are set Free by the Son of God The eleventh Book in Adversarijs Conteining a Treatise upon the Articles of Christs comming to judgement The Resurrection of the dead and Life everlasting The twelfth of the Catholick Church part whereof is Printed and mentioned above Besides a great number of Treatises and Sermons respective Appendices to the Books aforesaid So many as would fill a Page with a Particular Catalogue For the Publishing whereof in due Time and manner and suiting with this Volume The Worthy persons whom the Author made Supervisors of his Will will be conscientious and Prudent Accountants to the Church of Christ And some others Pious and Learned men of that University Chearfull Assistants thereto But here if the Reader be of my Temper Secretum peto I must lead him aside a little to Condole the losse the Great loss of one most Considerable piece Finished and Alas for the Day lost some yeers ago It was The Treatise of Prodigies or Divine Forewarnings betokening Blood I am bold to say Reader Write this a Prodigie And to render it the more Prodigious take notice that it was lost in the Authors Life Time as his ingenious Amanuensis Mr. B. told me inquiring after it above 9 yeers ago What shall be said or thought of This Surely The World was not worthy of such a Blessing It sentenced it self unworthy thereof by the stupid totall neglect of what he Preached at Court and Printed at Oxon in the Yeer 1637. about The Signes of the Times a Subject neer of Kin to that Treatise The longing impatient desire of Retreiving this Treatise makes me not blush to transform this Preface into a kind of Proclamation 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or rather into a most humble and earnest Supplication unto the Person that hath this Treatise in keeping if yet it be kept from the Malice of the Destroyer That he will please to bring it in unto the Stationer for whom this Book is Printed upon assurance to receive it again or for it twelve or twenty Copies or a sum of Money Aequivalent if it be Printed For it is the desire and designe of more and more able men then my self to Collect and Publish This Authors Works as Compleat as possibly may be The Earnest whereof is Given in this First Volume with this further Account The Quarto Impression was scarce and dear and ill Printed The weighty and many Quotations of Authors so exceeding falsly figured and disfigured too that it cost so much Time and great Turning sometimes to finde out One single place as none can believe that hath not tried the like nor could all the Authors be found in London This the Famous Library of Oxon and the chearfull Candor of a learned Friend there supplied I am hopefull that the Authors Sence is not altered in the least measure for the least sin in that kind is sacriledge I am sure I was so scrupulously carefull of changing as that I have omitted what I thought necessary correction For example in the Epistle to the Reader line 12. I think I ought to have changed the word Conscience into Conscious or lesse conscience into more conscientious unlesse you will say Conscience there signifies Guilt So Page the 12. Line 3. after And yet These two words They persecuted should be inserted as I conjecture unlesse the comparison betwixt the Roman and Turkish Emperours Subjects make them needlesse So in the 250 page in the Margin surely it ought to have been R. P. but it was R. B. in the old Copie and in the search of Parsons Resolutions not finding absolute evidence that he was the party meant I let R. B. stand Yet have I added now and then a Citation or Note in the Margin As where the Great Businesse of Charles Martell is Related page 110. I have cited divers Authours whom the Reader may consult for his own better satisfaction To conclude There is a saying and men may think 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 But the pecuniary profit be to the Tradesman If my heart deceive me not as divers Nutus Dei did invite the beginning and many remarkable momenta providentiae did encourage the Progresse in a Time of greatest trouble for outward estate so the Glory of God Almighty the Benefit of his Church and Children the doing of some small Thing in a Time of Cashierment that may tend to the discharge of a most unprofitable servants account at the last Day is the gain aimed at And if our Pr Brethren Sons of the same Fathers with us that cast us out viewing well the second and third Books and being here advertised That twenty of those men whom they have put from the Stations wherein God had set them in the Church of England as Factors for the Church of Rome have contributed each man their Symbolum to this Impression will by this be brought to see their mistake and taking this 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 for 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 confess themselves deceived and unwittingly made Proctors for 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and transported in this particular became partial and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 it will be an Accession above expectation The Good Lord lay not this sin to their Charge but reconcile them to their former selves and be Reconciled both to them and us in Christ and prosper the work both dispatched and intended to his Glory and the good of his Church for our Lord Jesus's sake The Prayer of the most unworthy One of all his servants B. O. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Plutarch 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 483. If I shall find favour in the eyes of the Lord he will bring me again and shew me both the Ark and his Habitation But if he say I have no delight in Thee Let him do to me as seemeth good unto Him Good is the Word of the Lord. The Law of the Lord is an undefiled Law converting the soul The Testimony of the Lord is sure and giveth wisdom to the simple Let the Word of God dwell in you plenteously Search the Scriptures Which are able to make thee wise unto salvation In which are some things hard to be understood which the unlearned and unstable wrest as they do also the Other Scriptures to their own destruction Remember them which are the Guides or have the Rule over you The Priests lips should keep knowledge and they should seek the law at his mouth He that heareth you heareth me Lo I am with you alway even to the End of the World THE LIFE and DEATH of the Venerable Dr. JACKSON Dean of PETERBROUGH and President of Corpus-Christi Colledge in OXFORD Written by a late Fellow of the same Colledge BEing earnestly desired by an intimate and Powerful Friend to deliver some Character of that Reverend and Learned Doctor Jackson late President of our Colledge I might very well excuse my self from my unworthiness to undertake so weighty a Task I must seriously confess it was not so much the Importunity of that
sinister Pretences or humorous though strong Perswasions of Conscience counselling us to the contrary our Punishment in this life is just whose present smart should teach us to beware of far more grievous in the life to come But whether offend or swerve more from the Rules of Scripture prescribed for their several Christian Carriage Superiours in commanding wrongfully or Inferiours in disobeying just commands cannot oft-times if we speak of particular Actions be infallibly known in this life but must be referred unto that day of Final Judgement The dread of which should in the mean time inforce every Superiour daily to consult his own Heart and strictly to examine his Conscience whether it be not likely then to give Evidence against him for imposing too heavy burthens upon his Inferiours And so must every Inferiour again use the like diligence in the daily examination of his Conscience whether it be likely or no to convince him before the Judge of quick and dead of Disobedience to such as he had set in Authority over him or of such sinister Pretences for using the Libertie of Conscience as Conscience it self never sought after but were suggested onely by Humour Popularitie or other Desires whose maintenance have either inforced him to obey Man against God or not to obey Man commanding for God 4 Our Partialitie it is towards our selves or rather to our sensual delights or pleasures that makes us so ignorant in all things which concern our Weal For would we truly and unpartiallie Judge our selves we should not be judged Not the best experienced Justice in this Land can by examining ordinarie Malefactors discern what issue their Cause shall have before an unpartiall Judge better then we by this strict pre-examination might foresee what finall Sentence were prepared for us good or bad according to the diversitie of our Actions and Course of Life To this end hath Christ left every mans Conscience in full Authoritie during his absence to examine reprove convince and sentence the desires of his own heart of which would we daily in sobriety of Spirit and fear of his last Judgement ask counsel and patiently expect Gods Providence we should by this ordinary Means discern who commanded aright who otherwise as clearly as others heretofore have done by Means most extraordinary For even the most extraordinary miracles did ascertain the Ancient of Divine Truth and confirme them in the practise of Christian Obedience not immediately as part of their Rule of Faith whereon finally to relie but by enforcing them to look into their own Souls and Consciences in which Truth was already written if they had urged it to confession If our examination without Miracles were as strict our Beliefe would be as firm Spiritual Governours commands as Christian-like and Inferiours Obedience in all points as sincere as was theirs 5 For Conclusion I would give the Christian Reader a present Antidote against all the poisonous inchantments of Romish Sorcerers The Medicine is very brief and easie onely to think every morning next his heart or at other seasonable hours That there is a Divine Providence in this life to guide us and after this life ended a fearful judgement to passe upon all such as here abjuring the Guidance of it follow either the Wayes of flesh and blood in breeding or of carnal Wisdom in composing strife and dissention about matters Spiritual He that will seriously ruminate on these matters in his vacant well composed thoughts calling the Adversaries Arguments home to the Point which they must touch ere they can wound us let me have onely his dying curse in recompence of all my pains if any Difficulty any Jesuite or other learned Papist either hitherto hath or ever shall be able to bring do trouble his mind Whatsoever can be brought either to countenance their unchristian Doctrine or disparage our Orthodoxal Assertions either presuppose a secret denial of Gods peculiar Providence and inward calling of men or else proceed from want of consideration that there is a final Judgement wherein all Controversies must be taken up all Contentious and rebellious Spirits punisht according to their deserts Indeed if the Authors or Abetters of Schisme and Heresie might escape for ever unpunished or Christian Modestie and Humilitie be perpetually over-born by Impudencie Scurrilitie and violent Insolencie the Inconveniences objected by the Romanists might as much trouble us as the wickeds thriving did the Heathen that knew not God nor his Providence But whilest we acknowledge him and It the best Arguments our Antagonists bring wil appear as improbable as they are impious TO THE RIGHT REVEREND Father in God and my Honourable Lord WILLIAM By Divine Providence Lord Bishop of DURHAM Grace and Peace be multiplied RIght Reverend Father the sweet refreshing your Honourable Favours did yield to such of my labours as hitherto enjoy the light when a suddain uncomfortable blast had sorely nipt them in the very setting makes these last gatherings of that spring seek that comfortable warmth under your benigne Protection which the unconstant frowning season would hardly afford them in their growth Besides these and other my personal Obligements that Famous and worthy Founder of this Attick Bee-hive of whose sweetness would God I had been as capable as I have been long partaker had never allotted any Cell therein for me or other Countryman of mine but with particular relation to that seat of dignity which he sometimes did â—…r Lordship now doth and to the encrease of Gods gloâ—… good of his Church long may enjoy Seeing this our â—… Foster-Father is now ignorant of his childrens deâ—… and knows not me it shall be my comfort to have â—… honourable successors witnesses of my care and industry to fulfil his godly desire whose religious soul in his life time as his written Laws do testifie did detest nothing more then idleness in the Ministry specially in his adopted-Sons The matters I here present unto your Lordships and the worlds view are sometimes in themselves so harsh and hard to be concocted as he that would strive to make them toothsome unto nice tastes should put himself to excessive pains unless his judgement be much riper his wit readier his invention pleasanter his opportunities better and his leisure greater then mine are But it is one and the same point of judgement not to require exact Mathematical proofs in discourses of mortality or a smooth facile Rhetorical stile in Logical or Scholastick conflicts And as by the Statutes of that Society wherein I live I am bound to avoid barbarisme so my particular inclination moves me in controversies especially to approve his choise that said Fortia mallem quam formosa If any professed enemy to the truth we teach will answer me from point to point or attempt not as their custom now is onely in scoffing sort but seriously to avert those unsupportable but deserved imputations I lay upon the foundation of his Religion I shall I trust be able to answer him the better by
greatnesse of authority is alwayes measured by the manner of obedience due unto it The Minor is as evident from the former reason Our obedience is more absolute and strict unto that authority from which in no case we may appeal then unto that from which we may in many safely appeal but by the Romish Churches doctrine there lies alwayes an appeal from that sence and meaning of Scriptures which Gods spirit and our own conscience gives us unto the Churches authority none from the Churches authority or meaning unto the Scriptures or our own consciences 7 Our Saviour Christ bids us search the Scriptures S. Paul try all retain that which is good S. John try the Spirits whether they be of God or no Suppose a Minister of our Church should charge a Romanist upon his allegiance to our Saviour Christ and that obedience which he owes unto Gods Word to search Scriptures trie Spirits and examin Doctrines for the râ—tifying of his faith he wil not acknowledge this to be a Commandment of Scripture or at least not to be understood in such a sence as may bind him to this practise What follows if our Clergie charge him to admit it he appeals unto the Church And as in Schools simus and nasus simus is all one so in their language is the Church and the Church of Rome This Church tels him he may not take upon him to trie of what spirit the Pope is nor examin his determinations decisions or interpretations of any Scripture by other known places of Scripture or the analogie of faith acknowledged by all Unto this decree or sentence of the Church although he have it but at the second hand or after it have passed through as many Priests and Jesuites mouthes as are Post Towns from London to Edenburgh he yields absolute obedience without acknowledgement of farther appeal either unto Scriptures or other authority whatsoever further manifestation of Gods wil he expects none Let all the reformed Churches in the World or all the Christian World besides exhort threaten or adjure him as he tenders the good of his own soul as he wil answer his Redeemer in that dreadful day of final Judgement to examin the Church or Popes decrees by Gods written Laws his answer is he may not he cannot do it without open disobedience to the Church which to disobey is damnation of soul and body But O fools and slow of heart to believe and obey from the heart that doctrine whereunto ye were delivered Know ye not that to whomsoever ye give your selves as servants to obey his servants ye are to whom ye obey whether it be the man of sin unto death or obedience unto righteousnesse Of all Mankind are onely Roman Catholicks not bought with a price that they may thus alienate their souls from Christ and become servants of men that they may consecrate themselves by solemn vow to the perpetual slavery of most wicked and sinful men even monsters of Mankind CAP. V. That in obeying the Romish Churches decrees we do not obey Gods Word as well as Them but Them alone in contempt of Gods principal Laws 1 BUt the simple I know are born in hand by the more subtile sort of this generation That thus obeying sinful men they obey Christ who hath injoyned them this obedience unto such That thus believing that sence of Scripture which the Church their mother tenders unto them they do not believe her better then Scriptures because these two Beliefs are not opposite but subordinate that they prefer not her decrees before Christs written Laws but her interpretation of them before all private Expositions This is the only City of refuge left them wherein prosecuted by the former arguments they can hope for any succour but most of whose gates already have been all shortly shall be shut upon them 2 That they neither believe nor obey Gods Word whilest they absolutely believe and obey the Church without appeal is evident in that this Church usually binds men not unto Positive points of Religion gathered so much as from any pretended sence of Scripture expounded by it but to believe bare Negatives as that this or that place of Scripture either brought by their adversaries or conceived by such amongst themselves as desire the knowledge of truth and right information of conscience have no such meaning as the Spirit of God not flesh and bloud as far as they can judge of their own thoughts hath revealed unto them 3 But the Spirit may deceive private men or at least they may deceive themselves in their trial of Spirits They may indeed and so may men in publick place more grievously erre in peremptory judging private men because obnoxious to errour in the general erroneous in this particular wherein they ground their opinions upon Gods Word plentiful to evince it at least very probable reasons they bring many and strong whereunto no reasonable answer is brought by their adversaries whose usual course is to presse them only with the Churches authority which appears to be of far greater weight then Gods word unto all such as yield obedience to her negative decrees without any evidence or probability either of Scripture or natural reason to set against that sence and meaning of Gods Laws whereunto strength of arguments unrefuted and probable pledges of Gods Spirit undisproved have long tied their souls Do we obey God or believe his word whilst we yield obedience to the Church in such Commandments as to our consciences upon unpartial examination seem condemned ere made by the very fundamental Laws of Religion and all this oft-times without any shew or pretence of Scripture to warrant us that we do not disobey God in obeying them 4 But doth the Romish exact absolute obedience in such points as if it were possible they could be false may endanger the very foundation of true Religion without evident demonstration that their daily practise neither doth nor can endanger it Yes For what can more concern the main foundation which Christians Jews and Mahumetans most firmly hold then those precepts in number many all plainly and peremptorily forbidding us to worship any Gods but One or any thing in the Heaven or Earth but Him only The Romanists themselves grant that cultu latriae God alone is to beadored that so to adore any other is Idolatry and Idolatry by their confession a most grievous sin O how much better were it for them to hold it none or Gods Word forbidding it of no authority then so lightly to adventure the hourly practise of it in contempt of such fearful threatnings as they themselves out of Gods Laws pronounce against it upon such broken distoynted surmises as are the best they can pretend for their warrant 5 To believe Christs flesh and bloud should be there present where it canot be seen or felt yea where we see and feel another body as perfectly as we can do ought is to reason without warrant of Scripture but a
purpose in whose will or pleasure the finall cause of any natural effect alwayes consists And seeing nothing in Nature can preoccupate his will no cause can be precedent to the finall This consideration of naturall effects tending as certainly to their proposed end as the arrow flyes to the mark caused the irreligious Philosopher to acknowledge the direction of an intelligent supernatural agent in their working the accomplishment of whose will and pleasure as I said must be the finall cause of their motions as his will or pleasure which bestows the charges not the Architect unlesse he be the owner also is the final cause why the house is built Finally every End supposeth the last intention of an intelligent Agent whereof to give a reason by the Efficient which onely produceth works or meanes thereto proportioned would be as impertinent as if to one demanding why the bell rings out it should be answered because a strong fellow puls the rope 7 Now that which in our Adversaries Doctrine answers unto the cause indemonstrable whereinto final resolution of Natures works or intentions of intelligent agents must be resolved is the Churches Authority Nor can that if we speak properly be resolved into any branch of the first Truth for this reason besides others alledged before that all resolutions whether of our perswasions or intentions or of their objects works of Art or Nature suppose a stability or certainty in the first links of the chain which we unfold the latter alwayes depending on the former not the former on the latter As in resolutions of the latter kind lately mentioned imitating the order of composition actual continuation of life depends on breathing not breathing on it breathing on the lungs not the lungs mutually on breathing so in resolutions of the other kind which inverts the order of composition the use or necessity of lungs depends upon the use or necessitie of breathing the necessitie or use of breathing upon the necessity or use of life or upon his will or pleasure that created one of these for another Thus again the sensitive faculty depends upon the vital that upon mixtion mixtion upon the Elements not any of these mutually upon the sensitive faculty if we respect the order of supportance or Natures progresse in their production Whence he that questions whether some kinds of plants have sense or some stones or metals life supposeth as unquestionable that the former have life that the second are mixt bodies But if we respect the intent or purpose of him that sets Nature a working all the former faculties depend on the sensitive the sensitive not on any of them For God would not have his creatures indued with sense that they might live or live that they might have mixt bodies but rather to have such bodies that they might live to live that they might enjoy the benefit of sense or the more noble faculties 8 Can the Jesuite thus assigne any determinate branch of the First Truth as stable and unquestionable before it be ratified by the Churches authority Evident it is by his positions that he cannot and as evident that belief of the Churches authority cannot depend upon any determinate branch of the First Truth much lesse can it distinctly be thereinto resolved But contrariwise presse him with what Divine precept soever written or unwritten though in all mens judgements the Churches authority set aside most contradictory to their approved practises for example That the second Commandement forbids worshipping Images or adoration of the consecrated Host he straight inverts your reason thus Rather the second Commandement forbids neither because the holy Church which I believe to be infallible approveth both Lastly he is fully resolved to believe nothing for true which the Church disproves nothing for false or erroneous which it allowes Or if he would answer directly to this demand To what end did God cause the Scriptures to be written He could not â—â—sonâ—â—t to his tenents say That we might infallibly rely upon them but rather upon the Churches authority which it establisheth For Gods Word whether written or unwritten is by their Doctrine but as the testimony of some men deceased indefinitely presumed for infallible but whose material extent the Church must first determine and afterwards judge without all appeal of their true meaning Thus are all parts of Divine truthes supposed to be revealed more essentially subordinate to the Churches authority then ordinary witnesses are to royal or supreme judgement For they are supposed able to deliver what they know in termes intelligible to other mens capacities without the Prince or Judges ratification of their sayings or expositions of their meanings and judgement is not ordained for producing witnesses but production of witnesses for establishing judgement Thus by our adversaries Doctrine Gods Word must serve to establish the Churches authority not the Churches authority to confirm the immediate soveraigntie of It ever our souls 9 Much more probably might the Jew or Turk resolve his faith unto the First Truth then the modern Jesuited Papist can For though their deductions from it be much what alike all equally sottish yet these admit a stabilitie or certainty of what the First Truth hath said no way dependant upon their authority that first proposed or commended it unto them The Turks would storme to hear any Mufti professe He were as well to be believed as was Mahomet in his life time that without His proposal they could not know either the old Testament or the Alcoran to be from God So would the Jews if one of their Rabbines should make the like comparison betwixt himself and Moses as the Jesuite doth betwixt Christ and the Pope who besides that he must be as well believed as his Master leaves the authority of both Testaments uncertain to us unlesse confirmed by his infallibility But to speak properly the pretended derivation of all three heresies from the First Truth hath a lively resemblance of false pedegrees none at all of true Doctrine and resolutions Of all the three the Romish is most ridiculous as may appear by their several representations As imagine there should be three Competitors for the Roman Empire all pleading it were to descend by inheritance not by election all pretending lineal succession from Charles the Great The first like to the Jew alledgeth an authentick pedegree making him the eldest The second resembling the Turk replies that the other indeed was of the eldest line but long since disinherited often conquered and enforced to resigne whence the inheritance descended to him as the next in succession The third like the Romanist pleads it was bequeathed him by the Emperors last Will and Testament from whose death his Ancestors have been intit'led to it and produceth a pedegree to this purpose without any other confirmation then his own authority adding withall that unlesse his competitors and others will believe his records and declarations written or unwritten to be most authentick they cannot
much grieved at the Trent Councels impietie but now I wonder at these grave Fathers folly that would trouble themselves with prescribing so many Canons or overseeing so large a Catechisme when as the beginning of Protagoras Book one or two words altered might have comprehended the entire confession of such mens faith as rely upon their Fatherhoods The Atheist thus began his Book De dijs non haâ—â—o quod decam utrum sint necne Concerning the Gods or their being I can say nothing A private Roman Catholick might render an entire account of his faith in termes as brief De Christo Christiana fide non habeo quod dicam utrum sint necne Whether there be a Christ or Christian Religion be but a Politick Fable I have nothing to say peremptorily yea or no the Church or Councel can determine whom in this and all other points wherin God is a party I will absolutely believe whilest I live if at my death I find they teach amâ—e let the devil and they if there be a devil decide the controversie Yet this conceit or conditional Belief of Christ and Christianity conceived from the former serves as a ground colour for disposing mens souls to take the sable dye of Hell wherewith the second main stream of Romish impietie will deeply infect all such as drink of it For once believing Gods Word from the Churches testimony this absolute submission of their consciences to embrace that sence it shall suggest sublimates them from refined Heathinisme or Gentilisme to diabolisme or symbolizing with infernal spirits whose chiefest solace consists in acting greatest villanies or wresting the meaning of Gods written Lawes to his dishonour For just proof of which imputation we are to prevent what as we late intimated might in favour of their opinion be replied to our former instance of light and colours 9 Some perhaps well affected would be resolved why as he that sees colours by the sun sees not only the sun but colours with it so he that believes the Scriptures by relying upon the Church should not believe the Church onely but the Scriptures too commended by it The doubt could hardly be resolved if according to our adversaries Tenent the Churches declarations did confirm our faith by illustrating the Canon of Scriptures or making particular truths contained in it inherently more perspicuous as if they were in themselves but potentially credible and made actually such by the Churches Testimony which is the first and Principal Credible in such sort as colours become actually visible by illumination of the principal and prime visible But herein the grounds of Romish doctrine and the instance brought by Sacroboscus to illustrate it are quite contrary For the light of the Sun though most necessary unto sight is yet necessary onely in respect of the object or for making colours actually visible which made such or sufficiently illuminated are instantly perceived without further intermediation of any other light then the internal light of the Organ in discerning colours alwayes rather hindered then helped by circumfusion of light external For this reason it is that men in a pit or cave may at noon day see the starres which are invisible to such as are in the open air not that they are more illuminated to the one then the other but because plentie of light doth hinder the Organ or eye-sight of the one Generally all objects either actually visible in themselves or sufficiently illuminated are better perceived in darknesse then in the light But so our Adversaries will not grant that after the Church hath sufficiently proposed the whole Canon to be Gods Word the distinct meaning of every part is more clear and facile to all private spirits by how much they lesse participate of the visible Churches further illustration For quite contrary to the former instance the Churches testimony or declaration is onely necessary or available to right belief in respect not of the object to be believed Scriptures but of the party believing For as hath been observed no man in their judgement can believe Gods Word or the right meaning of it but by believing the Church and all belief is inherent in the believer Yea this undoubted Belief of the Churches authority is that which in Bellarmine and Sacroboscus's judgement makes a Roman Catholicks belief of Scriptures or divine truths taught by them much better then a Protestants If otherwise the Churches declaration or testimony could without the belief of it infallibility which is inherent in the subject believing make Scriptures credible as the light doth colours visible in themselves a Protestant that knew their Churches meaning might as truely believe them as a Roman Catholick albeit he did not absolutely believe the Church but onely use her help for their Orthodoxal interpretation as he doth ordinary Expositors or as many do the benefit of the Sun for seeing colours which never think whether colours may be seen without it or no. For though it be certain that they cannot yet this opinion is meerly accidental to their sight and if a man should be so wilfull as to maintain the contrary it would argue only blindness of mind none of his bodily sight Nor should distrust of the Romish Churches authority ought diminish our Belief of any divine Truth were her declarations requisite in respect of the object to be believed not in respect of the subject believing 10 Hence ariseth that difference which plainly resolves the former doubt For seeing the Sun makes colours actually visible by adding vertue or lustre to them we may rightly say we see colours as truely as the light by which we see them For though without the benefit of it they cannot be seen yet are they not seen by seeing it or by relying upon it testimony of them Again because the use of light is onely necessarie in respect of the object or for presenting colours to the eye after once they be sufficiently illuminated or presented every creature endued with sight can immediately discern each from other without any further help or benefit of external light then the general whereby they become all alike actually visible at the same instant The Suns light then is the true cause why colours are seen but no cause of our distinguishing one from another being seen or made actuallie visible by it For of all sensible objects sufficiently proposed the sensitive faculty though seated in a private person is the sole immediat supreme Judge and relies not upon any others more publick verdict of them On the contrary because the Romanists supposed firm belief of Scriptures or their true meaning ariseth only from his undoubted belief of the Churches veracicie which is in the believer as in it subject not from any increase of inherent credibilitie or perspicuitie thence propagated to the Scriptures Hence it is that consequently to his positions most repugnant to all truth he thinks after the Church hath sufficiently avouched the Scriptures divine truth in general we
quam à Deo homines avocare ad 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 sui ab intellectu verae religionis avertere cum sint ipsi poenales quaerere quas ad 〈◊〉 comiâ—es quâ—â—â—… en soul fecerint errore participes Hi tamen adjurati per Deum verum à nobis statim cedunt fatentur de 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 extre coguntur These were the effects of Christs triumph over Satan sure pledges that the strong man was 〈◊〉 cast cut And the like power had not been so manifest before among the Sons of men * * 1 Kings 22. 24. †〈◊〉 5. 15. ‖ 〈◊〉 1◠〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a â—… * This Law of Deuteronomie holds true in proportion throughout al Ages If there arise among you a Prophet or a Dreamer of dreams and give thee a sign or wonder And the sign and the wonder which he hath told thee come to Passe saying Let us 〈◊〉 after other Gods which thâ—u hast not known and let us serve them Thâ—u shalt not â—eaâ—ken to the words of that Prophet or unto that Dreamer of dreams for the Lord your God proveth you to know whether ye love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul Deut. 13. 1. †1. Cor. 1. 26. * Phil. 2. 3. †1 Cor. 14. 32. That this 〈◊〉 â—… the 〈◊〉 should rather move all 〈◊〉 Christians to 〈◊〉 all in â—… 〈◊〉 of men then to rely upon any â—… 14. â—… Psal 119. 99. Heb. 3. 5. Psal 119. 100 * That our means for â—iscerning the â—â—â—ginal Causes oâ— O◠〈◊〉 of Conâ—…ns are fully â—â—ui â—aâ—â—nt to the Romish Churches †â—â—llaâ—miâ— lib. 3. de justif cap 3 4. c. disputes so eagerly against this Bishop as might have 〈◊〉 a Censurâ—â—f Irregulâ—…ty had â—e liâ—â—â— in his Diâ—â—esse ‖ Apostolica authoritate inhibemus omnibus tam Ecclesiasticis personis cujuscunque sint ordinis 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 qâ—â—m â—aiâ— is quocunque honore ac potestate praeditis Praelatis quidem sub interdicti ingressus Eccâ—… que â—uâ—rint sub eâ—communicationis latae sententiae poenis ne quis sine authoritate nostra audeat ullos 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 glosâ—â—s annotationes scholia ullumve omnino interpretationis genus super ipsius conciliâ— decretis quoâ—… aâ—â— quidquam quocunque nomine etiam sub praetextu majoris decretorum corroborationis aut executiâ—… â—… colore statuere Bullae Pij quarti super confirmatione oecum gener Concil Trident. * Maldoâ—atus censuâ—e of thâ—se men for dissenting as he thinks from their Church is so sharp and peâ—â—â—pâ—oâ—y as might well have caused Contention should his writings have come into their hands Impediunt nos quo â—inus acriter vehemeâ—ter invehamur in haereticos Catholici quidam qui nescio qua imprudentia hereticis se junxerunt Neminem nomino nâ—minem viâ—latae accuso religionis scio Catholicos scio doctos scio religiosos ac probos viros esse sed minimè profecto utilâ—m atque fidelem in hac re operam Ecclesiae navaverunt Quod contra Scripturae sensum contra Patrum omnium inter pretationem contra tacitum iâ—o minime tacitum sed satis superque explicatum consensum Ecclesiae dixerint atque contendeâ—int hoc loco de Sacramento non agi quod ut Benignissimè dicam est Temerarium gravioribus condemnarem verbis nisi crederem viros bene Catholicos Errore magis animi quam vitio in Haereticorum sententiam impegisse Maldonat Comment in sext Johan In this sense Christ is said to have come not to send Peace but a Sword unto the World That this very challenge of this insallible Authority of the Râ—mish Church for ending all Controversies â—â—th necessarily 〈◊〉 the greatest Diâ—…tion from it that can be in all relâ—giâ—us minds * â—… whether from the known or possible fruits of the Romish Churches Means so excellent as is pretended â—… Argument can be drawn to work a prejudicial conceipt in mens minds That it were â—… Authority to their Church before they come to direct examination of the main point what â—… Scriptures * See 〈◊〉 14 â—… 5 c. * Non ignoraâ—at dens multas in Ecclesia exorituras disâ—iculâ—ates circa fidem debuit igitur ju dicem aliqueÌ„ 〈◊〉 a providâ—◠〈◊〉 iste 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 non potest elle Scriptura neque Spirâ—aus revelans privatus neque princeps saecularis igâ—tur princeps Ecclesiasticus aut solus aut cerâ—e cum coÌ„silio coÌ„sensu Coepiscoporum Neque enim singitur neque singi potest aliquid aliud ad quod hoc judicium pertinere posse videatur Bellarm. lib. 3. de verbo Dei cap. 9. * Christs Church having by our Doctrine a most infallable written Law and living though but fallible Ecclesiastick Judges is much better provided 〈◊〉 in all matters Spiritual then Politick â—…ties whose Laws as wel as Judges are faluble in matters Câ—vil †The utmost Bounds of all Christian Obedience unto any Authority on earth is only to abide a peaceable â—ial before the lawful Judges patiently to imbrace the Penalty inslicted but not to think about Penalties soever they shall 〈…〉 cause for which 〈…〉 be just or such as shal staâ—â— for good in the day of final Judgement for so earthly Powers 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 absâ—lute Authority over our Souls which is Gods 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Our Adversaries go in t that a Prâ—viâ—cial Councel conjirmed by the Pope is as authentick as a General wherein be were presâ—â—t thâ—ugh a sâ—nt in the other 〈◊〉 acâ—quainted with particular Circumstances or carâ—â—ag of the Connoversie Much more availeable should a Popes Confirmation of such Councels be who were present and uel acquainted with all Occasions or other Circumstances of the Conâ—orersie or the Division Wherefore if Reason without Scripture might divide this Comrover sie it were more 〈◊〉 to have a many Popes as sâ—â—eralyâ—ce Statâ—â—o or Monarchies * Convenit etiam inter nos adversaries Sâ—… intelligâ— debere to Spiritu quo factae sunt id est Spiritu sancto Quod Apostolus Peâ—… Epist 2. cap. 1. doe et cum ait Ho◠〈◊〉 intelligentes quod omnis Prophetia Scripturae propria interpretatione non sit Non enim humana voluntate allata est aliquando Peopheâ—a sed Spirtu Sancto inspirati loquuti sunt Sancti Dei homines Ubi B. Petrus probat non debere exponi Scriptur as ex proptio ingenio sed secundum dictamen Spiritus Sancti quia non sunt scriptae humano ingenio sed ex inspiratione Spiritus Sancti Bel. lib. 3. de verb. Dei cap. 3. †2 Pet. cap. 1. vers 20. 21. ‖ Tota igitur quaestio in â—o posita est ubi sit iste Spiritus Nos enim existimamus hunc Spiritum etsi multis privatis hominibus saepe conceditur tamen cetto inveniri in Ecclesia id est in Concilio Episcoporum confirmato à summo Ecclesiae totius Pastore sive in sun mo Pastere cum Concilio aliotum Pastorum Bellarmin ibid. In this place as he professeth he will not dispute
before God had injoyned a General Silence throughout this Land that all might hearken more attentively unto the Criers voice appointed to prepare the wayes of the Lord after whose message once fully accomplished as it had been after the ringing of a Market-Bell every Mountebank throughout their coasts sets to sale the dreams and fancies of his own brain for Divine Prophecies 3 Lastly the Heathen in their most Sacred Traditions and matters of greatest consequence adde circumstances according to the occurrents of their own Times which suit no better with the Substance or Essence of their Ancestors Observations then a Pigmeies slipper with a Gyants Foot How shamefully doth the wanton Poets faign his Gods to long after such matters as he himself did most delightin The best end and use of his greatest Gods apparitions are oft times to accomplish beastly lust Divine truths are usually transformed into the Poets private affection Ovids description of Jupiters coming to Semele is not much unlike the manner of GODS passing by Eliah upon the mount and therefore not altogether unbeseeming the Majestie of the Great King if all circumstances were answerable to the substance of the description but it is brought to an absurd profane and foolish purpose So likewise Semeles petition unto Jupiter is but Moses his request unto God Effeminate and transformed in sundry circumstances to the Poets humour Moses Exod. 33 18. desired to see the Glory of the Lord and the Lord answered him Thou canst not see my Face for there shall no man see my Face and live Yet willing to confirm this his Servants Faith he condescends thus far to his suit Whilst my glory passeth by I will put thee into a cleft of the rock and will cover thee with mine hand whilst I passe by and thou shalt see my back-parts but my face shall not be seen Either from some mistaking of this place or from experience of others sodain death upon such apparition of the Divine Majestie as Moses and Elias by peculiar dispensation had escaped did that tradition spring which Manbah conceited so deeply Judg. 13. 22. And Manoah said unto his wife we shall surely die because we have seen God as Gideon had done likewise Judge 6. 22. Alas my Lord God for because I have seen the Angel of the Lord face to face I shall die This Tradition had come to Ovids hands who makes that Majestie which he had described to be so great so Improvident withall as to grant her foolish request on whom he doted to her utter ruine and so Impotent that he could not protect her albeit he strove to cover her with his hand and so finally neither the God could injoy his Love nor his best Beloved her Life Such are the consequences of latter Heathens greatest Miracles but in the Sacred Storie wherein are specified Events as strange as Poets relate any such causes are assigned of them as are more weighty and the manner of their relation more Grave and Serious then the Events are Rare if God at any time appear either in vision by night or corporal shape by day it is for some Extraordinary purpose All the Miracles or wonders wrought in Israel were to bring that people unto the knowledge of the true God to rely continually upon his Providence A matter more hard if we consider the frailty of our own flesh then the effecting of any Miracles reported to have been wrought for the Jews Why his Wonderful Works should be most frequent amongst this people this reason is as plain as probable from the End This people was placed as a Light unto all the Nations of the World besides They injoyed extraordinary prosperity that others might be allured to reverence them and Taste the Goodnesse of their God Their unusual Judgements and strange kind of Afflictions were as so many Proclamations unto the World to beware of like Rebellion seeing all the world was set on wickednesse and God had appointed a day wherein he would judge the world in righteousnesse necessary it was to set out a patern of his Mercie and Justice in some People and without wrong to any other it was His especial Favour to make choice of Abrahams seed for this purpose on whom he showred his mercies in greatest abundance whilst they were obedient and faithful in the works of Abraham but when they rebelled and vexed his holy Spirit then he turned to be their Enemie and he fought against them making them continual Examples of his unpartial Judgements as shall appear in the next Section SECT III. The Third Section of the Second general Part. Lib. 1. Containing Experiments drawn from the Revolution of States or Gods publick Judgements but especially of the Estate of the Jews from time to time OF all external Experiments the most Firm and solid for assuring the truth of these divine Oracles unto our soules are gathered from the Revolution of States or Gods Judgements upon several Lands and people In the observation of which the continual storie of the Jewish Nation doth best direct us The Intercourse of their particular afflictions before our Saviours time the maner of their Recoverie from them as from so many Spices of some grievous disease growing upon them The Epidemical disease which through every generation hants theirs since they desired our Saviours bloud to be upon them and their children are so many Probata or tried Experiments that these Celestial precepts containe the onley Method of preserving the Publick or private welfare of Mankind whose observations may cure whose neglect will breed all the miserie that can befall any people And this Method I would wish every Christian to follow First diligently to consider the State of the Iewes from time to time for it evidently confutes the Atheist and confirmes the Truth of the old Testament and the Truth of it established doth most evidently confute the Jew and witnesse the truth of the Gospel unto us as shall be proved God willing in due place CAP. XVIII Of the state of the Jews in General before our Saviours time with Tullies Objection against them 1 IT is storied of Alphonsus the Great that being sometime Prisoner to his Enemies he did so carry himself amongst them and prescribe them such Conditions for his release as might argue that they had overcome him only by Chance This was not so strange in a Prince so Famous and Venerable for the Integritie of his whole life and so Amiable in his cariage towards his Enemies A man as it were made to overcome and quel all the spightful malice or Base Intendments that could be devised against him by his Heroical open Heart and Bountiful Hand towards all and indefatigable Clemency even towards such as sought to outvie it by Ingratitude and just provocation of his heaviest displeasure But that the Jews a people whom others prejudicial conceipt of their peevish self-conceited Singularity raised from their strict observation of Laws
this come upon them that the Fulnesse of the Gentiles might come in With a more mightie hand hath God brought us out of the shadow of death and Dominions of Satan then he brought the Israelites out of Egypt out of the house of Bondage with a more powerful and harder stretched out Arm hath he scattered these Jews among all people from the one end of the world to the other then he brought the frogs flies and caterpillers into Egypt And it should be as a token in our hands and as frontlets between our childrens eyes that the Lord hath redeemed us through a mighty hand When Israel departed out of Egypt the Egyptian did not furnish him with weapons for his defence or Apologies for his departure These Jews scattered abroad are made such Messengers as Uriah was of their own destruction bearing records against themselves but sealed up from their sight holding Moses their chief Accuser in greatest Honour or to follow that faithful follower of Christ S. Augustine in his Similitude to this purpose although these Jews be desperately blind themselves yet they carry those Looking-glasses before them which long since put out their eyes by their too much gazing on them so as now they can hold them onely in their hands or turn their faces towards them not able to discern their misshapen visages in them but we Gentiles which come after them do herein go before them that we may clearly see their Deformity and Hideous blindnesse first caused by the glorious beams of the Divine Majestie shining in these sacred fountains whilest they used them as as Narcissus did his Well or little Babes do Books with fair Pictures only to solace themselves with representation of their Godly Forefathers Beauty set out in them in freshest colours not as Looking-glasses to discover much lesse to reform what was amisse in themselves whom they in the pride of their hearts still presumed to be in all points like their worthy Ancestors 8 If unto all their miseries throughout so many Ages we adde their perpetual Stupidity and Deadnesse of Heart to all works of the Spirit if to this again we adde their Incomparable Zeal and Courage in preserving the Letter of the Law and lay all unto our hearts what is it we can imagin the Lord could have none unto his vineyard that he hath not done to it He hath commanded the clouds not to rain upon the natural branches that the abundant fatness of the root might be wholly communicate to us Gentiles by nature wilde grafts He hath laid his vineyard in Israel waste and left the hill of Sion his wonted joy More desolate then the mountains of Gilboah that the dew of all his heavenly blessings might descend upon the vallies of the Nations Let us not therefore tempt the Lord our God in asking further Signs for confirmation of our Faith for no Sign can be given us Equivalent to this Desolation of the Jews Such as the dayes of Jerusalem were in her distresse such we know but how far more grievous we cannot conceive the Day of Judgement shall be even a Day of wrath and a Day of vengeance An end of dayes and an end of comfort a beginning of an endlesse night of sorrow troubles woe and miseries to the wicked Such as the condition of these Jews hath been for more then fifteen hundred years such shall the state of unbelievers be without end without all rest or securitie from danger disgrace and torture ten thousand times more dreadful and insufferable then what the others at any times have feared or felt What else hath been verified of them as in the Type must be fulfilled in unbelievers as in the Body or substance These shall fear both night and day and shall have no assurance of their life but in stead thereof an inevitable perpetuity of most grievous death In the morning they shall say Would God it were evening and at evening they shall say Would GOD it were morning and wish that Time might be no more or that no dayes of joy had ever been that all their mirth had been exchanged for sorrow even whilst it was first conceived within their breast that so no memory of sweet delights or pleasures past might adde gall unto the bitternesse of their present grief nor minister oyl unto that unquenchable flame wherein they frie. Thus much of Gods extraordinary mercies and judgements towards these Jews and of the Experiments which their Estate from time to time hath afforded for the establishing of our Assent to Scriptures 9 Particular judgements upon any Land or People as remarkable and perspicuous to common sense as heretofore have been we are not in this Age to expect The approach of this general and fearful judgement we may justly think doth swallow up the most of them as great plagues usually drink up all other diseases The conversion of these Jews we may probably expect as the chief Sign of later times onely this last part of Moses prophecy Leviticus chapter 26. 44. hath not been as yet fulfilled â—…ut must be in due time for so he saith Yet notwithstanding this even â—… the plagues and curses which he had threatned and we have seen fulâ—…d in these Jews when they shall be in the land of their enemies I will not cast them away neither will I abhor them to destroy them utterly and to break my covenant with them For I am the Lord their GOD But I will remember for them the Covenant of old when I brought them out of the land of Egypt that I might be their God I am the Lord. And the continuation of their former plagues seemeth much interrupted the plagues themselves much mitigated in this last Age since the Gospel hath been again revealed as if their misery were almost expired and the day of their redemption drawing nigh Yet would I request such as with me hold their general conversion before the end of all things as a truth probably grounded on GODS word not to put that evil day far from them as if it could not take them unawares unâ—l GODS promise to this people be accomplished For were that the point now in hand I could me thinks As probably gather out of Scriptures that their conversion shall be sodain As at all and such as many parts of the world shall not so soon hear of by Authentick reports or uncontroulable relation as sensibly see at our general meeting before our Judge 10 Like Experiments might be drawn from the Revolutions or Alterations of other states oft times wrought by such causes as are without the reach of Policie but most consonant to the Rules of Scriptures or from the Verification of such rules in Gods Judgements upon private persons But these observations cannot be made so evident to ordinary Readers before the doctrine of Gods providence be unfolded Wherefore I must refer them partly to that place partly to others of my Labours which have been most plentiful in this
privately conceive as evil but not more Authentick express then many Divine Precepts for obedience unto lawful Governours are As his Warrant was better so had his Action without it been more desperate then such as superiour powers usually impose upon inferiors The former Instance then was brought principally to mitigate the Rigour of their Preciseness who stifly maintain That no Obedience can legitimate such Actions as without it would be evil but all must be performed only in matters presupposed Good and Lawful or at least acknowledged for Indifferent unto Private Men before injoyned by Publick Authoritie The Contradictorie to which universal Negative appears most true in this particular Affirmative of Abrahams Resolution and Obedience from which we may further Argue thus As the immediate interposition of Divine Authority made that Action Holy and Religious which otherwise had been barbarously Impious so may the interposition of Authoritie derived from God make some Actions which barely considered would be apparantly Evil Desperate or Doubtful to be Honest Good and Lawful To beat one that is Sui Juris at his own disposition and in his right mind against or one that is not such with his Consent were insolent Wrong Because we have no Power over the one the other none over himself to Authorize such usage of his Bodie What would it be then in private Men to beat such as they know for Gods Embassadours though requested by them so to do when as the very Request might seem to argue some present Distemper or Distraction of Minde No doubt but he that refused to smite his Neighbour Prophet whether Elisha or some other the storie is in the first of Kings did not only pretend but truly had some scruple of Conscience left he should offend either that general Law of not doing Wrong unto his Neighbour or that peculiar Precept Do my Prophets no harm and yet for his Disobedience to the Prophets command became a Sacrifice to the Lion But he that took the Prophets Authoritie for his Warrant though he smote and in smiting wounded him yet did he not hurt his own Conscience a whit but rather by thus doing preserved it whole notwithstanding the former Precept of doing Gods Prophets no harm †To rifle a Spanish ship upon private Quarrels were Piracie in an English Navigator to kill a Spaniard Murther but suppose the Kings Majestie upon Wrong done by that Nation to our State not satisfied should grant his letters of Mart to rob them of their Goods were no Piracie to take away their Lives no Murther yet were the out ward Action in both Cases the same but the circumstances diverse and the partie that now undertakes it hath better Motives then before he had 4 Many Instances might be brought unto this purpose all evidently evincing thus much in general That sundry Actions which undertaken out of private Choice would be Wicked because we conceive in them some Evil without any conceit of possible good to set against it may by Injunction of publick Authority become Lawful to us because we have new Motives and better Warrants for to do them nor can our adventure upon such Actions be censured for Desperate as before it might well have been For first whilest Men of skill and judgement appointed by God to Advise in such Matters are otherwise perswaded then we in private are the Rule of Christian Modestie bindes us to suspect our own Perswasion and consequently to think there may be some Good even in that Action wherein heretofore we thought was not wherein as yet we our selves see none yet may safely perswade our selves that others see either more Good or lesse Evil. And unto this Perswasion we must adde this Consideration also That Performance of Obedience it self is a good and acceptable Action in the sight of God Or to come nearer the Point 5 The goodness of our sincere Obedience alone is not a Consequent only of the Action but either an essential part or such a Circumstance or Motive precedent as brings a new â—…ssence for it concomitant whereby the Evil which we out of private Perswasions fear may be countervailed as well as if we did conceive some good probably included in the very Object of the Action it self which might be equivalent to the Evil feared At the least then some Actions which privately we would avoid as altogether Evil may upon the former Motives be as lawfully undertaken as those which we hold as probably Good as Evil. 6 But as every Conceit of any Good is not sufficient to countervail all Conceit of Evil which may appear in the same matter so neither may all Authoritie countervail every private Perswasion in any man but the greater or more publick the Authoritie is the more should it prevail with all private Persons for the undertaking of such Actions as otherwise would seem Unlawful The like may be said of the danger or scandal which might arise from the Example of our Disobedience or non performance of Obedience The greater the Harm is likely to ensue such Neglect of Obedience the more we are bound to be lesse scrupulous in Obeying for these are not meer Consequents of the Action The Reason why men often mistake them for such is because they distinguish not between the real Harms themselves or scandalous Events which follow the Action and the serious Forecast of their Danger For as the Means are precedent to the real Assequution of the End and yet the Intention of the End doth alwayes go before the right Choice of Means and as it were seasons them for the Production of what we intend so albeit the real Events or Harms be meer Consequents yet the mature and prudent forecast of Danger likely to follow any Action or Resolution must be admitted into the Consultation precedent and ought to sway our Consciences according to every degree of their Probabilities unpartially conceived as wel as if we were as probably perswaded of so many degrees of inherent goodnesse in the Action it self or its essential Object For the Avoidance of any Evil equally probable is as good as the Attaining of an equal good If the danger which we justly fear may follow our Neglect of Obedience whether in things Forbidden or Commanded be as great as the Evil which upon like Probabilitie we conceive in the very Action it self it should make us as willing to do what we are Commanded as to refuse albeit we set apart the goodnesse which may arise from the meer Act of Obedience it self 7 That both goodnesse of meer Obedience as Obedience and also the danger of Evil likely to ensue our denial thereof are either Essential Parts of the Object or such Internal Motives precedent as may raise a new Form in the Action may be gathered from what hath been said afore of things Indifferent For the Injunction of Authoritie as none I think will deny makes things which to have done or not to have done was before Indifferent
now not to be such but Necessarie and good So as not only the Obedience is to be thought good but the very Action wherein Obedience is seen though before Indifferent is now inherently good and the Omission of it would be in it self Evil and not by Consequent only For Obedience either is or causeth a new Form or Essential Difference which doth as it were sublimate the outward Action to an higher Nature and Quality then it was capable of before For the same Reason may this goodnesse of Obedience and the due Consideration of Harms which may follow its Refusal make such Actions as before had been Evil for us out of private Resolutions to have undertaken not to be any more Evil but Good The Difficultie only is what private Doubts or Dislikes may be countervailed by publick Authoritie or what certain Rule may be given when they may and when they may not 8 General Rules in this Case are very hard to be given because the Circumstances may be many and divers The Authority may be greater or lesse so may their Dislike that are to perform Obedience be of the things enjoyned The Injunction likewise may be more or lesse Peremptorie Sometimes it may seem to resemble rather an Advice then absolute Command sometimes rather to Adjure then Command Sometimes the Parties in Authority may be of lesse and the parties of whom Obedience is exacted of greater Reach and deeper Insight in those matters whereunto Obedience is enjoyned according to the Diversitie of the Subject of Obedience which sometime may be such wherein men of Experience or Practice are to be most Believed wherein Concurrence of Judgements and Multitude of Voices may argue more Truth Sometimes the Subject of Obedience may be matters of abstruse Speculation wherein one man of profound Judgement is more to be Believed then five hundred but of ordinarie Capacitie For as things Visible but far Distant so matters of abstruse Speculation cannot be discerned by multitude of Eyes but by clearnesse of Sight and as he that could discern ships in the Carthaginian from the Lilibaean haven saw more then all Xerxes Armie could in like Distance so doth it oft fall out that some one profound Judicious Contemplator sees clearly that Truth which all the Wits of the same Age had not been able without him to discover Such men may sin in obeying Authority whereunto others in yeelding Obedience sin not because they can discern the Unlawfulnesse of the Command it self better than others But unlesse a man can justly plead this or some other like peculiar Reason or Priviledge it is a very suspitious and dangerous Case to Disobey lawfull Authority whether Spiritual or Temporal in such matters as he thinks others of his own Rank may with safe Conscience Obey or in such matters whereunto he sees many men by his own Confession of great Judgement and Integrity of Life yeelding Obedience with alacritie For if thus he think of them he cannot but suspect himself and his Perswasions of Error nay he cannot be otherwise perswaded but that the Commandment or publick Injunction of Authority is not absolutely against Gods Commandment for so it could not be Obeyed with safe Conscience by men of Skil and Integrity And this I take to be the safest general Rule that can be given in this Case Not to consider the particular Matters enjoyned with such of their Circumstances or Consequences as we out of our private Imaginations conceive or fear so much as the general Form of publick Injunction as it indistinctly concerns All. If we can truly discern the Law or publike Act it self to be against Gods Law and such as will lay a Necessitie upon us of transgressing Gods Commandements if we yeeld Obedience to particulars enjoyned by it Our Apostles have already answered for us It is better to Obey God then Men. Christ had commanded them to preach the Gospel The Priests and other Governours forbid them to preach Christ Here was a Contradiction in the Lawes themselves But GOD Commands us to Obey the Powers ordained by him and their Commandements are particular Branches of Gods General Commandements for this purpose and he that Disobeyeth them Disobeyeth God unlesse their Commandements be contrary to some other of Gods Commandements And it is a Course as preposterous as dangerous to Disobey Authority because we dislike the things Commanded by it in respect of our selves or upon some Perswasion peculiar to us not common to All. For seeing Obedience is Gods expresse Commandement yea seeing We can no more Obey than Love God whom we have not seen but by obeying our Superiours whom we have seen True Spiritual Obedience were it rightly planted in our hearts would bind us rather to like Well of the things Commanded for Authorities sake than to Disobey Authority for the private dislike of them Both our Disobedience to the one and Dislike of the other are unwarrantable unlesse we can truly derive them from some formal Contradiction or Opposition betwixt the publick or general Injunction of Superiours and expresse Law of the most High 9 It will be replied That albeit the general Form of publick Injunction be not absolutely Unlawful nor the things enjoyned for this reason essentially or necessarily Evil yet are these most Unexpedient and may be grand Occasions of great Evil. He that is thus Perswaded might as far as became his Place disswade any Publike Act concerning such Matters and yet withall was bound to consider whether the Want of such an Act might not Occasion as great Evils as he fears may follow the Practise of such Obedience as it commands or whether other might not as probably foresee some equivalent â—ood which he sees not But after such Acts are publickly made and Obedience duely demanded he that denies it upon fear onely of some Evil that may follow doth give great Occasion to others of Committing that Evil which he himself by this Refusal certainly Commits he opens the gap to that Capital Mischief of publike Societies Anarchie and Disobedience In Doubts of this Nature it will abundantly suffice to make sincere Protestation in the sight of God or if need require before Men that we undertake not such Actions upon any private liking of the things enjoyned but onely upon sincere respect of performing Obedience to Superiours whom God hath appointed to make Lawes for Us but not Us to appoint them what Lawes they should make nor to Judge of their Equity being made save onely where the Form of the Commandement is contrary to some of Gods Commandements so as the particulars enjoyned become therby essentially and necessarily Evil. In such Case the Lawes of Superiours are already Judged and Condemned by Gods Law by which whilest they stand Uncondemned they shall condemn us for Disobedience both to Gods Lawes and Them albeit we stand in Doubt whether that which they enjoyn would not be most unlawfull for us to do if we were left unto our Private Choyce
so great let him tell his flock for whose Souls he must answer that they must do Thus and Thus if they will be saved they can be diligent perhaps to hear him and say he spake exceeding well i. e. Very ill of others as they conjecture but not of them or their Adherents If for his good Lessons in the Pulpit he have good words returned at Table he seeth the best fruits of his labour For if one of his Flock shall have an advantage against his Neighbour or have picked a Quarrel with his Lease or let a Gentleman be disposed to put off his Tenants or inhance their Rents to their utter undoing let any gengle or mean have but good hope to make his own great Gain by some others Losse Here if we trie him and charge him upon his Allegiance unto Christ to remit his Hold to let go all Advantage and be good unto his Fellow-servant or poor Brother these are matters the Minister must meddle no more with than an other man the Law can determine whether he do Right or Wrong and this Case belongs properly unto the Lawyer As if the Power of Gods Spirit or Authority of his Ministers did consist onely in Words and required no other Obedience than a formal speculative Assent unto their general Doctrine not a full Resignation of mens Wills or heartie Submission of Affections unto such Rules as they shall prescribe for the preservation of a good and upright Conscience in particular Actions or entercourse of Humane Affairs Or if one of a thousand will be so good as to grant that he is to Obey the Precepts of Christ before the Customes of our Common-Law or other Civil Courts yet even the best of such when it comes to Points of private Commoditie will dispense with his Pastor and replie I would do as you admonish me if I saw any expresse Command for it in Gods Word or any evident Necessity that should bind me to renounce that Right which Law doth give me but for ought I can perceive I may prosecute my Right in this present Case with a safe Conscience and you do not know all particular Circumstances which belong unto this matter if you did or were in my Case I am perswaded you would be of my Mind This although it be the onely shelter under which the Infidelitie of later Ages takes its rest the onely Dormitory wherein Hypocrisie sleeps profoundly and never dreams of further Danger yet is it a most sillie Excuse and shamelesse Apologie in the judgement of any that knows or knowing rightly esteems the Principles of Christianitie For suppose thou see no Evidence that Christ hath commanded thee to confesse his Name in this particular doth the law lay any necessity upon thee to make thee prosecute thy supposed Right If it did charge thee upon pain of Death so to do thou hast some pretence to Obey it albeit thou shouldest fear him more that could Condemn thee and the Interpreters of it to everlasting Death but the Law doth leave it to thy Choise whether thou wilt use the Benefit of it or no and thy Pastour upon penaltie of incurring Christs displeasure commands thee that thou use it not Thou repliest Thou seest no Evidence that Christ Commands thee But dost thou absolutely and infallibly know that he doth not call thee at this time to trie thy Obedience in this Particular If thou canst out of sincerity of Heart and Evidence of Truth fullie inform thy Conscience in this Negative so the End of thy proceedings be good thou maist be the bolder to disclaim thy Pastours Summons If thou canst not how wilt thou answer thy Judge when thou shalt appear before him why thou out of the Stubbornnesse of thy Heart didst more respect thy private Gain than his heaviest displeasure For suppose thy hope of Gain were great as it is usually to such as thou art more great than certain yet cannot the greatnesse and certaintie of it countervail the least danger of incurring His Wrath nor could the certaintie of worldly Gain counterpoise much lesse oversway the least surmise or probabilitie of incurring thy Souls destruction unlesse thy Mind had been set more on Gold than upon thy God more enclined to private Commoditie and Self-love than unto Christ thy Redeemer Or shall thy answer stand for good in his sight when thou shalt say unto his Messenger It is more then I know that Christ Commands me Then should the damned be justified at the Day of Judgement when they shall truly replie they knew not that ever Christ did supplicate unto them sub forma panperis Most of them we may safely swear had lesse Probabilities to Believe this in their life time than thou hast now to perswade thee of this particular although thy Pastours Authoritie and frequent Admonitions were set aside which make thee so much the more Inexcusable For thou mightest have known by him that God had Commanded thee as much unlesse thy bad Desires had made thee Blind But neither shall theirs or thy Ignorance herein help For Ignorance which is bred of bad Desires corrupt Affections or greedy Appetites brings forth hardnesse of Heart and Infidelity so that seeing thou shalt not see and hearing thou shalt not hear nor understand the Warnings for thy Peace because thou hast formerlie shut thine ears at thy Pastors Admonitions or Raged at his just Reproof And the Law of God binds thy Soul upon greater penaltie and better hopes than all Laws in the World besides could bind thy Bodie even upon of everlasting Life and penaltie of everlasting Death to lay aside all Selfe-love all worldlie Desire for the finding out of the true sense and meaning of it as well as to Obey it when thou knowest it And when any point of Doctrine or Practise either in general or particular is commended to thee by thy Pastour Gods Word doth bind thee to search with all Sobrietie and Modestie the Truth and force of all Motives Inducements or Probabilities which he shall suggest unto thee all private respect laid aside lest thou become a partiall Judge of evil thoughts and if thou canst not find better Resolution it binds thee to relie upon his Authoritie And even in this again Gods Word so perfect a Rule is it doth rule thy thoughts to discern the Fidelitie Sinceritie or Authoritie of thy Teacher Unto such as approve themselves as Saint Paul did to every mans Conscience in the sight of God or to such as make not a Merchandize of the Word of God but speak in Christ as of sinceritie and as of God in the sight of God Christian People are bound to yeeld greater Obedience Generallie unto such as in their Lives expresse those Characters of faithfull Dispensers set down by Saint Paul and other Pen-men of Gods Word everie Auditor is bound to yeeld greater Obedience than unto others in Points wherein he hath no other Motives to Believe beside his Pastors Authority For this is a dictate of
of Scriptures unto some and Facility and Perspicuity unto others of like Profession cannot justly impeach them of greater Obscurity then befits the infallible rule as wel of theirs as of all other mens Faith in their several Vocations For as mens Callings are divers and Gods Gifts to men in their divers Callings in nature and qualitie different so likewise is the Measure of his like gifts to men in the same calling not one and the same To some he gives more Knowledge to others lesse yet all he commands not to presume above that which is Written and every man to limit his desires of knowing that which is Written by the distinct Measure of Gods Gifts in himself not to affect or presume of such skil as they have unto whom God hath given a greater Talent And besides this that the Scripture is the inexhaustible store-house â—hence all men have their several Measures of Divine Knowledge as wel he that hath most as he that hath least even in this again it is a perfect rule that it commands all sapere idque ad sobrietatem to be wise according to that Measure of Knowledge which God hath given them and not to seek to know at least not to say why should I not know as much as any other of any Profession For this were Pride and Arrogancie the fatal enemies of all true Christian Knowledge if so his Gifts be lesse then others And for the avoidance of these main Obstacles of Christian Knowledge or true Interpretation of Scriptures the Scripture hath commanded every man to think better of others than of himself and not to be wise in his own conceit 12 From the former General will follow this Particular Albeit some Parts of Scripture be very obscure unto some the same perspicuous unto other Ministers or Preachers of the Word yet may the whole Canon be the infallible Rule of Faith unto both according to the diverse Measure of their Gifts rightly and unpartially taken If the one either fail in the Exposition of sundrie Places which the other rightly expounds or cannot apprehend so much in them as the other doth he is in Sobriety of Spirit bound to acknowledge his own Infirmitie and content himself with that knowledge which is contained within the Measure of Gods Gifts bestowed upon himself and this again he is to take by the same Rule So that the Scriptures are a perfect Rule to both to all for Direction in the search of Divine Knowledge for limitation of mens desires whiles they seek it or Conceit of what they have gotten That they do not so thorowly instruct or furnish some as others though all men of God for exact performance of their Ministerial function can be no argument of their Insufficiencie to make all such in their Place and Order competently Wise unto Salvation more than it would be to prove Eâ—clides Elements or other more absolute Mathematical Work an insufficient and imperfect Rule for instructing Surveyours or other Practical Mathematicians whose skill lies onely in measuring Triangles Circles or other plain or solid Bodies because containing many Questions of higher Nature and greater Difficultie as of the Circles Quadrature of Lines or Numbers Surd or Asymmetral well befitting the exercise of speculatorie learned Mathematical Wits CAP. XIII The true state of the Question about the Scriptures Obscurity or Perspicuity unto what Men and for what Causes they are Obscure 1 THe Question then must be Whether the Scriptures be an absolute Rule of Christian Faith and Manners to every Man in his Vocation and Order according to the Measure of Gods Gifts bestowed upon him We affirm It is such to all None are so cunning none so excellent or expert in Divine Mysteries but must take it for a Rule beyond whose Bounds they may not passe from which they daily may learn more none so sillie but may thence learn enough for their Salvation so they will be Ruled by it And yet even of those Points which are perspicuously set down to the diverse Capacities of Men in the same or several Professions the Question is not Whether any can fully comprehend their intire Meaning Certain it is In this life they cannot But neither will our Adversaries I hope avouch that the infallible Authoritie of their Church can make us so comprehend the full meaning of Mysteries contained either in Scriptures or her pretended unwritten Traditions Of Scriptures the best learned Christian may say wth the Heathen Socrates Hoc unum scio me nihil scire I know this one thing that I know nothing Nothing as I should or as fully as I then shall when I shall know as I am known for in this life we know but in part and we propâ—… in part 2 Lastly even in respect of Places though containing Points of Salvation onely thus imperfectly known though as perspicuous and clear as can be required the Rule of Faith should be the Question is not whether they be very Obscure and Difficult unto some or unto the Major part of Mankind if we consider them as they are or may be not as they should or might be that is if we consider them as disobedient to the Truth known or carelesse to amend their lives by this light of Scripture For unto all such as hate it this very light it self proves an occasion of falling Nor could any thing be more plainly or perspicuously set down in any other Rule of Faith imaginable than this very Point we now handle is in Scriptures to wit that such Parts of them as contain matters necessary to Salvation are most easie to some most hard to others And albeit they might through the Iniquity of Mankind prove difficult to all or impossible to be understood of most now living living as for the most part we do yet were this Difficultie or Impossibilitie of understanding them aright upon these Suppositions no hindrance at all why they should not be a complete Rule of Faith to all no just reason for admitting any infallible Authority besides theirs 3 For of such as admit any Authority equivalent to theirs it must be further demanded whether the Infallibilitie of it can take away that Blindnesse of heart which by Gods just Judgement lights upon all such as detain the knowledge of God or his sacred Word in Unrighteousnesse If for their sins God punish them with this spiritual darknesse in discerning his Will revealed in his written Word no other infallible Authority as we suppose can take away those scales from their eyes which hinder their sight in the means of their Salvation If men have been called to this Light and prefer Darknesse before it either they must receive sight and direction from it again or continue still in ignorance and the shadow of death but doth God look up all or most mens eyes in such darknesse No for this blindnesse by our Doctrine befals onely such as have deserved it by the forementioned sins which once removed by Repentance the
These Hereticks some of you I imagin would say albeit they might pretend Scriptures for the Rule of Faith yet would not be ruled by Scriptures when they were evidently brought against them For your evidence of Scripture to prove these Points there mentioned we know them well enough for some of them you professe Tradition only CAP. XXII That our Adversaries Objections do not so much infringe as their Practise confirms the Sufficiency of Scriptures for composing the greatest Controversies in Religion 1 BUt suppose many Hereticks your selves for example will not submit their minds unto the Evidence of Scripture what Remedy who can help it Their Condemnation is just and Vengeance is Gods he will repay Man it behooveth to see evidently that they contemn or abuse Scripture before he adventure to iinflict Punishment upon them for it lest otherwise he become an intruder into the Almighties Tribunal But if the Evidence of Scripture will not what else shall recall such from Errour 2 Besides the former general Allegations let us see what more can be said why the Scriptures may not be the most effectual and infallible Rule that can be imagined to guide men in the way of Truth The Authority saith Valentian ordained by God for determining all Questions of Faith is without all question most apt to discern and prevent all Errours contrary to Faith Why may not the Authority of Scripture be accounted such The Scripture saith be is so framed yet was it God that framed it as Experience may also teach us that of it self alone it is so far from being a fit Rule for avoiding all Errours that by the secret judgement of God it is a stumbling Block and as a Snare to the feet of the unwise so that such as will rely upon it alone may soon trip or trâ—â—â— awry 3 The Reader must lay the Blame where it is due if these indefatigable mouthes of blasphemies reiterating the like absurd Impieties so oft enforce me often to oppose the same or like Answers to them Such an Occasion as Gods Creatures were of Idolatry the Scriptures we grant may be of Heresie For of Gods good Creatures wherewith the idolatrous Heathen polluted themselves the wise man speaks in that place whereto Valentian alludes And such an Occasion should this infallible Way of the Romish Church pretended for avoiding be of breeding Heresies were it any of Gods Wayes of which the wise son of Syrach saith indefinitely They are stumbling Blocks to the wicked so was the Way of Life the Gospel it self even whilest proposed and avouched by S. Peter and S. Paul The Question then must be For what Cause the Scriptures are a Snare to some mens feet because they admit and embrace them for their Rule of Life If thus either Valentians Ghost or any Jesuite now alive dare avouch I say no more then the Archangel said to Satan The Lord rebuke thee Only unto the unwise and wilfully wicked because Such the Mediator and Saviour of the world Salus ipsa Salvation it Self was a Stone of offence and unto all such not Scripture nor any of Gods Wayes serves as a Rule to save but to condemn them 4 This is the Article then upon which the Jesuite must once again be examined whether unto such as are by Gods just Judgements decreed to Destruction and given over by his Holy Spirit to believe Lies and follow lying Traditions or Fables of mans invention the Popes infallible Authority can be a Rule of Life or saving Faith If it can then we will grant it to be a more infallible Rule then Scripture because able to controul Gods immutable Decree if it cannot as none without open and presumptuous Blasphemy will say it can then is it no more effectual for to reclaim men from Errours then the Scriptures are nor doth it any wayes supply their want If they will not believe Moses and the Prophets saith our Saviour neither will they be perswaded though one were raised from the dead why So Because God hath decreed this Word as the onely Means of Salvation to such as have been partakers of it and such as refuse this are given over by his Spirit to the Stubbornnesse of their own hearts shall then the Popes Infallibility make such believe By what Means Are his words more effectual then the Words of Life Are his Buls able to withstand the Decrees of the Almighty Or are his Curses to the disobedient more terrible then the everlasting Woes pronounced by our Saviour Christ and his Prophets more piercing then the Relation of Hell-pains by a messenger from the dead By your Churches continual Practise I should guesse this would be your reply for there is no other left that the Pope can constrain men to subscribe to his Decrees by Fire and Sword This might command their Hands or Tongues but not their Minds For the Jesuites would teach such as feared the smart of their fleshly members to cosen their Conscience for saving their Bodies with this distinction Juravi linguâ mentem injuratam gero And if fire and sword be the best Weapons of spiritual Warfare or unrelenting Persecutions the ensigns of infallible Authority then the greater Tyrants may be alwayes the more infallible Teachers But these Weapons by your best writers consent ye may not use against any but such as are already admitted into Christs Fold Quae foris sunt judicabit Deus Such as are without God will judge The Pope may such as are within in what manner for what Cause he please not liable to any account whether in so doing he do right or wrong Let the fruits of our Practise then witnesse whether what is by you objected to us for using our Saviours language may not by fit Analogie be verified of your selves in this point whether We or Ye be the men of whom our Saviour gave the world warning when he told Of false Prophets outwardly appearing in sheeps clothing being inwardly ravening Wolves Unto such as are by us won to the Gospel we grant that Christian Liberty after which before their Conversion we promised Your Factors abroad as in the Indies or Japan appear to men in sheeps cloathing making fair promises of the glorious Gospel of Christ and the Liberty of the Son of God but inwardly as in Italy Spain or generally within your own Folds are ravening Wolves Or to sit you with an Emblem essentially parallel to your nature and custome ye are 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 inversi Men abroad and Wolves at your own home For whiles you seek to convert an Alien you magnifie the Doctrine of the Gospel your speech is fair your whistle pleasant and your feeding sweet and good if ye mention the Popes Authority it is moderately and urged in that stile 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Peter feed my lambs but when ye have once drawn these lambs within your hurdles ye change your note and turn into your proper shape then you cry with
challenge another as free and absolute as himself for his Tributarie or Vassal and traduce him for a seditious member of Christendome because he would not compose the Quarrel thus injuriously sought with the surrender of his Crown and Dignitie 3 Princes may conclude a Peace for civil and free commerce of their People though professing sundry Religions and they and their Clergie might perhaps procure a mitigation of some other Points now much in Controversie but Though all others might yet This admits no terms of parly for any possible Reconcilement The natural Separation of this Island from those Countries wherein this Doctrine is professed shall serve as an everlasting Emblem of the Inhabitants divided hearts at least in this Point of Religion and let them O Lord be cut off speedily from amongst us and their Posterity transported hence never to enjoy again the least good thing this Land affords let no print of their Memory be extant so much as in a tree or stone within our Coast or let their Names by such as remain here after them be never mentioned or alwayes to their endlesse shame who living here amongst us will not imprint these or like Wishes in their hearts and daily mention them in their Prayers Littora littoribus contraria fluctibus undas Imprecor arma armis pugnent ipsique nepotes Which words though uttered in another case applied to this sound thus much to all wel-affected English or Brittish ears Let our and for ain Coasts joyn battel in the Main Ere this foul blasphemy Great Brittain ever stain Where never let it come but floating in a floud Of ours our nephews and their childrens childrens bloud 4 The Leaven of the Pharisees whereof our Saviour willed his Disciples to beware was sweet Bread in respect of this pestiferous Dough whose poison is so diffused througout the whole Body and Masse of Romish Religion as it hath polluted every parcel therein and makes even those particular Points to be damnable in modern Papists which in the Ancient holding them from other Grounds were pardonable Such as held a kind of Purgatorie or third Place after this life Evangelical Counsels Invocation of Saints or the like because they thought the Scripture taught them were deceived in these particular Scriptures but yet reserved their faithful Allegiance to Gods Word in general Nay even those particular Errours and mistakings of the sense of Scriptures were witnesses and pledges of their Obedience unto the Scripture or Word of God when they therefore Believed them because they were immediately perswaded in Conscience that the Scriptures the Rule of their Conscience did teach them But while you hold the same Opinions not because you are perswaded in Conscience immediately ruled by Scripture that they are contained in Scripture but because the Church which as ye suppose cannot erre doth teach them or to speak more plainly whiles you your selves either Believe or teach others to Believe them or the Scriptures concerning them because the Church whose Authoritie in this and all other Cases you acknowledge for the infallible Rule of your Faith commands you so to do you hereby openly renounce your own and sollicit the the people to alienate their Allegiance from God and his Word and the passing over or yielding up of stedfast and absolute Assent unto any particular Point in your Religion upon these Grounds is as evident a witnesse of high Treason committed against GOD by the partie thus believing a swearing of that Fealtie or Allegiance to a pretended Vicegerent or Deputy which is only due to the Prince himself would be in a natural and sworn subject Wherefore the supposed Infallibility of your Church is no such excellent Means of taking up all Controversies if your meaning be in the former sense proposed For it is so far from taking up all that it puts an Imposibility of having any betwixt you and as taken up unlesse you abjure it quite for it makes all the rest of your Opinions deadly to such as stedfastly Believe it or for it them 5 Your meaning then must be That this Infallibility of your Church would be an excellent Means for taking up all Controversies if all men would subscribe unto it Indeed I must confesse there would soon be an end of all or rather no controversies should ever be begun if every man would resolve with himself not to dissent from others but let them hold what they list he would hold the very same or if all men would bind themselves to abide some one Mans or a Major part of some few or more determinate persons Determinations without more ado In this case one might say of his Judge He shall determin for me and another might reply nay but for my Opinion the third might say He shall judge as I will have him and the fourth reply or rather as I will and yet never a one dissent from other but all agree All of them might have the Judges Sentence at as absolute command as the Shepheard had the Weather For every one might have him determin as he pleased because all of them were fully resolved to be pleased with whatsoever he should determin If you dream of such an Unitie in Faith or such a manner of composing Contentions it must be further disputed whether this were not an open Dissention or solemn Compact for moving a general Apostasie from the true Faith And they that labour for such an Union in points of Faith and Salvation do in effect solicite the whole Christian world to run hand in hand but head-long into open Insidelitie lest perhaps by breaking companies some might slide into Schisms and Heresies Should the Ramists and Aristotelians or generally all the Professors of Secular Arts and Sciences in our Universities bind themselves under penaltie of Expulsion or by solemn Vow never to swerve from the Bedle of beggers or John-a-dogs his determinations and resolutions in any point of Logick Philosophie or Metaphysicks would this be a sweet match to take up all Controversies or Contentions between Colledge and Colledge in our Schools were this so excellent a way to retain the Unitie of the Truth and skill in those Faculties or rather the only readie way to make all bond-slaves to Errour Ignorance and Falshood And yet might we with more safety delegate greater Authority in these cases to every one then we may to any living in matters of Faith and Religion over which or over our selves in respect of which we have no lawful Power or Authority For this and other Reasons should we be more afraid to subscribe unto any mortal mans Authority as unto a Judge most absolute and infallible whose decrees we may not resist from whose Sentence we may not appeal in matters of Faith then to refer our seves wholly unto the sole Judgement of the meerest natural Fool living in matters of secular Learning and natural Knowledge For besides the danger hence accrewing to our selves GOD our Creator Christ our Redeemer and the Holy
his Apostles was THat the Church of Rome doth advance her decrees above the laws and ordinances of the Almighty her words that in this kind is called Gods above all divine Oracles written and unwritten is apparant out of their own positions hitherto discussed yet is this but the first degree of great Antichrists Exaltation 〈◊〉 second is the exalâ—â—ng the Popes above any personal authority that ever was either practised or established on earth This in brief is the assertion which by Gods assistance we are in this present section to maâ—e evident The authority which the Jesuites and Jesuited Priests give and would bind others upon pain of damnation to give unto the present Church or Pope throu 〈◊〉 every age is greater then any authority that ever was challenged since the world began by any man or visible company of men the man Christ Jesus not excepted This conclusion followeth immediately out of three Positions generally held and stifly maintained by that Church The first that the Pope live he as he list cannot erre in matters of faith and manners when he speaketh ex Cathedra that we are bound infallibly to believe whatsoever he so speaks without examination of his doctrine by Gods word or evident external sign or internal Experiment of Gods spirit speaking in him The second that we cannot assure our selves the Scriptures are the Oracles of God but by the infallible testimony of the Visible Church The third that the true sense and meaning of Scriptures in cases doubtful or controversed cannot be undoubtedly known without the infallible declaration of the same Church CAP. XI What restraint precepts for obedience unto the Priests of the Law though 〈◊〉 ing most universal for their Form did necessarily admit And how universal Propositions of Scriptures are to be limited 1 SEing we undertake to prove that no such authority as the Romish Church doth callenge was ever established on earth The answering of those arguments drawn from the authority of the Priests in the old Testament may to the judicious seem at the first sight needlesse yet because such as they set the fairest glosses upon if we look into the inside or substance are fullest fraught with their own disgrace and ignominy It wil not be superfluous to acquaint the Reader with some particulars prefixing some general admonitions to the younger sort for more commodious answering of all that can be brought of like kind 2 Their common places of cozening the world especially smatterers of Logick or school learning with counterfeit proofs of Scripture is either from some universal precept of obedience given to the people or general promises of infallibility made to the Priests in the old Testament Such as come unto the Scriptures having their mind dazled with notionâ— of universale primum or other Logick rules true in some cases think the former precepts being for their form universal may admit no exception limitation or restraint otherwise the holy Ghost might break the rule of Logick when as they admit many restraints not alwayes from one but oft-times from divers reasons from these following especially God sometimes injoyns obedience as we say in the Abstract to set us a pattern of such true accurate obedience as men should perform unto authority it self or unto such governours as neither in their lives nor in the Seat of judgement would decline either to the right hand or to the left but square all their proceedings to the exact rule of Gods word Unto such governours continual and compleat obedience was to be performed because the 〈◊〉 governed upon examination should alwayes find them jump with the law of God unto which absolute obedience as hath been shewed is due Nor doth the word of God in setting out such exact obedienc lie open to that exception which Politicians take against Philosophers as if it as Philosophers do did give instructions only for happy men of Aristotles making or for the Stoicks wise men who can no where be found but in Plato's common-wealth whose Metropolis is in the Region of Eutopia For the ancient Israel of God had this prerogative above all the nations of the earth that their Priests lips whilest they themselves were clothed with righteousness and bare holinesse unto the Lord in their breasts should still preserve knowledge and be able to manifest the wil of God unto the people not only by interpreting the general written law but by revelations concerning particular facts of principal moment as may be gathered from that law Also thou shalt put in the breast-plate of judgement the Urim and the Thummim which shall be upon Aarons heart when he goeth in before the Lord And Aaron shall bear the judgement of the children of Israel upon his heart before the Lord continually 3 To omit the various interpretations and divers opinions of this Brest-plates use why it was called the Breast-plate of Judgement Josephus and Suidas in my mind come nearest the truth That the Revelation by it was Extraordinary that Gods presence or Juridical approbation of doubts proposed was represented upon the pretious stones that were set therein is probable partly from the aptnesse of it to allure the Israelites unto Idolatry partly from that formality which the Egyptians in imitation of the Ephods ancient use amongst the Jews retained long after in declaration of the truth in Judgement For Diodorus tels us that the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or chief Judg in that Famous and venerable Egyptian high Court or Parliament did wear about his neck in a golden chain Insigne a Tablet of pretious stone or if the Reader be disposed to correct the Translator 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 which they called as the Septuagint did Aarons Breast-plate 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 on which he stedfastly looked while matters were debating as Suidas saith the High Priest did on his Breast-plate whilest they asked counsel of God and whilest he gave Sentence turned it unto the better cause exhibited as the fashion was in that Court in writing iâ— sign the Truth it self did speak for it That the Urim or Thummim were more then an Emblem yea an Oracle of Justice and right Judgement is apparant out of Scripture When Josâ—… was consecrated to be Israels chief Governour in Moses stead he was to stand before Fleazar the Priest ordained to ask counsel for him by the Judgement of Urim before the Lord So did Abiathar certisie David of Sauls malitious resolution against him and the Lords of â—eilahs treachery if he should trust unto them So again David is assured of victory by the judgement of Urim and Thummim if he would follow the Amalekites that had burnt Zâ—klâ—g 4 Such Priests as these were to be absolutely obeyed in answers thus given from the mouth of God And it is most probable that the parties whom these answers did concern had perfect notice of the Revelation made to the Priests howsoever the truths of such answers being confirmed by Experiment in those
repugnant to the end of this Precept were forbidden The end of the Sabbath was to sanctifie themselves unto the Lord to set forth his praise both in words and works Such works then onely are here forbidden as did distract the mind or make men unapt to hear read or meditate on heavenly matters all works of secular vocation or private consequence which might hinder mens endeavours for procuring the health or wel-fare of others not works of charity or present necessity not works tending to greater publick good or to the avoidance of greater harmes which could not be prevented but by present working for men are to read hear and meditate upon Gods Word that by it they may be fruitfull in good deeds by which Gods Name is more immediately glorified then onely by speaking well and not doing so Wherefore oru Saviour Christ did better observe the Sabbath by working upon it to save mens lives or recover their health then the Pharisees did by abstaining from such works of mercy as might have glorified Gods Name more immediately then any speculative or precise Rules how it should be kept Yea by not working these good works when fair occasion was offered they did the works of Satan even murther it self as our Saviour Christ implies in that question proposed unto the Scribes and Pharisees which sought an accusation against him I will ask you a question whether it is lawfull on the Sabbath dayes to do good or to do evil to save life or to destroy it 9 The like limitations this precept had in case of necessity or for the avoidance of some great extraordinary calamity not otherwise avoidable then by doing such works as upon ordinary and daily occasions were unlawfull to be done upon the Sabbath day It was an opinion received as it seems amongst the Jews that they might not fight nor build the breaches or places whereby their enemies did hope for entrance upon the Sabbath In this perswasion about the number of a thousand Jewes did lay down their lives But when Matthias heard of this his people and Countrey mens massacre more general then it needed to have been but for this their strict and precise interpretation of the former general commandment he and his friends wisely resolved Whosoever should come to make battell with us upon the Sabbath day we will fight against them that we die not all as our brethren that were murdered in the secret places Which they might have stopped but would not for fear of violating the Sabbath The reason of this their resolution contained in the 40 verse was most strong drawn from the end of the Sabbath For they said one to another If we all do as our brethren have done and fight not against the Heathen for our lives and for our Lawes then shall they incontinently destroy us out of the earth And if the whole Jewish Nation had been at that time utterly rooted out who should either have sanctified Gods Sabbaths or preserved his Lawes from the injurie of times or fury of the Heathen Nature had taught the Heathen that it was foolish propter vitam vivendi perdere causas much more might religious discretion teach all men how preposterous a course it were for the precise keeping of one to crosse or overthrow the end of all Sabbaths 10 Yet our Adversaries I am sure cannot bring any precept so peremptory or general for absolute obedience unto the High Priests and Governours as the former was for not working upon the Sabbath And yet this we see â—…ts restraint from the End and holds onely absolutely true in certain kind of works not in all The like restraint either from the End or from the Circumstances may all those places likewise suffer which seem to be most general for absolute obedience unto Gods messengers or spiritual governours 11 The end of obeying Gods messengers is that men thereby may obey God himself Suppose then God had said Thou shalt obey the Priest in all things whatsoever he shall command thee A Wise man not withstanding all this would thus resolve Suppose the Priest command me to do that in doing which I shall disobey God or to omit that continually in performing of which I sboul I obey God am I bound to obey him in all such commands so should I frustrate the End of the Law and commit the same offence by this my Blind Obedience which others do by presumptuous and wilfull disobedience unto spirituall governours But it will be replied who shall judge whether the spiritual Governour command thee such service as argues disobedience unto God or no If the case be Doubtfull and I be commanded by my lawfull Pastor I have answered already in what sence obedience must be performed But if the case be Evident men must openly disobey their Pastors before they certainly disobey God But who shall judge of the Evidence Every mans conscience Shall that then be Evident which every man shall say is Evident unto him No but what in deed and conscience is and so shall appear in his judgement that searcheth the heart and reins Such as do not fear his censure will make no conscience of disobeying men pretending authority from him Such as with fear and trembling expect the Son of mans appearance will not much esteem how they be judged by men further then in reason they may be perswaded their sentence shall be ratified in the last day of judgement And because God hath endued spiritual Governours with power of retaining and remitting sins every one that fears him which gave will fear to disobey them to Whom this power is given lest if they retain he will not remit and retain they justly may or rather must the sins of all such as adde thirst to drunkennesse contempt of Gods Messengers summons to repentance unto actual breaches of his Law This is as open rebellion upon a riot perhaps first attempted upon ignorance of the Law inconsideratenesse or foolish passion but continued after Proclamation made in the Kings Name by a publick Magistrate authorized for such purposes The parties admonished upon such high termes to desist from any suspitious enterprise though no more must be certain of the Princes or chief Law-givers future approbation of what they go about if they persist otherwise disobedience to a lawful Magistrate or inferiour Officer will be found rebellion against the State or Soveraignty 12 Though it be most true what hath been before delivered that unto Pastors conditional obedience is onely due yet is not the condition precedent to all acts of obedience but subsequent at least to some and to be inserted by way of Limitation or Caution for desisting upon discovery of farther danger rather then interposed as a stop to breed delay or prohibition of all obedience untill evident proof be made that it is expresly due in the particulars enjoyned The want of this distinction between a condition Precedent and a condition Subsequent or annexed unto actual obedience
to the right hand or to the left Was he to take all this pains only that he might learn to execute the Priests indefinite sentence This any heathen might have done But the Kings of Israel albeit they were not to meddle in the execution of the Priests office were not withstanding to be so well skilled in Scriptures as to be able to judge whether the Priest did according to that Law which God had set him to follow and to controle his definitive sentence if it were evidently contrary to Gods word which both were absolutely bound to obey 5 It may perhaps here be objected that the King had no such assurance of infallibility in judgement as the Priest had and therefore it was requisite he should rely upon the Priests definitive sentence What construction then can any Jesuite make of these words A divine sentence shall be in the lips of the King his mouth shall not transgress he saith not in execution of judgement given by the Priests but in judgement given by himself seeing it is an abomination to Kings to commit wickednesse for the throne is established by justice And again ‖ Righteous lips such as the Priests should and might have been but usually were not are the delight of Kings and the King loveth him that speaketh right things This place if we respect either the abstract form of precept or plenitude of Gods promise for abiliment to perform it is more plain and peremptory for the Kings then any can be brought for the High Priests infallibility in giving definitive sentence yet doth it not necessarily infer Kings shall not but rather shews that they should not or that they might not at any time erre in judgment so they would stedfastly follow those rules which God hath prescribed them For when God saith A divine sentence shall be in the lips of Kings this speech doth no more argue a perpetual certainty in giving righteous sentence then if he had said A corrupt or erroneous sentence shall not be in the lips of the King or his mouth shall not transgresse in judgement For as that which God saith shall not be done oft-times is done so may that which God saith shall be done be oft-times left undone Who is he then would make this collection God saith Thou shalt not steal that is no man shall steal ergo there can be no thieves no theft committed yet is our adversaries collection as foolish The Priests lips shall preserve knowledge Ergo they cannot erre in giving definitive sentence as again The spirit shall lead you into all truth they shall be all taught of God therefore the Church shall be infallibly taught by the spirit and shall as infallibly teach others live they as they list 6 These places shew what should be done and what God for his part will infallibly perform so men would be obedient to his word but neither do these or any of like nature include any infallibility of not erring without performance of due obedience in practise of life nor do they necessarily conclude that men alwayes shall perform such obedience The most which they infer is this that Governours by duty are bound to perform that performing such obedience in practise of life they might be freer from errour in their doctrine or difinitive sentence And it was abstinence and integrity of life that was to preserve sincerity of judgement in Princes as well as Priests lips for which reason Princes had their precepts of temperance answerable to those rules prescribed for the Priests So Solomon teacheth kings Give not thy strength unto a woman nor thy wayes this is to destroy Kings it is not for Kings O Lemuel it is not for Kings to drink wine nor for â—rinces strong drink lest he drink and forget the decree and change the judgement of all the children of affliction This place evidently shews that if their Princes were of riotous or intemperate lives they had no promise that they should not pervert the judgement of the children of affliction The conclusion hence arising is all the places that can be brought either for the King or Priests authority rather shew what manner of men they should be both in life and judgement then â—…ure them of any infallibility of judgement if they be dissolute in life This was a point never dreamt of by any before the Popes notoriously infamous lives did discredit the Titles of sanctity and infallibility which from a concert of their predecessors integrity they have usurped and inforced their parasites to frame a distinction of sanctity in doctrine separated from sanctity in life 7 It is questionable where both Priests and Princes of Judah had not an extraordinary priviledge above all other nations both for being infallible in their definitive sentences whilest they lived according to the laws which God had given them and also for their more then ordinary possibility of living according to such laws Gods blessings as is most probable in both thâ—se respects were extraordinary unto their Princes and Priests yet not so mâ—nitely extraordinary that either of them might without presumptuous blasphemy hope for ordinary integrity such as the more civil sort of heathens had much lesse for any absolute infallibility if they were extraordinarily wicked in their lives or unfaithful in their other dealings Even the peoples wickednesse did impair the force and vertue of these extraordinary blesings promised to their Kings and Priests God gave them Priests as well as Princes in his anger such as should be pliable to their humor not such as should infallibly direct them against the suggestions of the world and flesh for their spiritual good So that these gracious promises both for their spiritual and temporal governours sincerity in judgement did depend in part upon the condition of this peoples life 8 The usual Proverb was most true though the words thus inverted Like people Like Priests Thus did the wise Son of Sirach interpret Gods promises both to Priest and Princes †Because Phineas ofâ—leazar â—leazar had zeal in the fear of the Lord and stood up with good courage of heart when the people were turned back and made reconciliation for Israel therefore was there â—…venant of peace made with him that he should be the chief of the Sanctuary and of his people and that he and his posterity should have the dignity of the Priesthood for ever And according unto the covenant made with David that the inheritance of the kingdom should remain to his son of the Tribe of Judah so the heritage of Aaron should be to the only son of his son and to his seed God give us wisdom in our heart to judge his people in righteousness that the good things that they have be not abolished and that their glory may endure for their posterity 9 From what we have said it is most evident that the precepts injoyning obedience unto civil Magistrates are as large and ample as any can be found for obedience unto spiritual
you cannot that God can and what if he should expresly grant such authority as the Pope now challengeth would your arguments conclude him to be Antichrist or the Doctrine we teach to be blasphemous On the contrary seeing our Saviour Christ did never either practise or challenge seeing neither Moses nor the Prophets did ever so much as once intimate such absolute power should be acknowledged in that great Prophet of whom they wrote we suppose the imagination of the like in whomsoever cannot be without real blasphemie Yet suppose Christs infallibilitie and the Popes were in respect of the Church Militant the same The Popes authority would be greater or were their authority but equall his priviledges with God would be much more magnificent then Christs That which most condemned the Jews of infidelity in not acknowledging Christ as sent with power full and absolute from God his Father were his mighty signes and wonders his admirable skill in Gods Word already established but chiefly his sacred life and conversation as it were exhibiting unto the World a visible patern or conspicuous modell of that incomprehensible goodnesse which is infallible Now if we compare Christ his power fulnesse in words and wâ—… with the Popes imperfections in both or his divine vertues with the others 〈◊〉 strous viâ—es to equalize their infallibilities were to imagine God to be like man and Christ at the best but as his faithfull servant the Pope his â—inâ—on his Darling or Son of his age For such is our partiality to our own flesh that oft-times though the Wise man advise to the contrary a lewd and naughty son in that he is a son hath greater grace and priviledges then the most faithfull servant in the Fathers house So would the Jesuites make God dote upon the Pope whose authority be his life never so ungracious if they should deny to be lesse then Christs in respect of us their practises enjoyned ex Cathedra would confute them For much sooner shall any Christian though otherwise of life unspotted be cut off from the Congregation of the faithfull for denying the Popes authority or distrusting his decrees then the Jews that saw Christs miracles for contradicting him in the dayes of his flesh or oppugning his Apostles after his glorification Nor boots it ought to say They make the Popes authority lesse then Christs in respect they derive it from his rather because they evidently make it greater then Christs was it cannot be truly thence derived or if it could this onely proves it to be lesse then the other whilest onely compared with it not whilest we consider Both in respect of us for Christs authority as the Son of Man in respect of us is equall to his Fathers whence it is derived For the Father judgeth no man but hath ommitted all judgement unto the Son 2 But wherein do they make the Popes authority greater then Christs First in not exempting it from trial by Christs and his Apostles doctrine neither of which were to be admitted without all examination of their truth for as you heard before Gods Word was first uttered in their audience established by evident signes and wonders in their sight and presence of whom Belief and Obedience unto particulars was exacted And it is a rule most evident and unquestionable that Gods Word once confirmed and sealed by Experience was the onely rule whereby all other spirits and doctrines were to be examined that not Prophetical visions were to be admitted into the Canon of Faith but upon their apparent consonancie with the Word already written The first Prophets were to be tried by Moses the latter by Moses and their Predecessors Christs and his Apostles by Moses and all the Prophets for unto him did all the Prophets â—… The manifest experiments of his life and doctrine so fully consonant to their predictions did much confirm even his Disciples Belief unto the former Canon of whose truth they never conceived positive doubt 3 Again there had been no Prophet no signes no wonders for a long time in Iudah before our Saviours birth yet he never made that use either of his miracles or more then Prophetical spirit which the Papists make of their imaginary publick spirit he never used this or like argument to make the people relie upon him How know ye the Scriptures are Gods Word How know ye that God spake with Moses in the wildernesse or with your Fathers in Mount Sinai Moses your Fathers and the Prophets are dead and their writings cannot speak Your present Teachers the Scribes and Pharisees do no wonders Must you not then believe him whom daily you may behold doing such mighty works as Moses is said to have done that Moses as your fathers have told you was sent from God that Gods Word is contained in his writings otherwise you cannot infallibly believe that there was such a man indeed as you conceive he was much lesse that he wrote you this Law least of all can you certainly know the true meaning of what he wrote He that is the onely sure foundation of faith knew that faith grounded upon such doubts was but built upon the sand unable to abide the blasts of ordinary temptations that thus to erect their hopes was but to prepare a Rise to a grievous Downfall the ready way to Atheisme presumption or despair For this cause he doth not so much as once question how they knew the Scriptures to be Gods Word but supposing them known and fully acknowledged for such he exhorts his hearers to search them seeking to prepare their hearts by signes and wonders to embrace his admirable expositions of them And because the corruption of particular moral doctrines brought into the Church by humane tradition would not suffer the generality of Moses and the Prophets already believed to fructifie in his hearers hearts and branch out uniformely into lively working faith he laboured most to weed out Pharisaisme from among the heavenly seed as every one may see that compares his Sermon upon the Mount with the Pharisees glosses upon Moses If the particular or principal parts of the Law and Prophets had been as purely taught or as clearly discerned as the generall and common principles His Doctrine that came not to destroy but to fulfill the Law in words and works had shined as brightly in his hearers hearts at the first proposal as the Sun did to their eyes at the first rising For all the moral duties required by them were but as dispersed rayes or scattered beams of that divine light and glory which was incorporate in him as splendor in the body of the Sun Nor was there any possibility the Jews Belief in him should prosper unlesse it grew out of their general assent unto Moses Doctrine thus pruned and purged at the very root Had all believed Moses saith our Saviour 〈◊〉 would have believed me for he wrote of me but if ye believe not his writings how soâ—â—l ye believe my words For
erring is more stedfastly to be believed as more credible in it self then either the Canon of Scriptures or any thing therein contained because these become actually credible unto us onely by the Churches Declaration which cannot possibly ought avail for their belief unless it were better believed 6 Perhaps the Reader will here challenge me that this last instance proves not all that I proposed in the Title of this chapter For it onely proves the Popes supremacie is better to be believed then that Christ is come in the flesh that God did ever speak to men in former ages by his Prophets and â—…tter by his Son But this infers no absolute alienation of our belief from Christ seeing even in this respect that we believe the Church or Pope so well we must needs â—elieve that Christ is come in the flesh and that God hath spoken to us sundry ways for thus much the Pope avouâ—â—eth Yea but what if the Church teach us that Christ is our Lord and Redeemer and â—et urge us to do that which is contumelious to his Majesty What if it teach us that these Scriptures are Gods Word and yet binde us by her infallible dâ—â—â—â—es to break his Laws and give his spirit the lye Should we make profession of believing as the Pope teacheth and yet take his meaning to be only such as Marnixius whom we better believe would make it His Holiness would quickly pronounce us Apostat's from the Catholick faith Or if this suffice not the indifferent Reader for satisfying my former promise let him have patience but for a while and I will pay him all 7 Their first main position That no private man can certainly know the Canon of Scriptures to be Gods Word but by relying upon the present Church infers as much as hath been said much more will follow from their second That no man can certainly be perswaded of the true sense and meaning of particular propositions contained in the general Canon without the same Churches testimony unto whom the authentick interpretation or dijudication of Scriptures â—holly belongs Imagine the former parties now fully perswaded of the Scriptures divine truth in general should by the Consistory which late Câ—â—â—chized them be questioned about the meaning of some particular plaâ—â—â— Consist We hope you adore the consecrated host with Divine worship as oft as you meet it in procession Cat. Desirous we are to do any thing that becomes good Christians and obedient Sons unto our holy mother the Church but we cannot satisfie our consciences how this may stand with the principles of Christianity Your Holinesses for which we rest yours unto death have assured us these sacred volumes are the very words of God and his words we know must be obeyed Now since we know these to be his words we have found it written in them Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God and him onely shalt thou serve It is we doubt our simplicity that will not suffer us to conceive how the consecrated Host can be adored as God without open breach of his commandement For to our shallow understanding there is no necessity to perswade us Christ God and man should be hid in it These words Hoc est corpus meâ—m may bear many interpretations no way pregnant to this purpose And it is doubtful whether Christs Body though really present in the Sacrament should retain the same presence in procession whereas the former commandement is plain We must worship the Lord our God and him only must we serve Consist Ye think this Text is plain to your late purpose we think otherwise Whether is more meet ye to submit your private opinions to our publick spirits or us that are Pastors to learn of you silly sheep Cat. Therefore are your servants come unto you that they may learn how to obey you in this decree without Idolatry well hoping that as ye enjoyn us absolutely to obey you in it so ye can give us full assurance we shall not disobey the Spirit of God in the former great commandement whose exposition we most desire 8 Would these or like supplications though conceived in Christian modesty though proposed with religious fear and awfull regard of their persons though presented with tears and sighes or other more evident signes of inward sorrow find any entrance into Romish Prelates ears or move the Masters of the Inquisition house to forbear exaction of obedience to the forâ—er or other Decree of the Trent Councel Were the Form of the Decree it self unto private judgements never so contradictory to Gods expresse written lawes or the consequence of practizing as it prescribes never so dreadful to the doubtful conscience How much better then were it for such silly souls had they never known the Books of Moses to have been from God for so committing idolatrie with stocks and stones or other creatures they had done what was displeasing to their Master and justly punishable yet with fewer stripes because his will was not made known unto them But now they know it and acknowledge the truth of this Commandement To what end That they may be left without all excuse for not doing it They see the general truth of Gods Oracles that they may be more desperately blinded in wilfull perverting the particulars For what glory could the allurement of silly ignorant men to simple idolatry be unto great Antichrist Let them first subscribe to the written Lawes of the everliving God and afterwards wholly submit themselves to his determinations for their practise and so the opposition betwixt him and the Deity betwixt his injunctions and the Decrees of the Almighty may be more positive more directly contrary The Heathen or others not acknowledging Gods Word at all are rightly termed unbelievers men thus believing the Scriptures in general to be Gods Word from the testimony of the Church and yet absolutely relying upon her judgement for the meaning of particular places are transported from unbelief to misbelief from grosse ignorance to wilfull defiance of God and his Lawes Finally they are brought to know Gods Word that they may doubt in this and like fearful practises enjoyned that so first doubting and afterwards desperately resolving absolutely to follow the Churches injunction against that sence and meaning of the divine decrees which the holy Spirit doth dictate to their private consciences they may without doubt be damned for not abiding in the truth Like their first parents they hear Gods sentence but prefer the interpretations of Sathans first-born before their own because it must be presumed he is more subtle then they Or to referre the two main streames of thâ—s iniquity to their proper heads The first That we cannot know the old or new Testament to be Gods Word but by relying upon the Church makes all subscribers to it real Atheists or Infidels and Christians onely in conceit or upon condition If the Church whose authority they so highly esteem be as infallible as is pretende Heretofore I have
cannot infalliblie distinguish the true sence and meaning of one place from another but must herein also rely upon the Churches testimony and onely believe that sence to be repugnant that consonant to the analogie of faith which she shall tender albeit our private consciences be never so well informed by other Scriptures to the contrary The truth then of our former conclusion is hence easily manifested For seeing they hold both the Scriptures and their distinct sence to be obscure and unable to ascertain themselves unlesse the Church adde perspicuitie or facilitie of communicating their meaning to private spirits such after the Churches proposal cannot possibly discern them any better or more directly in themselves then they did before but must wholy rely upon their Prelates as if these were the onely watchmen in the Tower of Gods Church that could by vertue of their place discern all divine truth Others must believe there is an omnipotent God which hath given his Law a Mediator of the new Testament but what the meaning either of Law or Gospel is they may not presume otherwise to determine then weak sights do of things they see confusedly a farre off whose particular distance or difference they must take onely upon other mens report that have seen them distinctly and at hand 11 To illustrate these deductions with the former similitude of the prime and secondary visibles Let us suppose for disputations sake that the Sun which illuminates colours by its light were further indued as we are with sense and reason able to judge of all the differences between them which it can manifest to us and hence challenge to be a Pope or infallible proposer of colours This supposition the Canonist hath made lesse improbable For Deus fecit duo luminaria God made two lights that is by his interpretation the Pope and the Emperour Or if you please to mitigate the harshnesse of it let the Man in the Moon whom we may not imagine speechlesse be supposed the Sun or Pope of colours his Mercurie or Nuncio As the Papists say we cannot know Scriptures to be Scriptures but by the infallible proposal of the Church so it is evident we cannot see any colour at all unlesse illuminated or proposed by the Suns light But after by it we see them suppose we should take upon us to discourse of their nature or determine of their distinct properties as now we do and the Sun or Pope of colours by himself or his Nuncio should take us up as Duke Humphrey did the blind man restored to sight which he never had lost Yea who taught you to distinguish colours were you not quite blind but now as yet you cannot discern any colours without my publick light and yet will you presume to define their properties and distinguish their natures against my definitive sentence known Must not he that enables you to see them enable you to distinguish them seen Must you not wholly rely upon my authority whether this be white or that black If a man upon these Motives should absolutely believe the Suns determinations renouncing the judgement of his private senses could he truely say that he either knew this colour to be white or that black or another green Rather were he not bound to say I neither know white from black nor black from blew nor blew from green but I know that to be white which the Sun the onely infallible Judge of colours saith is white that onely to be black that blew and that green which he shall determine so to be I may think indeed that the snow is white or coals black but with submission to the Suns determination 12 And yet as you have heard at large out of the Trent Councel and best Apologies can be made for it the Church must be the infallible Judge of all Scripture sence and must absolutely be believed without all appeal to Scriptures not conditionally as she shall accord with them The conclusion hence issuing is most infallible and on their parts most inevitable Whosoever absolutely acknowledgeth this authority in the Church or Consistory and yeelds such obedience unto it in all determinations concerning the Canon of Scriptures doth not believe either this or that determinate proposition of faith or any definite meaning of Gods Word The best resolution he can make of his faith is this I believe that to be the meaning of every place which the Church shall define to be the meaning which is all one as if he had said I do not believe the Scriptures or their meaning but I believe the Churches decision and sentence concerning them He that believes not the Church saith Canus but with this limitation if it give sentence according unto Scriptures doth not believe the Church but the Scriptures By the same reason it followes most directly he that believes not the true sence and meaning of Scriptures but with this reservation if the Church so think or determine doth not believe them but the Church onely For as the Schoolmen say Ubi unum propter aliud ibi unum tantum He that serves God onely because he would be rich doth not serve God but his riches albeit he performe the outward acts of obedience Or if we love a man onely for his affinity with another whom we dearly love we truely and properly love but the one the other onely by way of reflexion or denomination in such a sence as we say a man appears by his proxie that is his proxie appears not he In like sort believing the sence of Scriptures onely from the supposed authentick declaration of the Church or because we believe it we infalliblie believe the Church alone not the Scriptures but onely by an extrinsecal denomination 13 Yet as a man may from some reasons lesse probable have an opinion of what he certainly knowes by motives more sound or as we may love one in some competent measure for his owne sake and yet affect him more entirely for anothers whom we most dearly love so may an absolute Papist in some moral sort believe the Scriptures for themselves or hold their authodoxal sence as probable to his private judgement albeit he believe them most for the Churches sake and that sence best which it commends But this his belief of the Church being by their doctrine more then moral or conditional doth quite overthrow all moral or probable belief he can possiblie have from what ground soever of Scriptures themselves For as I said before the Church shall determine ought contrary to his preconceived opinion the more probable or strong it was the more it encreaseth his doubt and makes his contrary resolution more desperate yea more damnable if habitual because 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 extreamly contrary to the doctrine of faith Bellarmins prescription in this case is just as if a Physitian or Surgeon should seek to case the pain by ending of the Patients dayes Lest a man should sin against his conscience this
Popes cause as they would make all other in Gods they could tell how to limit such commands though delivered in most universal and ample termes This is the matter then which so vexeth their devout hearts and sets them besides themselves with furious zeal in this argument that any Christian should be as wary and circumspect lest he should prove disloyall unto the Creator and Redeemer of mankind as they are lest they should disobey the advancer and supporter of their Order 16 But to come nearer the point and instance in some Precepts of obedience delivered in most general forme Might the literal or Logick note of Universalitie carry away such absolute soveraignty as they contend for far greater reason there is why every father or master should be an absolute Pope over his own familie then why the Pope of Rome should be a father of all Christian Congregations an absolute Judge of Scripture or master over mens faith Saint Paul Col. 2. 20. Commands children to obey their fathers in All things for that is well-pleasing unto the Lord which is as much as if he had said in obeying them you obey the Lord. Again he commands servants to be obedient unto them that are their masters according to the flesh in All things not with eye-service as men pleasers but with singlenesse of heart fearing God Both these precepts are conceived in termes as general as any precept for obedience to spiritual Governours In the Precept concerning wives obedience to their husbands the note of universalitie is omitted for he saith Wives sabmit your selves unto your husbands as it is comely in the Lord not in all things Had the Apostle made any mention of obedience unto spirituall Governours or were there any hope to comprehend Pastors under the name of fathers or masters it would quickly be inferred the note of universality was purposely added by our Apostle in these later precepts that men might know absolute obedience without limitation or examination was due unto the Pope 17 But the Holy men of God whose mouthes alwayes spake out of the abundance of their hearts as the spirit gave them utterance and were not curious to cast their words in such exact scholastick moulds as men addicted to artificial meditations having their brains more exercised then their hearts in Gods word usually do even where they seem to speak most Universally for the Form are to be Universally understood only in that subject or matter which for the present they mind most As when our Apostle commands servants and children to obey the one their masters the other their parents in all things the meaning is as if he had said ye that are christian servants be ye most willing to yield all obedience that is due unto masters ye that are christian children to yield all obedience unto your parents which is convenient for any children to yield to theirs So that the universal note doth rather injoyn a totality of heartinesse and cheerfulnesse a perfection of sincerity in performing that obedience which other children ought to their fathers or servants to their masters then any way extend the object of christian childrens or servants obedience to more particulars then others were bound unto at the least he doth not extend the object of their obedience to any particulars which might prejudice the sincerity of their obedience due unto other commanders whilest he enjoyneth servants to obey their masters in all things he reserves their allegiance intire unto Princes and higher powers Such must be obeyed both by masters and servants by fathers and sons Much more doth God when he injoyns obedience in most ample form unto Kings or spiritual governours reserve obedience due to himself most intire and absolute 18 Yet intire and absolute it cannot be unless it depend immediately and absolutely upon his laws unless it be exempt from the uncontrollable disposal or infallible direction of other authorities Nor can Christ be said our supream Lord unless our obedience to him and those laws which he hath left us do limit and restrain all other obedience due unto any authority derived from him and his laws more then a Prince could be said to be that servants supream Lord or Soveraign which were bound absolutely to obey his Master in all points without examination whether his designments were hot contrary to the publick laws and statutes of his Prince and Country Wherefore as the oath of Allegeance unto Princes doth restrain the former precepts Servants obey your Masters in All things that is in all things that are not repugnant to publick laws nor prejudicial to the Crown and dignity of your Soveraign so must that solemn vow of fidelity made unto Christ in Baptism and our dayly acknowledgement of him for our Soveraign Lord restrain all precepts injoyning performance of obedience to any power on earth and set these immoveable bounds and limits to them Obey thy King and Governour in All things that is in All things that are not repugnant to the laws and ordinances of the Great King thy supream Lord and Governour Whilest thou obeyest him thou doest wel in disobeying them as wel as that servant that takes Arms against his Master in the Kings desence whilest thou disobeyest him all other obedience is rebellion Ye are bought with a price saith our Apostle be not ye the servants of men Service according to the flesh he else-where approves he strictly injoyns for that is freedom in respect of this servitude of mind and conscience in being wholly at any other mans disposition 19 Nor is it more difficult for Christs servants to discern when governours solicit them to disloyalty against him then for servants according to the flesh to know when their masters seduce them unto rebellion so Christian men would fear God as much as natural men do earthly Princes Such as fear God are sure of a better expositor of his laws for fundamental points then servants can have for their Princes The transgression of both are easie to discern in the beginning of revolts or Apostasies but the later more difficult when traitors or usurpers are grown strong and can pretend fair titles unto soveraignties or coin false pedegrees yet it is not impossible for sober and observant spirits in such a case to foresee what party to follow unto such the Signs of the time and carriage of the several causes will bewray who have the true title But this difficulty is in none in our spiritual obedience challenged by the Church of Rome for that Church in words confesseth Christ to be the true King and supream Lord no usurper which is as much as to say the Pope is an usurper and a rebel that dares in deeds and substance challenge the soveraignty from him as you heard in the former dispute by making claim to this unlimited unreserved obedience Upon what grounds especially we are now to examin by these rules hitherto discussed CAP. XII The authority of the Sanhedrim not so
universal or absolute amongst the Jews as the Papists make it but was to be limited by the former Rules 1 ONe especial place on which they stand is from that Law in Deuteronomy If there arise a matter too hard for thee in judgement between bloud and bloud between plea and plea between plague and plague in the matters of controversie within thy gates then shalt thou arise and go up unto the place which the Lord thy God shall chuse And thou shalt come unto the Priests of the Levites and to the Judge that shall be in those dayes and ask and they shall shew thee the sentence of judgement and thou shalt do according to that thing which they of that place which the Lord hath chosen shew thee and thou shalt observe to do according to all that they inform thee According to the Law which they shall teach thee and according to the judgement which they shall tell thee sealt thou do thou shalt not decline from the thing which they shall shew thee neither to the right hand nor to the left And that man that will do presumptuously not hear kning unto the Priest that standeth before the Lord thy God to minister there or unto the Judge that man shall die and thou shalt take away evil from Israel so all the people shall hear and fear and do no more presumptuously 2 This precept admits of many restrictions any one of which doth take away all the force of our adversaries objections First it may without prejudice to our cause be granted although it cannot out of these words be necessarily inferred that God here prescribes obedience in the abstract such as was to be performed unto those Priests and Judges that lived according to that pattern which he had set them Thus may this precept of obedience for the extent be universal and concern all causes whatsoever spiritual or temporal doubts of conscience or matters of this life in all which such governours were to be obeyed but conditionally if they were such as God in his law required they should be unto such as you heard before he gave illuminations extraordinary such as the parties that were to obey might have perfect notice of But how great soever the extent of this precept be not one syllable in it makes more for absolute obedience unto spiritual then unto civil governours for it is said indefinitely vers 10. thou â—… do according to that thing which they either spiritual or temporal of that placâ—… which the Lord hath chosen shall shew thee And again the words are diâ—…ctive That man that will do presumptuously not hearkening unto the Prâ—… unto the Judge that man shall die whether the Priest were to be supream Judge or no it is not said at the least the High Priest was not the chief man alwayes in the Councel for he was not alwayes admitted into the supream Consistory or Sanhedrim which is established in this place yet Bellarmin will have the definitive sentence belong unto the Priest and the execution of it to the civil magistrate so indeed the present Romish Church in spiritual cases would be judge and mâ—ke Christian Princes her hang-men but their practise must not be taken for an infallible exposition of that Law whence they seek to justifie their practise quite contrary to the practise of the Jewish Church and Synagogue Nor doth Bellarmin or any other beside the base parasitical Canonists or the Popes trencher chaplains deny but that in many civil causes the Prince or temporal Magistrate hath a definitive sentence can he then gather out of any circumstance of this place that only spiritual causes are here meant nay he confesseth that the law is general concerning all doubts that might arise out of the law yet it is most probable that it only concerns civil controversies and Bellarmins reason to prove that it includeth spiritual causes or matters of Religion is most idle The occasion of this Law saith he was for them that did serve other Gods as appears out of the beginnning of the Chapter now the service of other Gods is a point of Religion But what though Moses in the former part of this Chapter speak of Idolaters must this law therefore concern Idolaters In the former part he speaketh only of Idolaters but this law is not only for them by Bellarmins confession Yet the circumstances of the place and the expresse law against Idolaters mentioned before evince that in this Chapter as in the former he first sets down laws concerning the true service of God and in the later part gives precepts for the observation of the second Table the maintaining of love by the final composition of all controversies that might arise betwixt neighbours In the former law Idolaters are sentenced to death and Idolatry saith Bellarmin is a point of Religion Was the Priest alone then to give sentence and the civil Magistrate only to execute it There is not the least pretence for it out of this Text. Any ordinary Magistrate might execute him that was lawfully convicted of this crime nor was it so hard a matter to judge who was an Idolater amongst the Jews as it is to determin what is an Heresie amongst the Romanists This was to be proved by witnesses not by Logical proof or force of speculative reason Had the cunningest Jesuite in the world been taken amongst them kneeling down before an Image and praying to it all the distinctions in the Master of sentences or Aquinas or both their Commentators could not have redeemed him against two honest men that had sworn he had done thus much there had been no appeal from any City in Judah unto any higher Court his doom had been read in the gates and without them he should as Homer speaks have put on a stony coat 3 That the Kings of Judah were only to execute the Priests definitive sentence in all hard controversies is a position well deserving execution without appeal at Princes hands And no doubt but it did so amongst the Jews The former Court as is most probable was to cease when they had a King amongst them And Moses in the former Chapter after he had given the other law for ending controversies gives the law for the election of their King if so be they would have one as if the former Court had then ceased to be the supream Tribunal seeing all Subjects might appeal unto the King from it in which this Soveraignty did before reside as being the supream Tribunal whence there could be no appeal 4 The King in the Law concerning his qualification is commanded to have the Law of his God written out And it shall be with him and he shall read therein all the dayes of his life that he may learn to fear the Lord his God and to keep all the words of his Law and these Ordinances for to do them that his heart be not lifted up above his brethren and that he turn not from the commandment
Valentian I absolutely deny as the Catholick Doctors upon good reasons generally do that the Pope can erre in such a business The certainty of this his belief he would ground upon those promises by which we are assured it shall never come to pass that the universal Church can be deceived in points of Religion But the whole Church should erre very grossly in such matters should it repute and worship him for a Saint which is none Hereit would be observed how Satan instigates these men unto such Tenents as may occasion God and his Gospel to be blasphemed First they would make it an Article of Faith that all must believe as the Pope teacheth whence it follows that either he cannot teach amiss or else faith may perish from off the earth Which if it could God were not true in his promises The surest pledge the Christian world can have of his fidelity in them must be the Popes infallibility so as from the first unto the last he must be held as true in his dealings as God in his sayings If he fail in Canonizing a Saint whom he cannot possibly know to be such unless he knew his heart which belongs wholly unto his maker God must be a lyar and there is no Truth in him The final issue intended by Satan in these resolutions is this When men have been a long time led on with fair hopes of gaining heaven by following the Popes direction and yet in the end see as who not blind sees not his gross errors and detestable villanies they may be hence tempted to blaspheme God as if he had been his copartner in this cosenage From this root I take it hath Atheism sprung so fast in Italy For whilest faith is in the blade and their hopes flourishing they imagine God and the Pope to be such friends as their blind guides make them But afterwards comming to detestation of this man of sin and his treachery holding his spiritual power as ridiculous they think either as despitefully or contemptuously of the Deity or say with the fool in their hearts there is no God 3 Thus Antichrists followers still run a course quite contrary to Christian religion For if it be true as it is most true that faith cannot utterly perish from off the earth what damnable abuse of Gods mercie and favour toward mankinde is this in seeking as the Jesuites do to make all absolutely rely upon one in matters of Faith For so if he fail all others must of necessity fail with him That is the whole world must be as kind supernatural fools to him as that natural idiote was to his Master who being demanded whether he would go to heaven with him or no replyed he would go to hel with so good a Master seeing any man would be willing to go to heaven with an ordinary friend yea with his enemy Though we should use no other argument but that Avoid ye sons of Satan for it is written ye shall not tempt the Lord your God It should me thinks be enough to put all the Jesuites in the world unto silence in this point did they not as far exceed their father in impudency as they come short of him in wit For this manner of tempting God is more shameless then Divels suggestion unto our Saviour when he was instanly silenced with this reproof A presumption it is more damnable to expect the protection or guidance of Gods spirit in such desperate resolutions as Valentian here brings then it were for a man to throw himself headlong from an high towr upon hope of Angelical supportance For seeing as I said God hath promised that true faith shal not perish from off the earth for all men to adventure their faith upon one mans infallibility who may have less saving faith in him then Turk or Infidel is but a provoking or daring of God to recall his promise Or what more damnable doctrine can be imagined then that all men should worship him for a Saint whom the wickedest man on earth doth commend unto him for such 4 But to proceed As the Doctrine is most impious so are the grounds of it most improbable For how can the Pope or Papists infallibly know this or that man to be a Saint Seeing there is no particular revelation made of it either to the Pope or others I answer saith Valentian that the general revelation whereby it is evident that whatsoever the Pope shall decree as pertaining to the whole Church is most true may suffice in this case Moreover saith he unto the Canonizing of Saints appertain these revelations of Scripture in which heavenly joyes are generally proposed to all such as lead a Godly life For by the Popes determination we know the Saint which he hath Canonized to be contained in the foresaid universal proposition Whence it is easie to frame an assent of faith by which we may perswade our selves that such a Saint hath obtained eternal bliss 5 I would request the Reader by the way to note the Jesuites injurious partiality in scoffing at such of our Writers as without express warrant of particular revelation hold a certainty of their own salvation when as they onely by Gods general promises to such as lead a godly life and the Popes infallibility in declaring who have so lived can be certain defide others are saved But the former doubt is rather removed then quite taken away by this his answer if it stand alone As yet it may be questioned how any can infallibly know the truth of what he cannot possibly know at all but onely by other mens testimonies in their nature the Jesuite being judge not infallible and in whose examination it is not impossible his Holinesse may be negligent For how men live or dye in England Spain or the Indies no Pope can tel but by the information of others no Popes The Reader perhaps wil prognosticate Valentians answer as in truth I did For when I first framed the doubt before I read it in him me thought it stood in need of such a reply as Bellarmin brought for defence of the vulgar interpreter Altogether as foolish it were to think any private mans information of anothers uprightness in the sight of God as to hold Theodotion the Heretick could not erre in translating of the Bible But though they may be deceived in testification of anothers sanctity yet Valentian tels you supposing the Pope is once induced by their testimonies though in nature fallible to pronounce him a blessed Saint all must infallibly believe their testimonies at least so far as they prove in general that he died a Godly and religious death are true and that the party commended by them is of that number which as we may gather from the general revelations of Scriptures shall be made partakers of everlasting life Again whether the Pope in defining a controversie use diligence or no yet without all question he shall define infallibly and consequently use the authority
Christ hath given him Wherefore in his judgement care and diligence are necessary to the Pope not so as if he could not define aright or rightly use his authority without them but that he doth not sin himself whilest he defines an infallible truth for others to believe Hereto may be added that albeit a diligent care were necessarily required for the infallibility of the Popes decisions yet the same faith which bindes us to believe he decides the controversie infallibly â—indes us also to believe that he used as much diligence as was requisite As for example in like case If God should promise that the next year should be a plentiful year of corn we would conceive he promised withall good and seasonable weather and whatsoever else necessary for effecting of his promise as Canus well notes But Valentians last conclusion is that no sure arguments can be brought why we should think study or diligence are necessary for the right use of the Popes authority so far as it concerns other mens faith that must rely upon it Rely upon it they must whether he determin ex tempore or upon deliberation and for ought I can see whether he give his sentence drunk or sober raving or in his right mind so he have the wit to charge all upon pain of damnation to believe it But what if some forrainer should of set purpose send a dead-mans water to trie this grand-Physitians skil could he without either care or diligence in examining their testimonies or special Revelation from above which in such businesses Valentian disclaims discover their knavery Or would his prognostication of life and health redeem the party deceased from the land of death as some say Pope Gregory by his prayers did Trajan These and many like questions might here be made which fall not within the reach of Valentians answers hitherto recited and yet these must abundantly suffice for resolution of all doubts concerning the Canonizing of Saints or approbation of Religious Orders in which business likewise we must believe the Pope cannot erre Let the Reader pause a while look on their madness and laugh his fil at their apish drunkenness in this argument that when his mirth hath found a vent and his heart is wel setled he may with a sober unpartial stedfast eye behold the Mystery of this iniquitie CAP. XXXII What danger by this blasphemous Doctrine may accrew to Christian States that of all heresies blasphemies or idolatries which have been since the world began or can be imagined till Christ come to judgement this Apostasie of the Jesuites is the most abominable and contumelious against the blessed Trinity 1 WHat the consequences of these positions may be none can doubt No less they are then I have said a resigning up of mens souls and consciences into the Popes hands a consecration of hearts minds and bodies to work any mischief imaginable at his appointment For what if the Pope upon the relation of Ravilliacks stubbornness they would say constancy in his torture or Catesbyes praying to the Virgin Mary at his death should Canonize both for Saints and enjoyn the Christian world so to honour them Every bloody Assasinate would pray unto the one for good success in acting his blood-thirsty designs on Princes bodies And if it should please the Pope so to determine all men should stand bound to give such solemn worship as by their Doctrin is due to Sacred reliques unto that bloody knife which hath been sheathed in Ravilliacks Soveraigns breast Every deep dissembling Polititian or ambitious cholerick discontented spirit would burn incense saltpeter sulphur and brimstone to the others image in hope of better speed in undermining states 2 If any Jesuite or other brazen faced favorer of their Order or this doctrin should here reply This dreamer casts doubts beyond the Moon for is there any likelihood his Holiness wil ever Canonize such wicked Imps for Saints I must answer him as Tully did Rullus utterly disclaiming all purpose of doing such wrong unto the Roman state as his Petition unto it once granted might enable him to effect and from my soul I wish every Christian Prince every Princes Councellor would take that grave Senators words for his motto Primum nescio deinde timeo posiremo non committam ut vestro beneficio potius quam nostro consilio salvi esse possimus First whether the Pope would Canonize such miscreants for Saints or no is more then we know Secondly his former practises minister so just cause of fear to Christian states that it stands them upon rather in wisdom to prevent his power of doing then rely upon his fidelity for not doing them some inestimable mischief by putting this practise in execution if opportunity serve and abilitie be left him thereby to strengthen his faction Did not his Legate into France upon notice of the Parisian Massacre bestow his Holinesses best blessing Cum plenitudine potestatis With absolute and plenarie power derived from himself upon the notorious assasinate Boydon chief Ring-leader of that immane and Wolvish Massacre committed at Lyons begun without any warrant of publick authority onely at this hellish miscreants instigation desirous to follow or rather out-go his Superiours in cruelty Was not that villany it self authorized from Rome where it found such extraordinary approbation Never did that City rejoyce so much in memory of Christs birth or Saint Peters as at the hearing of this more then Herodian butchery of so many thousands noble-minded gentlemen with other Innocents and Saints of God So full was this Legates heart of joy hence conceived that after he came into France out of the abundance of it his mouth did sound the praises of the bloody actors and contrivers of this shameful Tragedy Etiam cum delectu verborum With such choice and affected words as caused them blush to hear him that had not been ashamed to act the villany And as if this excellent exploit had been effected by vertue of the holy Catholick Church the Popes Petition to the French King was that the Trent Councel might upon that good success begin to be of force in France and be thus sealed with blood Yet can any man doubt whether this Church would authorize murther or Canonize Assasinates for her own advantage Publickly suppose she would not yet if the Popes Decrees when they expresly binde all must as Valentian contends be beleived by all upon such terms as he annexeth no question but if he give any special injunction to the Order of Jesuites or such as they shal adjudge fit Associates to whom these secrets may be imparted it shal be as devoutly entertained by them whom it concerns as if it were universal If charged they be under pain of damnation secretly to worship this or that damned villain it wil be held a formal denial of Faith either not to perform what is enjoyned or to bewray what they perform We may wel suppose the Jesuites and others of their