THE Way of the Churches OF CHRIST IN NEW-ENGLAND OR THE VVAY OF CHURCHES walking in Brotherly equalitie or co-ordination without Subjection of one Church to another Measured and examined by the Golden Reed of the Sanctuary Containing a full Declaration of the Church-way in all Particulars By Mr. J. COTTON Teacher of the Church at Boston in New-England 1 THES 5.22 23. Prove all things hold fast that which is good Abstaine from all appearance of evill Published according to Order LONDON Printed by Matthew Simmons in Aldersgate-streete 1645. not in our apprehension be said to hold no analogie Yet with much sweat and wiles some messengers have got through that Court of Guard to anticipate or satisfie if it might be those clamourers for a larger Narration 1. The 32. Questions or Church-government and Church-Covenant done by some Elders of N. E. they have had with seconds of frequent intimations that wee hold with the Churches of New England 2. The Apologeticall Narration they have had with our generall approbation of it 3. Mr Cotton of the Keys of the Kingdome of heaven they have had with our Brethrens Epistle to it how farre they approve it 4. The Reasons of the dissenting Brethren are in Print 5. Wee have been enformed that those our Brethren formerly have tendered themselves that in case they might be put into a Committee or like meet posture for such a work they would bring in the whole frame of their judgements in a body with their grounds and reasons 6. That now very lately they gave in seven Propositions to be discussed with promise of more But neither of them was debated Which wee alledge rather to vindicate our particular charge then to blame men whose reasons wee know not 7. With much adoe wee have presented you with a fuller declaration of all our way according to the Scriptures in this learned yet modest Treatise of THE WAY OF THE CHURCHES OF CHRIST IN NEVV-ENGLAND c. Written and sent over by Mr. Cotton And wee doe in this Epistle certifie our assent thereunto saving that wee doe not yet fully close with some expressions passim in the Book before some of which wee minded it to note a * in the Margin This we could not but say and doe pace tanti authoris or wee could not assert the Booke If all things in this Treatise as now printed doe not answer punctually word for word to the first written Copie let the reverend Authour and the candid Reader pardon us because wee had not the fairest Copie nor knew wee till the Book was neer done that there was a better to be had nor to this day yet ever saw it Therefore wee were forced to shift with this so as to keep the mind of the Authour make it constare sibi and by an interpretative leave in his absence not onely to doe as wee would be done by but also as he himselfe would have done wee are confident if he had been in our case or present here Least any should imagine that every thing in the Keyes doth not fit all the wards in this Treatise to an haire wee will here insert Mr. Cottons own words in his Letter coming from him in New-England to our hands in the very nick of time whiles this Epistle lay under the Presse viz. If you think the Draught of ChuRCH-DISCIPLINE which was sent over in your Ship varieth from that of the POVVER OF THE KEKES sent over the yeare after you may have some occasion so to conceive from some difference of expression in LOGICALL TERMES but not a jote in any DOCTRINE OF DIVINITIE or CHURCH-PRACTISE So Mr. Cotton in his Letter to Mr. R. M. Diverse Objections formerly laid against the Printing of this Book to the sadding of the Authour Some whereof are now answered by the late season of printing it Others by the necessitie of them that conscientiously and candidly cry out for information Others by the fore-printing of the Keyes to open the full minde and whole sphere of the Authours judgement in this Others by that putting forth in print of an answer to this Book before this was mid-wised by the Presse into the world All reason therefore now it can speake that it should answer for it selfe Wee hope wee have satisfied the minde of the Authour as well as our owne and of others too of the other judgement especially of those that call for fuller Declarations The Lord root out of all our hearts the spirit of contradiction that wee call not for Books with a resolution rather to confute them as wee imagine then to throw downe our selves humbly under the power of truth Wee are now fighting Modo militari for reformation let us not therefore fight against it more ecclesiastico With how much gravitie soliditie and modestie have Mr. Cotton the Apologists the Authours of 32. Questions or Church Covenant and other milde and judicious Authours written in our cause But with what a different spirit have the adverse part replyed as if personall invectives and imbittring a stile were Gods way of bettering a cause or battering an opinion Here is a Booke so grave and solid that it cannot be justly despised by ingenuous learned men So full of necessary cases and truths that it cannot but be desired of those that would be knowing men And so milde and gentle that it cannot but be causlesly quarrelled if quarrelled by Cholerick men Had wee not been perswaded that it would prove a welcome Tract on all hands for the reasons afore-intimated wee could with our injoyment of the written Copie well have saved this great travell If it fall out otherwise as it hath with diverse of the like nature Golden Lavers or Vessels made Common-shores and receptacles to be filled with all filthy contempt wee shall then clearly and fully decerne mens spirits and descry their intents in challenging us for larger Narrations and shall beware for time to come how wee anger them with kindnesses But if this be candidly entertained of them then have they encouraged us in due time to impart if God permit a fuller Treatise of the same subject with amplior demonstrations by joynt consent of the Churches of Old and New-England and meane while they have abundantly recompenced the labour of love of theirs in the Lord. N.H. I.H. THE Way of the Churches of Christ in NEW-ENGLAND Measured by the Golden Reed of the SANCTUARY CHAPTER I. The Order of gathering dispersed Christians into a Church PROPOSITION I. SECTION I. THat the Church which Christ in his Gospell hath instituted and to which he hath committed the keys of his kingdom the power of binding and loosing the tables and seales of the Covenant the Officers and censures of his Church the administration of all his publick Worship and Ordinances is Coetus fidelium a Communion of Saints a Combination of faithfull godly men meeting for that end by common and joynt consent into one Congregation which is commonly called a particular visible Church For the
Church to the which Christ committed the power of binding and loosing was a company of such as whereof Peter was one Beleevers professing that faith on Christ whereon as on a rock the Church is built Mat. 16.18 19. and such as unto whom Peter or any brother offended might in due order tell the offence which any brother had given him persisted in Mat. 18.17 And the Church of Corinth to which the Apostle commendeth the casting out of the Incestuous Corinthian 1 Cor. 5. was such a Church of which the Apostle saith They were Saints by calling sanctified by Jesus Christ 1 Cor. 1.2 and all of them even the whole Church did meet together every Lords day in one place for the Administration of the holy Ordinances of God to publick Edification 1 Cor. 14.23 16.1.2 Which frequent meeting every Lords day in one place to such ends cannot possibly be compatible to any Diocesan Provinciall or Nationall Assembly PROPOS 2. It is the part of all Christians who look for salvation by Christ Jesus to joyn themselves if God give them opportunitie to some one or other such a particular visible Church of Christ for of such a Church as continued in such Church-fellowship Act. 2.42 it is written The Lord added to the Church daily such as should be saved Act. 2.47 And seeing there is no holy Ordinance of Christ but every Christian standeth in need thereof for his spirituall edification in holy fellowship with Christ Jesus or else Christ ordained them in vaine and seeing withall Christ hath committed all his publick holy Ordinances to his Church it will be needfull for every good Christian to whom God giveth opportunitie to joyne himselfe to some one or other Church of Christ that so he may not deprive himselfe of the benefit and comfort of any of Gods holy Ordinances PROPOS 3. For the joyning of faithfull Christians into the fellowship and estate of a Church we finde not in Scripture that God hath done it any other way then by entering all of them together as one man into an holy Covenant with himselfe To take the Lord as the head of his Church for their God and to give up themselves to him to be his Church and people which implyeth their submitting of themselves to him and one to another in his feare and their walking in professed subjection to all his holy Ordinances their cleaving one to another as fellow-members of the same body in brotherly love and holy watchfulnesse unto mutuall edification in Christ Jesus For thus the Lord accepted and entered Abrahams family into Church estate by receiving them and their children into such a Covenant with himselfe though In generall termes yet such as imply the substance both of Christians and Church duties Gen. 17.7 And after that when the posteritie of Abraham had violated this Covenant in Aegypt the Lord againe made another Covenant with them whereby he took them to be a peculiar people unto himselfe in the Wildernesse and Mount of Sinai Exod. 19.1.5 Whence they were called the Church in the Wildernesse Act. 7.38 And by reason of this Covenant God calleth the whole body of that people as his owne Spouse I entered saith he speaking of that time into a Covenant with thee and thou becamest mine Ezek. 16.8 Moreover the next generation after them he established them to be his Church and people by entring them againe into a Covenant according to the Covenant made with Abraham Isaac and Jacob Deut. 29.10 to 13. By vertue of which Covenant as well as by the former they were joyned not onely to the Lord and to the Officers the Priests and Levites which he had given them Deut. 12.19 but also to mutuall watchfulnesse over one another Levit. 19.17 Deut. 29.18 In so much that through their neglect thereof the sinne of one Achan was the sinne of all Israel Josh 7.11 Which kinde of Covenanting with God we finde diversly translated in Scripture and every way sufficient for the constituting of a godly society or company to become a Church unto God Sometimes God or his Messengers in his stead propoundeth and giveth a Covenant unto a people and they accept it though not in expresse words yet by silent consent Gen. 17.7 Deut. 29.10 to the end of Chap. 30. Sometimes the people declare their consent and restipulation by expresse words Exod. 19.8 Deut. 5.27 and Josh 24.16 17 18.21 22 24 25. Sometimes they writing and sealing Neh. 9.38 In all which Covenants sometimes they make no expresse termes of cleaving to their brethren but onely in generall termes submitting themselves to every Ordinance and Covenant of God as in the places alledged sometimes they expresly declare their stedfast cleaving to their Brethren also and to their Officers Neh. 10.28 29. ver 35. to the end the rest of the people every one might have knowledge they cleave to their Brethren and entred into an Oath c. In some we account it all one and of like value when a Covenant of God is propounded and given on Gods part to a people whether they receive it by silent consent or by expresse termes either by word of mouth or by writing and seale and whether their cleaving to their Brethren and Officers and mutuall watchfulnesse over one another be expresly mentioned or included onely in their generall profession of subjection to all Gods holy Ordinances and Covenant For we see it evident by comparing the former Scriptures that by any one of these wayes a people is received and established to be a peculiar people and Church unto the Lord and each of them lay hold of the same spirituall priviledges and hold forth the same holy duties Neither is there any colour to conceive this way of entring into Church estate by Covenant to be peculiar to the Paedagogy of the old Testament for it is evident by the light of nature that all civill Relations are founded in Covenant For to passe by naturall Relations between Parents and Children and violent Relations between Conquerours and Captives there is no other way given whereby a people sui Juris free from naturall and compulsory engagements can be united or combined together into one visible body to stand by mutuall Relation fellow-members of the same body but onely by mutuall Covenant as appeareth between husband and wife in the family Magistrates and subjects in the Common-wealth fellow Citizens in the same Citie and therefore in the New Testament when a people whom the Apostles by their ministery had converted were to be gathered by them into a Church estate what did the Apostles else but combine them into one body as one chaste Virgin and Spouse unto Christ 2 Cor. 11.2 And how could that not universall but particular Church of Corinth be offered up in one body not as many Spouses as all the particular members of that Church were by their conversion but as one Spouse unto-Christ but onely by joyning all together in one Covenant or Espousage to
difference of those actions doe not argue a diversitie of functions but both teaching and exhorting are co-incident to one and the same Office as being severall actions of severall gifts not of severall Officers Answ The contrary is evident from the Text as may appeare by three severall reasons from the words of the Text. Reas 1. From the words which the Apostle useth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which doe not distribute severall gifts onely but severall persons to whom those severall gifts are severally committed according as the same Apostle distributeth the same divers sorts of gifts to the same divers sorts of persons 1 Cor. 12.8 To one saith he is given a word of wisdome to wit for direction of practice whereto the Pastor attendeth to another the word of knowledge to wit for direction of the judgement whereto the teacher attendeth and both by the same Spirit who distributeth to every man severally ver 11. Reas 2. Though Office be one thing and gift to discharge an office another and the actions or exercise of every severall gift doth not alwayes argue a severall office yet in this place it is the scope of the Apostle to expresse the different offices or functions of Pastors and Teachers by their different and proper acts for here he speaketh of the divers members of the Church as of divers members of the naturall body who having divers offices or functions in the body are to performe different proper actions according to their different functions as wee having many members saith he in one body ver 4 5. and all the members have not one office as the translator turneth it when the Originall saith have not one action or practise but both expressing the same meaning so wee being many are one body in Christ and every one members one of another having then saith he ver 6. different gifts gifts comprehending both offices and grace whether Prophecy let us prophecy according to the proportion of faith or ministery let us waite on our ministery whether he that teacheth on teaching or he that exhorteth on exhortation And looke then as in the naturall body it being the action of the tongue to speake it is his function and office to speak and not to see and it being the action of the eye to see it is his function to see and not to heare So it is in the members of the body of Christ it being the action of the teacher to teach he is to attend unto teaching not unto exhortation and it being the action of the Pastor or Exhortor to exhort he is to attend on exhortation not on teaching Reas 3. If the Apostle speake here onely of severall actions or exercises of severall gifts but both co-incident to the same person and officer in the Church why then doth he command the Teacher to waite on teaching and the Exhorter to waite on exhortation for he that performeth an action according to this gift which is not peculiar to his office but common to him with men of other offices is never commanded nor is it his dutie to attend or waite on such an action As if a man have a gift of love or mercy or liberalitie and according to that gift be fit to performe an action of giving Almes yet he is not commanded to attend or waite upon Almesgiving unlesse it be his office as well as his gift Object Attending or waiting is not expressed in the Originall but in the translation onely Answ Though it be not expressed in the Originall it is necessarily intended for either such a word as expresseth waiting or at least the verbe substantive 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 must needs be understood which holdeth forth the same sense He that teacheth let him be teaching he that exhorteth let him be in exhortation which is all one as let him attend to it let him make it his proper and constant worke So a like example in 1 Tim. 4.15 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which is the same phrase and which is fitly translated Give thy selfe wholly to them the same with 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ver 16. Continue or dwell in them And indeed experience sheweth that teaching and exhorting are so far different one from another and flow from such different gifts that they are seldome found at least in any eminency both of them in one and the same person and therefore require severall officers for the dispensing of them you have many men of eminent dexterity for cleare opening of a Text for judicious gathering and handling sound Doctrine from it and also acute and strong for conviction of a contrary error and heresie who yet are very cold in exhortation and on the other side you have some very fervent in exhortation who are very confused and generall and common in teaching But besides this the need of the Church and the weight of both the works of teaching and exhorting calleth for severall officers to attend to both the explication of Scripture and of the Principles and Doctrine of Religion solidly and distinctly with the discussion of controversies which are included in 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Doctrine and Reproof 2 Tim. 3.16 well attended too will take up the whole time and talents of a most judicious Divine and on the other side the direction and instruction of the people in matters of practice the reformation of their manners both in their private carriage and in their families as also in the Church and Commonwealth and the stirring up of men thereto with the reproof of all disorders and abuses in life and conversation which are included in 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 instruction and correction 2 Tim. 3.16 these well attended to will take up the vigour and strength of the most prudent and vigilant Pastor of any Congregation All which things considered we have thought it needfull to make use of the bounty of the Lord Jesus to finish our Churches as wee blesse his Name most of them be with both these sorts of preaching Elders Pastors and Teachers neverthelesse hee that is gifted for both these in any good measure let him use both yet attend principally on that to which he is most eminently gifted and called SECT II. AS for ruling Elders the same Text of Scirpture Rom. 12.8 speaketh as expresly for their distinct office also for there speaking of the severall members of the body of Christ which is his Church he directing them to attend to their proper work as the Teacher to teaching the Pastor to exhortation the Deacon to give with simplicity he directeth also the Ruler to rule with diligence and who is that Ruler in the Church but the ruling Elder of whom the Apostle saith to Timothy The Elders that rule well are worthy of double honour 1 Tim. 5.17 But as the wisdome of man is enmity to God so the wisdome and wit of man hath found out many inventions and exceptions against every Scripture that holdeth forth this Ordinance Object 1. The Elders the Apostle here
speaketh of may be rulers in the family as Parents are rulers to children husbands to wives Masters to servants Answ The Church and family are two distinct bodies the Apostle speaketh here not of the members of the families as such nor of the functions and duties of family-members but of the family of the Church and of their functions and duties one towards another His words are plain vers 4 5. As we saith he have many members in one body and all the members have not the same office so we being many are one body in Christ and every one members one of another One body in Christ is not one family in Scripture phrase but one Church and of this body of the Church the members they be whom Paul directeth to the due dispensing of their severall functions and gifts namely the publique officers of the Church Teachers Pastors Deacons and Elders to attend upon their proper work teaching exhorting giving ruling vers 6 7 8. and all the rest of the members to walk in such duties of love and purenesse brotherly kindnesse and modesty diligence and fervency c. as are requisite for every Christian vers 9. to the end of the Chapter Object 2. But Paul speaketh not of lay Elders ruling in the Church but of Rulers Answ Neither do we acknowledge ruling Elders in the Church to be lay Elders properly for to say nothing of the distinction between the Clergie and Laity which is of a later edition then Apostolique times the ruling Elders being ordained to the Office by the election of the people and imposition of hands as well as the preaching Elders they are no more lay men or private Christians then the Teachers or Pastors are lay Ministers and though the Pastor Teacher be either of them Church-rulers yet the Ruler is here distinguished from them as a distinct member attending to his action of rule as his proper function Object 3. Paul speaketh of severall gifts not of publike offices in the Churches for he speaketh of the severall powers and action of all the members of the body of Christ now the officers of the Church they alone are not the body of Christ but all the multitude of believers which of all these gifts in those times was not common as well to the people as to the Ministers and to women as well as to men Answ 1. Paul speaketh as well of publike officers as of particular gifts as hath been shewed by three reasons above out of the words of the Text. It is true indeed hee speaketh of particular gifts also not peculiar to any office but common to all believers from verse 9. to the end but gifts are not the members of the body of Christ but the persons indued with those spirituall gifts neither can it be said that all the members of the Church have all these gifts without manifest contradiction to the words of the Text for then all the members had the same power to do all of them the same actions which the Apostle expresly denieth vers 4. all the members saith he have not the same action which is translated office whence it is that when hee speaketh of different offices he divideth them by particles of partition 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 vers 7 8. and he injoyneth each office to attend his own function but when he cometh to speak of the private members and of the gifts common to them all he neither maketh any partition of them into severall sorts nor bindeth them to attendance on the imployment or exercise of any speciall gift as he doth the former But that as every truth so every ordinance of God may be confirmed by two or three witnesses there be other Texts of Scriptures which bear witnesse to For ruling Elders In 1 Cor. 12.28 the Apostle telleth the Corinthians that God hath set in his Church severall members as first Apostles secondly Prophets thirdly Teachers after that miracles then gifts of healing helps governments diversities of tongues Where government is expresly reckoned amongst these offices which God hath set in his Church for the government thereof long before it injoyed civill Magistracy and therefore he meaneth spirituall government or Church rulers Object 1. But these governments are spirituall gifts not spirituall offices or administrations Answ That they were gifts we willingly acknowledge because all the offices and officers of the Church were given to the Church as well as the spirituall gifts and graces whereby they do execute those offices for so saith the Apostle When Christ ascended up on high hee gave gifts to men What gifts some to be Apostles some Prophets some Euangelists some Pastors and Teachers Eph. 4.8.11 but yet governments and all the rest there mentioned are spirituall offices as well as spirituall gifts as will appeare from the context for the Apostle in this Chapter putteth a manifest difference between spirituall 1. Gifts and Graces 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 making the holy Ghost the giver of them vers 6. 2. Administrations or Ministers or Officers 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 making the Lord Jesus the giver and institutor of them vers 5. as he doth also Ephes 4.8.11 3. Operations efficacies or successees of their administrations making the Father the foundation of all power the giver of them vers 6. Now having spoken of the end for which spirituall gifts are given vers 7. hee reckoneth up nine of those severall spirituall gifts vers 8 9 10. hee declareth them to be given to severall members of the Church not all to any one that so every member might stand in need of the help and gifts one of another and thus having discoursed of the variety of spirituall gifts and their use he cometh in vers 28. to 31. to declare the variety of spirituall administrations that is Ministeries or offices which God hath set in his Church and reckoneth up eight First Apostles secondarily Prophets under whom your Euangelists are comprehended as being of equall rank with them thirdly Teachers under whom he includeth Pastors also the office of both whom was to teach or practise in the Church after that miracles or as the word in the originall is powers to wit to cast out Devils or to do the like works then gifts of healing helps opitulations that is Deacons governments who else can they be but governing Elders for we heare of teaching Elders before lastly the gifts of tongues true it is indeed the Apostle reckoned up three of these before for spirituall gifts 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 vers 9 10. Miracles or powers gifts of healing kinds of tongues but here he reckoneth them not as spirituall gifts and graces for that were a tautology and unsutable to the method of his discourse but speaketh of them as severall functions or offices wherein these gifts were exercised Object 2. But if these Governments were Officers or functions they were extraordinary and so are now ceased as gifts of tongues and healing and miracles be Answ Not so for no offices are
the direction of the Word Elders according to 1 Tim. 3.2 to 7. Tit. 1.6 to 9. Deacons according to Acts 6.3 1 Tim. 3.8 to 12. For the Church hath not absolute power to choose whom they list but ministeriall power onely to choose whom Christ hath chosen hath gifted and fitted for them If the Church can finde out none such in their own body they send to any other Church for fit supply and each Church looketh at it as their dutie to be mutually helpfull one to another in yeelding what supply they may without too much prejudice to themselves according to Cant. 8.8 9. Such being recommended to them for such a work they take some time of tryall of them partly by their owne observation and communion with them partly by consultation with the Elders of other Churches continuing there in so great a work to fulfill the command of the Apostle Lay hands suddenly on no man 1 Tim. 3.22 For every man of good gifts is not alwayes endowed with an honest and good heart and every good heart is not fitted to close so fully as were meet with every good people Every key is not fit to open every Lock nor every good mans gift fit to edifie every people But when upon tryall the Church doth finde every mans spirit among them desirous of the fellowship of the man and his gifts then they agree amongst themselves upon a certain day wherein in a solemne manner they intend to Elect him to office amongst themselves Of this they give notice to all the neare adjoyning Churches whom and when and to what office they intend to choose such a man whom they nominate to them intreating their presence and brotherly counsell and assistance at the day appointed They give notice also thereof unto the Governour and such other of the Magistrates as are near to them that the person to be chosen meeting with no just exception from any may finde the greater incouragement and acceptance from all When the day is come it is kept as a day of humiliation with fasting praying and preaching the Word according to the patterne Act. 14.23 13.1 2 3. Towards the end of the day one of the Elders of the Church if they have any if not one of the graver Brethren of the Church appointed by themselves to order the worke of the day standeth up and inquireth of the Church If now after this solemne seeking of God for his counsell and direction in this weightie work they still continue in their purpose to elect such a one for their own Pastor or Teacher or Ruling Elder whom before they agreed upon Then having taken their silence for a consent to their purpose He proceedeth to inquire into the approbation of the rest of the Assembly not onely the Messengers and Brethren of other Churches present but of all that stand by because and Elder is to be a man of good report of them that are without 1 Tim. 3.7 how much more well approved of the Churches of Christ He demandeth therefore of the Churches first and then of the rest whether any of them have knowne of any evill in the man presented before them either in judgement or practice which might give them just cause to forbeare his election If all keepe silence as usually they doe for if any have any just exception against the man he is wont to acquaint some or other of the Church with it before the day he turneth himselfe to the Church againe Now seeing all is clear for their free election of him to such an office he desireth all the Brethren of that Church to declare their Election of him with one accord by lifting up their hands which being done he desireth to know of the partie chosen whether he doth accept of that calling which the Church hath given him in the name of Christ unto that office He having expressed his acceptance upon such grounds as wherein he hath chiefly seene the hand of God leading him thereunto the Elder doth then admonish the Church what duties the Lord requireth of them all in his Word towards him whom they have thus chosen And afterwards advertiseth him what duties the Lord requireth of him in that place towards the Church And having taken the acknowledgements of them both of their mutuall dutie towards one another He then with the Presbytery of that Church if they have any if not two or three others of the gravest Christians amongst the Brethren of that Church being deputed by the body doe in the name of the Lord Jesus ordaine him unto that Office with imposition of hands calling upon the Lord who hath furnished him with spirituall gifts and bowed the hearts of the Church to call him to that office to accept and owne him therein to enlarge his heart and spirit according to all the duties thereof to breath in all his administrations and to guide and blesse all his going out and coming in before them And so turning his speech upon the person on whom their hands are imposed He as the mouth of the Presbytery expresseth their ordination of him to that office in the name of the Lord Jesus and puts a solemne charge upon him to looke well to himselfe and to the whole flock over which the Holy Ghost hath made him an overseer as one that must give account of all their soules unto the great Shepheard of the sheep at the day of his appearing After this the Elders of their Churches present observing the presence of God both in the duties of that day performed by the Officer then chosen and ordained and in the orderly proceeding of the Church to his Election and Ordination one of them in the name of all the rest doth give unto him the right hand of fellowship in the sight of all the Assembly testifying their Brotherly acceptance of him and their thankfulnesse to God for his gracious gift bestowed on him and doth exhort him in the Lord to fulfill the ministery which he hath received of the Lord. And so after publick praise given to God by him in the name of the Church he dissolveth the Assembly with a Blessing SECT V. FOr our calling of Deacons we hold it not necessary to ordaine them with like solemnitie of fasting and prayers as is used in the Ordination of Elders because wee doe not reade the Apostles gave any president thereof in the Ordination of the first Deacons at Jerusalem Act. 6. But the Brethren of the Church having looked out among themselves men fitly qualified for that calling according to the Scriptures formerly mentioned and having made some proofes of them according to the Rule 1 Tim. 3.10 the Elders with the consent of the Church upon some Lords day or other publick holy meeting doe ordaine them to the Office and appoint them over that businesse with prayer and imposition of hands SECT VI. OBject Two things are here demanded First by what warrant the People choose their Officers Answ From the President
received it from the Apostles and the Officers of the Churches from them also and not from the Church Answ It is true the Apostles being extraordinary Officers as they were immediately called and chosen of Christ not by the Church so they were most of them ordained by Christ and not by the Church And yet not all of them neither For Paul and Barnabas though chosen to the Apostolicall office immediately from God yet they were ordained to that office by the imposition of hands of some officers or members of the Church Act. 13.2 3. But that hindereth not but as the Apostles received their power immediately from Christ so did the Church receive their power immediately from Christ also For he that said to the Apostles Whose sinnes yee retaine they are retained whose sinnes yee remit they are remitted Joh. 20.23 He also said to the Church Whatsoever yee binde on earth shall be bound in heaven and whatsoever yee shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven Mat. 18.18 which is a Commission of the same power and to the same effect If then the Church have received as well as the Apostles the same Commission of Church-Power so farre as it is of perpetuall use that though the Church then presented their Officers chosen by them to receive Ordination from the Apostles yet when the Apostles are ceased and no other successors left in their roome from whom their Officers might receive ordination but from the Presbytery of their own Church then where such a Presbytery is yet wanting and their power is now to be executed the Church hath full power to give ordination to them themselves by the imposition of their hands SECT VIII Object VVHen the Apostles ceased Bishops were left as successors in their roome As Timothy in Ephesus and Titus in Crete to ordaine Elders in every Church Tit. 1.5 Answ Timothy and Titus were not left to ordaine Elders as Bishops but as Evangelists whose office was alike extraordinary in the Church as that of Apostles and Prophets Eph. 4.11 Their work being to follow the Apostles and so set forward the work which the Apostles had begun whereto the Apostles called them forth and directed them And not to keepe setled residence in any one Church as Elders doe or in any one Nation of Churches as Bishops doe Timothy is expresly commanded to doe the work of an Evangelist 2 Tim. 4.5 And Titus was not ordained a Bishop at Crete but left in Crete as having travelled up and downe with Paul Gal. 2.3 and comming to Crete was left to direct the Cretian beleevers in their Church-affaires after Pauls departure afterwards he departed to Dalmatia 2 Tim. 4.10 Sometimes Paul appointed him to meet him at Nicopolis Tit. 3.12 Sometimes he sent him to Corinth 2 Cor. 12.18 And commends him as his partner and fellow-helper to the Church of Corinth And at Troas Paul found no rest in his spirit because he found not Titus his Brother 2 Cor. 2.13 And in Macedonia he found much comfort because he found Titus there 2 Cor. 7.5 6. Which argueth his calling was not Episcopall to rest in a certaine charge but to travell up and downe with the Apostles or after them or whither the Holy Ghost should lead them forth to help forward the work of Christ and the Apostles Object But in the Subscriptions of the Epistles of Paul to them Titus is called the first ordained Bishop of all the Cretians And Timothy the first ordained Bishop of the Church of Ephesus Answ The Subscriptions of Pauls Epistles both those and the rest are no part of Canonicall Scripture but Apocrypha not written by the Apostles themselves but by some Scribes that copied them out in after ages as is observed by many learned both Protestants and Papists In particular this Subscription in the Epistle to Titus containeth an apparent mistake for the Subscription saith the Epistle was written from Nicopolis to Macedonia as if Paul had been at Nicopolis when he wrote this Epistle which conceit in the Scribe sprang from a mistake of Pauls words Tit. 3.12 where Paul bids Titus be diligent to come to mee to Nicopolis for I have determined there to winter but Paul doth not say I have determined here to winter as if he were there already in Nicopolis but I have determined there to winter to wit as intending to goe thither for to winter The Subscription of the Epistle to Timothy stiling him the first ordained Bishop of the Ephesians will not stand with the Apostles charge to him in the same Epistle 2 Tim. 4.5 doe the work of an Evangelist For a Bishop was to attend with personall residence upon his charge Act. 20.28 But an Evangelist was to travell up and downe with the Apostles or after them to come and goe at their appointment As Paul there doth command Timothy to be diligent to come to him 2 Tim. 4.9.21 Againe when Paul addresseth himselfe to goe to Rome from whence this Subscription telleth us this Epistle was written he intending to passe by Macedonia to Rome Act. 19.21 besought Timothy to abide still at Ephesus 1 Tim. 1.3 But if Timothy had been the Bishop ordained of the Ephesians his dutie would have bound him to abide there and should not have needed Pauls intreaty so to doe Besides when Paul in that journey came to Miletus he called for the Elders of Ephesus Act. 20.17 whom also he named Bishops for so the Greek word is which is translated overseers v. 28. and then Paul acknowledged no such singular ordination of any to a transcendent Episcopacy but what was common to all the Elders of Ephesus But that it may further appeare that it was not the intent of Paul or of the other Apostles to direct the Churches to send the Elders whom they have chosen unto any Transcendent or Diocesan Bishop for ordination nor left any to like eminent place after Timothy and Titus to performe that work Let it be considered that there is no direction at all in the Epistles of Paul to Timothy and Titus for the Churches election of any Evangelist or of any Bishop over many Churches For 1. The Bishop Paul speaketh of in Timothy of whose qualification he giveth direction 1 Tim. 3.2 to 7. he calleth them all when he commeth to give order for their maintenance by the name of Elders some Ruling Elders some Labouring in the Word and Doctrine And in his Epistle to Titus the Elders which Paul left Titus to ordaine in every Citie he calleth them Bishops Tit. 1.5.7 Now of these he appointeth many Elders and many Bishops in one Citie or Church not many Cities or Churches under one Bishop Act. 14.23 Elders in every Citie Act. 20.17 18. Many Elders and Bishops in the Church of Ephesus Phil. 1.11 Many Bishops as well as many Deacons in one Church of Philippi and that a poore one too for Philippi was a Church in Macedonia Act. 16.12 And all the Churches of Macedonia had tryall of deep povertie
Espousalls without a covenant and therefore they that will take hold of their Espousage must take hold of their covenant 3. The mutuall relation wherein all the members in the Church stand one to another members to members and all of them to their Officers and their Officers to them together with their mutuall interest one in another and mutuall power one over another doe all of them necessarily imply a mutuall confederacie one with another and that whosoever will partake herein must partake in their confederacie Suppose a godly Christian come over into these parts as every yeare some or other doe there is not any Minister of any of our Churches can usurpe Pastorall authoritie over him unlesse that Christian call him thereunto or professe his subjection to his Ministration according to God Nor can such a man expect any Ministers watchfulnesse over him as his Minister unlesse the Minister see just cause to accept such a charge and professe so much No Church in the Countrey nor all the members of any Church can take upon them to Censure any stranger though an inhabitant amongst them unlesse he give up himselfe to them and professe his subjection to the Gospel of Christ amongst them Nor can he challenge such watchfulnesse from them unlesse he have given them a just call to take upon them that care over him That Christian libertie which the Lord Jesus by his bloud hath purchased for his Church and for all his children giveth them all libertie to choose their owne Officers and their owne fellow-Members unto whom to commit the care of their soules according to the rules of the Gospel We speak not of Infants who make choice in their parents but of such who know their libertie and are called to stand fast in it till then that a man tender and offer himselfe to the Church to the Officers and Members of it they have no power to receive him For the Churches receiving a beleever which is the Apostles word Rom. 14.1 implyeth and presupposeth his offering and giving up of himselfe unto them in a professed subjection to the Lord and unto them according to the will of God and their receiving of him implyeth and holdeth forth no lesse then their professed acceptance of him unto all those holy liberties with them and performance of all such spirituall duties to him which belong to all the fellow-members of the same body and let men call this expression of mutuall agreement by what name they please this is no other then what wee call Church-Covenant SECT V. LEt us proceed then to give account of the third point why we communicate so much power to the people as to propound receiving of Members unto their approbation and consent our reasons are these 1. From the like power given unto them by Christ for the casting out of scandalous and corrupt members Matth. 18.17 1 Cor. 5.5 if the Church must be told of every member that is to be cast out and when he is to be cast out they are to deliver him to Satan then the Church must be told of every member that is received and when he is to be received they are to receive him into the fellowship of the Lord and of his Church but the former is cleare from those Scriptures and consequently the latter It is a received Maxime Ejusdem est potestatis aperire claudere instituere destituere as they call it they that have power to shut the doores of the Church by Excommunication they have power to open the doores of the Church by admitting to Communion 2. From the Example of the Church at Hierusalem Act. 9.26 who when Paul assayeth to joyne himselfe unto them did not at first receive him because the Disciples were not satisfied in his spirituall good estate untill Barnabas by his testimony of him had removed their scruple which argueth the private brethren in a Church as well as publique Officers must be satisfied in him who is to be received into Communion with them 3. From the Churches power in Electing and calling Ministers to office It hath been shewed above that it belongeth to the people the body of the Church to choose and call their owne Officers according to the speech of Cyprian Lib. 1. Epist 41. Plebs maxime potestatem habet vel sacerdotes dignos eligendi velindignos recusandi And if they have such power of choosing worthy Ministers and refusing the unworthy how much more of receiving worthy Christians and refusing of unworthy Yea in the Epistle going before he speaketh expresly he had much adoe to perswade the people to receive some whose repentance was not so cleare to them which argueth evidently their power in receiving Members CHAP. IV. Concerning our order and forme in administration of Gods publick Worship SECT I. THe Church being gathered and furnished with able helps Officers and Brethren they proceed to the administration of all the publick Ordinances in publick Assemblies especially on every Lords day wherein our principall care and desire is to administer and partake in all and no more then all the ordinances of Christ himselfe and in all those so farre as the Lord hath lent us light in their native puritie and simplicitie without any dressing or painting of humane inventions For as the first Commandement requireth us to worship him with his owne onely true worship as he hath appointed in his Word without adding ought thereto or taking ought therefrom Isa 29.13 Deut. 12.32 So we beleeve it to be unlawfull for any Church to take upon them to observe much lesse for the Officers of their owne or other Churches to impose upon them any institutions of their owne whether in doctrine or worship or government but what the Lord hath appointed in his Word Our reason hereof one in stead of many is taken from the extent of the Commission of the Lord Jesus given to his Apostles which is as large as ever was given to any Church-governours and yet reacheth no further then to teach the people to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you Mat. 28.20 If the Apostles themselves teach the Churches to observe more then he hath commanded them they goe beyond the bounds of their Commission The Apostles in the Synod in Hierusalem laid upon the Churches no other burden then necessary things Acts 15.29 Necessary they were some of them in their own nature others for the present estate of things to avoid offence and when they ceased to be offensive the prohibition of them ceased to binde Object If any shall say the Apostles Commission reacheth onely to matters of substance not circumstances of worship and formes of necessitie not indifferency Wee answer let them shew us another Commission to authorize them to put lawes upon the Churches for matters of circumstance of formes and of indifferencie and wee shall submit but the Scripture holds forth no such Commission given to any of the sonnes of men since the world began That much urged place 1
Lay-men but our ruling Elders wee utterly deny them to be Lay-men as the word is commonly meant in this controversie but Church-officers set apart to their office by the election of the people and by imposition of hands but if they were Lay-men which they are not yet you see it is no strange or unheard of matter that Churches should be bountifull to the maintenance of sundry sorts of Church Rulers who are meerly Lay-men as their adversaries misconceive these to be yea what were the many Cloysters of Munks and Friers and Nuns in the times of Popery were they Preachers of the Word were they not Lay-men women and yet did the Churches of those times grudge them their maintenance upon pretence of their laity But the world will love his own be there never so many idle Droans or stately Rulers of mans own devising the Church must supply them not only with maintenance but with magnificence but let the Lord appoint ruling Elders according to the simplicity of the Gospel to assist his Ministers in the work of government that they might attend the more to labour in the Word if they shall expect from the Church any maintenance for their works sake Oh! that seemeth a strange matter and unheard of from all antiquity till this present age The second Reason why lay Elders as they miscall them ruling Elders as we with Paul call them are not meant in Pauls Text is because Paul mentioning the Presbyters but once in all his Epistles excludeth all lay Elders from that Presbytery Neglect not saith he the grace which is in thee which was given thee by prophecy with impositions by the hands of the Presbyterie 2 Tim. 4.14 This Christian Presbyterie gave imposition of hands to ordain Ministers but lay Elders had no right to impose hands to that purpose therefore Lay-men were none of this Presbyterie for if the Presbyterie be taken for the company of Elders none were of that company but such as might give imposition of hands or if Presbyterie be taken for the office of an Elder then none might take that function on him but must receive imposition of hands as Timothy did then Lay-men which neither give nor receive imposition of hands are wholly debarred both from the degree and from the society of the Presbyterie that was in Pauls time Our answer consisteth of three points First Lay Elders wee disclaim but ruling Elders though not attending to preaching as they have their election from the people who are the body of the Church so are they ordained set apart from amongst the people by imposition of hands of the officers of the Church who are the Presbyterie the company of Elders for by Presbyterie we conceive cannot be there meant the office of an Elder for hee speaketh of such a Presbytery as laid on hands now it is not the office of an Elder but the company of Elders that lay on hands Answ 2. When it is said no man can give what hee hath not received the light of Nature the law of Moses the Gospel of Christ do all of them make a ready answer for us The law of Nature tels us It is not necessary that they that give should alwayes formally have before-hand received that power which they give it is enough if they have received it virtually For instance a multitude of free people may elect and ordain a King over them and yet none of them had before hand received Kingly power it is enough they have a virtuall power to set up and to submit unto any lawfull forme of government which they see good for themselves in the land The people of Israel to wit some in the name of the rest for all could not at once impose their hands upon the Levites Numb 8.10 and yet they were not Levites themselves nor had received imposition of hands themselves and yet may neverthelesse impose hands upon others In the Gospel of Christ the power of the Keys is given to the Church to Peter not as an Apostle nor as an Elder but as a profest believer in the name of believers and upon occasion of the profession of his faith Mat. 16.16 to 19. whereupon the binding and loosing which is the power of the Keys is attributed to the whole Church Mat. 18.17 18. If then the power of the Keys which is the whole body of Church-power be given to the body of the Church though it be not in their power to exercise their pastorall preaching of the Word and administring of the Sacraments yet it is in their power to elect such whom God hath furnished with gifts among them unto such offices as may dispense all the holy things of God to them and by imposition of hands to dedicate them to God and to the publique service of his Church Now if the whole Church have this power to impose hands upon their officers in their first ordination how can it seem a strange and unheard of thing or an absurd matter that ruling Elders should together with the Pastor and Teachers all of them making up the Presbyterie of the Church impose hands in the name of the Lord and of the Church upon the ordained Answ 3. Besides there be that conceive and that not improbably that in ancient time the children baptized in the Church were not received to the Lords Supper nor into the full fruition of all Church liberties untill that they being grown up to yeers did publikely before the Church professe their faith and ratifie the covenant made for them in Baptisme and so were confirmed as they which is but a small remnant in comparison 300. yeares were spent in the Primitive persecutions whereof wee have few monuments of Antiquitie extant written in that time those wee have speake so of Elders as doe indifferently comprise as well Ruling Elder as Teaching Elders Ignatius his Presbyters whom he stileth the Court of God the Combination of the Apostles of Christ the holy Assembly and Counsellors and Assessors of the Bishops with all these Epithets may as well agree to Ruling Elders as to Preachers The Scripture doth not disdaine to admit Civill Magistrates into the fellowship of Gods Tabernacle Psal 82.1 And why not then the Rulers of his Church For Tertullian his Elders who were Presidents over the Censures of the Church and attained that honour not by Bribes but by approved Testimony Apologetic Chap. 29. what is there in his whole description of them but is compatible to Ruling Elders as well as to Preaching Yea Cyprian who lived in those ancient bloudy but zealous times doth expresly acknowledge Elders that were not Preachers For it evidently appeareth in the fift Epistle of his fourth Booke that he ordained Calinus and Ancellus to be Presbyters of his Church who were no Preachers but readers onely and yet were to be maintained Sportulis communibus that is at the common charge of the Church with the Presbyters and to sit with himselfe in their growne yeares It appeareth also in
Cor. 14.40 doth not authorize the Church nor any Church-governours to make lawes for the observation of such things as they shall account decent and orderly but onely provideth that all the ordinances of God whether prayer or prophesie or singing of Psalmes or tongues or interpretations be all of them done decently without uncomelinesse and orderly without confusion and that this place reacheth no further appeareth evidently from hence that if this place should give unto the Church or unto Church-governours authoritie to prescribe and command decent and orderly things at their owne discretion a man could not transgresse the Commandement of the Church but he should also transgresse the Commandement of the Apostle but the contrary is evident For suppose the Church or Church-governours should make an order that Ministers should alwayes preach in a gowne the thing is decent enough but neverthelesse if a man shall preach in a cloake he shall transgresse the order of the Church but not of the Apostle for he that preacheth in a cloake preacheth decently also which plainly argueth that such a commandement of the Church is not grounded upon the commandement of the Apostle SECT II. FIrst then when wee come together in the Church according to the Apostles direction 1 Tim. 2.1 wee make prayers and intercessions and thanksgivings for our selves and for all men not in any prescribed forme of prayer or studied Liturgie but in such a manner as the Spirit of grace and of prayer who teacheth all the people of God what and how to pray Rom. 8.26 27. helpeth our infirmities wee having respect therein to the necessities of the people the estate of the times and the worke of Christ in our hands After prayer either the Pastor or Teacher readeth a Chapter in the Bible and expoundeth it giving the sense to cause the people to understand the reading according to Neh. 8.8 And in sundry Churches the other whether Pastor or Teacher who expoundeth not he preacheth the Word and in the afternoone the other who preached in the morning doth usually if there be time reade and preach and he that expounded in the morning preacheth after him Before Sermon and many times after wee sing a Psalme and because the former translation of the Psalmes doth in many things vary from the originall and many times paraphraseth rather then translateth besides divers other defects which we cover in silence wee have endeavoured a new translation of the Psalmes into English meetre as neere the originall as wee could expresse it in our English tongue so farre as for the present the Lord hath been pleased to helpe us and those Psalmes wee sing both in our publick Churches and in private The seales of the Covenant to wit the Sacrament of Baptisme and the Lords Supper are administred either by the Pastor or by the Teacher and though with some godly learned Divines it be a question whether the Teacher may dispense the seales yet the question doth rather concerne Schoole-Doctors then the Teachers of a particular Church but wee who have onely the Teachers of particular Churches doe beleeve that they to whom the preaching or dispensing of the Gospel or Covenant of grace unto the Church is committed to them is committed also the dispensing of the seales of the Covenant but to the Teacher as well as to the Pastor is committed the dispensing of the Gospel the Covenant of grace unto the Church and therefore to him as well as to the other is committed the dispensing of the seales of the Covenant Both the Sacraments wee dispense according to the first institution Baptisme to Disciples and who are included in them their seed The Lords Supper to such as neither want knowledge nor grace to examine and judge themselves before the Lord. Such as lie under any offence publickly known doe first remove the offence before they present themselves to the Lords Table according to Mat. 5.23 24. The members of any Church if any be present who bring Letters testimoniall with them to our Churches wee admit them to the Lords Table with us and their children also if occasionally in their travell they be borne with us upon like recommendation wee admit to Baptisme The prayers wee use at the administration of the seales are not any set formes prescribed to us but conceived by the Minister according to the present occasion and the nature of the dutie in hand Ceremonies wee use none but are carefull to administer all things according to the primitive institutions The Father presenteth his owne childe to baptisme as being baptized by the right of his Covenant and not of the Covenant unto God-fathers god-mothers for there is no such covenant of God unto them and their god-sonnes and therefore we have no use of them but omit them in Baptisme as the Apostle cast out love-feasts from the Lords Supper being both of them alike superadditions to the Lords institutions 1 Cor. 11.23 24. The Lords Supper we administer for the time once a moneth at least and for the gesture to the people sitting according as Christ administred it to his Disciples sitting Mat. 26.20.26 who also made a Symbolicall use of it to teach the Church their majoritie over their Ministers in some cases and their judiciall authoritie as co-sessors with him at the last Judgement Luk. 22.27 to 30. which maketh us looke at kneeling at the Lords Supper not only as an adoration devised by man but also as a violation by man of the institution of Christ diminishing part of the Counsell of God and of the honour and comfort of the Church held forth in it In time of solemnization of the Supper the Minister having taken blessed and broken the bread and commanded all the people to take and eate it as the body of Christ broken for them he taketh it himselfe and giveth it to all that sit at Table with him and from the Table it is reached by the Deacons to the people sitting in the next seats about them the Minister sitting in his place at the Table After they have all partaked in the bread he taketh the cup in like manner and giveth thanks a new blesseth it according to the example of Christ in the Evangelist who describes the institution Mat. 26.27 Mark 14.23 Luk. 22.17 All of them in such a way as setteth forth the Elements not blessed together but either of them apart the bread first by it selfe and afterwards the wine by it selfe for what reason the Lord himselfe best knoweth and wee cannot be ignorant that a received solemne blessing expresly performed by himselfe doth apparently call upon the whole assembly to look againe for a supernaturall and speciall blessing in the same Element also as well as in the former for which the Lord will be againe sought to doe it for us After the celebration of the Supper a Psalme of thanksgiving is sung according to Mat. 26.30 and the Church dismissed with a blessing SECT III. IN the afternoone after publick prayer