Paris sent to their King in the yeare 1555. after he had sent forth an Edict requiring great severity against those who differed in matters of Religion They professed to him they did not think his Edict equal and that they could not subscribe to it for say they we see that such severe punishments for matters of Religion render men detestible to the people but their errours abide the same still they are not at all altered in their opinions by severity but for their parts they give their judgements that it were better to go in the old way of the Church which did not propagate Religion by sword and fire but by pure doctrine and the good examples of the lives of their Bishops Let them live piously and teach the word of God sincerely this is the way to root out errours that encrease so fast but if this be not done no Lawes no Edicts of men will doe any good Sleidan in his Commentaries hath set down a Decree of the Emperour King Ferdinando and the rest of the Princes and States that the controversie of Religion should be appeased by none other but by godly friendly and quiet meanes But a few pages after he relates the effect of a Petition of those in Austria for their freedom in Religion to King Ferdinando with an answer of the King to them In which there was this passage That such as shall not like that Religion which the Prince hath chosen may have free liberty to sell that they have and go dwell in another place without any blemish to their estimation To which the Embassadors of Austria reply What discommoditie were herein how heavie and sorrowfull newes this would be to the people who seeth not When they shall heare that they which have been ever most ready to spend their bloud and life for the preservation and dignity of the House of Austria must now forsake their most sweet native Countrey so many yeers inhabited and enriched by their fore-fathers Therefore we admit not that Answer in this behalfe but as we have done heretofore for the honour of God we beseech you that you would suffer us to have no let in this matter c. But you will say What does all this tend to but to plead for an absolute Toleration which you seemed before to be against I answer In quoting these Authors I own not such a judgment that possibly you may think to be in some of them for an absolute Toleration How a Toleration should be limited and granted I have spoke to before but I produce the Authors to this end that the rigidnesse of the judgments of some amongst us that think all differences in religion thot cannot be quelled by argument must be quelled bâ— violence may be mollified I am sure if any of these men go too far one way those which I am now reproving goe as wide another Fierce violence in matters of Religion is dangerous as the Chirurgeons rigorous handling his patients arm breaks that bone quite which before was but out of joynt 6. Some take advantage by them to give themselves to loosenes in their lives it is a time of liberty and they will take their time If times were quiet and settled they would be observed more narrowly there would be means of restraint but in these times every man takes his own way and so will they But know that God takes this very ill at thy hands The more loose others are the more conscionable shouldest thou be the worse the dayes are the more circumspectly shouldest thou walk Ezek. 44. 10. The Levites that are gone from me which went astray when Israel forsook me they shall also bear their iniquity The commonnesse of a sin is an aggravation of it 7. Some make no other use of them then to observe which way there may be advantage got by them how they may sute themselves to this side or the other for their gaine or to drive on some private designe so long as they can make use of the times that run such a way they are for them if the stream turn they can turn too they can tack about to every wind their study is not to help to heale them but to contrive wayes how they may get by them Hence they wrench and sprain their consciences with the quick turnings this way and that way they will be on the sunny side wheresoever it be Cunning heads and corrupt hearts will serve their owne turnes by all varieties of times If they were in Dioclesians time they could be Pagans if in Constantines Christians if in Constantius Arrians if in Julians Apostates if in Jovians Christians againe and all this within lesse then the age of a man 8. Some have their spirits in a base manner subjugated by these divisions and troubles that come upon them they care not what they do or submit to so be it they may have peace they will bow down their backs and consciences they will put themselves and posterity under the yoke of perpetuall slavery so be it they may be at quiet and enjoy their estates for the present no matter what becomes of the publick no matter what becomes of the truth They are content to let all go to betray all for their own private advantage This is beneath the spirit of a man 9. Others are discouraged upon the sight of the great evils that daily â—low from our divisions and are like still to flow their hearts sinke in despaire They call into question whether it be the cause of God that we now undertake When the Temple was building there was no noise of hammer axe or any toole of iron heard in the house while it was in building But oh Lord is our work Temple-work We heare the noise not of hammer and axe but of swords and spears of drumms and cannons of railings and revilings these are dreadfull in our eares but let us not be discouraged for though there was no noise heard in the House yet in preparation for the House there was It may be all we are yet about is only preparatory work for the House of our God If God will use us in this only yet blessed be his name Wherefore though our divisions be many and very evill yet they are not so evill nor many but that there may be hope in Israel concerning this thing For consider It is no new thing for divisions to be in the Church THe Apostle would not have us think it strange concerning the fiery triall he means there of persecution The fiery contentions amongst us are another fiery triall We should not think strange of this neither as if such a thing had befaln us that nevâ—r yet befell any I think for all circumstances it is every hard to parallel but the Church in all ages hath been sorely afflicted with divisions Act. 15. 39. Paul and Barnabas two great Apostles were so divided that they could not keep company together but went one from another in anger
Thou shalt not consent unto him nor hearken to him neither shall thine eye pitty him neither shalt thou spare him nor conceale him But thou shalt surely kill him thine hand shall be first upon him to put him to death and afterwards the hand of all the people Let not any put of this Scripture saying This is in the Old Testament but we finde no such thing in the Gospel for we find the same thing almost the same words used in a Prophesie of the times of the Gospel Zech. 13. 3. In the latter end of the 12. Chapter it is prophecyed that those who pierced Christ should looke upon him and mourne c. having a spirit of grace and supplication powred upon them Chap. 13. 1. There shall now be opened a fountaine for sinne and for uncleannesse Vers 3. It shall come to passe that he that takes upon him to prophesie that his father and his mother that begate him shall say unto him Thou shalt not live for thou speakest lyes in the name of the Lord And his father and his mother that begate him shall thrust him through when he prophesieth You must understand this by that in Deut. The meaning is not that his father or mother should presently run a knife into him but that though they begat him yet they should be the means to bring him to condign punishment even the taking away his life those who were the instruments of his life should now be the instruments of his death Thirdly It is a dividing principle because by it the reines are let loose to all kind of wantonnesse and spirit of opposition in the matters of Religion Men naturally are wanton in nothing more then in the things of Religion and corrupt spirits are bent upon and pleased with opposition in these things above any other for being things supposed to have an excellency in them and above reason and so liable to contradiction from men of corrupt minds if there be nothing to restrain men from opposing one another in them the wantonnesse and pride of mens hearts will carry them forth to infinite jarrings contentions and divisions If it be said Christ hath left spirituall meanes to helpe this It is answered Christs spirituall meanes are to work in a spirituall way upon the heart to change it and secondarily upon the outward man while Christs means are working thus externall means may keep evill from breaking forth in the outward man Christ hath not left the outward man at absolute liberty to do what it will till spirituall meanes be made effectuall to the heart especially considering if you grant this liberty men may choose whether any of those spirituall means of Christ should at all come at them The first position that upholds this dividing principle Magistrates have nothing to do in the matters of Religion It must be granted that a Magistrate is not an Officer of Jesus Christ the Mediator in his Mediatory Kingdome There is a two-fold government that Christ hath 1. One as he is God equall with the Father together with the Father ruling heaven and earth 2. Another as he is God and man Mediator in a peculiar Kingdome of his that he hath by way of dispensation from the Father Now the Magistrate is an Officer of God both the Father and the Son in the generall government of the world But he is not the Officer of Christ in that Kingdome of his that he hath by way of dispensation from the Father that Regnum Mediatorum as Divines call it No though he be a Christian Magistrate there are no Officers of that but such as are by divine institution set down in the Word his Christianity doth only adde unto him further ability to execute the work of his Office in a better manner it adds no new authority to him An Infidell Magistrate converted to Christian Religion is thereby better enabled to performe the duty of his place then before but he had the same authority before it was his sinn he did not use his Authority now as he is able to do though he be a Christian who is a Magistrate yet the power of his Magistracy belongs to another Kingdom different from that the second person hath as he is Christ the Mediator But doth not this then exclude him from the exercise of any power in the matters of Christian Religion No for God in the exercise of his power governing the world hath a speciall ayme at the promoting the Kingdom of his Sonne Christ the Mediator Therefore Magistrates exercising this power of God ought to ayme at these ends that God himselfe aymes at in the exercise of his own power that is to be usefull to Christs Government in his Church and for the good of his Church God in all his wayes from the beginning of the world hath aymed at the setting up his Son to be King upon his holy Hill at the promoting of the glory of him who is God-man and if his Ministers doe not make use of their power to this end when this Kingdome of his Sonne comes to be revealed to them he will require it at their hands The power that God invested Magistrates withall in matters of Religion in the Old Testament is so full and cleare in that which God gave to the Kings of Judah and Israel that to name particulars would almost make a volume I find many who write about this subject spend most of their strength here but I wholly forbear mentioning instances in this because it is granted by all that they had power but the argument from thence to the power of Magistrates in the times of the Gospel prevails little with those who hold this Dividing Principle we are now speaking of For they tell us that their power was typicall they in the exercise of such a power were types of the Kingly power of Christ for we find glorious promises of dominion and stability made to Christ in the persons of many of those Kings 2. They tell us that it is no argument because Priests and Levites had in time of the Law power in temporall things in ordering the affairs of the State therefore Ministers should have civill authority now So neither is it an argument because Magistrates had power then in spirituall things therefore our Magistrates should have the like now 3. They tell us that the Church and Common-wealth of the Jews were mixed in one hence to be a stranger from the Church is expressed by being a stranger from the Common-wealth of Israel Ephes 2. 12. and therefore their Magistrates were Church-officers as well as Civill 4. That the people of the Jews were brought up in a more servile way then Christ would have his Church in the times of the Gospel brought up in Compulsion therefore in matters of Religion was more sutable to their condition then it is to our Jerusalem which is free 5. The whole Church was then bound to be under the same State-government the Laws of
their State were by divine appointment their Kings were chosen by God but now Christ chuses his Church out of all Nations of the earth and leaves them to the severall Governments Lawes Officers of severall Nations for their Civill State 1. I confesse were there nothing but meerly examples or Laws from the Old Testament to confute this dividing Posiâ—ion to an examining eye the argument would hardly be cogent or satisfactory only so far as there is a common reason and equity in them and so all the judiciall bind now as well as they did then 2. So far as the New Testament approves of for the times of it what was formerly done in the Old The strength of the argument from the power of Magistrates in the Old Testament lyes in these two First there is a common reason and equity what ever the strength of such kind of arguing be from one Spirituall Ordinances to prove another yet without all question it is strong enough from one Civill Ordinance to prove another though it be conversant about spirituall things It is the Dictate of Nature that Magistrates should have some power in matters of Religion The generality of all people have ever thought it equall It hath been ever challenged in all Nations and Common-wealths The Heathens would never suffer their gods to be blasphemed but punish such as were guilty thereof by the power of the Magistrate Socrates was put to death for blaspheming their multiplicity of gods 2ly Surely there is a common equity for there is a necessity of it as truly now as there was then I cannot argue the being of Spirituall Ordinances from our need of them not thus there is such an institution for the Church hath need of it but rather thus I find it in the Word to be an institution and therefore the Church hath need of it But in naturall or civill things this way of arguing is strong enough there is need of such a help and therefore we should seek to have it Now sure the need we have of such a power is exceeding great we were in a most miserable condition if we had no externall civil power to restrain from any kinds of blasphemies and seducements The condition of the Jews O how happy was it in comparison of ours if this were denyed us for if any one of theirs did blaspheme God or seek to seduce any from him they knew w ht to do with him besides perswading him to the contrary but if any should seek to seduce the wives of our bosoms children of our bodies friends as dear to us as our own lives into those wayes that we think in our consciences will undo their souls to all eternity yet wee must only desire them they would not do so we must only admonish and seek to convince them or reprove them but restrain them we cannot If the deliverance of us from the pedagogy of the Law hath brought us into this condition our burden is greater in this thing then any that the Law laid upon our fore-fathers Hath Christ delevered us from one burden to lay a greater upon us Must we now see those who are dearest to us drawn into the wayes of eternall destruction and stand and look on but no way left to help them or our selves unlesse wee can perswade to the contrary surely our condition is very sad Have we not cause to say Lord let any burthen of the Ceremonial Law be laid upon our necks rather then this If there were a company of mad men running np and downe the streets with knives and swords in their hands endeavouring to mischief and kill all they met with and we must doe nothing to restraine them if we could perswade them to doe otherwise well and good but that is all we can do for help what a dangerous thing were this The case is the same when those who are mad with damnable Heresies run from place to place seeking to draw all they can from the truth If we have no means of help but arguments it is ill with us Surely God hath not put his people into such a sad condition as this is he hath provided better for his people then thus Thirdly wee find in the Record of Scripture mention of Heathen Magistrates who had nothing but the light of nature to guide them interessing themselves in matters of Religion and this the Holy Ghost relates in way of commendation of them for this thing The argument from these examples cannot be avoided as that which is taken from the practice of the Kings of Judah We read Ezra 7. 26. Artaxerxes interposes his power in matters of Religion and Ezra blesses God for it Whosoever will not doe the Law of thy God and the Law of the King let judgement be executed speedily upon him And in the next words Ezra blessed God who put it in the heart of the King by these and other means to beautifie his house The making such a Law was one notable meanes whereby the House of the Lord came to be beautified Thus also Nebuchadnezzar Dan. 3. 29. I make a Decree that every people nation and language who speake any thing against the God of Shadrach Meshach and Abednego shall be cut in pieces and their houses shall be made a dung-hil c. This the Scripture records as a worke of the Kings repentance The King of Nineveh Jonah 3. by the decree of his Princes and Nobles proclaims a Fast and commands every one to cry mightily to God and to turne from his evill way Further let us see how the holy Ghost justifies this power of the Magistrate in the times of the Gospel First in the Prophesies of the times of the Gospel Secondly in divers places in the New Testament For Prophesies the fore-named place Zech. 13. 3. cannot be put off Isa 49. 23. Kings shall be thy nursing fathers and Queens thy nursing mothers The protection of their civil peace is not sufficient to give them such a denomination of nursing fathers and mothers Esay 60. 10. The sonnes of strangers shall build up thy walls and their Kings shall minister unto thee They shall not only be favourers of them but as Kings they shall minister to them even by their power So Rev. 21. 24. The Kings of the earth shall bring their glory and honour to the Church there is such a time coming This surely is more then meerly to protect their outward peace In the New Testament Rom. 13. 4. He is thy Minister for thy good 1 Pet. 2. 13 14. Submit your selves to every ordinance of man for the Lords sake whether it be to the King as to the supream or unto Governours which are sent for the punishment of evill doers and the praise of them that doe well Now seeing the Scripture speaks thus generally For thy good and for the punishment of evill doers and praise of them that doe well Non distinguendum ubi Scriptura non distinguit Except the nature of the thing
too then men who are not conscientious but of turbulent and corrupt spirits will abuse it We have given rules to find out those who onely pretend conscience and if by those or the like it does not appeare but that men are indeed conscientious in their way we should judg charitably of them you think much if those be not admitted to communion with Christ and his Saints when they professe godlinesse in word and life and nothing appears to the contrary why then should you think much to tolerate those as conscientious who professe it in words and life and nothing appears to the contrary Bishop Davenant in that exhortation to peace before quoted as one meanes for peace gives his opinion thus Because it belongs only to God to teach the hearts of men it is our duty alwayes to make the best interpretation of things and to presume of every one where the contrary appeares not by manifest signes that hee is kept from assenting by his conscience rather then by obstinacy As for the peaceablenesse of mens dispositions let it be judged from their carriages in other things of as great moment wherein the temptation for the attaining their owne ends is as great yea far greater then here Do they not carry themselves in as peaceable gentle self-denying way as any Mr. Parker upon the Crosse cap. 5. sect 14. pleads for himself and others who could not yeeld in some things enjoyned them when they were accused of pride contempt unpeaceablenesse What signes sayes he doe men see in us of pride contempt unpeaceablenesse What be our caetera opera that bewray such a humor Let it be named wherein we go not two mile where we are commanded to goe but one yea whether we goe not as many miles as any shooe of the preparation of the Gospel of peace will carry us What payment what paine what labour what taxation made us ever to murmure Survey our charges where wee have laboured if they be not found to be of the faithfullest Subjects that be in the land Wee deserve no favour nay there is wherein we stretch our consciences to the uttermost to conforme and obey in divers matters Are we refractory then other things As Balaams Asse said to his Master Have I used to serve thee so at other times And whereas it is said that some will abuse such liberty at this It is answered Surely those who are peaceable and conscientious must not be deprived of what sufferance Christ allowes them because others who are in the same way are or may prove turbulent and do or may not appear truly conscientious This is as farre beneath the rule of Justice as no sufferance in any thing conceived erroneous is above it Thirdly whatsoever errours or miscarriages in Religion the Church should bear withall in men continuing them still in communion with them as Brethren these the Magistrate should bear with in men continuing them in the Kingdome or Common-wealth in the enjoyment of the liberty of Subjects Grant what possible can be granted to the Magistrate in the extent of his power about Religion to be Custos utriusque tabulae yet certainly no man can imagine that this his charge reaches further then the charge of the Church That he is to be more exact in his oversight of these things then the Church is to be for what ever the power of the Magistrate be in these things yet to the Church especially are the Oracles the Ordinances the Truths of God committed The charge of the spirituall estate of men especially belongs to the Church Now the Church is to beare with men in their infirmities though they be ignorant of many things yea after means used for information No Church must cast off any from communion with it but for such things that all the Churches of Christ ought to cast them off for This is generally held by our Brethren if a man be rightly cast out of communion with one Church he is thereby cast out of all if this be so then surely many things must be suffered before we proceed to cast out a member it must not be for every errour or miscarriage Thus Bishop Davenant in his rules for Peace Those may not be cut off from communion with particular Churches who remaine joyned to the Catholique Church Yea none is to be cast out of communion but for that which if whole Churches were guilty of we must refuse communion with yea with all the Churches in the world if they could be supposed to be so far left of Christ as to be guilty of the same thing If this be so when a Church is about casting any out of communion it need be wary and not presently fall upon him because there is something evill in him and if the Church should be so the civill Magistrate much more whose care of a mans spirituall estate is not so immediate and full as the Churches is From what hath been said these 2. consequences are clear First Articles or rules for doctrine or practise in matters of Religion to be imposed upon men should be as few as may be there is a very great danger in the unnecessary multiplying them This in all ages hath caused divisions and exceeding disturbances in the Churches of Christ I finde an excellent passage in an Epistle of Isaac Causabon to Cardinall Perron which hee wrote in the name of King Iames by his command The King saith he thinks that the things that are absolutely necessary to salvation are not many therefore His Majesty is of that mind that there is no shorter way for peace then first by severing necessary things from things that are not necessary and then to labour a full agreement in those but as for things not necessary let them sayes he be left to Christian liberty And againe These necessary things are few and the King thinks this distinction to be of so great moment to lessen the controversies which this day doe so exceedingly trouble the Church that all who study peace should most diligently explicate teach and urge this God hath so graciously ordered things for the body that things necessary for life are not many nor costly the greatest stir in the world is about things not necessary So for the soule A second consequence from what hath been said is we see hence who is most for peace one professeth what he is convinced of to be a truth and a duty if it be not necessary he is not to force it upon his Brethren though he had never so much power in the Church or State to back him The other holds this principle That whatsoever he thinks to be a duty he must force it upon his brethren not only by the power of the Church but he must call in the power of the Magistrate to back him in it But doe not men in a Congregationall way urge upon others their owne conceptionâ— and practices according to the power they have