are known to have done more real and faithful service to the Protestant Cause than all those that have entertained and promoted that rumour have bin able to do I will at present only mention Arch-Bishop Laud whose Labours against Popery and the other Separation were equally vigilant Of whom the Letter of Discovery of the Treason against the King and Kingdom and the Protestant Religion Octob. 1640. thus speaks Yet notwithstanding there remained on the King's part a knot hard to be untied for the Lord Arch-Bishop by his constancy interposed himself as a hard Rock And yet it was a lamentable hard case that at the very same time the Reproaches and Seditions of the People were inflamed against King Charles I. of blessed memory and Arch-Bishop Laud under suspicions of their favouring Popery at the very same time the Jesuits were conspiring the killing of King Charles I. and also Arch-Bishop Laud and the Convulsion of the Kingdom and the Ruin of the Protestant Religion and introducing of Popery as appears by the Discovery to Sir William Boswell at the Hague 1640 and sent over by him to the King and the Arch-Bishop Even thus hath bin the practice of the Romanists to slander Princes also for being Papists and then to assassinate them for being too zealous Protestants * The Lord Chancellors speech March 6. 1678. 4. Whereas our Enthusiastical Friends are ready to object unto us That the Church of England is either Popish or in some degree prepared to be so namely because she hath Bishops a Liturgy and Ceremonies Such might know if they rightly understood things even what they object that these things do most of all oppose Popery and help to secure us from it For 1. Episcopacy asserted in our Church is the greatest opposition to Popery that is for the very formality of Popery is the Pope's Jurisdiction over all other Bishops and Churches which Authority of the Pope is no where so much contradicted as by our Episcopacy To say nothing what our Bishops undeniably and unanswerably have performed against Popery It is very well known what rejoicing that Vote for pulling down Episcopacy brought to the Romish Party how in Rome it self they sang their Io Paeans upon the tidings thereof and said triumphantly The day is ours * Bp. San derson's Preâ—ace §. 17. 2. A Reformed Liturgy as ours is separated from all Popish Soyl and Corruption must needs be it self the greatest security from Popery since the want of it tends to bring in the worst part of Popery which is Enthusiasm and Phanatical pretences to Revelation and an Infallible Spirit as hath bin abundantly experienced 3. Our Ceremonies reformed from all Popish Reasons and Ends of their Institution are useful to defend Christianity from Superstition using People to apprehend that Christian Religion consists neither in their necessary use nor in their being necessarily refused either of which is an equal infringing of Christian Liberty Much more might be added in defence of what is appointed in our Church as the Marks and Bounds of a moderate Reformation and do afford a better Apology and Defence against the Romanists in the Judgment of the General Church than they can have who fix upon false Principles and therefore may the more easily be turned unto the opposite extreme Whereas the true Moderation of our Church gives her establishment against each opposite Errors Yea it is manifest that our Church of England thus reteining Episcopal Government and a well-reformed Liturgy and while it observes Christian Festivals and a moderate outward decency in the Church of God as did the Churches of Christ in the Primitive Times hath a fairer Plea and foundation of Argument to invite and perswade any from Romish Corruption than a Dissenter who will tell such a one That all that is Popery which account of things may presently beat him back and make him conclude that Protestants call that Popery which in the purest and most Primitive Times was practised in all Christian Churches in the World Whereas how easy a thing is it for a Popish Priest to turn himself into a Gifted Brother And what Opinion is there of the Romanists which may not come forth as a New Light So that it was no ill Character of a Schismatic He is a Papist turned wrong side outward § 12. Wherefore an easy Prudence which is a perpetual kind of Divination * 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Proverbialis senarius qui sic apud Ciceronem redditur Benè qui conjiciâ— hunc vatem perhibeto optimum may readily foresee how soon if occasion present those Parties so seemingly opposite will close even more certainly than they themselves are aware of for Men of wrong Principles know not where to find themselves after a while especially in changeable Times because they know not where their Principles will lead them In the mean while such as hold a stedfast Communion with our Church must needs be the most firm Protestants of any because they follow the Moderation of the Church it self For Truth is ever found among the modest who never affect utmost extremes which the Vulgar of which our Dissenters consist so passionately and hastily run into Wherefore among the Considerations touching the true way to suppress Popery in this Kingdom* it was well laid down The best way P. 132. for the suppressing of Popery in this Kingdom is to get our Church to be better understood And indeed if all who call themselves Protestants of what denomination soever understood their own Interest they must needs be for upholding our Church of England For if it be overthrown it must either be by Divisions and certainly the watchful Adversaries of Rome will chiefly make their Game by them whose business is to promote them If our Divisions prevail the Romanists will prevail also * Thorndike Forb of Pen. p. 37. Or 2ly by Toleration by which the same Romanists will obtain but an opportunity openly and as it were by Authority to divide and work their Wills which without a Toleration they only dare attempt secretly Or 3ly by setting one of the Dissenting Parties uppermost But they all have given such proof of their Rigour already that all other Parties will think themselves equally grieved then and the cry for Toleration will continue to be as loud and they can never expect from any Constitution more Moderation than what our present Establishment affords Therefore all that love Moderation and are afraid of Popery ought to be solicitous for the welfare of the Church of England as it is now setled And now I have said thus much and more may be said on this Head if this be not enough to convince any who are sincerely dispassionate I may appeal to all the World of the truth of what hath bin said with no design to reproach any ones Persons or incense any one's Spirit but in the real Spirit of Meekness and most affectionate regard to such who are wrought upon to be
fidem sanctis vocibus pascimus spem erigimus fiduciam figimus c. Tertull Apol. All manner of persons within this Church of England that from henceforth they celebrate and keep the Lords Day commonly called Sunday and other Holy-days according to Gods holy will and pleasure and the Orders of the Church of England prescribed in that behalf that is in hearing of the Word of God read and taught in private and publick Prayers in acknowledging their offences to God and amendment of the same in reconciling themselves charitably to their neighbours where displeasure hath been in oftentimes receiving the Holy Communion of the body and blood of Christ in visiting of the poor and sick and using all good and sober Conversation Much to the same purpose is largely insisted on in the Homily of place and time of Prayer All persons saith the late Statute q Car. 2. 29. shall on every Lords Day apply themselves to the observation of the same by exercising themselves in the duties of Piety and true Religion publickly and privately and no Tradesman shall do or exercise any worldly labour c. Works of necessity and Charity only excepted r Cunctarum artium officia venerabili die solis quiescant l. 3. Cod. Tit. de Feriis Which Statute of the Kingdom seems to have taken its Rule of Moderation from our excellent Homilies Which do reprove those who ride Journeys buy and sell and make all days alike who profane such holy times by pride and other excesses Albeit the same Homily declares the Commandment of God doth not bind Christian people so straitly to observe the utter Ceremonies of the Sabbath Day as it was given to the Jews Å¿ Audimus apud Bohemos exoriri novum Judaeorum genus Sabbatarios appellant qui tantâ superstitione servant sabbatum ut si quid eo die inciderit in câ—â—lum nolint eximere Erasm de amab Concord as touching forbearing of work and labour in time of necessity and so the Injunctions of King Edw. 6. and Queen Eliz. § 20. conclude Notwithstanding all Parsons Vicars and Curates shall teach and declare unto their Parishioners that they may with a safe and quiet Conscience after Common-Prayer in time of Harvest labour upon the Holy and Festival Days and save that thing which God hath sent So by King Edw. 6. it was ordered that the Lords of the Council should upon every Sunday attend the publick affairs of the Realm The Church also and the Laws of the Kingdom have taken the same wise care to set such Holy-Dayes in every term t Taceat apparitio advocatio delitescat nihil â—odem die sibi vendicat scena theatralis l. 3. Cod. Tit. de feriis V. Act for abrogation of Holy-dayes 1536. R. Hen 8. V. R. H. 8. Injunctions Hist of Reform Collection of Records l. 3. p. 161. Legum conditores festos instituerunt dies ut ad hilaritatem homines publicè cogerentur tanquam necessarium laboribus temperamentum Sen. de Tranquill. c. 15. that beside the ordinary Vacations there may be some days of respite from secular businesses and contests of Law for the exercises of Peace Charity and Devotion So careful have our Laws in Church and Kingdom been to avoid profaneness on one hand and on the other hand all sorts of superstition that is either Heathenish or Jewish usages as such For as the Homily of Prayer earnestly blames them who abuse holy times and places with intolerable superstitions as hath been in use in the Church of Rome so on the other hand it doth not countenance those opinions which tend to establish among us such observances as were peculiar to the Jews After the recital of the fourth Commandment in the Decalogue our Church prays That our hearts be inclin'd to keep that Law therein rightly acknowledging a moral equity that Christians should observe such a proportion of time as hath been the practice of the Church in which time all impediments to sacred and religious duties publick or private are to be avoided according to the equity of the Divine Law and the Precept of Gods Church The Moderation of our Church in its judgment of the Lords Day Bishop Bramhall hath observed from the Homily of the Church as concurrent with his own judgment u Discourse of the Sabbath or Lords Day p. 932. 1. That the Homily denieth not the Lords Day the name of Sabbath That it finds no Law of the Sabbath Gen. 23. That the Homily finds no seventh Day Sabbath before Moses his time The Homily gives no power to the fourth Commandement as it was given to the Jews to oblige Christians but only as it was and so far as it was a Law of nature The Homily makes the first day of the week to signify the Lords Day The Homily makes the end of changing the Weekly Festival of the Church to have been in honour of Christs Resurrection The Homily derives the Lords Day down from the Ascension of Christ immediately But the Homily doth express that p. 916. the fourth Commandment doth not bind Christians over-streightly Not to the external Ceremonies of the Sabbath not to the rigorous part of it to forbear all work As to the question By what authority this change was made I find no cause to doubt saith the Bishop but that it was made by the authority of Christ that is by divine authority 'T is true we find no express precept recorded in Holy Scripture for the setting a-part the first day of the Week for the service of God Neither is it necessary that there should be an express Precept for it founded in Holy Scripture to prove it to be a divine right The perpetual and universal practice of the Catholick Church including all the Apostles themselves is a sufficient proof of the divine right of it that at least it was an Apostolical Institution and Ordinance not temporary but perpetual § 12. With the Festivals it may not be improper to join the notice of the Moderation of our Church in reference to her Musick and Psalmody wherein the Constitution of our Church sheweth us the true temper of Religion which as it is the most serious so it is the most pleasant of all performances and is most suited to the nature temper and condition of man in which joy and sorrow have a very interchangeable interest therefore S. James saith Is any afflicted let him pray is any merry let him sing Psalms Jam. 3. 13. Accordingly in our Church Prayer and praise fill up the measures of Divine Worship and can there be any performance more pleasant than to join with and imitate the Heavenly Host in the high praises of God Neither doth our Church judge it enough for us to make melody in our hearts to the Lord but doth require us to serve God also with our x Omnes affectus spiritûs nostri pro sua diversitate habent proprios modos in voce cantu quorum occultâ
in Matters Ecclesiastical either claiming a power of Jurisdiction over him or pleading a privilege of Exemption from under him The Papists do it both ways in their several Doctrines of the Pope's Supremacy and of the exemption of the Clergy The Presbyterians claiming to Ibid. p. 42 43. their Consistories as full and absolute Spiritual Jurisdiction over Princes with power even to Excommunicate them if they shall see cause for it as the Papists challenge to belong to the Pope And the Independents exempting their Congregations from all Ecclesiastical subjection to them in as ample a manner as the Papists do their Clergy whereas the English Protestant Bishops and Regular Clergy as becometh good Christians and good Subjects do neither pretend to any Jurisdiction over the Kings of England nor withdraw their subjection from them but acknowledg them to have Soveraign power over Can. 1. 1640. them as well as over their other Subjects and in all matters Ecclesiastical as well as Temporal Which considerations verifie what hath been often formerly declared Namely That whereas now we are governed by Canon and Civil Laws dispensed here by 26 Ordinaries easily responsible for any deviation from the Rule of Laws conceive should we be exposed to the meer Arbitrary Government of a numerous Presbytery who together with their Ruling Elders will arise to near forty thousand Church-Governors among us they with their adherents must needs bear so great a sway that they will not easily be reducible and not consistent with Monarchy And for the Title of Divine Right those of the Episcopacy rather purposely decline the mentioning of it as a term subject to mis-construction Or else so interpret it as not of necessity to import any more than an Apostolical Institution and is pleaded by them with more calmness and moderation and with less derogation from Regal Dignity than by any other of the three § 6. As the most excellent form of Government in our Kingdom most graciously and bountifully protects the Church so the Church doth all she can to acknowledg the favour by asserting our Monarchy which is but truly performed in Canon 1. 1640. if we throughly consider the same Since then there hath been spread abroad an Insinuation that the said Canon did immoderately extol the Divine Right of Kings as if no other Form but Monarchy could in other States be lawful or of God's Ordinance because the Canon saith The most High and sacred Order of Kings is of Divine Right I may have leave to vindicate the same with all submission where it is due Where I conceive the words the most High and sacred Order of Kings may be justly and reasonably interpreted First and especially of Monarchies and also of All those Supreme Powers under what Form or Name soever they are called in such places as they are lawfully Constituted Which doubtless are as the Canon proceeds The Ordinance of God founded in the Primitive Laws of Nature which Supreme Rulers are often exprest by the general Name of Kings And because of the Pre-eminence and Excellence of Monarchy above all other Forms the Denomination of the Order of Supreme Powers may not improperly follow the more noble and excellent part Especially in a Kingdom where that is our only lawful Form it is properly and truly so affirmed that the High and sacred Order of Kings is of Divine Right as being ordained of God Himself which just interpretation of the Canon is according to our Homily * V. Homily of Obedience Take away Kings Princes Rulers and Magistrates Judges and such Estates of God's Order and no Man shall ride or go by the way unrobbed Blessed be God that we in this Realm of England feel not the horrible Calamities which they undoubtedly suffer that lack this godly Order c. Which the same Homily expresseth by the Name of Kings or other Supreme Officers that is the Higher Powers as ordained of God And that the Canon means no other by the Denominations of Kings may be fairly gathered out of the following words of the Canon wherein ¶ V. 39 Articles 37. with excellent Moderation in opposition to the Usurpations of the Church of Rome and other Sectaries what is there set down is most true of all Rightful Supreme Powers secular § 7. The Moderation of our Church doth not favour any Doctrines or Practices which are prejudicial to the safety of Humane Society in general or this or any other Rightful State or Kingdom in particular It doth no where pretend to remit the Divine Laws or dispense with Oaths or transfer the Right of Kingdoms but leaves them without any imminution or change as it finds them * Apol. Eccl. Anglic. §. 67. But ¶ Homily of wilful Rebellion 5 part p. 374. after that ambition and desire of Dominion entred once into Ecclesiastical Ministers and that the Bishop of Rome being by the Order of God's Word none other than the Bishop of that one See and Diocess and never yet well able to govern the same did by intollerable ambition challenge not only to be the Head of all the Church dispersed through the World but also to be Lord of all the Kingdoms of the World he became at once the Spoiler and Destroyer both of the Church and of the Christian Empire and all Christian Kingdoms as an Vniversal Tyrant over all In so much that * Pag. 380. There is no Country in Christendom which hath not been over-sprinkled with the blood of Subjects by rebellion against their natural Soveraigns stirred up by the same Bishops of Rome ¶ Pag. 383. Would to God we might only reade and hear out of the Histories of old and not also see and feel these new and present Oppressions of Christians rebellion of Subjects c. being procured in these our Days as in times past by the Bishop of Rome and its Ministers †Pag. 382. by the ministery of his disguised Chaplains creeping into Houses c. * Pag. 361. What a Religion is this that such Men by such means would restore may easily be judged Contrariwise our Church of England requires all of its Communion to give the King such security of their Allegiance and Fealty as may be a sufficient security to his Government Which security V. Homily of Obed. part 2. is with great Moderation exacted in our Realm Nevertheless Pope Vrban 8 in the Year 1626 by his Bull bearing date May 30. forbad all Roman Catholics to take the Oath of Allegiance And since the happy Restauration of his Majesty when several of his Subjects of the Papal profession offered by Oaths wherein the Supremacy is wholly wav'd to assure their Duty and Obedience the Pope and his Agents look'd upon this Overture as an Apostacy from him that is from the Christian Faith and persecuted all those who were concerned in the Proposal * Diff. between the Church and Court of Rome p. 30. of which see the Controversial Letters and
is a Court of Faculties constituted on purpose to grant in many Cases not repugnant to the Law of God * Camden Britan. p. 110. a Dispensation of some Canons And if the Ecclesiastical Senate among the Disciplinarians might for the greater good of the Church dispence with a Rigid Law why Altare Damasc p. 85. may not the same be done in a Christian Kingdom by such Authority as the King and the Laws have constituted And we count it a great Moderation in our Establishment that there is amongst us a right of Appeal allowed in case of unjust Censure And the Moderation of our Public Government hath been such that Permissions which have been sometime known upon occasion were never allowed to make void the Laws of the Kingdom or the Church It may be added that in the separation and division of Causes which is made between our Ecclesiastical and Civil Courts as excellent Proportions and Measures are observable so instead of all is that the Rules of Ecclesiastical Practice are with all reserve and subordination to the Laws of the Kingdom For our Church useth no other voluntary Jurisdiction than what is established or confirmed and limited by the Statute or Municipal Law For the execution of which and to correct the Excesses and Defects which shall be found among the Ministers or People and to promote Piety Righteousness and Sobriety of Life and Conversation there are among us frequent Visitations appointed and practised by the Bishops and Arch-Deacons CHAP. XIII Of the Moderation of the Church and Kingdom referring to the Administration of Public Laws towards Offenders § 1. The occasion of that Mistake which is concerning the unlawfulness of Coercion in cases which concern Religion § 2. It may be very well consistent with the Moderation of the Church besides her own Censures to approve and sometimes desire such Coercion § 3. The Vse thereof in many Cases relating to Religion the undeniable Right of the Christian Magistrate § 4. Some of the chief Objections hereunto Answered § 5. Sundry proper Instances of the great Gentleness and most indulgent Care of our Church toward all its Members § 6. The Moderation of the Church and Kingdom not without their requisite and just Bounds § 7. The Recourse which our Church desires may be made to the Secular Arm is not but upon urgent and good Occasion § 8. Our Government defended from unjust Clamours of Persecution of the Romanists on one side and the Separatists on the other § 9. The Kings of England since the Reformation and especially his present Majesty Glorious Examples of this Moderation The effect of this Moderation yet much desired and wanted § 1. AS the nature of Moderation hath been Explained Ch. 1. The most proper Instances thereof are such as shew the Gentleness and Mildness of the Church with reference to such Censures and Punishments as are used and approved by Her Which is most necessary to be observed because the most general but groundless Objection against the Moderation of our Church hath been upon this Occasion Which if we truly consider ariseth either from a mistake in Judgment that all Coercion in matter of Religion is unlawful or else from an Impression which on the Phancy and Affection of easie and soft Dispositions hath been made from the Complaints of several to whom whatever looks like Penalty is commonly irksome and very unpleasing especially if it happens that they are guilty of the same wherefore they seem in haste to fly unto Religion as their Sanctuary against Punishment as if God's Religion and His Church had different Altars among us therefore I doubt not but when the Prejudice against the former Mistake is taken off Religion and the Church will appear to have the same Interest and the Moderation of the Church may be fairly acknowledged § 2. For the distinct understanding what is right in this Case we may first Consider how far toward this Coercion the Church can move of it self 1. We cannot but acknowledg the Church as a Society established by our Lord Christ and which was necessary to the being of a Church had Rulers therein appointed with Authority and Power to effect the necessary Ends of Government Which could not be without a power of Discipline to Rebuke Article 33 and Censure and Exclude from such a Society those who will not observe its just Laws Which proceeding was suitable to the Apostolical Practice and Command with relation to Offenders and agreable to what was practised among the Jews in their Synagogues the common Reasons of which are perpetually the same Namely that such a Community and Fellowship as the Church is be maintained in Unity Peace and Purity since without these no such Society can subsist and that such Offenders may if possible be reduced and amended who are bound to submit to such Censures by virtue of their own first Consent which was the Condition of being admitted to partake of the Privileges of such a Communion But in that general Contempt which is cast on Sacred things through the grievous Corruption of the Age since many are insensible of their Duty and Relation to the Church as Members and also are apt to despise the Church and her Spiritual Discipline Therefore the Church in a Christian Kingdom being in other Circumstances than considered alone by it self receiving thereby Defence in the exercise of its Power so far that many times the Christian Magistrate is pleased to add to the Spiritual Censures of the Church if need be such outward and sensible Punishments as may touch the Bodies or Goods or Temporal Interests of such Delinquents In such a case the Church hath reason to accept of such Defence and to approve also and defend the same civil Animadversions on Offenders since they are very lawful and useful and worthy a Christian Magistrate § 3. He being appointed of God for the punishment of Evil-doers and to execute Wrath on them Since they on whom the Church rightly inflicts her Censures are Evil-doers therefore such also the more they undervalue the Censures of the Church the more justly are they the subjects of the Civil Magistrates Punishment And since Offences which affront the Majesty of Heaven are of the highest Nature the more Religious a Magistrate is the more care he will take to see such Punished And since Christian Magistrates owe that duty to God from whom alone they receive their Power and Soveraignty they are therefore especially to take care of Religion and Common Reason and Experience instructs us This cannot be done unless such Laws are guarded with Sanctions of Punishments that so They may be indeed a Terror to those who will break the Peace and Order of the Church Especially when the Peace of the Church hath so great an Influence on the Peace of the Public State or Kingdom Which when it is Christian the Religion of the Kingdom is the chief part of its Laws This is the use of no other Power than what
his History of Pretended Saints Ch. 3. which other observable Testimonies notoriously do verify Arch-Bishop Whitgift frequently traced their footsteps in the dust they themselves raised I am persuaded saith he †Def. of Answ to the Admon p 349 that Antichrist worketh effectually at this day by your Stirs and Contentions whereby he hath and will more prevail against this Church of England than by any other means whatsoever These Divisions the Character of a Carnal and Unspiritual Temper the Learned Mede ¶ V. Medes Life §. 44. p. 30. rightly judged At once weaken and dishonour the Protestant Cause and occasion the grand Enemy to triumph who seeing much of his Work done for him by those who would seem most averse from him while they bite and devour one another claps his hands saying Aha Aha our Eye hath seen it so would we have it The Lord-keeper Puckering spake of the unquiet Puritans in Queen Elizabeth's time who pretended to be at War with the Jesuits yet by their separation they did join and concur with the Jesuits in opening the door and preparing the way to the Spanish Invasion King James in his Letter to the Assembly of Perth * Dat. Aug. 25. 1617. took notice how many of the Discipline shook hands with the upholders of Popery King Charles I. of blessed memory declared truly It is possible that a Papacy in a multitude may be as dangerous as in one Bishop Sanderson in his excellent Preface to his Sermons saith It hath bin observed that where the Jesuits have bin most busy other Factions have bin most Insolent and that those who have lived in those Countries where there are the most rigid Presbyterians there are the most zealous Romanists for saith he they help together to pull down the same form of Government Our present Lord Bishop of Lincoln †Popish Principles c. p. 78. takes notice of the favour the Papists had under Oliver Cromwel and the freedom from the punishment of the Penal Laws more than ever they had before under King Charles the Martyr No Oath of Allegiance and Supremacy was pressed upon them our Liturgie and Common-Prayer were taken away so that there was no way then to discover or legally convict a Popish Recusant Notwithstanding the same Oliver in a Speech to one of his Parliaments 1654. Sept. 4. * V. Mr. Fowlis Hist of pretended Saints p. 13. profest that he could prove by witness that they had a Consistory and Council that ruled all the Affairs in England And in the Year 1647 when the King's Cause was at the lowest ebb then the Romanists by approbation of the Sorbon Doctors were ready to give such full satisfaction and assurances of their fidelity to the Civil and Political Government in the Kingdom whatsoever it shall be †P. Walsh p. 522. Which they refused to do when by the Moderation of the Government they had a Convocation permitted them for that purpose at Dublin since the re-return of his Majesty Then the Roman Leviathan had a fine time to play his Game and to sport among the People which are like many Waters Then they laid their fruitful Spawn of Divisions in the Church as well as Dissention in our Kingdom As Arch-Bishop Laud most truly on the Scaffold declared The Pope never had such an Harvest in England since the Reformation as he hath now upon the Sects and Divisions that are amongst us 3. The same experience which our Church and Nation hath had of the Conspiracy of the Sectaries and the Romanists at least in event other Churches and Nations have also observed * V. Lib. Ecclesiast p. 10 11. As in Switzerland the Anabaptists were animated by the Papists And in Bohemia some furious Divines carried on the Pope's Interest A Jesuit who suffered at Strasburg confest that he was one of the thirty Jesuits who was employed to be Agents for the Roman Cause in the late German Wars †V. Mr. Fowlis Hist of our pretended Saints p. 12. And Crucius ¶ De Doctr. Jesuit l. 4 in his Speech as we have it in Hospinian saith We are sent into Germany not only or chiefly that we might be Teachers and Preachers and Schoolmasters in the Schools and Churches but that we use all means that the Protestants do not encrease that we may join our mutual Endeavours Strength and Arms that more easily we may root them out And for our overthrow if they are our Incendiaries as it is believed we may say with reference to them what Pliny in his Natural Philosophy speaks of the nature of things considering their Principles and the Fires which break forth out of the Caverns of the Earth It is the greatest wonder of all that every day All things are not in a conflagration * Excedit profecto omnia miracula ullum diem fuisse in quo non cuncta conflagrarent Plin. Hist Nat. l. 2. c. 107. 4. That sundry of our Separation have bin thus acted hath bin often among us in fact deprehended together with the Confessions of those who have bin both Actors and acted by them Which is matter of such known discovery that it needs no repetition here Yea of this sometime they have suspected one another for one of the Independent * P. Sterry 5 Nov. 1650. Brethren said The same Spirit saith he which dwells in the Papacy when it enters into the purer form of Presbytery as fuller of Mystery so is fuller of despite and danger †Inter finitimos vetus atque antiqua simultas Juven Satyr 15. In the late Morning Exercise against Popery one saith ¶ Serm. 4. p. 103. The Papacy together with their Religion have had a Party and kept up an Interest among the Protestant Churches But because the Dissenters love to have it thought that those of our Church are more guilty herein as there seems to be insinuated Therefore § 11. Unto all this if any object and tell us of the Advice of Cardinal Allen to the Persons who undertook to reduce Ireland again to Popery Among other things they should apply themselves to the Conformists and possess them with the Factiousness Disobedience and Disorders of the Nonconformists that so they might be provoked to spend their fury on each other to their mutual ruin We answer We hope that the Church of England and her right conformable Clergy have bin so setled by the establishment of our Church as not to have had their Principles corrupted by Popish Influence As appears 1. from the constant and stout opposition which Popery hath had from the Fathers and Sons of our Church And 2. in that the many surmises of the contrary have proved upon the test very notoriously foolish and false Let any of them prove our Principles and Practices such as we are able to do theirs to serve the real Interest of Rome 3. Let them know that those who have bin most violently slandred as favourers of Popery
Her sound and charitable judgment of such as die after Baptism § 3. In some necessary cautions referring to the administration of Baptism § 4. Referring also to the susceptors § 5. In what is required of them who administer that Sacrament In reference to the Holy Supper of our Lord § 1. The same is with us celebrated in both kinds § 2. The Doctrine of Transubstantiation is rejected by our Church not running to the other extreme of denying a real presence of Christ in the Sacrament § 3. The Moderation of our Church in complying with the necessity of the Age but not with the Church of Rome and others who require their people to communicate not so much as thrice a year § 4. Participation of the Holy Supper required after Confirmation but not after the rigid Examinations of some or the auricular Confessions of others Neither is it made a private banquet § 5. In our Church there is not to be a Communication of the Eucharist without Communicants The Moderation of the Church in other Rubricks referring to the Holy Communion p. 272 Chap. XI Of the Moderation of the Church in reference to other Rights and Usages § 1. The Moderation of the Church in its Judgment and use of Confirmation § 2. Concerning Matrimony allowing her Clergy to marry affording opportunity of voluntary celibacy in our Vniversities according to a commendable moderation Vndue degrees of Marriages and some particular Times forbid c. § 3. In reference to Holy Orders 1. The Moderation of the Church in her Consecrating Ministers 2. In taking care to have them be as they ought to be both before and after Ordination with good effect 3. Yet if not so great as is desired why the Church ought not to be accused 4. In retaining such Orders of Ministers in the Church as are Primitive 5. The Moderate Judgment of the Church concerning such as have been ordain'd in the Church of Rome and elsewhere 6. Our Church endeavours to preserve all due regard to what-ever is consecrated to God 7. The Power of the Keys asserted in our Church with due moderation § 4. Of Penance 1. The Moderation of our Church between those who sleight Penance and those who explain it extravagantly 2. The Confession of our Church which is required is suitable to the design of Repentance 3. The Seal of Confession in our Church is as sacred as it ought to be 4. The use of External Penance in our Church according to due Moderation 5. The use of Absolution in our Church maintained according to a just temper § 5. For Visitation of the Sick 1. The worthy care of the Church therein and some Instances of its Moderation referring thereunto 2. Our Churches care for preparing those who are of her Communion for Death without extreme Vnction in use in the Church of Rome 3. Many Instances of the Moderation of the Church referring to the Burial of the Dead p. 289 Chap. XII Of the Moderation of our Church in what concerns the Power of the Church § 1. The Moderation of our Church owns the Power of the Church to be only Spiritual § 2. All other Power which Ecclesiastical Persons receive is readily acknowledged entirely depending on the favour of our Kings § 3. The Interests of the Kingdom and the Church are excellently accommodated in our Constitutions which is not done in other Models § 4. The pious Moderation of our Kings preserving their own rightful Supremacy and leaving to the Church the exercise of their Spiritual Power acknowledged by our Church § 5. The just Right of Kings shamefully invaded by other Sects pretending Divine Right Concerning which Claim the Moderation of our Church observed § 6. The dutiful Moderation of our Church in asserting Monarchy The first Canon 1640. justified § 7. All Interests of Humane Society especially of Subjects Allegiance in our Church abundantly secured which is not done by those in separation from her § 8. The Ordinances of our Church are framed with great Mildness and Moderation § 9. The same compared with the mild Obligation which Cardinal Bellarmine pretends the Church of Rome lays upon those of her Communion § 10. Sundry Instances of our Church's great regard to Equity p. 331 Chap. XIII Of the Moderation of the Church and Kingdom referring to the Administration of Publick Laws towards Offenders § 1. The occasion of that Mistake which is concerning the unlawfulness of Coercion in cases which concern Religion § 2. It may be very well consistent with the Moderation of the Church besides her own Censures to approve and sometimes desire such Coercion § 3. The Vse thereof in many Cases relating to Religion the undeniable Right of the Christian Magistrate § 4. Some of the chief Objections hereunto Answered § 5. Sundry proper Instances of the great Gentleness and most indulgent Care of our Church toward all its Members § 6. The Moderation of the Church and Kingdom not without their requisite and just Bounds § 7. The Recourse which our Church desires may be made to the Secular Arm is not but upon urgent and good Occasion § 8. Our Government defended from unjust Clamours of Persecution of the Romanists on one side and the Separatists on the other § 9. The Kings of England since the Reformation and especially his present Majesty Glorious Examples of this Moderation The effect of this Moderation yet much desired and wanted p. 353 Chap. XIV Of the general Moderation of our Church toward all that differ from her and are in error § 1. Our Church takes universal care to satisfy and reconcile those who differ from her Particularly our Domestick Dissenters to whom sundry Concessions have been made § 2. Our Church is not forward to denounce Curses against those who are not of the same Judgment with her § 3. Our Church doth not judge all according to the Consequences of their Doctrines § 4. In refusing an adverse Party Our Church gives an excellent Example not to use odious Names § 5. Our Church useth great care to preserve and restore peace § 6. The Moderation of the Church gives it a singular advantage to convince Dissenters upon right and proper Principles § 7. The Moderation of our Church doth incomparably qualify Her to arbitrate and reconcile the present differences of the Christian Churches § 8. A Supposition laid down of the most possible means of Reconciling a Protestant and such a Romanist as lays aside Infallibility and that the Church of England hath done her part in what was fit toward any just Reconciliation § 9. An Answer to that common Calumny of the Separatists that our Governours in the Church of England have more peace and reconciliation for Papists than for the most moderate Protestant Dissenters p. 385 Chap. XV. Of the Moderation of the Church toward other Churches and Professions of Men. § 1. In that Vniversal Concord which our Church hath maintained with all so far as lawfully and usefully it may § 2. Her protesting
against unsufferable Abuses well consisting with her Moderation and Charity § 3. Our Church leaveth other Churches to the use of their liberty and vindicateth that use mutually § 4. Her especial Moderation and Charity toward the Greek Church § 5. Our Church's Modesty and well-becoming Behaviour toward other Churches and their mutual affection unto Ours p. 411 Chap. XVI Of the Moderation of the Church of England in her Reformation § 1. The Reformation of our Church as it had just grounds and was by just Authority so it was managed with due Moderation the Idea of our Reformation having been impartial § 2. The whole manner of it so far as concerned our Church was with great temper § 3. She separated from the Romish Errors not from their Persons any more than needs must § 4. Our Charity exceeds that of the Church of Rome which denies Salvation to all who are not of her Communion § 5. The Preparation of our Church to submit to the Church Vniversal saves us from Schism § 6. The Reformation of our Church was the more Christian because not fierce but well governed § 7. Albeit the Moderation of our Church seems to have enraged her Adversaries yet because of this Moderation our Church is the better prepared to survive Persecution § 8. The Moderation of our Church in her Reformation was founded on Rules of absolute Justice as in sundry great Instances is made to appear p. 423 Chap. XVII Of the Moderation of our Church in avoiding all undue Compliances with Popery and other sorts of Fanaticism among us § 1. Notwithstanding our Reformation is the most of any opposite to Popery how it hath been the craft of the Roman Agents to raise of it such a suspicion of Popery as hath been artificially made a very unhappy Instrument of the Divisions which are from our Church § 2. How the great Labours of our Bishops and our Clergy remaining the most impregnable defence of the Reformation hath stir'd up the more earnest opposition of the Church of Rome to our Church § 3. The vain and ungrateful jealousies of our Separatists and Enthusiasts are the more unjust because they have appeared really acted by that Interest not in intention but in event § 4. Therefore it is a most seasonable work at this time to cast open those Mâ—squcrades § 5. Some Moderate Cautions here inserted to prevent any unkind Mistakes § 6. Some Objections to such an undertaking here answered § 7. That our Separatists and Enthusiasts generally more or less do conspire in fact albeit not in intent with the Romanists instanced as a Specimen in twenty Particulars § 8. Particularly how the Quakers are one with the Papists how ignorantly soever in sundry Instances § 9. By what steps and degrees these Progresses commonly are made toward Popery by such as separâ—te from Communion with our Church § 10. What hath been said confirmed by other rational Proofs § 11. Some further Reasons why the Clergy and faithful Sons of our Church cannot be thought thus concerned in so much as an Eventual Conspiracy § 12. An easy Divination of the Consequences of these things if a due sense of these Matters be rejected when so fairly and often recommended to the common notice of all with a sincere and affectionate close to such as this Address most doth concern p. 455 Chap. XVIII Of the Moderation of our Church as it may influence Christian Practice and especially our Union § 1. Some proper Inferences from what hath been insisted on at large § 2. Sundry general Rules agreeable to Reason and Christianity by which the Moderation of private Persons may be measured and directed particularly of our Dissenting Brethren § 3. Some proper means to reduce Dissenters into Vnion with the Church with all Moderation proposed § 4. The hearty Profession of the moderate and sincere purposes of the Writer § 5. One or two Caveats entred to prevent mistake and for the Caution of such as will attempt to disprove the main Proposition here designed to be evinced § 6. Some good Wishes to the Adversaries of our Church on both sides such as a fit to conclude a Treatise of the Moderation of our Church p. 507 ERRATA Vitiis nemo sine nascitur optimus ille Qui minimis urgetur Horat. PAge 5. marg r. importabile p. 55. l. 10. for r. p. 128. marg r. Fur p. 294. marg r. quam p. 306. r. carybdin p. 311. r. sacerdotali p. 315. r. apud p. 324. marg r. exprimo p. 325. marg r. Milev and exeq p. 328. l. 22. dele those l. 24. dele were p. 346. l. 8. r. Counsels p. 378. l. 27. r. oppress p. 385. l. 20. r. refuting p. 387. l. 26. r. rightly p. 485. l. 8. r. austerity p. 495. l. 1. r. Pucklington p. 533. l. 16. r. laught THE MODERATION OF THE Church of England CHAP. I Of Moderation in general § 1. The loud demands of late among us for Moderation taken notice of § 2. The specious pretences of several Factions thereunto exposed § 3. The general meaning of Moderation noted § 4. The use of the Greek word for Moderation 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as it is borrowed from the Law explained § 5. The forensic notion of Moderation applied to Moderation in Religion § 6. What is justly expected of those who causlesly blame our Church with want of Moderation § 7. Moderation considered not only as a vertue of publick but of private persons both toward their Governours first and also toward one another § 8. Some general rules or measures according to natural Justice and Christianity whereby we may judge of the Moderation of the Church with the design of this Treatise declared § 1. WE have of late with both Ears heard the loud demands made for Moderation among us even since the Restitution of our Church to its own admirable and equal temper even since the unspeakable Clemency of our most Gracious King and the extraordinary indulgence of the Laws have really anticipated so much Moderation as reasonably might have dampt some of those vehement out-cries which seem still to offer violence to our senses as well as to the peace of the Kingdom and the Church But that the sound might come more awful to religious Ears on both sides the cry hath been set up in the words of Holy Scripture Let your Moderation be known unto all the Lord is at hand Phil. 4. 5. Moderation therefore being the word in fashion by which all divided parties among us use to sanctify their appeals and make their pretences seem virtuous It is first to be wisht that real Truth and Goodness which are the genuine effects of true Moderation were as common as the noise of either § 2. All agree that Moderation is an excellent vertue as they said of Hercules Who ever dispraised him hence the several Factions make such specious pretences thereunto The sanctimonious Pharisees affected the appearance of mighty moderate Men they could in the very
Gospel Ch. 1. v. 7. But unto them of Philippi also was this grace given in the behalf of Christ not only to believe in him but also to suffer for his sake v. 29. § 3. Thus it is evident that this Exhortation of S. Paul here to Moderation is indeed directed by him absolutely to the patient and suffering sort of Christians Which let those take notice of especially who affect so much to be counted the suffering party which if they are who call themselves so then the Apostle speaks more to them than any Let your Moderation be known unto all d Of this perhaps they may be better satisfied from Mr. Pools Synopsis Criticorum De afflictionibus hîc agitur Zanch. Ver. Er. Bez. c. But it is the cause only makes the Martyr Some may suffer indeed justly as a due reward of their deeds through their own ill will Others according to the will of God 1 S. Pet. 4. 16 19. when they have done nothing amiss S. Luke 23. 41. and this I take to be the real Case of the Church of England Wherefore we seriously wish they would present themselves real examples of the thing it self who make so much noise of the word We may heartily wish they who seem so earnest for Moderation would consider whether it seems not agreeable to that equal temper of mind recommended in the Text for all to be disposed to interpret every thing to the best and to go as far as they can for peace and unity in the Church and compliance with what is enjoin'd I wish such would please to consider and read the words in their true sense with any of those Versions which are given of them Let your equity e Bez. Castell Your gentleness f Trem. Dr. Ham. Your patient mind g Our old English Tr. Erasm Par. Your taking all in good part h Bez Com. Your reasonable Conversation i S. Ambr. Your modesty k Vulg. Lat. S. Hier. Your giving way one to another l Erasmus Your Moderation be known unto all § 4. That we may the more clearly understand the Moderation of our Church we will further inquire into their false notions of Moderation who so vehemently seem to require it in our Church which requiries are made either to private persons or to those in authority 1. When private persons are called upon to let their Moderation be known unto all men They as far as they know their own minds themselves and are not averse to declare it in their writings and other expressions of their meaning undeniable by Moderation would have 1. Either an Indifferency whether they do or do not what is required or 2. They mean an Omission of what is appointed or 3. They understand by it the doing quite contrary When appeal for Moderation is made to Governours by Moderation they would understand either 1. A forbearance of the execution of Laws especially which relate to matters Ecclesiastical or 2. An abolition of them or 3. An utter alteration of Government So that all the burden for Moderation relates to the remission of the obligation and observance of the Laws especially of the Church and their whole sense of Moderation doth contain many odd suppositions particularly that the conditions of our Communion are very unlawful very immoderate and inexpedient Wherefore if in the following discourse we make it appear that the entire constitution of our Church doth exhibite as great Moderation and as equal temper as any Church in the Christian World doth or ever did since the Primitive Times we shall justify our Constitutions from those exceptions mentioned and a thousand times as many more as they can raise For supposing at present which afterward I shall plainly demonstrate that the conditions of our Communion are not unlawful and that the appointments of the Church as they are and what relates thereunto are very moderate then it will plainly and necessarily follow 1. That an indifference in doing or not doing what is required or an omission of what is matter of duty or doing quite contrary must needs be so far from Moderation that it will appear to be a great affront to the authority of a well-setled Kingdom and Church and the more moderate this is the higher will be the aggravation of their crime 2. As to the forbearance of the execution of such Laws I shall only say thus much That if for political considerations Superiours should give way at any time to such a forbearance it may not be unseasonable to consider as among the Jews there were some things permitted or tolerated not for their own goodness but because of the hardness of the hearts of the people So when Constitutions equal in themselves are remitted in consideration only of the weakness of the people the people ought to be instructed of the reason they have to be humbled for their own imperfection that they may not glory in their shame lest they go on to take heart against the Laws and accustom themselves to frowardness 3. As to change or abolition of Laws I only here touch upon what hereafter will be more amply shew'd That the Moderation of our Church is such that she always hath publickly profest That the Rites of the Church and particular forms of worship are in their own nature indifferent and mutable And it is notorious matter of fact among us that the Church hath often made those alterations which occasion hath required and for the same reasons can do the like again 4. As to an utter alteration of the Government which some there are would look at as a prime point of Moderation I should be very injurious to truth if I should not observe That some who begin with but desires of Moderation never leave till they end in the utter subversion and extirpation of what they declare themselves averse from which renders this undertaking more necessary Thus King Charles I. m 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Med. 11. took notice of some Reformers who by vulgar clamours and assistance did demand not only Toleration of themselves in their vanity novelty and confusion but also abolition of Laws against them and a total extirpation of that Government whose Rights they have a mind to invade Lastly To take their words in the most mild sense not for an absolute change of the entire Government but for such an alteration of the Laws as seems to be meant by the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Moderation as it is sometimes taken for a correction of the Laws by Equity Most known unto all it may be that the Church of England never refuseth this But in cases of such mitigations and remissions as are called for we must consider there is generally supposed either an unjust sentence or some rigour of the Law or some great inconvenience attending All which the wisdom of Government will not hastily and at every motion determine especially when such alterations are challenged as matter of
duty and when they cannot be done without a publick acknowledgment of some great errour or sin before admitted n See the Proclamation of K. Edw. 6. for the authorizing an Uniformity of Common-Prayer Wherefore such Concessions are not properly admitted without great reasons moving thereunto because of the publick honour of Laws in them concerned Lest also the frequent change of publick Laws encourage the mutable vulgar in their common unreasonable levity and desire of Innovation Lest well-setled Order and the common Peace be disturbed and lest good men be discouraged in their regular obedience therefore Christian 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Moderation doth not in such like Cases encourage alterations especially when there is no end of gratifying such sick phancies and where it is not agreed between the parties complaining what they would have relieved This would be to expose the dignity of the Church and of Constitutions setled by such long prescription to the scorn of every bold dissenter which can have no other effect but to encourage them in their Schism and heap contempt upon our selves when we prostitute Law and authority to such affronts Vnless our dissenters had the humility and the honesty to confess they had been mistaken and were now resolved to go as far towards the repairing of breaches as their Consciences could allow and did propose a clear Scheme of what they would submit to and on what terms they would again enter into the Communion of the Church then I am confident such candid dealing would find an entertainment beyond what they can justly hope for o Modest Survey of Naked Truth CHAP. III. Of Moderation with respect to the Church of England § 1. What is to be understood by the Church of England § 2. The Moderation of our Church frequently confessed by her Adversaries sometime truly sometime upon design but most often our Church is reproached and opposed for her Moderation by each sort of Adversaries § 3. From the joint opposition made against our Church by her Adversaries on either hand is taken the chief inartificial proof of her Moderation § 1. TReating of the Moderation of the Church of England some will not be ashamed to ask what is meant by the Church of England a V. Reasons for the necess of Reform p. 3. 'T is pretty odd that in a setled Church as ours is such a question should be so confidently made as it is by some who while they ask it may be members of it if they please But because this Treatise is so immediately concerned in this question I shall make the answer more clear from all exceptions if I come thereunto by some steps The Church in general is a select Society that is of such as are called out of the World to the worship of God b 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 coetus evocatorum 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Clem. Alex Strom. l. 7. This Society is either that invisible Company of all the faithful throughout the World who are inwardly and really holy known unto God Or is the Society of those who confess Christ before men and by this visible profession of the true Faith have right to the Sacraments and other priviledges of their spiritual Community especially those which are a necessary and publick sign before God and Man that such do confess Christ Jesus For God who is the alone searcher of hearts hath left only this presumption for the rule of mortal men that the visible profession of the Faith should give right to the outward priviledges of the Church without granting which even the true members of the invisible Church could never communicate in any outward Society which all that call themselves Christians are oblig'd to do and therefore the nineteenth Article of our Religion begins thus The visible Church is a Congregation of faithful people c. In every moderate Constitution as I show ours is the Rule obtains Every one is presumed to be good till the contrary appears in a lawful manner Wherefore that visible Company of faithful people who here under the Dominion of our Sovereign Lord the King call themselves Christians and profess the Faith of Christ which he defends They are the Church of England c Hooker 's Eccl. Pol. l. 3. §. 1. For as the main body of the Sea being one yet within divers Precincts hath divers names so the Catholick Church is in like sort divided into a number of distinct Societies every one of which is termed a Church within it self so the name of Church is given betokening severally as the Church of Corinth Ephesus England and the like d Multas quidem Ecclesias tamen unam modò unaquaeque intra seipsam cum universali adeoque cum omnibus ejus partibus servat Catholicam unitatem Forbesi Iren. l. 2. c. 20. But to come to the head of the exception which commonly is this If the Church be a Congregation of faithful people as the Article defines the visible Church How comes the determination of the Convocation the Orders of the Bishops to be lookt upon as the appointments of the Church which are also governed by the will of the King What of all this is the Church of England In answer hereunto let such take notice that the people among us do bear as great a part as they ought in what is constituted in our Church whether they will own it or no For where the consent of the people is not actually required it is either included in the Laws of the Land by which they are governed or in the will of the King to whom beside his own power over the Church in his own Kingdoms which is very great in many Cases they have made over their right e Refertur ad universos quod publicè fit per majorem partem ff de reg ju ad sect refertur whatever it is themselves and frequently by their Ecclesiastical Governours they also consent to what is constituted in the Church For we must remember what our Article expresseth That the Church is a Congregation of faithful people as it there follows according to Gods Ordinance We must also remember that the Church in its beginning did not form it self neither did it ordain or appoint its own Rulers For Christ gave some Apostles Pastors Teachers Eph. 4. 11. 1 Cor. 12. 28. Yea they had their power given them somewhat before the Church was formed Mat. 28. 18 19. to shew that they were not to depend upon the people for their power Whatever voluntary condescensions were made by the heads of Ecclesiastical Communion in the tender beginnings of the Church to oblige them more firmly in their Christian Fellowships yet all rights of Administration of the spiritual power of the Church did always properly belong to the Rulers of the Church within their own limits So S. Ignatius Cyprian f Cum Ecclesia quae Catholica una est connexa cobaerentium sibi invicem sacerdotum glutine
Religion than the Holy and Divine inspired Scriptures with Melancthon and the Church of England I wish all Doctrines of Faith were brought to us derived from the Fountain of Scripture by the Channels of Antiquity otherwise what end will there be of innovation And thus our King James of Happy Memory did declare in the words of St Austin That what could be proved the Church held and observed from its first beginning to those Times That to reject He did not doubt to pronounce to be an insolent piece of madness So that the counsel and judgment of the Church of England seems to be moderated according to the Sentence of St Hierom in his Epistle to Minerva My purpose is to read the Ancients to prove all to hold fast what is good and never to depart from the Faith of the Catholick Church and conformably King Charles I. h His Majesties fifth Paper to Mr. Henders My Conclusion is That albeit I never esteemed any Authority equal to the Scriptures yet I do think the unanimous consent of the Fathers and the universal practice of the Primitive Church to be the best and most authentical Interpreters of Gods word For who can be presumed to understand the Doctrine and practice of the Christian Religion better than those who lived in the first and purest times Wherefore i Of Heresy §. 14. Dr Hammond reckons it among the piè Credibilia that a truly general Council cannot erre § 3. And because the Catholick Church is and hath been so much divided and the Monuments of the ancient Church Universally accepted do contain but a few determinations Therefore the Church of England moderately remits her Sons to the first four general Councils as in the 28th year of K. Henry 8. k Fullers Eccl. Hist ad An. 1536. it was Decreed That all ought and must utterly refuse and condemn all those opinions contrary to the said Articles contained in the three Creeds contained in the four Holy Councils that is to say in the Council of Nice Constantinople Ephesus and Chalcedon and all other since that time in any point consonant to the same So in the Institution of a Christian Man set forth 1537. and approved by the Convocation 1543. 't is there said A true Christian man ought and must condemn all those opinions contrary to the twelve Articles of the Creed which were of a long time past condemned in the four Holy Councils that is to say c. Isaac Casaubon also in the name of King James to Cardinal Perron saith l Primo R. Eliz. c. 1 The King and the Church of England do admit the four first Oecumenical Councils and following the judgment of the Church the Law of the Kingdom doth declare m Dicimus Ecclesiam Britannicam adeò venerari Concilia generalia ut speciali statuto caverit nè quisquam spirituali jurisdictione praeditus praesumat censuras suas Ecclesiasticas aliter distringere vel administrare aut quicquam Haereticum pronunciare quod non à scripturis Canonicis quatuor Conciliis generalibus aut alio quocunque Concilio pro tali judicatum fuerit J. B. de antiq libertate Eccl. Brit. Thes 4. That none however Commission'd shall in any wise have authority or power to order or determine or adjudge any matter or cause to be Heresy but only such as heretofore have been determin'd ordered or adjudged to be Heresy by the authority of the Canonical Scriptures or by the first four general Councils or any of them or by any other general Council wherein the same was declared Heresy by the express and plain words of the said Canonical Scriptures or such as hereafter shall be ordered judged or determined to be Heresy by the Court of Parliament of this Realm with the Clergy in their Convocation Thus the authority of the four first general Councils are placed by our Church in the superiour order of Tradition forasmuch as Spalatensis according to St Austin n A plenariis Conciliis tradita Quarum est in Ecclesiâ salubrâ—â—ima authoritas S. Aug. Ep. 118. speaks of such Councils they have obtained a wholsom authority because from the Apostolick Declarations faithfully received they have explained the Holy Scriptures and beside because they have been approved by the Universal Church which with great reason contradicts what Curcellaeus p Curcell Rel. Christianae Instit l. 1. c. 15. hath delivered to depreciate the honour even of the first four Oecumenical Councils So that Mr Cressy in Answer to Dr Pierce might very well cite the Protestant acknowledgments of the Authority of Councils as that of Ridley Acts and Mon. p. 1288. Councils indeed represent the Vniversal Church and being so gathered together in the name of Christ they have the promise of the gift and guiding of the Spirit into all truth To the same purpose are named Bishop Bilson Hooker Potter c. Instead of all these he might have owned if he had pleased the judgment of our Church it self giving all due honour to general and Provincial Councils whose wholsome Decrees she hath accepted and imitated Yea our Church maintains the right of Provincial Synods taken away by the See of Rome q Tertullianus veneratur Provinciale Concilium quasi esset Oecumenicam assentiente sc universali vel iis decernentibus secundùm universale quomodo fit repraesentatio totius nominis Christiani virtualiter tota Ecclesia Neither is this honour diminisht by the further Moderation which our Church hath shown in not taking those for Councils or general Councils which are not such as neither the Council of Florence nor Lateran nor of Trent and we know that our Articles though they are very moderately framed are many of them directly oppos'd to those of Trent being in those points of Doctrine wherein the Church of Rome hath departed from the Catholick Church and made her Doctrines of design more than truth the unjust conditions of Communion A truly free and general Council we look upon as the best expedient on Earth for composing the differences of the Christian World if it might be had but we cannot endure to be abused by meer names of Titular Patriarchs but real Servants and Pensioners of the Popes with Combinations of interested parties instead of general Councils r Dr. Stillingfleet's first Part of an Answer c. 284. When Pope Paul III. call'd a Council then to be held at Mantua and King Henry VIII refusing thither to send He defended his Protestation in a Letter to the Emperour and other Christian Princes 1538. In which the King declares t Acts and Monuments p. 11â—2 Truly as our Forefathers invented nothing more holy than general Councils used as they ought to be so there is almost nothing that may do more hurt to the Christian Faith and Religion than general Councils if they be abused to lucre to gains to the establishment of errors And verily we suppose that it ought not to be called a General
of the Church the Ministration of Sacraments and other Rites and Ceremonies but also the Doctrine and Religion set out by King Edw. VI. to be more pure and according to Gods word than any other used in England these thousand Years c. § 4. In all the Churches of this Kingdom Cathedral and Parochial the Church now hath moderately appointed the same Rules and Cautions and the same use among us every where and those few in number plain and easy to be understood f The Preface to the Common-Prayer Book Whereas the Rubricks and Orders of the Church of Rome are so innumerable intricate and various that scarce an Apprentiship may suffice to learn the practice of them which whether it suit with the simplicity of the Christian Gospel may without difficulty be judged Among us an easy Calendar is prefixt with few Canons and Prescriptions and those very intelligible wherein according to an excellent Moderation the People have their parts for excitation sake and to unite their affections although no where in what is properly ministerial § 5. The Moderation of our Church is sufficiently known to the whole World in requiring our Common Prayers to be in the vulgar tongue for the general benefit of all According to our 24. Article It is a thing plainly repugnant to the word of God and the Custom of the Primitive Church to have publick Prayer in the Church or to administer the Sacraments in a tongue not understood of the people Which Article is further confirmed and proved in the Homilies especially in that of Common-Prayer and Sacraments from the nature and end of Prayer Resolving also As for the time since Christ till that usurped power of Rome begun to spread it self and to enforce all the Nations of Europe to have the Romish Language in admiration it appeareth by the consent of the most ancient and learned Writers there was no strange tongue used in the Congregation of Christians Yet for the same reason that common people should have their Prayers in English among us those who have been educated in sufficient learning are allowed to use them in another tongue as in Vniversities and Colleges The use of the Latin Form of Prayers is also commended to the Ministers of the Church of England by Queen Elizabeth's Letters Dated April 6. 1560 g Bishop Sparrow's Collection and also the first Rubrick before the Preface of Ceremonies In all which the Moderation of our Church doth comply as the Queens Letters doth express it with the necessity of those who do not understand other tongues and the desire of those who de § 6. Notwithstanding the Church hath provided most excellent Prayers for the use of private devotion upon all general occasions and what is readily and properly applicable to more occasions particular yet the Moderation of the Church hath not thought fit any where to bind all who are of her Communion to the use of her Common Prayers in private Families or Closets The Rubrick which enjoins All Priests and Deacons to say daily the Morning and Evening Prayer either privately or openly is set down with great Moderation Not being let by sickness or some other urgent cause In the Family or in Visitation of the sick if the particular condition of the one or the other do require it and in private and in the Closet It is not supposed by our Church but that every one may ask their own wants in what form of words he shall think fit h Dr Hammonds Pract. Cat. of Prayer The Consideration of which Liberty indulged by the Church caused I suppose another excellent Writer i Dr Patricks Devout Christian Preface thus also to express himself It is possible also that some may judge this whole work to be but a needless labour since they have the Book of Common Prayers at hand which they can use at home as well as at the Church With these persons I shall not contend but only deliver my opinion freely about this matter which is that the reverence due to that Book will be best preserved by employing it only in the publick Divine Service or in the private where there is a Priest to officiate However the design of it is not to furnish the people with Prayers for all those particular occasions wherein devout Souls would make their requests known to God and the constant opinions of pious Divines in this and other Churches we see by their Writings hath been that other Books of Prayers are necessary for the flock of Christ beside their publick Liturgy Though in the choice of such Prayers as are so accommodate to the occasions of humane Life and such Cases as are incidental to the spiritual needs and circumstances of Christian people there hath been sometimes wished some further advice and recommendation made common by Authority The 55. Canon thus directs That before all Sermons Lectures and Homilies Preachers and Ministers shall move the people to join with them in this Form or to this effect as briefly as conveniently they may in hunc aut similem modum The Title in the Latine Canons is Precationis formula à concionatoribus in Concionum suarum ingressu imitanda In the English Canons the Title is A Form of Prayer to be used by Preachers before their Sermon From all which I only note That the Moderation of the Church is certain and undoubted But the disagreeing variety in practice consequent thereon whether it be so convenient it remains for Superiours to judge § 7. Although some of the ancient Christians used the distinction of Hours of Prayer which at first was thought orderly and useful as a voluntary task and determining of the Christian Liberty of those who profess Gods Service is perfect freedom Yet our Church considering the common employment of most and the natural infirmities of all hath appointed and required only a daily Sacrifice of Morning and Evening Service as of constant observance not excluding but inviting other voluntary oblations of a sincere Devotion to God according to our leisure and opportunity But our Church doth no where countenance the novelties of those that put any trust in the bare recital only of a few Prayers k Dr Cosins of the antient times of Prayer or place any vertue in the Bedroll or certain number of them at such and such hours notwithstanding many of the said Prayers are also directed otherwise than Prayers should be § 8. Although according to the judgment of the Church and in truth the entire worship of God is complete in the Divine Service of the Church even as among the Jews Sacrifices Prayers and Thanksgivings made up the entire notion of Divine Worship so under the Gospel the Sacrifices of Prayer and Thanksgiving do absolutely compleat the worship of God yet our Church judgeth according to an excellent temper of the use and necessity of Sermons acknowledging their great use as occasion requires to convince reprove to excite and comfort
Christian people Let Archbishop Laud be heard for once by those who have doubted his judgment in this matter l Archbishop Laud §. 16. Num. 31. I ever took Sermons and do still to be the most necessary Expositions and applications of Holy Scripture and a great ordinary means of Salvation To the same purpose Hooker's Eccles Pol. l. 2. § 22. Neither hath the Church of God ever had any where more useful practical and judicious Preachers than those who with the Church of England have thus ingenuously and equally judged of the use and necessity of Preaching on one hand esteeming its real use and benefit on the other hand not judging it the chief exercise of Religion and the worship of God nor allowing that for the hearing of a Sermon which spends its Life in its Birth as Mr Hooker saith the Prayers of the Church should be slighted neglected or mangled m In concione solâ totum fermè Divini cultûs ritum collocant non tales erant antiquae piae Synaxes Ar. Spalat l. 7. c. 12. At the Conference at Hampton-Court the Bishop of London humbly desired his Majesty That there might be a praying Ministry among us it being now come to pass that men think it the only duty of Ministers to spend their time in the Pulpit I confess saith he in a Church newly to be planted Preaching is most necessary not so in one long established that Prayer should be neglected I like saith King James your motion exceeding well and dislike the Hypocrisy of our time who place all Religion in the Ear. At the very dawning also of the Reformation Preaching was also especially useful and few were exercis'd therein and had a right skill therein which made the Institution of a Christian man set out 1537. because of the difficulty thereof say Surely the office of Preaching is the chief and most principal office whereunto Priests or Bishops be called by the authority of the Gospel though by Preaching there might be meant the Annunciation of the Gospel which is done by lively reading of the Scriptures and in sundry other Ministerial Offices Wherefore in the Church of England we have the lively Oracles of the Holy Scriptures declared and read among us n Coimus ad divinam Literarum commemorationem Tert. Apol. We have Catechising and Expositions on the Church Catechism We have also excellent Homilies too much despised for their plainness yet the same which Bucer o Quid illi qui non sustineant audire erectis animis cupidis tam breves easque tam salutares Homilias totas Censura M. Buceri magnify'd as short and wholsome Sermons not only for the help of non-Preaching Ministers but withal a pattern and as it were a boundary for the Preaching Ministers as King James hath it in his Directions 1623. of which how modestly and moderately doth the Church her self speak in its 35. Article That they contain a Godly and wholsome Doctrine necessary for these times We have also the Lives and Counsels of the Church's Ministers which are living Sermons too p Vereor nè pancae extant inregno vivae conciones Calv. Ep. 87. So that among us we have all sorts of Preaching if the commonness of it did not make it despised Great care also is taken for other Sermons too q Canon 45 46. Rubrick after the Nicene Creed Yea our Church hath used all possible means that the Preaching of her Ministers may be useful and as they ought to be as appears from the exhortations which are made at the Ordinations of Bishops Priests and Deacons and the subscriptions which are made before the Bishops which are also incomparably enforced by r V. librum quorundam Canonum 1597. Can. 50. C. 54. Q. Elizabeth's Articles for doctrine and Preaching 1554. their Majesties directions from time to time as hath been instanced Ch. 6. § 5. Notwithstanding many are of the mind with those in Scotland who esteemed the Directions of King James to Preachers to be Limiting of the Spirit of God ſ Spotswood History of Scotland ad an 1622. What would they have thought of the Proclamation of King Edw. VI. which inhibited all Preaching throughout the Kingdom that the Clergy might apply themselves unto Prayer The Copy of which Inhibition is in Fuller's Church History t Fuller 's History Ec. ad an 1548. 2 Ed. 6. In the Preface to the Directory we see the Prelates accused for the crime of making Preaching inferiour to the Common-Prayer which charge contains a fallacy like that of a complex Interrogation For our Liturgy doth not exclude but suppose and require Preaching and doth contain in its daily Offices sundry sorts of real Preaching beside Among professed Christians ought Preaching to contend with Prayer either as to the necessity of it or dignity when Prayer is our duty to God immediately and doth suppose people already instructed In the Notes on the view of the Civil and Ecclesiastical Law u P. 3. Ch. 4. §. 3. it is very well concluded All this while we should not detract any thing from Preaching considering our selves to live under a State so maturely composed and so throughly advised and setled in the Faith it would be expected that we should so far moderate our opinion of Preaching as that our magnifying thereof may no way tend to the discredit or disadvantage of most necessary Prayer Our Church doth not admit to the Office of Preaching any but who are ordained and licensed thereunto Yet our Church doth allow such kind of Sermons as we call in the Colleges Common places for the training up of Candidates in Divinity and for their tryal of skill before competent Judges The Moderation in our Church is further known in that among us its Ministers are not expected nor do they endeavour to take the people in their Preaching by mysterious non-sense or by storm and sensible noises and uncouth tones and grimaces whereby a tumult and confusion is rais'd in the animal passions scaring weak people almost out of their wits and common sense just as the Valentinian Hereticks x 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Euseb Hist l. 4. used hard words and thundring noises in their Conventicles to cause astonishment in the people y Nihil tam facile quà m vilem plebeculam indoctam concionem linguae volubilitate decipere quae quicquid non intellexit plus miratur S. Hier. ad Nepotian Ep. 3. Our design is otherwise by a rational and sober surrender of their minds to gain our Hearers to truth and goodness Whence it follows that among such as Mr Hooker well notes z Eccles Pol. l. 5. §. 2. The vigour and efficacy of Sermons do grow from certain accidents which are not in them but in their maker his gesture his zeal his motion of body inflexion of voice c. Here it is not improper also to justify the Moderation and good reason our Church hath for the distinction it hath
the Devotion wherefore as it is in the 49. Injunction of Queen Eliz. A modest and distinct Song is enjoined k Itaque operosam Musiâ—am quae figurata dicitur infâ—rri placet V. Reform Leg. Eccl. de Div. off c. 5. V. Vossium de viribus rythmi such that the sentence of the Hymn may be understood And for Organs or other Instruments of Musick in Gods worship they being a help Mr Baxter's Christian Direct p. 412. partly natural partly artificial to the exhilarating the spirits for the praise of God I know no argument to prove them simply unlawful but what would prove a Cup of Wine unlawful or the tune and metre and melody of singing unlawful And now we are discoursing of Melody the use of Bells l Vbi pulchriores plures magis sonorae etiam ad modos Musicos confectae Campanae quam in Anglià Spal contra Suarez c. 2. §. 27. among us deserves our notice since the Archbishop of Spalato hath taken particular observation how choicely we are furnished in our Kingdom for Assembling the Congregation for testimonies of publick joy and for pious admonition of Christian people to pray for such as are departing this life but among us they are not us'd with any superstitions m Nec Campanas superstitiosè pulsari vel in vigiliâ animarum vel postridiè omnium Sanctorum qui dies non ita pridem geniis mortuorum sacer erat Lib. quo Canonum 1571. What Cardinal Bellarmine n C. Bell. Apologia calls only Benediction of Bells is not after that manner as might make it be thought they are Christned o Centum gravam 51. § 13. Having observed the Moderation of the Church in its Feasts the same also is very true of its Fasts The keeping up of the Festivals and Fasts in the Greek Church hath been observed as a chief means of preserving the Christian Religion from sinking among them p De Eccl. Gr. statu hodierno p. 10. L. Canon 72. 1603. Our Church is neither so remiss as not to give any Counsel or Command for Fasting nor suffers any not Ministers to appoint solemn Fasts without authority q In observantiis afflictivis videtur providendum de aliquâ Moderatione Pet. de Aliaco in fasc re exp Jejunium Ecclesiae non debuit abrogari licebit moderari Wicelius in viâ Regiâ p. 374. neither is she immoderate in what she injoins but observes its due measures as are most conducing to assist Meditation Prayer and the exercise of Repentance and works of Piety With Fasting we join Alms and the Commemoration of what Christ hath done and suffered for us And as among the Jews it was usual for them voluntarily to fast on that day yearly they buried their Parents so in the Christian Church on the time that the Bridegroom was taken away before the Paschal Festivity the Custom hath been to fast more or less Some few times beside are appointed as opportunities to call off the mind from the blandishments of sense Mortification and temperance we are enjoin'd by our Christianity and further it appears to all most reasonable that there should be some seasons proper for Fasting and Mourning which private persons may appoint to themselves r Tantum tibi jejuniorum modum impone quantum fâ—â—re potâ—sâ—s siâ—t tibi pura casta simplicia moderata non superstitiosa jejunia S. Hier. de vitâ cler ad Nepotian much more the publick authority of the Church for the common good of all In which appointed Fasts let us well observe that the Precepts of the Church make no difference of meats but require such an abstinence as may best subdue the flesh to the Spirit There are three ends of Fasting saith the Homily To chastise the flesh That the Spirit may be more fervent to Prayer and that our Fast may be a witness with us before God of our humble submission to His Majesty So that the difference of meats which we observe is accidental to the Commands of the Church and not at all directly intended in it but left to every one 's Christian Liberty and choice Å¿ Pâ—â— temporibus causis uniâ—scuâ—â—sque non pro imperio novae Disâ—ipline Tert. adv Psych Cap. 2. so long as the purposes of Religion before-mentioned be observed and the Commands of Governours Thus the Moderation of the Church leaves us here as she finds us in our Christian Liberty But we are to consider that it is part of the Christian liberty of publick Governours in Cases left by God indifferent therein to Command especially for publick good So that it is the Law of the Kingdom only which streightens and confines our liberty from meats at some particular times While therefore it is the Law of the Kingdom people must have a care of charging the Church with a superstitious difference of meats because the Church of Rome usurps that power The Statute indeed of Queen Eliz. provides concerning observing Lent and also that Lent be not counted a Religious Fast that is by the Statute None are to affirm that any eating of fish or forbearing of flesh is of any necessity for saving the soul of man or that it is the service of God otherwise than as other politick Laws are for as the Homily t Homily of Fasting further expounds it The Laws of Princes are not made to put holiness in one kind of meat or drink more than another but are grounded meerly on policy All subjects therefore are bound in Conscience to keep these Laws Conscience I say not of the thing which is in its own nature indifferent but of our obedience we owe to Gods Minister According to which sense also must the Laws be understood which respect the Wednesday Fast called by some the Jejunium Cecilianum u Quòd putetur Cecilii esse inventum De Schism Angl. p. 172. If any person should affirm it to be impos'd with an intention to bind the Conscience he should be punished like a spreader of false news that is to burden the Conscience with a superstitious difference of meats or as of necessity to bind the Conscience by any Law equivalent to the eternal word of God which are the words of the Advertisement of Queen Elizabeth in her order of Ceremonies 1554. Thus in the Visitation Articles of King Edw. 6. The manner and kind of fasting in Lent and other days in the year is but a meer positive Law and therefore all persons having just cause of sickness x 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Can. Ap. 69. or other necessity or being licensed by the Kings Majesty may moderately eat all kinds of meats without grudge or scruple of Conscience So careful is our Church according to the practice of the ancient Church that the Fasts be observed with all just and equitable Moderation lest any fall into an excess of abstinence y 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 S. Basil M. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉
with the like the Articles of K. Edward 6. call Blind Devotion There is not consecrating and reconciling Church-Yards with so many Ceremonies and opinion of Efficacy and Necessity as in the Church of Rome ¶ V Form of Consecration of Churches Bishop Sparr Collect. 1675. The Bells which sound at Funerals among us are not appointed for any Superstition †Centum gravam 50. or to drive away Spirits from the Grave And because by Death all are made equal therefore all have the same Office for Burial All amongst us are deposited in the same general place of the Earth * Redditur Terrae Corpus ita locatum quasi operimento Matris obdusitur Cic. de leg l. 2. In other Circumstances Respect and Distinction is permitted according to the Custom of the Country and the condition of the Person deceased The Moderation of our Church is the same with that of the Christian Religion as it also leaves all Nations to their proper Usages and doth not oppose any Civil Laws or indifferent Customs of this or of any other Kingdom As it is observable That God himself tho he forbid the People of Israel ¶ Lev. 19. 28. Deut. 14. 1. to cut themselves or make any baldness upon themselves for the Dead or printing any Marks upon themselves which were the practices of that Idolatrous Nation Yet in such ancient Customes they had those which were Innocent referring to the manner of their Burial were permitted the same notwithstanding they had them from the Egyptians and other Heathen Nations Whereunto even also the Burial of our Blessed Lord Jesus was Conformable of which it is Recorded †John 19 4â— They took the Body of Jesus and wound it in Linnen with the Spices as the manner of the Jews is to Bury Among whom as hath been noted * Bishop â—earson on the Creed notes on Expos Art 4. there was a kind of Law that they should use no other Grave-clothes Notwithstanding it is all one ¶ Tabésne Cadavera solvat Aut rogus aut refert Capit omnia tellus Quae genuit coelo tegitur qui non habit urnam to our Bodies whether they are deposited in Linnen or in Woollen with Spices or without in the Earth or in any other Element whether we lie in S. Innocent's Church-yard where the Bodies soon consume or in the Sands of Egypt where they last longer or under the Moles of Adrianus And if the Minds of some seem uneasie in relation to one way of Burial more than another it convinceth us how great Tyrants Custom and Imagination are and perhaps in no Instance can it be confirmed more than in the late alteration referring to Burial Concerning which St. Austin's Comment might be of use †S. Aug. de Doct. Chr. l. 3. V. de civita Dei l. 1. c. 13. The Evangelist saith he doth seem to me not in vain to have said As the manner of the Jews is to Bury for so unless I am deceived he admonisheth in such offices of Piety which are exhibited to the Dead The Custom of every Nation is to be observed Wherefore our Church of England always leaves the Government of the Kingdom to have its Reasons to it self in what it appoints Instructing her Sons also how little soever the Matters are from thence to receive the greater honour of Obedience And because at so solemn a Providence as is the death of our Friends if some well-disposed Persons finding their Minds then more lifted up to the desires of Heaven and become more mortified to the World would take an opportunity of seriously commemorating the Death of our Lord who by Death overcame Death and opened the Gate of Heaven unto all Believers Therefore there is a brief peculiar appointment for the Celebration of the Holy Supper of the Lord at Funerals * Peculiaria quaedam in funeribus c. R. Eliz. V. Bishop Sparows Collections appointed 1560 with a Collect Epistle and Gospel which bears a part of the Reformed Liturgy which here is taken notice of as a proof how refined every part thereof is from Romish Superstition The like Instance of Inoffensive Moderation may be the public Office appointed by Q. Elizabeth for the Commemoration of Benefactors which is used in our Colleges and Vniversities which doth testify what worthy care we have of the memory of the deserving tho deceased and also doth shew how much purged these honourable Offices are from Superstition CHAP. XII Of the Moderation of our Church in what concerns the Power of the Church § 1. The Moderation of our Church owns the Power of the Church to be only Spiritual § 2. All other Power which Ecclesiastical Persons receive is readily acknowledged entirely depending on the favour of our Kings § 3. The Interests of the Kingdom and the Church are excellently accommodated in our Constitutions which is not done in other Models § 4. The pious Moderation of our King 's preserving their own rightful Supremacy and leaving to the Church the exercise of their Spiritual Power acknowledged by our Church § 5. The just Right of Kings shamefully invaded by other Sects pretending Divine Right Concerning which Claim the Moderation of our Church observed § 6. The dutiful Moderation of our Church in asserting Monarchy The first Canon 1640. justified § 7. All Interests of Humane Society especially of Subjects Allegiance in our Church abundantly secured which is not done by those in separation from her § 8. The Ordinances of our Church are framed with great Mildness and Moderation § 9. The same compared with the mild Obligation which Cardinal Bellarmine pretends the Church of Rome lays upon those of her Communion § 10. Sundry Instances of our Church's great regard to Equity § 1. THe Church of England always hath confessed That the Power of the Church is only Spiritual and Ministerial for the Head the Authority the Conversation of the Church is in Heaven Hence it is that the Appointments of the Church are not called Laws but Canons or Rules by which the Moderation of the Church rather leads than compels Yea In matter of Canons the Bishops and Clergy do but propound such Constitutions as they think useful and when they have done send them to his Majesty who perusing and approving them puts Life into them and of dead Propositions makes them Canons so are they the King's Canons not the Clergies * Bishop Hall's Remains p. 430. And the Inflictions Ecclesiastical the Church her self doth not call Punishments but Censures for Temporal Punishments are for Vengeance Spiritual for Discipline ¶ Bishop Lany on 1 Thess 4. 11. The Temporal Judg except he be Supreme in many things cannot pardon the Ecclesiastical Judg cannot but pardon upon Repentance as our Church doth express it self in the Canons if the Offender revoke that his wicked Error To this purpose St. Chrysostom †St. Chrys Homil 4. in Isaiam speaks The King remits the guilt of Bodies
the Kings of Israel and Judah had And in Christian Kingdoms * Cod. l. 1. Tit. 1. hath been used ever since any Kings have become Christian for the real good of the Church whose Members with all thankful acknowledgment have approved the same As hath often appeared from sundry Testimonies of the Ancients which need not be repeated since the several Sects which oppose our Church in this Matter make use of the same Power to the utmost when they can come to it As ¶ Thorndike Forbear of Penal ch 29. The Independent Congregations in New-England have not only Banished the Antinomians and put Quakers to Death but have imposed a Penalty of Five Shillings a day upon all that come not to hear their Sermons And as the Synod of Dort said There is no Order no Peace in the Church where it may not be lawful to the Church to judg of its own Members and retain within due bounds their Licentious Humours * Vt vaga ingenia coerceat intra debitos limites We know God commended Abraham because he would command his Children and his Houshold after him to keep the Way of the Lord Gen. 18. 19. And People of different Persuasions do not question but it is reasonable for Parents to correct their Children when they absent themselves from such Teaching as they order them and when they refuse to reade or hear what concerns Divine Matters in the way they judge fitting And shall not the Power of the Supreme Magistrate have the like effect for the good Order of the Church § 4. But many Object First Nothing ought to be so voluntary as Religion And indeed Religion ought to be most free even the choice of our Mind otherwise it cannot be our reasonable and acceptable Service But Penalties say they make that to be Servile which ought to be most Free To which may be Answered That all Acts of Vertue are to be free likewise and it is indeed more Noble to observe good Laws for the love of Goodness than the fear of Punishment But sometime Fear is the beginning of Wisdom and if Men will not willingly observe such good Laws the suffering Punishment is a less bondage than the slavery of Sin All Christian Duty ought to be free and voluntary but if Men are voluntarily Vitious Heretical and Schismatical the Christian Magistrate may Act religiously voluntarily to Punish them even because they wilfully do what is evil when they might have freely Acted what was good Which offence is the more aggravated in Matters of Religion therefore for any to make Religion their excuse for irregular practices is to turn Religion and the Church into a Sanctuary of Wickedness Irreligion and Heresies have their sensual baits and temptations which fear of punishment wholsomely prevents and usefully takes away 2. Others Object That no Man can be compelled to believe for Belief must follow the evidence of things to the Understanding T is true The Rules of the Christian Church do not allow Force as a means to bring any to believe * Sed nec Religionis est cogere Religionem quaeisuscipi sponâ—e debet non vs. Tertul. ad Scapulam But those who have professed that they do believe and thereby have become Members of the Christian Society within a Christian Kingdom and so ought to be Obedient to the Laws and Orders thereof If such by their speeches and behaviour say and do what tends to destroy that Society and disturb its Peace and Order when by the execution of good Laws the pravity of their Minds as it betrays it self by disorderly speeches and actions is corrected it may be a proper means to reduce such to a better Mind which may be the more thereby prepared to entertain a sound belief When speculative Errors become voluntary they become sinful and are springs of Vice and therefore as the interest of the Public may be concerned so they properly may come under the animadversion of Laws Yet we may take notice that the case is quite different between either Infidels or weak Christians and those who have been taught the Christian Religion Who call themselves Christians and profess themselves of the Society of Believers Who presume of themselves that they are far above the rank of Ignorant or weak People When these disturb the common Peace of the Church and are in danger to infect others When the same disorder in the Church hath a dangerous influence on the Peace of the Kingdom Such from the Nature and Laws of Christian Society deservedly come under the Censure of the Church and the Punishment of the Civil Laws especially in a Christian Kingdom And it is a great Blessing if such can by any means be reduced It is but what is necessary and what is a great work of Charity as our Homily hath it 3. Others pretend they ought not to be punished while they follow their Conscience But in answer What if such a Conscience shall cast off all Subjection must therefore all Execution of Laws be unlawful And they may so do if they will by the same Reason Again What if any call that by the awful name of Conscience which is their Prejudice their false Judgment of things caused by the irregular inclination of their wills Shall that excuse them from their manifest Christian Duty When they ought to inform their Consciences right And also as of necessity be obedient for Conscience sake The Conscience therefore of any who are punished for their Disobedience cannot render that Punishment unjust when the Laws themselves are good and the execution of those Punishments upon them are according to those Laws 4. Many will say That Counsels and gentle Instructions are a surer and better way to prevail And it is very true and God forbid but they should be in their due place used But if they will not prevail they are left the more inexcusable who notwithstanding are captious of exceptions against their Governours to justifie their own Schism Others frequently appeal to experience of the inefficacy of Punishments to these ends and that they rather confirm than root out the persuasions they strike at And this also may be very true when such Penalties are either executed very unconstantly or in excess either to a degree of Injustice or Cruelty And when the due ends and measures of Punishments are not observed whereas moderate and sober Punishments are justly thought proper to awaken the minds of Offenders into due consideration and regard of their Duty But none can ever reasonably think that it will conduce to the peace of the World for any to do as they list And whereas it is frequently objected That the omissions of Forms and Ceremonies is more severely punished than greater Faults How greater said Bishop Lany before the King Our Earthly Tribunals are not erected to anticipate the Day of Judgment to try Men according to the proper measure of their Guilt but for a particular End and Vse therefore in some
of Women Burial-Service the Gloria Patri to come under the name of Popery Altho by no Instance was it ever made to appear That our Church agrees with the Romanist in any thing contrary to Scripture and the practice of the Primitive Church As she is truly also most remov'd from Fanaticism neither using nor encouraging any Enthusiastic way of Religion nor allowing any resisting of Authority under any Religious Pretences whatsoever Any one may be convinced that no formed Church in the Christian World is more truly Protestant than is the Church of England nor any which all things compared less compromiseth with Rome If they will but consider in our Articles Liturgy Canons Constitutions Practice Oaths of Supremacy c. how firmly our Church preserves and enforceth the Reformation Yea the Canons of 1640 did excellently take care for the suppressing the growth of Popery Canon 3. 6. and also of Socinianism Canon 4. Which Seeds of Socinianism have bin scattered amongst our Sectaries and have of late had great growth amongst them Yet nevertheless if such Friends as they should slip into greater Heresy so long as they are with them in the Schism there is a special respect due to them rather than to the close adherents of the Church of England who because they run not into the madness of their extremes and are not outragious too in that madness they are forward to clamour against our Church it self as Popish and turn their own silly Surmises into powerful Calumnies Neither do those who reproach our Constitution sufficiently call to mind what hath bin done all along since the Reformation by our Kings of England and the great Councils of the Kingdom and the Orders of the Church and the Industry of our Bishops for the suppression of the growth of Popery § 2. But as a sufficient Evidence that our Church according to its establishment doth in no sort favour Popery They must be very disingenuous and wanting to Truth who will not readily acknowledg that the Labours of our Bishops and our Conformable Clergy remain the most impregnable defence of the Reformation For who I pray have more strenuously and constantly opposed the Innovations and immoderate Extravagancies of the Church of Rome than our Bishops and the Learned Men in firm Communion with our Church even since Queen Mary's days when some were Martyrs and Confessors and whose Writings but theirs who have held firm Communion with our Church remain as the constant Bullwark of our Protestant Reformation Wherefore the Romanists keenest displeasure * Immortale odium nunquam sanabile vulnus Ardet adhuc Combos Tentyra Juven Sat. 15. and jealousie hath bin always against the Church of England because from Her they have always received as forcible repulses as any As nothing doth more stir up the anger of a Zealous Enemy than the equal behaviour of those they malign and a moderate carriage doth sometime provoke their sharpest hatred So certainly nothing hath more stir'd up the jealousy of the Romanists than the excellent temper which is observed in our Churche's Constitution 'T is for the sake of this poor Church alone said our most noble Lord Chancellor †that the March 6. 1678. State hath bin so much disturbed It is her Truth and Peace her Decency and Order which they labour to undermine and pursue with so restless a malice And since they do so it will be necessary for us to distinguish between Popish and other Recusants between them that would destroy the whole Flock and them that only wander from it As for those of our Separatists who have sometimes menaged Debates with the Romanists the cunning Adversary commonly lets them alone for how seldom do we see a Romanist write against or oppose a Nonconformist and be in much earnest against him Not merely because he thinks such inconsiderable but because these are doing their Work for them as fast as they can * Hoc Ithacuâ— velit Magno mercentur Atrida Whereas those Contests which have bin menaged upon the Principles of our Church's Reformation have given the Romanists greatest awe and have always exercised their utmost strength § 3. Wherefore those of the Separation who have bin concerned in these Clamours and Surmises of our Church favouring Popery have acted therein as appears first very falsly and then very imprudently in reproaching so excellent a Reformation and by joining with them in their opposing our Church they strengthen the hands of the Romanists whom they pretend to oppose to the great scandal of the Christian Religion and great mischief to the true Protestant Interest Which caused Bishop Morton in his Epistle to the Nonconformists to tell them Beside their notorious Scandals given to the Church of God it self of their breaking the Hedg of Peace and opening the Gap for the wild Bore out of the Romish Forest to enter in and root out that goodly Vine which many Pauls industrious Bishops many Apollo's faithful Martyrs have planted and watered Even as Josephus * notes the Divisions of the Jews laid †Prol. ad bel Jud. them open to their overthrow And by their several Divisions which they help to propagate among us they join with the Romanists in endeavouring to overthrow and destroy our Constitution While they are crumbling into Factions biting and devouring one another a vigilant Adversary who is intent upon his advantage and opportunities may when he spieth his time over-master them with much more ease and less resistance †Bishop Sanderson's Preface to his Sermons Ad rerum momenta cliens seseque daturus Victori And the more unreasonable and vehement they are in their clamours the more they help the Roman Engineer to confound and overturn Therefore Arch-Bishop Whitgift ¶ Arch-Bp Whitgift Answ to the Admon p. 55. See his Letter to Q. Eliz. Fuller's Hist l. 9. now above a hundred years since said I am persuaded you and they do the Pope great good Service and he would not miss you for any thing For what is his desire but to have this Church of England which he hath cursed utterly defaced and discredited to have it by any means over-thrown if not by Foreign Enemies yet by Domestic Dissention And what apter Instruments could he have for that purpose than you who under pretended Zeal overthrow what others have built under colour of Purity seek to bring in Deformity under cloâ—e of Equality would usurp as great Tyranny and Lofty lordliness over your Parishes as ever the Pope of Rome over the whole Church Which also was the judgment of the University of Oxford 1603. Verily these Men are like Sampson 's Foxes they have their heads severed indeed the one sort looking toward the Papacy the other to the Presbytery but they are tied together by the Tails with Fire-brands between them to the injury of the Church Who would ever have thought said Bishop Bancroft 1588 in a Sermon at St. Pauls that we should ever have lived
be lawful to attempt any thing against his Person and Life are so much the same that they cannot be more if we compare Lessius Suarez Bellarmine and many other Jesuits and Mr. White of Obedience and Government with Knox and Buchanan and many other Republicans since wherein both sorts as Rivals seem to deal with the People as some Gallants do by foolish Women flatter them so long into a pride and conceit of themselves so great that at length they become intolerable and ungovernable Of this sort were the Discourses in the Council of Basil related by Aeneas Sylvius afterward Pope who could not contain from highly commending * Quem Sermonem sic doctè sie verificè sic suaviter disputarit Commentar de gestis Concil Bas in Fascic rer expe◠fol 4. the Bishop of Burgen for his admirably vilifying the Power of Kings Thus the worst of our Enthusiasts and of the Romanists agree in that Character of the Pharisees They mightily employed their Powers to oppose Kings †Jos Antiq l 17. c. 3. So true is the observation of King Charles the First ¶ 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 §. 15. of some Protestants They seem to have learned and to practise the worst Principles of the Papists And of both the Lord Bishop of Salisbury The Bigot and Jesuited Romanist the frighted and transported Reformist have bin Authors of the most horrible Treasons and Rebellions 20. I need not here particularly relate how many Doctrines of the Romanists tend to dissolve the very Bonds of Relative Duty one toward another as in their Monastical Vows absolving People from their Oaths and Allegiance and Faith with Hereticks c. How do many Principles of our Enthusiasts and Separatists tend to destroy the Relation of King and Subject Bishop and People Their very Divisions how do they alienate the minds of Christians one from another Tho they ought to belong to the same moderate Church are Subjects of the same most Gracious King are of the same Protestant and Reformed Interest beside the danger they bring to themselves and their Families by their pernicious and destructive Separation so many and more might be the Instances of their loosing the Bonds of Relative Duty § 8. Among other Sects it would grieve any one to behold so many seduced into the silly Herd of Quakers a Sect into which the very dregs of Heresy and Schism seem to have bin drein'd as it were into one Common Shore In the inventing and propagating which even Satan and the Jesuit seem to have club'd their utmost Art possessing them with an evil Spirit of Delusion which they call the Light within them according to which what is most contrary to Holy Scriptures and Right Reason and the testimony and judgment of the whole Church and the prudent command of Governors and the sence and custom of wise and pious Men must pass for an extraordinary illumination from God merely on the credit of their own saying so This one Enthusiastical Conceit of the Light within and Opinion of such Revelation from God is the most unhappy contrivance and suggestion that can be to lift up silly People above a possibility of being contradicted by any sober Principles of Scripture or Reason or regular Authority fitted to possess such with a lusty pride and bewitched conceit of themselves an incorrigible moroseness and obstinacy an intolerable censoriousness a sordid scorn of whatever is in just place above them and wonderfully disposeth such for Popery for when once they are sufficiently divided from our Church the Work is sufficiently done Then if any arch-Emissary from Rome will come with Visions and Revelations and a shew of extreme Authority and humor this People still in their outragious clamours against our Church especially if they will fall a quaking and groaning intolerably and appear in the Streets as some have done soundly be-dunged with Calumny and Filth such may make some People believe any Romish Tenets as Revelations from God That they have bin wrought and acted unto this by the common Authors of our Divisions is such plain attested matter of Fact that I suppose few considering Persons question it Some long since took notice that in the Northern Parts where there abounded most Popish Priests and Recusants there this upstart Sect of Quakers first sprung up sending thence their Emissaries two by two into other quarters of the Kingdom as the unclean Beasts entred the Ark by Couples beside which many Reasons confirm the same 1. The effect in that Spirit of Division and Delusion which so succesfully obtains among them to break in pieces the Peace and Order of the Church unto which of all Sects these are the most Antipodes to 2. There are none whose Tenets more tend to destroy the Holy Scripture as a perfect Rule of Faith and Manners instead of which and in opposition to the same they set up the Suggestions of their Light within them which they call the Word the only Guide unto Perfection * Perfectos se appellantes semina electionis De Valentinianis Iren. l. 1. which they and the Romanists pretend the one even unto supererogation of Merits the other to be above all need of confession of sin 3. None come so near the Papists in the matter of an infallible Judg of Doctrines 4. The Light within them is very much like the Enthusiasms of the Romanists as Dean Stillingfleet hath set them forth in the Fanaticism of the Church of Rome 5. They join with the severest Romanists in their reproaching the Offices and Orders of our Church and especially villfying her Clergy whom they would have by all means to vow wilful Poverty 6. By refusing all Oaths their Allegiance is left uncertain to the King which is the main thing such Papists would have 7. The King's Supremacy is left unacknowledged which is another principal preparation for the owning of the Pope's Supremacy 8. In that they refuse to assist their Prince in his Wars and pretend they hold it unlawful for any to fight By that Principle they not only take away the Power and Sword of the Magistrate and leave the King and Country undefended that none can live in peace and safety and consequently that Opinion leads to overthrow the very being of the whole Kingdom But the Pope also serves his Design by them being sure that so many as there are of that Sect so many will never oppose him by Arms Whereas they who bind can also loose and the same Agent can be able to stir up their Spirit of Zeal also which the longer it hath bin contained will be the more furious a Specimen and taste of which fury we experience in the keen violence of their Tongues which are as a very sharp Sword upon sundry slight occasions And when once they shall be assured that the Lord hath delivered a People to slaughter then Down Dagon then they will pretend they must be the Sampsons and like Pope Pius 5. in his
last Will. Walton in his Life the Superstition which the Puritan on the other hand lay to our charge are very justly chargeable on themselves respectively It is the Church of England in its legal Constitution which I defend and not the Assertions and Practices of particular Persons Neither have I undertaken to commend the Church in all her equal Constitutions nor shewn all the Proportions and Instances of her Moderation neither have I illustrated the same from all the extremes and immoderate extravagances of other Professions in Religion which would have bin a boundless and an infinite task But if I have made out this excellent Vertue to be truly conspicuous in our Church If I have fairly wrested out of our Adversary's hands that glorious Calumny in which so many have cheared and vaunted themselves in their fond Hopes strange Demands and very dismantled Confidences That our Church is devoy'd of all true Moderation I am sure I have done reason to our most indulgent Mother to defend her from the imputation of unjust Rigour which our Church justly disdains as in her 8th Canon Whosoever shall affirm that their pretended Schismatical Church hath a long time groaned under the burden of certain Grievances imposed upon them by the Church of England let them be Excommunicate § 5. But whereas some forward to censure will be apt to judg of our justifying the Moderation of the Church as an endeavour to prevent any Reformation or Union such may consider That admit our Superiors should think fit to remit or at any time change any thing in our present Order The so doing doth not necessarily infer that our Constitution is not very moderate as it is For Concessions which are for the future ought not to be an accusation of the Church in what is past But may our sins never bring upon us such a wretched condition of the Church when every one shall judg he hath a right to think and speak in Religion what he pleaseth * In liberâ Repub. unicuique sentire quae velit quae sentiat liberè dicere Tractat. Theologo Pol. Unto this state of things or unto Popery those hasten us whether they know it or no who are in no wise satisfyed with the Moderation of our Church How far our present establishment may be any way moderated to compass a more general and lasting uniformity we hope if ever there should be occasion God will guide our Governors to determin but I am sure as the present Moderation of the Church is most justifiable so I suppose the change may more easily be allow'd when ever the generality of Dissenters shall be agreed and resolv'd of their own Reasons among themselves In the mean while if any will undertake to disprove the Proposition which this Treatise principally doth ovince Namely That the great Moderation of the Church of England doth rightly argue those who are in separation from the same to be the more unjust and guilty in their Schism * Et refellere sine pertâ—nacâ—â refelli sine iracunâ—iá paraâ—i sumus Tuscul 9. l. 2. I hope such will menage their Exceptions with respect to the Rules of Moderation especially as they have bin laid down in the second paragraph of this Chapter Neither I conceive is it enough to excuse their Schism nor to render our Church so immoderate as not to be communicated with for any to give some Instances which according to some Judgments they would have otherwise since it is most impossible to have any constitution of things free from all manner of exception and also against the most perfect things great enmities may be raised for want of equally considering the Principles Rules and Ends for which those things were established Neither is it enough to except against what is faulty in particular Persons when the same is no vice of the public Constitution Sure then it may be judged a very unreasonable manner of sundry sorts of Men answering such Discourses as pinch them namely by catching at some little scattered parts of the Skirts and Margent of the Cause Or when they cannot by unbiassed Reasons have victory in their Contest then they readily fall off to Personal Matters which in no sort tend to the Merits of any Cause and by these methods they hope to buoy up the Party which is the main thing they generally aim at § 6. Such was the Moderation of our Church when she had any hopes to reduce any of the Romish Profession unto our Communion she left out of the Public Litany that Clause From the Tyranny of the Bishop of Rome and all his detestible Enormities Good Lord deliver us Yet it may be very proper now to make the same our Petition here adjoining thereunto another seasonable Prayer of Isaac Casaubon's O Lord Jesu preserve this Church of England and give a sound mind to those Nonconformists who deride the Rites and Ceremonies of it * Faxit Deus ut ad sanâ—orem mentem redeant Amen Lud. Capellus Thes 51. Salmur de moresis in Angliâ And since I have named the Learned Casaubon 't is most suitable here also to add some of his words to King James * Exercit. in Baron Ep. Dâ—d Sir You have a Church in these Kingdoms partly so framed of old and partly by great labours of late so restored that now no Church whatsoever comes nearer than yours to the form of the Primitive flourishing Church having taken just the middle way between those that offended in excess and defect In which Moderation the Church of England hath obtein'd this first of all that those very Persons who envyed her happiness yet by comparing one with the other have bin compelled to praise Her As for any of those who think it their Interest to decry the Moderation of our Church We wish first that the Roman Church would once take advice of her own Cassander * De nimio â—â—origore aliquid remâ—â—â—ant Ecclesiae paci aliquid concedant Consult ad Artic. 7. To remit of their immoderate rigour and hearkning to the Admonitions of Pious Men would set themselves to correct manifest abuses according to the Rule of Divine Scripture and of the Primitive Church from which they have swerved And that those of the other extreme would practise the Counsel which * Vt vos ultra modum rigidos esse nolim ita rursus altos monitos esse cupio ne sibi in suâ inscitiá nimis placeant Ep. 200. Calvin gave the English Brethren at Frank fort As I would not saith he have you beyond measure rigid so again the rest I desire they will be advised not to please themselves too excessively in their own ignorance * Offâ—â—sions suae modum statuere nesciunt nam ubi Dominus clementiam exigit omissâ illâ totos se immoderatae severitati tradunt Calv. Inst l. 4. c. 1. For I suppose that according to the best Reason it may be made out very probable that as the overthrow of Popery may as probably be wrought by the growth of its own rigour and immoderate claims as any way we can imagin †Inde exitium imminere Pontificiâ— imperio A. Sall. votum prâ—pace so if any thing in the mean while endanger the Protestant Reformed Interest it will be the immoderate behaviour of those of the Separation in their Schism against our Church Between both taking auspicious hopes from the Moderation of our Church We trust its Constitution being most Primitive will be also most lasting ¶ Eâ— demùm tuta est potentia quae viribus suis modum imponâ—t Val. Max. de Animi Moder l. 4. c. 1. in the esteem of the Church Universal and in the approbation of wise and good Christians And while our Church continues thus moderate it must needs argue the Separation which is from it to be the more unequal and sinful For the same Moderation which exonerates the Church of England from the guilt of Schism with respect to the Romanists doth aggravate also the Schism of other Separatists and however some dissenting Brethren while they remain drencht in their Tinctures will not be forward to acknowledg the Moderation of our Church yet we are assured that nothing would more tend to bring People in love with happy Peace and blessed Order nothing would contribute more to the quieting Mens Minds to reconcile all Parties and to accommodate the most and greatest differences which are among us than a right and full persuasion of the excellent Temper and Constitution of our Church I cannot close a Treatise of the Moderation of the Church of England more properly than with some of the mild and pathetical Soliloquies of our late Blessed Martyr King Charles I. Most merciful God stir up all Parties pious 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 §. 19. 16. Ambitions to overcome each other with Reason Moderation and such self-denial as becomes those who consider that our mutual Divisions are our common Distractions and the Vnion of all is every Man's chiefest Interest Keep Men in a pious Moderation of their Judgments in Matters of Religion Give us wisdom to amend what is amiss within us and there will be less to mend without us Evermore defend and deliver thy Church from the Effects of blind Zeal and over-bold Devotion Glory to God in the highest on Earth Peace Good Will toward Men. FINIS