Principles of Natural Reason and Religion But when Miracles were perform'd which both for the End and Design of them as well as for the Manner and Circumstances of their Performance had all the Credibility that any Miracle could have if it were really wrought by God's immediate Power to confirm a Revelation if these Miracles have been foretold by Prophecies as on the other side the Prophecies were fulfill'd by the Miracles if they were done publickly before all sorts of Men and that often and by many Men successively for divers Ages together and all agreed in the same Doctrine and Design if neither the Miracles themselves nor the Doctrines which are attested by them can be discover'd to have any Deceit or Defect in them but be most excellent and divine and most worthy of God in such a Case we have all the Evidence for the Truth of the Miracles and of the Religion which they were wrought to establish that we can have for the Being of God himself For if these Miracles and this Religion be not from God we must suppose either that God cannot or that he will not so reveal himself by Miracle to the World as to distinguish his own Revelation from Impostures Both which Suppositions are contrary to the Divine Attributes contrary to God's Omnipotence because he can do all things and therefore can exceed the Power of all finite Beings and contrary to his Honour and Wisdom and Goodness because these require both that he should reveal himself to the World and that he should do it by Miracles in such a manner as to make it evident which is his Revelation But if he both can and will put such a Distinction between False Miracles and True as that Men shall not except it be by their own Fault be seduc'd by false Miracles then that Religion which is confirm'd by Miracles concerning which nothing can be discover'd to be either impious or false must be the true Religion For we have seen that there must be some Reveal'd Religion and that this Religion must be reveal'd by Miracle and we have the Goodness and Truth and Justice of God engag'd that we should not be impos'd upon by false Miracles without being able to discern the Imposture And therefore that Religion which both by its Miracles and Doctrine and Worship appears to be Divine and could not be prov'd to be false if it were so must certainly be true because the Goodness and Honour of God is concern'd that Mankind in a Matter of this Consequence should not be deceiv'd without their own Fault or Neglect by Impostures vented under his own Name and Authority Upon which account the Sin against the Holy Ghost in ascribing the Miracles wrought by Christ to Belzebub was so heinous above all other Crimes this being to reject the utmost Means that can be us'd for Man's Salvation and in Effect to deny the Attributes and very Being of God The Summ of this Argument is That though Miracles are a most fit and proper Means to prove the Truth of Religion yet they are not only to be consider'd alone but in Conjunction with other Proofs and that they must necessarily be true Miracles or Miracles wrought to establish the true Religion when the Religion upon the account whereof they are wrought cannot be discover'd to be false either by any Defect in the Miracles or by any other Means but has all the Marks and Characters of Truth Because God would not suffer the Evidence of Miracles and all other Proofs to concur to the Confirmation of a false Religion beyond all Possibility of discovering it to be so 3. How Divine Revelations may be suppos'd to be preserv'd in the World It is reasonable to suppose that Divine Revelations should be committed to Writing that they might be preserv'd for the Benefit of Mankind and deliver'd down to Posterity and that a more than ordinary Providence should be concern'd in their Preservation For whatever has been said by some of the Advantage of Oral Tradition for the Conveyance of Doctrines beyond that of Writing is so notoriously fanciful and strain'd that it deserves no serious Answer For till Men shall think it safest to make Wills and bequeath and purchase Estates by Word of Mouth rather than by Instruments in Writing it is in vain to deny that this is the best and securest way of Conveyance that can be taken So the common Sense of Mankind declares and so the Experience of the World finds it to be in things which Men take all possible Care about and it is too manifest and much to be lamented that Men are more sollicitous about things Temporal than about Eternal which affords too evident a Confutation of all the Pretences of the Infallibility of Oral Tradition upon this Ground That the Subject Matter of it are things upon which the Eternal Happiness or Misery of Mankind depends Now go write it before them in a table and note it in a book that it may be for the time to come for ever and ever Isa xxx 8. 4. It is requisite that a Divine Revelation should be of great Antiquity Because upon the same Grounds that we cannot think that God would not at all Reveal himself to Mankind we cannot suppose that he would suffer the World to continue long under a State of Corruption and Ignorance without taking some Care to remedy it by putting Men into a Capacity of knowing and practising the Duties of Vertue and Religion 5. Another requisite of a Divine Revelation is that it should be fully promulg'd and publish'd to the World for the general Good and Benefit of Mankind that it may attain the Ends for which a Revelation must be design'd THE Reasonableness and Certainty OF THE Christian Religion PART II. FROM what has been already Discours'd it appears That these Things are requisite in a Divine Revelation I. Antiquity II. Promulgation III. A sufficient Evidence by Prophecies and Miracles in Proof of its Authority IV. The Doctrines deliver'd by Divine Revelation must be Righteous and Holy consistent with the Divine Attributes and suitable to their Condition to whom it is made and every way such as may answer the Design of a Revelation CHAP. I. The Antiquity of the Scriptures AS it is evident from the Divine Attributes that God would not so wholly neglect Mankind as to take no Care to discover and reveal his Will and Commandments to the World so when there was so great a Necessity of Divine Revelation in order to the Happiness of Mankind both in this World and the next it is not to be believed that he would defer it so long before he made known his Will as till the Date of the first Antiquities amongst the Heathen It cannot be deny'd that some Books of the Seripture are much the Ancientest Books of Religion in the World for it were in vain to pretend that the Works in this kind or indeed in any other of any Heathen Author can be compar'd with
World though Men will take no Warning by never so many Examples but have need of continual Advice and Exhortation to keep them from the Commission of them Is there the less Certainty in the Mathematicks because Euclid Apollonius and innumerable others of all Ages and Nations have put forth Books and Systems of Mathematicks in several Forms and Methods When many write upon the same Subject it is an Argument of the Excellency and Vsefulness of it not that they are dissatisfy'd in what has been already said by others but that they think more may be said or that some Things may be prov'd more clearly in another Method with more Advantage to some Capacities and with greater Probability of removing the Scruples of some Men. It is undoubtedly very fit that all necessary Doctrines upon which the Eternal Happiness or Misery of Mankind depends should be treated of in all kinds of Ways and Methods and they cannot be too often discours'd of nor by too many Men that no Objection may remain unanswer'd nor Scruple unobserv'd Though a little may be sufficient upon a plain Matter to wise Men yet too much cannot be said upon a Subject wherein all Men are concern'd And it is the great Assurance of the Truth of Religion and Charity to the Souls of Men that has engag'd so many Authors in this Cause Besides the Primitive Fathers and Apologists Men of the greatest Learning and Abilities in latter Ages have undertaken this Subject having made it their Study and Business to consider the Grounds of our Holy Religion And I think few will pretend to more Judgment to discover Truth or to more Integrity to declare it than such Authors who have had no particular Interest or Profession in reference to Religion but were under only the common Obligations of all Christians which if they had valu'd as little as some others they could with as much Wit and Learning have appear'd in the Cause of Irreligion as any that ever undertook it Many of the most Eminent in all Professions and Callings have been the most zealous Assertors of Religion as I might shew by particular Examples which are in every Man's Memory Indeed I believe few Men have so vain an Opinion of themselves as to think they understand their several Studies and Professions better than such Persons who have given undoubted Evidence of their unfeigned Belief of the Christian Religion Men of the greatest Sagacity and Judgment have not been mov'd with such Objections as others so much stumble at but have liv'd and dy'd the Glory of their Age and an Honour to their Religion such were the Learned Prince of Mirandula and that Learned French Nobleman Mornaeus such were Grotius Sir Matthew Hales Dr. Willis and many besides both of our own and other Nations I shall mention but one more who indeed was so Eminent that I scarce need mention him for he must be already in every Reader 's Thoughts I mean the Honourable Mr. Boyle who was as inquisitive and as unwilling to be impos'd upon and knew as much of Nature perhaps as ever any Man not Inspir'd did and had withal as stedfast a Belief and as aweful Apprehensions of Reveal'd Religion which he endeavour'd to Establish and Propagate not only by his own Writings but by the Labours of others which he Engag'd and rewarded by his Last Will and Testament 2. But Men do not always live answerably to what they profess to believe It were heartily to be wish'd that there had never been any Occasion given for this Objection For though it be very inconsiderable in it self yet it does I believe the most mischief of any because Men naturally govern themselves more by the Example than by the Judgment of others or even than by their own Reason But if we will judge aright the Example of one Man who lives according to the Doctrines of Religion ought to be of more weight with us than the Example of never so many who live contrary to their Profession Because when Men profess one thing and act another their Actions are surely as little to be regarded as their Profession And if we will not believe their Profession against their Actions why should we regard their Example against their avowed Principles and Profession It is in all other cases esteemed a good Argument for the Truth of any thing when Men confess it against themselves And the Motives and Temptations are visible by which they are led aside from their own declared Faith and Judgment this Pleasure or that Profit is the cause of it which every Man can point to But when he who lives conformably to his Principles denies himself when he loses and suffers by it he must needs be in great earnest whereas the others are apparently bribed to forsake that in Practice which notwithstanding they cannot but own in the Theory and Principles This was an old Prejudice against Philosophy That the Philosophers did not observe their own Precepts But it was rejected by wise Men as no Argument against the Truth and Vsefulness of Philosophy It is a great Objection against the Men but sure it can be no Argument against the Things themselves that they are disregarded by those who understand their worth and pretend to have a due value and esteem for them And whoever renounces the Faith or takes up Principles of Irreligion because of any ill Practices of others too plainly declares either that in Truth and Sincerity he never had any or that he is very willing to part with his Religion All Men make some pretence to Reason and those Men most of all who are so apt to decry Religion upon this account That many who profess to believe it do not always live up to its Rules and Instructions But they do not consider in the mean time That Men generally act as much against Reason as against Relgion and that therefore this Objection if it can signifie any thing must banish all Reason and good Sence out of the World If there be no True Religion because so few practise it as they ought there can be no True Reason neither because the Lives of so many Men contradict it And some perhaps would be contented that there should be no True Religion rather than that there should be no True Reason because then they must be no longer allowed to be able to Reason against Religion But if the Truth and Reality of Things depend upon the Practice of Men then the same Religion may be true and false at the same time it may be true in one Age and false in another or true in one Countrey and false in the next and must be more or less true or false in the same proportion as the Lives and Manners of its Professors are more or less vertuous or vicious Indeed this is so unreasonable and unjust a Prejudice against Religion though it be grown a very common one that methinks every Man should be ashamed of it especially Men of Reason
demure Pretenders to Humane Reason and Moral Vertue and the Enemies of Revealed Religion We are fallen into an Age in which there are a sort of Men who have shewn so great a forwardness to be no longer Christians that they have catch'd at all the little Cavils and Pretences against Religion and indeed if it were not more out of charity to their own Souls than for any credit Religion can have of them it were great pity but they should have their Wish for they both think and live so ill that it is an argument for the goodness of any Cause that they are against it It was urged as a confirmation of the Christian Riligion by Tertullian that it was haved and persecuted by Nero the worst of Men And I am confident it would be but small Reputation to it in any Age if such Men should be found of it They speak evil of the things they understand not and are wont to talk with as much confidence against any point of Religion as if they had all the Learning in the World in their keeping when commonly they know little or nothing of what has been said for that against which they dispute They seem to imagine that there is nothing in the World besides Religion that has any difficulty in it but this shews how little they have considered the Nature of Things in which multitudes of Objections and Difficulties meet an observing Man in every Thought And after all Religion has but one fault as they account it which they have been able to discover in it and that is that it is too good and vertuous for them for when they have said all they can this is their great quarrel against it and as it has been truly observed no charity less than that of the Religion which they despise would have much care or consideration for them Thus have some Men dishonoured Religion by their Lives some by an affectation of Novelty some by invalidating the Authority of Books relating true Miracles and Prophecies and others by forging false ones some again by their too eager and imprudent Disputes and Contentions about Religion whilst from hence others have taken the liberty to ridicule it and to dispute against it but so as to expose themselves whilst they would expose Religion And thus has the clearest and most necessary Truth been obscured and despised whilst it has been betrayed by the vanity and quarrels of its Friends to the scorn and weakness of its Enemies However in all their opposition and contradiction to Revealed Religion I find it asserted by these Men that Atheism is so absurd a thing that they question whether there ever were or can be an Atheist in the World I have therefore here proved from the Attributes of God and the Grounds of Natural Religion that the Christian Religion must be of Divine Revelation and that this Religion is as certainly true as it is that God Himself exists which is the plainest Truth and the most universally acknowledged of any thing whatsoever And because there is nothing so true or certain but something may be alledged against it I shall besides discourse upon such Heads as have been most excepted against In which I shall endeavour to prove the Truth in such a manner as to vindicate it against all Cavils though I shall not take notice of particular Objections which is both a needless and indeed an endless labour for there is no end of Cavils but if the Truth be well and fully explained any Objection may receive a sufficient Answer from the consideration of the Doctrine against which it is urged by applying it to particular Difficulties as one Right Line is enough to demonstrate all the variations from it to be Crooked It is very easie to cavil and find fault with any thing and to start Objections and ask Questions is even to a Proverb esteemed the worst sign that can be of a great Wit or a sound Judgment Men are unwilling to believe any thing to be true which contradicts their Vices and the weakest Arguments with strong Inclinations to a Cause will prove or disprove whatever they have a mind it should But let Men first practise the Vertues the Moral Vertues which our Religion enjoins and then let them disprove it if they can nay let them disprove it now if they can for it stands in no need of their favour but for their own sakes let them have a care of mistaking Vices for Arguments and every profane Jest for a Demonstration I wish they would consider whether the Concern they have to set up Natural against Revealed Religion proceed not from hence that by Natural Religion they mean no more than just what they please themselves or what they judge convenient in every case or occasion whereas Revealed Religion is a fix'd and determined thing and prescribes certain Rules and Laws for the Government of our Lives The plain truth of the matter is that they are for a Religion of their own contrivance which they may alter as they see sit but not for one of Divine Revelation which will admit of no change but must always continue the same whatever they can do Vnless that were the case there would be little occasion to trouble them with Books of this kind for the Arguments brought against the Christian Religion are indeed so weak and insignificant that they rather make for it and it might well be said as M. Paschal relates by one of this sort of Men to his Companions If you continue to dispute at this rate you will certainly make me a Christian I shall venture at least to say of this Treatise in the like manner as he doth of his That if these Men would be pleased to spend but a little of that time which is so often worse employed in the perusal of what is here offered I hope that something they may meet withal which may satisfie their Doubts and convince them of their Errors But though they should despise whatever can be said to them yet there are others besides the profess'd Adversaries of Revealed Religion to whom a Treatise of this nature may be serviceable The truth is notwistanding the great Plainness of the Christian Religion I cannot but think that Ignorance is one chief cause why it is so little valued and esteemed and its Doctrines so little obeyed A great part of Christians content themselves with a very slight and imperfect Knowledge of the Religion they profess and are able to give but very little Reason for that which is the most Reasonable thing in the World but they profess it rather as the Religion of their Country than of their own choice and because they find it contradicts their sensual Desires they are willing to believe as little of it as may be and when they hear others cavil and trifle with it partly out of Ignorance and partly from Inclination they take every idle Objection if it be but bold enough for an unanswerable
worought to confirm any sound and useful Doctrine The Confession of the False Gods when they were adjur'd by Christians p. 401. CHAP. IV. The Defect in point of Doctrine in the Heathen Religions The Theology of the Heathens absurd p. 403. Their Religious Worship wicked and impious p. 405. Humane Sacrifices customary in all Heathen Nations p. 406. No Body of Laws nor Rules of Good Life proposed by their Oracles p. 402. But Idolatry and Wickedness approved and recommended by them ibid. CHAP. V. Of the Philosophy of the Heathens The Heathen Philosophy very defective and erroneous p. 411. Whatever there is of Excellency in the Philosophy of the Heathens is owing to Revelation p. 423. If the Heathen Philosophy had been as certain and as excellent as it can be pretended to be yet there had been great need of a Divine Revelation p. 429 CHAP. VI. The Novelty and Defect in the Promulgation of the Mahometan Religion p. 436. CHAP. VII The want both of Prophecies and Miracles in the Mahometan Religion p. 439 CHAP. VIII The Alcoran is false absurd and immoral p. 441 CHAP. IX Of Mahomet That he was Lustful Proud and Cruel appears from the Alcoran it self p. 443 PART IV. CHAP. I. THat there is as great Certainty of the Truth of the Christian Religion as there is of the Being of God p. 447 CHAP. II. The Resolution of Faith The Scriptures considered 1. As Historically true 2. As to their Doctrine which concerns Eternal Salvation p. 451 452. From both these Considerations it follows that they are infallibly True p. 455. In many cases there is as much cause to believe what we know from others as what we see and experience our selves p. 456. And thus it is in the present case concerning the Resolution of Faith p. 460. The Evidence of Sense and of Humane Testimony in this case compared p. 462. The Certainty of both ultimately resolved into the Divine Veracity c. ibid. An Objection from Joh. xx 29. answered p. 467. The Truth of the Christian Religion evident even to a Demonstration p. 470 Newly Publish'd CHristian Thoughts for every Day in the Month with Reflections upon the most Important Truths of the Gospel To which is added Prayers for every Morning and Evening Price 1 s. A Course of Lectures upon the Church Catechism By Thomas Bray D. D. The Third Edition Price 5 s. Very proper to be read in Families A Minister's Counsel to the Youth of his Parish when Arrived to Years of Discretion Recommended to the Societies in and about London By Francis Bragge Vicar of Hitchin Hertfordshire Price 2 s. THE REASONABLENESS AND CERTAINTY OF THE Christian Religion BOOK I. PART I. IN Discoursing of the Reasonableness and Certainty of the Christian Religion I shall use this Method I. I shall shew That from the Notion of a God it necessarily follows That there must be some Divine Revelation II. I shall enquire into the Way and Manner by which this Revelation may be suppos'd to be deliver'd and preserv'd in the World III. I shall shew That from the Notion of a God and the Nature and Design of a Divine Revelation it follows That the Scriptures of the Old and New Testament are that Divine Revelation IV. That no other Books or Doctrines whatsoever can be of Divine Revelation V. I shall from hence give a Resolution of our Faith by shewing That we have the same Evidence for the Truth and Divine Authority of the Scriptures that we have for the Being of God himself because it follows from the Notion of a God both that there must of necessity be some Divine Revelation and that the Scriptures are that Divine Revelation VI. Having done this I shall in the last Place endeavour to clear such Points as are commonly thought most liable to Exception in the Christian Religion and shall propose some Considerations which may serve to remove such Objections and obviate such Cavils as are usually rais'd against the Holy Scriptures CHAP. I. That from the Notion of a God it necessarily follows that there must be some Divine Revelation IN the first Place I shall shew how Reasonable and Necessary it is to suppose That God should Reveal himself to Mankind And I shall insist the rather upon this because it is not usually so much consider'd in this Controversie as it ought to be for if it were it certainly would go very far towards the proving the Divine Authority of the Scriptures since if it be once made appear that there must be some Divine Revelation it would be no hard Matter to prove that the Scriptures are that Revelation For if it be prov'd that there must be some Revealed Religion there is no other which can bear any Competition with that contain'd in the Scriptures of the Old and New Testament My first Business therefore shall be to shew from the Consideration of the Attributes of God and of the Nature and State of Mankind that in all Reason we cannot but believe that there is some Revealed Religion in the World There is nothing more evident to Natural Reason than that there must be some Beginning some first Principle of Being from whence all other Beings proceed And nothing can be more absurd than to imagine that that wonderful Variety of Beings in the Heavens and Earth and Seas which all the Wisdom of Man is not able in any Measure to understand or throughly to search into should yet be produc'd and continu'd for so many Thousand Years together without any Wisdom or Contrivance that an unaccountable Concourse of Atoms which could never build the least House or Cottage should yet build and sustain the wonderful Fabrick of the whole World that when the very Lines in a Globe or Sphere cannot be made without Art the World it self which that is but an imperfect Imitation of should be made without it and that less Skill should be requir'd to the forming of a Man than is necessary to the making of his Picture that Chance should be the Cause of all the Order and Fortune of all the Constancy and Regularity in the Nature of Things and that the very Faculties of Reason and Understanding in all Mankind should have their Original from that which had no Sense or Knowledge but was meer Ignorance and Stupidity This is so far from being Reason and Philosophy that it is down-right Folly and Contradiction From a Being therefore of infinite Perfection must proceed all things that are besides with all their Perfections and Excellencies and among others the Virtues and Excellencies of Wisdom Justice Mercy and Truth must be deriv'd from him as the Author of all the Perfections of which the Creatures are capable And it is absurd to imagine that the Creator and Governor of the World who is infinitely more Just more Wise and Good and Holy than any Creature can be will not at last reward the Good and punish the Wicked For Shall not the Judge of all the Earth do Right
and of seducing and Apostate Spirits without any sufficient Means afforded them to undeceive and rescue themselves Can we suppose that God of Infinite Majesty and Power and who is a Jealous God and will not give his Honour to another should suffer the World to be guilty of Idolatry to make themselves Gods of Wood and Stone Nay to offer their Sons and their Daughters unto Devils and to commit all manner of Wickedness in the Worship of their False Gods and make Murther and Adultery and the worst of Vices not only their Practice but their Religion Can we imagine that the True God would behold all this for so many Ages among so many People and yet not concern himself to put a stop to so much Wickedness and to vindicate his own Honour and restore the Sense and Practice of Vertue upon Earth I shall in due place prove at large That Mankind have in all Ages had the greatest necessity for a Revelation to direct and reform them and That the Philosophers themselves taught abominably wicked Doctrines who yet were the best Teachers and Instructors of the Heathen World And we have no true Notion of God if we do not believe him to be a God of Infinite Power and Knowledge and Holiness and Mercy and Truth and yet we may as well believe there is no God at all as imagine that the God of Infinite Knowledge should take no notice of what is done here below that Infinite Power should suffer it self to be affronted and despised without requiring any Satisfaction that Infinite Holiness should behold the whole World lie in Wickedness and find out no way to remedy it and that Superstition and Idolatry and all the Tyranny of Sin and Satan for so long a time should enslave and torment the Bodies and Souls of Men and there should be no Compassion in Infinite Mercy nor any Care over an erroneous and deluded World in the God of Truth Would a wise and good Father see his Children run on in all manner of Folly and Extravagancy and take no care to reclaim them nor give them any Advice but leave them wholly to themselves to pursue their own Ruine And if this be unworthy to suppose of Natural Parents how much more unreasonable is it to imagine this of God himself whom we cannot but represent to our selves with all the Compassions of the tenderest Father or Mother without the Weakness and Infirmities that accompany them in Humane Parents How unreasonable is it to entertain such a Thought of Almighty God infinite in Goodness and Mercy as to suspect that he would suffer Mankind to make themselves as miserable as they can both in this World and the next without putting a Stop to so fatal a Course of Sin and Misery or interposing any thing for their Direction to shew them the Way to escape Destruction and to obtain Happiness The Fall of our First Parents is known to us only by Revelation and therefore is not to be taken into Consideration when we argue upon the meer Principles of Reason But I consider Mankind as we find it in Fact setting aside the Advantages of Revelation Wicked and abandoned to Wickedness in the Snares of the Devil taken captive by him at his will unable to work out their own Salvation lost and undone without Power or Strength without any Help or Remedy And in this State of the World however it came to pass is there no Reason to believe that infinite Goodness should take some Course and not disregard all Mankind lying in this Condition The great Argument of the Scoffers of the last Days St. Peter tells us would be this That all things go on in their constant Course and that God doth not meddle or concern himself with them Where is the Promise of his Coming For since the Fathers fell asleep all things continue as they were from the Creation 2 Pet. iii. 4. And if no Promise had ever been made they would have had some Reason in their Arguing For that which rendred the Heathen without Excuse was That they did not make use of the Natural Knowledge that they had of God to lead them to the Knowledge of his Revealed Will which they had frequent Opportunity of becoming acquainted withal and had many Memorials of it amongst them in every Nation but they did not like to retain God in their Knowledge And this is the Force of St. Paul's Argument Act. xvii Rom. i. unless this latter Chapter were to be understood as Dr. Hammond interprets it of the Gnostick Hereticks That the Gentiles ought not to pervert and stifle those Natural Notions which God had implanted in their Minds but from the Law of Nature to proceed to find out the Written Law and for this Reason the Bounds of the Habitation of other Nations were determin'd and appointed by God according to the Number of the Children of Israel that they might seek the Lord and might be able to find and discover the True Religion and Way of Worship among that People to whom he had reveal'd himself Deut. xxxii 8. Act. xvii 26 27. They might have been less vicious than they were without the Knowledge of a Revelation and therein they were inexcusable that though they could not free themselves from the Power of Sin yet they might not have given themselves so wholly up to it as to become excluded from the Grace and Salvation to be obtained by the Revealed Will of God And when God has revealed himself all who will not use the Means and by a due Improvement of their Reason endeavour from Natural Religion to arrive at Revealed become inexcusable for their Negligence and Contempt of God and the Abuse of those Talents and Endowments which God has bestowed upon them For when God has once given Men warning and directed them in the way of Salvation and they will not regard it they must be wilfully ignorant if they will not consider that one day is with the Lord as a thousand years and a thousand years as one day and it is Argument of his Patience and Long-suffering that he doth not bring speedy Vengeance upon a disobedient and rebellious World The Lord is not slack concerning his promise as some men count slackness but is long-suffering to us ward not willing that any should perish but that all should come to repentance But the day of the Lord will come as a thief in the night Now this is very well consistent and exceedingly agreeable with all the Divine Perfections that he should give Men Warning of the Evil and Danger of Sin and afterwards leave them to their own Choice whether they will be Righteous and Happy or Wicked and Miserable and then that he should not take the first Opportunity to punish them nor lay hold of any Advantage against them but give them time for second Thoughts and space for Consideration and Repentance but if they abuse so much Patience and Loving-kindness that he should at last come
come hereafter that we may know that ye are Gods Isai xlii 23. But because Things foretold may sometimes come to pass by Chance or it may be in the Power of Evil Spirits to foretell them when they are in Design and Agitation and just ready for Action or to discern Things done at distant Places and to make probable Guesses which may prove true from the various Circumstances of Affairs which they observe in the World We may therefore be assur'd from the Consideration of the Divine Attributes of Goodness and Truth that God will not suffer false Religions to be impos'd upon the World under his own Name by Diabolical Predictions without affording Means to discover them to be such When a Prophet speaketh in the Name of the Lord if the thing follow not nor come to pass that is the thing which the Lord hath not spoken but the Prophet hath spoken it presumptuously thou shalt not be afraid of him Deut. xviii 22. This is the Mark of Distinction between a False and a True Prophet That whatever the latter foretold in the Name of the Lord should come to pass but whatever the first foretold in his Name should not come to pass which implies that God will disappoint such Predictions and not suffer them to come to pass otherwise the coming to pass of Things foretold could be no certain Mark of a true Prophet because they might come to pass by Chance The Prophet which prophesieth of peace when the word of the Prophet shall come to pass then shall the Prophet be known that the Lord hath truly sent him Jer. xxviii 9. But if the Prophecy were not pretended to be in the Name of the True God but were given out with a profess'd Design to entice Men to the Worship of False Gods then God might suffer it to be fulfill'd to prove his People Deut. xiii 1 2 3. For this was consistent with God's Truth and Goodness especially after Warning given and after so clear a Revelation both by Prophecies and Miracles If any Man in this Case would be seduc'd by any Wonder or Prophecy to follow other Gods it must be great Perverseness in him But when Prophecies are deliver'd by many Prophets in divers Ages and different Places all teaching the same Doctrine and tending to the same End and Design in their several Revelations and that End is the Discouragement of all Wickedness and the Maintenance of all Vertue and true Religion these Prophecies have all that can be requisite to assure us that they are from God and God by suffering them to pass so long in the World under his own Name and with all the Characters of his Authority upon them has given us all possible Assurance that they are his and engag'd us in Honour to his Divine Attributes to believe that they really are by his Authority And the Certainty of Prophecies being thus grounded upon the Divine Attributes besides the direct Evidence which they afford to whatever is deliver'd by them they add an undeniable Confirmation to those Miracles which have been foretold and are wrought at the Time and in the Manner and by the Persons foretold by the Prophets and the Prophecies likewise receive as great a Confirmation from such Miracles For Prophecies and Miracles which are singly a sufficient Evidence of Divine Revelation do mutually support and confirm each other and hereby we have all the Assurance that can be expected of any Divine Revelation And therefore as Prophecy is in it self a most fitting and proper way of Revelation so in Conjunction with Miracles it is the most certain way that can be desir'd 2. The Suitableness and Efficacy of Miracles to prove a Divine Revelation It is an extravagant thing to conceive that God should exclude himself from the Works of his own Creation or that he should establish them upon such inviolable Laws as not to alter them upon some Occasions when he foresaw it would be requisite to do it For unless the Course of Nature had been thus alterable it would have been defective in regard to one great End for which it was design'd viz. it would have fail'd of being serviceable to the Designs of Providence upon such Occasions The same Infinite Wisdom which contriv'd the Laws for the Order and Course of Nature contriv'd them so as to make them alterable when it would be necessary for God by suspending the Powers or interrupting the Course of Nature to manifest his extraordinary Will and Power and by the same Decree by which he at first establish'd them he subjected them to such Alterations as his Wisdom foresaw would be necessary We can as little doubt but that He who made the World has the sole Power and Authority over it and that nothing can be done in it but by his Direction and Influence or at least by his Permission and that the Frame and Order of Nature which he at first appointed can at no time be alter'd but for great Ends and Purposes He is not given to change as Men are and can never be disappointed in his Eternal Purposes and Designs But when any thing comes to pass above the Course of Nature and contrary to it in Confirmation of a Revelation which for the Importance and Excellency of the Subject of it and in all other respects is most worthy of God we may be sure that this is his doing and there is still further Evidence of it if this Revelation were prophesy'd of before by Prophets who foretold that it should be confirm'd by Miracle As when Men Born blind receiv'd their Sight when others were cur'd of the most desperate Diseases by a Touch or at a Distance when the Dead were rais'd and the Devils cast out these were evident Signs of a Divine Power and Presence which gave Testimony to the Doctrine deliver'd by those by whom such Miracles were wrought and the Divine Commission and Authority was produc'd for what they did and taught For what could be more satisfactory and convincing to Men or more worthy of God than to force the Devils themselves to confess and proclaim his Coming To cause the most insensible things in Nature to declare his Power by giving way as it were and starting back in great Confusion and Disorder at his more immediate and particular Presence to inform Men that the God of Nature was there This gave Testimony to the Things reveal'd and challeng'd the Belief of all Men in a Language more powerful than any Humane Voice whilst God shew'd forth his Glory and made known his Will by exercising his Sovereignty over Nature in making the whole Creation bow and tremble and obey All which was perform'd according to express Prophecies concerning Christ that there might be a visible Concurrence both of Prophecies and Miracles in Testimony of him And this Dispensation of Miracles was admirably fitted to propagate that Religion which concern'd the Poor as well as the Rich the Unlearned as well as the Learned Miracles were suitable
to the Simplicity of the Gospel and to the universal Design of it For they are equally adapted to awaken the Attention and command the Assent of Men of all Conditions and Capacities they are obvious to the most Ignorant and may satisfie the wisest and confute or silence the Cavils of the most Captious or Contentious And this is what all the World ever expected That God should Reveal himself to Men by working somewhat above the Course of Nature All Mankind have believ'd that this is the way of Intercourse between Heaven and Earth and therefore there never was any of the false Religions but it was pretended to have been confirm'd by something miraculous We may appeal to the Sense of all Nations for the Authority of Miracles to attest the Truth of Religion For whenever any thing happen'd extraordinary they always imagin'd something supernatural in it they expected that Miracles should be wrought for the Proof of any thing that had but the Name of Religion and no false Religion could have gain'd Belief and Credit in any Age or Nation but under the Pretence of them The only Difficulty therefore will be to know how to distinguish True Miracles from False or those which have been wrought for the Confirmation of the True Religion from such as have been done or are pretended to have been done in Behalf of False Religions But here it must be observ'd That it is not necessary in this Controversie that we should be able to determine what the Power of Spirits is or how far it extends and what Works can proceed only from the immediate Power of God It is sufficient that we know that God precides over all that Good Spirits act in constant Subjection and Obedience to him that Evil Spirits act for Evil Ends that Good Spirits will not impose upon Men and that he will not suffer the Evil to do it under any Pretence of his own Authority without affording Means to discover the Delusion And the Question here is not concerning any strange Work whereof God is not alledged to be the Author but concerning such as are wrought with a profess'd Design to establish Religion in his Name Suppose then that there have been many Wonders wrought in the World which exceed all Humane Power and which yet we know not to what other Power to ascribe This makes no Difficulty in the present Case because here not only the Works themselves but the Design and Tendency of them is to be consider'd For Instance Whether the Miracles reported to have been done by Vespasian were true or false by a Divine or a Diabolical Power they are of no Consequence to us he establish'd no new Doctrine and pretended to no Divine Authority but doubted the Possibility of his working them And supposing them true and by a Divine Power the most that can be said of them is that as God mention'd Cyrus by Name to be the Deliverer of the Jews so he might by Miracle signalize this Prince who was to destroy them But the Miracles of our Saviour and his Apostles were wrought with this declar'd Purpose and Design That they were to give Evidence to the Religion which they were sent from God to introduce as necessary to the Salvation of Mankind Having premis'd this I must resume what was before observ'd concerning the Means by which false Prophecies might be detected It has been already prov'd from the Notion of a God that there must be some Divine Revelation and it has been shewn That Prophecies and Miracles are the most fit and proper way of Revelation and that way which Men have ever expected to receive Revelations by If then there have been False Prophecies and Miracles they must be suppos'd to have been either before or at the same time or after those Prophecies and Miracles by which the True Religion was deliver'd if before or at the same time then the same Divine Wisdom and Goodness which obliges God to reveal his Will to Mankind must oblige him to take care that the Impostures of those false Prophecies and Miracles by some Means might have been discover'd But there is great Reason to believe that true Revelations should be first made to Men before God would suffer them to be tempted with false ones and if the false were after the true Revelations then the true Revelations themselves are that by which we ought to judge of all others But to speak more particularly of Miracles which are the present Subject It is inconsistent with the Infinite Truth and Honour and Goodness and Mercy of God to suffer Man to be deluded by false Miracles wrought under a Pretence of his own Authority without any possibility of discovering the Imposture And therefore if we should suppose there had past any time before the Discovery of his Will to Mankind he could not suffer Men but through their own Fault to be impos'd upon by such Miracles but either by the false and wicked Doctrines which they were brought to promote and establish as Idolatry Uncleanness Murders c. or by some other Token of Imposture they might have been undeceiv'd and both in the Old and New Testament God has given us Warning against false Miracles Deut. xiii 1. Mat. xxiv 24. Gal. i. 8. so that we may be assur'd that we are to give no Credit to any Miracle that can be wrought to confirm any other Doctrine than what we find in the Scriptures and if we can but be certify'd that they were true Miracles which gave Testimony and Evidence to them we need concern our selves about no other And the Miracles by which the Scriptures are confirm'd and authoriz'd must be true because there is no precedent Divine Revelation which they contradict nor any immoral or false Doctrine which they deliver nor any thing else contain'd in them whereby they can be prov'd to be false And in this Case that which all the Wit and Understanding of Men cannot prove to be false must be true or else God would suffer his own Name and Authority to be usurp'd and abus'd and Mankind to be impos'd upon in a thing of infinite Consequence without any Possibility of discovering the Imposture which it is contrary to the Divine Attributes for him to permit but either by the Works themselves or by the End and Design of them or by some Means or other the Honour and Wisdom and Mercy of God is concern'd to detect all such Impostures If Miracles be wrought to introduce the Worship of other Gods besides him whom Reason as well as Scripture assures us to be the only True God if they be done to seduce Men to immoral Doctrines and Practices if they be perform'd to contradict the Religion already confirm'd by Miracles in which nothing of this Nature could possibly be discover'd if never so astonishing Miracles be wrought for such ill Designs as these they are not to be regarded but rejected with that Constancy which becomes a Man who will act according to the
the Ammonites were descended from Lot and therefore it must be through their great Sin and Negligence if they did not retain a true Notion of Religion They had Possession given them of the Land they dwelt in by God himself by whom the former Inhabitants a wicked and formidable Race of Giants were destroyed before them as the Canaanites afterwards were before the Children of Israel Deut. ii 9 19. Our Saviour was descended from Ruth the Moabitess And the Ammonites are distinguished from the Heathen Ezek. xxv 7. But as Abraham has the peculiar Character given him of the Friend of God and the Father of the Faithful so his Power and Influence was very great He is said (i) Justin l. 36. 〈◊〉 2. Nic. Damas apud Joseph Antiqu. l. 1. c. 8. both by Justin and Nicolaus Damascenus to have been King of Damascus and the latter further adds that in his own time the Name of Abraham was famous in that City and that a Village was nominated from him being called Abraham's House or Palace He was a mighty Prince among the children of Heth and was respected as such by them Gen. xxiii 6 10. The Saracens and other Arabians were descended from Abraham and Circumcision which was practised by so many Nations being a Seal of the Covenant and a Rite of Initiation must be supposed to have some Notion of the Covenant it self communicated together with it For there is no probability that Circumcision used as a Religious and Mysterious Rite could have any other Original among Heathen Nations than from Abraham and the only Reason brought to prove that it had another beginning amongst them is because it was used upon a Natural Cause and varied in the Time of Administration but the Time might happen to be changed by some unknown Accident and it was always I think used upon a Religious account whatever Natural Causes might be likewise assigned and such the Jews themselves were (k) Philo Moimonid wont to assign as well as that of their Religion and it is possible that in some places the Religious cause of its Observation might be forgot and the Natural only retained Besides the other Sons of Abraham which were many Isaac and Ishmael must have been very instrumental in propagating the true Religion and we can suppose none educated under Abraham or belonging to him but they must have been well qualified for that purpose and must more or less retain the Impressions they had received from him this being the Character which God himself gives of Abraham I know him that he will command his children and his houshold after him and they shall keep the way of the Lord Gen. xviii 19. The Jews make particular mention of the care which both Abraham and Sarah took in instructing Proselytes and Maimonides de Idololatr l. 1. writes that Abraham left a Book behind him upon that Subject Ishmael was the Son of an Aegyptian Mother Gen. xvi 1. and his Wife was an Aegyptian his Sons were Twelve in number and of great Power being styled Princes and their Dominions were of a large extent Gen. xxv 16 18. Isaac was to marry none of the Daughters of Canaan but one of his own Kindred and a Messenger is sent into Mesopotamia to bring Rebekah from thence God directing and prospering him in his Jurney Which Alliance and Affinity renewed with the Chaldoeans could not fail of a good effect for the preservation and advancement of Religion in those Countreys But a Famine being again in the Land Isaac removes to Abimelech King of the Philistines unto Gerar and by him the Beauty of Rebekah was admired as Sarah's had been by Pharaoh in Aegypt and here by Abimelech but tho' he had said she was his Sister as Abraham said likewise of Sarah meaning in that latitude of the word usual in those Countries whereby Women were call'd the Sisters of all to whom they were nearly related yet the Providence of God so order'd it that no Attempts should be made to her Dishonour but the King of the Philistines had a great regard and reverence for Isaac and his Wife the Blessing of God was visible in all his Undertakings he became much mightier than the Philistines and therefore they envied him which occasion'd his remove to Beersheba whither Abimelech with his Friends and Attendance came to enter into a strict League and Covenant with him professing that they saw certainly that the Lord that is Jehovah the True God was with him and declaring him to be the blessed of the Lord Gen. xxvi 11 14 16 26. And for the same reason the Philistines had formerly desired to make a Covenant with Abraham saying God is in thee with all that thou dost c. Gen. xxi 22. Esau at the Age of Forty Years marry'd two Wives of the Daughters of the Hittites Gen. xxvi 34. which tho' it grieved Isaac and Rebekah who would have had him marry with their own Kindred yet must give the Hittites further Opportunities of acquainting themselves with the Religion and Worship of the Hebrews but he marries besides a Daughter of Ishmael Abraham's Son Gen. xxviii 9. which confirmed and strengthned the Alliance between true Believers Esau was the Father of the Edomites and of a numerous Off-spring of Dukes or Princes Gen. xxxvi 9. And according to the Custom and Design of the Book of Genesis the Generations descended from Esau had not been so particularly set down unless they had retained the Knowledge and Worship of the True God The Edomites as well as the Moabites and Ammonites were put into possession of their Countrey by the same Divine Power by which the Israelites became possest of the Land of Canaan and the Children of Israel were not to meddle with them Deut. ii 5. Jacob is sent to Padan-Aram to take to Wife one of the Daughters of Laban and with him he abode twenty Years Gen. xxxi 38. and all which he took in hand prospered so that there was the visible Power and Blessing of God in it as Laban confessed Gen. xxx 27. Isaac was not to leave the Land of Canaan but was forbid to remove into Aegypt when there was a Famine in the Land Gen. xxvi 2. and he was not upon any account to return into Chaldaea or to go out of Canaan Gen. xxiv 6 8. but Jacob went out of it when there were enough of Abraham's House besides to keep up a sense of the true Religion among the Canaanites Afterwards God manifested himself to the Aegyptians by a various and wonderful Providence for the Children of Israel dwelt in Aegypt Four hundred and fifty Years till at last by Signs and Wonders and dreadful Judgments by Judgments upon their First-born and upon their Gods Num. xxxiii 4. they were brought out from thence and the nations heard the fame of it and all the earth was filled with the glory of the Lord Num. xiv 15 21. Thus Chaldaea and Aegypt the most famous and flourishing Countreys in those Ages
the Gods of other Nations did not worship them after their manner and yet the Rites of the Romans themselves in the worship of Cybele Flora Bacchus c. were very scandalous and wicked And all their sports and spectacles which had nothing surely in them that could be proper for Divine Worship were invented and performed in honour of their Gods (p) Quintil Institut lib. iii. c. 8. whence Quinctilian says the Theatre might be stiled a kind of Temple 3. But besides their bloody Spectacles where men were exposed to be killed by Beasts or by one another their Altars themselves were not free from humane Blood For the barbarous cruelty of the Religions amongst the Heathens was such that they were obliged to offer up innocent Men and Children in Sacrifice to their Deities Some of the Rabbins have been of opinion that Jephtha sacrificed his Daughter but others deny it (q) Utcunque autem seres ea habuerit id certum puto esse non reperiri apud Magistros qui ex jure aliquo immolandam eam esse affirmaveâ—it Selden de jure Nat. Gent. lib. iv c. 2. The â—aughters of israel went yearly to lament or to talk with 〈◊〉 as it is in the Margin Judg. xi 40. and all are agreed that if he did sacrifice her he sinned in doing it and we know that Abraham was hindred by a Miracle and a voice from Heaven when he was about to slay Isaac But it was a custom among the (r) Grot. ad Deutr. xviii 10. Phoenicians and Canaanites for their Kings in times of great calamity to sacrifice one of their Sons whom they loved best and it was common both with them and the Moabites and Ammonites to sacrifice their Children The Egyptians the Athenians and Lacedaemonians and generally all the Graecians the Romans and Carthaginians the Germans and Gauls and Britains and in brief all the Heathen Nations throughout the world offered up men upon their Altars and this not on certain emergencies and in imminent dangers only but constantly and in some places every day but upon extraordinary Accidents multitudes were sacrificed at once to their Bloody Deities (Å¿) Diodo Sic. apud Euseb de laudib Constant c. xiii Lanctant lib. i. c. 21. ex Piscennio Festo as Diodorus Siculus and others relate that in Africk two hundred Children of the principal Nobility were sacrificed to Saturn at one time And (s) Euseb Praepar lib. iv c. 16. Macrob. Saturn lib. i. c. 7. Alex. ab Alexand. lib. 6. c. ult Aristomenes sacrificed three hundred men together to Jupiter Ithometes one of whom was Theopompus King of the Lacedâ—emonians And the same custom is found practised amongst the Idolatrous Indians of offering whole Hecatombs of humane Sacrifices to their false Gods (t) Jos Acost Hist lib. 5. c. 19 21. In Peru when their new Ingra was crowned they sacrificed two hundred Children from four to ten years of Age And the Son was wont to be sacrificed for the Life of the Father when he was in danger of death Sometimes the Mexicans have sacrificed above five thousand of their captives in a day and in divers places above twenty thousand as Acosta writes out of the informations he had from the Indians (u) Liv. lib. xxii c. 57. Livy makes mention of Humane Sacrifices at Rome and (w) Plutarch in Marcello initio Plutarch says they continued in his time and it was not till about the time of Constantine's Reign that A final stop was put to so strange and Abominable a Practice for tho it abated very much under Adrian yet it was used when Minutius Felix wrote and (x) Lact. lib. 1. c. 21. Lanctantius mentions it as not laid aside in his time Notwithstanding it is so much against humane Nature as well as contrary to the Divine Mercy and Goodness yet it made up so great a part of the Heathen Religion and was become so customary that it was hard to bring men off from it which at the same time demonstates both how false such Religions were and that men had a most undoubted experience of invisible Powers or else in so many Nations both the Kings and People would never have sacrificed their own Children to their false Gods to avert the evils which they were threatned withal The Persons that introduced the Heathen Religions were either Men of Design who established themselves in their Power and Authority by it as Numa or Men of Fancy and Fiction as the Poets whom Plato would have banished out of his Common-wealth And the Gods of the Heathens who must be supposed to reveal these Mysteries and Ways of Worship were always more wicked than their Votaries whose greatest Immoralities consisted in the Worship of them the gross Enormities not only of Venus and Bacchus but of Saturn and Jupiter are too well known to need any particular relation There was no Body of Laws or Rules of good Life proposed by their Oracles but on the contrary they were in commendation of lascivions Poets or they flattered Tyrants or they appointed Divine Worship to be paid to such as won the Mastery at the Olympick Games or to Inanimate things or they promoted some other ill or vain and unprofitable design as Oenomaus the Philosopher observed and proved by particular instances recited out of him by (y) Euseb Praepar lib. v. c. 34 35. Eusebius The Laws of (z) Plutarch in Lycurg Lycurgus were approved of and confirmed by the Delphick Oracle and yet Theft and a Community of Wives and the Murder of Infants was allowed by these Laws This is enough to shew that the Heathen Religions could not be from God since they taught the Worship of Idols and of Devils and the Mysteries and Rites of them were utterly inconsistent with the Goodness and Purity of Almighty God And whoever doth but look into the Religions at this day amongst the Idolatrous Indians by their ridiculous and cruel Penances and other Superstitions besides the sacrificing of Men and sometimes of themselves as the Women who offer themselves to be burnt with the Bodies of their dead Husbands and the like will soon be convinced that they cannot be of God's Institution The Chineses themselves who have so great a Reputation for Wisdom are like the rest both in their Idolatries and in many of their Opinions and Practices It is evident therefore that none of the Heathen Religions can make any probable claim to Divine Revelation having none of the Requisites to such a Revelation but being but of a late Original not far divulged supported neither by Prophecies nor Miracles from God and containing Doctrines that are Idolatrous Impure Cruel and every way wicked and absurd CHAP. V. Of the Philosophy of the Heathens BUT besides the Religions of the Heathen divers of the Philosopherss pretended to something Supernatural as Pythagoras Socrates and some others and therefore it will be proper here to examinlikewise the Justice of their Pretensions And
But thus much in this place shall suffice all particulars having been largely insisted upon in their proper places And since as sure as there is a God there must be a Revealed Religion if any Man will dispute the Truth of the Christian Religion let him instance in any other Religion that can make a better Plea and has more certainty that it came from God let him produce any other Religion that has more visible Characters of Divinity in it and we will not scruple to be of it but if it be impossible for him to shew any such as has been proved then he ought to be of this since there must be some Revealed Religion and if that Religion which has more evidence for it than any other Religion can be pretended to have and all that it could be requisite for it to have supposing it true and which it is therefore impossible to discover to be false if it were so If this Religion be not true God must be wanting to Mankind in what concerns their eternal Interest and Happiness he must be wanting to himself and to his own Attributes of Goodness Justice and Truth And therefore he that upon a due examination of all the Reasons and Motives to it will not be a Christian can be no better than an Atheist if he discern the consequence of things and will hold to his own Principles for there can be no Medium if we rightly consider the Nature of God and of the Christian Religion but as sure as there is a God and nothing can be more certain the Gospel was revealed by him CHAP. II. The Resolution of Faith HAving proved the Truth and Certainty of our Religion I shall in the last place upon these Principles give a Resolution of our Faith which is a subject that has caused such unnecessary and unhappy Disputes amongst Christians in these latter Ages for in the Primitive Times this was no matter of Controversie as indeed it could not then and ought not now to be 1. Considering the Scriptures only as an History containing the Actions and Doctrines of Moses and the Prophets and of our Saviour and his Apostles we have the greatest humane Testimony that can be of men who had all the opportunities of knowing the truth of those Miracles c. which gave Evidence and Authority to the Doctrines as Revealed from God and who could have no Interest to deceive others but exposed themselves to all manner of dangers and infamy and torments by bearing Testimony to the Truth of what is contained in the Scriptures whereas Impostures are wont to be invented not to incur such sufferings but to avoid them or to obtain the advantages and pleasures of this world And so this Testimony amounts to a moral certainty or as it is properly enough called by some to a moral infallibility because it implies a moral impossibility of our being deceived by it such a certainty it is as that nothing with any reason can be objected against it We can have as little reason to doubt that Christ and his Apostles did and suffered and taught what the Scriptures relate of them in Jerusalem Antioch c. as that there ever were such places in the world nay we have that much better attested than this for many men have died in Testimony of the Truth of it II. This Testimony being considered with respect to the nature of the thing testified as it concerns eternal Salvation which is of the greatest concernment to all mankind it appears that Gods Veracity and Goodness are engaged that we should not be deceived inevitably in a matter of this consequence So that this Moral Infallibility becomes hereby Absolute Infallibility and that which was before but Humane Faith becomes Divine being grounded not upon Humane Testimony but upon the Divine Attributes which do attest and confirm that Humane Testimony and so Divine Testimony is the ultimate ground why I believe the will of God to be delivered in the Scriptures it is no particular revealed Testimony indeed but that which is equivalent to it viz. the constant Attestation of God by his Providence For it is repugnant to the very notion of a God to let men be deceived without any possible help or remedy in a matter of such importance And so we have the ground of our Faith absolutely Infallible because it is evident from the Divine Attributes that God doth confirm this Humane Testimony by his own III. The Argument then proceeds thus If the Scriptures were false it would be impossible to discover them to be so and it is inconsistent with the Truth and Goodness of Almighty God to suffer a deceit of this nature to pass upon mankind without any possibility of a discovery therefore it follows that they are not false Here is 1. The object or thing to be believed viz. that the Revelation delivered to us in the Scripture is from God 2. The Motive or Evidence to induce our Belief viz. Humane Testimony 3. A confirmation of that Testimony or the Formal Principle and Reason of our Belief viz. the Divine Goodness and Truth The object therefore or thing believed is the same to us that it was to those who saw the miracles by which the Scriptures stand confirmed viz. the revealed Will of God and the Ground and Foundation of our Belief is the same that theirs was viz. the Divine Goodness and Truth whereby we are assured that God would not suffer Miracles to be wrought in his own Name according to Prophecies formerly delivered and with all other circumstances of credibility only to confirm a Lye The only difference then between the resolution of Faith in us and in the Christians who were Converted by the Apostles themselves is this that tho we believe the same things and upon the same grounds and reasons with them yet we have not the same immediate motives or evidence to induce our Belief or to satisfie us in these reasons and convince us that the Revealed Will of God contained in the Scriptures is to be believed upon these grounds that is to satisfie and convince us that the belief of the Scriptures being the Word of God is finally resolved into the Authority of God himself and is as well certified to us as his Divine Attributes can render it For they were assured of this from what their own senses received but we have our assurance of it from the Testimony of others The Question therefore will be whether the motives and arguments for this Belief in us or the means whereby we become assured that the Revealed Will of God is contained in the Scriptures be not as sufficient to produce a Divine Faith in us and to establish our Faith upon the Divine Authority as the motives and arguments which those had who lived with the Apostles and saw their Miracles could be to produce that Faith in them which resolved it self into the Divine Authority And this enquiry will depend upon these two things 1. Whether
last Days of the Jewish Dispensation p. 388. The Times of the Gospel meant by the last Days p. 389. St. Paul did not suppose that the Day of Judgment was approaching in his time p. 391. There is no reason to suppose that the last Judgment must be confined to one Day p. 393. CHAP. XXIII Of Sacraments THE Nature and design of Sacraments p. 396. 1. They are outward and Visible Signs of our Entrance into Covenant with God or of our Renewing our Covenant with him ib. 2. They are Tokens and Pledges to us of God's Love and Favour p. 402. 3. They are means and Instruments of Grace and Salvation p. 404. 4. They are Federal Rites of our Admission into the Church as a Visible Society and of our Union with it as such p. 406. The Sacraments of Baptism and the Lord's Supper fully Answer the end and Design of the Institution of Sacraments p. 407. CHAP. XXIV Of the Blessed Trinity THere is no Contradiction in this Mistery of our Religion p. 412 The Distinction of the Three Persons in the Deity p. 413. The Unity of the Divine Nature p. 414. The Difference between the Divine Persons and Humane Persons 417. Other things are and must be believed by us which are as little understood as this Doctrine p. 421. The necessity of the Belief of this Doctrine explained and Defended p. 423. This Doctrine exceedingly tends to the Advancement of Vertue and Holiness and has a great Influence upon the Lives and Conversations of Men p. 427. CHAP. XXV Of the Resurrection of the Dead GOD is certainly able to raise the Dead p. 431. Bodies after their Corruption and the Dissolution of the Parts which Compose them may be restored to Life by the Reunion of these Parts again p. 436. We may rise again with the same Bodies which we have here notwithstanding any change or Flux of the Parts of our Bodies while we Live or any Accidents after Death p. 437. It is not only credible and Reasonable to believe that God can but likewise that he will raise the Dead p. 443. CHAP. XXVI Of the Reasons why Christ did not shew himself to all the People of the Jews after his Resurrection THere are Reasons peculiar to this Dispensation of his Resurrection why Christ should not shew himself to all the People after he was risen from the Dead p. 449. It had not been suitable to the other Dispensations of God towards mankind for him to have done it p. 451 Great Numbers of the Jews being given over to hardness of Heart would not have believed tho' they had seen Christ after his Resurrection p. 452. If the Jews had believed in Christ their Conversion had not been a greater Proof of the Truth of his Resurrection than their Unbelief has been p. 453. The Power of Christ's Resurrection manifested in the Miraculous Gifts bestowed upon the Apostles was as great a Proof of his Resurrection as the Personal Appearance of our Saviour himself could have been p. 454. CHAP. XXVII Of the Forty Days in which Christ remained upon the Earth after his â—â—â—surrection and of the manner of his Ascension MAny things in the Life of Christ before his Passion omitted by the Evangelists p. 459. And likewise after his Resurrection p. 461. What may be concluded from that which we Read of his conversing with his Disciples after it p. 463. The manner of his Ascension p. 465. CHAP. XXVIII Why some Works of Nature are more especially ascribed to God why means was sometimes used in the Working of Miracles and why Faith was sometimes required of those upon whom or before whom Miracles were wrought ALL Creatures act with a constant dependance upon the Divine Power and Influence but things may be said more especially to be done by God himself whereby upon some extraordinary Occasion his Power and his Will are more particularly manifested or his Promise fulfilled p. 469. Miracles are more peculiarly the Works of God because they are wrought without the concurrence or subserviency of Natural Means ib Means used as Circumstances to render Miracles more observable not as concurring to the Production of the effect 470. Christ had given undeniable Proof of his Miraculous Power before he required Faith as a condition in such as came to see his Miracles and to receive the benefit of them p. 471. Whether he required Faith of any before his working of a Miracle who had not already seen him work Miracles p. 481. Great Reason that no Miracle should be purposely wrought for the captious and Malicious p. 482. The case of his own Country-men was particular ib. The case of those who came to desire his Help p. 487. Our Saviour hereby signified that he requires the same Faith of those who have not seen his Miracles as he did of those who had seen them p. 489. CHAP. XXIX Of the ceasing of Prophâ—â—â—es and Miracles THe Antiquity of Prophecies adds to their force and Evidence p. 491. The Cessation of Miracles We read of no Miraculous Power bestowed upon any Man before Moses p. 492. Neither Prophecies nor Miracles in the Jewish Church for more than four hundred years before Christ p. 495. Miracles if common would lose the design and nature of Miracles p. 498. Men would pretend to frame Hypotheses to solve them p. 499. A constant Power of Miracles would occasion Impostures ib. They would occasion Pride in those that wrought them p. 501. No more Reason for Miracles to prove the Christian Religion among Christians than there is need of them to prove a God ib. A Divine Power is notwithstanding evident among Christians living in Heathen Countries p. 502. CHAP. XXX Of the Causes why the Jews and Gentiles rejected Christ notwithstanding all the Miracles wrought by him and his Apostles ASupernatural Grace necessary to True Faith p. 504. Jews and Proselytes were converted in great Numbers p. 508. Many durst not own Christ Others had their hearts hardned p. 511. They had violent prejudidices against the Gospel p. 512. The Signs and Wonders of false Prophets a cause of the Infidelity of the Jews p. 514. The unbelief of the Jews being foretold by the Prophets is a confirmation of the Gospel p. 515. Great Numbers of the Heathens converted p. 516. The cause of unbelief in the Philosophers ib. Of Epictetus and Seneca p. 518. The prejudices of the Gentiles p. 521. They would not be at the Pains rightly to understand the Christian Religion p. 522. Oracles had foretold that it should not last above 365 Years p. ib. Heresies and Schisms gave great Scandal p. 523. Many Heathens however had more favourable and just Thoughts of the Christian Religion p. 524. Of the Writings of the Heathens against it p. 528. The Writings of the ancient Jews confirm it p. 530. CHAP. XXXI That the Confidence of Men of false Religions and their Willingness to suffer for them is no prejudice to the Authority of the True Religion THe Martyrs for the Christian Religion more
fitting to reveal such things to us as are above our understandings but then we must be contented to take his word for the Truth of them and not apply our Principles and Maxims taken from things of an inferiour Nature to things of which we can have no conception but from revelation which would be as absurd as for a deaf man to apply the Notion which he has of Colours to Sounds or for a blind man to fancy that there is no such thing as Colours because he is told they cannot be heard And there must be a due proportion between the Faculty and its object For the Faculties both of our Bodies and Minds are confined and limited in their exercise about their several objects The parts of Matter may be too small and fine to be any longer discerned or perceived by sense For only Bodies which are so big as to reflect a due quantity of Rays to the eye can be perceived by the sight it self the quickest and subtilest of all our senses And as objects in their bulk are sensible but are insensible in their minute parts so it is in the inward sensations or preceptions of the mind in respect of its objects We may puzzle and perplex our selves in the deductions which may be made from the most common Notions Nothing is more certain and familiar to our Minds than our own thoughts that we think and understand and will we all know but what is the principle and subject of thought in us and how our understanding and will act upon and determine each other is matter of perpetual dispute The summ of this argument is that our Faculties are finite and of no very large extent in their operations but are confined to certain objects and limited to certain bounds and periods Both our Natural and Acquired knowledge is conversant about certain kinds of objects and our Faculties are fitted and suited to them and from the properties and affections which we observe in them we form Notions and make Conclusions and raise Maxims and Axioms Now if we apply our Natural Notions to things which we know only by Revelation we must be very liable to great mistakes about them For thus it is in things not so much out of the reach of our capacities and which are not of a spiritual Nature if we frame speculative and abstract Ideas from the Principles and Maxims which are formed in our Minds from sensible objects we may soon puzzle our selves and seem to demonstrate contradictions which demonstrates only that all arguments of this Nature are vain and unconcluding And therefore it must be absurd to reject the Mysteries of Religion because they will not come under the Rules of Logick and Philosophy when they are acknowledged to be incomprehensible and therefore not to be judged of as to the Manner and Nature of them by the Rules and Principles of Humane Sciences What has been here alledged concerning the Contradictious about the divisibility of Matter is no more than has been generally confest by the best Philosophers and Mathematicians And the excellent Mr Boyle having produced the Testimony of Galileo and Des Cartes upon this subject concludes with this observation (a) Considerat about the Reconcileableness of Reason and Religion Sect 2. If then such bold and piercing Wits and such excellent Mathematicians are forced to confess that not only their own Reason but that of Mankind may be passed and non-pluss'd about Quantity which is an object of contemplation Natural nay Mathematical and which is the subject of the rigid demonstrations of pure Mathematicks why should we think it unfit to be believed and to be acknowledged that in the attributes of God who is essentially an infinite being and an ens singularissimum and in divers other divine things of which we can have no knowledge without Revelation there should be some things that our finite understandings cannot especially in this life clearly comprehend II. Every man believes and has the experience of several things which in the Theory and Speculative Notion of them would seem as incredible as any thing in the Scriptures can be supposed to be It was well observed by (b) Sunt onim plurima vera quidem sed parum credibilia sicut falsa quoque frequenter verisimilia Quintil. Institut l. 4. c. 2. Quintilian aad may be observed by any one that will consider it that very many things are true which scarce seem credible and as many are false which have all the appearance of Truth and yet the cause of unbelief in matters of Religion is chiefly this that we are hardly brought to believe any thing possible to be done which we never saw done and judge of things not from any principle of Reason but from our own experience and make this the measure of what is possible to be not considering that many things may be altogether as possible which we never knew done and that we should think many things impossible of which we have the daily experience if we had never seen nor known them to be For what we have the daily experience of we are apt to think very easy and scarce suspect that there can be any difficulty in it but frame to our selves some kind of account of it and please ourselves perhaps with a conceit that we perfectly understand it and conclude that such and such things must needs come to pass from the causes which we assign For when a thing is common and familiar to us we either take no pains at all to consider the nature of it or when we do observe and consider it being ashamed to confess our own ignorance we perswade ourselves that there is no such great difficulty in it but fancy we understand the true Reason and Cause of it And if it were not for the carelesness of some in not minding the wonderful effects of Nature and the Pride of others in fancying that they are ignorant of nothing which is the constant object of their senses I am perthat there are several things in the World which we daily see and experience that would seem as wonderful almost as the Resurrection itself or any Mystery in Religion The greatest Philosophers have been able to give but a very imperfect account of the most ordinary and obvious things in Nature and if we had only a relation of them without any tryal or experience we should be inclin'd to conclude them impossible The King of Siam it is said would not believe the Dutch Ambassador but thought himself affronted when he was told by him that in Holland Water wou'd become so hard in cold weather that Men or Elephants might walk upon it and the relations of things in those Countries would have seem'd as strange to us if the constant report of men who have been there had not made them familiar to us It was formerly disbelieved nay absolutely deny'd as absurd and impossible that there could be any such place as that which is now known
caused the Christians in their Apologies to press earnestly for a fair and impartial Hearing of their Cause beseeching their Enemies that they would not be so injurious to the Truth and to themselves as to despise and condemn what they did not understand They were desirous to undergo any Tryal if they might but be admitted to be heard 6. Yet many who did not actually become Christians had more favourable and just Thoughts of the Christian Religion (l) Ael Lamprid. in Alex. Severo Alexander Severus had the Effigies of Christ in his Chappel and had designed to erect a Temple for the Worship of him and to insert his Name among the Heathen Gods As it is reported that Adrian likewise with the same Intention had commanded Temples to be built without Images in all Cities but was dissuaded by some who consulted the Oracles about it which gave out that all Men would then become Christians and the other Temples would soon be forsaken This which is related concerning Adrian has been by some supposed to be a mistake because the Fathers say nothing of it But Ael Lampridius or rather Spartianus who mentions it being a Heathen might perhaps have it from the Gentiles for it was only in Adrian's Intention to set up the Worship of Christ which might be unknown by the Christians of his time the design being laid aside upon consulting the Oracles It was certainly reported in the Historian's time as he declares and yet this Objection lies as well against the Report as against the Reality of the thing For it is strange that a Report of this nature should be mentioned by no Christian Writer though there had been no Truth in it (m) Euseb Hist lib VII c. 11 Aemilianus the Prefect of Egypt asked Dionysius Bishop of Alexandria when he was brought before him why if he whom the Christians Worshipped be God they could not Worship him with the other Gods Many admired the Doctrin and were convinced of the Truth of the Christian Religion who could not free themselves from the Prejudices of their Education they would have been willing to have it taken in among others but could not bring themselves to relinquish all their old Religions for it The Calumnies raised against the Christians had caused the popular Odium and Rage against them but they were Vindicated by (n) Plin. lib. X. Epist 97. Just Mar. Apol. 2. Eus Hist lib. IV. c. 8 9 13. Pliny in an Epistle to Trajan by Serenius Granianu◠Proconsul of Asia in his Epistle to Adrian by Adrian himself in his Rescript by Antoninus Pius in his Epistle to the Common Council or the Community of the Estates of Asia though some ascribe this Epistle to M. Antoninus not to mention his Epistle to the Senate of Rome (o) Just Martyr Dial. Trypho the Jew likewise frees them from the Crimes commonly laid against them and owns the Excellency of their Precepts contained in the Gospel And it is observable that those Crimes which had been wont to be objected against the Christians by their former Adversaries were not mentioned by Julian in Discourses written to oppose them who (p) Epist 49. Fragm Epist p. 305. elsewhere speaks of them in such a manner and so much to their commendation as shews the mighty force of Truth which could extort it from him But the Fear and Shame of Men hindred divers from embracing the Christian Religion who had a truer Notion of Things than to approve of their own (q) Aug. Civit. Dei lib. VI. c. 11. Seneca exposed the Heathen Worship and express'd himself with bitterness against the the Jews but being able to find nothing to blame in the Christian Religion nor daring to commend it for fear of giving Offence to the Heathens he made no mention of it at all These and such as these were the Occasions of the Unbelief of the Jews and Gentiles Though it must be confessed that there is nothing more difficult to be accounted for than the Notions and Actions of Men it is as hard to give an Account how (r) Senec. de Ira. lib. I. c. 25. Plut. in Lycurg Seneca and Plutarch should allow of the Murdering or Starving of poor Infants as they certainly did as why they were not Christians No Phaenomena in Nature can be more variable and uncertain in their Causes than the Opinions and Practices of Men which differ according to their Tempers and Capacities and Circumstances it is sufficient if we can find out any probable Solution and have several to offer which might take place according to several Cases But the Writings of such as opposed the Christian Religion were very slight and frivolous containing a Confession for the most part of the principal Matters of Fact upon which our Faith is established and raising only some weak Cavils which never came up to the main Cause or undertook to disprove the Truth of the Miracles and Prophecies upon which it is founded They could not deny the Miracles upon which our Religion is established and then let any Man judge what Reasons they could have for their Infidelity And indeed the prevaling of the Christian Religion under all manner of Disadvantages as to Humane Means shewed that the Adversaries of it had little to say against it For they must be but poor Arguments which could not dissuade Men from becoming Christians when they must incurr all the Dangers and Sufferings of this World to be so The Books of the first Heathen Writers against the Christian Religion are frequently cited by St. Jerom and St. Austin and other Authors of their Time as commonly known and probably they were extant long after So that their Arguments were baffled and destroyed long before the Books themselves and they had Time and Opportunity enough to do all the Mischief that they were capable of And their Writings are not yet so far lost but that we still know their Principal Arguments which the Christian Writers have not concealed but have given them their full Force and commonly in their own Words Origen was so careful to omit nothing considerable which Celsus had alleged that he was often forced to make Apologies for mentioning the same things over again rather then he would seem to let any things pass which was Material that his Adversary had said without taking Notice of it (s) Ambr. lib. 2. Epist 11. Aug. Epist 43. And some Pieces are preserved entire as the Petition of Symmachus among the Epistles of St. Ambrose and the Epistle of Maximus Madaurensis among those of St. Austin The Arguments of Julian are set down at large by St. Cyril and we Learn from (t) 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Vid. Spanhem in Julian oper Praefat St. Chrisostom that the Books of the Philosophers against the Christian Religion were neglected and despised by the Gentiles themselves and were scarce to be found but among the Christians before the Edict of Theodosius Junior to prohibit them There
was a long Succession of Philosophers and Sophists who made it their business to oppose the Christian Religion The Shool of Platonists which continued at Athens for some Ages would revive or reinforce any Arguments that had been used by their Predecessors in Opposition to Christianity Proclus and Damascius who were of this School lived about the middle of the Sixth Age and the Writings of Damascius were extant (u) Phot. cod CLXXXI CCXLII. LXXVII in Photius's time in the middle of the Ninth Age the History of Eunapius was then likewise extant and is (x) Voss de Graec. Hist said to be preserved at Venice We have the Abridgment of it by Zosimus and a sufficient Specimen of his malicious Invectives in his other Writings And it is probable that these and many other Books of the like nature which are now lost continued much longer than any Accounts which we have now remaining of them mention Of about Thirty Answers (y) Holstein de Vit. Script Porphyt c. 10. which were written to Porphyry by several Authors not one of them is now to be found When the World was satisfied of the insufficieny of his Objections the Answers to his Books were as little regarded as the Books themselves but underwent the same Fate with them The Jews who from the beginning of Christianity before but especially since the Destruction of Jerusalem have in vast Numbers been spread all over the World and have ever been the most implacable Enemies of the Gospel had the greatest Opportunity to detect any falshood in it and have never omitted any Advantage of improving and enforcing the Arguments against it and and therefore would be sure to retain any thing considerable which had been objected by their Fore-Fathers or by the Heathens with whom they conversed The Jews have been a perpetual restless Enemy in all Parts and Ages of the World and nothing material in this Case would escape their Observation But out of the Writings of the Ancient Jews which are still extant many things have been alleged by many Learned Men of our own and other Nations in confirmation of our Religion from the Confession of the Jews themselves The Unbelief therefore both of the Jews and Gentiles of those Ages is no material Objection nor altogether so unaccountable as the Unbelief of too many now who were born among Christians and have had their Education in the Christian Religion The Truth is Example is always the weakest Argument in any Case and can be of no Force or Authority against the clearest rational Evidence CHAP. XXXI That the Confidence of Men of false Religions and their Willingness to suffer for them is no Prejudice to the Authority of the True Religion THE Christian Religion doth infinitely surpass all others in the Number of its Martyrs of both Sexes of every Age and Nation and Rank and Condition Mistaken ignorant Zealots may often have suffered for other Religions but Men of the highest Station and Worth and inferiour to none in the Knowledge and Experience of every thing that the World esteems Excellent have renounced all and upon choice and after a full consideration of the Merits of the Cause have laid down their Lives for the sake of the Gospel Tyrants of the greatest Power and Cruelty have made it their Aim and Ambition by all sorts of Tortures to extirpate the Christian Religion they esteemed their Persecutions matter of Triumph and a fit subject for the (a) Gâ—uter Inscript p. 238 280. Inscriptions of Monuments erected to their Memories But the invincible Patience and glorious Sufferings of the Christians prevailed against all the Rage and Force of their Enemies If the Martyrologies of all Religions were to be compared there would soon appear so manifest a difference between the Christian Martyrs and the Sufferers for other Religions that nothing would be needful to be said upon this subject But remembring with whom I have to deal I am resolved to take every thing at the lowest and argue with them upon their own Terms Let us for a while set aside whatever of this nature might be said in preference of the Christian Martyrs and suppose the Numbers and Zeal of the Martyrs for so we must call them at present of other Religions to have been as great as can be imagined yet the Cause it self makes a plain difference between them An ignorant Zeal in a wrong Cause is no Argument against the Goodness of any Cause which is maintained and promoted by such a Zeal as is reasonable and proceeds upon sure Grounds Indeed it were very hard and very strange if that which is true should be ever the less certain or the less to be regarded and esteemed because there may be other things that are false of which some Men are as firmly persuaded and are as much concerned for them as any one can be for the Truth it self And yet this is the wisest thing that many have to pretend against the certainty of the Religion in which they were Baptised that there are many Impostures in the World and none is without its Zealots to appear in Vindication of it I am confident no Man ever parted with any thing but his Religion upon so weak a Pretence A false Religion is not the only thing for which Men are wont to have an undeserved Value but their Country their Friends and themselves they are commonly as much mistaken in and do as highly overprize Is there then no real difference or solid worth in any of these Some of the most unlikely Countrys in the World have been admired by the Natives as if they were the Garden of Eden and the Place of Paradise Though there is nothing easier than to make a distinction concerning different Countrys And it is as easie to distinguish between the Elysium of the Heathens or Mahomet's Paradise and the Kingdom of Heaven and between the Ways which lead to them There is nothing especially if it be of any Moment and Consequence to them for which Men have not shewn themselves passionately concerned and it is not to be expected that they should be so much more infallible in Religion than in other things or should be so much less in earnest about it as not to discover the same Frailties and the same Affections which are visible in all the other Actions and Business of their Lives It is often seen in most Cases that some are as earnest and zealous in a false Cause as others are in a True but doth this prove that there is no difference between Falshood and Truth When two Men of opposite Parties are equally confident of the Goodness of their Cause it is certain that but one of them can be in the right and it is as certain that one of them must be at least so far in the right as he contradicts the other because as the two Parts of a Contradiction cannot be both True so they cannot be both False If then a confident and zealous
Persuasion doth not determine Right and Wrong True and False the remaining difficulty is how to distinguish them and that must be by the proper Evidence and the intrinsick Goodness of the Cause And our Evidence in behalf of our Religion is plain matter of Fact as the Death and Resurrection and Ascension of our Blessed Saviour and the Miracles wrought by him and his Apostles And if our Religion has sufficient Proof of what we assert in matter of Fact and other Religions have not sufficient Proof of that Authority to which they lay claim this must determine the Point though a Mahometan or Pagan should be as zealous for his Religion as a Christian can be It is commonly and truly said that it is not the Suffering but the Cause which makes the Martyr and if Men of False Religions have never so much Confidence of the Truth of them and have no Ground for it this can be no Argument against the Grounds and Proofs upon which the Evidence of the Christian Religion depends Other Religions may have their Zealots who offer themselves to die for them but the Christian Religion properly has the only Martyrs For Martyrs are Witnesses and no other Religion is capable of being attested in such a manner as the Christian Religion no other Religion was ever propagated by Witnesses who had seen and heard and been every way conversant in what they witnessed concerning the Principles of their Religion no Religion besides was ever preached by Men who after an unalterable Constancy under all kinds of Sufferings at last died for asserting it when they must of necessity have known whether it were true or false and therefore certainly knew it to be true or else they would never have suffered and died in that manner for it no other Religion was ever attosted from its first Propagation for several Hundreds of Years together by Men who had either seen the first Preachers themselves or had been acquainted with others who had seen them or had wrought Miracles and seen others work them no other Religion is contained in Books which were written at the first Propagation of it and dispers'd into all Countries in all Languages amongst all sorts of Men and especially amongst those who were most concerned and most able and desirous to disprove it if it had been false no Religion besides has by so weak and unlikely means prevailed over all the Power and Policy of the World none is in its Doctrin so agreeable to Reason and so worthy of God for its Author and none has been delivered down with so clear a continued and uninterrupted Testimony through all Ages and conveyed by a succession of Testimonies to this present Age And therefore no other Religion can have Martyrs who can die in confirmation of such a Testimony as this or who can be Martyrs and Witnesses to it by assuring the World at their Death that they have received the Religion thus testified and confirmed for which they die It is not the bare asserting a thing boldly and then dying for it which makes a Martyr but the Qualifications necessary in a Witness are necessary in him that is that he should have all Opportunities needful to know the Truth as well as no Temptation to speak the contrary Which Qualifications were evident in the Apostles and first Martyrs whose Testimony is that upon which the Proof of our Religion is founded and the Martyrdoms of latter Ages are additional Testimonies which without the former would be insignificant but supposing them are all the Testimony that can be given to any matter of Fact at this distance of Time and are as much beyond the Sufferings in behalf of any other Religion as the Evidence of the Christian Religion is beyond the Evidence for all others It is not merely Zeal though it proceed even to Death and Martyrdom upon which we build our Faith but the Reasons which Christians have for their Zeal Divers Nations have been as earnest Assertors of their Fabulous Antiquities as others can be of theirs which are known to be true but are these ever the less or those ever the more true upon that account We insist upon it that we have Books to shew and clear Evidence to produce for what we maintain and these have been examined by many Men in every Age and compared with what is to be alleged in behalf of contrary Religions and Men of the greatest Learning and Judgment and Prudence have chosen to die rather than to renounce this Religion for any other after the nicest and most impartial Examination they could make Whereas the Zealots and Martyrs for the Religions which are contrary to Christianity must be acknowledged to be Men that understand nothing of Antiquity but are ignorant of the History of their several Religions and take all upon uncertain Report and absurd Traditions without any Proof or Possibility of it and even against manifest Reason and the Evidence of undoubted History So plain is it that the Zeal and Confidence of Men of false Religions and their willingness to die for them can be no prejudice to the Authority and Certainty of the true Religion The Enthusiasms and vain Notions and Conceits of some Zealots can be no more a Prejudice to the Truth and Reality of our Religion than it is an Argument against the Truth and Certainty of Human Reason that there are so many Fools and Madmen in the World CHAP. XXXII That Differences in Matters of Religion are no Prejudice to the Truth and Authority of it THere is nothing which has proved a a greater Snare and Scandal to weak Minds nor which gives the Enemies of Religion greater Advantage as they think against it than the Dissentions amongst Christians and the different Sects and Parties into which they are divided This makes some willing to conclude that there is no certainty on any side when they see equal Zeal and equal Confidence in Men of all Persuasions that contend for their several Opinions But St. Paul writes to the Corinthians that there must be not only Divisions but Heresies also and not only that they must be but that they are not without their use and expediency in the Church They are so far from being any real Prejudice to the Truth and Certainty of Religion that they do indeed conduce to manifest the Excellency of it and the Sincerity of those that profess it For there must be also Heresies among you that they which are approved may be made manifest among you 1 Cor. xi 19. From whence I shall shew I. That Differences in matters of Religion must be among Christians unless God should miraculously and irresistibly interpose to prevent them II. That it is not necessary nor expedient that God should thus interpose III. That these Differences how great and how many soever they be even the worst of Schisms and Heresies are no prejudice to the Truth and Authority of Religion I. That Differences in matters of Religion must be among
they held a Correspondence after their Separation and lived long to educate and train up their Children in that Knowledge of God which they had received and been instructed in themselves and besides they had little else to discourse upon but such things as would necessarily lead them to it The History of their own Nation and Family is that which Men are naturally most fond of and in these Ages the Particulars could be but few and those very remarkable and almost within the memory of some yet living and every Occurrence must bring to their remembrance what they had heard and had been taught concerning God and his Dealings with them and their Forefathers Moreover there was the special Hand of God and a particular Over-ruling Providence in the Dispersion and Division of Nations For when the most High divided to the nations their inheritance when he separated the sons of Adam he set the bounds of the people according to the number of the children of Israel Deut. xxxii 8. He determined the bounds of their habitation that they should seek the Lord if haply they might feel after him and find him Act. xvii 26 27. This was the reason of the Division of the Nations according to the number of the children of Israel There was a particular regard had to the Number of the Chosen Seed that they might bear a fit proportion to the rest of Mankind and might be as so much Leaven to the whole Mass as a quickning and enlivening Principle to excite and maintain due Apprehensions of God and his Worship and Service in the World And this is the Reason given why Polygamy was permitted them That they who were the peculiar People of God and were to teach his Commandments to the rest of the World might sufficiently encrease and multiply For though it appears by our Registers (g) See Graunt on the Bills of Mortality that here more Males are born than Females to a considerable disproportion and that therefore Polygamy amongst us would not tend to the multiplication of Mankind but rather to the contrary yet in Judaea it might be otherwise or the Captive Women whom they were permitted to marry might raise the number of Females above that of the Males or their perpetual Wars lessen'd the number of Males to a degree beneath the Females However this is the reason alledged by learned Men why Polygamy which was not permitted from the Beginning should be allowed the Israelites for indeed it was of great cousequence that they should multiply so as to have a due proportion to the rest of the World and for the same reason the surviving Brother was to raise up Seed to the deceased Barrenness was a Reproach and to die Childless a Curse and a numerous Off-spring a Blessing so often promised that it is evident that many Dispensations of the Divine Providence depended upon it And the better to revive and keep up a Sense of Religion amongst Men those who were most eminent for Piety were employed to be God's Heralds and Embassadors to the rest of the World as the whole People of Israel are appealed to as his Witnesses Isai xliii 12. and xliv 8. The Jews have a Tradition (b) S. Hierom Quaest. in Genes S. August Quaest in Genes l. v. qu. 25. That Abraham refusing to worship the Fire the God of the Chaldaeans was thrown by them into it and was delivered out of it by Miracle And therefore they understand it not that he went forth from Vr of the Chaldees as it signifies a Place but from the Fire of the Chaldees Vr in the Hebrew Tongue signifying Fire But we have no need of recourse to such Traditions This is certain Abraham was sent by God's Command out of Chaldaea into Canaan and there he had no fix'd or settled Habitation but journeyed going on still towards the South Gen. xii 9. till a Famine happening in that Countrey the Providence of God so disposed of Things that He and Lot went into Aegypt And when he was there he was by a very remarkable Accident taken great notice of by Pharaoh himself For Pharaoh admiring the Beauty of Sarah Abraham's Wife takes her into his House for which great Plagues were inflicted on him and his Houshold and Pharaoh perceiving the reason of it sends him away with his Wife and all that he had By this it became notorious to Pharaoh and his Princes that Abraham was under God's peculiar Care and Providence and that therefore it concerned them to regard what he professed concerning Religion and the Worship of God Abimelech likewise King of Gerar sent and took Sarah Upon which God appeared to him in a Dream and declared to him that Abraham was a Prophet and that he should pray for him and this Abimelech told to all his servants Gen. 20.7 8. and he calls upon God by his Name Jehovah ver 4. which shews that he had Knowledge of the True God After Abraham and Lot were returned into Canaan from Aegypt upon some disagreement between their Herds-men they parted from each other Lot going towards Sodom and Abraham to the Plain of Mamre in Hebron And it came to pass that there was War between Nine Kings of that Countrey four being Confederate on the one side and five on the other But the King of Sodom and his Confederates being defeated in Battle Lot who dwelt in Sodom was with all his Goods carried away by the Enemy Of which when Abraham was informed he armed his Servants and with no more than Three hundred and eighteen Men gained a signal Victory retook Lot and brought him back with all his Family and Goods And at his return he is met by the King of Sodom and by Melchizedeck King of Salem who being the Priest of the most high God in a most solemn manner blesseth Abraham who gives him the Tenth of all his Spoil Which whole Action must needs render Abraham mightily renowned in all that Country So much Mercy did God extend to the Canaanites who after they had filled up the measure of their Iniquities were to be rooted out to make way for the Israelites to possess their Land that Abraham and Lot and Melchizedeck and their Families were appointed as Monitors and Instructors to them in the ways of Righteousness and Piety And when all this was ineffectual to their Amendment Sodom and Gomorrah were destroyed by a most miraculous and visible Judgment with Fire from Heaven after God had declared at Abraham's Intercession that if there had been but Ten Righteous Persons in those Cities he would have saved the rest for their sakes Lot with his Family only escaped this dreadful Judgment and his Wife looking back out of fondness for the Place she had left was turned into a Pillar of Salt which were so strange and so remarkable Judgments that it must be a prodigious obstinacy in Sin not to be reclaimed and brought to an acknowledgment of God's Power and Authority by them The Moabites and
after a Captivity of Seventy Years and Cyrus sent forth his Proclamation declaring that he had received his Kigdom from God with a charge to re-build the Temple at Jerusalem 2 Chron. xxxvi 23. And this Decree of Cyrus was reinforced by Darius and Artaxerxes Ezra vi vii Now so many several Decrees put forth in favour of the Religion of the Jews and the miraculous Power and Wisdom which gave occasion to them and the Advancement of Daniel and others and the long life and continuance of Daniel in that Power and Esteem must leave all the Eastern part of the World without any excuse who were not converted to the Knowledge and Worship of the True God The Advancement of Esther and Mordecai under Ahasuerus and of Nehemiah under Artaxerxes gave the Jews great Authority and great opportunites of propagating their Religion from India even unto Aethiopia over an hundred and seven and twenty provinces for this was the extent of the Dominions of Ahasuerus Esth i. 1. and the Jews were dispersed in all the Provinces of the Kingdom of Babylon chap. iii. 8. And they wanted no Care nor Diligence to improve every Opportunity as we learn from the Books of Ezekiel Daniel Ezra Nehemiah and Esther and the very Names of such Persons is enough to convince us that that part of the World could want no means of Conversion Confess him before the Gentiles ye Children of Israel for he hath scattered us among them there declare his greatness and extol him before all the living for he is our Lord and he is the God our Father for ever In the land of my captivity do I praise him and declare his might and majesty to a sinful nation Tob. xiii 3 4 6. This was the Practice of Pious Men among the Ten Tribes of whom some were likewise in great Place and Authority chap. i. 13 21 22. And as the Ten Tribes were first carried away Captive so upon the Restoration of the Tribes of Judah and Benjamin all but a few in comparison of the other Tribes remained in the places of their Captivity and many (c) Joseph Antiq. l. 11. c. 1. Mede's Discourse 20. p. 75. of those Two Tribes also chose rather to continue in Babylon than forsake the Possessions which they enjoyed there It is supposed that not much more than half of them returned and there were afrerwards three celebrated Universities (c) Lightf Harm N.T. p. 335. Exercit. on Acts p. 681 799. of the Jews in Babylon Nehardea Pombeditha and Soria besides several other Places famous for Learning The Jews relate (e) Hier. in Zech. x. that the Ten Tribes were carried away not only into Media and Persia but into the Northern Countries beyond the Bosphorus and Ortelius finds them in Tartary The Odomantes a People of Thrace were Circumcised and the (f) Aristophan Acharnens Act. 1. scen 4. Scholiast of Aristophanes says that they were reported to be Jews The Restoration of the Jews by Cyrus who had been so long before appointed and named by God himself for that Work was ordained for this end that they might know from the rising of the sun and from the west that there is no God besides him Isa xlv 6. And it is observable that after the Captivity the Jews were never given to Idolatry and tho' they were bofore too much addicted to it yet this gave occasion to Prophecies and Miracles to withdraw them from it and these with the Judgments of God which befell them for their Iniquities gave continual Manifestations to the World of the Truth of their Religion When the Ten Tribes were carried from Samaria and strange Nations were transplanted thither in their room God would not suffer his Name and Worship to be quite neglected and forgotten amongst them but they were forced to send for a Priest back again to teach them the fear of the Lord 2 King xvii And after the Taking of Jerusalem by Nebuchadnezzar and the Death of Gedaliah who was set over them that were left behind in the Land of Judah all the People that were not before carried to Babylon fled into Aegypt Jeremiah being forced along with them who there prophesied against Aegypt and foretold its Destruction by the Babylonians Jer. xliii and at last suffer'd Maâ—yrdom Their going into Aegypt was indeed contrary to the Word of the Lord by Jeremiah but the Providence of God so order'd things that Jeremiah should be carry'd thither with the rest to testifie against their Wickedness and Obstinacy and to denounce God's Judgments upon them and upon the Aegyptians in whom they placed their confidence rather than in the Living God and then to die in testimony of the Truth of what he had delivered Cyrus and Darius desired the Prayers and Sacrifices of the Jews in behalf of themselves and their Kingdoms Alexander the Great Pâ—olemaeus Philadelphus Augustus Tiberius and Vitellius sent Victims to be sacrificed at the Temple of Jerusalem as we learn from Philo and Josephus The Jews constantly offer'd Sacrifice and Prayers for the Kings and Emperor under whom they lived and for their Allies and Confederates 1 Maccab. vii 33. xii 11. and it was expected of them for the omission of this contrary to their known and approved Custom in all former Times was the thing which hastned their final Destruction by the Romans The course of Alexander's Victories was so unexpected so sudden and every way so wonderful that it alarm'd the World And no Man can believe that this was designed by Providence only to gratifie the Ambition and Vanity of a rash Youth but to open a way for a communication between the several Parts of the Earth to the benefit of Mankind in the improvement of all useful Knowledge and when this Work was done he was no longer the same Man he had been before but soon resigned his Conquests with his Life Alexander is said by (g) Joseph Antiqu. l. 11. c. ult Josephus to have been mightily encouraged in his Enterprise against Persia by the Prophecy of Daniel He remitted the Tribute of every Seventh Year in which by their Law they were obliged not to sow their Ground (h) Ibid. l. 14. c. 17. which was afterwards remitted to them likewise by the Romans He granted the Jews who in great numbers listed themselves in his Army the free Exercise of their Religion and promised to grant the same to the Jews of Babylon and Media and those of Sanballat's Faction who followed him into Aegypt he placed in Thebais Hecatoeus who lived in Alexander's time wrote (i) Joseph contra Ap. lib. 1. pag. 1048 c. a Book concerning the Jews in which he took notice of their great Zeal for their Law which he proves by this Instance That when Alexander repaired the Temple of Belus at Babylon his Soldiers who were Jews could by no means be brought to help forward that Work and at last the King excused them He related that Hezechias the High-Priest of the Jews
a Venerable Man of about Sixty six Years of Age of great Prudence and Experience and withal very Eloquent whom he knew and had conversed with was one amongst others who followed Ptolemaeus Lagi after the Battle at Gaza in which he overcame Demetrius Poliorcetes He mention'd likewise that Mosollamus a Jew marching with him when the rest made a stand by reason of a Bird which the Augur said portended ill Luck to them if they should march on shot that Bird in the sight of them all and defended what he had done by Argument And indeed the Jews wanted neither Zeal nor Wit nor Courage upon every occasion to appear in behalf of their own Religion against the Superstitions and Idolatries of the Heathen This Book of Hecataeus was extant in the time of Josephus and he referrs his Reader to it and he appeals to the Letters of Alexander the Great and of Ptolemaeus Lagi and the Kings of Aegypt his Successors in favour of the Jews When Ptolemaeus Lagi (k) Joseph Antiqu. l. 12. c. 1 2. took Jerusalem he transplanted the Jews in great multitudes into Aegypt putting many of them into his Garrisons and allowing them equal Priviledges with the Macedonians by which Encouragement many besides those whom he transported voluntarily went to dwell there And the Captives of that Nation set at liberty by Ptolemaeus Philadelphus were above 110000. And besides the signal Favours and Honours bestowed upon the Jews by Ptolemaeus Philadelphus who likewise caused the Holy Scriptures to be translated into the Greek Tongue which was an exceeding great furtherance to the Propogation of Religion Seleucus Nicanor granted them the freedom of Antioch and of the Cities which he had founded in Asia and the Lower Syria and these Priviledges remained to them till Josephus's time after all which the Jews had done to deserve to be deprived of them Antiochus the Great sent forth his Letters and Edicts which are to be seen in (l) Joseph Antiquit. l. 12. c. 3. Josephus in favour of the Jews more-especially in what related to their Religious Worship And Seleucus Son to this Antiochus after his Father's Example out of his own Revenues bore the Cost belonging to the Sacrisices 2 Mac. iii. 3. Antiochus Epiphanes himself at last under the avenging Hand of God upon him for all his impious Cruelties acknowledged himself punished for his Sacrilege and other Mischiefs committed at Jerusalem 1 Mac. vi 12 13. 2 Mac. ix 17. Antiochus Pius when he besieged Jerusalem (m) Ibid. l. 13. c. 16. not only granted a Truce for Seven Days during the Feast of Tabernacles but sent rich and noble Presents for Sacrifices and the City being delivered into his hands upon honourable Conditions with regard particularly to Religion Hyrcanus accompanied Antiochus in his Parthian Expedition and the Feast of Pentecost falling the Day after the Sabbath Antiochus stopt his Army those two Days for the sake of the Jews The Lacedaemonians claimed (n) 1 Mac. viii xii xiv 2 Mac. xi Joseph Antiqu l. 13. c. 9 13. l. 14. c. 16. Justin lib. 36. c. 3. Kindred with the Jews and both They and the Athenians and Romans enter'd into Leagues with them which from time to time were continued and renewed Josephus mentions a Pillar then standing at Alexandria containing the Priveledges (o) Joseph contr Ap. l. 2. granted to the Jews by Julius Caesar And when no other Religion was tolerated except those established by the Laws of the Empire the Jews only had Allowance for a free Exercise of their Religion even in Rome it self and for this and many other Edicts and Decrees of the Senate in favour of the Jews Josephus (p) Joseph Ant. quit l. 14. c. 16. l. 16. c. 4 5 10. l. i9 c. 4 6. appeals to the Tables of Brass then extant and preserved in the Capitol and other places in which they were engraven The Sufferings and Martyrdoms under the Maccabees and the Resolution and Constancy which they shewed upon all occasions in defence of their Religion rendred the Jews renowned over all Nations and besides their Conquests were very considerable and the Advantages which accrued to Religion by reason of them In the time of Hyrcanus (q) Joseph Antiquit. l. 13. c. 17. all Idumaea embraced the Jewish Religion Aristobulus having conquered great part of Ituraea caused all their Males (r) Ibid. l. 13. c. 19. to be circumcised and to observe the Law of Moses as Strabo testifies Under Alexander Father to Hyrcanus (s) Ibid. l. 13. c. 23. l. 14. c. 3. the Jews took twelve Cities from the Arabians and became possessed of many Cities in Syria Idumaea and Phenicia all which they brought over to the Possession of their own Religion and demolished Pella for refusing to embrace it The (t) See Mr. Mede's Discourse 12. Temple built by Sanballat for Manasses who had married his Daughter was an occasion of the Samaritans leaving their False Gods And after the building of the Temple in Aegypt the Babylonian Talmud says (u) Lightf Harmon p. 205. that the Jews there were double the number of those that came out from thence under Moses The Zeal of the Scribes and Pharisees though they were Hypocrites did exceedingly conduce to the propagation of their Religion for they compassed sea and land to make one Proselyte and so far they were to be commended but then they made him two-fold more the child of hell than themselves Mat. xxiii 15. yet still they taught the necessary Points of Doctrine though in Hypocrisie and with the mixtures of Superstition and our Saviour commands his Disciples to observe and do what they bid them but not to do after their works And it was required of the Fathers of the Sanhedrin (x) Lightf Excercit on 1 Cor. xiii 1. p. 783. that they should understand many Languages that the Sanhedrin might hear nothing by an Interpreter which qualified the Scribes and Pharisees who aspired to that Dignity to be the better able to make Proselytes The Jews were dispersed all over the World but chiefly seated themselves in Rome and Alexandria and Antioch the three chief Cities of the Empire in all which they had great and peculiar Priviledges and in Alexandria they had Magistrates of their own (y) Joseph Antiquit. l. 14. c. 12. and lived under a peculiar Government by themselves Never any other Nation had such various Changes and Revolutions to mix them with the rest of the World and never any People were so industrious and zealous and so succesful in the propogation of their Religion They had their Proseuchae and their Synagogues for Divine Worship and for Reading and Explaining the Scriptures which Men of all Religions were admitted to hear in all places where-ever they dwelt and in Aegypt they had a (z) Joseph Bell. Jud. l. 7. c. 30. Temple like that at Jerusalem built by Onias which continued for the space of Three hundred and forty three Years
several Prophecies we have recorded in the Books of Moses and ascribed to others and the last comaining so many remarkable things is from the mouth of an Enemy Moses himself foretold That the Children of Israel should after Forty Years come into the Land of Promise That they should prove Victorious over the Canaanites and That their Country should by the Divine Care and Protection be preserved in safety whilst they went up to worship at Jerusalem thrice every Year Thrice in the year shall all your men-children appear before the Lord God the God of Israel For I will cast out the nations before thee and enlarge thy borders netther shall any man desire thy land when thou shalt go up to appear before the Lord thy God thrice in the year Exod. xxxiv 23 24. Here is the Promise of a constant Miracle to be fulfilled to the Israelites thrice every Year as long as their Government stood all their Males were to go up to Jerusalem at three set and known times every year and yet their Enemies round about them whom they had so many ways provoked were by the Almighty Power of God restrained from taking any advantage of this opportunity which was frequently and notoriously given them of Invading their Countrey The very Nature and Constitution of the Jewish worship made it impossible for their Government to subsist in the observation of their Religion without a Miracle wrought three times in a Year for their preservation And the fulfilling of this Promise which God had made to them by Moses and the preserving of them in the performance of that Worship which he had appointed them was a continual Confirmation of his Law and a repeated Assurance that it was from God By the Law of Moses likewise every Seventh Year they were Permitted neither to sow their Land nor to prune their Vineyards nor to gather any Corn or Fruits that grew of their own accord which was a Law that must have brought them under great extremities and the observation of it had been impracticable if the extraordinary and miraculous Blessing of God had not supplied this constant want of the seventh year's Product with as constant an Overplus in the preceeding years For as God by Moses foretold That on the Sixth Day there should fall Manna enough to supply them on the Sabbath-day so they had a Promise of Three Years Fruits precisely every Sixth Year to supply that want which the Sabbatical Year must otherwise have reduced them to And if ye shall say What shall we eat the seventh year behold we shall not sow nor gather in our encrease Then I will command my blessing upon you in the sixth year and it shall bring forth fruit for three years And ye shall sow the eighth year and eat yet of old fruit until the ninth year until her fruits come in ye shall eat of the old store Lev. xxv 20 21 22. Which is another clear Instance that the People of Israel could never have subsisted in the observation of their Law but by the constant and miraculous accomplishment of the Prophecies which contained the Promises made to them for their Preservation In blessing the Twelve Tribes of Israel he foretold the peculiar state and condition of every distinct Tribe Deut. xxxiii He foretold to them all in general That they should have miraculous success against the Canaanites That they should possess themselves of their Land That they should set Kings over them That they should have a peculiar Place of Worship whither they should all resort and that they should have the Divine Oracles and a succession of Prophets for their direction in all Matters of great importance and difficulty And Joshua appeals to the Experience of the children of Israel whether all had not been fulfilled which was promised as far as his time And be hold this day I am going the way of all the earth and ye know in all your hearts and in all your souls that not one thing hath failed of all the good things which the Lord your God spake concerning you all are come to pass unto you and not one thing hath failed thereof Josh xxiii 14. The extent of the Dominions of the children of Israel after they came to be setled in the Land of Canaan is foretold Exod. xxiii 31. and fulfilled 2 Sam. viii 3. Ezra iv 20. And Solomon at the Dedication of the Temple declared in the audience of all the People That there had not failed one word of all God's good promise which he promised by the hand of Moses his servant 1 King viii 56. Moses also foretold that besides a constant succession of Prophets for many Ages there should arise a Prophet of extraordinary Power and Authority and whosoever would not hear that Prophet should be destroyed Deut. xviii 18. This Prophet was the great expectation of the Jews at the time of out Saviour's coming Joh. 1.21 vi 14. vii 40. and the Apostles prove our Saviour to be him Act. iii. 22. vii 37. Lastly Moses foretold the Disobedience and the Revolt of the children of Israel the Judgments that should befall them for their Iniquities and their Deliverance upon their Repentance he foretold so many Years before they had any King That they and their King whom they would set over them should be carried into Captivity and that at the same time when they were taken Captive by the Assyrians who are described in the very same words that the other Prophets use concerning them the remainder should be carried into Aegypt Deut. xxviii 36 49 50 68. and we see it came accordingly to pass Jer. xliii And the Siege of Samaria by the Assyrians and of Jerusalem both by them and the Romans is particularly described to the very circumstance of their eating the flesh of their sons and of their daughters Deut. xxviii 53. which is a thing that has scarce ever happen'd in any other Siege but those of Samaria and of Jerusalem Lam. ii 20. iv 10.2 King vi 29. This monstrous and dreadful thing was twice known in Jerusalem first when it was besieged by Nehuchadnezzar and again when it was destroyed by the Romans under Titus And such a circumstance could not be foretold so long before but by a Divine Prescience and that so strange and unnatural a thing should befall the Children of Israel three several times according to the express words of a Prophecy could have nothing of Chance in it Thus we see that besides the Prophecies concerning the other Nations of the Earth every State and Condition of the People of Israel from their first Original to the Destruction of Jerusalem was the Perpetual Fulfilling of express Prophecies contained in the Books of Moses CHAP. VI. Of the Miracles wrought by Moses IF it be once proved That Moses did what is related of him in the Pentateuch it will unavoidably follow That he did it by a Divine Power and that he was God's Servant and Minister and that
would recover he died while the Answers were reading that foretold his Recovery For the sins of Men against natural Conscience and the contempt of the Divine Revelations made to Mankind and so often promulged amongst all Nations God might permit the Devil to delude the World with such Signs and Predictions as either were indeed true or could not be discerned to be false but by the Doctrines and Practices which they were brought to countenance and establish There is no doubt but that evil Spirits may be able to delude and impose upon men and to do many things by their sagacity and cunning which may be above the power of man not only to perform but to understand or find out but their Miracles were never wrought to confirm any sound and useful Doctrine nor had they been plainly foretold by ancient Prophecies as the Miracles of our Saviour and his Apostles had been And the power by which our Religion was attested and established was so much superiour to any power in the Heathen Gods that when they were adjured by Christians they were forced to confess themselves to be wicked and seducing Spirits as the Primitive Christians declare in their writings and appeal to the Heathens of their own times for the truth of it and undertake upon pain of death to prove it before them This Tertullian undertakes in (n) Tertul Apol. c. 23. his Apology as I have before observed written to the Emperor and Senate of Rome or at least to the proconsul of Afric and the Governours of the several Cities and Provinces And St. Cyprian affirms the like in his Treatise to Demetrianus a Judge of Carthage or as some think the Pro-consul to the same purpose likewise speak Origen Minutius Foelix and others of the Primitive Christians And we cannot imagine that men of common sense would ever have made such publick and repeated Appeals if their pretences had been false to the hazard of their own lives and the utter disgrace and extirpation of their Religion which they endeavoured to plead for by such confident and bold discourses so easie to be disproved if they had not been true Men who have the wealth and power of the world on their side may perhaps sometimes make large boasts and high pretences when they can easily hinder others from bringing them to the Test but men that had all the power and policy of the Empire against them would never have offered any thing of this Nature in defence of their Religion unless they had been able to make it good to the faces of their worst Enemies to whom their Apologies were directed CHAP. IV. The Defect in point of Doctrine in the Heathen Religions IT is undeniable that the Doctrines of all the Heathen Religions have been wicked and contrary to the Unity and Goodness and Purity of God and to the vertue and happiness of Mankind This might be made out at large by particulars as I. The Theology of the Heathens was so confused and absurd that the only Evasion which the Philosophers could find who undertook the defence of Paganism against Christianity was to expound their Theology by Allegories but this Philo (a) Eâ—seâ— praepar lib. i. c. 9 10. Biblius censures as absurd and maintains that it was a mere abuse and innovation in their Divinity in proof of which he alledges the authority of Sanchoniathan and Eusebius besides makes good the charge (b) Magnam molestiam suscepit minime necessariam primus Zeno post â—â—eanthes deinde Chrysippus commentitiarum balarum redâ—ere rationem Ciâ— de Nat. Deor. lib. iii. Zeno first begun this way of Allegorizing in which he was followed by Cleanthes Chrysippus and other Stoicks (c) Tertull. ad Naâ— lib. ii c. â— Aug. Civ De◠〈◊〉 6. c. 5. Varro makes three sorts of Heathen Theology in the Fabulous invented by the Poets The Physical or that of the Philosophers and the Civil or Popular being such as the several Cities and Countries had set up (d) Euseb praepar lib. 4. c. 5. The Greek Theology was thus distinguished 1. God who rules over all 2. The Gods who were supposed to govern above the Moon 3. The Daemons whose jurisdiction was in the Air below it and 4. The Heroes or Souls of dead men who were imagined to preside over Terrestrial affairs which gives some account of the prodigious multitude of their Gods (e) Hesiod oper Dier lib. i. v. 250. whereof Hesiod computes thirty thousand hovering in the Air unless he be to be understood of an indefinite number Orpheus reckoned but 365 (f) Theop ad Autol. lib. iii. and at his death in his Will asserted only one (g) Tertul Apol. c. 14. Gages survey of the W. Indies c. 12. Varro reckoned up three hundred Jupiters and the Gods of Mexico as the Indians reported to the Spaniards were two thousand in number Varro Tully and Seneca and most sober and discreet men were ashamed of the Heathen Gods and believed that there is but one God to which purpose the verses of Valerius Soranus (h) Aug. de Civ Dei lib. iv c. 31. vii 9. are produced and expounded by Varro The worship of their Gods and of their Images or Idols was so gross amongst the ancient Heathen and is to this day in China and in both the Indies that one would almost think it impossible for men to be so far deluded by the Devil they worshiped not only the Ghosts of dead men but Birds and Beasts and creeping things and the Devil himself under Images of such hideous forms and shapes as are frightful to look upon The wiser Heathens were ashamed of these Idolatries (i) Aug. Civ Dei lib. iv c. 31. and Varro particularly commends the Jews for using no Images in their Divine Worship which he fays were not in use at Rome till above one hundred and seventy years after the Foundation of the City (k) Plut. in vit Numae for Numa the contriver of their Religion forbad Images which makes it the more strange that the (l) Cic. de Nat. Deor lib. iii. de legib lib. ii Romans should afterwards erect Temples and Altars to the most unlikely things to a Fever and to ill Fortune as the (l) Cic. de Nat. Deor lib. iii. de legib lib. ii Athenians did to contumely and Impudence but it is still more amazing that they should deify the worst of men the very Monsters and reproaches of Mankind and whilst the Christians suffered for refusing Adoration to their Emperors they had divine Honours paid them by the gravest Heathens such as (m) Quint Inst lib. Prooem Quinctilian not only through fear of death but out of compliment and base flattery 2. All manner of Debauchery and Lewdness made up so great a part of the Heathen Religion that it is too shameful and too notorious to relate (n) Euseb Praepar lib. ii c. ult ex Dionys Halicaâ—â— lib. ii The Romans when they received
If we have nothing to object but the imperfection of human nature we may rely upon God that this shall never mislead us in a matter of such consequence whether the imperfection be in our own sences or in the Testimony of others In short the Miracles related in the Scriptures will as effectually prove a Divine Revelation to us as they could to those that saw them but the difference is that they believed their sences and we believe them and all things considered we have as much reason to believe upon their evidence as they could have to believe upon the evidence of their sences Let us consider History as a medium by which these Miracles become known to us and compare this medium with that of Sight If a man would be sceptical he might doubt whether any medium of Sight be so fitly disposed as to represent objects in their due proportion and proper shape he might suspect that any Miracles which he could see were false or wrought only to amuse and deceive him and there would be no way to satisfy such an one but by telling him that this is inconsistent with the Truth and Goodness of God So in this other medium of History which to us supplies the want of that of Sight a man may doubt of any matter of Fact if he Pleases notwithstanding the most credible evidence but in a matter of this nature where our Eternal Salvation is concerned we may be sure God will not suffer Mankind to be deceived without all possibility of discovering the deceit The circumstances have all the marks of credibility in them and therefore if they be duely attended to cannot but be believed and the Doctrine which they are brought in evidence of being propounded to be believed under pain of Damnation require that they should be attended to and considered and that which is in its circumstances most credible and in its matter is supposed necessary to Salvation must be certainly true unless God could oblige us to believe a Lye For not to believe things credible when attended to and known to be such is to humane nature impossible and not to attend to things proposed as from God of necessity to Salvation is a very heinous Crime against God and to think that God will suffer me to be deceived in what I am obliged in Honour and obedience to him to believe upon his Authority is to think he can oblige me to believe a Lye But it may be objected if this be so how comes it to pass that they are prâ—nounced blessed who have not seen and yet have believed John xx 29. Which seems to denote that a peculiar Blessing belongs to them because they believe upon less evidence I answer that they are there pronounced Blessed who had so well considered the nature and circumstances of things the Prophecies concerning the Messias and what our Saviour had delivered of himself as to believe his Resurrection upon the report of others not because others might not have as sufficient Grounds for their Belief as those who saw him after his Resurrection but the evidence of sense is more plain and convincing to the generality of men though Reason proceeds at least upon as sure and as undeniable Principles A demonstration when it is rightly performed is as certain as the self evident Principles upon which it proceeds though it be so far removed from them that every one cannot discern the connexion Demonstrations may be far from being easie and obvious but are oftentimes we know very difficult and intricate which yet when they are once made out are as certain as sense it self The Blessing is pronounced to him who believes not upon less evidence But upon that which at first seems to be less which is less observable and less obvious to our consideration but not less certain when it is duly considered For which reason our Saviour after he had wrought many Miracles that were effectually attested by sufficient witnesses required Faith in those who came to be healed of him because the Testimony of others was the means which in Ages to come was to be the motive of Faith in Christians and he thereby signified to us that there may be as good Grounds for Faith upon the report of others as we could have from our own sences and generally those who came in unbelief went away no better satisfied Wherefore it is said that in his own Country because of their unbelief he could do no mighty work save that he laid his hands upon a few sick Folk and healed them Mark vi 5. He could not do his mighty works because they would be ineffectual and would be lost upon them and he could do nothing Insignificant or in vain if they would reject what had been so fully witnessed to them they would not believe whatever Miracles they should see him do It is very remarkable that amidst all his Miracles our Saviour directs his Followers to Moses and the Prophets and appeals to the Scriptures for the Authority of his very Miracles and that even after his Resurrection he instructs his Disciples who saw and discoursed with him out of the Scriptures to confirm them in the truth of it Luke xxiv 26 27. He requires the Jews to give no greater credit to his own Miracles than that which he implies they already gave to the wrirings of Moses so as firmly and stedfastly to believe that he came from God And we having all the helps and advantages which the Jews had to create in them a Belief of the Scriptures of the Old Testament and many more and greater Motives if it be possible to believe these of the New must therefore have sufficient means to excite in us that Faith which our Saviour required of those who saw his Works and heard his Doctrine which certainly was a Divine Faith and all the Faith which if it be accompanied with sincere and impartial obedience is required in order to Salvation Upon the whole matter I conclude that the Truth of the Christian Religion is evident even to a Demonstration for it is as Demonstrable that there is a God as it is that I my self am or that there is any thing else in the World because nothing could be made without a Maker or created without a Creator and it is as Demonstrable that this God being the Author of all the perfections in men must himself be infinitely perfect that he is infinitely Wise and Just and Holy and Good and that according to these Attributes he could not suffer a false Religion to be imposed upon the world in his own Name with such manifest Tokens of credibility that no man can possibly disprove it but every one is obliged to believe it FINIS BOOKS Printed for and Sold by R. Wellington at the Dolphin and Crown in St. Paul 's Church-Yard Newly Published A Treatise of Medicines containing an Account of their Chymical Principles the Experiments made upon them their Various Preparations and Vertues and the
or other preserv'd than that they are able to make it out It was the Custom of the Aegyptians to omit the mâ—ntion of these Persons of whom they haâ— any â—islike or who had made themselves oâ—ioâ—s to them Thus in the xxth Dynasty of their Kings there is a total Vacancy for the spacâ— of clxxviii Years which the Learned Mr. Greaves with great Probability Supplies with the Names of those Kings who built the Pyramides two whereof Cheops and Chephren as (m) Herod lib. 2. c. 128. Herodotus says the Aegyptians out of Hatred to them would not so much as name but called the Pyramides which they had erected the Pyramides of Philition a Shepherd who in those days fed his Cattle there The which Hatred says (n) 〈…〉 â—â—idoâ—raph Mr. Greaves occasioned by their Oppressious as Diodorus also mentions might cause Manethos to omit the rest especiaâ—â— Sabachus an Aethiopian and an Vsurper But whatever account is to be given of the Aegyptian History in that particular this makes the History of that Nation in general very uncertain and may afford a sufâ—â—erent Reason why the Jews are either omitted or 〈◊〉 by Heathen Historians who had what they relate of them from the Aegyptians and the Hebrews neither liv'd with the Aegyptians nor left them upon such Terms as to have their Story faithfully told by a Nation who would suffer nothing to pass down to Posterity if they could help it that was displeasing to them when it happened but if any thing were so Notorious as not to be capable of being wholly stifled they would be sure to vary and deface it with false Circumstances in the Reports which they gave out concerning it And here I must once more complain of Mr. Blount who as if he had been an Aegyptian Historian that had an implacable Hatred of our Religion professing to translate that place of Tacitus which concerns the Original of the Jews cuts his Translation short and goes no fâ—rther than the Vilifying and false part of the Account which Tacitus gives for his Character of their Religion and the Relation of what Pompey discovered upon his Entrance into the Temple is omitted And besides that which he has translated is far from being exact but as I observed before that in speaking of the Ark he had made Sir Thomas Brown say that will not appear feasible which the Learned Knight had said will appear feasible so he has dealt no better with Tacitus making him likewise deny what he had affirmed Tacitus (o) Tâ—â—â— Hist lib. v. says Hi ritus quoquo modo inducti Antiquitate defenduntur These Rites by what means soever introduced are defended by their Antiquity which (p) Oâ—â—â— of Reason p. 13â— Mr. Blount translates thus But by what means soever they have been introduced they have no Antiquity for their Patronization This is to use the History of Tacitus as ill as he doth that of the Bible and much worse than Tacitus himself has done the Jews For if it be rightly understood what Tacitus has written of the Jews proves a very remarkable Vindication of their Religion He says indeed that they consecrated the Image of an Ass but he says it only as a Report which he confutes afterwards himself by acknowledging that Pompey when he entred into the Temple found no Image in it and giving an Account of their Religion he says Aegyptij pelraque Animalia effigiesque compositas venerantur Judaei mente sold unumque 〈◊〉 intelligunt Profanos qui Deum imagines mortalibus materiis in species Hominum effingunt Summum illud aeternum neque mutabile neque interiturum Igitur nulla simulachra Vrbibâ—s suis nedum Templis sunt Which is so contrary to what this Historian writes before in these words Effigiem animalis quo monstrante errorem sitimque depâ—lerunt penetâ—ali sacravere that some have charged him with contradicting himself but it is evident that the Story of their Worshiping an Ass is related as a Tradition which is afterwards sufficiently confuted by his own Account of their Doctrine and Worship and by what Pompey found Nullà nitus Deum Effigie vacuam sedem inania Arcana Whatever his Design was and however his obscure way of writing has made him to be misunderstood there can hardly be any thing said more for the Truth and Honour of the Jewish Religion than what Tacitus has delivered of it And if any one will compare that which Tully hath said in the same (q) Pro Flacco Oration of the Greeks and of the Jews he must conclude that what is spoken against the Jews is rather to their Commendation than to their Disgrace Tully there declares the Greeks to be of no Credit nor Esteem but unfaithful and of the worst Reputation even to a Proverb in their Testimonies and Oaths He is careful not to involve the Athenians and Lacedaemonians in the common Scandal who appeared for his Client and gives a high Character of the Massilians and would seem to confine his Discourse to the Asiatick Greeks by whose own Confession he says the People of Phrygia Mysia Caria and Lydia were proverbially Infamous When he has exprest this Contempt of the Greeks he falls next upon the Jews But what has he to say of them He calls their Religion a barbarous Superstition and Jerusalem a Suspicious and Railing City and he pronounces the Jewish Religion to be unsuitable to the Splendor and Gravity and the Customs of the Romans he insinuates that they were a People not well affected to the Roman State and urges the Conquest of them by Pompey as an Argument against the Truth of their Religion When so very Learned an Orator had nothing but these common Topicks of Slander to charge them withal tho' it was for the Interest of his Câ—use to speak the worst he knew of them what could be a greater Justification of the Jews and their Religion One of the Accusations laid against Flaccus whose Defence Tully had undertaken was that Summs of Gold having been wont to be sent out of Italy and out of all the Roman Provinces to the Temple at Jerusalem Flaccus had forbidden any to be exported from Asia Here it concern'd Tully to expose the Worship of the Jews and to vindicate the Prohibition relating to it but he who never spoke little upon any Subject that could afford a Scope for his Eloquence says so little here to the dispraise of the Jews and their Religion that the Commendation of another had been less to their Honour It is observable that Tully mentions nothing of their Worshiping an Ass which was so groundless and foolish a Slander that it is hard to imagine what could give occasion to it and perhaps no better Account of it can be assigned than that the Enemies of their Religion were resolved to fasten the worst and most ridiculous Falshood they could upon it But if it may be permitted me to add a Conjecture to those which have been made by
others it seems probable that the highest degree of Excommunication among the Jews being styled Shammatha which is the same with Maran Atha Sham signifying Lord as †Vid. Grot. Ham. ad 1 Cor. xvi 22. Maran also doth in the Syriac and other Languages and Atha signifying cometh Atha might either Ignorantly or Maliciously be mistaken for Athon which signifies an Ass And it is likely that this Calumny might be first raised by some Body who had been Excommunicated and turned Apostate It would be a very wrong inference from what has been said to conclude that there is no certainty in the Greek and Latin and other Heathen Historians For the Circumstances of the Relation and the Consent of divers Authors may put most parts of History past doubt But it ought to be considered that those which have been mentioned are exceptions to which the Sacred Historians are by no means liable they do not charge one another with Falshood nothing can be discovered of Partiality in their Writings but they tell the most disgraceful Truths of their Ancestors and of themselves and the History it self has so many publick Circumstances that they clear it beyond all suspicion of Deceit If the Names of some Men be omitted upon particular occasions in the Scriptures we find them mentioned there upon others And there is evident Reason that the Names of infamous Men should in some Cases be omitted and should not be inserted in Genealogies and enrolled in the Registers of Honour But when the Memory of Persons and Actions is totally supprest this must extreamly abate the Credit of any History The Jews are the only People in the World that have had their Antiquities by an uninterrupted Tradition delivered down and preserved in an Authentick Book unanimously asserted by the whole Nation in all Ages which they have never changed nor altered but have in great numbers sacrificed their Lives in Testimony of it If the Heathens in divers things contradict the History of the Jews they contradict one another as much in the Accounts of their own Antiquities and what they relate of the Jews is upon uncertain and contrary Reports If they conceal what concerns the Jews it was their Custom to stifle that which did not please them The Histories as well as the Religion of most other Nations were kept secret and not communicated to the People no Book of History among them was ever put into the hands of a whole Nation with a strict Charge to every one to read and study it as the Books of Moses were when the Principal and most Memorable things related were within the knowledge and Memory of all that read them The Jews were under a necessity of preserving their Genealogies with all imaginable Care and Exactness if they would make good the Claim and Title to their Inheritances so that the meanest among them could with the greatest certainty derive his Line from Adam whereas the Persian Kings as we learn from (r) Herod lib. vii c. 11. Herodotus could boast but of a short Descent and the Kings and Emperours of the Romans and of other Nations to advance their Pedigrees were forced to have recourse to fabulous Reports And the Heathen Accounts of the Original not only of particular Families but of the several Nations of the World are acknowledged to be Fabulous or at the best but very uncertain by the most accurate Historians The Account of the Prophecies and Miracles contained in the Scriptures was impossible to be mistaken at first and it has been transmitted with all the certainty that any History is capable of to Posterity And the Writers of the Old and New Testament all agree in the Account of the Creation of the Deluge of Abraham and the other Patriarchs of the Bondage of the Israelites in Aegypt their Miraculous Deliverance from thence and their Journying into the Land of Canaan they all frequently assert suppose or imply the Truth of these things there is a continued Series and Line of Truth observable throughout the whole Scriptures But among Heathen Writers it is otherwise they contradict one another in Matters of any considerable Antiquity if they agree in some material Passages it is commonly with much variation in the Circumstances and with great Uncertainty and Doubtfulness and the things in which they most agree are such as have been taken from the Scriptures which compose a Book that if it were but for the Antiquity and Learning of it is the most valuable of any Book in the World and nothing but Vice and Ignorance and that which is the worst sort of Ignorance a Pretence to Learning could make it so much despised II. If the Histories of Heathen Nations be so little to be relied upon their Philosophy will appear to be worthy of no more Regard which for any thing of Truth and Usefulness there is to be found in it depends so much upon Historical Traditions That Poetry is the most antient way of Writing is not only asserted by Heathen Authors but may with great probability be made out from the Scripture it self Poets were the Chief upholders of the Religion and the Philosophy in use among the Heathens both these were at the first taught in short Maxims which that they might be the better received and the more easily retain'd in Memory were put into Verse without any farther Ornament than just what was necessary to give a clear and full Expression to their Notions and Precepts (s) Xenoph. Conviv Memorab lib. 1. Socrates and the Philosophers of his time had a value for the Verses of Theognis and those which go under the Name of Pythagoras are at least as antient as (t) Apuâ— A Gell. lib. vi c. 2. Chrysippus who alleg'd their Authority Solon himself wrote Elegies whereof some Remains are still preserv'd This gave the Poets a mighty Reputation and we find not only Solon but others of them quoted and appeal'd to by Demosthenes and Aeschines in the Courts of Judicature as well as by Philosophers in their Discourses But the Poets for the more delightful Entertainment of the People not only indulged themselves in that antient and useful way of Instruction by Fables for he (u) 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Plat. Plâ—et was hardly esteem'd a Poet who had been the Authors of none but they became the Promoters of all manner of Superstitions and Idolatrous Worship the Oracles were delivered in Verse every Poet wrote something in Honour of the false Gods and (w) Plat. â—b Socrates himself during his Imprisonment made a Hymn in praise of Apollo By which means the Original Notions of Religion and Vertue were so obscured and corrupted that it was impossible in any Humane way to provide a sufficient Remedy Plato complain'd of the Fictions of Poets but when he set himself to recover Men to a true Sense and Notion of things by the help of some antient Traditions which he had met withal he fell into very absurd and sinful
and Instruments whereby he is pleas'd to convey into our Souls the blessed Influences of his Holy Spirit Or lastly they may be consider'd as visible Rites whereby we are admitted into the visible Society of Christ's Church or profess our Communion with it And in all these respects it will appear how beneficial and requisite the Institution of Sacraments is and how fitting it is that God in his Dispensations with Men should appoint something outward and visible to be done or received by them I. Ceremonies and Rites of Initiation and of Worship have been Instituted in all Religions which is Evidence sufficient that the Nature of Man requires them and that our Worship cannot be wholly Mental and Spiritual And God is pleas'd in his Dealings with Mankind to condescend to their Capacities to ascribe to himself their Passions to allude to their Customs and to make use of such Means and Methods as Men are accustomed to in their Dealings with one another He best understands Humane Nature and knows all the dispositions and tendencies of it he knoweth our frame he remembreth that we are dust Ps ciii 14. He considers that we are Flesh as well as Spirit he fully comprehends the strict Union between the Soul and the Body and the cause and manner of it and how great influence the one hath upon the other in their several Operations he planted in us all our Powers and Faculties and sees all their Motions and Inclinations the secret Springs of Action and Passion and has accordingly fitted and proportioned the Institution of his Laws and Ordinances We see among Men that they are not content only to understand one anothers Meaning or to express their Minds in words tho' they be the most solemn and significant but are wont to use some Ceremony and Solemnity of Action and Circumstances in matters of great Importance because this makes greater impression upon the Mind and lays upon it a more forcible and lasting engagement by taking in the Senses and Passions as Parties concerned with it and this is by experience found to have the best effect to all the ends and purposes of Agreement and Obligation between Men. Oaths themselves are not found to be so secure to be rely'd upon when they are only pronounc'd as when they are taken with such Circumstances of words and gesture as may create an awe and reverence in those who take them For the manner and circumstances in which any action is done raise and fix the Attention and express the Mind and Design of the Doer and are better retain'd in the Memory and work more upon the Will and Affections than the Action of itself can do This Orators very well understand for the Art of Rhetorick is almost nothing else but a skilfull management of the circumstances of actions to the advantage of a Cause And Philosophy informs us that the evil or goodness of Actions depends chiefly upon their Circumstances from whence we learn what the intention of the Mind is and to what degree of Resolution it came in the performance of any Action If an Action be performed at a solemn time and place in the presence of Witnesses met together for that very purpose upon great deliberation with such words and gestures as are very significant to express our full Design and Intention all these Circumstances consider'd make it much more our own proper Act and Deed than if it were done without them tho' the Intention were the same For what we declare before others to be our mind and purpose to do or undertake we cannot but think our selves bound to under more obligations than if we barely design'd it or promis'd it only to the Persons concern'd because the design of declaring it is to lay upon our selves a farther obligation to perform it and to call others as Witnesses against us if we neglect the performance of it and since our Resolution may be declar'd as well by Actions as by Words he that expresses his Resolution both these ways shews a farther design to oblige himself than if he should only use words to express it and if the Circumstances of Actions be stated and solemn and significant then all the ways and means concurr by which it is possible for Men to declare and express their Minds in any Case and to oblige themselves to the performance of any Covenant Now Sacraments are the Seals of the Covenant between God and Man and when God is pleas'd to receive Men into Covenant with himself it is requisite that Men should not barely give their assent to the Terms and Conditions of it and declare that they will undertake them but it is farther necessary that this should be done with all the Solemnity of Words and Actions that may engage them to the performance of it and render them inexcusable if they transgress it it is fitting it should be entred into and renewed in the presence of Witnesses that the Words should be Solemn and the Actions Significant and that nothing should be wanting which may testifie the Sincerity and secure the Fidelity of the Undertakers For if Covenants between Man and Man be made with all the formality of Witnesses and Hands and Seals and Delivery in solemn and express words if Men know themselves too well to trust one another without all this Solemnity it may well be expected that when God is pleas'd to permit them to enter into Covenant with himself he should not receive them under less Obligations of Caution and Security for their Integrity than Men are wont to use amongst themselves For every breach of Covenant with him is infinitely more affronting and sinful than any breach of Covenant with Man can be and therefore God who will not be mocked has appointed the most effectual Means to secure his Laws from contempt he knows the deceitfulness of Man's heart how perverse and stubborn it is especially in things of such a Nature as these are of to which Men are obliged by that Promise and Vow that they are required to make to him and that all the Restraints and all the Remembrances which Words or Actions can afford are little enough to keep Men in any tolerable measure to their Duty God was pleas'd to confirm his Promise to Abraham with an Oath and therein shew'd himself willing to give all the assurance that the most Incredulous Man can desire of the fix'd and unalterable stedfastness of his purpose and the Immutability of his Council that we might have a strong Consolation Heb. vi 17 18. And when God himself is pleas'd so far to condescend for our comfort and satisfaction it is most reasonable that he should oblige us to perform our part of the Covenant by all the ways that may put us in remembrance of our Duty and make us faithful and constant in the performance of it And this could be effected by no better Means than by outward Acts and visible Signs to testifie and profess in the most serious and solemn
manner what our inward Faith and Resolutions are This is that sort of security which Men have of one another and when God makes a Covenant with Men he considers them as Men that is he appoints such Solemnities of it as have respect to the Body as well as to the Soul he doth not deal with us as with immaterial Spirits but as with Creatures consisting of Soul and Body and who little regard and are little affected with that which doth not some way concern the one as well as the other And it is strange to see to what Extravagancies those have proceeded who have set up for a purely Spiritual Worship without any thing Sacramental for a visible Sign in it For not to mention the Pretensions of our Enthusiasts who by decrying the use and necessity of Sacraments have made Religion nothing but an empty and uncertain Name amongst them Prophyry who was a Man of Study and Learning after he had Apostatiz'd from the Christian Religion upon a ridiculous Occasion as History relates it was ashamed to return to the Heathen Idolatry which after the appearance of Christianity in the World soon became too notoriously absurd and abominable for any Man pretending so much to Reason and good Sense to own it but he placed all Divine Worship in Mental Prayer and so far rejected all outward and Bodily Worship (g) Porphyr de Abstinent lib. 2. §. 34. that he pretended the Prayers of Men were polluted and defiled by any thing of that Nature and rendred unacceptable to the Deity and that they never were sufficiently pure and perfect if they were express'd by the Voice but were then in their highest degree of Perfection when they were all Contemplation and Rapture and Extasie And the very same Notions were taught by (h) Euseb Praepar Evang. lib. iv c. 13. Apollonius Tyanoeus and have been revived of late by such as undervalue all outward Ordinances which may be a Warning to others and an Evidence of the Divine Wisdom in appointing Sacraments as outward and visible Signs of our Covenant and Communion with God 2. As these outward Signs serve to raise our Attention and fix our Minds and to put us in Remembrance that Heaven and Earth Angels and Men are Witnesses against us if we prove treacherous and unfaithful in this Covenant so they are as Tokens and Pledges to us of God's Love and Favour and of his merciful and gracious Intentions towards us in taking us into Covenant with himself they give us sensible and visible Assurances of that Grace which is invisible and Spiritual And this seems but necessary for Creatures that are led so much by Sense as we all are in this Life that God together with his Word and Promises should besides appoint something which may be perceiv'd by our Bodily Senses in Token of those Blessings which are bestow'd upon the Soul that what is no Object of Sense may yet be represented and signified by something that is sensible to bring as far as it is possible the most Divine and Heavenly things down to our very Senses which may be a Sign and Token of present Grace and Favour and a Pledge and Earnest of future Glory and Happiness And this is what is found very useful and necessary amongst Men who are better contented with something present and in hand tho' of little value and insignificant in itself as a Token and Pledge of what is promised and made over to them than they are with the greatest Promises and Protestations without any thing as an Earnest to confirm them because this is a Natural Evidence that they are indeed in Earnest as our English word expresses it and really intend what they say and it may be produced against them if they should fail of Performance Now what is inward and invisible is absent as to Sense and what is future has need of something present to represent it to us And God who was pleased to bind himself even by an Oath for our farther Comfort and Trust in him has been pleased likewise that he might be wanting in nothing which might help our Infirmities and assist our Faith he has been pleased in condescention to the Condition and Frailty of Humane Nature to appoint visible Signs and Pledges of that which is Invisible and to give all the Assurance to our very Senses that they are capable of that all the Promises of his Spiritual Blessings and Graces shall as certainly be fulfilled to us as the outward Signs and Pledges are appointed for us and duly received by us 3. Sacraments are not only Signs and Tokens of Spiritual Gifts and Graces but they are ordained as Means and Instruments of Grace and Salvation to us that as the Body partakes in the Moral Actions of Vertue and Vice so it might concur in the Religious Acts ordained for our Sanctification For God who has made us so as to consist of Soul and Body and to have the Vital Union between Soul and Body depend upon a fit Disposition of the Body and to be maintained by the Health and Nourishment of it has been pleas'd to appoint certain Bodily Actions as the Means and Instruments of our Spiritual Life that the Soul might not even in this Case where itself is more immediately concern'd be wholly independent of the Body but that since both must be either happy or miserable together in the next Life both might concurr in the way and means of Salvation in this yet so as that the Soul should be the first and principal Agent and the Body should act only in subordination and subserviency to it in this as it doth in other Cases that as in Moral Actions the Soul acts vertuously or viciously by the Body so in Spiritual Actions the Soul might receive Advantage and Benefit by Bodily Acts and be deprived of it upon the Omission or Neglect of such Acts. The Body without the Soul is not the Man nor the Soul without the Body but both Soul and Body together and the whole Man becomes dedicated and consecrated to God's Worship and Service in the use of Actions performed outwardly in the Body And it is requisite that the Body as well as the Soul should be thus dedicated to God in Token of the Resurrection of the Body and of that Happiness which it must receive in Heaven if the Soul be happy St. Paul exhorts the Corinthians to glorifie God in their Body as well as in their Spirit 1 Cor. vi 20. he tells them that the Body is not for Fornication but for the Lord and the Lord for the Body know ye not says he that your Bodies are the members of Christ what know ye not that your Body is the Temple of the Holy Ghost There have been those in several Ages who have made such high Pretences to Spiritual Worship that they would allow the Body no part or share in it and others from the great irregularity and corruption which they could not but observe in
thing else be of the same Colour or Tast which it appears to be of because they could amuse themselves with Difficulties and they were too much Philosophers to assent to any thing that they did not understand tho' it were confirmed by the Sense and Experience of all Mankind They were rational Men and it was below them to believe their Senses unless their Reason were convinced and that was too acute to be convinced as long as any Difficulty that could be started remained unanswered And thus under the pretence of Reason and Philosophy they exposed themselves to the Scorn and Derision of all who had but the common Sense of Men without the Art and Subtilty of imposing upon themselves and others And it is the same thing in effect as to matters of Religion The Scriptures come confirmed down to us by all the ways of confirmation that the Authority of any Revelation at this distance of time could be expected to have if it really were what we believe the Scriptures to be Why then do some Men doubt whether they be Authentick Can they disprove the Arguments which are brought in defence of them Can they produce any other Revelation more Authentick Or is it more reasonable to believe that God should not reveal himself to Mankind than that this Revelation should be his No this is not the case but there are several things to be found in the Scriptures which they think would not be in them if they were of Divine Revelation But a wise Man will never disbelieve a thing for any Objections made against it which do not reach the Point nor touch these Arguments by which it is proved to him It is not inconsistent that that may be most true which may have many Exceptions framed against it but it is absurd to reject that as incredible which comes recommended by our Belief by such Evidence as cannot be disprov'd Till this be done all which can be said besides only shews that there are Difficulties to be met withal in the Scriptures which was never denied by those who most firmly and stedfastly believe them But Difficulties can never alter the Nature of Things and make that which is true to become false There is no Science without its Difficulties and it is not pretended that Theology is without them There are many great and inexplicable Difficulties in the Mathematicks but shall we therefore reject this as a Science of no Value nor Certainty and believe no Demonstration in Euclide to be true unless we could Square the Circle And yet this is every whit as reasonable as it is not to acknowledge the Truth of the Scriptures unless we could explain all the Visions in Ezekiel and the Revelations of St. John We must believe nothing and know nothing if we must disbelieve and reject every thing which is liable to Difficulties We must not believe we have a Soul unless we can give an account of all its Operations nor that we have a Body unless we can tell all the Parts and Motions and the whole Frame and Composition of it We must not believe our Senses till there is nothing relating to Sensation but what we perfectly understand nor that there are any Objects in the World till we know the exact manner how we perceive them and can solve all Objections that may be raised concerning them And if a Man can be incredulous to this degree it cannot be expected that he should believe the Scriptures But till he is come to this height of Folly and Stupidity if he will be consistent with himself and true to those Principles of Reason from which he argues in all other Cases he cannot reject the Authority of the Scriptures upon the account of any Difficulties that he finds in them whilst the Arguments by which they are proved to be of Divine Authority remain unanswered And all the Objections which can be invented against the Scriptures cannot seem near so absurd to a considering Man as to suppose that God should not at all reveal himself to Mankind or that the Heathen Oracles or Mahomet's Alcoran should be of Divine Revelation CHAP. XXXIV The Conclusion containing an Exhortation to a serious Consideration of these things both from the Example of the wisest and most learned Men and from the infinite Importance of the Things themselves AS Wise and as Learned Men as any that ever lived in the World have died in the Belief of the Christian Religion when they had no Interest to engage them to it and many of them have led their Lives under Pesecutions and have at last been put to Death rather than they would renounce that Faith which the Scriptures declare to us It cannot be denied but that there have been Men of as great Learning and as great Numbers of them professing the Christian Religion as have been of all other Religions in the World Indeed all manner of Arts and Sciences have been more improved by Christians than by all other sorts of Men whatsoever and all rational and solid Learning is confined as I may say within Christendom For besides the Idolotrous Worship and other Impieties notorious among them whatsoever Learning is to be found among the Chinese or other Heathen Nations their Notions of Things so far as they differ from what is contained in the Scriptures are so obscure and confused at the best and so groundless that that Christian must be very weary of his Religion who can think of changing it for such Uncertainties And no Man that profess'd and called himself a Christian ever disbelieved the Scriptures but there were visibly other Reasons for it than these which the Nature of the Christian Religion could afford It was apparent in his Life that he wished the Christian Religion were false before he endeavoured to persuade himself that it is not true Some are possess'd with that intolerable Spirit of Pride and Contradiction that meer Vanity and a Conceit of being wiser than others makes them find fault with any thing that is generally received and the greatest Fault which these Man can find with the Christian Religion is that they have been bred up in it and therefore they make heavy Complaints of the prejudices of Education and the hindrances which ingenuous Minds labour under from the influences of it in the pursuit of Truth And these Men perhaps might have talk'd as much and to as much purpose for Christianity as they now talk against it if they had not been Born among Christians and been bred up in the Christian Religion they scorn to be the better for their Education and are ashamed of nothing more than to believe and think like other Men and they might almost be persuaded to be Christians still if they could but be singular in being so For the mere Affectation of Singularity makes them dispise and dispute against any thing which others allow and esteem But it will be hard to find any learned Man of tolerable Modesty and Vertue and