inducement to the Answerers mind to lay down such a Position or Thesis as this is It is not lawfull to persecute the Lord Iesus Search all Scriptures Histories Records Monuments consult with all experiences did ever Pharaoh Saul Ahab Iezabel Scribes and Pharises the Jewes Herod the bloudy Neroes Gardiners Boners Pope or Devill himselfe professe to persecute the Son of God Jesus as Jesus Christ as Christ without a mask or covering No saith Pharaoh the Isrealites are idle and therefore speake they of sacrificing David is risen up in a conspiracy against Saul therefore persecute him Naboth hath blasphemed God and the King therefore stone him Christ is a seducer of the people a blasphemer against God and traytor against Caesar therefore hang him Christians are schismaticall factious hereticall therefore persecute them The Devill hath deluded Iohn Hus therefore crowne him with a paper of Devils and burne him c. Peace One thing I see apparantly in the Lords over-ruling the pen of this worthy Answerer viz. a secret whispering from heaven to him that although his soules ayme at Christ and hath wrought much for Christ in many sincere intentions and Gods mercifull and patient acceptance yet he hath never left the Tents of such who think they doe God good service in killing the Lord Jesus in his servants and yet they say if we had beene in the dayes of our Fathers in Queene Maries dayes c. we would never have consented to such persecution And therefore when they persecute Christ Jesus in his truths or servants they say Doe not say you are persecuted for the Word for Christ his sake for we hold it not lawfull to persecute Iesus Christ. Let me also adde a second So farre as he hath beene a Guide by preaching for persecution I say wherein he hath beene a Guide and Leader by mis-interpreting and applying the Writings of Truth so far I say his owne mouthes and hands shall judge I hope not his persons but his actions for the Lord Jesus hath suffered by him Act. 9. 3. and if the Lord Jesus himselfe were present himselfe should suffer that in his owne person which his servants witnessing his Truth doe suffer for his sake CHAP. XII Peace THeir second Conclusion is this It is not lawfull to persecute erroneous and blinde conscience even in fundamentall and weighty points till after admonition once or twice Tit. 3. 11. and then such consciences may be persecuted because the Word of God is so cleare in fundamentall and weighty points that such a person cannot but sin against his conscience and so being condemned of himselfe that is of his conscience hee may be persecuted for sinning against his owne conscience Truth I answer in that great battell betweene the Lord Jesus and the Devill it is observable that Sathan takes up the weapons of Scripture and such Scripture which in shew and colour was excellent for his purpose but in this 3. of Titus as Salomon speakes of the Birds of heaven Prov. 1. a man may evidently see the snare and I know the time is comming wherein it shall bee said Surely in vaine the Net is laid in the sight of the Saints heavenly Birds So palpably grosse and thicke is the mist and fog which Sathan hath raised about this Scripture that he that can but see men as trees in matters of Gods worship may easily discerne what a wonderfull deepe sleepe Gods people are fallen into concerning the visible Kingdome of Christ in so much that this third of Titus which through fearfull prophanations hath so many hundred years been the pretended Bulwark and defence of all the bloudy Wolves dens of Lions and mountains of Leopards hunting and devouring the Witnesses of Jesus should now be the refuge and defence of as I hope the Lambes and little ones of Jesus yet in this point so preaching and practising so unlike to themselves to the Lord Jesus and lamentably too like to His and their Persecutors CHAP. XIII Peace BRight Truth since this place of Titus is such a pretended Bulwark for persecuting of Hereticks under that pretence of persecuting all thy followers I beseech you by the bright beames of the Sun of Righteousnesse scatter these mists and unfold these particulars out of the Text First What this Man is that is an Hereticke Secondly How this Hereticke is condemned of himselfe Thirdly What is this first and second Admonition and by whom it is supposed to be given Fourthly What is this rejecting of Him and by whom it is supposed this Rejection was to be made Truth First What is this Heretick I find him commonly defined to be such an one as is obstinate in Fundamentalls and so also I conceive the Answerer seems to recent him saying That the Apostle renders this reason why after once and twice Admonition he ought to be persecuted because in fundamentall and principall points of Doctrine and Worship the Word of God is so cleare that the Hereticke cannot but be convinced in his owne Conscience But of this reason I finde not one tittle mentioned in this Scripture for although he saith such an one is condemned of himselfe yet he saith not nor will it follow that fundamentalls are so cleare that after first and second Admonition a person that submits not to them is condemned of himself any more then in lesser points This 11 verse hath reference to the former verses Titus an Evangelist a Preacher of glad Newes abiding here with the Church of Christ at Creet is required by Paul to avoid to reject and to teach the Church to reject Genealogies disputes and unprofitable questions about the Law Such a like charge it is as he gave to Timothy left also an Evangelist at Ephesus 1 Tim. 1. 4. If it should be objected what is to be done to such contentious vain strivers about Genealogies and questions unprofitable The Apostle seems plainly to answer Let him be once and twice admonished Ob. Yea but what if once and twice admonition prevaile not The Apostle seems to answer 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and that is the man that is wilfully obstinate after such once and twice admonition Reject him With this Scripture agrees that of 1 Tim. 6. 4 5. where Timothy is commanded to withdraw himselfe from such who dote about questions and strife of words All which are points of a lower and inferiour nature not properly falling within the tearms or notions of those 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 first principles and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 foundations of the Christian Profession to wit Repentance from dead workes Faith towards God the doctrine of Baptismes and of laying on of hands the Resurrection and eternall Judgement Heb. 6. 2. c. Concerning these Fundamentalls although nothing is so little in the Christian Worship but may be referred to one of these six yet doth not Paul to Timothy or Titus speake in those places by me alledged o◠of any of these as may evidently appeare by the context
viz. That tares must needs signifie hypocrites or doctrines or practices who are like Gods children Truth c. I answer first The Parable holds forth no such thing that the likenesse of the tares should deceive the servants to cause them to suppose for a time that they were good wheat but that as soone as ever the tares appeared ver 26. the servants came to the housholder about them ver 27. the Scripture holds forth no such time wherein they doubted or suspected what they were Peace It may be said they did not appeare to be tares untill the coâ—ne was in the blade and put forth its fruit Truth I answer The one appeared as soone as the other for so the word clearly carries it that the seed of both having been sowne when the wheat appeared and put forth its blade and fruit the tares also were as early and put forth themselves as appeared also Secondly there is such a dissimilitude or unlikenesse I say such a dissimilitude that as soone as tares and wheat are sprung up to blade and fruit every husbandman can tell which is wheat and which are tares and cockle c. Peace It may be said true So when the hypocrite is manifested then all may know him c. but before hypocrites be manifested by fruits they are unknowne I answer search into the Parable and aske when was it that the servants first complained of the tares to the housholder but when they appeared or came in sight there being no interim wherein the servants could not tell what to make of them but doubted whether they were wheat or tares as the Answerer implies Secondly when was it that the housholder gave charge to let them alone but after that they appeared and were known to be tares which should imply by this interpretation of the Answerer that when men are discovered and knowne to be Hypocrites yet stilâ—â—uch a generation of Hypocrites in the Church must be let alone and tolerated untill the harvest or end of the world which is contrary to all order piety and safety in the Church of the Lord Iesus as doubtlesse the Answerers will grant so that those Tares being notoriously knowne to be different from the Corne I conclude that they cannot here be intended by the Lord Iesus to signifie secret Hypocrites but more open and apparent Sinners CHAP. XXI THe second reason why these tares cannot signifie hypocrites in the Church I take from the Lord Iesus His own Interpretation of the field in which both wheat and tares are sowne which saith he is the World out of which God chooseth and calleth His Church The World lyes in wickednesse is like a Wildernesse or a Sea of wilde Beasts innumerable fornicators covetous Idolaters c. with whom Gods people may lawfully converse and cohabit in Cities Townes c. else must they not live in the World but goe out of it In which world as soone as ever the Lord Iesus had sowne the good seed the children of the Kingdome true Christianity or the true Church the Enemy Sathan presently in the night of security Ignorance and Errour whilest men slept sowed also these tares which are Antichristians or false Christians These strange Professours of the Name of Iesus the Ministers and Prophets of God beholding they are ready to runne to Heaven to fetch fiery judgements from thence to consume these strange Christians and to pluck them by the roots out of the world But the Son of Man the meek Lamb of God for the Elect sake which must be gathered out of Iew and Gentile Pagan Antichristian commands a permission of them in the World untill the time of the end of the World when the Goats and Sheep the Tares and Wheat shall be eternally separated each from other Peace You know some excellent Worthies dead and living have laboured to turne this Field of the World into the Garden of the Church Truth But who can imagine that the Wisdome of the Father the Lord Iesus Christ would so open this Parable as He professedly doth as that it should be close shut up and that one difficulty or locke should be opened by a greater and harder in calling the World the Church contrary also to the way of the Light and Love that is in Jesus when he would purposely teach and instruct His scholars contrary to the nature of Parables and similitudes And lastly to the nature of the Church or Garden of Christ. CHAP. XXII IN the former Parable the Lord Iesus compared the Kingdome of Heaven to the sowing of Seed The true Messengers of Christ are the Sowers who cast the Seed of the Word of the Kingdome upon foure sorts of ground which foure sorts of ground or hearts of men cannot be supposed to be of the Church nor will it ever be proved that the Church consisteth of any more sorts or natures of ground properly but one to wit the honest and good ground and the proper worke of the Church concernes the flourishing and prosperity of this sort of ground and not the other unconvertedâ—â—ree â—â—ree sorts who it may be seldome or never come 〈◊〉 the Church unlesse they be forced by the Civill sword which the paternâ— or first sowers never used and being forced they are put into a way of Religion by such a course if not so they are forced to live withoutâ— Religion for one of the two must necessarily follow as I shall prove afterward In the field of the World then are all those sorts of ground high way hearers stony and thorny ground hearers as well as the honest and good ground and I suppose it will not now be said by the Answerer that those three sorts of bad grounds were hypocrites or tares in the Church Now after the Lord Iesus had propounded that great leading Parable of the Sower and the Seed He is pleased to propound this Parable of the Tares with admirable coherence and sweet consolation to the honest and good ground who with glad and honest hearts having received the word of the Kingdome may yet seem to be discouraged and troubled with so many Antichristians and false Professours of the Name of Christ. The Lord Iesus therefore gives direction concerning these tares that unto the end of the World successively in all the sorts and generations of them they must be not approved or countenanced but let alone or permitted in the World Secondly he gives to His owne good seed this consolation that those heavenly Reapers the Angells in the harvest or end of the World will take an order and course with them to wit they shall binde them into bundles and cast them into the everlasting burnings and to make the cup of their consolation run over He addes vers 4. Then then at that time shall the Righteous shine as the Sun in the Kingdome of their Father These tares then neither being erronious doctrines nor corrupt practises nor hypocrites
in His Church His spirituall judicature and executes this sentence in part at present and hereafter to all eternity Such a sentence no Civill Iudge can passe such a Death no Civill sword can inâ—lict I answer secondly Dead men cannot be infected the civill state the world being in a naturall state dead in sin what ever be the State-Religion unto which persons are forced it is impossible it should be infected Indeed the living the beleeving the Church and spirituall state that and that onely is capable of infection for whose helpe we shall presently see what preservatives and remedies the Lord Iesus hath appointed Moreover as we see in a common plague or infection the names are taken how many are to dye and not one more shall be strucke then the destroying Angel hath the names of So here what ever be the soule infection breathed out from they lying lips of a plague-sicke Pharisee yet the names are taken not one elect or chosen of God shall perish Gods sheep are safe in His eternall hand and counsell and he that knowes his materiall knows also his mysticall stars their numbers and calls them every one by name none fall into the Ditch on the blinde Pharises backe but such as were ordained to that condemnation both guid and followers 1 Pet. 2. 8. Iude 4. The vessells of wrath shall breake and split and only they to the praise of Gods eternall justice Rom. 9. CHAP. XXXIV Peace BUt it is said be it granted that in a common plague or infection none are smitten and dye but such as are appointed yet it is not only every mans duty but the common duty of the Magistrate to prevent infection and to preserve the common health of the place likewise though the number of the Elect be sure and God knowes who are His yet hath He appointed meanes for their preservation from perdition and from infection and therefore the Angel is blamed for suffering Balaams doctrine and Iesabel to seduce Christ Jesus His servants Rev. 2. Tit. 3. 10. Rom. 16. 17. Truth I answer Let that Scripture and that of Titus reject an Hereticke and Rom. 16. 17. avoid them that are contentious c. let them and all of like nature be examined and it will appeare that the great and good Physitian Christ Iesus the Head of the Body and King of the Church hath not been unfaithfull in providing spirituall antidotes and preservatives against the spirituall sicknesses sores weaknosses dangers of his Church and people but he never appointed the civill sword for either antidote or remedy as an addition to those spiritualls which he hath left with his wife his Church or People Hence how great is the bondage the captivity of Gods owne People to Babylonish or confused mixtures in Worship and unto worldly and earthly policies to uphold State Religions or Worships since that which is written to the Angel and Church at Pergamus shall be interpreted as sent to the Governour and City of Pergamus and that which is sent to Titus and the Church of Christ at Creet must be delivered to the civill officers and City thereof But as the Civill Magistrate hath his charge of the bodies and goods of the subject So have the spirituall Officers Governours and overseers of Christs City or Kingdome the charge of their souls and soule safety Hence that charge of Paul to Tim. 1 Tim. 5. 20. Them that sinne rebuke before all that others may learne to fear This is in the Church of Christ a spirituall meanes for the healing of a soule that hath sinned or taken infection and for the preventing of the infecting of others that others may learne to feare c. CHAP. XXXV Peace IT is said true that Titus and Timothy and so the Officers of the Church of Christ are bound to prevent soule infection But what hinders that the Magistrate should not be charged also with this duty Truth I answer many things I have answered and more shall at present I shall only say this If it be the Magistrate duty or office then is he both a Temporall and Ecclesiasticall officer contrary to which most men will affirme and yet we know the policie of our owne Land and Country hath established to the Kings and Queens thereof the supreme heads or governours of the Church of England That doctrine and distinction that a Magistrate may punish an Heretick civilly will not here availe for what is Babel if this be not confusedly to punish corporall or civill offences with spirituall or Church censures the offendour not being a member of it or to punish soule or spirituall offences with corporall or temporall weapons proper to Delinquents against the temporall or civill state Lastly woe were it with the civill Magistrate and most intolerable burthens do they lay upon their backs that teach this doctrine if together with the common care and charge of the Commonwealth the peace and safety of the Towne City State or Kingdome the bloud of every soule that perisheth should cry against him unlesse he could say with Paul Acts 20. in spirituall regards I am clear from the blould of all men that is the bloud of soules which was his charge to looke after so far as his preaching went not the bloud of bodies which belongeth to the civill Magistrate I acknowledge he ought to cherish as a foster-father the Lord Iesus in his truth in his Saints to cleave unto them himselfe and to countenance them even to the death yea also to breake the teeth of the Lions who offer Civill violence and injury unto them But to see all his Subjects Christians to keepe such Church or Christians in the purity of worship and see them doe their duty this belongs to the Head of the Body Christ Iesus and such spirituall Officers as he hath to this purpose deputed whose right it is according to the true paterne Abimelech Saul Adonijah Athalia were but usurpers David Salomon Ioash c. they were the true heires and types of Christ Iesus in His true Power and Authority in His Kingdome CHAP. XXXVI Peace THe next Scripture brought against such persecution is Luke 9. 54 55. where the Lord Jesus reproved His Disciples who would have had fire come downe from Heaven and devoure those Samaritanesâ— that would not receive Him in these words You know not of what spirit you are the Son of Man is not come to destroy mens lives but to save them With this Scripture Mr. Cotton joynes the fourth and answers both in one which is this 2 Tim. 2. 24. The servant of the Lord must not strive but must be gentle toward all men suffering the evill men instructing them with meeknesse that are contrary minded and oppose themselves proving if God peradventure will give them repentance that they may acknowledge the truth and that they may recover themselves out of the snare of the Divell who are taken captive by him at his will
Unto both these Scriptures it pleaseth him thus to answer Both these are directions to Ministers of the Gospel how to deale not with obstinate offendors in the Church who sin against conscience but either with men without as the Samaritanes were and many unconverted Christians in Creet whom Titus as an Evangelist was to seek to convert Ot at best with some Iewes or Gentiles in the Church who though carnall yet were not convinced of the errour of their way And it is true it became not the Spirit of the Gospel to convert Aliens to the Faith such as the Samaritanes were by fire and brimstone nor to deale harshly in publicke Ministery or private conference with all such severall minded men as either had not yet entred into Church fellowship or if they had did hitherto sin of ignorance not against Conscience But neither of both these Texts doe hinder the Minister of the Gospel to proceed in a Church way against Church members when they become scandalous offenders either in life oâ— doctrine much lesse doe they speake at all to the Civill Magistrate CHAP. XXXVII Truth THis perplexed and ravelled Answer wherein so many things and so doubtfull are wrapt up and intangled together I shall take in pieces First concerning that of the Lord Iesus rebuking his Disciples for their rash and ignorant bloudy zeale Luc. 9. desiring corporall destruction upon the Samaritanes for refusing the Lord Iesus c. the Answerer affirmeth that hindreth not the Ministers of the Gospell to proceed in a Church way against scandalous offenders which is not here questioned but maintained to bee the holy will of the Lord and a sufficient censure and punishment if no civill offence against the Civill State be committed Secondly saith hee Much lesse doth this speake at all to the Civill Magistrate Where I observe that he implyes that beside the censure of the Lord Iesus in the hands of his spirituall governours for any spirituall evill in life or doctrine the Civill Magistrate is also to inflict corporall punishment upon the contrary minded whereas First if the Civill Magistrate be a Christian a Disciple or follower of the meeke Lambe of God he is bound to be far from destroying the bodies of men for refusing to receive the Lord Iesus Christ for otherwise hee should not know according to this speech of the Lord Iesus what spirit he was of yea and to be ignorant of the sweet end of the comming of the Son of Man which was not to destroy the bodies of Men but to save both bodies and soules vers 55. 56. Secondly if the Civill Magistrate being a Christian gifted prophesie in the Church 1 Corinth 1. 14. although the Lord Iesus Christ whom they in their owne persons hold forth shall be refused yet they are here forbidden to call for fire from heaven that is to procure or inflict any corporall judgement upon such offenders remembring the end of the Lord Iesus his comming not to destroy mens lives but to save them Lastly this also concernes the conscience of the Civill Magistrate as he is bound to preserve the civill peace and quiet of the place and people under him he is bound to suffer no man to breake the Civill Peace by laying hands of violence upon any though as vile as the Samaritanes for not receiving of the Lord Iesus Christ. It is indeed the ignorance and blinde zeale of the second Beast the false Prophet Rev. 13. 13. to perswade the civill Powers of the earth to persecute the Saints that is to bring fiery judgements upon men in a judiciall way and to pronounce that such judgements of imprisonment banishment death proceed from Gods righteous vengeance upon such Hereticks So dealt divers Bishops in France and England too in Queene Maries dayes with the Saints of God at their putting to death declaiming against them in their Sermons to the people and proclaiming that these persecutions even unto death were Gods just judgements from heaven upon these Heretickes CHAP. XXXVIII Peace DOubtlesse such fiery spirits as the Lord Jesus said are not of God I pray speake to the second place out of Timothy 2. Epist. 25. 26. Truth I acknowledge this instruction to be meeke and patient c. is properly an instruction to the Ministers of the Gospel Yet divers Arguments from hence will truly and fairly be collected to manifest and evince how farre the civill Magistrate ought to bee from dealing with the civill sword in spirituall cases And first by the wayâ— I desire to aske What were these unconverted Christians in Crete which the Answerer compareth with the Samaritanes whom Titus saith he as an Evangelist was to seek to convert and whether the Lord Iesus have any such Disciples and Followers who yet are visibly in an unconverted estate O that it may please the Father of mercies the Father of lights to awaken and open the eyes of all that feare before him that they may see whether this be the Language of Canaan or the Language of Ashdod What is an unconverted Christian but in truth an unconverted Convert that is in English one unturned turned unholy holy Disciples or Followers of Iesus not following of him In a word that is Christians or anointed by Christ Antichristians not anointed with the Spirit of Iesus Christ. Certaine it is such they were not unto whom the Spirit of God gives that name Act. 11. And indeed whither can this tend but to uphold the blasphemy of so many as say they are Iewes that is Christians but are not Rev. 2. But as they are not Christians from Christ but from the Beast and his Picture so their proper name from Antichrist is Antichristians How sad yet and how true an evidence is this that the soule of the Answerer I speake not of his inward soule and person but of his worship hath never yet heard the call of the Lord Iesus to come out from those unconverted Churches from that unconverted Antichristian Christian world and so from Antichrist Belial to seeke fellowship with Christ Iesus and his converted Christians Disciples after the first patterne Againe I observe the haste and light attention of the Answerer to these Scriptures as commonly the spirits of Gods children in matters of Christs Kingdome are very sleepy for these persons here spoken of were not as he speakes unconverted Christians in Crete whom Titus as an Evangelist was to convert but they were such opposites as Timothy to whom Paul writes this Letter at Ephesus should meet withall CHAP. XXXIX Peace BUt what is there in this Scripture of Timothy alledged concerning the civill Magistracy Truth I argue from this place of Timothy in particular thus First if the civill Magistrates hee Christians or members of the Church able to prophesie in the Church of Christ then I say as before they are bound by this command of Christ to suffer opposition to their doctrine with meeknesse and gentlenesse and to
Pergamus and Thiatira and the Angel or Officers of those Cities to suppresse not only such practices but such Doctrines also as the Roman Emperour justly punished Ovid the Poet for teaching the wanton Art of Love leading to and ushering on laciviousnesse and uncleannesse 4. Yet so far as Balaams teachers or Iesabel did seduce the members of the Church in Pergamus or Thiatira to the worship of the Idolaters in Pergamus or Thiatira which will appeare to be the case I say so far I may well and properly answer as himselfe answered before those Scriptures brought from Luc. 9. 2 Tim. 2. to prove patience and permission to men opposite viz. These Scriptures saith he are directions to Ministers of the Gospel and in the end of that passage he addes Much lesse doe they speake at all to Civill Magistrates Fifthly Either these Churches and the Angels thereof had power to suppresse these doctrines of Balaam and to suppresse Iesabel from teaching or they had not That they had not cannot be affirmed for Christs Authority is in the hands of his Ministers and Churches Matth. 16. 18. 1 Cor. 5. If they had power as must be granted then I conclude sufficient power to suppresse such persons who ever they were that maintained Balaams doctrine in the Church at Pergamus although the very Magistrates themselves of the City of Pergamus if Christians and to have suppressed Iesabel from teaching and seducing in the Church had she been Lady Queen or Empresse if there were no more but teaching without hostility And if so all power and authority of Magistrates and Governours of Pergamus and Thiatira and all submitting or appealing to them in such cases must needs fall as none of Christs appointment Lastly From this perverse wresting of what is writ to the Church and the Officers thereof as if it were written to the Civill State and Officers thereof all may see how since the Apostacie of Antichrist the Christian World so called hath swallowed up Christianity how the Church and civill State that is the Church and the World are now become one flocke of Iesus Christ Christs sheepe and the Pastors or Shepherds of them all one with the severall unconverted wilde or tame Beasts and Cattell of the World and the civill and earthly governours of them The Christian Church or Kingdome of the Saints that stone cut out of the mountaine without hands Daniel 2. now made all one with the mountaine or Civill State the Roman Empire from whence it is cut or taken Christs lilies garden and love all one with the thornes the daughers and wildernesse of the World out of which the Spouse or Church of Christ is called and amongst whom in civill things for a while here below she must necessarily be mingled and have converse unlesse she will goe out of the World before Christ Iesus her Lord and Husband send for her home into the Heavens 1 Cor. 5. 10. CHAP. LVIII Peace HAving thus by the help of Christ examined those Scriptures or writings of truth brought by the Author against Persecution and cleared them from such vailes mists wherewith Mr. Cotton hath endeavored to obscure darken their light I pray you now by the the same gracious assistance proceed to his answer to the second head of Reasons from the profession of famous Princes against persecution for conscience K. Iames Steven of Poland K. of Bohemia unto whom the Answerer returneth a treble answer First saith he We willingly acknowledge that none is to be persecuted at all no more then they may be oppressed for righteousnesse sake Againe we acknowledge that none is to be punished for his conscience though misinformed as hath been said unlesse his Error be fundamentall or seditiously and turbulently promoted and that after due conviction of his conscience that it may appeare he is not punished for his conscience but for sinning against his conscience Furthermore we acknowledge none is to be constrained to beleeve or professe the true Religion till he be convinced in judgement of the truth of it but yet restrained he may be from blaspheming the truth and from seducing any unto pernicious error Truth This first answer consists of a repetition and enumeration of such grounds or conclusions as Mr. Cotton in the entrance of this Discourse laid downe and I beleeve that through the helpe of God in such replies as I have made unto them I have made it evident what weak foundations they have in the Scriptures of truth as also that when such conclusions excepting the first as grasse and the flower of the grasse shall sade that holy Word of the Lord which the Author against such persecution produced and I have cleared shall stand for ever even when these Heavens and Earth are burnt Peace His second answer is this What Princes professe and practice is not a rule of conscience They many times tolerate that in point of State-policie which cannot justly be tolerated in point of true Christianity Againe Princes many times tolerate offendours out of very necessity when the offenders are either too many or too mighty for them to punish in which respect David tolerated Ioab and his murders but against his will CHAP. LIX VNnto those excellent and famous speeches of those Princes worthy to be written in golden letters or rows of Diamonds upon all the gates of all the Cities and Palaces in the World the Answerer without any particular reply returnes two things Truth First that Princes profession and practice is no rule of conscience unto this as all men will subscribe so may they also observe how the Answerer deales with Princes One while they are the nursing Fathers of the Church not only to feed but also to correct and therefore consequently bound to iudge what is true feeding and correcting and consequently all men are bound to submit to their feeding and correcting Another while when Princes crosse Mr. Cottons judgement and practice then it matters not what the profession and practice of Princes is for saith he their profession and practice is no Rule to Conscience I aske then unto what Magistrates or Princes will themselves or any so perswaded submit as unto keepers of both Tables as unto the Antitypes of the Kings of Israel and Iudah and nursing Fathers and Mothers of the Church First will it not evidently follow that by these Tenents they ought not to submit to any Magistrates in the world in these cases but to Magistrates just of their owne conscience and Secondly that all other Consciences in the world except their owne must be persecuted by such their Magistrates And lastly is not this to make Magistrates but steps and stirrops to ascend and mount up into their rich and honourable Seats and Sadâ—les I meane great and setled maintenances which neither the Lord Iesus nor any of his first Messengers the true patternes did ever know CHAP. LX. Truth IN the second place hee saith that Princes out
Wrath after he had persecuted David the figure of Christ Iesus who hath given his people the Scepter and Sword of his Word and Spirit and refused a temporall Crowne or Weapons in the dispensation of his Kingdome Where did the Lord Jesus or his Messengers charge the Civill Magistrate or direct Christians to petition him to publish declare or establish by his Arme of Flesh and Earthly weapons the Religion and worship of Christ Jesus I finde the Beast and false Prophet whose rise and doctrine is not from Heaven but from the Sea and Earth dreadfull and terrible by a Civill Sword and dignitie Rev 13. 2. I find the Beast hath gotten the power and might of the Kings of the Earth Revel 17. 13. But the Lambes weapons are Spiritually mighty 2 Cor. 10. c. his Sword is two-edged comming out of his mouth Revel 1. His preparations for War are white Horses and white Harnesse which are contest by all to be of a spirituall nature Revel 19. When that whore Iesabel stabbed Naboth with her Pen in stirring up the people to stone him as a Blasphemer of God and the King what a glorious maske or vaile of Holines put she on Proclaime a Fast set a day apart for humiliation and for confirmation let all be ratified with the Kings Authoritie Name and Seale 1 1 Kings 21. 8. Was not this recorded for all Gods Naboths standing for their Spirituall interests in heavenly things typed out by the typicall earth and ground of Canaans land that they through patience and Comfort of the Scriptures might have hope Rom. 15â— 4. Againe I demand who shall here sit Judge whether the Magistrate command any other Substance or Ceremonie but what is Christs By their former Conclusions every Soule must judge what the Magistrate commandeth and is not bound even in indifferent things to the Magistrates Law further then his own Soule Conscience and judgement ascends to the Reason of it Here the Magistrate must make Lawes for that Substance and Ceremony which Christ appointed But yet he must not doe this with his eyes open but blindfold and hoodwinkt for if he judge that to be the Religion of Christ and such to be the order there in which their Consciences judge otherwise and assent not to they professe they must submit only to Christs lawes and therefore they are not bound to obey him Oâ— what is this but to make use of the Civill Powers and Governours of the World as a Guard about the Spirituall Bed of Soulewhoredomes in which the Kings of the Earth commit Spirituall fornication with the great Whore Rev. 17. 2 as a Guard while the Inhabitants of the Earth are drinking themselves drunke with the wine of her fornication But oh what terrifying what allurings are in Iereinies Curse and Blessing 1 Ier. 17. Cursed is the man that trusteth in man that maketh Flesh his Arme too too common in spirituall matters and whose heart departeth from Jehovah He shall be as an Heath in the Wildernes even in the spirituall and mysticall wildernes and shall not see when comfort comes but shall abide in drouth in the wildernesse in a barrenland c. CHAP. XCVI Peace O What mysteries are these to Flesh and Blood how hard for flesh to forsake the Arme thereof But passe on deare Trutly to their proofe propounded Ezra 7. 23. Wherein Artaxerxes confirmed by Law what ever was commanded by the God of Heaven Truth In this Scripture I mind first the people of God captivated under the dominion and government of the Kings of Babel and Persia. Secondly Artaxerxes his favour to these Captives 1. Of freedome to their Consciences 2. Or bountie towards them 3. Of exempting of some of them from common charges Thirdly Punishments on offenders Fourthly the ground that â—aries him on to all this Fifthly Ezra praising of God for putting this into the heart of the King Concerning the people of God the Iewes they were as Lambes and Sheep in the jawes of the Lyon the dearely beloved of his Soule under the devouring Tyrants of the World both the Babylonian and the Persian farre from their owne Nation and the Government of their own anointed Kings the figures of the true King of the Iewes the Lord Iesus Christ. In this respect it is cleere that the Iewes were no more subject to the Kings of Babylon and Persia in Spirituall things then the Vessels of the Sanctuary were subject to the King of Babels use Dan. 5. Concerning this King I consider first his person a Gentile Idolater an oppressing Tyrant one of those devouring Beasts Daâ— 7. 8. An hand of bloody Conquest set the Crown upon the lead of these Monarchs and although in Civill things they might challenge subjection yet why should they now sit down in the throne of Israel and governe the people and Church of God in Spirituall things Secondly consider his acts of Favour and they will not amount to a positive Command that any of the Iewes should goe up to build the Temple nor that any of them should practice his own worship which he kept and judged the best for his owne Soule and People 'T is true he freely permits them and exerciseth a bounteous assistance to them All which argues no more but that sometimes it pleaseth God to open the hearts of Tyrants greatly to favour and further his people Such favour found Nehemiah and Daniel and others of Gods people have and shall finde so often as it pleaseth Him to honour them that honour Him before the Sonnes of Men. Peace Who sees not how little this Scripture contributes to their Tenent but why say some should this King confirme all with such severe punishments and why for all thisâ— should Ezra give thankes to God if it were not imitable for after-times Truth The Law of God which he confirmed he knew not and therefore neither was nor could he be a Judge in the Case And for his Ground what was it but the common terrours and convictions of an affâ—ighted Conscience In such sits and pangs what have not Pharaohs Sauls Ahabs Herods Agrippa's spoken and what wonderfull decrees have Nabuchadnizzar Cyrus Darius Artaxerxes put forth concerning the God of Israel Dan. 3. 6. Ezra 1 7 c. and yet as farre from being charged with as they were from being affected to the Spirituall Crown of Governing the Worship of God and the Conscience of his people â—Tis true Ezra most piously and justly gave thankes to God for putting such a thing into the heart of the King But what makes this pattern for the Laws of Civil Governours now under the Gospell It suited well with that Nationall state of Gods Church that the Gentile King should release them permit them to returne to their own Land assist them with other favours and enable them to execute punishments upon offenders according to their Nationall State But did God put such a thing as this into
Cor. 5. CHAP. CXXVII Peace DEare Truth you have uprightly and aptly untied the knots of that 11 Head let me present you with the 12 Head which is Concerning the Magistrates power in the Censures of the Church First say they he hath no power to execute or to substitute any Civill officer to execute any Church censure under the notion of Civill or â—cclesiasticall men Secondly Though a Magistrate may immediately Civilly censure such an offender whose secret sinnes are made manifest by their casting out to be injurious to the good of the State yet such offences of excommunicate persons which manifestly hurt not the good of the State he ought not to proceed against them sooner or later untill the Church hath made her complaint to him and given in their just Reasons for helpe from them For to give libertie to Magistrates without exception to punish all excommunicate persons within so many moneths may prove injurious to the person who needs to the Church who may desire to God who cals for longer indulgence from the hands of theÌ„ Thirdly for persons not excommunicate the Magistrate hath no power in mediately to censure such offences of Church members by the power of the Sword but onely for such as doe immediately hurt the peace of the State Because the proper end of Civill Government being the preservation of the peace and welfare of the State they ought not to breake downe those bounds and so to censure immediately for such sins which hurt not their peace Hence first Magistrates have no power to censure for secret sinnes as deadnesse unbeleefe because they are secret and not yet come forth immediately to hurt the peace of the State we say immediately for every sinne even originall sinne remotely hurts the Civill State Secondly hence they have no power to censure for such private sinnes in Church members which being not hainous may be best healed in a private way by the Churches themselves For that which may be best healed by the Church and yet is prosecuted by the State may make a deeper wound and greater rent in the peace both of Church and State the Magistrates also being members of the Church are bound to the rule of Christ viz. not to produce any thing in publike against a brother which may bee best healed in a private way Now we call that private First which is only remaining in Families not knowne of oothers and therefore a Magistrate to heare and prosecute the complaint of children against their parents servants against masters wives against their husbands without acquainting the Church first transgresseth the rule of Christ. Secondly that which is between members of the same Church or of divers Churches for it was a double fault of the Corinthians 1 Cor. 6. first to goe to Law secondly to doe it before an Infidell seeing the Church was able to judge of such kinde of differences by some Arbitratours among themselves So that the Magistrates should referre the differences of Church members to private healing and try that way first By meanes whereof the Churches should be free from much scandall and the State from much trouble and the hearts of the godly from much griefe in beholding such breaches Thirdly such offences which the Conscience of a Brother dealing with another privately dares not as yet publish openly comming to the notice of the Magistrate accidentally he ought not to make publique as yet nor to require the Grand Jurie to present the same no more then the other private brother who is dealing with him untill hee see some issue of the private way Thirdly hence they have no power to put any to an oath ex officio to accuse themselves or the brethren in case either criminis suspecti or praetensi because this preserves not but hurts many wayes the peace of the State and abuseth the ordinance of an Oath which is ordained to end controversies not to begin them Heb. 6. 16. Fourthly hence they have no power to censure any for such offences as breake either no Civill Law of God or Law of the State published according to it for the peace of the State being preserved by wholesome Laws when they are not hurt the peace is not hurt Truth In this passage as I said before I observe how weakly and partially they deale with the soules of Magistrates in telling them they are the Guardians of both Tables must see the Church doe her duty punish c. and yet in this passage the Elders or Ministers of the Churches not only sit Iudges over the Magistrates actions in Church affaires but in civill also straitning and inlarging his commission according to the particular interests of their owne ends or at the best their Conscâ—ences I grant the Word of the Lord is the only rule light and lanthorn in all cases concerning God or Man and that the Ministers of the Gospell are to teach this way hold out this Lanthorne unto the feete of all men but to give such an absolute power in Spirituall things to the Civill Magistrate and yet after their owne ends or Consciences to abridge it is but the former sporting with holy things and to walk in Contradictions as before I noted Many of the particulars I acknowledge true where the Magistrate is a Member of the Church yet some passages call for Explication and some for Observation First in that they say the Civill Magistrate ought not to proceed against the offences of an Excommunicate person which manifestly hurt not the good of the state untill the Church hath made her complaint for helpe from them I observe 2 things First a cleare grant that when the Church complayneth for helpe then the Magistrate may punish such offences as hurt not the good of the state and yet in a few lines after they say the Magistrates have no power to censure such offences of Church members by the power of the civill sword but only such as doe immediately hurt the peace of the civill state and they adde the Reason because the proper end of the civill Government being the preservation of the peace and welfare of the state they ought not to breake downe those bounds and so to censure immediately for such sinnes which hurt not their peace And in the last place they acknowledge the Magistrate hath no power to punish any for any such offences as breake no civill Law of God or Law of the state published according to it For the peace of the state say they being preserved by wholesome Lawes when they are not hurt the Peace is not hurt CHAP. CXXVIII Peace DEare Truth here are excellent confessions unto which both Truth and Grace may gladly assent but what is your second Observation from hence Truth I observe secondly what a deepe charge of weaknes is layd upon the Church of Christ the Lawes Government and Officers thereof and consequently upon the Lord Iesus himselfe to wit that the Church is not enabled with all the power of Christ to censure sufficiently an offendour on whom yet they have executed the deepest censure in the world to wit cutting off from Christ shutting out of Heaven casting
the principall Contents of the Booke TRuth and Peace their rare and seldome meeting Page 15 2 Great complaints of Peace 16 Persecutors seldome plead Christ but Moses for their Authour 17 Strife Christian and unchristian ibid A threefold dolefull cry ibid. The wonderfull providence of God in the writing of the argumentâ—s against persecution 18 A definition of persecution discussed 19 Conscience will not be restrained from its owne worship nor constrained to another 20 A chaste soule in Gods worship compared to a chaste wife ibid. Gods people have erred stom the very fundamentalls of visible worship ibid 4 Sorts of spirituall foundations in the New Testament 21 The 6 fundamentalls of the Christian Religion ibid. The comming out of Babel not Iocall but mysticall ibid. The great ignorance of Gods people concerning the nature of a true Church ibid. Common-Prayer written against by the New English Ministers 23 Gods people have worshipped God with false worships ibid. God is pleased sometimes to convey good unto his people beyond a promise ibid. A notable speech of King James to a great Nonconformist turned persecutor 24 Civill peace discussed ibid. The difference between Spirituall and civill state 25 Six cases wherein Gods people have been usually accounted arrogant and peace breakers but most unjustly 26 The true causes of breach and disturbance of civill peace 29 A preposterous way of suppressing errours 30 Persecutors must needs oppresse both erroneous and true consciences ibid. All persecutors of Christ professe not to persecute him ibid. What is meant by the Hereticke Tit. 3. Pag. 33 The word Heretick generally mistaken 34 Corporall killing in the Law typing out Spirituall killing in the Gospell 36 The cariage of a Soule sensible of mercy towards others in their blindness c. 38 The difference between the Church and the World wherein it is in all places 38 The Church and civill State confusedly made all one 39 The most peaceable accused for peace-breaking 40 A large Examination of what is meant by the Tares and letting of them alone ibid. Sathans subtletic about the opening of Scripture 41 Two sorts of Hypocrites 44 The Lord Iesus the great Teacher by Parables and the only Expounder of them 44 Preaching for conversion is properly out of the Church 45 The tares proved properly to signifie Antichristians ibid. Gods Kingdome on Earth the visible Church 46 The difference between the Wheat and the Tares as also betweene these Tares and all others 46 A civill Magistracie from the beginning of the world 47 The Tares are to be tolerated the longest of all sinners 48 The danger of infection by permitting of the Tares assoyled ibid. The civill Magistrate not so particularly spoken to in the New Testament as Fathers Masters c. and why 50 A two-fold state of Christianitie Persecuted under the Romane Emperours and Apostated under the Romane Popes ibid. 3 Particulars contained in that prohibition of Christ Iesus concerning the Tares Let them alone Mat. 13. 51 Accompanying with Idolaters 1 Cor. 5. discussed 52 Civill Magistrates never invested by Christ Iesus with the power and title of Defenders of the Faith 54 Gods people ever earnest with God for an Arme of Flesh. 55 The 〈◊〉 punishment of the blind Pharises in 4 respects ibid. The point of seducing infecting or Soule killing examined 57 Strange consusions in punishments 59 The blood of Soules Acts 20. lies upon such as professe the Ministrie the blood of Bodies only upon the State ibid. â—surpers and true Heires of Christ Iesus Page 60 The Civill Magistrate bound to preserve the boâ—â—s of their subjects and not to destroy them for conscience sake 61 The fire from heaven Rev. 13. 13. 2 Tim. 2. 25 26. examined 62 The originall of the Christian name Acts 11. 63 A Civill sword in Religion makes a Nation of hypocrites Isa. 10 64 A difference of the true and false Christ and Christians 65 The nature of the worship of unbeleeving and naturall persons ibid. Antoninus Pius his famous act concerning Religion 66 Isa. 24. Mic. 4. 3. concerning Christs visible Kingdome discussed ibid. Acts 20 29. The suppressing of Spirituall wolves discussed 67 It is in vaine to decline the name of the head of the Church and yet to practise the headship 68 Titus 1. 9. 10 discussed 69 Vnmercifull and bloody doctrine 70 The Spirituall weapons 2 Cor. 10. 4. discussed ibid. Civill weapons most improper in Spirituall causes 71 The Spirituall artillerie Eph. 6. applied 72 Rom. 13. concerning Civill Rulers power in Spirituall causes largely examined 73 Pauls appeale to Caesar examined 77 And cleared by 5 arguments ibid. 4 Sorts of swords 79 What is to be understood by evill Rom. 13. 4. 81 Though evill be alwayes evill yet the permission of it may sometimes be good 83 2 Sorts of commands both from Moses and Christ. 84 The permission of diverce in Israel Mat. 19. 17 18. ibid. Usury in the Civill state lawfully permitted 85 Seducing teachers either Pagan Iewish Turkish or Antichristian way yet be obedient subjects to the Civill Laws 86 Scandalous livers against the Civill state 87 Toleration of Jesabel and Balaam Rev. 2 14. 20. examined 88 The Christian world hath swallowed up Christianity 89 Christ Iesus the deepest polititian that ever was yet commands be a toleration of Antichristians 91 The Princes of the world seldome take part with Christ Iesus 93 Buchanans items to King James ibid. King James his sayings against persecution ibid. King Steven of Poland his sayings against persecution Page 93 Forcing of conscience a soule rape 94 Persecution for conscience hath been the launcet which hath let blood the Nations All Spirituall whores are bloody ibid. Poligamie or the many wives of the Fathers ibid. David advancing of Gods worship against order 95 Constantine and the good Emperours confest to have done more hurt to the Name and Crowne of Christ then the bloody Noroes did ibid. The language of persecuters 96 Christs Liâ—â—ies may flourish in the Church notwithstanding the weeds in the world permitted 97 Queen Elizabeth and King James their persecuting for cause of Religion examined ibid. Queen Elizabeth confessed by Mr. Cotton to have almost fired the world in civill combustions 98 The Wars between the Papists and the Protestants ibid. The Wars and successe of the Waldensians against three Popes 99 Gods people victorious â—ver commers and with what weapons ibid. The Christian Church doth not persecute but is persecuted ibid. The nature of excommunication 100 The opinion of ancient Writers examined concerning the doctrine of persecution 101 Constraint upon conscience in Old and New England ibid. The Indians of New England permitted in their worshipping of devils 102 In 2 cases a false Religion will not hurt 103 The absolute sufficiencie of the Sword of the Spirit 104 A Nationall Church not instituted by Christ. ibid. Man hath no power to make Lawes to binde conscience 105 Hearing of the word in a Church estate a part of Gods worship 107 Papists plea for
of thy Witnesses that dare to plead thy Cause how are they charged to be mine Enemies contentious tarbulent seditious Secondly Thine Enemies though they speake and raile against thee though they outragiously pursue imprison banish kill thy faithfull Witnesses yet how is all veâ—illion'd o're for Iustice 'gainst the Hereticks Yea if they 〈◊〉 and blow the 〈◊〉 of devouring Warres that leave neither Spirituall nor Civill State but burns up Branch and Root yet how doe all pretend an holy War He that kills and hee that 's killed they both cry out It is for God and for their conscience T is true nor one nor other seldome dare to plead the mighty Prince Christ Iesus for their Authour yet both both Protestant and Papist pretend they have spoke with Moses and the Prophets who all say they before Christ came allowed such holy persecutions holy Warres against the enemies of holy Church Truth Deare Peace to ease thy first complaint t is true thy dearest Sons most like their mother Peace-keeping Peace-making Sons of God have borne and still must beare the blurs of troublers of Israel and turners of the World upside downe And t is true againe what Salomon once spake The beginning of strife is as when one letteth out Water therefore saith he leave off contention before it be medled with This Caveat should keepe the bankes and sluces firme and strong that strife like a breach of waters breake not in upon the sons of men Yet strife must be distinguished It is necessary or unnecessary godly or ungodly Christian or unchristian c. It is unnecessary unlawfull dishonourable ungodly unchristian in most cases in the world for there is a possibility of keeping sweet Peace in most cases and if it be possible it is the expresse command of God that Peace be kept Rom. 13. Againe it is necessary honourable godly c. with civill and earthly weapons to defend the innocent and to rescue the oppressed from the violent pawes and jaws of oppressing persecuting Nimrods Psal. 73. Iob 29. It is as necessary yea more honourable godly and Christian to â—ight the â—ight of faith with religious and spirituall Artillery and to contend earnestly for the faith of Iesus once delivered to the Saints against all opposers and the gates of earth and hell men or devils yea against Paul himselfe or an Angell from heaven if he bring any other faith or doctrine Iude vers 4. Gal. 1. 8. Peace With the clashing of such Armes am I never wakened Speake once againe deare Truth to my second complaint of bloody persecution and devouring wars marching under the colours of upright Iustice and holy Zeale c. Truth Mine eares have long beene filled with a threefold dolefull Outcry First of one hundred forty foure thousand Virgins Rev. 14 forc'd and ravisht by Emperours Kings and Governours to their beds of worship and Religion set up like Absalems on high in their severall States and Countries Secondly the cry of those precious soules under the Altar Rev. 6. the soules of such as have beene persecuted and slaine for the testimony and witnesse of Iesus whose bloud hath beene spilt like water upon the earth and that because they have held fast the truth and witnesse of Iesus against the worship of the States and Times compelling to an uniformity of State Religion These cries of murthered Virgins who can sit still and heare Who can but run with zeale inflamed to prevent the destowring of chaste soules and spilling of the bloud of the innocent Humanity stirs up and prompts the Sonnes of men to draw materiall swords for a Virgins chastity and life against a ravishing murtherer And Piety and Christianity must needs awaken the Sons of God to draw the spirituall sword the Word of God to preserve the chastity and life of spirituall Virgins who abhorre the spirituall defilements of false worship Rev. 14. Thirdly the cry of the whole earth made drunke with the bloud of its inhabitants slaughtering each other in their blinded zeale for Conscience for Religion against the Catholickes against the Lutherans c. What fearfull cries within these twenty years of hundred thousands men women children fathers mothers husbands wives brethren sisters old and young high and low plundred ravished slaughtered murthered famished And hence these cries that men â—ling away the spirituall sword and spirituall artillery in spirituall and religious causes and rather trust for the suppressing of each others God Conscience and Religion as they suppose to an arme of flesh and sword of steele Truth Sweet Peace what hast thou there Peace Arguments against persecution for cause of Conscience Truth And what there Peace An Answer to such Arguments contrarily maintaining such persecution for cause of Conscience Truth These Arguments against such persecution and the Answer pleading for it written as Love hopes from godly intentions hearts and hands yet in a marvellous different stile and manner The Arguments against persecution in milke the Answer for it as I may say in bloud The Authour of these Arguments against persecution as I have beene informed being committed by som then in power close prisoner to Newgate for the witnesse of some truths of Iesus and having not the use of Pen and Inke wrote these Arguments in Milke in sheets of Paper brought to him by the Woman his Keeper from a friend in London as the stopples of his Milk bottle In such Paper written with Milk nothing will appeare but the way of reading it by fire being knowne to this friend who received the Papers he transcribed and kept together the Papers although the Author himselfe could not correct nor view what himselfe had written It was in milke tending to soule nourishment even for Babes and Sucklings in Christ. It was in milke spiritually white pure and innocent like those white horses of the Word of truth and meeknesse and the white Linnen or Armour of righteousnesse in the Army of Iesus Rev. 6. 19. It was in milke soft meeke peaceable and gentle tending both to the peace of soules and the peace of States and Kingdomes Peace The Answer though I hope out of milkie pure intentions is returned in bloud bloudy slaughterous conclusions bloudy to the souls of all men forc'd to the Religion and Worship which every civil State or Common-weale agrees on and compells all subjects to in a dissembled uniformitie Bloudy to the bodies first of the holy witnesses of Christ Iesus who testifie against such invented worships Secondly of the Nations and Peoples slaughtering each other for their severall respective Religions and Consciences CHAP. III. Truth IN the Answer Mr. Cotton first layes downe severall distinctions and conclusions of his owne tending to prove persecution Secondly Answers to the Scriptures and Arguments proposed against persecution Peace The first distinction is this By persecution for cause of Conscience I conceive you meane either for professing some point of doctrine which you
sonnes of men in this point To illustrate this The Church or company of worshippers whether true or false is like unto a Body or Colledge of Physitians in a Citie like unto a Corporation Society or Company of East-Indie or Turkie-Merchants or any other Societie or Company in London which Companies may hold their Courts keep their Records hold disputations and in matters concerning their Societie may dissent divide breake into Schismes and Factions sue and implead each other at the Law yea wholly breake up and dissolve into pieces and nothing and yet the peace of the Citie not be in the least measure impaired or disturbed because the essence or being of the Citie and so the well-being and peace thereof is essentially distinct from those particular Societies the Citie-Courts Citie-Lawes Citie-punishments distinct from theirs The Citie was before them and stands absolute and intire when such a Corporation or Societie is taken down For instance further The City or Civill state of Ephesus was essentially distinct from the worship of Diana in the Citie or of the whole city Againe the Church of Christ in Ephesus which were Gods people converted and call'd out from the worship of that City unto Christianitie or worship of God in Christ was distinct from both Now suppose that God remove the Candlestick from Ephesus yea though the whole Worship of the Citie of Ephesus should be altered yet if men be true and honestly ingenuous to Citie-covenants Combinations and Principles all this might be without the least impeachment or infringement of the Peace of the City of Ephesus Thus in the Citie of Smirna was the Citie it selfe or Civill estate one thing The Spirituall or Religious state of Smirna another The Church of Christ in Smirna distinct from them both and the Synagogue of the Iewes whether literally Iewes as some thinke or mystically false Christians as others called the Synagogue of Sathan Revel 2. distinct from all these And notwithstanding these spirituall oppositions in point of Worship and Religion yet heare we not the least noyse nor need we if Men keep but the Bond of Civility of any Civill breach or breach of Civill peace amongst them and to persecute Gods people there for Religion that only was a breach of Civilitie it selfe CHAP. VII Peace NOw to the second Quaerie What it is to hold forth Doctrine or Practice in an arrogant or impetuous way Truth Although it hath not pleased Mr. Cotton to declare what is this arrogant or impetuous holding forth of Doctrine or Practice tending to disturbance of Civill peace I cannot but expresse my sad and sorrowfull observation how it pleaseth God to leave him as to take up the common reproachfull accusation of the Accuser of Gods children to wit that they are arrogant and impetuous which charge together with that of obstinacie pertinacie pride Troublers of the Citie c. Sathan commonly loads the meekest of the Saints and Witnesses of Iesus with To wipe off therefore these fowle blurs and aspersions from the faire and beautifull face of the Spouse of Iesus I shall select and propose 5 or 6 cases for which Gods witnesses in all Ages and Generations of Men have been charged with arrogance impetuousnes c. and yet the God of Heaven and Iudge of all men hath graciously discharged them from such crimes and maintained and avowed them for his faithfull and peaceable servants First Gods people have proclaimed taught disputed for divers months together a new Religion and Worship contrary to the Worship projected in the Towne City or State where they have lived or where they have travelled as did the Lord Iesus Himselfe over all Galile and the Apostles after Him in all places both in the Synagogues and Market-places as appeares Acts 17. 2. 17. Acts 18. 48. Yet this no Arrogance nor Impetuousnesse Secondly Gods servants have been zealous for their Lord and Master even to the very faces of the Highest and concerning the persons of the Highest so far as they have opposed the Truth of God So Eliah to the face of Ahab It is not I but thou and thy Fathers house that troublest Israel So the Lord Iesus concerning Herod Goe tell that Fox So Paul God delivered me from the mouth of the Lion and to Ananias Thou whited wall and yet in all this no Arrogance nor Impetuousnesse Thirdly Gods people have been immoveable constant and resolved to the death in refusing to submit to false Worships and in preaching and professing the true worship contrary to expresse command of publicke Authority So the three famous Worthies against the command of Nobilchadnezzar and the uniforme conformity of all Nations agreeing upon a false worship Dan. 3. So the Apostles Acts 4 and 5 chap. and so the witnesses of Iesus in all ages who loved not their lives to the death Rev. 12. not regarding sweet life nor bitter death and yet not Arrogant nor Impetuous Fourthly Gods people since the comming of the King of Israel the Lord Iesus have openly and constantly profest that no Civill Magistrate no King nor Caesar have any power over the Soules or Consciences of their Subjects in the matters of God and the Crowne of Iesus but the Civill Magistrates themselves yea Kings and Keisars are bound to subject their owne soules to the Ministery and Church the Power and Government of this Lord Iesus the King of Kings Hence was the charge against the Apostles false in Civill but true in spiritualls that they affirmed that there was another King one Iesus Acts 17. 7. And indeed this was the great charge against the Lord Iesus Himself which the Iews laid against Him and for which he suffered Death as appears by the Accusation written over His Head upon the Gallows Iohn 9. 19. Iesus of Nazareth King of the Iewes This was and is the summe of all true preaching of the Gospell or glad newes viz. That God anointed Jesus to be the sole King and Governour of all the Israel of God in spirituall and soule causes Psal. 2. 6. Acts 2. 36. Yet this Kingly power of His he resolved not to manage in His owne Person but Ministerially in the hands of such Messengers which he sent forth to preach and baptise and to such as beleeved that word they preached Iohn 17. And yet here no Arrogance nor Impetuousnesse 5. Gods people in delivering the Minde and Will of God concerning the Kingdomes and Civill States where they have lived have seemed in all shew of common sense and rationall policie if men looke not higher with the eye of saith to endanger and overthrow the very Civill State as appeareth by all Ieremses preaching and counsell to King Zedechia his Princes and people insomuch that the charge of the Princes against Ieremiah was that he discouraged the Army from fighting against the Babylonians and weakned the Land from its own defence and this charge in the eye of reason seemed not to be unreasonable
Church of Christ abideth and secondly the Commonweale may be in perfect peace and quiet notwithstanding the Church the Commonweale of Christ be in distractionsâ— and spirituall oppositions both against their Religions and sometimes amongst themselves as the Church of Christ in Corinth troubled with divisions contentions c. Secondly I observe it is true the Church helpeth forward the prosperity of the Commonweale by spirituall meanes Ier. 29. 7. The prayers of Gods people procure the peace of the City where they abide yet that Christs Ordinances and administrations of Worship are appointed and given by Christ to any Civill State Towne or City as is implied by the instance of Geneva that I confidently deny The Ordinances and Discipline of Christ Iesus though wrongfully and prophanely applied to naturall and unregenerate men may cast a blush of civillity and morality upon them as in Geneva and other places for the shining brightnesse of the very shadow of Christs Ordinances casts a shame upon barbarisme and incivillity yet withall I affirme that the misapplication of Ordinances to unregenerate and unrepentant persons hardens up their soules in a dreadfull sleep and dreame of their owne blessed estate and sends millions of soules to hell in a secure expectation of a false salvation CHAP. LXXXIV The second head concerning Superiority of each Power Peace BEcause contention may arise in future times which of these Powers under Christ is the greatest as it hath been under Antichrist we conceive first That the power of the Civill Magistrates is superiour to the Church policie in place honours dignity earthly power in the World and the Church superiour to him being a member of the Church Ecclesiastically that is in a Church way ruling and ordering him by Spirituall Ordinances according to God for his soules health as any other member so that all the power the Magistrate hath over the Church is temporall not spirituall and all the power the Church hath over the Magistrate is spirituall not temporall And as the Church hath no temporall power over the Magistrate in ordine ad bonum spirituale So the Magistrate hath no Spirituall power over the Church in ordine ad bonum temporale Secondly the delinquencie of either party calleth for the exercise of the power of terrour from the other part for no Rulers ordained of God are a terrour to good works but to evill Rom. 13. 3. So that if the Church offend the offence of the Church câ—lleth upon the Civill Magistrate either to seeke the healing thereof as a nursing father by his owne grave advice and the advice of other Churches or else if he cannot so prevaile to put forth and exercise the superiority of his power in redressing what is amisse according to the quality of the offence by the course of civill Justice On the other side if the Magistrate being a member of the Church shall offend the offence calleth upon the Church either to seek the healing thereof in a brotherly way by conviction of his sinne or else if they cannot prevaile then to exercise the superiority of their power in removing of the offence and recovering of the offendour by Church censures If the end of Spirituall or Church power is bonum spirituale a spirituall good and the end of Civill or State power is bonum temporale a temporall good And secondly if the Magistrate have no spirituall power to attaine to his temporall end no more then a Church hath any temporall power to attaine to her Spirituall end as is confest I demand if this be not a contradiction against their owne disputes tenents and practices touching that question of persecution for cause of conscience For if the Magistrate be supreme Iudge and so consequently give supreme judgement sentence and determination in matters of the first Table and of the Church and be custos utriusque Tabule keepers of both Tables as they speake and yet have no Spirituall power as is affirmed how can he determine what the true Church and Ordinances are and then set them up with the power of the Sword How can he give judgement of a false Church a false Ministery a false Doctrine false Ordinances and with a Civil Sword pull them down if he have no Spiritual power authority or commission from Christ Iesus for these ends and purposes Further I argue thus If the civill officers of State must determine judge and punish in Spiritual causes his power authority and commission must be either Spirituall or Civill or else he hath none at all and so acts without a commission and warrant from the Lord Iesus and so consequently stands guilty at the Bar of Christ Iesus to answer for such his practice as a transcendent Delinquent Now for civill power these worthy Authors confesse that the Government of the civill Magistrate extendeth no further then over the bodies and goods of the Subject and therefore hath no civill power over the Soule and therefore say I not in Soule-causes Secondly It is here confest in this passage that to attaine his Civill end or Bonum temporale he hath no Spirituall power and therefore of necessitie out of their own mouths must they be judged for provoking the Magistrate without either Civill or Spirituall power to judge punish and persecute in Spirituall causes and to feare and tremble lest they come neere those frogs which proceed out of the mouth of the Dragon and Beast and false Prophet who by the same Arguments which the Authours here use stirre up the Kings of the Earth to make warre against the Lambe Christ Iesus and his Followers Revel 17. CHAP. LXXXV IN the next place I observe upon the point of Delinquencie such a confusion as Heaven and Earth may stand amazed at If the Church offend say they after advice refused in conclusion the Magistrate must redresse that is punish the Church that is in Church offences and cases by a course of Civill justice On the other side if the Civill Magistrate offend after Admonition used and not prevailing in conclusion the Church proceeds to censure that is to Excommunication as is afterward more largely proved by them Now I demand if the Church be a Delinquent who shall judge It is answered the Magistrate Againe if the Magistrate be a Delinquent I aske who shall judge It is answered the Church Whence I observe which is monstrous in all cases in the World that one person to wit the Church or Magistrate shall be at one time the Delinquent at the Bar and the Iudge upon the Bench. This is cleere thus The Church must judge when the Magistrate offends and yet the Magistrate must judge when the Church offends and so consequently in this case must judge whether she contemne Civill Authority in the Second Table for thus dealing with him Or whether she have broken the rules of the first Table of which say they God hath made him Keeper and Conserver And therefore though the
simply unlawfull as unto a falsely constituted Church Ministry Worship Administration and they shall not escape the Dâ—ch by being led blindefold by the Magistrate but though hee fall in first yet they shall in after him and upon him to his greater and more dreadfull judgement In particular thus If the Magistrate may restraine me from that gesture in the Supper of the Lord which I am perswaded I ought to practice he may also restraine me by his commands from that Supper of the Lord it selfe in such or such a Church according to my conscience If he cannot as they grant constraine me to such or such a garment in the worship of God can he constraine me to worship God by such a Ministry and with such worship which my soule and conscience cannot be perswaded is of God If he cannot command me in that circumstance of time to worship God this or that day can he command mee to the worship it selfe Peace Me thinkes I discerne a threefold guilt to lye upon such Civill powers as impose upon and inforce the conscience though not unto the ministration and participation of the Seales yet either to depart from that worship which it is perswaded of or to any exercise or worship which it hath not faith in First of an appearance of that Arminian Popish doctrine of freewill as if it lay in their owne power and ability to beleeve upon the Magistrates command since it is confessed that what is submitted to by any without faith it is sinne be it never so true and holy Rom. 14. Secondly since God only openeth the heart and worketh the will Phil. 2. it seemes to be an high presumption to suppose that together with a command restraining from or constraining to worship that God is also to be forced or commanded to give faith to open the heart to incline the will c. Thirdly A guilt of the hypocrisie of their subjects and people in forcing them to act and practice in matters of Religion and Worship against the doubts and checks of their consciences causing their bodies to worship when their soules are far off to draw near with their lips their hearts being far off c. With lesse sinne ten thousand fold may a naturall â—ather force his 〈◊〉 or the Father of the Commonweale force all the maydens in a Country to the marriage beds of such and such men whom they cannot love then the soules of these and other subjects to such worship or Ministry which is either a true or false because Cant. 1. 16. Truth Sweet Peace your conclusions are undeniable and O that they might sinke deep into those Noble and Honourable Bosomes it so deeply concernes but proceed CHAP. XCV Peace IN that fifth head they further say thus Thirdly in matters Ecclesiasticall we beleeve first That Civill Magistrates have no power to make or constitute Lawes about Church affaires which the Lord Jesus hath not ordained in his Word for the well ordering of the Church for the Apostle solemnely chargeth Timothy and in him all Goverours of the Church before God and the Lord Jesus Christ who is the only Potentate the King of Kings and Lord of Lords that the Commandement given by him for the ordering of the Church be kept without spot unrebukeable to the appearing of the Lord Jesus Christ 1 Tim. 6. 14. 15. And this Commandement given in the Word the Apostle faith is able to make the man of God perfect in all Righteousnesse 2 Tim. 3. 17. And indeed the adminstration of all Christs affaires doth immediately aime at spirituall and divine ends as the worship of God and the salvation of mens soules and therefore no Law nor meanes can be devised by the wisdome or wit of man that can be fit or able to reach such ends but use must be made of such onely as the divine Wisdome and holy Will of God hath ordained Secondly We beleeve the Magistrates power in making Lawes about Church affaires is not only thus limited and restrained by Christ to matters which concerne the substance of Gods worship and of Church government but also such as concerne outward order as in Rites and Ceremonies for uniformities sake For we finde not in the Gospell that Christ hath any where provided for the uniformity of Churches but onely for their unity Paul in matters of Christian libertie commendeth the unity of their Faith in the holy Spirit giving order that wee should not judge nor condemne one another in difference of judgement and practice of such things where men live to God on both sides even though there were some errour on one side Rom. 14. to the 6. How much lesse in things indifferent where there may be no etrour on either side When the Apostle directeth the Church of Corinth that all things be done decently and in order he meant not to give power to Church Officers or to Civill Magistrates to order what ever they should thinke meet for decencie and order but only to provide that all the Ordinances of God be administred in the Church decently without unnaturall or uncivill uncomelinesse as that of long haire or womens propheâ—ying of the like and orderly without confusion or disturbance of edification as the speaking of many at once in the Church Thirdly we doe neverthelesse willingly grant that Magistrates upon due and diligent search what is the counsell and will of God in his Word concerning the right ordering of the Church may and ought to publish and declare establish and ratifie such Lawes and Ordinances as Christ hath appointed in his Word for the well ordering of Church affaires both for the gathering of the Church and the right administration of all the Ordinances of God amongst them in such a manner as the Lord hath appointed to edification The Law of Artaxerxes Ezra 7. 23. was not usurpation over the Churches liberty but a Royall and just confirmation of them Whatsoever is commanded by the God of Heaven For why should there be wrath against the King and his Sonnes Truth Deare Peace me thinkes I see before mine eyes a wall daubed up of which Ezekiel speakes with untempered morter Here they restraine the Magistrate from making Lawes either concerning the substance or ceremony of Religion but such only as Christ hath commanded and those say they must publish and declare after the example of Artaxerxes I shall herein performe two things First examine this Magistrates duty to publish declare c. such Laws and Ordinances as Christ hath appointed Secondly I shall examine that proofe from Artaxerxes Ezra 7. 23. In the first me thinks I heare the voice of the people of Israel 1 Sam. 8. 5. Make us a King that may rule over us after the manner of the Nations rejecting the Lord ruling over them by his holy Word in the mouth of his Prophets and sheltring themselves under an Arme of Flesh which Arme of Flesh God gave them in His Anger and cut off againe in His
for with a word to his Father he could have 12 legions of Angels 3 The councell of God to be fulfilled in the Scripture Thus it ought to be Peace It is much questioned by some what should be the meaning of Christ Iesus in that speech All that take the sword shall perish by the sword Truth There is a threefold taking of the sword First by murtherous crueltie either of private persons or secondly publike States or Societies in wrath or revenge each against other Secondly a just and righteous taking of the sword in punishing offenders against the Civill peace either more personall private and ordinary or more publike Oppressors Tyrants Ships Navies c. Neither of these can it be imagined that Christ Iesus intended to Peter Thirdly There is therefore a 3. taking of the sword forbidden to Peter that is for Christ and the Gospels cause when Christ is in danger which made Peter strike c. Peace It seemes to some most contrary to all true Reason that Christ Iesus 〈◊〉 it selfe should not be defended Truth The foolishnes of God is wiser then the wisedome of Man It is not the purpose of God that the Spirituall battailes of his Son shall be fought by carnall weapons and persons It is not his pleasure that the World shall flame on fire with civill combustions for his Sons sake It is directly contrary to the nature of Christ Iesus his Saints and Truths that throats of men which is the highest contrarietie to civill converse should be torne out for his sake who most delighted to converse with the greatest sinners It is the councell of God that his servants shall overcome by 3 weapons of a spirituall nature Revel 12. 11. And that all that take the sword of steele shall perish Lastly it is the Councell of God that Christ Iesus shall shortly appeare a most glorious Iudge and Revenger against all his Enemies when the Heavens and the Earth shall 〈◊〉 before his most glorious presence Peace I shall propose the last Scripture much insisted on by many for carnall weapons in spirituall cases Revel 17. 16. The 10 hornes which thou fawest upon the Beast these shall hate the whore and shall make her desolate and naked and shall eat her flesh and shall burne her with fire Truth Not to controvert with some whether or no the Beast be yet risen and extant Nor secondly whether either the Beast or the Hornes or the Whore may be taken literally for any corporall Beast or Whore Or thirdly whether these 10 Hornes be punctually and exactly 10 Kings Or fourthly whether those 10 Hornes signifie those many Kings Kingdomes and Governments who have bowed down to the Popes yoake and have committed fornication with that great Whore the Church of Rome Let this last be admitted which yet will cost some work to cleer against all opposites Yet First can the Time be now cleerly demonstrated to be come c Secondly how will it be proved that this â—atred of this Whâ—re shall be a true chaste Christian hatred against Antichristian whorish practices c Thirdly or rather that this hating and desolating and making naked and burning shall arise not by way of an ordinance waranted by the institution of Christ Iesus but by way of providence when as it useth to be with all whores and their lovers the Church of Rome and her great lovers shall fall out and by the righteous vengeance of God upon her drunke with the blood of Saints or holy Ones these mighty fornicators shall turne their love into hatred which hatred shall make her a poore desolate naked Whore torne and consumed c. Peace You know it is a great controversie how the Kings of the Earth shall thus deale with the Whore in the 17 Chap. and yet so bewaile her in the 18 Chapter Truth If we take it that these Kings of the Earth shall first hate and plunder and teare and burne this Whore and yet afterward shall relent and bewaile their cruell dealing toward her Or else that as some Kings deale so terribly with her yet others of those Kings shall bewaile her If either of these two answers stand or a better be given yet none of them can prove it lawfull for people to give power to their Kings and Magistrates thus to deale with them their subjects for their conscience nor for Magistrates to assume a title more then the people betrust them with nor for one people out of conscience to God and for Christ his sake thus to kill and slaughter and burne each other However it may please the Righteous Judge according to the famous types of Gideous and Iehosaphats battells to permit in Iustice and to order in Wisdome these mighty and mutuall slaughters each of other Peace We have now deare Truth through the gracious hand of God clambered up to the top of this our tedious Discourse Truth O 't is mercy unexpressible that either Thou or I have had so long a breathing time and that together Peace If English ground must yet be drunk with English blood O where shall Peace repose her wearied head and heavy heart Truth Deare Peace if thou finde welcome and the God of peace miraculously please to quench these all-devouring flames yet where shall Truth finde rest from cruell persecutions Peace Oh will not the Authority of holy Scriptures the Commands and Declarations of the Sonne of God therein produced by thee together with all the lamentable experiences of former and present slaughters prevaile with the Sons of Men especially with the Sons of Peace to depart from the dens of Lyons and mountaines of Leopards and to put on the bowels if not of Christianitie yet of Humanitie each to other Truth Deare Peace Habacacks Fishes keep their constant bloody game of Persecutions in the Worlds mighty Ocean the greater taking plundring swallowing up the lesser O happy he whose portion is the God of Iacob who hath nothing to lose under the Sun but hath a State a House an Inheritance a Name a Crowne a Life past all the Plunderers Ravishers Murtherers reach and furie Peace But loe Who 's here Truth Our Sister Patience whose desired company is as needfull as delightfull 'T is like the Wolfe will send the scattered Sheep in one the common Pirate gathers up the loose and scattered Navie the slaughter of the Witnesses by that bloody Beast unite the Independents and Presbyterians The God of Peace the God of Truth will shortly seale this Truth and confirme this Witnes and make it evident to the whole World That the Doctrine of Persecution for cause of Conscience is most evidently and lamentably contrary to the doctrine of Christ Iesus the Prince of Peace Amen FINIS Errata PAge 23. line 28. for this reâ—d that p. 31. l. ult his soule p. 32. l. 12. read month â—bid r. person p. 35. l. 16. r. turned off or loosed from p. 37. l. 8. for to read doc p. 38. l. 2. dele affirme p. 41.