Selected quad for the lemma: law_n

Word A Word B Word C Word D Occurrence Frequency Band MI MI Band Prominent
law_n england_n king_n people_n 13,931 5 5.0853 4 true
View all documents for the selected quad

Text snippets containing the quad

ID Title Author Corrected Date of Publication (TCP Date of Publication) STC Words Pages
A36230 Honors pedigree, or, The [se]veral fountaines of gentry [be]ing a treatise of the distinct degrees of the nobilitie of this kingdome, with their rights and priviledges, according to the lawes and customes of England / [by] that juditious lawyer, Sir John Dodoredge ... Doddridge, John, Sir, 1555-1628. 1652 (1652) Wing D1793; ESTC R37279 103,037 198

There are 9 snippets containing the selected quad. | View lemmatised text

or imagine the death of the Kings eldest Sonne and Heir is crimen laesoe Majestatis high treason or if a man do violate the Wife of the Kings eldest Sonne and Heir it is high treason and see the Statute 20. Hen. 8. cap. 13. And so was the ancient common Law of England and not a new Law made by this Statute Cooks 8. Part. 28. 6. But this Statute is a manifestation and declaration or publication of the ancient common Law in this Case By a Statute made in the said 25. yeer of King Ed. 3. It is declared because the people be in ambiguity and doubt of the children born in the parts beyond the Sea out of the Kings Legiance of England should be able to demand any inheritance within the same Legiance or not Whereof a Petition was put into the Parliament late holden at Westminster the 17. yeer of the raign of our Soveraign Lord the King assembled in this Parliament and was not at the same time wholly assented Our Soveraign Lord the King willing that all doubts and ambiguities should be put away and the Law in this case declared and put i● a certainty hath charged the said Prelates Earls Barons and other wise men of his Counc●ll assembled in this 〈◊〉 to deliberate upon this point who with one asseur hath said That the Law of the Crown of England is an● alwayes hath been such that Les Enfants du Roy the children of the King of England in whatsoe●e● part they be born in England or elsewhere be able and ought to bear the inheritance after the death of their Ancestors which Law our Soveraign Lord the King the said Prelates Earls Barons and other great m●n and all the C●●amons assembled in this Parliament do approve and affirm for ever Note These words in the Statute Les Infants du Roy have briefly set down and in a vulgar manner for loquendum ut vulgus and not in form of exquisite pleading for sentiendum ut docti and therefore ought to be understood largely Cooks 7. part 11. 6. and as the Latine word liberi is with the Civilians Bract. lib. 2. cap. 29. hath these words Item descendit jus vero beredi ubicunque natus fuerit vel in utero matris intra mare vel ultra Nec potest sibi aliquis facere heredem quia solus Deus heredem facit The right doth descend unto the true Heir wheresoever he shall be born in the Womb of his Mother on this side the Sea or beyond no man can make an Heir unto himself because God only doth make the Heir read the Statute and Cook 7. part 18. a. Where you shall see that though generally the birth place is observable yet many times Legiance and obedience without any place within the Kings Dominions may make a Subject born for though we see by experience almost in every Parliament Ambassadors Merchants and the Kings souldiers doth shew there in such causes to have their children naturalized or made denizens yet that doth proceed onely of doubt and needlesse sc●pulosity and ignorance of the Law even as we see men that are doubtfull desire to be resolved as may appear by sundry covenants in bargaining more then necessary And by renuing of Chartes though there be no forfeitures and by suing forth particular pardons when a generall is granted by Parliament Priests and Ministers sue to the Parliament for legitimation of their children And in the Articles confirmed by Parliament touching the marriage between Philip Prince of Spain and Queen Mary a speciall proviso was to barre him from being Tenant by the courtesie of the Crown in case he should have issue by her and survive which was superfluous because the Common-Law would have denyed this last point See the Lord Cromwels Speech in the case of the Postnati fol. 36 But note that if an Alien Enemy come into this Realm and his Wife Engiish or stranger be delivered of a childe within England this childe notwithstanding his birth-place is an Alien born for want of allegeance in the Parents Ibidem King Henry did create Edward his eldest Sonne the first Prince of Wales and did give unto him the dignity and Dominion of it to be holden of him and his Heirs Kings of England and after that time the eldest sonne of the King of England hath been Prince of Wales and as incident to the State and dignity of a Prince and might make Laws and Statutes and use jurisdiction and authority as amply as any King of that Nation could do Plowden Cooks 7. part 21. 6. Vide Mills fol. 312. 126. For Wales was a Kingdom in ancient time But in a Statute made in the 12. Ed. 1. Wales was united and incorporated into England and made parcell of England in possession And note in Tho. Mylls 112. the devise of the said King was to draw the Welchmen to acknowledge the Kings eldest Son Edward of Carnarvan to be their Prince Also by another Statute made 27. Hen. 8. cap. 24. a generall resumption of many liberties and franchises heretofore taken or granted from the Crown as the authority to pardon Treason murther man-slaughter and fellony power to make Justices in Oyre Justices of assize Justices of peace Goal delivery and such like so that from thenceforth the Kings eldest Sonne hath only the name and stile of Prince of Wales but no other Jurisdiction then at the Kings pleasure is permitted him and granted by his Letters Patents as by the tenour thereof following made by King Henry the eight to Edward his sonne and heir apparent may appear Henry By the grace of God King of Ireland was before 33. Hen. 8. a Lordship and now is a Kingdom and the King of England was as absolute a Prince and Soveraign when he was Lord of Ireland as now when he is stiled King of the same Cooks 7. part England and of France Lord of Ireland c. To all Archbishops Bishops Abbots Priors Dukes Earls Barons Justices Viscounts Governours Ministers and to all our Bailiffs and faithfull Subjects greeting out of the excellency of Royall preheminence like as the beams from the Sunne so doth inferiour honour proceed neither doth the integrity of Royall lustre and brightnesse by the naturall disposition of the light-affording light feel any losse or detriment by such borrowed lights yea the Royall Scepter is also much the more extolled and the Royall Throne exalted by how much more noblenesse preeminences and honours are under the power and command thereof And this worthy consideration allureth and induceth us with desire to the increase of the name and honour of our first begotten and best beloved Sonne Edward in whom we behold and see our selves to be honoured and our Royall House also and our people subject to us hoping by the grace of God by conjecture taken of his gratious future proceedings to be the more honourably strengthned that we may with honour prevent and with aboundant grace prosecute him who in reputation
apparant of the King of England and of such a King who is heir unto the said Prince Edward And such a first begotten son and heir apparant to the Crown shall inherit the said Dukedom in the life of the said King his father with manner of limitation of estate was short excellent and curious varying from the ordinary Rules of the Common Law touching the framing of any estate of inheritance in fee-simple or fee-tail And neverthelesse by the authority of Parliament a speciall fee-simple i● in that onely case made as by judgment may appear in the Book aforesaid and the case thereof fol. 27. and 21 E. 3. 41. b. And ever since that creation the said Dukedom of Cornwall hath been the peculiar inheritance of the Kings eldest son ad supportandum nomen onus bonoris to support the name and weight of that his honourable estate during the king his fathers life so that he is ever Duxnatus non creatus a Duke born not created and the said Duke the very first day of his nativity is presumed and taken to be of full and perfect age so that he may sue that day for his livery of the said Dukedom and ought of right to obtain the same as well as if he had been full 21 yeers of age And the said Black-Prince was the first Duke in England after the Conquest for though Bracton who made his Book in H. 3. saith Et sunt sub reg●duces as before appeareth yet that place is to be understood of the ancient kings who were before the conquest for in Mag. Charta which was made in Anno 9 H. 3. we finde not the name of Duke amongst the Peers and Nobles there mentioned For seeing the Norman Kings themselves were Dukes of Normandy for a great while they adorned none with this honour of Duke And the eldest son of every King after this creation was Duke of Cornwall and so allowed As for example Henry of Munmouth eldest son of H. 4. and Henry of Winso● eldest son of H. 5. and Edw. of Westminster the first son of Ed. 4. and Arthur of Winchester first son of H. 7. and Edward of Hampton first son of H. 8. but Richard of Burdeaux who was the first son of the Black-Prince was not Duke of Cornwall by force of the said creation for albeit after the death of his father he was heir apparant to the Crown yet because he was not the first begotten son of a King of England for his father dyed in the life time of king Ed. 3. the said Richard was not within the limitation of the grant and creation by authority of Parliament made in the 11 yeer of king Edward above mentioned And therefore to supply that defect in the 5. yeer of Ed. 3. he was created Duke of Cornwall by a speciall Charter Elizabeth eldest daughter to king Edw. 4. was not Dutches of Cornwal for she was the first begotten daughter of king Edw. 4. but the limitation is to the first begotten son Henry the 8. was not in the life of his father king H. 7. after the death of his eldest Brother Arthur Duke of Cornwall by force of the said creation for albeit he was sole heir apparant to the king yet he was not his eldest begotten son Cooks 8 part 29. b. and 30. a. And the opinion of Stamford a learned Judge hath been that he shall have within his Dukedom of Cornwall the kings Prerogatives because it is not severed from the Crown after the form as it is given for none shall be inheritour thereof but the kings of the Realm For example whereas by the Common Law if a man hold divers Mannors or other lands and to●ements of severall Lords all by knights service some part by priority and ancient Feoffment and other lands by posterity and by a latter Feoffment and the Tenant so seized dyeth his son and heir within age In this case the custody of Wardship of the body and his marriage may not be divided among all the Lords but one of them onely shall have right unto it because the body of a man is intire and the Law doth say That the Lord of whom some part of those lands be holden by priority and by the same tenure of Chivalry shall have it except the king be any of the Lords for them though the Tenant did purchase that land last yet after his death the king shall bee pre●erred before all or any other the Lords of whom the Tenant did hold by priority And so shall the Duke of Cornwall in the same case have the same Prerogative if his Tenant dye holding of him but by posterity of Feoffment for any tenure of his Dutchie of Cornwall although the said Duke is not seized of any particular estate whereof the reversion remaineth in the king for the Prince is seized in fee of his Dukedom as before is said Iohn of Gaunt the fourth son of king Edward 3. did take to wife Blanch who was daughter and heir to Henry Duke of Lancaster who had issue Henry afterwards king of England so that the said Dutchy of Lancaster did come unto the said Henry by discent from the part of his mother and being a subject he was to observe the Common Law of the Land in all things concerning his Dutchie For if he would depart in Fee with any part thereof hee must make livery and seizen or if hee had made a Lease for life reserving rent with a reentery for default of payment and the rent happen to be behind the Duke might not enter unlesse hee doe make a demand or if he had aliened any part thereof whilest he was with age hee might defeat the purchaser for that cause and if hee would grant a reversion of any estate for life or yeares in being there must also be Attornment or else the grant doth not take effect But after that hee had deposed King Richard the second and had assumed upon him the Royall estate and so had conjoyned his naturall bodie in the bodie Politique of the King of this Realme and so was become King Then the possessions of the Duchie of Lancaster were in him as King and not as Duke For the name of Duke being not so great as the name of a King was drowned by the name of King and by the State Royall in him who was Duke for the King cannot bee a Duke within his owne Realme but out of his Realme hee may And likewise the name of the Duchie and all the Franchizes Liberties and Jurisdictions of the same when they were in the hands of him who had the Crowne and Jurisdiction Royall were gone by th● Common Law and extinct for the greater doth distinguish the lesse and after those times the possessions of the Dutchie of LANCASTER would not passe from King Henry the fourth but by his Letters Patents under the great Seal of England without livery of seifin and without Attornment and if he make a Lease for life being Duke
Honors Pedigree OR THE SEVERAL FOUNTAINES OF GENTRY Being A Treatise of the distinct degrees of the NOBILITIE of this Kingdome with their Rights and Priviledges according to the Lawes and Customes of England By that Juditious Lawyer Sir JOHN DODOREDGE one of his Majesties Judges of the Kings Bench. LONDON Printed for William Sheares at the Signe of the Bible in St. Pauls Church-yard M. D C. LII THE TABLE The severall Dignities Degrees and Titles treated of in this discourse IMprimis of the King 1 Of the Prince 14 Of Dukes and their Patents 36 Of Marquesses 58 Of Earles and their originall 60 Of Viscounts 90 Of Barons in generall 91 The definition or description of a Baron 92 The Etimology and derivation of the word Baron 94 The antiquity of the dignity of Barons and the sundry uses of the name 95 The tenour and proper signification of the word Baron 99 Of Barons by tenure 99 Of Barons by writ 134 Of Barons by Patent 155 Priviledges incident to the Nobility according to the Law of England 162 Certaine cases wherein a Lord of the Parliament hath no p●iviledge 200 Of Nobility and Lords in reputation onely 208 Of Noble Women 210 Of Ladies in reputation 234 Of Knights and matters incident to the degree of Knight-hood according to the Law of England 237 Observations concerning a Knight-Batc●elour 277 Of Esquires 278 The definition of Gentry or Civill Nobility 285 Of Yeomen 288 A Treatise concerning the Nobility according to the Laws of ENGLAND AS in mans body for the preservation of the whole divers Functions and Offices of Members are required even so in all well-governed Common-wealths a distinction of persons is necessary And the Policy of this Realm of England for the maintenance and government of the Common-wealth of the same hath made a three-fold division of persons That is to say First The King or Soveraign Monarch under which names also a Soveraign Queen is comprized as declared by the Statute thereof made in the first yeer of Queen Mary Anno 5 Parl. Secondly The Nobility which do comprehend the Prince Dukes Marquesses Earls Viscounts and Barons Spirituall and Temporall Thirdly The Commons by which generall words are understood Knights Esquires Gentlemen Yeomen Artifi●ers and Labourers But my purpose at this time being onely to speak of the Nobility and especially so much of them as I finde written in the Books of the common Law and Statutes of this Realm This first I have observed That our Law calleth none Noble under the degree of a Baron and not as men of forraign Countries do use to speak with whom every man of Gentle Birth is counted Noble for we dayly see that both Gentlemen and Knights do serve in the Parliament as Members of the Commonalty vide Lamberts Justice of Peace Lib. 4. Cap. 13. Neither do these words the Nobles the high or great men of the Realm imply the Person and Majesty of the King Dier 155. But with the Civilians the King is reckoned among his Nobles Doct. Ridley fol. 93. The Nobility are known by the generall name of Peers of the Realm or the Barony of England for Dukes Marquesses and Earls and all other of the Nobility do sit together in the Kings great Councell in Parliament as Barons and in right onely of their Baronies And therefore by the g●nerall names of Barons of this Realm and for the Baronage thereof we do understand the whole Body of the Nobility The Parliament-Robes of Dukes differing nothing from the Barons but they wear the Guards upon their shoulders three or four fold for although Dukes Marquesses Earls and Viscounts in their Creations are attired with Garments of Silk and Velvet yet in the Parliament they use the same as Barons do made with Scarlet with divers differences of white Furre set with Freinges or Edging on their shoulders for there they sit by reason of their Baronies and according to their dignity take their places Thomas Mills fol. 66. And hence it was that those bloody Civill Warres concerning the liberties granted by the great Charter both in the time of King John and H. 3 his sonne persecuted by all the Nobility of this Realm some few excepted are called in our History The Barons Warres Neither have the Spirituall Lords and Peers of the Parliament any other title to that preeminency but because of their ancient Baronies For although originally all the possessions of Bishops Abbots and Pryors were given and holden in Franckalmayn yet shortly after the Norman Conquest most of their Tenures were altered viz. per Baroniam as appeareth by Matthew Parris Anno 1070. 66. and of that Tenure have continued ever since as you may reade by the Consulations of Claringdon in the Raign of Hen. 2. and in Glanvile and Bracton But the Tenure of all Abbots and Pryors were extinguished by the uniting and conveying them to the Crown by the Statute of dissolution of Monasteries made Anno 31 Hen. 8. Cap. 13. And though the Nobility of England in Titles and by certain Ceremonies may be distinguished yet a Baron is in equipage as unto Nobility and priviledges incident to their diguities with Dukes Marquesses Earls Cooks 6. part 53. And it is in ordinary experience That Dukes and others of any high degree of Nobility in cases criminall are tryed by Barons together with many Earls and Viscounts as their Peers and Peers of the Realm Nobilitas generally signifieth and is derived of the word Nosco to know signifying in common phrase of speech both with the Latines and eke with us English-men a generosity of Blood and Degree and therefore one said vir nobilis idem est quod not us per omni● c. A Noble-man is he who is known and the Heroicall vertues of his life talkt of in every mans mou●h But especially it is applyed and used to expresse the reward of vertue in honourable measure g●neris claritatem And this is not to be omitted That the Law doth prohibite any Subject of this Realm to receive Titles of Honor or dignity of the gift or D●nation of a F●rraigne Prince or King or Emperour for it is a thing greatly touching the Majesty of the King and the State of his Kingdom Est jus Majestatis inter insignia summ● potestatis It is the right of Majesty and amongst the Ensignes of high power vide Cook 7. part 25. 6. And if that m●n shall bring an action and in the Writ is stiled by such forraigne title and name of Honour the defendant may plead in abatement of his Writ That he is no Duke Marquesse Earl or Baron whereupon if the plaintiff or demandant take issue this issue shall not be tryed by Jury but by Records of the Parliament wherein he faileth And if an English man be made Earl of the Empire or of any other forraign Nation created into Honour and the King also do make him into any Title of Honour in England he shall now be named in all his judiciall
is no heire male at all that may claime the same for then doth this question take place whether the husband of such heire female shall enioy the dignitie in the right of his wife or no wherein wee are to rest upon a resolution had and given in this speciall question which was in this manner In the time of Hen. 8. when Mr. Winbie tooke upon him the stile of Lord Talboys in the right of his wife having none issue by her the said King assisted both by Civill and Temporall Lawyers gave sentence that no husband of Baronesse in her right should use the stile and dignitie untill he had by her a Child whereby he should become Tenant by the courtesie unto her inheritance The speciall reasons that occasioned this sentence were two First it should be inconvenient for her husband this day to bee a Baron and Peere of the Realme and to morrow by the death of his wife to become none and that without the death of the partie Secondly if he had issue by his wife and were intituled to be Tenant by the curtesie of England of the wives land if hee shall not also beare the stile and dignitie of her Barony then should his sonne after the death of his mother dying in the life time of his father bee Baron and Lord without land for so the Father should have the land as Tenant by the curtesie and the sonne the Lordship without Land And thus much said concerning the nature quality and estate of a Baron by writ and for resolution of the severall points and Articles of the question proposed may suffice Barons by Patent which is the third kind of Barons mentioned in the former division of Barons THere is also a fourth meanes of creation by act of Parliament but the first 2. mentiond and this by Patent are most for the honour of the King for thereby the donation doth proceed from his highnes onely as from the fountaine of all honour and dignity but when the creation is by Parliament every one may bee said donator Cookes 8. part 19. A Baron by creation by reason of Letters Patents is that Noble person whom the Kings Maiesty or any of his progenitors Kings of the Realme have created Barons by such their Letters Patents But this manner of creating Barons by Patent began in the Raign of R. 2. who created first Iohn Beauchamp of Holt Baron of Kidderminster by his Letters Patents 8. October anno 11. But Mils saith in 30. H. 6. this was brought in This kind of dignity of Baron shall bee of such countenance in discent or otherwise as shall beelimited in the Habendi in such Letters Patents contained for it may be but for the life of him to whom it is given or for terme de anter vie of some other mans life as some hold opinion in 9. H. 6. 29. for Cujus est dare eius est dispo●ere it may be in speciall a generall tayle and this kind of estate tayle was usuall before the Statute made 13. E. 1. by which estate tayle in Lands and Tenements was created as appeareth by the Patent whereby Hubert de Burgo was made Earle of Kent in the time of H. 3. by these words Habend sibi hered suis de corpore Ma●ga●etaeuxoris su● sororis Alexandri Regis Scoti● procreatis pro defectu talis exitus rema●ere rectis hered●bus dicti Huberti and that estates in tayle are at this day titles of honour by the Statute of Westm 2. vide Nevils case Cooks 7. part 33. For the better explanation of this kind of dignity the resolution also of certaine questions shall be very requisite Question If a Nobleman and his Progenitors have for a long time been called to the Parliament and be a Baron either by tenure or writ have had in regard thereof a place certaine in Parliament if afterwards the same Nobleman should be created a Baron of that Barony and by the same name by Letters Patents whether shall hee and his heires retaine his old place in Parliament which hee had according to the former dignity or whether shall he lose ●is old place and take a new place according to the time of his creation onely Answer The case of the Lord Delaware received a resolution Coo 11. part ●●e Lord de la wares case somewhat answerable to this question Tho. Lord Delaware 3. ● 6. being in some displeasure with William West his Nephew and heire who was Father to the now Lord De la ware procured an Act of Pa●liament by the which the said W●ll West was during his naturall life only clearly disabled to clayme demand or have any manner of right title or interest by discent ●evenue or otherwise in or to the mannor lands tenements or hereditaments title and dignity of Thomas Lord De la w●re his Vncle Af●er the said Thomas De la ware dyed and the said VVilliam West was in the time of the late Queene Elizabeth restored and afterwards in the 8. yeare of her Raigne was ●teated Lord De la ware by Patent and had place in Parliament according to his creation by Patent for that by the said Act of Parliament in the time of E. 6. hee was excluded to challenge the former ancient Ba●ony and after hee dyed whether the new Lord Dela ware should take his place to the ancient Barony by writ or according to his Fathers creation by Patent was the question the opinion of the late Queenes Counsell being Her Majesties Atturney Generall and Solicitor were that the acceptance of the new creation by the said William West could not distinguish the ancient dignity in him at the time of his creation but the dignity was at that time by the Act of Parl●ament 3. E. 6. in obeyance suspence or consideration of Law and hee thereby utterly disabled to have the same during his life only so as other acceptance could not extinguish that dignity which hee then had not nor could not conclude his h●ire who was not disabled by the said Act of 3. E. 6. to clayme the ancient Barony which opinion of theirs was seene and allowed by the resolution of the chiefe Iustice of England and Lord chiefe Baron and so signified unto the Lord Keeper but this is to bee noted by the reasons made for the said resolution that if the said William West had beene Baron and intituled or in possession of the ancient dignity when hee accepted the said creation the Law perchance might have been otherwise but that remayneth as yet unresolved neverthelesse the rule eodem mod quo quid constuitur dissolvitur but by grant which is made a matter in fact a man cannot transferre his title of honour Cook 7. part And thus much concerning the three degrees of Barons within this Realme may suffice to be said in gene●all upon this occasion for the better understanding and direction of that which followeth to be handled And in this place I thinke it not impertinent
of one and twenty yeares he shall be in ward but if the King had made him Knight in the life of his Father he should not have beene in ward after the death of his Father neither for the lands descended or for his marriage though he be within age Cooks 6. part 74. in Druries case Nobility and Lords in reputation onely THere are other Lords in reputation and appellation who neverthelesse are not de jure neither can they enjoy the priviledge of those of the Nobility that are Lords of the Parliament The sonne and heire of a Duke during his fathers life is onely by curtesie of speech and honour called an Earle and the eldest sonne of an Earle a Baron but not so in legall proceedings or in the Kings Courts of Iustice Brook Treason 2. But the King may at his pleasure create them in the life of their Ancestors into any degree of Lords of the Parliament Cook 8. part 16. b. A Duke or other of the Nobilitie of a forraigne Nation doth come into this Realme by the Kings safe conduct in which the Kings said Letters of Conduct he is named Duke according to his Creation yet that appellation maketh him not a Duke c. to sue or to be sued by that name within England but is onely so reputed But if the King of Denmark or other Soveraigne King come into England under safe conduct he during his aboad in England ought to bee stiled by the name of King though hee have not merum imperium out of his owne Kingdome yet he shall retaine honoris titulos Cook 7. part 15. b. sequentia All the younger sonnes of the Kings of England are of the Nobility of England and Earles by their birth without any other Creation and onely Lords in reputation And if an English man be created Earle of the Empire or of other title of honour by the Emperour he shall not beare the title in England and therefore is an Earle onely in reputation A Lord of Ireland and Scotland though he be a Postnatus is not a Lord in England in legall Courts of Iustice though he be commonly called and reputed a Lord. NOBLE VVOMEN ALthough Noble women may not sit in Parliament in respect of their sexe yet they are in the law Peeres of the Realm and all or most of the Prerogatives before mentioned which to Noblemen are belonging doe also appertaine to them Cook 8. part 53. But the opinion of some men hath been that a Countesse Baronesse or other woman of great estate cannot maintaine an action upon the statute de scandalis Magnatum because the statute of 2. R. 2. cap. 5. speaketh but of Prelates Dukes Earles Barons or other Nobles and other great men of the Realme and of the Chancellour Treasurer Clarke of the Privie Seale Steward of the Kings house Iustice of the one Bench or of the other great officers of the Realm by which words they conceive the meaning of the makers of that statute was onely to provide in that case for Lords and not for women of honour Crompton Justice of Peace 45. b. Also if any of the Kings servants within his Check-roll doe conspire the death of any Noble man it is not felony within the compasse of the statute 3. H. 7. cap. 13. Honourable women are of three sorts By creation by Descent or by Marriage King Henry the eighth created Anne Bullen Marchionesse of Pembrook and so may the King create any woman into any title of honour as to his Highnesse shall seem good As the King by by his Letters Patents openly read in the Parliament did create Widow the sole daughter of late Baron of Abergavenny Baronesse De le Spencer Cambden 63. 6. Noble women by descent are those to whom either the lands holden by such dignity do descend as heir and they are said to be honourable by tenure or those whose Ancestors to whom they are heires were seised of an estate descendable unto them in their titles of Dukedomes Earldomes or Baronies or those whose Ancestors were summoned to the Kings Parliament for thereby also an inheritance doth accrue to their posterities Noble women also are those who do take to their husbands any Lord or Peere of the Realme although they of themselves were not of any degree of Nobility Fortescue de laudibus legum Angliae fol. 100. Question and doubt hath been made whether if a man be summoned to the Parliament and afterwards die without issue male the dignity and title of honour may descend to the heire female and many arguments have beene made pro contra in that which at this time ● doe purposely omit because I have before discoursed thereof in the title of Barons in this Treatise Concerning the title of honour descendable to the heire female by reason of a tenure in her Ancestor there need no more doubt to be made than of offices of honour the which doe much import the publike wealth and being of estate of inheritance doe descend to the heire female if there be no heire male as the office of high-Constableship of England challenged in the time of H. 8. by the Duke of Buckingham and judged by the advice and resolution of the Judges as by a note of that case extant whereof my Lord Dyer in his Reports hath a memoriall is most evident Dyer 283. b. Kellaway 6. H. 8. 170. b. which descended to the daughters of Humphrey de Bohun Earle of Hereford and Essex as afore is declared the office of a Lord Steward descended to Blanch daughter of Henry Earle of Lancaster in whose right John of Gaunt her husband enjoyed the same The like may be said of the office of Earle Marshall which descended by an heire female unto the house of Norfolk all which offices are as unfit to be exercised by a woman as it is unfit for a woman to be summoned to the Parliament as Baronesse by writ as before is written And when the title of honour doth descend to a woman if question in Law doe arise betweene the noble woman and any other person whether she be of that degree of noblenesse or no the issue shall be tried by the Record thereof and by the Kings writ it shall be certified and not by a Jury of twelve men even as it should be in case her Ancestors had beene party Cooks 6. part 53. 7. part 15. Although the Lawes of this Realme regularly doe make all the daughters where there are no sonnes equally to inherit Lands and Tenements and to be but one heire to their Ancestor yet it is not so in the descent of dignities and titles of honour for inheritances concerning matters of honour being things in their nature entire paticipating of superiority and eminency are not partable amongst many and therefore must of necessity descend unto one and that is to the eldest daughter sister aunt or cosin female inheritable where there is no heires males that may lawfully challenge the same and so in
tryall hereof shall not be by Record as in the former case but by a Jury of 12. men and the reason of the diversity is because in this case the Dignity is accrewed unto her by marriage which the Lawyers tearme matter in fact and not by any record Cookes 6. part 53. a. But a noble Woman by Marriage though she take to her a second Husband a man of meane degree yet shee may keepe two Chaplaines according to the Proviso in the Statute of 21. H. 8. c. 13. for and in respect of the honour which once she had viz. at the time of the retayner and every such Chaplaine may purchase lycense and dispensation Cookes 4. part 117. Cowels Instutions lib. tit 10. 15. but her Chaplaines may not be nonresident afterwards And forasmuch as the retayning of Chaplaines by Ladies of great estates is ordinary and neverthelesse some questions in law have beene concerning the true understanding of the said Statute law I thinke it not impertinent to set downe some subsequent resolutions of the Judges touching such matters Anne Baronesse of Mount Eagle in her Widdowhood did retaine two Chaplaines according to the Statute and one of them had but one Benefice and therefore did obtaine a dispensation with a confirmation from the Queene according to the tenour of the said Statute but before he was presented to his second Benefice the Lady did take to Husband Henry Lord Compton whereby she did forsake her former dignity of Baronesse of Mount-Eagle and afterward the said Chaplain did accept a second Benefice and was therunto admitted and inducted and the Judges have resolved that the Chaplain hath done nothing herein but according to the meaning of the Statute and that the Ladies marriage between his Retainer and acceptance of his second benefice was no Countermand Revocation or determination of that Retainer which the Lady lawfully then did make but that she living he might proceed to the filling up of the qualification Causa origio est materia negoti for though the wife of a Noble-man during the covecture cannot by Law rerain a Chaplain to be quallified according to the statute because by Intendment her Husbands Chaplains are sufficient for that Office yet forasmuch as the Retainer was lawfull then she was widdow that being the principall matter shall enable him to take use and benefice after her marriage for though the husband and wife are but one person in Law yet as the Text is sunt animo duo in carne uno Bracton lib. 5. fol. 363 a. And in this case by the death of the Lord Compton her first Retainer was not determined for without any neer Retainer her said Chaplain may take his second benefice and also for that cause so long as the said Chaplains do attend upon their said Lady in her House they shall not be endammaged for Non-residency Cooks 4. part 117. fol. 90 76. That which remains concerning the further exposition of this statute you may read before in the title of priviledge of Lords So long that the wife of a Duke be called Dutchesse or of an Earl be a Countesse and have the fruition of all the Honours appertaining to that estate with kneeling tasting serving and the rest and so long shall a Barons widow be saluted Lady and a Knights wise also by the courteous Speech of England quandiu Maj. aut viduitas vic durant except she happen to relaps with an Adulterer for as the Laws of this Kingdome do adjudge that a woman shall lose her dower in that case viz. west cap. B. F. N. B. fol. 150. H. Perk. fel. 70. Kitchin 162. b. as Ruto Lands and Tenents so justly so doth the Laws of Gentry and Noblenesse give sentence against such a woman advanced to Titles of Dignity by the husband to be unworthy to enjoy the same when she putting her husband out of mind hath subjected her self to another If a Lady which is married come through the Forrests he shall not take any thing but a Dutchesse or a Countesse shall have advantage of the statute de Charta Forest 11. Art during the time that she is unmarried Cromptons Court fol. 167 b. Wheras it is contained in the great Charter amongst other things in the Form which followeth no Freeman shall be taken or imprisoned or deseised of his Free-hold or his Liberties or Free-customs or shall be outlawed or banished or in any wise destroyed nor go upon him but by the lawfull judgment of his Peers or by the Law of the Land In which statute is no mention made how women Ladies of great estate because of their Husbands Peers of the Land married or sole that is to say Dutchesse Countesse or Barronesse shall be put to answer or before what Iudges they shall be judged upon an Inditement of Treason or Fellonyes by them committed or done because wherof it is an Ambiguity in the Law of England before whom and by whom such Ladies so endicted shall be put to answer and be judged by our said Soveraign Lord the King willing to put out such Ambiguities and Doubts hath declared by Authority aforesaid that such Ladies so endicted or hereafter to be endicted whether they be married or sole therof shall bee brought in answer and put to answer and judged before such Iudges and Peers of the Realm as Peers of the Realm should be if they were endicted of any Treasons or Fellonyes done or hereafter to be done and in like manner and Form and in none otherwise Anno 2. H. 6. Cap. 9. Which statute was but a Confirmation or Declaration of the common Law vide Cooks 6 part 52. b. This is a Rule in the civill law si filia R. nubat alicui dom vel Comiti dicetur semp Regalis As amongst Noble women there is a difference of degrees so according to their distinct excellentnesse the law doth give speciall Priviledges as followeth By the statute of 25. E. 3. cap. 2. It is High Treason to compose or imagine the death of the Queen or to violate the Kings Companion The Kings Espouse is a sole person exempted by the common law and she may purchase by Fee-simple or Make leases or Grants without the King she may plead and be impleaded which no other married woman can do without her husband Cook 4 part 23. B. Theol. lib 1. cap. 4. 24. E. 3. 63. vide Bracton 363. a. All Acts of Parliaments for any cause which any way may concern the Queen and her Capacity are such statutes wherof the Judges ought to take recognisance as of generall statutes for though the matter do only concern the Capacity of the Queen yet it doth also concern all the subjects of the Realm for every subject hath interest in the King and none of his Subjects who are within his Lawes in divided from the King being his head and Soveraigne so that his businesse and things do touch all the Realme and as all the Realme hath interest in the King so and
remember that in our Law books I have read any thing concerning the Order of Knights with addition viz. Knight of the Honourable Order of the Garter Knight of the Bath Knight Barronet Knight Banneret But in the statute of 21. H. 8. cap. 13. where it is thus enacted Every Knight of the Garter may have three Chaplains wherof every one may purchase license or dispensation and receive have and keep two Benefices with tare of souls and they of this Order wherof I have now writ are called Knights of the sput and Butcher Knights And so it is used in the statute of 13. R 2. cap. 1. and in the statute of 3. Ed. 4. cap. 5. Hereof see Cambden 176. and M. Seldens Title of Honours fol. 336. Between Doctors of the Civill law and Knights have ●ver bin question for precedency and Serjeants at law since either of them have obtained credit in the Common-wealth as may appear by the comparison that Tully maketh between Mucius Maurena a Knight of Rome and Publius Sulpicius a Lawyer either of them standing for the Consulship In his Eloquent Oration m●de for Murena and many Disputes of Bardell and Bardus arguing the Case to and fro which although it be yet disputable in forreign Countries where the civill law is in credit yet here amongst us in England it is without controversie and so the precedency thereof is undoubtedly in the Knight and Sergeant at law in regard of their Callings But if they both are of equall degree of knighthood or a Serjeant at law not Knight then it goeth otherwise as by Knighthood by Seigniority and by Serieantship by the Kings Writ and degree allowed thereupon Dr. Ridley 95. and so Selden his Titles of Honour fol. 55. touching part of this Discourse not all The opinion of some men hath lately bin that Knights Lieutenants that is to say such as have beene Ambassadours to forraigne Princes or Judges within the Realm may and ought to have during their lives precedencie above men of their owne rankes after these their Offices expired and many of them doe stand strongly hereupon sub judice lis est not determined by judgement but admitting it to be so by way of Argument in that case yet all the Heraulds doe utterly deny that priviledge to the Maior of London and Aldermen or Justice of the peace who have their limited Jurisdiction of Magistracie confined within the compasse of their owne walls and divisions But touching the former they are generall Magistrates throughout the Realme and their imployment concerneth the whole Common-weale and having the publike Justice of Honour of the whole estate committed unto them do more meritoriously draw from thence a greater respect of honour according to the generallitie of their administrations and imployments which an inferiour and more confined Magistrate may have The name of a Knight is the name of Dignity and a degree as is the name of a Duke Earle c. But in all actions he shall be named Knight otherwise the Writ shall abate See Thetwall lib. 3. cap. 3. A Knight also must be named by the name of Baptisme and by his sirname as Sir Ierome Bowes Knight but those of degree honourable who are made by pattent may be named onely by their Christian name and by their title of honour as Iohn Earle of Clare and that for two causes first because of their solemne creations it is notorious et nomen dicitur a noscendo Secondly there is but one of that title of honour within England and therefore it is certaine what person he is but otherwise of Knights as it is certainely knowne in Anno 8. Edw. 4. 24. a. And Priscot Chiefe Justice saith in 32. H. 6. fol. 26. b. that if an Esquire be made a Knight hee loseth his name of Esquire but albeit a Knight may be made a Nobleman or of any high degree he still retaineth the name of Knight and so ought to be stiled in the making of all Writs See Milles fol. 81. Also if a man do recover in an action by the name of Iohn Stibes Esquire and afterwards he is made a Knight he must sue out his Scire facias by the name of Knight Vide Long. anno 5. Ed. 4. fol. 19. And this name shall not dye with him for if hee were bound by an Obligation by the name of Gentleman or Esquire and afterwards is made Knight and dyeth the Plaintiffe in the Action to be brought against his Executors must name him Knight otherwise the Writ shall abate Vide anno 7. H. 4. 7. 6. 26. Ed. 3. fol. 64. a. Thomas Ormond was attainted by Parliament by the name of Thomas Ormond Knight whereas hee was no Knight he shall not forfeit any thing by that attainder because it cannot be intended the same person for this word Knight is parcell of his name 21. E. 4. fol. 17. a. If a Grant be made to H. Knight when he is no knight it is a void Grant But if it be a Feofment in Fee with livery of seisin the livery it maketh good Vide Brock titulo Grants 50. Anno 4. H. 6. If the Plaintiffe or Demandant do in his Writ name the Defendant or Tenant Esquire when he is a Knight the Writ shall not only abate but also the Plaintiffe or Demandant may not have another writ by Iournier account Finches book 59. Vide Cooks b. part de les Reports 1. b. But by the statute Anno 1. Ed. 6. cap. 7. It is amongst other things Enacted that albeit any person or persons being Justices of Assise Justices of Goal delivery or Justices of the Peace within any of the Kings Dominions or being in any other of the Kings Commissions whatsoever shall fortune to be made or created Duke Arch-Bishop Earl Marquesse Viscount Baron Bishop Knight Justice of the one Bench or on the other or Sergeant at Law or Sheriffe yet notwithstanding he and they shall remain Justices and Commissioners and have full power and Authority to execute the same in like manner and Form as he or they might or ought to have done before the same By the statute of Anno 5. H. 5. cap. 5. It is enacted as followeth That every Writ originall of accounts personall appeals and Ind●ctments shall be made with the addition of their Estates and Degrees c and a little after it is provided That if the said Writs of accounts personall be not according as the record and deed by the surplusage of the additions aforesaid that for this cause they are not Iohn a Stile Gent. is bound by obligation to one A. B. the Obliger is afterwards made Knight the Bond is forfeited A. B. by his Attorney draweth a note or title for an originall Writ according to the defendants degree though it vary from the originall specially as it ought to be made by the statute But the Curfitor mistaking did make the originall only according to such addition as was specified in the Obligation omitting his degree
Anno 8. H. 6. 10. because Dominae is generally a● men Domini so women after 14. yeares of age called Dominae Ladies or Dames and which were antiently navigeable women were called Dominae and by our English Poets Dames First Dominae is often for women generally as speciall Honour for that sex not being out of use with us at this day nor with the French as also amongst the Italians Dominae for them is familiar vide Seldens title of Honour 1. part fol. 53. But if shee bee named Countesse or Baronesse shall abate the writ 14. H. 6. 2. And Cookes 6. part des reports 53. b. By the statute of Magna charta cap. 21. Knights are free from cart taking that no Demeasne cart of them shall bee taken By the statute of 1. Iac. cap. 27. It seemeth that Knights may keepe Greyhounds and setting Dogges or Nets to take Pheasants or Partridges in though they cannot dispence 10. l. per a●num nor bee worth 200. l. For the expresse words of that statute are that all the Sons of Knights are excepted Observations concerning a Knight Batchelour A Knight Batchelour cannot claime the priviledge that Knights have from cart-taking by Magna ch●rta cap. 21. A Knight Batchelours Sonne cannot keepe a Greyhound because hee is not within the statute of 1. Iac. cap. 27. unlesse hee have 10. l. Lands c. Quaere whether the Knight Batchelours addition doe abate any action c. If one hee Knighted in the life time of his Father it frees him of wardship but e contrario of a Knight Batchelour Knights are excused from attendance at Leets but so are not Knights Batchelours Of Esquires ALthough by the Civill Law there bee no Gentlemen of title under Knights but all the rest went under the name of people yet with us there are in the ranke who have names of preheminence whereby they are in degree above the rest as Esquiers and Gentlemen all which give ensignes or coates of armes and thereby are distingnished from the meaner sort of people in which respect Bartol Tract de Insignis calleth Noble but of a weake Nobility for it hath no further prerogative in it then that it makes them differ from the baser sort of people Of these two sort of Gentlemen with us the Esquire hath the Prerogative priority but it seemes if an Esquire bee named Gentleman or a Gentleman bee named Esquire it is no vice in legall proceedings Brooke additions 44. Esquire seemeth by the Common name wee give him in Latine to have had his originall either for that hee carried the armour of the King Duke or other great personage as wee see not onely in the Scriptures as Saul and Jonathan had their armour bearers but in Poets and other Prophane stories Patroclus was Achilles his armour bearer and Clitus great Alexanders whereupon some write that hee whom wee call Armiger in Latine is a Foot-man that with a speare shield or head peece followeth an armed Knight in battaile or rather as some others suppose It is the Foot-man himselfe armed in the field but howsoever the word bee taken this is sure those men were of good accompt in old time as those who wonne themselves credit out of warre and so their estimation remained unto their posterity And as those were in time before so are these which are in our dayes as descending for the most part from their worthy Ancestours and our bookes of the Common Law doe distinguish them thus that is to say Knight-hood is a dignity but Esquires and Gentlemen are but names of worship An. 14. H. 5. And Brooke in his Abridgement in that case T it nosmer de dignity 33. saith to bee a Knight est Gradus but to bee an Esquire or Gentleman est Status For Gradus continet Statum in se non e contrari vide Thesoal 105. concerning this word worshipfull read in the printed booke Master Seldens title of honour Prima pars fol. 124. sequentia In time past every Knight had two of these waiting upon him they carried his morion and shield and as inseperable Companions they stuck close to him because of the said Knight their Lord they had certaine lands in escuage like as had the Knight himselfe who held them of the King by Knights service The beginning of armes in Europe amongst Christians is supposed from the holy warres for the Turke paint them not and so with us about H. 3. They became more hereditarily established and when the Prince enabled any hee gave them the particuler of his bearing in Blason Master Seld●n in his Preface fol. 5. where you may also see an example in the Raigne of R. 2. But now adayes there are five distinct sorts of these for those whom I have spoken already bee now no more in any request the principall Esquires at this day are accompted those that are elected Esquires for the Princes body The next unto them be Knights eldest Sonnes successively In a third place are reputed younger Sonnes of the eldest Sonnes of Barons and of other Nobles of higher estate and when such Heires Males failes together with them also the title faileth In a fourth ranke are reckoned those unto whom the King himselfe together with the title giveth armes or createth Esquires by putting about their necks a silver Collar of S. S. and in former times upon their heeles a paire of white spurres silvered whereupon at this day in the West part of the Kingdome they are called white spurres and to the first begotten Sonne onely of these doth this title belong In a fift and last place be those ranked and taken for Esquires who have any superiour publike office in the Common-wealth or serve the Prince in any worshipfull calling at the Coronations of Kings and Queenes Knights of the Bath are made men of worth and honourable blood to the end that their Majesties may bee accompanied in their owne honours every of which Knight having two Gentlemen to attend him in that Ceremonie who are ever after enabled by that service to be Esquires during their lives But this name of Esquire which in ancient time was a name of charge and office only first crept in amongst other titles of dignity and worship so farre as ever I could observe In the raigne of R. 2. Camden fol. 176. vide Sir Thomas Smith de republica Anglorum fol. 26. where saith he that the Esquire is no distinct order of the Common-wealth and hereof see the statute of An. 16. R. 2. cap 4. and an ejusdem Regis cap. 2. A Serjeant of the Kitchin in the Kings house may beare the name and addition of Cooke or of Esquire by the opinion of Newton But Ienny said that such officers of the Kings House-hold would be much agreved if they should be named by their trade or occupation Paston peradventure saith in that case the writ may be good because of the Statute Anno 1. H. 5. cap 5. For the Statute is That hee shall be named
Labourer Long 5. E. 4 33. 14. H. 6. fol. 15 a. Dyer If a Gentleman bee bound an aprentice to a Merchant or else c. he hath not thereby lost his degree of Gentry Estopell 47. But if a Recovery be had against a Gentleman by the name of yeoman in which case no addition is necessary then it is no errour Brooke Cron 83. addition 58. So if any deed or obligation be made unto him by the name of yeoman If a Capias goe against A. B. yeoman and if the Sheriffe take A. B. Gentleman an action of false imprisonment lyeth against the Sheriffe vide An. 21. E. 4. fol. 71. b. But if a yeoman be indicted and A. B. Gentleman being the same man bee produced it is good Kelway 58. b. Gentlewomen have the same additions vide Dyer 88. IF one be a Gentleman by office and looseth his office then he doth also lose his gentility 28. H. 6. 2. Estopel 47. By the Statute of 5. Eliz. cap. 4. intituled an act touching divers orders for Artificers Labourers Servants of husbandry and apprentices amongst other things It is enacted that a Gentleman borne c. shall not be compelled to serve in husbandry If any Faulcon be lost and is found it shall be brought to the Sheriffe who must make Proclamation and if the owner come not within foure moneths then if the Finder bee a simple man the Sheriffe may keepe the Hawke making agreement with him that tooke it but if hee be a Gentleman and of estate to have and keepe a Faulcon then the Sheriffe ought to deliver unto him the Faulcon taking of him reasonable costs for the time that hee had him in custody An. 34. E. 3. cap. 22. and anno 37. E. 3. cap. 19. A Commission is made to keepe chrildren into Cathedrall Churches where children be instructed to sing for the furnishing of the Kings Chappell These generall words by construction of Law have a reasonable intendment viz. That such children who be brought up and taught to sing to seeke and sustaine their living by it Those may bee taken for the Kings service and it shall be a good preferment unto them to serve the King in his Chappell but the sonnes of Gentlemen or any other that are taught to sing for their ornament delight or recreation and not thereby to seeke their living may not bee taken against their will or the consent of their Parents and friends and so it was resolved by the two chiefe Iustices and all the Court of Star-chamber anno 43. Eliz. in the case of one Evans who had by colour of such Letters Patents taken the sonne of one Clifton a Gentleman of quality in Norfolke who was taught to sing for his recreation which Evans was for the same offence grievously punished Cook 8. Reports fol. 46. And to the end it may withall appeare what degrees of Nobility and Gentry there were in this Realme before the comming in of the Normans and by what merits men might ascend and bee promoted to the same I will shew you the copie of an English or Saxon antiquity which you may reade in Lamberts Perambulation of Kent fol. 3 64. and Englished thus viz. It was sometimes in the English Lawes that the people and lawes were in reputation then were the wisest of the people worship-worthy in his degree Earle and Chorle They●●e and under Theyne and if a Chorle so thrived that had fully five hides of land of his owne a Church and a Kitchin a Bel-house and a Gate a seat a severall office in the Kings Hall then was hee from thenceforth the Theines right worthy and if a Theyne so thrived that hee served the King on his message on his journey-ward in his houshold if he then had a Theyne which him followed who to the Kings experience had five hides and in the Kings Pallace his Lord had served and thrice with his errand had gone to the King hee might afterwards with his foreoath his Lords part play at need and if a Theyne that hee became an Earle then was hee from henceforth the Theynes right worthy and if a Scholler so thrived through learning that he had degree and served Christ he was thenceforth of dignity and peace so much worthy as thereunto belonged unlesse hee forfeited so that he the use of his degree ne might Mils 73. Nobility Politicall and Civill It is observeable that the Saxons out of all these trades of life which be conversant in gaine admitted to the state of Gentry such onely as increased by honest husbandry or plentifull merchandize of the first of which Cicero affirmeth that there is nothing meeter for a Free borne man and of the other that is prayse-worthy also if at the length being satisfied with gaine as it hath often come from the sea to the haven so it changeth from the havens into lands and possessions and therefore whereas Gervasius Tilburiensis in his observations of the Exchequer accounting it an abasing for a Gentleman to occupy Publicum mercimonium common buying and selling it ought to bee referred to the other two parts of merchandize that is to negotiation which is retayling or keeping of an open shop and to invention which is exercise mercery or some call it to play the Chapman and not to navigation which as you see is the onely laudable part of all buying and selling And againe whereas by the Statute of Magna charta cap 6. and Merton cap. 7. It was a discouragement for a ward in Chivalry which in old time was as much as to say a Gentleman to bee married to the Daughter of a Burgesse I thinke it ought to bee restrained to such onely as professed handy crafts or those baser arts of buying and selling to get their living by But this matter I leave to the Heraulds And in this place it may bee remembred that King Hen. 8. thought it no disparegement unto him when hee tooke Anne Daughter of Thomas Bullen sometimes Major of London to his wife The Statute of Westminster 2. cap. 1. which was made Anno 13. E. 1. was procured especially and purposely at the desire of Gentlemen for the preservation of their lands and hereditaments together with their surnames and faculties and therefore one called this Statute Gentiliteum municipale and the Lawyers call it Ius taliatum taliabile The children onely of Gentlemen were wont to bee admitted into the Innes of Court and thereby it came to passe that there was scant any man found within the Realme skilfull and cunning in the Lawes except hee were a Gentleman borne and came of a good house For they more then any kind of men have a speciall care to their Nobility and to the preservation of their honour and fame for in those Innes of Court are vertue studied and vices exiled for that for the endowment of vertue and abandoning of vice Knights and Barons with other States and Noblemen of the Realme place their Children in these Innes though they desire