then for you to have pressed the necessity of the first resurrection for all fallen and corrupted men Revel 20.6 Blessed and holy is he that hath his part in the first resurrection on such the second death hath no power CHAP. XXXIII Of the last Judgment GOD hath appointed a day wherein he will judge the world in righteousness by Jesus Christ a Acts 17.30 to whom all power and judgement is given of the Father b Joh 5.22 27. In which day not only the Apostate Angels shall be judged c 1 Cor 6.3 Jude 6. 2 Pet 1.4 but likewise all persons that have lived upon earth shall appear before the tribunal of Christ to give an account of their thoughts words and deeds and to receive according to what they have done in the body whether good or evil d 2 Cor 5.10 Ec 12.14 Rom 2.16 Ro 14.10 12. Mat 12.36 37. II. The end of Gods appointing this day is for the manifestation of the glory of his mercy in the eternal salvation of the elect of his justice in the damnation of the Reprobate who are wicked and disobedient For then the righteous go into everlasting life and receive the fulness of joy and refreshing which shall come from the presence of the Lord but the wicked that know not God and obey not the Gospel of Jesus Christ shall be cast into eternal torments and be punished with everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his power e Mat. 25.31 to the end Rom 2.5 6. Rom 9.22 23. Mat 25 2â— Acts 5.19 2 Thes 1.7 8 6 10. III. As Christ would have us to be certainly perswaded That there shall be a day of judgement both to deter all from sin and for the greater consolation of the godly in their adversity f 2 Pet 3.11.14 2 Cor 5.10 11. 2 Thes 1.5 6 7. Luke 21.27 28. Rom 8.23 24 25. so will he have that day unknown to men that they may shake off all carnal security and be always watchful because they know not at what hour the Lord will come and may be ever prepared to say Come Lord Jesus come quickly g Matth 24 36 42 43 44. Mark 13.35 36 37. Luke 1â— 35 36. Rev 22 20. Amen CHAP. XXXIII Of the last Judgement Examined THis argument de rebus novissimis is a good subiect for you and us to close with but as you want some light in the beginning so we cannot commend your discerning or Judgement in your end You by your Scriptures to which you referr us confounding so many kinds and times of Judgment very different in themselves First you might have observed that Christs office of Judicature is twofold the one in the Saints and the other outward over all persons of Angels and men The former of these his inward and spiritual office Christ executes two wayes at two distant times yea in two several degrees The first is when he judgeth betwixt them and their spiritual enemies and not only delivers his servants from them but guideth and ruleth them according to his Lawes and Will Thus as types of Christ Othnicl Gedion Jephtha and the Judges of old were said to judge Israel and sutably hereunto David speaks thus of Christ Psal 72.4 He shall judge the poor of his people he shall save the children of the needy and break in peices the oppressors and Christ himself saith John 12.31 Now is the judgement of this world now is the Prince of this world cast out Christs second way of judging in his Saints is when he riseth up in them in fulness of light and power after they are dead with him in which day and coming of his he manifests unto them truth and errour light and darkness life and death yea every Councel of their own hearts even as the light of the Sun laies all open to the eye 1 Cor. 4.5 Therefore judge nothing before the time until the Lord come who both will bring to light the hidden things of darkness and will make manifest the counsels of the heart and then shall every man have praise of God for this very cause the Apostle would have all men forbear judging till that time but not until the general day of judgment now the outward judging of Christ is either in this life or the other in this life he judgeth and punisheth persons nations yea and sometimes the whole earth as he did in the daies of Noah After this life he first judgeth every man at his death Heb. 8.27 It is appointed unto all men once to die and after that cometh the judgement and then as you have here set it forth all men and Angels at or in the last day Thus then is a manifold day or time of Christs coming to judgement spoken of Matth. 24. and 25. Chapters and elsewhere First His particular coming to every man at his death Matth. 24. Secondly His coming to judge and punish the nation of the Jews Matth. 24.23 which came to pass about 38 yeers after his death Thirdly His coming to punish the fals proud and Apostate Jerusalem of the Gentiles a work now in hand Matth. 24.3 20 36 37. Fourthly Christs inward and spiritual coming promised to his Apostles and Disciples John 14.19 20. and spoken of 1 Corinth 1.7 Heb. 10.36 37. Jam. 5.7 which spiritual coming of his was after a time to cease in the Church by reason of mens Apostacy and the departure away from the true faith Luke 17.12 The daies will come when ye shall desire to see one of the daies of the Son of man and shall not see them Fifthly There is Christs second coming and his spiritual entrance into his Church in the same kinde called also the day of the Lord of which 2 Thes 2.2 in which the man of sin the son of perdition that mystery of iniquity should be revealed yea and destroyed by the brightness of his coming which coming of his brings the Gospel with it that was to be preached unto all Nations Matth. 24.30 And then shall appear the sign of the Son of man in Heaven and then shall all the Tribes of the earth mourn and they shall see the Son of man coming in the Clouds of Heaven with power and great glory and he shal send his Angels with a great sound of a Trumpet the Gospel aforesaid and they shall gather together his Elect from the four winds which time is by Zachariah described to be a gracious time chap. 12.10 11.12 and wished and longed for by St John Revel 1.7 22. This seems to be that blessed time wherein Christ shall come in the spirit but not in the body as many Chiliasts dream to errect a Kingdom throughout the earth in the hand of his Saints Dan. 7.13 14 27 28. which kingdom shall continue a thousand years Rev. 3.4 5 6. yea some are so bold as to say that this comming of Christ is the great day of judgment spoken of Acts 17.30 and elsewhere wherein Christ cometh spiritually with all his Saints to give a true and upright sentence concerning all spiritual things good and evil for which purpose they alledge that text 1 Thes 3.13 But St. John describes another judgement which shall follow after the thousand years are ended Rev. 20.7 8.15 which seem to be that very judgement which you aim at in this chapter And so sixthly and lastly There is Christs day or time of his last coming to keep a great and general Assizes Thus much in reference to your first Section especially In your second Section we admit your reasons produced to shew why there should be such a judgement with the proceedings then and the several events by you set forth and the rather because you there in the manifestation of the glory of Gods justice against there probates seem to lay their own condemnation upon their own disobedience and demerit and no way ascribe it to Gods absolute preterition or soveraignty to the want of means or sufficient grace for their effectual calling as you have done heretofore Lastly For a peaceable and friendly conclusion we grant you that which you assume in your third and last Section namly that Christ would have us certainly perswaded of a general judgement to deter all men from sin and for the greater consolation of the godly yet would he have us as well assured of our personal and particular going to judgement for the same ends so he would not have us ignorant of his spiritual coming but hope thereupon prepare our selvs thereunto 1 Thes 5.23 and though to take away security make us watchful he would have the day and hour both of our particular and his general judgment unknown unto us yet by such foregoing tokens and Characters as he hath set forth in his word we should learn to know his approaching judgements and commings and order our selves accordingly Matth. 24.32 33. Now learn a Parable of the Fig tree when its branches are yet tender and pntteth forth leaves you know that summer is nigh so likewise you when ye shall see all these things know that it is neer even at the door Against your 15. Article by you revised and here published we have not much to say but what hath been spoken upon those heads and should have had the less if you had left them all standing in statu quo prius And therefore we will here exhibite no articles against them as being more Orthodox then your selves though you hold them not for oracles We have here endeavoured to follow the Councel of St. Jude verse 3. Earnestly to contend for the faith which was once given to the Saints If any will be contentious against the truth we have no such custome nor the Church of God 1 Cor 11.16 But beloved building up your selves in your most holy faith praying in the holy Ghost keep your selves in the love of God looking for the mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ unto eternal life Now unto him that is able to keep you from falling and to present you faultless before the presence of his glory with exceeding joy To the onely Wise God our Saviour be Glory and Majesty Dominion and Power Now and ever Amen Jude 20 21 24 25. FINIS
preaching of Noah 2 Pet. 2.5 or extraordinarily by Angels Dreams Visions Inspirations and the like revealed his will to the Prophets and Apostles of old you are very much mistaken For as Gods arm is not now shortened so neither is his care good will and love towards the sons of men changed He hath of late as elsewhere so in Wirtembergh spoken to a servant of his by an Angel and forewarned them of the return and reinvasion of the Turks to chastise all those parts of Europe for their wickedness And for raising up of Prophets upon special occasion consider these ensuing Scriptures among many others Numb 12.6 If there be a Prophet among you I the Lord will make my self known unto him in a vision and will speak unto him in a dream Where the Lord speaketh of that which is his usual course and practise and that which he will continue to do Isai 59.21 As for me this is my Covenant with them saith the Lord my spirit which is upon thee and my words which I have put in thy mouth shall not depart out of thy mouth nor out of the mouth of thy seed nor out of the mouth of thy seeds seed saith the Lord from henceforth and for ever Amos 3.7 Surely the Lord God will do nothing but he first revealeth his secrets to his servants the Prophets Joel 2.28 29. And it shall come to pass afterwards that I will pour out of my spirit upon all flesh and your sons and your Daughters shall Prophefie and your old men shall dream dreams and your young men shall see visions c. Matth. 28.34 Wherefore behold I send unto you Prophets and wise men and Scribes and some of them yee shall kill c. Rev. 6 9 10 11. Among other things to come John saw when Christ had opened the fift seal under the Altar the soules of them lying which were slain for the word of God and for the Testimony which they held c. and heard that more of them should be slain Now this their Testimony is not onely called the Testimony of Jesus Christ Rev. 12.17 but also the Spirit of prophesie it self Rev. 9 10. Even when Babylon is not onely come to her height but her downfal also there are Apostles and Prophets found in the Church who are called to rejoyce at her overthrow Rev. 18.20 Rejoyce over her thou Heaven and ye holy Apostles and Prophets for God hath avenged you on her see also vers 24. For in her was found the blood of holy Prophets and of Saints and of all that are slain upon the Earth To all which add that of Wisdom 7.27 For shee that is Wisdom being but one can do all things and remaining in her self she maketh all things new and in all ages entring into holy souls she makes them friends of God and Prophets Out of all which and many Scriptures more it is evident that the Lord wil have Prophets in all ages and especially when he is about to bring extraordinary Judgments upon the World in generall and the Churches in speciall and that the last times shall abound most of all with the prophetical Spirit so that these extraordinary ways of Gods revealing himself neither are ceased nor shall determine in the Militant Church Secondly in the third Section you Words are these The Books commonly called Apocrypha not being of Divine inspiration are no part of the Canon of the Scriptures and therefore are of no authority in the Church of God nor to be any otherwise approved or made use of then other humane Writings Where we cannot but wonder at three things First that you should equal those Books to other humane Writings without any discrimination for you know that some humane Writings are prophane some meerly fabulous some obscene some impious some blasphemous and some Atheistical Secondly that you should give the Books in the generall commonly called Apocryphal no preheminence above other humane Writings since you know that they cannot only plead their Antiquity but Gods special preservation that the Church and Saints have bin their Treasurers and Library keepers that they have been bound up and translated in various Languages with the other Oracles of God which by all are acknowledged Canonicall that they have been allowed and appointed to be read not only in private but publickly Nor are you ignorant what an high esteem both Saint Augustine and other Fathers had of them above all humane Writings though they did not hold them coequal every way with those commonly called Canonicall And lastly we marvail that you should use no distinction at all concerning these Books but pass the same censure upon them all alike Since that the Book of Tobit or Tobias is extant in the Hebrew as wel as Greek and Latin the Book of Ecclesiasticus was translated out of the Hebrew text by Jesus the son of Sirach as himself confesseth This Book with the Book of Wisdom breaths forth such a spirit of Wisdom and Holiness that it may be said Non vox hominem sonat that it transcends all humane capacity To say nothing that the words which the Apostle hath Hebrews chap. 1. vers 3. Who being the brightness of his glory and the express Image of his person c. seem to be taken out of the 7 chap. of Wisdom vers 26. these words Hebr. 11.5 That he had pleased God are taken out of Wisd 4.10 compare 1 Cor. 6.2 with Wisd 3.8 More especially the fourth Book of Esdras is acknowledged by Clemens Alexandrinus Faber and many more learned men to be written by inspirement of the Holy Ghost It is owned as Canonicall by diverse holy Prophets of later times Our Saviour cites these words which are written Mat. 23.37 38 How often would I have gathered thy children together even as a hen gathereth her chickens under her wings and ye would not Behold your house is left unto you desolate out of the second Book of Esdras chap. 1. vers 30. Many things shewed to St John in the Revelation are found in that Book It is doubtless a most lively prediction of these last times and the great famine and generall desolation spoken of in the last Chapter which is now in his accomplishment will ere long convince all the world that this Book is or should be Canonicall When you shal shortly see three Emperours at once in Europe one set up by the Pope another by the Princes and People and then the great Turk usurping that place and dignity think upon Esdras his vision of the Eagle with three heads Chap. 11.12 Thirdly Whereas you say in the sixth Section That nothing at any time is to be added to the holy Scriptures of the Old and New Testament whether by new relations of the Spirit or Traditions of men We desire to know what warrant you have thus to determine If you say that Rev. 22 18. it is written that if any man shall add unto these things God shall add unto him the plagues
have spoken in darkness shall be heard in the light and that which ye have spoken in the ear and closets shall be proclaimed upon the house topps Seventhly Whether the Apostle reciteing the parts and holy vessels of the Tabernacle in order Hebr. 9.1 2 3 4 5. and telling us ver 5. of which things we cannot now speak particularly to wit by way of exposition do not imply that a time should come wherein all those things and likewise all other mistical things of the Old and New-Testament should be opened and declared The Holy Scriptures being written for our instruction here upon earth and not in heaven or after this life 8. Whether this Gospel which is to be published to all Nations shall not be written as well as the former was that it may be so published especially since it is called an Everlasting Gospel Rev. 14.6 shall it not be written for the ages to come as the Old and New Testament were before 9. Yea may not those Waters which issued out of the Temple Ezek. 47.1 c. and Joel 3.18 Zach. 14.8 Rev. 22.1 be understood as of all the gifts of the Spirit so of Gods most pure and holy doctrine which shall then proceed from the mouth and pen of the Holy Ghost as is promised Isa 2.2 3 4 c. especially since the Word of God is expresly compared to Water Jo. 15.3 Now are ye clean through the Word which I have spoken unto you Eph. 5.26 That he might sanctifie and cleanse it with the washing of Water by the Word 10. Shall that Spirit of God which is to be powred out in the last dayes upon all flesh lose his writing faculty which he formerly had and used in precedent ages 11. Shall not the Art of Printing or gift of God bestowed upon the last age be made the instrument of Gods Holy Spirit to publish his sacred and infallible Truth as well as it hath been made Satans way of disspreading his falshoods But to conclude this point let us entreat you of the Synod if you have any Germanes sitting among you to enquire of them or others what inspired men or professing to be such even of their Nation have written any Gospel to the whole world within six score yeares last past and whether some one of them hath not written more then all the Books of the New Testament amount to If so it may concern them you and us to finde them out to read them with diligence and earnest prayer to God for true enlightening judgement and guidance to compare and examine them not with the Writings of men bee they who they will but with and by the Holy Scriptures themselves for the Holy Ghost cannot contradict it self If we finde upon due search any such grace and mercy vouchsafed to this last age it may shew the true cause why Germany before and above all other Countreys according to that Acts 3.22 23. hath bin plagued and also afford us a present mean and expedient whereby all controversies in Religion may be decided from Gods own mouth and hold forth a true Modell to reform all Churches and Commonwealths by Sed verbum sat Sapientibus Fourthly and lastly in the tenth Section of this Chapter you say The supreme Judge by which all controversies of Religion are to be determined and all Decrees of Councels opinions of Ancient Writers Doctrines of men and private Spirits are to bee examined and in whose sentence we are to rest can be no other but the holy Spirit speaking in the Scriptures If you had added these words to private Spirits even publique Spirits also or pretending to be such we would have closed with you in that enumeration and have acknowledged that the Holy Ghost yet left at large must be the only supreme Judge to wit either speaking in the holy Scripture or without it although in all his determinations of Doctrine he doth speak according to former Scriptures And hence it is that for the tryall of Spirits in his dayes Isaiah sends men to the Law and the Testimony Isa 8.20 And Saint Paul in his time transmits men to the former Prophets 1 Cor. 14.32 And the Spirit of the Prophets is subject to the Prophets And accordingly for the tryall of new or late professing Prophets we are to examine their Doctrine by the former Writings of the Old and New-Testament but not by our own or our private Authors corrupt and darkned Iudgments For the true Prophets were sent to judg and reprove our Errors and not to be judged or condemned by us 1 Cor. 2.15 The only exception that we take against your tenth and last section is this That you limit the holy Ghost as if he was inherent in the Scriptures or could not determinate without the same when he pleaseth saying It is the holy Ghost speaking in the Scripture Howbeit if you meant no more by that expression then this That the Holy Ghost which first dictated the Scripture or still speakes in them being taken in his own sense We admit it to be true but your exposition there is both obscure and ambiguous CHAP. II. Of God and of the Holy Trinity THere is but one onely a Deu. 6.4 1 Cor. 8.4.6 living and true God b 1 Thess â—9 Jer. 10.10 Who is infinite in Being and Perfection c Job 11.7.8.9 Job 26.14 a most pure Spirit d Joh. 4.21 invisible e 1 Tim. 1.17 without body parts f Deut. 4.15 16. John 4.24 with Luk. 24.39 or passions g Acts 14.11 15. immutable h Jam. 1.17 Mal. 3.6 immense i 1 Ki. 8.27 Jer. 23.23 24. eternal k Psa 90.2 1 Tim. 1.17 incomprehensible l Psal 135.3 almighty m Gen 17.1 Revel 4.8 most wise n Rom 16.27 most holy o Isa 6.3 Revel 4.8 most free p Psal 115.3 most absolute q Exod 3.14 working all things according to the counsel of his own immutable and most righteous will r Ephes 1.11 for his own glory Å¿ Prov 16.14 Rom 11.36 most loving t 1 John 4.8 16. gratious merciful long suffering abundant in goodness and truth forgiving iniquity transgression and sin u Exod 34 6 7. the rewarder of them that diligently seek him w Hebr 11.6 and withall most just and terible in his judgments x Nehem 9.32.33 hating all sin y Psal 5.5 6. and will by no means clear the guilty z Nahum 1.2 3. Exod 34.7 II. God hath all life a Joh 5.26 glory b Acts 7.2 goodness c Psal 119.68 blessedness d 1 Tim 6.15 Rom 9.5 in and of himself and is alone in and unto himself all-sufficient not standing in need of any creature which he hath made e Acts 17.4 25. nor deriving any glory from them f Job 22.2 3. but onely manifesting his own glory in by unto and upon them He is the alone fountain of all Being of whom through
Seventhly If it were for sins what sins did better deserve such a preterition then mens own personal and actual sins yea then their contempt and contumacy against grace offered Eighthly If this preterition was for the praise of God's glorious justice must not his justice first be apparent and conspicuous in this his passing by them But he accounts it neither honorable for him that the Son should die for the sin of the Father Ezek. 10.1 2 3 20. nor yet just for he hath forbidden the self same thing in the Law Deut. 24.16 Lastly Is there no difference betwixt a vessel of dishonor and a vessel of wrath Many vessels are made by the Potter for dishonorable uses yet none of set purpose for destruction Finally Your Caution in the last Section is very good where you say that The Doctrine of the high mystery of Predestination is to be handled with special prudence and care that men attending the will of God revealed in his word and yeelding obedience thereunto may from the certainty of their effectual vocation be assured of their eternal election Where you should have added and from their perseverance in that obedience till the death of sin be assured of their spiritual final and everlasting election there being a twofold election from eternity as hath been said But this caution of yours you your selves have not very well observed and kept And whereas you add in conclusion So shall this Doctrine afford matter of praise reverence and admiration of God and of humility diligence and abundant consolation to all that sincerely obey the Gospel We report our selves to your own consciences and to all men whether your Doctrine or ours here set forth is likely to produce the good effects here by you remembred But now we come in the third and last place to answer such objections as seem to lie as so many rocks of offence in your and other mens wayes Object It is written of Hophni and Phineas the sons of Eli 1 Sam. 2.25 That they hearkened not unto their father because God would destroy them Answ It is true God now had a purpose so to do for their abominable wickedness which they had committed but it doth not follow that the Lord had so decreed from eternity unless it was out of prevision of their lewdness and in order thereunto Object 2. It is written Prov. 16.4 That the Lord made all things for himself even the wicked for the day of â—â—il Answ The first part of the text speaks of God's ends the latter part of the event as it is now fallen out through their own default as Hosea speaks in a like expression Chap 9.13 Ephraim as I saw Tyrus is planteâ— in a pleasant place But Ephraim shall bring forth his children to the murderer that is eventually not industriously and so are the wicked created for the day of evil Object 3. It is said of Rehoboam 2 Chron. 10.15 So the King hearkened not unto the people for the cause was of God that the Lord might perform his word which hâ— spake by the hand of Ahijah the Shilonite to Jeroboam the son of Nebat Answ This Text speaks not of Gods eternal Decree but of his wise and just providence leaving a man sufficiently wicked before to follow his own counsels for a temporal punishment of his own and his Fathers sins Object 4. Jeremiah saith Chap 52.3 For through the anger of the Lord it came to pass in Jerusalem till he had cast them out from his presence that Zedekiah rebelled against the King of Babylon Answ This Scripture imports no more but that wicked Zedekiah for a just punishment of his own and Judah's rebellion against the Lord wat left at length in the hand of his own Counsels to rebel against his Lord and King upon Earth who was able to punish him and did it accordingly Object 5. Mat. 11.25 At that time Jesus answered and said I thank thee O Father Lord of Heaven and Earth because thou hast hid these things from the wise and prudent and hast revealed them to babes Answ This is to be understood of the second grace withholden from those who refused the former and did shut their eies against the first light and so is that place also Deut. 29.4 Yet the Lord hath not given you an heart to perceive and cies to see and eares to hear unto this day For God reveales his secrets to wit his further counsels to them that fear him Psal 25.14 see Matth. 13.12 13 14 15 c. For whosoever hath to him shall be given and he shall have abundance but whosoever hath not from him shall be taken away even that which he hath but useth not as wee see in him that hid his talent Mat. 25. â—â— 19. Object 6. Acts 13.48 It is said that when the Gentiles heard that they were glad and glorified the word of the Lord and as many as were ordained to eternal life beleeved Whence it seems to be clear that some persons are not so ordained Answ The original Text 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is wrested and forced in the translation For it signifies not ordained but prepared or disposed and such onely are they who are good willing to leave their sins and to follow after righteousness according to the requiring of the Gospel Titus 2.11 12. for to such the Angels wish peace and happiness as knowing them onely capable of it Luke 2.14 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Glory be to God on high and in the earth peace to men or in men of good will For so did St. Jerome St. Augustine and many of the Ancients read that Text in their daies and so it is yet found in the best Greek copies Yet we could give another answer if the Text before alledged were 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that is fore-ordained to wit that so many as then and there were out of Gods special fore-knowledge predestinated to life did at that time beleeve which notwithstanding hinders not but that many more yea all there present were appointed to life conditionally as is there partly testified of the unbeleeving Jewes by the Apostle vers 46. Object 7. Rom. 9.6 It is said That they are not all Israel which are of Israel It seems then that all are not elected Answ The Apostle intimates that the carnal Israel or all that are come of Jacob surnamed Israel are not the Israel to whom the promises of salvation are absolutely and finally made Though in the general the conditional promises belong to all Israel as the Apostle shews vers 4. and to the Gentiles also vers 24 25. That we may not be misunderstood know that there are among others seven promises made to the overcomers Revel 2 and 3. Chap. and such as persevere in the Christian race unto the end of it or to the death and burial of sin Now these and the like promises belong unto the Elect that are chosen out of the furnace of affliction
〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in the former place Heb. 1.2 fignifies ages or generations as sometime that word is found to do this last place which clearly speakes of the work of creation having the same word again will evict that the former place speakes of worlds truly so called as it is well and truly rendred in our translation If you reply again that perhaps the Apostle useth the word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as the Rabbins sometimes take the word gnolam gnolam caton for the Microcosme and gnolam gadol for the Macrocosme gnolam hazzeh for this world and gnolam habha for the world to come and the same word again for the lower world that is the earth sometimes for the middle world which is all these visible heavens and lastly for the Angels world or the invisible heavens Answer It may be so yet are these neither one entire world nor were all these things created in the space of six dayes as you untruly affirm First That the Angels world called by our Saviour and the Apostle Paul Paradise Luke 23.43 2 Cor. 12 4. and this present world are not one entire but two remote and distinct worlds it is evident out of the words of our blessed Savior Mat. 12.32 But whosoever speaketh against the Holy Ghost it shall not be forgiven him neither in this world nor in the world to come Luk. 20.34 5.36 And Jesus answering said unto them the children of this world marry and are given in marriage but they that shall be accounted worthy to obtain that world and the resurrection from the dead neither marry nor are given in marriage neither can they die any more for they are equall to the Angels c. Secondly Nor were the Angels and their heavens created within the space of those six dayes wherein all things of this world were made Gen. 1.1 but long before For 1. It is certain that Moses makes no mention of them in the narration and history of those six dayes workes 2. Esdras in his second Book of which we spake before saith expresly Chap. 3.6 That Gods right hand planted Paradise before ever the earth came forward and that he having created man in time did lead him into it Nor doth he alone speak this that the Angels were existent before the creation of this world but the Lord himself also Job 38.4 Where wast thyou when I laid the soundations of the earth and then followes When the morning Stars sang together and the sons of God shouted for joy So that those sons of God who are at all hands confessed to be the Holy Angels were present and glorified God when he laid the first foundation of this world Nor is it improbable which some late prophetical men affirm that man was created in the room of the faln Angels which so much the more stirred up the envy of the Devil against him Certain it is that the wicked Angels were not only pre-existent but had faln also from their first estate before man was created 3. As the Scriptures make frequent mention of the Heavens of Heavens which can be no other then Paradise or the Angels which also are Gods heaven in whom he dwelleth So the Psalmist shews that they were of old Psal 68.33 To him which rideth upon the Heavens of Heavens which were of old Nor can we or you justly reject their opinion who say that as the Angels are in nature nearer to God then the creatures of this gross visible world so he first laid forth himself in them and that many ages before he proceeded to the creation of those things which were remoter and further distant from him But whether the Lord used the ministry of these Spirits in the creation of this world as he doth in the government of the same we will not dispute Howsoever it was the unanimous consent of most of the Greek fathers if not of them all and the assertion of divine Nazianzen in special and of Jerom among the Latines that the creation of Angels did precede the making of this world and that upon these grounds before alledged among many other After you have spoken of this world in general you come to the composure of the creature for whose sake this world was especially made even mankinde where according to holy Scriptures we finde another world not only because man is stiled a Microcosme by â—o contemptible Authors but by reason of an inteâ—â—â— and spiritual world and that far greater and more excellent then this outward Fabrick placed 〈…〉 of which Solomon not a stranger to any of these worlds speaks Eccles 3.11 He hath made every thing beautifull in his season he hath also set the world in their bea rt so that no man can finde out the worke of God from the beginning to the end Which world was Gods Kingdome in the man or the beautifull Image of God upon the inward and outward man as may appear by the promises of God which he hath gratiously given us in Christ for the repairing and re-edifying the same when it was decayed and defaced Esay 51.16 And I have put my words in thy mouth and have covered thee in the shadow of my hands that I may plant the Heavens and lay the foundation of the earth and say unto Zion Thou art my people Esai 65.17 18. For behold I create new Heavens and a new earth and the former shall not be remembred nor come into minde But be yee glad and rejoyce for ever in that which I create for behold I create Jerusalem a rejoycing and her people a joy 2. Pet. 3.13 Nevertheless we according to his promises look for a new heaven and a new earth wherein dwelleth righteousness But the outward heaven and earth of which many understand this place never was nor ever shall be the subject of righteousness for they are irrational yea liveless creatures Nor is this spiritual and glorious workmanship of God though to the world and her wise ones invisible called a world in the Old Testament alone but in the New also Rom. 4.13 For the promise that he should be heir of the world was not to Abraham and his seed through the Law but through the righteousness of faith Now if any hearing of more worlds be sorry with Alexander that he hath taken so much travaile for one growing ambitious to have the other also let him first by faith obedience prayer and all other good means seek to get the inward and spirituall world planted and created in him and upon him by the grace and power of Christ and he may be in the better possibility of the third and highest world and prove an heir of Paradise with the blessed Angels For as the Lord himself proceeded gradually first to that creation which was spiritual and invisible and then to that which was visible and corporeal so let the sons of men now faln and corrupted turn from the outward creature get the inward world of righteousness and holiness and so
that tends this way more then the Prophets their Predecessors or the Prince of the Prophets their Master did in which point all are silent if not cleerly opposite unto you The Lord commanded by Moses that Cities of fefuge should be set apart in all the coasts and habitations of Israel for such persons to flee to as had slain any man at unawares that the avenger of blood should not slay the innocent with a temporal death Deu. 19. c. And will the Lord pursue the innocent seed of Adam and hold them guilty for their Fathers sin perpetrated ere they were born yea will he himself be the avenger of the blood against these innocents Amaziah is commended for his justice and his obedience in that behalf to the Law of the Lord in not slaying the sons of those that murderd his father Joash but only the fathers that did the Villany 2 Ki. 14.5 6. And wil ye Brethren father upon God the fountain of all justice and the Father of mercies a cruelty forbiden in his own Law Deuteronomy 24.16 who was so far from destroying the infants of Nineveh though but an handful compared to the vast harvest of Adams posterity that he spared the whole Cities mainly upon that accompt next after the peoples repentance as he declares unto Jonas who was not a little displeased to see by this means his prediction contradicted or come to nothing Ionah 4.10 11. But having here vindicated the justice and mercy of the Lord from this your putative most putid imputation of the first Adams sin to all his succeeding off-spring as also derived innocency and righteousness in some measure from God the true Author of it instead of propagated corruptioÌ„ to the ensuing generations let us now come to answer such objections as seem to stand in our way or the passage of others who are willing to be brought to the knowledge and imbracement of the truth First here it is objected that the Lord saith Gen 8 21. The imaginations of mans heart are evil from his youth Answer Even as Esau or Edom though he had a birth right yet sold it in his youth to satisfie some strong desires kindled in him So men though created innocent do in the time of temptation and tryal too often and too soon yeeld unto the temptation and sell or forfeit that their innocency and birth right and so their imaginations become evil from their youth but are not so from their birth unless you here understand a spiritual conception and birth in sin by our personal fall Object 2. Job saith chap. 11.4 Who can bring a clean thing out of an unclean not one Answer Job here confesseth that himself was unclean and that ever since his personal fall and therefore he of himself could not bring forth an obedience or righteousness that was clean and pure no nor the adaequate fruits of righteousness which might pass for such before the Lords judgement of a long time though he was holpen by grace for grace is not had all at once Object 3. Job 15.14 15 16. Eliphaz speakes thus What is man that he should be clean and be that is born of a woman that he should he righteous Behold he puteth no trust in his Saints yea the heavens are not clean in his sight How much more abominable and filthy is man which drinketh iniquity like water Answer this is an hy perbolical speech of his tending to the further accusation of Job whom he had more then sufficiently yea very unjustly charged before For first God doth put trust and confidence in his Saints and Angels whom he dayly employeth Secondly The heavens and all other creatures as they come out of the Creators hands are pure and good in his sight And thirdly though some men are so accustomed to sin that they have contracted an hypodropical chirst thereunto yet neither Job of whom he means all this in hypothesie nor any other of the Saints upon earth do drink iniquity like water But suppose all men did so yet it doth not from hence follow that we are all so deeply tainted and corrupted by sin drawn from Adam our first parent For as he corrupted himself by his personal Lapse disobedience so may any other man and so doubtless do all lapsed men do likewise See Psal 14.2 3. The Lord looked down from heaven upon the children of men to see if ther were any that did understand and seek after God They are all gone aside they are all together become filthy there is none that doth good no not one Of this fall and corruption Pilagius unmindfull in pleading mans ability in and of himself still to keep and fulfill the law which Saint Austin grants ought to be done by grace not by corrupt nature The like answer we give to those words of Bildad Job 25.4 5 6. How then can man be justified or how can he be clean that is born of a woman behold even to the Mâ—on and it shineth not and the Stars are not pure in his fight How much less man that is a worme and the son of man who is a worme for as it must be granted that man since his fall cannot by himself be either made just or clean so it is false that the Moon and Stars are not pure in Gods sight Thus Jobs friend would make good their unjust charge against him with false principles and glarifie God with lies for which he is afterwards justly displeased with them as he is with all other that plead for him in a wicked way Job 42.7 The Lord said to Eliphaz the Temanite My wrath is kindled against thee and against thy two friends for ye have not spoken of me the things that as right my servant Job hath Object 4. David saith Psal 51.5 Behold I was shapen in iniquity and in sin did my mother conceive me which words seem expresly to speak of his conception and birth in the corruption by you set forth Answer we would first gladly know of you whether it be not Davids scope in this confession to aggravate his sin But if he here pleadeth the inevitable corruption of nature which you hold forth his words will be found a meere extinuation of his offences if not a throwing of all or most of the blame upon God who had brought him forth so corrupt so averse to all good and so propense to all evil and that without hope of an absolute cure while he was in this world Secondly for the clearing of the truth let us first consider whether David had no other parents but Jesse and his wife and then if he had which is the mother that he here speak of As to the first besides our natural parents we have spiritual Fathers and mothers whether for our begetting in the evil and iniquity or for our regeneration in grace and goodness Concerning our procreation in sin our Saviour speaks thus unto the Jewes Iohn 8.44 Ye are of your father the devil and his
Inâ—rdinate affection evil concupiscence and coveâ—ousness c. This is that Earth which is opposed to be the Heaven of Gods holiness Eccles 5.2 For God is in Heaven and thou upon the Earth For the Lord is present in this outward Earth aswel as we in this Earth all men sin but there are some places in the new Testament also which you oppose us with as first that Luke 17.10 So likewise you when ye have done all these things say ye are â—â—p ofitable servents But this place if well considered makes more against you then for you for our Saviour there implyes that we may do all things which are commanded to wit through his grace yet having so done we are unprofitable servants to God for we have done but our duties and that through grace also and so have added nothing to the Lord. But a second and a grand objection is made out of Rom. 7.14 15 16 17 18 19. c. For the Law saith the Apostle is spiritual But I am carnal sold under sin Answer Although this place is commonly taken as if the Apostle spoke here of his own personal and present estate yet it is certain he did not first because elsewhere speaking of that estate he contradicts what is here spoken by him as 1 Cor. 4.4 For I know nothing by my self but here the person spoken of knowes much evil by himself and Phil. 4.13 I can do all things through Christ which strengtheneth me but he that is here intended though to will is present with him yet findes no means or power to do any good yea that which the Apostle speaks of his present estate chap. 8. of this Epistle to the Romans verse 2. is directly opposite to what is complained of verse 23 of this 7 chapter for in that 23. verse the complaint speaketh thus But I see another law in my members warring against the law of my minde and bringing me into coptivity to the law of sin which is in my members Oh wretched man that I am who shall deliver me from this body of death But Rom. 8.2 Paul saith For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus hath made me free from the law of sin and death what can be more contradictory then this last place is to the former So that of necessity the fist place must be understood of babes in Christ whom Paul here personates instructs and comforts and the latter of his own present condition and victorie as Occumenius and others well observe and what was more usual with the Apostle then to speak of that which concerns others in his own person 1 Cor. 4.6 And these things brethren I have in a figure transferred to my self and Apollos for your sake 1 Cor. 13.11 c. When I was a child I spake as a child c. Thirdly You alledge against us and this truth the words which the Apostle speaks to the Galatians chap. 5. verse 17. For the flesh lusteth against the spirit and the spirit against the flesh and these are contraeâ—y the one to the other so that ye cannot do the things that ye would Here say you the Apostle describes that combat betwixt the flesh and the spirit which must continue while we endure in the body Answer But where do you read that this conflict must last so long The Apostle saith a good space before his death 2 Tim. 47. I have fought a good fight I have finished my course I have kept the faith Were not the Galatians Babes in Christ so young and weak that the Apostle had no sooner left them then they were ready to be drawn away from Christ by the false Apostles See Gal. 1.6 with 3.1 2. Now to make their estate the highest pitch growth of a Christian in this life is as if we should take the scantling of a child and conclude that it is the full stature of mankinde and that no man is or can be of a taller groth Fourthly You object what St. James writes chap. 3.2 For in many things we offend all where you imvolue him and his fellow Apostles in that plural number To which we answer That the Apostle can no more be there implyed then in the 9 verse where he saith again and that plurally With the same tongue we bless God even the Father and with the same tongue we curse men which are made after the similitude of God Was James or the Apostles now of the number of those that still cursed men But it is frequent for lenity sake and in a winning way for the Prophets and Apostles of Christ to speak in the plural and sometimes in the singular number those things which concern not themselves but their hearers onely Nebem 5.10 I pray you let us leave of this usury saith the man of God who was no wayes guilty of that sin Isa 59.10 the Prophet speaketh this We groap for the wall like the blind and we groap as if we had no eyes Lastly It is objected out of 1 John 1.8 That the Apostle saith directly If we say that we have no sin we deceive our selves and there is no truth in us Answer The same Apostle implyes ch 4 17. that he and his fellow Apostles were now without sin Herein is our love made perfect that we might have boldness in the day of Judgement because as he is so are we in this present world There is no fear in love but persect love casteth out fear The Apostle therefore speaks the former words to those that were young in Christ and yet imperfect as is evident chap. 2. verse 1. My little children these things write I unto you that ye sin not c. Yea he explains himself so Chap. 1. verse 10. that he may be safely taken into the number If we that say we have not finned we make him a lyar and his word is not in us And thus much of your first erroneous proposition in your 5th and last Section Your other Thesis wherein you affirm That though this corruption remains in the regenerate during life yet it is actually pardoned is false also and contradictory to these ensuing and many other Scriptures Prov. 28 13. Luke 24.47 Acts 8.20 Acts 26.18 or as we shall shall shew at large chap. 11. by Gods assistance Now for a conclusion of this last Section give us leave to propound these Queries unto you First whether those ten unbeleeving spies did not highly displease God and much hinder injure and prejudice the people which hearkened unto them who cryed that there were such Anakiâ— in the way that they could not be subdued by them and Cities so high that they were walled up to Heaven and therefore not 〈◊〉 be scaled Numb 14. Did not the people too slothful and averse before to fight the Lords battail against the Canaanites become therethrough wholy unbeleeving even despairing of victory and altogether indisposed to the fight enjoyned by the Lord Were not both they and those their leaders
cross by him to reconcile all things unto himself by him I say whether they be things in Earth or things in Heaven And you that were sometimes alienated and enemies in your mind by wicked works yet now hath he reconciled in the body of his flesh to present you holy and unblameable and unreprovable in his fight Where you may take these things into consideration First Whom he reconcileth All the members of the Church who are regenerate Secondly From what from the enmity in their minds whereby they are set upon wicked works Thirdly Where through the spiritual blood of the Covenant or the spirit of grace which is called the blood of his cross because it is then sent unto us and poured down upon us when we are upon the cross with him and suffer with him not yeelding unto temptations Fourthly That Christ is said to be still doing of that work 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Lastly In what way as a precedent for us he hath done it to wit in the body of his flesh through death as these ensuing Scriptures shew 2 Tim. 2.11 12. 'T is a faithful saying for if we be dead with him we shall also live with him if we suffer wiâ—h him we shall also raign with him see Rom. 6.8 But that it is unpossible to have reconcilement and communion with God unless it be in such a way the Apostle witnesses likewise 1 John 1.5 6 7. This then is the message we have heard of him and declare unto you that God is light and in him is no darkness at all If we say that we have fellowship with him and walk in darknesâ— we lye and haue not the truth But if we walk in the light as he is in the light we have fellowship one with another and the blood of Jesus Christ his Son cleanseth us from all Sin Thus far of Christ's spiritual and true reconciling us unto God which is then perfected and consummate when besides the slaying of the enmity aforesaid he hath made us in all things of one spirit with the Father For which unity and reconcilement he prayeth John 17.21 That they all may be one as thou Father art in me and I in thee that they also may be one in us Now for the purchasing of an everlasting inheritance for us eternal life is the free gift of God through Jesus Christ our Lord Rom. 8.23 And as the Father hath it in his hand to bestow so it is in the Sons gift likewise and consequently as it seems to us he needs not to purchase it But if you will call the fulfilling of that way and process whereby the faln man must attain it the way race of obedience aforesaid a purchasing of it it is by the inward and spiritual obedience of Christ especially that we attain Heb. 10.36 For ye have need of patience that after ye have done the will of God ye may receive the promise Howbeit his outward passive obedience was requisite thereunto without which as we could not be delivered from the curse so neither could we come to inherit life By this you see we stand in need of an inward and spiritual mediation from Christ aswel as that outward of which alone you here speak Nor can we partake of the benefit of the outward till qualified and prepared first thereunto by the work of the inward In your Sixth Section you proclaim your great ignorance or small regard of our great and most necessary redemption from the power of sin and Satan saying That the work of redemption was not actually wrought till after Christs incarnation For were not the fathers before and after the flood with the Prophets and other holy Saints in the Old Testament in their respective times spiritually saved and redeemed by Christ And much more doth that great secret of the Father's sparing and forbearing us along time for his Sons sake who in patience and meekness hath been led as a lamb to the slaughter and the end of whose long sufferance in us is salvation as St. Peter speaks Epist 2 3. Chap. 15. seem to be hidden from you Yet here you grant some truths at unawares as that Christ is the promised enmity against sin who must break the Serpents head and consequenly that his power and Kingdom must be within us where Satan is to be trodden down Rom. 16.20 You grant also that he is the Lamb slain from the beginning of the world But whereas you add for a proof thereof out of Hebr. 13.9 That Christ is the same yesterday and to day and for ever That speakes of his immutable Deity and not of his humanity though now made unchangeable Yet this we say brethren ere we leave this Section that you hold forth a very lame and imperfect redeemer which which hath indeed redeemed us by his death from the curse of the Law when our iniquities are put away from us but who must redeem us from all our corruptionsâ— who must save and deliver us out of the hand of all our enemies who must inable us to keep and fulfil the Law of God who must renew the Image of God in us Is not the true Christ made of God unto us wisdom righteousness and sanctification as well as redemption 1 Cor 1.30 In your Seventh Section As we grant it to be true that Christ in the entire office of a Mediator acteth according to both natures joyntly or severally as occasion requires doing by each that which is proper to its self so perhaps it may be granted that sometimes in the Scriptures by reason of the unity of the person that which is proper to one nature is attributed to the person denominated by the other Howbeit the places to which you refer us do not prove so much for that of Acts the 20.28 It s true First of Christ in the Godhead that he hath purchased his Church with his own blood having redeemed it from the power of Satan by his Spirit Secondly To that of John 3.13 it may be said that as Christ is spiritually born in us he is the Son of man which comes from Heaven and is or dwells in the heavenly being Finally To 1 John 3.16 It may be truly answered that Christ the Son of God hath laid down his life for us while he died in us to keep off the deserved wrath of God from us and to preserve us from the death threatned in the Law as also to set us an example how we may in following him overcome sin and recover life again we seeking his grace and help thereunto In your eighth and last Section being like checquer-work you have black as well as white errour as well as truth where your first affirmation That Christ doth certainly and effectually apply and communicate his redemption to all those for whom he hath purchased it will prove false in what sense soever it be taken For first If we here understand Christ's outward redemption as you undoubtedly do that being made for
perverseness he saith But none that is very few of the stubborne ones saith where is God my maker who giveth songs in the night Who teacheth us all mankinde more then the beasts of the earth and maketh us Wiser then the foul of Heaven How can the wicked say to the almighty Job 21.11.22 17. depart frou us we desire not the knowledge of thy wayes if he were not present with them at times teaching rebuking drawing and calling them that he might turn them to him yea with their wills from their wiked and destructive wayes doth not wisdom utter her voice to all the fallen race of mankinde Prov 8.4 5. Unto you O men I call and my voice is to the sons of men O ye simple understand wisdom and ye fools be ye of an understanding heart yea is not her invitation as universal and particular also Prov. 9.4 11. as the call and seductive allurements of folly is verse 16. for each of them useth the self-same words Whoso is simple let him turn in hither c. yea what is the true cause that wisdome saith Prov. 1.28 29. Then shall they call upon me but I will not answer they shall seek me early but they shall not finde me But this which followeth there verse 29 30 31. For that they bated knowledge and did not chuse the fear of the Lord They would none of my counsel they despised all my repreof Thus of our first assertion come we now to the second That some of those which stand out are more earnestly and industriously called by the Lord then many true converts which continue stedfast with the Lord for which purpose take these places First Gods gracious and effectual dealing with Cain when his wrath and envy was kindled against his brother What could the Lord without offering violence to his will do more to him then he did saying Gen. 4.6.7 Why art thou wrath And why is thy countenance fallen If thou dost well shalt thou not be accepted and if thou dost not well sin lieth at the door And then it follows as one both judicious and skilful in the original hath it Idque a te pendebit tuque ei imperabis And in thee shall be the will or desire of it and thou shalt have dominion over it viz. if thou wilt seek that grace Did not the Lord also complain that he had striven with the men of the old world till he was weary again Gen. 6.3 And the Lord said my spirit shall not alwayes strive with man for that be also is flesh yea were not their spirits or human souls cast into the prison of Hell for their disobedience and refractoriness 1 Pet. 3.19 20 doth not the Lord say also Isa 5.4 What could have been done more to my vineyard which I have not done unto it Wherefore when I looked that it should bring forth grapes brought it forth wild grapes you will say Is not God almighty Could he not have compelled them Answer Yes but he will not violate the order which he hath set in our creation he will not force the will but deals with man as a free agent by commands promises threatnings rebukes chastisements allurements and rewards So true is that of the Father Nemo invitus fit bonus To conclude this point what can be more express then those three ensuing texts among many others Ezek. 3.6 7. Thou are not sent to many people of a strange speech and of an hard language whose words thou canst not understand Surely had I sent thee to them they would have hearkened unto thee but the house of Israel will not hearken unto thee c. Matth. 11.21 Woe unto thee Chorazin woe unto thee Bethsaida for if the mighty works which were done in thee had been done in Tyre ond Sidon they would have repented long ago in sackcloth and ashes Of which text we spake before upon the last occasion Finally That of Matth. 12.21 brings full conviction with it The men of Niuive shall rise in judgement with this generation and condemn it because they repented at the preaching of Jonah and behold a greater then Jonah is here If you demand here what 's the cause that these obstinate men do not answer Gods call and return We answer It is not want of illumination and instruction as we have shewed nor want of reproof as we have proved but this let lies in mens abuse of their free-will as we heard before Prov. â— 29 30. Not that mens wils are inflexible when God first cals them as we have evicted at large in the foregoing chapter but some men are self wise and self-righteous already through the illusion of Satan and think that they need no repentance or conversion to any better thing aâ— the Scribes and Pharisees were in the daies of our Saviour who taught them with power and authority Matth 7.29 and whose doctrine was confirmed sufficiently by miracles also And others which know and acknowledge that they are evil doers yet do defer their return till it be too late as Prov. 1.28 29. Psal 32.6 aforesaid Hence it is that they shall be filled with weeping and mourning for the opportunity which they have lost as the other shall be with envy and gnashing of teeth the concomitant of pride and self-wisdom Matth. 8.12 Luke 13.25 26 27 28. And these are Satans two wayes of destroying men he either casts them into the sin of contention wrath and envy through the riches of their self knowledge self-holiness and self zeal or into the stolen and pleasant waters of voluptuousness or worldly cares therein detaining them till they be drowned in sensuality see Mark 9.22 But now to return to our first task back again The third falshood which you affirm in you first Section is That God calleth all his predestinate only by his Word and Spirit where we must grant you that his Spirit is alwayes the cheif actor and that oft times God is pleased to use his word whether written or spoken as an instrument in that work but not alwayes as yourselves after confess Section the third Besides the Lord hath many other instruments and means to call and convert men besides his word as Elihu shews at large Joh. 33.14 29. of which also we speak before Yet are none more general or more effectual then Gods chastisments both inward and outward Psal 94.10 He that chashseth the Heathen shall not he correct Psal 119 67. Before I was afflicted I went astray but now have I kept thy word For whomsoever God loveth as he loveth all mankinde he chasteneth and scourgeth every son whom be receiveth Heb. 12.6 7 8 9 10. see Job 5.17 Behold happy is the man whom God correcteth therefore despise not thou the chasining of the Almighty Pro. 3.11.12 Psal 94.12 13. Isa 27.7 8 9. Isa 9.13 Isa 28.23 24 25 c. 38.16 By this was Pharaoh wrought to obey the will of God for the present though he afterwards rebelled and perished If this will not
13. Matth 28.19 20. Isa 59.21 IV. This Catholick Church hath been sometimes more sometimes less visible h Rom. 3.4 Revel 12 6 14. And particular Churches which are members thereof are more or less pure according as the Doctrine of the Gospel is taught and imbraced Ordinances administred and publick Worship performed more or less purely in them i Rev 2.3 Chapters 1 Cor 5 6 7. V. The purest Churches under Heaven are subject both to mixture and errour k 1 Cor 13.12 Rev 2.3 Chapters Matth. 13.24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31. and some have so degenerated as to become no Churches of Christ but Synagogues of Satan l Rev 18.2 Rom 11.18 19.20 21 22. Nevertheless there shall be alwayes a Church on earth to worship God according to his will m Matth 16.18 Psa 72.17 Psal 102.28 VI. There is no other Head of the Church but the Lord Jesus Christ n Col 1.18 Ephes 1.22 nor can the Pope of Rome in any sense be head thereof but is that Antichrist the man of Sin and son of Perdition that exalteth himself against Christ and all that is called God o Matthew 23.8 9 10. 2 Thes 2 3 4 8 9. Rev 13 6. CHAP. XXV Of the Church examined YOur Doctrine of the Church here exceeds not the state of the Churches whereof you speak Section the fifth saying That the purest of them under heaven are subject to mixture and error Yet in your first Section you begin well with a tolerable description of the universal Church in heaven and earth where notwithstanding you are mistaken in making this congregation wholly invisible which is but so in part and to some men And secondly in making it to consist of the whole number of the elect whereas we have proved before that all men are ordained to life though but conditionally But if you understand by elect those only who are called out of the furnace and chosen from thence then is your congregation defective for infants who dyed in infancy and are no smal part of this blessed number will hereby be excluded we say nothing to your calling of the Church the Spouse of Christ because she is one of his brides yea among all other people the Spouse of Christ yet there is another thing which is his first and principal Spouse to wit the Jerusalem or Kingdom of God which descendeth from heaven of which we spake before See Rev. 21.2 And I John saw the holy City New Jerusalem comming doâ—â— from God out of Heaven prepared as a Bride adorned for her husband In your Second Section you faile much more First in going about to speak of the Catholike Church upon earth and fastning upon her a fals name and property or adjunct in that you call her the visible Church wherein besides that you close with Papists in that appellation you both shew your gross mistakes for is the husband invisible and the wife visible Is the head invisible and the body visible See John 15.21 Now all these things will they do unto you for my names sake because they have not known him that sent me where was that possibility of the Church even in the new Testament for the space of 1260. dayes or yeers all which time the woman that brought forth the man child Christ which parturient or the Church did hide her self in the wilderness Rev. 12.5 6 c. if you say first That they are visible in the body we answer what markes have they in the outward man to distinguish them from others especially from formalists and hypocrites If you reply again That they are visible and discernable to those that have spiritual eyes We answer that even the invisible God is so in some measure to those men but this is to make them intelligible and spiritually discernable but not visible The work that makes them a Church is invisible 1 Cor. 2.15 But be that is spiritual judgeth or discerneth all things yet is he judged or discerned of none Secondly In this Section you describe a formal not a true Church when you make it to consist of men professing Religion which thing formalists and hypocrites may do Thirdly whereas by way of limitation you add professing the true Religion you still leave us in suspence For as the true Church fled into the wilderness Rev. 12. so you leave us in a wood to finde her out for do not every kind and sort of Religious people account their Religion to be the true Religion not only the Papists Lutherans and Calvinists do so in the West but the Greek Churches the Jews yea the Turkes hold their professed Religion to be right We say nothing here of the manifold and different Sects among Christians each of which maintain their Religion to be the only true Religion where then shall we pitch to finde your true Church But the true Church especially that of adult men as the very name 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 imports is a Congregation or collection of those who are truly called or in some measure sanctified 1 Cor. 1.2 To the Church which is at Corinth to them that are sanctified in Jesus Christ called to be Saints c. from which we do not exclude the Infants of them or others dying before they sin actually since our Saviour saith expresly that Of such is the Kingdom of God Mat. 10.14 out of which numbers and societies there is ordinarily no possibility of salvation In your third Section you build upon a false and rotten foundation which you had laid in the former Section For it is not to that visible and formal Church which you describe but to the congregation of true Saints that God hath given the ministery and his oraâ—les and ordinances in the right use of them And to those he hath given those offices and gifts which you will not now admit as some to be Apostles some Prophets some Evangelists c. Eph. 4.9 10 11. yea and the spirit of Prophecy as we have proved before as the placeâ— which you refer us unto of Esay 59.21 with Mattheâ— 28.19 20. Ephesians 4.9 10 11 12. do evict But it is true which you say in the beginning of your fourth Section That the Catholike Church hath sometimes been more visible and sometimes less if you understand it of discernableness otherwise it hath been alwayes invifible to carnal men And particular Churches as you afterwards there assert are more or less pure according as the doctrine of the Church is taught and imbraced and Gods ordinances administred but what you add in the close concerning the pure performing of publick worship is a dream since Christ hath appointed none in the new Testament But herein we will joyn with you if you will alter your words and say So far as the true worship of God consisting in holiness and righteousness of truth is observed for that makes a true Church or society of worshipers Luk. 1.74 75. John 9.31 Act. 10.34 35. Eph. 4.22
and Psal 34.9 O fear the Lord all ye his Saints for there is no want to them that fear him Secondly there are Saints in God the Son who are called to know him and believe on him for salvation from their spiritual enemies deliverance from the curse Jude 1. To them that are sanctified by God the Father and preserved in Jesus Christ and called which is the common Classis of the Saints in the new Testament Rom. 1.6 7. 1 Cor. 1.2 And thirdly there are Saints in the holy Ghost as the Apostles were made in the day of Pentecost when they were filled with the holy spirit of promise Act. 2.1 2 3 c. Secondly All those have neither the same degree of fellowship with God nor with each other but have their respective communion either with the father alone as the first or with the Father and the Son as the second or with the Holy Ghost also and so with the whole Trinity as the third John 14.25 Jesus answered and said unto him If a man love me he will keep my words and my Father will love and we will come unto him and make our abode with him See 1 John 1.3 4 5. And as the Saints have different degrees of communion with God according to their several ages and growth so they all have not alike fellowship with each other in communicating spiritual guifts for the Saints in Christ Jesus can condiscend to those in God the Father and those in God the Holy Ghost can stoop to both the other to do them service but the first cannot communicate much in spiritual things to the second nor either the first or second to the third though all may in outward things be serviceable to each other upon earth These things premised for order and distinction sake We finde then in your first Section these three errors First That you make none to be Saints but those that are actually united unto Jesus Christ their head hereby excluding out of that number and communion all those who as yet are onely bgotten by God the Father as were Cornelius Act. 10.1 2 3. and many other Secondly You untruly affirm that all those which are united to Christ by his spirit and saith have actual communion in his sufferings death resurrection and glory for none of them have fellowship in his resurrection and glory till they be dead with him and that the holy Ghost be poured down from Heaven upon them as he was upon the Apostles Act. 2. See Ro. 6 5. For if we have been planted in the likeness of his death we shall be also in the likeness of his resurrection 2 Tim. 2.11.12 neither have all that beleeved in Christ for the present proceeded so far as to suffer with him and much more to pertake with him in his death he is a good proficient in Christianitie that knows what Christ hâ—th suffered in him and for him and is come to suffer with him not onely outward afflictions but inward sorrows in resisting temptations without yeelding to them in their solicitations wherein lies the main part of our fellowship of Christs sufferings And as for our becomming wholly dead with Christ you your selves hold it a thing not fully attainable in this life wherin you greatly wrong the grace and power of Christ in his saving work and office and are not onely injurious to others who give ear unto you but fall short of that happy conquest and salvation ensuing which is held forth unto you in the Gospel almost everywhere as hath been shewed before See Luke 1.74.75 Rom. 6.5 and 14. Ephes 5.25 26 c. Titus 2.11 12 13. Rev. 16.7 11 17.26 and Revel 7.14.15 c. And thirdly you here make no distinction betwixt interest and actual communion where you say That the Saints have communion in each others graces which is true of the first not of the last where the place which you cited out of Epbes 2.5.6 speaks of the Apostles high attainments rather then of the present state of the Ephesians and other common beleevers In your second Section you seem tacitely first to imply that there are two sorts of Saints the one by profession onely such as the members of your Church Catholick were in your former Chapter and some that are really such but we are sure that the Lord admits of no Saints for his Church or people but such as are truely sanctified and continuing such he rejects them not Secondly You truly say that Saints are bound to maintain an holy communion in the worship of God but this must be understood with diverse limitations to fence it from error For first it must not be Saints living remotely from each other Secondly It holds not concerning an outward worship unless the Church set up one that is pious and profitable or lawful at the least for Christ himself hath instituted no such worship as we said before Thirdly Yet must all the Saints wheresoever they live joyn in one true spiritual worship of the living God in his living righteousness Lastly We grant notwithstanding that such as conveniontly can come together ought as frequently as their occasions and safety will bear to meet together for the edification and comfort of each other and especially if the Christian Magistrates and spiritual Governours command such meetings But the residue of this Section about the relief of the Saints is sound and good In your third and negative Section you truly and upon good grounds disavow two things First That the Saints are coequal with Christ for no creature in his highest perfection can be equal to Christ the one being finite the other infinite in his divine essence And Secondly that the Communion of Saints upon Earth doth not abolish no nor infringe the title or propriety which each man hath in his goods and possessions which is clearly imported in those Scriptures of Exod. 20.15 Ephes 4.28 and Acts 5.4 which you point us unto as also in many other places of the Old and New Testament But whether that estate which the Saints attain at length when with the Apostle they are raised up together with Christ and made sit together with him in the Heavenly places or things Ephes 2.5 6. be a bare quality or accident or whether it be a spiritual life power and substance we will not dispute sure we are the Apostle calls it the divine nature 2 Pet. 1.4 and our Saviour or Wisdom calls it substance in one notion or other Prov. 18.21 And I will cause them to inherit substance whatsoever that estate is the Platonists called him that had attained it not onely 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 but 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a deified man and not onely some of the modern but even of the ancient writers of the Church use the word codeifying in a good sense of such as are made pertakers of the Divine nature according to the capacity of creatures CHAP. XXVII Of the Sacraments SAcraments are holy Signes and Seales of the
to â— the end with Inde verse 23. IV. For the better attaining of those ends the Officers of the Church are to proceed by admonition suspension from the Sacrament of the Lords supper for a season and by excommunication from the Church according to the nature of the crime and demerit of the person d 1 Thess 5.12 2 Th 3.6 14 15. 1 cor 5.4 5 23. Matth. 18.17 Thus 3.10 CHAP. XXX Of Church Censures examined HERE Brethren if we first agree what the true Church is that have power to censure and then who are those Governours or Superiours in whose hand especially that power lies we shall not we hope be thought over censorious in other things It is true then which you speak in the first Section That the Lord Jesus is King and head of his Church and of no other though the Lord of all creatures and such an head he is both of the universal Church whether upon Earth alone or in Heaven also and of each particular Church yea of every member of those Churches which are in Christ or are brought to beleeve on him obey and serve him in holiness and righteousness of truth but those Saints or Churches which are onely begotten in God the Father and not as yet taught led to the Son have the Father only for their Head and king for the present It is true also That Christ appointed a Government distinct from that of the Civil Magistrate in and for his true Church which consists not of formalists and outward professors for the greatest part but of true Saints which obey and follow Christ daily in his active and passive obedience but he hath ordained no such thing in his Gospel for national and visible Churches whose religion stands in outward professions and formalities mainly or onely Therefore the outward Government of such Churches whether Episcopal or Presbyterian or mixt of both are but prudential and humane although it is evident out of both the Epistles to Timothy that to Titus and many other Scriptures that there ought to be not onely a Presbytery or joynt society of Elders in compleat congregations of such Saints but if they be great a superintendent Bishop over them if we will follow the constitution and patern of Christ and his Apostles in the pure Primitive Churches so that both these in their right State were Jure Divino Thirdly It is not to be denied that this Government is left or to be placed in the hands of some special members or society of the Churches rightly called and constituted but we rather call those Governours or Overseers with the Apostles then Officers as you do for that word among Governours signifies Agents Instruments and Ministers under others or inferiours rather then Superiours Howbeit Christ hath thousands of Saints in several nations which living dispersedly here and there either conveniently cannot or actually do not reduce themselves into one or more Congregations and so want the benefit of that Government and other means of comfort and edification likewise And this is the common state of the Saints in Europe and elsewhere who nevertheless are members of the invisible and true Church of Christ we know notwithstanding that there are some Congregations that by consent meet together and erect a Government among themselves the greatest part of which are but formalists and as their Doctrines and Administrations are none of the purest so their Government is but arbitrary or prudentiall also But here Brethren you are very defective in three things among others First In not shewing what Officers or Governours each true Congregation in Christ should have Secondly By whom they should be chosen And thirdly By whom the respective censures of the Church should be administred For the first we find That a compotent congregation in one City or place had their Elders as Teachers Councellors and Rulers appointed over them Act 14.23 And when they had ordained them Elders in every Church c. we read also Acts 6.16 That when the number of the Disciples was increased at Jerusalem and some of the widows had been neglected in the daily ministration of almes and distributions there were Deacons men of honest report and full of the holy Ghost and of wisdom chosen to be both treasurers and dispensers of the almes and so were assistants to the Apostles and Elders of the Church in providing for the poor especially yet did they upon occasion declare the true Faith and Doctrine of Christ also And afterward in the absence of the Apostles there were superintendent Bishops set over the great Churches as James at Jerusalem Acts 21.18 And the day following Paul went in or unto James and all the Elders were present and Tymothy at Ephesus as appears out of the tenor of both the Epistles writ unto him by St. Paul and the subscription to the second And finally Titus over the Churches in Crete a very spacious Iland Titus 1.5 As to the second thing the Elders and Officers of the Church are not to be chosen by the congregation but by the Superiours both in growth and place and such as were first called and chosen by the Lord. Thus Paul and Barnabas ordained Elders in all the Churches which they had converted as before Acts 14.23 and the superintendent Bishops had the same power Titus 1.15 For this cause left I thee in Greet that thou shouldst set in order the things that are wanting and ordain Elders in every City See 1 Timothy 3. throughout 1 Timothy 5.22 And though the Apostles gave leave to the congregation to chuse out wise and faithful men of which things they could judge to be trusted with the keeping and dispensing of the treasures of the Church under themselves especially as almoners yet they gave them that authority by laying their hands upon them Acts 6.2 3 4 5 6. Nor doth it follow from hence that the Congregation of Saints should choose their Teachers and Elders and much less that the Vulgar in every Parish should make their Election of ministers for then there would be many a weak if not a wild and mad choice in too many places or Parishes As to the third the Elders are to be admonished or rebuked by the Bishop 1 Timothy 5.1 19 20. the Elders are to be suspended by those who ordained them to wit the Bishop and Presbytery 1 Timothy 4.14 2 Timothy 1.6 The common people are to be admonished according to their several ages and degrees either by the Bishop 1 Timothy 5.1 2 3 or by the other rulers and Elders Or finally By the Congregation 1 Timothy 5.14 15. but excommunication or delivering up to Satan should be executed by the whole body though considered and resolved upon by the Bishop and Elders first 1 Cor. 5.3.4.5 and the like we say of absolution or receiving into the Church again 2 Cor. 21.12 These things premised we may admit that which you speak of the committing of the keyes of the Kingdom of Heaven in your
fal for so they then begin to be True it is that the great wickedness which the Psalmist complains of in his enemies and the persecutors of Gods people Psal 14 1 2. and Psal 36.1 2 c. as also that which Isaiah confesseth to God Chap. 59.2 3 4 c. is to be sound in too many and that not alone in those that are meer strangers unto God but in many members of the visible Church and therefore the Apostle applies those sayings to the Jews to prove them guilty of sin and death as well as the Gentiles Rom. 3.9 10 But though it must of necessity be granted which the Apostle affirms there afterwards Rom. 3.23 That all both Jews and Gentiles since the fall have sinned and come short of the glory of God Yet it will not follow from hence that all are alike deeply corrupted as they imply And this is your second mistake in this Section Lastly Whereas you say in the close of this Section That all actual transgressions do proceed from this original corruption of which you here speak It is false undoubtedly For Satan tempts men to many sins whereunto they have no previous inclination and suggests unto some of Gods servants such blasphemies as they abhor so far are they from being natural or familiar to them cannot that subtile powerful adversaries now tempt men aswel without corrupt inclinations as he did our first parents in their innocency Lastly to take a view of your fifâ—h Section you do not only affirm gross untruths there but seem to contradict your selves also As first That this corruption of nature doth remain in the regenerate during this life of which afterwards And then you adde Though it be in Christ both pardoned and mortified What do you say brethren Is it mortified by Christ and yet doth it remain Secondly Is it pardoned and yet doth it abide still in us For the first of these must it remain in us all our life time when then must it be quite purged out Must it be done in Purgatory hereafter or must men carry the remainders of sin with them into Gods Kingdom whereinto no unclean thing can enter Rev. 21.27 Surely you did not foresee what a world of absurdities would follow hereupon Must we not be implanted into the similitude of Christs death his total death that we may be implanted into the likeness of his resurrection Rom. 6.5 Certainly as the pattern was not a bare wounding or an half death in Christ so must our mortification be no less then a full death likewise Can Christ also be frustrate of the end of his coming who gave himself for his Church that he might sanctifie and cleanse it with the washing of water by the word That he might present it to himself a glorious Church not having spot or wrinckle or any such thing but that it should be holy and without blemish Ephes 5.25 26 27. Since this washing as the Apostle speaks must be by the water of the word surely it must be effected in this life Thirdly Is corruption a thing so well pleasing to God and his Chirst that he will not depart with it or wholly lose the presence and society of it See 2 Cor. 6.14 15 16. For what fellowship hath righteousness with unrighteousness and what communion hath light with darkness and what concord hath Christ with Belial and what agreement hath the temple of God with Idols Is not sin and corruption an enemy to Christ as well as death Now the Apostle faith That the last enemy which shall be destroyed is death If death then be the last enemy then of necessity sin must be destroyed before But since you are wont to object many things against this Let us take a view of your objections First you say That as the Canaanites were left to prove the faith and obedience of the Israelites Judg. 3.1 so the Lord in the beginning of our regeneration leaves many corruptions to exercise our faith love and obedience likewise Answer It is true that they are left at the first for that end But would the Lord have them alwayes to continue in us On no For as the Lord was displeased with his people Israel for permitting those Nations still to dwel among them when they should have subdued them or cast them out Judg. 2.1 2. so will the Lord be highly offended with us if we roote not out these wicked Nations through the help of his Christ 1 Cor. 15.25 It is certain that David a man after Gods own heart subdued all the Canaanites so that when Solomon succeeded him there was neither enemy left nor evil occurrent 1 King 5.4 And so hath Christ the promise that all his enemies shall be his foolstoole Psal 110.1 Acts 2 34. Yea he is given to us for our final deliverance from them and conquest over them Luk. 1.71 John 3.8 Secondly You say That corruption is lest to keep us humble least we grow proud Answer If all corruption were purged out what should become of pride Are not the Angels and Saints in Heaven most humble Thirdly you alledg that which Salomon speakes 1 King 1.48 's For there is no man that sinneth not Answer peradventure it may be granted that there is no man that ordinarily lived to mans estate who hath not often sinned Christ excepted Howbeit it doth not follow from hence that the regenerate shall always do so for St. John 1 Epist cap. 2. ver 1. writes to the Saints not to sin see also cap. 4. vers 17. Fourthly You are wont to urge that place Prov. 20.9 who can say I have made my heart clean I am pure from my sin Answer First that kind of interrogation doth not always imply a nullity but sometimes a paucity onely as Isa 53.1 who hath beleeved our report Secondly No man can say that he hath done this by his own strength Fifthly Some also object that place Prov. 24.16 the righteous falleth seven times and riseth again Answer The words following shew that this is to be understood of affliction not of sin which words are these But the wicked fall into mischief Sixthly That place Eccles 7.20 is much insisted upon For there is not a just man in the earth which doth good and sinneth not which place may be three wayes answered and yet the saying hold true First That though there were no such man in Solomons time being the infancy of the Church yet after-times might bring forth many such when a fuller dispensation of grace should come James 4.6 and Hebr. 11.40 God having provided some better things for us that they without us should not be made perfect Secondly It is not improbable that there hath been no man in any age Christ excepted who hath not sinned or done that which is good continually as we said before Thirdly There is an Earth of sin and corruption in which there is no man but sinneth often Colos 3.5 Martifie therefore your members which are upon earth Fornication Vncleanness