Mat. â— in the name 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of iudgement Another was called the Little Synedrium consisting of 23. Iudges Wherein the greater and the capitall causes were heard It is thought that Christe Mat. 5. named that 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Hâ— tâ—at â—aith to his brother Racha sâ—albe guiltie of a Counsell or of the Synodrion The third was the great Synedrium or Sâ—nate of 70. Seniors ordeyned of Moses Num. 11. ouer which sate the high B. and the Elders excelling in wisedome vertuâ— leâ—â—ning and authoritie chosen out of the Priests and Leuites and of euerie Tribe were the assistants or sitters with him Vnto whom afterward by the ordinance of Dauid the chief of the Royall â—ooke which weâ—e called 〈◊〉 â—â—at is the Kings brâ—thren â—arrâ—â—ttiuâ— that is endowed with the right of succession were adioyned as the highest Counsell of the â—â—ole Common-weale chief Senate of the Kingdome To whom beloâ—ged the power of iudgeing the most weightie causes pertaining to the summe of the CoÌ„mon-weale aâ—d of Religion of the King and the Kingâ—ome of warre and peace of aunswering and pronouncing of the most difficult controuersies of opinions of other businesses To conclude of what manner the forme â—nd iâ—â—isdiction of this most high Senate was to the which they appealed from the other inferiour Iudgements in whose sentence and decrâ—e they must hold themselues coÌ„tented without anie gainsaying may for the most part cleerelie be gathered out of the reformation of the iudgements made by King Iosaphat For these are the words of the storie 2. Paral. 19. In Ierusalem also Iosophat appointed Priests c. But as in highest Senâ—te of the Iewish people the Priests and Princes of the Families gouerned together the Counsels of the Common-weale the two chiefe Presidents were the B. which gouerned the causes of religion and the ecclesiasticall businesses and the Kinges Cousin which gouerned the businesses Politicall euen so almost is the like forme in the chiefe Senate of the Kingdome of Germanie consisting of 7. Electors whereof three are Priests or Archbishops which ought to inâ—truct and with their counsels and labors ought to helpe the Emperor and conserue the CoÌ„mon-weale concerning the lawes of God for religion and the worship of God or the first Table of the x. Commandements 4. politike Princes which ought to instruct and with their counsels and labors to help the Emperor and to conserue the Common-weale concerning the Politike Lawe office of the Emperor in ordeining iudgements in warre and peace in taxes c. Thus more grauelie in my simple iudgement doth Chytreus allude not on these words Dic Ecclesia to the Sanedrin of the Iewes to haue the same or the like translated and established in euerie or in anie Congregation of the Church of Christe for that were cleane to ouerthrow all the States in Christendom But that in those places which he meÌ„cioneth Mat. 5. he alluded to the order of their lowest Senate of 3. Elders which was in euerie Citie and of their lesser Sanedrin that was of 23. in Ierusalem not of the 70. which was the highest instituted by God Num. 11. But not that Christe translated anie of all these Senates into him Church or established anie lawe thereon for adminâ—stration of gouernment in his Church Although he say almost the like form is in the highest Senate of the Kingdome of Germanie But not simplie that it is the like and much lesse the same and least of all that it was grounded on the Iewes forme otherwise than that all Estates and Kingdomes take their generall grounds from Gods lawe but wee are not tieâ— to this or that forme of Senate and Iudicials of the Iewes And so haue we also our chiefest Senate of Parliament and oâ—her Senates Sesâ—ions or Assemblieâ— both of the Clergie and of the Temporaltie and Counâ—els and Iudgements in some respects not much vnlike to the Iewes Assemblies Senates Councels and Iudgements And they draw néerer a great deale to the vncorrupted orders of the Iewes and are more fit requisit and 〈◊〉 for the State and condition of our Realms then thesâ— Consistories or Senates would be of these Seniors that our Brethren call for and thus hale the words of Christe to presse them vpon vs to be established in euerie Congregation for the administration of gouernmeÌ„t in the hearing and determining of all difficult and weightie matters amongst us 〈◊〉 so to continue for euer as long as the Church continueth in this world 〈◊〉 the great bondage of our Christian libertie by reducing vs to these Iudicials of the Iewes and to the quite ouerthrowe of ours and of all Kingdomes by reducing this Senate of the 70. Elders into all Congregations throughout Christendome Hauing nowe thus farre considered as I take it the verie grounde wherean Caluine and all our Brethren following him woulde say the foundation of this Consistorie Senate of Elders in euerie Congregation to wit vpon this construction of these words of Christ Dis Ecclesia Tell the Church that is to say Tel the Segniorie Seâ—ate or CoÌ„sistorie â—et vs now returne to the processe of our Br. learned discourse 〈◊〉 And the name of Elders dooth most aptlie agree vnto them that bee Gouernors in the Church now euen as it did to the Auncients of Israel so that the Pastors seeme to haue borrowed the name of Elders especialy in respect of their gouernment The name of this Consistorie also in the new Testament we finde to be agreable with that of the Iewes whereof our Sauiour Christe speaketh when he saith Tell the Congregation or assemblie S. Paul 1. Tim. 4.14 Despise noâ— the gift which was giuen thee through Prophecâ—â— wish iâ—position of hands of the Eldership Where the Greek word is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the assemblie or Consistorie of the Elders Which word was vsed also by S. Luke in his Gospel speaking of the Consistorie of the Iewish Elders Luke 22.66 As soone as it waâ— day the whole Eldership or Assemblie of Elders came together both chiefe Priests and Scribes and brought him into their Councell In which saying their CouÌ„cell 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is called 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Also S. Paul Act. 20.5 â—hat he had ben a persec of christiaÌ„s taketh witnes of the high Priest and of the whole Consistorie of Elders vsing the same word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 By which it is euident that our Sauiour Christe by this word Ecclesia in that place meaneth a Consistorie or assemblie of Elders whose authoritie c. This is but descant on the name and we woulde rather heare of the 〈◊〉 The name of Elders serued to more than to those of the Segniorie which were of the Sanedrin or Synedrion And we graunt it most aptly agreeth to them that be Gouernors in the Church new and those Ecclesiasticall Gouernors to and was but borowed as well in respect of the gouernment as of the
women gouerned Gods people Whereby hee séemeth to clayme this to bee the prerogatiue of Fraunce that whether it bée right or whether it bee wrong they will not suffer womens gouernmtnt Neyther is Cenalis thus content to haue thus once or twise heerein abused the Scripture but he goeth on moste blasphemousely to God and iniuriously against all Christendome and sayth in which thing that most noble Realme of the Nation of the French Gaulles hath whereupon to congratulate vnto it selfe that by the singular benefite of God it may woorthily be called before other kingdomes a sacerdotall or Priestly kingdome For it hath this thing common with Priest-hoode that euen as the Priest-hoode can not passe ouer vnto a woman so no more can the Monarchiall Empire of the Salike Monarchie What therefore remayneth but that being mindefull of the grace receaued of God they breake foorth into these wordes Apocal 5. Thou art worthy O Lorde to take the booke and to open the seales therof because thou wast slaine hast redeemed vs in thy bloud out of euery tribe language people and Nation to wit whome thou hast vouchsafed to illustrat with the title of the most ChristaÌ„ kingdom And moreouer hast made vs kinges and Priestes and we shall raigne vpon the earth to wit being enriched with this sacerdotall dowrie Nothing therefore letteth whereby that Nation should not be called a holy Nation a royall Priest-hoode or if ye had rather a priestly or sacerdotall kingdom a people of purchase For the religion which afterward once it got neuer intermitted but happely prosperously euer encreased Gallia or the couÌ„trie of the Gaules sayth Ierom alone hath wanted monsters with the which almost the residue of Nations haue abounded more than inough Thus monstrously writeth Caenalis against womens regiment Howbeit I hope Caluin tooke not this terme of monster for womens regimeÌ„t from this monstrous Popish Bishop As for that which Ierome wrote was not against the regiment of women in Gallia neither was Gallia in his time called Francia nor Pharamundus borne and so no such Salike lawe as yet inuented And therefore this must needes be wrested hereunto Besides this intollerable arrogancie in the French to claime that spirituall priuilege of Royall Priest-hoode that is both common to all true Christian nations and to all true Christian people not onely men but to women also and to children And therefore this is both iniurious vnto theÌ„ to take this title from them and a grosse errour in a Bishop not vnderstanding what these termes doe meane For although he deâ—arre his Popish sacrificing Priest-hood from a woman leâ— him laye that hardely to Pope Iohanes charge yet in this spirituall and mysticall kingdome and Priest-hoode that either S. Peter or S. Iohn speaketh of euery good Christian woman neuer so priuate or poore person and all the electe children of God haue as good title right and interest as not onely the French king but as any or all the Emperours Kinges Queenes and Princes in the worlde Now after Caenalis hath thus craked of the French prerogatiue in this Salike lawe so much pretended and so greatly vrged when he commeth to the reason of the same and of this worde Salica he sheweth what diuersities of opinions are thereon Munster thinkes it is deriued of the worde Sala a riuer at a village of the same name Other that the lawes Salike are deriued of the woorde Sala or vne salle in Frenche signifying in Latine Aulam a Courte or Hall as who say the Courtly or Palatine law Some thought the deriuation of the lawe Salike came of certaine lawes of the French Emperours beginning Si aliquis or Si aliqua and so by contraction striking of a letter or two in the ende per syncopen it was vulgarly termed the lawe Salike Some sayth he arise higher more commodiously who fetch the Etimologie of the lawe Salike not so much out of the marrowe or pythe of the worde as out of the barke or rynde of the worde A Sale from salte as by a certayne allusion that they would haue the Salike law to be spoken hereupon as though it were perpetually constant inuiolable and incorruptible for all times to endure For salte in the holy scriptures is a token of incorruption and perpetuall enduring and moreouer both of Wisdome and discretion As is expressed in plaine wordes Numb 18. and Leuit. 2. In the booke of Numbers All the first frutes of the sanctuarie which the children of Israell â—ffer to God I haue giuen to thee and to thy sons by a perpetuall right it is an euerlasting couenant of salte vnto thee and to thy sonnes before the Lorde And in Leuiticus Whatsoeuer sacrifice thou shalt offer thou shalt season with salte nor shalt take awaye the salte of the couenant of thy God from thy sacrifice In euery oblation thou shalt offer salte And againe 2. Paral. 13. Yee are not ignoraunt that the Lorde GOD of Israell hath giuen the kingdome vnto Dauid ouer Israell for euer to him and to his sonnes for a couenaunt of salte By this it manifestly appeareth that salt hath the tooken of incorruption And as for the token of discretion Let your speech sayth Paule be seasoned with salte And in Marke Bâ—â—rie offering shall bee salted with salte Salâ— is good but if so be it be vnsauorie in what will yee season it That so yee may vnderstande the lawe Salike being sprinkled with the salte of discretion and with the sauce of muche reason perpetually to remaine in his vigor Thus doth Caenalis séeke all the shiftes he can to enforce this lawe not sparing thus more and more to hale and drawe these places of scripture to the same But sence he alleageth so manye originalles thereof and dare not resolue himselfe vppon any one of them but sayth Let euerie mans iudgement remayne to himselfe for I will not vppon this thing contende with any man what certaintye therefore can this lawe haue The very title whereof when it is tossed and tombled withall these diuersities of opinions and wrestlinges of the scripture is so vncertaine But if this were suche a wise and incorruptible lawe that it had his name of seasoning with salte to resemble those auntient offringes couenantes and spéeches in the olde and newe Testament then it maketh more for women than against them For although that saying 2. Paral 13. mention onely Dauid and his sonnes yet did Caenalis himselfe confesse before that the Nation of the Iewes did admitte the gouernement of a woman And the place mentioned Numbers 18. conteyneth not only sonnes as Caenalis citeth it but the verie wordes are to thee and to thy sonnes and to thy daughters So that the offering that is the salte of couenant or incorruptible couenant if the Frenche can drawe it to holde still incorruptiblie with them or the resemblance of their Princes estate thereunto giueth the same not onely to the man
stained her selfe with such horrible murther and open Idolatrie as she did she ought not for anie reason of her sexe by him or all or anie neuer so noble in that kingdome to haue bene deposed But now the right and title lineallie descending to her nephew to wit her sonnes sonne which by Ioiada had beene harboured in the Temple vnwitting to this vnnaturall Queene mother and cruell grandame it was Ioiada his duetie not onelie to giue notice of the true heire but to iâ—yne with all the Cleargie the Princes and the people that hee coulde to inthronize the King for so he is also called for his right before he was seazed in his kingdome verse 7.8 and 11. and to dispossesse this vsurper so that euen by this example of Athalia beeing better considered we sée that this supreame gouernment vnder God and ouer Gods people was not prohibited to a womaÌ„ if by right of inheritaÌ„ce it fel vnto her that she vsed it well although there were no occasion of the like example among the Iewes al the time of the estate of their Kings God furnishing thâ—â—ill with heires male to succéede their parents in that kingdome And as we now sée this in the tract of Dauids line froÌ„ Salomon til after that estate of the Kings it ioyned with the race of Nathan so euen for Salomon himself in whom this issue of the Kings began and was of them all the most magnificent let vs sée likewise what was his opinion of this matter For as we reade 1. Reg. 10. verse 1. c. The Queene of Saba or Sabea hearing of the fame of Salomon in the name of the Lorde came to â—rie him in harde questions We haue heard alreadie the iudgement of Vadianus out of Iosephus concerning this Queene that shee was the Queene of Sabea in Aethiopia and that the Queenes there had continually the supreme gouernment as wee haue séene both Plinies and Straboes testimonies of Candace But as I said before I take Peter Martyrs iudgemeÌ„t to be the truer that she was rather the Queene of the Sabeans a people of the happie Araby And when as sayth he the Countrie beeing so happie and blessed with much riches maketh the inhabitants daintie this woman is to be commended which casting daintinesse aside tooke vpon her such a farre peregrination She was of the stocke of Chanaan the sonne of Cham. For Saboth as is contained in the tenth Chapter of Genesis was the sonne of Chus and Chus the sonne of Canaan We are also taught in this historie that there is no accepting of persons with God but that of euerie people and nation he hath his elected Christ calleth her the Queene of the South because that coast is Southward if it bee compared with the Citie of Ierusalem And he saith that shee came to Salomon from the endes of the North. Wherevpon I beleeue the rather that she came out of Arabie the happie than out of the Iland Meroe Neither happened this without God for verily it was he that stirred vp this Queene with the fame of Salomons wisedome Yea in a manner hee drew her thether to the end that it might bee fulfilled which was spoken of before all nations shall knowe thy great name c. And againe Let vs in the meane time ponder this speech wherewith it is sayde In the name of the Lord and in the Hebrue 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 For therby is first declared that this Queene did acknowledge the true God And also as Kimhi saith that the wisedome of Salomon was not spread forth but in this name that the Lorde had inspired the same vnto him c. By this sentence also may bee declared that although Salomon was adorned with an heauenlie spirite in all kinde of learning and wisedome notwithstanding this thing most of all inflamed the Queene that he was richtly instructed with diuine matters such I saie as pertayned to the name of god As thogh peculiarly she sought that wisdome the which is ioyned together with religioÌ„ And this thing is very honorable to trauaile for wisedome and godlynesse sake Plato Pythagoras and Apollonius Tianaeus are commended for that they wandered through the world to attaine wisedome Verilie great studiousnesse of excellent learnings were in them and therefore woulde they both see and heare also the men that excelled in erudition and vertue Other besides theâ—e haue bene and are at this daie not a few that of curiositie delightes and pleasures are stirred vp to trauaile and drawe themselues thether where they liue more delicatlie and with more pleasure and where they hope they shall see certaine new and strange things but these are not worthie to bee praised but rather to be discommended As for the fact of this woman may be numbred among the famous examples wherewith wee may bee inkindled to the studies of godlinesse and true doctrine And although verie many came to Salomon yet doth the sacred history make mencion especially of this woman and that verie exquisitelie because shee among other obtayneth the principall place For shee was a Woman whome the weaknesse of her sexe did easilie withdrawe Shee was also a Queene wealthie and abounding in delightes Whereunto besides did come also the farre distaunce of the iourney neuerthelesse shee staying not for these things went forth to Salomon But if wee saie was it lawfull for her to forsake the Region committed to her administration that shee might enquire after the learning and wisedome of Salomon yea although it were for religion To this maye be sayde that it might be shee lefte eyther her husbande or her sonne or some other which in her place might haue gouerned the Kingdome Moreouer shee tooke the iourney that she might get not onelie to her selfe but also to her people sounde religion and sincere godlynesse shee therefore profited more her people in trauayling abroade than in sitting quiet at home To the which yee maye adde that in this folded vp secrete was signified the calling of the Gentiles which were to gather themselues to Christ the true Salomon Wherevpon Christ himselfe as is contained in the Gospell commended this woman and affirmed that in time to come shee shall iudge the Hebrues because shee farre excelled them in faith And in this place yea and by this declaration the contemners of Gods word are grieuously noted which dailie more than needes doe bewraie themselues While in so greate a light of the sacred doctrine which by the goodnesse of GOD euen at this present daie hath shined they are nothing at all mooued For often times doe they linger and forslow euen to arise out of their bed to heare the sacred sermons So farre off are they to suffer themselues to leaue their Country or their house They despise the holy Bookes in respect of their delights The Doctours also and the Preachers they hate worse than a snake and with their tongues vehemently detest good studies And if they see
the liuing because though the bodies only be there lodged as in a house yet their soules sléeps not but are liuing The Germanes call it Gottes acker of ager dei the aker or field of God And we terme it the Churchyearde as the measure of yearth pertaining to the Church deriued of the old worde kyrke-gerth yet vsed in the North as the yearth that is dedicated vnto the Lord not vnaptly fetched from 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 And what place fitter all superstition being disclaimed than is this ground if not of the Churche yet of this Churchyeard for our burials But as our Brethr. finde fault with this distinction of places so they finde fault with this distinctioÌ„ of our maner of burying the dead that we burie some with more pompe as singing ringing c. some with lesse If our Brethren take pompe in the better sense would they haue all persons buried with like pompe Or if in the worst sense would they haue no pompe nor solemnitie vsed at al at any persons burial but what this pompe should be except that they mention only singing ringing I can not certainly tel For they suppresse the residue with an c. but that singing or ringing is vtterly or then vnlawfull or any to be buried with more solemnitie than other according to the decencie of their state calling me thinks our Brethr. herein should not be so hard to condemne the distinction of that also as in it selfe meerely superstitious We read in the old Testament of great distinction about the buriall of the dead euen of the holy Patriarkes Who were all buried in such solemne place maner as Abraham buried his wife Gen. 23. And was himselfe buried Gen. 25 and as Isaac was buried and Rachel Iacobs wife Gen. 35. and as Iacob Ioseph Gen. 50. and diuerse others that were buried more solemnly than other were Neither was the greater pompe of their funerall estéemed of the holy fathers before the coÌ„ming of christ a superstitious but a decent an honorable thing Neither was it any such figure of Christes more honorable buriall as Zegedinus thinketh that it should cease after the buriall of Christ and that we should now be buried all alike no it rather argueth as Selnecserus therein thinketh much better in my opinion that a Christian man according to his higher estate or to the excellencie of his life in his calling may haue without superstition a more honorable buriall And as it appeareth how Stephen was buried Act. 8. with greater mourning than were the common sort of Christians in those daies As for the offence which our Brethren take with burying towards the East I thinke it not a matter so worthy as to haue bin once noted in their Learned Disc. Indéede it is a common order among Christians so to burie the dead as wel to differ from Turkes Iewes as also making no necessitie of the matter nor matter of religion to be the more signe that they haue the better hope of the resurrection in laying the corps of the dead Christians in such maner as though they respected the reddier lifting vp of them selues when they shall all be raysed to life againe to beholde the coÌ„ming of our Sauiour Christe which to vs warde asâ—ended in the Easte Not to tie him to descende here or there or that they doubted but that whersoeuer they be howsoeuer they lie or shal be coÌ„sumed he will at the glorious appearance of his coÌ„ming gather theÌ„ all vnto him as he saith Luc. 13.29 Then shall many come from the East from the West froÌ„ the North and from the South shal sit at the table in the kingdome of God And I take that our auncestors in these west parts in so laying the dead had this especiall respect If any did it superstitiously or made any matter of religion in so doing I excuse him not and thinke so it be done without offence or contempt of the common order that they may vse it otherwise without anie daunger or impediment for any thing I know to the contrarie As for the other things meÌ„tioned here by our Brethr. as they were proper to the aduersaries of the Gospell so God be praised they are remooued Neither doth our prescribed forme of Buriall allow them or giue any the least occasion to any of all those heresies errors or superstitions But now to auoide all occasion oâ— heresies errors and superstitions what forme of buriall would our Brethren haue Forsooth they say It is thought good to the best right reformed churches to bury their dead reuerently without any ceremonies of praying or preaching at them Here is a short manner indéede of burying the dead and agréeth herein with the booke of the Forme of Common prayer which our Brethren haue of late set out Wherein vpon the title of buriall they say The corps is reuerently to be brought to the graue accompanied with the neighbours in comely manner without any further ceremonie And this is all that they say there of the forme of buriall But if this be the forme of the best and right reformed Churches what shall we then say to goe no further than euen to the Church of Geneua it selfe to the booke called The forme of prayers and ministration of the sacramentes c. vsed in the English congregation at Geneua and approued by the famous and godly learned man Iohn Caluine Which booke on the title of buriall pag. 88. sayth on this wise The corps is reuerently brought to the graue accompanied with the congregation without any further ceremonies which being buried the minister goeth to the Churche if it be not farre off and maketh some comfortable exhortation to the people touching death and resurrection Here is yet a Sermon to be preached at least wise some comfortable exhortation to be made by the Minister at the buriall of the dead though not at the very place for neither doe we so tie it to the place of buriall The dead may be buried in the Church-yeard or any other place assigned thereunto and the sermon be in the Churche and neuerthelesse be well saide to be at the buriall because it is made for that especiall purpose and for that commonlye the congregation is not dismissed all in a doombe and silent action but that some wordes of consolation are vttered by the Minister ere they depart Bucer in his Epitome Ecel Argentinae cap. 27. saith on this wise We teach concerning those whom the Lord in the confession of his name hath receaued to himselfe out of this life that they are withal feare of God and honestly to be committed to the earth and there the people out of the worde of God to be admonished of the heauie iudgement of God against sinne and also of the redemption of Christe who hath redeemed vs from death and of the aeternall life which he hath purchased to all his faithfull After which men are to be exhorted
Synode must a Synode which is an assembly out of many perticuler Churches be alwayes called together so often as any contention or default happeneth among Pastors or among the Elders in anie one church or coÌ„gregation If it be such a default or controuersie say they as cannot be determined in the particuler churches Loe heere may our bretheren see and learne what it is to take away the Bishops Iurisdiction in a Diocese and in a Prouince the Archbishops and the Princes Superiour aucthoritie also in a Realme or Kingdome for let their Iurisdictions and aucthorities stande these controuersies and defaultes might be punished decided and reformed well inough and neuer tâ—ouble so many Churches by calling so often their Pastors from them by gathering and continuing Synodes for these matters and so perhaps breede moe and newe contentions But saye they some example wee haue thereof Actes 15. where those contentious Scismatikes that withstoode Paule and Barnabas at Antiochia were constrayned to yeelde by aucthority of the Counsell and Paule and Barnabas restored to their credite Wee doe not denie the aucthoritie of a Councell nor of that holye assemblie and if they will so call it a Councell or Synode whereby Paule and Barnabas were restored to their credite and the contentious Scismatikes constrayned to yeelde And woulde God our â—rethren woulde consider more aduisedly the force of this Example least in their not yeilding to the aucthoritye and decrees of the lawfull Synodes and Councells holden in this Realme and Churche of Englande about these matters whiche they impugne they shewe themselues to be more factious than were those contentious Scismatikes But nowe if wee shall more neerely leuell these Synodes and Councels that our brethren would haue for the determining of these controuersies concluding all contentions and for the punishing of all suche notorious defaults and misgouernements to be called together into an assembly of the Bishops or Pastors of diuers particuler Churches comparing the same with this assembly Act. 15. of the Apostles and Elders at Ierusalem wee shall not finde that besides the parties sent from Antiochia where the controuersie arose there was any assemblie at all either from diuers or froÌ„ any other particuler Churches but onely the assemblie of the Apostles and Elders of Ierusalem Wherein the text is cléere vers 1. c. Then came there downe from Iudea certeyne men taught the bretheren saying except ye bee circumcised after the maner of Moses ye can not be saued And when there was great dissentioÌ„ and disputation by Paule and Barnabas against them they ordeyned that Paule and Barnabas and certeyne other of them should goe vp to Ierusalem vnto the Apostles and Elders about this question that is sayth Beza Iudices illis ferebant Apostolos Seniores Hierosolymitanos they appoynted the Apostles and Elders of Ierusalem to be their Iudges Thus sayth Luke being sent foorth by the Church they passed through Phoenicia and Samaria declaring the conuersion of the Gentiles and they brought great ioye vnto all the bretheren But here Luke telleth not that they brought any of the Elders of the churches either of Phoenicia or Samaria or of any other Churches els with them to Ierusalem And when sayth Luke they were come to Ierusalem they were receiued of the Church and of the Apostles and Elders and they declared what things God had done by them But sayd they certeyne of the Sect of the Pharisies which did beleeue rose vp saying that it was needfull to circumcise them and to commaunde them to keepe the lawe of Moses Then the Apostles Elders came together to looke to this matter Here when they came together no mention is made of Churches but of the Church and of the Apostles and Elders Which Elders wee haue shewed out of Caluin were the Pastors of the Church of Ierusalem So that if this assemblie shal be called a Synode or Councell yet was it but a Synode or Councell of one particuler Church and the Apostle S. Iames being the Gouernour or Bishop of that Church as is before proued was the concluder and finall determiner of that controuersie And therefore where our Brethren say some example we haue hereof Act. 15. This example fitteth not so well as they weene neither for the Synodes that they would haue nor for the authoritie of the Synode But if they will decide the matter by examples especially for redressing by Eccl. censure defaultes and controuersies and for punishing those Pastors or Elders of the Church which should be refourmers of others and haue notoriously misgouerned themselues Why forget they here how Saint Paule gaue Timothie not only authoritie to make Pastors ouer diuers particuler Churches but also how to receiue accusation agaynst the Pastorall Elders and those that sinne that is as our bretheren call it notoriously misgouerne themselues to rebuke them openly that is as Caluin exposideth it vt quisquis inter eos male se gesserit seuerè corrigatur Whosoeuer among them behaueth himselfe ill that he bee say our Bretheren seuerely punished So that if the Pastors defaults and controuersies cannot bee redressed by Ecclesiasticall censure not determined in the particuler Churches wherein they are Pastors why should they not first go either to the Bishop of the Dioces or further to the Archbishop of the Prouince as we haue seene sufficient proofe that Timothie was But if the matter be so difficult that it cannot yet be by them determined then in deede by the authoritie and licence of the Christian Magistrate if there be a Christian Magistrate as GOD be praysed we haue if we can be thankfull and obedient a Synode or Councell of many Bishops and Pastors may bee called and holden to refourme and redresse those enormities Sic tamen conuocetur Prouinciale concilium c. saith Danaeus lib. 3. Isag. cap. 38. But let the prouinciall Councell bee so called together that the same Synode be signified vnto the faithfull Magistrate of that place wherunto it commeth together to the ende that all suspition of cluttering together or of faction may be auoyded besides that neither ought that Prouinciall Synode to come together nor yet to bee summoned but that the power of calling together such an assemblie either generally or specially from the chiefe faithfull Magistrate of all that Region Kingdome or Common weale wherof that Prouince is a parte be before hand expresseâ—y or by silent yeelding graunted and giuen vnto the Church and to the Pastors thereof And in deede for such great matters and controuersies in Religion and notorious misgouernances not onely of Pastors but of the Bishops and Archbishops themselues when the matters could not bee concluded nor the persons seuerely punished in their particuler Churches many Prouinciall and generall Councels were called and holden as against the Arrians Macedonians Nestorians Eutichians Monothelites c. Which Councels haue decided those great controuersies deposed
which before they had receaued â—s wée haue heard Caluines prescription Epist. 373. and so continued still in the office or ministery thus repurged And therefore since the masse was taken away and all â—he other corruptions of the Ministerie that were vsed in the popish priesthood an other Ministration appointed as is sette downe in our booke of publike prayer by the godly lawes of the realme and Church of England established which was done so soone as conueniently it could be done forthwith after her Maiesties moste happy entrance into this kingdome this is not truly sayd that the popish priesthood being the greatest blasphemie that euer was was alowed for a lawfull Ministerie vntill by the godly meaning of the sayd parliament Anno. 13. some brande-marke of shame was sette vppon it As though the sacrificing Priesthoode had continued with allowance therof for thirteene yere together of the Queenes Maiesties raigne which was as long a time as before they mencioned for the inforcing of the ministers to studie Yea by this rule it continueth still though disallowed or rather as they say but noted onely with a brand-marke of shame set vpon it So that this is not the taking of it awaye but the continuing of it with more shame to the parliament and to all the states of the Realmâ— that haue marked it with a brand-marke of shame and yet shame not to continue it though we disallow it And this withall is but a shamefull and vnreuerent terme that here they vse in calling eyther the statute or the booke of articles agreed vppon by all the clergie of the Churche of England and approued in the high courte of parliament by al the states of the realme and by the statute commaunded to be read a brand-marke of shame But our brethren to mittigate the matter say the parliament had a godly meaning in making that statute for Priestes that had bin made in the tyme of Popery to professe their consent to the true doctrine agreed vpon in the booke of articles by their publike reading of the same booke in their benefices Yea verily the parliament had therein a very godly meaning and it was also as godly an act â—s meaning of the parliament But saye they how pitifullye that authority was abused which by the same statute was committed to the Bishops in allowing of Priestes that came to doe their pennance by negligence of the Bishops and bribery of their officers the country cryeth out of it and the state of the Church is little amended by it There is no such crying out in the country as are these outcries of our brethren If it be but little amended yet little is somewhat But if it bee not greate that is not to be unputed to the good lawe but to the euill and indirect accidents For it was not pitifull that that authority was committed to the Bishops in allowing of Priestes that came not as our brethren here say to doe their pennance or to haue a brand-marke of shame set vpon them but the statute it selfe more reuerently and rightly setteth downe the cause and order of their act saying That the Churches of the Queenes Maiesties dominions maye bee serued with Pastors of sound religion be it enacted by the authority of this present Parliament that euerye person vnder the degree of a Byshop which doth or shall pretende to be a priest or Minister of gods holy worde and Sacramentes by reason of anye other fourme of institution consecration or ordeyning than the forme set foorth by Parliament in the tyme of the late King of most worthye memorye King Edwarde the sixte or now vsed in the raigne of our moste gratious Soueraigne Ladye before the feaste of the Natiuitie nexte following shall in the presence of the Bishop or gardian of the spiritualties of some one diocoese where he hath or shall haue ecclesiasticall liuing declare his assent and subscribe to all the articles of religion which onely concerne the confession of the true Christian Faith and the doctrine of the SacrameÌ„ts comprised in a booke imprinted intituled Articles wherupoÌ„ it was agreed by the Archbish. Bish. of both prouinces the whole Clergy in the Conuocation holden at London in the yeare of our lorâ— God 1562. According to the computation of the Church of england for the auoyding of the diuersities of opinions and for the establishing of consent touching true Religion put forth by the Queenes Authoritye And shall bring from suche B. or gardian of Spiritualties in wryting vnder his Seale authentike and testimoniall of such assent subscription openly on some Sonday in the time of publike seruice afore noone in euery church wher by reasoÌ„ of any Ecc liuing he ought to atteÌ„d reade both the said Testimoniall the said articles vpon paine that euery such persoÌ„ which shal not before the said feast do as is aboue appointed shall be ipso facto depriued al his Eccl. promotions shal be voyd as if he then were naturally dead These are the very words of the statute Wherein what could they better haue prouided than whatsoeuer they should ordeyne for the bringing of those persons to the more sure confession and consent of sound Religion firste to come before the Bishoppe or the Gardian of the â—pirituall iurisdiction in the Bishops vacancie in some one Diocoese where hee had any ecclesiasticall promotion or liuing and there before him declare his consent and also subscribe to all the articles of religion which onelye concerne the confession of the true Christian Faith c. Before whom should he haue done this if he should doe it authentically than before the Bishop or the bishops gardian being the publike officers that haue competent authority ouer him in those matters which withall confuteth our brethrens equall authority of all Pastors If the bishops were negligent or the officers take bribes this was the bishops the officers fault not any default in the lawes Wise men should not doe like WilliaÌ„ Summer strike one for another But if the bishops negligence and the bribery of the officers be so great that the countrye cryeth out of it and the state of the Church is little amended it is then so much the easier to be knowne who are the offenders that so pitifâ—lly abused this godly meaning of the statute that authority committed to them and not they to be thus disorderly cried out vpon and that in this vncharitable maner by inuectiue libelles vnder the tytle of learned discourses to be thus discoursed vpon with taunts slaunders defamed to all the worlde so much as lyes in them If the matter be little amended this is not to amend it more but to make it worse for this is naught worth but to norishe malice suspitioÌ„ sclaunder yet the fault not knowne much lesse ameÌ„ded Let the negligence briberies with true desire of reformation as the title of this learned discourse pretendeth
pitie But say they he was carryed first to the Bishop whom he chose if hee might for his purpose such one as had bin a priest of his owne order cared least what ministers serue in his diocoese From the disdayning of poore sir Iohn our brethren mount vp againe to another slaunder of the Bishop burdening him also not onely with the popish priesthood and so to be one for the popish priestes purpose as a fauorer of popery but also to be carelesse what ministers serue in his diocoese But till they name and proue any to haue then bene or yet to be suche euill Bishops this againe may go for so a foule slaunder that it deserueth for answere a due rewarde of so great an obloquie But to come downe againe from the Bishops to olde sir Iohn lacke Latine that was carryed about on his mare or in a carte if hée was so poore to bée carryed thus baselye aboute howe is it sayd that hée had not seene some of his benefices in a dozen yeare before and that hée was carryed from shire to shire one benefice beinge distante from another 100. mile mumbling vp his articles in his morrow masse voyce in euery Church where he had liuing It might haue beene that this olde popish priest sir Iohn lacke latine might haue serued some smale cure or perhaps in some odde corner haue got a benefice but if hee had so many it is not likely that he was but a sir Iohn lacke latine if not rather had he had withall grace and truth that he had latine inough and siluer ynough also if not too much so that hée néeded not to be carryed about on his mare or in a carte for the matter There is no probability in this tale But what liuinges soeuer he had or hauing liuinges how beastly soeuer he spared his money and rode thether on his widge beaste when hee came there if he mumbled vp his articles in his morrowe masse voice meaning heereby that he did it also in such a beastely sorte that the people did not vnderstand him or that he did it not in the best reuerent hartie maner he could but that he shewed himself to doe it against the hart and for fashion sake only to saue his liuing and so returned if he came such a beaste thither as very a beast as he came this was no sufficient satisfaction to the intendement and godly meaning of the lawe And therefore if anye godly disposed persons were iustly offended at his mockery and manifest eluding of the godly meaning of this act cryed out vpon him for a counterfeite or but orderly coÌ„playned on his misdemeanor they might most easily haue had him punished the matter amended euen with the losse of all his liuinges for so apparant mocking of the statute But now howsoeuer this old sir Iohn lacke latine shifted since our brethren here cite this act of parliament anno 13. And withall doe so greatly commend the godly meaning of the sayd parliament and pitie that the authority of the same statute was abused and would haue the priestes made by the popish Priesthood and with good reason to haue bin seuerelye looked vnto in the full accoÌ„plishment of that which the said statute of so godly meaning did enact sith I hope our Bre. also meane as they speake may it please them to consider with me or with their pillow a little better of this godlye meaning of the act of the words therof then tell me whether that some if not all of their owne selues might not haue bin shrewdly touched yet may be by their manifest breach thereof And for to begin with the entendment godly meaning of the act to repeate the wordes againe marke them better The words are these That the churches of the Queenes Maiesties dominions may be serued with Pastors of sound religion beit enacted by the authority of this present parliament that euery person vnder the degree of a B. which doth or shall pretend to be a Priest or minister of gods holy word sacrameÌ„ts by reason of any other forme of institution consecration or ordering than the forme set foorth by parliament in the time of the late king of most worthy mermory king Edward the 6. or now vsed in the raigne of our most gracious soueraigne Lady c. Doe these words and the godly meaning of them reache onely to the popish Priesthood do they not plainely reache also to any fourme of institution consecration or ordering of any other neuer so much reformed churches beyond the seaâ—â— or in this realme other than the forme set foorth by Parliament in the raignes of king Edward of our now most gratious soueraigne Lady Queene Elizabeth so that the forme of institution consecration or ordering ministers Priestes or Elders which our brethren doe pretend and vrge in this learned discourse the forme that they haue prescribed in their new boke of coÌ„mon prayer these words godly meaning of the statute comprehend theÌ„ And what now if any protestation were ordeined in any reformed churches beyond the seas according to their formes of institution consecrating or ordering or according to that our brethren desire yet read not the articles nor were depriued will our brethren crie out how pitifully that authority was abused which was by the same statute committed to the B. by the negligence of the Bishops and bribery of their officers And although that braunche touche not so much these our Bre. now bicause it saith which doth or shal preteÌ„d to be a Priest or Minister of gods holy word sacraments by reason of any other institution consecratioÌ„ or ordering sith our Bre. as I take it do not pretend to haue bin ordered or made ministers by anye other forme but onely that they should or would bée made ministers by another that is by the forme following the Geneua order set out in their communion booke so that withall it haue the additions of this learned discourse and be in a Synod so escape the danger of the statutes words yet therin they both do much discredite themselues in holding by that ordeyning which they desire to leaue writing against it yet retaining it calling theÌ„selues faithful ministers are made ministers by the very same forme of a B. ordeining them which they condemne to be an vnfaithfull forme of ordeining ministers or rather no ordeining at al except Antichristian being done by the authority of one man besides that they manifestly oppose themselues to the godly meaning of the statute But how soeuer for that point of the Statute ordeined as is aforesaid they will flee for holding their Benefices from the meaninge thereof which neuerthelesse they confesse to be godly to the wordes of the statute that they pretend not to haue bin ordeined by another forme that is allowed in the statute notwithstanding in that part of the statute that
is decreed amongst themselues that must be called the determination of the whole Synode I meruell that our Bretheren shamed nor feared not to stuffe their learned discourse with so many manifest vntrueths It is most euident that nothing is or can bee decreed in the name of the whole Synodes determination without the whole Synode comprehending at least the greatest number for the whole haue decreed and determined the same So that say they no man must bee suffered to speake any thing agaynst it bee it neuer so reasonable or agreable to the worde of God This is another most great and manifest vntrueth sclaunderous to the Bishoppes and reproachfull to the whole Conuocation There is none of the house but that may in any matter that is propounded to bee debated vppon yea any other though not of the house being knowne to be a reuerent godly wise and learned person either of the Ministerie yea in some cases though he were not any Ecclesiasticall person yet might he also bee freely admitted according to the auncient Canons to speake before the house in such sorte and manner as the order of the house requireth for those that bee or should bee learned men to speake their minde in the Latine tongue for feare some young Sir Iohn lacke latine would bee ouer busie and so to reason freely pro contra obseruing alwaies that modestie and reuerence which beseemeth the assemblie of graue and learned men And in this maner many haue propounded and reasoned vpon diuers matters as those that are auncients in the Conuocations heretofore can witnesse Yea saye they whosoeuer will not subscribe to all such thinges as they decree must bee excluded out of the Conuocation as was practised and threatned in the Conuocation at the foresayde Parliament vnto diuers godly and learned Preachers that offered to speake agaynst diuers grosse and palpable errors that had escaped the Bishops Our Bretheren hauing so often broken the squire of trueth in these matters doe here waxe bold to rappe out vntrueths now by huddles What one Preacher hath bene excluded out of the Conuocation for this that he would not subscribe to all such thinges as the Bishoppes among themselues haue decreed Or can they bring any instance but of such one threat made vnto them And albeit a threat differeth from the putting it in practise yet this also is a notorious sclaunder There was no such thing either practised or threatned at any tyme in our Conuocations namely at that tyme they mention which I remember well and so doe many others when some speaking in English began to bee ouer busie and to vse disordered behauiour with vnreuerent termes they were by the Prolocutor as moderator commaunded to silence or els to departe and not to disturbe the house nor alter the lawdable orders thereof except they would and that in seemely modestie speake in Latine which these godly and learned Preachers that our Bretheren commende liked not to doe Neuerthelesse other being indeede godly and learned Preachers did very reuerently and with great learning discusse those matters And so with generall consent either of all or which sufficed of the most and best parte those Articles were condescended vpon and approoued for good and sound doctrine And so I hope will stand for any thing that our Bretheren or any other shall euer bee able to say agaynst them As for any and much lesse diuers grosse and palpable errours that escaped the Bishops I remember none nor can learne of any The Decrees conteyned in the articles aforesayd are published to the open viewe of of euery man if our Bretheren as yet can burthen them with any grosse or palpable errour or with any errour at all though not grosse nor palpable or but with apparance or suspition of errour it were worth the hearing But if there bee no such errour in them who are then worthie the punishing or at least worthie to acknowledge with repentaunce and reuoking this so great a sclaunder For it toucheth not our Bishoppes and the Conuocation onely but béeing established also as is aforesayde by act of Parliament and so the professed doctrine of all the Realme and Church of England how are wee not all hereby defaced to maynteyne grosse and palpable errours and that in no small poynts of doctrine If Papistes had sayd this it had bene lesse meruell which hate our doctrine and count it stuffe full of errours and heresies too But they neuer were nor are nor euer shall bée God willing able to prooue that we mainteyne any one errour in any one article of doctrine but agree in all the substance of Religion with the true and syncere worde of God Yea our Bretheren their selues bearing vs witnesse who in the Preface of this learned discourse confesse that for the substance of Religion it is resolued and now publikly maynteyned for our true and holy faith How could this bee true if those articles namely these which here they note being matter of faith and publikely maynteyned and resolued by all the Church of England to bee true and holie were grosse and palpable errours But to shewe both vnto them and to all the worlde least the Papistes should take holde hereon when they heare of this our owne Bretherens accusation which will bee euen meate and drinke to them béeing glad to feede vppon such sclaunders that as wee are sounde GOD bée blessed for it in all other articles of doctrine so in these wee maynteyne no errour at all but a most sure and syncere trueth let vs come to the viewe of these two Articles that here they mention for example As for the distinction saye they of Canonicall and Apocryphall bookes Although this bee a matter wherein good and godly Fathers haue had some difference yet for our Bishoppes and Conuocations decree thereon I see not how our Bretheren shall bee able to finde that wee holde any error in that matter It is the sixth Article the wordes whereof are these Holy Scripture conteyneth all things necessarie to saluation so that whatsoeuer is not read therein nor may bee proued thereby is not to be required of any man that it should bee beleeued as an article of the faith or bee thought requisite or necessarie to saluation In the name of the holy Scripture wee doe vnderstand those canonicall bookes of the old and newe Testament of whose authoritie was neuer any doubt in the Church Of the names and number of the Canonicall bookes Genesis Exodus Leuiticus Numeri Deuteronomie Iosue Iudges Ruth The first booke of Samuell The 2. booke of Samuell The first booke of Kings The 2. book of Kings The 1. booke of Chroni The 2. booke of Chroni The 1. booke of Esdras The 2. booke of Esdras The booke of Hester The booke of Iob. The Psalmes The Prouerbes Ecclesiast or preacher Cantica or songs of Sal. 4. Prophets the greater 12. Prophets the lesse And the other bookes as Ierome
at Cabellinum especially in the Counsell that he held at Mentz where the Counsell craueth his ayde and confirmation of such Articles as they had agréed vpon so that he iudge them worthy to be confirmed beséeching him to cause that to be amended that is found to be worthy of amendment Which Counsell also giueth God thanks that he had giuen vnto his Church a Gouernour godly and deuout in his seruice who in his time opening the fountaine of godly wisedome doth continually feede the sheepe of Christ with holy foode instructeth them with diuine knowledge c. And in his Edicts set out not only to the Layty but to the Cleargy he writeth thus Charles by the grace of God King and Gouernour of the Kingdome of Fraunce c. Wherefore I thought good to moue you O yee Pastors of Christes Churches ye leaders of his flocke and cleere lights of the world that ye would trauaile with vigilant care and diligent admonition to guide Gods people through the Pastures of eternall life c. Therefore they are with earnest zeale to be admonished and exhorted yea to be compelled to keepe themselues in a sure faith reasonable continuance within and vnder the rules of the Fathers In the which worke and trauell wit ye right well that our industrie shall workâ— with you For the which cause we haue also addressed vnto you our messengers which by our authoritie shall with you amend and correct those things that are to be amended and therefore we haue also added such Canonicall constitutions as to vs were thought to be most necessarie Let none iudge this to be presumption that we take vpon vs to amend that which is amisse to cut off that which is superfluous For we reade in the bookes of the Kings how the holy King Iosias trauelled in going about the circuits of his Kingdome correcting and admonishing his people to reduce the whole Kingdome vnto the true religion and seruice of God I speake not this to make my selfe equall to him in holinesse but bycause we ought alwayes to follow the examples of the holy Kings and so much as we can we are bound of necessitie to bring the people to follow a vertuous life to the prayse and glory of our Lord Iesus Christ. And so he entreth into his rules exhortatioÌ„s to the B. and Priests how they should guide their Diocesses and Churches both by reading and preaching and the Bishops to sende foorth the Priests to preach It belongeth saith he vnto your office O ye Pastors guides of Gods churches to sende foorth through out your Dioceses Priests to preach vnto the people and to see that they preach rightly and honestly that ye do not suffer new things that are not canonicall but forged of their owne minde not according to the holy scriptures to be preached vnto the people yea you your own selues preach the things that are true and honest and that lead vnto euerlasting life And instruct ye other that they doe the same c. Yea Alcuinus in his preface of his treatise on the trinitie which he being his Chaplaine dedicated vnto this French king being then also made Emperour maketh the Prince to haue so farre authoritie aboue all other ciuill persons in Ecclesiast matters that he calleth him also a Preacher and sayth that he hath as it were a priestly office in these thinges And least sayth he I should seeme not to helpe and further your preaching of the faith I haue directed and dedicated vnto you this booke thinking no gift so conuenient and worthy to be presented vnto you seeing that all knowe this most plainely that the Prince of the people ought of necessitie to know all things and to preach the things that please God Neither doth it pertaine to any man to know better or mo things than it doth to an Emperour whose doctrin ought to profite all the subiects c. All the faithfull haue great cause to reioyce of your godlines seeing that you haue a Priestly power as it is meete so to be in the preaching of Gods worde a perfect knowledge in the Catholike faith and a most holy deuotion to mens saluation This authoritie and interest euen in the chiefest Eccl. matters doth that famous Alcuinus a countriman of our owne acknowledge vnto the Christian Prince And the like doth this Emperours sonne Lewes take vppon him and it was yéelded vnto him both in the Councell that he called at Aquisgraue in Germanie and afterwarde in Italy at Ticinum where hee giuing in charge to the Bishops and Councel to consult among other matters concerning the conuersation of the Bishops the Priestes and other Eccl. persons of their doctrine and preaching to the people of writing out of bookes c. He concludeth I am very much desirous to knowe and couet to reforme them according to Gods will and your holy aduise in such sort that neither I bee founde reproueable in the sight of God neither you nor the people incurre the wrathfull indignation of God for these things How this may be searched found out brought to perfection that I committe to be treated on by you and so to be declared vnto me The lesser matters which in generall touch all but that touch some in speciall and neede reformation I will that yee make enquirie also of them and make relation thereof vnto me Whereby we sée that these Princeâ— had the chiefe authoritie in those Councelles and both made Ecclesiasticall lawes them selues with the Bishops aduise and counsell and also all the Bishops decrées and determinations depended on the Princes ratifying This then was the order and not that onely which our Brethren here say we read to be obserued by the Christian Kings of France And euen as much do we read to be obserued by the Christian kings of Spayne by whose authoritie the first second third Councell at Brachara were called and many pointes for doctrine and discipline disposed After whom Richaredus commaunded a Councel to be assembled and holden at Toledo where the king sitting among the Bishops deâ—lareth vnto them how he called them together that he might by the common consultation in the Synode repayre and make a newe forme of Eccl. discipline which had bin long time hindred by Arianisme The which impedimeÌ„t sayth he it hath pleased God to put away by my meanes whereupon he exhorteth them to giue God thankes for his so doing and admonisheth them before they enter into the consultation to fast and pray to God that he would vouchsafe to open vnto them a true order of discipline And so after a thrée dayes fast appointed vnto them the Synode beginning to enter into consultation the king commeth in with his Queene and nobles and sitteth amongest them and causeth the confession of his faith which he had written and subscribed with his and the Quéenes hands to be publikely reade before them