hauing power to iustifie therefore faith only iustifieth The Maior I haue shewed before is not to bee denyed of any Papists because that they seeke not to ioyne with faith any thing in the matter of Iustification but only workes As for my Minor Stap. Antid in Act. 3.10 it is granted by Stapleton in the words before alleadged that the Apostle excludeth Workes from hauing power to iustifie absolutely that is to forgiue sinnes Thus haue we one more on our side then we hoped for and so may be bold I trust to conclude Now although this cloud of witnesses is sufficient I hope to cleere vs from any sinister imputation of euill dealing as if wee would teach that is strange and not heard of but of late dayes yet we haue in this point a better testimonie then all men can affoord vs. For the assurance of this Doctrine is this that the holy Ghost sealeth vp this confidence in our hearts Rom. 8.16 and Gods Spirit beareth witnesse with our Spirit that wee are the children of God and hauing receiued the Sprit of adoption we are bold to cry Abba Father This this I say is the argument that more perswadeth the children of God then all that men can bring This argument did so conuince euen the very conscience of Saint Paul Phil. 3.8.9 That the righteousnesse of the Law was as I may so say but lothsome to him in comparison of that righteousnes which he longed after by Christ This righteousnesse whoso hath a true feeling of he doth but laugh to scorne the idle disputations of them that seeke to proue it must bee had by Workes But I am not ignorant how our Aduersaries doe what in them lyeth to elude the testimonies of God and all good men and as much as they can to dimme the verie light of our consciences that wee should not see this comfort Bell. de Iustif l. 1. c 25 Annot. in Iam. 2.24 And therefore Bellarmine seemeth to make some answer to some few places alleaged out of the Scriptures and Fathers against them So doe the Rhemists too in their Annotations vpon the new Testament But all in vaine the Sunne of truth shineth so cleere that all they can doe is not sufficient to dimme the light thereof For this word Faith only being so commonly vsed as it is teacheth vs that nothing but faith is that which by our Sauiour Christ iustifieth For it only cannot be said to doe it if eyther Law of Ceremonies or of the Commandements the workes eyther of the vnrighteous or of the faithfull bee ioyned with it And therefore though our Aduersaries would sometime exclude one thing from iustifying sometime another yet so long as they exclude not all but faith in Christ Iesus from being cause of our Iustification they seeke but to deceiue vs. Aug de fide operibuc 14. Good workes necessarie when we are iustified Aug. de fide operibus cap. 14. Yet I denie not but workes as S. Augustine sayth doe follow him that alreadie is iustified though they goe not before him that is to be iustified For they are as a little before I said out of Thomas of Aquine the execution and manifestation of our righteousnesse but no causes therof In which sence the Fathers very often especially Saint Augustine in many places hauing shewed plentifully out of the Apostle That we are iustified by faith without the workes of the Law Yet withall he giueth vs to vnderstand that Hoc non agit vt percepta ac professa fide opera iustitiae contemnantur hee goeth not about thereby to make vs contemne the workes of righteousnesse we once hauing receiued and professed faith No we when once we are iustified are Gods workemanship Ephes 2.10 created in Christ Iesus vnto good works which God hath ordained that we should walke in them Againe they tell vs some of the Fathers speake of faith as it is Dogmaticall for our profession or Religion and that in such sence only they affirme Faith only to iustifie because it is the true and not a false faith that must saue Of which I sayd somewhat before when I alleadged the words of Leo for confirmation of our Doctrine But yet somewhat more to explane the matter wee must consider that faith hath two respects Outward Doctrine The one as it is an outward thing which is taught or wee may reade of it in Bookes That pierceth the eares it hath also consent of the minde and vnderstanding when we yeeld to the truth therof But this though a true faitht yet vntill it be planted in the heart and beleeued iustifieth not As for example the Deuill may and did know the true faith as when he said Iesus the Sonne of God Mat. 8.29 Mark 1.24 what haue wee to doe with thee Againe What haue we to doe with thee Iesus of Nazareth art thou come to destroy vs I know what thou art That holy ome of God We reade also elsewhere in Saint Marke Mark 3.11 When the vncleane Spirits saw Christ they fell downe before him and cryed saying Thou art the Sonne of God And Saint Iames sayth plainely Iam. 2.19 The Deuils beleeue that there is one God and tremble But our Aduersaries will grant that although it is a Catholicke faith that the Deuils haue yet it furthereth them not to saluation That faith in Christ Iesus doth iustifie is a true faith that is a true Doctrine yet no doubt acknowledged of many that shall neuer find with comfort the sweetnesse thereof But when this perswasion is well rooted in the heart Inward assurance so that it maketh vs to rest and repose our selues vpon God which we call beleeuing in God then doth it iustifie Thus then although it is most true that it must be a Catholike not an Hereticall faith that saueth yet euen that true Catholike faith doth not quicken it doth not sanctifie or iustifie vnlesse to our endlesse comfort we receiue the same into the heart And so as the Catholike faith is only auaileable so vntill it be receiued into the heart it helpeth not and then it only iustifieth But many things are out of the Scripture obiected against this Doctrine whereby the simple and such as are not acquainted with the Word Heb. 3.14 neyther by long custome haue their wits exercised to discerne both good and euill as the Apostle to the Hebrewes speaketh may soone be deceiued For to such as haue not iudgement to trye Metals euen Tinne will seeme Siluer and Copper Gold because in colour they are somewhat like To say nothing of such places it may bee dangerous in these our euill dayes lest thereby some that desire to know the truth by the name of Scripture wrested to a wrong sence may be led into errour And yet to speak of euery particular place alleadged would bee verie tedious for they are many I haue therefore thought good to draw them into some few heads and so
minde But if in the heart it bee not then can it not haue the application that I spoke of Faith must bee in the heart Against this their opinion I thus reason Iustifying faith is in the heart Popish faith is not in the heart therefore Popish faith is not that iustifying faith My Minor is the doctrine of the Papists and of Bellarmine among other as is said before The Maior or first proposition S. Paul will proue for me sufficiently so that it may not be denyed Rom. 10 10 Gal. 4.6 With the heart a man beleeueth vnto righteousnesse What can be more plaine Because you are sonnes saith the same Apostle elsewhere God hath sent forth the Spirit of his Sonne into your hearts And what worketh it thereby The Apostle telleth vs Whereby wee cry Abba Father And how learne wee this lesson of the Spirit First the Spirit teacheth vs to beleeue and to haue confidence and then this faith bringeth forth prayer as a fruit For How shall they call on him in whom they haue not beleeued Rom. 10.14 The Eunuch after Philip had instructed him in the faith asked if he might not be baptized Philip made answere Act. 8.37 38. If thou beleeuest with all thine heart thou maist Arator therefore a Christian Poet who wrote about 1100. yeeres since hath these wordes Arator in Act. lib. 2. Corde salus credentis erit confessio voce In the heart is the saluation of the beleeuer the confession is in the mouth To be short vnfaithfulnesse is by the Apostle assigned to the heart Hebr. 3.12 Take heed brethren saith he lest there be in any of you at any time an euill heart and vnfaithfull to depart away from the liuing God therefore by the Law of contraries faith must be in the heart too A third fault that I find with this definition is that they say it is assensus solùm An assent onely No true faith without knowledge Bellar. de Iustific l. 1. cap. 7. as before out of Bellarmine I shewed whereby their meaning is to exclude knowledge as a thing nothing at all required in faith In so much as Bellarmine shameth not to affirme that fides melius per ignorantiam quà m per notitiam definitur Faith is better defined by ignorance then by knowledge But herein the common prouerbe is verified plus vident oculi quà m oculus Mo eyes see more then one For the Vniuersity of Colen in their Censure Censur Colon explic Dial. 4. written against Monhemius though they were Papists and in other points aduersaries to the truth yet in this write farre otherwise then Bellarmine doth Fidei ratio in firma notitia consistit The definition say they of faith standeth vpon firme knowledge We cannot herein speake more contrary to Bellarmine then they haue done Yet true it is that Bellarmine in the Booke and Chapter last alleaged by mee granteth that in faith there is a kinde of knowledge for he saith there are in him that beleeueth two things Bellar. de Iustif l. 1. c. 7 assent and apprehension which apprehension he saith is notitia rudis confusa A rude and confused knowledge A knowledge belike such as his sight was Mar. 8.24 who saw men walking like trees sauing that this knowledge is not like to bring forth so good an effect as his vnperfit sight did 25. For he soone after was restored to his sight and saw euery man a farre off cleerely but they who seeke for faith in this confused knowledge shall neuer finde it An vnknowing knowledge the Papists brag of And if you desire to know what this confused knowledge is wherewith they content themselues you may giue a great ghesse thereof by that which they tell vs of the Colliars faith holden for a true faith in the Romish Church commended by Staphilus that slanderous Apostata approued also by Stapleton who translated that idle pamphlet Staphilus his Apologie The Colliar told the Deuill he beleeued as the Church beleeueth and the Church beleeued as he did But further what the Church beleeued or himselfe either he could not tell This is that confused knowledge then that they would men should content themselues withall to bee able to speake of the Church in generall but not of the particular doctrine thereof to call God Father but not to know by what meanes hee is our Father to say wee beleeue in Iesus Christ not vnderstanding any thing of his person or office And thus not to know how to apply vnto our selues the comfort of these or any other generall points is a found faith with our great Masters of Rome But though Staphilus say the Deuill was ouercome with that answere and put to flight yet sure I am that God requireth greater knowledge and therefore giueth his word and appointeth his ministerie for the instruction of his people A particular knowledge is needfull Exod. 12.26 Neither did Moses suppose such a generall knowledge would serue the turne when hee so straitly chargeth the Israelites to instruct their children in the true cause of their feast of Passeouer When your children saith he aske you what seruice is this you keepe Then shall yee say It is the sacrifice of the Lords Passeouer 27. which passed ouer the houses of the children of Israel in Aegypt when he smote the Aegyptians preserued our houses Ioshua also thought it not enough that Gods people should haue a generall perswasion that God was good but hee tooke order that his particular benefits should bee remembred euen of their children Iosh 4.6 7. And when Ioshua would that Moses should forbid Eldad and Medad Num. 11.29 to prophecie in the Host Moses answered Would God that all the Lords people were Prophets and the Lord would put his Spirit vpon them wishing a more speciall knowledge vnto them then was ordinary among Gods people And the Apostle prayeth that the Colossians may be fulfilled with knowledge of Gods will in all wisedome and spirituall vnderstanding He addeth his reason Coloss 1.9 that you may walke worthy of the Lord and please him in all things 10. giuing vs thereby to vnderstand that without particular knowledge of his will in all things we cannot please him But what stand I vpon this point Doth not Saint Peter who they say was the first Pope and therefore that he commandeth they will confesse must bee obeyed require such knowledge in euery Christian 1. Pet. 3.15 that they may be readie to giue answere to euery man that asketh a reason of the hope that is in them Shall wee then content our selues against so many expresse testimonies of the word with that rude and confused knowledge of Bellarmines or the Colliars faith so well liked of Staphilus But what reason haue they so to reioyce in this dimme light Why this generall knowlege is so praised of Papists Ioh. 3 20. like such as haue sore eies and therefore hang
something before them to keepe the brightnesse of the light from them Our Sauiour Christ yeeldeth the reason in these words Euery man that doth euill hateth the light neither commeth to the light lest his deedes should be reprooued Our aduersaries teach so many doctrines which cannot abide the light of the word and touchstone of truth they haue deuised and daily doe deuise so many fruitlesse workes and blind deuotions so many false and wil-worshippings and superstitious seruices repugnant to the Sacred Scriptures and so little sauouring of that obedience that is eyther commended in the godly or commaunded in the word that to cloke the wickednesse and abomination in many but folly and vanitie in the best of these their deuices they are forced to tell the people that ignorance is the mother of Deuotion for so they may lead them into a very dungeon of Superstition and that a folded vp faith is good enough for them Stapl. Antidot in Act. 16.31 Nec aliam simplex idiota Christianus habere tenetur neither is a simple and vnlearned Christian bound to haue any other faith Is not this the way to make fooles and idiots of Christians This this I say is the way to cast men into a gulfe of Idolatries Mat. 23.15 and to make men two-fold more the children of hell then you are And then with an Iöpoean you reioyce that Ignorance hath hatched many Deuotions A mother worthie of such badde Daughters Now this assent being proued to bee no true iustifying faith for thereby wee only beleeue that which God teacheth not in God as in our Creed we professe let vs step a little forward and see what this faith is which we affirme doth iustifie And if wee rightly consider thereof True faith we shall find two things necessarie for one that beleeueth the one is Knowledge the other is the Application of that our knowledge Knowledge That knowledge is necessarie to attaine to faith if we had no other proofe yet this were sufficient that God vseth so many wayes for the instruction of his people that by Ignorance they should not erre Hee giueth his Law to bee a rule of life and Religion appointeth his Priests to teach the same and to supply their negligence hee sendeth his Prophets extraordinary Messengers to iogge his people vpon the elbow so putting them in minde when they did amisse And hath hee not ordained the Ministerie Ephes 4.13 1. Cor. 14.26 that wee may meete together in the vnitie of faith and knowledge of the Sonne of God The sundry gifts that GOD hath giuen vnto his Church ought all to bee imployed to the edifying thereof Luk. 1.17 Iohn the Baptists office was to make readie a people prepared for the Lord as the Angell doth foreshew or as Zacharie his father sayth Luk. 1.76 To prepare the way of the Lord that is to make men fit to beleeue in Christ And how doth he execute this his function Euen by giuing knowledge of saluation vnto Gods people 77. by the remission of their sinnes Our Sauiour Christ thus speaketh vnto the Iewes Ioh. 10.38 If I doe the workes of my Father then though you beleeue not mee beleeue the workes that ye may know and beleeue As if he would say Vnlesse you know you cannot beleeue and therefore consider of my workes that you may know and so beleeue To this purpose also Act. 15.7 is that which Saint Peter said Among vs the Apostles God chose out me that the Gentiles by my mouth should heare the word of the Gospell and beleeue Now it is most plaine that men heare vnlesse they bee such forgetfull hearers as S. Iames misliketh that they may know Iam. 1.24 and so beleeue But that I may bee short Knowledge is so necessarie for such as beleeue as that it is taken for faith it selfe and that by one that did know better how to speake of these matters Ioh. 17.3 then all our Romish Rabbies This is life eternall sayth Christ to know thee to bee the only very God meaning that it is life eternall to beleeue God to bee the only verie God and whom hee had sent Iesus Christ and such speeches are common in the Scripture But as meate how good so euer nourisheth not but such as eate it and Physicke be it neuer so medicinable helpeth not but such as receiue it Euen so Application second thing required in faith if this knowledge be not applyed to the grieued or wounded conscience the offendour shall neuer haue peace with God therby The Apostle hauing handled at the ful the example of Abraham and set forth his constant faith with the comfortable effect it had That it was imputed to him for righteousnesse Rom. 4.22.23.24 then teacheth vs by application what vse we must make thereof It was not written for him only that it was imputed to him for righteousnesse but also for vs to whom it shall be imputed which beleeue in him who raysed vp Iesus our Lord from the dead Notably for this point Benard de Annunt Serm. 1. Saint Bernard writeth Si credas peccata tua non posse deleri nisi ab illo cui soli peccasti in quem peccata non cadunt bene facis If thou beleeue thy sinnes cannot be done away but by him against whom thou hast only sinned and who himselfe is not subiect to sinne thou dost well Here is a good and a Christian knowledge now marke what vse wee must make of it Sed adde adhuc sayth he in that verie place vt hoc credas quia per ipsum peccata tibi donantur Hoc est testimonium quod perhibet Spiritus Sanctus in corde tuo Dimissa sunt tibi peccata tua But yet adde this sayth good Bernard that thou also beleeue that by him thy sinnes are forgiuen thee This is the testimonie that the holy Ghost beareth in thine heart Thy sinnes are forgiuen thee Heere wee haue a particular application of that generall knowledge before mentioned And out of this place of Bernard wee are by the way to note how the Romish Church which would though most vniustly bee counted the true Church hath this long time deceiued the world in making men beleeue the Pope hath power to forgiue sinnes Man cannot forgiue sins whereas Saint Bernard most plainly and to the Scriptures most agreeably doth teach that God only can forgiue sinnes both because our sinne is a breach of his Law and himselfe cannot sinne Fye therefore vpon that man of sinne who being himselfe full fraught with sinne and ouerloden with wickednesse dare take vpon him that office that belongeth only to our Sinne-lesse GOD. He only can make cleane that which is conceiued of vncleane seed Job 14.4 and besides him none He I say hee only can truly make this Proclamation I I am he that putteth away thine iniquities Esa 43.25 for mine owne sake and will not remember thy sinnes
GOD had done no doubt many good Workes and offered many Sacrifices vnto God yet without respect vnto any of his Workes that hee now the childe and seruant of God had done Abraham beleeued God Gen. 15 6. Gal. 4.9.3 Rom. 4.13 and that his beleeuing was imputed to him for righteousnesse And therefore Paul is bolde to vse such exclusiue words The promise was not giuen through the Law but through the righteousnesse of faith And Sicut Abrahae nostra filiorum eius per gratiam sayth Primasius Primas in Epist ad Rom. 4. As was the Iustification of Abrahams so is ours also who are his children by grace But to be short I suppose we may bee bold to gather out of that which is said this reason As Abraham was iustified so shall wee bee but Abraham was iustified by faith without the workes that he did being Gods seruant therefore we also shall so be iustified All this argument may well and strongly be prooued out of this fourth Chapter of the Epistle to the Romanes But what neede many Arguments Confitentem habemus reum Stapleton our Countriman a sure friend to the Romish Church and as loth as any of them to write any thing that might any way impugne their Popish Maximes seeing the deadly wound which these words of the Apostle giue to their Doctrine of Merits is very carefull to salue that sore yet the force of truth driueth him to grant that heere the Apostle Antidot in Rom. 3.28 Our works cannot merit forgiuenesse of sinnes Excludit opera à virtute iustificandi absolutè id est à virtute remittendi peccata Excludeth Workes from hauing power simply or absolutely to iustifie that is to remit sinne or from power to remit sin What can be more plaine Good Workes cannot obtaine remission of sins sayth Stapleton and therefore not iustifie absolutely or perfitly Now an vnperfit Iustification we are not acquainted withal neither hath Christ or any of his Apostles taught vs any such But we know that a perfect cause hath her perfect effect a perfit Sacrifice such an one was that which Christ offered hath obtained perfect Iustification before God for all beleeuers But heere I would faine haue asked a question of Stapleton if he had beene aliue or of some other friend of his seeing hee is gone to giue an account how well he hath vsed his talent whether to gaine soules to Christ or to Antichrists how Parish Priests shall doe hereafter When men and women come to bee shriuen and haue confessed their sinnes shall their Ghostly Father bid them fast so many Frydayes Wednesdayes or Saints Eeues gad on Pilgrimage to Hales or Buxton to Compostel to Rome or to Loretta weare Haire-cloth next their skinne goe bare-foote and bare-legged shall they torment their bodie with Whips or other punishments Popish penances plaine cozenages or begger their Posteritie in building Chaunteries and such like places for satisfaction for sinne All this is to no purpose For Stapleton assureth vs there is in these or any other though better workes by farre such as GOD hath commanded no power to remit sinne so that Iustification must bee sought for some better way And so it seemeth the World hath beene couzened a great while by these cogging Companions which haue made men and women beleeue that by such Workes they may satisfie for their sinnes And thus I trust vpon so good a confession of Stapleton so good warrant of the Word and sure grounds of doctrine wee may conclude that a man is iustified and accounted guiltlesse before God by faith apprehending Christ Iesus in whom we haue redemption by forgiuenesse of our sinnes without any Merit of our Wrokes whether before or after our Iustification Now that which out of these words we conclude doth of necessitie follow but that our Aduersaries fearing lest their Diana of Merits should be nothing esteemed if they cast not a mist before mens eyes to hinder from them seeing the cleere light of truth that shineth in our Doctrine Act. 19.25.28 assemble as did the Siluersmiths at the call of Demetrius who told them by that craft they got their goods and with such other speeches made them full of wrath insomuch as they cried out saying Great is Diana of the Ephesians Euen so is it with vs. The Romish Demetrius that getteth much by selling such as they call good Workes with his followers seeking to defend the Doctrine of Merits cry out of that which teacheth Iustification by faith only whereby they may haue much losse if want of euill gotten goods may bee counted losse I confesse we teach that Faith only doth iustifie that is that a true and liuely faith wrought in our hearts by Gods Spirit working by loue True faith only iustifieth fruitfull in good workes adorned and beautified with holinesse of life for these are badges whereby to know a true faith doth iustifie and acquite vs before God so as wee boldly stand and plead not guiltie Whereby our Aduersaries may see how vniustly they slander vs and our Doctrine as if wee were enemies to all good Workes And yet we only teach that such a true faith as I haue now described without respect of the Workes that alwayes accompanie it doth iustifie not by the Merit of this faith but in that it is our hand whereby we apprehend and hold fast that Iustification which we haue in Christ through the vnspeakeable mercie of God And this our Doctrine is so warranted in Sacred Scripture as nothing more Saint Paul doeth often vse exclusiue words Exclusiue words Negatiue Equiualent as these are without the Law without Workes Sometime plaine negatiue words Not by Workes not by the Law Otherwhile words equiualent or of such like force As by grace Freely These manners of speech when I consider of I cannot but like well of the good and Christian counsell giuen by Primasius an ancient Writer Audi gratis tace de Meritis Heare what the Apostle sayth freely and speake not a word of Merits Thus therefore I reason for our Doctrine of Iustification by faith only If Workes are not to be ioyned with faith in the matter of Iustification then faith only euen by the confession of our Aduersaries doth iustifie For our Romish Catholikes denie not this our Doctrine but in respect of workes neyther doe they in any their Bookes or Writings seeke to match any thing with faith as cause of Iustification but workes only But workes are not to be ioyned with faith in the matter of Iustification as the Apostle most plainly proueth Gal. 2.16 Know ye that a man is not iustified by the Workes of the Law but by the faith of Iesus Christ Againe Ye are saued by grace Eph. 2.8.9 through faith not of your selues it is the gift of God not of Workes lest any man should boast himselfe Lastly these words to the Romanes are very effectuall Rom. 1.28 Therfore wee conclude that a man is iustified