Selected quad for the lemma: church_n

Word A Word B Word C Word D Occurrence Frequency Band MI MI Band Prominent
church_n answer_v argument_n prove_v 3,101 5 5.5305 4 false
View all documents for the selected quad

Text snippets containing the quad

ID Title Author Corrected Date of Publication (TCP Date of Publication) STC Words Pages
A36119 The Discovery of a great plot intended against the city of London to have robbed and murthered the citizens and inhabitants, and the names of the actors ; also the victory at Arundell Castle obtained by Sir William Waller ... together with a full satisfaction concerning the three queries about the great controversie and different opinions of the observing of holy dayes. 1644 (1644) Wing D1634; ESTC R29735 4,234 8

There is 1 snippet containing the selected quad. | View lemmatised text

THE DISCOVERY OF A GREAT PLOT INTENDED Against the City of LONDON to have robbed and murthered the Citizens and Inhabitants And the Names of the Actors ALSO The victory at Arundell Castle obtained by Sir WILLIAM WALLER And the taking of 2. Ladies 4. Collonels 3. Sergeant Maiors 12. Lieut. Collonels and Captains 90. New Captains for the Commission of Array 100. Gentlemen 50. Gentlewomen 4000. pound in money 25. Barrels of Gunpowder 1000. Common souldiers with other rich commodities TOGETHER WITH A Full Satisfaction concerning the three Queries about the great Controversie and different Opinions of the Observing of Holy dayes Published according to Order Ian 8. London Printed for AND COE 1644. Full Satisfaction concerning the three Quaeries about the great Controversie and different opinions of the observing of Holy dayes 1. Quer. VVhether the Institution of other Holy dayes besides the Sabboth be of Divine Right Answ THat which is of divine Right is recorded in holy Scripture to be expresly commanded by God or warrantably practised by his people But so are none of our Holy dayes Ergo not of Divine Right 2. Quer. VVhether there by any Precept or example Apostolicall to warrant or condemne the celebrating of any such dayes or neither Answ This Quere is needlesse but to give further satisfaction In Scripture there is no such precept but the superstitious observation thereof is so farre forbidden that Paul would have us so to carry our selves herein that no man may condemn us for the superstitious respect of an Holy day Coloss 2.16 But the third is the main Querie intended 3. Quer. VVhether the Church and Civill Magistrate have Authority to iustitute any such yeerly Festivals Answ We are here to understand who is meant by the Church and Civill Magistrates and that first negatively not such as the Apostles in the primitive Church for they were spoken of in the former queries but affirmatively the Church now remaining and the Governours and Officers thereof To which we answer That in respect of civill obedience they may impose lawfull commands on certain dayes but have no power to consecrate a day or make it holy The Sillogisme is this If we finde that the Church and Civill Magistrate or either have authority in godly policy and civill respects to appoint the solemnity of yearely Festivall dayes the Holy dayes by them appointed may be observed but they have authority if they see it expedient Ergo they may be observed But this argument of theirs proves nothing to impose a necessity or that the conscience is bound to observe such dayes as more holy then others no more then if one should say We are bound in conscience to spend all we have in house-keeping this Christmas For if the Ministers and Churchwardens have authority to beg our charity for the poor we may give them all we have But they have such authority therefore in conscience we must give away all this proves nothing but to search the particulars more exactly 1. The Major they prove thus That the Church or Civill Magistrate have Authority to appoint and institute yearly Festivals in policy and civill respects is warrantable by the example of Purim Esther the 9. Mordecheus and Esther appointed a new Festivall day not instituted of God and binde every one to the observing thereof that none should fail to observe it Verse 27. From this Bellarmine concludes That men are bound in conscience to observe Festivall dayes Bellar. cap. 10. So also our Doway Men. pag. 1050. Answ 1. Though we do not utterly reject Festivall dayes yet we acknowledge none necessary saith Doctor VVillet more then are of the Holy Ghosts appointing in the Scripture 2. We deny that the constitutions of the Church do binde christians in respect of the dayes themselves in conscience to keep them otherwise then they may give offence by their contempt and disobedience to the wholsome decrees of the Church for it selfe in its owne nature is indifferent nothing bindeth absolutely in conscience but that which is warranted by did Word Wherefore keeping of Holy dayes being not enjoyned but left indifferent in the Word bindeth no otherwise then as we have said 3. The example of Esther did binde the observer in conscience not in regard of the day but of the promise which was made for themselves and their seed to keep it but first their consent was required and therfore there was no feast instituted for that so miraculous a passage over Jordan none for the walles of the fall of Jerico nor for the slaughter of the Midianites in the time of Gideon nor for that other no lesse admirable of the Ammonites and other people confederate in the dayes of Jehoshophat neyther for that of the Assyrians when the Angell of God destroyed the whole hoast And who can reckon up those so many the like miraculous deliverances for remembrance whereof notwithstanding there were no solemn dayes dedicated Ser. 25. on Esther 9.4 Mordecheus besides his ordinary authority as a chiefe Governour had also some Propheticall directions to institute this day of rejoycing being held to have written also that Book of Esther which cannot now be drawn to an ordinary president 5. Lastly it seemeth rather to have been appointed as a Festivall day of rejoycing and thankesgiving for the joyfull remembrance of that deliverance then as a new Holy day to be kept with that stricktnes as the Holy dayes appointed by the Law for they kept it with joy and feasting and sending presents one to another v. 19 Like as now in the Church of England the 5. of Novemb. is appointed by Act of Parliament to be celebrated not as a new holy day with Injunctions of abstinence from worke the whole day but only to assemble together in the Congregation to give God thanks for so great a deliverance 2. They bring in the example of the dedication of the Temple to which I answer Answ 1. There was no yearly memory thereof kept nor instituted neyther for the restitution of the Temple by EZekiah after the prophanation thereof by Ahaz and Urias nor by Iosias after the same had been most horribly polluted by Manasses and Amon. Nor by Zerobbabel Esdras or Nehemiah after it was reedified when it had been utterly destroyed by the Chaldees 2. These were shadowes of the things to come but the body is in Christ The first Argument you see is nothing worth The minor they prove thus If the Church or Magistrate may celebrate Festivalls for temporall mercies they may doe it for spirituall mercies and appoint dayes for the one as well as for the other Answer The difference is not in the cause but in the thing not about the matter for which the dayes are celebrated but how farre the celebration it selfe is superstitious and what is binding and therefore we shall proceed to the ensuing considerations 1. Whether an holinesse may be ascribed to these dayes or whether they be only indifferent and meerely civill and politic●ll But assuredly