for some others may follow by degrees or in a Croud Let us not be wiser than God or trust our strength too much we give Papists advantage upon us and matter of bragging with cause of hardning themselves that we borrowed our Ceremonies from them and this string they hung upon amongst us or else one way or other they had been gone but by the same reason some Ceremonies were taken away all ought to have been We return to the Intention and say 't is not the Opinion that Men have that makes a true or false Worship but the nature of the thing as already said for thus a Man may go to Mass conceiving a private Opinion to himself different from that which Massmongers have so he may fancy he doth not sin when he commits a gross one Calderinus when he was about going to Mass used to say eamus ad communem errorem let us go to the vulgar Error but going to Mass that is doing all those outward actions which Massmongers use to perform is Idolatry which to avoid the three young Men would not fall down and Worship the Image of Nebuchadnezar Dan. 3.18 If the Intention had made the thing lawful or unlawful they might have fallen down before the Image but intentionally worship'd God but they would not going to Mass with what intention you please is to approve of and commit Idolatry God hath made Body and Soul and will be Worshipped in both the proper Nature of Worship consists in honouring of God so that all outward Ceremonies whose proper use is the honouring of God will be external Worship 'T is sad to see how to defend these Ceremonies retained in our Church they are put upon shifts they are resolved to keep and defend them let what will become of it In order to it they call upon Sophistry for help and to avoid coming to the point they make a Logomachy a Dispute about words coining Definitions Divisions Distinctions as Doctrinal and Ritual Ceremonies essential accessary accidental simple double and treble significant sacred by application mutable ambulatory arbitrary reductively sacramental moral Ceremonies immediate Worship in respect of means by vertue of something else in respect of the manner and reductively in respect of the utmost and Divine Worship and many more of the same stamp so 't is like to me when I hear such words to be with Lombard Durandus Occam and other Schoolmen to hear of entity quiddity ut qui ut quo and such other barbarous terms under which they confounded the Nature of Things Thus they will talk of Altars commanded and Altars permitted under the Law Deut. 4 2â— And when out of Scripture we press them against Additions to be made unto the Word and Worship of God then they will tell us of corrupting Additions but not preserving are there forbidden let them shew the least step in Scripture to ground that shameful and pitiful distinction upon as despicable as those I heard hissed out in Philosophy Schools ex creditis concedo ex credendis nego ut soepius concedo ut semper nego which yet considering the matters they were about and only to try Man's Wits were much more tolerable than this which concerneth things of so high a Nature But such distinctions can never put off the blow of these words Ye shall not add unto the Word which I Command neither shall ye diminish ought from it Besides that these preserving additions are an inlet for Superstition and incongruous Acts of Parliament are for preservation of Religion but they would not hear their Laws are an Addition to the Word and Worship of God All this while our Ceremonies go upon a wrong Principle which 't is necessary to beat them off and this is it they think the Church hath power to institute all such things but a preliminary question is who that Church is They will say 't is the Convocation out of which most Ministers and all the Laity a Chancellor excepted are excluded so this will be a National Church Thus if we ask Papists what they mean by their Church they will say Pope and Council or else Pope and Cardinals Well that 's for Papists For us the Convocation decides and then the whole Church as well Ministers that have right to sit there and give in their Opinions and all the Laity must submit But this Convocation never concludes any thing for the common good of the Church they generally are servile to those whom they depend upon and Tyrannical over those that are subject to them and though sometimes some good motions be made amongst them 't is nothing but what we may say of the Council of Trent and of other mercenary publick Assemblies But doth not this Convocation except they will be above St. Paul think that what Authority the Church hath is for edification 2 Cor. 10.8 and not for destruction 't is a bound power not Magisterial but Ministerial If they may institute Ceremonies then Circumcision if thought fit may be imposed as well as Cross in Baptism It may be as of the King who was not to multiply Horses Wives Deut. 17.16 17 Silver and Gold to himself which Solomon made a shift to go thorough So the Church or Convocation might in time happen to multiply Ceremonies that which is not grounded upon the Word may at last be upon ill Custom if it was thought fit to bring in that which hath been kept out not heeding what Paul saith if I build again things which I destroyed I make my self a transgressor Gal. 2.18 To see how in these matters they tread the steps of Popery they assert how some such Worship is good which is not taught in Scripture that many teaching Ceremonies which God never instituted may by Men be brought in to Worship Images themselves not excepted that Additions to God's Word so they be not contrary to it may and ought to be made The sum of their Doctrine in this point is by Hooker set down in his Book of Ecclesiastical Policy He hath these words much the Church of God shall always need that which the Scripture teaches not Page 125. Which argueth the Word of God of insufficiency contrary to what our Saviour and Sr. Paul say which no doubt must be supplied with Traditions These are rare Principles They further say Scripture is as perfect in giving general Rules as it should be in setting down of particular Instances this is only to make good to themselves the adding and enlarging Power But general Rules make only the proposition tending to particulars and particulars are not so fully inferred as if they were expresly set down General Rules for Civil Policy may be given in the New Testament yet not so fully and clearly taught as in the Old or as Religious Worship is now in the New the Rule of clean and unclean Beasts was general and easily discernable without Institution of Men as now for Bread and Wine in the Communion
nor be a Hinderance for Ministers to exercise the Gift of Prayer or to make them neglect it nor to justle out preaching neither must Men make the publick Worship of God consist only or chiefly in hearing Prayers read With these Cautions we approve well of a Liturgy wherefore let it be known we except not against Liturgies in general and as such but in particular against such as we think to have just Exceptions against either as to the matter or to the manner of using them As to those Liturgies fathered upon St. Peter St. James and Mark they are spurious and were obtruded upon the World by the Romanists Although I do not intend to insist upon those Places of the Common-prayer-book which we have just Cause to except against because others have done it before yet something must be said to it and we must come to some particlars I shall begin with the Rubrick concerning the Order how the rest of the holy Scripture besides the Psalter is appointed to be read in the first Paragraph is a Brand and a Slight put upon holy Canonical Scripture of the Old Testament for it is said It shall be read through once every Year except certain Books and Chapters which be least edifying and might be spared yet instead of these are read several of the Apocryphal Books as Ecclesiasticus the Wisdom 2d of Esdras Baruch Judith Tobith c. Whereby a visible Preference is given to those Humane Writings before the authentick Word of God for they are lookt upon as best edifying and least to be spared In the point this is worse than Papists who give the Apocryphas and their Traditions an equal Authority to Canonical Scripture which is the Word of God when the others are the Word of Man but this as I already observed giveth the Preference to some of the Apocrypha before some of the Canonical I hope this shall be no Question between us we all know the Reasons we have against Papists about the Authority of the Apocrypha First They were all written after the Time of Malachy the last of the Prophets Secondly None of the Apocrypha is written in Hebrew which is the Tongue used by the Prophets Thirdly Neither the Jews nor the primitive Apostolical Church ever received them as Canonical Fourthly they were never quoted in the New Testament by our Saviour or his Apostles tho there be Places quoted out of every Book of the Old Testament and our blessed Saviour mentioned the Old Testament under three Heads The Law of Moses the Prophets Luke 24.44 and the Psalms But the fifth and chief Reason because in every thing they do not agree with the Canonical Scripture nor with themselves as hath been shewed by some of our Divines as Whitaker Reynolds c. specially in Vsher's Body of Divinity and by Forreigners as Polanus Chamierus and so many more And this I press the more because the Authority of it in Scripture is one of the Fundamental Points of our Religion and one of the greatest Controversies between Papists and us In the last Paragraph of the same Rubrick 't is ordered thus as often as the first Chapter of St. Matthew is read either for Lesson or Gospel ye shall begin the same at Vers 18. and the third Chapter of St. Luke 's Gospel shall be read unto the middle of Verse the 23d Surely that which is ordered to be left out is Part of Scripture as that which is read the one as well as the other are written for our Instruction as well as Comfort That which is unread is of a high Concernment for though it consists only of proper Names yet contains a most important Matter every Degree of our blessed Saviour's Genealogy which God under the Old Testament took such Care to preserve clear that when the Messiah came to be born there should be no Doubt no Difficulty made of his being of the Seed of Abraham of the Family of David which St. Matthew proves on Joseph his supposed Father's side as St. Luke on Mary's the first divided into three Classes of 14 Generations every one of which makes undisputably a great Article of our Faith how Jesus Christ born of the Virgin Mary is the true Messiah promised to the World out of Abraham's Seed and then the mention amongst Christ's Ancestors made of Thamar of Rachab of Ruth of her that had been Vrias's Wife Bersheba whereby Christ owns for his Relations according to the Flesh some branded with notorious Faults others though Aliens from the Common-wealth of Israel and Strangers from the Covenants of Promise to shew how in his Spiritual Relations he would not disown the most notorious Sinners and never so much Gentiles This I say affords matter of Meditation and so is not to be unread Here followeth the Table of the proper Lessons to be read at the Head whereof we find the Word Mattens for Morning Prayer and to have matched things well there should have been the Word Vespers instead of Evening Song both Words in that Sence used in the Church of Rome from whom we borrow both Names and things as we shall have Occasion farther to speak of now these Words are derived from Latin and used in Italian Spanish French c. 'T is no wonder if having taken things out of their Latin Books we also retain some of their Names as Advent Epiphany Quinquagesima Sexagesima Septuagesima c. which are barbarous to every English Man unacquainted with the Latin Tongue or with the Customs of that Church so we do continue their Mass Names and Days as Christmas the Day when Mass is said for the Birth of Christ Candlemass the Day of the Mass of Candles for then Popish Churches are full of them Lammas Day the Day when here in Time of Popery they said Mass for the Preservation of Lambs Michaelmass the Day when Michael's Mass is said c. We say no Mass upon those Days but we have Collect Epistle and Gospel some of which Papists use upon those very Days Now if we look into the Kalender we shall there find the Names of many Saints which either were never in Nature or else are honoured upon Earth when may be their Souls are tormented in Hell Boniface Silvester Clement Dunstan George Martin Denis for there must be Champions to defend the rest specially the Ladies as Margaret Agnes Magdalene Katharine Agathe c. and to be merry Cicely the Patroness of Musitians with Nicolas Crispin Blasius Patrons of Seamen Shoemakers c. Hugh Valentine Edward Machal amongst other Inventions that of the Cross must be in too Remige and several other Popish Saints whose Names should not be in our Mouths much less in our Common-prayer-book we must not omit how there are five Holy Days for the blessed Virgin Purification Annunciation Visitation Nativity and Conception there should have been also her Assumption when she was as they pretend carried up to Heaven in Body and Soul then we could have
us to let the World know we are no such Men acted by meer Fancy and Turbulent as misrepresented and to give our Reasons why we cannot consent and conform May the Lord out of his infinite wisdom and mercy be pleased in his due time to unite us in judgment and affection for the truth Now something also must be added as to the subject matter of the following Papers We have Cause to thank God that since our late happy Revolution the Yoke of Persecution is broke off from our Neck and we now enjoy the Liberty of meeting pulickly to serve God and are secured by an Act of Parliament which I pray God may last for ever except it were taken off upon a better account namely to unite us all voluntarily to joyn together in the Worship of God Wherefore many things as are said in this Paper must be understood according as things were when the Laws were strict and severely put in Execution against us and not since the Time of Indulgence but in relation to Laws it ought to be taken notice of how the Penal Laws which at first were intended only against Popish Recusants were thorough the Malice and Craftiness of some Men willing to keep up Divisions fully turned against us as we may believe contrary to the Intention of the Makers thereof I desire what I say in this short Treatise may be so interpreted as arising as indeed it doth out of a Principle of Vnion and Peace grounded upon Truth for without it they can never stand long nor be acceptable to God Now I desire those who are concerned in these matters to consider the Necessity of this Vnion by the Greatness of the Danger which the Want of it doth constantly expose us to from our common Enemy doth not former and latter Experience convince us of this Truth And were we not very lately like to have been all swallowed up by Papists when not thinking themselves strong enough at home they combined with forreign Powers to bring it about They have too well learned the Maxim divide impera and therefore all our Divisions were ever fomented by them striving to set us together by the Ears with one Party to ruin another and at last to destroy us both so that besides the Glory of God if there was no other Reason but Self-preservation we ought to be convinced of the Necessity of labouring to come to a Reconciliation and doth not Experience sufficiently teach us how these Matters ever have been the Occasion of Differences in Church and State Out of what hath been said I lay this for a Foundation that it is our common Interest and for the Preservation of us all there is a Necessity to agree and unite Now it is undeniably true that these Matters have been the Causes of our Divisions the partition Wall which hath kept us asunder and that this maintains still the Papist Interest amongst us which would presently fall down if that Door was shut upon them As to the Doctrinal Part of the 39 Articles we are all agreed and as to Church Government in the general we unite thus far that there ought to be a Discipline with a Ministery by way of Office and that none ought to take care of Souls and administer God's Ordinances but these who have a lawful Call to it we agree or ought to agree how the Word of God and Apostolical Practice therein contained must be the Rule of Doctrine and Worship when afterward we come to differ why should we not be judged by that Law which is the Word of an infallible God preferrably to the Judgment of any Man or of all Men together who are all subject to Error And why upon this Difference should the strongest go about cutting the Throat of the weakest as good as to say I cannot perswade you but will force you a good Cause as we say to Papists must never be promoted by such evil means for it cannot be denied but a great deal of Violence hath been therein used against Dissenters Men who cannot agree amongst themselves must about a Judge Now Infallibility and Impartiality the two necessary Qualifications for a just Judge are not to be had but in the Word of God which is not wanting in giving us Directions for the Well-being as for the Being of the Church or else it were imperfect All Scripture is given by Inspiration of God and is profitable for Doctrine for Reproof for Correction for Instruction in Righteousness that the Man of God may be perfect Where Perfection is nothing is wanting to make us wife unto Salvation 2 Tim. 3.15 16 17. We say it is against our Conscience to do the things they would have us to do they cannot say it is against theirs to leave them I do not speak to one single Person who for his Excuse will pretend they are commanded him but I speak to the Law Makers Now is there not more Reason for you to leave them off which doth not wound your Conscience than for us to do them and thereby offend ours Why do you impose such Necessity such Oaths such Subscriptions as you do which are or become meer Snares contrary to St. Paul's Rule This I speak for your own Profit not that I may cast a Snare upon you 1 Cor. 7.35 which Dr. Whitaker calls Aureus locus libertatis vindex a golden Text Asserter of Liberty The Question is about Ceremonies religious in their Nature Vse and Signification which we say ought not to be brought into the Worship of God without a Warrant from the Word the Rule of it and I doubt what Beza and Bald win do express is too true it is not to be doubted but that most of the antient Bishops were somewhat too busie in devising Rites but unhappy was their Counsel I suppose they had been instituted for a good End yet being abused they are taken away for a better Dr. Fulk speaks much in few Words Rejoynder to Martial Art 1. The Gates of Hell saith he assaulted the Church in idle Ceremonies the Fathers in them declined from the Simplicity of the Gospel Bellarmin de eff sacr l. 2. c. 32. can condemn vain and unprofitable Ceremonies Lyra another Papist saith the Memory of Idolatry is totally to be wiped out and the Jesuit Coster Enchir. chap. 8. confesseth that if the Substance of Bread remain in the Sacrament then their Idolatry is more intolerable than the Egyptians was in worshipping of an Ox or a Crocodile they agree as to the Point but when we justly come to apply it then they will not hear of it they will assert a Transubstantiation before they will own an Idolatry worse than that of the Egyptians or that their Ceremonies are vain unprofitable and Idolatrous and yet we are satisfied they are so though some of our Church would qualifie things and say they are not so idolatrous as the Heathenists and all this to what purpose Only to make ours which we have from
without naming of Wheat Rye c. or French Spanish or Rhenish Wines c. but Kneeling at the Sacrament Bowing towards the Altar Cross and Surplice are not so in general appointed Moses and the Lord Jesus were compared in Faithfulness in all God's House Heb. 3.2 their Faithfulness equal because they both did that which was Commanded them of God however if it were God's revealed Will that more immediate means of Worship had been instituted in the Christian Church more then Christ hath instituted who was appointed to ordain the means of Worship under the New Testament as Moses was under the Old and Moses gave all such Rules of Worship under the Old Testament which God would have it followeth that the Faithfulness of Christ was not so extended to all the necessities of the Church as Moses's was which is meer Blasphemy Wherefore we must agree that the Lord Jesus appointed all necessary things for the being and well-being of his Church so there is nothing left for Men to add unto it and let those who pretend to an Authority to make Additions have a care what they do for this is to bring strange fire into the House of God and let them remember the Crime and Punishment of Nadab and Abihu Now God will suffer unpunished Inventions of Men in his Worship no more then he would allow them of strange Fire and the reason of this terrible Judgment given in the Text is which he commanded them not Levit. 10.1 So that in this case what is not commanded is forbidden and to do any thing without a Precept is an heinous sin Thus we need no other reason against all these Ceremonies Additions and Humane Inventions then this God hath not commanded them The words of one of our Doctors upon the place are observable Bishop Babington We may hence learn and settle in our hearts with what severity the Lord challengeth and defendeth his Authority in laying down the manner and way of his Worship not leaving it to any Creature to meddle with but according to Prescription and Appointment from him content he is that Men shall make Laws for Humane Matters c. But for his Divine Worship he only will prescribe it himself and what he appointed that must be done and that only or else Nadab and Abihu their Punishment must be expected that is God's Wrath in such a manner as he shall please These Words are full when God threatned Judah for building the high places of Tophet he saith Jer. 7.31 which I commanded them not He makes a high Aggravation to the Sin because in matter of Worship nothing is to be done without his express Commandment so that which is without and besides the Word is against it Of this Nature are their double and significant Rites which no meer Order and Decency doth necessarily require but only the meer Will of Men but we mean it not of every particular Rite belonging to Order and Decency which are besides the particular Determination of Scripture Concerning the Altar to be made unto the Lord Exod. 20.24 25. he prescribed the matter of Earth or of Stone and the manner too not to have the Stone hewen Deut. 27.5 6. 1 Jos 8.31 or to have Steps to go up to it What may some say if we may not conveniently make it with Earth or Stone we will make it of something else as Bricks it will still be an Altar to offer Sacrifices only to the Lord and shall be wholly dedicated to his Service Thus man's corrupt Reason is apt to speak and is pleased with its Notion but to know how heinously God takes it let us hear God himself Isa 65.3 a People that provoketh me to Anger continually to my Face That burneth Incense upon Altars of Brick There is an End when Men will pretend to be wiser than God It is strange but true how the Foolishness of man would be wiser than the Wisdom of God as if we would take upon us to outwit him God thinks such and such ways are best but men know of better some had as good as to say we like not what God prescribed we our selves know better than so even in those things that belong to his Worship Did the most notorious Idolaters ever proceed to a higher Degree of Presumption than this is They that go so far would go farther if they could they who take upon them to make Additions or Alterations in his Service would prescribe the whole too and may be at last order his actings and perhaps meddle with his own Nature for indeed by the same reason they meddle with one they might do so with the other yet when God speaks the whole Earth should be silent and hold their peace Yet some will not but as it were would be prescribing and make in his house new Laws contrary to or at least different from those he hath enacted To shew how pragmatical and peremptory our Nature is in such things let the Case of Naaman the Syrian 2 Kings 5. a great Man with his Master honorable and a mighty Man in Valour be observed he comes to the Prophet Elisha to be cured of his Leprosie one would think that coming so far to a Doctor he should take the Doctor 's Advice who bids him go to and wash in Jordan seven times but thereupon that great man is very angry and goes away what saith he I thought he would surely come out to me and stand and call on the Name of the Lord his God and strike his Hand over the Place and recover the Leper All this very plausible to Human Sense and Reason for a man who looks upon Abana and Pharphar Rivers of Damascus better than all the Waters of Israel and may be he had never been cured if God had not put it into the Hearts of his Servants to speak to him If the Prophet had bid thee to do some great thing wouldest thou not have done it He despised the Plainness and Simplicity of the Remedy yet it proved a true one So though the plain Worship free from Ceremonies instituted of God be the right one yet some look for things of a great Pomp and Shew but they are worse than Naaman was for he upon the Voice of his Servants obeyed the Word of the Prophet but these will not hearken to the Word of God let him speak never so plainly by the Mouth of his Servants they will take no Warnings but rather follow their own ways It were well if that People who have so great a mind to be meddling with a legislative and institutive Power in the Church would consider this there is no such thing no such Ceremony either done or instituted by Christ therefore let us not think our selves wiser than he or his Apostles De Sacram. Commonpeople saith Dr. Whitaker are not to be taught with Ceremonies God hath given the Scriptures that out of them they might receive necessary Instruction
Logicians are they all But if this was litterally to be taken I see no Reason but we may do so of all those Places where Bodily Members as Eye Hand Arm c. and Passions as Anger Fury Vengeance Jealousie c. are attributed to God and thus fall into the Heresies of Antropomorphites and Antropopathites I must not omit to say how Papists make use of this Place in the Philippians to the same Purpose as our Men do so that this Practice is not free from Superstition Of Holy-days NEXT comes the Point of Feasts by them called Holy-days but there is no other Holy-days besides the Sabbath which God blessed and sanctified and now the Christian Sabbath or the first Day of the Week which our Saviour sanctified by his Resurrection after which he at several times appeared unto his Apostles who constantly observed it so that in St. John's time it was called the Lord's Day Rev. 1.10 As for all other Days kept in Memory of Creatures we disallow Keeping of Days hath Relation to God's Worship which ought not to be communicated to Men We are not satisfied to keep Apostles Days but we must also keep All Saints Michael and his Angels the Innocents c. All idle and superstitious Fopperies for which we have neither Precept nor Example in the Word of God to what purpose they contribute neither to Decency to Order nor to Edification only are an Inlet to Superstition He that keeps a Day let him keep it unto the Lord and not to Man either dead or alive An African Council condemned certain Feasts used in Memory of Martyrs because they were drawn from the Errors of the Gentiles whose Abominations Christians must not meddle or have to do with 1 Cor. 10.20 for the things which the Gentiles sacrifice they sacrifice it to Devils and I would not that ye should have Fellowship with Devils So that when a Man saith to us this is offered in Sacrifice to Idols we ought not to eat Upon this Consideration that Council resolved on this And this we are to seek of the Emperor that such Feasts as are in many Places contrary to the Word of God and from the Errors of the Gentiles be forbidden for indeed some Christians being too ready to draw such things from them they transmitted them to others Christians and their Guides and Pastors instead of fencing against these things such was their Frailty that they rather complied therewith For Proof of this De Origin fest In Tertul. de Cor. Mil. let us hear what Hospinianus saith after Beat. Renany The old Bishops saith he were used when they could not call Men from the Superstitions of the Heathens by the preaching of the Word to seek at least to do it by observing their Holy-days with their own Worship but this was to drive out one Nail with another no Way to take off Superstition Although at the Beginning these Solemnities seemed tolerable yet at last they grew to such a Heap of Superstitions that they became the Fountain and Beginning of most horrible things Thus far he and Austin who then was alive wished them abolished and he gives in a Counsel for a good End Hom. 6. de Verb. dom in Matth. If ye ask how the Pagans may be won enlightened called leave all their Solemnities and forsake their Toys So we may say at this time only changing the Word Pagans into those of Papists Now the great Reason in those Days used by their learned Men not to receive those Vanities or if received to abolish them was because they were derived from Heathens which made Tertullian so sharply dispute that a Christian might not wear a Lawrel Crown for no other Cause but that the Gentiles did so which makes him say elsewhere Those Ceremonies are superstitious and vain which we used without any Authority of Divine or Apostolical Command and are to be accounted superstitious and therefore be restrained because in some sort they make us like the Gentiles and we may say they in some kind make us like the Papists for certainly we have it from them as they had it from the corrupt Church and this had it from Pagans so that the Springs whence they came and the Pipes thorough which they were conveyed are corrupt if there was no other Fault but this that they are empty Observations to be justly upbraided with Vanity as being done without any Warrant out of the Word for such things serve not to Religion but to Superstition and are affected and forced and rather over curious than any wise rational at all and therefore to be restrained because they do some of them suit with the Gentiles and all with the Papists Why then should we practise Ceremonial Festivals of Man's making 't is well to take occasion of hearing the Word and praying upon any Day when 't is offered but 't is not the Day but the Word of God that puts us in mind of the Birth Resurrection and Ascension of Christ and with Bucer we may well say I would to God that every Holy-day whatsoever besides the Lord's Day In Matth. 12. were abolished that Zeal which at first brought them in was without all warrant from the Word and it meerly follured corrupt reason to drive out the Holy-days of the Pagans as one Nail drives out another Those Holy-days have been so tainted with Superstition that I wonder we tremble not at their very Names and yet these every Year upon certain Days are observed with Mention of him or her whose Day it is and with an Epistle Collect Gospel Of Fasts WHAT I say of Feasts may also be spoken of Fasts We own Fasts publick or private being kept out of a right Principle in a true manner and for a good End are commendable but it must be upon occasion either to prevent an imminent Danger to remove some Judgments or to be humbled for our Sins then it must be joyned with Prayer for 't is an Accessary and Help to it and to speak more generally there is a Fast from Sin and evil Works which we are constantly bound to observe 't is what Scripture calleth ceasing from Evil but here this is not the Question 't is of prescribed Fasts which ought not always to be upon certain Days of the Year which are a Yoke upon the Church but as I said only upon Occasion voluntary and not forced and they ought not to consist in the Abstinence of some Meats but of all sorts for a time the better to fit us for Prayer not to have them too frequent as in the Church of Rome which looks on it as meritorious The Heretick Montanus brought in and promoted the stinted Fasts which afterwards did superstitiously multiply and to this Day Papists are full of them from them we borrowed some as those by the Church ordered to be kept upon Eves of several Holy-days so called all to be returned to those whom we had it from as well as the Feasts of
be the better for it or else they would not do it nay they think it to be no Church till it be done for till then there is in it no preaching at least no administring of Sacraments yet both they administer in private Houses Other things there are as churching of Women after the Jewish Way of Purification as we keep a Day about it for the blessed Virgin which God never required at our Hands nor she ever desired but all is our Fancy after the Pattern of Popery there are also the private Communion private Baptism Burial of the Dead at Sea there was also a Form about healing or touching for the King 's Evil a Popish Foppery too but now quite out all which we omit speaking to having things enough besides to discourse upon so we must proceed to a second general Head namely the Discipline of the Church Of Church-Government THUS having spoken of Ceremonies we must now say something of the Government of the Church which is much after that of Rome Triplicat art whitak cap. 9. Hierarch Anachrys lib. 2. pag. 45. in the manner of Hierarcy by Archbishops Bishops Archdeacons Deans and Chapters then Chancellours Commissaries Officials c. These have been the Steps for Popes to ascend upon that Throne of Iniquity which they now sit upon these are of Man's Invention whether or not the Design was good I shall not dispute but certainly it hath proved fatal Staplet and Scalting Two of the great Champions of Rome both highly commend and in it do much approve of our Constitution and Practice Those Offices in the Church which are of God's Institution we have them named in Scripture Eph. 4.11 and 1 Cor. 12.28 God gave some Apostles and some Prophets and some Evangelists and some Pastours and Teachers The Apostles were universal Preachers of the Gospel immediately called by Christ who wrought Miracles and were infallible in Doctrine The Prophets did interpret and expound Scriptures by a Divine Light having the Gift of Tongues and of things to come The Evangelists were the Writers of the History of the Gospel inspired of God or else Preachers of the Gospel called by the Apostles and attended on them in their Journeys Pastors also called Bishops that is Overseers were Ministers settled in certain Churches to teach and govern them The Doctors or Teachers were Successors of Prophets whose Office it was to explain Scriptures and vindicate them from the Errours of Hereticks The Apostles instituted Elders or Presbyters for that 's the true Signification of the Word who also are called Bishops though not always some being only to rule the Church others also to preach Men chosen by the Church endued with Gifts and Authority above others who with the Pastors took care of the publick Doctrine administred Ecclesiastical Discipline and in the Churches Name were taken up with the Vocation of Ministers Acts 6. There were also Deacons to take care of the poor to visit the sick to maintain Hospitality and sometimes to preach the Word These are all the Offices in the Church we have in the Word of God for all are reduced under these Heads No Lord Pastour and Ministerial Pastour no Bishop of Bishop or Arch-bishop that is Prince Bishop no Deacon of Deacon or Archdeacon This is contrary to the Rule of Christ so expresly forbidding his Disciples to affect any thing of Dominion or Superiority of one over another and indeed those Offices named in that to the Ephesians are sufficient for the Church as 't is said in the 12th Verse for the perfecting of the Saints for the work of the Ministry for the edifying of the Body of Christ All besides this is of a Humane Superstructure Rectors Curates Vicars c. are Names Things and Limbs of the Roman Church most of the hyerarchical Officers are not for these good Ends. Now Bishops which answer to Watchmen Pastors Ezech. 23.27 and Elders in God's Word are but for one and the same Office We see it clearly out of that place of Scripture where 't is written how St. Paul sent for the Elders of the Church of Ephesus to come to him to Miletus in the Charge he giveth them he saith Act. 20.17 82. Take heed therefore unto your selves and to all the Flock over the which the Holy Ghost hath made you Overseers to feed the Church of God In this Text we have the three Names given to the same Persons those he sent for and speaks to are called Elders God made them Overseers v. 17. for that 's the Sgnification of the Word in the Original and what in other places of Scripture is translated Bishops is here rendered by the Word Overseers though in the Greek the Word be the very same and amongst the Translators was debated whether or not in this Place it should be Englished by the Word Bishop but upon Consideration that it might prejudice the Difference they make between Bishop and Pastor or Elder they made use of the Word Overseer which could not be taken notice of by those that understand no Greek this by the by then these Elders of the Church of Ephesus the Holy Ghost had made Bishops them he charged to seed the Church and do the Office of Pastors so that in the 28th Verse Pastors and Bishops are but one and the same and here by the way I shall make this general Observation how in the Exposition of a Text three things are chiefly to be taken notice of first The true Signification of the Word in the Original secondly The Scope of the Author in the Place Thirdly The Analogy of Faith and Relation to other Places of Scripture The first I have spoken of the second here is a Charge of St. Paul for those Elders to perform their Duty of overseeing and feeding their Flock 1 Pet. 5.1 2. which St. Peter asserts also to be the Duty of Elders whereof he owns himself to be one The third is the Analogy of this Place with others as that which Paul writes to Titus For this cause I lest thee in Greet that thou shouldest ordain Elders in every City Tit. 1.5 6 7. If any be blameless c. for a Bishop must be blameless In the 5 Verse he calls Elders and in the 7. Bishops the same Persons This is the divine Bishop of a divine Institution for as to the Diocesian Bishop 't is but an Humane and Prudential Institution and there is no such thing known in Scripture as it appears out of that Place to the Philippians St. Paul directs the Epistle to all the Saints in Christ Jesus which are at Philippi Chap. 1.1 with the Bishops and Deacons out of which Place after Jerome we may say that Philippi is one Town in Macedonia and as now Bishops are reckoned there is but one not many of one Town or City but here are Bishops of the plural Number of Philippi therefore the Pastors and Elders of the Place are meaned which also
confirmeth it to be the same Office as we said but just now out of Acts 20. 'T is a thing I here have no mind to discuss Mr. Clarckson of primitive Episcop one having lately done it so well where he clearly shews how Bishops were but Ministers of Parishes as formerly Cardinals were but Priests of Parishes in Rome and to this very Day every Cardinal assoon as he is made hath with that Dignity the Title of one Parish or other in or about Rome What is said of Timothy and Titus being Bishops one of Ephesus the other of Creet is amongst some a vulgar Error grounded upon the Subscriptions of the second Epistle to the former and of the onely Epistle to the later But those do not belong to the Epistles but are Additions to them long after the Time when they had been written they are no Part of those holy Writings as it appeareth out of the Subscription of that to Titus where is a Mistake of the Place which St. Paul could not commit and is confuted out of the 12th Verse of the last Chapter where St. Paul desires him to be diligent to come to him to Nicopolis for I have determined there to winter if the Epistle had been written from Nicopolis as 't is said in the Subscription he would have said I determined here to winter as of a Place where he was and not there as of a Place where he was not at that Time when the Epistle was written The Truth is both Timothy and Titus were Evangelists who went with him in his Journeys and when he had formed a Church he left one to set things in order whilest he was gone to preach the Gospel in some other Place as to Timothy 't is clear when he exhorteth him to do the Work of an Evangelist 2 Tim. 4.5 therefore in his Epistles to them he chargeth exhorteth and doth direct them how to carry on the Work he had set them upon during his Absence and then come to him when and where he appointed them Here I shall not enter into a long Discussion only in few Words shall say how after holy Scripture the antient orthodox Doctors as Austin Jerome Ambrose and some of the Papists as Hugo Cardinal Anselm Lumbard Cusan Johan Parisens and others whose Words upon occasion we can produce hold the Distinction between Diocesian Bishops and other Ministers Elders or Pastors not to be jure divino but only jure positivo or Humane Right hence all Ministers by Decrees of ancient Councils ought to have Voices both deliberative and decisive in Councils as Gratian Duraren Gentilet exam Cone Trid. Pag. 216. and Gentiles do declare this last alledging the Councils of Nice Calcedon and Carthage and others Hierom's Words are well known and very remarkable In Tit. 1. Idem est ergo presbiter qui Episcopus Episcopi noverint se magis consuerudine quam c. The Elder is therefore the same as the Bishop and before there were in the Church Divisions through the Devil's Instigation and some said I am of Paul others I am of Apollo and others I am of Cephas Churches were governed by the common Consent of the Elders If any one thinks it is only our Opinion and not of Scripture that the Bishops and Elders are but one and the same and that one is a Name of Age the other of Office let him but read the Apostle's Words to the Philippians Paul and Timotheus the Servants of Jesus Christ to all the Saints which are in Philippi with the Bishops and Deacons Let the Bishops know that they are greater than the Elders more by Custom than by the Lord's Institution and that in common they ought to govern the Church And to Evagrius so upon these Matters Cyprian is to be consulted who declares how from the Beginning of his being made Bishop he resolved to do nothing without the Advice of the Elders and the Consent of the People Every Plant saith our blessed Saviour which my Heavenly Father hath not planted shall be rooted up Matth. 15.13 to be understood not only of Persons but also of Doctrines but now we speak of Persons The Lord Jesus declareth by himself how every true Commission must come from the same Hand I am come in my Father's Name John 5.43 and when he gives his Disciples their Commission he mentions by Vertue of what thus as my Father hath sent me so do I send you John 20.21 The Commission is originally from the Father and by the Son to the Disciples thence derivatively to others any other Commission is wrong so void and null This same Commission gives an equal Power to all and is of the same Extent for one as for the other wherefore let Prelates shew their Commission of Authority over their Fellow-ministers sure we are their Commission is not for but against it Luke 22.25 26. If they pretend to any other we say 't is not right but null and is insignificant Nothing of that Lording Office in the Place where ordinary and extraordinary Offices of God's Appointment are named Eph. 4.11 A poor Woman can say that when the Messiah cometh which is called Christ he will tell us all things John 4.25 yet he never spake of such Offices of Superiority as Lords Bishops Archbishops c. He is our Lord and Master yet gives us a wonderful Example of Humility John 13.13 14 15. elsewhere he bids us to learn of him but what To domineer over others or to be high above Fellow-servants or to assume Names or things of Superiority no such thing but Meekness of Humility for I am meek and lowly of Heart Matth. 11.29 Wherefore let Prelates be satisfied with the Rank which civil Authority hath given them as to an outward Respect but not to stretch out their Commission beyond Bounds lest they give cause to renew the Complaint of King Frederigo of Spain An. 1300. Episcopi Ceremonias c. As for Ceremonies saith he and such things as do serve to the advancing of the vain Glory of the Prelacy the Bishops take solemn Care for the promoting of these but of the Government of Souls and their eternal Salvation they are the very Plagues c. But we must leave off the Discourse about Diocesian Bishops and shall not meddle with it any further However let them not wholly engross to themselves all Jurisdiction and Ordination the whole Ecclesiastical Power and the sole Right of Ordination whereof the laying on of Hands which is an essential Part of it is called the laying on of the Hands of the Presbitery 1 Tim. 4.14 which is a collective Body not of one but of many so that for a Bishop wholly to arrogate it to himself is a great Abuse so 't is though one or two more be called if it be done pro formâ and for Fashion sake which is an owning that that thing ought really to be so though it be otherwise like one who is made to sign a
Pleasure have justled out Right and Reason and when selling and buying and such like evil Practises turn the House of God into a Den of Thieves But this Point I shall conclude with an excellent Letter sent to the Bishops by Dr. Humphrey President in Magdalen College in Oxford and Reader of Divinity Lecture there It is thus Your Lordship's Letters directed unto us by our Vice-chancelour although written in general Words yet hath so hearted our Adversaries that now we are no more accounted Brethren and Friends but Enemies And seeing the old Mass Attires be so straighly commanded the Mass it self is shortly look'd for a Sword is now put into the Enemies Hands of those that under Queen Mary have drawn it for Popery and under Pretence of good Order are ready without Cause to bewreck their Popish Anger upon us who in this will use Extremity in other Laws of more Importance Partiality I would my Lords have wished rather privy Admonition than open Expulsion yet I had rather receive Wounds of my Brother than Kisses of mine Enemy If we had privily in a convenient Day resigned then neither should the Punisher have been noted of Cruelty nor the Offender of Temerity neither should Papists in their seditious Book have accused Protestants of Contention Religion requireth naked Christ to be preached professed glorified that graviora legis the most weighty things by the most faihful Ministery of feeding Pastours should be furthered and after that Orders tending to Edification and not to Destruction advanced and finally the Spouse's Friends should by all means be cherished favoured and defended and not by Counterseit and false Intruders condemned over-born and defaced But alas A Man qualified with inward Gifts for lack of outward how is he punished And a Man only outwardly conformable inwardly quite unfurnish'd is let alone yea exalted the painful Preacher for his Labour is beaten the unpreaching Prelate offending in the greater is shot-free the learned Man without his Cap is afflicted the capped Man without Learning is not touched is not this directly to break God's Law Is not this the Pharisees Woe Is not this to wash the Outside of the Cup and leave the inward Part uncleansed Is not this to prefer Mint and Anise to Faith Judgment and Mercy Man's Tradition before the Ordinance of God Is not this in the School of Christ and in the Method of the Gospel a plain Disorder Hath not this preposterous Order a Woe That the Catechism should be read as the Word of God it is the Order of the Church to preach it a necessary Point of a Priest to make quarterly Sermons is Law to see poor Men of the poor Men's Box reliev'd Vagabonds punish'd Parishes communicate Rood Lofts pulled down Monuments of Superstition defaced Service done and heard is Scripture is Statute That the Oath to the Queen's Majesty should be offered and taken is required as well by Ordinance of God as of Man These are plain Matters necessary Christian and profitable to wear a Surplice a Coap or a cornered Cap is as you take it an accidental thing a Devise only of Man and as we say a Doubt or Question in Divinity seeing then all these substantial Points are in all Places of this Realm almost neglected the Offenders little or nothing rebuked and seeing the Transgressors have no Colour of Conscience it is Sin and Shame to proceed against us first having also reasonable Defence of our Doings Charity my Lords would first have taught us Equity would first have spared us Brotherliness would have warned us Pity would have pardoned us if we had been found Trespassers God is my Witness who is the Beholder of a I Faith I think of your Lordships honourably esteeming you as Brethren reverencing you as Lords and Masters Alas Why have you not some good Opinion of us Why do you trust known Adversaries and mistrust your Brethren We confess one Faith of Jesus we preach one Doctrine we acknowledge one Ruler upon Earth in all things saving in this we are of your Judgment shall we be used thus for a Surplice Shall Brethren persecute Brethren for a forked Cap devised singularly of him that is our Enemy Now shall we fight for the Popish Coat his Head and Body being banished Shall the Controversy so fall out in Conclusion that for lack of this necessity Furniture as it is affirmed Labourers shall lack Wages and Churches preaching shall we not teach shall we not exercise our Talents as God hath commanded us because we will not wear that which our Enemies have desired and that by the Appointment of Friends O that ever I saw this Day that our Adversaries should laugh to see Brethren fall together by the Ears O that Ephraim should thus eat up Manasseh and Manasseh Ephraim My Lords before this takes place consider the Cause of the Church the Triumphs of Antichrist the Laughter of Satan the Sorrow and Sighs of a Number the Misery and Sequel of the Tragedy I writ with Zeal without Proof of my Matter at this present time but not without Knowledge of it nor without Grief of Mind God move your Spirit at this present to fight against Carnem Circumcisionem imo Concisionem against Literam Legem which principally is now regarded and rewarded Speak I humbly beseech you to the Queen's Majesty to the Chancellour and to Mr. Secretary and the rest that these Proceedings may sleep that England may understand your zealous Mind towards the Worship of God your Love towards the poor Well-willers your Hatred towards the professed Enemies your Unity in true conformity the other neither be needful now neither exacted in any good Age so shall the little Flock be bound to you so shall the great Shepherd be good to you There appears in this Letter a Sence of Piety Modesty and Christian Resolution not to halt between two but to suffer rather than to sin according to our Saviour's Rule we cannot serve God and Mammon When one is convinced of a Truth he ought to adhere to it Yet one Dr Burgess who hath written for that Cause would make us believe our blessed Saviour was a Trimmer when in his Rejoynder he saith our Saviour walked a middle Path between the Excess of the Pharisees and the Preciseness of the Sadducees observing many significant Ceremonies in Religion The instituted Ceremonies under the Law he fulfilled but as to their Traditions the Evangelists declare how smartly he reproproved them for certainly such Expressions to speak of them as moderately as may be shew a great Want of Reverence for our blessed Saviour but thatStyle is no Stranger with some of them witness what Dr. Morton saith in his Defence In Hezekiah's Time saith he the Idolatry about the Serpent could not be cured but by abolishing the Serpent but in our most truly Reformed Church which doth most lively express the Face and full Body of her primitive Mother Church this Disease would be found curable without any such Extremity
all the Papists keep for her when alas I defie them all together to prove any of those Days to be the Day which they keep it for so then they are kept at a Venture What shall we say of the Names of Rogations Ember Week and so many more to be found in our Prayer-book which are the Quintessence of Popish Superstitious Holy Days What I say is not in Relation to the civil Part of those Names but as to the Spiritual as they are brought into the Church But they will say we keep not all such Dayes there is only a certain Number mentioned after the Kalender but I ask wherefore then do you set them down yet there are Mornings and Evenings first and second Lessons for the very Day which I make no doubt are read where Service is every Day In the same Kalender we find the fasts as well as Feasts and those Fasts are always upon the Eves of certain Holy Days which are many only I find St. Mark and St. Luke have none whilest All Saints have wherein a Partiality appeareth we have Good Friday Holy Thursday no better nor holier than another whole Lent c. But this matter of Feasts and Fasts I have spoken of before Upon the first of May is the Feast by Papists dedicated to Philip and James but we are so fond of the Latin Tongue that because Jacobus is the Latin for James in the Payer-book 't is called Jacob and not James I know no other Reason why it should be so only because it hath a greater Affinity to the Latin the Latin Church we still retain a Kindness for After the Kalender are certain Notes belonging to it whereof one is that the 13th Chapter of Daniel is to be read until such Words The Book of Daniel hath but 12. Chapters in all and must the History of Susanna against which as an Apocrypha are lawful Exceptions be fathered upon that holy Prophet and be inserted into his Book as a Chapter of it In the Morning and Evening Prayers when the general Confession is read by the Minister it were well for the People within themselves or with a very low Voice to follow him but so loud as usually it is is not pertinent but makes a Noise and Confusion for the same Reason the Answers that follow the Lord's Prayer which indeed have very little Relation if any at all with what goeth before or what followeth In Prayer the Minister is the Mouth of the People to God and the People with their Hearts are to joyn with the Minister in his Prayer as with Reverence and Attention they ought to hear when he is God's Mouth to them that is when he preacheth I might take notice of what is said there of singing the Lesson in plain Tune to sing the Collect Epistle and Gospel which are very improper things So of their Benedicite Magnificat Nunc dimittis which I suppose might admit of English Names of which I shall speak hereafter as for the Answers at the latter End they contain good Expressions but ill applied without a Connexion between themselves all after the Romish way which 't is to be wished we had not so much of as we have we could well enough be without it as without those Portions of Apocryphas when we are wanting something for Instruction Comfort and Edification which the Word of God may supply us with 'T is not enough to sing our Prayers but our Creed and Confession of Faith must also be sung as ordered in the Evening Prayer upon some certain great Days therein named We grant that 't is well to have those several things in Verses to use them however herein Men ought not to allow themselves oto much Liberty for the Word of God ought always to be handled with a great Respect and Reverence the Tone of our Voice ought to be adapted to the Matter and the Occasion according to that Rule of St. James Jam. 5.13 Is any among you afflicted Let him pray is any merry Let him sing Psalms Prayer and Singing are different Duties to be used upon several Occasions as are Affliction and Mirth Before I proceed farther one thing I must take notice of which to me seems unaccountable that is the using of the Word Priest in our Prayer-book In the two Places I quoted before Ephes 4.11 1 Cor. 12.28 whereunto we may joyn Rom 12 the Apostle mentioneth the several Offices belonging to the Church but there is no sign either of the Name or of the Office of a Priest under the Law there were some because Sacrifices were to be made but under the Gospel no Sacrifice but of Prayer and Praise we have the Eucharisty or Commemoration of our Lord and Saviour's Sacrifice upon the Cross but that 's good for Papists to have Priests who pretend daily to make an Expiatory Sacrifice for the Sins of the Living and of the Dead but we abhor such a thing at least pretend to do so We say we abolish the thing and yet retain the Name the Name of Minister is in Scripture known in this Sence 1 Cor. 44.1 Let a Man so account of us as of the Ministers of Christ and Stewards of the Mysteries of God The Names Bishop Pastor and Elder are known in Scripture but if they think the Word Minister below them which I charitably believe they do not because sometimes though seldom they use it then they may use the Word Elder or Presbyter which is the Greek for Elder 1 Pet. 5.1 Presbyter as St. Peter calls himself and Presbytery are Scripture Names signifying Office in the Church but there is a great Difference between 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a Presbyter and a Priest which is the proper Signification of the last as Heb. 5.6 so then the Word Priest is fetched afar off and there is no such Office in the Christian Church As to the Litany the same may be said by the People at the same time with the Minister but with a low Voice and not not after and separately they do it after the manner of the Kirie Eleison used by Papists here the People not the Minister make the Prayer for they and not he say Spare us good Lord Good Lord deliver us We beseech thee to hear us good Lord. When 't is said from Fornication and all other deadly Sin the Word deadly doth favour the Popish erroneous Distinction of Mortal and Venial Sins They hold but seven Mortal Sins whereof Fornication is one but they hold there are Sins of their Nature not mortal and which do not deserve Death which is contrary to the whole Course of Scripture Ezech. 18.20 Rom. 6.23 which saith expresly the Soul that sinneth it shall die and the Wages of Sin is Death This may easily be mended with changing the Word deadly into any of these gross horrid enormeous or such like which to deny is certainly to refuse Peace upon easie Terms to
pray against Lightning is as good as to pray against Rain Snow and the like by thine Agony too much like an Oath The Word gracious meaned of King or Queen is not proper in a Prayer to God who knoweth whom we mean without such Titles in Prayer the Attribute most gracious which is a superlative Degree is not well applied to Princes we can say no more to God and as good to call most holy King there ought to be a Difference in Titles given to God and those given to Princes specially in Church at the Worship of God In God's Sight they are but Men and the Lord is jealous of his Honour and Glory which he declared he will not communicate to any one Let Men keep flattering Titles when they speak to Princes though I think none but due ones were better but in Prayers to God let Names of Blasphemy be avoided which we all condemn in the Pope of Rome Farther it were well to forbear the often unnecessary Repetitions of the same thing which in this Litany and other Parts of the Book are frequent and those broken Parts of Scripture which have no relation one to another all might be made up into one Prayer and not be divided into so many Then in one of the Prayers 't is said Turn from us all those Evils that we most righteously have deserved We think the Word justly is more proper the other being ambiguous Justice and Righteousness do differ Now for the Collects there are many for several Sundays in Advent and so many after Epiphany and Trinity an odd Way of reckoning the Lord's Days by in that on St. Stephen's Day God is prayed to grant us to learn by the Example of St. Stephen The Name of the Lord Jesus is a strong Argument and sufficient to prevail with God if any can so that of any Man is not necessary but there is a Day appointed to be kept for that Martyr and upon it something of him must be said but we take a great deal of Pains more than the Believers in his Time who appointed no Day for him Who gave the Name of Innocents to the Children killed by Herod's Order They confessed not with speaking but with dying and because they were put to Death to satisfie Herod's Policy and State Jealousie it doth not follow they died either Confessors or Martyrs they did not lay down their Lives for the Testimony of the Lord Jesus for they were not able to know and discern Why to observe the Day of Christ's Circumcision and not of his Baptism No Man as I observed before can say for certain the Day of any such Feasts they keep why to keep Epiphany or Twelft Day so much turned to Excess in Popery and amongst us too None of these produceth Decency nor Edification I think amongst Christians in our publick Devotion book as the Liturgy is The Words Lord's Day or Sabbath were more proper than Sunday Rev. 1.10 having as we have a Warrant out of Scripture This is the Way of reckoning after Popery I pray God we be not called to an Account for too much following after them As to observing Days for the Apostles I know of no Warrant we have to believe God is pleased with it on the contrary nor of the Purification of the blessed Virgin which is but a Continuation of a Jewish Ceremony all which are or ought to be abolished under the Gospel As to the Collect wherein it is said thine only begotten Son was this Day presented in the Temple it containeth either a Lie which no Man can disapprove or at least an uncertain and doubtful thing there being no Certainty of the Day If by Michael the Archangel or Prince of Angels be meaned our Lord and Saviour for the Name Michael signifying who is like unto thee O strong God is appliable to him then he hath his Day called the Lord's Day if Michael be an Angel then he is a Creature so not to be joined with the Creator and no Days to be kept for Angels there being no Warrant for it in Scripture Honour the Angel would receive none Rev. 19.10 and Chap. 22 9. Psal 16.4 As for all Saints Days 't is a Shame a Day for all Popish Saints with David we should say I will not take up their Names into my Lips As for the Apostles whilst alive they never thought nor desired to have Days kept for them after their Death St. Paul the zealous Asserter of Mercy and sworn Enemy to any thing of Merit in Man would never have approved that a Day should be kept for his Conversion he sufficiently declares against observerving of Days Months and Times and Years which makes him say Gal. 4.10 11. 1 Cor. 1.12 and Chap. 3.5 2 Cor. 4.7 Rom. 9.21 I am afraid of you least I have bestowed upon you Labour in vain he would have said Who is Paul Who is Apollo Who is Cephas But Ministers or Servants Earthen Vessels And a Lump of Clay in the Potter's Hand whilest alive when Instruments in God's Hand but much less are they after their Death he would have said what are they that Days should be kept for them and for himself Which once was a Persecutor a Blasphemer and the chief of Sinners After this followeth the Order for the Administration of the Communion there in the Beginning of the Rubrick we read of the Curate and in other Places of Vicars and such inferior Limbs of Hierarchy whereof not the least Step in Scripture If Prayers be appointed to be read in the Chancel for Conveniency of Reader and Hearers it 's well but if upon any Opinion of Holiness or other Privilege of the Place then 't is ill for that Place is no better than any other in the Church but why the Minister should stand on the North Side of the Table except for Conveniency I see no Cause for the Temple of Jerusalem stood on the North Side of the City but now we ought not to stand upon such Points of the Compass The People saying after every Precept Lord have mercy upon us c. is superfluous specially with a loud Voice once after the last as we humbly conceive might be enough Matth. 6.7 Christ forbiddeth to use vain and unnecessary Repetitions for Men are not heard for their much speaking It may be observed that the two Prayers for the King are improper upon that Occasion it supposeth a Communion without a Sermon before instead of which an Homily to be read which is better than nothing but there ought to be a Preparatory Sermon except in Case of Accident or else the Ministers are encouraged to Laziness and Neglect and used to read rather than to preach After Sermon or Homily the Minister or Curate is to declare unto the People Popish Custom still whether there be any Holy-Days the Week following and if there be what To shut their Shops and give over working for the Day By a Moral Commandment of God the
hold a Communication with and in some kind own a Dependency upon the Church of Rome with using her Language nay we seem so fond of it that we use it also in Law a Bond and some other Deeds are in Latin which is a shameful Subjection as if they were our Masters whose Tongue we ought to speak When England was subject to the Roman Empire there was something to say for it but now nothing at all except we have a mind to go back to Rome all that can be pleaded for 't is an old Custom and an evil one too to be left off But much having by others been said upon the matter I shall no further enlarge upon it only as to the manner of using the Prayer-book This particular I shall add concerning the Word of God read sometimes standing and sometimes sitting But if to stand at the reading of God's Word be a more reverend Posture than to sit why do they sit when the Epistle is read and stand when the Gospel is Surely there is for this Difference not the least Shaddow in Scripture the Epistle is as much the Word of God as the Gospel but they not only make Epistle to differ from Gospel but also Gospel from Gospel for at the second Lesson they stand when some Part of a Chapter of the Gospel is read and yet they sit when a whole Chapter is read in the first Lesson what 's the meaning of all this One Part is read with more Reverence than the whole for when that very same Chapter out of which the Part is taken happeneth to be read at the first Lesson People doth sit and is a greater Respect to be shewed at the reading of the second Lesson than at the first To me this seems unaccountable But a thing there is which I must not omit taking notice of it being liable to a just Exception though not in the Common-prayer-book At the latter End of most of our old Bibles is a Form of Prayers for private Families in that for the Evening are these Expressions That all the World may know that at what time soever a Sinner doth repent of his Sins from the Bottom of his Heart thou wilt put all his Wickedness out of thy Remembrance as thou hast promised by thy holy Prophet But no Prophet saith so Ezech. 18.21 we know they ground it upon the Prophet who in God's Name declareth that a holy penitent Sinner shall live Three things are here to be observed first That turning and Repentance upon which Life is promised is not in the Power of Man but a special Gift of God The second That the turning therein mentioned is upon a legal Bottom for he saith If the wicked will turn from all his Sin that he hath committed and keep all my Statutes and do that which is lawful and right he shall surely live To keep all God's Statutes is impossible for Men however there is nothing but what the Law says do this and thou shalt live thus our Saviour doth interpet it Matth. 19.17 if thou wilt enter into Life keep the Commandments The third thing here to be observed and upon which I ground what I said is That in the Place there is no such thing as at what time soever nor nothing equivalent nor in any other Prophet for out of such a Text if there was the wicked would take Encouragement to continue in Sin to the last now Scripture presses Sinners not to delay Repentance we know some say they can repent when they will but God never said so in his Word thus though this be not in the Prayer-book yet I bring it under that Head Now after this to shew we are not singular in our Judgment concerning these Points we will back our Reasons with the Evidence of some few eminent Instruments of Reformation pious and learned Men both abroad and at home Calvin Epist and Protect Calvin is the first Forreigner in his Letter to the Lord Protector in good King Edward's time he saith thus I come to the other Head about abolishing and plucking up by the very Roots Abuses and Corruptions which the Devil in Ages passed hath brought into God's Ordinances it is evident that the Christianity or Religion of Popery is Bastardy and false wherefore if we resolve to bring the People out of that Gulf we must follow the Apostle's Example 1 Cor. 11. from whence it is generally taught that when Men would reform as they ought to do and acceptably to God they must then betake themselves to the pure Word of God for see how many Mixtures which Man's Brain hath hatched do remain so many Pollutions are there which distract Men from the right Use of those things which he hath appointed for their Salvation Wherefore while such a Sink as that is but in the Part pumpt out things cannot be said to be as they should be specially when Religion appeared rather masked than sincere and with open Face which I therefore note because I perceive many now a-days are of another Judgment as if petty Abuses were to be let alone as long as grosser matters be removed whereas contrariwise Experience it self shews what a fertile Soil and faithful Seed-plot of Lies Man's Invention is that being but thin sowen as it were with lesser Grains groweth to such an Heap as if his Measure did intend nothing else Now the Scripture is far different from this when David speaketh of Idols he professeth their Name should not go in or out at the Door of his Lips to shew extream Detestation let us remove our Foot as far as we can from the Snares of Satan for what were all those Ceremonies but so many whorish Enticements to let silly Souls into Mischief yea even Snares to catch Men in But if we talk that the People may be warned least they stumble yet notwitstanding who doth not behold Men hardned by them So little doth that Warning avail to any purpose Therefore if any such thing be left untouched it will be but the Foment and Fewel of greater Mischief and very blind set up to hinder sincere Doctrine from all Entrance as were fit In his second Epistle he exhorteth the same Protector to help Hooper who stood against those Foppish Ceremonies this is all we shall for the present make use of out of him though abundance more might be produced Beza is the next he often speaks much to our Purpose specially in the Place mentioned before now quoted in the Margent not to be repeated here in his Annotations upon these Words 1 Cor. 7.23 Ye are bought with a Price be not ye the Servants of Men He condemneth those that contrary to that Part of Scripture do press superstitious Rites upon the Consciences of Men and from Colos 2.20 he demonstrates how Man's corrupt Nature is too much inclined to loose Liberty and submit to Superstition which with Seneca we may well call insanus Error a mad Error which Superstitious Ceremonies
to kindle his Fury against us And though the Epistle deserves wholly to be transcribed yet not to be too tedious I shall shorten it He calls those Garments unknown to the Christian World in the Times of the Apostles and of the Apostolical Men Garments of Godless Priests and Slaves of Antichrist So assuredly by the arguing of things indifferent to trouble the Peace of Churches and to cause Strife between good Men and bad yea between good Men themselves is so wicked that it can by no means be defended If your gracious Majesty desireth as you would to seem Apostolical then in this matter imitate the Apostles Neither lay and impose this Yoke upon the Neck of Christ's Disciples your self nor suffer others to do it For all Men know that most part of all the Churches that are fallen from the Bishop of Rome for the Gospel's Sake not only have left off but also abhor those Garments 'T is in vain to hope in so doing to bring in Papists over to us who can never amend their Doctrines nor part with their abominable Superstitions and Idolatries then saith he this woundeth the Consciences of private Believers a tender Conscience that feareth God is a most precious thing and acceptable to him for if these things be imposed as necessary we do ungodlily because we make those things to be necessary which Christ would have to be free if indifferent they ought to be left free These are the same Arguments we use but here we leave off thinking we have done enough to shew the Sence of that Learned and Famous Divine upon so solemn an Occasion But this Letter nor other weighty Reasons could not prevail for any thing they were resolved upon another way the Queen was young when she came to the Throne and they that were about her and coming upon the Stage were willing to retain Part of that Pomp and as much as they could of that Power which popish Predecessors in their places had enjoyed Self denial and a perfect Zeal for the Glory of God did not wholly govern in the Spirits of some Men wherefore in that Convocation in 1571 when the Cranmers Hoopers Latimers c. were gone instead of following The Reformation began in King Edward's Days they made those Alterations which we all know But I need not to insist upon these Evidences of particular though eminent Men seeing we have for us that of whole Churches I mean that the Generality of Reformed Churches doth about the Matters now in Hand joyn and agree with us so that we are not fingular in our Opinion but well grounded therein For first we affirm that Christ hath instituted a Discipline according to which and no other his Church ought to be governed The French Reformed Churches say the Order which Christ hath by his Authority setled in his Church ought inviolably to be kept Confes Gallic Articl 25. and somewhat lower they add we believe the true Church must be governned according to the Rule and Order setled by the Lord. Art 29. And this is the Perswasion of the Church in the low Countries how the Church ought to be governed according to the Spiritual Policy which God hath taught in his Word Conf. Belgica Art 30. which containeth three things First There is a Government already settled secondly That Government is set down in Scripture thirdly The Church ought to be governed according to that exclusively to any other seeing a Divine Institution doth exclude Humane Inventions To this also agree the Churches of Switzerland for say they Discipline is administred according to the Order which the Lord hath given in his Word Helv. Conf. cap. 18. quemadmodum suo verbo praescripsit dominus Docemus Gubern c. And a little lower the Church-Government given us by the Apostles is sufficient to keep it in good Order And the Church of Scotland in her Confession of Faith published in the beginning of Reformation giveth for a Mark of the true Church the Administration of Church Discipline such as God hath prescribed in his Word Conf. Scot. Art 18. This overthroweth the prelatical Opinion that 't is left to the Prudence of the Governors of the Church to establish what Government they shall think fit Secondly We say all Ministers of Christ have the same Authority and by the Commission none is to have more Power than another and are not these the positive Words of a Confession of Faith we believe all true Pastors to have one and the same equal Power among them Gal. Conf. Art 30. Let this be taken notice of how 't is an Article not only of their Discipline but also of their Faith we believe the low-Dutch Churches speak to the same purpose Conf. Belg. Art 31. whatsoever Place God's Ministers are in they have the same Power and unequal Authority Helv. Conf. cap. 18. So do those of Switzerland all Ministers of Christ have received the same Power and Office Observe how as there is but one and the same Power so there is but one and the same Office whereby are condemned Primacy and the Episcopal Distinction which they explain elsewhere Apostolis suuis principatum Christus Severis sine prohibuit c. Christ hath most strictly forbidden his Apostles Primacy in the Church who then can but perceive that those who oppose this plain Truth and do bring in a different Government and as it may be taken Diversity of Government into the Church ought to be taken for those of whom Christ's Apostles have foretold 2 Pet. 2. and Paul Acts 20.29 2 Cor. 11. 2 Thess 2. and in several other Places It is also the third and chief Advice of that religious Prince Conf. Palat. at the latter end the Palsgrave in his Confession of Faith to his Children and Successors to take heed of those who acted by meer Ambition as 't is practised in Popery dostrive for a Command over the Consciences of Magistrates and Subjects and to erect for themselves some new Primacy of a large Extent And to shew that Union Equality and Affection which ought to be between Ministers The antient Church of the Waldenses saith Discip of the Vaud Chap. 2. about the middle speaking of Pastors He that is ordained last ought to do nothing without the Leave of him that was ordained first and he that was first must do nothing without the Leave of him that was chosen last Now all this doth ruine the superiority settled by Bishops We say in the third place that no Humane Invention ought to be introduced into God's Worship and that Men must not impose upon Consciences the Yoke of Ceremonies and the Reformed Conf. Gal. Art 24. reject Ceremonies partly because they are Humane Inventions and a Yoke which Humane Authority imposeth upon Consciences Indeed Divine Worship ought to be practised according to the Purity and Simplicity of the Gospel which Mind the Vaudois are of Compend Conf. Art 1. Divine Worship
it appears enough whom he means in such Disputes as this Reasons and not Injuries should be made use of 't is a bad Cause that uses such means to defend it self We own there are Fanaticks in the World but Men must not be so peremptory as magisterially to Father it upon those who are no such Men they are Fanaticks as before observed who are wholly guided by Fancy under the Notion of Inspirations and Lights of the Spirit different from and contrary to the revealed Will of God who feed upon meer Appearance and bare Imaginations but that Name doth not belong to those who make the Word of God the Rule of their Faith and of Divine Worship to retort we say it belongs to those which make their own Inventions the Rule thereof There is another thing which indeed upon this Occasion I cannot avoid taking notice of how that Author flies out against the Writer of the Book called Patronus bonae fidei in few places specially Pag. 231. where he uncharitably and unjustly charges him with Rage and Madness and not to be endured in a christian Common-wealth c. Who art thou that judgest another Man's Servant I confess I am concerned to see that worthy Person so unworthily abused if alive he now could have defended himself thereby I judge the Author knew him not if he did may be only by Relation and not so well as I. He had I confess some Notions and few Opinions which as I sometimes as a Friend said to him I did not approve of nor could joyn with him in but they did not concern the Fundamentals of Faith or Christian Religion only Church-government outward Worship and Ceremonies in some of which he was in the right as to all Essentials very sound as far as I could find by him but as to Practice Life and Conversation in my Opinion one of the best and uprightest Men that ever I knew As to what is said that his Friends that is a Brother assisted him I must say he did nothing for him but what before he had received from him yet that which he gave being mixed with chidings brought him no great comfort Once he shewed me a Letter from that same Brother wherein he would have sastned upon him those very Words of Peter to Simon Thou art in the Gall of Bitterness Act 8.23 and in the Bond of Iniquity because he went a different Way from his and I am sure those Supplies for a while were stopped but whether for altogether I cannot tell for certain Thus far I think my self bound to vindicate his Memory His Words that make that Author so angry with him as to say like a mad Man he leaves him to his Keeper namely that Egyptians pretended some Ground for their Idolatry as that an Ape a Cat or a Wolf c. had some Participation of the Divinity but those that bow down to a Wooden Table are themselves Stocks These Words I say deserve not so hard a censure as is passed upon their Author Here I intended to have made an end but before I do I am bound to take notice of a thing now come to my Mind too common abroad a Token of the Ignorance and uncharitableness of some of our Adversaries and a clear Demonstration of their Love for and Inclination to Popery take it as it followeth Amongst those that are so possest with a Spirit of Violence and Persecution are some so depraved in their Judgment or so perverse in their Hearts or both that to express their perfect Hatred against those who in some things dissent from them they openly say they had rather to be Catholicks for that 's the Name which out of respect they give Papists than Fanaticks Schismaticks as they are pleased to call them and Presbyterians That which is bred in the Bone never goes out of the Flesh there is in their Hearts still something of the Nature and Seed of that elder Sister the Roman Church that savoureth the Ambition Tyranny and the desire of the Exercise of an absolute Authority over the Souls and Consciences of Men which all that oppose must be Fanaticks but they should know that Names signifie things and ought not to be given but to those whom the things by the Names signified do belong unto otherwise they be misapplied we are guided neither by our own Fancy or that of others nor are Entheusiasts led by Dreams Visions and meer Appearances I leave every impartial Man that hath but common Sence and Reason to judge whether such a Name be proper for those who make the Word of God the only Judge of the controverted Questions and will be by their Reason directed no longer than it is ruled by holy Scripture the Judge of all Controversies in Matters of Religion The Malice of such doth not stop here against us in these present or late Times but they go back and would fasten upon the Persons tread under Feet the Ashes and unworthily defame the Memory of the first and eminent Instruments of Reformation with all the ill Names and Words their Malice can invent making them as St. Paul speaks of himself pass thorough evil Report as better Men than they do thorough good a thing as unhansome as can be let them speak to the living and some will be able to answer for themselves when none of the dead can These Men like those whom the Prophet speaks of encourage themselves in an evil Matter They commune of laying Snares Psal 64.5 Then they had rather to be Papists than Presbyterians or Independents they need not to say so or express themselves in those Terms but 't were more proper for them to say they are Papists more than Presbyterians and then they will speak the Truth and to the purpose for such amongst us are Papists under the Cloke of Protestants Spies and Emissaries of the Church of Rome to work Divisions Animosities and all possible Mischief to promote the Interest of that Antichrist who would not refuse to take a fat Abbey if they were restored among us though they were to say Mass for it much less Palliums Patriarchs Cardinals Caps and the rest of the proud Titles and Dignities of that Antichristian Hierarchy All these according to such Men's Principles could easily and with Pleasure be swallowed up by them and these are such grievous Wolves entered in amongst us which St. Paul speaks of and our blessed Lord had foretold before And to shew we can never enough abhor such Notions as these for a Protestant to say I had rather to be a Papist than a Presbyterian he who talks at such a rate must either be a Papist indeed or ought to be looked upon as such Every Papist must own and believe the Fundamental Points of their Religion which by them are thought necessary to Salvation and which daily they are brought to believe and to practise and none but Papists will believe those Fundamental Errors wherein all Protestant and Reformed Churches do differ
from them on the other side to say so argues a very great Ignorance of what Popery and Presbitery are as indeed it is common amongst some of our ordinary Sort of People which like Parrets in a Cage have learned the Name they often heard repeated unto them by some of the Church's passionate Teachers who will as confidently affirm Arminianism to be the Doctrine of the Church though never so false and who sometimes have been heard to complain how the first Reformers went too far they might have spared several things and not have been so rigid to have preserved Union with the Romish Church and not made an absolute renting from it doth not a sensible Man believe that Men of such Principles will be ready when it doth not cross their Worldly Interest to meet half way with the Church of Rome but such no Reason can cure the very Springs of their Souls are corrupt the Disease is past Recovery without the immediate working of God's Spirit wherefore I shall not trouble my self with speaking to those that are such But to the unlearned that are imposed upon and that sin out of Ignorance I shall give Reasons to inform and Satisfie their Judgments no Man may with himself to be of a Church except he already be a Member of it that believeth such Fundamental Errors which a Man dying in cannot be saved and doth practise Idolatry if Scripture saith Truth Here I desire not to be mistaken as if I should say how none that is a Papist can be saved for God's Mercy is great and free and when he pleases he can reveal his Truth to some that now lie in the Ignorance and Blindness of the Errors in Judgment and Practice of that Church so the good God may do to any Jew Mahometan or of any other wrong Perswasion whatsoever as in Practice to the repenting Thief but I say that a Papist dying in the Belief of those effential Errors God not imparting the Light of the Truth unto his Mind and the Love of it into his Heart such an one if God's Word speaks Truth shall not be saved Why so Because the Church of Rome hath instituted several Ways of Salvation when Scripture speaketh but of one surely all but that must be wrong and false so Christian Religion owns but one only Saviour namely the Lord Jesus Christ Acts. 4.12 Neither is there Savation in any other For there is none other Name under Heaven given amongst Men whereby we must be saved and as there is a Saviour and but one Saviour so there is a Mediator and but one Mediator there is one God and one Mediator mark as there is but one God so there is but one Mediator for in the Original the Word to express one God is the same to signifie one Mediator the Man Jesus Christ Now any one though but little versed with the Doctrines of the Popish Religion knows that they have other Mediators to trust to to intercede for them whom they worship and pray to as all their Saints specially the blessed Virgin and these in a high Degree as her Litany doth fully evidence they attribute her a Power of commanding her Son the Lord Jesus Now as to their other Ways of Salvation they are many and by Vertue whereof they pretend to be justified before God as are good Works Indulgencies of Popes See seasonable Discourse about Religion in 1689. Treasures of the Church Merits of Saints for the Favour of one Saint or other whose Protection they put themselves under they do much trust to and depend upon 'T is true they do not exclude the Merits of Christ but they come in only in part and as Sharers to what purpose this Heb. 7.25 Seeing Christ is able to save them to the utter most that come unto God by him seeing he ever liveth to make Intercession for them he alone hath satisfied God's Justice and pacified his Wrath I have trodden the Winepress alone Isa 63.3 and of the People there was none with me saith he by the Mouth of his prophet neither Archangel or Angel or any Creature in Heaven or in Earth being joyned with him in that Work and can we think that after he alone hath endured the Torments of making Atonement for our Sins he would leave with the Creatures the Honour to have it applied throrough their Intercession Heb. 12.2 Now he is the Author and Finisher of our Faith take notice of both Author and Finisher of our Salvation and of all things belonging thereunto which is more clearly explained in that other Place he became the Author of eternal Salvation unto all them that obey him and he is also called the Captain of our Salvation Chap 2.10 Again I say they which for Salvation depend upon any other Sacrifice than that which Christ made of himself upon the Cross may not upon any good Grounds hope for Salvation because no Promise for it in the Word Scripture makes mention of none other but of that only We shall be content with quoting some few Places all out of one Book of Scripture where the Point of the Lord Christ's Priesthood is of a set purpose and fully treated of and therein the pretended and abominable Sacrifice of the Mass is condemned which Point alone if there was none other is a sufficient Cause for true Christians to break off Communion with that Church Heb. 9.25 26 28. 't is in the Epistle to the Hebrews Nor yet that he should offer himself often speaking of the Lord Jesus for then must he often have suffered since the Foundation of the World Hence we see how Christ was not often to offer himself The Reason is because he was not often to suffer wherefore they that would have him often offered would have him also often to suffer for whether he offereth himself or be offered by a Priest still a Sufferer he must be Now to shew how often this was to be 't is expressed and fixed v. 28. so Christ was once offered to bear the Sins of many once and no more and that 's passed too Christ was once offered and it must be of a high Concernment for us to know it ought to have been but once for Chap. 10. 't is repeated twice in v. 10. We are sanctified thorough the Offering of the Body of Jesus Christ once for all and v. 12. But this Man Jesus after he had offered one Sacrifice for Sins for ever but one Sacrifice and that for ever that is never to be reiterated any more and v. 14. the Reason is given why there ought to be no more because there is no Necessity for it for by one offering he hath perfected for ever them that are sanctified But why should I trouble my self any longer to insist upon these essential and abominable Tenets and Practices of the Church of Rome which is full of Errors in Doctrine and of Idolatry and Superstition in Worship I hope no true Son of the Church can have the Face to deny the Church of Rome to be guilty of Idolatry for they yield a religious Worship to the Creature as to the Pope whom after his Election Cardinals do place upon the Altar and there adore him for that 's the Word to signifie the Homage which at that time they give him then to the Virgin to Saints to Images and to their Wafer-God whereof they have Millions amongst them Now I say no more only neither Presbyterians nor Independents believe or do so that is that there is any other Mediator than the Lord Jesus that there are other Ways of Salvation than by the only Sacrifice he once made of himself upon the Cross neither do they practise any Idolatry as the Church of Rome doth and we know for certain that no Idolaters shall inherit the Kingdom of God I hope these few things of many more I might have said will satisfie any impartial Reader not blinded with Prejudice or with a violent Passion As for those that had rather to be Papists than Presbyterians let them now with their Mass in their Mouth their other Saviour and Saints upon their Backs with their Superstition and Idolatry about their Girdle go home with Shame and hide themselves or rather amongst the Church of Rome where they would be in their proper Place and not amongst us for we can spare them well enough FINIS