place unto all the Members of it was a particular Congregation 6. The things that he ascribeth unto this Leader to be done at this general meeting of the Church every Lords day were 1. That he prayed 2. That after the reading of the Scripture he preached 3. That he consecrated the Eucharist the Elements of the Bread and Wine being distributed by the Deacons unto the Congregation 4. That he closed the whole Worship of the day in prayer 7. In the Consecration of the Sacramental Elements he observes that the President prayed at large giving thanks to God 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 So vain is the pretence of some that in the Primitive times they consecrated the Elements by the Repetition of the Lords prayer only After the participation of the Eucharist there was a Collection made for the poor as he describeth it at large what was so gathered being committed to the Pastor who took care for the distribution of it unto all sorts of poor belonging unto the Church Hereunto was added as Tertullian observes the Exercise of Discipline in their Assemblies whereof we shall speak afterwards The close of the Administration of the Sacrament Justin gives us in these words 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 The Pastor again according to his ability or power poureth forth or sends up prayers the people all joyfully crying Amen c. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that is as Origen expounds the Phrase often used by himself 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 lib. 8. ad Cels. according unto the present Ability given unto him This was the state the Order and the Worship of the Church with its Method in the days of Justin Martyr This and no other is that which we plead for Unto these times belongs the most excellent Epistle of the Churches of Vienna and Lyons in France unto the Brethren in Asia and Phrygia recorded at large by Eusebius Hist. lib. 5. cap 1. Their design in it is to give an account of the holy Martyrs who suffered in the persecution under Marcus Antoninus I am no way concerned in what state Irenaeus was in the Church at Lyons whereon after the writing of this Epistle he was sent to Eleutherius the Bishop of Rome which he gives an account of Chap. 4. He is indeed in that Epistle called a Presbyter of the Church although as some suppose it was sundry years after the death of Pothinus whom they call Bishop of Lyons into whose room he immediately succeeded And Eusebius himself cap. 8. affirming that he would give an account of the Writings of the antient Ecclesiastical Presbyters in the first place produceth those of Irenaeus But these things belong not unto our present contest The Epistle we intend was written by the Brethren of those Churches and it was written to the Brethren of the Churches in Asia and Phrygia after the manner of the Scripture wherein the fraternity or Body of the Church was designed or intended in all such Epistles From them was this Epistle and unto those of the same sort was it written not from one Bishop unto another And as this manifests the concern of the Brotherhood in all Ecclesiastical Affairs so with all other circumstances it evidenceth that those Churches were particular or Congregational only Nor is there any thing in the whole Epistle that should give the least intimation of any other Church state knowâ— unto them This Epistle as recorded by Eusebius gives us as noble Representation of the Spirit and Communion that was then among the Churches of Christ being written with Apostolical simplicity and gravity and remote from those Titles of Honour and affected swelling words which the faigned writings of that Age and some that are genuine in those that followed are stuffed withal Tertullâ—an who lived about the end of the second Century gives us the same account of the State Order and Worship of the Churches as was given beâ—ore by Justin Martyr Apol. ad Gen. cap. 39. The Description of a Church he first lays down in these words Corpâ—s sumus de conscientia Religionis Disciplinae unitate spei foedere We are a Body united in the Conscience of Religion or a conscientious Observation of the Duties of Religion by an Agreement in Discipline whereby it was usual with the Antients to express Universal Obedience unto the Doctrine and commands of Christ and in a Covenant of Hope For whereas such a Body or Religious Society could not be united but by a Covenant he calls it a Covenant of Hope because the principal respect was had therein unto the things hoped foâ— They covenanted together so to live and walk in the Discipline of Christ or Obedience unto his commands as that they might come together unto the enjoyment of Eternal Blessedness This Religious Body or Society thus united by Covenant did meet together in the same Assembly or Congregation Corpus suâ—us â—oâ—mus in coeâ—um Congregationem ut ad Deum quasi manu facta precationibus ambiamus orantes And cogimur ad divinarum literarum commemorationem c. Designing to declare as he doth in particular Negotia Christianae factionis as he calls them or the Duties of Christian Religion which in their Churches they did attend unto he lays the foundation in their meetings in the saâ—â— Assemâ—ly or Congregation In these Assemblies there presided the Elders that upon a Testimony of their meetness unto that Office were chosen thereunto President probati quique seniores honorem istum non pretiâ— sed Testimonio adepti And in the Church thus met together in the same place Assembly or Congregation under the rule and conduct of their Elders among other things they exercised Discipline that is in the presence and by the consent of the whole Ibidem etiam exhortationes castigationes censura divina Nam judicatur magno cum pondere ut apud certos de Dei conspectu summumque futuri judâ—cii praejudicium est sâ— quis ita deliquerit ut à communicatione Oratinis conventus omnis sancti commercii relegetur The loss of this Discipline and the manner of its Administration hath been one of the principal means of the Apostacy of Churches from their Primitive Institution To the same purpose doth Origen give us an account of the way of the gathering and establishing Churches under Elders of their own choosing in the close of his last Book against Celsus And although in the days of Cyprian in the third Century the distinction between the Bishop in any Church eminently so called and those who are only Presbyters with their imparity and not only the precedency but superiority of one over others began generally to be admitted yet it is sufficiently manifest from his Epistles that the Church wherein he did preside was so far a particular Church as that the whole Body or Fraternity of it was admitted unto all advice in things of common concernment unto the whole Church and allowed the exercise of their
lies therein To assert this expresly would be to exalt him above Jesus Christ at least to give him power equal unto his though really unto the Institution of the Gospel Church state and the Communication of Graces Offices and Gifts to make it useful unto its end no less than all power in Heaven and Earth be required Some plead that there is no certain Form of Church-Government appointed in the Scripture that there was none ordained by Christ nor exemplifyed by the Apostles and therefore it is in the power of the Magistrate to appoint any such form thereof as is suited unto the publick Interest It would seem to follow more evidently that no Form at all should by any be appointed for what shall he do that cometh after the King what shall any one ordain in the Church which the Lord Christ thought not meet to ordain And this is the proper inference from this consideration Such a Church-Government as men imagine Christ hath not appointed therefore neither may men do so But suppose that the Lord Christ hath appointed a Church-state or that there should be Churches of his Disciples on the Earth let them therein but yeild Obedience unto all that he hath commanded and in their so doing make use of the light of nature and rules of common prudence so as to do it unto their own edification which to deny to be their duty is to destroy their nature as created of God trusting in all things unto the conduct of the promised Divine Assistance of the Holy Spirit if any instance can be given of what is wanting unto the compleat state and Rule of the Church we shall willingly allow that it be added by the Civil Magistrate or whosoever men can agree upon as was before declared If it be said there is yet something wanting to accommodate these Churches and their Rule unto the state of the Publick Interest and Political Government under which they are placed whereon they may be framed into Churches Diocesan and Metropolitical with such a Rule as they are capable of I say 1. That in their Original Constitution they are more accommodated unto the Interest of all righteous Secular Government than any Arbitrary moulding them unto a pretended meetness to comply therewithal can attain unto This we have proved before and shall farther enlarge upon it if it be required And we find it by experience that those Additions Changes and Alterations in the State Order and Rule of the Churches pretended for the end mentioned have proved the cause of endless Contentions which have no good aspect on the publick peace and will assuredly continue for ever so to be 2. It is granted that the Magistrate may dispose of many outward concerns of these Churches may impart of his favour to them or any of them as he sees cause may take care that nothing falls out among them that may occasion any publick disturbance in and by itself may prohibit the publick exercise of Worship Idolatrous or Superstitious may remove and take away all Instruments and Monuments of Idolatry may coerce restrain and punish as there is occasion persons who under pretence of Religion do advance Principles of Sedition or promote any Forreign Interest opposite and destructive to his Government the welfare of the Nation and the Truth of Religion with sundry things of the like nature And herein lies an ample field wherein the Magistrate may exercise his power and discharge his duty It cannot well be denyed but that the present pretences and pleas of some to reduce all things in the practice of Religion into the power and disposal of the Civil Magistrate are full of offence and scandal It seems to be only a design and contrivance to secure Mens secular Interests under every way of the profession of Christian Religion true or false which may have the advantage of the Magistrates Approbation By this device Conscience is set at liberty from concerning itself in an humble diligent enquiry into the mind of God as unto what is its duty in his Worship And when it is so with the Conscience of any it will not be much concerned in what it doth attend unto or observe What is in Divine things done or practised solely on the Authority of the Magistrate is immediately and directly Obedience unto him and not unto God Whatever therefore the Supreme Power in any place may do or will be pleased to do for the accommodation of the outward state of the Church and the exercise of its Rule unto the Political Government of a People or Nation yet these two things are certain 1. That he can form erect or institute no new Church-state which is not ordained and appointed by Christ and his Apostles by vertue of his Authority and what he doth of that nature appoint is called a Church only equivocally or by reason of some resemblance unto that which is properly so called 2. To dissent from what is so appointed by the Supreme Power in and about the State Form Rule and Worship of Churches whatever other evil it may be charged with or supposed liable unto can have nothing in it of that which the Scripture condemns under the name of Schism which hath respect only unto what is stated by Christ himself That which in this place we should next enquire into is what these particular Churches themselves may do by their own voluntary consent and act in a way of Association or otherwise for the accumulation and exercise of a power not formally inherent in them as particular Churches but I shall refer it unto the Head of the Communion of Churches which must be afterwards spoken unto CHAP. VIII The Duty of Believers to joyn themselves in Church-Order UNto some one or other of those particular Congregations which we have described continuing to be the ground and pillar of Truth it is the duty of every Believer of every Disciple of Christ to joyn himself for the due and orderly observation and performance of the commands of Christ unto the glory of God and their own edification Matth. 28.18 19 20. This in general is granted by all sorts and Parties of men the grant of it is the ground whereon they stand in the management of their mutual fewds in Religion pleading that men ought to be of or joyn themselves unto this or that Church still supposing that it is their Duty to be of one or another Yea it is granted also that Persons ought to chuse what Churches they will joyn themselves unto wherein they may have the best advantage unto their Edification and Salvation They are to chuse to joyn themselves unto that Church which is in all things most according to the mind of God This it is supposed is the Liberty and Duty of every Man for if it be not so it is the foolishest thing in the world for any to attempt to get others from one Church unto another which is almost the whole business of Religion that some think
they make herein may possibly keep up some Churches but is the ready way to destroy all Religion 2. That many of those by whom this Liberty is denyed unto professing Christians yet do indeed take it for granted that they have such a Liberty and that it is their Duty to make use of it For what are all the Contests between the Church of Rome and the Church of England so far as Christians that are not Church-men are concerned in them Is it not in whether of these Churches Edification may be best obtained If this be not the Ball between us I know not what is Now herein do not all the Writers and Preachers of both Parties give their Reasons and Arguments unto the People why Edification is better to be had in the one Church then in the other and do they not require of them to form a Judgment upon those Reasons and Arguments and to act accordingly if they do not they do but make a Flourish and act a Part like Players on a Stage without any determinate Design 3. All Christians actually do so they do judge for themselves unless they are brutish they do Act according unto that Judgment unless they are hardened in Sin and therefore who do not so are not to be esteemed Disciples of Christ. To suppose that in all things of Spiritual and Eternal Concernment that men are not determined and acted every one by his own Judgment is an Imagination of men who think but little of what they are or do or say or Write Even those who shut their Eyes against the Light and follow in the Herd resolving not to enquire into any of these things do it because they judge it is best for them so to do 4. It is commonly acknowledged by Protestants that private Christians have a Judgement of Discretion in things of Religion The Term was invented to grant them some Liberty of Judgement in Opposition unto the blind Obedience required by the Church of Rome but withal to put a restraint upon it and a distinction of some superiour Judgement it may be in the Church or others But if by Discretion they mean the best of mens Vnderstanding Knowledge Wisdom and Prudence in and about the things wherein it is exercised I should be glad to be informed what other Judgment than this of Discretion in and about the things of Religion this or that or any Church in the World can have or exercise But to allow men a Judgement of Discretion and not to grant it their Duty to act according unto that Judgement is to oblige them to be Fools and to act not discreetly at least not according unto their own Discretion 4. The same is to be spoken of Gospel Discipline without which neither can the Duties of Church Societies be observed nor the Ends of them attained The neglect the loss the abuse hereof is that which hath ruined the Glory of Christian Religion in the World and brought the whole Profession of it into Confusion Hereon have the fervency and sincerity of true Evangelical mutual Love been abated yea utterly lost For that Love which Jesus Christ requireth among his Disciples is such as never was in the World before amongst Men nor can be in the World but on the Principles of the Gospel and Faith therein Therefore it is called his New Commandement The Continuation of it amongst the Generality of Christians is but vainly pretended little or nothing of the Reality of it in its due Exercise is found And this hath ensued on the Neglect of Evangelical Discipline in Churches or the turning of it into a Worldly Domination For one principal End of it is the Preservation Guidance and acting of this Love That mutual Watch over one another that ought to be in all the Members of the Church the Principal Evidence and fruit of Love without Dissimulation is also lost hereby Most men are rather ready to say in the Spirit and Words of Cain Am I my Brothers Keeper than to attend unto the Command of the Apostles Exhort one another dayly least any be hardened through the Deceitfulness of Sin Or comply with the Command of our Saviour if thy Brother offend thee tell him of it between him and thee By this means likewise is the Purity of Communion lost and those received as principal Members of Churches who by all the Rules of Primitive Discipline ought to be cast out of them Wherefore this also is to be considered in the Choice we are to make of what Churches we will joyn our selves unto as unto constant compleat Communion and in whose Communion we will abide For these things are Matters of Choice and consist in Voluntary free Acts of Obedience With those unto whom they are not so who would on the one hand have them to be things that men may be compelled unto and ought so to be or on the other that follow no other Guidance in them but outward Circumstances from the Times and Places where they are born and inhabit I will have no Contest It follows from hence also That Where there are many Churches wherein these things are found whereon we may lawfully and ought in Duty to joyn with some of them in particular every one is obliged to joyn himself unto such a Church as whose Principles and Practises are most suited unto his Edification CHAP. XI Of Conformity and Communion in Parochial Assemblies FROM what we have insisted on we may borrow some Light into the Determination of that Case wherein Multitudes are at this day concerned And the Case it self may be briefly stated in this Enquiry namely Whether all Protestants Ministers and People are bound to joyn themselves unto the Church of England as now by Law established in its Parochial Assemblies as unto compleat constant Communion without the use of any other Church means for their own Edification So as if they do not so do they are Guilty of Schisme This is that which is called Conformity unto the Church of England which as unto private Persons can be expressed only in constant compleat Communion in Parochial Assemblies according to their Present Constitution without the Use or Exercise of any other Church Worship or Discipline but what is by Law established in them Refraining from an absolute compliance herein is called Schisme But whereas Ecclesiastical Schisme whatever it be in particular in its general nature hath respect only unto divine Institutions this which respecteth only the Laws Rules and Determinations of men can have no alliance thereunto Yet is it not only charged as such without the least countenance from Scripture or Antiquity so far as it may be allowed of Authority with us but the supposition of it is accumulated with another Evil namely that those who are so guilty of it in the Judgment of them who are interested with secular Power though Peaceable and Orthodox ought to be punished with various Penalties gradually coming unto the loss of Goods Liberty and in some Cases of
in his laborious endeavour to stigmatize all Protestant Dissenters from the Church of England with the odious name of Schismaticks I have therefore altered nothing of what I had projected either as to Matter or Method in this first Part of the Discourse designed on the whole Subject of Church Affairs For as I have not found either Cause or Reason from any thing in the Doctors Book to make the least change in what I had writtâ—n so my principal Design being the Instruction and confirmation of them who have no other Interest in these things but only to know and perform their own Duty I was not willing to give them the trouble of perpetual diversions from the Matter in hand which all Controversial Writings are Subject unto Wherefore having premised some general Considerations of things insisted on by the Dr. of no great Influence into the Cause in hand and vindicated one Principle a supposition whereof we rely upon namely the Declension of the Churches in the Ages after the Apostles especially after the End of the second Century from the Primitive Institution of their State Rule and Order in the Preface I shall now proceed to consider and examine distinctly what is opposed unto the Defence of our Innocency as unto the Guilt of Schisme But some things must be premised hereunto As 1. I shall not depart from the state of the Question as laid down by our selves on our part as unto our Judgement of Parochial Churches and our Refraining from Communion with them Great Pains is taken to prove the several sorts of Dissenters to be departed farther from the Church of England then they will themselves allow and on such Principles as are disavowed by them But no Disputations can force our Assent unto what we know to be contrary unto our Principles and Perswasions 2. We do allow those Parochial Assemblies which have a settled unblamable Ministry among them to be true Churches so far as they can pretend themselves so to be Churches whose Original is from occasional Cohabitation within Precincts limited by the Law of the Land Churches without Church-Power to choose or ordain their Officers to provide for their own Continuation to admit or exclude Members or to reform at any time what is amiss among them Churches which are in all things under the Rule of those who are set over them by vertue of Civil Constitutions forraign unto them not submitted willingly unto by them and such for the most part as whose Offices and Power have not the least countenance given unto them from the Scripture or the Practice of the Primitive Churches Such as are Chancellours Commissaries Officials and the like Churches in which for the most part through a total Neglect in Evangelical Discipline there is a great Degeneracy from the exercise of Brotherly Love and the Holiness of Christian Profession whatever can be ascribed unto such Churches we willingly allow unto them 3. We do and shall abide by this Principle that communion in Faith and Love with the Administration of the same Sacraments is sufficient to preserve all Christians from the Guilt of Schisme although they cannot communicate together in some Rites and Rules of Worship and Order As we will not admit of any presumed Notions of Schisme and inferences from them nor allow that any thing belongs thereunto which is not contrary to Gospel Love Rules and Precepts in the Observance of Christs Institutions so we affirm and shall maintain that men abiding in the Principles of Communion mentioned walking peaceably among themselves refraining Communion with others peaceably wherein they dissent from them ready to joyn with other Churches in the same Confession of Faith and in the Defence of it and to concur with them in promoting all the real ends of Christian Religion not judging the Church state of others so as to renounce all Communion with them as condemning them to be no Churches continuing in the occasional exercise of all Duties of Love towards them and their Members are unduely charged with with the Guilt of Schisme to the disadvantage of the Common Interest of the Protestant Religion amongst us 4. Whereas there are two parts of the Charge against us the one for refraining from total communion with Parochial Assemblies which what it is and wherein it doth consist hath been before declared the other for gathering ourselves into another Church Order in particular Congregations as the Reasons and Grounds of the things themselves are distinct so must they have a distinct consideration and be examined distinctly and apart These things being premised I shall proceed to examine what the Reverend Doctor hath further offered against our former Vindication of the Non-conformists from the charge of Schisme and I desire the Reader to take notice that we delight not in these contentions that we desire nothing but mutual Love and Forbearance but we are compelled by all Rules of Scripture and natural Equity to abide in this Defence of ourselves For whereas we are charged with a Crime and that aggravated as one of the most heynous that men can incur the Guilt of in this World and to justifie men in severities against us being not in the least convinced in our Consciences of any Accessions thereunto or of any Guilt on the account of it I suppose the Doctor himself will not think it reasonable that we should altogether neglect the Protection of our own Innocency In the Method whereinto he hath cast his Discourse he begins with the reinforcement of his Charge against our refraining from total Communion with Parochial Assemblies If the Reader will be pleased to take a reveiw of what is said in the preceding Discourse unto this Head of our Charge in several Chapters he will easily perceive that either the Reasonings of the Doctor reach not the Cause in hand or are insufficient to justifie his Intention which I must say though I am unwilling to repeat it is by all ways and means to load us with the Guilt and disreputation of Schisme That which I first meet withal directly unto this Purpose is Part 2. pag. 157. The Forbearance of Communion with the Church of England in its Parochial Assemblies that is in the way and manner before described he opposeth with two Arguments The first respects those who allow occasional Communion with Parochial Churches but will not comply with them in that which is constant and absolute For he says if the first be lawful the latter is necessary from the commands we have to preserve the Peace and Vnity of the Church And the not doing it he says is one of the provoking sins of the Non-conformists but whether it be a sin or no is sub Judice that it is provoking unto some is sufficiently evident I shall not make this any part of my Contest Those who have so expressed their Charity as to give countenance unto this pretended Advantage will easily free themselves from the force of this Inference For it must be remembered that
to choose out from among themselves Persons meet for an Ecclesiastical Office Act. 6. The same People who joyned with the Apostles and Elders in the consideration of the grand Case concerning the continuation of the legal Ceremonies and were associated with them in the Determination of it Act. 15. The same to whom all the Apostolical Epistles excepting some to particular Persons were written and unto whom such Directions were given and Duties enjoyned in them as suppose not only a Liberty and Ability to judge for themselves in all Matters of Faith and Obedience but also an especial Interest in the Order and Discipline of the Church Those who were to say unto Archippus their Bishop take heed unto the Ministry thou hast received in the Lord that thou fulfil it Col. 4. unto whom of all sorts it is commanded that they should examine and try Antichrists Spirits and false Teachers that is all sorts of Hereticks Heresies and Errors 1 Joh. chap. 2.3 c. That People who even in following Ages adhered unto the Faith and the Orthodox Profession of it when almost all their Bishops were become Arian Hereticks and kept their private Conventicles in opposition unto them at Constantinople Antioch Alexandria and other places and who were so many of them burned here in England by their own Bishops on the Judgement they made of Errors and Heresies And if the present People with whom the Dr. is acquainted be altogether unmeet for the Discharge of any of these Duties it is the fault of some body else beside their own This Principle of the Reformation in Vindication of the Rights Liberties and Priviledges of the Christian People to judge and choose for themselves in Matters of Religion to joyn freely in those Church Duties which are required of them without which the work of it had never been carried on we do abide by and maintain Yea we meet with no Opposition more fierce than upon the Account of our Asserting the Liberties and Right of the People in reference unto Church Order and Worship But I shall not be afraid to say that as the Reformation was begun and carried on on this Principle so when this People shall through an Apprehension of their Ignorance Weakness and Unmeetness to discern and judge in Matters of Religion for themselves and their own Duty be kept and debarred from it or when through their own Sloth Negligence and Vitiousness they shall be really uncapable to mannage their own Interest in Church Affairs as being fit only to be governed if not as brute Creatures yet as Mute Persons and that these things are improved by the Ambition of the Clergy engrossing all things in the Church unto themselves as they did in former Ages if the Old Popedome do not return a new one will be erected as bad as the other Thirdly another Principle of the Reformation is that there was not any Catholick Visible Organical Governing Church traduced by Succession into that of Rome 〈◊〉 all Church Power and Order was to be derived I will not say that this Principle was absolutely received by all the first Reformers here in England yet it was by the Generality of them in the other Parts of the World For as they constantly denied that there was any Catholick Church but that invisible of Elect Believers allowing the External Denomination of the Church unto the diffused Community of the baptized World so believing and professing that the Pope is Antichrist that Rome is Mystical Babylon the Seat of the Apostatized Church of the Gentiles devoted to destruction they could acknowledge no such Church state in the Roman Church nor the derivation of any Power and Order from it So farre as there is a Declension from this Principle so far the Cause of the Reformation is weakened and the principal Reason of Separation from the Roman Church is rejected as shall be farther manifested if occasion require it This Principle we do firmly adhere unto and not only so but it is known that our fixed Judgement concerning the Divine Institution Nature and Order of Evangelical Churches is such as is utterly exclusive of the Roman Church as a body organized in and under the Pope and his Hierarchy from any pretence unto Church State Order or Power And it may be hence judged who do most weaken the Cause of Reformation we or some of them at least by whom we are opposed A second Absurdity that he chargeth on our way is that it would make Vnion among the Protestant Churches impossible supposing them to remain as they are Sect. 24. pag. 186. To make good this Charge he insists on two things 1. That the Lutheran Churches have the same and more Ceremonies and unscriptural Impositions then our Church hath 2. That notwithstanding these things yet many learned Protestant Divines have pleaded for Vnion and Communion with them which upon our Principles and Suppositions they could not have done But whether they plead for Union and Communion with them by admitting into their Churches and submitting unto those Ceremonies and unscriptural Impositions which is alone unto the Doctors Purpose or whether they judge their Members obliged to Communicate in local Communion with them under those Impositions he doth not declare But whereas neither we nor our Cause are in the least concerned in what the Dr. here insist upon yet because the Charge is no less then that our Principles give disturbance unto the Peace and Vnion of all Protestant Churches I shall briefly manifest that they are not only conducive thereunto but such as without which that Peace and Union will never be attained 1. It is known unto all that from the first Beginning of the Reformation there were Differences among the Churches which departed from the Communion of the Church of Rome And as this was looked on as the greatest Impediment unto the Progress of the Reformation so it was not morally possible that in a work of that Nature begun and carried on by Persons of all for us in many Nations of divers Tongues and Languages none of them being divinely inspired that it should otherwise fall out God also in his Holy Wise Providence suffered it so to be for Causes known then to himself but since sundry of them have been made manifest in the Event For whereas there was an Agreement in all fundamental Articles of Faith among them and all necessary meanes of Salvation a farther Agreement considering our Sloth Negligence and proness of men to abuse security and Power might have produced as evil effects as the Differences have done For those which have been on the one hand and those which have been on the other have been and would have been from the corrupt Affections of the Minds of men and their secular Interests 2. These Differences were principally in or about some Doctrines of Faith whereon some fiery Spirits among them took occasion mutually and unjustly enough to charge each other with Heresie especially was this done among the Lutherans
least that any other Person had undertaken or would undertake the Consideration of the Drs. Sermon I thought that My endeavour for the removal of the Obstacle cast in the way unto a sincere Coalition in the Vnity of Faith among all sorts of Protestants might not be unacceptable Neither did I see any other way whereby this might be done but only by a Vindication of the Dissenters from the Guilt of that state which if it be truly charged on them must render our Divisions irreconcileable And continuing still of the same Mind I have once more renewed the same Defensative with no other Design but to maintain hopes that Peace and Love may yet be preserved among us during the continuation of these Differences And whereas it is a work of Almighty Power to reduce Christian Religion unto its first Purity and Simplicity which will not be effected but by various providential Dispensations in the World and renewed Effusions of the Holy Spirit from above which are to be waited for and seeing that all endeavours for National Reformation are attended with insuperable Difficulties few Churches being either able or willing to extricate themselves from the Dust of Traditions and Time with the Rust of Secular Interests I would hope that they shall not be always the Object of publick Severities who keeping the Vnity of the Spirit in the Bond of Truth and Peace with all sincere Disciples of Christ every where do design nothing but a Reformation of themselves and their ways by an universal compliance with the Will and Word of Christ alone whom God hath commanded them in all things to hear and obey The Reduction I say of the Profession of Christianity in general unto its Primitive Purity Simplicity Separation from the World and all Implication with Secular Interests so as that it should comprize nothing but the Guidance of the Souls of Men in the Life of God towards the Enjoyment of him is a Work more to be prayed for to come in its proper season then to be expected in this Age. Nor do any yet appear fitted in the least Measure for the undertaking or attempting such a Work any farther then by their own Personal Profession and Example And whilst things continue amongst Protestant Churches in the State wherein they are under the Influence of divided secular Interests and advantagious Mixtures with them with the Reliques of the Old General Apostasie by differences in points of Doctrine in Rules of Discipline in Orders of Divine Worship it is in vain to look for any Union or Communion among them in a compliance with any certain Rule of Vniformity either in the Profession of Faith or in the Practice of Worship and Discipline Nor would such an Agreement among them could it be attained be of any great Advantage unto the important ends of Religion unless a Revival of the Power of it in the Soules of Men do accompany it In the mean time the Glory of our Christian Profession in Righteousness Holiness and a visible Dedication of its Professors unto God is much lost in the World innumerable Souls perishing through the want of effectual means for their Conversion and Edification To attempt publick National Reformation whilst things Ecclesiastick and Civil are so involved as they are the one being riveted into the legal constitution of the other is neither the Duty nor Work of Private men Nor will as I suppose Wise Men be over forward in attempting any such thing unless they had better Evidence of means to make it effectual then any that do as yet appear For the Religion of a Nation in every form will answer the Ministry of it What is the present Duty in this State of things of those private Christians or Ministers who cannot satisfie their Consciences as unto their Duty towards God without endeavouring a Conformity unto the Will of Christ in the Observance of all his Institutions and Commands confining all their Concerns in Religion unto things Spiritual and Heavenly is the Enquiry before us CHAP. I. Of the Original of Churches WHEN any thing which is pleaded to belong unto Religion or the Worship of God is proposed unto us Our first Consideration of it ought to be in that Enquiry which our Lord Jesus Christ made of the Pharisees concerning the Baptism of John Whence is it from Heaven or of Men He distributes all things which come under that Plea or Pretence into two heads as unto their Original and Efficient cause namely Heaven and Men. And these are not only different and distinct but so contradictory one unto another that as unto any thing wherein Religion or the Worship of God is concerned they cannot concur as partial causes of the same effect What is of Men is not from Heaven and what is from Heaven is not of Men. And hence is his determination concerning both sorts of these things Every plant which my Heavenly Father hath not planted shall be rooted up Mat. 15.13 Designing therefore to treat of Churches their Original Nature Vse and End my first Enquiry must be whether they are from Heaven or of Men that is whether they are of a Divine Original having a Divine Institution or whether they are an Ordinance or Creation of Men For their Pedigree must be derived from one of these singly they never concurred in the Constitution of any part of Divine Worship or any thing that belongs thereunto This would seem a case and enquiry of an exceeding easie determination For the Scripture every where makes mention of the Church or Churches as the Ordinances and Institutions of God But such things have falln out in the World in latter Ages as may make men justly question whether we understand the mind of God aright or no in what is spoken of them At least if they should allow that the Churches so mentioned in the Scripture were of Divine Appointment yet it might be highly questionable whether those which have since been in the World be not a meer product of the invention and power of men 1. For many Ages such things alone were proposed unto the world and imposed on it for the only Church as were from Hell rather than from Heaven at least from Men and those none of the best For all men in these Western parts of the world were obliged to believe and profess on the penalties of Eternal and Temporal Destruction that the Pope of Rome and those depending on him were the only Church in the World If this should be granted as it was almost universally in some Ages and in this is earnestly contended for there would be a thousand evidences to prove that the institution of Churches is not from Heaven but from Men. Whether the inventions of men in the mystery of iniquity be to be received again or no men of secular Wisdom and Interest may do well to consider but he must be blind and mad and accursed in his mind and understanding who can think of receiving it as from
not or is neglected It is therefore fond to suppose that our Saviour should prescribe this Rule for that season wherein there was no need of it and not for those times wherein the Church could not subsist in order without it 3ly The Church here directed unto is a Christian Church For 1. whereas it hath been proved it concerned the times to come afterwards there was in those times nothing that could pretend unto the name of the Church but a Christian Church only The Jewish Synagogues had an utter end put unto them so as that an Address unto any of them in this case was not only useless but unlawful And as unto Magistrates or Arbitrators to have them called the Church and that in such a sense as that after the Interposition of their Authority or Advice a man should be freed from the discharge of all Christian Duties such as are mutually required among the Disciples of Christ towards his Brother is a fond Imagination For 2 It is such a Church as can exercise Authority in the Name of Christ over his Disciples and such as in Conscience they should be bound to submit themselves unto For the Reason given of the Contempt of the Voice Judgment and Sentence of the Church in case of offence is their Power of spiritual binding and looâ—ing which is comitted by Christ thereunto and so he adds immediatley ver 18. Whatever ye shall bind on Earth shall be bound in Heaven and whatsoever ye shall loose in heaven shall be loosed on earth is the Priviledge of a Christian Church only 4thly It is a visible particular Congregation alone that is intended For 1. As unto the Church in other acceptations of that name either for the Catholicâ— invisible Church or for the whole Body of professed Believers thoroughout the world it is utterly impossible that this Dâ—ty should be observed towards it as is manifest unto all 2. We have proved that the first and most proper signification of the word is of a single congregation assembling together for its Duties and Enjoyments Where ever therefore the Church in general is mentioned without the Addition of any thing or circumstance that may lead unto another signification it must be interpreted of such a Particular Church or Congregation 3. The Persons intended offending and offended must belong unto the same society unto whom the Address is to be made or else the one party may justly decline the Judicatory applyed unto and so frustrate the Process And it must be such a Church as unto whom they are known in their Circumstances without which it is impossible that a right judgment in sundry cases can be made in point of Offence 4 It is a Church of an easie Address Go tell the Church which supposeth that free and immediate aâ—cess which all the Members of a Church have unto that whole Church whereof they are members Wherefore 5 It is said 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 tell the Church not a Church but the Church namely whereunto thou and thy Brother do belong 6 One end of this Direction is that the offending and the offended parties may continue together in the Communion of the same Church in Love without Dissimulation which thing belongs unto a particular Congregation 7 The meaning is not tell the Diocesan Bishop for whatever Church he may have under his Rule yet is not he himself a Church Nor is it 8 the Chancellours Court that our Saviour intended Be it what it will it is a disparagement unto all Churches to have that name applied thereunto Nor Lastly Is it a Presbytery or Association of the Elders of many particular Congregations that is intended For the Power claimed in such associated Presbyteries is with respect unto what is already in or before particular Congregations which they have not either Wisdom or Authority as is supposed finally to order and determine But this supposeth that the Address in the first place be made unto a particular Congregation which therefore is firstly and properly here intended All things are plain familiar and exposed to the common Understandings of all Believers whose minds are any way exercised about these things as indeed are all things that belong unto the Discipline of Christ. Arguments pretendedly deep and learned really obscure and perplexed with logical Notions and distinctions applied unto things thus plain and evident in themselves do serve only to involve and darken the Truth It is plain in the place 1 That there was a Church-State for Christians then designed by Christ which afterwards he would institute and settle 2 That all true Disciples were to join and unite themselves in some such Church as might be helpful unto their Love Order Peace and Edification 3 That among the members of these Churches Offences would or might arise which in themselves tend unto pernicious Events 4 That if these Offences could not be cured and taken away so as that Love without Dissimulation might be continued among all the Members of the Churches an Account of them at last was to be given unto that Church or Society whereunto the Parties concerned do belong as Members of it 5 That this Church should hear determine and give Judgment with advice in the cases so brought unto it for the taking away and removal of all Offences 6 That this Determination of the Church is to be rested in on the Penalty of a Deprivation of all the Priviledges of the Church 7 That these things are the Institution and Appointment of Christ himself whose Authority in them all is to be submitted unto and which alone can cast one that is a Professed Christian into the condition of an Heathen or a Publican These things in the Notion and Practice of them are plain easy and exposed to the Understanding of the meanest of the Disciples of Christ as it is meet that all things should be wherein their daily Practice is concerned But it is not easily to be expressed into what horrible Perplexities and Confusions they have been wrested in the Church of Rome nor how those who depart from the plain obvious sense of the words and love not the Practice they direct unto do lead themselves and others into ways and paths that have neither use nor end From the corrupt abuse of the holy Institution of our Lord Jesus Christ here intended so many Powers Faculties Courts Jurisdictions legal Processes with Litigious Vexatious oppressive Courses of Actions and Trials whose very names are uncouth horrid foreign unto Religion and unintelligible without Cunning in an artâ—ficial barbarous Science of the Canon Law have proceeded as are enough to fill a sober rational man with astonishment how it could ever enter into the minds of men to suppose that they can possibly have any Relation unto this Divine Institution Those who are not utterly blinded with Interest and Prejudice wholly ignorant of the Gospel and the mind of Christ therein as also Strangers from the Practice of the Duties which it requires will hardly
which is become a principal Article of Faith in the Roman Church There was a Reformation attempted and attained in some measure by some Nations or Churches in the last Ages from the Corruption and Impositions of the Church of Rome However none of them ever pretended that it was compleat or perfect according to the Pattern of the Scripture as unto the Institution and Discipline of the Churches no nor yet to the Example of the Primitive Church of after Ages as is acknowledged by the Church of England in the beginning of the Commination against Sinners But suppose it to be compleat to conclude that because an outward Rule of it was established so long as that outward Rule is observed there can be no need of Reformation is a way to lead Churches into a Presumptuous Security unto their Ruine For whereas Men being secured in their Interests by that Rule are prejudiced against any Progress in Reformation beyond what they have attained which that it should be a Duty is contrary unto the whole nature of Christian Religion which is the conduct of a Spiritual Life in the growth and encrease of Light and a suitable Obedience so they are apt to think that whilst they adhere unto that Rule they can stand in no need of Reformation which is but a new name for trouble and Sedition though it be the Foundation on which they stand But generally Churches think that others stand in need of Reformation but they need none themselves If they would but give them leave to Reform themselves who judge that it is needful for them without the least Prejudice unto their Church Profession or secular Interest it is all that is desired of them 2. Where Churches do so stand in need of Reformation and will not Reform themselves being warned of their Duty the Lord Christ threatens to leave them and assuredly will do so in the time that he hath limited unto his Patience This is the Subject of five of his Epistles or Messages unto the Churches of Asia Rev. chap. 2 3. And where the Lord Christ doth on any Cause or Provocation withdraw his Presence in any kind or degree from any Church it is the Duty of any of the Members of that Church to remove from themselves the Guilt of that Provocation though it cannot be done without a Separation from that Church It it safer leaving of any Church whatever then of Jesus Christ. I suppose most men think that if they had a Warning from Christ charging their defection and calling for Reformation as those Churches of Asia had they would Repent and Reform themselves But whereas it doth not appear that some of them did so whereon they were not long after deserted and destroyed it is like that there are others who would follow their steps though one should rise from the dead to warn them of their danger But this Instruction that Churches who lose their first Faith Love and Works who are negligent in Discipline and tolerate offensive Evils in Doctrines and Manners among them who are Luke-warm as unto Zeal and dead for the greatest Part of their Members as unto the Life of Holiness are disapproved by Christ and in danger of being utterly deserted by him is given unto all Churches no less divinely then if they had an immediate Message from Heaven about these things Those therefore who being under the Guilt of them and do not reform themselves cannot claim the Necessity of a continuance in their Communion from any Disciples of Christ as we shall see afterwards 3. Reformation respects either Doctrine and Worship or Obedience becoming the Gospel The Debates about such a Reformation as concerns the retaining or removing of certain Ceremonies we concern not ourselves in at present Nor shall we in this Place insist on what concerns Doctrine and Worship which may afterwards be spoken unto But we shall confine our selves here unto the consideration of Gospel Obedience only And we say That the Church of England in the Generality of its Parochial Assemblies and in itself stands in need of Reformation by reason of the woful degeneracy of the Generality of its Members that is the Inhabitants of the Land from the Rule of the Gospel and Commands of Christ as unto Spiritual Light Faith Love Holiness Charity and abounding in the fruits of Righteousness unto the Praise of God by Jesus Christ. These things are the immediate ends of Church Societies the principal means whereby God is glorified in the World Where they are neglected where they are not attained where they are not duely improved by the Generality of the Members of any Church that Church I think stands in need of Reformation This Assertion may seem somewhat importune and severe But when the sins of a Church or Nation are come to that height in all Ranks Sorts and Degrees of Men that all Persons of Sobriety do fear daily that desolating Judgements from God will break in upon us it cannot be unseasonable to make mention of them when it is done with no other design but only to shew the Necessity of Reformation or how necessary it is for some if all will not comply therewith For if a City be on fire it is surely lawful for any of the Citizens to save and preserve if they can their own houses though the Mayor and Aldermen should neglect the Preservation of the whole City in General It might be easily demonstrated what great numbers amongst us 1. Who have imbibed Atheistical Opinions and either vent them or speak presumptuously according unto their Influence and Tendency every day 2. Who are prophane Scoffers at all true Christian Piety and the due expressions of the Power of Godliness an Evil not confined unto the Laity such things being uttered and published by them as should be astonishable unto all that know the Fear of the Lord and his Terror 3. Who are profoundly Ignorant of the Mysteries of the Gospel or those Doctrines of Christian Religion whose knowledge is of the highest importance and necessity 4. Who are openly flagitious in their Lives whence all sorts of gross Immoralities do fill the Land from one end unto the other 5. Who live in a constant neglect of all more private holy Duties whether in their Families or in Personal Retirements 6. Who are evidently under the Power of Pride Vanity Covetousness Profaneness of Speech in cursed Oathes and Swearing 7. Who instruct the worst of men unto an Approbation of themselves in such ways as these by petulant Scoffing at the very name of the Spirit and Grace of Christ at all Expectation of his Spiritual Aids and Assistances at all fervency in religious Duties or other Acts of an holy Converse These and such like things as these do sufficiently Evidence the Necessity of Reformation For where they are continued the Use and End of Church Societies is impaired or lost And it is in vain to pretend that this is the old Plea of them who â—aused Schismes in the
impartial Consideration he chargeth on us with great Solemnity as we Love our own Souls Now although that passage in that great and Holy Person be not new unto me having not only read it many a time in his book but frequently met with it urged by Papists against all Protestants Yet upon the Drs. intimation I have given it again the Consideration required The Words as they Lye in the Author are to this purpose We shall also judge them who make Schismes being vain qui sunt immanes or inanes not having the Love of God rather considering their own Profit than the Vnity of the Church who for small or any causes rend and divide the Glorious body of Christ and as much as in them lyes destroy it speaking Peace but designing War straining at a Gnat and swallowing a Camel For there can be no rebuke of things by them to equal the mischief of Schisme Lib. 4. cap. 62. I know not why he should give us such a severe Charge for the impartial Consideration of these words that as we love our souls we should impartially and without prejudice consider them We hope that out of Love to the Truth the Glory of Christ and Care of our own Souls we do so Consider and have long since so considered whatever belongs unto the Cause wherein we ingaged and the Oppositions that are made unto it Nor will we be offended with any that shall yet Call on us to persist and proceed in the same way But why such a Charge should be laid on us with respect unto these words of Irenaeus I know not For although we greatly value the Words and Judgment of that Holy Person that great Defender of the Mystery and Truth of the Gospel and of the Liberty of the Churches from unwarrantable impositions yet it is the Word of Christ and his Apostles alone whereby we must be regulated and determined in these things if we Love our own souls Besides What are we Concern'd in them is every Separation from a Church a Schisme Our Author shews the contrary immediately Is refraining Communion in a Church state not of Divine Institution and in things not prescribed by the Lord Christ in the Worship of God holding Communion in Faith and Love with all the true Churches of Christ in the World a damnable Schisme or any Schisme at all hath the Reverend Author in his whole Book once attempted to prove it to be so though this be the whole of the matter in difference between us is our Forbearance of Communion in Parochial Assemblies upon the Reasons before pleaded especially that of humane impositions of the same Nature with the Schisme from the whole Catholick Church without pretence of any such Impositions Doth he judge us to be such as have no Love unto God such as prefer our own profit before the Unity of the Church I heartily wish and pray that he may never have a share in that profit and advantage which we have made unto our selves by our principles and practise Poverty Distress Ruine to our Families Dangers Imprisonments Revilings with Contemptuous reproaches Comprize the profit we have made unto our selves Is our refraining Communion in some outward Order Modes and Rites of Mens institution our want of conscientious submission unto the Courts of Chancellours Commissaries Officials c. a rending and destroying of the glorious Body of Christ is it Cemented United and Compacted or fitly framed together by these things They formerly pretended to be his Coat and must they now be esteemed to be his glorious Body when they no way belong unto the one or the other Is the Application of these things unto us an effect of that Love Charity and Forbearance which are the only preventive means of Schisme and whereof if men are void it is all one upon the matter whether they are Schismaticks or no for they will be so when it is for their Advantage Wherefore we are not concerned in these things Let whosoever will declare and vehemently assert us to be guilty of Schisme which they cannot prove we can cheerfully subscribe unto these Words of Irenaeus It may not be impertinent on this occasion to desire of some others that as they Love their own Souls and have compassion for the Souls of other men they would seriously consider what state and Condition things are come unto in the Church of England how much Ignorance Profaneness Sensuality do spread themselves over the Nation what Neglect of the most important Duties of the Gospel Yea what scoffing at the power of Religion doth abound amongst us What an utter decay and loss there is of all the primitive Discipline of the Church what Multitudes are in the way of Eternal Ruin for want of due Instruction and Example from them who should lead them How great a necessity there is of an universal Reformation and how securely Negligent of it all sorts of Persons are What have been the pernicious Effects of imposing things unnecessary and unscriptural on the Consciences and Practises of men in the Worship of God whereby the Church hath been deprived of the labour of so many faithful Ministers who might have at least assisted in preventing that Decay of Religion which every day encreaseth among us How easie a thing it were for them to restore Evangelical Peace and Vnity amongst all Protestants without the loss of their Ministry without the diminution of their Dignity without deprivation of any part of their Revenues without the Neglect of any Duty without doing any thing against their light and Consciences with respect unto any Divine Obligation and thereon set themselves seriously to endeavour the Remedy of these and other Evils of the like nature under a sense of that great Account which they must shortly give before the Judgement seat of Jesus Christ. He proceeds to Consider the Cases wherein the Scripture allows of Separation which he affirms to be three The First is in Case of Idolatrous Worship This none can Question they do not see from whom yet we all separate as from Idolaters The second is in Case of false Dostrine being imposed instead of true which he confirms with sundry Instances But there is a little Difficulty in this Case for 1. It is uncertain when a Doctrine may be said to be imposed Is it when it is taught and preach'd by the Guides and Governours of the Church or any of them without controul if so then is such preaching a sufficient cause of Separation and will justifie them who do at present separate from any Church whose Ministers preach false Doctrine How false Doctrine can be otherwise imposed I know not unless it be by exacting an express Confession of it as Truth 2. What false Doctrine it is which is of this Importance as to justifie Separation is not easily determinable 3. If the Guides and Governours of the Church do teach this false Doctrine who shall judge of it and determine it so to be and that ultimately so as
AN ENQUIRY Into the Original Nature Institution Power Order and Communion of Evangèlical CHURCHES The First Part. With AN ANSWER To the Discourse of the Unreasonableness of SEPARATION Written by Dr. Edward Stillingfleet Dean of Pauls And in Defence of the Vindication of Non-conformists from the Guilt of SCHISME By JOHN OWEN D. D. Stand ye in the ways and see and ask for the old paths where is the Good way and walk therein and ye shall find rest for your Souls JER 6.16 LONDON Printed by J. Richardson for Nath. Ponder at the Peacock in the Poultrey And Sam. Lee at the Feathers in Lumbardstreet 1681. TO THE READER 〈…〉 omitted the Consiâ—â—ration 〈…〉 of Dr. Stillingâ—â—â—â—◠〈…〉 the 〈…〉 the 〈◊〉 of 〈…〉 by Non 〈…〉 passed it by 〈◊〉 the 〈…〉 I supposed 〈…〉 assign it 〈◊〉 the provocation which he 〈…〉 received from those who answered his Sermon or 〈◊〉 and so have â—â—ssed it by among such other excursions as Diâ—â—â—es are incident unto in their Controversal Writings For that no Countenance was given unto it either from Truth or any useful End as unto the present state of 〈…〉 the 〈…〉 the Times or rather 〈…〉 rest of some then any just rational projections For what other success this Book hath had I know not nor am solicitous Certain it is that many of the same mind and perswasion with himself have been encouraged and emboldened by it Confidently to report tâ—â—â—â—â—e Non-Conformists are great promoters 〈…〉 Papal â—â—terestâ— ye◠〈…〉 to facilitate its Introduâ—tâ—â—◠〈…〉 evident in the 〈…〉 Topiâ—â—◠〈…〉 importâ—â—◠〈…〉 need 〈…〉 were 〈…〉 from amongst 〈…〉 it came in as 〈…〉 notâ—â—â—â— will 〈…〉 influenced â—y 〈…〉 â—â—vantages to deâ—â—â—◠〈…〉 â—â—cessary that such an 〈…〉 true Reasonâ—â—nd Means of the advance of Popery in this Naâ—â—on as shall give them occasion to consider themselves and their own ways For we are to look for the Causes of such Effects in things and means that are suited and fitted to be productive of them so as that they cannot but follow on their being and operation and not in Cold Stories Surmizes and far fetch'd or feigned Inferences And if we do reckon that the real advancement of Religion depends onely on the secular advancement of some that do profess it we may be mistaken in our measures as others have been before us But at present the Insinuations of that Preface do seem to prevail much with those of the same Party with its Author who want nothing at any time but the Countenance of such a Pen and Story to vent their ill will against Non-Conformists Report say they and we will Report it But also as he said Mendacium mendacio tegendum ne perpluat First evil Inventions alway tend unto and stand in need of new Additions to render them useful unto their End without which they quickly evaporate Wherefore least the Insinuations of this worthy Person should not be sufficiently subservient unto the Uniting of all Protestants in one common Interest against Popery which was the original Design of the Drs. Sermon some have added unto it that which is Homogeneal as unto Truth and so easily mixing with the other Discourse that the Non-Conformists some of them at least do receive or have received Money from the Papists to act their Affairs and promote their Interest And although this be such a putid Calumny such a malicious falshood such a frontless Lye as Impudence it self would blush at being made an instrument to vent it and withal extreamly ridiculous Yet because it seems useful unto the Good End of Uniting Protestants and Opposing Popery it hath not onely been reported by sundry of the Clergy but embraced and divulged also by some of their weak and credulous Followers who seem to believe that other mens Advantage is their Religion But when the utmost bounds of Modesty are passed nothing but an outrage in Lying and Calumny out of hopes that something will stick at last can give Countenance to men in such false Accusations And those by whom they are first whispered probably understand better than the Non-formists what Influence Money or the things which they know how to turn into it hath into their Profession and actings in Religion It seems to me that some such men are afraid lest the present opposition unto Popery should issue in such an establishment of the Protestant Religion as that hereafter it should not be in the disposal of any nor in their power to make a bargain of it either for their Advantage or in their Necessity For unless we should suppose such a defect in common Prudence as is not chargeable on men of Understanding in other affairs it is hard to judge that these things can proceed from any other ground but a design to encrease distrusts and Jealousies amongst Protestants to heighten their Differences to exasperate and provoke them to Animosities to weaken the hands of each Party by a disbelief of the Sincerity of each other in the same common Cause whence whether it be designed or no it will follow that we shall be all made a prey unto our restless Adversaries For what else but a strong inclination thereto can give the least Credit or Reputation to such vile insinuations false Surmizes and Fables I do not say in the Preface but in the Reports that have been occasioned thereby wherein Folly and Malice Rival one another against that plain open uncontroulable evidence which the Non-conformists alwayes gave and yet continue to give of their faithful cordial adherence unto the Protestant Religion and interest in the Nation And what now if in way of Retaliation a charge should be laid and mannaged against those of the Episcopal way that they should contribute their assistance whether knowingly or being deluded it is all one to the Introduction of Popery would not all things be cast into an admirable posture amongst us for an opposition thereunto But let none mistake nor deceive themselves neither the past Sufferings of the Non-conformists nor their present hopes of Liberty nor the reproaches cast upon them shall shake them in their Resolutions for a Conjunction with all sincere Protestants in the preservation of their Religion and opposition unto all Popish Designs whatever And to speak with Modesty enough as they have hitherto in all Instances of Zeal and Duty for the preservation of the Protestant Religion been as ready and forward as any other sort of men so whatever may befall them however they may be traduced or falsly accused they do and will continue in giving the highest security that Conscience Profession Principles Interest and Actions can give of their stability in the same Cause Onely they desire to be excused if they make not use of this notable Engine for opposing of Popery namely the stirring up at this present time of Jealousies Fears and Animosities amongst Protestants which others judge serviceable unto that End But that which animates all these insinuations charges and Reports is our Thankful acceptance of
He hath not left this great concernment of his Glory unto the Wills of men or any Order they shall think meet to appoint Lastly As a means of it it depends on three things in Believers themselves 1 A due sense of their Duty to be found in Obedience unto all the Commands of Christ. Hereby they find themselves indispensibly obliged unto all those things which are necessary unto the continuation of this State and that all Believers should absolutely at any time live in a total neglect of their Duty though they may greatly mistake in the manner of its performance is not to be supposed 2 The Instinct of the new Creature and those in whom it is so associate themselves in holy Communion for the joynt and mutual exercise of those Graces of the Spirit which are the same as unto the Essence of them in them all The Laws of Christ in and unto his Church as unto all outward Obedience are suited unto those inward Principles and Inclinations which by his Spirit and Grace he hath implanted in the Hearts of them that believe Hence his Yoke is easy and his Commandments are not grievous And therefore none of his true Disciples since he had a Church upon the Earth did or could satisfy themselves in their own Faith and Obedience singularly and personally but would venture their lives and all that was dear unto them for Communion with others and the associating themselves with them of the same Spirit and way for the observance of the Commands of Christ. The Martyrs of the Primitive Churches of old lost more of their Blood and Lives for their Meetings and Assemblies than for personal Profession of the Faith and so also have others done under the Roman Apostacy It is an usual Plea among them who ingage in the Persecution or Punishment of such as differ from them that if they please they may keep their Opinions their Consciences and Faith unto themselves without Meetings for Communion or publick Worship And herein they suppose they deal friendly and gently with them And this is our present Case It is true indeed as Tertullian observed of old that men in these things have no Power over us but what they have from our own Wills we willingly choose to be and to continue what they take advantage to give us trouble for And it is naturally in our Power to free our selves from them and their Laws every day But we like it not we cannot purchase outward Peace and Quietness at any such rate But as was said the inward Instinct of Believers from the same Principles of Faith Love and all the Graces of the Spirit in them all doth efficaciously lead and incline them unto their joynt exercise in Societies unto the Glory of Christ and their own Edification or encrease of the same Graces in them When this appears to be under the Guidance of the Commands of Christ as unto the ways of Communion lead unto and to consist in a compliance therewithal they find themselves under an indispensible Obligation unto it Nor hath the Lord Christ left them liberty to make a Composition for their outward Peace and to purchase Quietness with foregoing any part of their Duty herein This therefore I say is a Means and Cause on the part of Believers themselves of the continuation of this Church-State For this Instinct of Believers leading them unto Communion which is an Article of our Faith in conjunction with the Law and Commands of Christ giving direction how and in what ways it is to be attained and exercised binds and obliges them unto the continuation of this State and the decay of this inward Principle in them that profess Christian Religion hath been the great and almost only ground of its neglect 3. The open Evidence there is that sundry Duties required of us in the Gospel can never be performed in a due manner but where Believers are brought into this State which that they should enter into is therefore in the first place required of them what these Duties are will afterwards appear On these sure Grounds is founded the Continuation of the Gospel Church-State under ordinary Officers after the Decease of the Apostles and so far secured as that nothing needs be added unto them for that end Do but suppose that the Lord Christ yet liveth in Heaven in the Discharge of his Mediatory Office that he hath given his Word for a perpetual Law unto all his Disciples and a Charter to convey Spiritual Priviledges unto them that he abides to Communicate Gifts for the Ministry unto men and that there are any Believers in the World who know it to be their Duty to yield Obedience unto all the Commands of Christ. and have any internal Principle enclining them to that which they profess to believe as a fundamental Article of their Faith namely the Communion of Saints and no man is desired to prove the certainty and necessity of the continuance of this State But there are some who maintain that the Continuation and Preservation of this Church State depends solely on a successive Ordination of Church Officers from the Apostles and so down throughout all Ages unto the end of the World For this they say is the only means of conveying Church Power from one time to another so as that if it fail all Church-State Order and Power must fall never in this World to be recovered There is they say a Flux of Power through the hands of the Ordainers unto the Ordained by vertue of their outward Ordination whereon the Being of the Church doth depend Howbeit those who use this Plea are not at all agreed about those things which are essential in and unto this successive Ordination Some think that the Lord Christ committed the Keys of the Kingdom of Heaven unto Peter only and he to the Bishop of Rome alone from whose Person therefore all their Ordination must be derived Some think and those on various Grounds that it is committed unto all and only Diocesan Bishops whose Being and Beginning are very uncertain Others require no more unto it but that Presbyters be ordained by Presbyters who were rejected in their Plea by both the former sorts and other differences almost innumerable among them who are thus minded might be reckoned up But whereas this whole Argument about Personal successive Ordination hath been fully handled and the Pretences of it disproved by the chiefest Protâ—stant Writers against the Papists and because I design not an Opposition unto what others think and do but the Declaration and Confirmation of the Truth in what we have proposed to insist upon I shall very briefly discover the falseness of this Pretence and pass on unto what is principally intended in this Discourse 1. The Church is before all its ordinary Officers and therefore its continuation cannot depend on their successive Ordination It is so as essentially considered though its being Organical is Simultaneous with their Ordination Extraordinary Officers were before the
Obedience unto the Commands of Christ in its Integrity For the First the Scripture is full of Predictions all confirmed in the Event that after the days of the Apostles there should be various Attempts to wrest corrupt and pervert the Doctrine of the Gospel and to bring in pernitious Errors and Heresies To prevent or reprove and remove them is no small Part and Duty of the Ministerial Office in the Dispensation of the Word But whereas those who taught such perverse things did for the most part arise at first in the Churches themselves Act. 20.30 2 Pet. 2.1 1 John 2.19 as the Preaching of the Word was appointed for the rebuke of the Doctrines themselves so this Discipline was ordained in the Church with respect unto the Persons of them by whom they were taught Rev. 2.2.14 20. 3 Joh. 8.9 Gal. 5.12 And so also it was with respect unto Schisms and Divisions that might fall out in the Church The way of suppressing things of this Nature by external force by the Sword of Magistrates in Prisons Fines Banishments and Death was not then thought of nor directed unto by the Lord Jesus Christ but is highly dishonourable unto him as though the ways of his own appointment were not sufficient for the Preservation of his own Truth but that his Disciples must betake themselves unto the secular Powers of this World who for the most part are wicked Prophane and ignorant of the Truth for that end And hereunto belongeth the Preservation of his Commands in the Integrity of Obedience For he appointed that hereby care should be taken of the Ways Walkings and Conversation of his Disciples that in all things it should be such as became the Gospel Hence the exercise of this Discipline he ordaâ—ned to consist in Exhortations Admonitions Reproofs of any that shouâ—d offend in things Moral or of his especial Institutâ—on with the total Rejection of them were obstinate in their Offences as we shall see afterwards 2. The second End of it was to preserve Love entire among his Disciples This was that which he gave in especial charge unto all that should believe in his Name taking the Command of it to be his own in a peculiar manner and declaring our Observance of it to be the principal Pledge and Evidence of our being his Disciples For although mutual Love be an old Commandment belonging both unto the Moral Law and sundry Injunction under the Old Testament yet the Degrees and Measure of it the Ways and Duties of its exercise the Motives unto it and Reasons for it were wholly his own whereby it becomes a new Commandment also For the preservation and continuance of this Love which he lays so great weight upon was this Discipline appointed which it is several ways effectual towards As 1 In the Prevention or Removal of Offences that might arise among Believers to the impeachment of it Matth. 18.15 16 17 2 In that Watch over each other with mutual Exhortations and Admonitions without which this Love let men pretend what they please will not be preserved That which keepeth either Life or Soul in Christian Love consists in the exercise of those Graces mutually and the Discharge of those Duties whereby they may be Partakers of the fruits of Love in one another And for the most part those who pretend highly unto the Preservation of Love by their coming to the same Church who dwell in the same Parish have not so much as the carcase nay not a shadow of it In the Discipline of the Lord Christ it is appointed that this Love so strictly by him enjoyned unto us so expressive of his own Wisdom and Love should be preserved continued and encreased by the due and constant Discharge of the Duties of mutual Exhortation Admonition Prayer and watchful care over one another Rom. 15.14 1 Thes. 5 11 12. 2 Thes. 3.15 Heb. 3.12 13. Ch. 12.15 16. 3. A third End of it is that it might be a due Representation of his own Love Care Tenderness Patience Meekness in the acting of his Authority in the Church Where this is not observed and designed in the exercise of Church Discipline I will not say it is Antichristian but will say it is highly injurious and dishonourable unto him For all Church Power is in him and derived from him nor is there any thing of that nature which belongs unto it but it must be acted in his Name and esteemed both for the manner and matter of it to be his Act and Deed. For men therefore to pretend unto the exercise of this Discipline in a worldly frame of Spirit with Pride and Passion by tricks of Laws and Canons in Courts Forein to the Churches themselves which are pretended to be under this Discipline it is a woful and scandalous Representation of Christ his Wisdom Care and Love towards his Church But as for his Discipline he hath ordained that it shall be exercised in and with Meekness Patience Gentleness evidence of Zeal for the good and compassion of the Souls of men with Gravity and Authority so as that therein all the holy Affections of his mind towards his Church or any in it in their mistakes failings and miscarriages may be duly represented as well as his Authority acted among them Isa. 40.11 2 Cor. 10.1 Gal. 5.22.23 1 Thes. 2.7 2 Tim. 2.24 25 26. Jam. 3.17 1 Cor. 13. 4. It is in part appointed to be an Evidence and Pledge of the future Judgment wherein the whole Church shall be judged before the Throne of Christ Jesus For in the Exercise of this Discipline Christ is on his own Judgment Seat in the Church nor may any man pronounce any Sentence but what he believeth that Christ himself would pronounce were he visibly present and what is according to his mind as declared in his Word Hence Tertullian calls the Sentence of Excommunication in the Church futuri judicii praejudicium A Representation of the future Judgment 4. In all that Degeneracy which the Christian professing Church hath fallen into in Faith Worship and Manners there is no Instance can exceed the corruption of this Divine Institution For that which was the Honour of Christ and the Gospel and an effectual means to represent him in the Glory of his Wisdom and Love and for the Exercise of all Graces in the Church unto the blessed Ends now declared was turned into a Domination Earthly and Secular Exercised In a Prophane Litigious Unintelligible Process according unto the Arts Ways and Terms of the worst of Law Courts by Persons for the most part remote from any just Pretence of the least Interest in Church Power on causes and for ends forein unto the Discipline of the Gospel by a Tyranny over the Consciences and over the Persons of the Disciples of Christ unto the Intolerable scandal of the Gospel and Rule of Christ in his Church as is evident in the State and Rule of the Church of Rome As these are the general Ends of the Institution