Place that the Plea hitherto insisted on cannot be managed without great Disadvantage to Christian Religion For if we take away the Rational Grounds on which we believe the Doctrine of Christ to be True and Divine and the whole Evidence of the Truth of it be laid on things not only derided by Men of Atheistical Spirits but in themselves such as cannot be discerned by any but such as do believe on what Grounds can we proceed to convince an Unbeliever Answer 1. By the way it is one thing to prove and believe the Doctrine of Christ to be True and Divine another to prove and believe the Scripture to be given by Inspiration of God or the Divine Authority of the Scripture which alone was proposed unto Consideration A Doctrine True and Divine may be written in and proposed unto us by Writings that were not divinely and infallibly inspired and so might the Doctrine of Christ have been but not without the unspeakable Disadvantage of the Church And there are sundry Arguments which forcibly and effectually prove the Doctrine of Christ to have been True and Divine which are not of any Efficacy to prove the Divine Authority of the Scriptures though on the other hand whatever doth prove the Divine Authority of the Scriptures doth equally prove the Divine Truth of the Doctrine of Christ. 2. There are two Ways of convincing Vnbelievers the one insisted on by the Apostles and their Followers the other by some learned Men since their Days The Way principally insisted on by the Apostles was by preaching the Word it self unto them in the Evidence and Demonstration of the Spirit by the Power whereof manifesting the Authority of God in it they were convinced and falling down acknowledged God to be in it of a Truth 1 Cor. 2. 4 5. ch 14. 25 26. It is likely that in this their Proposal of the Gospel the Doctrine and Truths contained in it unto Unbelievers that those of Atheistical Spirits would both deride them and it and so indeed it came to pass many esteeming themselves to be Bablers and their Doctrine to be errant Folly But yet they desisted not from pursuing their Work in the same way whereunto God gave success The other VVay is to prove unto Vnbelievers that the Scripture is True and Divine by rational Arguments wherein some learned Persons have laboured especially in these last Ages to very good purpose And certainly their Labours are greatly to be commended whilst they attend unto these Rules 1. That they produce no Arguments but such as are cogent and not liable unto just Exceptions For if to manifest their own Skill or Learning they plead such Reasons as are capable of an Answer and Solution they exceedingly prejudice the Truth by subjecting it unto dubious Disputations whereas in it self it is Clear Firm and Sacred 2. That they do not pretend their rational Grounds and Arguments to be the Sole Foundation that Faith hath to rest upon or which it is resolved into For this were the ready way to set up an Opinion instead of Faith Supernatural and Divine Accept but of these two Limitations and it is acknowledged that the rational Grounds and Arguments intended may be rationally pleaded and ought so to be unto the Conviction of Gainsayers For no Man doth so plead the self-evidencing Power of the Scripture as to deny that the Use of other external Motives and Arguments is necessary to stop the Mouths of Atheists as also unto the further Establishment of them who do believe These Things are subordinate and no way inconsistent The Truth is if we will attend unto our own and the Experience of the whole Church of God the way whereby we come to believe the Scripture to be the Word of God ordinarily is this and no other God having first given his Word as the Foundation of our Faith and Obedience hath appointed the Ministry of Men at first extraordinary afterwards ordinary to propose unto us the Doctrines Truths Precepts Promises and Threatnings contained therein Together with this Proposition of them they are appointed to declare that these things are not from themselves nor of their own Invention 2 Tim. 3. 14 15 16 17. And this is done variously Unto some the VVord of God in this Ministry thus comes or is thus proposed preached or declared whilst they are in a Condition not only utterly unacquainted with the Mysteries of it but filled with contrary Apprehensions and consequently Prejudices against it Thus it came of old unto the Pagan World and must do so unto such Persons and Nations as are yet in the same state with them Unto these the first Preachers of the Gospel did not produce the Book of the Scriptures and tell them that it was the Word of God and that it would evidence it self unto them so to be For this had been to despise the Wisdom and Authority of God in their own Ministry But they preached the Doctrines of it unto them grounding themselves on the Divine Revelation contained therein And this Proposition of the Truth or Preaching of the Gospel was not left of God to work it self into the Reasons of Men by the Suitableness of it thereunto but being his own Institution for their Illumination and Conversion he accompanied it with Divine Power and made it effectual unto the Ends designed Rom. 1. 16. And the Event hereof among Mankind was that by some this new Doctrine was derided and scorned by others whose Hearts God opened to attend unto it it was embraced and submitted unto Among those who after the Propagation of the Gospel are born as they say within the Pale of the Church the same Doctrine is variously instilled into Persons according unto the several Duties and Concerns of others to instruct them Principally the Ministry of the Word is ordained of God unto that End wheron the Church is the Ground and Pillar of Truth Those of both Sorts unto whom the Doctrine mentioned is preached or proposed are directed unto the Scriptures as the Sacred Repository thereof For they are told that these things come by Revelation from God and that Revelation is contained in the Bible which is his Word Upon this Proposal with Enquiry into it and Consideration of it God co-operating by his Spirit there is that Evidence of its Divine Original communicated unto their Minds through its Power and Efficacy with the Characters of Divine Wisdom and Holiness implanted on it which they are now enabled to discern that they believe it and rest in it as the immediate Word of God Thus was it in the Case of the Woman of Samaria and the Inhabitants of Sychar with respect unto their Faith in Christ Jesus John 4. 42. This is the way whereby Men ordinarily are brought to believe the Word of God Rom. 10. 14 15. and that neither by external Arguments or Motives which no one Soul was ever converted unto God by nor by any meer naked Proposal and Offer of the Book unto them
Scripture to be the VVord of God in a way of Duty For it is not to be meerly Human how firm soever the Perswasions in it may be but Divine and Supernatural of the same kind with that whereby we believe the things themselves contained in the Scripture 7. VVe cannot thus believe the Scripture to be the VVord of God nor any Divine Truth therein contained without the effectual Illumination of our Minds by the Holy Ghost And to exclude the Consideration of his VVork herein is to cast the whole Enquiry out of the Limits of Christian Religion 8. Yet is not this VVork of the Holy Spirit in the Illumination of our Minds whereby we are enabled to believe in a way of Duty with Faith Supernatural and Divine the Ground and Reason why we do believe or the Evidence whereon we do so nor is our Faith resolved thereinto 9. VVhereas also there are sundry other Acts of the Holy Spirit in and upon our minds establishing this Faith against Temptations unto the contrary and further ascertaining us of the Divine Original of the Scripture or testifying it unto us yet are they none of them severally nor all of them joyntly the formal Reason of our Faith nor the Ground which we believe upon Yet are they such as that as without the first VVork of Divine Illumination we cannot believe at all in a due manner so without his other consequent Operations we cannot believe stedfastly against Temptations and Oppositions VVherefore 10. Those only can believe the Scripture aright to be the VVord of God in a way of Duty whose minds are enlightned and who are enabled to believe by the Holy Ghost 11. Those who believe not are of two Sorts for they are either such as oppose and gainsay the VVord as a cunningly devised Fable or such as are willing without prejudice to attend unto the consideration of it The former Sort may be resisted opposed and rebuked by external Arguments and such moral Considerations as vehemently perswade the Divine Original of the Scripture and from the same Principles may their mouths be stopped as to their Cavils and Exceptions against it The other Sort are to be led on unto believing by the Ministry of the Church in the dispensation of the VVord it self which is the Ordinance of God unto that purpose But 12. Neither sort do ever come truly to believe either meerly induced thereunto by force of moral Arguments only or upon the Authority of that Church by whose Ministry the Scripture is proposed unto them to be believed VVherefore 13. The formal Reason of Faith Divine and Supernatural whereby we believe the Scripture to be the VVord of God in the way of Duty and as it is required of us is the Authority and Veracity of God alone evidencing themselves unto our Minds and Consciences in and by the Scripture it self And herein consisteth that Divine Testimony of the Holy Ghost which as it is a Testimony gives our Assent unto the Scriptures the general nature of Faith and as it is a Divine Testimony gives it the especial nature of Faith Divine and Supernatural 14. This Divine Testimony given unto the Divine Original of the Scripture in and by it self whereinto our Faith is ultimately resolved is evidenced and made known as by the Characters of the infinite Perfections of the Divine Nature that are in it and upon it so by the Authority Power and Efficacy over and upon the Souls and Consciences of Men and the Satisfactory Excellency of the Truths contained therein wherewith it is accompanied 15. Wherefore although there be many cogent external Arguments whereby a moral stedfast Perwasion of the Divine Authority of the Scriptures may be attained and it be the principal Duty of the true Church in all Ages to give Testimony thereunto which it hath done successively at all all times since first it was intrusted with it and so although there be many other Means whereby we are induced perswaded and enabled to believe it yet is it for its own sake only efficaciously manifesting it self to be the Word of God or upon the Divine Testimony that is given in it and by it thereunto that we believe it to be so with Faith Divine and Supernatural Corel Those who either deny the necessity of an internal subjective Work of the Holy Ghost enabling us to believe or the objective Testimony of the Holy Spirit given unto the Scripture in and by it self or do deny their joynt concurrence in and unto our Believing do deny all Faith properly Divine and Supernatural This being the Substance of what is declared and pleaded for in the preceding Treatise to prevent the Obloquy of some and confirm the Judgment of others I shall add the Suffrage of Antient and Modern Writers given unto the principal Parts of it and whereon all other things asserted in it do depend Clemens Alexandrinus discourseth at large unto this purpose Stromat 7. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 We have the Lord himself for the Principle or Beginning of Doctrine who by the Prophets the Gospel and blessed Apostles in various manners and by divers degrees goeth before us or leads us unto knowledg This is that which we lay down as the Reason and Ground of Faith namely the Authority of the Lord himself instructing us by the Scriptures So he adds 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 And if any one suppose that he needeth any oâ—her Principle the Principle will not be kept that is if we need any other Principle whereinto to resolve our Faith the Word of God is no more a Principle unto us But he who is faithful from himself is worthy to be believed in his Sovereign Writing and Voice which as it appeareth is administred by the Lord for the benefit of men And certainly we use it as a Rule of judging for the invention of things But whatever is judged is not credible or to be believed until it is judged and that is no Principle which stands in need to be judged The Intention of his Words is that God who alone is to believed for himself hath given us his Word as the Rule whereby we are to judg of all things And this Word is so to be believed as not to be subject unto any other Judgment because if it be so it cannot be either a Principle or a Rule And so he proceeds 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Wherefore it is meet that embracing by Faith the most sufficient indemonstrable Principle and taking the Demonstrations of the Principle from the Principle it self we are instructed by the Voice of the Lord himself unto the acknowledgment of the Truth In few Words he declares the Substance of what we have pleaded for No more do we maintain in this Cause but what Clemens doth here assert namely that we believe the Scripture for it self as that which needeth no antecedent or external Demonstration but all the Evidence and Demonstration of its Divine Original is to be taken from it self alone which yet
as a sufficient and perfect so the only Treasury of divine Revelations And what hath been offered by any to weaken or impair its esteem by taking off from its credibility perfection and sufficiency as unto all its own proper ends hath brought no advantage unto the Church nor benefit unto the Faith of Believers But yet Fifthly In asserting the Scripture to be the only external means of divine Revelation I do it not exclusively unto those Institutions of God which are subordinate unto it and appointed as means to make it effectual unto our souls As 1. Our own personal endeavours in reading studying and meditating on the Scripture that we my come unto a right Apprehension of the things contained in it are required unto this purpose It is known to all how frequently this Duty is pressed upon us and what Promises are annexed to the performance of it see Deut. 6. 6 7. chap. 11. 18 19. Josh. 1. 8. Psal. 1. 2. Psal. 119. Col. 3. 16. 2 Tim. 3. 15. Without this it is in vain to expect Illumination by the Word And therefore we may see multitudes living and walking in extreme darkness when yet the Word is every-where nigh unto them Bread which is the Staff of life will yet nourish no man who doth not provide it and feed upon it no more would Manna unless it was gathered and prepared Our own Natures and the Nature of divine Revelations considered and what is necessary for the application of the one to the other makes this evident For God will instruct us in his mind and will as we are men in and by the rational faculties of our souls Nor is an external Revelation capable of making any other impression on us but what is so received Wherefore when I say that the Scripture is the only external means of our Illumination I include therein all our own personal endeavours to come to the knowledge of the mind of God therein which shall be afterwards spoken unto And those who under any pretences do keep drive or perswade men from reading and meditating on the Scripture do take an effectual course to keep them in and under the power of Darkness 2. The mutual Instruction of one another in the mind of God out of the Scripture is also required hereunto For we are obliged by the Law of Nature to endeavour the good of others in various degrees as our Children our Families our Neighbours and all with whom we have Conversation And this is the principal Good absolutely considered that we can communicate unto others namely to instruct them in the knowledge of the mind of God This whole Duty in all the Degrees of it is represented in that Command Thou shalt teach my Words diligently unto thy Children and shalt talk of them when thou sittest in thy house and when thou walkest by the way and when thou lyest down and when thou risest up Deut. 6. 7. Thus when our Saviour found his Disciples talking of the things of God by the way side he bearing unto them the person of a private man instructed them in the sense of the Scripture Luk. 24. 26 27 32. And the neglect of this Duty in the World which is so great that the very mention of it or the least attempt to perform it is a matter of scorn and reproach is one cause of the great ignorance darkness which yet abounds among us But the nakedness of this folly whereby men would be esteemed Christians in the open contempt of all Duties of Christianity will in due time be laid open 3. The Ministry of the Word in the Church is that which is principally included in this Assertion The Scripture is the only means of Illumination but it becometh so principally by the application of it unto the minds of men in the Ministry of the Word see Mat. 5. 14 15. 2 Cor. 5. 18 19 20. Eph. 4. 11 12 13 14 15. 1 Tim. 3. 15. The Church and the Ministry of it are the Ordinances of God unto this end that his Mind and Will as revealed in the Word may be made known to the Children of Men whereby they are enlightned And that Church and Ministry whereof this is not the first principal design and work is neither appointed of God nor approved by him Men will one day find themselves deceived in trusting to empty Names it is Duty alone that will be Comfort and Reward Dan. 12. 3. Sixthly That the Scripture which thus contains the whole of divine Revelation may be a sufficient external cause of Illumination unto us two things are required 1. That we believe it to be a divine Revelation that is the Word of God or a Declaration of Himself his Mind and Will immediatly proceeding from Him or that it is of a pure divine Original proceeding neither from the folly or deceit nor from the skill or honesty of men so is it stated 2 Pet. 1. 19 20 21. Heb. 1. 1. 2 Tim. 3. 16. Isa. 8. 20. It tenders no light or instruction under any other notion but as it comes immediatly from God not as the Word of Man but as it is indeed the Word of the Living God 1 Thes. 2. 13. And what ever any one may learn from or by the Scriptures under any other consideration it belongeth not unto the Illumination we enquire after Nehem. 8. 8. Isa. 28. 9. Hos. 14. 9. Prov. 1. 6. Psal. 119. 34 Mat. 15. 16. 2 Tim. 2. 7. 1 John 5. 20. 2. That we understand the things declared in it or the Mind of God as revealed and expressed therein For if it be given unto us a sealed Book which we cannot read either because it is sealed or because we are ignorant and cannot read whatever Visions or means of Light it hath in it we shall have no advantage thereby Isa. 29. 11 12. It is not the Words themselves of the Scripture only but our understanding them that gives us light Psal. 119. 130. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the opening the Door the entrance of thy Word giveth light It must be opened or it will not enlighten So the Disciples understood not the Testimonies of the Scripture concerning the Lord Christ they were not enlightned by them until he expounded them unto them Luk. 24. 27 45. As we have the same instance in the Eunuch and Philip Acts 8. 31 35 36. To this very day the Nation of the Jews have the Scriptures of the old Testament and the outward Letter of them in such esteem and veneration that they even adore and worship them yet are they not enlightned by it And the same is fallen out among many that are called Christians or they could never embrace such foolish opinions and practise such Idolatries in worship as some of them do who yet enjoy the Letter of the Gospel And this brings me to my design which we have been thus far making way unto and it is to shew that both these are from the Holy Ghost namely that we truly believe
so many uncertain and fierce Digladiations wherein not any one Truth is asserted nor any one Duty prescribed that is not spoiled and vitiated by its Circumstances and Ends besides they never rose up so much as to a Surmise of or about the most important matters of Religion without which it is demonstrable by reason that it is impossible we should ever attain the End for which we are made nor the Blessedness whereof we are capable No account could they ever give of our Apostacy from God of the Depravation of our Nature of the Cause or necessary Cure of it In this lost and wandring Condition of Mankind the Scripture presenteth it self as a Light Rule and Guide unto all to direct them in their whole Course unto their end and to bring them unto the enjoyment of God and this it doth with that clearness and evidence as to dispel all the Darkness and put an end unto all the Confusions of the minds of Men as the Sun with rising doth the shades of the Night unless they wilfully shut their eyes against it loving Darkness rather than Light because their deeds are evil For all the Confusion of the minds of men to extricate themselves from whence they found out and immixed themselves in endless Questions to no purpose arose from their Ignorance of what we were originally of what we now are and how we came so to be by what way or means we may be delivered or relieved what are the Duties of Life or what is required of us in order to our living to God as our chiefest end and wherein the Blessedness of our Nature doth consist All the World was never able to give an Answer tolerably satisfactory unto any one of these Enquiries yet unless they are all infallibly determined we are not capable of the least Rest or Happiness above the Beasts that perish But now all these things are so clearly declared and stated in the Scripture that it comes with an Evidence like a Light from Heaven on the Minds and Consciences of unprejudiced Persons What was the Condition of our Nature in its first Creation and Constitution with the Blessedness and Advantage of that Condition how we fell from it and what was the Cause what is the Nature and what the Consequents and Effects of our present Depravation and Apostacy from God how Help and Relief is provided for us herein by infinite Wisdom Grace and Bounty what that Help is how we may be interested in it and made partakers of it what is that System of Duties or Course of Obedience unto God which is required of us and wherein our eternal Felicity doth consist are all of them so plainly and clearly revealed in the Scripture as in general to leave Mankind no ground for Doubt Enquiry or Conjecture set aside inveterate Prejudices from Tradition Education false Notions into the Mould whereof the mind is cast the Love of Sin and the Conduct of Lust which things have an inconceivable power over the Minds Souls and Affections of Men and the Light of the Scripture in these things is like that of the Sun at Noon-day which shuts up the way unto all further Enquiry and efficaciously necessitates unto an Acquiescency in it And in particular in that Direction which it gives unto the Lives of Men in order unto that Obedience which they ow to God and that Reward which they expect from him there is no instance conceivable of any thing conducing thereunto which is not prescribed therein nor of any thing which is contrary unto it that falls not under its Prohibition Those therefore whose Desire or Interest it is that the Bounds and Differences of Good and Evil should be unfixed and confounded who are afraid to know what they were what they are or what they shall come unto who care to know neither God nor themselves their Duty nor their Reward may despise this Book and deny its divine Original others will retain a sacred Veneration of it as of the Off-spring of God 4. The Testimony of the Church may in like manner be pleaded unto the same purpose and I shall also insist upon it partly to manifest wherein its true Nature and Efficacy doth consist and partly to evince the vanity of the old Pretence that even we also who are departed from the Church of Rome do receive the Scripture upon the Authority thereof whence it is further pretended that on the same Ground and Reason we ought to receive whatever else it proposeth unto us 1. The Church is said to be the Ground and Pillar of Truth 1 Tim. 3. 15. Which is the only Text pleaded with any Sobriety to give countenance unto the Assertion of the Authority of the Scripture with respect unto us to depend on the Authority of the Church But the Weakness of a Plea to that purpose from hence hath been so fully manifested by many already that it needs no more to be insisted on In short it cannot be so the Ground and Pillar of Truth that the Truth should be as it were built and rest upon it as its Foundation for this is directly contrary to the same Apostle who teacheth us that the Church it self is built upon the Foundation of the Prophets and Apostles Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner Stone Eph. 2. 20. The Church cannot be the Ground of Truth and Truth the Ground of the Church in the same sense or kind Wherefore the Church is the Ground and Pillar of Truth in that it holds up and declares the Scriptures and the things contained therein so to be 2. In receiving any thing from a Church we may consider the Authority of it or its Ministry By the Authority of the Church in this matter we intend no more but the weight and importance that is in its Testimony as Testimonies do vary according to the Worth Gravity Honesty Honour and Reputation of them by whom they are given For to suppose an Authority properly so called in any Church or all the Churches of the World whereon our Reception of the Scripture should depend as that which gives its Authority towards us and a sufficient Warranty to our Faith is a nice Imagination For the Authority and Truth of God stand not in need nor are capable of any such Attestation from Men all they will admit of from the children of Men is that they do humbly submit unto them and testify their so doing with the Reasons of it The Ministry of the Church in this matter is that Duty of the Church whereby it proposeth and declareth the Scripture to be the Word of God and that as it hath occasion to all the World And this Ministry also may be considered either formally as 't is appointed of God unto this End and blessed by him or materially only as the thing is done though the Grounds whereon it is done and the manner of doing it be not divinely approved We wholly deny that we receive the Scripture or ever
unto it as I have elsewhere proved at large We shall therefore proceed There are two Things considerable with respect unto our Believing the Scriptures to be the Word of God in a due manner or according to our Duty The first respects the Subject or the mind of man how it is enabled thereunto the other the Object to be believed with the true Reason why we do believe the Scripture with Faith divine and supernatural The first of these must of necessity fall under our Consideration herein as that without which what ever Reasons Evidences or Motives are proposed unto us we shall never believe in a due manner For whereas the mind of man or the minds of all men are by nature depraved corrupt carnal and enmity against God they cannot of themselves or by virtue of any innate Ability of their own understand or assent unto spiritual things in a spiritual manner which we have sufficiently proved and confirmed before Wherefore that Assent which is wrought in us by meer external Arguments consisting in the rational Conclusion and Judgment which we make upon their Truth and Evidence is not that Faith wherewith we ought to believe the Word of God Wherefore that we may believe the Scriptures to be the Word of God according to our Duty as God requireth it of us in an useful profitable and saving manner above and beyond that natural humane Faith and Assent which is the Effect of the Arguments and Motives of Credibility before insisted on with all others of the like kind there is and must be wrought in us by the power of the Holy Ghost Faith supernatural and divine whereby we are enabled so to do or rather whereby we do so This Work of the Spirit of God as it is distinct from so in order of Nature it is antecedent unto all divine objective Evidence of the Scriptures being the Word of God or the formal Reason moving us to believe it wherefore without it whatever Arguments or Motives are proposed unto us we cannot believe the Scriptures to be the Word of God in a due manner and as it is in duty required of us Some it may be will suppose these things 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and impertinent unto our present purpose For while we are enquiring on what Grounds we believe the Scripture to be the Word of God we seem to fly to the Work of the Holy Ghost in our own minds which is irrational But we must not be ashamed of the Gospel nor of the Truth of it because some do not understand or will not duly consider what is proposed It is necessary that we should return unto the Work of the Holy Spirit not with peculiar respect unto the Scriptures that are to be believed but unto our own Minds and that Faith wherewith they are to be believed For it is not the Reason why we believe the Scriptures but the Power whereby we are enabled so to do which at present we enquire after 1. That the Faith whereby we believe the Scripture to be the Word of God is wrought in us by the Holy Ghost can be denied only on two Principles or Suppositions 1. That it is not Faith divine and supernatural whereby we believe them so to be but only we have other moral Assurance thereof 2. That this Faith divine and supernatural is of our selves and is not wrought in us by the Holy Ghost The first of these hath been already disproved and shall be further evicted afterwards and it may be they are very few who are of that Judgment For generally whatever men suppose the prime Object principal Motive and formal Reason of that Faith to be yet that it is Divine and Supernatural they all acknowledg And as to the second what is so 't is of the Operation of the Spirit of God For to say it is divine and supernatural is to say that it is not of our selves but that it is the Grace and Gift of the Spirit of God wrought in us by his divine and supernatural Power And those of the Church of Rome who would resolve our Faith in this matter objectively into the Authority of their Church yet subjectively acknowledge the Work of the Holy Spirit ingenerating Faith in us and that Work to be necessary to our Believing the Scripture in a due manner Externae omnes humanae persuasiones non sunt satis ad credendum quantumcunque ab hominibus competenter ea quae sunt fidei proponantur Sed necessaria est insuper causa interior hoc est divinum quoddam lumen incitans ad credendum oculi quidam interni Dei beneficio ad videndum dati saith Canus Loc. Theol. lib. 2. cap. 8. Nor is there any of the Divines of that Church which dissent herein We do not therefore assert any such divine formal Reoson of Believing as that the mind should not stand in need of supernatural Assistance enabling it to assent thereunto Nay we affirm that without this there is in no man any true Faith at all let the Arguments and Motives whereon he believes be as forcible and pregnant with Evidence as can be imagined It is in this Case as in things natural neither the the Light of the Sun nor any perswasive Arguments unto men to look up unto it will enable them to discern it unless they are endued with a due visive Faculty And this the Scripture is express in beyond all possibility of Contradiction Neither is it that I know of by any as yet in express terms denied For indeed that all which is properly called Faith with respect unto divine Revelation and is acceptted with God as such is the Work of the Spirit of God in us or is bestowed on us by him cannot be questioned by any who own the Gospel I have also proved it elsewhere so fully and largly as that I shall give it at present no other Confirmation but what will necessarily fall in with the Description of the Nature of that Faith whereby we do believe and the Way or Manner of its being wrought in us The Work of the Holy Ghost unto this purpose consists in the saving Illumination of the Mind and the Effect of it is a supernatural Light whereby the Mind is renewed see Rom. 12. 1. Ephes. 1. 18 19. chap. 3. 16 17 18 19. It is called an Heart to understand Eyes to see Ears to hear Deut. 29. 4. The opening of the Eyes of our Vunderstanding Ephes. 1. 18. The giving of an Vnderstanding 1 John 5. 20. Hereby we are enabled to discern the Evidences of the divine Original and Authority of the Scripture that are in it self as well as assent unto the Truth contained in it and without it we cannot do so For the natural man receives not the things of the Spirit of God for they are foolishness unto him neither can be know them because they are spiritually discerned 1 Cor. 2. 14. And unto this end it is written in the Prophets that we
compleat Revelation of the Will of God already made but new Revelations it hath neither need nor use of And to suppose them or a necessity of them not only overthrows the Perfection of the Scripture but also leaveth us uncertain whether we know all that is to be believed in order unto Salvation or our whole Duty or when we may do so For it would be our Duty to live all our days in expectation of new Revelations wherewith neither Peace Assurance nor Consolation are consistent 2. Those who are to believe will not be able on this Supposition to secure themselves from Delusion and from being imposed on by the Deceits of Satan For this new Revelation is to be tryed by the Scripture or it is not If it be to be tried and examined by the Scripture then doth it acknowledge a superiour Rule Judgment and Testimony and so cannot be that which our Faith is ultimately resolved into If it be exempted from that Rule of trying the Spirits then 1. It must produce the Grant of this Exemption seeing the Rule is extended generally unto all Things and Doctrines that relate unto Faith or Obedience 2. It must declare what are the Grounds and Evidences of its own 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or self-credibility and how it may be infallibly or assuredly distinguished from all Delusions which can never be done And if any tolerable Countenance could be given unto these things yet we shall shew immediatly that no such private Testimony though real can be the formal Object of Faith or Reason of Believing 3. It hath so fallen out in the Providence of God that generally all who have given up themselves in any things concerning Faith or Obedience unto the pretended Conduct of immediate Revelations although they have pleaded a respect unto the Scripture also have been seduced into Opinions and Practices directly repugnant unto it And this with all Persons of Sobriety is sufficient to discard this Pretence But this internal Testimony of the Spirit is by others explained quite in another way For they say that besides the Work of the Holy Ghost before insisted on whereby he takes away our natural blindness and enlightning our minds enables us to discern the divine Excellencies that are in the Scripture there is another internal Efficiency of his whereby we are moved perswaded and enabled to believe Hereby we are taught of God so as that finding the Glory and Majesty of God in the Word our Hearts do by an ineffable Power assent unto the Truth without any Hesitation And this Work of the Spirit carrieth its own Evidence in it self producing an Assurance above all humane Judgment and such as stands in need of no further Arguments or Testimonies this Faith rests on and is resolved into And this some learned men seem to embrace because they suppose that the objective Evidence which is given in the Scripture it self is only moral or such as can give only a moral Assurance Whereas therefore Faith ought to be divine and supernatural so must that be whereinto it is resolved yea it is so alone from the formal Reason of it And they can apprehend nothing in this Work that is immediately divine but only this internal Testimony of the Spirit wherein God himself speaks unto our Hearts But yet neither as it is so explained can we allow it to be the formal Object of Faith nor that wherein it doth acquiesce For 1. It hath not the proper Nature of a divine Testimony A divine Work it may be but a divine Testimony it is not but it is of the nature of Faith to be built on an external Testimony However therefore our minds may be established and enabled to believe firmly and stedfastly by an ineffable internal Work of the Holy Ghost whereof also we may have a certain experience yet neither that Work nor the Effect of it can be the Reason why we do believe nor whereby we are moved to believe but only that whereby we do believe 2. That which is the formal Object of Faith or Reason whereon we believe is the same and common unto all that do believe For our Enquiry is not how or by what means this or that man came to believe but why any one or every one ought so to do unto whom the Scripture is proposed The Object proposed unto all to be believed is the same and the Faith required of all in a way of Duty is the same or of the same kind and nature and therefore the Reason why we believe must be the same also But on this Supposition there must be as many distinct Reasons of believing as there are Believers 3. On this Supposition it cannot be the Duty of any one to believe the Scripture to be the Word of God who hath not received this internal Testimony of the Spirit For where the true formal Reason of believing is not proposed unto us there it is not our duty to believe Wherefore although the Scripture be proposed as the Word of God yet is it not our duty to believe it so to be until we have this Work of the Spirit in our hearts in case that be the formal Reason of believing But not to press any further how it is possible men may be deceived and deluded in their Apprehensions of such an internal Testimony of the Spirit especially if it be not to be tried by the Scripture which if it be it loseth its 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or self-credibility or if it be it casteth us into a Circle which the Papists charge us withal it cannot be admitted as the formal Object of our Faith because it would divert us from that which is publick proper every way certain and infallible However that Work of the Spirit which may be called an internal real Testimony is to be granted as that which belongs unto the Stability and Assurance of Faith For if he did no otherwise work in us or upon us but by the Communication of spiritual Light unto our minds enabling us to discern the Evidences that are in the Scripture of its own Divine Original we should often be shaken in our Assent and moved from our Stability For whereas our spiritual darkness is removed but in part and at best whilst we are here we see things but darkly as in a Glass all things believed having some sort of Inevidence or Obscurity attending them and whereas Temptations will frequently shake and disturb the due respect of the Faculty unto the Object or interpose Mists and Clouds between them we can have no Assurance in Believing unless our minds are further established by the Holy Ghost He doth therefore three ways assist us in believing and ascertain our minds of the things believed so as that we may hold fast the beginning of our Confidence firm and stedfast unto the end For 1. He gives unto Believers a spiritual Sense of the Power and Reality of the things believed whereby their Faith is greatly established And although
the Word of God with no less Firmness Certainty and Assurance of Mind than do the wisest and most Learned of them Yea ofttimes the Faith of the former Sort herein is of the best Growth and firmest Consistency against Oppositions and Temptations Now no Assent of the Mind can be accompanied with any more Assurance than the Evidence whose Effect it is and which it is resolved into will afford Nor doth any Evidence of Truth beget an Assent unto it in the Mind but as it is apprehended and understood Wherefore the Evidence of this Truth wherein soever it consists must be that which is perceived apprehended and understood by the meanest and most unlearned Sort of true Believers For as was said they do no less firmly assent and adhere unto it than the Wisest and most Learned of them It cannot therefore consist in such subtil and learned Arguments whose Sense they cannot understand or comprehend But the Things we have pleaded are of another Nature For those Characters of Divine Wisdom Goodness Holiness Grace and Sovereign Authority which are implanted on the Scripture by the Holy Ghost are as legible unto the Faith of the Meanest as of the most Learned Believer And they also are no less capable of an Experimental Vnderstanding of the Divine Power and Efficacy of the Scriptures in all its Spiritual Operations than those who are more Wise and Skillful in discerning the Force of External Arguments and Motives of Credibility It must therefore of necessity be granted that the formal Reason of Faith consists in those Things whereof the Evidence is equally obvious unto all Sorts of Believers 2. Whence it is that the Assent of Faith whereby we believe the Scriptures to be the Word of God is usually affirmed to be accompanied with more Assurance than any Assent which is the Effect of Science upon the most demonstrative Principles They who affirm this do not consider Faith as it is in this or that Individual Person or in all that do sincerely believe but in its own Nature and Essence and what it is meet and able to produce And the Schoolmen do distinguish between a Certainty or Assurance of Evidence and an Assurance of Adherence In the latter they say the Certainty of Faith doth exceed that of Science but it is less in respect of the former But it is not easily to be conceived how the Certainty of Adherence should exceed the Certainty of Evidence with respect unto any Object whatsoever That which seems to render a Difference in this Case is that the Evidence which we have in Things scientifical is Speculative and affects the Mind only but the Evidence which we have by Faith effectually worketh on the Will also because of the Goodness and Excellency of the Things that are believed And hence it is that the whole Soul doth more firmly adhere unto the Objects of Faith upon that Evidence which it hath of them than unto other Things whereof it hath clearer Evidence wherein the Will and the Affections are little or not at all concerned And Bonaventure giveth a Reason of no small weight why Faith is more certain than Science not with the Certainty of Speculation but of Adherence Quoniam fideles Christiani nec Argumentis nec Tormentis nec Blandimentis adduci possunt vel inclinari ut Veritatem quam credunt vel ore tenus negent quod nemo peritus alicujus scientiae faceret si acerrimis Tormentis cogeretur scientiam suam de conclusione aliqua Geometrica vel Arithmetica retractare Stultus enim ridiculus esset Geometra qui pro sua scientia in Controversiis Geometricis mortem anderet subire nisi in quantum dictat Fides non esse mentiendum And whatever may be said of this Distinction I think it cannot modestly be denied that there is a greater Assurance in Faith than any is in scientifical Conclusions until as many good and wise Men will part with all their worldly Concernments and their Lives by the most exquisite Tortures in the Confirmation of any Truth which they have received meerly on the Ground of Reason acting in Humane Sciences as have so done on the Certainty which they had by Faith that the Scripture is a Divine Revelation For in bearing Testimony hereunto have innumerable Multitudes of the Best the Holiest and the VVisest Men that ever were in the VVorld chearfully and joyfully sacrificed all their Temporal and adventured all their Eternal Concernments For they did it under a full Satisfaction that in parting with all temporary things they should be eternally Blessed or eternally Miserable according as their Perswasion in Faith proved true or false VVherefore unto the Firmitude and Constancy which we have in the Assurance of Faith three Things do concur 1. That this Ability of Assent upon Testimony is the highest and most noble Power or Faculty of our rational Souls and therefore where it hath the highest Evidence whereof it is capable which it hath in the Testimony of God it giveth us the highest Certainty or Assurance whereof in this VVorld we are capable 2. Unto the Assent of Divine Faith there is required an especial internal Operation of the Holy Ghost This rendreth it of another Nature than any meer natural Act and Operation of our Minds And therefore if the Assurance of it may not properly be said to exceed the Assurance of Science in Degree it is only because it is of a more excellent kind and so is not capable of Comparison unto it as to Degrees 3. That the Revelation which God makes of Himself his Mind and Will by his Word is more excellent and accompanied with greater Evidence of his infinitely Glorious Properties wherein alone the Mind can find absolute Rest and Satisfaction which is its Assurance than any other Discovery of Truth of what sort soever is capable of Neither is the Assurance of the Mind absolutely perfect in any thing beneath the Enjoyment of God Wherefore the Soul by Faith making the nearest Approaches whereof in this Life it is capable unto the Eternal Spring of Being Truth and Goodness it hath the highest Rest Satisfaction and Assurance therein that in this Life it can attain unto 3. It followeth from hence that those that would deny either of those two Things or would so separate between them as to exclude the Necessity of either unto the Duty of Believing namely the internal Work of the Holy Spirit on the Minds of Men enabling them to believe and the external Work of the same Holy Spirit giving Evidence in and by the Scripture unto its own Divine Original do endeavour to expell all True Divine Faith out of the World and to substitute a probable Perswasion in the room thereof For a Close unto this Discourse which hath now been drawn forth unto a greater Length than was at first intended I shall consider some Objections that are usually pleaded in Opposition unto the Truth asserted and vindicated It is therefore objected in the first