with your Countrey that chose you for that Place You know that no Act of Parliament is binding but what is Acted by King Lords and Commons And now as you would make God the Author of your Offence so likewise you would make the People guilty of your Opinion But your Plea is over-ruled To which the Court assented Mr. Harrison I was mistaken a little Whereas it was said the Points were one I do humhly conceive they were not so I say what was done was done in Obedience to the Authority If it were but an Order of the House of Commons thus under a Force yet this Court is not Judge of that Force I say if it was done by one Estate of Parliament it is not to be questioned Court It was not done by one Estate They were but a Part nay but an eighth Part. Denz Hollis It was not an House of Commons They kept up a Company by the power of the Sword Do not abuse the People in saying It was done by the Supreme Power Councel My Lord if it were an House of Commons neither House of Commons nor House of Lords nor House of Lords and Commons together no Authority upon Earth can give Authority for Murthering the King This that he alledgeth is Treason my Lord this that is said is a clear Evidence of that which is charged there is only this more in it he hath done it and if he were to do it again he would do it Lord Chief Baron It is clear as the Noon-day that this was not the House of Commons Suppose it had been an House of Commons and full and suppose which far be it from me to suppose they should have agreed upon such a Murtherous Act for the House of Commons to do such an Act it was void in it self nay any Authority without the House of Lords and King is void You plead to the Jurisdiction of the Court whether we should Judge it or no. Yes I tell you and proper too We shall not speak what Power we have The Judges have Power after Laws are made to go upon the Interpretation of them We are not to judge of those things that the Parliament do But when the Parliament is purged as you call it for the Commons alone to Act for you to say that this is the Authority of Parliament it is that which every man will say Intrenches highly upon his Liberty and Priviledge And what you have said to your Justification what doth it tend to but as much as this I did it justifie it and would do it again which is a new Treason The greatest Right that ever the House of Commons did claim is but over the Commons Do they claim a particular Right over the Lords Nay over the King Make it out if you can but it cannot possibly be made out What you have said doth aggravate your Crimes It is such an approvement of your Treason that all Evidences come short of it King Lords and Commons is the Ground of the English-Law Without that no Act of Parliament binds Justice Mallet I have been a Parliament-Man as long as any man here present and I did never know or hear that the House of Commons and Jurisdiction over any saving their own Members which is as much as I will say concerning the Parliament I have heard a Story of a Mute that was born Mute whose Father was slain by a Stranger a man unknown After twenty years or thereabouts this Mute-man fortuned to see the Murtherer of his Father and these were his Words Oh! here is he that slew my Father Sir The King is the Father of the Country Pater Patria so saith Sir Edward Coke He is Caput Reipublicae the Head of the Common-wealth Sir What have you done Here you have cut off the Head of the whole Common-Wealth and taken away Him that was our Father the Governour of the whole Countrey This you shall find Printed and Published in a Book of the greatest Lawyer Sir Edward Coke I shall not need my Lord to say more of this Business I do hold the Prisoner's Plea vain and unreasonable and to be rejected Justice Hide I shall not trouble you with many Words I am sorry that any man should have the Face and Boldness to deliver such words as you have You and all must know That the King is above the Two Houses They must propose their Laws to him The Laws are made by Him and not by Them by their consenting but they are His Laws That which you speak as to the Jurisdiction you are here Indicted for High Treason for you to come to talk of Justification of this by Pretence of Authority your Plea is naught illegal and wicked and ought not to be allowed As to having of Councel the Court understand what you are upon Councel is not to be allowed in that Case and therefore your Plea must be over-ruled Mr. Justice Twisden I shall agree with that which many have already said onely this You have eased the Jury you have confessed the Fact I am of the same Opinion that you can have no Councel therefore I over-rule your Plea if it had been put in never so good Form and Manner Earl of Manchester I beseech you my Lords let us go some other way to work Sir William Wild. That which is before us is Whether it be a matter of Law or Fact For the matter of Law your Lordships have declared what it is his Justification is as high a Treason as the former For matter of Fact he hath confessed it I beseech you My Lord direct the Jury for their Verdict This Gentleman hath forgot their Barbarousness they would not hear their King Court No Councel can be allowed to Justifie a Treason that this is a Treason you are Indicted by an Act of the 25th of Edw. 3d. That which you speak of the House of Commons is but part of the House of Commons they never did nor had any power to make a Law but by King Lords and Commons and therefore your Plea is naught and all the Court here is of the same opinion if they were not they would say so therefore what you have said is over-ruled by the Court. Have you any thing else to offer Mr. Harrison Notwithstanding the Judgment of so many Learned ones that the Kings of England are no ways accountable to the Parliament The Lords and Commons in the beginning of this War having declared the King's beginning War upon them the God of Gods Court Do you render your self so desperate that you care not what Language you let fall It must not be suffered Mr. Harrison I would not willingly speak to offend any man but I know God is no Respecter of Persons His setting up his Standard against the People Court Truly Mr. Harrison this must not be suffered this doth not at all belong to you Mr. Harrison Vnder Favour this doth belong to me I would have abhorred to have brought him to Account
begin with that first we are upon our Oaths the Witnesses that are against you I took notice of them you have had a great deal of Liberty which you have made use of civilly but Sir for the fact I think it is a great deal more full than as you have answered First The first witness produced against you was Mr. Nutley I shall speak only the material parts that concern your Charge He swears expresly that he saw Price a Scrivener writing a Charge in the Court of Wards that he saw his Charge in your hands He saw afterwards when the King of blessed memory was brought as a Prisoner that there you delivered the Charge in there is more than words you delivered that Charge in that alone is an overt act then if ther were nothing else in that Case that a man in a paper should call the King Traytor Tyrant Murtherer and implacable enemy as there the words are and he deliver this paper and this be read if this be not an overt act of imagining and compassing the Kings death I do not know what an overt act is and he gives further evidence if I mistake take free liberty to interrupt me Cook Sir they were not my words but their words that commanded me Lo. Chief Baron This I say that this very thing alone such a paper approved by you delivering this paper to an Assembly requiring it may be read this is an overt act to prove the imagination of your heart for the Death of the King the reason is if the King should be a Tyrant a Traytor c. it stirs up hatred in the people and the consequences of that hatred is the death of the Prince The next thing that Mr. Nutley said was this He said that you demanded positively Judgement against him against the blessed King then Prisoner at the Bar. I remember you said that you did demand Judgement but that you did not demand Judgement against the King take it so whether you did or not though you shall find in some other Witnesses that I shall repeat that you said Judgement against the King the consequence will be the same who could you demand Judgement against but the King he was the Prisoner because he did demand a further hearing by the Parliament you urged that his Charge might be taken pro Confesso then it must needs be Judgement against the K. it is effectively and implicitely the same He went further and that was that being your friend acquaintance acknowledging your parts as a Lawyer which truly I do very much know my self and do know this Gentleman to be a man of very great parts in his profession he had familiar acquaintaince with you he told you what a base business it was and you did your self acknowledge it said the Prisoner to M. Nutley himself it is a base business but they put it upon me He did discourse further to him of the Oaths of Allegiance Supremacy which he knew very well no man better this Gentleman he very ingenuously confessed it saying I confess it is so they put me upon it I cannot avoid it but then excuses it I am the servant of the people Afterwards he pressed the K. to answer positively whether guilty or not guilty the pressing of the K. to answer what was it in effect but to hasten Judgement and that was to hasten his death so that that is the substance of Mr. Nutley's testimony that he pressed Judgment Judgement was demanded by the Prisoner now at the Bar it is not only demanded but pressed and all the current of the witnesses at several days are to this purpose it is true that I may repeat the whole for you and against you that this Gentleman the Prisoner at the Bar when Mr. Nutley did urge this to him said he hoped they did not intend to take away the Kings life I verily believe they do not intend to take away the Kings life I hope they do not But Mr. Cook it is no excuse to say you hope or you believe they will not c. How far it may be in such a crime something in extenuation in foro Coeli but not in foro Civili you opened it your self that if a man should go about to take the K. Prisoner it is Treason the Law adjudged that to be Treason when you knew they would condemn him as a Tyrant Murtherer c. you must easily believe what would follow such a condemnation Truly death that is no colour of excuse in foro Civili Farrington swears to the same purpose that he saw you having a Parchment in your hands delivering it in prayed it might be read as a Charge of the People you did not speak I deliver this in as from those that deliver'd it to me that was not in the paper that you said of your self My brethren will tell you all this is an apparent point of the imagination of your heart at that time he swears the same thing that you did desire it might be taken pro Confesso Master Bodurdo is the third he swears the same thing too that you exhibited a charge of High Treason against the Prisoner then at the Bar tells you the substance of it he saith that all but the first day you demanded Judgement for not pleading to the Charge he adds that you complained of the delaies I am sure that was not dictated to you that could not be thought that you should desire Judgement for the Prisoner It is very true which you say for your self in that that you did not demand it first till it was demanded by the Court Master Bodurdo tells you and so it was granted the first day that Bradshaw onely said it but afterwards that you alwaies demanded it The next was Master Herne he swears the same words again that you did in the Name of the Commons assembled in Parliament and the People of England exhibit a Charge c. These are your own words if you did exhibit a Charge against the King to exhibit a Charge of High Treason the very thing followed If it were so there was death so certainly there cannot be a greater expression of the imagination of a mans heart than that is it is true you asked then a question and that was whether that that you concluded was not that you desired them to proceed according to Justice it is true the words of the Charge are so but before you come to conclusion you charge him as a Traytor Tyrant c. Communis Hostis after you had given that Charge you demanded Justice those that spit in his face they demanded Justice every one knew what belonged to that Justice Then Baker he swears positively that you did exhibit the Charge in this manner he said this that you said you had exhibited a Charge of High Treason c. and that the King sought delays there is your insisting upon it he sayes further that you said these words
in that Case one was called the Banishment of Hugh Spencer and the other is in 1. Edward 3. upon the Roll. My Masters In the first of Henry the Seventh you shall find it in the printed seven Books he saith That as to the Regality of his Crown he is immediately subject unto God Mark the Doctrine of the Church of England Gentlemen I do not know with what Spirit of Equivocation any Man can take that Oath of Supremacy You shall find in the Articles of the Church of England the last but one or two it is that Article which sets forth the Doctrine of the Church of England they say That the Queen and so the King hath the Supreme Power in this Realm and hath the chief Government over all the Estates of the Realm the very words are so this was shortly after making the Act the Articles were in 1552 and she came in 1558 or 1559 it is to shew you the King hath the chief Government over all the Estates within the Nation and if you look upon it you shall find it was not only the Judgment of the Church but of the Parliament at the same time They did confirm this Article so far that they appointed that no Man should take or be capable of a Living but those that had taken that Oath God forgive those Ministers that went against it The Queen and the Church were willing that these should be put into Latin that all the World might see the Confession of the Church of England and of the People of England you may reade it in Cambden I have told you how and wherein the chief Power consisted not in respect the King could do what he would no the Emperors themselves did not challenge that but this they challenge by it That they were not accountable to Man for what they did No Man ought to touch the Person of the King I press it to you in point of Conscience you see in the Scripture in Psalm 51. the Psalm of Mercy whereby we ask pardon of God for our great Offences I think none of you in this condition but will join in this you know the Adultery and Murder that David committed this penitential Psalm was made for that What doth he say Against thee thee only have I sinned c. tibi soli peccavi Domine not because he had not sinned against Man for 't is plain he had sinned both against Bathsheba and Vriah too But because he was not liable to the Tribunal of Man he was not bound nor accountable to any Man upon Earth And now my Masters I beseech you consider that some of you for ought I know suddenly and some of you for ought I know not long after all of us we do not know how soon must come to make a right account to God of what we have done After this Life you enter into an Eternity an Eternity of Happiness or of Woe God Almighty is merciful to those that are truly penitent the Thief upon the Cross and to all that are of a penitent heart You are Persons of education do not you go on in an obstinate perverse course for shame of Men even this shame which you now have and which you may have when you come to die a sanctified use may be made of it you pay to God some part of that punishment which you owe to him for your sins I have no more to say but the next thing I have to do is to give the Sentence the Judgment which truly I do with as unwilling a heart as you do receive it You Prisoners at the Bar the Judgment of the Court is this and the Court doth award that c. And the Lord have mercy on your Souls Court adjourned till Friday morning seven a Clock Friday Octob. 19. 1660. Set William Heveningham to the Bar. Serjeant Keeling May it please your Lordships the Prisoner at the Bar William Heveningham hath been indicted of High-Treason for compassing and imagining the Death of the late King of blessed memory he has been tried the Jury has found him guilty I do humbly move your Lordships in the behalf of the King that you will proceed to Judgment Clerk William Heveningham hold up thy hand what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Heveningham My Lords I have nothing more to say than I said formerly only I plead the benefit of the Proclamation and cast my self upon the Mercy of our most gracious Sovereign and desire your Lordships to be Mediators on my behalf Lord Ch. Baron By the Act of Indempnity of which you claim the Benefit and we ought to take notice of it we are to proceed to Judgment but no Execution of this Judgment is to be until by another Act of Parliament by consent of the King it shall be ordered And therefore I need not speak any more of that or any Exhortation to prepare your self for Death our work is only to give Judgment The Judgment of the Court is this and the Court doth award that you the Prisoner at the Bar be led back to c. And the Lord have mercy upon your Soul THus having given the Reader a most impartial view of every Passage occurring in this so solemn and legal Indictment Arraignment Trial and Condemnation of these twenty nine black Regicides with their several Pleas and Defences in their own words It may be also some additinal satisfaction to let the Reader know the time and manner of the Death of such of them who were according to the Sentence Executed For their last Discourses and Prayers as they were made in a Croud and therefore not possible to be taken exactly so it was thought fit rather to say nothing than give an untrue account thereof chusing rather to appear lame than to be supported with imperfect assistances ON Saturday the 13th of October 1660 betwixt nine and ten of the clock in the Morning Mr. Tho. Harrison or Major General Harrison according to this Sentence was upon a Hurdle drawn from Newgate to the place called Charing-Cross where within certain Rails lately there made a Gibbet was erected and he hanged with his face looking towards the Banqueting-house at Whitehall the place where our late Sovereign of eternal memory was sacrificed being half dead he was cut down by the common Executioner his Privy Members cut off before his Eyes his Bowels burned his Head severed from his Body and his Body divided into Quarters which were returned back to Newgate upon the same Hurdle that carried it His Head is since set on a Pole on the top of the South-East end of Westminster-Hall looking towards London The Quarters of his Body are in like manner exposed upon some of the City Gates Monday following being the sixteenth of October abouâ— the same hour Mr. John Carew was carried in like manner to the same place of Execution where having suffered like pains his Quarters were also returned to Newgate on the same Hurdle which carried him His Majesty was pleased to give upon intercession made by his Friends his Body to be buried Tuesday following being the sixteenth of October Master John Cook and Mr. Hugh Peters were about the same hour 〈◊〉 on two Hurdles to the same place and executed in the same manner and their Quarters returned in like manner to the place whence they came The Head of John Cook is since set on a Pole on the North-East end of Westminster-Hall on the left of Mr. Harrison's looking towards London and the Head of Mr. Peters on London-Bridg Their Quarters are exposed in like manner upon the tops of some of the City Gates Wednesday October 17 about the hour of nine in the 〈◊〉 Mr. Thomas Scot and Mr. Gregory Clemenâ— were â—ought â—n several Hurdles and about one hour after Master Adriâ—n Scroop and Mr. John Jones together in one Hurdle were carried to the same place and suffered the same death and were returned and disposed of in like manner Mr. Francis Hacker and Mr. Daniel Axtel were on Friday the 19th of October about the same time of the morning drawn on one Hurdle from Newgate to Tiburn and there both Hanged Mr. Axtel was Quartered and returned back and disposed as the former but the Body of Mr. Hacker was by his Majesties great favour given entire to his Friends and buried FINIS 3. Jan. 1647.
these Sacred Persons that the Sons of Violence should never approach to hurt them For My Lord the very Thoughts of such an Attempt hath ever been presented by all Laws in all Ages and all Nations of the World as a most unpardonable Treason My Lord This is that that brought the two Eunuchs in the Persian-Court to their just Destruction Voluerunt insurgere saies the Text and yet that was enough to Attain them And so My Lord it was by the Roman Laws too as Tacitus observes Qui deliberant desciverunt To Doubt or Hesitate in a Point of Allegiance is direct Treason and Apostasie And upon this Ground it is that the Statute upon which your Lordships are now to proceed hath these express Words If a man doth Compass or Imagine the Death of the King c. Kings who are God's Vicegerents upon Earth have thus far a kind of Resemblance of the Divine Majesty that their Subjects stand accountable to Them for the very Thoughts of their Hearts Not that any Man can know the Heart save God alone but because when the Wicked Heart breaks out into any open Expressions by which it may be judged 't is the Thoughts of the Heart which makes the Treason the overt-Overt-Act is but the Evidence of it My Lords This Care and Caution is not so to be understood as if it were the Single Interest of One Royal Person only The Law doth wisely judge and foresee that upon the Life of the King depends the Laws and Liberties the Estates and Properties the Wealth and Peace the Religion and in Sum the Glory of the Nation My Lords This Judgment of the Law ha's been verified by a sad Experience for when that Blessed King whose Blood we are now making Inquisition for was untimely taken away Religion and Justice both lay buried in the same Grave with Him and there they had slept still if the miraculous Return of Our Gracious Sovereign had not given them a new Resurrection My Lords My Lord Coke in his Comment upon this Statute ha's one Conceit which is somewhat strange I am sure it is very new he seems to think that it would have added to the Perfection of this Law if there had been a time limited for the Party to be accused But certainly the work of this Day has quite consuted that Imagination For here is a Treason that has so long out-faced the Law and the Justice of this Kingdom that if there had been any time of Limitation in the Statute there would have been no Time nor Place left for Punishment And if this Treason had but once grown up to an Impunity it might perhaps have drawn the Guilt of that Innocent Blood and with it the Vengeance due to it upon the whole Nation The Scope of this Iudictment is for the Compassing the Death of the King the rest of the Indictment as the Vsurping Authority over the King's Person the Assembling Sitting Judging and Killing of the King are but so many several Overt-Acts to prove the Intention of the Heart We are not bound under favour to prove every one of these against every particular Person who is Indicted for he that is in at one is guilty in Law of all rest as much as if he had struck the Fatal Stroke it self Nay under favour if we can prove any other Overt-Act besides what is lai'd in the Indictment as the encouraging of the Souldiers to cry out Justice Justice or Preaching to them to go in this Work as Godly and Religious or any other act of all that Catalogue of Villanies for which the Story will be for ever Infamous this may be given in Evidence to prove the Compassing and Imagining the King's Death The conclusion of this Indictment alledges the Fact done to be to the great Displeasure of Almighty God and to the great Disgrace of the People of England A Truth so clear and known that it can neither be heightned by any Aggravation or lessend by any Excuse As for the Fact it self with the Manner of it I shall not need to open it at large for these things were not done in a Corner every true English Heart still keeps within it self a bleeding Register of this Story only my Lords in the way to our Evidence with your Lordships favour this I think may be fit to be said First for the year 1648. for that was the Fatal year of this King and beyond that year we shall not now enquire I say whatsoever in the Year 1648. could have been done by a Parliament to save the Life of a King was done in this Case They opened the way to a Treaty in spight of the Army and while these Sons of Zerviah who were too hard for them were engaged in Service in the Remoter Parts they hastened the Treaty as much as was possible the Debater upon His Majestie 's Concessions were Voted a good ground for Peace notwithstanding the Remonstrances of the Army still flew about their Ears and notwithstanding the Oppositions of a fearful and unbelieving Party of the House-of Commons whom the Army had frighted into an Awful and a Slavish Dependance upon them And when nothing else could be done for Him they were so true to the Obligations they lay under that they resolved to fall with Him and did so For the Army who saw the Treaty proceed so fast made as great hast to break it They seize upon the blessed Person of our Sacred King by Force and bring Him to London and here they force the Parliament shut out some Members imprison others and then called this wretched little Company which was left a Parliament By this and before they had taken upon them the Boldness to dissolve the House of Peers they pass a Law and Erect forsooth an High Court of Justice as they call it a Shambles of Justice appoint Judges Advocates Officers and Ministers sit upon the Life of the King Now they Speak out and Expound their own Declarations and tell us what that was which before they had demanded in obscure Terms when they called for Justice against all Delinquents Now they speak plainly what they mean and call this blessed King this glorious Saint the grand Delinquent Haec Acies victum factura Nocentem est My Lords When they had thus proceeded to appoint their Judges Officers and Court then they call this Person their onely Liege Lord and Soveraign to the Bar and by a formal Pegeantry of Justice proceed to Sit upon Him Arraign Try Sentence Condemn and Kill I had almost said Crucifie Him whom they could not but know to be their King And all this against the clearest Light the sharpest Checks and most through Convictions of Conscience that ever men resisted And yet in this moment of time such was the Majesty and Innocene of our Gracious Soveraign that the People followed Him with Tears in their Eyes and Acclamations in their Mouths God save the King even then when the Souldiers were ready to fire upon
the Hand-writing of the Prisoner at the Bar The Instrument being shewed him Mr. Farrington I did not see him write it my Lords but I believe it to be his for I have often seen his Hand-writing It is his hand so far as possibly a man can know any Person 's hand that did not see him write Mr. Harrison I desire to see the Instrument Which being shew'd to him he said I believe it is my own Hand Councel That 's the Warrant for summoning that Court that he owns his hand too Court Shew him the other Instrument That being for Execution of the Sentence Mr. Harrison it being shew'd him I do think this is my hand too Councel If you think it the Jury will not doubt it That 's the Bloody Warrant for Execution And we desire they may be both read Mr. Harrison My Lords do these Learned Gentlemen offer these as being any Records Councel No but as your own hand-writing Mr. Harrison If you do not read it as a Record I hope your Lordships will not admit of any thing of that kind against me Councel He knows that a Letter under his hand and Seal may be read in a Court We do not offer it as a Record but prove it by Witnesses that it is your hand-writing Court You have Confessed these to be your hands Whether they are Records or no whether Papers or Letters they may be read against you You signed the Warrant for Convening together those which you called The High Court of Justice and you signed the other Warrant for putting the King to Death You do Confess these two things We do not see what further Use may be made of them Court You might observe how the Indictment was for the Imagining Compassing and Contriving the King's Death To prove that there must be some overt-Overt-Act and a Letter under the Partie's Hand is a sufficient overt-Overt-Act to prove such Imagination to that end these are used Mr. Harrison I do not come to be denying any thing that in my own Judgment and Conscience I have done or Committed but rather to be bringing it forth to the Light Court Sir you must understand this by the way this you must take along with you That these are read not as any thing of Authority in themselves or as used to any other purpose but as an Evidence of the Fact against you Take that along with you The two Bloody Warrants for Trial and for Execution of His Majesty were here read the later of which is as followeth At the High Court of Justice for the Trying and Judging of Charles Stuart King of England Jan. 29. 1648. WHereas Charles Stuart King of England is and standeth Convicted Attainted and Condemned of High Treason and other High Crimes and Sentence upon Saturday last was pronounced against him by this Court to be put to Death by the severing his Head from his Body of which Sentence Execution yet remaineth to be done These are therefore to will and require you to see the said Sentence executed in the open street before White-hall upon the marrow being the 30th day of this instant Moneth of January between the hours of ten in the Morning and five in the Afternoon of the same day with full effect And for so doing this shall be your sufficient Warrant And these are to require all Officers and Souldiers and other the good People of this Nation of England to be assistant unto you in this service To Colonel Francis Hacker Colonel Hunks and Lieutenant-Colonel Phayre and every of them Given under our Hands and Seals Sealed and subscribed BY John Bradshaw Lord President Jo. Hewson Per. Pelham Thomas Grey Oliver Cromwel Edward Whalley John Okey Jo. Danvers Mich. Livesey Jo. Bourchier Hen. Ireton Thomas Maleverer Jo. Blakestone Jo. Hutchinson Will. Goff Thomas Pride Hen. Smith Peter Temple Tho. Harrison Isaac Ewer Val. Wanton Simon Meyn Tho. Horton Jo. Jones Jo. Moor. Hardress Waller Gilbert Millington Geo. Fleetwood Jo. Alured Rob. Lilburn Wil. Say Rich. Dean Rob. Tichbourn Hum. Edwards Dan. Blagrave Owen Roe Will. Puefroy Adrian Scroop James Temple Aug. Garland Edmond Ludlow Hen. Marten Vincent Potter Will. Constable Rich. Ingoldsby Will. Cawley Joh. Barkstead Anth. Stapeley Greg. Norton Tho. Challoner Tho. Wogan Jo. Ven. Greg. Clement Jo. Downs Tho. Wayt. Tho. Scot. Jo. Carew Miles Corbet Mr. Wyndham Gentlemen of the Jury We have done our Evidence and you must know Gentlemen that the principal Point of the Indictment is for Compassing Imagining and Contriving the Death of his late Majesty of Glorious Memory There lies the Treason So saies the Statute of the 25th Ed. 3d. It hath nothing of Killing the King there but of Imagining and Compassing the Death of the King The going about it that 's the Treason as hath been learnedly opened to you The rest are but Overt-Acts If there be such an Imagination or Compassing the Death of the King once declared though no fruit at all follow it is Treason Here certainly you have a very full Evidence given We shew you a Consultation this is one Overt-Act which would do the work if there were nothing else I must tell you and that with Submission to my Lords the Justices if they had advised and gone no further that had been Treason in the Letter of the Law They Convened and met together and suppose then they had absolved and acquitted him do you think they had absolved themselves from Treason With reverence be it spoken if they had acquitted him they had been guilty of Treason Assuming a Power to put the King to Death is an Overt-Act declaring such an Imagination You see this Prisoner was no ordinary Actour in it his Hand is in at all Games Taking of Him Imprisoning of Him bringing Him to London and setting Guards on Him You see also his Malice Let us Blacken Him for they knew His Innocency would Shine forth unless it was blackened by their Imputations He Sate many times as your hear and Sentenced Him and Assented to that Sentence by standing up and likewise by Concluding the Catastrophe of that sad beginning of Sufferings his making a Warrant for his Execution and accordingly you know what did follow I think a clearer Evidence of a Fact can never be given then is for these things Here the Spectatours Hummed Lord Chief Baron Gentlemen This Humming is not at all becoming the Gravity of this Court. Let there be free-speaking by the Prisoner and Counsel It is more fitting for a Stage-Play then for a Court of Justice Mr. Harrison It is now time my Lords to offer what I have to say Have these Learned Gentlemen offered what they will say Councel We have no more till he hath given us occasion not for Evidence of the Fact Mr. Harrison My Lords The matter that hath been offered to you as it was touched was not a thing done in a Corner I believe the sound of it hath been in most Nations I believe the Hearts of some have felt the
be deterred from committing such Acts the Magistrate is bound to put him to death But where there is not such a thing there it is different though it is said the land is defiled that is where there is danger that the like may be committed again now all things are setled there is no danger at all now there can never come such a case as this again I say my Lord what I acted I did as a Counsellor I had no malitious intention in it Mr. Nutley bare testimony so far that I told him there was not intention of putting his Majesty to death I only did say that I desired them to do Justice and I hope what was done was their Act not mine and so I leave my self to your Lordships Court Silence commanded Mr. Sol. G. My Lords this Gentleman who is the prisoner at the Bar requires such an evidence of the Fact as may be evident he saith so evident as may be as clear as the Sun I think that evidence is not to seek but if he must never be convicted till he be so far convinced as to be speechless I believe we may stay long enough nevertheless if he be willing as he saith he is to pay his debts to political Justice we shall quickly give him the total sum That which he hath said hath been like a Lawyer the best that his Case will bear but withal it is a great aggravation to his Crime that he that knew the Law so well should so much transgress it He began Words do not make treason he mistakes his Charge is not for words Gentlemen his Charge is for compassing and imagining the Death of the King and the evidence of that Charge is meeting in that Assembly and the part that he bore in that Assembly And yet my Lords he will be much mistaken too under favour and with submission to your Lordships Judgement and those that hear him if they think that in all Cases it is a general rule that words are no Treason for when a man shall proceed to declare the imagination of his heart as to exhort and perswade men to effect that wicked thing The killing of the K. certainly there cannot be a greater overt act than these words nor a clearer evidence of such an imagination for out of the abundance of the heart the mouth speaks My L. to say that the demanding of Justice is not Treason though injustice do follow is a very weak gloss upon a wicked action The Subject matter was a Charge of High Treason against the King the conclusion of the Charge was a Protestation by which he saved to himself a Liberty to put in a new Charge if that was not sufficient upon the whole he desires that the King as a Traytor may be brought to Justice Judge you now Gentlemen upon the nature of this demand whether this were such a demand of Justice as might end in acquital Whether he that presses that this Charge may be taken pro Confesso did mean that when the Court had recorded it they should acquit him when they had done My Lords to say there are four Actors in this Case the Witness or accuser the Judge the Jury and the Executioner and that he is none of them and therefore in this Case he cannot be a Traytor still my Lord that is to beg the question for if he be one of them that did Assemble in the place and were any instrument of that Assembly he hath thereby given an evidence of an Overtact of his wicked heart when all is done this poor gloss amounts but to this I am none of those four Ranks that is there were others worse than my self and therefore I am none at all My Lord the thing that he hath mainly insisted upon is the Act of Indempnity my Lord he doth observe that his name is excepted in that Act That he doth hope that it is so pen'd as by the favour of the Parl. It may reach his Case he hath argued very much upon it and he speaks as if he did believe it himself But surely there is no colour for that interpretation that he should step out of this proviso by the very Act of Indempnity that was made on purpose to bring him in by-Name the words are provided that this Act nor any thing therein contained shall extend to Pardon or give any benefit to John Cook c. All which persons for their execrable Treasons in Sentencing to Death or signing the Instrument for the horrid Murder or being instrumental in taking away the precious Life of our late Sovereign Lord King Charles the First of glorious Memory are left to be proceeded against as Traytors c. First my Lord this general and clear answer I conceive is to be given that the Prisoner at the Bar being by Name excepted out of the Act of Indemnity by the proviso mentioned in it although the subsequent lines that follow be the reasons why the Parlim do except yet if he be within the very words of the Exception whether he be in the reasons that moved them to that exception is not material if he could distinguish that he was not instrumental in that sense to which he labours to restrain this Proviso he can but say this the Parliament was mistaken in their reason but not in their conclusion but he is directly within the exception and the reason of it too for the word instrumental goes as far as far can be and he is properly literally in the strict notion of the word an instrument of the death of the King The King could never have been brought to death if not to the Bar never had been sentenced if he had not been impeached that impeachment could never have been taken pro Confesso nor the impeachment it self delivered if he had not delivered the one and pressed the other He that brought the Axe from the Tower was not more instrumental than he and besides a Lawyer as he of great understanding and of good parts he knows very well there are no accessaries in Treason but he that Acts any part in so wicked a Conspiracy let him begin at what end he will he stands responsible for the utmost consequence of it and in effect the very penning of this proviso is an express Judgement of Parliament that he was instrumental but that is not to be pressed The next thing he doth insist upon is the Declaration of his Majesty that he sent from Breda which he saith he laid hold upon here lies the weight of his answer The King writes his Letter to the Parliament now sitting that he doth purpose for the quieting of the hearts of men that may be in doubt to pardon all persons all crimes of what nature soever either against himself or Royal Father excepting those which shall be byAct of Parliament excepted and my Lord he doth say and modestly presses that he doth conceive the meaning of that is to pardon all persons what
that you did desire Judgement should be given against him and not so much you as the blood that had been shed that cryed for Judgement truly whether that was a Judgement that you intended for acquital that must be left to the Jury You asked because I will repeat it in order as my memory will give me leave whether there was any other words in the charge than was in the Proclamation Mr. Cook Whether there was any other words or no that differed in the Proclamation as it was a great sin and foul fact in the Proclamation so it was as foul in the Charge Master Masterson swears the same too he heard you say the second day you had delivered a charge the day before against the King and that he had delayed his answer you desired he might plead guilty or not guilty the last day that you did in the names of the Commons Assembled in Parliament and the people of England demand Judgement against the King and then another swears those words Judgement against the Prisoner at the Bar which was the King Burden swears you examined him as a Witness against the King in what place he was with the King It seems he was in the King's Army he swears you gave him an Oath it is testimony fit to be believed but however if you did not give the Oath by what you say your self you may be by and asked him the question Master Starkey he tells you that during the Tryal and before the Sentence that you being an old acquaintance of his in Grayes-Inn speaking with him he spake like a friend to you I hear you are up to the ears in this business and whereas you talk of the people there is a thousand for one against it that you should tell him again You will see strange things but you must wait upon God these words of waiting upon God are words of that nature people do use them now adaies when they would do some horrid impiety which hath been the sin of too many it is but a canting language that is the best term I can give it you told him then He must die this was before the Sentence that is to be observed Gentlemen of the Jury you say you did not know of the Sentence you said He must die and Monarchy with him you must here know that some of those persons that sate upon him said the King was a gracious and wise King and as Mr. Cook did say and they were the best words they spoke and I think he thinks so in his conscience but in conclusion He must die and Monarchy must die with him others said they did not hate King Charles but they hated Monarchy and Government but Monarchy was the thing that they would behead I think I have done with the Evidence that was given against you the Indictment it self was read the Overt acts was the meeting propounding consulting about it It appears he was in the Chamber about the Charge that he did propound it he delivered the Charge it appears withal that he demanded Judgement he desired the King might answer or that it might be taken pro confesso these are overt acts to declare the imagination of his heart The answer of Mr. Cook I will repeat it as clearly as I can because nothing shall go to the extenuating of the fact but it shall be spoken Mr. Cook in your answer your defence that you make you set forth the heads of this Indictment and you set them forth very truly the heads are the aggravations of the Indictment the Indictment was the compassing and imagining the death of the King you said it was upon these grounds that you did propound abet and consult the death of the King that you with others did assume power and authority to kill the King that thereupon a person unknown in a Frock did accordingly kill the King You say to the first part if it did not appear that you did advise the death of the King that you were not guilty for that Sir as I told you before taking them either complexly or singly if any of the particulars reached to one of these acts it was enough but it reaches to all you required Judgement against the King as a Traytor and that with a reason and certainly death must follow you say you were appointed to give your advice you had a Proclamation first for Tryal of the King you had the Order of Jan. 10. whereby you were appointed to give your advice if it were so it will be no excuse at all the Proclama gives you no warrant at all he that obeys so wicked a Proclamation it will not save him it appears you were privy to this before the Proclamation if you were not at all when such a thing as this is such a Proclamation and Act and such a manner of Tryal as I believe though you have read very much you never heard of such a thing in our Law or foreign Nations That you thereupon should take upon you to be of Council against the King it aggravates the fact other men may be impudent ignorant but you that were a learned Lawyer your being of Council doth aggravate the thing You say Secondly by Law words will not amount to Treason for that I would not have that go for Law by no means though it be not your Case for you are not indicted for words but words are Treason and Indictments are often for it but the difference is this The Indictment is not for words but compassing and Imagining the death of the King words are evidences of the compassing imagining the Kings death It is the greatest evidence of the imagination of the heart Words do not make a Treason that is if it be by inference or consequence but reductively but if it be immediately I shall say to a man go kill the King by theat which is an absolute immediate necessary consequence to say this is not Treason I would not have that go for Law your Case is not for words but for delivering a Charge the ground that you speak of words may make a Heretick but not a Traytor it was a witty saying but you have no sufficient authority for it these are words put in writing we all know if a man put his words in writing if a man speak Treasonable words and put them in writing they have been several times adjudged Treason and so in my Lord Cook 's 3. Institutes the Case of Williams of the Temple there was a Book of Treason in his own Study of his making and he was indicted for it words put in writing is an express evidence of the imagination of the heart you say it was dictated to you but when words are written in a Charge and your name to it which I had almost forgotten that 's more than words the Witnesses swear the likeness of your hand they do but swear the likeness of your hand no man can swear
equitie of the Act. They had not all the Authority at that time they were a few of the people that did it they had some part of the Army with them the Lords were not dissolved then when they had adjourned some time they did sit afterwards so that all the particulars you alledge are against you The last thing was this you say that it having pleased God to restore the King Judgement should be given for example for terrour to others that this could not be drawn into example again why because by the blessing of God peace was restored no probability that if your life was spared that it would be drawn again into example this is the weakest thing you have urged you must know the reason there are two things there is the punishment and example punishment goes to the prisoner but example to the documents of all others God knows what such things may be in after ages if there should be impunity for them it would rather make men impudent and confident afterwards if you have any more to say I will hear you if not I must conclude to the Jury You hear the evidence is clear for compassing and imagining the Death of the King you have heard what he has said and what he hath done he has within and examined Witnesses against the King that he was by at the drawing of the charge where it was drawn you hear he exhibited this charge in the name of the Commons assembled in Parliament and the good people of England and what this charge is it is high Treason and other high misdemeanors you find that he does complain of delays dosagain and again speak of this Charge desire it may be taken pro confesso in the close of all it was not so much he as innocent blood that demanded Justice this was more than was dictated to him You have heard the Witnesses he was perswaded to forbear acknowledged the King to be a gracious and wise King The Oaths alledged against him and you have heard his excuse I have nothing to say more I shall be very willing to hear you further I have not absolutely directed the Jury Cook I do humbly acknowledge your patience in hearing me and that your Lordships have truly and justly stated both proofs and my answer If your Lordships are pleased to lay aside these Acts or Orders or Authority whereby I did at that time truly conscientiously act and did think that it would bear me out if you lay aside that and look upon it as so many men got together without authority and aswell those that were instrumental though not sentencers or signers and that clause in the Act I confess I humbly make bold to say I have not received satisfaction in my judgment those very words of not so much I as the innocent blood cries for justice were dictated to me there was nothing at all left to me because his Majesty did not plead there was no Tryal that which I did was according to the best though it may be according to the weakest part of my judgment I have no new matter L. Ch. Bar. You have said no new matter unless it be worse than before for now you warrant that Authority Cook Do not mistake me my Lord I mean so far as to excuse me in the point of High Treason L. C. B. We delivered our opinions as to that formerly we were of opinion that the acting by colour of that pretended authority was so far from any extenuation that it was an aggravation of the thing the meeting by that authoty was Treason and in them that acted under them and approving of it the making of that trayterous pretended Act making the Proclamation sitting upon it they were all so many Treasons That was the reason why that was urged against you assuming upon you the power that was you approving of their power by acting under them so that there is nothing more to be said Gentlemen of the Jury you have heard the indictment was for compassing and imagining the death of the King you have heard the several Overt acts repeated and whether these are guilty of Treason to deliver in a charge against the K. such a one as that was in these words as against a Traytor Tyrant Murderer and implacable enemy to the Commonwealth in these very words to desire Judgement against the Prisoner then the King at the Bar angry at delayes to desire that the Charge might be taken pro confesso to have it expresly again again to demand Judgement if these be not Overt acts of compassing and imagining the Death of the King that which hath been said by the Witnesses it must be left to you I think you need not go from the Bar. Jury went together Silence is commanded Clerk Are you agreed of your Verdict Jury Yes Clerk Who shall speak for you Jury The Fore-man Clerk John Cook hold up thy hand look upon the Prisoner at the Bar how say you is he guilty of the Treason in manner form as he stands indicted or not guilty Fore-man Guilty Clerk Look to him Keeper Clerk What Goods and Chattells Jury None that we know of The Tryal of Hugh Peters the same 13. of October and at the same Bar. Clerk of the Crown SET Hugh Peters to the Bar he was brought accordingly H. P. Hold up thy hand thou standest indicted c. If you will challenge any of the Jury you must challenge them when they come to the book before they are sworn L. Ch. Bar. Mr. Peters You may challenge to the number of 35 peremptiorily but beyond that you cannot without good cause shewn and you may have Pen Ink and Paper Peters My Lord I shall challenge none Jury sworn 12. Sir Jer. Whitch James Hally Christo Abdy Nich. Rainton Rich. Cheyney Jo. Smith Rich. Abell George Terry Charl. Pickern Jo. Nichol. Fran. Dorrington Anthony Hall Cler. Hugh Peters hold up thy hand Look on the Prisoner you that are sworn c. Sir Ed. Turner to the Jury You have often heard repeated to you that the substantial part of the charge is the compassing and imagining the death of the King and all the rest will be but evidence to prove that imagination against the Prisoner at the Bar whom we will prove to be a principal actor in this sad Tragedy and next to him whom God hath taken away and reserved to his own Judgment and we shall endeavour to prove That he was a chief Conspirator with Cromwell at serveral times and in several places and that it was designed by them We shall prove that he was the principal person to procure the Souldiery to cry out Justice Justice or assist or desire those for the taking away the life of the King He did make use of his profession wherein he should have been the Minister of peace to make himself a Trumpeter of war of Treason and Sedition in the Kingdom He preached many Sermons to the Souldiery in direct
by law that the right of the Militia was in them and your Lordships will remember in several Declarations and Acts that was mutually exchanged between his Majesty and Parliament and my Lord that was the Authority the Lords and Commons assembled in Parliament raised a Force and made the Earl of Essex Ceneral and after him the Earl of Manchester of the Eastern Association and after that Sir Tho. Fairfax Lord General of the Forces by this Authority I acted and this Authority I humbly conceive to be legal because this Parliament was called by the Kings Writ chosen by the People and passed a Bill they should not be dissolved without their own consents that the Parliament was in being when the Tryal was and a question whether yet legally Dissolved In the fourth place they were not only owned and obeyed at home but abroad to be the chief Authority of the Nation and also owned by Foreign States and Kingdoms sent Ambassadors to that purpose under them did all the Judges of the Land Act who ought to be the Eye of the Land and the very light of the People to Guide them in their right Actions and I remember the Judges upon Tryal I have read it of High Treason Judg Thorp Nicholas and Jermin have declared it publickly That it was a lawful justifiable thing by the Law of the Land to obey the Parliament of England My Lord it further appears as to their Authority over the People of this Nation petitioning them as the supreme and lawful Authority and My Lords as I have heard it hath been objected that the Houses of Lords and Commons could make no Act. Truly my Lord if you will not allow them to be Acts though they intitle them so call them so and obeyed as so by the Judges Ministers and Officers of State and by all other persons in the Nation yet I hope they cannot be denied to be Orders of Parliament and were they no more but Orders yet were they sufficient as I humbly couceive to bear out such as acted thereby And my Lord the Parliament thus constituted and having made their Generals he by their Authority did constitute and appoint me to be an Inferior Officer in the Army serving them in the quarters of the Parliament and under and within their power and what I have done my Lord it hath been done only as a Souldier deriving my power from the General he had his power from the Fountain to wit the Lords and Commons and my Lord this being done as hath been said by several that I was there and had command at Westminster-Hall truly my Lord if the Parliament command the General and the General the inferiour Officers I am bound by my Commission according to the Laws and Customs of War to be where the Regiment is I came not thither voluntarily but by command of the General who had a Commission as I said before from the Parliament I was no Counsellor no Contriver I was no Parliament-man none of the Judges none that Sentenced Signed none that had any hand in the Execution onely that which is charged is that I was an Officer in the Army if that be so great a crime I conceive I am no more guilty than the Earl of Essex Fairfax or the Lord of Manchester Judg Mallet You are not charged as you were an Officer of the Army Axtell My Lords That is the main thing they do insist upon my Lord I am no more guilty than his Excellency the Lord General Monck who Acted by the same Authority and all the People in the three Nations and my Lord I do humbly suppose if the Authority had been only an Authority in Fact and not Right yet those that Acted under them ought not to be questioned but if the Authority commanded whatsoever offence they committed especially that that guided me was no less than the declared Judgment of the Lords and Commons sitting in Parliament they declared that was their right as to the Militia and having explained several Statutes of Henry the 7th wherein the King having enterchanged Declarations with the Parliament the Parliament comes to make an Explanation on that Statute and my Lord it is in Folio 280. wherein they do positively expound it and declare it as their allowed Judgment To clear up all scruples to all that should take up Arms for them saith the Parliament there as to the Statute of 11. of Henry the 7th Chapter the first which is printed at large comes there to explain it in general and comes here Folio 281. and gives this Judgment It is not say they agreeable to Reason or Conscience that any ones duty should be known if the Judgment of the High Court of Parliament be not a Rule or Guide to them In the next place this is the next Guidance Rule and Judgment of Parliament upon the Exposition of this Statute and as they have said in several places was it not too much to take up your Lordships time they are the proper Judges and Expounders of the Laws The High Court of Parliament have taken upon them to expound the Law and said that we Lawyers will give the meaning of the Text contrary to what they have expounded the meaning under their hands in the same Declaration his Majesty is pleased to quit that Statute upon which I stand Indicted the 25th of Edward the Third where they do my Lord expound that very Statute in the Declaration made in 1643. Folio 722. I come to the declared Judgment wherein they did positively say that the persons that do Act under their Authority ought not to be questioned as persons Guilty Folio 727. that is the Exposition that the Lords and Commons Assembled in Parliament doth make upon the statute Councel My Lord this is an Argumentation of Discourse in justification of his proceedings we desire to know what he will answer as to the Plea Axtell My Lords I have this further to say that if a House of Commons Assembled in Parliament may be Guilty of Treason for the truth is if I Acted Treason that Acted under the Authority of the Lords and Commons in Parliament and of the Commons in Parliament then doubtless they must begin the Treason if the House of Commons who are the collective body and Representation of the Nation all the people of England who chose them are guilty too and then where will there be a Jury to try this concerning the Commons alone I have been over ruled L. ch Bar. If you have any thing to say to the Lords and Commons answer to your charge your charge is nothing of the Lords and Commons but what you Acted when the house was broke and Forced Coun. You cannot but know that there is nothing charged against you for which you can so much as pretend an Authority of the Lords and Commons you know before you could do this Horrid Murther you were the persons that destroyed the Lords and Commons both indeed you Ravel in a
business and to make people gaze upon you without any Ground Axt. I am upon my life I hope you will hear me patiently L. ch Bar. God forbid but we should Axt. I do desire to assert my Authority if any thing was done upon the House of Lords and Commons I do not come here to justifie their Actions I was not concerned in it My next Plea is this that if a House of Commons can be charged Guilty of High Treason as a community the distributive Body must needs be Guilty Court If there should have been 20 or 40 men come out of the House of Commons and should Murther a man they must answer for that it is not the community that can do such an Act of Treason these persons that you call a House of Commons there was but 26 of them and these must be the people this is the state of the case and when you have thrust out thrice the number of those remaining only those can serve your turn L. Annesly Mr. Axtell I am very sorry to see you in that place and it troubles me as much to hear you vent that for an Authority which you know your self was no Authority you would now for your defence for life and it is reason you should make as full a defence for life as you can you would shelter your self under that Authority which I am sorry I must say were one of the greatest Violators of you cannot forget how near a close of this bloody war by the mercy of God this Nation was when the Army interposed whose Trade it was to live by War when they had felt so much of the sweet of War they would not suffer the people to enjoy peace though the Lords and Representatives in Parliament had agreed to it A Treaty was begun terms of peace propounded and agreed to this you cannot forget and will have no need of Notes or Books to help your Memory when the people Groaned under the miseries of War and thirsted after Peace then came up the Army who were servants to the Parliament till that time taking upon them the Authority you cannot forget that your self was one of the number that came to offer accusations against the majority of the Commons House calling them Rotten Members the House of Lords was not then suffered to sit they would not joyn in that Ordinance that was preparing for the Tryal of the King when the Lords had refused they were no longer fit to be Lords neither then comes in a new Authority which we never heard of before a remnant of the House of Commons joyning with the Army that had driven away the greatest part of the House of Commons for in all Assemblies and Courts the major part must determine or no determination after this course was taken then is an Act set on foot they take upon them by Votes of their own to be the Parliament of England that the supreme power of the Nation is in the Representatives of the people who were they those few only that remained almost all the Cities Counties and Burroughs of England had none left to represent them they were driven away by Force then was this Act of Parliament such an Act as was never heard of before set on foot and passed as an Act by a few of the House of Commons if you can plead this for your defence this is the Act that you must shelter under But you know the Lords and Commons had Unanimously resolved for peace and so agree with the King if this Act will be any defence you may plead it to the full and this is all you have to say therefore go upon no Forreign matter Axt. If it please your Lordship that worthy Lord that spoke last is pleased to say that I was one of the persons that did accuse some of those Members of Parliament truly my Lord I never did come to the Commons Bar but once presenting a petition and for my hand either in charging any of the Members or Secluding any of them I never had any hand in that matter this is all to that part Next I Humbly conceive here I must ground my bottome and if I perish I perish by a Judgement in a Parliament My Commission that did Authorize me to obey my General was given me when the Lords and Commons sate in Parliament I had no other Commission then this my Lord Fairfax commanded the Army after the Kings Death by the like Commission I did but my duty in going to my Regiment the General saith go to such a place stay there if I refuse by the law of War I Dye if I obey I am in danger likewise I say my Commission was given me by the Lords and Commons and therefore I hope my Lord that what I have said and offered in that particular is not Truthless but of Weight Court The Effect of your Commission is only to make you an Officer Axtell My Commission bears date the 27th of March 1648. Ten months before the Kings Death we had no other Commissions therefore I humbly conceive the question will be this in point of law and I humbly desire it may be Truly and Fairly stated by your Lordship and these Honourable Jugdes that whether a man being guided by the Judgment of the Lords and Commons Assembled in Parliament and having declared their Judgments and Exposition of that Statute of the 25th of Edward the Third and Acting only by that Judgment of Parliament and under their Authority can be questioned for Treason That my Lord is a question that I do humbly think is a point in law and that you will please fairly and truly to state it whether I am within the compass of that Statute whereupon I am indicted Councel My Lord We do not charge him with any thing that he did Act under the colour of his Commission or with any thing he did before that but that which we charge him with are rhe Acts that he did at the Tryal of the King shew us your Commission from the Lords and Commons Assembled in Parliament for Tryal and Execution of the King you say something we do not charge him for any thing done by Vertue of that Commission but with those violent Acts that he did in encouraging the Souldiers to cry Justice Justice Execution Execution and all those other Violent Actions of his own malicious heart against the King We humbly beseech you he may answer to that which is the charge against him and that is the Compassing and Imagining the Death of the late King and his declaring that by those overt-acts that we have proved My Lords we desire that the Prisoner at the Bar may remember that he is not Indicted for levying War against the King if so then that Sir which you offer might be given as a Plea and we should have spoken to it but you are Indicted for Compassing and Imagining the Death of the King and that which we have given in Evidence
were the subsequent overtacts to prove the same Axtell I hope you will not think it much to give me some more freedom for my own defence for life My Lord I must needs say though there was a force on the Parliament I am not to justifie it I was no Lawyer no Statesman no Councellor but a Souldier and if the General who had a Commission from the Lords and Commons and that some years before and after the King's Death be not guilty of Treason what I did was by command from my General and though I am charged with being in Arms in Westminster-hall and at such and such a place yet it was not a Voluntary Act for I was bound to obey my General I do humbly pray that I may have your Lordships Judgment in this point I must say it was from the sense of their exposition of the Law and of the Statutes and from the Authority that every one took up Arms for and served them and obeyed either the one General or the other I say it was under this very Authority and this must needs acquit me from all the guilt that is laid upon me L. ch Bar. You put your self upon the Judgment of the Court upon this which you call a point in Law First it is manifest that there is no excuse at all for Treason no man by his Commission can warrant the doing of an Act which is Treason you must take notice of the Authority whether it be good or no your Commission was not to put the King to Death but on the contrary to preserve the Kings life The Lords and Commons what they did we do not meddle with the Reason and Ground of what they did was the preservation of the Kings Person as well as the maintenance of the Laws and Liberties of this Nation they made Protestations Declarations and Oaths for the preservation of the King's Person and you could not but take notice of those things Now whereas you go about to shroud your self under the Lord Fairfax he had no such Power and therefore you can challenge no more then he had and to what you say concerning the Judgment of the Parliament there will be a great deal of difference between a particular Case and a Declaration of Lords and Commons there is nothing you have said that hath any thing of Force and God forbid you should make use of it But I must tell you you could not but notoriously know all those Transactions that were in the Army what the Army had done that they came up with Swords in their Hands and turn'd out whom they would you saw what the Lords and Commons had done that the Treaty was ready for his Birth And then you come up with your Mermidons with Force and Arms and Exclude the greatest part of the Members and then the Lords were laid aside it is true the Lords were not wholly dissolved but they would not suffer them to Sit nor Act at all and this was apparent to the Nation If men under colour and pretence of such things Namely that a few persons for so they were but an Eighth part of the House of Commons permitted to remain and of that Eighth part which was but 46 in the whole there were but 26 that Voted that Act which you say you obeyed but you say you obeyed the General you were not to obey the General in this Case for the Facts that you have committed are not charged as Acts of War you are not charged for bringing the Souldiers in but for those Violent Actions that you were guilty of there you made the Souldiers cry out Justice Justice Execution Execution you sent officiously for a Hang-man to come down to you your Commission gave you no power for this the Death of the King you know how it was designed you know the Act for the bringing in of that Commission as they call'd it to sit in justice was after the House of Commons was reduced to a very small Number and some of those dissenting too what you did Act under that Authority if you can justifie it in the Name of God say so but do not Engage the Nation in those things which they abhorred and by the mercy of God are laid asleep Mr. Justice Foster You begin at the wrong End you ought as all men ought to do First to answer the matter of Fact and not to put in these long dilatory Pleas till you have answered the matter of Fact whether those things charged on you be true or not then if you have any thing further to say for your self by way of excuse it will be the time to speak and not before Axt. May it please your Lordships I humbly conceive I am upon that method to the first part of the witness they accuse me for commanding my Souldiers in Westminster-hall then I must prove my Authority which I have been about to do and declared the Judgment of Parliament L. ch B. The Court have heard you with a great deal of patience and that which is not at all to the business Axtell I only refer this as to the Authority I humbly conceive you will give me leave to insist upon this and how far I may improve it for my own defence here is the Commission by which my Lord Fairfax acted and that after the King's Death and I acted by the same Authority he did I had not been at Westminster-hall but on the command of the General Court Doth that Commission Authorize you to cry Justice Justice and to look up and down to get Witnesses against the King is that in your Commission Axt. I am to serve and obey all my Superior Officers that is my Commission if I do not I die by the Law of War Court You are to obey them in their just commands all unjust commands are invalid If our Superiors should command us to undue and irregular things much more if to the committing of Treason we are in each Case to make use of our passive not active Obedience Axt. Under Favour it is not proved that I did either Compass or Imagine the King's Death that is matter of Fact Court Let us try that Axt. My Lord I did nothing but as a meer Souldier I had Authority from the General I would leave this before your Lordships and the Jury that what I have done hath been by Authority of the Genetal L. Hollis Sir a word to you If you could satisfie the Court that you had received a Commission from the General to do those things with which you stand charged it were something then were it proper for you to plead it and the Court to judg Pray take this along with you the General gave you no such command what you are charged with in the Indictment is for Compassing and Imagining the Death of the King and that by such and such overt acts as making your Souldiers cry out Justice and Execution for being active and forward in sending for the
a sentence that he did conjure them to withdraw once again and to consider of it if it were but half an hour or saith he if that be too much for you I will withdraw My Lord here I can make my appeal to him that must judg me when you have done with me I had not a murderous nor a trayterous thought against him but Sir I confess such deep passions did fall upon me that truly my self I was not I remember the persons betwen whom I sate as it fell out were one Mr. Cawly and Col. Walton these two I sate betwixt these were the very words I speak to them Have we hearts of stone are we men they laboured to appease me they told me I would ruine both my self and them said I if I die for it I must do it Cromwel sate just the seat below me the hearing of me make some stir whispering he looked up to me and asked me if I were my self what I meant to do that I could not be quiet Sir said I No I cannot be quiet upon that I started up in the very nick when the President commanded the Clerk to read the Sentence I stepping up and as loud as I could speak spoke to this effect these words or to the like purpose My Lord said I I am not satisfied to give my consent to this Sentence but have Reasons to offer to you against it and I desire the Court may adjourn to hear me presently he stept up and looked at me Nay saith he if any one of the Court be unsatisfied the Court must adjourn Sir accordingly they did adjourn into the inner Court of Wards when they came there I was called upon by Cromwel to give an account why I had put this trouble and disturbance upon the Court I did speak Sir to this effect it is long ago the very words I think I cannot speak but to this effect I did speak My Lord I should have been exceeding glad if the Court had been pleased to condescend to this gracious Expression but it is not too late for me I desire not his Death but his Life and that the Nations may be setled in Peace The King now is pleased to offer That if he might but speak with his Parliament he would offer to them such things as should be satisfactory to us all So said I what would you have Your pretence of bringing him to these Proceedings was That after such a long and bloody War his Majesty would not condescend to such Concessions as might secure the Parliaments Party but now you hear him that he will give every one of us satisfaction I told them sadly told them I think I may truly say more sadly then than at this time that if they should go precipitantly on and give Judgment upon him before they had acquainted the Parliament with what the King was pleased to offer we should never be able answer it the rather my Lord and that I did press with all the little understanding that I had if they did but consider the last concluded Order that the Parliament made after the passing of the Act for Trial that which was so called I say there was this Order that shut up all That upon any Emergency that could not at that time be thought on in the House the Court should immediately acquaint the House with it My Lord I did infer as strongly as I could to them That if this were not Emergent I could not tell what was The King denied the Jurisdiction of the Court and yet with all vehemency desired to speak with his Parliament were not these Emergencies if not I knew not what were Emergences My Lords Besides this there was another thing I did press that I thought was of greater consequence than this as to the satisfaction of every Man 's particular Conscience that admitting if it might be admitted that the King was liable to his Subjects that they might call him to an account and might condemn him I beg your pardon that I take the boldness to make such admissions but if such a thing might be admitted certainly it did exceedingly become those Judges that were to give such a Sentence not against a common Person but against the greatest to be very well satisfied in Matter of Fact to a full Evidence before them that such and such things that were said were true I do acknowledg this that to the best of my apprehension I wish it had been so to others there was a great shortness in this I do humbly affirm this That not one Member of the Court did hear one Witness Viva Voce I did press That if the Court did give Judgment against the King without a fair Examination I said it was such a thing as no Judg at any Assizes would do against a common Person what I had was from Peters and from some private Whispers from one of them that is gone and hath received his Sentence and Doom Cromwel did answer with a great deal of storm He told the President that now he saw what great reason the Gentleman had to put such a trouble and disturbance upon them saith he Sure he doth not know that he hath to do with the hardest hearted Man that lives upon the Earth however it is not fit that the Court should be hindred from their Duty by one peevish Man he said the bottom was known that he would fain save his old Master and desired the Court without any more ado would go and do their Duty Another that spoke to me in answer was one that hath been before you and hath rereived his Sentence but is not dead and I desire I may not name his Name his answer was to what I have said That some Men were either Scepticks or Infidels After this I did go into the Speaker's Chamber and there I did ease my mind and heart with tears God only knows I have an unhappy memory I have slipt many thinâ—s Lord Chief Baron Remember your self by Papers if you have any no man will hinder you Downes I have no papers but my Lord for the truth of this I have said there are some witnesses that will make the substance the effect of this appear Lord Chief Baron Mr. Downes there is one particular before you come to the witnesses that after all these Convictions you signed the Warrant you deny it the Council will prove it Downes I did never hope or think that any thing I can say should be so satisfactory to you but things might be retorted upon me and perhaps what I thought might be for extenuating my Crime my fall out to my disadvantage I understand you do proceed upon three particulars either signing the first Warrant for constituting the Court To my remembrance I know not of it if my hand was to it I have forgot Counsel Your hand is not to that but we mean your hand is to the Warrant for execution pray shew it him It was shewn him Downes My Lord
was forced to run through out what they had imposed upon me Having seen me I could not shrink from them for fear of my own destruction and thereupon I did go in and did that which I have confessed to your Lordships not out of any malignity to his Majesty I had never any disrespect to him in my life My Lord I did not know which way to be safe in any thing without Doors was misery within Doors was mischief I do appeal to all that had any thing to do with me that I never did any wrong to any that was of the Kings party but helped them as I was able My Lord when the Government was thus tossed and turned and tumbled and I know not what and the secluded Members came into the House I knew not what to do in that case neither Assoon as this Parliament had declared the Treaty which was the eighth of May the ninth of May I appeared before the right honourable the Lord Mayor of London and did claim the benefit of his Majesties gracious Declaration and to become a Loyal Subject as in my heart I alwayes was and my Lord Mayor being there I hope he will testifie that assoon as I heard of the Proclamation I rendered my self according to the Proclamation My Lord this hath been the carriage of me being alwayes under fear and force I refer my self to your Lordships Symon Meyne When I was last here my Lord that I did then speak Not guilty was not as to the matter of fact but my Conscience telling of me that I had no malice or ill intention to his Majesty that was the reason For Matter of fact I shall acknowledge what I have done and lye at his Majesties feet for mercy I am an ignorant weak man in the Law I will confess the fact Couns Did you sign the Warrant for summoning that Court and did you sign the Warrant for Execution of the King Meyne I did sit in Court Counsel Did you sign the Warrant for Execution Meyne My Lord I knew not of the King 's bringing up I never was at any Committee Counsel We do not ask you that Look upon the Warrant and see if your hand and seal be not to it Meyne My Lord it is my hand Counsel Then my Lord we have done Meyne My Lord I acknowledge it is my hand By what importunity it my be known to some here I was very unwilling to it I was told What fear was there when forty were there before and twenty was of the Quorum I was thereupon drawn in to set my hand to it My Lord I never plotted nor contrived the business There was a Gentleman that told me if I did offer to speak in the House pluckt me down by the Coat and he told me I should besequestred as a Delinquent the name of this person I shall omit saith he you will rather lose your estate then take away the King's life I leave it with you James Temple At the last time I pleaded to the Indictment Not guilty but I shall now desire to see my hand and if it be my hand I must confess all circumstances must follow The Warrants being shewn him I do accknowledge it is my hand to both I never did consult concerning the Court. Counsel There are some worse then he but he is bad enough James Temple I refer my self to the King and Parliament and presented a Petition which was received by the Court. Peter Temple When I was here the last time I pleaded Not guilty the reason was because there are divers things in the Indictment that my Conscience tells me I am not guilty of for I had not a malicious or trayterous heart against the King To save your Lordships time I will confess what I am guilty of I was in the Court sate there if I see my hand I shall confess it Counsel Were you there when Sentence was given Temple Yes Sir Counsel Shew him the Warrants which being shewed him I acknowledge they are my hand and refer it to your Lordships Counsel Mr. Wayte you heard the Charge read against you what say you to it Thomas Waite Truly my Lord when I was here last I pleaded not guilty I humbly desired then your Lordships to hear me a word or two You promised me then I should be heard I shall desire to speak for my self Lord Chief Baron God forbid but you should Mr. Sol. G. By your Lordships favour we must speak first if he will confess the fact he my speak what he will Did you sit in the Court Waite Yes Counsel The day of Sentence Waite Yes Counsel Is your hand to the Warrant for Execution Waite I know not pray let me see it It was shewen him My Lord I confess it is like my hand but I do not remember it Counsel If you do not acknowledge it it will be proved Waite Truly my Lord I do beleive it is my hand Counsel Then the Jury will not doubt it Waite But I desire to be heard I am loath to trouble you much I will tell you how I was brought into this business My Lord I was a Member of that House that erected this Court when the Treaty was in the Isle of Wight Immediately after the Army came up I was utterly against that Act in the House When the Army came up to purge the House I was much troubled at it I desired to know the Charge they had against them Two or three dayes after I did move and there were other Gentlemen that did move to know what Charge there was They sent word we should have a Charge in due time we sent and none came but said we should have it in due time I went to those worthy Gent. to see them in prison and seeing nothing would be done I took my leave and made account to see them no more and went down into the Country to Leicester-shire I was sent for up several times I would not come with threats upon pain of Sequestration My Lords there were Petitions going up and down in the Country for bringing the King to that business which was against my conscience I went to Rutlandshire I heard there were some things working there I used my interest and I thank God I stopt it I came then to London when all these things were destroyed I came to London the day before the Sentence was given I went to the House thought nothing some were sent to the Tower and I was sent for to the House and my name was in the Act unknown to me but one sent a Note in my Lord Gray's Name that he would speak with me I went to him and I said my Lord what would you do with me saith he I did not send for you Thereupon Cromwel and Ireton laid hold on me said they We sent for you you are one of the High Court No said I not I my Judgement is against it they carried me to the Court. When the King desired to
speak with his Parliament I rising up one told me I must not be heard for the President was to give Judgement and said there was an order that none should speak in Court Mr. Downes did move and they did adjourn the Court and I was glad I got out Cromwell laughed and smiled and jeared in the Court of Wards I hope your Lordship will be pleased to consider I was no Contriver no Soldier that put the force upon the House that erected the Court None of the Law-makers or did any thing maliciously against the King My Lord I was looked upon with an evil eye for regarding the King's friends in the Country Gray he told me the King would not die I hope he will not said I. The next day on Monday I went to the House they were labouring to get hands for his Execution at the Door I refused and went into the House saith Cromwell those that are gone in shall set their hands I will have their hands now That night I went to the Lord Grays and he said I am afraid they will put him to death I said so also My Lord I have been a great sufferer I was drawn in trapan'd into it since being a friend to the Kings friends I am almost ruined in my estate I beseech your Lordships make the best interpretation I hope you will believe I was no Contriver I humbly lay hold upon the Kings mercy and favour I came in upon the Proclamation I pray that this Honourable Court will prefer my Petition to the King and both Houses of Parliament which the Court then received William Heveningham My Lord in 1648. we were under a force under the tyranny of an Army they were our Masters for a malicious and a traiterous heart I had not I do absolutely deny the signing the Warrant for summoning the Court and also that Warrant for execution of the King at the time of sealing I had that Courage and Boldness that I protested against it Counsel We do not question him for that but for sitting in the high Court of Justice and that upon the day of the sentence do you deny that Heveningham My Lord I cannot say positively Counsel If you deny the matter of fact it must be proved Heveningham I cannot say positively but it may be I might Counsel Either say positively you did or else let the Witnesses be call'd Heveningham Truly my Lord I think I did but my after-actions Lord Chief Baron Mr. Heveningham that shall be considered Counsel My Lord to sit upon the day of Sentence was high Treason in it self and is an evidence of Compassing and Imagining the Kings death Hev I shall lay hold of the Declaration I came in upon the Proclamation I pray your Lordships to interceed for me to the King and both Houses of Parliament I pray the mercy of this Court L. C. B. You of the Jury they have all confessed and therefore you may go together Simon Meyne My Lords I have forgot my Petition it is at my lodging I desire I may send it at night John Downes and Peter Temple prayed the like favour L. Ch. B. Do send them they shall be received The Jury having consulted together a certain time they went to their places Clerk Gentlemen are you agreed of your verdict Jury Yes Clerk Who shall say for you Jury Our Fore-man Clerk John Downes hold up thy hand Look upon the prisoner how say you is he guilty of High Treason whereof he stands indicted and hath been arraigned or not guilty Forem Guilty Clerk Look to him Keeper What Goods and Chattels c. Forem None to our knowledge And the like verdicts at the same time passed in the same manner against Vincent Potter Augustine Garland Symon Meyne James Temple Peter Temple Thomas Waite and William Heveningham Potter I hope I may be freed from Irons I am in pain and a man of bulk L. Ch. B. We can give no order in it we must leave it to the Sheriff Potter I begg it of you my Lord. L. Ch. B. We must leave it to the Sheriff Mr. Heveningham You must withdraw from the Bar. Clerk Officer bring down VValler Fleetwood Hacker Axtel Hulet Penington Marten Millington Titchborne Roe Lilburne Smith and Harvey and set them to the Bar which was done accordingly Clerk Hardress VValler hold up thy hand thou hast been Indicted and found guilty of High Treason what canst thou say why judgment should not pass on thee to dy according to Law VValler My Lords I am now it seems Convicted by Law and so adjudged Your Lordships the other day on my desire told me I might have liberty to speak upon my trial I must now beg the like upon a condemned person L. Ch. B. You are Convicted not Condemned Waller My Lords I was the first that pleaded Guilty I bless God that he gave me a heart to do it I find most peace in the doing of it and since there is nothing left but hopes of Mercy I humbly submit it to your Lordships to hear me in this sad condition that that may make me seem more capable of mercy I have my Lords been so unhappy to have been transplanted out of my Country these thirty years I have been but once these eleven years in England this must needs make me a stranger L. Ch. B. I must not hinder you because it is for mercy that you plead but consider with your self whether it will not be better to give it in a Petition I leave it to you we can do nothing in point of Mercy but Judgment Waller Onely this My Lord whether I am not the more capable of your mercy L. Ch. B. That you may understand it the Act of Indempnity of Parliament hath excepted you yet upon some qualifications we are to proceed according to Law that is to go to Conviction and Judgment The Act sayes that after Judgment there shall be no execution but that it shall be suspended till a further Act of Parliament to be passed for that purpose so that in the mean time we are to proceed no further then Judgment That which concerns Mercy is referred to another place If you please to say any thing to satisfie us or to go by way of Petition it must be left to you but what you say for mercy is nothing to us Waller I humbly thank your Lordships for this clear and noble dealing and withall I would beg that these people that are witnesses of my shame and guilt may know that it was a force and temptation upon me I shall not insist much I have said that I did plead guilty which was most safe to my own Conscience yet I should make it appear that I did appear more to preserve the King from Tryal and Sentence then any other Lord Finch Sir Hardress Waller I have heard of late of your sorrow which I was glad to hear of because you are my kinsman both by your Father and Mothers side and also my
nothing but indeed to make a new Government which is the highest Treason next to the Murthering of the King in the world To subvert the Laws and to make a few of the Commons nay if they had been the whole to make them to have the Legislative power Mr. Scot if you have any thing in extenuation of the Fact we shall hear you further we cannot L. Finch If you speak to this purpose again for my part I will profess my self I dare not hear further of it It is so poysonous blasphemous a doctrine contrary to the Laws if you go upon this point I shall and I hope my Lords will be of that opinion too desire the Jury may be directed Scot. I thought my Lord you would rather be my Councel it is not my single opinion I am not alone in this Case therefore I think I may justifie my self in it it was the Judgement of many of the Secluded Members to own us to be a Parliament Lord Annesley What you said last doth occasion my rising you seem to deliver my opinion who you know could never agree to what you have alledged truly I have been heartily sorry to hear the defence you have made to day because you know I have had Letters from you of another nature I was very confident to have heard you an humble Penitent this day instead of justifying your self As to that which you say of the Secluded Members owning you to be a Parliament they were so far from it that you know for how many years they lay under sufferings and obscurity because they could not acknowledge that an Authority which was not so You cannot forget the Declaration of both Houses that was published upon a Jealousie that the people had they would change the Government of King Lords and Commons It was far from their thoughts it was called in that Declaration A black scandal cast upon them This Declaration you know was by Order of both Houses affixed in all Churches of England that people might take notice what they held to be the Fundamental Government of this Kingdom King Lords and Commons After this for you to set up another Government and under them to act such things that one would think should hardly enter into the heart of any man You know very well all along they declared themselves faithful Subjects to the King and so would have lived and dyed and you might have had your share of the happiness of that peace if you could have had an Inclination to submit to that which both Houses had resolved when you and others could not bring your hearts to stoop to your Fellow Subjects when you could not submit to that equal rule to take your share with them When Pride carried some so high then was the beginning of your fall and others and none could expect other than what is now come to pass That they should come to that shame and sorrow that this day hath brought upon you I could have wished to have heard nothing but an humble confession of the fault that hath been clearly proved and no Justification of it You have sworn among others to preserve the Laws and People of the Kingdom but you drove away not only the House of Lords but most of the Commons and then to give the name of a Parliament to the Remainder this is a great aggravation of your Treason I think we of the Secluded Members could not have discharged our duty to God and the Kingdom if we had not then appeared in Parliament to have dissolved that Parliament and so by our joynt assent put an end to all your pretences which if we had not done we had not so soon come to our happiness nor you to your miseries Lo. Ch. Bar. The Court hath told you before their opinions in the thing and no further debate is to be allowed in this the Justification of it doth comprehend treason We our selves are not by Law to allow the hearing of it If you have nothing to say for your self I must give direction to the Jury Scot. I humbly crave leave to move the Jury that they bethink themselves and consider of it rather as a special Verdict than of a definitive one I think there is cause of a special Verdict Court If there was need of a special Verdict We are upon our Oaths I should give direction to the Jury What We do We do upon our Oaths and must answer it before God Almighty The Court hath delivered their opinions before that in this Case the Pretended Authority under which you did derive that Power which you did execute that it is no Authority it is void in Law it is a foundation if it were true of subverting all Laws and indeed of all Religion a Power that you assumed to your selves of Judging and Condemning your King that you would countenance such an Authority is a great aggravation of the fault They are Jugdes whether you did Imagine or Compass the Kings Death that is all the Jurors have to do Gentlemen of the Jury Scot. I would know what particular Law I have transgressed in this thing Court The Law of God and Man 25 Edw. 3. Scot. I humbly conceive that reaches not to this Case Court To satisfie you in that the very words of the Statute are If any man do Compass or Imagine the Kings Death it is Treason The Indictment is That you did Imagine and Compass the death of the King if the Fact be proved against you you are within the Statute Scot. You will not say the King shall be a Traytor if he shall Compass the death of the Queen Court The Queen is a Subject Scot. I am not yet convinced Lo. Ch. Bar. Gentlemen of the Jury Scot. I do plead and claim that I am within the Compass of several Pardons and desire Councel in that particular I do come within the Compass of his Majesties Pardon Lo. Ch. Bar. If you had not gone on to matter of Justification you might have been more heard to this of Pardon but after a Justification then to come for a Pardon which implies a confession of Guilt they are contradictory I must tell you we are now upon point of Law That Proclamation I doubt not but his Majesty will inviolably make good but we are not to judge of that it is nothing to a legal proceeding You are now in a Court of Law it is not to be pleaded in a Court of Law the Kings Pardon in Law must be under his Broad Seal How far you are under that Proclamation care will be taken and what is fitting to be done will be done but it is nothing in the matter of the Charge to this Jury Scot. I desire Councel touching the Statute of 25 Edw. 3. Court You should have done it before you had confessed the Fact Scot. I may do it in Arrest of Judgement Lo. Ch. Bar. Mr. Scot for that of the Kings Proclamation if you be within the benefit and
that blessed be God the house is purged and the Lords will be shortly pull'd out and the twenty eighth day of January which was the day after the King was sentenced at Saint James's his Chappel you took for your Text the 149. Psalm the 6 7 8 and 9 verses whereof these words were part To bind their Kings in chains and their Nobles with fetters of iron there in the middle of that Sermon having spoken before of the King you said you did intend to preach before the poor wretch upon the 14 of Isaiah the 18 19 and 20 verses speaking of all the Kings of the nations Thou art cast out of thy grave like an abominable branch c. he saith further you said look upon your lesser Bibles and you will find the title is The Tyrants fall There is another witness that is one Bowdler a few days before the Kings death at S. Sepulchres there you fell upon the old comparison all along you compared the King to Barabbas and that a great many would have Christ crucified and Barabbas released all along comparing the King to Barabbas One more and that was Ryder he heard this text He shall call his name Emanuel you fell to speak of news what shall become of the King and you said the King was Barabbas and a great many would rather have Christ crucified than Barabbas And then Mr. Walker he saith that after the King was first brought to his tryal he heard you say this I have prayed and preached this twenty years and now may I say with old Simeon Lord now lettest thou thy servant depart in peace for mine eyes have seen thy salvation he mentions that you made use of the other comparison of the Major and the Bishops man and inferred from thence that the King and Prince c. were not excepted out of the Scripture where it is said Whosoever sheds mans blood c. you have heard all this witnessed against you what have you to say for your self Peters These are but single witnesses Lord Chief Baron The statute is two witnesses for Treason but not two to one individual thing though there are several witnesses have proved the same thing about Barabbas and our Saviour Bind their Kings with chains c. and of your other actions there is a whole Jury of witnesses two witnesses expresly we agreed upon the Kings death and we resolved to set the King aside Pet. I do not know the witnesses Lord Chief Baron One is Sir Jeremy Whitchcot the other is Doctor Young you shall do well if you have any thing to say to invalid these witnesses to speak to it else the Jury will be sent together to deliver up their verdict Peters My Lord if I had time and opportunity I could take off many of the witnesses but because their testimony is without control I cannot satisfie my self I have no skill in the Law else I might have spoke for my self I do not know what to say more unless I had more time and counsel Mr. Soll. Gen. If the prisoner can say no more here is this in it here are five places where he did consult about the Kings death at Windsor at Ware in Colemanstreet in the Painted Chamber and in Bradshaws house and four witnesses to prove this there are two witnesses to his comparison of the K. and Barabbas and two witnesses to his text of binding their K. inchains c. proof that he hath been in action in New-Eng that he came from it with that intent and then went to Holland that he had been in arms that he called the day of his Majesties tryal a glorious day resembling the judging of the world by Saints he prays for this in the Painted Chamber preaches for it at Whitehall S. James's Chapel Sepulchres what man could more contrive the death of the King than this miserable Priest hath done the honour of the Pulpit is to be vindicated and the death of this man will preach better than his life did it may be a means to convert many a miserable person whom the preaching of this person hath seduced for many come here and say they did it in the fear of the Lord and now you see who taught them and I hope you will make an example of this carnal prophet The Jury went together and after a little consultation settled in their places Cl. Are you agreed in your Verdict Jury Yes Cl. Who shall say for you Jury Our foreman Cl. How say you is the prisoner at the Bar guilty of the Treason whereof he stands indicted or not guilty Foreman Guilty Cl. And so you say all Jury Yes Cl. Look to him Keeper Coun. We desire Mr. Cook may be brought to the Bar and that they may both have their judgement pronounced Cl. John Cook hold up thy hand what hast thou to say why the Court should not pronounce judgement for thee to dye according to Law Cook I have a few words matter of Law First there is no averment in the Indictment that J. Cook mentioned in the Act of Indempnity is the same with the John Cook mentioned in the Indictment and that I am the John Cook mentioned in both L. Ch. Bar. This will not help you in this case you have owned and have pleaded by the name of John Cook Cook The second is this that the overt acts should be particularly expressed in the Indictment L. Ch. Bar. This cannot be alledged in arrest of judgement the Jury have found you guilty of compassing and imagining the death of the King by the statute of 25 Edw. 3. and this cannot help you Cook I say it was professionately L. Ch. B. That hath been overruled already we have delivered our opinions the profession of a Lawyer will not excuse them or any of them from Treason and this hath been overruled and is overruled again Cook I humbly conceive that the remaining part of the House of Commons were to be Judges whether there was a force or not L. Ch. B. This is all past and overruled Cook Then I have no more Cl. Hugh Peters Hold up thy hand what hast thou to say for thy self why Judgement should not pass against thee to die according to law Peters I will submit my self to God and if I have spoken any thing against the Gospel of Christ I am heartily sorry Silence Commanded L. Ch. Bar. You are both persons of that ingenuous and liberal education as I hope I shall not need to tell you what it is to die you have had a great a deal of time to think of it you could not but think of this issue of your doings long ago and therefore I shall spare my labour of telling you what it is to die and of that eternity that you are to enter into only give me leave in a few words in relation to both of your professions to say something to shew the nature and hainousness of this offence the murther of the King if you were not
the contrary I leave it upon the consciences of the Jury to weigh it carefully how I could be guilty of Compassing or Imagining the Death of the King when nothing is charged against me to be either of Counsel Sentencing or Signing or to be at the Execution only one man as I told you before he spoke something wrathly and that he had suffered much and therefore he is come over now and saith I should send for the Executioner which I never knew of or had any hand in sending for how much validity that hath I leave to the Jury if it were so it is not treason for words may make a Heretick not a Traytor I speak that by way of preface I do humbly conceive that these being only noted words Execution and Justice the King not so much as named nor any thing done to it by me I say I conceive it doth not amount to Treason by the Law and besides it is against the Law of the great Judg the Judg of Judges all of us that are now and are to come shall stand before him to receive our deserts I say it is against the Law of God to make me an Offender for a word for a word I have heard the Judges say that the Laws of England are grounded upon the Laws of God and the Laws of England are Laws of mercy not of rigour My Lord if a man shall be destroyed in his Life in his Posterity for a word admit the thing had been so I leave upon the consciences of my Jury before the presence of Jesus Christ and before whom they and I must come to be rejudged again at the Tribunal and besides it is only words and words uncertain and Sir Edward Cook saith he must declare plain truth in matter of Treason nothing must be taken for Evidence that may be a presumption or inference or strain of wit I hope upon this consideration that the word Justice fixed upon me by two Witnesses may be taken up at second or third hand from the People or Souldiers by chastising them for the Tumult Then my Lord in the next place these words were never put in writing and so not Treason then my Lord there was never an overt act done by me for that Act of Indemnity that his Majesty and both Houses of Parliament passed wherein they were pleased the very last to except me I wonder'd when I came to be excepted of that number I do come back to the place where I left and that is the overt act My Lord I would only bring it in in this place when I was excepted by the House of Commons one of the twenty I was excepted thus not extending to life I went up and down free at noon day I did not hide my self ingaging a person that was one of his Majesties Servants to do me a courtesie he promised me he would do it and contrary to his promise he was pleased to bring the Kings Warrant to carry me to the Tower and after that I came to be excepted with that black Catalogue of excepted persons and to be brought to the Tryal of the Law Now my Lord I return to that overt act as it was but words uncertain and they may be words repeated from the third or the fourth hand for they were not put in writing according to that Act of Indemnity which I understand the meaning of to be thus That for their Execrable Treasons in Sentencing Signing or otherwise Instrumental they are excepted out of this Act and to be Tryed according to the Laws of this Nation I understand that to be Instrumental to be Instrumentally the Executioner of the King I never had any hand in that Upon the whole this is the Fact that is proved by two Witnesses they heard me say Justice and Execution which must relate to the Execution of Justice which by the Law of God is not Treason especially when there was not the word King for a word to take away and destroy so many my Life Wife Children and many Fatherless that are under the Charge of the Prisoner at the Bar is very sad the words I do not grant but upon such probabilities as I have said I might repeat them I will Justice you I will Execution you and then the words were not written I say as Sir Edw. Cook said they may make a Heretick but not a Traytor the other part of the Evidence is this that I was there with Souldiers at Westminster-Hall I must say if that be Treason to be guided by Judgment of Lords and Commons in Parliament I must say if that be Treason to take up Arms for a Parliament upon such Grounds and Expositions of the statute which they have made and published by their own Authority if I am Guilty under the General then the Parliament would be guilty of Treason L. Ch. Bar. That you have spoke to I am loath to interrupt you Axt. I thank your Lordships for informing me but I was commanded to be there by my General if I had not gone I must have dyed I did only stand there for preservation of the peace in no other sense if the General order me to be at such a Rendezvous I must be there if I disobeyed he would have condemned me by the Law of War The next thing against me material are these two things that is that I should send one Elisha Axtell for the Executioner I must say it is most Admirable such things should be laid to my charge I hope your Lordships and the Jury do observe he told you he suffered much and a poor man under his extremities and losses and sufferings perhaps might start some unadvised words and being now sent over may ascertain it But doubtless this Elisha Axtell being in Ireland if by command it had been so would have been sent over truly I must say I had no hand in the business it was left wholly to them amongst themselves and what ever was done or whatever was said it was said and done by them I never was acquainted with any thing of that nature he said he heard I should send Elisha Axtell for an Executioner if hearsays may be Treason it will be a hard Lesson and my Lord Sir Edw. Cooke saith there must be two witnesses here is but one It comes from such a man my Lord as the providence of God but I will say no more as to that but pray the Jury will take notice of it L. Ch. Bar. You need not doubt of it it shall be taken notice of this of Burden Axt. Now my Lord I have but two or three words more the Statute of the 25th of Edward the Third it doth intend private persons my Lord here is my Commission L. Ch. Bar. It is owned you had it from your General Axt. My Lord his Majesty is pleased to say in his Gracious Letter We do by these presents declare That we do grant a free and General Pardon to all our Subjects of
Countrey-man I was glad to hear of your great penitence for that horrid crime and I would have been glad to have seen it now advise with your self whether you do your self any good in speaking to extenuate when you know there is no man against whom there are such circumstances of aggravation as against you consider whether a publick penitence would not be more proper Waller I beseech you report me both to his Majesty and Parliament and receive me into your grace as being penitent truly penitent To say so now were a small thing for the fear of the punishment may procure it but I have been more penitent when no eye hath seen me but God when I never imagined to be questioned for this sin then my heart hath yerned in the business but I shal not trouble your Lordships God holds forth Mercy his Majesty holds forth Mercy the Parliament holds forth Mercy My Lords let me say something to you though it be but a word of the violence and force of temptation you may have been under it or may come to it Christ himself was under it we find that faithful Abraham by the power of a Temptation delivered up his wife to commit Adultery which scarce a Heathen would we finde that valiant Peter denied his Master righteous Lot committed incest None abhors this fact more then I do I have done it so long beforehand I need not be afraid to speak it in the face of the Judge of all men that is all I shall say I rendred my self three times I had as much opportunity to make my escape as any person whatsoever Lord Chief Baron It is understood Sir Hardress Clerk Isaac Pennington hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition as the former what canst thou say for thy self why judgment c. Pennington My Lord I have said what I have to say and shall not trouble your Lordships any further Clerk Henry Marten hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Marten I claim the benefit of the Proclamation Clerk Gilbert Millington hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Millington I shall not trouble you with long discourses I will say no more but this I have made a publick resentment of my sorrow for this offence formerly and many times I shall now desire no more but humbly beg that I may have the benefit of the Proclamation and pray his Majesties most gracious Pardon Clerk Robert Tichborne hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c Tichborne My Lord I will not trouble you with any repititions I have made my humble request before I leave it with you Clerk Owen Roe hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Roe My Lord I have no more to say then I said before Clerk Robert Lilburn hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Lilburn I shall refer my self without further trouble to the Court my Lord I beg the benefit of the Proclamation Clerk Thomas Waite hold up thy hand Thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Waite I can declare no more than what already my heart is sorry for what I have done I beg the benefit of the Proclamation Clerk Edmond Harvey hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Harvey My Lords I have no more then what I have said before Clerk John Downes Hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Downes I shall not trouble you any further I shall desire the benefit of his Majesties Proclamation Clerk Vincent Potter hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Potter My Lord I do not know Law I understand it not I am not in a condition to speak what I would have willingly spoke I desire that God would have mercy and I look for mercy from God and wept Clerk Augustine Garland Hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Garland I humbly desire your Lordships charitable opinion of me notwithstanding what has been objected against me I humbly refer my self to the Parliament Clerk George Fleetwood hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Fleetwood My Lord I have already confessed the fact I wish I could express my sorrow and wept Clerk James Temple hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. I. Temple My Lord I can say no more I beg the benefit of the Proclamation Clerk Simon Mayn hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Mayne I have told you before my Lord I have no more Clerk Peter Temple hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Peter Temple My Lord I came in upon the Proclamation and I humbly beg the benefit of it Cl. Tho. Waite hold up thy hand thou art in 〈◊〉 same condition what canst thou say for thy self Waite My Lord I refer it to your Lordships Clerk Francis Hacker hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Hacker My Lord. I have nothing to say but what has been before your Lordships Clerk Daniel Axtel hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Axtell May it please your Lordships my case differs from the rest of the Gentlemen L. Ch. B. I would be loth to hinder you but I must tell you that what hath been over-ruled must not be spoke to if you have any thing against the Indictment matter of Law go on Axtell I have one thing more that I did not then mention L. Ch. B. If it tend not as an exception to the Indictment it is not to be heard Axtell My Lord then I shall apply my self to that point I humbly conceive my Lord that my overt acts were not sufficiently set down in the Indictment as might be sufficient in Law to attaint me of high Treason I do not remember that the Overt act that was applyed to me in evidence was charged in the Indictment I have onely that exception because of the insufficiency of that point In the next place my Lord there is not the right additions to my name there are many persons of the same name I am arraigned by
the name of Daniel Axtel of Westminster in the County of Middlesex Gentleman I think none knew me to live there and inhabit there Lord Chief Baron I would not interrupt you this is past you should have made your exception to that as Master Matten did before concerning his name that should have been first done you have appeared and pleaded to that name and it was late of Westminster Axtell My Lord I have this to speak in arrest of Judgment that the Indictment being grounded upon that statute of the twenty fifth of Edward the third it is either mistaken or not pursued my Lords I did yesterday give you the Judgment of the Lords and Commons concerning the statute in relation to my case I say the Statute was mistaken or not pursued Lord chief Baron That was offered before Sir as to the matter of it Axtell My Lord I think not I am mistaken if it were Lord Chief Baron Then open it Axtell My Lord I do not find in that statute that words are an overt act words only L. Ch. B. This was over-ruled The things that you objected were these That there is not any overt act that is laid that could be applicable to your case if it were not particularly applicable you are found guilty by the Jury it would be nothing But there is an overt act you were present at the Court beating the Souldiers sending for an Executioner but for words if one man should say here is the King go and kill him this is Treason but you were guilty in all according to Law You being there and doing this you were not guilty onely of the words but of all that was done there is none but Principals in Treason What we say and do to you we well know we must answer before God Almighty for it Axtell I have but one word more truly I do appeal to God before whom I shall have another tryall I do not find my self guilty either of consulting contriving or having a hand in the death of the King I am innocent and I pray God that my innocent blood Lord Chief Baron Pray Sir Axtell May not cry Lord Chief Baron You are now to speak in arrest of Judgment Axtell I have no more I pray your Lordships favour and mercy to me William Hulet alias Howlet hold up thy hand thou art in the same condition what canst thou say for thy self why Judgment c. Hulet Truly my Lord I have little further to say If you had been pleased to give me further time I should have cleared my self I call God above to witness upon this account that I am as clear as any man I submit to the mercy of the Court. L. Ch. B. For that I do but cannot positively say it that at your request notwithstanding the Judgment will pass against you there may be some time till his Majesties pleasure be known before any execution will be upon that Judgment against you in the mean time we must proceed according to Law and Justice Proclamation for silence whilst Judgment is giving The Lord Chief Barons speech before the Sentence pronounced against the aforenamed Prisoners found guilty YOu that are Prisoners at the Bar you stand here in several Capacities yet all of you persons convicted of the detestable and execrable murder of our Soveraign Lord King Charles the first of blessed memory Mistake me not I do not say that you are all of you guilty of executing the fact but in Law and in conscience pro tanto though not pro toto you are guilty of it in that you prepared the way and means to it in that you brought his head to the block though you did not cut it off You are here in three sorts and I must apply my words accordingly and truely I do it with as much sorrow of heart as you have many of you being persons of liberal education great parts I say you are of three sorts There are some of you that though the Judgment of death is to pass against you by his Majesties grace and favour and the mercy under him of the two houses of Parliament Execution is to be suspended untill another Act of Parliament shall pass to that purpose that is all of you but three for those three the one of them that was last called William Heveningham he is in another capacity too for I presume some time will be given to him to consider of something relating to him before any order will be given for his execution there are two others of you and that is Dan. Axtel and Francis Hacker and for you as it yet stands before us there is no mercy there is no room for it but though you be in these several Classes yet what I shall say will concern you all because I do not know how it may fall with you none of us know how soon we may come to our deaths some probably sooner then others all must come to it you are now before the Tribunal of man but that is for Judgment for your offence here but there is another Judgment hereafter and a Tribunal before which both you and we must stand every man here and we must receive according to our work those that have done ignorantly by a serious and unfeigned repentance God Almighty may shew mercy unto them He hath reserved mercy even for the greatest offenders Saint Paul himself when he presecuted Christ ignorantly upon his repentance he found mercy those of you that are not yet convicted in your consciences of the foulness of this horrid fact look into your Consciences a little more and see if it be not a great Judgment for your former offence that you should be given over to a reprobate sense let me tell you a seared Conscience a bold confidence not upon good grounds is so far from securing the Conscience it may stifle perhaps the mouth of Conscience but it will rise up more in Judgment against you Here you have made your defence and I do not blame you for it life is precious but remember the thoughts of your hearts are open whether you did it ignorantly covetously or to get the Government into your own hands that I am not able to search into God and you only know that give me leave to say something perhaps I have repeated it by parts before God is my witness what I speak I speak from mine own Conscience and that is this Gentlemen because I saw it stuck with some of you that is that whatsoever the case was that by the Laws of these Nations the fundamental Laws there could not be any coercive power over your King I speak it again because I would as near as I could speak the whole truth and would not mislead any man in such a case remember that no power no person no Community or body of men not the people either collectively or representatively have any coercive power over the person of the King by the fundamental Laws for that