Romans such as Pythagoras Socrates Plato Epicâ—etus Cicero Seneca nor as those of later date Plutarch Porphyry Hierocles Jamblicus But as that one sacrifice abolish'd the Typical yet divinely instituted Sacrifices much more those mock-sacrifices that there are no such now in the more famous Religions in the world as divine Oracles and Prophecies absolv'd and finish'd in Christ and the Apostles silenc'd all those fallacious ones from below so the resplendent light of Natural Religion in the Gospel-revelation since its prevalency in the world and that it is become the Religion of Nations seems to have dazled natural reason that there is not the apparence of it as in former ages but a kind of barbarity hath invaded as a thick darkness the world out of the Goshen of Christianity while the Jews trust to the letter of the Old Testament not 2 Cor. 3. 15. yet unvail'd to them in its glory and further obscur'd by Rabbinick Dotages and Mahometans to the Spite-prophet and his senseless Alchoran set up by Satan and permitted by Divine Justice in opposition to the only true Prophet the Lord of life and glory and his everlasting Gospel All besides these lye obscure and at a distance from us in a manner like a Terra Incognita in Reason and Religion having only some relational glimpses no bodies of their discourse in either A great argument of the Truth of Christian Religion that hath drawn up all Rational Religion Reason and Learning within it self and under its own Horizon For though for a time it pleased God to allow the notable efforts of that sort of learning and in opposition to Christianity one of his unsearchable Judgments as in Porphyry and Hierocles yet being vanquished by the greater light of the Gospel since the days of Constantine it hath never risen in any other parts of the world unchristianiz'd to appear with any remarkable strength But all this doth not diminish so much from Natural Religion as it brings it into question Whether there is now such a thing in the world as Natural Religion without Christianity nay indeed it may be doubted whether notwithstanding or even for the sake of those great Names I just now recorded who were but a sort of Parelian lights to the true light of Natural Religion whether there was ever such a true copy of it as that of the Book of Job in any mans heart life or writings that was without the help of divine Illumination and yet Natural Religion is never the less natural nor the less felt and acknowledg'd to be so When besides such a proportion as is always ready to men not degenerate into beasts being so preserv'd by God that he may not leave himself without witness nor men without Luk. 15. 17. means in order to their conversion and recovery when I say besides this God restores to any man or number of men the perfection of it by his Word or by particular illumination of his mind it is not the less natural even as the prodigals Self he came to was not the less natural Self because he had been so long a fugitive from it and it became necessary to him to be so restor'd so no less is Natural religion natural because it is return'd by revelation after being lost And this carries the great uses indeed of Natural religion that whether it be that part of it by general providence preserv'd to the generality of men or by ordinary means improved or whether by divine Illumination and Revelation it is given as it were anew yet we still find it natural and as it were our own properly belonging to our natures and it comes to us as by way of Reminiscency of what we had once but had lost Thus all the ends of the earth Psal 22. 27. shall remember and turn to the Lord. And as I have now stated things that which may seem a great objection against what I have discoursed of Natural Religion will be more easily reconciled And it is taken out of those places of the Apostle John first what he records in his Gospel that our Saviour said He that honoureth not the Son honoureth not the Father that Joh. 5. 23. 1 Joh. 2. 23. 2 Joh. 9. 10. sent him And in his Epistles Whoever denieth the Son hath not the Father And in his second Epistle Whoever transgresseth and abideth not in the Doctrine of Christ hath not God and if any man come and brings not this Doctrine receive him not into your house neither bid him God speed for he that biddeth him God speed is partaker of his evil deeds By all these sayings laid together it seems undeniable that even the acknowledgment of that first and great principle of Natural Religion The believing in and adoring the one God is made of no value by not acknowledging honouring and believing in Christ the Son which is the principal point of Divine Revelation For the setling therefore this doubt these three Things are to be consider'd 1. That after due Instruction and Explanation of the Doctrine of Christ it is as I have said so united with Natural Religion that who ever hath that in sincerity is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 set in a posture ready to receive and believe Christianity So that if any one upon Instruction commensurate to the Understanding Christian Religion does not receive it he hath not God he hath not true Natural Religion in that Fundamental point especially if he have had the Preparations of Divine Revelation in the Old Testament as the Jews to whom these words were especially directed had Yet still I suppose this case reserv'd to Divine judgment and not to Humane nor that such an unbeliever may be dealt with by men or by Magistratical Authority as an Athiest man can only deal with him by Remonstrances out of Scripture and reasons flowing from it 2. The severity of the Apostle hath greater force upon those who having receiv'd Christianity apostatize from it transgressing and not abiding in the Doctrine of Christ for it is most certain in the thing it self they have not nor can have Natural Religion that prove Apâ—states from Christianity understood so intimate to it 3. This hath yet much greater force upon those whom the Apostle seems especially in his Epistles to intend those who come with a high pretension of an extraordinary spirit of an immediate Doctrine from Heaven and yet bring not the Doctrine of Christ For there being at that time such infallible proofs and assurances of all sorts to the Apostles and that have descended down from them to us in Sacred History we must needs conclude they might justly Anathematize in the highest degree an Angel from heaven that preacht any other Gospel they were most certain who ever Gal. 1. 8. call'd or proclaim'd Christ Lord were authoriz'd to do so by the Spirit of God and therefore that no man could by the 1 Cor. 12. 3. same spirit declare him accursed seeing that Spirit
that doth but a little consider will find first It is a very good answer to endless cavil and querulousness against the best of things that can be obtain'd here that every thing in this world is injur'd disorder'd and defiled by the pravity of Humane Nature there being nothing in the whole Vniverse of Good and Excellent that is not debaucht by the lusts of men or where shall he fix himself that would upon earth remove himself from all things that have been by sin if but possible to be deprav'd by ill use to ill ends But yet this is not answer enough for the defiling the very light and the Sun even Religion it self and that in so great degrees and to so heinously contrary ends for whereas the very height and transcendency of Divine Things might in all reason plead an exemption from such debasements yet coming so near to our corrupted Atmosphaere it is even as the very light though in it self remaining always pure and clear as it self notwithstanding prostituted by men to their own abominable impieties This then alone answers so great a Doubt That God is exceedingly offended and displeas'd with Humane Nature that so excellent an instrument of the Divine Glory the Happiness of the world in present and the eternal life and happiness of it hereafter should be depraved into an instrument of greatest unhappiness and mischief to mankind both in this world and that which is to come For so far as we can see much of that Blood and Devastation Tumult and Convulsion much of the Cruelty and Inhumanity that hath fallen out had been sav'd and prevented had it not been that Religion had a place in the world Much of that deep and almost inexpiable guilt that hath been contracted through the persecution of the True Religion and opposition to it from the false had never come into account now or at the day of Judgment It is therefore evident upon the whole state of Humane Nature that though there is a main difference in regard of the goodness of God in the Mediator between it and the Angelick Nature fallen that one is universally in chains of darkness to the Judgment of the great Day and without hopes of remedy the other not universally nor without hope Yet those chains are due to the one even as to the other and in what degrees to the Divine Justice in its wisdom it seems meet it casts men into them even as it distributes as it pleases measures of the punishment of sin in taking the forfeitures of the Blessings of Earth of some and not of others when it was given to the children of men alike as to their substantial enjoyment however one might have differ'd from another in glory and laying great calamities upon some and not on others as greatly deserving of them and that in this time of general patience If it were not thus no reason could be given why so great Tracts of Humane Nature lye in the valley of the shadow of death having no light of the True Religion to shine upon them And why without the great discomposure and disturbance of the world and without the ruin and destruction of those that make the offers there can be no offers of better made to them If it were not thus no reason could be given why there is so great a corruption even of Christianity it self where it is generally profest and the attempts of Reformation in Christianity are every whit as dangerous or more than the persuasions to it addrest to Turks or Pagans the lingring Acts of Cruelty in the Inquisition and horrible bloodiness of Massacres exceeding any thing of any other kind Lastly If it were not thus those smaller Differences among Protestants themselves who have had opportunity to look over the unreasonableness and prodigious Inhumanities of Pagans Turks Jews and Papists in their persecutions could never have brought forth so much of spleen hate and sufficient proportions of the same cruelty among themselves when they have had before their eyes not only those pregnant motives to detestation of such Barbarity in those forenamed examples but that mirrour of patience meekness forbearance The Gospel of Jesus Christ Nor is it unworthy of good observation to this purpose that the proceedings against offenders in the Laws of Natural Religion or Morality are generally with leisure moderation proportion between the offence and the punishment a compassion of Humane Nature even where severity is of greatest necessity But in what men levy against different Religions all is carried in storms and whirlwind in fury and rage in blood smoke and fire arguing to us That the Cause not fairly lying before Humane Justice there being an error in the very foundation of the procedure the evil increases and grows upon mens hands till it becomes too mighty for any Government and so carries all before it into prodigious violence of Ferity and salvageness And also that Divine Justice therein shewing to man his great degeneracy and liableness to Divine severity as God himself pleases suffers the power of that Degraded Spirit the God of this World to triumph in nothing more than the abusing Religion and especially Christian Religion that great Contrivance of Heaven for mans recovery out of the state of Devils and to make it like an Engine of destruction to recoil upon man himself and fly every way with terrible death and ruin as if Hell rather than Heaven came along with it Yet notwithstanding all this it is most certain this whole misery is conceiv'd and brought forth by the sin and unworthiness of man to himself by his own stupidity and folly or by his wisdom that is worse than folly earthly sensual and Devilish for the interposal of the Mediator runs so through the whole state of Humane Nature that there are sure ground-works laid how men might in every case recover happiness even out of misery and degeneracy and principally in this very Cardinal Point of that Happiness True Religion and the Peace and Mercy of it care is taken how the World might be secured if it would both from the Ambitious and unquiet man in his designs how Government Anthority Soveraignty might be kept safe and yet unbesmear'd too with Martyrs Blood yea even the blood of those who though they are mistaken yet are willing to profuse it for their Religion For whom it should move pity the nearness of their case to the Honour and Honesty of dying for True Religion I mean when plain Foundations of Natural Religion are not destroyed for that case deserves no more mercy than poysoning Fountains or setting on fire if men could the whole course of Nature Now to discover this path or way to universal peace in Religion which is like Wisdoms The Vulturs eye hath not Job 28. 7. seen it nor the Lions whelp trod it Death and destruction say It is not with them and well they may For it is the way of peace which they have not known though they
Inducements fâ—om Scripture there is the same urgency of Reason for the Day of Judgment passing upon men as in Nations and lesser Communities as upon their single persons for else their actions can never be judged the very complyance with the custom of Nations with the sway of such an Age and time being the reason of many sins and the sinful ways of men are so locked into one another that the Day of Judgment that gives sentence upon all things most righteously comprehends them together even as the Fallen Angels the old World were judged together and in common In Sodom and Gomorrah was given a pre-appeatance of the final Jude 7th Judgment upon the world for the Apostle tellâ— us they were set forth for an ensample and that they suffered the Vengeance of Eternal Fire and we know they suffered in their Community Corah Dathan and Abiram with all their company were involved as in the sin so in the punishment and there is no separation except where Repentance and that with great difficulty hath made it So on the happy side of things Religious Nations and Communities encourage and assist one another in acts of Love Service and Duty to God in Virtue and all Goodness and infold their piety mutually so that on neither side the recompences of Mercy or Justice can be proportioned but as in Community 2. There is the same Reason for the last Judgment passing upon Nations as Nations as for its passing upon private persons as private persons For let any one survey History and he shall find Nations as Nations have escaped the vengeance of God in this world as much as single Persons and the same sort of Revolutions Changes and final Periods have befallen Nations professing God and Christ as those that have been enemies to such Profession as is most apparent in a compare of the Jews or Christian Nations Yea generally those that have been called by the Name of God and Christ have been most speedily punished as those that God hath most especially known of all the Nations of the Earth The Prophet Habâ—kkuk's First Chapter is spent upon this very Subject of that wicked Nation of the Chaldaeans so prosperous above the Jews described in many elegant similitudes and vehemently expostulated from the twelfth verse to the end Whoever shall consider the ancient Romans or the Papacy or the Turkish Empire since the rising of it must needs conclude that to judge Nations as Natiâ—â—â— at last appertains as much to the Paramount Soveraignty oâ—â—â—vine Justice and more than single Persons Nations that have been so great and formidable and Princes swelling with the height of Pride and contempt of God and Religion should in all reason stand in those very Appearances at his Tribunal with their wise Senates mighty Captains Armies and Multitude about them and so be Sentenced and Condemned by the Righteous Judge of all the World the only Potentate the King of Kings Lord of Lords and Prince of Princes even Christ the Son of God in humane Natue else they would not be judged at all as Nations For here neither Love nor Hatred can be known any more to Nations than to single Persons by any thing that is before us There is often one event to all to the Righteous and Merciful and to the Vnjust and Tyrannick Nations to the Good and to the unclean People to them that sacrifice to the True God and to them that sacrifice to Idols There are as many Instances of the severity of God against private particular wicked persons as against such Princes Nations or particular Ages and of his patience and forbearance to the one as to the other There are as great examples of the mercy and favour of God to private particular good men as to pious Nations and Governments and of his severe corrections upon the one as the other The piety therefore and the wickedness of Nations according to their particular Generations equally waits for the last Day even as of single Persons For though there are Periods Judgment sets to it self and when sin is come to its height Judgment stays no longer yet this without a future Judgment will not give satisfaction for the Ages of Prosperity and Greatness the many signal Victories the stupendious Grandeur many very bad Nations and their Princes have arrived at and continued in before the final Calamity hath overtaken them any more than dying at last with great circumstances of pain and horror answers for the worldly prosperity of many a wicked man if after Death there were no Judgment So that especially as to particular Generations there is the same Reason for the Judgment of Nations as of particular Persons 3. If all things were not to be as publickly transacted at the Day of Judgment and to be set upon as open and universal a Theatre as they were acted upon here and that before the Congregation of Heaven and Earth at that day there were not so great reason for an Vniversal Judgment The Privatâ—â—udgment of Souls might suffice Nor could there be any reason 〈◊〉 â—cripture should lay so great weight upon the Resurrection and 〈◊〉 in the very same Bodies at least as to the principal parts and so as that men should be known to be the same persons Why thus If men were not to be presented in the same Circumstances Relations Communities and the most notorious Appearances wherein they conversed and whereby they were most known in the world Let this then be granted and it will rise up to States Governors Senates Princes their Laws and Transactions with the temper of their Times And indeed this setting Persons their places of Habitation their Nation their Times together must needs break out with the greatest lustre of Justice and the Supremacy of Divine Judgment when every thing shall be called to account and represented over again just as it was in this world Things high and low publick and private national and personal but without this all would be dark private obscure and imperfect notwithstanding the gathering all together to that Tribunal For very momentous Causes Circumstances Aggravations or Extenuations of Good or Evil could not be understood The Pride of Sin and Wickedness would not be sufficiently humbled and abased nor despised goodness enough raised and honoured and so would amount to little more than a private Judgment as I said before but Scripture every where instructs us it is the very design of the Day of Judgment to shew and present the whole Scene of things and to seâ— the ballance of them even in all particulars It is the Day not only of the righteous Judgment of God but of the manifestation of it every thing is then composed to shew and Manifestation it is the appearance of Christ whom God will then show in the highest glory of the humane Nature and so that his low despised humbled and crucifyed State shall also be seen and the glory triumph over it to the utter confusion and wailing of
Chains of Scandal till the Judgment of the great day that Jude 6. it may then be decided whether they had just cause of Offence or not Thus the Devil was a Lyar from the beginning and the Father of it of the Lye of Scandal For all Scandal is a Lye John 8. 44. And now when there was an actual Fall a Defection of any of the Rational Creatures actually come to pass God still permitting things to their own Liberty then it cannot be but that Scandals come For when once the Activity of an Understanding carried with a perverse and disorderly Will is in motion then it traverses all ways cuts all those Lines of Allyance and Connexion betwixt Things and Things scales the heights dives down into the bottom fills all things with Confusion and Perplexity that it may Scandalise mis-represent and mis-report God and Supream Goodness extols forbidden Pleasures and Enjoyments and an imaginary Happiness as if enviously denied and that denial unreasonably and to no benefit complyed with And the more Agents there are thus perverted and ill disposed the more Scandals must needs arise and shew themselves when therefore Angels fell or if some Principal fell first there must needs be Scandals in motion from them and they drew down innumerable lesser Stars with them when they propagated Scandal to Men as we read in the History of the Fall and Men grew numerous and wicked Scandals must needs come amain and multiply themselves For so many sinful and impure Understandings at work and hurried on by extreamly bad and unholy Wills Scandals must become like a Deluge and cannot but increase to a kind of Infinite and must be pressing every where for there is no Light so clear but a dim and dark Eye may report it black and obscure there is no way so smooth and even but Lame Legs Crooked Feet being themselves unequal may stumble and fall in it When a Man as Solomon says is cast into a Net by his own Feet when his Feet are a Net to themselves he must be Scandalised and Catch'd wherever he goes There is no Sense so grave and seriously compos'd but a vain Fancy that is full of odd and antick Shapes and Images within it self may travestee and turn it into Ridicule Even the plainest Sense by Ignorance or Malice may be so transpos'd as to be made most unintelligible Non sense and by separating the parts from their due order one to another may be perverted into Falshood and Blasphemy Thus therefore by the Darkness of Mens minds by the Maliciousness and ill Designs of corrupted Intellectuals enraged by impure Lusts and Passions the plainest things in Religion may be mis-understood mis-represented mis-reported and disguised out of themselves much more the more secret retir'd and even unfathomable parts of Divine Truth Providence and Government God hath made every thing good that he hath made and his very permissions of Evil are all over-ruled by him to Good and even to us they may be Medicinal and of use if taken by the right Handle On the other side Scandal turns the very best things into Evil to the Person Offended and nothing can be so Good that it both not so abuse The Spies it sends out upon the Land of Promise bring up an ill Report of it Indifferent Things that are by God prepared and intended to turn each way either to use or not to use according as Circumstances lead and both ways to be advantages for Good Scandal hath a great hand over and turns them to Evil all ways Things that are Evil the Sins and Falls of Men either Good Men or Bad Men or Men seemingly Good and inwardly Bad are as the proper Dominion and Territory of Scandal and it raises what it can against Religion by them Thus every thing by the not only Permission but Justice of God upon the faln World is subjected to Scandal not willingly for all things work together for good as they are impressed with Motion from the Divine Hand but deserted by that but so much as permissively Scandal violently transports them upon Evil. Now things standing thus there is the God of Scandal and his Angels the Angels of Scandal the Divel and the whole Hoast of faln Spirits the Great Reasons and Wits of this World the Prophets of Scandal the Ambitious Powers and Interests of Worldly Greatness Secular Policy Ecclesiastical Domination Debauched Religion and in one word the whole Universe of Lusts all at the service of Scandal and employed by it From hence are all those Atheistick Discourses those Heretical Opinions those Monstrous Idolatries and Superstitions those Burlesques of Lucian Wits those Bold and Authoritative Examples of general Wickedness Prophaneness and Irreligion that have spread themselves over the whole Earth those Severities in matters of Indifferency And where there is in any Time or Place such a sense of Truth and Religion that any of these Evils plain and bare-faced take very little but are hated and hooted at every thing that is better is borrowed against it self the Mantle of Law and Right is put on pretences of Religion are made the Rayment of things most contrary to it And in all times True Religion Piety and Vertue expulsed under the worst Names and covered with the ugly Vizor of Evil it being hard to bring Goodness into mis-repute in its own likeness under its own appearance To this purpose besides every Man being the first and worst Scandaliser to himself besides the lower and lesser Ministeries of Scandal within privater Communities there are in all Times and Places the publick Councels of Scandal and the Cabals of it that are neither Idle nor Lukewarm but pursuing all things to the utmost And the Men of this World are always greedy of Scandal of receiving it either through miserable Ignorance and Inapprehensiveness or from Propensions of their own and to serve their particular Occasions or as they embark their Interests in the Bottom of a Common Scandal as most safe and of the richest Return or if it were no more they are always so near of Kin to Degeneracy and Depravedness Now lay all these together and we may easily find Scandals must come not only lesser Scandals but greatest and most prevailing ones that do as it were sweep the World before them If any thing therefore can be added to Scandal it will be we must expect it though there hath been so much done upon it to improve it and especially since the Rising Progress and yet surviving Contest of the Western Antichristianisme And whether there may be yet a Reserve in the Counsels of God for Scandal before its Final Abolition to unite and summon all its Strength and become in a sort Oecumenical I mean the Scandal of Antichristianism especially these latter Days must discover In the mean time I will not be afraid to say There is a very horrible Scandal rising at this very time even a Protestant Popery placing such an absolute Dependence upon
according to the undeniable Sense of Scripture Quest But the nearness of these Fathers to the Days of Christ and the Apostles must needs enable them either from what they themselves received warm from their Lips or from what they had from others not quite cold to know the Apostles Doctrine Discipline Manner of Life Purpose their Sense of the Scope and Meaning of those Things wherein they were Divinely Inspired and so to deliver it to After-ages Answ Whatever they have spoken or written giving us more light and advantage to understand and behold Scripture in its own Light ought from them or from any other to be accepted with great regard but if it do not thus it cannot be accepted even from the Writers of Scriptures themselves upon a single or divided Authority They were so bounded by the very Things and Words they themselves had once spoken and written by the Holy-Ghost that all the deference to their knowledge in Divine Things above others was to be made reasonable in the clearest Expounding what themselves and others had written by Divine Inspiration and to be discerned in the very Writings themselves and not to be drawn oracularly out of their Breasts when the Evidences of Divine Inspiration were not upon them For he that is Spiritual i. e. that God vouchsafes Inspiration to or pretends to it must acknowledge all that is either truly written or spoken by the same Inspiration to be the Commandments of the Lord 1 Cor. 14. 37. And as for the newness freshness and life of Truth given by Divine Revelation God graciously providing it should remain as Revelation left it and the Evidences it hath done so appearing with it it is the same in all Ages Divine never loses of its life nor abates of its vigor what it was so many Ages ago that it abides now what the Holy-Ghost spoke so many Ages ago that it speaks now as warmly as then All Divine Truth given is after the power of an endless life the Eternal Increated Spirit lives in it and gives Divine Quickness to it It is yesterday to day the same for ever and so breathes its own sense in Scripture by the ordinary Assistances it vouchsafes to Holy Humble and diligent Waiters upon him in this even as it did in the first Ages though the extraordinary Motions are withdrawn Quest But still the Gifts and Endowments of those Eminent Men with all the Light Truth Grace Learning and Reason they shine to us with ought to be esteemed and improved Answ Yes doubtless For whatsoever Things are true whatsoever things are pure are of Virtue and deserved praise they are Publick and of God wherever they are found And whatever there is in these Elders in their nearness to the First Times their Holiness their Sufferings their great Learning their Encounters of Paganism their Apologies for Christianity their Heavenliness their Contempt of this World all is a Donation and a Grace of God by them to his Church and Mankind in general Quest And does not there arise great Evidence to Christianity and the Doctrines and Practices of it from such eminent Witnesses Answ No doubt there does both to Christianity in particular and to all Religion Virtue and Goodness in general But yet neither their Writings nor Practices can in any wise become Scripture to us they all lead to Scripture and ought to do so they are all to be seen and reflected in Scripture Light and from thence they receive their lustre For though they are a Subordinate Testimony as hath been said yet Christian Religion hath greater Testimony and first enabled them to give a valuable Testimony to it self by Communicating so great knowledge and worth to them And besides all that hath been spoken the Writings of the Fathers are so Voluminous as not to be read over by the most so doubtful in their Genuiness that they cannot be Examined but with great Labour and well prepared Judgment so disputable in their sense that to attain a certainty in it would cut off Time from the greater Imployment of Meditation in the Word of God day and night where Men's Callings lie otherwise so that to receive our Religion from hence were of too remote an assurance to any one much more to those who have not Books and studie for their Profession But every Man whether learned or unlearned is concerned deeply to try his Religion with his own Eyes and not anothers for him and God hath therefore provided a Word nigh him even in his Mouth and in his Heart and hath also taken care by stirring up so many both of the Ancient and Modern Christians to separate themselves to intermeddle with all sacred knowledge that there is a worthy exercise of the learned World herein and great advantages arise thereby for universal knowledge even to the less learned and the very unlearned Quest But did the Fathers themselves distinguish thus their own and one anothers Writings from Scripture Answ It is most evident as hath been already affirmed they put a greatest difference betwixt the most excellent Monuments of Christianity that were but Humane whether their own or others and inspired Pages else Clement Ignatius and others might as well have been Canoniz'd by them as what is from them come down to us for Sacred Canon it self and even as they did we may see the great odds betwixt the one and the other and as we adore God the supreme Author so the Sovereign Preserver of Scripture who by Divine Evidences and by superintending Providence hath divided the bound of Scripture at so great a remove from all the Writings in the World whether Christian or Prophane the Apocryphal Books not excepted which though too adventurously joyn'd so generally in a Volume with Scripture yet are evidently disproportioned in the Majesty of Sense and Divine Eloquence Quest Is there no greater Authority of the First Councils Answ How many Humanes soever meet they cannot make up Divine where it was not before nor can a multitude of Privates constitute a Publick Divine and Publick may be declared but cannot be made so by such Contribution All Determinations of Councils are infinitely outweighed in Value and over-ruled in Authority by Scripture indeed Publick and Divine Quest But in such a number of his Servants may we not conclude God is certainly among them and does guide them Answ Give them all the advantages that can be given and either we must say they are Infallibly guided and then we must receive their Decrees as Scripture and they must be attested to us as Scripture is attested or they are not Infallibly guided and then their Decrees must be tryed as all Fallibles ought to be by a Rule surer than themselves If even Divine Revelation it self was at first tryed and found perfect nay if even all that God proposes to us as from himself comes laden with its own proper Evidences how much more must that which is confessedly humane be tryed by that which is confessedly
God Answ I aknowledge the Resolution of this Doubt contains many difficulties in it and cannot be given at once but I shall endeavour so to lead your Questions by every Degree of Answer as may direct into the best method for your satisfaction Quest What I pray you is the first step necessary to be taken in order to the Resolving this Doubt Answ To settle a True Understanding how the Magistrates Power and Authority in Religion made entrance into the World Quest I very much desire to know that and believe it to be of very great Influence into all things that concern the unfolding this Question Answ This then I take to be the best Account of it After the apparent Degeneracy of Humane Nature so that the Laws written in Mens Hearts were evidently defaced and blotted by contrary Practices there was a necessity of forming the great Notions of Natural Religion Godliness Righteousness and Soberness into Laws that Men might be thereby preserved from highest Irregularities and excess under the pretence of being at Liberty or every Man being a Lawgiver to himself Quest I desire you further to Explain how this brought in Magistracy Answ That such Laws might be made and Executed there must be some supreme Legislative and Executive Power in every Community whether placed in one or more whether by the Title of Paternity or Primogeniture whether Hereditary and Successive or Elective whether by Agreement and Covenant primarily or by Submission and Pacts after Conquest These things aâ—e variously ordered by God in his Paramount but secret Government of the World But the Laws of Godliness Righteousness and Soberness are so necessary and Men know them to be so necessary that they cannot be without them nor without some Supreme Legislation and Execution of Laws formed according to them They that are above see a necessity of Governing by them they that are below see a ncecessity of being Governed by the same and therefore submit by Common Consent to some supreme Authority and Subordinate Magistrates under the Supreme to that end Mankind is touch'd by this Impression from God and all that are not are branded as Sons of Belial Quest But how are Princes and Magistrates secured in the Exercise of their Power against those that would not be Subject Answ Besides the Laws of God written in the Heart and promulg'd in the World besides the secret Touches and Motions of Providence and Interlinkings of Common Interest with the Rights of Soveraignty Princes and Soveraign Rulers are both by the Will of God and the Common Consent of Mankind surrounded with Grandeuâ— of Highest Estate that they may draw Subjects into their Service and Dependence upon them by the greatness of their Rewards being both the Fountain of Honour and of Splendor of Condition But especially they are Arm'd with the Power of the Sword intrusted with them by God that by the awe of their Wrath and Vengeance they may bring People into Subjection and a Readiness to Obey Thus they appear as Gods in the World as Living Images of the most High in their Vicegerency according to what is said to them by Inspired Wisdom I have said ye are Gods and Sons of the Most High Quest But why hath it not pleased God to appear himself in this Authority and Power Visibly and Immediately which would cut off all Dispute as to Supreme Right and Male-Administration which do now often disturb the Peace of Government and the People under it or at least why hath he not given Angels a Superiority and Visible Presidency over Kingdoms as that which would much more awe and Compose the World Answ The Wisdom of God hath in all things appeared in attempering things one to another with greatest Equality So he hath thought fit in infinite Wisdom to Govern Men by Men. He hath Committed all Judgment to Christ because he is the Son of Man he will Judge the World at last by that Man whom he hath appointed Christ Jesus Thus he Governs Men all along by the Men of his Right-Hand as Images of himself but more immediately of Christ the Great Son of Man thus in his Word he speaks to Men by Men like themselves And as to the Conceit of Mankind Submitting with greater awe to a Government from Heaven it is but like that of having one from the Dead to speak to them when they have Moses and the Prophets by which if they are not persuaded neither would they be persuaded though one should rise from the Dead nor would they be Governed by one from Heaven that are not Governed by that Humane Majesty and Soveraignty Created by God on purpose for them as is most Evident in those many Rebellions of the People of Israel under so evident a Theocrasie or so immediate a Government of God Quest Is the Power of Magistrates only in those clear and undoubted poiâ—ts of Godliness Righteousness and Soberness Answ Because under the two latter of these there is a vast Compass of the Interests of the Peace and Weal and Honour of Nations in all Traffique and Commerce in provision for safety and security and adjusting of Laws to all these ends there must be a vast Compass also of Power in these extending to all Indifferent things Indifferent till they come to be determined by Princes and Powers but then by the Ordinance of God to be observed according to those Laws determining them this way or that way Quest But I desire you to give yet a closer and stricter Account of the Power of Soveraigns in Religion or Godliness being the main point of of the present Enquiry Answ That I may answer your desire I must consider Religion as it is Natural Religion written in the Hearts of Men as it is Revealed Religion published by extraordinary Ministers and Consign'd to after Ages by inspired Writing or Scripture and lastly as Religion is so or so Circumstantiated and Modelled in the External Administration of it Now by Natural Religion as distinguish'd from Revealed Religion I do plainly intend that Religion whether it be drawn out by the meer force of Natural Conscience without any plain or known Assistances of Revealed Truth or whether it was not known to be Natural Religion till being Revealed Natural Conscience acknowledges it and must needs Confess it to be True Natural Religion or that the wisest and soberest part of Mankind confesses it to be so or whether it be what Natural Religion teaches upon the supposition of Revealed Religion acknowledged and confessed to be from God for then Natural Religion confesses and urges that all Revelations from God that evidence themselves to any Mans mind to be from God should be received with Reverence and submitted to with Obedience In all these cases of Natural Religion I boldly and positively assert the Soveraign Power hath a Right given it by God to Make and Execute Laws according to the Obligations of Natural Religion even as in all Cases of Righteousness and Soberness or Common
THE PRINCIPLES OF PROTESTANT Truth and Peace IN FOUR TREATISES VIZ. The TRUE STATE of LIBERTY of CONSCIENCE In Freedom from Penal Laws and Church-Censures The OBLIGATIONS to NATIONAL TRUE RELIGION THE NATURE of SCANDAL Particularly as it relates to Indifferent Things A CATHOLICK CATECHISM Shewing the True Grounds upon which the Catholick Religion is ascertained Zech. 8. 19. Love the Truth and Peace By THO. BEVERLEY Rector of Lilley in Hertfordshire LONDON Printed for Tho. Parkhurst and Will. Miller at the Bible and Three Crowns in Cheapside and the Acorn in St. Paul's Church-yard 1683. To the Reader I Have very sadly observed the great distress of Humane Affairs through miscarriages every way in point of Religion For while the Powers of this world and Ecclesiastick Jurisdictions take it for their Right to impose by severe Penalties and dreadful Censures what they think fit under so great a name they yet neither can assure any one they are not or do not use to be mistaken in their recommendations or that all their Authority or Power shall excuse and acquit those that obey them when they appear before Gods Tribunal so that it is impossible the Judgment or Conscience should have any repose here On the other side some not only out of Recoyl for self-preservation or out of design but from Furious Wild Principles have broken out into publick disturbance to make room for what they have proclaim'd as the Kingdom of God and Christ to the great scandal of True Religion the imbrewing their hands very horridly in Blood and the seeming Justification of utmost Rigors against any pretences of Religion except according to Law Besides all this private Feuds and Animosities vehement and angry disputes are every where clamorous and people hereupon in great Amuse what they should believe or do Now since there is no doubt all these evils are foreseen by God there is as little doubt that there are sure Remedies provided against them I have then upon the whole this account to give the Reader That the observation of so many Counter-Cries of Opinion such great Exasperations in mens Affections such Complaints of oppression of Conscience by undue Laws such Recriminations of Faction Sedition Fanaticism not only among Christians but among Protestant Christians and of the same Common National Interest mov'd me to seek Retirement to some Rock of Certainty that I might be at perfect Peace upon in full satisfaction of Judgment and composure of Affection and having found Natural Religion as certain as our Faculties and Fundamental Christianity in most things of the same immediate certainty as Natural in all things after due exploration of the same final certainty I am so far at Peace in my Judgment as to have no doubt WHAT IS TRVTH in relation to Eternal Happiness if ten thousand more of Opinions encompassed me round about so far at Peace in my Affections as not to be in Commotion with any man that gives Testimony to Christian Charity that he is a strict observer of Natural Religion and Fundamental Christianity one Essential Rule of both which is Love Peace and Mercy to all that are centred in this Natural Christian Religion though they may adjoyn or refuse some Eccentrick Placits that do not harm the Foundation Lastly I am assur'd this very Natural Religion espoused by Christianity well considered and observed would disarm the world of those Instruments of Cruelty in the Cause of Religion so extreamly abhored by it whether used by angry supreme Powers or unjustly taken up by Seditious Ambitious or Fanatick Subjects Which Cruelty men are sain to borrow from wild Beasts no such being given by the Gracious Author of all things to so excellent a Nature as he made the Humane and therefore most certainly not by the Redeemer nor his Religion who came to fill the world with Innocency Goodness and Peace after so great an Invasion of Barbarity and Cruelty Now having found this satisfaction my self I make offer of it if it may be the same to others asking only Candid Interpretation in particular management the main Principle being above the need of pardon or the Fear of Indignation Although the Discourse being intended much shorter is not distinguished in the Body of it into Chapters or otherwise yet that the Reader may have a guidance into the main Designs of it I have prefixed this Summary of Heads of Discourse following each other The Contents THE Introduction Explaining the Text and shewing the merciful Design of Christianity against contrary appearances The always present way of determining Doubts in Religion 1. to 8. Of Natural Religion as sure as our Faculties and the Examination of Things by it 10. to 26. Of Natural-Religion united by Christian Religion to and with it self as the only Assurance and Test of Revealed Religion and of the little value of Ceremonies in Religion either Natural or Christian 27. to 45. Of Natural Religion the only standard of Humane Paenal Laws in Religion 45. to 79. Of the great use of Natural Religion in composing and deciding Differences in Christian Religion applied to some of the greatest Controversies in it 80 82. Of the first Principle of Peace in Christianity it self The important Honourable Business given as one Rule to walk by wherein it engages all its Disciples several ways producing peace 88 to 94. Of the grand Principles of the Vnion of Christians into one Body on which love and peace are infallibly to ensue 95 to 99. Of Heresie and the nature of it cutting off from that Vnion exemplified in Popery and whether the Roman Society be a True Church Of Schism and its nature as it cuts off from the Body of Christ 99 to 110. Of the Laws for Christians being imbodied in a Catholick Church in particular Congregations or Churches and the Order of Both to National Christian Constitutions Of the great value the word of God gives to Publick National Religion requiring our utmost attemperation of our selves to it consistently with conscience Of the Peace of Christianity in relation to the Ministerial presidency of it in relation to Magistracy to Vniversal Goodness 121 to 127. A Lamentation over the World's unhappiness in relation to so excellent a thing as Religion and Christian Religion 127. An Offerture for the Amicable Return of all Protestants one to another within our English Nation and the Methods of it 136. ERRATA PAGE 2 l. 28. r. action p. 7. l. 25. for thus r. that p. 17 l. 17. blot them p. 23 l. 1 for them r. that l. 5. for it self r. themselves p. 27. l. 32. r. appellation p. 91. l. 37. for they r. that p. 109. l. 7. blot why l. 10. blot who being p. 1220 Marg. r. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 p. 141. l. 7. r. done ISA. XI 6 7 8 9. The wolf also shall dwell with the lamb and the leopard shall lie down with the kid and the calf and the young lion and the fatling together and a little child shall lead them And
of matter or body in a perpetual transmutation can bear And that this Doctrine also of a future state is to the utmost cannot be denied since nothing can more compleat happiness or misery than the Scripture expressions reach to But I insist no further upon this being in the main substance of it in my account of it a fundamental point of Natural Religion but that God will transact this Judgment by Jesus Christ is indeed perfect Revelation and falls in with the former account given of his Mediatorship and enhanses still this principle as to its greatest certainty so to all its possible height since God in humane nature God in the Mediator Judging the world turns about with greatâ—st consolation to good men and terror to evil men that can be comprehended by humane understanding And so I have endeavoured to make good the second Head of discourse under this first foundation of universal peace Consent in Natural Religion viz. that Christian Religion in what it reveals beyond Natural Religion agrees yet with Natural Religion and is recommended by it and herein I have insisted upon those points of Christian Religion that are truly Christian for those private disputes among Christians were much better silenced within the Gates of Christianity it self in that way wherein they are managed and therefore much more ought not to be declared in Gath nor published in the streets of Ashkelon neither indeed need the points themselves upon which the disputes are For if together with those undoubted Principles of Natural Religion in Doctrine Worship and Practice as they are reveal'd by Christian Religion wherefrom none can make defection but under the most righteous severity of the Magistrate who in those cases bears not the sword in vain I say if together with these the substantial truths and institutions of Christian revealed Religion wherein we are all agreed were presented as the general confession or profâ—ssion of Christians before we come to lanch out into parâ—icular opinions or modes of worship our excellent Râ—ligion would stand much more like a City set on an hill Mat. 5. 14. whose Magnificence and Beauty could not be hid for the benefit both of strangers and its own Citizens since things so great so excellent so agreeable with all the inward sense of mens minds could not be rejected by those that would be accounted men of Mind Soul and Reason and especially there could upon these terms Christianity offers be no possible place for hurting or destroying Christians by any party except men are resolved to lay aside the Man and put on the Lion and Wolf Now by all that hath been spoken upon this point it appears three sorts of Opinions whatever of Christianity they assume to themselves are indeed the injury and horrible scandal of it because they contradict Natural Religion which is an abomination to Christianity 1. That Opinion which adoring our Mediator as having all power in Heaven and Earth allows him an ubiquitary presence and addresses prayers to him allots him all Divine Honours and yet denies him Coeternal God with the Father for this brings in supreme worship love confidence in more than the One God it cloaths Finite with Infinite which is a contradiction to the Law of Natural Religion every where illustrated and confirmed by the Word of God Of this great evil Socinianism Arrianism and the several names of Heresy of that Alliance are guilty 2. That which brings in Image-worship prayers to Saints and Angels which supposes Invisible Beeings though creatures Omniscient and Omnipresent as God that in all places men may lift up hands to them in prayer without doubting of their being lost in their direction to those that are not that they know able to take any notice of them and further which is not the least of the Idolatry it gives them the honour of being absolutely knowable by natural light in the Divine Attribute of hearing prayers that all flesh may come to them viz. in their Knowledg in their Mercy in their Power all which must be absolute as Gods and as evident to reason as in God seeing men have no justifiable revelation to any such purpose the Arto latria or adoration of the bread in the Sacrament is of the same family now however these things are intricated by various pretexts yet as the spectacle in the last especially is horrid to sense so the things to Reason and Natural Conscience and can ne'r be reconciled we have otherwise learnt Christ who in the days of his flesh neither requir'd nor receiv'd worship directed to his body upon any such pretensions Mark 10. 17. Luke 11. 27. 28. John 6. 36. John 20. 17. but refus'd it except when at sometimes the mighty Emanations of his Divinity prostrated men into the Adorations of him 3. Whatever Dogme or Sect of men subvert the very nature of Religion as a Proteus-Thing that sneaks into all shapes and professions according to the earthly powers it appears before fearing men rather than God All things that overturn morality and distinction betwixt good and evil the denial of Spirits a future State as undermining the very Life and Beeing of the Almighty Spirit all Phanatick Principles turning Religion into Raunterism or moving the pillars of humane societies as consisting in submission to principalities and powers in subjection to Laws civil customs and decencies all such things as these and the whole lineage of them however they may presume to Christianize themselves are a just abhorrence to the true Christian Spirit as most contrary to the Law of nature These opinions therefore now named are excluded and shut out of that universal Peace and Quietness I am to speak of under this last Head of the survey of Natural Religion which I now come to viz. The third thing proposed under this first head of Natural Religion and upon which the whole weight of it rests and turns as to the intention of this Discourse is this That Christianity supposes it a firm ground of enjoying the Common Peace and Tranquility in Religion that a man receives and owns all the grand points of Natural Religion Godliness Righteousness Soberness and acknowledges it his duty and makes it his profession to live according to them that he avows no Principles contrary hereunto though he believes and professes to be assur'd of some other Divine Revelations in order to his Eternal Happiness It supposes a man that in all his discourse and action gives abundant security of his fidelity to Natural Religion A man that is no Idolater Atheist Blasphemer of Religion Impugner of Morality that observes the Worship of God in Prayers Praises and Religious Discourses should be free to commend himself to God in what he thinks most agreeable to his will though in distinction from others whom he no way disturbs against rules of Reason Modesty Peaceableness and Humility but only offers the Apology of his own faith yet with meekness and fear and the perswasives â— Pet. 3. 15.
before God from the guilt and destruction of those that may be yet heinously guilty before God as Jonah's Mariners did from the Blood of that Prophet consigned over to the Sea by his own Sentence Oh Lord lay not this mans blood to our charge who have Jon. 1. 14 done all it pleased thee to command us When Soveraigns and Nations have considered the Wisdom Rationality and Heavenliness of Proposals in Religion and setled upon what they find of the highest Character as the Religion of their Nation by Law to be established to which they allow the encouragement of their publick Honours and Maintanance and taken care for the propagation of it by Instructions Arguments Reasons and good Examples they have done all that God expects from them to do and so have delivered their own souls That which was of their free judgment and arbitrement as proper to them as to families and persons to dispose of their own they have placed as they thought upon due consideration most to the glory of God and the good of the people but to deprive men of their native rights or to punish them in their Persons or Estates who are not Offenders against Natural Religion for the sentiments of their minds of which they have only a humane judgment is not a Power wherewith they think themselves invested of God and so forbear it This is indeed the Religion of a Nation of Men a Nation of Christians a Vertuous an Honourable Government and more hopeful to propagate true Christianity than that which writes its Laws in Blood And this is to Rule over men and not over Beasts bound up as men should be with the cords of a man in Natural Religion in what is beyond that as revealed from God with Bands of Love to serve the Publick Blessed are the people who are in such a case blessed is that people whose God is thus the Lord Jehovah Object 2. What Peace can there be in the world amongst private and particular persons while there are several opinions in Religion how many Disputes and Calumnies and Invectives are continually flying up and down by reason of differences in Religion and how much better are all compelled into Vnion Answer All these evils are but so many Arguments of depraved Nature which creates its own occasions out of every thing and if the mischiefs of Compulsion or the ill state even of those parts of thâ— world where the voice of Religion is all one laâ—â—â—â—ge were cast up I doubt they would be found to ballance the worst that can be charged on differences in Religion But yet Natural Religion and most evidently Christian Religion is most severe and positive against all Strife Envy Railings evil Surmisings and bends men upon Peace Love Meâ—kness Quietness Charity towards all men and especially Christians as is after to be shâ—wn and therefore undoubtedly those evil effects where they grow to excess may be restrained by Civil Magistracy as in any other case and the rather that True Religion so much disowning them they are more inexcusable in that cause than any other for though we find Scripture severe in its language in great cases as St. Paul against the Bigots of the Law yet we must also consider the Infallible Spirit that guided Sacred Writers who alone knows how to direct those sharp arrows and what effect they shall take Object 3. This clips off the Royalty and Prerogative of Princes if they have not the command of mens Sentiments or at least of their outward Actions and Practises in Religion Ans The unjust Enlargements of Earthly Power into the Divine Sanctuary hath been always fatal to Princes Vzziah's rude entrances into it were punished by God with infamous Leprosy Herods Letting that sacrilegious acclamation It is 1 Chron. 28. 18 19. Act. 12. 22 23 the voice of a God not of a man sink into him was presently reveng'd with a dreadful hand of Judgment Humane Power is safest keeping it self within the verge of Divine Institution beyond that though it may seem greater yet it becomes only like a swelling wall the bigger it is the more ready to fall or a tottering Fence expatiating to ruine Their Honour is great in being nursing-Fathers if God had intended Civil Magistracy to govern in any Religion but Natural they should have had as certain Rules to act by as they have in Natural Religion Besides what is the good of being great Masters in Religion except in that wherein God hath shewed every man what is good seeing the greater Judgment waits for such Thus the Apostle James James 3. 1. My brethren be not many masters imposers or prescribers in Religion that is do not affect it knowing we shall receive a greater Judgment Object 4. But it is impossible to govern with any security if Governours hold not the Reins of mens Consciences if they have not the Rule of that Helm that turns about so great Bodies of people which way soever they that have that Pylotry please with what vigor and courage are men animated while the Principles and Rewards of Religion are in their hearts and eyes If therefore the Prince rules not in these his Command is but Cypher Answer 1. Religion is too great and noble a thing to be but an Expedient of Government 2. The History of Christianity assures us no Princes have had more obedient Subjects a more valiant Souldiery than Heathen Princes of Christians True Religion knows its obligation to Government and pursues the Laws of it though that Government hath stood distinct from that True Religion And this is the standing-Rule of Christians Object 5. But what Tumults Factions Seditions have been rais'd under Religious pretences when Subjects have not yielded themselves to the Empire of Princes in Religion Answ These evils as they are falsely pretended by men of turbulency to be for the service of Religion so they are unjustly charg'd upon it There can be therefore no severity too great upon those that so abuse so excellent a thing But the sâ—mâ— care that secures against ambition sedition rebellion in one shape will do it in another without taking away lawful liberties Nor is there any remedy so specifick against the great Hypocrisie of covering Rebellion with Religion Faction with Faith as the severest Regiment of men according to the indisputable Laws of Natural Religion and allowance of the greatest Tolleration in what no way contradicts that For then is the artifice strongest when it is planted in the oppression of mens consciences so great an illegality against Natural Principles Take away severe Impositions and what have such Politicians to work upon Object 6. But what a Hydra a many-headed Monster of Opinions will Religion become by such a Toleration Answ 1. Severe Natural Religion enforc'd and strictly pursued will so rebate mens corruptions besides the hopes and expectations of Divine Blâ—ssing accompanying so vertuous a Government that there will be a much greater retrenchment of Opinions than can be
Rome and the Reformed Churches Although I have a just value for all those renowned labours of the great lights God hath raised up in the Protestancy a very rational and Christian entertainment of the Writer and Reader Yet I must profess the unshaken Assurance I center upon in all those Controversies is a short Conclusion of the matter That Romish Religion not only is not but cannot be true it is impossible it should be of God if Scripture and our Faculties are true if Natural Religion or Christian Religion that we have in the Scriptures be true And this I take to be a ready and sure Antidote against Popery to all that are equally concern'd to know which is the True Religion Catholick Religion falsly so called Popish Religion or Protestant Religion though they have not opportunity to acquaint themselves with all the Learning so plentiful so valuable at this day in the world for the decision between them 2. That great Principle of Natural Religion Hear Oh Israel the Lord thy God is one Jehovah and Thou shalt love Deut. 6. 4 5. the Lord thy God with all thy soul with all thy mind with all thy might and strength And that great Principle of Christian Religion If any man love not the Lord Jesus let 1 Cor. 16. 22. him be Anathema Maranatha these two joyned together assure me beyond doubt Our Mediator upon whom our Love Trust Service is to rest and that at such a distance as is Heaven from Earth cannot be but the One God with the Father and so I am resolved in the Socinian Controversie And further if he be the Eternal Son of God and his offering up the Humanity united to him a sacrifice I know it must be of infinite value and not a martyrdom not an example only 3. By Natural and Christian Principles united I am convinc'd the great foundations on which the Controversies between the Arminian and Calvinist as we use to express them rest must have great truth on both sides but they being related to those judgments of God that are as a great depth it is impossible to find them out to perfection for how can Finite wade in Infinite without being swallowed by it We need not therefore stay till these two things can be reconcil'd in our Judgments the infinite soveraignty and dominion of the Almighty over every particular immortal spirit that he hath made so that it cannot be dispos'd of or dispose it self without the counsel and foreknowledg of God and yet that no one is prejudg'd by any determination of God in the true liberty of a rational creature much less determin'd to sin and misery upon it by any over-ruling power We may safely with respects to both sides be profoundly abased in the sense of Incomprehensible soveraignty over us in a self-condemnation wherein soever we find our selves degenerate and fallen into sin as knowing our destruction of our selves Nor need we stay till supreme grace and our own free-will are reconcil'd in dispute we may safely on both sides make our humblest and most lowly appeals to him that worketh in us both to will and to do We must do so and are under the same security and obligation in stirring up our utmost Phil. 2. 13. Ezek. 18. 32. powers in turning our selves that we may live in working out our salvation with fear and trembling And all beyond Phil. 2. 12. these two conclusions are but Speculation in which we may imploy and entertain our selves in considering infinite wisdom and glory and searching as near as we dare approve its holy and gracious ways but need not be angry we can't agree in things out of our depth so as to be certain 4. In all the Disputes concerning Forms of Church-Government Modes of Worship we have thus much of resolution from the consent of Christian with Natural Religion Whatever is most substantially good is fittest to be the center of Agreement and Vnion and other things doubtful allowed to particular reason and choice with mutual tolleration and charity As is further to be shewn us under the next Head of Discourse Having now spoken so much of Natural Religion I think it necessary before I quite leave it besides the survey I have taken of it to add these Characters concerning it that it may not possibly be mistaken 1. It is that which depends upon nothing particular but must be the same to all Nations and times it is all essence and hath no accidents or circumstances as it is natural To pray is Natural Religion that is to lift up Desires to God with humility and hope this is and must be the same without any variation to every man in the world Now whatever can be suppos'd to pertain to it if it be not the same every where is not Natural Religion There can be but one nation of a God to all the world there can be but one Justice Sobriety throughout there can be but one notion of sin or of the pardon of it of Judgment to come as they are natural Till you come to Essence you come not to Natural Religion 2. It is that which cannot be demurr'd to but with the failure of all sober reason nor indeed without a consciousness of it while denied I am fully assured no man can deny a God a distinction between good and evil a future state without a strong recoil of the Natural Faculties returning as by an Intellectual Moral Elastick force 3. It is that whereof if any of the Principles be taken away grand inconveniencies and absurdities will follow like taking away light air or water out of the natural world What an infinite necessity is there of God of Prayer to him of Praises of him of his pardoning-mercy since sin of Judgment to come Take away these and universal nature flys in pieces runs every way upon so great a vacuum as the want of any these Principles immediately makes This is Natural Religion and nothing else is Natural Religion but this Having discours'd what a foundation of Vniversal Peace Christian Religion hath laid in not only assuming to but uniting with it self Natural Religion I shall come now to present as in perspective Christian Religion it self and shew the admirable contrivances for unity peace and love it hath found out and most earnestly prest on all its Disciples so infinitely wise reasonable and good so efficaciously insinuated so strongly argued and enforc'd so awfully commanded so to the life the very Divine life of it even Hypostatiz'd in our Lord that it is indeed the inexpiable shame and guilt of the Christian world that it is so unlike the Divine Philosophy the Laws the grand Exemplar of it That I may pursue this Intention with greatest advantage I shall propose under several Heads how this design is laid by the infinite wisdom of our Saviour much different from what is ready on all occasions to offer it self to Humane Imagination that is Vnity in Vniformity without which as
Testament the Apocalypse foretel the kingdoms of the world in the very state of Kingdoms becoming the Lords and his Christs All these things argue a great encouragement of Nations receiving and making a publique profession of the Gospel as Nations even as Families may and ought as Families And though it be undoubtedly the great Honour and Glory of Nations to come as near and as exact and close as may be to the Laws and Order of Christ in the Government as in the Constitution of their National Christianity yet because there will and generally falls out to be a mixture of National Customs in such publique Administrations a Comprimise of them to the Laws and Government of Nations hence it also comes to pass there may be a dissatisfaction in many of the subjects of such Nations to comply with their National Constitutions of Religion Hence there is apt to arise Discomposure and Disquiet if Princes or Powers exceed that exercise of Power allotted to them by God as we have before discours'd and also by the very essential constitution of Christianity seeing Christ hath made none Lords of his peoples Faith or Divine Worship and Princes are no more than Nursing-fathers The quiet therefore and peace of Nations is most advanced by setting up nothing in Christianity but what is absolutely necessary according to the Laws of Christ and yeilding the tenderest and opening the most bountiful hand to the professors and Ministers of essential Christianity Covering all the faulty divisions of Christians with their Royal and compassionate PVRPLE This is most Princely Generous and Great this is most exalting of Christianity it self But if this cannot be obtained the next Best and that which is indeed as I have already made out but Just is That no native Rights and Liberties be defaulked nor punitive oppressions inflicted but that the Honorary Rewards of Nations and Princes be adjudged to men who are of the Publique Sentiment in their Administrations in Christian Religion And this indeed cannot be excepted to it being the Right of National Powers to dispose of their own according to their own Reason and Judgment Yet is there still an obligation upon Christian subjects beyond these Considerations to examine all things with the greatest prejudice for and on the side of the National sense especially when they find the substantials of Religion secure and in safety and besides their private adjustments of Christian performances in particular Societies according to the exacter Rules of Christianity as they are Judges for themselves to encourage also promote and as far as possibly they can communicate with National Religion putting the fairest and kindest interpretation and Hope upon all things tolerating all that can without disobedience to God be tolerated observing Rites and Customs of Nations as far as they can with security from vain worshipping of God by the commandments of men both because of the Honour Christianity gives to Magistracy according to Natural sanctions and also and more especially because of the esteem Christianity hath of a Publique and National Religion Let me then resume upon the whole matter And it plainly appears Christianity notwithstanding the Freedom it allows to every man's conscientious sentiments is no Enemy but a Friend 1. To Society 2. To the Order and Peace that bind Society Yea and strictly commands them and hath given positive Institutions for them 1. For first It unites all its true disciples in that common ample universal center of Love Peace and Order God and Christ to whom the first dedication of a Christian is made and in whom it always rests 2. It unites them with that most publique wise rational and most holy Assembly under Heaven the Catholick Church even all that are that one Body acted by that one Spirit united in one Hope one Faith one Baptism In all which every Christian being one with the whole desires and rejoyces in the encrease of that one Body the advancement of that one Faith communicates in the prayers and praises of that one Body sorrows in its Afflictions ministers to its necessities and if opportunity be offer'd communicates in Spiritual Gifts and Services with any member of it and values not their particular Rites as any obstruction while they agree in Essentials And indeed every Christian should be suffer'd to drop that Mantle of Ceremonies as he pleases when he ascends in holy offerings of himself â—o God 3. 〈◊〉 to particular Societies or Churches of Christians in whiâ—â— the Essentials of Doctrine and Worship are preserved uncorrupted and so they must be or else such Societies deserve not the name of Churches and when they are in such a neighbourhood to the true Christian that he may freely enjoy his choice he considers these two both recommended by the Word of God 1. Private particular Congregations that cannot conform to publique settlement such must needs be the first Churches when Christianity had no publique allowance such may be still 2. The most publique Settlement of Christian Religion and wherein he may do it he uses both promiscuously wherein he must divide he considers upon the Ballance of his most humble and impartial judgment which tends most to the glory of God to publick edification as well as his own and so as not to do evil that good may come If he chuses that which is more particular as best according to his Sentiment he is yet careful to do all he does with the greatest vigor of Charity Inoffensiveness and desire of promoting of that publique worship as it contains the Essentials of Christianity If according to the sincere sense of his mind he prefer the publique Appointment either as publique and in that regard overweighing smaller doubts and so taking the best advantages afforded therein as to all the Duties particular Congregations seem most adapted to or that the whole composure of the publique is most agreeable to his Sentiment he considers the more private as being of the same body and cannot be severe to the Retirers thereto knowing every man hath the proper sense of his own mind and what Essentials Christianity consists in and therefore would not forcibly hale any into the publique but remonstrate to them as he sees reason with mild and Christian arguments the disadvantage of separating from it beyond plain necessity 4. In the differences of judgment of publique Societies and private in relation to one another or the differences of private among themselves the true Christian still keeps himself upon that Love Mercy and Peace Christianity teaches him and in the midst of those diversities considers the higher tyes worth and value of those Vnities wherein they all meet 5. If a Christian fall into such places where the Essentials are corrupted he esteems Religious solitude the best Communion yet refuses not to improve any thing of Truth he can extract from such Corruption or if there be any parts of publique worship not so adulterated but to admit a possible separation in the exigence of present service
to God yea if it were but pure true natural worship he would not deny to joyn in it when no better can be had and therein is ready to take any advantage to improve that little to such great purposes as St. Paul did the Altar to the unknown God at Athens Lastly In every one of these Associations He considers some universal and undeniable practices of all Christian Churches that are yet not pertaining to the Essentials of Christian Worship in themselves but either to natural Order and Decency or at least to the decency observed in such parts of the world wherein Christians so meet and most freely complies with them some of which I shall observe ordained as such by the Apostle such as he ordained in all Churches 1. That of every mans walking as God hath call'd him in Circumcision or Vncircumcision Bond or Free and esteem neither state any prejudice upon his Christianity 1 Cor. 7. 17 18. 2. That of women keeping silence in the Churches 1 Cor. 14. 34. 3. That of Prophets speaking one by one and not in Confusion and a Medley of voices IN A KNOWN TONGVE with Interpretation v. 5. These pertain to natural Decency and Order in all the Churches of the Saints of which God is the Author and so are to be observed 1 Cor. 14. 33 40. 2. Decency proper to such Ages of the world or to such Parts of the world So I esteem those Rules of the Apostle concerning men and women Praying cover'd or uncover'd wearing their Hair shorn or unshorn And in such cases the Custom of Churches determines them or the Churches of God have no Custom to be Contentious concerning them 1 Cor. 11. 16. Such Rules of uncontestable Order and Decency as these a Christian Wise and Sober always and most ncessarily acknowledges Ceremonials and Rituals beyond these he suffers to have no Ascendent over him if for other Reasons he uses them as if he used them not Now such a person as this and such a one Christianity teaches every man to be I boldly affirm concerning him he is a Christian he is no Schismatick he is no Boute-Fen in society nor is he as some may mistake him any Ambidexter in Religion no more than the Apostle who became to the Jews to them under the Law to them without Law to the weak such as themselves that he might by all means save some To allow no latitude in these things that are to vere to opportunity of doing good is starchedness and not constancy even in the judgment of a St. Austyn who avowed the greatest Indifferency and freedom from Rites having any power over him And so I have passed through the third Head concerning the Peace Christianity designs viz. Christians imbodying themselves into Societies I come now to a fourth Head shewing how Christianity hath provided for Peace and Quiet within its own Gates and Walls And that is this 4. The Ministerial Presidency our Saviour hath ordained in and for the conduct of Christian Religion is such as plainly demonstrates he did not intend there should be a striving or a cry or a clamorous lifting up the voice in tâ—e Mat. 12. 19 20. Thes 5. 12. Heb. 13. 7. 1 Pet. 5. 1. streets for his Kingdom that the bruised Reed should be broken or the smoaking Flax quench'd for his sake For though this Ministry is frequently styl'd a Being over Christians a Rule over them an Eldership an Eminency and such like ways of speaking as carry Superiority and Submission Obedience Honour and High esteem are required of Christians as of an under Degree to that higher Order in the Church Yet the Designation of the whole Office is wholly for the service of Christ and his Church for the Administration of the word of God to watch for souls that they may Heb. 13. 17. give an account of them with Joy for the good success of having guided them to Salvation the Honour and Esteem is for their works sake it is a labour in the Word and Doctrine it is no Dominion or Lordship over mens Persons or 1 Tim. 5. 17. Estates nor over their Faith or Consciences but as they offer Divine Commands all their Superiority is in the Lord. It is not Grandeur or Imperiousness but Vse Service Ministry and Work that expresseth this Precedency not as having Dominion over your Faith but helpers of your Joy saith the Apostle Paul Not as Lords over Gods Heritage but as ensamples of the Flock saith the Apostle Peter But above all ought that of our Lord and Master the chief Shepherd and Bishop to be remark'd to this purpose Mat. 20. 25. c. Mark 10. 42 c. Luk. 22 25. Having describ'd the great Assumptions of the Princes and Chiefs of this world he expresly warns and declares to his Disciples it is not in the nature of Christian Greatness so to assume But if any one would be accounted Great or Chief among the Disâ—iples of Christianity it must be his Service his plâ—in Service his Ministry that must 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 so advance him Indeed it were enough to the purpose if our Saviour intended no more than this Let such a man that loves Preeminency under the Profession of Christianity let him be turned down into the lowest Classe among the Disciples of lowest and meanest Account as a just Recompence of his Ambition But it is altogether most probable our Saviour intends a more kind sense to represent the great serviceableness of all those of more Eminent Character in his Kingdom it is their publick Use that recommends them to Grandieur in it For this he exemplifies in himself The Son of man came not to be minisired to to be attended upon and served in state but to minister to give his life a Ransom for many They who witness a good Confession who can be instant in season out of season who can instruct publickly and Act. 20. 19 31. from house to house who are apt to teach who can serve tâ—e Lord in tâ—e salvation of Souls with many Tears and Prayers Day and Night and seal their Ministry with their blood They are the Great ones in the Account of Christianity I speak not this to detract any thing from the Figure Bishops or any in Ecclesiastical Dignities make by the Favâ—ur of Princes who as I have often said may dispose what is their own as they measure themselves from the Donation of mâ—n to their Superiority over men from the favour of Princes and Laws to the Government they place them in over others of their Subjects so they are Great and Honourable and may exercise Authority secular Authority standing indeed upon that Foot though call'd Spiritual and very reasonably and justly so far as I know But this is not the Greatness proper to Christs Kingdom that lies wholly in service in condescension in application to mens Souls As they measure from Christ to Christians this is the true Account of Christian Greatness
all that pierced him whose very own eyes shall see him as so pierced by them It is the appearance of men in their Bodies of Nations in their National Capacities of all men and things in their Restitution For it is the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Regeneration Mat. 19. 28. to their former state that Religâ—on and Piety may receive its recompences of Glory that Irreligion and Wickedness may have its just rewards of Shame and Punishment and that in the very circumstances wherein each were seen and known and shall then be remembred to â—ave stood here in the world though for the generality very different from the esteem and disesteem they then found Lastly This Representation of the day of Judgment is the most lively feeling and sensible Engagement to speedy Repentance and Reformation that our sins may be blotted out when the times 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of Re-enlivening all things shall come from the presence of the Lord Who would not take greatest care that when they are Acts 3 19. sought for they may not be found Who would not desire and so use the most effectual means to appear in Glory and not under shame and contempt This is also among the strongest Arguments upon the most honourable Personages and Governors of a Nation yea upon all that love the honour of their Nation and desire the glory of it with the true publick Spirit to mind the promotion of sincere Religion Piety and Goodness in themselves together with the State of the People Times and Governments to which they belong since if they desire their Nations Renown in this world and that their management in it may be transmitted fair in Chronicle that they may live High in Story how much more must they if at all serious desire to mâ—ke an Honourable Figure in that most Illustrious Representation of the last Judgment and the Eternal Records of All Things They and their Countrey together according to the station and Relation wherein they have stood to it and the love they have born to it And certainly every good man desires by an immutable Instinct by a Law of Goodness within himself to be good in a Community and to be saved in their Salvation which he earnestly aspires to in and with his own and his own in and with that Yea though he be so low or mean in his Fortunes Abilities or Discourse as not to be in any Advantages for propagating True Religion yâ—â— he hath an inward force to it and as every good man rises in his Stature and Condition and influence in the Nation to which he belongs so in his service to the publick Religion but especially every eminent great truly Religious Person of a publick Character and a Lover of his Nation hath a most vehement and ardent desire not only of his own Salvation but of the Salvation of his Nation of as many and great numbers of as universal a Body of it as may be Moses was so high in this that he desired to be blotted out of Gods Book of Exod. 32. 32. Favour that he rather than his Nation should and the Apostle Paul for Israel his National Kindred wished to be Anathema from Christ The scruples of either of which I will not dispute being satisfied Rom. 9 3. they express a high and mighty zeal for the National Salvation and which in a degree is to be imitated by the best men Therefore such Persons as Moses Paul and other of the Worthies of Nations and People that have been successful in bringing many to Righteousness and Happiness shall have as our Saviour speaks Rule over Cities proportionable to their service they shall for ever be exalted as Princes over their People in Eternal Glory even as the Apostles shall sit upon Thrones judging that is shall be Rulers and Governors over the twelve Tribes of Israel Those that have not been successful as Noah Lot Esay c. that have yet had the Zeal the publick Spirit that was commensurable to the Piety Religion and Salvation of their whole Community shall not though Israel be not gathered yet spend their strength for nought their judgment is with the Lord and their work with their God They shall be glorious in the eyes of the Lord they shall Isa 49. 3 4 be a sweet savour to God of true Holiness and Piety in them that perish even as in them that are saved The glory and happiness shall accumulate upon themselves though it redound not on the Nation God makes them of themselves as it were a great Nation in the blessedness of Eternity as he promised Moses if he would have been contented with the destruction of that present Nation of Israel They are reckoned as a Nation by themselves and not of that Community that perishes For as the Apostle says The Lord knows how to deliver the Righteous out of Temptation and so out of the Infamy of a common corruption and especially that everlasting contempt and reserve the wicked to swallow it wholly in themselves Their Reproach their Lord will return upon them for ever it being turned off from himself and his Servants But though there is an infinite wisdom in the Divine Judgment in rescuing thus his own Glory and the Glory of his Servants that have been unsuccessful in turning men to righteousness while they have been faithful with all their Talents and in all their House yet the salvation of Men and Nations is the plain and manifest glory of God and of his most Eminent Servants Those that are their Converts are their Hope now and their Joy their Rejoycing their Crown of 1 Thes 2. 19 20. Rejoycing in the presence of Jesus Christ at his coming in that day only thus Men of eminency in holiness are secur'd against loss if they save only their own souls while they endeavour the good of many that they may be saved they are Crowned with those whom God hath given them as Children by being inâ—truments of their Conversion On the other side they are assur'd of their reward with God in them that perish But further Every man that is good in a Nation though his Interest be private may like the one poor wise man have done all he can to save a City and therefore shall not be forgotten here If he be a holy good man he will not be lost by being alone nor overseen by being low in the world though he be but one of a Family or even of a City yet God will bring him to Zion the City of the living God Every one shall with Daniel stand in his own lot proportionable to what it was here it shall be in that future state God will seek his Sheep out of all places whither they have been driven in the dark and cloudy day though but the poor of the flock and they shall stand at his right hand at that great Division of the Sheep from the Goats To conclude this Particular The honour of Nations
every man shall appear and be judg'd singly by himself Our Resurrection which is the day of our Regeneration of our new life and appearance in Bodies will present us not only single but in our state of Community wherein we were here in the world even from Families to Nations that we may receive the things done in those Bodies as well as in our own Bodies then the Good we have done or omitted to do and the Evil we have withstood or been the occasion of or not prevented when we might shall be severely accounted for by each in their station Each Magistrate shall be surrounded with his sphere of Authority wherein he was set here and judg'd in that And each Minister of Religion justified or condemned in that very Orb wherein he was fix'd as a Star And the several Magnitudes of both Magistrates and Ministers will then be dreadful to them however they have coveted and been Ambitious of them here if they have not inlightned their whole space because their Judgment will be greater Even every man shall be judg'd by his Services to the Publick in his place and station how private soever if it hath never so little exceeded his single capacity And who in his Reason can think God will then account with men for Mint and Cummin small and disputable Things howsoever zealous or rather fond of them they have been in themselves and earnest with others concerning them Those things that have truly center'd in the Glory of God and the Salvation of mens souls in Faith Repentance and a Holy Life in Love and Peace will be of the only moment at that Tribunal This therefore should be the most powerful perswasive upon us to do all the good herein we can in that Community wherein we are fix'd according to our Talent though but a single one much more if our Talents have been Two or Five that we may in that Day of Recompences enter into the joy of our Lord. THE END THE Woe of Scandal OR SCANDAL In its General NATURE and EFFECTS DISCOURS'D As one strongest Argument against Impositions in Religious Things acknowledg'd to be Indifferent LONDON Printed for Tho. Parkhurst at the Bible and Three Crowns at the lower end of Cheapside 1682. THE PREFACE TO THE READER THAT which I will endeavour in preparation to the following Discourse be to present my Design and Method in stating the Nature of Scandal that it may be more intelligible by being seen first as in a Landscape in this Entry and then to add some Considerations of great strength to each part of that Undertaking that have since arrived to my Thoughts As to the Method I must in my own defence say that I have to do with a Subject in which so much of the deceitfulness of Sin is treasured up of so moveable a consideration as Scripture from its own various shapes offers it to us that it cannot easily be known or trac'd I hope therefore it will be allowed as some part of an Apology that the Thread of my Treating concerning it does not run so even and streight along as it ought Further I must take Sanctuary at the Reader 's Candor for the acceptance of my sincere intention and any degree of performance in so difficult a task I confess the want of the most advantageous Arts of Method and a clear unperplexed Style Yet that I might take the truest measure of so multiform and vague a Notion 1. I have taken hold of it in the most strict and precise Description I could frame as it is applicable to all cases of Sin therein resting especially upon those words Scripture uses to convey the sentiments of it to us Thus Scandal is that by which we are drawn into any sin and off from the course of Duty and Religious Action and so intangled in Guilt disease of Conscience and indangered as to Eternal Happiness under a pretext of Reason or Religion 2. Because I find the Scripture applies the Notion of Scandal especially when some of the grand Principles and Laws of Religion are violated under such pretext I have considered it as referred to those great Principles by such sacred use 3. Because there is a very peculiar and most remarkable use of it in the case of indifferent Things by the Apostle when they are turned into sin by being determined upon in practice with a doubting Conscience besides other ways wherein being used amiss they may become Scandals or occasions of it I have therefore allowed a very peculiar Head of Discourse to that Case 4. Because by deeply considering Scandal and that as our Saviour pronounces Scandals must needs come I found there must be some Primitive Fundamental and Vniversal Scandal that covers the whole State of Sin in general I addressed the last part of my Meditation on the Nature of Scandal to this Primitive Vniversal Scandal And lastly I resume upon the whole a representation of Scandal adjusted to what I found upon each of those forementioned Inquiries after it And herein I hope I may have hung up Lights to discover in some degree and to avoid so dark and mysterious an Evil as Scandal though I have not been able to do it to those degrees I desired or to compose into so happy an Order or so perspicuous an Expression what I had my self clearer apprehensions of Thus far as to the Method Now for the strengthening some parts of this discourse by Considerations that have arrived to my Thoughts since I had set an end to the Treatise it self they have arisen from the close observation of the Contexture of the Lord's Sermon upon Scandal as it is Recorded especially in this 18th of Matthew and Mark 9. and Luke 17. Compared with the Debates of the Apostle to the Romans and the Corinths which are the most eminent Seats of the Doctrin of Scandal we have in all the Scripture Our Saviour therefore whose chief business into the World was his recovery of it from Scandal the Deception and the Ruin of it by giving satisfaction to the Divine Glory for the dishonour done to it by Scandal hath blessed us with as Soveraign Arguments and Instructions against either giving or receiving it Our Lord hath so embraced all sorts and degrees of Scandal within this Sermon that none can be exempted from the force and energy of thosâ— his Arguments Instructions or severe Denunciations But yâ—t that they have a particular poignancy against Scandals within his Church and one more particular kind given by a particular sort of Men and directed against another particular sort of Men will be most evident from the survey I am now to give of his Heaven-born Discourse The occasion of it was the Disciples coming solemnly to him with a grand Quere in which no doubt their Ambition a very ignorant Ambition was deeply concerned Who say they is the greatest in the Kingdom of Heaven That is as was generally understood at that time in the Kingdom of the Messiah The Lord
and mute in the Commission of Sin or neglect of Duty upon these appearances and who can say herein I have made my Heart clean I am pure from this Transgression so far hath he been Scandalised and indanger'd to his Ruine This is the first great Pillar of Truth and the primary Scandal is placed here That Men think there is no reason God should have so much Love Fear Honour Obedience so much Worship and Service And the Second is like to it 2. Even the Faith of Jesus Christ the Saviour of the World is like to that first great Principle and equal to it both because the whole Riches and Treasure of all Religion is deposited and concentered in it so that he hath not the John 17. 3. Father nor the Knowledge of the only true God nor the Eternal Life proceeding from it who hath not the Son who hath not the Knowledge of Jesus Christ whom God hath sent Even as Christ is the brightness of the Fathers Glory and the express Image of his Person so is the knowledge of Christ the express Image of the Knowledge of God and the brightness of it wherever it is revealed if it be not believed in the God of the World hath blinded the 2 Cor. 4. 6. minds of them that believe not least they should see the light of the Glory of God in the Face of Jesus Christ who is the Image 2 Cor. 4. 4 6. of God shining to them Especially and more particularly that great Attribute of Divine Mercy and Pardoning Grace is illustrated and breaks out with brighter and warmer Beams in this Son of his Love the Lamb of God who takes away the Sins Acts 4. 12. of the World by the Sacrifice of himself His is the only Name given under the whole Heaven to the Children of Men whereby they can be saved This indeed was the Scandal of the Jews who assumed to themselves as the only Masters of the true Religion in the World and foolishness to the Greeks who took Isa 28. 16. upon them as the like Masters of Reason but this corner Stone of Truth was laid so sure and of so tryed an excellency 1 Pet. 2. 6. that all that reject and spurn at it stumble and fall are snared and broken They are false Notions of God and Truth that will not be reconciled to it and while even the Builders refuse it it will yet rise to be the Head of the Corner Ver 7. It hath now surmounted before any Impartial Judges all other Names of Religion in the whole World so that to strike at it where it is known and received argues a disaffection and being Scandalised at Religion it self and is become the same with denying God Providence and Eternal Judgment Corrupted Reason and Lucian-Wit aims at Religion in its very Essence when it pretends to dash upon that and if when it seem'd to encounter with Gods own Administration by Moses there was yet such a presence of God with it that it would be more tolerable Mat. 10. 15. c. for Sodam and Gomorrah in the day of Judgment than for those that refused it as the Lord in several places testifies how much greater will the Condemnation be now when it hath so perfectly antiquated all that pretension against it and worn out the Prejudices of Elder Paganisme And yet so far as the Foolishness of God as the Apostle 1 Cor. 1. 25. styles it does not appear to us wiser than Men and the weakness of God stronger than Men we are ready to be Scandalised at the Doctrine of a Crucified Saviour And it seems the easiest place for the Attacks of Atheism Irreligion and Prophaneness who yet at last will find themselves in a Gin or Trap when they thought they had gained Ground and made entrance and shattered to pieces when they believed a Conquest For God taketh the wise in their own 1 Cor. 3. 19 20. Craftiness and he knoweth the wisest thoughts of Men that they are vain Every Degree of Apostacy from Christ is Heb. 3. 12. departing from the Living God Transactions in Prayer or Publick Discourses of Religion are so much the more Divine as they send forth the sweet savour of his Name which is as an Oyntment poured out The Apostle desired to 1 Cor. â— 2. Phil. 3. 8. know nothing but Christ and him crucified It is the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Top and Transcendency of Knowledge Apostolick Epistles full of Christ and the Truth as it is in Jesus are the best Patterns for Sermons much exceeding the Rationalism or Moralism of tâ—â— wisest Philosophy It is a Degree of Scandal first taken â—nd then given to speak little of him All Preaching is not giving the savour of his Knowledge 2 Cor. 2. ult and if it have not Life to the Soul it is deadly a Symptom to Death The very diverting though to other Parts of Sacred Scripture speaks Men offended in him when they do not find him and express him the Alpha and Omega in all the Bright Morning Star the Amen And though a Battology a vain Repetition in naming him is blamable yet it is more blame to conceal him even in the best Discourses of his Religion The Rays of Religion are paler more weak and chill as they fall farthest off from him He is the Sun of Righteousness with healing in his wings and Blessed is he in these days even in these days whoever is not offended in him 3. The Spirituality Purity Cleanness and Chasteness of the Worship of God dictated by the clearest and sincerest Light of Natural Conscience approved by Divine Revelation or founded instituted and directed by that undoubted Heavenly Oracle is the next great Pillar of Truth upon which the Glory of God and the Salvation of Mens Souls is setled But against this sensual and defiled Imagination hath in all Ages raised Scandal and so befool'd Reason that it hath cast down many wounded yea many strong Men in their Intellectual Endowments and Reputation for Wisdom have been ensnar'd and ruin'd by it It hath been the Renown therefore of those Princes in Sacred Story that have had the Religious Magnanimity to resist the Charmes of this Sorceress and kept Divine Worship uncorrupted in whose Glory so much as the High Places was a dark Shade and ecclips'd them though it had fair Pretence Idolatry and Superstition have been most evidently branded in Scripture for the most wretched State of being scandaliz'd and Idols for the most abhorr'd Scandals This was the Snare of Gideon and his House and yet as Interpreters give us in a Matter as innocent at first as laying up the Ephod he had inquir'd at in his Danger as a Monument of Gratitude for his Victory that was after turn'd thus into a Scandal Judges 8. 27. This was the Scandal Balaam taught Balak to cast before the Children of Israel These were the Wiles the Gins and Traps in which the
are Infamous Malefactors Male-contents under the most wise and sage Government or Wits ill employed that Lampoon it 6. Let us continually look to Jesus who in himself subdued the whole power of Scandal keeping steady and uniform Obedience to the Divine Will and did always the things that were pleasing to it though Scandals of all sorts pressed in on every side Who being in the Form of Phil. 2. 6. God thought it not robbery to be equal with God yet made himself of no Reputation but took on him the Form of a Servant and was made in the likeness of Men and being found in fashion as a Man he humbled himself and became obedient to death even to the death of the Cross Hereby even by the Dignity of his Person and the Profound Humility of his Obedience he hath not only done that Honour given that Glory to the Divine Soveraignty and Righteousness the Glory of that Supreme Authority as hath made Recompence for all the Scandals of Angels and Men so far as that Soveraignty or Righteousness are absolutely concerned whether any should believe in him or not but hath also made Attonement perfect Attonement and Reconciliation for all that do believe in and obey him into a share of which I make no doubt the Holy Angelical Nature immediately entred according to their state even from the time he was declared the Lamb slain from the foundation of the World Through his Obedience and Meditaion ador'd and applyed to they have persever'd free from Scandal by which so great a part fell upon account of which when the First begotten came into the Heb. 1. 6. World all the Angels of God Worshipped him The virtue from himself as the Exemplar as the First-born among many Brethren Rom. 8. 29. to whose Image they are Predestinated to be conformed does by degrees extirpate all the very remains of Scandal in his Church and he presents it without blame spot wrinkle blemish or any such thing even by real and efficacious operation before the Eyes of Glory His Example alwaies stands before them as the most absolute and sublime Pattern to which they daily are exercised in fashioning themselves Thus our Lord does every way dissolve the Works of the Devil and deliver them who by reason of Scandal were all their lives time subject to bondage by destroying Scandal and him that hath the great Power of it the Devil 7. This should make Heaven desirable to us where no Scandal dwells nor any more since the Angels of Scandal were cast out of it can so much as once enter where there is perfect light without any variation or shaddow of turning The Holy ones there are vext with Scandal's Wiles no more with the Wiles of the God or Ministers of Scandal or those that by his Stratagems are made any way serviceable to it 8. It makes Hell more dreadful the seat and Center the Fund of Scandal where all the good Principles men have had or seem'd to have while they were in the World or the Church the best state of this World and their Temporary good Actions are all swallowed up and by the great power of Scandal turned all into it self wherein all the temporary partial Righteous men of this World whose being Scandalis'd as to the main the true love of God and his Children turned their best things now into a sort of Splendida peccata better complexioned sins have then all that they seemed to have taken from them And by reason of that great Stumbling Block the Eternal loss of God They turn from all their Righteousness and all that they have done is not remembred to them any more for ever They sink into that unpardonable Blasphemy against the Holy Spirit whch is an irreconcilable Enmity to what is known to be of God undeniably of him and that Enmity expressed in the proper language of Scandal Blasphemy and is never forgiven whether committed in this World or that which is to come Now what is there more dreadful to the mind that hath any thing remaining of an Ingenuous sense towards God that hath but so much Love and Reverence towards him though too faint for true saving Grace as will answer a profession of God and the Lord Jesus but will be horribly afraid at the supposition of such a hatred of God such a Blasphemy of him and so of Hell on this account that every sin boils up there into this Height of Scandal 9. We are dreadfully warned from being the Ministers of Scandal either through Design or through great Falls and Miscarriages in our Religious Course this we ought to take care of in Relation to the World in general but especially towards the Little ones that believe in Christ stronger Christians are most out of our danger who grieve or have a just Zeal against our Scandals but in the mean time themselves grow stronger and stronger as Trees that cast their Roots the deeper for being assailed with the Winds But the Little ones are in the Eye of Christ of the tenderest concern because they need it most While we are in the way of our Duty if any receive Scandal and are resolved to do so they create it to themselves we must let them alone but in all things wherein we can save a Soul from Scandal let us consider the Recompence we save a Soul from Death and hide a multitude of Sins a glorious Reward without any more And herein let us always remember we have an Eminent Seat of Doctrine not to Scandalise for the sake of Indifferent Things a Doctrine prepared on purpose for all Ages of the Church of Christ concerning Indifferents one of the Eminent Seats of Doctrine of the New Testament and more particularly in relation to Scandal and therefore by no means to be lightly regarded To Conclude all that we may neither give nor receive Scandal three things are most necessary to which I shall subjoin great Counsels of Scripture in each Case 1. That we have our Judgments well settled within our selves in all the substantials and necessary points of true Religion upon a Divine and not an Humane assurance only that in that part we may neither Offend nor receive Offence for which Solomon's Advice is our great Security Bow down Prov. 22. 7. thine Ear to the Words of the Wise and apply thy Heart to my Knowledge For it is a pleasant thing if thou keep them within thee they shall withal be fitted in thy Lips That thy Trust may be in the Lord I have made known to thee this day even to thee Have I not Written to thee excellent things in Counsels and Knowledge That I might make the know the certainty of the words of Truth that thou mightest answer the words of Truth to them that send unto thee Or those Admonitions of the Apostle Paul That we henceforth be no more as Children tossed to and fro and carried about with every Wind of Doctrine by the sleights of Men and cunning
highest elevation is but Created and Created is not firm and sure enough for a Foundation nor can it raise an Assent noble and generous enough for a Faith in that which is Divine All that can be summon'd may be an outward Fortification or Introduction but the Rock of Truth is the Son of God Divinity it self Upon this the Church is built that the Gates of Hell cannot prevail against it Quest But are there no Parts of Scripture that receive greater Service from Humane Testimony than others Answ There are some Parts of Scripture that are but Ministerial and almost Servile in comparison of others And that these are found in all Authentick Copies and have been delivered down from Age to Age with the Sacred Rolls may depend more upon Humane Testimony especially where the Connexion with the more Divine Parts is not evident For these being but as the Body and some of them of the more remote Parts from the Soul of Scripture cannot sparkle that Divine Light and Heat the Spirit of Scripture does and so may stand in need of borrowed Light from the Superiour Luminaries of Sacred Truth and in many Cases may like the Moon need Reflexions of Light from our very Earth but the Sun of Scripture receives the Highest Testimony by the strongest Reflexions of its own Original Beams Quest How comes it to pass that there are such different Degrees of Scripture-Excellency in the several Parts of it and that it is not one Even Form of Doctrine methodically laid together and of the same Tenour of Discourse Answ In this seeming Disorder appears the great Wisdom and Majesty of Divine Contrivance that without obliging it self to the low and even pedantick Laws of Humane Discourse it raises so great a Record of Truth upon variety of Occasions and by an Infinite Foresight predetermining to it self the several Measures and Ends of Scripture raises them out of a great variety of Accidents and in such an Order as seem'd best to it self for those Ends so as to give easie and ready Advantages to him that runs to read and gather Instructions of weightiest moment and also of quickest and suddenest sally upon his Mind of greatest aptness to fix upon the Memory without loading it and yet in the mean time to lay the Obligations of all Degrees of Search and Diligence to join one part of Scripture to another so as to comprehend the whole Complex of Divine Doctrine and extract the Order of History For by a most natural free and unaffected occasional way all Truths to make wise to Salvation and a complete Sum of all Goodness is to be found in Scripture with infinite Varieties of Address all the ways possible to the Understanding Will Affections Conscience Memory Imagination suited to all Capacities States Conditions full of plain and obvious of most retir'd secret and farthestreach'd Wisdom which no Mind can fully grasp nor Tongue express And with these Things of main Importance runs along such a Chronology of the Dealings of God with the World and especially with his Church as serves the main Design All Learning and Knowledge in the mean time attending with lowliest Submission and not with pompous Appearance Now from this Supreme Dispose of all things to the Ends of God in Scripture out of such a variety of Emergencies of all sorts arises such a diversity of several Excellencies in the Parts of Scripture that yet all meet in that Great Center of the Glory of God in a Communication of his Counsels concerning Man and that turn round those Two Globes that little one of the present World a Point like this Earth and the other that vast Circumference of Eternity Quest But is there not as great a difference arising from the various States and Conditions of the Writers of Scripture and the so different Periods of Time they were upon Answ That there is and must needs be a difference is undeniable yet to the great Glory of Scripture and assurance it is from God even those smallest and lowest things last spoken of are all treated with all the Purity Gravity becoming the Penmen of the Holy Spirit and with all the Usefulness their Nature can extend to Even so the Holy Men used by God in this Service how various and differing soever in their several Ages and Times of writing in their Circumstances of State and Condition in this World High Low Rich Poor Learned Unlearned how distant soever in their Times of Writing in the outward Forms and Modes of their Worship of God in the Things that fell under their Account and Relation before the Law under the Law in the Days of the Messiah after his Death yet there is the same Spirit Scope Chastness of Style Majesty and Authority in the Contexture one Aspect upon the Glory of God Obedience to him Desire of his Favour as the whole Happiness of Man the same Reflexions upon the great Evil of Sin and the consequent Misery and even of their own Sins So that where any Combination or Conference to concert things was impossible yet there is such an Union without a set Uniformity as assures the One Hand of the Divine Spirit and Guidance upon All. Quest Is not the Church of God the Trustee and Depository of Sacred Oracles Answ It is so in Divine Ordination and the general Course of Providence but yet it adds nothing to them but receives all from them The Church is known to be the Church by the Scriptures not the Scriptures by the Church except declaratorily only The Church is the Pillar and Rest of Scriptures where God is pleas'd to fix them that they may be exposed to Publick View but their Authority is of God evident in themselves Quest Do we then attribute nothing more to the Church in which we were Baptiz'd and received the Knowledge of Religion Answ A very great Favour it is of God that when he writes up the People he counts that we were born within his True Church where all the Springs of Salvation run but as to the Proof of Religion or the Records of it it can be no more than a Private Proof For till we make a true Judgment by what is Divine and Publick and of God in the true Church it does no more than equal other Societies walking with Confidence and Assurance with great Awes and Devotion in the Name of their God in the Profession of their Religion Till therefore there is a Trial of every Religion and the Records of it all such Societies are upon the same Level When the Religion and Oracles of every Religion come to be tried and duely examined the Church of God rises to Heaven and all else except so far as they joyn in any Parts of the same Truth sink down beneath Quest But how can we know that every Book of Scripture is Scripture but by the Testimony of the Church or that we have all the Books of it but by the same Testimony Answ That the Books we own
fanciful Distinction of themselves under Christ as an ordinary Chief of a Party and not as the Divine Head of the whole Body in the Catholick Truth Even as he erred that vulgarly called Christ Good not knowing him to be God the Supremely Solely Good Quest Are they all true Converts that are of the Church Answ All that are indeed the Church are so but all that may appertain to the Church are not so as all that were of Israel were not Israel There is a visible Profession that is too often not sincere yet this makes Men Of or belonging to the Church but not truly The Church Many are so called that are not chosen But all that are truly The Church are also truly called and truly Converts not only outwardly and visibly the Church but inwardly and invisibly so too whose praise is not of Men but of God In the mean time they that are onely of the Visible Church have the Means of Grace and are not thrown out of that Register of God's People till the Final Judgment cuts them off A very great Benefit in it self Quest Is not the Church then so Catholick or General as the Profession of the True Religion is Answ The Catholickness of the Church as hath been often inculcated is its Union to God and Christ and that in sincerity As to the general Profession though the number of it be as the Sand of the Sea a Remnant only shall be saved For God will finish the Account and cut it short in Righteousness for a short work will the Lord make in the Visible Church There shall be an often eating or brousing it off a retrenching of it again and again it shall cast the Leaves of its meer Professors as the Teyle-tree or Oak when yet their Substance is in them the Holy Seed are the Substance of it Isa 6. ult not losing them it loses nothing Quest In what sense is it then said The Gates of Hell shall not prevail against the Church Answ It is undoubted none can fail while they are the Church while united to Truth to the God of Truth to Christ the Way the Truth and the Life It is also certain from this high Declaration there always shall be a Church in the World so united Hades or Mortality shall not prevail over it and how much farther it assures the Perseverance of those that are once truly the Church I leave the thing it self to speak It is said They that overcome ar Pillars that never go out of it and They that go out of it were not of it for if they had been indeed of it they would no doubt have continued with it And how the Church it self shall always continue if any True Member of it may perish is not easie to conceive Quest How is the Church ordained by God to actuate Scripture as it is the Record of Catholick Religion Answ The Apostle in his Noble Description of the Church hath laid the Foundations of our Instruction herein in those three Honourable Titles he hath given it 1. That it is the House of the Living God 2. That it is the Pillar of Truth 3. That it is the Ground of Truth Quest Before the Explanation of each of these Titles in the first place I desire it may be determined whether these things are spoken of the Catholick or of a Particular Church the Particular Church of Ephesus Answ Although I have already affirmed That the Catholick Church differs from a Particular True Church only in the Compass and Comprehensiveness of it yet I very willingly represent it over again in this Instance These things are truly applied to the Catholick Church to the Particular Church of Ephesus to every Particular Church nay it reaches down to every single living Member of the Church so far that God makes his abode with him dwells in him he is a Pillar in the House of God the Truth rests and dwells in him and shall be with him for ever so that he is a Ground of Truth and hath more of the Church in him than greater seeming Portions of it that erre from the Truth Quest If you please now to proceed in the Explanation of these Titles and first What is the Importance of the Churches being the House of God for the actuating the Scripture Answ God the most High Possessour and Owner of Heaven and Earth places his Court Family and particular Residence where he pleases and he hath chosen the Church to be this to him This is my Rest here will I dwell for ever for I have desired it Heaven is my Throne Earth is my Footstool where is the House you will build me To this Man will I look that trembles at my Word And where God dwells there he manifests himself As a Master of a Family makes known in his House and Family his Nature Will Laws and Government so God does in his Church In Judah is God known his Name is great in Israel In his Church he shews the Light of his Countenance expects and rewards Services as a Great Master and makes known his Dislikes and Displeasure This is brought to pass in the Church by those many Ways that God hath of bringing his Word to any Places or Persons giving it Reception among them and then stirring up his Children and Servants to hear his Voice to search his Mind and Will and to understand it so that it is as a Voice continually behind them In his Temple therefore in his House every one must needs speak of his Glory His Word cannot lie still for all are concerned to meditate ponder inquire and discourse of it and are by Supreme Management excited so to do and so much as this Exercise in his Word is by any means depressed so far God is withdrawn and the Excellency of the Church-state lost Now of the Church being the House of God there was this great Type God dwelt in the Temple at Jerusalem as in a Palace there was such a Diet of Shew-bread changed every day of Sacrifices of all sorts such Perfumes of Incense and Odours such Officers and Servants attending continually such Resorts of the whole Body of the People to the Court of this Great King and Princely Housholder Together with this State runs along in a mighty Stream Gods shewing his Word to Jacob his Statutes and Judgments to Israel In the New Testament the Pomp and Ceremonial Part is wholly transferred into Spirituality but Spirituality is not lower but higher in the Substance of all that could be figured by these things and the substantial part of that State the Communication of the Word of God is much exalted in the true Christian Church that the Light of One Day is now as much as the Light of Seven was before Thus the Church as the Family of God cannot but actuate his Word Quest What is the meaning of the Church being the Pillar of Truth Does the Church support Truth Answ Not so for it self is built upon the
discern them but by the Word of Righteousness of which all True Ministers are the Ministers on account of which alone Obedience and Submission to them is due Their bringing that Word in its own Life Evidence and Power is their best Commission Quest But how are they most orderly enstall'd into so high a Function Answ Christ as the Head of the Church hath ascended up on high and given gifts to Men and as the Lord of the Harvest takes it upon him as his Supreme Care to thrust forth Labourers into his Harvest The several Congregations of Christians observing Ministerial Abilities and Meetness to Teach call out to such to help them and herein in the Cessation of Extraordinary Gifts the Schools of Learning and Religious Education like the Schools of the Prophets do best prepare and the Judgment of those that have been Pastors and Teachers before them does most orderly recommend to Choice and Acceptance in the great Service such as are Scribes instructed to the Kingdom of Heaven and commits to them the Charge of Teaching others For in this as in all other Acts the Elders of the Church are to preside with due Respect to the Congregation Quest Is the Lord Christ pleased then to act generally by the Elders and Officers of the Church Answ Generally and ordinarily he does so the Officers are therefore more particularly entrusted by Christ with the Keys even as the Church in general is Thus eminently by the Ministry of the Apostles our Lord founded his Church and so edifies and builds it up in After-ages by Pastors and Teachers and when great Defections have prevailed upon it summons it to Reformation by some rais'd up among those Officers and whom he sends out as such to reform and recover his Church Yet still all this Power is in and according to his Word and no other and so that in all things as much as may be the Knowledge Judgment and Approbation of the Church is to be joyn'd in all the Officers do as having their Interest in the Keys also because they have their Interest in the Word of God in the Understanding Opening and Applying of which to Particular Cases the whole Power of the Keys rests The Apostles Elders and the Brethren or whole Church were together pleased and together joyn'd in that Famous Conciliary Epistle Acts 15. 22. Quest I desire your more full Explanation of the Publick Offices of the Christian Church and the Power accompanying it Answ I will very willingly do as you desire and begin with the Apostles Quest Wherein stood their Power Answ It stood in their Preaching Acting Directing Governing by that Immediate and Infallible Assistance of the Divine Spirit by which they writ and sealed Scripture and by which they were so guarded every way that they could turn neither to the Right Hand nor to the left in any thing wherein they exercised this Power Quest How was this Power Justified Answ By the Divineness substantial Goodness and Reasonableness of all their Prescriptions propos'd in all the Methods of Rational Discourse and manifestation of themselves in Mens Consciences witness'd to by the Holy Spirit and authorised by a Power of Miracles generally of Beneficence or doing good and in some but sparing Instances of infliction of Bodily Pains or Death Quest Did the Apostles never err in their Administration Answ Whenever that Infallible Guidance was not present to them they might err as was before observed in the Apostle Peter's Miscarriage which no doubt was recorded to shew their Power was not in themselves but in the Divine Spirit acting by them that none in After-ages might pretend to dictate as their Successors having not their Power and yet requiring Obedience as if they had it whereas even the Apostles themselves might err and so lose their Power if never so little deserted by the Holy Spirit And therefore what they consigned over to After-ages was winnowed from every thing Humane and Fallible that both Officers and People might know the one Common Rule by which one is to Govern the other in the Application of it is to be Governed Quest Who were next to the Apostles in this Office and Power Answ Evangelists such as were Timothy and Titus who having a Portion of the Apostolick Work to plant and settle Churches and Ordinary Officers in them had also a Portion of their Power to enable them to it it being absolutely necessary there should be such till the General Rule was fully settled and fixed Quest Were not the Apostles and Evangelists above Ordinary Pastors and Teachers Answ They were in this great Point of Difference that they had the Word of God by Immediate and Infallible Revelation committed to them to commit the same to others by direction from the same Spirit who gave them Discerning to whom to entrust it till all things relating to the Kingdom of God in the Church were sealed in the Canon of the New Testament else they owned themselves Compresbyters as the Apostle Peter stiles himself A Presbyter with Presbyters Quest From all that hath been spoken we are to conclude That the whole Power in the Church and in all things pertaining to Religion is retained in the Word of God Answ It is so For Christ in his Word is the only King and Lawgiver of his Church which Glory he will not give to another Whatever Power can be supposed resident in the whole Church together is no other than in that Word of Truth publickly offered by it The Apostles Power was only the presence of that Word to them by the Immediate Revelation and infallible Guidance of the Holy Spirit for the Preaching it throughout the World and thereby founding the Christian Church Such was the ordinary Power of any extraordinary Ministers under them The and constant Rulership of the Elders of the Church remains unmoveably in the Word which it is their Office to speak Quest Are not those we distinguishingly call Bishops Successours to the Apostles in that Preeminency they had over other Pastors and Elders Answ That Successors to the preeminency of the Apostles may be well established Three things are necessary 1. That there be found and produced Distinct Commands given in Scripture â—o the Inferior Ministers of the New Testament to obey Superior Ministers or Bishops Commands to Christians to obey Inferior Ministers or Ordinary Presbyters as Inferior Ministers with respect to Superior Ministers and those Superior Ministers as Superiors We must find the Apostle distinguishing ordinary Presbyters as Inferior Ministers with respect to Superior Ministers and those Superior Ministers as Superiors as we find him distinguishing Civil Magistrates into the King as Supreme and Governors as those that are sent by him 2. Seeing it is very clear and apparent there is nothing more distant from the Design of the Gospel than to Constitute any thing for the sake of making a great Figure without as great an Use or End and that Christ hath not given Power to his Rulers to Command
of this Truth under an apprehension of a greater moment than there is indeed in the Causes of such a Disunion and a proportionable abatement of Christian Love arising from it All Heresie therefore includes Schism but all Schism does not rise up to Heresie Quest Are these the Scripture Notions of Schism and Heresie according to its use of those Words Answ They are most agreeable with the Sense of it but the words were not so set solemn and formal in Scripture as afterwards in Ecclesiastick Writers for Dichostasyes or Division into two or more Parties and Contentions are by the Apostle used to the same Sense as Schism and Heresie sometimes signifies no more than a Sect or Division though that is remarkably used in its worst Sense by both the Apostles Paul and Peter Quest Is every different Apprehension and Practice ensuing upon it though distant from Truth immediately to be Condemned of Schism Answ By no means if it be a Modest and Humble Distrust and Suspension concerning the Truth and Command of God in some things of smaller moment and doubtful yea though it comes to a positive Determination so far as a Man's judgment and yet erroneous can at the present discern it cannot be branded as Schism if there be no stress laid upon the Thing beyond its desert if the Union in the greatest and clearest Truths and Commands remains firm and the Love due to such an Union with the Church of God be sincere and fervent yea even Dissent in greater points thus qualified and free from ill practice hath not been rigidly censur'd for Heresie Quest Is there no danger then of running into Schism if there be an Vnion with Truth Answ In this Sense only when the weakness or misapprehension of others are rated against them beyond their Merit and without regard to the greater Truths they agree in and the Love due to them upon Union in those greater Truths is withdrawn or the Spirit of meekness in endeavouring to restore the Erring Christian denied This may be justly esteem'd like Schism as it recedes from the just value of Great Truths and from the Charity of Christians upon Union in them but no Man is to espouse any Mans Errors or to receive even Truth by an implicit Faith for fear of Schism in things that carry not a broad Evidence of Divine Truth there is great scope for Modest Suspensions and even Dissents without Imputation of Schism for Truths of magnitude either in Doctrine Worship Practice or Discipline are too bright to be refused by sincere and honest Minds after due admonition Quest Wherein lies then the great Evil of Schism Answ That Schism and the Evil of it may better be understood I will set before you the several Instances of Schism in Scripture and the Evils noted by the Apostle in each of them 1. The first sort of Schism is the Disunion in the sincere Doctrine of the Gospel and bringing in upon it the necessity of the Judaique Rites to concur with it This the Apostle to the Romans Rom. 16. 17. calls making Divisions or Parties beside or contrary to the Doctrine received The great Evil of this adding to the Word of God is that it lays Scandals before Men and draws them into this great mischief that instead of the pure nourishment of Divine Truth all runs into this over-beloved Sentiment and so deprives the Soul of the true and vigorous Spirits of Truth and also the Service due to True Christianity is drain'd away and consumed upon this private Opinion which is indeed the mischief of all Falshood in Religion and Devotion in Things not appointed by God who only can prescribe what is truly fitted to our Good and bless it with suitable Effect Miscarriage from Divine Truth is always found in Schism with this mischievous Consequence that it deceives the Soul with a Cloud and Wind instead of Truth and solid Good 2. A Second kind of Schism the Apostle Notes 1 Cor. 11. 19 20. was the Disorder in Divine-Worship in that great Ordinance of the Lords Supper wherein they that were reprov'd were necessitated to withdraw and to stand apart for the manifesting themselves in the purity of that Worship and Service for the very honor of it The great Evil of this Schism is that it brings in a necessity of divided Parties in Publick Religion and the Duties of it seeing good Men must separate from such Corruptions and stand at a Distance from them on Account of which Religion it self is dishonoured as if it were a Jumble of Sects and gave an uncertain sound and further than that is charged as if it were but a Sect it self because it stands by it self Thus Christianity was called This Sect and the Sect of the Nazarenes Idolatry damns the True Worship of God as a Heresie from it self and the False Church charges the truly Publick-Assembly with Schism and a Private Religion 3. Another Degree of Schism the Apostle taxes in the Corinthians 1 Cor. 1. 11. c. 4. 3. was that this one intire Profession of Christianity in the one Universal Church of Christ they thought ought to be shred into little Fraternities under the Names of some prime Minister of Christianity or even under the Name of Christ himself as an ordinary Master of a Party except we will understand that Those Approved who stood firm in Christ alone were manifested and stood alone by being at a distance from the Schism of others and so appeared as was said before like a Schism themselves Thus vain Philosophy parcell'd out it self under its great Masters The great Evil of this is that it raises Feuds Contentions and Factions as if this one Integral Christianity could have distinct Interests and some ingross one Interest others another Whereas the Apostle thus reduces this Schism all Ministers saith he with all their Gifts Graces and Functions are the whole Churches without any cantoning other than that Order and Conveniency requires the more constant administration of Religion in certain Congregations with their Elders Cephas the Apostle of the Circumcision was the Corinthians though Gentiles as well as the Apostle of the Gentiles Paul himself and not only the Churches Ministers â—ut the whole World and the Cargo of Light and Truth in it are the Churches Every Truth every Ordinance every Minister whâ—ther of Truth Natural or Revealed Religion with all the happy Effects of them are all the Donation of Christ to the Catholick Church whose the Catholick Church is and no Ministers whatever and Christ is Gods who is the Foundation Center and Supream Head of this Unity and Union 4. The last Instance of Schism I find in Holy Scripture is intimated to us under that curious Parable 1 Cor. 12. 12. of the Wise and Excellent Temperament betwixt the several Members of the same Body set in different Degrees of Dignity the less comely parts have more abundant Comliness and those that we think to be less Honourable on these we bestow more abundant