguine suo Take heede to your selues and to the whole flocke wherin the holy Ghost hath placed you Bishops to rule the Church of God which he hath purchased
Which no man can denie but that it is spoken with the Emperours honour for what more honourable then that the Emperour should be called the sonne of the Church And then say I if he be a sonne he is a subiect no lesse then the sonne to the father The same Doctour in a booke wrote of Priestlie Dignitie sayth yet more Honor sublimitas Episcopalis sayeth he nullis poterit comparationibus adaequari Lib. de dignit sacerd cap. 2. Si Regum fulgori compares Principum Diademati longè erit inferius quà m si plumbi metallum ad auri fulgorem compares quippe cum videas Regum colla Principum submitti genibus sacerdotum exosculatis ecrum dexteris orationibus eorum credant se communiri The honour dignitie and Highnes of a Bishop cannot be equalized by any comparisons If thou compare it to Kinglie lustre and the diademe of Princes thou shalt say lesse then if thou shouldst coÌ„pare lead to the glittering gould for as much as thou seest Kinges and Princes neckes submitted to the knees of Priests and theÌ„ selues kissing their right handes to be waranted by their prayers Hom. 4. de verbis Isaiae S. CHYSOSTOME Regi corpora commissa sunt sacerdoti auima Rex maculas corporum remittit sacerdos autem maculas peccatorum Ille cogit hic exhortatur Ille necessitate hic consilio Ille habet armasensibilia bic arma spiritualia Ille bellum gerit cum Barbaris mihi sacerdoti bellnm est aduersus Daemones Maior hic Principatus propterea Rex caput submittit manui sacerdotis vbique in veteri scriptura sacerdotes inungebant Reges To the King bodies are committed to the Priest soules The King forgiueth the punishments of the bodie the Priest the blottes and blemishes of sinnes He compelleth the Priest exhorteth he by necessitie this by counsell he hath sensible weapons this spirituall he makes warre against the Barbares I the Priest am to wage battaile against the deuils Greater is this Principalitie and therfore the King inclineth his head to the hand of the Priest and euerie where in the old Testament Priests did annoint Kinges And againe SiquideÌ„ sacerdotiuÌ„ Principatus est Hom. 5. de verbis Isaiae ipso etiaÌ„ regno venerabilius ac maius c. Because Priest hoode is a Principalitie and that greater and more venerable then the Kingdome Speake not to mee of the purple and diademe and goulden robes these all be but shadowes and more vaine then springe flowers Speake not to mee of these thinges but if thou wilt see the difference betwixt a King and a Priest way the power giuen to them both and thou shalt see the Priest fitting much higher in dignitie then the Kinge For a though the Throne of a Kinge seeme to vs admirable for the pretious stones wherewith it is couered yet he hath allosted him onely the administration of earthlie thinges But to the Priest a throne is placed in heauen and he hath authoritie to pronounce sentence in heauenlie businesses Who sayth so Mat. 18. The King of the heauens him selfe What soeuer you shall bynde vppon earth shall be bound also in heauen and whatsoeuer you shall loose vppon earth shal be loosed also in heauen What can be compared with this honour from earth heauen taketh the principall power of iudging For the iudge sitteth on earth our Lord folioweth his seruaunt and whatsoeuer he shall iudge heere below that he approueth aboue And a little after Eoque Deus ipsum regale caput sacerdotis manibus subiecit not erudiens quod hic Princeps est illo maior Siquidom id quod minus est benedictionem accipit ab eo quod praestantius est And so much God hathsubmitted the Kinges head to the handes of the Priest teaching vs that this Prince is greater then he for he that is lesse receaueth benediction from him that is greater Yea S. CHYSOSTOME giueth not only Bishops but also euen Deacons Hom. 33. in Matth hom 83. in eund Authoririe ouer Kings Si dux igitur quispiam saieth he si Consul ipse si qui diademate ornatur indignè adeat cohibe ac coërce maiorem tu illo potestatem habes If therfore any Capitaine or Consul if he that is adorned with a diademe approach vnworthilie keepe him backe and restrayne him thou hast greater power then he And to this purpose we read that S. Re. MIGIVS the Apostle of France Histoire de l'Eglise de Reins lib. 1. cap. 13. a little before his death commanded the Bishops to excommunicate the Kinges of France if they should waste or inuade the Churches But aboue all most forcible is the testimonie of Ignat. Epist ad Smyrn S. IGNATIVS an Apostles scholler who so extolleth Princelie dignitie that yet he giues the precedence vnto the Bishops authoritie Honora Deum sayth he vt omnium authorem Dominum c. Honour God as the Authour and Lord of all and the Bishop as the Prince of Priests bearing the Image of God and houlding his princedome of him and his Priesthood of Christ And after him you must honour also the King For none is to be prefered before God nor equal to him nor none more honourable in the Church then the Bishop exercising the Priesthood of God for the saluation of the world Neither is any equall to the King in the Hoste or Campe procuring peace and beneuolence to the other Princes vnder him For he that honoureth the Bishop shal be honoured of God and he that dishonoureth him shall of God be dishonoured For if any man rising against the King is worthie of damnation how shall be escape Gods Iudgements that attempteth any thing against or without the Bishop For Priesthood is the Chiefe and summe of all mans good which whâ— soeuer disgraceth dishonoureth God and our Lord IESVS Christ the Chiefe Priest of God 11. Sixtlie this I proue by Emperours and Kings proper confession who all of them haue acknowledged Bishops and especiallie the Chiefe Bishop of Rome their Fathers Pastours and superiours and those that haue supreame authoritie ouet them CONSTANTINE the Great in an â—ict of his shortely after his baptisme â—saieth thus Cap. CoÌ„stantinus 2. dist 96. Vtile iudicauimus c. vt sicut in terris Beatus Petrus Vicarius filij Dei videtur esse constitutus it a etiam Pontifices qui ipsius Principis Apostolorum vices gerunt Principatus potestatem amplius quà m terrenae Imperialis Nostrae Serenitatis mansuetudo habere videtur concessam à nobis nostroque Imperio obtineant Wee haue Iudged it profitable that as blessed Peeter is appointed the vicaire of the sonne of God in earth so also Bishops who are Vicegerents of this Prince of the Apostles should haue more amplie the power of principalitie graunted by vs and our Empire Ruffin lib. 1. cap. 2. then our terrene Imperiall Serenitie seemeth to haue And Russinus relateth how that when certaine Bishops assembled at
by the peoples consent and although IOAS who was the right heyre was yet liuing yet because that was not knowen it seemeth that the people generallie consented to ATHALIA which consent was sufficient to make her lawfull Queene otherwise we must call in question the Titles of many Kings whose Predecessours entred into the possession of their Kingdomes by violence and inuasion and without all Title and yet afterwards prooued lawfull Kings by the common reception and consent of the people actually raigning for some time with expresse or tacitt consent of the people giuing à sufficient Title At least this example sheweth that the High Priest might be Iudge of the Kings right and Title which was to meddle in a Temporall matter and no lesse then a Kings Title 5. ELIAS also though a Prophet onlie 3. Reg. 18 4. Reg. 1. 2. and no Temporall Prince consumed by fire from Heauen OCHOSIAS Captaines and their fifties and made a massacre of Iesabels false Prophetes Againe ELISEVS his scholler by his curse sett Beares vpon those vngracious boyes who called him by scorne Bald-pate he stroke Giezi with the leprosie which he had taken from NAAMAN for his symonie Certes ELIAS was so famous for chrastizing rebellious Princes and their Captaines Eccl. 48. that Ecclesiasticus pronounceth thus of him VVho didst cast downe Kings to destruction and didst easilie breake their might and the glorious from their bed And howbeit they did this by extraordinarie and Propheticall power yet these examples shew how it is not vnbeseeming Spirituall power to controule sometimes Princes and to punish them euen temporally when Gods glorie and his Churches right and honour requireth it Num. 25 I could alleadge the example of MOYSES who caused the Princes to be hanged on Gibbets against the sunne for communicating with the Moabites in sactifice Exod. 32 who also by the assistaÌ„ce of the sonnes of LEVI killed aboue three thowsand for adoring the Goulden Calfe But I will come to the Newe law and see what proofes it yeeldeth 6. The new law though it be the law of Charitie not seueritie loue not feare yet it is not without examples of Temporall punishment vsed euen by the spirituall sword 1. Cor. 5 1. Tim. 1 S. PAVL excommunicated the In cestuous Christian as also Hyminaeus and Alexander and deliuered them vp to Satan for the destruction of the flesh for in the Primatiue Church to excommunication was annexed a Temporall punishment D. Th. 3. p. in Addit q. 21. a. 2. ad 3. Act. 13. by reason that then when any was excommunicated the Deuill by and by possessed him and tormented him corporally In the new law I behould S. PAVL stricking Elymas the Magician with corporall blindnes for hindring the fruict of the Ghospell Act. 5. and I find S. PETER pronouncing sentence of present death against Ananias and Saphira his wife for defrauding the Apostles in the price of the peece of land which they had vowed And although this also they did by the guift of miracles and extraordinarie prerogatiue of their Apostleship yet this sheweth that TeÌ„porall punishment doth not altogether surpasse the actiuitie and force of Spirituall power 7. Secondlie I prooue this by another Argument drawne from the persons of theÌ„ on whom it seemeth the Church may by warrant of scripture inflict Temporall punishment such as are obstinat Hereticks disobedient Princes to the Church D. Kellyson Rep. p. 185. Deut. 13 Blasphemers persecutours c. which examples a writer of this tyme alleageth though to another end In the old law which was a figure of the new false Prophets who persuaded to follow false Gods were slaine and stoned to death and the whole Citie that permitted worship of straunge Gods was commanded to be sacked and vtterly destroyed Deut. 17 And as we haue seene whosoeuer stubbornlie disobeyed the High Priest in matters pertaining to the law was to be killed And shall the Heretick stubborne against the Church who persuadeth vs to follow straunge Religions goe scotfree The person that was infected with a Corporall leprosie Leu. 13â— was separated from all societie and shall obstinat Hereticks prefigured by such infected and infecting persons be permitted to conuerse with vs yea to rule and gouerne amongst Christians heresie being a spirituall leprosie Aug lib. 2. quaest Euang. cap 40. Leu. 24. which mixeth falsehood with truth as a leprosie infecteth some parts of the flesh others remaining sound and infecting not only the bodie as that doth but euen the soule The blasphemer in the same law was by Gods owne mouth commanded to be cast out of the Camp and to be stoned of the people and shall the heretick in words commonlie blasphemous in deeds sacrilegious be permitted in the Church and not be cast out by Censure of excommunication Leis. 20â— and by death also when that will not serue NADAD and ABIV though sonnes of AARON for vsing straunge fire in their Censors were deuoured with fire from heauen Nu. 16. CHORE DATHAN ABIRON and HON for arrogating vnto them Aarons office were swallowed vp by the Earth and shall the Heretick who inuenteth straunge doctrines and who commonly without right ordination or vocation arrogateth Priestlie Authoritie be free from all Temporall punishment he commonly contemning all spirituall Censures Matt. 7. Ioan. 10. No no an heretick is a woolf and consequentlie to be driuen from the fold with stones and clubbes he is a theefe and so to be hanged he is a Canker Ioau 10. ergo to be burned and seared he is a false Coyner that is a deprauer of Gods word ergo to be hangâ—â— drawne 2. Tim. 2. Lib. 2. 3. de falsâ— moneta Mat. 13. Iudae 1. and quartered he is cockle ergo to be pluckt vp by the rootes least he hinder the growth of the good corne he is a tree of Autumne vnfruitfull twise dead being deuoid both of the life of faith and charitie ergo to be cast into the fire he is an euill humour ergo to be purged and expelled Mat. 7. he is a rotten and rotting member ergo to be cutt of least he infect the whole bodie 8. Thiralie I prooue this out of those verie wordes by which S. PETER was constituted supreame Pastour vnder Christ and vnder-Head of the Church Pasce oues meas Ioan. 21. Feed my sheep for to a Pastour it appertaineth to rule and gouerne his sheepe to feede them to cure them and to defend them from the woolfe or rauenous beast VVherfore S. PETER and his successour the Pope being the supreame visible Pastour of the Church is not onlie to rule and gouerne them by lawes nor onlie to feede them by the word and Sacraments nor only to cure and correct them by spirituall Censures but if they beinfected and infecting sheepe he may not only separate them from the Church by excommunication but also if they contemne that punishment by deposition and depriuation
of their Kinglie Authoritie and if the woolfe come he may not only crie out against him by denouncing Gods law and Iudgements nor only strike him with his spirituall staffe but he may also vse euen the Temporall Club to chase him from the flocke and fould as many worthy Prelates of the Church haue done whose examples we shall anon alleadge And yet this not withstāding there shall still be a difference betwixt the Pope and the Temporall Prince because the Pope is to vse in the first place his spirituall glaiue and not to meddle with Kinges Regalities or temporall armes but onlie when it is necessarie for the good of the Church and when the Spirituall censures will no◠suffice the Prince is to vse Temporall armes and not to meddle with the Spirituall at all 9. Mat. 18. The like Argument I deduce out of these wordes of CHRIST Si Ecclesiam non audierit sit tibi tanquam Ethnicus Publicanus If he will not heare the Church Chrysost in hunc locum let him be to thee as an Ethnike and Publican By the Church are vnderstood the Prelates of the Church and especially the Chiefe Prelate the Pope who gouerneth and commandeth in the Church and so this place is like to the former place of Deuteronomie Deut. 17 For as God there sayth that he that will not obey the high Priest shal be sentenced to death so here CHRIST sayth that he who will not obey the Pastours and especiallie the high Pastour shall be holden as an Ethnick and Publican that is by excommunication shal be cast out of all societie of the Church for with the Ethnikes and Publicans the Iewes had no commerce nor communication If then he contemne this censure of the Church the Chiefe Pastour may take his armes from him by which he molesteth her and seing that his Temporall power is that which is his Chiefest weapon the High Pastour may depriue him of it else the high visible Priest of the New law should be inferiour to the High Priest of the oulde law and MOYSES should be preferred before CHRIST and the Synagogue before the Church To make this deduction of more force I obserue that this place conuinceth that the Pastour of the Church may separate a disobedient Christian from the societie of the rest which is a Temporall punishment being a priuation of Temporall conuersation whence it followeth thar if the disobedience and default deserue it he may also depriue a Prince of his Crowne and Temporall Authoritie that being also a Temporall paine Which Argument shall be confirmed more hereafter 10. Many also and not improbablie alleage for proofe of that which hath bene said those words of our Blessed Sauiour to his Apostles Mat. 18. Whatsoeuer you shall binde vpon earth shall be bound also in heauen and what soeuer you shall loose vpon earth shal be loosed also in heauen For although this power of binding and loosing giuen to the Apostles and their Successours especiallie the Chiefe Pastour hath for her ordinarie functions loosing or detaining sinnes excommunicating or absoluing dispensing in vowes and oathes c. yet the wordes being generall VVhat soeuer you shall bind vpon earth it seemeth that they should not so be restrained but that they may be extended to loosing and absoluing euen from Temporall allegeance and obedience to the Prince when obedience to the Prince can not stand with the conseruation of the Churches right or faith for which that power was giuen And if the Pastour may free the subiects in this case from all obligation of obedience or dutie to the Prince he may make them no subiects and consequentlie the Prince no King nor superiour for the Prince and subiects are correlatiues which are of this nature that one cannot be without the other and one destroyed the other is destroyed VVherfore if the Chiefe Pastour of the Church can absolue the subiects from their allegeance be can make them no subiects if he can make them no subiectes he can make the Prince no Superiour and consequentlie depriue him of all Temporall Authoritie by which he is Superiour VVherevpon not only the learned writers of this time Cardinall BELLARMINE SVAREZ SCHVLKENIVS and others but also some of the auncients haue vnderstood this place of loosing in some case euen from Temporall allegeance S. GREGORIE the Seuenth who deposed HENRIE the fourth Emperour of that name in his depositiō which BARONIVS alleageth Baron tom 11. Anno 1080. num 11. calling vpon S. PETER and S. PAVLE sayth thus Agite nunc quaeso Patres Principes sanctissimi vt omnis mundus intelligat cognoscat quia si potestis in Coelo ligare obsoluere potestis in terra Imperia◠Regna Principatus Ducatus Marchias Comitatus omnium hominum possessiones pro meritis tollere vnicuique concedere Goe to now I pray you ô most holy Fathers and Princes that all the world may vnderstand and know that if you can bynde and loose in heauen you can in earth take away according to their deserts from euerie one and giue to others Empires Kingdomes Principalities Dukedomes Marquisdomes Counties and all mens possessions So INNOCENT the fourth in the Councell of Lions and in the deposition of FREDERICK the second expoundeth the same and warranteth therby his authority in deposing And thus much concerning proofes of the Popes authority out of scripture for deposing Princes and punishing Hereticks and rebelles to the Church by Temporall chastisements CHAPTER IX By Theologicall arguments grounded in principles of faith and the Nature of the Church as it is an absolute Common wealth the same power of the Supreame Pastour is prooued 1. WHat proofe holie Scripture yeeldeth for this veritie we haue seene in ther former Chapter Now let vs see what proofe reason grounded in faith and the Churches Nature can afforde vs. My first Argument I deduce from the comparison before mentioned betwixt the Spirituall and Temporall power by which I haue made it manifest that the Spirituall power exceedeth the Temporall as in many other things so in inflicting penalties and punishments for the Temporall power can onlie punish the bodie the Spirituall can chastize the soule that power can only decree and indict Temporall penalties and mulcts this can lay spirituall Censures and bonds vpon the soule euen excommunication This power which the Church hath to excommunicate I haue aboue in part prooued out of diuerse places of Scripture which here with some others I shall alleadge againe for my present purpose For to omitt that S. PAVL excommunicated that Incestuous Corinthian 1. Cor. 5. 1. Tim. 1. Tit. 3. 2. Thes 3. 2. Ioan. 1 2. Cor. 10 as also Hyminaeus and Alexander he insinuateth the same power where he commands vs to shunne hereticks and not to say Aue vnto them As also where he sayth Arma militiae nostrae non carnalia sunt sed potentia Deo ad destructionem c. The weapons of our warfare are not
sayth he let none of you suffer as a murderer or a chiefe or a rayler or coueter of other mens thinges but if as a Christian Catholique let him not be ashamed 1. Pet. 2. Bee you therfore Subiect to euerie humane Creatur for God whether it be to the King as excelling or to rulers as sent from him whether it bee to the Prelate or to the Prince Church or Common wealth it hauing been my onlie intention and the onlie drift of this booke that Prelate and Prince should both haue their due neither should bee iniuried 78. And therfore I exhort you to refuse the Oathe of pretended Allegeaunce because your Chiefe visible Pastour hath forbidden it and for that his Authoritie and Right therin is interessed and yet I would haue you also obey the King in all Temporall and Ciuill causes because such obedience Gods Law commaundeth and consequentlie to defend his Royal parson euen with hazard of your goods Landes and liues to pray for him and his Royall posteritie that he may liue and raigne long in his own person and after in a long posteritie that he may soe gouetn his Kingdome of England heere as he may not loose but gaine a greater Kingdome of Heauen herafter 79 And I most humblie also desire his most Excellent Maiestie An humble petition to the Kings maiestie out of his rare wisdome deepe Iudgement and long experieÌ„ce not to esteeme those his onlie faithfull Suhiectes who are best Temporisers because as many of these men serue not so much the King as the tyme and in it their own turnes so if tyme Fortune chauÌ„ge they also like the Fishe Polypus which taketh the hewe and colour of the stone to which it cleaueth will chaunge and varie The noble CONSTANT vs Father to CONSTANTINE the Great will be vnto his Maiestie a good President in 〈◊〉 Kinde Hee on a tyme to trye who were like to prooue his most faithfull Subiectes commaunded as EVSEBIVS relateth that all those of his Court Euseb li. de vita CoÌ„stan tini non longe ab initiâ— who would enâ—oy his frendship or participate of any his Honours and Dignities which he vsed to bestowe should sacrifice to the Goddes and that they who would not should be expelled the Court and depriued of all honour and fauour At which commaundement some of them loath to loose their honorable places and Dignities obeyed the King and forsaking Christian Religion sacrificed to the Idolles others fearing God more then the King and more him that can kill soule and bodye in hell then him that can kill onlie the body Mat. 10. but can not touch the soule left the Court and all hopes of preferrement rather then they would leaue their Religion or do any thing against their conscience which when the King Sawe he called backe those constant Christians and reiected from his Courte and companie those-false harted Temporizers saying that they whoe were not faithfull to God would neuer be sure and trustie to the King and that they who would not for any thing the world could afforde forsake God or their Religion or do any thing against conscience were most like to prooue most faithfull freinds and Subiectes to their Prince Which President if 〈◊〉 Maiestie our Soueraigne respect accordinglie he will deeme and shall by experience find that those his Catholique Subiectes who out of Religion and Conscience stand most constantlie for their faith the Church and her chiefe Visible Pastour will out of the same Religion and conscience which are the most strong and forcible bondes stand most stiffelie when occasion shal be offered for their King and Soueraigne and will prooue his most obedient peaceble and faithfull Subiectes The Printer to the Reader Although the Authour gentle Reader by publishing this his Treatise so late This is spoken of the first Edition may seeme to haue obserued no oportunitie of time yet I can assure thee that it was two yeeres since readie for the presse and much against his will hath all this while vppon some occasions been differred But seeing that the Oath is still proposed by the Magistrate and by some few also who feare more the losse of a Temporall then an eternall estate taken and moreouer defended he shall not be like to that Phisition who prescribeth Phisick after the disease is cured but rather to him who expecteth till the disease coÌ„meth to maturitie and ripenesse that so shewing it selfe more euidently he may apply the better remedie Receaue it therefore how late soeuer it come and vse it for thy good according to the Authours desire and sincere intention FINIS FAVLTS ESCAPED IN PRINTING PAg. 7. lin 10. bath corrige hath selue cor selfe p. 8. l. 11. Defert cor Desert p. 1â— l 22. to watdes cor towardes p. 14. l. 10. Indâ—â—h 8. Iudiâ—h 8. p. 14. l. 21 your co your p. 15. l. 3 Ghildbirth co Childbirth l. 15 eins cor eius p. 17. l. â—6 fornacet rieth cor fornace trieth p. 22. l. 26. substantiam cor substantiam p. 25. l. 2. tberfore corrige therfore p. 26. l. 3 you cor you p. 31. l. 18. visible cor visible p. 33. l. 8. followeth co floweth p. 3â— l. 9. and cor and. p. 43. l. 24. gnbernator cor guâ—ernator p. 48. l. 29. declare cor declare p. 50. l. 13. meantes cor meanes p. 55. l. 3 priuarelie or prâ—uate lie l. 5. children cor children p. 70. l. 1. that is cor that it l. 25. and cor and pag. 71. l. 29. ge cor goe p. 7â— l. 11. spirituall cor spirituall p. 75. l. 8 Fightlie cor Eighlie p. 76. l. 18. gouernmet co gouernment p 81. l. 24. defcendeth cor descendeth l. 28 Kâ—uges cor Kinges p. 82. l. 7. out cor our p. 85 l. 5. Enangelists cor Euangelists l. 10. nobis â—o vobis p 81 l. 22. and cor and. l. 2â— inâ—â—fidictio cor-iurisdictio p. 87. l. 12. facrifice cor sacrifice p. 91. l. 13. especiallig cor especiallie l. 23. is cor as pag. 93. l 10. infect cor infect p. 96. l. 11. thout cor thought lin 27. excommunication cor excommunication p. 98. l. 29. illnm cor illum p. 100. l. 25. of cor of p. 102. l. 19. bic cor hic l. 20. bellnm cor bellum p. 105. l. 9. ouet cor ouer l. 14. qui cor qui. l. 24. Russinus cor Ruffinus p. 107. l. 9. soue cor sonne l. 28. einsque cor einsque p. 108. l. 14. aud cor and. l. 19 hodie cor holie p. 11. l 16. first cor first p. 119. l. 24. howsoeuer cor howsoeuer p. 110. l. 23. derest cor detest p. 121. l. 3. Ecclesiastiaall cor Ecclesiasticall p. 123. lin 10. is cor if p. 127. l. 17. notwitstanding cor notwithstanding l. 20. snmendum cor sumendum l. 28. Ecclefiasticall cor Ecclesiasticall lin 31. Aristocle cor Aristotle p. 128. l. 5. Church cor Church p. 130. l. 12. os cor of l. 33. Generall cor Generall p. 131. l. 23. enerie cor euerie p. 132. lin 29. eternall cor externall p. 135. l. 12. aster cor after p. 137. l. 33. snpreme cor supreme p. 143. lin 21. gouerue cor gouerne pag. 1â—0 l. 21. quicquam cor quicquam pag. 151. l. 19. inconsiderrti cor inconsiderati p. 152. l. 10. BBCAMVS cor BECANVS p 153. l. 16. BYRHIL cor BVRHIL p. 154. l. 20. King cor King p. 155. l. 2. Supremacie cor supremacie p. 172. l. 24. heanen cor heauen lin 33. thetof cor therof p. 174. l. 17. although cor although p. 175 l. 17. Authontie cor Authoritie p. 179. l. 21. selues cor selues p. 186. lin 2. rempnblicam cor rempublicam l 5. The same doth also cor The same doth also p. 187. li. 18. Councell cor Councell pa. 190 l. 32. chrastizing cor chastizing p. 190. l. punish cor punish lin 13. sacrifice cor sacrifice p. 192. infecting co infecting p. 195. l. 18. that cor that p 196 l. 22. be cor he p. 198. l. 9. ther cor the. pag. 200. l. 6 hane cor haue p. 201. l. 25. Kingdomes cor Kingdomes p. 205. l 23. for as cor for as c. pag. 20â— l 19. Priuces cor Princes p. 208. l. 25. offensiue cor offensiue p. 214. l. 24. subiect corrige subiect p. 218. l. 11. And cor And. pag. 224. li. 24. selue cor selfe p. 228. l 31. which cor which p. 23â— l. 7. Prelares cor Prelates p. 235. l. 6. Lordes cor Lordes p. 237. l. 25. te cor to p. 238. l. 18 hecause cor because p. 240. l. 5. not cor not pag. 243. l. 18. which cor which p. 245. l. 1â— should cor should p. 246. l. 28. of cor of p. 249 lin 33. from cor from p. 257. l. 5. Epistle cor Epistles p. 257. l. 18. Regnnn cor Regum pa. 262. l. 17. denouuced cor denounced p. 268. l. 22 contronersie cor controuersie p. 269. l. 22. Englisch cor English p. 270. l. 2 Azorins cor Azorius p. 272. l. 2. cafu cor casu lin 22. edministrare cor administrare lin 28. propoaetion cor proposition l. 30. ne cor one p. 276. l. 21. aud cor and. p. 2â—8 l 22 trulie cor trulie p. 279. l. 16. Freunce cor Fraunce p. 284. l. 3. Councell co Councell p. 29â— l. 23. murout cor mirrour p. 288. l. 13. subiectes co subiectes l. 18. Queene cor Queene l. â—2 thc co the. p 290 l. 2. where cor were l 28. Thirdlie and lastlie cor Fourthlie and lastly p 297. l. 32. leisnre cor leisure p. 298. l 31. vndes cor vnder p. 2â—9 l 12. TViddrington cor VViddrington lin 24. beeause cor because p. 300. l 13. see cor soe p. 312. l. 32. os cor of p. 330 l. 21. Fot cor For. p. 334. l. 2â— saferie cor safetie Pag. 351. in marg dele Anton lib 4. and lib. cor l. pag. 353. lin 26 adde before if yet pag 353 lin 30. depose cor depose also pag 465. l last dele of excommunication denounced pag. 361 lin 10. abolendum cor abolendam pag. 368. l. 25. coe correct condemned pag. 368. l. 26. and cor but practised and. pag. 400. l. 23. perswaded cor perswade End