by this key The accomplishment and actual donation of this power God remitteth by the Churches act The form of Priestly ordination Heresie of the Novatians denying in the Church power to reconcile Penitents Seed and bellows thereof austerity of those times Absolution in the Priest not absolutely efficacious but as relating to conditions in the Penitent the Priest not secured from failing in the act of absolution The erring key Priestly absolution declarative and demonstrative and in a moral sense energetical Judgments forinsecal are applied declarations of the Law to the fact Absolution a Ministerial act but powerful and judicial but not Soveraign nor despotical The spirit of judgment to discerne and determine how necessary for Priests in the act of absolution Fathers making Priests Judges of the Conscience The exercise of the keys 1. In the word of reconciliation 2. In prayer ancient formes of absolution expressed in a deprecative manner not indicative 3. In the Sacraments 4. In interdictions and relaxations of publick Censures Keys abused at Rome Dangerous to Soveraign Majesties and Republicks The superciliousness of Roman Priests in Usurping upon Divine right subjecting the power of forgiveness in God to their arbitrements Their preposterous way in absolving first and afterwards in enjoyning Penance The feigned virtue of absolution Ex opere operato destructive of piety and penitency Conditions requisite in the Penitent to be relieved by the keys and lawfull use of absolution 3. Persons Tibi dabo IN the next place it comes to be considered who the persons are to whom this Commission is directed the Trustees to whose charge this power is deposited Some throw it open too far extending it to all Christians which if so what need of special offices and functions in the Church He gave saith the Apostle some Apostles Ephes 4.11 some Prophets and some Evangelists and some Pastors and Teachers Now if all are Pastors and all Teachers then not some and if some are Apostles and some Prophets then not all Others shrink it up and confine it unto Peter or if to his Successors such as they appoint entailing it upon those that sit in the Chaire at Rome But if none but that Chaire be Apostolical Hoc modo Ecclesiae Apostolicae census suos deferunt sicut Smyrnaeorum ecclesia babens Polycarpum à Joanne conlocatum refert sicut Romanorum Clementem à Petro ordinatum edit Tert. advers haeres praescript cap. 32. Tertullian was mistaken in affirming the Chaire of Polycarpus at Smyrna to be Apostolical and instituted by John Christus Apostolis omnibus post resurrectionem suam parem potestatem tribuit Cypr. de unit eccles Universam significabat ecclesiam Aug. tr 124. in Joan. Ecclesia quae fundatur in Christo claves ab eo regni coelorum accepit in Petro i. e. potestatem ligandi solvendique peccata Id. as well as the choire of Clemens at Rome ordained by Peter and Cyprian in writing how Christ after his Resurrection bestowed the power upon all the Apostles and Saint Augustine that Peter at that time represented the whole Church and againe the Church founded upon Christ received the keys of the kingdome of heaven that is the power of binding and loosing by Peter And Theophylact All they have the power of remitting and binding that have obtained the sacred function of a Bishop 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Theoph. in Matth. 16. p. 94. Paris 1635. as well as Peter for albeit it was said unto Peter onely I will give to thee yet the keys were given to all the Apostles It is the Inheritance of the Church to whose use Peter was seised of these keys and the power executed by all that succeed in the function of Priesthood nor can Peter boast herein to have been anointed with any oyl above his fellows But withall as this oyl descended from Aarons beard to the skirts of his garment so it condescendeth no further for omni soli sacerdoti to all the Priests and to them onely is this authority conferred and confined To this purpose the Oracle of our Divines Bishop Andrews resolveth Serm. of Absolution the Apostles to be three wayes considerable 1. as Christians in general so it was said unto them Vigilate watch 2. or else as Preachers Ministers Priests so it was said Ite praedicate hoc facite Go and preach and Do this Mark 13. ul◠c. 3. or lastly as Apostles and so personally They were to be witnesses of his miracles and Resurrection Now the power of absolution was not peculiar to them as Apostles nor common as Christians but committed to them as Preachers Ministers Priests and consequently to those that in that function and office do succeed them yet not so committed unto them as if God could not work without them for Gratia Dei non alligatur mediis the grace of God is not bound but free can work without means of Word or Sacrament or Ministers either but ordinarily this is an Ecclesiastical act or course by him established the Ministery of reconciliation to Ecclesiastical persons And if God at any time vouchsafeth by Lay-men that are not such they are Ministri necessitatis non officii in case of necessity Ministers but by office not so Hitherto are Mentis aureae verba bracteata the grave resolves of that learned Prelate at the feet of this Gamaliel we sit and take these Dictates 1. The Apostles received power to absolve as Priests and Ministers of the Gospel and so those that succeed them in that calling 2. That God can and doth remit sins by himself immediately without any subordinate means at all 3. That this power conferred upon Ministers is an ordinary and Ecclesiastical act 4. And that Lay men taking unto themselves this power are Ministers in case of necessity onely and not usual nor called to that office Hereupon saith Ambrose This right is onely permitted unto the Priests Jus hoc solis permissum est Sacerdotibus rectè igitur ecclesia vendicat quae veros Sacerdotes habet Ambr. de Poen l. 1. c. 3. therefore the Church may truly pretend thereunto that hath true Priests The Church then includeth Priests and Priests absolution The poor Christians in the Vandalick persecution were sensible hereof for when the Orthodox Clergis were exiled by the Arrians the People casting themselves at their feet Victor Uticens lib. 2. cried out To whom will you leave us wretches while you go forward to your Crown Who shall Christen these sucklings in the font of the everlasting water Who shall impart unto us the benefit of penance by reconciling and indulgence absolving us from the bands of our sins The Laity could not be in such distress if the grace of absolution had not been inherent in the person of the Priests and ready to go into banishment with them Furthermore the words of absolution cannot have the same power from the lips of a Lay-brother as from them whom God hath made able
to care for none of these things and do drive the attenders from these judgment seats But if no disease be more deadly than sin and no law hath so powerful an avenger as God it will follow no ordinance to be more acceptable and necessary than that which reconciles the loft favour of God unto the transgressors of his laws Thou then whosoever thou art that disesteemest the power of God in the Ministery of his Priests be first without sin before thou cast the first stone against it and except thou beest exempted from common infirmities vilifie not these Physicians It is not the least of Satans subtilties to weaken this ordinance in many mens estimations as no useful institution of God but an usurpation of the Prelates serving more to establish their tyrannie over the peoples consciences than to quiet and pacifie them and as the Priests are too supercilious to prescribe so the people may be too superstitious to observe thus the Serpent by degrees hath brought this laudable practice first out of credit and next out of use for the most part and so highly that by many transported with impudence the Priest is questioned as Moses was by the Hebrew Quis te constituit Judicem Exod. 2.14 Who hath made thee a Prince and Judge over us though his intents be onely to part the fray betwixt God and the sinner and set them at peace as Moses betwixt his countrey-men And as Korah and his complices said to Moses and Aaron Ye rake too much upon you Numb 16.3 seeing all the congregation is holy and the Lord amongst them So is the Ecclesiastical Hierarchy traduced by our modern Schismaticks for Vsurpation Matth. 12.14 for Tyrannie for Lording it over Gods inheritance Are not all the Brethren Saints why do you Prelates then lift up your selves above them Saints let them be is there not principality amongst Saints as well as amongst Divils But are not all Gods people a royal Priesthood why do you Priests arrogate unto you any prerogative above your fellows to such tender ears the very name of absolution is odious and the keys themselves disliked because born cross-wise at Rome lest therefore such Monsieurs les Greffiers question us as the Scribes did our Saviour By what authority doest thou these things We will clear the coasts and evidence these disquisitions 1. what power is given unto the Priest in the matter of sin and therein whence this commission issueth and to whom it is directed 2. what are the acts and exercises thereof and wherewithall the same is executed 3. then of the properties thereof whether the Priests sentence be absoluâ—e and infallible and whether Ministerial and judicial 4. and lastly the abuses shall be parallel'd with the positive truth and thereby measured and discerned The first grant of this power unto man Of the Power of the keys Matth. 16.19 is the promise of Christ made unto Peter under the metaphor of the keys saying I will give unto thee the keys of the Kingdom of heaven and whatsoever thou stalt bind on earth shall be bound in heaven and whatsoever thou shalt loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven a power of great latitude and extent equivalent in the opinion of Saint Chrysostome as to give the places on his right and lest hand in his kingdome 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Chrys in Matth. 16. Tom. 2. pag. 344. whereupon that Father questioneth but answereth himself how shall Christ give the power of the keys that hath not in his hands the placing of the seats thereby also demonstrating himself to be God in conferring that property power of remitting sins which appertaineth to God onely These termes are to be opened 1. what the keys mean 2. next how they are to be used under these words of binding and loosing 3. in the third place about what they arâ—â—â—oployed the object quicquid whatsoever 4. and lastly by whom Keys Tibi Dabo I will give unto thee For the first The holy Ghost compareth a sinners case to the estate of a person imprisoned the very termes of keys of opening and shutting seem to have relation as it were to the prison gate and the termes of binding and loosing as it were to the fetters and bonds as if sin were a prison and the case of sinners like theirs that are shut up whereupon the power given unto Christ as man Luke 4.18 was to preach 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 remission or deliverance to captives And keys imply a faculty to that person to whose custody they are committed as when Eliakim was invested into Shebnabs place Esay 22.22 it is said I will lay the key of David upon his shoulder which words seem to be lent unto the Apostle and by him applied unto our Saviour These things saith he that is holy Revel 3.7 that is true he that hath the key of David he that openeth and no man shutteth that shutteth and no man openeth with this difference the word house omitted in the latter Discrimen est quod illud videtur inferioris Ministri puta 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 idque tantùm in familia Davidis hoc supremi Gubernatoris atque quidem totius regni Brightman Apocalyps cap. 3.7 and that advisedly to distinguish betwixt the Type and the Truth Eliakim and Christ in Hem resideth regal power and despotical in Eliakim Ministerial and Oeconomical onely as steward of Davids house for that room he sustained 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 aben Ezra Thesaurarius super domum regalem 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 1 Cor. 4 1. 1. Clavis authoritatis solius Dei 2. Clavis excellentiae solius Christi as appeareth 2 King 18. By the delivering then of this key Peter was made not a Lord over Gods inheritance but a steward of the mysteries of God for our case was thus As Adam was exâ—led and shut out of Paradise so are sinners from heaven and as Paradise was shut against him so was heaven against them also sin being the embargo betwixt us and heaven Now what key shall siâ—ners find to open heaven gate God hath a commanding key who onely hath authority to forgive sin against whom it is committed and so often as a sinner is pardoned so often is heaven opened this key God keeps to himself 2. Christ hath an excellent key which openeth where no man shutteth for by his merits hath this Angel of the Covenant like Peters Angel loosed our bands Acts 12.7 and set open the Prison doors enlarging the Captives and not them onely but the Palace doors Heb. 10.19 Sanguis Christi clavis Paradisi Tert. for by the bloud of Jesus we have boldness to enter into the holiest and elegantly it was said by Tertullian his bloud is the key of Paradise 3. The Apostles had an Oeconomical key as stewards in the Lords house 3. Clavis Ministerii for in Princes Courts the key is the ensign of that Office because unto
their trust is committed the Ministery of Reconciliation of this key Saint Ambrose thus Behold sins are forgiven by the holy Ghost Ecce quia per Spiritum Sanctum peccata donantur homines autem in remission em peccatorum Ministerium suum exhibent non jus alicujus potestatis exercent neque enim in suo sed in Patris Fihi Spiritus Sancti peccata dimittuntur isti rogant divinitas donat humanum enim obsequium sed Munificentia supernae est potestatis Ambr. l. 3. de Spir. S. cap. 19. but men contribute their Ministery toward the Remission of sin but exercise no right of any power for sins are not remitted in their name but in the name of the Father the Son aâ—d the Holy Ghost they supplicate and pray God grants and pardoneth the service is from man but the bounty from an higher power So then the higher power is the key of authoâ—ity and the humane service is the key of Ministery These several keys were well known to Scotus who writeth thus Authoritas judiciaria sententiandi coelum huic aperiendum vel apertum esse tripliciter intâ—lligitur 1. Authoritas simpliciter principalis solius Dei 2. Non Princâ—palis sed praecellens solius Christi quâ—tatum ad duplicem prae minentiam 1. unam quidem in universaâ—itate causarum judicaâ—darum 2. aliam in siâ—mitate sementiae dâ—siâ—itivae utraque praeeminâ—nia potest conâ—nircilli qui omnia mâ—rita dâ—â—â—rita novit quae sunt â—ausae propâ—er quas coeluÌ„â—st aperiendu vel claudenduÌ„ habet etià voluâ—taâ—eÌ„ inseparaâ—iliter conformem justitiae divinae propter pâ—imuÌ„ pâ—rest in omnibus causis sentâ—â—tiarâ— quia omâ—â—es novit propter secuadum potâ—st ejuâ— sententia sâ—aplicitâ—r esse fiâ—ma irrevocabilis quia semâ—er justa Non potest haec Clavis esse in ecclesiâ— Militante qâ—ia nullus in ecâ—lesia novet omnes causaâ—â—udiciarias nec habet voluntatem imâ—nutabilitâ—r justam 3. Paâ—ticulaâ—is quantâ—m ad causas cognoscendas infirma quantum ad sententiam ferendam puta quia ipsa fit aliquando revocabilis si quando praeter lâ—gem divinam judicat potest ergò esse in ecclesia una clavis coelum aperiendi sc autoritas sententiandi particulariter non irrevocabiliter coelum esse apertum Scot. l. 4. dist 19. Sect. Haec secunda Judicial authority in censuring heaven to be open or to be opened to any man or not is understood in a threefold sense 1. as the most principal and absoluâ—e residing in God onely 2. not as the most principal but a very excellent authâ—rity appertaiâ—ing unto Christ by a double preeminence which he hath 1. â—ver all causes as one who knoweth all mens hearts and can judge thereof 2. in the validity of his sentence definitive as ever just and never to be repealed which prerogative can onely sort with him who knoweth how well or ill all men have deserved for heaven stands open and shut towards us according as our deserts are as also in regard the will of Christ is and ever was undividedly conformable to divine justice for the first reason He may be a Judge in all causes who knoweth all things and for the second his sentence is firm and irrevocable because alwayes just The militant Church is not capable of this key because there is not any member in that Church endowed with so ample intellectuals as to know all causes nor hath a will so confirmed in justice as therein to be immutable 3. There is a particular authority to hear causes but weak to give sentence and is many times revocable as pronounced besides the law of God there may be then in the Church a certain key to open heaven that is the authority of sentencing in particular and yet heaven not irrevocably open unto any Thus much Scotus from whose testimony clearly stream these deductions 1. The Ministerial key in the custody of the Church is not so ample and firm as that excellent key which is upon Christs shoulder and those words As my Father sent me so send I you relate to the certainty of the Commission and not to the extent thereof 2. That there is not in the Militant Church therefore not at Rome such a key as can fit all wards or such a Judge as can take cognizance of all causes nor is there that Oecumenical jurisdiction intituling Rome above all and unto all nor do all causes turn upon that Rota 3. That there is no mortal Judge either Ecclesiâ—stical or Civil so confirmed in justice Clavis triplex 1. Authoritatis istam habet solus Dâ—us qui solus dimittit peccata authoritativè 2. Excellentiae quaÌ„ solus homo Christus habet ia quantum essecâ—uÌ„ Sacramentorum potest dare siâ—e Sacrameatis 3. Clavis Ministerii istam clavem habent Sacerdotes per quam ligant solvunt Raymond sum tract 4. de Poenit. but that he may swerve and deviate from that rule Nullus in Ecclâ—sia saith Scotus In the Church no not one but hath a will subject to change the Pope then that boasteth of the infallibility of his keys either is not of the Church or above it And as this Schoolman hath expressed the differential properties of these keys so a Canonist the several titles and persons to whom they appertain The key saith he is tripartite 1. of Authority and that is in the hands of God alone who onely forgiveth sins with authority 2. Of Excellency which the man Christ hath insomuch that he without the Sacraments can confer the effect and benefit of the Sacraments 3. Of the Ministery and this key is in the custody of the Priests by virtue whereof they bind and loose The Church then must rest contented and good cause she hath so to do with this Ministerial key for the first authentical key posuit pater in potestate sua the Father hath put in his own power for the excellent key omnem potesâ—atem dedit filio he hath given that power to his Son and for the Ministerial key habemus thesaurum istum in vasis fiâ—â—ilibus 2 Cor. 4.7 we poor Clergy-men are rich in this treasure the vessels containing the same are earthly but the key is from the Lord and heavenly the excellency of this power is from God the Ministery from us onely And that we may not be thought to accomplish any thing as from our selves 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Theophil Com. in 1 Cor. 4. but that every one who seeth it may say it is wholly of God nipping withall the false Apostles who ascribed all unto themselves as Theophilact piously admonisheth And indeed we need not be ambitious of further dignities 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. Chrys 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 God having highly honoured our Order with this depositum for to which of the Angels said he at any time To thee will I give the keys c. and whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in
non est justitia imma potest esse sine justitia ita potestas vel authoritas cognoscendi in aliqua causa potest esse sine cognitione aliqua Scot. lib. 4. dist 19. whereby they have power to make inquisition into and examine the case of the Penitent as a man that standeth by may know as much Law as he that sitteth upon the Bench although he hath not a Commission to examin the truth of a cause then in question according to his skill as the Judge hath for saith Scotus that authority whereby the Judge possesseth himself with the true information of the matter depending although it may require skill and discretion to manage the same aright even as the key of power requireth justice in the right use thereof notwithstanding as the power to judge is distinguishâ—d from Justice and may be found where there is no justice as in Pilat so the power and authority to take cognizance of a cause may ofttimes be without any discretion or science at all aâ— in Festus and Fâ—lix Saint Pauls Judges the gift then of knowledge and understanding is not the key but the guide thereof and the authority rightly placed when a man of understanding is in place The Second is the Authority of censuring 2. Clavis Potestatis or the key of power which we call the power of absolution consisting in the solemn denunciation of the Sentence for the former key which investeth the Priest with authority to discern Claves sunt discernendi scientia potentia judicandi i. e. solvâ—ndi ligandi usus harum Clavium 1. discernere ligandos solvâ—ndos 2. dein ligare solvere Magislr l. 4. dist 18. and examine between leprosie and leprosie is but preparatory maturing onely and ripening the sinners case for sentence Judicium sumitur prouâ— significat actum Judicis ut Judex est jus dicit i. e. juridicam sentâ—ntiam pronuaciat Apol. pro Jure Princip pag. 173 174. final determination being the scope thereof wherein the Priest after a full notice and examination of the sinners case and comparing the same with the law of God the rule to direct his hand and key judgeth according to that law and pronounceth the sentence judicial I say as delegated from God whose Commissioner for such causes he is and proceedeth not as a Witness to give in Evidence nor as a Herauld or Crier or Pâ—rsevant to make intimation of the Magistrates decree as a Messenger onely but as a Judge though subalternate clothed with authority from Christ and Christ from his Father to give the sentence The Father saith Chrysostome hath given all power unto the â—on and I set that they 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Chrys 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Tom. 6. p. 16. the Priests to have been made partakers of all that power by the Son for witnesses discover and declare the fact and Judges proceed according to their evidence for example whether such a Murder were committed or no the eye-witnesses are the evidence as present and observing the fact although the Magâ—strate denounce the sentence and punishment The Penitent then becomes a selfe-accuser and witness and the Priest turns the key according to Gods law whose Deputy and Steward in that case he is Nor doth this power to be a Judge contradict his office as a Minister for as Magistrates are the (a) 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Rom. 13.4 Ministers of God and bear not the sword in vâ—in so are Ministers the Magistrates of God and bear not the keys in vain But of this there will be occasion to say something in the exercise of this power whether it be judicial or no. Onely thus as the Magistrate is a temporal Mâ—nâ—ster and the end of his power the preservation of publick peace and tranquility so is the Mâ—nister a Spiritual Magistrate to procure the salvation of souls and the enlargement of Gods kingdome and as the Magistrates sword is Terrestrial punishing evil doers and protecting such as do well so is the Ministers key Celestial binding the obstinate and loosing penitent offenders And it goeth well with Church and State when the Ecclesiastâ—cal Ministery and Civil government keep the bounds God hath set them and in truth the mutual incroachments and confusions of these two powers have been the occasions of all the alterations and combustions in Christendome For as when the roof of the Temple rent in sunder not long after followed the ruine of the Temple it self So if these two principal beams and Top-rafters the Prince and the Priest rent asunder the whole frame of Christian religion will be shaken The abuse of the keys hath occasioned the Civil Magistrate to abridg in some cafes the lawful use thereof and when the Church-men began to use them like swords the Sword-men seized upon them as belonging to their Regiment Know then O Priest what the inscription is that is ingraven upon thy keys They are the keys of the kingdome of heaven and remember that he who gave the keys to Peter said unto the same man put up thy sword into thy sheath And let the Magistrate be afraid to draw too near unto this holy ground to handle the Censer and approach unto the Altar or to Usurp upon the true function of the keys 2. Chro. 26.16 which appertain not unto them but unto the Priests that are consecrated left they participate in the judgment and leprosie of Vzziah As the Spiritual keys are of the kingdome of heaven because they open and shut the same to different offenders Revel 1.18 so are they of Death and Hell too from the dire effects thereof to such as are impenitent for Hell hath gates as well as Heaven and the same key that shutteth Heaven-gates openeth Hell and where the gates of heaven are opened thosâ— of hell are shut Now heaven is opened and hell shut when a sinner is loosed and absolved in like manner hell is opened and heaven shut when a sinner is bound and his sins retained The next thing we are to consider Whatsoever thâ—u shalt bind on earth c. It had been more correspondent to the Metaphor 2 Of Absolutioâ— legation and use of the keys to have used the termes of opening and shutting as did Esaias the Prophet and John the Divine but the Holy Ghost hath chosen to express this power under the words of binding and loosing Esay 22.22 Rev. 3.7 to signifie the miserable estate of such to whom heaven is shut up as remaining bound with the cords of their own sins Nempè ut intelligamus quam misera sit conditio illorum quibus Coâ—lum clauditur manent enim ol stâ—icti pecâ—aturum vinculis Contrà verò quà m beati suntillâ— quibus apertum est coelum qui scilicet à filio Dei libâ—â—nti sunt sint ipsius cobaeredes Beza Annot. in Matth. 16. and contrariwise the blessed condition of those to whom heaven is opened as freed by the Son of God that
ne peut estre violé P. Bess Caâ—esme Tom. 2. pag 736. and preacher in the Court of France being in the place of God hath no mouth to reveal what he knoweth in Confession and for proof hereof he alleageth that of the Psalmist They have mouthes but speak not By his words setting him in the place of God but by his proof making him an Idol the seal of confession saith he is so important and religious that it may not be violated for any thing in the world And so great is the religion of the seal of confession saith a Jesuite that in no case Tantam esse sigilli confessionis religionem ut in nulla casu propter nullum finem etiam pro tuenda tota republica ab ingenti malo temporali vel spirituali violare illud liceat Eudaemon Joh. Apol. pro Garnet p. 335. and for no end yea though it were to protect the State from any great mischief be it Temporal or Spiritual it may not be violated They are the words of Eudaemon or rather Kacodaemon Johannes and addeth withal that this is a received principle amongst men of his rank with whom the keeping of this seal is preferred before the keeping of the Princes safety and State Yea a deep silence is herein required that if our Lord Jesus Christ should again be conversant on earth Perpetuum silentium praestare licet cum Regis Reipublicae internecione conjunctum vel certissimo Salvatoris nostri interitu si nobiscum hic denuò versaretur in terris Jacob. Rex Medit. in Orat. Dom. p. 63. and Judas and the Priests conspiracy to do again and the same delivered under seal of Confession to save our Saviours life it must not be detected as our late Dread Soveraign hath observed from the writings of some of that society No marvel then at those that â—each the seal must not be broken to save a Kings life Non debet manifestare quae audivit in confessione etiamsi aliquod gravissimum malum non revelando immineret ut â—ccisio Regis vel civitatis ruina Armil Au. 5. Confes n. 5. or City from ruine that will not break it to save the life of the Son of God Could it ever be imagined that reasonable men should broach such fearful paradoxes prejudicial to Church State God and man King and subject making the office of Confession the den and cave of villanies and treason and the keys of heaven the keys of hell to lock up sulphurious treasons and to keep in that fire and brimstome that it should not break forth except the Prince flower of the kingdom be born up before it Inconveniences attending the popish seal of confession The holy Eucharist the seal of Grace is with such Fiends the seal to fold up horrid treasons sealing them up with the receiving of that Sacrament silencing their confessions with the pretended seal of another Yea in some cases the preservation of this seal may prove of much detriment to the Confessor himself as they put the case Two men conspire to draw their Priest into a wood and there to murder him as they are in the way one of the Conspirators repenteth and revealeth the same to him in confession what must he do in this case Debet plus timere Dâ—um se offerre Martyrio quà m transgredi Dei legem Ecclesiae revelando confessionem Gabr. l. 4. d. 21. Q. 1. ad primum not go back for that were to break the seal but proceed rather and die a Martyr so sealing this seal with his bloud It causeth a necessary connivency and toleration of sin As if a man confess unto his Priest that he hath married in other Countreys two wives already and in his parish intendeth the marriage of a third the former yet living the resolution is rather than to break the seal the Priest is to marry him and to give the Benediction It is also a stop and bar to the proceedings of justice If a Confessor be examined upon oath concerning a truth detected unto him in Confession under the seal he may safely forswear it that he knoweth nothing thereof for that the same was made known unto him not in the person of man but in the person of God as the Angel in the bush said to Moses in the person of God I am the God of thy father c. But Scotus liketh not this evasion Sacerdos non audit confessionem ex persona Dei sed Ministerialiter loqui autem ex authoritate alterius loqui in persona sua propria ex commissione alterius Scotus because the Confessor speaketh not in the person of God but as a Minister of his put in authority under him therefore he adviseth him to flie in his answer to equivocations And lastly it may prove the * E Seminariis missi Sacerdotes ad intestinas seditiones sub Confessionis sigillo concitandas Cambd. Elizab. ad An. MDLXXX p. 298. School and nursery of treason A Traytor may first feel his Confessor let it be F. Garnet with general notions if he be fordable Another may crave his advice by way of Consultation what course may best be taken to promove the same and in case it take effect he may be questioned who shall succeed in the Crown and because these detections consultations and questions were proposed under the veil and shadow of Confession Cave verò ne contrà odiosa magis fiat si soveat in sinu scelera talia tam odiosa perniciosa Tortura Torti pag. 292. be sure of the Confessor his mouth is stitched up not a word for a world because these things relate to confession the seal and confession would wax odious should the seal be ripped up But as a Reverend Prelate replied Take heed if it grow not more odious if it cover and nourish in its bosome crimes so odious and pernicious And because there may be security given on both sides the Confessée or Penitent is obliged to keep close what the Confesseur or Ghostly Father shall say or do at that time also Non solùm Confessor celare tenetur acta dicta Confitentis sed etiam Confitens ad ipsum tenetur quantum ad acta dicta Saâ—erdotis Gabr. l. 4. d. 21. Q. 1. Concl. 3. so that in this vault Trayterous plots may be conferred upon and banded to and fro without fear of any discovery Gen. 49.6 O my soul come not thou into their secret unto their assembly mine honour be not thou united Yet for all their close dealings sometimes mischief will come out yea hath when such hellish projects have come before loyal Priests Sundry Examples of conspiracies confessed and detected Bodin de Repub lib. 2. c. 5. that have made more Conscience of the safety of their Anointed Soveraign than of the secrecy of this seal A Gentleman in Normandy confessed unto a Franciscan how he had a purpose to have
ever do so and we cannot imagine any erroneous sentence to be confirmed above sine Coeli infamia without dishonouring the Supream Judg. And that sometimes the Priest is out the School distinguishing of the erring key confirmeth for what need to distinguish of the erring key if the key never erreth therefore Lyra hedgeth him in and tells him that his sentence is allowed of by God Hoc tamen intelligendumest quando judicium ecclesiae divino judicio conformatur Lyr. in Ioan. c. 20. When the judgment of the Church is conformable to his Never any simple Priest hath been so arrogant as to assume this priviledge to be infallible the claim whereof the high-Priest at Rome hath made his prerogative but what will you say if the Pope hath erred and that in this present business of absolution and eke in his own case Read this ensuing story you that are devoted to his chair and tell me how you like it Popes have power to make choice of their Confessor of whom they please and there was a Pope perceiving his life to draw to an end Capellano suo authoritatem Apostolicam contulit se absolvendi sub plenaria remissione ut fieri solet in anno Jubilaeo that committed to a Chaplain of his own Apostolical power to absolve with plenary authority as in the year of Jubile By virtue whereof after confession made he received absolution and so departed this life Not many dayes after he appeared to his Chaplain with a heavy look and in a mourning weed and being demanded If he was the late Pope answered yea also the Chaplain desiring to know why he was so dejected in countenance and clothes for that quoth the Pope I am adjudged to eternal death Is it possible replied the Chaplain since upon thy confession thou receivedst the benefit of plenary absolution it is even so said the Pope Supremus judex absolutionem illam ratam non habuit Spec. Exempl dist 9. Sec. 30. because the highest Judge would not ratifie that absolution The Relator tells us how by this apparition God would let us know that if it be so in the green wood and top of the Church we should consider what may fall out in the dry and under branches thereof where there is less authority that although God and the Pope have but one Consistory yet they are not alwayes of one mind and if Christ confirm not in heaven the sentence of his Vicar on earth we may well doubt if every Sir John's absolution discharge us before God and if the Popes keys may erre in his own case we may suspect their integrity in other mens and so we see the second link in this Sorites is feeble and apt to be broken For all this let it be granted that sins must be fully opened before the Priest can proceed to Sentence and that he could not proceed amiss in the sentence of absolution and pardon yet except God had made over the hearing of all sins unto his Priests Illa potestas remittendi peccata non ita intelligenda est data Sacerdotibus quasi Deus se eâ abdicarit eam prorfùs transtulerit in Sacerdotes ità ut in absolutione non Deus sed Sacerdos remittat peccata Chemnit Exam part 2. p. 176. and reserved none to himself as not minding to be troubled about any such matters and had resolved neither to forgive the sin nor give the audience but to such onely as the Priests have remitted the argument would be the more impregnable But if our God be contrary minded as sure he is having shut out no sins from his gracious audience and is of so quick an ear as to hear the very desires of our hearts and so swift to mercy as to prevent oral Confession with a pardon how loosly doth this reason hang The present Greek Church upon confidence hereof addresseth her self unto God for a pardon even for those sins which upon some causes were left out in Confession Thus writeth their late Patriarch 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Hierem. Patr. Constant ad Tubing Resp. 1. c. 11. Whatsoever sins the Penitent for forgetfulness or shamefastness doth leave unconfessed we pray the merciful and most pitiful God that those also may be pardoned unto him we are perswaded that they shall receive a pardon of them from God thus he God then remitteth sins never confessed to a Priest and ofttimes retaineth sins that are confessed for the Priests sentence is not alwayes agreeable with his nor of the same latitude and extent God remitting whomsoever the Priest assoileth if he proceed aright and many more besides and retaining whose sins soever he retaineth and many millions besides Thereupon Scotus observeth that the words of this Commission are not precise that is whatsoever you remit I remit also and no more and whatsoever you retain I retain and that onely For that many more sins are retained by God over and above those which the Priest retaineth is evident The Priest onely retaining such which are detected Illud verbum Quorum retinueritis c. non est praecisum non solùm enim illa retenta sunt à Deo peccatori ad poenam quaeretenta sunt à Sacerdote quia Sacerdos noa retinet aliqua nisi aliquo modo sibi accusata sed signis indebitis poenitentiae tamen illa quae nullo modo sunt ostensa Sacerdoti Deus retinet ad vindictam Gehennae Ergò nec istud verbum Quorum remiseritis c. erit praecisum in such a confession whereof there are apparent signs that it proceeds not from a penitent heart in such cases where a sinner shall confess his sins and express no sorrow for the same like those Qui peccant publicant sin and glory in their sin wherein the Priest doth not absolve that is he retaineth and reserves for future sorrow or punishment Now God retaineth those that draw nigh to himself and the Priest with their lips but are far from both in their hearts God I say retaineth these and all those likewise that are not known to the Priest if they be not repented of to be punished in hell fire So for the other member viz. remission of sins If more sins be retained by God than are by the Priests it followeth that more sins are forgiven by God than are by Priests also for be it far from us to think that God shall be more strict than the Priest in retaining and not more copious than the Priest in pardoning or that God should exceed the Priest in detention of sins and not in remission No no God is rich in mercy and though in mercy he so far remember justice as to reâ—ain more sins than Priests take notice of yet his goodness is so great as to forgive more than Priests are able to take notice of or well understand Therefore the Commission runnes in words affirmative and not negative as if the remission and retention of sinnes made by the
is engendered this way is more than evident for who hath not heard of that of the Apostle Fide ex auditu Acts 4.4 And many of them which heard the word believed the increase and addition made daily to the Church was by the Apostles planting and watering 't is true the efficacy is from God for neither is he that plâ—nteth any thing nor he that watereth but God that giveth the increase His the seed is the Minister is but the sower or rather the hopper where it is deposited and as the seed is his so is the blessing and increase the Priest concurring as a servant in this Spiritual husbandry it pleased God by the foolishness of preaching as the world accounted it to save them that believe 1 Cor. 1.21 Conclude we with Pacianus Nunquam Deus non poenitenti comminaretur nisi ignosceret poenitenti solus hoc inquit Deus poterit verum est sâ—â—i quod per Sacerdotes suos facit illius potestas est Pacian ad Sympron Epist 1. God would never threaten the impenitent except he were minded to pardon the Penitent But it will be said God onely can do this very true but that which he doâ—h by his Priests is his power And to these two heads of disposition and application the more ancient Schoolmen limited the power of absolution preaching forgiveness not directly Sacerdotes dimittunt ostendendo manifestando habent se ad modum demonstrantis non directè sed dispositivè ea adhibentes per quae Dâ—us dimittit peccata dat gratiam and from themselves but as disposing thereunto exhibiting those means by which God conferreth grace and forgiveth sin By the Word and Sacraments doth the Priest dispose and prepare sinners for repentance thereby to make them capable of forgiveness and doth actually apply unto such as are so disposed absolution and forgiveness first chafing and preparing the wax to receive the seal and when their hearts are lâ—ke wax mâ—lted in the midst of their bowels Psal 22.14 as saith the Psalmist then as Officers they put a seal to the diploma of their pardon and absolution in the name of Christ actually absolving them so far as their Ministerial power can extend them I say qui non ponunt obicem that hinder not by unbelief or impenitency So the Minister in the first place disposeth to repentance and then applieth pardon to them that repent and as it appeared in Davids case upon whom the reproofs discharged by Nathan fell like claps of thunder the King thereupon truly humbled to repentance 2 Sam. 12.13 breaks forth into tears and confession which Nathan apprehending comforts him with the sweet news of pardon and absolution And this is all we can safely afford unto the Priest whose care must be not to exceed his instructions and to take that which is his own and to go his way Thou wilt say the words of his Commission give him further and more ample authority wherein the Priest hath power not to apply meerly but to absolve not to bear witness but to bind and so farr that Heaven shall not onely ratifie and confirm but second and answer his definitive resolves upon which surmise Hilary thus addresseth himself to Saint Peter O blessed Porter of heaven O Beate Coeli janitor cuâ—us arbitrio claves aeterni aditûs traduntur cujus terrestre judicium praeâ—udicata authoritas sit in coelo ut quae in teâ—ris aut ligata sunt aut soluta statuti ejusdem conditionem obtineant in coelo Hilar. Can. 16. in Matth. to whose disposing the keys of that eternal entrance are delivered whose judgment upon earth doth prejudicate that authority which is in heaven that whatsoever is bound or loosed upon earth the same statute should be of force in heaven also And Chrosostome affirmeth the Priests throne to be founded in heaven 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Chrys 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 tom 5. p. 152. and he that averreth the same is the very king of heaven himself saying whatsoever ye shall bind on earth c. what can compare or be equal with this honour heaven takes the principality or beginning of judgment from earth The Lord followeth his servant and look what the servant judgeth below the Lord confirmeth above For the clearing of these evidences there are three points to be debated 1. If the Priest can be said to be an author or doer of absolution 2. How and when his sentence is ratified in heaven 3. And then how and in what sense these Fathers can rightly affirme and which the words of Christ seem to import The Priests censure on earth to have the precedency and to take place of heaven and to these the resolutions succinctly follow 1. To the first we affirme that the Priest doth discharge his function Priests absolve Operativè not onely declaratively as a Messenger but operatively as a causer and procurer of absolution but a Causer after his kind because he laboureth in the work of the Ministery such as take pains in planting and watering the Lords husbandry are 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 1 Cor. 3.9 labourers together with God And as the Apostle styles himself a Father to the Corinthians 1 Cor. 4.15 and that he begat them in Christ Jesus through the Gospel though in the adoption of sons the seed be immortal and the quickner thereof the holy Spirit 1 Tim. 4.16 and as Timothy by his doctrine is said to save himself and them that hear him whereas salvation is from the Lord So are the Priests said to absolve as instruments ordained by God to work faith and repentance for the procurement thereof Revel 16.1 for as in the binding part of their Ministery they are like the Angels in the Apocalypse which pour out the vials of the wrath of God upon earth (a) 2 Cor. 10.6 having vengeance ready against all disobedience and a charge from God to deliver up unto Satan yet are they not the Avengers for to God vengeance belongeth but the inflicters thereof for unto the Priests the execution apperâ—aineth And in the Levitical Law which concerneth the Leprosie by so many of the Ancient made a type of the pollution of sin 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 LXXII Levit. 13.6 vers 44. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 LXXII we read the Priest shall cleanse him and the Priest shall pollute him and the Priest polluting shall pollute him where we translate the Priest shall pronounce him clean and the Priest shall pronounce him utterly unclean for the Priest was not the author of that pollution Haud dubium quin Sacerdos non quò contaminationis author sit sed quò ostendat eum contaminatum qui priùs mundus plurimis videbatur Hieron lib. 7. in Esay c. 23. neither making him that had the Leprosie unclean or him clean that was cleared thereof but onely declared him to be polluted saith Saint Hierom who before seemed unto many to
Judicial in regard of the exercise thereof A Judge he is though not supreme and in his own right So God is the Soveraign and absolute Judge and in all cases the Priest subordinate and substituted by his auâ—hority yet a Judge though the Lords Officer and giveth judgment albeit he declareth his Masters divine will and pleasure In the case of the Incestuous Corinthian Paul takes upon him the Authority of a Judge and denounceth the Spiritual censure 1 Cor. 5.3 For I verily as absent in body but present in Spirit have judged already as though I were present concerning him that hath done this deed where the sentence immediately followeth Now what judgment is here required and herein to be used will appear JudiciuÌ„ quandoque sumâ—tur pro discretione undè dicitur quod insans furiosus carent judicio quandaque pro examinatione seu deliberatione quandoque pro authoritate Abbas Clavis discretionis if we consider the several kinds of judgments which in Panormitan are threefold 1. of discretion 2. of examination or inquisition 3. of authority or definition Of which the first is held so requisite that one of the keys hath been called after that name the key of discretion and where this is wanting the blind Priest may call light darkness and darkness light Discretion serving like the two lights in the firmament to distinguish virtue and vice asunder and the more to be required in a Priest who is not onely to put a difference betwixt light and darkness but betwixt darkness and darkness betwixt Leprosie and Leprosie betwixt sin and sin and how shall a Priest know sin that is ignorant of the law and how shall the law be understood without discretion In that great variety of sins and sinners which may come before the Priest he had need to have his eyes in his head that shall take the true distance of Criminal cases for then is the sentence of the Priest approved and confirmed of God and the Court of Heaven Tunc sententia Sacerdotis judicio Dei caelestis curiae approbatur consiâ—m â—tur cùm ita ex discretione prodit ut Reorum merita non contradicant Quoscunque ergo solvunt vel ligant adhibentes Clavem discretionis Reorum meritis solvuntur vel ligantur in coelis Magistr lib. 4. dist 18. when it proceeds from that discretion as the merits of the guilty person contradict not the same whomsoever therefore they loose and bind by the key of discretion and according as the person may deservs such are bound and loose in heaven saith the Perpetual Dictator in the Schools Peter Lombard Of such necessity is discretion And when sins are discerned great judgment is required as well in the curation of sin as in the punishment of sin for in some sinners it hapneth that the punishment of sin is the best help and means for the curing thereof of whom that may be verified Perieram nisi periissem I had perishâ—d utterly if I had not perished Of this sanative and purgative humour are afflictions like Northern winds blowing cold but sweeping and cleansing the air Thus the incestuous person was delivered unto Satan 1 Cor. 5.5 for the destruction of the flesh that the Spirit might be saved in the day of the Lord Jesus which censure was a curative Medicine from a Spiritual Physician and careful 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Chrys in 1 Cor. 5.5 not from an enemy or destroyer chastising the flesh for the benefit of the soul And is there not need of judgment in administring such receipts where the ingredients may be poysonable and desperate if not allaied with much skill and discretion Again the Priest had need to be judicious in discerning unfeigned sorrow and contrition for sin Poenitentia est quae dam dolentis vindicta semper puniens in se quod dolet commisisse Aug. apud Aquin. part 3. Qu. 85. art 1. for as much as Repentance is an act of vindictiâ—e or corrective Justice whereby a sinner taking vengeance on himself for offending God in a sort preventeth his justice And to repent is (a) Ezek. 33.14 to do judgment in the Prophet or to (b) 1 Cor. 11.3 judge our selves as the Apostle calls it to which there belongeth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 a revenge or punishment Now there ought to be a correspondence betwixt sin and sorrow and an Analogy betwixt the iniquity of sin and the fruit worthy of Repentance And if the Priest find some sinners to take on but little for hainous offences he is to aggravate the offence and to proportion the sorrow not with any intent thereby to satisfie God but to please him And in the case the Penitent be swallowed up of grief he is to alleviate the burthen and great judgment is requâ—red in making this allotment what sorrow sorteth for each sin and to pronounce when the same is defective and excessive And lastly great judgment belongeth in the right application of this power that it may work and produce good effect To whom and to whom not and which way the key is to be turned to loose or to lock the offender since it is not but with advice to be applied nor hands hastily to be laid on any man 1 Tim. 5.22 A place referred by the ancient writers to repentance and the circumstance of the place giveth no less Pacian in paraenesi 16. Aug. de Bapt. â—5 20 23. I said before that the best Physick works not upon indisposed Patients nor doth one receipt cure all diseases Judge then the Priest must of the nature of the disease of the state of the sinners soul as well as the efficacy of his Medicine And it fareth with those that are diseased in mind as with some such that are visited with corporal diseases as not to question the virtue of the physick but to suspect their own weakness in the use and operation thereof It being usual with many especially at the last gasp not to doubt of the power of remitting sins but of their own indisposition to receive it whether the physick will stay with them or no and work upon their souls and a judicious Priest must see to that These circumstances considered and many more that may fall in tell me if the handling of the keys and discreet managing thereof be not a judicial act In such ballances as these causes are to be weighed and then the power of binding and loosing to be practised Causae ergo pensandae sunt cù ligandi atque solvendi potestas exercenda videndum est quae culpa aut quae sit Poenitentia secula post culpam ut quos omnipotens Dâ—us per compunctionis gratiam visitat illos Pastorâ—s sententia absolvat Greg hom 26. in Evang. Priests must consider what the fault is and what repentance hath followed thereupon that such as Almighty God doth visit with the grace of compunction those the sentence of the Pastor may absolve
past and for which signes of sorrow appear in the Penitent never extending the same to future sins for to cry Peccavi I have sinned may be the voice of a Penitent but Peccabo I will sin never now where there is a resolution to sin there with safety can lie no absolution Then if such sins are to be lock'd under secrecy which are confessed in ord ne ad claves with relation to absolution and remission It will follow that peccata committenda sins purposed to be committed and in fieri to be done not in fa â—o done already although spoken of in confession are not so necessary to be concealed Panormitan puts the case A certain man confessed unto the Priest Quidam fuit confessus Sacerdoti quòd intend bat interficere Sempronium vel aliud malesicium committere quòd non poterat abstinere Nunquid Sacerdos peccet revelando Innocentius instat concludâ—t quod hoc peccatum non dicitur detectum in poenitentia tum quia peccatum est committendum non commissum tum quia non habet contritionem Undè Sacerdos dâ—bet quantùm cautiùs potest revelare ut peccatum impediatur â—ene hoc semper menti quod peccatum commissum non committendum dicitur detegâ— in Poenitentia Panorm supra 5. de poenit remiss c. Omnis utriusq n. 24. that he had a mind to kill Sempronius or to do some other mischief and that be could not hold his hand The Question is whether the Priest offendeth in revealing the same oâ— no Innocentius instanceth and at length coâ—cludeth that this sin cannot be said to be detected in a repentant way as well because the sin confessed remaineth to be committed and is not committed already as also because the sinner had no contrition wherefore the Priest ought as warily as he may to reveal the samâ— that the sin may be prevented for keep this alwayes in mind that sin committed and not to be committed is commanded to be concealed in Penance And Frier Angelo when any one confisseth that he will do a mischief Quando quis confitetur se velle faccre aliquod malum quia istud non est dictum in poenitentiali foro ut ideò propter rationem istius Sacramenti non tenetur celare sed quando vergeret in periculum communitatis vel alterius tum si nullo modo cessaret talis quin illud faciat credo sine praejudicio quòd non solùm potest immo tenetur revelare ei quâ— potest prodesse non obesse ut mâ—lo obviâ—tur Sum. Angel v. Confe ult nu 7. because the same is not opened in the consistory of Repentance wherefore the Priest is not tied by virtue of that Sacrament to conceal the same but when it shall verge and incline to the prejudice and danger either of the whole Commonalty or of any man in particular then if the sinner cannot be taken off but that be will needs do it I am of opinion without prejudice to any that the Priest not onely may but is tied to â—eveal the same to such an one as will further and not hinder the prevention of further mischief This Canonist maketh the purposed evil to be of two sorts 1. either when the damage may light upon the sinners own head alone 2. or which may redound to the prejudice and hurt of others the former the Priest may reveal if he please but the later he is bound to discover for the crossing and averting thereof And the first School-man our Countrey man Alexander of Hales thus A man may confess a sin not present Potest quis confiteri peccatum non tamen ut praesens sed potius ut est â—n proposito de futuro ut cum dicit se velle fornicari nolle desistere dico ergo quòd non tenetur celare simpliciter nec si Sacerdos talâ—m confessionem revelaret posset condemnari tanquam violator sigilli confessionis tamen quia hoc species esset mali infamia sequeretur propter hoc credo et si non tenetur de jure talem confessionem occultare debet tamen celare ratione publicae honestatis nisi inconveniens aliquod grave sequeretur tunc enim credo quòd non esset talis confessio penitùs tacenda nec tamen publicè revelanda propter periculum infamiae sed cautè secretò alicui qui possit vellet prodesse innotescenda Alex. Halens part 4. Qu. 28. nu 2. art 2. in Resp but yet to come and in purpose as that he will commit fornication and not forbear I say therefore that the Priest is not bound simply to conceal it nor may he for any such detection be justly condâ—mned as a violater of the seal of Confession Yet because it may seem to have an outward shew of evil and infamy may follow thereupon for that cause I am thus minded that although by law he is not tied to hide such a confession yet he should do well to conceal it for publick honesties sake except some grievous inconvenience may like to ensue upon the same then I believe that such a Confession ought not altogether to be silenced nor yet openly to be published for dread of infamy but cautelously and secretly to such an one that can make good use of the discovery wherein he would seem to be more circumspect and cautelous in the manner of the detection than those Canonists whereas the following School-men Scotus and Biel are so strict upon the matter that purposed sins and not committed come under the seal of secrecy also Non solùm peccata commissa sed etiam committenda in confessione detecta sunt tanquam secreta celanda Biel l. 4. d. 21. Qu. 1. Conclus 3. And again it is not lawful for a Priest in any case come what will come to reveal confession whether the party confessing be Penitent or not In nullo casu licet Sacerdoti revelare confessionem sive confitens poeniteat sive non sive confiteatur peccata jam opere perpetrata sive perpetranda sive sit peccatum in moribus sive in fide Biel sup resp ad dub 2. whether he confess sins already committed or which he hath a mind and resolution to commit whether it be a sin in faith or in behaviour And the Modern Divines in the Roman Church are no way moderate herein but so Stoicall and stiff for the seal as let the sin be what it will whether past or to come it skils not whether the welfare of Church or State depend thereon 't is not material Heaven and Earth shall pass away rather than the seal of Confession shall be opened A Ghostly Father saith a late Sorbonist Car estant en le place de Dieu il n'a point de bouche pour reveler ce qu'il a entendu Os habent non loquentur Et le Sceau de la confession est si important religieux que pour rien du Monde il