If the Church of Rome were not a Church in some respects but a meere Idoll the Pope could not be that Antichrist a principall rebell a notorious traitor against Christ If we speak absolutely or compare Rome with Churches truly Christian it is no true Church but the Synagogue of Satan But if we speake of it in opposition to the Jewes of Turkes or other professed Infidels it hath so much of a visible Church as a man cannot say it is no Church at all so much true doctrine is in it as sufficeth to support the title of Antichrist and some ordinances are so administred as that it cannot be said they are meer nullities In the true Church many wicked ones are found that are no lesse prophane sacrilegious enemies to peace the vassals of Satan possessed by the Divell dead in sin and accursed of God than heretiks or schismatiks who yet for that they have that order office or degree of ministerie which is holy doe no lesse nor with lesse effect administer the holy sacraments than those who are the samplars of all pietie and vertue The faithfull and holy Ministers administer and receive the Sacraments with good profit and benefit to themselves and others The hypocriticall with benefit to others not to themselves The prophane being not put from their places doe officiate with hurt to themselves scandall to others but to the everlasting comfort of them that partake worthily The hereticall and idolatrous administer the Sacraments that are holy and in their owne nature the meanes pledges and assurances of salvation but without benefit to themselves and others that continue in sin Thus the Prophets Apostles Martyrs and faithfull have held communion in the Ordinances of grace with such whose calling and conversation was not approved of God You say the Martyrs first and last would not receive this distinction lest to save their lives they should lose their soules and you reckon up many who as you write would rather give their bodies to the fire than heare or receive the Sacrament in false Churches or Societies But in this you lavish as in every thing else and hide the truth under the ambiguitie of the phrase The Martyrs laid downe their lives rather than they would defile themselves with idolatry bee present at the Masse or joyne themselves as members of that Antichristian Synagogue in all which they did as becommeth the faithfull servants of Jesus Christ But you cannot produce one Martyr of your opinion who denyed that any thing of God was to be found in those Assemblies or that refused to joyne in the pure ordinances of God with Societies separated from spirituall Babylon because of some defect or may me in their Church constitution In the whole Catalogue of Martyrs try if you can bring forth one who in these things was of your minde And what a vaine thing is it to pretend the example of all the Martyrs when there is not one among them that doth approve your cause If the example of the Martyrs be of any weight with you as here you beare the Reader in hand CAN Neces of separation p. 190 191 192. of necessitie you must condemne your rash and presumptuous censuring your unadvised sinfull separation from the worship and ministerie in our Church as Antichristian and Idolatrous For certaine it is the Martyrs stood members of our Societies and dyed in the defence of that doctrine and worship which we professe and practise Many words you spend in answer to this reason and reproaches you cast upon your adversarie but one word is not to be found that makes directly to take away the force of the Argument It was the answer of Frederick Duke of Saxonie who being prisoner to Charles the fifth and promised releasement if hee would goe to the Masse Summum in terris Dominum agnosco Caesarem in coclis Christum The like did the Prince of Condee but neither of them did refuse to joyne with the reformed Churches because they deemed their Church constitution defective or erroneous in this or that particular To pretend the consent of popish and protestant Divines in this matter is egregious ignorance or impudency for it is well knowne they are all generally of another minde Your instance from a City or Towne Similitudes bee no syllogismes Earthly similitudes of your making may not controll the heavenly precepts of Gods owne giving Bilson Christ part 4. pag. 322. Have you no surer ground of your catholike doctrine for adoring Images than a single similitude taken from the civill and externall reverence that is yeelded to Princes seates and seales Id p. 329. if the Civill power be usurped is not to the purpose nor true in all respects Not to the purpose because what is of God in these Societies is not done by power meerely usurped but by power and vertue from God though in the ministration that which is evill be not approved of God for wheresoever any supernaturall truth of Christian Religion is taught and any ordinances of grace dispensed truly for substance there is some truth of ministery though many wayes polluted And where the intire faith is professed and received and the ordinances of grace administred truly there is a true ministery for substance ordained of God what other defects or maimes soever it may labour under Not true because in the Civill estate That which is done by power usurped and unlawfull in some cases is a nullitie but in other some it is available and stands in force For it is a rule in the Civill law That it is one thing to be a true Magistrate another to bee in the Magistracy or to execute the Magistrates office From which distinction is gathered this generall ruled case or sentence That the acts of him that was a false or unlawfull Magistrate may be lawfull and just And the same may bee said and was ever held in the Church of God of corrupt and ungodly Ministers though they bee not true Ministers that is approved fit and rightly qualified yet so long as they be in the place of Ministers the acts of their ministery be good that is effectuall and of force if they observe the forme of administration prescribed by Christ CAN Stay Sect. 15. pag 133. The Lord hath not promised to them his blessing and acceptance what the Lord may accept or will we dispute not only this I say whosoever heareth in a false Church cannot by any promise that he hath in the word of God expect Gods blessing on that which he doth the reason is because a true constitution of a true Church that is where men are gathered according to the Gospell of Christ is that only lawfull religious societie or communion of Saints wherein God will be honoured whereby hee will bee served and whereto hee hath promised his presence and acceptance so then howsoever we are not bound unto hearing in a true Church necessitate medii as if Gods grace were tyed to the meanes this way
yet as they say in Schooles necessitate praecepti if we consider Gods commandement CAN Stay §. 3. pag. 59. so we are bound to Church hearing only in a true Church and in no other Church can we expect Gods presence promise and acceptance Such Churches unto whom God hath made no promise in his word to blesse the things there done ought not by Gods people to be resorted to but God in his word hath made no promise to blesse the things done in a false church therefore Gods people are not to goe unto false churches The proposition cannot be excepted against for 1. The Scriptures prove it clearly Jer. 23.21 22. Exodus 20 24. Psalme 134.3 and 147.13 Again there is no dutie charged upon us but there is a blessing promised unto the due performance of it The assumption is as cleare and thus wee prove it If false churches have not the promise of Gods presence they cannot from the word of God expect his blessing upon what they doe but the first is true Ergo the second The Major which is only controversall we prove thus If every false church be an Idoll Exod. 20.4 5. And God require his people to come out thence Rev. 18.4 threatned to destroy it Rev. 20.8 9. and will doe it and promise his presence unto his true church Mat. 18.20 Then he is not present in the false But the first is true therefore the second ANSWER You struggle hard as all men may perceive but set not one foot forward Our Church is an idoll therefore wee must not hold communion with it God hath promised no blessing to his ordinances therein because the Church is an Idoll This is your circle wherein you walke up and down But to helpe you out of this mire if it may be 1. Rom. 3.2 Can 1.6 Rain de idolola l. 2. c. 1. p. 2. Where you take it for granted that our Church is false and therfore Christ is not present with us we on the contrary are assured that we are a people in covenant with Christ to whom hee hath committed his heavenly oracles and seales of the covenant amongst whom he feedeth his flock in greene pastures and causeth them to lye downe by the still waters with whom he is present when they meet together Mat. 18.20 Exod. â—0 24 Psal 134.3 Ioh. 10.4.5 He hath set up his tabernacle amongst us and dwelleth with us and watcheth over us and worketh by his Ministers not only to call men unto salvation but to nourish and build them forward unto life everlasting We are separated from Idols wee heare the voice of the true shepheard and follow not strangers but fly from them we believe in the Lord Jesus Christ for salvation and worship him sincerely according to his will He standeth at the doore knocking and to such as open unto him hee commeth unto them and they sup with him and he with them And therefore Christ is our Shepheard our King our Saviour and of his rich grace and love doth embrace us as his people and the flock of his pasture beareth our prayers and accepteth our service This is our glory that Christ is ours and we are his and it were better for us to dye than that our glorying herein should be made void Secondly seeing this tearme False Church is so familiar with you we will consider what it meaneth and how farre it doth stand true that God hath made no promise to blesse things done in a false Church These words True and false Church are used oft to signifie as much as pure and corrupt found and languishing Church And as there is scarce a Church so pure which hath not some impuritie nor so true which hath not some falshood admixed so there is no Church so false or impure which hath not somewhat of God or some supernaturall Christian truth within it For if no supernaturall Christian truth bee received or professed there is no Church Infidels being cleane without the Church deny and utterly reject the principles of Christianitie Heretikes or false Christians in respect of generall truths which they openly professe are Christians or of the Church but in respect of their particular errours condemned of all men that be of sound beliefe A Church is not to be esteemed false for some corruptions nor impure for some disorders no more than we account him a sickly man who now and then findes some wearinesse or distemper Neither is a Church to be accounted true because of some truths which they professe Act. 2.41 42 46 worship which they practise or use of the Sacraments which they retaine The notes of a pure Church are intire profession of the Gospell and saving truth of God the right use of the Sacraments holinesse of conversation the sound preaching of the word of life fervent and pure calling upon Gods name subjection to their spirituall guides whereby they may bee directed and built forward in the wayes of life mutuall communion in the ordinances of worship Eph. 4.11 12. and Christian fellowship with all Saints and true visible Churches of Jesus Christ Those Churches to which all these notes agree truelie are to bee esteemed pure in their measure but those to whom all doe not agree or not so truely they are to be esteemed lesse pure or true and that in comparison more or lesse according as more or fewer of these notes common speciall or proper shall be found more or lesse pure amongst them Where all these notes are to be found purely the Church is excellent for degree pure and famous where any of these is wanting or impure the Church is so much defective or impure though it may be pure in comparison of others The profession of the true faith Acts 14.22.23 27 and the framing of our life and conversation according to the direction of the word with the right administration of the Sacraments and comely order Ier. 4.22 Mat. 13.14 15. Isa 30.9 10 11. 5.7 8 9 c. are signes of a Church in a good state and condition But it may fall out that the profession of faith alone by publike preaching and hearing of the word administration of the Sacraments prayers and thanksgiving doth take place when good order is neglected and if life degenerate from the profession for in this case she ceaseth not to be the true CHVRCH of Christ so long as it pleaseth him not to give her a Bill of divorce True doctrine in all points and the due and right administration of the Sacraments in all things according to the word both for substance and circumstance is the note of a pure Church and in good plight But true Doctrine in the maine grounds and Articles of faith though mixt with defects and errours in other matters not concerning the life and soule of Religion and the right administration of the Sacraments for substance though in the manner of dispensation some things be not so well ordered as they might and ought
6. 8. Beza epist 81. Quid interim misera Dei ecclesia nempe haec tunc erat ipsius cōditio quae olim in Israele temporibus Eliae delirescentibu◠in spelūca fidelibus Dei Prophetis et qualis rum erar quum everso Dei templo jugi cessante sacrificio captiva in Babylone teneretur Servabat tamen Dominus renascituri suo tempore populi semen Manebat salvus in papatu Baptismus in patris filij Sp. Sancti nomen c. decayed and corrupt Church If any of our men deny the Churches wherein our Fathers lived to be the Churches of God their meaning is limited in respect of the prevailing faction that was in the church and including them and all the wicked impieties by any of them defended in which sence their negative is to be understood These things standing thus might not the christian Magistrate take away the Idoll of the Masse injoyne the reading of the Scriptures in a knowne tongue appoint that prayer should be made to God onely in the mediation of Jesus Christ and take order that the Sacrament of the Supper might be administred in both kindes * 2 Chron. 17.7 8 9 10. according to the institution Might he not n Nabuchadneezer made a law That no man should blaspheme the God of Shadrac c. Dan. 3.29 Darius that men trēble feare before the God of Daniel Dan. 6.26 Joshua made a covenant with the people that they should put away their strange gods Ios 24.23 Asa destroyed Idolatrie commanded the people to serve and seeke the Lord 2 Par. 14.3 4. 15 8 9 10 c. Jehosaphat sent Princes to teach in the Cities of Judah with them Levites 2 Chro. 17.7 8 9. 19.4 Hezekiah sent to all Israel Iudah that they should come to the house of the Lord 2 Par. 30.1.6 Also he took away the high places 2 Reg. 18.4 Iosiah brake downe the altars of Baal and brought backe the people to the worship of God 2 Chron. 34.3 4 5.7 29 30 32 33. Polonia Russia Lithuania was forced at the commandement of their Rulers to forsake their ancient Idols and receive Baptisme Munster Cosmograph fol. 894.902 and divers good Princes maintained long and sharpe warres of purpose to compell the Saxons and Vandals to the faith Idem lib. 3. fol. 719.743 It is a strange new kind of preaching for Bishops to drive men to beleeve with whippings as Bonner did but in Princes who beare the sword and are Gods Lievetenants not onely to procure peace between men but also by Lawes to maintaine Religion towards God we neither did nor doe dispraise moderate correction when need so requireth August Epist 127. Idem contra Erescon lib. 3. cap. 50. Idem contra lit Petilian lib. 2. cap. 86.83 Codex lib. 1. tit 5. de Haeretic Socrat. lib. 1. ca. 34. Gr. lat 21 22. Euseb de vità Const lib. 1. cap. 37. Theoderet lib. 5. cap. 20. Multa enim cogit ferre necessitas quae tamen non probantur command all people throughout his Dominions professing the faith to learne the grounds of Religion to call upon the Name of the Lord to heare his Word and to worship him truly and purely according as the Lord himselfe hath appointed And when the people could not or were carelesse and negligent might he not provide meanes for their instruction and edification in the faith of the Lord Jesus This the Christian Magistrates did amongst us by authority from God They provided that the Scriptures should be read in a known language in all Congregations Ministers injoyned to catechise in the grounds of Christian Religion the Gospell was preached in many places disputation was profered to the learned for satisfaction If these things be advisedly confidered we shall heare no more from the Brethren of the Separation that our Church was gathered without the Word by meere Proclamation not called but made up a Church in one day at the commandement of the evill Magistrate at least no man that hath truly tasted of the Word of life will be moved with such like cavills unlesse it be to condemne their rashnesse and unthankfulnesse so much the more It might here be added that before reformation many did earnestly desire it some lay hid all the dayes of Queene Mary who never came to the Masse but trained up their children and servants at home in the grounds of Christian Religion others fled into forraine parts some met together in private in their owne Countryes as they had opportunitie and many groaned under that bondage in which they were held all which did gladly welcome the truth when it shined forth and rejoyced when they might joyn in the Congregation understand their prayers heare the Scriptures and be instructed in the principles of faith and holinesse And if I should say that at the first reformation there were more godly learned painfull Preachers that endeavoured to bring forward the people in the wayes of godlinesse by an hundred to one than ever wane of your Separation since the Gospell shined unto the world I conceive you shall not be able to finde an Hyperbole in the speech And now suppose in this great and admirable worke such a course to be held as cannot be justified in all things shall this make a nullitie of that which is prosperously effected by the blessing of God If ignorant Ministers should not have beene set over the people when better could not be had if people should not have been admitted to the Lords Supper before better instruction in the grounds of Christian Religion when yet the Law doth presuppose them in some sort instructed If prophane and notorious wicked persons which should have been cast out unlesse they had repented were received into communion without any due course held before to reform and amend them this argueth o Beza epist 1. ad Dudetium Valentinian the elder was a good man worthy the Empire being himself of the Nicene faith Theod. lib. 4. ca. 5. Sozom. lib. 6. cap. 6. and yet he molested not any that were of the contrary faith neither thought he it good to change Ecclesiastical laws into better or worse Sozom. li. 6. ca. 20. Socrat. l. 4. c. 1 and made a Law that every man that would might have two wives himselfe gave the first example in taking two Socrat. l. 4. Gr. ca. 30. lat ca. 16. Can. Neces of Separat p. 175 176 1 Reg. 6.17 18. 2 Chron. 1.8 9. imperfection in the reformation and just cause that we should strive forward to perfect what was happily begun but proveth not the assemblies to be Antichristian or the reformation to be of no worth and validitie Looke through all the Reformations mentioned in Scripture or recorded in other Antiquities and set if this reformation be a nullity whether ever there was a reformed church in the world for any continuance SECT II. THe materiall Temple was a type of the visible Churches under the
CAN stay Epist to the Reader CAN Neces of separation Epist to the Reader wisheth tendernesse of conscience to his Reader ever and anon objecteth to his â—pposites what abominations and vile corruptions they labour to justifie which formerly they condemned beareth in hand that the Scriptures speak expresly for him and the learned of all sorts ancient and moderne who would not expect faire cariage and honest dealing whereas let the whole frame of his writings be looked into with a single heart and unpartiall eye and it will be found wery corrupt loose deceitfull for the matter and stuffed with scorne reproach slander insolency and falsifications for the manner Herein whether I speake the words of truth and sobernesse let the Reader search and then give sentence But for mine owne part I desire to answer in the feare of God and not to strive with him in the like measure of sinning A good cause needs no such tricks of wit but as it is of God so it is able to maintaine and defend it self and the more sincerely it is propounded the more it will prevaile In controversies if men will keepe a good conscience their zeale must be tempered with wisedome truth and meeknesse of spirit they must speake as in Gods presence give the right sense of Scripture and make fit application of it seeke the truth in love and that victorie alone which truth will carrie According to the measure of grace received from God I shall desire to walke within these bounds and with this resolution I come to compare cause with cause and reason with reason Let the Scriptures be the only judge betweene us upon which all a Aug. Epist 48. Audi quid dicit Dominus non quid dicit Donatus c. Et de Pastor ca. 4. Ego vocem Pastoris requirâ— lege de Psalmo c. Hieron in Mat. 23. Quod ex Scriptura non habet authoritatem c. Basil de vera fide Nos omnem a Dominica doctrina alienam vocem sententiam fugiamus Chr. in 2 Cor. hom 13. Obsecro oro omnes vos ut relinquatis quid huic vel illi videatur de his scripturis haec omnia inquirite Ambr. tom 3. lib. 5. epist 31. Caeli mysterium doceat me Deus ipse non homo qui seipsum ignoravit Petrus de Aliaco praec Gerson Nullum principis edictum aut ecclesiae decretum est justum nisi sit Divinae legi consonum Novum Testamentum est malleus qui universas haereses interimit est velut lucerna lumen exhibens recurrendum est ad folas Scripturas ut aeteâ—nam salutem adipiscamur conclusions in Divinitie if sound are grounded whereby all distinctions if true are warranted After the voice of God in Scripture the determinations and practices of our Guides who are no b Mat. 11.8 Luc. 7.14 1 Reg. 14.15 sc calamus arundincus non aromaticus sâ—â— mensorius CAN stay answ sect 1. p. 47. Howsoever we must live by our owne faith notwithstanding wee are not lightly to esteeme of the determinations and practices of our Guides specially when we know they are no reedes but men stable and unchangeable in the truth Bilson Christian subject part 2. pag. 351. Many Bishops have taught lyes and and seduced Princes in the Church of God and therfore not their dignitie but their doctrine is it that princes must regard for neither prince nor people stand bound to the persons of men but unto the truth of God and unto their teachers so long as they swerve not from the truth Id. Absolute judge of truth neither prince nor priest may challenge to be for God is truth and of God I trust no man may bee judge The sonne of God saith of himselfe I am truth c. Angust de nuptiis ad Valentin l. 2. cap. 33. Optat. lib. 5. ad Parmenian And page 351. Only God is to limit and appoint by his word what shalt stand for truth and what for errour c. And as Bishops ought to discerne which is the truth before they teach so must the people discerne who teacheth right before they believe Idem page 355. As the pastors have authoritie from Christ to preach the truth and woe be to them that resist the preachers of truth so have all hearers both libertie to discerne and a charge to beware of seducers given them by the same Lord and woe be to them that doe it not reeds but men stable in the truth shall be produced for they are not lightly to be esteemed though their consent cannot bee the ground of Divine faith and assurance The Lord in mercie give us to know the things which concerne our peace comfort and salvation and make us wise to walke in all pleasing before him CHAP. I. THe Question betwixt us is Whether by the Scriptures and principles of the Nonconformists The state of the Question Separation from the Church of England be necessary or lawfull Those that hold it lawfull to be present at the preaching of the Word but not to partake in the prayers of the Congregations nor to be present at the Sacraments there administred I leave to their owne defence The necessity or lawfullnesse of Separation is that which I deny Neither is it here questioned CAN. Necessit of Separ Epist to the Reader Whether the principles of the Nonconformists be true and justifiable but whether the necessity or lawfulnesse of separation can truly and justly be inferred and concluded from them This Position therefore I lay downe as directly contrary to the other That separation from the prayers Sacraments and preaching of the Word of God in the congregations and assemblies of the Church of England is unlawful by the Scriptures that whatsoever complaints whether just or unjust the Nonconformists judicious learned and holy have made of the corruptions in our Church government Ministerie Worship Prayers Administration of the Sacrament and people received or permitted as externall members they doe not inferre either in their judgements or in truth a necessitie or lawfulnesse of Separation from our Churches as no true Churches of Christ our Ministerie as false and Antichristian our Worship as Idolatry And therefore I shall shall hope such as have separated unadvisedly if men of tender hearts they will repent of their rashnesse seeing the grounds where upon they build are rotten the building ruinous and the practice directly tending to the scandall of Religion and discomfort of their soules And now I proceed in the feare of God by the beames of Truth to try and examine what is objected to shew the necessitie of Separation from the Nonconformists principles SEC I. TO Communicate in a false Ministerie CAN. Neces of Separat ca. 1. S. 3 pag. 26 27. The Church acts of Antichristian Ministers are Idolatious Id. Stay sect 1. pag. 5. s 4. p. 28. Id. Stay Answ s 5 pag. 66. Mat. 24.5.24 Hos 4 17. See Jun. on the the place See
33. A rotten contagion creepeth at this day through the whoâ— body of the Church the 〈◊〉 the de perater the more inward the more deadly c. Ye be called Pastors when indeed ye be spoilers and would God the milke and fleece â—â—d suffice you ye thrist for blood The Arch Priest visiteth his charge to fill his purse he betrayethen â—ocent blood he filleth murders adultenes incests fornications c. Hokâ—â— in sap lib. lect 1â—2 The Priests or our age are like the Priests of Baal they are wicked Angels they resemble the Priests of Dâ—gâ—n they are priests of Prinpus and Angels of Heb. 〈…〉 123. Dâ—v 〈…〉 have been brought us against Clerkes 〈…〉 Bishops thâ—◠〈…〉 not their lives according to the â—â—cred Ca 〈…〉 which should be a â—â—at the 〈…〉 〈…〉 But who are dogs False Teachers who did barke against the doctrine of salvation by Christ pressed Circumcision as necessarie to salvation were returned to their old vomite and being formerly of Jews made Christians were fallen back to Judaisme And is there any Question but we must take heed of these and all others of the same kinde And this is that which Zanchy confirmeth by many other Texts of Scripture Viz. That not onely the Teachers but the Faithfull must learne to know and beware of ravening wolves blinde guides who bring not the doctrine of Christ denie all the Articles of Faith or some at least speake perverse things and draw Disciples after them But what is become of shame and honestie when men apply this against them that preach Christ truely and intirely and administer the holy things of God purely by authority received from God Or against communicating with them in the Ordinances of God who professe the faith are called to dispence the ordinances of Religion because in some particular their calling was not orderly as it ought or the persons endued with gifts as God requireth Further answere may be taken out of that which hath been spoken to the former passages for one answer will fit them all To communicate in the true Worship of God with Ministers no better than ignorant idle proud cruell covetous and profane Priests no better than Scribes and Pharisees is neither a vaine worship nor an abetting of the party in his sinne nor to rebell against the Lord nor to commit spirituall whoredome or to embrace the bosome of an harlot These are great words to affright but they are of no force to hurt if a man will not cowardly yeeld without any combate No to communicate with such when God called us thereunto is to worship God aright to reverence his ordinances to rely on his grace to hearken unto his voice and submit unto his good pleasure To such communicating he hath promised and vouchsafed his blessing their service is acceptable unto God because commanded by him and they have found him graciously present to cheere and refresh them It is without question the Prophets our Saviour the Apostles the Faithfull in all ages have communicated with such in Gods Ordinances but not in their sinne And what man well advised will say of that practice that it was either Rebellion against God or spirituall whoredom or vaine worship The Faithfull must not communicate with those societies in mind or body where Christ is not at all present with the presence of his grace and love nor in those polluted Congregations Rev. 18.4 where reall Idolatrie is so practised that they cannot be present but they must partake therein We have forsaken the Strumpet that made drunke the inhabitants of the earth with the wine of her fornication and are gone out of her lest wee should be partakers in her sinnes and receive of her plagues otherwise wee have divided our selves neither from God nor his Church Bilson Christ an part 3. pag 19. They must not communicate with false Prophets in things of their owne devising and which they bring meerly upon their owne braine and not at all from God but if ignorant scandalous corrupt men who neither please God nor are approved of him in their Office and Ministration in a societie professing the intire Faith of Christ doe by authoritie dispense the Ordinances of God the Faithfull may and ought to communicate with them if they want power to redresse and amend things out of order They must not Communicate in sin but they may and ought to hold Communion in the exercises of Religion with the true Church of Christ The sheep of Christ heare his voice but will not heare the voice of a stranger Joh. 10.5 But who is that stranger whom the sheep will not heare From whom they flie both in minde and body with whom they must hold no Communion CAN. Stay §. 11 p. 112 113. inward or outward Thus farre you extend the words of our Saviour and unlesse they be so meant they conclude not what you purpose Is every unlawfull Minister this stranger Deodat Itaâ— Joh. 10.1 Thieves and robbers are the false Doctors vvho thrust in themselves without a lawfull calling with false doctrine and an evilâ—n ind The true shepheard is onely Christ the rest are his servants and not the owners of the sheep The sheep must not rule their shepheards but they have leave to discerne strangers and flie from thieves and murderers Cyp. lib. 1. Epâ—st 4. Therefore the flock or people obeying the Lords Pâ—â—cepts and fearing God ought to separate themselves from a sinful Bishop Bilson 〈…〉 part 3. page 301. 353. CAN Stay § 3. p. 26. Jer. 23.14 15. Acts 20.25 26 27 28 29 30 31. Is every unlearned scandalous corrupt Minister this stranger Is every one whom Christ calleth a thiefe and a robber who enters not in by the dore but climbes up some other way this stranger Is every one that smiteth but feedeth not the flock that maketh sad the heart of the Godly strengtheneth the hands of the wicked mingleth the Truth of God with his owne dreames this stranger If these be not strangers meant by Christ much lesse the painfull godly sincere Pastor who feedeth the flock with sound and wholsome foode and leadeth them unto the waters of life And then this passage is impertinently alledged But all these cannot be meant according to your interpretation for then absolutely all communicating with them in the Ordinances of God is not forbidden but to receive their doctrine embrace their errours or follow their manners which was evermore unlawfull The Godly and Faithfull among the Jews might not refuse to heare the Scribes and Pharisees when they had no power to cast them out and yet they were thieves and robbers who corrupted the Law and without question spake most reproachfull things against the way and worship of God The godly could not be sure that the Pharisees would not deliver such things neither did they offend in being present at the worship of God and yet it will not follow that a man may heare any one or any where Thieves and
murderers in the Church of the Jewes sprung up with them and continued amongst them and neither departed themselves nor were cast out by others that had authoritie In the Christian Church divers false Teachers ravening Wolves Antichrists rose up 1 Joh. 2.19 Tit. 3.10 1 Tim 1.20 2 Thes 2.3 4. Phil. 1.15 not from among the heathen or Jews but in and from themselves whereof some went out from the Church and separated themselves others were cast out by excommunication and delivered up to Satan that they might learne not to blaspheme Others were tolerated in the Church either because their heresies were not so pernicious at the first or the better side had not power to cast them out or they preached the fundamentall Truths but of evill mindes These in respect of outward order were lawfully elected or called but false Prophets discovered by their doctrine not by their calling When the Apostle exhorteth Timothy not to partake in other menâ— sins doth he not intimate that unfit unable unworthy Ministers might be ordained in the Churches though unlawfully and some of them continuing in the Church the Faithfull are not forbidden to partake of the Ordinances of God because they are present but to beware of their errours that they be not infected by them But if by strangers we understand onely such as did arise from without and brought blasphemous doctrine directly contrary to the foundation of the Faith or such as are justly cast out by the Church that they might learne not to blaspheme then the Faithfull might neither communicate with them in publike nor receive them unto house but flie from them both in minde and body But thieves who lead not in by the doore Christ who have strange voices which the sheep acknowledge not who bring another foundation besides Jesus Christ Atha ad solitariam vita agentes complaineth against Constantius That whereas the Bishops in those daies were wont to be lawfully chosen by the people of the place and sufficiently examined and allowed by other Bishops ad joyning and openly created in the Church Constantius in stead of the Church would have his â—alace succeed and for the multitude of people and right Assemblies to elect he commanded three Euâ—uches to be present and three of his Spies or Prolers for you cannot call them Bishops that they sixe in his palace might create one Felix a Bishop And notiâ—g what manner the Emperor and his Eunuches made he saith In illorum locum juvenes libidinosos e hnieos ne catechismo quiaem imbutos neâ— non bigamos maximis crimin bus male and entes modo aurum darent vesâ—i emptorese forâ— ad Episcopatu summiserere Bilson Christian Subj part 2. pag 255. these are not to be enrolled with such as teach the doctrine of Faith truly for they are not strangers either in respect of Sect Religion or Lawes they are of the houshold of God they serve the Lord as he hath prescribed and walke according to his Law And what is it to wrest the Scripture if this be not when that which is spoken against utter enemies of our Saviour Christ who refused to be shepheards under him and his Ensigne is applied to them who are furnished with singular knowledge wisedome and utterance teach the truth of the Gospell intirely and leade the sheep of Christ to the waters of life whose labours God hath blessed whose voice the sheep heare and receive in whose message they rejoyce and whom they follow as they teach Christ You pretend the testimony of the learned in this matter but let the places be examined and they will be found either to make directly against you or nothing for you as I shall have occasion to shew in the next Section and shall be done more fully when you shall set downe the words of the Authors whereupon you build and attempt from them to make good your conclusion In the meane space I will forbeare tediously to repeat over and over again that such and such make nothing for you and such and such are grossely abused and falsifyed Now let us lay the Principles and Inference together and see if they close The Nonconformists complain of many grosse abuses in the Ministerie in the Election Ordination Qualities of the Person admitted and execution of the function as that ignorant negligent profane men are set over the flock and Non-residents Pluralists men of corrupt mindes who discourage the godly and hearten the profane But this complaint they put not up against all but many in the Ministery The Inference you would make upon their ground is That it is unlawfull to communicate not onely with these men in the Ordinances of Gods Worship but even with the most learned godly and painfull who teach the Truth live holily dispence the Mysteries of Godlinesse purely be approved of the Congregations and blessed of the most high If I took pleasure in your veine call it as you please I could say CAN. Stay §. 11. p. 114. I suspect my sight and I aske of my selfe againe and againe could the Treat write so unskilfully For if this be not a Non sequitur then Fooles cannot speake Non-sense You may take it home For I know not to whom it can be so fitly applyed as to your selfe When this Inference is made good by Scripture Reason or Learned Author I shall suspect that the Non-conformists doe not walke according to their Principles But till then there is just ground to think that in making such Inferences you abuse both your selfe and others That which you adde concerning the dumbe Ministers out of M. Penry CAN. Neces of Sep. p. 43. Id. Neces of Sep. Epist to the Reader is besides the point for he was no Non-conformist but a Separatist by your confession and if no man of pietie will pleade for them yet men of piety learning and judgement doe and must pleade for it is a truth that there is not an absolute Nullitie of their Ministerie and this I presume upon better advice you will not denie or if you doe you must not stay in the Separation which you have made SEC II. CAN Necessitie of Separation pag. 29 30. NOne may heare or joyne in Spirituall Communion with that Ministerie which hath not a true vocation and calling by election approbation and ordination of that Faithfull people where he is to administer Id pag. 46. If their Parsons Vicars Parish Priests Stipendiaries c. be neither in election nor ordination made Ministers agreeable to the Word of God then is their Ministerie false unlawfull Antichristian and so consequently they deale with the holy things of God CAN. Stay §. 11. pag. 113. All these affirme That whosoever taketh upon him to preach without a lawfull sending commeth in not by a lawfull election and holy Church ordinance but breaketh in against order by force and favour of men and by humane lawes he is a Stranger a thiefe a murderer according to Christs
honor him as our God if we alter that which he hath appointed for himselfe or adde any thing unto it he rejecteth all our service as done not unto him but to the conceit of our hearts which by nature is no God c. Grat. Caâ—s 11. Qu. 3. c. 101. Sats qui praeest Aug. de Conser Evang. l. 1. c. 18. Socratis sententia est Vnumquemque Deum sic coliopercere quomodose ipse colendum esse praeceperit Aug. in Qu. ex veteri Teslam Qu. 43. Constat â—â—den stultam non solum minime prodesse sed etiam obesse Chry. in Matth. hom 51. Discaâ— us Coristum ex ipsius voluntate honorare Nam qui honoratur â—o maximè honore laetatur 〈◊〉 vuit non quem nos optamus Bils dâ—ffer betw Christ Subj part 1 p. 7. Touching the Sacraments I 〈◊〉 Baptisme and the Lords Supper c. We swerve not a jot from the example of Christ and his Apostles the Scriptures vvill not lie let them be judges is fairely passed over with a brave flourish of words and nothing else If you meet with such company as will be ashamed not to see because you cry out so vehemently It is as cleere as the Sun it cannot be denied with any modest face You may lead him blindfold But if a man will build upon his owne faith and not be led by your fansies he shall never see it proved by any evidence that you have or can bring That by communicating in our Assemblies in the ordinances of Religion God is worshipped in any other way or manner than he hath prescribed But seeing this reason is brought so often and for so many purposes I will examine it more particularly If the meaning of your proposition bee That no positive worship or substantiall means of worship is lawfull but what is in speciall appointed or instituted of God and that no duties of Religion be necessary to salvation but what are taught in Scripture then we grant it is true and confirmed by the course of Scripture though many passages cited by you will not reach unto it For the law of nature commandeth all men who have any sense of a Godhead to receive and not give rules of Religion and Worship The holy care of the Patriarchs was to reverence and obey that which they had received and to attend upon further direction but of themselves not to appoint or undertake any thing as necessary to salvation Divine institution of legall and Evangelicall obedience and worship is equally full and complete in all things necessary which it seemed good to divine Wisedome to determine not leaving any thing of this nature more undetermined in time of the Gospel than it was in time of the Law As the Jews had a commandement neither to adde ought unto nor take ought from the law Deut. 4.2 which the Lord gave unto them so the Apostles received a charge to teach whatsoever the Lord commanded them Whence it is truly observed Matth. 28.20 Zanch. de Ecript that men may not teach their own doctrine but whatsoever Christ hath taught them for hee reserveth this authoritie to himselfe to be the onely Teacher and Author of the doctrine Genev. Bible annot in Matth. 28.20 Shew but one word element or action added omitted or altered in either of them c. Galv Instit l. 4. ca. 10. §. 1.2.5 Hon. Ainsw first answ p. 26. That he taught any thing as needfull for salvation without warrant from the Scriptures I denie Harm confess Helvetic confess cap. 24. Ang. confess ca. De discrim ciborum Chamier tom 4. de Sacram. l. 1. c. 13. §. 8. Bils differ betw Christ Suâ—j par 1. p. 25. This is the duty that Baptisme requireth of us to beleeve no teacher but one which is Christ to follow no stranger to regard or obey no Lord or Law-maker in the Church but only the Son whom the Father appointed to be Master Leader and Ruler of the Gentiles Basil ser de fide It is an evident sliding from the faith c. either to depart from that which is written or to receive that which is not written The King of the Church is her only Lawgiver at all times But if the way or manner of Worship be stretched to the circumstances of time place order phrase of speech and such like not determined by God in particular but left to the libertie of Christians so the generall rules of Scripture be observed then the proposition is not true the Scriptures doe not confirm it it was never acknowledged by Divines of any sort or sect that have appeared to the world For what is in generall only Divine but in particular left without determination from God that in it selfe is indifferent and variable of which sort were the houres of the morning and evening sacrifice their Synagogues Oratories and places of Worship throughout the land of Canaan their course of reading and many the like What God hath commanded in his Word that is not left to the libertie of Christians What is prescribed as necessary worship holy that he hath not left undetermined But that which may be done this way or another at this time or another in this forme of speech and method or another that in respect of this order time method or phrase of speech is not necessarie holy or worship Any circumstance as time place or whatsoever else if it be either appropriated or commanded of God it is necessarie in point of conscience holy and worship as in conscience it must be observed and submitted unto But to place necessitie holinesse or worship in these things when they be not determined or commanded is Will-worship or superstition lawfull they be as agreeable to the Word but not necessary because not determined by the Word The time was when it was lawfull to offer sacrifices upon the high places Drus ad dissic loc O at 12. p. 571. Rivet in Hos 4.13 Ainsvv annot in Levit. 17.5 Iun. annot in Levit. 17 5. in 1 Reg. 3.3 Illud in Theologia bonum est quod Deus praecepit lex enim Deiperfecta est bonitatis moralis regula in Theologia prohibitio Divina perfecturest index Theologieus mali iae mâ—ralis Hen. Ainsvv 3. ans p. 151. Explications of Gods Law by them â—â—uâ—h of his Ministers are allowed of God Neh. 8.8 These are not additions such as God forbids Gal. 3.15 15 Our question is of other or moe lavves or Doctrines than God hath taught Scotia Confess art 20. Iua thes theol c. 6. thes 11.12 Quaecunque verò in carcumslantiis posita sant corumtradiâ—iâ—nes in ecclesiâ—◠â esse auâ—â—esse posse verumtamen pat lares temporaliliberas agnoscimus Atque barum quidem traditionum quae in circumstantiis versantur sex sor Paulo 1 Cor. 14 c. Dan. in 1 Tim. 3.15 Calvin Inst 4. l. c. 15 §. 19. 17. §. 45. 〈◊〉 resp ad lib. de pii veri offic p. 413. Th Beza cansess c. 5.
same I leave it to your conscience to judge This is sure neither Scripture nor Author cited doth speake with you in that matter but plainly professe that it was unlawfull because it was expresly forbidden That exercise saith Zanchie did seeme praise-worthy to the Israelites and yet it is to play the harlot Why because it is sacriledge to depart from the Word of the Lord. But the Word of the Lord had commanded that they should worship the Lord only at Ierusalem and by such rites as hee had instituted The Kings who are commended in Scripture who yet tooke not away the high places as Asa Jehosaphat Amasias Azarias and Jothian they were not commended for suffering the high places but that they were constant in faith and religion although they fell into some peculiar sins But withall the abuse of the high places in the worship of God was no light sin but very grievous because it was properly and expresly against the divine law and precept As for the ten Tribes who departed from the house of David they shined grievously in that they worshipped the Calves and that in a place of worship elected of themselves contrary to the word of God leaving and forsaking that place which the Lord bad chosen to himselfe They professed the true God and turned not aside to the gods of the Heathen and in that respect are called the house and family of the Lord 2 King 10.16.31 Hos 9 15. 1 King 12.31 Lev. 17.7 Hebr. Sep. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Iun. demonibus Deu. 32.17 1 Cor. 10.10 Ex. 32.1.8 Acts 7.41 1 Cor. 10.7 1 King 12.28 and 14.9 2 Chron. 11.15 Heb. Sept. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 See Ainsw Annot. in Lev. 17.7 et Iun. ibid. Rainold de Idolola l. 2. c. 3. Isa 44. Qu. Co. pag. 61. CAN Sta. §. 3 pag. 18. Babingt in Lev. 17. See Iun. in Lev. 17.3 4 11. But as they sacrificed at Bethel and committed Idolatry in worshipping the Calves so their service was abominable and their Priesthood appointed for that service a meer nullitie and humane device Thus all the Jewes and Gentiles are said to sacrifice unto Divels who sacrificed in such sort and place as God had forbidden especially it they sacrificed unto Idols though in them they sacrificed unto the true God in their imagination as the Israelites had done when they made the golden Calse and sacrificed unto it and Ieroboams Idols are called Divels and he is said to make Priests for the high places and for Divels Further this Ordinance of God was typicall and did shadow forth Christ as the learned do observe and not without ground and warrant All Altars Sacrifices Priests and the Temple it selfe where the Altar stood were but types and shadowes of Christ You your selfe cite out of Bishop Babington that hereby was signified that only in the Church by faith in the chiefe high Priest Christ Jesus sacrifice and service accepted of God is and can be offered and done and no where els By the erudiments saith another Christ was shadowed among the Jewes and expiation made on the crosse by his blood From hence briefly let these things be observed 1 That the Jewes sinned by facrificing in the high places and the Israelites at Dan and Bethel because God had forbidden it expresly but against communicating in our assemblies no such prohibition can be brought forth which haply might bee the reason why you had rather say because they had no divine precept for it than because it was forbidden which yet you know to bee most certaine 2 Though it bee not lawfull to communicate with the people of God in their sins yet wee may partake in the ordinances of worship with such as offend grievously in the worship of God as the Prophets and faithfull communicated in the ordinances of God at Jerusalem with them that sacrificed upon the high places 3. That in Idolatrous and false Churches that which is meerely of men is vaine and fruitlesse and a meere nullitie but if among them something which is of God remaine it is not to bee esteemed a thing of nought 4 Wee must neither forsake all societies wherein wee espie many things repugnant to the Word of God nor cast off every thing in those societies wherewith we must not hold communion as false vaine and ineffectuall In Idolatrous societies Cyp. lib. 1. c. 4. The people must not partake with the sacrifice of a sacrilegious Priest there may be some truth which I must not cast away though I must not hold society in their Idolatry In the true Churches of Christ there may be diverse errors and abuses wherewith I must not communicate though I must live and hold fellowship in the society I am bound to keepe the unity of that living body S. B. Second ansvver pag. 20. whereof I am a member even with some inconvenience of sickenesse and unsound parts but I must not joyne my selfe to a strange body and so become a member of Satan 5. They that communicate in the Worship of God in our Assemblies doe neither bring a strange oblation nor goe to a place forbidden for the worship is of God and the Congregation assembled in his Name and he is there present to feast them that draw nigh unto him in truth of heart Can. Stay Sect. 3. Pag. 19. Ought we not to beleeve that as God had commanded us to worship Him that is to heare his Word receive the Sacraments and to use other His Ordinances so Hee hath also called and separated unto himselfe a Church a Communion of Saints and holy ones in and amongst whom these holy things are to be used and that we are to looke in what fellowship wee receive the holy things of God as what the things are we doe receive In a word ought we not to be perswaded that as the legall Sacrifices out of the Tabernacle or Temple within whose circle they were prescribed by the mouth of God were unlawfully offered so all the Ordinances and exercises of the Church under the Gospell done out of a true constituted Church are altogether and every way sinfull Deut. 12.5 6 7. ANSWER God hath separated unto himselfe a Church and amongst them hee is to bee worshipped according to his owne appointment But this Church is of larger extent than that which you call a true constituted Church wee reade that the Lord did chuse a certaine place for sacrifices Deut. 12.5 6 7. after which it was unlawfull to sacrifice in any other and so we read also that the remaindes of the Paschall Lamb was to be burnt and the flesh of the Ramme of Consecration with the bread that remained unto the morning Exod. 12.10 Exod. 29.34 Levit. 15.19 I yeeld the Scripture a witnesse of my sense and my exposition without the Scripture let it bee of no credit Orig. Hom. 9 in Jer. CAN. Necess of separ pag. 2 11. Can. Stay Epistle to the Reader Iohn 2.19 21. 2 Cor. 6.16 So
the Altar is put for Christ in the Ancients Ignat. ad Magnesian To one Altar to one Lord Iesus Christ Ad Philadel one Altar to all the Church Iren. adv haeres l 4 ca. 34. est Ergo Altare in caelis Euseb Hist lib. 10. cap. 4. and the flesh of the peace-offering But that all Ordinances of the Church done out of a true constituted Church in your sense should be altogether unlawfull or that the Ordinances are tyed to your Church constitution as the Sacrifices were to the Temple that we reade not and how then shall we be perswaded of it Remember your owne request Let the Scripture speake in the points betweene us for without it nothing is to be affirmed and beyond it nothing to be concluded Principally of old the Temple shaddowed Christ in and through whom we must present our service unto God and then the Church of Christians but that the externall constitution of a Congregationall societie is represented thereby in such sort as if it be thus or thus constituted it should be lawfull to joyne with them but if this or that externall rite be lacking it should be unlawfull to joyne in the worship of God is most unprobable In all ages the Lord hath had his Church in which he hath beene worshipped But evermore the faithfull were not to bring their sacrifices to the Tabernacle or Temple And if the Lord had chosen not that place for sacrifice other service pleasing and acceptable might and ought to bee performed in other places Therefore that Sacrifices should prefigure all Ordinances and exercises of the Christian Church Fulke in Matth. 23. Sect. 7. The Lords Altar that was in the Temple was a figure of Christs onely true sacrifice once offered Bishop Babin comfort notes upon Exod. 27. and the Tabernacle and Temple the externall frame and constitution of a Church is an unwritten tradition It is more reasonable a great deale to compare the externall frame of the Iewish Church with the outward order which God hath instituted for the Evangelicall Churches and worship with worship substance of Religion with substance and then it will follow that as the faithfull and religious Iewes might and ought to hold societie in the Ordinances of Religion when many things were amisse in the externall frame and constitution of the Church as the Priests idle covetous prophane the people dissolute impenitent rebellious so the faithfull in the Christian Church must hold Communion in the Ordinances of Grace though in the constitution of the Church the Officers and members much be out of order Doway annot in 3. booke of Kings pag. 7 15. The Doway glosse hath much more probbaility than yours To conserve unity say they there was but one Tabernacle one Altar for sacrifice in the whole people of Israel Wherupon when the two tribes and an halfe on the other side Iordan had made a severall Altar all the Tribes that dwelt in Canaan suspecting it was for Sacrifice sent presently to admonish them Aug. Epist 48 Quis non impudentissemè c. vid page seq Omnis ea distinctio in re Theologica est inanis fictio quae ex Dei mentiri nescis authoritate non accipitur quaeque rem ipsam de qua agitur tollit c. Martin de persona Christ page 632. c. but what end shall we have if every man upon his owne head may devise or Coyne significations of Gods Ordinances What is this but to bring in a new word to set up Sacraments upon our own heads Herein we say to you and them as you to your opposite I require the voyce of the Shepheard Read it mee out of the Prophets Shew it mee out of the Psalmes c. In the interpretation of the Types and Figures of the Law mens judgements if the Scripture goe not before them are of small credit Can. Stay Sect. 3. Pag. 20.21 If that be true in the Philosopher Opposit a sunt simul natura Arist Topic l. b. 6. Bonum est cujus contrarium est malum Rhetor. l. 1. If vvee take a strâ—ct vievv and enquirie of that Ministery Worship and Government vvhich they left at Dan Bethel it will appear evidently that the same was not more salfe idolatrous and unlawful than the present Ministerie worship and Government of the English Assemblies is by the Non-conformists affirmed to be Jeroboams Apolog in his Arrovv against Idolatry CAN Necess of Sep. p. 85.86 87 88. Course of Comfor p. 161.162 Opposite things in nature are alike Againe That is good whose contrary is evill It must needs followes that as some Churches are visibly true in respect of faith and order so others may bee true too having outward order albeit the members thereof have no faith at all The which assertion is not to bee answered but abhorred The tenne Tribes which departed from the Lord from his Temple Sacrifices Priests Altar and other holy signes of his presence at Ierusalem from the time and still after were not Gods Church so the Scriptures shew Hos 2.2 and 2 Chron. 15.3 Ier. 3.8 Amos 9.7 c. And the Israelites when they worshipped at Dan and Bethel were not in respect of faith and Doctrine more corrupt than the other now is Mr. Amsworth and the Non conformists affirme that the Apostate Iewes could justifia their way and course of Religion as well if not better than the other ANSWER The Philosophicall Maxime to which you have reference is Arist. de Caelo lib. 2. cap. 3. Text. 19. Posito une contrariorum ponitur alterum But as you cite it It is as hard to be found as your translation is to be understood That it is not universall appeareth out of Arist himselfe who putteth down the contrary Maxime as true and certaine Arist Gategor l. c. 11 de contrar Non necessarium est Si contrariorum alterum sit alterum esse Nam si omnes sint sanitas quidem erit morbus non erit So in the first Creation of all things all things were very good and there was nothing evill All things created are finite in act but amongst things created there neither is nor can be a naturall infinite Truth and false-hood good and evill Piety and Idolatry are opposite and that before ever false-hood evill or Idolatry had any being in the world Contraries we know expell one another Or if one be necessary in the subject the other cannot be in it at least in the intense degree as if fire be hot it cannot be cold Now it is necessary that every thing created be finite and good as created and therefore good had a being before evill If it be objected that opposites are relatives and relatives are together in nature the answer is they are relatives secundum dici as they speake not secundum esse which may bee said to be together in nature Not that both are in act existent out of their causes but because the nature of
are notes and markes of a true and sound Church though somewhat crased in health and soundnesse by errors in doctrine corruptions in the worship of God and evils in life and manners A false Church is that which holds neither the truth of faith intirely nor the integrity of divine worship nor comely order which God hath appointed for the government of his house nor holinesse of conversation But addeth to the Articles of faith to that which is worshipped and to the substantiall means wherby God is worshipped and to the holy Commandements which God hath given for the direction of his people or detracteth and perverteth the right sense of faith not considering that which is worshipped as is meete mangling the Ordinances of God and transforming the lawfull manner of worship into another forme and inverteth the holy Commandement by corrupt glosses and sinister interpretations which destroyeth the life and power of godlinesse One false Church may bee more corrupt and rotten than another as being more deepely tainted in matters of higher importance and more generally than another as some may bee corrupt in matters of faith others in doctrine and worship both Ier. 2.11 13. 2 Reg. 16.3 1 Reg. 18.21 Ezek. 16.20 and some in all the particulars mentioned Thus Israel worshipped God and the Calves yea the Lord and Baal And as one false Church may be more corrupt than another Hen. Ains 2. part page 62. Did not the Priests rulers and people condemne the Prophets of God sent in all ages and vvas not Ierusalem the holy City seate of the Priest-hood guilty of their bloud Luke 13.33 34. vvas not vile and grosse Idolatry practised often in Judah and Jerusalem by the Priests and Princes Ezek. 23.11 Did not Iuda forsake the Lord and turne their faces from his Tabernacle shut the doores of his house quench his Lamps and neither burn Incense nor offer burnt offering in the Sanctuary unto the God of Jsrael 2 Chro. 29.6 7. Vriah the Priest made an Altar Idolatrous like that in Damascus and polluted Gods Worship in the Temple 2 Reg. 16.10 11 12 16. Pashur the sonne of Immer the Priest being Governour in the House of the Lord persecuted Ieremie for preaching the truth Jer. 20.1 2. and himselfe prophesied lyes ve 6. See Ier. 32.31 32 33 34 35 36. Mic. 3.11 Mal. 2.8 9. or at one time than another so one false Church may have more of God in it than another and at another time For the lesse grievous the errors are which the false Church holdeth or the lesse abominable the idolatry which it maintaineth the more divine truth it embraceth the more effectuall is that worship of God which it retaineth The true Church of God which is comparatively pure may be called false though improperly in respect of that corruption in doctrine and manners errours schismes divisions superstition or prophanenes which through humane frailty and negligence cleaveth unto it And a false Church may comparatively be called a Church true or pure in respect of them that be more grossely defiled as it hath more truth and purity in it Also the true Churches of God have sometimes bin distinct visible societies from the false Churches and by many degrees in themselves more pure from tincture and infection than at other times and some others have beene As in the dayes of Abiah Iudah was by many degrees more free from pollution than afterwards In Pauls time the integrity of Rome was famous Corinth many wayes reproved They of Galatia much more out of square But the true and Orthodox Church hath sometimes beene so mixed with others in outward society that it hath beene hard to find in the whole world a distinct Congregation of sound and intire professors of all supernaturall truths who joyned in the use of Gods Holy Ordinances but the members of the true visible Church were dispersed and scattered and mingled with false Christians or false worshippers in society and the true Church lay hid in the false Now to apply these things 1. If by a false Church you understand a Church erring in points of faith exceeding dangerous and corrupting the pure worship of God with reall Idolatry with whom the faithfull may not lawfully hold Communion yet then that which they have of God amongst them though not rightly administred is effectuall by the blessing of GOD according to promise As Baptisme administred by the Heretikes holding the forme of Baptisme and of Popish Priests is true Baptisme and not to be reiterated For one and the same society may in one sense have somewhat of the true Church and in another bee the Synagogue of Satan and their Ministers exercise the Ministery and service of Christ when they themselves bee the bond-slaves of Satan It is true God threatens to destroy such societies and is highly displeased with the service that is done there as such because it is not done as it ought but as he is pleased to continue his Ordinance so he is pleased to give it force and validity according to his institution And it is not strange that God should bee displeased with a thing not done according to his institution when the institution it selfe hee doth approve and blesse to some according to his free covenant 2. If by a false Church you understand a Church maimed and corrupt with errors in doctrin and manners neglect of discipline disorders in Ministers and people then as occasion may bee offered Christ hath bound the faithfull to bee present at his ordinances in such Assemblies and promised to blesse them that draw nigh unto him therein In the Church of Corinth there were Divisions Sects Emulations 1 Cor. 3.3 1 Cor. 6.1 2. 2 Cor. 10.10 1 Cor. 15.12 1 Cor. 5.1 1 Cor. 11.19 20. contentions and quarrels going to Law one with another for every trifle and that under Infidels Pauls name and credit was despitefully called into question there the resurrection of the dead was denyed by some that wickednesse was there wincked at which was not heard of among the heathen the Lords Supper was horribly profaned things indifferent used with offence 2 Cor. 12.20 21. Ambr. in 1 Cor. 11 They stood striving for their oblations Hier. in 1 Cor. 11. In Ecclesia convenientes oblationes suas separatius offerebant Apoc. 2.4 5 6. Apoc. 3.20 21. Fornication not repented of and idolatry practised in eating meats sacrificed to Idols in the Idoll Temple And all this notwithstanding the assemblies were kept the faithfull frequented the Ordinances and God did blesse them according to promise Ephesus was extreamly decayed in her first love and though threatned to have her candlesticke removed unlesse she repent Christ doth never lay his charge upon the faithful to depart from his Ordinances Of Laodicea it is said that she was neither hot nor cold and then we may easily conceive she was overgrown with corruptions the proper fruits of negligence security selfe conceitednesse c. For which unlesse she
repent a terrible judgement is denounced against her and yet the faithfull are never exhorted to flee from her society but to repent of her sinne and the promise is made for encouragement that if they open unto him Apoc. 2.20 hee will come in and Suppe with them and they with him If by a false Church you unde stand a visible society wherin the faire greater part is corrupt in the profession of Faith concerning the Articles of Religion and in the wo ship of God by adding and detracting in the substaniall meanes and transforming the object of worship it selfe corrupt in the calling and ordination of Officers the forme of government the Officers set a part for the worke of God and the lives and conversations of the members of that society If in this sense the false Church bee taken then it may and hath fallen out for a long time together that the true Church of God hath lyen hid in the false and that by Gods allowance and approbation Field of the Church lib. 3. cap. 8. in which case the LORD commanded the faithfull to bee present at His Ordinances and promised His blessing unto them though administred in a corrupt Church and after a corrupt manner The true Church in corrupt times hath been mixed with the false not as actuall members of that society as corrupt but as they have been hid in that society as good Corne overtopped with Weedes or a little gold or purer metall in a great clod of Earth God of his infinite mercy so providing for and preserving his poore people In time of the Iudges the Israelites did every man that which seemed good in his owne eyes that is Iudges 1.76 Sept. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Ad bujus loci similitudinem legitur in Sederzata sic extitit seculum absque rege Ioseph lib. 5. c. 2. 1 Reg. 19 10. Rom. 11 3 4. Hosea 4 1 6. 2 Par. 13 5. Isa 1 2 3 4 21 22 29. Isa 57 3. Ezc. 14 5. Ier. 23 8 14 Lam. 4 13 14. Ier 2 8 11 13. Sept. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Verse 26 27 Verse 29. worshipped God as hee pleased The Prophets testifie that the Church did not only faile in Israel but in Iudah likewise I have brought up Children and they have rebelled against me Ah sinfull Nation a people laden with iniquitie a corrupt seede How is the faithfull Citie become an Harlot Thy silver is turned into drosse and thy Wine mixed wiâ—h water They shall be confounded because of their Oakes wherein they delighted The Land viz. of Iudah is filled with Idols they worship the worke of their Hands the Priests said not where is the Lord and they that should minister the Law knew mee not saith the Lord. The Pastors also offended against me and the Prophets prophesied by Baal and went after things that did not profit My people have changed their glory for that which did not profit My people have committed two evils they have forsaken me the fountaine of living waters to digge them pits even broken pits that can hold no water The house of Israel is confounded they and their Kings and their Princes and their Prophets saying to the wood Thou art my Father All of you have forsaken me saith the LORD Her treacherous Sister Iudah feared not but went and played the Harlot also The backe-sliding Israel Ier. 3 8 11 11 13 14. Ezek. 16 46 47 48 51 52. Ier. 5 1 6 13 7 28 9 1. Isay 57 3 4. hath justified her selfe more than treacherous Iuda And as shee was thus horribly corrupted with Idolatrie so with profanenesse impenitency impudencie in sinning rebellion stubbornnesse oppression and what not But when all things were thus miserably disordered the faithfull in Iuda did not separate themselves from the Ordinances of Religion or withdraw themselves into a distinct visible societie from the rest In the age before our Saviours time it grew exceeding wicked againe Mat. 8.4 Mar. 5.36 Luke 7.4 5 9. Mat. 4.23 Mar. 1.21 Luke 4.6 Iohn 18.20 Luke 2.22 37 41. Iun. animad in Bel. contr 4. lib. 3. c. 16 s 14. But neither did our Saviour nor his Disciples before his death take upon them to crect a new visible Church altogether distinct from the erring Synagogue but lived in that Church and frequented the Ordinances neither as absolute members of the Synagogue nor yet as the visible Church distinct from it But as visible members of that Primitive Church from which that Synagogue had degenerated In the New Testament 2 Thes 2.7 Revel 17.5 Iniquitas sed mystica id est pietatis nomine palliata Gloss ordinar Syr. Mysterium iniqui jam incipit efficaz esse 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 est vis certa operandi non autem significandi Cham. panst som 2. lib. 16. cap. 7. Hesych 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 praeparatur adornatur instruitur 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 quoddam doctrinae quod si 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 sumptum contrarium sit fidei Cham. panst tom 2. l. 16. cap. s 5. 2 Thes 2.3 Heb. 3.13 Matth. 13.25 39. 2 Cor. 11.3.13 15. Jun. cont 4. lib. 3. cap. 16. Generalis decessio sen Apostasia dicitur universalis ant communis Vniversalem negamus fore semper igitur erit Ecclesia quamvis lalens Communem fore affirmamus ut affirmat Paulus Ier. 28.16 29 32. Sept. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Deut. 13.10 the Apostle telleth us the mysterie of iniquitie began to worke in his dayes whereby he understands not common heresies and corruption of manners but some great and hidden thing begun in the Apostles time to creepe on by degrees not suddenly to vanish but to continue for many ages and to grow into an exceeding high mountaine As the mysterie of godlinesse which began presently after the fall took it complement by degrees and that at a certaine and appointed time so it was in this also which at the first was small but grew as things durable by degrees into an exceeding huge bignesse The spirit hath foretold that there should come an Apostasie or defection not from the Roman Empire for that was not opposite to Christ but from the faith and that not light or in some particular point or for a short time for such Haeretickes there had beene already but grievous generall and of long continuance That which the Prophet Ieremy when he speaketh of false Prophets and their Prophecies calleth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that is as the 70. translate it and the thing it selfe requireth a declining a revolt or Apostasie not every one but that to which the authority of the true God is pretended And so the departure from the faith is not a revolt to Gentilisme 2 Tim. 4.1 2. Aug. De Civ Dei li. 26. ca. 19. Quem refugam vocat utique a Deo vero but a giving too easie heed and attention to some doctors professing yet indeed corrupting the Christian Religion As when it is
but a new furbishing over of the same broken staffe might well be passed over in silence But lest the credulous reader should conceit it is slighted because it containeth some matter of importance I will in few words lay open the weaknesse and vanitie thereof First you translate the Schoolmans words vel cui non debet vel non eo modo quo debet very improperly when divine worship is not exhibited either to the person it should be c. and indeed make his speech absurd or senselesse For it was never imagined to be superstition not to exhibite divine worship to God but Atheisme or prophanesse rather You say superstition is that which is done supra statutum when more estimation is had of a thing more dignitie placed in it than is meet which is contrary to the not exhibiting of divine honour to God but this is your common practice 2. Your reasons to prove it superstition to heare Antichristian Ministers in their false assemblies as you stile them are none of the best If there vvere no more but giving obedience to such â—â—dinance as are imposed vvith a necessitie upon us that meerely for conscience of the ordinance it is enough to infect the actions vvith superstition A dispute against Engl. popish part 1. ca. 3. p. 9. Calvin Instit l. 4. c. 10. §. 16 27 29. Aug. confes ca. de discyiminâ— ciboruÌ„ though all should be granted which you desire for though it be no particular ordinance in respect of time or place yet it followeth not that it is superstition For if for substance the duty be of God it may be done without superstition when it is not in particular commanded May not the case fall out that it is free for a man whether he will heare the word at such a time or follow the duties of his calling and if hee doe the one or the other in so doing he is not to be deemed superstitious To place opinion of necessitie holinesse or worship in that which God hath not instituted or sanctified is superstition But to do this or that act which is commanded or allowed of God cannot be called superstition though in some particular circumstance above mentioned it be no particular ordinance You say whosoever takes to himselfe practice Chemnit Exam part 2. in Sess 13. can 10. Calvin de neces reform Eccles Quum putarentur observatu necessariae esse hominum leges corrigi debuit perniciosus hic error c. Châ—mier panstr tom 4. de Eus. l. 6 c. 4 sect 3 4. Magdeb. praef 7. cen It is not lavvfull for civill Magistrates to devise formes of Religion in destruction of the truth and so to reconcile truth and errour that they may both bee lulled asleepe They may not prescribe religion alone they must not engender new articles of faith they must not strangle the truth vvith errour nor shackle it vvhen it is revealed that they may let loose the bridle of corruption c. Matthevv 4. 9 See Par. in loc Luke 4.7 2 Chroni 11.15 1 Cor. 10.20 Rev. 9.20 1 Tim. 4.1 which is not grounded upon Gods word and is strict therein hee is just overmuch why doe you adde and is strict therein if every act simply not commanded be superstition And if by such hearing a man did approve countenance or give honour unto any the wayes of Antichrist or did simbolize with Idolaters yet could not this hearing be condemned as will-worship or superstition unlesse the breach of every commandement be will-worship or superstition Men may be superstitious in the use of Antichristian rites or devices and so they may in the use of their owne devices yea of the ordinances of God themselves But whosoever doth countenance or approve any of the wayes of Antichrist he is not therein though hee breake the commandement some other way superstitious or a wil-worshipper 3 If superstition be committed when more estimation or regard is had to a thing than God alloweth or can stand with his will revealed in his word beware lest you convince your selfe superstitious in an high degree For when you magnifie your Church order and constitution as an ordinance of that absolute necessitie as that God cannot lawfully be worshipped in any other societie or assemblie and that none other Church is true You place more excellency and dignitie in it and give more estimation and regard unto it than God alloweth in his word I might adde that in many particulars you advance your owne imaginations as the necessarie and holy ordinances of God which if it bee not idolatry at least is superstition in your language Observable it is you say whereas one Evangelist setting downe the Tempters words to Christ saith worship me another hath it worship before me shewing it is all one to worship before the Divell or to worship him Whereupon you adde now hee is worshipped when Idols are worshipped or any false institution is observed or practice used which if it was true I should not feare to charge you as a pernicious idolater or worshipper of the Divell But I will not make use of such leaden weapons CAN. Stay Sect. 4. page 63. For it is a most notorious and grosse absurditie For if every false institution and practice bee the worship of the Divel it must necessarily follow that every error concerning the worship of God concerning the commandements of the first table is the worship of the Divell which a Christian should blush to speake and abâ—â—ere to heare 4 In your esteeme all Churches are false which are not constituted after your manner and all Ministers Antichristian who are not called and ordained by that particular congregation where they are to administer and being so taken I answer It is neither superstition nor will-worship to heare Antichristian Ministers in your stile but indeed the true lawfull approved Ministers of Jesus Christ in their Assemblies To heare or to communicate with them is not to approve or honour any Antichristian way or sembolize with idolaters but to approve maintaine and exercise purely the ordinances of grace to yeeld obedience to Gods commandement to regard honour and esteeme what bee alloweth and honoureth and to worship him both for matter and manner according to his will The precepts promises and institution of God Ames Bell. Eâ—â—â—tem 2. lâ—â—de â—ccâ—notis 〈…〉 catus ille in quo christus adest dum demonstratur ubi sit Christus Ille autem caetus est ecclesia christus erim ambulat inter 7. candelabâ—â— quae sunt 7. ecâ—lesie the approved practice of the Saints from the beginning of the world unto this day doth plentifully warrant this practice to be holy profitable and necessarie in respect of divine institution This doctrine hath evermore been professed in all Churches defended by Orthodox Divines taught in Sermons received by the Faithfull and most plainely confirmed by the Scriptures But not to repeat so many things spoken already I proceed to examine what you have
vvhat need is there to lay dovvne their false office I cannot say of this mans Logicke as Aristotle did of Theodorus his making Epithites It is his vvhole art CAN. Stay p. 27. that a man may remaine a Minister of a false Church all his life time provided hee onely teach the truths of the Gospell Our reason is for in this if he doe no idolatrous act then hee sinneth not and so consequently no just cause of his comming out from among them ANSWER Ill might you twit your adversarie with his little skill in Logicke unlesse it was done in policie to hide your own loosenes in this and the like arguments For though it be not an Idolatrous act to preach the truth of the Gospell in a false Church in other respects it may be sinne to continue a member in that societie and so also to teach the Gospels Truths As it may be scandalous and offencive an appearance of evill A man may doe that whereunto he is not called from an evill mind Also it may bee sinne to continue in a false Church though a man teach nothing but the truth of the Gospell because he cannot professe all maine and fundamentall truths or that border thereupon nor testifie against all corruptions grosse haereticall reallie Idolatrous which in Conscience cannot bee tolerated or borne withall without grosse hypocrisie or dissimulation or hee cannot keep himselfe from the tincture of Idolatrie in practicâ— As for example though it be not an Idolatrous act for a Popish Priest to preach the Gospell or administer the Sacraments of Baptisme yet it is not lawfull for a Christian to remaine as a member in that society because he cannot partake with them in the Ordinances but he shall commit reall Idolatrie or must dissemble many grievous and hatefull abominations which cannot bee dissembled and shall bee thought to bee of the same Religion with them or of no Religion c. The multitude of Authors which you quote against hearing false Prophets or continuing in false Churches doe they not give other reasons why wee ought to separate from them or doth any one ever lay this down as a truth or foundation of separation In the page following you alledge sixe reasons which you say may bee applyed against the going with others to an Idol ministerie Church or worship c. But if they bee of any strength this reason whereof now wee speake is nought worth for they are directly crosse Here you say If in preaching the truth of the Gospell he doe no Idolatrous act he sinneth not but there you say he sinneth many other wayes But in all this you take that for granted which we confidently denie sc That our Churches worship or Ministerie is false and Idolatrous And therefore taking the proposition in your sense we say It is not only lawfull but necessary to remaine Ministers or members of some Churches which lye under your censure as false and Idolatrous but indeed are the true Ministers and Churches of Iesus Christ graced with his presence covered with his banner and beautified with his Ordinances and tokens of love And that which you call an unblessed standing wee make no question but it is approved and blessed of Christ and therefore regard your reviling the lesse Can. Stay Sect. 5. Pag. 73. If a man performe an action in a state and of publike nature he is to be considered in respect of himselfe as is that state and according to the publike Ordinances For if the state be false and the officer unlawfull it is familisme for him to say I know this state is set up against the Lord Iesus Christ and every commer here to worship according to the constitution is an Idolater but I will have in my selfe a secret meaning from the rest Id. page 77. Seeing false Churches and false Ministers are reall Idols set up by earthly Princes c. Whosoever comes and bovves before those Idols cannot escape the just blame of Idolatry Id. pag. 73. This is a sure thing and let it bee noted No administration performed in a state and by a power and constituted office can be sought desired and received but in so doing the doer ipso facto really approves of that state power and office bee the same lawfull or unlawfull And as for any mans saying to the contrary it is sine capite fabula a vision of his owne Head and will prove as good as the miracles which Iannes and Iambres wrought even meanes to harden his owne heart and some others as they did Pharaohs by doing them ANSWER You say it is an easie thing to Conquer CAN. Stay Sect. 5. page 66. Wee are no such Children as to give the cause so avvay CAN. Necess of sep p. 226. But this vvee cannot give him though hee begge it shamefully because the thing is othervvise as their ovvne vvritings manifest CAN. Stay Sect. 5. page 74. Calfeh against Mart art 3. page 86. if begging might procure it and if confident assertions will carrie a matter you will not goe without it But we must not be driven from the Church the Ordinances and worship of God communion with Christ and societie of Saints by an emptie blast of words No though you shamefully boast you have proved it by our owne writings Doe you thinke your bold impudent asseveration that any mans saying to the contrarie is sine capite fabula a vision of his owne head will make us by and by yeeld to your definitive sentence for which you can produce neither Scripture nor reason nor authoritie but your owne as if your ipse dixit Pope-like were to be rested in Wee are no such Children We are not to be feared with rattles You must bring better matter than your vaine fictions and sounder proofe than vaine repetitions of the same things over and over or else you must expect small credit to bee given unto your words They that joyn together in the worship of God Ambr. in Luk. 6. c. 9. Fides Ecclesiae imprimis quaerenda in quâ si Christus habitator sit haud dubiè legenda c. sed siqua est Ecclesia quae fidem respuat nec Apostolicae praedicationis fundamenta possideat ne quam labem perfidiae posâ—it aspergere deserenda est Sadeel de legit Minist vocat p. 6. Aug. Ex. 166. Our heavenly Master gave us vvarning before hand to make the people secure touching evill overseers lest for their sakes the chaire of vvholesome doctrine should be forsaken And Tract in Ioh. 46. The Lords fold hath some overseers that bee Children some that be hirelings ordinances of Religion they approve the faith protessed in points fundamentall the worship performed for the substance Ordinances administred and the truth of Ministerie for substance whereby these things are dispensed For of necessitie if the doctrine of salvation be restored the lawful use of the ministery is restored also Where God is truelie called upon in the Congregation and the Sacraments
against Martiall Preface to the reader Bellarm. lib. 3. de justifi c. 8. Non potest aliquid certuÌ„ esse certitudine fidei nisi aut immediate contineatur in verbo Dei aut ex verbo Dei per evidentem consequentiaÌ„ deducatur Park de pol. Eccl. l. 1. c. 1.4 Separabant se sacerdotes et Levitae qui Deum timebant 2 Chro. 11.14 Atqui haec separaâ—â—o ab Israelitis idolatris erar quâ— legemcult umque Dei per idola Ieroboam fundamentaliter sustulerunt Aug. de unit eccl c. 16. Let the Donatists if they can shew their Church not in rumors and speeches of the men of Africa nor in the couÌ„cels of their Bishops nor in the discourses of any writer whatsoever nor in the signes and miracles that may be forged but in the prescript of the Law in the predictions of the Prophets in the verses of the Psalmes in the voyces of the Shepheard himselfe c. that all devised false and idolatrous worship is to be abhorred is confessed and professed by Conformists and Nonconformists It is a constant received position That nothing ought to be tolerated in the Church as necessary unto salvation or as an article of faith except it be expresly contained in the word of God or manifestly to be gathered therefrom and that all ceremonies are to be rejected wherein there is placed opinion of merit worship or necessitie to salvation But that the worship tendred to God in the English Congregations is devised false idolatrous that the Nonconformists never said nor thought and whosoever shall rashly affirme it he shall never be able to make proofe thereof by the word of God If any rite prescribed in the book of Common-prayer be worship in the use thereof the word being taken in a large signification that is not so in the intention and profession of the Church nor apprehended to be so in them that conforme unto it neither doth it defile the worship of God to them that joyne in the ordinances of grace notwithstanding the corruption which in their judgement is annexed to it and practised by some For notwithstanding such corruption or abuse the worship it selfe is that which God hath prescribed approved blessed to them that seeke his face aright and serve him unfeignedly whereat he requireth our presence and wherein he hath promised to sup with us and we with him That the Non-conformists should affirme the worship of God or ministery in the English Assemblies to be as false idolatrous and unlawfull as was the worship of Jeroboam at Dan and Bethel is a most lewd and impudent slander which the sworne shavelingâ— of Antichrist whose profession is to lye and slander for the catholique cause would blush to vent You know it is contrary to their judgement practice prosession and protestations many times renewed Whether the phrase be tolerable or no if you will be prodigall to pawne your head in this case take heed lest you loose it not in Gods cause but in your owne And if you shall be desperate herein your forwardnesse will move no wise man for Religion is to be learned from the truth of God and not from the high adventures of inconsiderate men The Non-conformists can prove the Religion and worship of the Church of England to be of God not by petty reasons and colourable shewes which they leave to them that maintaine a bad cause but by pregnant evidence from the word of truth not by similitudes allegories and forced interpretations of Scripture as you dispute against it but by plaine texts of Scripture and sound reason deduced therefrom against which the gates of hell shall never prevaile The Author of that Booke Bilson Christ subject part 4. p. 349. This is the doubt betwixt us whether we should coÌ„tent our selves with such meanes as he hath devised for us and coÌ„mended unto us thereby daily to renew the memory of our Redemption or else inveÌ„t others of our own heads fit perhaps to provoke us to a naturall and humane affection but not fit to instruct ourfaith c. He knowing that images though they did intertaine the eyes with some delight yet might they snare the souls of many simple silly persons and preferring the least seed of sound faith beholding adoring him in spirit truth before all the dumbe shewes and Imagerie that maÌ„s wit could furnish to win the eye Can. Neces of Separat c. 2. p. 78 79. 254. according to a prescript form culled out of the blasphemous Mass-book 238. That which was takeÌ„ out of the vile Masse-booke c. Sold. â—aâ—w T. C. repl 1. pag. 130. Abridg. p. 89. Adm. 1. p. 9. 2. Adm. p. 41. Fall of Babyl â—9 Altar Damasc pag. 612 613. Syons plea. 29. Perth Assemb 64. Syons plea. 30. pag. 40. 〈…〉 intituled The course of Conformitie sheweth that the Israelites might in generall pretend for Jeroboams calves the same excuses that were made in defence of some corruptions thrust upon the Church of Scotland but the corruptions he doth not make to be like nor the pretences to be of equall validitie nor the state of the Church where such corruptions are tollerated to be the same with the state of the Israelites who worshipped the Calves Abuses that agree in the generall nature of abuse may be coloured with the same pretences when they be not of the same weight qualitie or degree the one may be small the other hainous The same distinction may be brought to countenance the vilest heresie and a petty errour if I may so speake Heresie and Idolatry are both talkative and who doubts but corrupt wits can say much in defence of both shall we thence conclude that errour or heresie are both one every abuse is grosse idolatry The Author you quote was not so unadvised His drift was onely to shew the vanitie of such excuses and not to match the things pleaded for with Jeroboams Idolatry as hath been shewed before But let us see whether you can alledge any colourable shew or petty reason to prove our worship to be false and idolatrous The whole forme of the Church-service is borrowed from the Papists peiced and patched together without reason or order of edification yea not onely is the forme of it taken from the Church of Antichrist but surely the matter also For none can deny but it was culled and picked out of that popish dunghill the portius and vile Masse-booke full of all abhominations From three Romish Channels I say was it raked together namely the Breviarie out of which the common prayers are taken out of the Rituall or booke of Rites the administration of the Sacraments Buriall Matrimony Visitation of the sick are taken and out of the Masse-booke are the Consecration of the Lords Supper Collects Gospels and Epistles And for this cause it is that the Papists like so well of the English Masse for so King James used to call it and makes them say Surely the Romish is the true and
the word and elements Bilson Christ subject part 4. p. 356. To the Papists objecting that as Magistrates Parents have part of Gods externall honour because they present his person in judging and blessing so many Images have part of his externall though not of his internall honour Answer is truly returned It is not in your hands to make allowance of Gods honour to whom you list and againe God himselfe hath made a plaine prohibition in this case that Images shall have no part of his externall honour The words are as cleare as day light Thou shalt no bow downe to them Tho Beacon Catech in his workes in fol. printed at London Ann. 1562. f. 484. Fox in Osor lib. 3. pag. 27. The Booke of Common-prayer before the Communion Cypr. Ep. 63. ad Caecisiâ—m Justin Martyr in Apol. 2 Iren. lib. 4. cap. 34 lib. 5. cap. 4. Gratian. Decret part 3. de Conseâ—r dist 2. cap. 10.12 18.36 Durand rational divin offic lib. 4. cap. 5â— how comes it to have those things which are so directly contrary to the Masse that both cannot possibly stand together In our booke of Common-prayer we pray to God onely in the mediation of Jesus Christ and in a knowne language We professe that Christ by one oblation of himselfe once for all hath made a full perfect and sufficient satisfaction for the sinnes of the whole world that he hath commanded a perpetuall remembrance of his death and passion in that his ordinance of the Supper and that the Sacrament is to be administred in both kinds the Minister and the people communicating together were these things taken out of the Masse-booke The Church of Rome joyneth the two first Commandements in one or taketh away the second thereby to cloake their Idolatry in the worshipping of Images But the common-prayer-booke of the Church of England divideth them into two therein following two of the Fathers at most excepted all Antiquitie and fetteth downe the words of the second Commandement at large The Church of Rome teacheth that in the Sacrament of the Eucharist the body and bloud of Christ is received and eaten carnally that as much is received in one kinde as in both and that in the Masse Christ is offered 〈…〉 a propitiatory unblouddy Sacrifice for the sinnes of 〈◊〉 and dead But the common-prayer-booke of the Church of England in the forme of administring that Sacrament teacheth expresly That spiritually by faith wee feed on him in our hearts eating and drinking in remembrance that Christ dyed and shed his bloud for us In the Masse the Priest receiveth alone the people standing by gazing on but the Minister and people are appointed with us to communicate together according to the institution of Christ and practice of the primitive Church We make the communion of the Eucharist properly a Sacrament They a Sacrament and a Sacrifice propitiatory They celebrate at an Altar wee at a Table according to the example of our Saviour Christ his Apostles and the primitive Church in the purest times Wee pray for the living They for the living and dead And if these be not points directly and expresly contrary to the Romane service Rome is much departed from her selfe Carriers pretence in that particular is a meere jugling trick that he might insinuate a change of Religion might be made among us without any great alteration which is as likely as the light should be turned into darknesse and not espied If many points of Popery be not condemned expresly in the Catechisme or Service-booke which are for the instruction of the simple in the grounds of Religion and the administration of the holy things of God and not to shew what is condemned in Religion yet so many points are there taught directly coÌ„trary to the foundation of Popery that it is not possible Popery should stand if they take place And whereas Antichristianisme standeth in ungodly superstructions and additions to the truth and worship of God both matter and object if the Catechisme and Service-booke have not enough in them in his sense of necessitie they contradict the whole bulke of Popery which confisteth in abhominable superfluities or impious inventions of their owne It is mone proper to say the Masse was added to our common-prayer than that our common-prayer was taken out of the Masse-booke For most things in our common-prayer were to be found in the Liturgies of the Church long before the Masse whereof wee speake was heard of in the world And the Masse was patched up by degrees and added to the Liturgie of the Church now one peice then another so that the ancient truths and holy Liturgies were at last stained with the Idoll of the Masse Bishop Jewel Ser. on Josh 6.1 2 3. The things that may bee reserved viz. in the destruction of Hiericho must not bee dust or chasse or hay or stubble But gold silver iron and brasse I meane they may not be things meet to furnish maintaine superstition but such things as be strong and may serve either directly to serve God or els for comelinesse and good order which was sacrilegiously thrust into them But the prayers and truths of God taught in that Booke pertained to the Church as her prerogative the Masse and the abhominations thereof belonged into the man of sinne And if a true man may challenge his goods which the theese hath drawne into his denne the Church of God may lawfully make claime unto those holy things which Antichrist hath unjustly usurped That answer which is returned to the accusation makes against them that sue for discipline viz. That a great part of their discipline is borrowed from the Anabaptists will serve as a buckler in this case And it is this which I doubt not you will approve Whatsoever is proper either to the heresie of Papists and Anabaptists Donatists or Puritanes that wee utterly condemne to the pit of hell But if amongst the filth of their heresies there may be found any good thing as it were a graine of good corne in a great deale of Darnell that we willingly receive not as theirs but as the Jewes did the holy Arke from the Philistins T. C. repl 2. par 1. Epistle to the Chh of England whereof they were unjust owners For herein that is true that is said The sheepe must not lay downe her fell because shee seeth the Wolfe sometimes cloathed with it August lib. 2. Serm. de Monte yea it may come to passe that the Synagogue of Satan may have some one thing at one time with more convenience than the true and catholique Church of Christ Bishop Jewel Ser. in Iosh 6.1.2.3 In religion no part is to be called little A haire is but little yet it hath a shadow If our Booke please the Papists it is but in some things wherein in reverence to Antiquitie we come too nigh them in some rites and ceremonies but with the substance of the ministration it selfe they cannot be pleased unlesse they be
Dispute upon communicating at confused Communions affirming that the sitter is accessary to the sinne of the kneeler But he was no English-Nonconformist nor doth intreat of English conformitie And if there be any speciall reasons why presence should be accounted approbation with them in that particular it is no equitie his private opinion should be brought to the prejudice of them that maintaine another cause But as yet we cannot see either from Scripture grounds or Nonconformists principles that it is utterly unlawfull to be present at the worship of God in the administration whereof some superstitious rite is used or some fault committed Your long labour in setting downe the faults to be found in our Liturgie is to small purpose The Nonconformists doe except against many things appointed in the Booke as inconvenient at least and such as should be taken away or reformed as The reading of Apocryphall books under the title of holy Scripture specially such parts as be corrupt for matter The Crosse and Surplice as Idolothites by participation and signes of mysticall signification The corruptions in the translations and some things in the formes of Buriall Matrimony Thanksgiving for Women after child-bed c. But these they condemne not as Idolatry nor as that which maketh the worship it selfe m Magdeburg centu 2. ca. 2. col 109. A true Church as it containes the pure doctrine so also it keepes simplieitie of ceremonies but an hypocriticall Church as it departs from pure doctrine so for the most part it changeth augmenteth the ceremonies instituted of God and multiplieth its owne traditions c. Can. Stay pa. 123. false and idolatrous It is one thing to say such a rite is inconvenient superstitious scandalous borrowed from the Papists not warranted by the word of God in the use will-worship if the word be taken largely another that the worship it selfe is false and idolatrous Therefore I will not stand to examine the particulars therein but proceed to examine what you bring further to shew the necessitie of Separation SECT IV. HEre is a fit place to propound a Question or two First whether to hold teach and practise the errours and lyes contained in their Canons Service-booke Booke of Articles and the ordering of Bishops Priests and Deacons doe mak◠a false Prophet Secondly Whether to hide from the people the knowledge of all the maine truths which concerne the outward regiment of Christs visible Church make a false Prophet Thirdly Whether it be lawfull to heare any false Prophet knowne so to be Qu In what ranke of Prophets unlawfull Ministers be and under what Scripture they are comprehended I would have a private Christian aske this Question of some learned Divine whom he knowes doth hold it lawfull to heare false Ministers And it is very likely he will answer him with deep silence There is one Question more viz. whether the Lords lawfull Priests which served at the Altar in Jerusalem might not as well urge their people to heare Jeroboams Priests at Dan and Bethel as the Ministers now under the Gospell to perswade men to heare in false Churches If is be not all one shew the difference ANSVVER TO your two last Questions answer hath been made divers times in sundry Treatises and in the first chapter of this present answer and you know the Scriptures plainly alledged to confirme what is said which you should have confuted if you had been able and not againe and againe to come over with the same thing If any learned Divine shall answer the demand with deep silence it may be because the partie demanding is uncapable of an answer not because there is any great difficultie in the matter It is a received Rule That the Accuser Plaintiffe and Affirmer should make proofe of what they say and if you erre your Questionist will affirme it is all one for the people of the Jewes to heare Jeroboams Priests at Dan and Bethel and the people in England to heare the word of God in our assemblies you must either bring good evidence for what you say or beare the brand of Slaunderers or false n Beza Epist 2. An enim obsecro aliter est de Sacramētis i. de doctrinae appendicibus quà m de ipsa doctrina judicandum At qui si nullam esse ecclesiā dicamus ubi nullus est prorsus in cunctis doctrinae Christianae dogmatibus naevus refellent nos Pauli Epistolae Corinthiacis et Galaticis Ecclesiis inscriptae c. Itaque ubi non satis pura est Ecclesiâ Ecclesia tamen est in qua salvum manet fundamentum ac multo magis ubi ritus Caenae Domini mutilus est Caena tamen est c. Accusers Is it sufficient thinke you to say If it be not so let them shew the contrary Your second Question will come to be handled in the next Chapter and there it shall be answered Your first Question onely which I scarce thinke another man would have asked pertaineth to this place wherunto I answer directly and plainly That a Minister of the Gospell may hold teach and practise according to the Book of Common Prayer Articles and Ordination and be a true Minister of Jesus Christ Nay he cannot truely hold and practice according to them but of necessitie he must be a true Minister in respect of his office and administration For the worship for substance there prescribed is of God the doctrine professed in respect of faith and Sacraments sound and true No errour either in speech hereticall or which doth tend to overthrow the foundation which is taught in them Suppose the seventie errours which o Can. Neces of Separat pag. 243 244 245. you reckon up were all true and justly taken against the Books and as many more to them might be named as it is not the number but the qualities of the errours which make a false Prophet false Church or false worship One fundamentall errour as the word is commonly used overthroweth the faith and twenty errours of inferiour alloy doe not much hurt the truth and soundnesse of faith The maine truths which concerne the very life and soule of Religion be p Vsher de success Eccl. cap. 1. few and the failings which may stand with the substance of Religion many Let it aske a better wit and head then ever Mr Dar. or your q Can. Neces of Separat pag. 185. selfe had to prove that there are halfe so many corruptions in the Religion professed by the English-Anabaptists adde if you please the Separatists Pelagians Arrians as are to be found in the English-Liturgie It will not be hard to prove that errours must be r The communion of the Catholique Church is not broken by the varietie of rites customes laws and fashions which many places and countries have different each from other except they be repugnant to faith or good manners August Epist 118. ad Ianuar. Euseb hist lib. 5. cap. 26. lib. 5. c. 23. Socrat. lib.
no this is evident your inferences in this point are not correspondent to their Principles nor can be deduced from them as in the beginning you promised And then upon what bottome doth this reason stand or by what prop is it underset but your own bare affirmation which is much too weake to beare so great a weight Whosoever meanes z Can. Neces of Separat pag. 210. you say to settle well the conscience especially in a maine point of faith and Religion ought necessarily to bring good proofes from Scripture for the things whereof he speaketh For otherwise men must give no trust unto his words or if they doe it must be unadvisedly And what thinke you then if men upon your bare word give credit unto this argument is it not unadvised You bid a Bilson difference part 1. pag. 20. What we say without proofe reject you without answer If that rule may stand we need no further confutation of the rest of your Apologie for there besides taunts termes I see nothing prove the contrary if any man be able But that is not to ground the conscience upon Gods truth If your assertion be not taught in holy Scripture it is an unwritten tradition an humane invention a dreame of your owne in your conceit false worship and flat Idolatry though your opposites be able to say nothing against it but this that it is not taught of God What the Nonconformists will say to this argument you know not but hitherto they have said nothing or as good as nothing It is well you say not both Propositions are theirs as you doe in the former with as little truth as if you had said it here But if you had perused their writings against Separation as you have observed what sharp words they let fall against the corruptions in our Church and Liturgie you might have knowne that they say somewhat and somewhat to the purpose not worthy your answer but what can never be truly answered First Discipline they say is taken two wayes First Largely for the whole order pertaining to the gathering and governing of a Church the ordering of divine worship and manner of men And in this sense b Bilson perpet Ch. govern cap. 1. pag. 3. Order and Discipline the very nurse and mother of all peace and quietnesse as well in divine as in humane Societies assemblies though it be not the life or spirit that quickneth the Church yet doth it fasten and knit the members thereof as joynts and sinewes do the parts of our bodies Id. ca. 9. The Gospell must be preached the Sacramēts must be frequented for which purpose some must be taken to the publique service and ministery of the Church c. Neither onely the lack of the Word and Sacraments but the prophanation and abuse of either how greatly doth it endanger the state and welfare of the whole Church of Christ yea the casting of holy things to dogs and of pearles before swine how dreadfull a judgement doth it procure as well to the consenters as presumers A little Leaven sowreth the whole masse So that power to send Labourers into Gods harvest and to separate prophane persons for defiling the mysteries and assemblies of the faithfull must be retained and used in the Church of Christ unlesse we will turne the house of God into a den of theeves c. Act. 2.41 42.44 45 46 47. 11.20 21.26 13.43.48 14.1.21 22 23. Discipline is neither the matter nor forme of the Church but an inseparable propertie and so there can be no Church without some Discripline Secondly It is taken strictly for the administration of the censures in which sense it is not absolutely necessary to the being but to the well-being and safetie of the Church Secondly They answer that by divine right the power of the keyes is given to every compleat Apostolicall Church but the execution of this power may be wanting either through their negligence or because they are hindred as in Sardis Thyatira Ephesus c. And this is to the purpose for the Question is of the power to execute the Discipline of Christ and not of the simple right to execute it And in your opinion the execution of Discipline is absolutely necessary to the being of the Church without which it can neither be gathered nor subsist Take your owne comparison unlesse the body doe both receive food and purge out excrements it is not possible it should subsist and live If therefore Sardis Pergamus Thyatira c. continued the true Churches of Christ when the greater sort would not and the better could not purge out excrements or all were grossely negligent it followeth that the execution of discipline or power to execute discipline is not absolutely necessary to the being of the Church Thirdly The Church of England wanteth not the discipline of Christ for substance either in respect of right or execution though it be not administred as it ought These are the Answers which they give and they are too heavie to be spurned away with scorne when ever you shall try their weight Thus I might dismisse your first band as being put to flight already But I will spend a little time to examine both propositions And for the first it is to be noted that the word Church to let passe other significations is taken First For the communitie of the faithfull few or many two three or more men or women without guides or officers for beleevers dispersed and scattered by persecution spoyled of their guides or such as being newly called never had guides set over them are yet the true Church of Christ Secondly The societie of the faithfull joyning together in the ordinances of worship under a lawfull Pastour is a true Church though defective in many officers and ordinances required to the perfection of the Church Thirdly A c Bilson ibid. ca. 1. The internall regiment that God hath by his Spirit and truth in the hearts of the faithfull is the true kingdom of christ cannot be varied is not questioned in the Church of England But there is a necessitie also of externall goverment which respecteth the appointing of meete men and repelling of unmeete to be trusted with the heavenly treasures of the Word and Sacraments As also the good using and right dividing of so precious Iewells committed to their charge competent number of faithfull people joyned in societie under lawfull Pastours Teachers and Elders to watch over rule feed and guide them in the waies of God are a true and compleat constituted Church of Jesus Christ The word Discipline also is used two wayes as hath been said First In a larger sense as comprehending all order and behaviour concerning a Church in outward duties and so among the rest the daily planting and building by the calling and offering of the Word by the Ministers and the hearing receiving and obeying by the people As military discipline is put for the whole art or manner of
Arian infection both in the reignes of Constantius and Julian the Apostata Athanas Graecolar tom 1. pag. 309. edit Comelit Theodor. hist l. 4. c. 3. Pelagius a Britaine by birth troubled the Churches with his pestilent Doctrine denying the grace of God attributing power and libertie to man to live without sinne and keepe the Commandements if he would This Heresie arose about the yeare 405. or 406. and the Author thereof drew his first breath in Britaine Prudent 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Trim. 13. speaking of Cyprian saith Gallos fovet imbuit Britannos praesidet Hisperiae Christum serit ultimis Hiberis Vsser de prim Eccles Britan. ca. 16. pag. 787. but he sowed not this hereticall doctrine in Britaine And though it must be confessed That these Churches were not altogether free from that infection yet at first it was opposed and after it was banished by the blessing of God About the yeare 420. flourished Fastidius of whom Gennedius in his catalogue of Ecclesiasticall Writers saith Fastidius Bishop of the Britaines wrote to Fatalis one booke of Christian life and another of keeping Widdow-hood in sound doctrine and according to the truth of God And John Trithemius Fastidius Bishop of the Britaines was a man learned in the holy Scriptures and an excellent Preacher of the word of God famous in life and conversation in speech and wit notable Prosper contra collater cap. 41. Vsser de prim pag. 319 320 323 324. He wrote some devout little works c. And by the vigilancy and care of Lopis and Germanus Antisiodorensis the Britaines were delivered from the contagion which had begun to infect the Churches After this the face of things was miserable in that Kingdome by reason of the invasion of the g Repellūt nos barbari ad mare repellit mare ad barbaros Inter haec duo genera funerū aut jugulamur autmergimur Bed hist eccl l. 1. cap. 14. Bilson The true difference betweene Christians Par. 1. pa. 56. That this Land was infected with Arianisme Pelagianisme as many other places then were I find it reported in the story of Beda Eccl. his gent. Angl. l. 1. c. 8. lib. 1. cap. 17. And the Bishops of France our neighbours upon request made unto them by the Britaines sent Germanus and Lupus two French Bishops chosen in a Synod by the generall liking to convert this realm from Pelagius errour which also they did with great celeritie barbarous enemy the terrible famine the direfull contagion of the Pelagian and Arian heresies and the loosenesse negligence drunkennesse contentions and other vices of the Clergie The Christian Religion thus corrupted was restored againe by the second comming of Germannus but after that grievously oppressed by the comming in of the Anglo-Saxons who could not yet so extinguish the truth of God but it did revive spread and grow though sometimes more pure sometimes more corrupt and sometimes with greater sometimes with lesse freedome But to come to the last reformation which was made of Religion in this Land and it was not the conversion of England from infidelitie to the profession of the Gospell but the restoring of it from a corrupt state or profession to a more pure from Christianitie polluted to Christianitie unpolluted Christians they were who inhabited this Land baptized into the true faith of Jesus Christ but Christians defiled with manifold superstitions led aside into manifold errors which errors and superstitions removed they become sound and true Christians indeed The true h Chaloner Credo S 2. part sect 2 It will soone appeare that the Ch◠of Rome for a thousand yeares after our Saviour professed no other faith nor published any other beliefe in points fundamentall either negative or affirmative than we doe c. After a thousand and some few yeares more were expired Transubstantiation and Adoration of the Host with other dregs of Antichrist being established though we cannot say that the Church of Rome was from thence forth absolutely our Church yet we may boldly say that our church was from that time untill Luther both within the Romane Church and without it Church lay hid in Popery as a little oare in a great lump of drosse not refined not purified not coyned but true gold for substance yea that very same for substance which being purified and stamped is currant coyne When the invocation of Saints worshipping of Images the Latine Service and fabulous Legends the sacrifice of the Masse and adoration of the Sacrament with such like abhominations were taken away and in the roome thereof the true worship of one true God in the mediation of Jesus Christ and the right administration of the Sacraments and the reading of the holy Scriptures in a knowne tongue established when the omnipotency of the Pope is abandoned with all corrupt superstitions which did undermine the foundation it selfe and in stead thereof the intire faith of the Lord Jesus in all points necessary to salvation taught professed and received then is the Church refined and separated from that drosse To bring Infidells from the state of infidelitie to the faith it is necessary that instruction goe before either by reading exhortation preaching or report of Christian faith for faith commeth by hearing But where men professe Christianitie abuses may be reformed by the Edict of the Magigrate without such particular instruction going before as in the former case is requisite Many times * Jo. 2.19 heresie departeth from the Church or Heretickes goe out from the Church and sometimes the Church is compelled to goe out from heresie the heresie still remaining * Revel 18.4 Come out of her my people saith the Lord the godly then departing from Babylon according to Gods commandement gathering themselves into Christian societies the religious Magistrate by his Edict or Proclamation going before them are the true churches of Christ The i Raynold orat epist ad fratrem Non semper heresis exit ab ecclesia aliquando manet heresis ecclesia exire cogitur Papacy was not the church but the church lay hid in the Papacy untill the time of separation which being made according to Gods commandement by the authoritie of the Lords Vicegerent the church which was before k August epist 48. ad Vincent Donatist Ecclesia est quae aliquando obscuratur tanquam obnubilatur multitudine scandalorum obscured doth now shine forth Thus our Divines doe soundly and truely answer to the Papists demanding where our Church was before Luther That it was where now it is but unrefined unstamped that it lay l Beza epist 1. ad Duditium et si Papatun non sit Ecclesia voluit Deus in Papatu servare ecclesiam hid among them for the time as some fit stones for the building under a great heap of rubbish and that we have not erected a new Church but repaired and restored a ruinous m See Dr. Feild of the Church lib. 3. c.