became I praye you of Harolde that by briberie aÌ„d helpe of his kiÌ„red vsurped the crowne against the foresaide yonge Eadgar as I haue saide aÌ„d as the olde monumeÌ„rs of our historiopraphers do plainlie testifie was the trewe aÌ„d lawful hâ—ire Cui de iure debebatÌ„ regnuÌ„ Anglo ruÌ„ Io. â—od in chronic Angliae Coulde he thincke you enioye his ambitiouse aÌ„d nawghtie vsurpinge one whole aÌ„d eÌ„tier yeare No suerlie eare the first yeare of his vsurped reigne turned aboute he was spoyled aÌ„d turned owt bothe of crovne aÌ„d †Rex Edvvardê° misit c. Vt velâ—pÌ„e Edvvardê° vel filiae eâ—ê° sibi succedereÌ„t c. Rich. Cicest vid vvil Malmesb de regi Ang. l. 2. c. 45. l. 3. cap. 5. his lief with all FadeÌ„ verba sunt in Mat. vvestmo 1Ì„ flor hist Anâ—o 1066. Yea his vsurpatioÌ„ occasioÌ„ed the coÌ„queste of the whole realme by williaÌ„ Duke of NormaÌ„die bastarde Sonne to Roberte the sixte duke of the same And maye we thincke all saufe aÌ„d sownde nowe from like danger yf vve shoulde treade the saide vvroÌ„ge steppes vvithe Harolde forsakinge the right aÌ„d highe vvaye of lavve aÌ„d iustice What shall I nowe speake of the crevvell aÌ„d ciuill vvarres betvvene kinge Stephen and kinge HeÌ„rie the secoÌ„de Which vvarres rose by reasoÌ„ the saide HeÌ„ry vvas vniustlie kepte froÌ„ the crovne devë to his mother mavvde aÌ„d to him aftervvardes The petifull reigne of the saide IohnÌ„ vvho doth not lamente vvith the lamentable losse of Normandie Aquitanie and the possibilitie of the Dukedome of Britanie What cala mities fell to this real me by the vsurpiÌ„g of kinge Harrold K. Stephen and IohnÌ„ aÌ„d vvith the losse of our other goodlie possessions in Fraunce Wherof the crovvne of Englande vvas robbed and spoiled by the vnlavvfull vsurpinge of him againste his nephevve Arthur Well let vs leaue theys greauouse and lothsome remembrances and lett vs yet seake yf vve maye fynde any later interpretation either of the saide statute or rather of the coÌ„mon lavve for our purpose And lôa the greate goodnes and ê“uidence of God vvho hathe yf the foresaide exaÌ„ples wolde not serue prouided a later but so good so sure so apte and mete interpretation for our cause as any reasonable harte maye desier The interpretation directlie tovvchethe our case vvhiche I meane by the mariage of the Ladye Margaret eldest davvghter to kinge HeÌ„rie the seaveÌ„the vnto Iames the fowrthe kinge of Scotlande and by the opinion of the saide most prudente Prince in bestowinge his saide dawghter into Scotlande A matter sufficieÌ„t inoughe to ouerthrowe all those cauellinge inuentions of the aduersarie For what time kinge Iames the fowerth senâ—e his ambassadour to kinge Henrie the seauenthe to obteine his good vvill to espouse the saide Ladie Margaret Polid. 26. there were of his counsaile not ignorante of the lawes and customes of the realme Kinge H. vvith his cownsaile ys a good interpÌ„tour of our present cause that did not vvell like vppon the saide mariage sayenge yt might so fall ovvte that the right aÌ„d title of the crovvne might be deuolued to the Ladie Margaret and her children And the realme thereby might be subiecte to Scotlande To the vvhich the prudente and wise kinge ansvvered that in case any suche deuolution shoulde happen yt vvolde be nothinge preiudiciall to Englande For Englande as the cheif and principall and worthieste parte of the Isle shoulde drawe Scot lande to yt as yt did Normandie from the time of the coÌ„queste vvhiche ansvvere was vvonderfullie vvell liked of all the counsaile And so coÌ„sequentlie the mariage toke effecte as appearethe by Polidor the historiogropher of this realme And suche a one as vvrote the actes of the time by the instructioÌ„ of the kinge him self I saye theÌ„ the vvise worthy SalomoÌ„ foreseinge that suche deuolutioÌ„ might happen was an interpretatour with his prudent and sage consayle for our cause for eles they neaded not to reasoÌ„ of any suche subiection to Scotlande Yf the children of the Ladye Margaret might not lavvfullie inherite the crovvne of Englande For as to her husbande vve coulde not be subiecte hauinge him self no right by this mariage to the title of the crovvne of this realme Where vpon I maye well inferre that the saide nevve maxime of theis men whereby they wolde rule and ouer rule the succession of Princes was not knowen to the saide wise kinge neither to any of his counsaile Or yf yt were yet was yt taken not to reache to hys bloudd royall borne in Scotlande And so on everie side the title of Quene Marye ys assuerid So that nowe by this that we haue saide yt maye easelie be seen by what light and â—klender consideration the adversarie hathe gone abowte to straine the wordes Enfants or childreÌ„ to the first degre onlie Of the like weight ys his other consideration imageninge aÌ„d surmisinge this statute to be made by cawse the kinge had so manye occasions to be so often over the sea vvith his spowse the Quene As thowghe diuers kinges before him vsed not often to passe over the seas As thowghe this were a personall statute made of speciall purpose and not to be taken as a declaration of the coÌ„mon lawe Whiche to saie ys moste directlie repugnaÌ„te and contrarious to the letter of the saide statute Or as thowghe his children also did not verie often repayre to owterwarde contreies as IohnÌ„ of Gawnte Duke of Lancaster Polid Polychr Froserd that Maried Peters the kinge of castilles eldest dawghter by whose right he claimed the crovne of castill as his brother Edmunde The mariages of k. E. 3. sones Erle of camebridge that maried the yongeste dawghter as lionell Duke of clarence that maried at Millain Violane Dawghter and heire to Galiatius Duke of Millan But especiallie Prince Edwarde whiche most victoriouslie toke in battaile IohnÌ„ the Frenche kinge and browght hym into Englande his prisoner to the greate triumphe and reioicinge of the realme whose eldest sonne Edwarde that died in shorte time after was borne beyonde the seas in Gascoigne and his other sonne Richarde that succeded hys grandfather was borne at Burdeauxe As theis noble kinge Edwardes sonnes Married withe forrainers So did theye giue ovvte theire dawghters in Mariage to forraine Princes As the Duke of Lancaster his dawghter Philippe to the kinge of Portingale and his dawghter Katherin to the Kinge of Spaine And his nece IohaÌ„ dawghter to his sonne Erle of Somersett was ioined in mariage to the Kinge of Scottes IohaÌ„ dawghter to his brother Thâ— mas of Wodstocke Duke of GloÌ„cester was Quene of Spaine And his other dawghter Marie Duches of Bretaigne Nowe by thys mans interpretation none of the issewe of all theis noble womeÌ„ coulde have enioyed the crowne of Englande wheÌ„ yt had fallen to them thowghe they had bene of the neareste royall bloudd after the deathe of theire Auncesters Which suerlie had bene against the auncientâ— presidentes and examples that we
one as for the excelleÌ„te giftes of God and nature in her most princelie appearinge ys vvorthie to inherite either this noble realme or any other be yt of muche more dignitie and worthines But nowe I claime nothinge for the vvorthines of the person whiche God forbidd shoulde be any thinge preiudiciall to the iuste title of others yf moste open and manifeste right Iustice and title do not coÌ„curre with the worthines of the person Then lett the praise and Worthines remaine where yt ys And the right Where God and the lavve hathe placed yt But seinge God nature and the lavve dothe call the person to this expectation whose intereste and claime I do novve prosequute I meane the right excellente Ladie The Quene of Scots is the right heire appareÌ„te to the crovvne of Englande Ladie Marie Quene of Scotlande I hope that when her right and iuste title shall be throwghlie harde and considered by the indifferente Reader yf he be persvvaded alredie for her right he shall be more firmelie setled in his trevve and good opinion and that the other parties beinge of a contrarie minde shall finde good cavvses and grovvndes to remoue them from the same and to geaue ouer and yelde to the trevvthe Her graces title then yf God call our Souereigne ovvte of this transitorie life hauinge no issue of her maiesties bodye as yt ys moste open and euidende so yt ys moste conformable to the lavve of God of nature and of this realme And consequentlie in a manner of all other realmes in the vvorlde as grovvinge by the neareste proximitie of the royall bloude She ys a kinges and a Quenes davvghter her self a Quene Davvghter to the late kinge Iames of Scotlande sonne to ladie Margarett the eldest sister to our late Souereigne kinge Henrie the eight Whose Davvghter also the ladie Lenoux ys but by a later husbande The ladie Frances late vvyfe to Henry Marques dorsett aftervvarde Duke of Suffoocke And the ladie Elenour late vvyfe to the Erle of Cumberlande and theire progenye procedethe from the ladie Marie dowager of France yongest sister of the saide kinge Henrie late vvife to Charles Brandon Duke of Suffolke I might here fetche forthe olde farne dayes I might reache backe to the noble and vvorthie kinges longe before the conqueste of vvhose royall bloude she ys discended vvhiche ys no parte of our purpose neither dothe enforce her title more then to proue her no stranger vvithin this realme But the argumentes and proufes which vve meane to alleage and bringe forthe for the confirmation of her right and title in succession as heire apparente to the crovvne of Englande are gathered and grovvnded vpon the lavves of God and nature and not onlie receaued in the ciuill pollicies of other nations but also in the olde lawes and customes of our ovvne contrey by reason approued and by vse and longe concontinevvance of time obserued from the firste constitution of this realme in politicall order vnto this presente daye And yet for all that hathe yt bene aÌ„d yet ys by some men attempted artificiallie to obiecte and caste manie mistie darke clovvdes before meÌ„nes eyes to kepe from them yf yt maye be the cleare light of the saide iuste title the vvhiche they vvolde extingvvishe or at the leaste blemishe withe some obscure shadovve of lavve But in deede against the lavve and vvith the shadovve of parliameÌ„ts But in deede against the trewe meaninge of the pliameÌ„tes And albe it yt were inowghe for vs our cawse beinge so firmelie aÌ„d suerlie established vpoÌ„ all good reason aÌ„d lawe to stande at defence and onlie to auoide as easelie vve maye theire obiections Whiche principallie and cheifelie are grovvnded vpon the common lawes and statutes of this realme yet for the betteringe aÌ„d strengtheninge of the same vve shall laye forthe sondrie greate aÌ„d inuincible reasons coÌ„ioyned vvithe good and sufficieÌ„t aucthoritie of the lawe so approued and coÌ„firmed that the aduersaries shall neuer be able iustlie to impugne them And so that vve truste after the readinge of this our treatise aÌ„d the effectes of the same vvell digested no manner of scruple owght to remaine in any indiferent mans harte concerninge her right and title Whose expectatioÌ„ aÌ„d coÌ„science althovvghe we truste fullie in this discourse to satisfie aÌ„d doubte nothinge in the vvorlde of the rightfulnes of our cause Yet must we nedes coÌ„fesse the maÌ„ner aÌ„d forme to eÌ„treate therof to be full of difficultie aÌ„d ê‘plexitie For suche causes of Princes as they be seldome and rare so ys yt more rare and stange to finde them discoursed discussed and determined by any lawe or statute Albe it nowe and then some statutes tende that vvaye Neither do our lavves not the corps of the Romaine and ciuill lavve lightlie medle With the princely gouernemente but vvith priuate mens causes And yet this not withstandinge for the better iustifiengè of our cavvse albe yt I denye not but that by the coÌ„mon lavve yt muste be knovven vvho ovvght to haue the crovvne And that the coÌ„mon lavve muste discerne the right aswell of the crowne as of subiects Yet I saye that there ys a greate difference betvvene the kinges right aÌ„d the right of others And that the title of the crovvne of this realme ys not subiecte to the rules and principles of the coÌ„mon lavve of this realme as to be ruled and tried after suche order and course as the inheritance of priuate personnes ys by the same The coÌ„moÌ„ lavve of this realme ys rather grouÌ„ded vpon a generall custome then any lawe written For the prouf wherof let vs consider What the comon lavve of this rerealme ys and howe the rules therof be grownded and do take place Yt ys verie manifeste and plaine that the comon lawe of this realme of Englande ys no lawe WritteÌ„ but grovvnded onlie vppoÌ„ a coÌ„mon and generall custome throvvghe ovvte the vvhole realme as apparethe by the treatise of the aunciente and famous vvriter vpon the lavves of the realme named RANVLPHVS DE GLANVILLA In ê“logo suo eâ—sdeÌ„ libri fol. 1. 2. Who wrote in the time of the noble kinge Henrie the secoÌ„de De dicto Ranulpbo Glanuilla vide GeralduÌ„ CaÌ„breÌ„sem in Topogra de vvallia of the lavve and custome of the realme of englande Beinge then and also in the time of the reigne of kinge Richarde the first the cheif counsailler and iustice of the same kinge And also by the famous Iustice Fortescue in his booke which he wrote beinge Chancellour of Englande Fortescue de laud legum Angliae ca. 17 De laudibus legum Angliae And by 33 H. 6 51. and by 8. E. 4. 19. Which custome by vsage and coÌ„tinuall practise heretofore had in the kinges covvrtes vvithin this realme ys onlie knovven and mainteined 8. E. 4 19 33. H. 6 51 piÌ„soÌ„s printe Wherein we seame muche agreable to the olde lacedemoniaÌ„s vvho manie hundred yeares past most politikelie and famouselie gouerned theire common
the kiÌ„ge Yet vntill suche time as the Kinge be intitled ther vnto by matter of recorde the inheritance remaynethe in the alien by the opinioÌ„ of all men And so ys a verie alien capable of inheritance within this realme And then it muste nedes fall ovvte plainlie that your generall maxime vvhere vpon you haue talked and braged so muche ys novve become no rule of the common lavve of this realme And yf it be so then haue you vttered very many vvordes to small purpose But yet let vs see farther vvhether there be any rule or maxime in the coÌ„mon lavve that maye seame any thinge like to that rule Whervpon any matter maie be gathered against the title of the saide Marie Quene of Scotland There ys one rule of the coÌ„mon lavve in vvordes somevvhat like vnto that vvhiche hathe bene alleaged by the aduersaries Whiche rule ys sett forthe and declared by a statute made An. 25. of Kinge Edwarde the thirde Whiche statute recitinge the dovvbte that then vvas Whether infantes borne ovvte of the allegiance of Englande shoulde be able to demaunde any heritage vvithin the same allegiaÌ„ce or no Yt vvas by the same statute ordained that all Infantes inheritours Whiche after that time shoulde be borne owte of the allegiance of the kinge whose father and mother at the time of theire birthe were of the faithe and allegiance of the kinge of Englande shoulde haue and enioye the same benefittes and aduantages to haue aÌ„d carrie heritage within the saide allegiance as other heires shoulde Where vpon yt ys to be gathered by dewe and iuste construction of the statute and so hathe bene heretofore coÌ„monlie taken that the common lawe alwayes was and yet ys that no person borne owte of the allegiance of the kinge of Englande whose father and mother were not of the same allegiance shoulde be able to haue or demaunde any heritage within the same allegiance as heire to any person Whiche rule I take to be the same supposed maxime whiche the adâ—saries do meane But to stretche yt generallie to all inheritances as the aduersaries wolde seame to do by anie reasonable meanes caÌ„ not be The statute of Edvvard 3. anno 25. touchethe inheritaÌ„ce and not purchasse For as I haue saied before euery straÌ„ger and alien borne maye haue and take inheritance as a purchasâ—er And if an alien do marrie a woman inheritable the inheritance therby ys bothe in the alien and also in his wife And the alien therby a purchasâ—er No man dowbteth but that a denizen maye purchasse landes to his owne vse 11. H. 4. fol. 25. but to inherite landes as heire to any person vvith in the allegiance of Englande he can not by any meanes So that yt seamethe verie plaine that the saide rule bindethe also denizens and dothe onlie extende to discentes of inheritance and not to the hauinge of anie landes by purchasse Nowe will we then consider whether this rule by any reasonable coÌ„struction can extende vnto the ladie Marie the Quene of Scotlande for and concerninge her title to the crowne of EnglaÌ„d Yt hathe bene sayed by the aduersaries that she was borne in Scotlande whiche realme ys owte of the allegiance of Englande her father and mother not beinge of the same allegiance And therefore by the saide rule she ys not inheritable to the crowne of this realme Althowghe I might at the begininge verie vvell and orderlie denie the consequente of your argumente yet for this time we will firste examine the antecedente whether yt be trewe or no And then consider vpon the consequenâ—e That the Quene of Scotlande was borne in Scotlande Scotlande ys within the allegiaÌ„ce of Englande yt must nedes be graunted but that Scotlande ys owte of the allegiaÌ„ce of EnglaÌ„de thowghe the saide Quene of Scotlande and all her subiectes of Scotlande vvill stovvtely affirme the same yet there are a greate nomber of men in Englande both learned and others that be not of that opinion beinge ledd and persvvaded there vnto by diuers histories registers recordes aÌ„d instrumeÌ„tes of homage remaininge in the treasurie of this realme Wherin ys mentioned that the kinges of Scotlande haue acknovvledged the kinge of Englande to be the superiour lorde ouer the realme of Scotlande and haue done homage aÌ„d fealtie for the same Which thinge beinge trevve not vvithe standinge yt be comonlie denied by all Scottes men then by the lavves of this realme Scotlande muste nedes be accompted to be vvith in the allegiance of Englande And altowghe sins the time of kinge Henrie the sixt none of the kinges of ScotlaÌ„de haue done the saide seruice vnto the kinges of Englande Yet that ys no reason in our lavve to saye that therefore the realme of Scotlande at the time of the birthe of the saide Ladye Marie Quene of Scotlande beinge in the thirtie and fovverthe yeare of the reigne of our late Souereigne lorde kinge Henrie the eight vvas ovvte of the allegiance of the kinges of Englande For the lavve of this realme ys verie plaine that thovvghe the tenaunte do not his seruice vnto the lorde yet hathe not the lorde therby lost his seigneurie for the lande still remainethe within his fee and seigneurie that not with standinge The lorde losethe not his sâ—igniâ—rie though the tenaÌ„te dothe not his seruice But paraduenture some vvill obiecte and saye that by that reason FraÌ„ce shoulde likevvise be sayed to be with in the allegiance of Englande for as muche as the possession of the crovvne of France hathe bene vvithin a litle more then the space of one hundred yeares novve laste paste lavvfullie vested in the kinges of EnglaÌ„d Whose right and title still remainethe in the Quenes maiestie that novve ys To that there ys a greate difference betvvene the right and title vvhiche our Souereigne ladie claimethe to the realme of France aÌ„d the right and title vvhiche her highnes claimethe to the realme of ScotlaÌ„d Althowghe yt be trevve that the kinge of Englande hathe bene lavvfullie possessed of the crowne of France vvhose right and title by iuste and lavvfull succession ys deuolued vnto our saide Souereigne ladie Yet duringe suche time as her highnes by vsurpation of other ys dispossessed of the saide realme of France the same realme by no meanes can be saide to be with in her highnes allegeaÌ„ce especiallie coÌ„sideringe howe that sins the time of vsurpation the people of France haue wholie forsaken theire allegeance and subiection whiche they did owe vnto the kinges of EnglaÌ„de And haue geuen and submitted them selues vnder the obedience and allegeance of the vsurpers But as for the realme of Scotlande yt ys oterwise For the title which our Souereigne Ladie and Quene and her ê“genitours haue claimed vnto the realme of ScotlaÌ„de ys not in the possession of the lande and crowne of Scotlande but onlie vnto the seruice of homage and fealtie for the same And althowghe the kinges of Scotlande sithe the time of kinge Henrie the eight haue intermitted to
And no dovvbte in case she had any children by the Emperour they shoud haue bene heires by succession to the crovvne of EnglaÌ„de After vvhose deathe she retorned to her father yet did kinge HeÌ„ry cause all the nobilitie by an expresse othe to embrace her after his deathe as Quene olid and after her her children Not longe after she vvas Married to Geffrey Plantagenet a Frencheman borne Erle of Anievve vvho begart of her this Henrie the seconde beinge in France Where vpoÌ„ the saide kinge did reuiue aÌ„d renevve the like othe of allegeaÌ„ce asvvell to her as to her sonne after her Withe the like false persvvasion the aduersarie abusethe him The like foÌ„de imagination to vvchyngeâ—k Rich. hu nephewe self and his Reader towchinge Arthur Duke of Britanie nephewe to kinge Richarde the firste As thowghe for sowthe he were iustlie excluded by kinge IohnÌ„ his vncle by cause he was a forrainer borne Flores historiarum an 1153. Yf he had sayed that he was excluded by reason the vncle owght to be preferred before the nephevve thovvghe yt shoulde haue bene a false allegation and plaine against the rules of the lavves of this realme as maye vvell appeare amoÌ„ge other thinges by kinge Richard the secoÌ„d who succeded his grandfather kinge Edwarde the thirde which Richarde had diâ—ers worthy aÌ„d noble vncles who neither for lacke of knowledge coulde be ignoraÌ„te of their right Diuersitie of opinioÌ„s towchinge the vncle aÌ„d nephewe whether of them ovvght to be preferred in the royall gouernemeÌ„t neither for lacke of Frendes cowrage aÌ„d power be enforced to forbeare to chaleÌ„ge theire title aÌ„d intereste yet shoulde he haue had some countenance of reason aÌ„d ê“babilitye by cause many argumeÌ„tes aÌ„d the authoritie of many learned aÌ„d notable ciuiliaÌ„s do coÌ„curre for the vncles right before the nephewe But to make the place of the natiuitie of an inheritour to a kingdome a sufficient barre against the right of his bloude Polid. yt seameth to haue but a weake and slender holde and grovvnde And in our case yt ys a moste vnsure and false grownde seinge yt ys moste trewe that kinge Richarde the firste as vwe haue saide declared the saide Arthur borne in Britanye and not sonne of a kinge but his brother Geffreys sonne Duke of Britanye heire apparente Flores his an 1190. his vncle IohnÌ„ yet liuinge and for suche a one ys he taken in all our stories and for suche a one did all the vvorlde take him after the saide kinge Richarde his deathe Neither vvas kinge IohnÌ„ taken for other then for an vsurper by excludinge him The possessioÌ„s of the crowne of â—nglands that were beyoÌ„de the seas seased into the Frenche kiÌ„gs handes for the murther of Arthur and aftervvarde for a murtherer for imprisoninge him and priuelie makinge him avvaye For the vvhiche facte the Frenche kinge seased vpon all the goodlie contreies in France belonginge to the kinge of Englande as forfeited to him beinge the cheif lorde By this ovvtragiouse deede of kinge IohnÌ„ vve loste Normandie vvith all and our possibilitie to the inheritance of all Britanie the right and title to the saide Britanie beinge devve to the saide Arthur and his heires by the right of his mother Constance And thovvghe the saide kinge IohnÌ„ by the practise and ambitioÌ„ of Quene Elenour hys mother aÌ„d by the speciall procuremente of Huberte then Archbusshoppe of Caunterburie and of some other factious persons in Englande preven tid the saide Arthur his nephewe as yt was easie for hym to do havinge gotten into his handes all hys brother Richardes treasure besides many other rentes then in Englande And the saide Arthur beinge an enfante and remayninge beyonde the sea in the custodie of the saide Constance Yet of this facte beinge againste all iustice aswell the saide Archebusshoppe as also manie of the other did after moste earnestlie repente consideringe the crewell and the vniuste puttinge to deathe of the saide Arthur procured Polid. lib. 15. Flor. histor an 1208. and after some authours comytted by the saide IohnÌ„ hym self which moste fowle and shamefull acte the saide IohnÌ„ neaded not to have comitted yf by forraine birthe the saide Arthur had bene barred to inherite the crowne of EnglaÌ„de And muche lesse to have imprisoned that moste innocente ladie Elenour Sister to the saide Arâ—hur in Bristowe castle where she miserablie ended her life Yf that gaâ—e Maxime wolde have serued to have excluded theis two children by cawse theye were straÌ„gers borne in the parteis beyonde the seas Yea yt appearethe in other doinges also of the saide time and by the storie of the saide IohnÌ„ that the birthe owte of the legeance of Englande by father aÌ„d mother forraine was not taken for a sufficient repulse and reiection to the right and title of the crowne For the Barones of EnglaÌ„de beinge then at dissention with the saide kinge IohnÌ„ renowncinge their allegeance to hym receaued Lewes the eldeste Sonne of Phillippe the frenche kinge to be theire kinge in the right of Blanche his wife which was a stranger borne Albeit the lawfullnece of the saide Richard and dawghter to AlphoÌ„s kinge of castill begotten on the bodie of Elenour hys wife one of the dawghters of kinge Henrye the seconde and sister to the saide kinge Richarde and kinge IohnÌ„ Whiche storie I alleage onlie to this purpose thereby to gather the opinion of the time * Levves the fraÌ„che kinges sonne claimed the crovne of this realme iÌ„ the title of his vvife that forraine birthe was then thowght no barre in the title of the crowne For otherwise howe coulde Lewes of France †Pro here ditatevxoris iâ—re scilicet neptis Reg Io. vsque â—d mortem 〈◊〉 necessitas exigeret decertabâ— pretende title to the crowne in the right of the saide Blanche hys wife beinge borne in Spaine Theis exaÌ„ples are sufficieÌ„te I suppose to satisfie and contente any man that ys not obstinatelie vvedded to his ovvne fonde fantasies and frowarde friuoulous imaginations Flores histo An. 1216. or otherwise worse depâ—aued for a good suer aÌ„d substanciall interpÌ„tation of the coÌ„mon lawe And yt were not altogether froÌ„ the purpose here to coÌ„sider aÌ„d weighe with what aÌ„d howe greauouse plagues this realme hath bene ofte afflicted aÌ„d scowrged by reason of wroÌ„gfull aÌ„d vsurped titles I will not reuiue by odiouse rehearshall the greatnes aÌ„d noÌ„ber of the same plagues aswell otherwise as especiallie by the contentioÌ„ of the noble howses aÌ„d famelies of yorke aÌ„d LaÌ„caster â–ª Seinge yt ys so fortunatelie and almoste with in maÌ„s remeÌ„braÌ„ce extiÌ„ctâ— aÌ„d buried Haroldê° muneribê° genore fretê° regni diadema inuasit HeÌ„r Hunt histâ— Angliae li. 6. I will nowe putt the gentle Reader in remeÌ„braÌ„ce of those onlie with whose vsurpinge titles we are nowe pÌ„sentlie in haÌ„de And to begiÌ„ne with the moste auncient Cui regnum iure hereditario debebatur Ealredus Rieuall in hist. R. Angl. ad H. 2. what
suche lawfull prouffe againste the saide will ê“ducted For yf yt had bene yt wolde haue bene publisshed in the starre chamber preached at Pawles crosse declared by acte of parliamente proclaymed in euerie quarter of the realme Yea admittinge saye they that yt were proued that the saide pretensed will lacked the kinges haÌ„de yet neuerthelesse saye they the verye copies we haue spoken of beinge writteÌ„ signed or at leaste interlined with his owne hande maye be saide a sufficiente signinge with his owne hande For seinge the scope and finall purpose of the statute vvas to haue the succession prouided for and asserteined which ys sufficientlie done in the saide vvill And seinge his ovvne hande was required but onlie for eschevvinge euill aÌ„d sinister dealinge vvherof there is no suspition in this vvill to be gathered What matter in the vvorlde or vvhat differeÌ„ce ys there When the kinge fulfilled and accomplished this gratious acte that was loked for at his handes Whether he signed the will vvith his ovvne hande or no. Yf yt be obiected that the kinge was obliged and bovvnde to a certaine precise order and forme vvhiche he coulde in no vvise shifte but that the acte withoute yt muste perishe and be of no valewe Then saie they we vndoe vvhole ê‘liameÌ„tes asvvell in Quene Maries time as in kinge Henrie the eightes time In Quene Maries time by cawse she omitted the stile appointed by parliamente Anno Henrici octaui tricefimâ— quinto Ann. H. 8. 35. In kinge Henries time by reason there was a Statute that the kinges will abseÌ„te maye be geaven to an acte of parliameÌ„t by hys lettres pateÌ„tes signed with his hande Ann. H. 8. 33. 21. thowghe he be not there personallie And yet did the saide kinge supplie full ofte hys consente by the stampe onlie This yet not with standinge the saide parliamentes for the omission of formes so exactelie and precisely appointed An ansvvere by the vvaye of reioynder to the same are not distroied and disanulled After this sort in effecte Haue the aduersaries replied for the defence of the saide pretensed will To this we will make our reioynder and saye Firste that our principall matter ys not to ioyne an issewe whether the saide kinge made and ordeined any sufficiente will or noo We leaue that to an other time But whether he made any testamente in suche order and forme as the statute require the. Wherefore yf yt be defectiue in the saide forme as we affirme yt to be were yt otherwise neuer so good and perfecte thowghe yt were exemplified by the greate seale and recorded in the chauncerie and taken coÌ„monlie for his will and so accomplished yt ys nothinge to the principall question Yt resteth then for vs to consider the weight of the aduersaries presumptions whereby they wolde enforce a probabilitie that the testamente had the foresaide requisite forme yet firste yt ys to be considered what presumptions and of what force and nomber do occurre to auoide and frustrate the aduersaries presumptions and all other like We saye then there occurre manye likelihoddes Diuers pÌ„sumptions aÌ„d reasons agaiÌ„st the supposed vvill manye presumptions manye greate and weightie reasons to make vs to thincke that as the kinge neuer had good and iuste cause to mynde and entreprise suche an acte as ys pretended So likewise he did entreprise no suche acte in deede I denie not but that their vvas suche auctoritie geaueÌ„ him neither denie but that he might also in some honorable sorte haue practised the same to the honour aÌ„d welthe of the realme to the good coÌ„teÌ„tatioÌ„ of the same realme But that he had either cause or did exercise the saide aucthoritie in suche strange aÌ„d dishonorable sorte as ys pÌ„teÌ„ded I plainlie denie For beinge at the time of this pÌ„tensed will furnissâ—ed and adorned with issewe our late kiÌ„ge Edward aÌ„d ladie Marie late Quene aÌ„d with our graciouse souereigne Elizabeth theire state aÌ„d successioÌ„ beinge also latelie by acte of ê‘lameÌ„te established what nede or likelyhode was there for the kinge theÌ„ to practise such newe deuises as neuer did I suppose any kinge in the realme before aÌ„d fewe in any other beside And vvhere they vvere practised comonly had infortunate and lamentable successe What likeliehodd was there for him to practise suche deuises especiallie in his later dayes when wisdome the loue of God and his realme shoulde haue bene most ripe in him That were likely to sturre vppe a greater fier of greauouse contention and wofull distruction in Englande Then euer did the deadlie factioÌ„ of the redd rose and the white lately by the incorporation and vnioÌ„ of the howses of yorke and Lancaster in the ê‘soÌ„ of his father throwghe the mariage of Ladie Elizabeth eldeste dawghter to kinge Edwarde the fowrth most happelie extinguished aÌ„d buried And thowghe yt might be thowght or saide that there wolde be no suche cause of feare by reason the matter passed by parliameÌ„te yet coulde not he be ignorante that nether pÌ„liameÌ„tes made for Henrie the fowrthe or continewance of two discentes Which take no place in geuinge any title touchinge the crowne in kinge Henrie the sixte nor parliamentes made for kinge Richarde the thirde nor ê‘liamentes of attaynder made againste his father coulde either preiudice his fathers right or releue other againste suche as preteÌ„ded iuste right and title And as he coulde not be ignorante therof so yt ys not to be thought that he vvolde abuse the greate confidence putt vpon him by the parliamente and disherite vvith ovvte any apparente cause the next royall bloude and thincke all thinges suer by the colour of a ê‘liamente The litle force vvherof againste the right inheritour he had to his fathers and his ovvne so ample benefitt so latelie and so largelie seen and felte and yet yf he mynded at any time to preiudice the sayde Ladye Marie Quene of Scotlande of all times he wolde not haue done yt then wheÌ„ all his care vvas by all possible meanes to contriue and compasse a mariage betwene his sonne Edwarde and the saide Ladie and Quene Suerlie he vvas to vvise of him self and vvas furnisshed vvithe to wise counsailours to take suche an homelie vvaye to ê“cure aÌ„d purchasse the saide mariage by And leste of all can vve saye he attempted that disshonorable disherison for anye speciall inclination or fauour he bare to the freÌ„che Quene his sisters children For there haue bene of his nere and priuie counsaile that haue reported that the kinge neuer had any greate likinge of the mariage of his sister vvith the Duke of Suff. Who married her firste priuelie in Fraunce aÌ„d afterwarde openlie in Englande and as yt ys saide had his pardon for the same priuie mariage in vvritinge Howe soeuer this matter goethe certaine yt ys that yf this pretensed vvill be trewe he transferred and transposed the reuersion of the crowne not onlie from the Quene of Scotlande from my Ladie Lenneux and theire issewe but eauen from
senteÌ„ce as well in publike as in priuate causes Wâ—meÌ„s regiment in Spaine PortiÌ„gale â–ª Burgundie aÌ„d Flaunders Irmelgardis daughter of Conrade Duke of FraÌ„con Whose gouernement was also prosperouse happie and fortunate More ouer yt appeareth that the IllyriaÌ„s and Slauons were ruled by Quene Teuca what shall I speake of Spaine and Portugale of the Dukedome of BurguÌ„dye aÌ„d of the Erledome of Flaunders and of other partes of lower Germanie Conrade the Duke of FraÌ„conye and LaÌ„rgraue of Hesse vvas made countye Palatine of Rhene and Duke of LorraÌ„ne by the inheritance of his wife Irmelgardis Monster Cosâ— vniuersal li. 3. pag. 620. He had but one daughter who was maried to CoÌ„rade duke of Sueuia whereby he was made comtye Palatine of Rhene Agnes vvife to HeÌ„ry duke of Saxonie This Conrade had a dawâ—hter called Agnes maried to HeÌ„rie Duke of Saxonie and Limâ—burge who thereby enioyed the countie Palatine The like maye be sayed of diuers other partes of the Germanicall Empire Agenes wif to Henrie the 3. Emperour Yea a vvoman hathe ruled and gouerned the saide vvhole Empire as yt ys euideÌ„te in Agnes the vvif of the Emperour Henrie the thirde duringe the time of the minoritie of her sonne HeÌ„rie the fowrthe And yet the same Empire Paul Aemil lib. 3. ye wote well passeth by choise and election and not by liniall succession of bloude Chari li. 3. Yea manye hundrethe yeares ere she was borne and in the floreshinge time of the olde Romaine Empire Fulgo l. 8. cap 16. de dict fac memor Mesa Varia graÌ„dmother to the Emperours Heliogabalus and AlexaÌ„der Seuerus sat with the senate at Rome hearde and examined the vveightie causes of the Empire Crana noah daughter and sett her hand also to suche thinges as passed towchinge the publike affaires I do nowe adioine the kingdome of Sicilie Beros li. 5. Lâ—uâ— lib. 1. Dec. 1. and Naples in Italye of the vvhich I talye Noah vvhome the prophaâ—e vvriters call Ianus made Crana his dawghter rulâ—r aÌ„d Quene Aene. Sylui de Asia ca. 20. Where also Lauinia reigned after the deathe of Aeneas And as for Naples this presidente of vvomanlye gouernemeÌ„te ys not to be fownde there onlye of later yeares in bothe the Quenes called Iohanne Quene of Naples Amalacintha but eauen from verye Auncient time Which thinge the stories do recorde in Amalasyntha that gouerned after kinge Theodoricus with her sonne Athalaricê° Cronic Palmerij H. contracti MuÌ„st vniuers Cosmo. lib 4. The saide Amalasyntha vvas mother to Almaricus kinge of Spaine and after his death ruled her self the saide realme WomeÌ„s regiment in Loraine aÌ„d Mantua Lett vs nowe adde further the Dukedomes of Lorane Mantua the kiÌ„gdomes of Swethia Aeneas Siluiê° in desc Asiâ— c. 10. Hector Boet l. 1. Hâ— Sco. Vide la Geneal des Rois de FraÌ„c impr Paris 1561 in Carolo Magno of Dania and of Noruegia In the kiÌ„gdome of Svvethia Dania and Norwegia Boeame Hungarie and Scotlande Wherof Margarett the dawghter of waldemaâ—us was gouernesâ—e and Quene The kingdomes of Beame of Hungarie And to drawe nerer home the realme also of ScotlaÌ„de vvhich realme hathe denomination of a woman as theire stories reporte as hathe likewise FlauÌ„ders The like some of our stories reporte of EnglaÌ„de wherein I will make no fast foringe Now touchiÌ„ge the feminine successioÌ„ to the right of the croune of EnglaÌ„d Englande it ys no newe fownde succession and muche lesse vnnaturall We reade in our cronicles of Quene Cordell the thirde heire davghter of kinge Leire the tenthe kinge of Britannie that restored her father to the kiÌ„gdome beinge deposed by her tvvo other sisters We reade that abowte three hundred fiftie and fiue yeares before the Natiuitie of Christe Martia ê“ba Martiae proba duringe the nonage of her sonne did gouerne this realme full politikelye and vviseâ—ye HeleÌ„a mother to CoÌ„staÌ„tine the greate and established certaine lavves called Leges Martianae There be aswel of our owne as of externall historiographers that for a moste certaintye affirme that Helena the noble Constantine his mother vvas a Britane Onuph de Rom. priÌ„c Eusâ—bi de vita CoÌ„staÌ„ lâ— 1. and the onlye dawghter and heire of Coëlus kinge of Britane and that the saide constantine was borne in Britanie suerlye that his father Constantinus died in Britanye at yorke Eutropius and that the saide Constantinus begane his noble victoriouse race of his moste worthie Empire in Britanye yt ys reported by Aunciente vvriters and of greate faythe and creditt And likevvise that longe before the saide Helens time vvomen bare the greateste svvaye Britanes had vvomen for theire Capitaines in vvarfare Voadicâ— Amonge other Coâ—nâ—lius Tacitus writethe thus His atque alijs inuicem instructi Voadica generis regij foemina duce neque enim sexum in imperijs discernunt sumpsere vniuersi bellum In vita Agricolae We have nowe alredie shevved of Henrie the seconde Henry the secoÌ„dâ— kinge by hys mothers right who obteined the crowne by hys mothers right Which sayde kinge by the title of his wife and after him his successours kinges of Englande did enioye the Dukedome of Aquitania and the ErldoÌ„e of Poyctieres Vide AlliaÌ„t geneal claud paradini 1561. as the saide kiÌ„ges successours shoulde haue done also as we haue shewed before the Dukedome of Britanye yf Arthure kinge Richardes nephevve had not by the vsurpinge of kinge Iohan his vnnaturall crueltye died withovvte issewe And by what other right then by the womans inheritance devve to kinge Edwarde the thirde by his mother the FreÌ„che kinges Davvghter do the kinges of this realme beare the Armes and title of the kinges of France The Frenche men make not vvomens regiment vnnaturall And thovvghe the french men thâ—nâ—ke theire parte the better against vs yt ys not but vppon an olde politike lawe of theire owne as they saye aÌ„d not vpon anye suche fonde grovvnde as ye pretende that womens regiment ys vnnaturall Which regimente ye stowtelie affirme to be farre a sonder from any naturall regimente Yea trewlie as farre as was the boyes head from the shovlders the laste Bartholomewe fayre at London Which manie a poore sowle did beleave to be trewe For as the boyes head remained still vpon hys necke and shoulders thowghe yt seamed by a light livelie Legerdemayne to be a greate waye froÌ„ the bodie So wolde ye nowe caste a myste before our eies and make vs beleave that womanlie governemente and nature be so deuided aÌ„d sondred that they maye in no wâ—se be linked aÌ„d cowpled to gether But suerlie the Frenche nation was never so vnwise to thincke this kinde of governemente repugnante to nature or to godes hâ—lie worde for then they wolde never have suffered theire realme to have bene so often governed and ruled by women in the time of the Nonage or absence of theire kinges as by
⧠A defence of the honour of the right highe mightye and noble Princesse Marie Quene of Scotlande and dowager of France with a declaration aswell of her right title intereste to the succession of the crowne of Englande as that the regimente of women ys conformable to the lawe of God and nature ⧠Imprinted at London in Flete strete at the signe of Iustice Royall against the Blacke bell by Eusebius Dicaeophile Anno Dom. 1569. ⧠THE AVTHOVR TO THE GENTLE READER IT ys not vnknowen to the geÌ„tle Reader beinge an Englishe man vvhat greate contention hathe of late risen in Englande what talke and vvritinge haue bene towchinge the ryght of the Quene of ScotlaÌ„de to the succession of the crovne of EnglaÌ„d what hote scholes and disputations haue bene kepte in manye places here towchinge the right heire apparente of the crowne of Englande yf God call to his mercie our gratiouse Quene Souereigne Elizabethe with owte issewe of her bodye Neither hathe this sturre stode withe in the liste of ernest and feruente talke of eche side but men haue gone on farther and haue aswell by printed as vnprinted bookes done theire indeuour to disgrace blemishe and deface as muche as iÌ„ them liethe the iuste title claime and intereste of the noble and excellente Ladie Marie Quene of Scotlande to the foresaide crowne Yea they haue in vtteringe theire grosse ignoraÌ„ce or rather theyr spitefull malice againste her grace ronne so on headlonge that they haue expressely denied and refused all womanlye gouernemente All vvomans regiment refused of some Amonge other one of theys rashe hote hastie and headye companions hathe caste abrode abowte Iulye last a poysoned pestiferous pamflett against the saide Quenes clayme and interest Wherein he auouchethe also that the ciuill regimente of women ys repugnante bothe to the lawe of nature and to the lawe of God It ys more ouer well knowen to all Englande and Scotlande what a busines and sturre there hathe bene what earnest vehemente and violeÌ„te talke what false fained and forged reportes and opprobriouse slaunders haue bene bruted as well in the one as in the other realme againste the sayde vertuouse good innocence Ladye and Quene by the craftie maliciouse drifte of her rebelliouse subiectes Who haue not onlye blowne abrode and filled mennes eares with lothesome and heynouse accusations against her grace towchinge the slawghter of her late deare husbaÌ„de But haue also vpon this false slaunderouse crimination taken armes agaiÌ„st her emprisoned her spoyled her of all maÌ„ner her costelye apparell Iewelles and also bereaued her of her princelye and Royall aucthoritie intrudinge them selues into the same vnder the name and shadowe of the yonge Prince her sonne Towchinge all theys poinctes ye shall haue nowe good reader in this treatise followynge deuided in to three bookes The contentes of the bookes followiÌ„ge an answere And for as muche as Salomon writethe and this good Ladye so takethe yt that a good name ys to be praised and valewed aboue all pretiouse oyntementes Ecclesi 7. aboue all golde and syluer Proue 22. and that the impayringe of her honour by theys fowle and slawnderouse reportes dothe towche and nippe her harte nerer then maye the losse of anye worldelye honour hanginge vpon her by expectation or that she hathe enioyed or dothe presentlye enioye or any other greauouse iniuries that she hathe most wrongfullye but most pacientlye suffred Yt ys thowght good that the defence of her honour shoulde forgoe the other two bookes wherof the former entreatethe debatethe and discussethe the right title and interest of the sayde Quene Marye to the succession of this crowne of Englande Declaringe her sayde right and title to be good and lawfull by the common lawe of this realme and the actes of parliameÌ„te therein holdeÌ„ with a full answere of suche obiections as the aduersaries laye forthe against her saide right by coulour of the saide lawe or parliamentes And for as muche as with our foresaide newe fouÌ„de doctour neither common lavve nor actes of parliamente seame to serue for a sufficiente plea but that we are by him driuen also to pleade by the lavve of nature and by scripture We haue adioyned in the thirde booke a coÌ„ueniente answere to this fonde fantasticall and daungerous assertioÌ„ as well to the states of other Princes as to the state of his and our gratiouse Souereigne Wherein we auouche womans regimeÌ„te to be coÌ„formable bothe to the lawe of God and the lawe of nature Which tretise maye seme ê‘chance to some as superfluous neither I greatlye denye yt and there fore might and vvolde gladlye haue spared so muche labour and trauaile yf this litle poisoned pamflett had not manye readers and many also fauorers and allowers or yf the matter did not so nighe towche euen our owne gratious and noble Souereigne or yf this lewde assertion were not as yt were by a Sampsons poste vvithe the countenance of the lawe of nature and Godes holye vvorde vnderpropped or yf that Godes holye vvorde were not nowe a dayes wretchedlye applied God reforme yt and licenciouslye vvreathed vvrested to the maintenaunce of euerye priuate maÌ„s fansie and follye and as fondelye and folisshelie credited embraced also of other fantasticall persons or yf this man were the first Se the first Blaste or like to be the lâ—ste mainteyner and setter forthe of suche a straÌ„ge and daungerous Paradoxe Or yf there haue not alredy bene publisshed and divulged by printe englishe bookes for the maintenance of the saide strange doctrine Which vvas yf vve shall creditt the setters forthe of yt firste well coÌ„sidered then aduisedlye allowed by suche persons as a greate multitude of people in manye contreyes do nowe greatlye esteme and honour or yf the daunger of this doctriÌ„e stretched not to many other greate Princes and kingdomes or to conclude yf the divulgation of this doctrine stode onlye in Englishe Bookes and that there vvere not Bodinus in metho ad cognit hisstor that haue shewed theire fonde fansie therein euen in the latin and most common tongue of all For theys and other causes vve haue sett in the last booke a confutation of this grosse and dangerous error where as also he eÌ„ueyethe most slanderouselye against her highnes for the foresayde slaughter vvith bare naked but spitefull reproches and oute cries with ovvte anye manner of kinde or countenance of good proufe we will referre the Reader to the foresaide defence of her honour By the which ansvvere ye shall see her integritie innocencie and vvith all that her accusers have in this matter played suche a Tragedie agaynst they re gwyltles Ladie and gratiouse Sovereigne as lightlie the worlde hathe not harde of the lyke The whiche theire false slaunderouse The commeÌ„dations of diuers kinges for releauinge of other PriÌ„ces beinge in extremitie owtragiouse rebelliouse doynges yt ys hoped that our gratiouse Quene wyll well consider and ponder and wyll take
some conveniente order also aswell for the repressinge of them as for the restitution of the sayde Quene Marie into her owne realme And the rather bycause our saide Quene ys learned and therefore not ignorante what greate coÌ„meÌ„dation and immortall fame manie kynges haue purchased to them selves for suche benefitt bestowed vpon other Princes beynge in the like distresse and extremitie The monumeÌ„tes of antiquitie as well prophane as Ecclesiasticall are filled withe the memorie of suche noble factes In holye scripture we reade that Abraham cowragiouselie and manfullie delivered hys brother Lothe Genes 14. whith certaine Kynges taken prisoners by they re enimies Esdrae â–ª 1. Cyrus deliuered the Iewes from captiuitie 4. Reg. c. vlt. Evelmerodache delivered Ioachim the Kynge of Iuda ovvte of prison 1 Machab. 15. The Romans dyd write to divers Kynges in the favour of the Ievves vniustlie oppressed What shall I speake of Alexander the greate that restored Ada the Quene of Caria Or of the foresaide Romans that restored Masinissa the Kynge of Numidia with manie other Kynges Or of our noble Cordell that sett vp agayne in the Royall throne of our Britannie her father driuen from thence by hys two other vnkinde and vnnaturall dowghters Some Princes of this our realme haue in they re greate calamitie amoÌ„ge other kinge Henrie the sixte fownde muche coÌ„forte freÌ„dshippe succour and relief at the kinges handes of Scotlande This Ladie Quene desierethe nowe to taste the like at our Quenes handes Whereby she shall winne greater commendation then did Charles the late Emperour for restoriÌ„ge either of FraÌ„cis Sfortia to the dukedome of Millane or of Muliasses to the kiÌ„gdome of Tunes or of his soÌ„ne kinge Philippe for ê“curinge the restitution of the Duke of Sauoye For this Ladye and Quene ys her most nighe neighbour by place And her nighe cosen and sister by bloude She ys a Quene and therefore this vvere a fitt benefitt for her relief from a Quene Yea she ys as yt were her dawghter bothe by dawghterlye reuereÌ„ce she bearethe her maiestie and by reason she ys of God called to the daughters place in the succession of the crowne yf her maiestie faile of issewe And I dowbte nothinge yf she imploye this motherlye benefitt vpon her but that she shall finde her a myndefull thankfull an obediente dawghter For of all women in this vvorlde she abhorrethe ingratitude She hathe hitherto depended onlye vpon the hope The greate truste that the Quene of Scottes hathe euer had in her deare sister the Quene of EnglaÌ„d to haue helpe and succour of her maiestie geuinge ouer partelye voluntarie partelye at the motion of her maiestie diuers profers of ayde and succour by other mightie and puissante Princes her frendes frelye to her offered reposinge her self vpoÌ„ the fayre and princelye promises that her Maiestie hathe made to her sondrye tymes aswell by lettres as by messengers for her relief when so euer oportunitie shoulde occasion her to craue yt For theys and manye other coÌ„siderations there ys good hope as ys a foresayde that our gratiouse Maistresse will take in hande her restitution Wher vpon I trust shall followe suche farther and entire amitie betwene them bothe and theire realmes that the benefitt fruite and commoditie therof shall plentifullye redowne aswell to all the posteritie of bothe the sayde realmes heare after as to vs presentlie ⧠The printer to the reader I Require aÌ„d hartelie praye the good and louinge reader that yf in this praesent Boke thou finde any alligation not dewlye coted or a poinct out of place a lettre lackiÌ„g or other wise altered as n for u and suche littill light faultes against orthographiae thov wilt neither impute the same to the authour of this worthie Worke nor yet captiouslye controule the errour but rather of thy humanitie and gentilnes amende that which is amisse with thy penne For if thou diddist knowe with what difficulté the imprinting herof was atchiued thou woldest rather curtouslye of frendlye faueur pardon many greate faultes than curiouslye withe rigorouse censure to condemne one litle Christe kepe the in his faithe and feare praesentlie and perpetuallye Amen ⧠A DEFENCE OF THE HONEVR OF THE ryght hyghe ryght myghtye and noble Princesse Marie Quene of Scotlande aâ—d Dowagere of France The fyrste Booke IT WERE to be wisshed that as God and nature hathe moste decentlie ordinatelie and providentlye furnisshed and adorned man with two eyes whie that nature hathe geven co man too eyes and tvvo eares aud but on tongue two eares and butt withe one mowthe and one tongue woÌ„derfulye brydled and kepte in with the lippes the teathe â–ª So men wolde coÌ„sider the cause of yt aÌ„d the greate prouideÌ„ce of God therein And after dewe consideration vse them selues accordingelie Then shoulde we sone learne and practise a good lesson to heare and see manye thynges and yet not to rune headloÌ„ge nor rudelie aÌ„d rashelie to talke of all we here and see But to talke within a coÌ„passe and to referre all our talke to a temperancie and sobrietie and to a knoven tryed trevthe especiallie where the sayde talke maye sownde to the blemishinge and disgracinge of anie mans good name and estimatioÌ„ But nowe a daies the more pittie thereis nothinge almoste but that as sone as yt ys perceaued by the eye or eare must forthwithe be lasshed owte agayne by the mowthe suche a superfluouse and curiouse ytchinge we haue dissolutelie and vnadvysedlie to talke of all matters thowghe they tende to the greate hynderance and infamie of manye of our bretherne And thowghe we be nothinge assured of the certaine trewthe of the matter yea withoute respecte to pryuate or publike persons Of suche vnbrydeled talke no man or woman in our dayes hathe as I suppose more iuste cause to coÌ„plaine then the ryght excellente Princesse ladie Marie Quene of ScotlaÌ„de whose honour manie haue gone abowte to blotte and deface in charginge her most falselie and iniustlie withe deathe of her late husboÌ„de the lorde darley For the defence and mainteynynge of whose innocencye in thys behalf we intende to laye forthe before the gentle reader the moste cheif and principall reasons grounds and arguments where vppon the patrones the inuenters and workers of all theis myscheavouse and develyshe dryfts grownded them selves and all they re owteragyouse doyngs And then consequentlye to infringe and repulse the same For to rehearse answere to and repell all they re assertions and obiections yt woulde require a verie longe tediouse and a superfluouse discourse in as muche as theis iolye gaye oratours measuringe theire doings more by nombre of false obiections then by trewe substanciall and pithie matter to make a goodlie florishe and a trime shewe to face owte and countenance they re craftie iuglings And to cover they re disordered dealings there with all have raked vppe and heaped together onevppoÌ„ an other against they re good maistresse and Sovereyne Quene no small nomber
all seake vnlavvfull meanes to his distrustion This vehement presumption of her innocencie is much holpen for that she vvold not coÌ„sent to a diuorse betvveÌ„ her and the lorde Darlie as vve shall hereafter declare thoughe she vvere moued thereto by a greate numbre of her nobilité and by such as be nowe her greateste aduersaries â— adde farther thereto as a greate and an vrgeÌ„te presumptioÌ„ and token of her innocencie and pure conscience The Quene coÌ„trarie to the minde of her nobles came into Englande that she voluntarilie came into Englande refusinge the offers of diuers of her ovvne subiects vvho besovvght her grace to repaire into theire quarters proferringe to preserve her grace sauf therein vvhere she knevve right vvell vvere the father and mother of the saide lorde Darlei And a noble Quene that vvolde not see the bloudde of her neare cosen vnrevenged and a vvorthie sorte of men of nobilitie also vvho vvolde neither suffer suche a facte to passe and escape vnpunished nor so vertuouse and gwyltles a Quene to remaine withoWte aide helpe and succour beinge Withe rebells aÌ„d traitours shamefullie opressed aÌ„d bereaued of her roiall dignitie The worthie sainge also of the Wise Cassius Cicero pro milo ys here to be remeÌ„bred The notable saieÌ„ge of Cui bono Wherby he did signifie that in suche dowbtfull coÌ„iectural cases a man maye make a greate aime and coniecture against the persoÌ„ appeached Cassiê° cui bono yf by the facte doinge he shoulde enioie anie special profitt emolumente or commoditie Yf the Quene had after his fatall and finall ende purchased to her self the matchinge in mariage Withe anie greate and mightie Prince for her greate aduancement or anie other encrease of her honour or aduantage whatsoeuer there had bene some color aÌ„d shewe Whereby you might haue an apparent presumptioÌ„ Againe she was not ignorante but that his deathe either procedinge from suche nawghtie meanes or otherwise naturallie was likelie to be a meruelouse greate staie and impedimeÌ„te to her greate affaires AmoÌ„ge other things the testimonie aÌ„d coÌ„fessioÌ„ of diuers gwyltie as they be reported executed in ScotlaÌ„de for the saide offeÌ„ce which they opeÌ„lie made at the time of theire deathe dothe tende muche to the aduancinge and approbation of her innocencie Theys men yet paradueÌ„ture will replie and saye that theys are but slender presumptioÌ„s And yet were yt so that they were of force sufficiente they must yelde to an approued trewthe It remainethe now then that We coÌ„sider hovve suer and substanciall theire prouf ys Concerninge therefore the first ê‘te We Will not al to gether denie but that she Was somewhate estraÌ„ged from him aÌ„d therefore they might haue spared a greate sorte of theire neadelesse aÌ„d friuolouse arguments and yet flatt and plaine lies Withall to proue the same But fie vpon the crueltie of theis accusers The Quenes ennemies laye to her discorde with the lorde Darley wherof they were the authours Who vvere the verie authours them selues And them selues the onlie Workers and bringers to passe of all this discorde traininge this selie yonge gentleman by theire gwylefull and vvilie circumuentions Wretchedlie to conspire Withe them against his owne deare Wife and dreade Souereigne to the moste cruell and detestable slawghter of her trustie Secretorie Dauid and to the imprisonmente of the roiall person of the verie Quene her self Theis and manie other like prancks and practises as the reuocation of you the Erle murraie and of other traitours of your allie and affinitie vvith ovvte the Quenes knowledge by the lorde darley his yowthfull rashe and temerariouse deuice to departe the reaulme vvithe manie other like practises purposes and atteÌ„pts for his princelie parson verye vnmete and farre vnseamelie ye craftelie suppresse and speake no vvorde off for feare off burnynge your ovvne clothes I saye therefore fie aÌ„d dovvble fie vpoÌ„ the impudeÌ„cie of theis traiteurs Novve to laye to the Quenes charge and reprochfullie to obiecte to her changinge of her minde tovvarde her husbande vvich rose aÌ„d begane vppon causes for the vvich they had bene longe earst trysed vppe yff they had not fortuned vppoÌ„ aÌ„d mett vvith so gratiouse a maistresse As I knovve and they thovvghe vndeseruinge yt do vvell feale that the vvhole vvorlde hathe verie fevve her like And yet all this your preteÌ„sed alienation of her accustomed faueur from hym not vvith staÌ„dinge her verie motherlie care for besids all other respects thovvghe they Were not farre differente in yeares she vvas to him not onlie a loyall Prince a louinge aÌ„d deare vvyfe but a most carefull and tendre mother vvith all vvas neuer a deale lessed or minisshed Albe yt for a time she did dissemble and forebeare ovvtevvardelie to shevve and vtter her invvarde harte and affectionate loue vpon moste iuste and good respects As the manner and practise of prouidente and moste louinge parents oftentimes ys tovvarde theire deare children for the better reclaiminge of the vvanderinge minde and vvaueringe vvill of the yovvthfull vnaduised gentleman And therfore heatinge and advertissed that he vvas repentante and sorovvfull and that he desired her presence she vvithoute delaie thereby to renevve quicken and refreshe his sprites aÌ„d to comforte his harte to the amendement and reparinge of his healthe lateli by sicknes sore impaired The Quene vvas fullye reconsiled to the l. Darley before his deathe hasted vvith suche speade as she conuenientlie might to see and visit him at clasco Where as also at diuers other places especiallie at Edenborovvghe she froÌ„ time to time most louingelie entertayned and most tenderlie cherisshed him euer eauen to the verie laste hovvre that euer she savve him Whereby yt did to all men moste euidentlye appere that all manner of displeasure or variaÌ„ce vvhatsoeuer your coniecturall surmises suppose to haue bene betvvene them or your seditiouse practises and ambitiouse procedings had sovven in theire stomaks and mindes vvas not onelie novve vvell asvvaged and fullie appeased but vtterlie for euer quenched as beinge altogether forgotten and troden to your muche mislikinge and greate discomforte vnder foote of them bothe neuer to be renevved againe But for as muche as theys men do vvell perceaue that yâ— this be treve which ys in deade so certaiÌ„elie trevve that they them selues are for the manifest euidence therof eauen driuen and forced to acknovvledge and confesse the same Then theire greate Samsons post of discorde and debate vvhere vvithe they vvolde vnderproppe and vpholde all theire traiterouse procedings as also this theire mischiuouse accusation and greauouse crimination the vvhiche they had fullie novve conceaued and brovvght as they hoped to perfection by the mischeuouse drifts of theire shrevvde vvilie develishe disposed braines against her vvolde faile then fall to the grovnde For this consideration I saie they novve measuringe theis moste commendable doings of the verie vertuouse and vvell meaninge Quene by theire ovvne deape and doble dissemblinge craftie nature theire former drifte failinge them begane to
detestable practizes neyther vvill suffer them selves to be spotted with the favoringe and assistinge of your abominable doinges We can tell you that this good ladie ys vniustlie accused aÌ„d wrongfullie oppressed as good Susanna was We can tell you that ye altogether resemble the tvvo olde vvicked gouernours that vvroÌ„gfullye accused her as an advowtresse beinge the advouterers them selves and brovvght her into daunger of present deathe by theire false testimonie as ye haue done withe your vvell intendinge Quene for that she vvolde not consente and yelde to the olde lustie lecherouse Rebelles We can tell you that yf you do not the soner repeÌ„te ye see by example of them What your revvarde shal be And that in the meane while God hathe as wonderfullie delivered owte of your handes this our innoceÌ„te Susanna as ever he did the other from them For thovvghe she vvere kept straight in a stroÌ„ge fortresse and castle vvith vvatche aÌ„d vvarde in suche sorte that none of her vvell willers and Frendes no not so muche as the Frenche kinges or our maistresse her moste deare sisters ambassadours might be suffred to come at The Quene in a manuer miraculouslie delivered out of lochleven â—rison or to speake with her Thovvgh she vvere daile gvvarded withe greate nomber thovvghe the gates vvere euery eaveninge suerlie and customablie locked and the keies therof vvere continuallie night by night delivered to the lorde of the saide castle Thowghe the botes were contiâ—uallie fastened aÌ„d locked vppe Yet god so vvrowght that the keies of the saide castle were in the saide lords verie presence takeÌ„ avvaye by a poore orphan simple boye beinge not yet eightene yeares olde bredd alwayes browght vppe iÌ„ the same howse Whiche feate by hym Wrovvght aÌ„d a tokeÌ„ or significatioÌ„ geaven therof to the Quene she departed ovvte of her prisoÌ„ hovvse into the courte therof at seaven of the clocke at night vpon the seconde daye of Maye And so passinge vvente to the saide gates vnlocked and opened by the saide orphan boye Who takinge bote also rowed her her waitinge maide vvith all vvith muche a doo over the vvater vvho havinge nowe passed the vvater vvas on the other side receaued by certaine gentlemen aÌ„d by them coÌ„veied coÌ„ducted to HamiltoÌ„ where she before her nobilitie revoked annichilated made voide all that she did iÌ„ prisoÌ„ before with solemne ê“testation vpoÌ„ her othe that she vvas violentlie forced therto aÌ„d putt in iuste feare of the losse of her life After this yt pleased god to putt her in miÌ„de to tacke her iourney into Englande aswell for the speciall and singuler truste she hathe in her deare Sister her coÌ„fortable ê“mises to her before her cominge by messeÌ„gers letres tokens sente from her bothe confortinge and promisinge her oportunitie seruinge all conueniente succour and helpe as that we Englishemen whiche muste neades honour and reuereÌ„ce her Who ys of the nexte Royall bloudd and trevve heire apparente of the crovvne of this realme of Englande shoulde throvvghelie knowe and fullie vnderstande to our greate comforte her purenes integritie and innoceÌ„cie in the matter vnder pretence vvherof her traitours and rebelliouse subiects thereby to accomplishe theire seditiouse aÌ„d ambitiouse minds and purposes haue molested vexed and disquieted her in maÌ„ner a foresaide And nowe at the laste kepethe her not onlie from her crowne aÌ„d realme but from all whatsoeuer either her priuate or other goods as vnwillinge that she shoulde either kepe the state aÌ„d porte of a Prince or any other meaner estate vvhatsoeuer Neither hathe it altogether fallen ovvte coÌ„trarie to her expectatioÌ„ and desire For the nobles of Englande that vvere appointed by the Quene to heare aÌ„d examine all suche matters as the rebelles shoulde laye againste the Quene haue not onelie fownde the saide Quene innocente aÌ„d gvviltlesse of the deathe of her husbaÌ„de but do vvithall fullie vnderstande that her accusers Were the verie coÌ„triuers deuisers practitioners aÌ„d vvorkers of the saide murther aÌ„d haue farther also so muche encreased aÌ„d in suche Wise renued the good estimation and greate hope they alvvayes had of her novve ê‘fectlie knowinge her innocencie and therto moued throvvghe other princelie qualities resplendente in her with many Wherof she ys muche adorned The commissioners appointed in EnglaÌ„d to hear the Quene of Scotts matters vvell liked of her saide innoceÌ„cie and of her title to the successioÌ„ of the crovvne aÌ„d singulerlie endevved that they haue in moste earnest vvise solicited aÌ„d eÌ„treated the Quene of EnglaÌ„d to geue her aide aÌ„d strengthe vvhereby she maye be restored againe to her honour aÌ„d crovvne They haue moued the saide Quene of Scotlande also that yt maye please her to accepte and like of the most noblest man of all EnglaÌ„de betvvene vvhom aÌ„d her there might be a mariage coÌ„cluded to the quietinge and comforte of bothe the realmes of Englande and ScotlaÌ„de Finallie the noble men of this our realme acknovvledge aÌ„d accepte her for the verye true and rigthe heire appareÌ„te of this realme of Englande beinge fullie minded aÌ„d alvvayes readie if God call to his mercie the Quene that novve ys then to receaue and serue her as theire vndovvbted Quene Maistresse aÌ„d Souereigne Wherby yt maye easelie appeare hovve Well they like of her cause that had the hearinge and triall of the same allthovvghe she never as yet came in theire presence Theis thinges novve and manie other whiche for the eschewinge of prolixitie we forebeare to enlarge our treatise vith maie be alleaged for the defeÌ„ce of the Quenes integritie and for the vprightnes of her cause the vvhiche I vvolde vvishe you the Erles Murraye and Morton vvithe your allied confederates before all other most deapelie and by times to vveighe and consider accordingelie as the vveight and greatnes of the cause An exhortatioÌ„ of the Erles MurrayeÌ„ mortoÌ„ others to reconsile theÌ„selves to the Quene as your owne sauftie vvith the wealthe honour of your natiue coÌ„trey do require I am not ignorante that the matter ys gone verie farre vvith you that many impedimeÌ„ts do concurre to with dravve you to seake that remedie for the reformation of things paste vvhiche ys the beste and th' onelie remedie But suerlie vvhen ye have fullie vveied all things on everie side accordingelie ye shall finde no sure and sovvnde remedie but in makinge a true a sincere and an vnfained humble submission to your gratiouse Quene vvhoÌ„ ye haue so greavouselie offended and molested Let not the greatnes or nomber of your treasons wrovvght against bothe your Quene and cuntrey Let not any vaine false imagined opinioÌ„ either of the worlde or of your vtter ouerthrovve by reason of anie suche fonde presumption of your presente highe estate of your greate povver force and strengthe Let no vaine expectatioÌ„ of externall succours staie or stoppe you from so necessarie a devvtie and so comendable before God and the worlde Ye best knovve that amonge all the princelie ornameÌ„tes and
that yt was never taken to exteÌ„de vnto the crovne of this realme of EnglaÌ„de as yt maie appeare by kinge StepheÌ„ by kinge HeÌ„rie the secoÌ„de who were both straÌ„gers FreÌ„ch meÌ„ And borne oute of the kiÌ„ges allegiaÌ„ce and neither vvere they the kinges children immediate nor theire pareÌ„tes of the allegiance And yet they haue bene alwayes accompted lawfull kinges of Englande nor theire title vvas by any man at any time defaced or comptrolled for any suche consideration or exceptioÌ„ of forren birthe And yt ys a worlde to see hovve you vvolde shifte your handes from the saide kinge Henrie Ye saie he came not to the crovne by order of the lavve The aduersaries obiectioÌ„ tovchinge kinge H. 2. avoided but by capitulatioÌ„ or agrement for as muche as his mother by whome he conveied hys title vvas then livinge Well admitt that he came to the crowne by capitulation duringe his mothers life Yet this dothe not proue that he vvas dishabled to receaue the crovvne but rather proveth his abilitie And althovvghe I did also admitt that he had not the crovvne by order of the lavve duringe his mothers life yet after his mothers deathe no man hathe hytherto dovvbted but that he vvas kinge by lavvfull succession and not againste the lavves and customes of this realme For so might you putt a dovvbte in all the kinges of this realme that ever gouerned sithens and driue vs to seake heires in Scotlande or elles where whiche thinge we suppose you are over vvise to goo abowte Besides this I haue harde some of the adversaries for farther helpe of theire intention in this matter saie that kinge Henrie the seconde vvas a Quenes childe and so kinge by the rule of the common lavve Trevvlie I knovve he vvas an Empresse childe but no Quene of Englandes childe For althovvghe Mavvde the Empresse his mother had a right and a good title to the crovvne and to be Quene of EnglaÌ„de Yet vvas she never in possessioÌ„ but kept from the possession by kinge Stephen And therefore kinge Henrye the seconde can not iustlie be saide to be a Quene of Englandes childe nor yet any kinges childe vnlesse ye wolde intende the kinges children by the wordes of infantes de Roy c. to be children of farder degree aÌ„d discended fom the right line of the kinge so ye might saie trevvlie that he vvas the childe of kinge Henrye the firste beinge indede the soÌ„ne and heire of Mavvde the Empresse davvghter and heire of kinge Henrie the firste As tovvchiÌ„ge Arthure kiÌ„ge Richardes nephewe Whereby your saide rule ys here fovvlie foiled And therefore ye Wolde faine for the maintenance of your pretensed maxime catche some holde vppoÌ„ Arthure the sonne of Ieffrey one of the sonnes of the saide Henrie the seconde Vt autem pax ista summa dilectio tam multiplici q arctiori viÌ„culo coÌ„nectaâ— pÌ„dictiscuriae vestriae magnatibê° id ex ê‘te vrÌ„a tractaÌ„tibê° dnÌ„odisponeÌ„te condiximê° intet Arthurum egregiuÌ„ ducem Britanniae nepoteÌ„ nostruÌ„ heredeÌ„ fi fortè sine ê“le obire nos coÌ„â—gerit filiaÌ„ vestraÌ„ matrimoniuÌ„ coÌ„trahenduÌ„ c. Ye saye then like a good and iolie antiquarie that he vvas reiected from the crovvne by cause he vvas borne ovvte of the realme That he vvas borne ovvte of the realme ys verie trevve but that he was reiected from the crovvne for that cause yt ys verie false Neither haue you any aucthoritie to proue your vaine opinion in this pointe For yt ys to be ê“ued by the cronicles of this realme that kinge Richarde the first vncle vnto the saide Arthure takinge his iorney tovvarde HierusaleÌ„ declared the saide Arthur as vve haue shevved before to be heire apparente * In tractatu pacis inter Rich. 1. TancreduÌ„ RegeÌ„ Siciliae vid. Rog. Hoâ—enden Richar. canonicuÌ„ sancta Trinitatis Londini vnto the crowne Whiche vvolde not haue bene yf he had bene taken to be vnhable to receaue the crowne by reasoÌ„ of foreÌ„ birthe And althovvghe kinge Iohan did vsurpe aswell vpoÌ„ the saide kinge Richarde the firste his eldest brother as also vpon the saide Arthur his nephevve yet that ys no proof that he vvas reiected by cause he vvas borne owte of the realme Yf ye colde proue that then had ye shewed some reason and presidente to proue your intente Whereas hitherto you haue sheued none at all nor I am Well assured shall euer be able to shevve Thus maye ye se geÌ„tle reader that neither this pretensed maxime of the lavve sett forthe by the aduersaries nor a greate noÌ„ber more as generall as this ys which before I haue sheued can by anye resonable meanes be stretched to biÌ„de the crovvne of EnglaÌ„de Theis reasons aÌ„d auctorities maye for this time suffice to ê“ue that the crowne of this realme ys not subiecte to the rules and the principles of the common lavve neither can be ruled and tried by the same Whiche thinge beinge trevve all the obiections of the aduersaries made against the title of Marie the Quene of Scotlande to the successioÌ„ of the crovvne of this realme are fullie ansvvered and thereby clierlie vviped avvaye Yet for farther argumentes sake and to the ende vve might haue all matters sifted to the vttermoste and therby all thinges made plaine Let vs for this time some vvhat yelde vnto the aduersaries admittinge that the title of the crovvne of this realme vvere to be examined and tried by the rules and principles of the common lavve aÌ„d then lett vs consider and examine farther whether there be any rule of the common lavve or elles statute that by good and iuste construction can seame to impugne the saide title of Marie the Quene of Scotlande or no. For tovvchinge her lineall descente from kinge Henrye the seauenthe and by his eldeste davvghter as we haue shevved there ys no man so impudeÌ„te to denie yt What ys there then to be obiected Amonge all the rules maximes aÌ„d iudgementes of the common lavve of this realme onlie one rule as a generall maxime ys obiected against her And yet the same rule ys so vntrevvlie sert forthe that I can not vvell agree that yt ys any rule or maxime of the comon lawe of this realme of Englande Your preteÌ„sed Maxime ys who soeuer ys borne ovvte of the realme of Englande A false maxime set forthe by the aduersarie and of father aÌ„d mother not beinge vnder the obedience of the kinge of Englande can not be capable to inheriteany thinge in EnglaÌ„de vvhich rule ys nothinge trevve but altogether false For euerie stranger and alien ys able to purchasse the inheritance of landes vvithin this realme as yt maye appeare in 7 7. E. 4. fol. 28. 9. E. 4. fo 5. 11. H. 4. fol. 25. 14. H. 4. f. 10. 9 of kinge Edvvarde the fovvrthe And also in 11 14 of kinge Henrie the fovvrthe And altovvghe the same purchasse ys of some men accompted to be to the vse of