light to deceiue my soule withall and so I confessed them as ordinarie temptations against faith till at length with a more powerfull light it pleased the true Sonne of iustice and God of glorie to enlighten my vnderstanding in such sort that all the clouds of error and endarkened affections were dispersed like mist before the Sunne what before I held to be hereticall I approued to be most Catholike what before was falsehood was now truth what before was darknesse was now light I found my selfe suddainely in my meditations vpon the grounds of true faith and beleefe like S. Paul enuironed not with a corporall but with a spirituall and most comfortable light from heauen placing my vnderstanding in the paradise of truth and all her delights struck downe to the ground in the humble acknowledgement of mine vnworthinesse and terrified with a voice from heauen not sounding in the eares of my bodie by their corporall Organs but sweetly making a most delightfull harmonie in my soule mollifying the obdurate crust of my heart and forcing me to say Act. 9. vers 6. Domine quid me vis facere O Lord what wilt thou haue me to doe with perfect true conformitie of all my thoughts actions and endeauors answerable to his will Hence was I moued with great power working euen with comfort to my soule to call to mind innumerable passages of Scriptures and auncient Fathers in former times obserued and other reasonable congruencies moouing me most effectually to conuert my selfe to the onely Apostolike Primitiue and Catholike faith truly professed in the Church of England as it were destined hereunto by a presage in my youth when being borne beyond the seas I was by Gods directing prouidence inspiring my parents mindes by my nurse and her husband who were purposely sent for out of England sent into this Realme when I was but few daies old to be nursed here which was a great furtherance and meanes that now in the ninth yeare of my Priesthood I am in this Realme nursed and growne to such a spirituall strength as to embrace the right faith of a true Christian which heretofore I wanted And although lately since my conuersion one said vnto me that it had been better if I had been drowned at sea in the great storme which happened in my passage into this Realme so young which I escaped with exceeding great danger being forthwith entertained into the Castle by the Captaine thereof for my fathers sake than at riper yeares thus to liue an Apostata and to be a scandale vnto the Church of God Yet I trust that I shall make it apparant that it was much better I escaped Gods prouidence in the first escape of my bodie foreshewing a more dangerous second escape from the shipwracke of my soule whereby his glorie in my happinesse may be manifested to the good of many that they may truly say Exod. 1. vers 19. Digitus Dei est hic the finger of God is here 7. The working of the Trinitie in my conuersion the first cause of this treatise Hereby you may see courteous Reader whether I haue not iust cause to make knowne to the world this my conuersion and the true occasions and motiues thereof that all that beare of it may say as I haue cause to say in mine owne soule The finger of God is here For first you may obserue that whilest I wandered out of the right way of true Catholike doctrine Gods goodnesse following the Church of Rome the finger of Gods mercie and goodnesse directed and pointed me which way to take into the right path of heauen most fauorably bestowing vpon me beartie contrition for my former errors both in faith and manners more than euer before Secondly the finger of his wisdome Gods wisdome euen when I was most addicted to the studies of the Roman doctrine occasion being giuen me of conference with some Protestants requiring satisfaction of me in some capitall points of controuersie which I promised either to proue by the Scriptures ancient Fathers and naturall reason or else to embrace the Protestants faith as Catholike therewithall intending to impugne the doctrine of the Religion here professed in England directed my vnderstanding so to examine the controuersies weighing all Cardinall Bellarmines reasons for both sides that doing it with sinceritie I fell into such doctrinall and morall obseruations vpon the grounds of the Romane faith that I most cleerely discouered the darke clouds of error and ignorance wherewith my iudgement and reason were ouercast I found the weakenesse of their grounds the fallacies of their reasons and the insufficiencie of iudgement shewed in most of their controuersies I found many places of Scripture impertinently alledged diuers citations of auncient Fathers fondly wrested against their true vnderstanding many naturall reasons alledged most repugnant to reason Lastly the finger of his Almightie power Gods power as efficaciously as the Load stone draweth yron vnto it drew all the affections of my heart to a firme resolution no longer to sleepe or slumber in my errors but to breake off all the bands of erronious and superstitious doctrine and nouelties wherewith the present Church of Rome holdeth soules in slauerie to Sathan and to embrace the truth of the Ancient Catholike and Apostolike doctrine which I found to bee most purely taught in the Church of England according to the primitiue sinceritie Hence it is most cleerely apparant how much the glorie of God appeareth in my conuersion and the three diuine attributes of goodnesse wisedome and power of the blessed Trinitie Qui tribus digitis appendit molem terrae Esay 40. vers 12 who weighteth the earth with three fingers in the contemplation of which great benefit I may well crie out with holy Saint Paul Rom. 12. vers 33 O the depth of the riches both of the wisdome and knowledge of God how vnsearchable are his iudgements and his waies past finding out for who hath knowne the mind of the Lord or who hath bin his counsellor Or who hath first giuen to him and it shall be recompenced vnto him againe for of him and through him and to him are all things to whom be glorie for euer For to God himselfe must I needes attribute this fauour hauing iust cause for the same with the kingly Prophet to say Psal 34. vers 2. I will alwaies praise the Lord his praise shall be alwaies in my mouth who chiefly hath wrought in my soule the vnderstanding the will and the accomplishment hereof which I can doe no lesse in gratitude than make knowne that his name may be glorified therein Satisfaction the second cause Secondly if my blinded zeale of your soules good did so much transport me in my ignorance and errors as to imploy my best endeuours yea and to venter my life for your good and for the reducing of any in this Realme to the pretended Catholike faith which then I professed without feare of incurring
and when I noted that I could neuer heare any one Iesuit to speake reprouingly of it and further heard some very rashly and foolishly to cast the imputation of inuenting it vpon the best States-men of this land as a traine to make Catholikes the more odious to the State I began to obserue a custome vsed by some which is without any regard of truth or knowledge to speake the worst they can to blemish the reputation of their aduersaries so I heard a certaine young Iesuit report when Garnet was in the Tower A pretty deuice that day and night oyle was put into his eyes with feathers and other means vsed to keepe him from sleepe that so being weakened both in bodie and minde he might be easily drawne to confesse all he knew which circumstances with diuers others belonging to this vnmatchable treason though they made mee not then abandon the faith and beleefe of those that were actors thereof yet did they sow such seedes of doubtfulnesse and care in me to be sound in faith that the effects and fruits issuing from them of doctrine concerning disallegeance to the King which is contained in the Popes Breues hath much auerted me since as namely the doctrine of Bellarmine teaching that the Apostles were not subiect to temporall Princes de iure but de facto retracting the former opinion Bellarmin cont Barclaium tract De potest summi Pontificis in rebus temporalibus ca. 3. fol. 48. extant in his controuersies these many yeares now holding the quite contrarie notwith standing it is a doctrine of faith that as well the Clergie as the Laitie are subiect to Kings and Princes because obedience to Kings whether they be good or wayward in Scripture is commended vnto all 1. Petri 2.18 behold here the second occasion 7 A third occasion concurring to my conuersion Conference with others was conference with others into whose companies by chance I haue falne as once with a learned Knight who not knowing me to be a Priest conferred with me as with a professor of the Romane faith who winded me into such a circle about the Scriptures and the Church that I could neuer winde my selfe out of it till I winded my selfe out of the Romane Church and stayed my selfe vpon a ground not admitted there which is that the Scriptures are the most sufficient and certaine rule of faith that Christians haue which if you take away all religion all faith all knowledge of God falleth to the ground And another time I fell into dispute with a graue ancient Iustice of Peace who pressed me so farre that I promised to send him some principall doctrines of the Roman Church so sufficiently proued by Scriptures by Fathers and by naturall reason that if they could bee answered I would subscribe to his Church but in the examination of the proofes of those very points brought in by Bellarmine and due consideration of them I found them to be of very little force to proue the verities intended as hereafter shall appeare concerning the Masse Transubstantiation the ministration of the Sacrament vnder one kinde to lay people Pardons auricular confession and others whereupon I haue proued since as good as my promise in ioyning my selfe to the Church of England 8 A fourth occasion of examining more carefully the controuersies hath been grounded vpon his Maiesties Title His Maiesties Booke in his Premonition to Christian Princes stiling himselfe the Defendor of the true Christian Catholike and Apostolike faith which seemed so strange vnto me at the first considering that no Church more chalengeth the name of Catholike than the Church of Rome that I began to consider with my selfe whether I could finde any capitall points of faith taught now by the present Church of Rome that were not taught and professed by the ancient and Primitiue Church and now impugned by the Church of England and finding that the doctrine of deposing Princes and Kings by the Pope was not ancient nor Transubstantiation nor the Masse as now it is practised nor the Sacrament as now it is ministred by the Church of Rome nor Pardons nor prohibition of Priests marriages I haue since beene enforced to conclude that certainely the present Church of Rome professeth not in those points the true Christian Catholike and Apostolike faith Further as I noted the profession his Maiestie maketh in his Premonitorie Epistle to Princes Praemonit ful 35 acknowledging himselfe to be such a Christian Catholike as beleeueth the three Creedes that of the Apostles that of the Councell of Nice and that of Athanasius admitting the first foure generall Councels as Catholike and Orthodox the ioint consent of Fathers in the Primitiue age the authoritie of Scriptures c. I could not but conceiue at last that his Maiestie went vpon the strongest foundations of the Catholike faith that could bee layed to auoid the danger of new doctrines which obseruations did much facilitate my search and scrutinie into the true grounds and reasons of faith besides many other occasions of priuat conference with diuers particular persons who thought themselues much tempted in matters of faith and religion because they could hardly beleeue what the Church of Rome teacheth or at least not without great difficultie Whereby you may see courteous Reader the prouidence of God working in me by degrees towards my conuersion affoording mee the occasions and meanes first of searching and examining which brought me at length to the motiues of resoluing as hereafter you shall vnderstand more at large when I shall first haue layd downe vnto you certaine fundamentall obseruations as grounds on which the true Christian Catholike faith must of necessitie stand and the whole frame thereof be surely builded CHAP. III. Containing the first fundamentall obseruation of the end of man and his chiefe happinesse AFter the manifestation of the occasions which by Gods prouidence occurred to forward this worke of my conuersion The chiefe businesse of man is to seeke his end the next thing to be spoken of is to acquaint thee deare Christian Reader with those fundamentall obseruations which made further way to the complete perfection thereof the first of which was of that nature that I assure my selfe no man who hath care of his soule and saluation can chuse but allow for I assured my selfe that if I went vpon such sure foundations and principles as religion ought to stand vpon I could neither stay in error nor fall into any Hence I was moued to resolue most constantly that the most immoueable foundation that all my sp rituall building should stand on should be a frequent consideration that the chiefe and most principall affaire and businesse of greatest importance in this world wherein it was my dutie to employ my endeuors ought to be the saluation of my soule and my future happinesse in the life to come since to this end God created me to his similitude and likenesse redeemed mee with the most precious bloud of his most
find also the wise Salomon to affirme that Gods words will make a man vnderstand righteousnes and iudgement and equitie and euery good path I find likewise in Saint Luke and other Euangelists Luke 1. vers 4. These things are written that we might haue the certaintie of that whereof we are instructed and that we might beleeue in Iesus and in beleeuing haue life eternall through his name I find further that Christ saith Search the Scriptures Ioh. 20. vers 31. for in them yee thinke to haue eternall life and they are they which testifie of mee as also in another place When one asked Christ what he might do to be saued Luk. 10. vers 26. he referreth him to the Scriptures for his direction saying What is written in the Law So did Abraham answere the rich Glutton They haue Moses and the Prophets Luke 16.29 I find also Saint Paul free from all exception herein saying The Scriptures are able to make vs wise to saluation 2. Tim. 3. vers 15. Vers 16. Vers 17. through the faith that is in Christ Iesus and are profitable to teach to improue to conuert to instruct in righteousnesse that the man of God may be absolute and perfect to euery good worke And in another place we may not presume aboue that which is written I find likewise Saint Peter to accord with Saint Paul 2. Pet. 1.19 when hee saith Wee haue a more sure word of the Prophets whererunto wee cannot take heed as vnto a light that shineth in a darke place till the day dawne and till the day-starre arise in our hearts Many more proofes would the canonicall Scriptures afford to the same effect therefore since by the premised places of Scripture I see that he that speaketh not according to the word of God hath no light in him since the Scriptures can make vs know righteousnesse iudgement equitie and euery good path since they were written that we might haue certainty in that we are instructed in and beleeuing haue life eternall since we are sent to the Scriptures by Christ since they are able to make vs wise to saluation since they are profitable to make vs perfect to euery good worke since it is presumption to go aboue that which is written since the Prophets be our light in darknesse what better rule can we haue of our faith what can excuse any mans ignorance that knoweth this or what an obstinate wilfulnesse were it for me that knowing these testimonies of Scripture shall not beleeue them or why should I not thinke that the Church of England hath not the best reed or mete-wand to measure the truth of her doctrine by when she teacheth Juel Apol. part 2. cap. 9. diuis 1. That the Scripture comprehended in the canonicall bookes of the old and new Testament is the rule of faith so farre that whatsoeuer is not read therein or cannot be proued thereby is not to be accepted as any point of faith or needfull to be followed 4 Which doctrine cannot be shaken or ouerthrowne By proofes of Fathers if we esteeme the authoritie of the learned who do most plentifully giue witnesse and vnanswerable proofes for the same S. Basil who liued in the fourth centurie after Christ saith Let the holy Scriptures be arbitrators betweene vs Basil opist 80. ad Eustac medicum pag. 334. and whosoeuer hold opinions consonant to those heauenly oracles let the truth be adiudged on their side And Optatus disputing against a Donatist presseth him thus Contra Parmem lib. 5. pag 393. We are saith he to equire out some to be iudges betweene vs in these controuersies The Christians cannot because both sides cannot yeeld them and by parts taking the truth shall be hindered The Iudge must be had from without our selues If a Pagan he knowes not the mysteries of Christianitie if a Iew he is an enemie to Baptisme therefore vpon the earth no iudgement concerning this matter can bee found the Iudge must be had from heauen but to what end should we kocke at heauen when heere we haue one in the Gospell Heere we see Saint Basil appeales for iudgement to the Scriptures and so Optatus likewise to the Gospell no acknowledgement here of other arbitrement vpon earth What shall I speake of Tertullion who is most plaine for me Tertul. contra Hermog calling the Scriptures the rule of faith The golden-mouthed Chrysostome will not heere forsake me who termeth the Scriptures Chrysost hom 13. in 2. Cor. Hom. 3. de Laz. A most exquisite rule and exact squier and ballance to trie all things by And also in another place saith God hath left vs the Scriptures more firme then any miracle And vpon the Acts of the Apostles discourseth very fitly to this purpose Chrysost hom 33. in Act. A Gentile saith hee commeth and saith I would bee a Christian but I know not which side to cleaue vnto many dissensions are among you and I cannot tell which opinion to hold euery one saith I speake the truth and the Scriptures on both sides are pretended so that I know not whom to beleeue to this Chrysostome replieth Truly saith he this maketh much for vs for well might you be troubled if we should say we relie vpon reason but seeing we take the Scriptures which are so true and plaine it will be an easie matter for you to iudge And tel me now hast thou any wit or iudgement Note this for it is not the part of a man barely to receiue whatsoeuer he heareth but if thou marke the meaning thou mayest throughly know that which is good when thou buyest a garment though thou hast no skill in wearing yet thou sayest not I cannot buy it they deceiue me but thou doest all things that thou mayest learne to know it say not then I am no scholler and will be no iudge I can condemne no opinion for this is but a shift and a cauill and let vs not vse it for all these things are easie There is nothing can bee more cleere for this most sufficient rule of faith then that which is written by this ancient Author of the imperfect worke falsely fathered as some thinke vpon Saint Chrysostome whom because he is often alleaged by the learned of the Romane Church I will also alleage against them this Author expounding those of Saint Matthew Chrysost opus imperfect hom 49. Then those that are in Iurie let them flie vnto the mountaines explicateth them thus that is they that are Christians let them repaire vnto the Scriptures The mountaines are the writings of the Apostles and Prophets and wherefore doth he at that time command all Christians to repaire to the Scriptures because in that time heresie hath obtained the Curches there can be no proofe of true Christianity neither can there be other refuge for Christians which shall desire to know the truth of faith but the sacred Scriptures Before it was many wayes shewed which was
light of Scriptures Psal 119. vers 10.4 Psal 119. vers 18. vnto thy Lord God Lucerna pedibus meis verbum tuum lumen semitis meis Thy word is a lampe vnto my feete and a light vnto my path And againe Open thou mine eyes that I may behold wonderous things out of the Law 11 Yet thou art to haue great care that thou make not this rule longer than it is nor shorter for this is forbidden by Christ himselfe speaking against such a one saying I protest vnto euery man that heareth the words of the prophecie of this Booke Apoc. 22.18 19. if any man shall adde vnto these things God shall adde vnto him the plagues that are written in this Booke and if any man shall take away from the words of the booke of this prephecie God shall take away his part out of the Booke of life and out of the holy Citty and from the things which are written in this Booke This fault of adding to the Books of holie scripture is very notorious in the Church of Rome as I haue duly obserued Ses 41. For the Councell of Trent addeth to the Canon of the old Testament diuers Apocriphall Books which must be beleeued as Canonicall Scriptures as namely Tobias Iudith Hester and the two bookes of the Macchabees Esdras Wisedome and Ecclesiasticus all which are learnedly proued to be Apocriphall by the right reuerend Father in God my Lords grace of Canterburie in his answer to master Doctor Hill his eight reason Num. 3. sequent the consideration whereof made me plainely conclude that heerein the Church of Rome giues great and apparent occasion for any to iudge that she erreth and consequently not to heare her voice thus vttering falshood for trueth giuing equall authoritie to the Apocriphall Bookes with the holy canonicall Scriptures CHAP. VII Containing an obseruation how the Ministerie of the true Church of Christ is the meanes of teaching the true sense and vnderstanding of Scriptures where and when it hath a visible and externall gouernement ALthough I haue cleerely discouered The externall ministe rie of the Church an ordinarie meanes to know the true sense of Scripture that the sacred Scriptures are the chiefe infallible rule of faith and most sufficient in the precedent obseruation yet could I not rest satisfied till I found also a meanes for the simple and vnlearned to ground their faith vppon because Deus vult omnes saluos fieri ad agnitionem veritatis venire God will haue all to be saued 1. Tim. 2.4 and come to the knowledge of his trueth And as well as he in the gouernment of his creatures hath his end to which he designes them so also by his wisedome he doth most prudently substitute subordinate means for the full accomplishment of such his designements now therefore how those that are neither able to reade the scriptures or though they be able haue not sufficient skill and knowledge to consider the circumstances of Texts and by the analogie of faith not learned enough to find out the true meaning of the Scriptures nor haue the gift of interpretation as many and most haue not whereupon arise many deprauations of Scriptures how such should be directed in the right vse of the rule of Scriptures in finding out the right meaning of them I thought it a matter of great weight wel to discouer and by the declaration thereof to affoord a stay to weake consciences in this behalfe In the scrious discussion of which point it pleased almightie God so to second my carefull Labours and indeuours herein as that I receiued ful satisfaction in mine owne iudgement by this conclusion namely That the most ordinary externall direction left by God especially to direct vnlearned men in the finding out of the true sense and meaning of the Scriptures is the ministerie of the true visible Church of Christ assisted by the holie Ghost and the Church in this respect is called 1. Tim. 3.15 Matt. 5.14 The pillar of truth and the ministers thereof The light of the world 2 And therefore as master Harding himselfe confesseth True vnderstanding of Scripturs only in the Church Doctor Hard. conâ—ut of the Apologie of the Church of England fol. 36. Mester Celuine admonisheth very well That it is especially to be noted that out of the Church there is no light of the sound vnderstanding of the Scriptures But the inconsiderate Doctour maketh a verie fond inference vpon this ground saying This ground being laid on which each part must sland and be tried in crow no more against vs boast your selues no more we feare not the iudgement of the holie Scriptures nay it is your selues that feare this iudgement for your owne conscience telleth you that on this ground you are the weaker side Jnstit lib. 4 cap. 8. num 7. hee forgot that master Caluine said Let this be a firme axiome That no other word of God is to be had to which place must bee giuen in the Church than what is maintained first in the Law and Prophets then in the writings of the Apostles neither is there anie way of teaching in the Church of God but by the prescript and rule of his word If master Harding had well obserued this hee would not haue made such an inference or affirmed that the Protestants feare this iudgement but rather would haue concluded as I doe That since both stand vpon the outward ministerie of the true Church let vs seeke the true Church of Christ and hauing found it The deuties of the true church then heare and follow her doctrine teaching according to Scripture and out of Scripture 3 The due obseruation whereof sheweth That the true visible Church is to represse the deprauations of Heretickes and partly to informe those that are vnlearned and to exercise euen the obedience of those that are learned and by the externall ministerie of teaching the true sence of Scriptures is to giue directions and is duetifully by her members to bee heard and followed Which assertion I find not to make either for the present Church of Rome or of Engl. or any other particular Church till it bee prooued which of them is the true Catholike Ancient and Primitiue Apostolike Church teaching the sound Doctrine of the first pure and vntainted ages whereof I am to speake in the Chapter following CHAP. VIII Containeth a fundamentall obseruation how that consormity of doctrine with the ancient doctrine of the Primitiue Church may bee a good meanes in these latter ages to know the true Church of Christ. AFter that I had thus discouered both the most sufficient rule of faith to be the canonicall and true Scriptures and the most ordinarie externall meanes to find out the true sence to be the ministerie of the true Church Antiquitie a good inducement to the true Church I could not yet giue sufficient contentment to my vnderstanding vntill such time as I had found out also
as the Church of Rome teacheth who being deuoted much to the virgine Marie prayed often vnto her to bee deliuered from this doubt Who being one day at Masse the Hoast before the saying of the Pater noster was gone out of his sight whereof as hee was in a great amazement the virgine Marie appeared vnto him holding her sonne Iesus betwixt her armes and said vnto him This is he whom I brought into this world this is he whom you haue consecrated this is he whom you haue held and touched with your hands and shewed to the people to be adored which you eate and drinke in the Sacrament behold here I giue you my Sonne with reuerence and deuotion to be receiued of you and so as shee presented him vnto him he changed at that instant againe into the forme of bread whom he receiued and so his doubt ceased Here you see courteous Reader strange miracles alledged by the Papists in confirmation of their doctrine one while the bread is vnseene then Christ and our Ladie and then againe the forme of bread another while a Mule forsaking his prouender to adore God in the Sacrament whether these be not such signes wonders and great prodigies as may seduce the elect if it were possible I leaue to the holy Ghost to informe you the truth saying Nolite eis credere beleeue them not And one more yet I will relate vnto your memorie which hath beene wrought of late yeares and may be esteemed for a notable lie Till Bred. 7. Col. sac c. 7. There was a certaine Caluinist that married a Catholike woman that is Papist that long endeuoured to induce her to heare a Caluinist Minister preach The wife after she had a long time contradicted him was at last constrained to goe by the rigorous speeches and threatnings of her husband yet did she first acquaint her ghostly father there with who aduised her to obey the commaundement of her husband and to goe onely once to the said Sermon yet with condition to goe first to Confession and to the Communion The woman hauing performed the aduise of her ghostly father strengthned with the Sacraments went to the Sermon and she was no sooner entred but the Preacher became as silent and mute as a fish yet said at last after a little pause Here is some bodie present that hath eaten of the bread of Papists which is the cause that I will now giue ouer preaching hoping to make recompence another time The husband who was present seeing the Preacher A pretie fiction to disgrace Caluinists by Gods permission to become silent and disabled to prosecute his matter for the presence of one that had receiued the holy Communion who being returned home enquired of his wife whether shee had not receiued the Communion that morning or not she without dissimulation answering yes her husband suddainly knew that this doctrine of the Caluinists was false and accursed in that being placed with the light of the Sacraments of the Catholike Church it withered so and came to nought whereupon presently he made a good fire burned all his bookes to pouder and ashes and became himselfe a child of the Catholike Church In which miracle first I obserue that the ghostly father of this woman gaue her leaue for obedience to her husband to go to the Church of Caluinists which how it can hang with the doctrine of Paule the fifths Breue who sheweth it vnlawfull for English Catholikes to goe to the Churches of Heretikes viz. of all Caluinists and Protestants that are so in his iudgement vnlesse it be said that the Church of Rome holds one doctrine of faith lawfull at one time that is not lawfull at another time I should be glad to be resolued But this I obserue to proceede from Gods prouidence that the inuentors of these and the like miracles for the confirmation of their doctrine in one point doth often in some circumstance or other shew such ignorance or falsehood that discouereth them either not to approue the matter they intend or else runneth into some other error lesse tolerable shewing them most plainely to be such signes and wonders as Christ giueth a Caueat of them Not to be beleeued Many other miracles I might here insert but that I will not be too tedious in such idle tales fitter to be told amongst children as fables than to any men of more ripe iudgement yet are they amongst the Clergie of Rome of such account that their Sermonists are stuffed with them as may be obserued in Iacobus de Voragine Iohannes Meff Bernard de Bust Philippus Dies and many the like and are held more profitable for the people than any other manner of doctrine Yet I obserue one thing by reading of their liues of Saints that many miracles which were authenticall for many hundred yeares past are now growne to be Apocryphall as may be seene by comparing the auncient liues of S. George S. Katherine the Queene and others with them as they are of late yeares corrected and written by Lipeloo following Baronius and other writers of the same kind 12 Now therefore to draw neere my conclusion My conclusion about miracles what fruit could I better gather vpon the due obseruation of Christs warning vnto the world Not to beleeue such miracles than that the Church of Rome cannot bee the true Church of God that either winketh or authoriseth infinite numbers in the same nature as these are of which I haue alreadie recorded out of her owne Writers for which cause I could not but abandon her Communion and flye to that Church which like a faithfull Spouse resteth contented with the former miracles where with Christs Church was begun and chiefely relying vpon the holy Scriptures and the auncient doctrine of the Primitiue Church Yet is not my opinion in this point of miracles so to bee vnderstood as that I doe thinke no true miracles at all shall euer be done in the declining age of Gods Church but I would haue it knowne that my iudgement is that none are to be beleeued which are pretended to be done in confirmation of new doctrines not taught in the Scriptures not knowne to the auncient Church because it is most euident that Christ hath forbidden all beleefe of them and therefore not to be esteemed of otherwise than as of illusions of Sathan wherewith to enchant soules and to make them beleeue lyes in stead of truth and verities Oh what a miserie is it to see how many simple sincere and ouer-credulous Christians are cousened with these deceits and illusions of the Diuell and the true markes of Antichrist Let me therfore entreat thee courteous reader to remember the predictions of these signes and wonders aboue mentioned forespoken of by Christ S. Paule and S. Iohn and not so fondly to be lead blind-folded to the eternall destruction of thy soule by too much credulitie Be not like the Scribes and Pharisies seeking after signes from heauen for the faith least you
haue heard reported once by an English Gentleman that serued sometimes amongst them of a Countriman of his who fighting against the Souldiers of the Reformed Religion in the Low Countries and finding his powder so moist that with often putting match to it it would not take fire in most blasphemous manner see swore in the Spanish tongue I vow to God that this day I thinke God is become a Lutheran For in very truth if the Texts which Viguerius citeth so confidently thinking by them to ouerthrow all the Lutheranes in the world be well and rightly vnderstood you shall finde them to be of no efficacie at all and to be but match powder without fire that is Scripture and his owne sense and priuate vnderstanding without the fire of the holy Ghost without the Spirit of truth and the comfortable Master teaching all truth for the prophecie of Esay only foresheweth how Christ the Messias comming into the world should Preach the remission of sinners to all in generall and deliuerie to those that liued in the darknesse of ignorance before the comming to Christ as the Gentills who should finde mercy and truth by Christ as well as the Iewes Neither will I denie which maketh nothing for Viguerius but that the remission of sinnes and also the remission of paines due to sinne is meant by the word Indulgence the infinite guilt of sinne and the eternall paine due to sinne in hell fire both which belong to sinne being taken away by the bloud of Christ and therefore if the eternall paine why not also the temporal what reseruation did Christ make or his Apostles to shew that the ternall pain should be remitted and the temporall be reserued only for the Pope to be pardoned by means of crosses medalls graines rings knotted cords and the like childish trinkets O miserable blindnesse that cannot discerne such grosse errours and so great a prophanation of Christs merites and satisfaction Sweet Iesu open the eyes of all that are thus blinded let them see how the sacred Scriptures are foolishly misapplied wickedly wrested racked and most impiously prophaned for the supporting of Romish nouelties I will not shew how impertinently other places are applied by Bellarmine for the confirmation of the same Romish errour my designement not being to write a whole Booke of Confutations but only to point at the chief obseruations I made in diuers points of religion inducing me from Romish errors and idolatries vnto the light of truth 4 Vpon further consideration of indulgences I find also The doctriue of Romish In dulgences not ancient that as they are not established by Scriptures rightly vnderstood so neither are they supported by antiquity in the primitiue age of the Church Bellar. cites Greg. the first to haue graunted Indulgences in the dayes of stations Bellar. de sacra poenit lib. 5. ca. 3 in 4. dist 20. q. 1 artic 3 quast 2. Alt. sum Theol. tract 6. ca. 9. for proofe wherof he citeth Thomas Aquinas and Altisiodorensis who was before Thomas hee citeth also Leo the third who as S. Lugderus writeth at Aquisgraue in the Pallace dedicated a Church to the blessed virgin Mary enduing the same Church with many indulgences He citeth besides Sergius the second about the yeere 844. who graunted indulgences of three yeares and of three Quadrigenaries vnto those that should visite the Church of S. Martin vpon the mountaine Spist de sanct Suuiberto apud Sur. tom 2 post S. Suuibert vpon the feast of the same Church He citeth likewise Vrban the second to haue graunted a plenary indulgence to those that went to the holy warres Hee citeth also Martine the fift to huae graunted a plenarie indulgence And the Councell of Trent to haue approued also the vse of Indulgences Amongst all which cited by Bellarmine Pope Gregorie the first liued in the sixt centurie Pope Leo the third who was successour to Pope Adrian the first liued in the eight centurie Sergius the second successor to Gregory the fourth liued in the ninth century Vrban the second successor to Victor the third liued in the eleuenth centurie Pope Martin the fift by some called Martin the third successour to Iohn the one and twentieth liued in the fifteenth centurie as appeareth in the French Iesuite Iames Gaultier Table Chron. de l'estate du Christianisme Now therefore when I doe seriouslie consider these assertions of Ioannes Viguerius and Cardinall Bellarmine for the practise of Indulgences the ancientest they cite is Gregory the great who liued in the sixt centurie which was after the sowing of much cockle and more heresies man being asleepe no such practise hauing beene knowne by anie Pope before then whereby it appeareth that their doctrine euen by their owne assertions about these pardons and indulgences is but a new doctrine lately sprung vp in the christian world and hath not the marke of Antiquitie to stand in defence of it 5 This I find also euen by Bishop Fisher to be most true Other late writers shew the noueltie of Indulgences who saith That so long as there was no care of Purgatorie no man sought after Pardons for on it dependeth the credite of Pardons When therefore Purgatorie was so lately knowne and receiued in the Church Assert Luther confut art 18. pag. 86. who now can maruell at Pardons that in the beginning of the Church there was no vse of them Pardon 's therefore began after that they had trembled a while at the paine of Purgatorie I find also that Durandus saieth There are few things to be affirmed for certainetie concerning Pardons 4. d. 20. q. 3. because the Scripture speaketh not expresly of them and the Saints Ambrose Hillarie Augustine Ierome speake not of them at all Caietane also the great Schooleman saith There can no certaintie be found of the beginning of paerdons There is no authoritie of the Scripture or auncient Fathers Greeke or Latine that bringeth it to our knowledge Tra Hat de Indulg ca. 1. And Alphonsus sheweth in verie plaine termes that they are but nouelties saying Their vse seeme to haue come but lately into the Church Haeres verbo Indulg And Henriquez a Iesuite often cited by the Readers in Rome hath these wordes There bee ceertaine late Dinines which affirme it is no rashnesse Sum mor. li. 7. cap. 3. if a man say the vse and practise of Indulgences is not from the Apostles times Now this beeing considered which these Writers esteemed most learned by their owne associates doe finde euen contrary to cardinall Bellarmine who citeth Scriptures for proofe of Indulgences that there is no mention of in the holy Scriptures nor Fathers nor the ancient Church I could not but conclude but that certainely they are nouelties not to bee embraced the doctrine of them is but cockle that ouergroweth the good corne it is after-comming and therefore not to be esteemed So that now finding no good ground of these Pardons I can find no truer
of the Church of Rome when they came to the Church of England they prooued dissolute of life most licentious in their conuersations whereas such as went from the Church of England to the church of Rome though they were neuer so disorderly before they afterward were reformed in their conuersations and most religiously exemplar in their behauiours Now therefore to shew that this obseruation proueth not alwayes so and that those of the English Church might not bee deceiued with this illusion of the Diuell you may from me take notice that it hath pleased almighty God heretofore to cōuert diuerse who haue liued with good fame in the Church of England and of late one master Richard Sheldon whose both learning vertuous conuersation euen in the Church of Rome hath beene such as is vnimpeachable by any of his Aduersaries as farre forth as euer I could heare and so still manifesteth as much in religious zeale to the Church of England and for mine owne part I can boldly say that I find as good curbes by the Doctrine of the Church of England to keepe men from sinne as in the Church of Rome by vertue whereof I doubt not but with Gods assistance I shall liue to serue him in this Church with lesse sinne than euer I could haue done in the Church of Rome 4 Thirdly I must giue you further notice that it is a thing wel knowne that there are in this realme many dissembling Protestants which outwardly doe all the acts of Religion belonging to this Church of England either to stay in their places in the common-wealth or to anoyde their penall lawes and yet in their hearts are resolued beleeuers of the Roman Faith egregiously dissembling both with God and men and practising most notorious equiuocation aswell in matters of faith as manners who will not sticke to take oathes receiue Sacraments go to Church and commit many a like act directly against their consciences perswasion which according to Saint Paul is sinne Rom. 14. vers 23 nay I dare affirme that it is a hainous mortall sinne approaching neare to that sinne against which Christ himselfe pronounceth a dangerous threatning ful of terror to any considerat heart saying That he that sinneth against the holy Ghost shall neuer be forgiuen Luc. 12. vers 10. neither in this world neither in the world to come Whence it may appeare that such men as they are most treacherous to God so may it be probably thought they cannot be loyall vnto men and therefore are they to bee held the most dangerous men that can be in any Common-wealth preferring the glorie of men before the glorie of God which being a thing much practised by some affected to the Church of Rome I haue beene the more willing both for their better information to publish these my obseruations as also to giue satisfaction to the Church of England concerning my selfe who am I thanke God most free from so hatefull a crime odious both to God and man 5. Fourthly I am further to let you vnderstand that my intention in these my Obseruations being more for the instruction of the Professors of the Church of Rome than for those of the Church of England who stand in no neede of so meane a scholler as my selfe I haue cited often the Authors of that Church euen against themselues thinking no way better to confute their Doctrines than by their owne grounds and their owne Teachers And although I handle not all points controuersed betwixt Rome and the reformed Churches at this day yet doe I so entreat of the chiefest points of Practise and Doctrine that all those being discouered to be but erronious and nouell and such as cannot stand with the true grounds of Christianitie I thinke there is no man of sound iudgement can thinke I had iust cause to stay any longer in that Church or that themselues can be partakers of Saluation remaining in the same 6. Fifthly my further desire is that thou who vouchsafest to be the Reader of these my vnpolished lines wilt with as fauourable a minde entertaine them for thy profit as I out of charitable affection to Gods seruants doe most freely publish them to the world desiring Almightie God to giue thee grace to reade them with due attention and to ruminate vpon them with mature deliberation laying aside all partialitie in thy censures or inordinate desire of any curious nouelties my resolution in the writing of them being more for the profit and spirituall good of others than for any purchase either of praise or estimation to my selfe desiring that the naked truth set forth without any colours of art or elocution may shew it owne power and force to preuaile against falshood And so wishing you all happinesse both temporall and eternall I leaue thee to the protection on of Almightie God Yours zealously affected in Christ Iesus I. C. A table of all the matters contained in this booke of Doctrinall and Morall Obseruations CHAP. I. COntaineth the first obseruation shewing the reasons of this Treatise Fol. 1. Chap. 2. Containeth an obseruation of Gods prouidence in ministring occasions of times places and persons concurring to the Authours conuersion Fol. 15. Chap. 3. Containeth the first fundamentall obseruation of the end of man and his chiefe happinesse Fol. 26. Chap. 4. Containeth the second fundamentall obseruation of the supernaturall and reuealed knowledge which is necessarie to saluation Fol. 30. Chap. 5. Containeth the third fundamentall obseruation about the absolute necessitie of supernaturall faith Fol. 34. Chap. 6. Containeth the fourth fundamentall obseruation about the rule and straight mete-wand of the true Christian Faith Fol. 38. Chap. 7. Containeth the fift fundamentall obseruation how the Ministerie of the true Church of Christ is the meanes of teaching the true sense and vnderstanding of Scriptures where and when it hath a visible externall gouernement Fol. 52. Chap. 8. Containeth the sixt fundamentall obseruation how that conformitie of doctrine with the ancient doctrine of the primitiue Church may be a good meanes in these latter ages to know the true Church of Christ Fol. 55. Chap. 9. Containeth an obseruation of the wonders and supposed Miracles which as Christ hath fore-told the Pseudo-Christs and false Prophets shall doe for the seducing of Gods Elect if it were possible Fol. 72. Chap. 10. Containeth an obseruation of the great hypocrisie of false teachers fore-spoken of in the holy Scriptures Fol. 100. Chap. 11. Containeth an obseruation of the fruits by which false Prophets are to be knowne and discerned Fol. 113. Chap. 12. Containeth an obseruation about the Sacrifice of the Masse which is accompted by the Church of Rome the chiefest act of Religion that can be done to God Fol. 133. Chap. 13. Containeth an obseruation about the doctrine of Transubstantiation which is a principall noueltie taught in the Church of Rome Fol. 160. Chap. 14. Containeth an obseruation about the Sacrament ministred but vnder one kind to Lay-people in the Church
any displeasure of the State then can I now doe no lesse in satisfaction to God and the world being now enlightned with truth it selfe than to shew a more earnest zeale burning charitie towards your conuersions from the former errors laboring to reduce you vnto the same light of Catholike truth whereto I my selfe am called that whereas I haue formerly wronged the soules of many in the time of my blindnesse by diuers labors and exhortations and the wrong ministration of the blessed Sacrament but vnder one forme vnto you quite contrarie to Christs institution and commaundement reioycing therein I may now in the time of better knowledge endeuor to make part of amends by vsing any possible paines to informe you rightly of the same way which it hath pleased God to call me vnto The true motiue of my conuersion the third cause Thirdly that you may haue true notice that not any temporall motiue hath wrought this change in me not persuasion of any worldly friend for till my conuersion I conuersed with none ordinarily but those of the Romane profession not naturall affection to kindred because my neerest and deerest friends of bloud are of that faith and gentlemen of worshipfull qualitie not want for mine owne meanes haue beene able contentedly to maintaine me with such helpes as the practise of my function drew vnto me besides the loue and willingnesse of many good friends most readie to assist me in all my needes not inordinate affection to carnall delights vnapprouable by Gods word for I thanke God I am free from all such or any other as farre as I know who am best able to examine mine owne conscience in this behalfe 8 Accept therefore I beseech you deere Recusants vnto whom I wish as much good as to mine owne soule To Recusants and all happinesse in the most tender bowels of Christ Iesus these my ensuing obseruations grounded vpon the sacred letters and the doctrine of the ancient Church earnestly praying to God they may beare the same sway with your vnderstanding and will as they haue with mine for your inducement to a perfect conuersion of your soules according to my example vnto the true worship of God in the true Catholike English Church whose doctrine you may find agreeable to the true grounds of Christianitie and the doctrine of the primitiue Church as I doubt not but you may most cleerely perceiue if you will vouchsafe without all passion and peruerse affection to peruse my obseruations which as they haue been powerfull to worke my true conuersion so from the truest affections of my soule I wish they may be as profitable vnto you for your reduction vnto the same most true Catholike faith with abundance of Gods blessings to your soules with perfect allegeance to your lawfull Soueraigne with edification to his Church with true contentment and peace to your hearts with quietnesse to your present life and euerlasting glorie to your life to come through the grace and mercie of our Lord Iesus CHAP. II. Containing an obseruation of Gods prouidence in ministring occasions of times places and persons concurring to my conuersion SVch is the mercifull prouidence of Almightie God which reacheth from one end to another mightily and sweetly ordereth all things Gods prouidence ordereth all things Sap. 8. vers 1. that as he disposeth all humane actions to happen in fit times so doth he suffer fit accidents and occasions to fall out that the workes which he intendeth by men may haue successe answerable to his will and designements Qui mundum per seipsum regit Greg. lib. 14. Mor. cap. 26. ante medium quem per seipsum condidit who as Gregorie sayth ruleth the world by himselfe which by himselfe he created For his vnderstanding and will being the cause of all thinges as the great Doctor of the Romane Church teacheth Tho. Aq. part 1. q. 19. in corpore Qui operatur omnia secundum consilium voluntatis suae who worketh all things according to the purpose of his will as Saint Paule affirmeth Ephes 1. vers 11. and his will being knowne as the Schoole-men teach by diuers signes as by prohibition permission of euill Thom. Aqu. part 1. q. 19. operation of good and by precepts c. Saint Augustine also saying August enchirid c. 29. in fine Tom. 3. Nihil fit nisi omnipotens fieri velit vel sinendo vt fiat vel faciendo Nothing is done but what the Almightie will haue done eyther by suffering it to be done or by doing it it followeth by necessarie consequence that all occasions helpes and benefits of his creatures subordinately concurring to euerie act of his will proceedeth from his prouidence and wisedome 2 Hence My bond of gratitude to Gods prouidence gentle Reader I obserue in how strong bands of dutifull thankfulnesse I stand obliged vnto God for ministring vnto me at seuerall times and in seuerall places and vpon different occurrences such occasions and meanes to search and examine the controuersies of religion betwixt the Romane and English Church that whilest by my studies and labours my purpose designement was to draw others into the net of Rome I my selfe was led into the sheepefold wherof Christ in heauen is the chiefe Pastor wherein I see truly verified that of King Dauid Psal 13. vers 2. Dominus de coelo prospexit vt videat si est intelligens aut requirens Deū the Lord looked down from heauē vpon the children of men to see if there were any that did vnderstand and seeke God who neuer ceaseth to minister occasions and means concurring to the good of his seruants Matth. 11. ver 1. who numbreth all the haires of their heads in his knowledge and suffereth not any thing to happen without his prouidence vnto them For so we find that Abrahams exile concurred to his greater good Gen. 11. vers 1. Gen. 22. vers 29. Gen 37. vers 18 the commandement of Isaacks Sacrifice gaue occasion to approue Abrahams faith the felling of Ioseph by his brethren and his imprisonment were occasions concurring to his greater glory and to the manifestation of his vertues Exod. 2. vers 3. and Gods more singular prouidence towards him the laying of Moses by the brinke of the riuer 1. Reg. 17. vers 6. the often deliuerie of Dauid from Sauls furie the feeding of Elias with bread and flesh by Rauens the preseruation of Daniel in the denne of Lions Dan. 6. vers 22. Dan. 3.20.24 the protection of the three Children in the Babilonian furnace doe most cleerely shew how by this prouidence of God all occasions and circumstances of mens liues do concurre to the happines of his chosen seruants and therefore most truly singeth the Psalmist Psal 90. vers 1. Qui habitat in adiutorio altissimi in protectione Dei coeli commorabitur he that dwelleth in the secret place of the most high shall abide vnder the shadow of the Almightie
the true Church of Christ and which was Gentilisme but now it is no way knowne vnto those which desire to know which is the true Church but onely by Scriptures wherefore because all these things which belongs so properly to Christ in truth heresies haue the same also in schisme Churches likewise holy Scriptures likewise Bishops likewise and other orders of Clerkes Baptisme likewise the Eucharist and all the rest lastly Christ himselfe One therefore that desireth to know which is the true Church whence shall he know it in the confusion of such likenesse but only by the Scriptures Note this likewise heretofore they were knowne by miracles who were true Christians who false How false Christians either could not do miracles as true Christians did or else they could not do such as true Christians did But now the working of miracles is altogether taken away and it is more found that false miracles are wrought by those who are false Christians as Peter according to Clement expouÌ„deth also power is to be also giuen of doing ful miracles vnto Antichrist Likewise heretofore the Church of Christ was vnderstood by their maners when the conuersation of al or most Christians was holy which was not among the wicked But now either such or worse Christians are become then Heretikes or Gentiles And moreouer greater continencie is found amongst those who liue in scisme then among Christians He therfore that will know which is the true Church of Christ whence shall he know it but only the Scriptures Note this The Lord therefore knowing that such a confusion of things should come in the last dayes he therefore commandeth that Christians who are in the Christianitie being desirous to obtaine firmenesse of the true faith should flie vnto nothing but vnto the Scriptures Note againe For otherwise if they haue regard to other things they shall be scandalized and shall perish not vnderstanding which is the true Church and by this they shall fall into the abomination of desolation which shall stand in the holy places of the Church Whereby it appeareth that the only means to find out the true Church is the canonicall Scriptures especially in these latter times to which we are now arriued 5 To our purpose also Gregorie Nissen calleth the Scriptures Other fathers Orat. de eis qui adeunt Hierosolimam A straight and inflexible rule I obserue also Saint Augustine to ioyne with the former who saith The Scripture pitcheth downe the rule of our faith De bono vid. cap. 1. And againe hee saith This controuersie depending betweene vs requireth a Iudge and let the Apostle Paul iudge with him because Christ also speaketh in his Apostle De nupt cencup ad Vater lib. 2. cap. 33. Epist 112. ad Paulin. In another place If a matter be grounded on the cleere authoritie of the holy Scripture such I meane as the Church calleth canonicall it is to be beleeued without all doubt but as for other witnesses and testimonies vpon whose credit any thing may be vrged vnto vs to belieue it it is lawful for thee either to credit or not to credit them according as thou shalt perceiue them of waight to deserue or not to deserue credit He saith besides De doctrin Christiau lib 2. cap 9. Ibid. cap. 42. All points which concerne faith and good life are found in those things which are plainly set downe in Scripture And againe in another place Whatsoeuer it be that a man learnes out of the Scripture if it be hurtfull there it is condemned if it bee profitable there it is found Tract 3. in 1. epist Ioh. Contra lit Petilian Dâ—â—at lib. 3 cap. 6 de vnit Eccles cap. 11. Againe hee saith The Church is our mother her breasts are the two Testaments of the Scripture whence she giueth her children milke Againe further If we or an Angell from heauen declare vnto you either concerning Christ or his Church any other matter or any thing belonging to our faith or life but what you haue receiued in the Legal and Euangelicall Scriptures let him be accursed The same famous Doctor likewise reuoketh from miracles to Scriptures De vnit Eccles cap. 16. saying Say not these things are so because such a one did such and such marualles but let them proue their Church by the canonicall bookes of Scripture and by nothing else These are the demonstrations of our cause these are our foundations these are our grounds whereupon we build And againe Our faith shal reele totter if the authoritie of the Scriptures stand not fast By all which according to this famous Doctor who is termed malleus haereticorum the hammer of heretikes you see this rule of faith most cleerely approued and iustified 6 Neither doe other auncient Writers swarue from the same doctrine Other fathers De error prophan relig p. 61. for Iulius Firminus sayth Let the venerable mysteries of the Prophets be opened let the credit of the holy Oracles stand by vs. Origen further sayth Hom. 1. in Ierem We must of necessitie call the Scriptures to witnesse for our sences and interpretations without them are of no credit Cyrill the Bishop of Hierusalem sayth Concerning the holy and heauenly mysteries of faith Catech. 4. pag. 15. we must not deliuer any thing though neuer so small Note this without the holy Scripture neither may we be led away with probabilities and shew of words neither yet beleeue me barely saying these things vnto you vnlesse thou also beleeue the demonstration thereof from the Scripture for the securitie of our faith ariseth from the demonstration of the holy Scripture The Emperour Constantine in his speech to the Bishops of the Nicene Councell hath this memorable saying Theod Hist li. 1. c. 7. pag. 284. We haue the teaching of the holy Ghost written for the Enangelicall and Apostolike bookes and the Decrees of the old Prophets doe euidently teach vs the things that are needfull to be knowne concerning God Therefore laying aside all contention let vs out of the dinine inspired Scripture take the rersolution of those things we secke for Neither will I let my penne paste another notable saying of Saint Augustine which is diligently to bee noted saying In Io. tract 21. Some may obiect we doe rashly in discussing and searching out the wordes of God but way are they vttered if they may not be knowne Why haue they sounded if they may not be heard and why are they heard but that we should vnderstand them Thus the Ancient resolued me in the securitie of this rule 7 And not onely these Proofes of late Writers but also the moderne Writers of the Church of Rome forgetting themselues as it seemeth in their writings euen against their owne grounds about the rule of faith haue giuen me no lesse euidence for this most straight and sufficient rule of the sacred letters and Canonical bookes than the former For first their great
medio tom 4. That when Sorcerers doe those thinges which Saints doe they are don for a different end and by a different power for Sorcerers doe them seeking their owne glorie Saints doe them seeking the glorie of God Sorcerers doe them by certaine priuate contracts Saints doe them by publique administration and commaund of God vnto whom all things created are subiect 3 Now therefore since seeming miracles done by the Diuell The true Catholike church the approuer of true miracles exceeding the ordinarie power of Nature may deceiue many if they iudge their Doctrine by them and for that it is hard for a man to bee able to say whether a miracle bee done by the power of almighty God or by the power of the Diuell because both exceede our vnderstanding and the ordinarie course of Nature it stoode mee vppon to search out some infallible meanes by which I might bee assured that they were true miracles and such as I might confidently relie vppon In which scrutinie I could finde no better rule than to obserue whether they bee done in the Catholique Church or no which I doe learne out of Saint Augustine Aug. de vnit Eccles ca. 16. saying Whatsoeuer things of this quality are done in the Catholicke Church Therefore they are to bee approued because they are done in the Catholicke Church Therefore shee is not manifested Catholicke because those thinges are done in her Whereby it is cleere that miracles absolutely are not a proofe of the Catholicke Church but the Catholicke Church an approouer of true miracles whence it followeth That the miracles of the Primitiue Church were not so much a confirmation of her truth as her truth a confirmation of them Whence I obserue further That the present Church of Rome not beeing the true Catholicke Church because shee teacheth not the true Catholicke ancient Faith without mixture of many nouelties doth in vaine all eadge miracles in her behalfe which for that they are done out of the true Church are to bee reckoned amongst Antichrists lying signes prodigies Therefore I may pronounce confidently with S. Aug. vnto the Papists I say not that these things are so Aug. de vnit Eccles ca. 16. because such a one did such and such maruailes but let them proue their Church by the Canonicall bookes of the Scripture and by nothing else these are the demonstrations of our cause Note this these are our foundations these are our grounds whereupon we build Whereby wee see Miracles excluded from beeing a marke of the Church as the Cardinall Bellarmine would faine perswade the world that so his Romaine Church might bee approued for the true Church of God Vnapproueable therefore is the assertion of master D. Hill who chalengeth much vnto the Roman Church by her glorie of miracles wrought by her Saints his words are these The tenth reason of this quarterne Now it is so manifest that there haue beene an infinite number of miracles wrought by those who were of the Catholicke Romaine Religion and neuer any by them who were not of that Church since Christs time as he who shall deny it may bee prooued no lesse impudent and shamlesse than bee who shall denie that euer there was any Masse said in times past in England or that euer there were any warres betweene Turkes and Christians or that there bee any such countries as the East and West-Indies which thing if a man should denie would hee not of all men be deemed not only impudent but madde drunken or afoole In which words because Master Doctor Hill seemeth much to forget himselfe I must needs refresh his memorie with some few interrogatories What master Doctor I pray since Christs time did not Simmon Magus worke miracles who as Baronius saith Baron an 68. nu 22. made images to walke and would lie in the fire without hurt and flie in the ayre and make bread of stones hee could open doores fast shut and vnloose bands of iron and had many shadowes following him as it had been men Will you say he was a Roman Catholike Tacit. lib. 4. did not Vespasian the Emperour at Alexandria restore a blind man to sight will you say hee was a Roman Catholike Who be they Christ spake of when he said Matth. 7 22. Many will say to me in that day Lord haue we not by thy name prophesied and by thy name cast out diuels and by thy name done many great workes and then will I professe to them I neuer knew you depart from me yee that worke iniquitie What will you say that these workers of miracles and also of iniquity were of your Catholike Romane religion What think you of those Saint Augustine speaketh of August de vnit Eccles cap. 16. saying If there be done some miracles of heretikes we ought the more to take heed because when the Lord had said that there should be some deceiuers who by doing many signes should deceiue the very Elect if it were possible he did adde commending it vehemently said behold I haue foretold it vnto you What will you grant all these were of the Catholike Romane religion August tract 13. in loan What will you say vnto the same ancient Doctor in another place where he saith Against these miracle-mongers as I may so call them my God hath made mee warie saying In the last times there shall arise false Prophets doing signes and wonders What will you grant none of these to be yet come or will you grant them all to be of your religion What will you say to your Country-man Prompt mor. part aestiu pag. 627. dom 24. nu 4. Master Doctor Stapleton publike professor of Diuinitie in Louaine and if I mistake not your acquaintance in Doway who saith For the more triall of the godly not onely Antichrist himselfe and his nearest forerunners but all heretikes also may do true miracles by the permission of God as the sorcerers may doe Will you grant such forerunners and Heretikes to be of your Catholike Romane religion or will you say Doctor Stapleton erreth in calling them true miracles or will you recant your former assertion acknowledging your former mistaking and then shall I be as glad as now I haue commiseration of your error beseeching God in the meane time of his infinit mercie that you may see both your owne error and the errors of others of the present Romane religion and how different it is from the ancient Roman religion which in Saint Pauls dayes was famous through the world For my part I could not but vpon these and other considerations obserue the Church of England to be free from such false Prophets and Pseudochrists that they miracles as Christ fore told should deceiue the very Elect if it were possible for neither doe they pretend themselues to worke miracles and so to hunt after their owne estimation and applause for their holines as the teachers of the Roman Church do neither do they hold
great and more in number then euer before well she may be termed wicked and adulterous herein if when I consider what strange yea and often ridiculous miracles she pretendeth not only to iustifie falsehood sinne and impietie but also by them to commend the actors of them before all ancient Saints 6 Whereof I will now gentle Reader giue thee a taste by some few presidents happened in these latter ages of the world Examples of false miracles in the Church of Rome as the bookes and publike writings of the Church of Rome haue left recorded to the world which as they moued me to see mine owne former ouer-credulous spirit so haue they not strengthned me in the true faith wherunto through Gods exceeding great mercy I am now arriued And first for the iustification of Garnets innocencie in the busines of the Powder Treason what a ridiculous inuention is published and hath bin preached to the world by Costerus the Iesuite in Bruxells vpon the report but of a bare Letter from England some few yeres since when I liued in Louaine of a certaine prodigious straw in which a little bloud hath made such a liuely resemblance of his face that as it is by his fauorers reported and with mine owne eares I haue heard it it is one of the most stupendious miracles shewing Gods loue to their societie that euer hapned therfore since that time one M. Iohn Wilson the Author as is saide of the English Martirologe assuming vnto himselfe Papall Iurisdiction hath canonized him for a Saint in heauen who was put to death for concealement of treason against his King and Countrey whilest hee liued vpon earth Indeed I must needes confesse it a stupendious worke which since the first appearance thereof in print hath assumed not onely one but diuerse shapes for first at Louaine I saw it drawn with three horns of haire vpon his head ouer his forehead so that it appeared more like a monster than a man I saw him at Antwerpe after that drawne without those hornes yet a starre shining in the middest of his forehead in great glorie of which kind I saw many pictures in paper tendred by a Iesuitesse woman as she seemed by her habite and carriage to bee sold as the chiefe pictures then in request since that time here in England I haue seene a Latine booke in which another miracle as it should seeme hath beene added vnto it representing two Seraphines vnder his beard as it were holding vp his chinne that men might the better beholde his glorie But besides all these transformations one thing is most remarkable which I haue heard reported by diuers that is some can see this goodly Image at the first looking on it others canno see it till one of a better sight oint where it is and others can not behold the glorie thereof at all I haue spoken with some of those three kindes of beholders who according to the measure of their eie sight haue tolde mee as much besides at the first the picture of this miracle was very small but now it is greater and perhappes it will carry yet a greater shape and be the mother of miracles increasing to the end of the world and so surpasse all the miracles done in Christs time which were not permanent but transitory about which if a man should aske the Author of Pruritanus that monstrous and athisticall libell how so strange a miracle could be done he would soone no doubt answer you according to his sacrilegious manner of applying the sacred Scriptures with the Diuell quia scriptum est maiora hijs facietis Which words Saint Augustine expoundeth of the conuersions of sinners by the ministery of Preachers because the conuersion of sinners is the greatest worke of God Now beloued Reader how could I with any reason giue credite to this miracle howsoeuer at the first report I was ouer-credulous when I obserued the maner how it was carried and if such reuerend Fathers of the christian world will stand in defence of it and beknaue better men than themselues without regard to the magistracie as I heard one principal Father do in Bruxels in great choler indignation against those that should gainsay it I may beloued wel call in doubt enter into a iealous suspition of many other strange miracles deuised for the maintenance of vntruth falshoode by others of the Roman Church Secondly I remember an other strange miracle had it not proued false for the great credit of the Iesuites and their holysocietie in Persia Not long before the discouery of the Powder treason ther was dispersed by thē among some of their Catholike friends here in England a litle Pamphlet in the French tongue reporting the miraculous conuersion of the King of Persia The miracle of Persia by one Campion a Iesuit and Englishman that dispossessed one which had a diuell who commanded the diuell at his departure out of the body to giue a signe therof by striking downe the top of a steeple whereupon followed the Kings conuersion with many of the nobilitie to the Roman faith with liberty to preach it publikely and to build vp Churches and monasteries throughout all his Dominions Which of many here in England was beleeued to be true especially by a friend of mine vnto whom that Pamphlet was sent who requested me to say masse in thankesiguing to GOD for so great a benefit but in the end that Iesuit who sent the Pamphlet gaue out that it was but a thing deuised by French Hugonets to disgrace their societie What strange deuises are these What hatefull illusions wherewith honest sincere soules are made gulls through deceitfulnes and diuelish policies vsing all things for nothing but their owne ends I can not but now smile at my selfe to remember the plaine sinceritie of my heart in beleeuing this prettie inuention and with how thankefull a minde I offered vp the sacrifice of the Masse with a tacite and silent wish that God by the like meanes would procure the conuersion of England 7 Thirdly Other pretended miracles in the Church of Rome I will not omit here to call to mnind two strange miracles inuented to the honour of S. Francis that people might be the more excited to pray to him before all others The first I heard preached at S. Iames Church in Antwerpe in the Lent time some fiue yeres since by a Capuchine Friar and affirmed to be such an euident truth that no iust exceptions might be entertaind against it before a great assemblie and confluence of people Of one that roasted her childe with many particular circumstances of place and persons which made it carrie the more likeliehood of truth with it and since that time I know where it hath been related by the Prouinciall of the Franciscans here in England The storie in briefe is this in effect A certaine Gentlewoman there was in a towne in Sicilie some few yeeres since that longing much to taste of
many others which I haue before in the ninth Chapter shewed not to be ancient and consequently hereticall because they are new and aftercome into the Church 7 Againe The corrupt and rotten fruits of Romish doctrine when I considered further the second way to iudge of false prophets by the Church of Rome as Stapleton teacheth by the proper fruits of their doctrine I found also by this way the fruits of Romane teachers to be most corrupt and rotten issuing forth of their doctrine for what proceedeth from their dogmaticall teaching the lawfulnesse of the Stewes tolleration but too vnrefrained a licence and liberty of sinning to all that are loosely affected What greater incentiue to sin can there be for lasciuious persons then assurance of place and persons where conueniencie and consent may assuredly bee expected Or what greater occasion to yong persons prodigally to spend their temporall substance and ruine their soules then grant of such open passage to si◠What can more encourage poore minds to be dishonest then permission to get themselues liuings by dishonestie As also what can more demonstrate the Popes couetousnes and insatiable auarice then the permission of such offenders paying yearely tribute vnto him for the free exercise of all filthie abominations Againe what proceedeth from the prohibition of Priests marriage but infinite and almost innumerable sinnes against nature as bestialitie Sodomie vnnaturall euacuations Incest adulterie fornication sacriledges and a thousand other abominations which abound in the present Church of Rome whilest that lawfull wedlocke and honorable bed which Saint Paul calleth vndefiled may not be permitted nor commended without imputation of incontinencie sacrilege and filthy pollution which is truely the doctrine of Diuells as Saint Paul termeth it I omit to speake how many virgins haue beene defloured how many matrons dishonoured how many monastcries peruerted how many good husbands wronged how many widdowes abused how many wilfull abortments how many slaughters of children and other foule abominations committed by vnmarried Priests therefore though chastitie and single life are both highly commendable and profitable to him that hath the gift to liue so yet the restraint thereof hath more disgraced the Church of God then almost any one point whatsoeuer making euen sacred things to appeare to the world deformed and full of such blemishes as wil neuer be taken away I haue obserued further also that the doctrine of pardons for the release of temporall paines due to finnes either in this life or in Purgatory annexed vnto graines meddals crosses rings and the like paltry things which is a doctrine most currant in the Church of Rome doth serue for the root offpring of much couetousnes and auarice of much losse of time vnprofitably of simony in selling Masses which are counted sacred things for money of neglecting to pray for the liuing while so many dirges masses funerals trentals and Aniuersaries are said for the dead without fruit or profit nay how farre did Pope Gregorie Lipeloo in vita Greg. Mag. stiled the Great proceed in the vanitie of this doctrine whilest he praied not for deceased Christians only but for a damned Pagan who as it is fabulously writtē in his life and hath passed currant these many hundred years deliuered the soule of Traian the Emperour out of hell fire by his praiers which hath hitherto beene obtruded vnto the Christian world for an especial fauor shewed by God vnto that Pope which shall neuer be shewed vnto any other Be not these goodly illusions of the world most abominable abuses of religion growne vp in the Church of Rome enameled with zealous and charitable pretences whilest such tales must set forth this Popes worth and be beleeued and the holy Scriptures teaching no remission after this life must not be of any credit at all I haue noted many euil branches to rise out also frō another root of their doctrine which cōfisteth in teaching men to pray to Saints how much Gods glory thereby is takē from him is apparent to any man of experience trauel who hath seen obserued how much the outward solemnities of Saints daies do excell the solemnities of Sundaies which are the feasts of the Son of God that hath obserued many more Churches dedicated to thē then to God himself that hath noted the ordinary common praier of lay-men to be called our Ladies office whilest they haue none at all made in honor of the holy Trinity or of the Father or the Son only a short one they haue in honor of the holy ghost another of the crosse yet not free from superstition idolatry whilst they pray Officium sanctae crucis ad Mat. By the signe of the cresse to be deliuered from their enemies whilest they attribute the victory Christ got vpon the crosse to the crosse it self saying O victory of the crosse and admirable signe cause vs to hold our triumph in the heauenly court Againe Antipho By a tree we were made bond-mē by the holy crosse we are set free The fruit of the tree seduced vs the Sonne of God redeemed vs. And againe O blessed crosse c. sweet wood sweet nailes c. Antipho ad noc Againe O venerable crosse which hast brought saluation to wretches by what praise shall I extoll thee for that thou hast prepared vnto vs thy heauenly life Againe speaking to Christ By thy holy crosse thou hast redeemed the world c. Al which in my iudgement seemed very derogatory to Gods glory as tēding to a diuine worship of the creature for the Son of God And thus in their excessiue deuotions to Saints and creatures they haue little feeling or vnderstanding of the true loue and deuotion they should feele and shew to their Creator 8 When moreouer I consider how the Church of Rome freeth the Clergie from true obedience to temporall Princes Other instāces of the corrupt fruits of Romish doctrine by their immunity it pretēdeth they enioy euen by Gods law and great priuiledges freeing frō ciuil courts gouernment I find here an open gap made to al busie heads tumultuous spirits to say thinke do what they list against the sacred authority of Kings and Princes confirmed by God himselfe But withal when I adde the doctrine now so much taught in the Church of Rome by her false prophets viz. that the Pope hath power and ecclesiasticall authoritie from God for the good of the Church to depose Emperours Kings and Princes from their regal dignities kingdomes in the execution whereof the Pope himselfe as the head of Christianity wil be the chiefe iudge commander in his owne cause I find al the wals defences of security for Kings shaken to the ground and doores let open to the wicked intentions designmēts of factious spirits to plot against Kings and to subuert kingdomes with liberty of conscience free from all scruple or remorse Hence and from no other spring ariseth so much contempt in the
adore it but all the rest standing by and that are present although they receiue not Fourthly when it is set forth vpon the Altar for publike praier as experience sheweth in their fortie houres prater By which it is apparent how frequently the Church of Rome enforceth men to giue that worship which is only due to God vnto the Creature which is by them to bee worshipped as God For the Councell wordes are these Sess â—3 can 6. de sacr Euchar. If any shall say that Christ the only begotten Sonne of God is not to be adored in the holy Sacrament of the Eucharist with the worship of Latria yea externall and therefore not to bee worshipped with any peculiar festiuall collebritie nor the bee carried solemnely in Processions according to the laudable and vniuersall rite and custome of the holy Church or not to bee proposed to the people to bee adored and the adorers thereof to be Idolaters be he accursed Here is a strange peece of doctrine yet is it not vnaccompanied with the malediction of the Bishop of Rome I cannot obserue any place or passage of Scripture that makes for this doctrine no neither doth Stephanus Durantus cite either Scripture or other auncient Father that maketh for this Latria worship whence it followeth that it is a new doctrine vnheard of in the primer ages of Christs Church onely this I note that he citeth some auncient Fathers seeming to approue the worship of Christ in Heauen when they behold the Sacrament yea and also some kind of reuerence to the Sacrament but no such as is due to God but rather as may be thought such a kind of reuerence as is vsed in Baptisme and fit to bee vsed in the vse of signes of holy things and therefore to conclude since in the sacrifice of the Masse where the consecrated Hoast must be adored with Latria-worship most detestable Idolatrie is committed I could not but with a great dislike of so foule an abuse in doctrine disauow that Sacrifice of the Masse and hold it most abhominable in the sight of Almightie God Hence I conceiued the more worthily of his Maiesties iudgement and learning for if the verie essentiall parts of the publike sacrifice of the Masse haue no warrant in Scripture and the essentiall part thereof so idolatrous he might well confidently affirme of priuat Masse Praemonit If the Romish Church hath ioyned new articles of faith neuer heard of in the first 500 yeres after Christ I hope I shall neuer be condemned for an Heretike for not being a Nouleist Such are the priuat Masses where the Priest playeth the part both of the Priest and of the people For what an absurd thing is it for the Priest to say Dominus vobiscuÌ„ or orate fratres The Lord be with you or pray ye brethren or to turn about as if there were people to answere when nothing but bare wals appeareth saying Ite Missâ— est Go ye Masse is done Nay what a ridiculous prayer is it wheÌ„ the Priest saith vnto God none being present but either a man or a woman playing the office of a clerke Memento Domina famuloruÌ„ famularum In Can. Missae que tuaruÌ„ omniuÌ„ circuÌ„stantiuÌ„ queruÌ„ ubi fides cognita est nota deuotio pro qubius tibi offerimus c. Remember O Lord thy men-seruants and women-seruants and all that stand round about whose faith and deuotion is manifest and knowne vnto thee This is as ridiculous a false prayer as that which the Priests alwayes say vpon the feast of an ordinarie Confessor Ad sacrum cuius tumulum frequenter Membra languentum modo sanitati Quolibet morbo fuerint grauata Restituuntur Breuiar in com mu. Confessorum Vnder nunc noster chorus in honorem Ipsius hymnum canit hunc libenter Vt pijs eius meritis iuuemur Omne per aeuum Englished thus At whose sacred Tombe sicke people Euen now often with whatsoeuer Diseases they are oppressed are restored To health Our Quier therefore now in honor Of him singeth this Hymne willingly That by his pious merits we may be Holpen for euer Is not this strange that so notorious a lye must by millions of Romish Priests be sung and said vpon the Feasts of such Confessors at whose Tombes not so much as a lame dogge was euer cured and yet they sticke not to say that often and from euerie disease they are cured But by this it may be gathered that the Romish Church hath little care what she alloweth or practiseth how grosse or absurd soeuer it be so long as her erronious doctrines may either be beleeued or practised and hence shee suffereth the Latria-worship of the Hoast to be instilled into the vulgar sort of people without any remorse or scruple for so vnwarrantable an error 5 Now as for the ceremonies of the Masse The ceremonie of the Masse hath no certaine signification as I haue beene carefull to learne their meaning and significations thereby haue I also found as great cause to disgust the sacrifice of the Masse as for the former for so vncertaine is the disagreement of Romish Authors about them as none can be greater Michael the Suffragane of Mets tels vs The Amies that the Humerale which is made of thinne linnen Michael Suffragan Mongunt explic myst sacrosanct nus yet pure and cleane couering the Priests head signifieth Christs Diuinitie couered with fraile humane flesh free and cleane from sinne In another place he sayth That it designeth the indefatigable labour of doing good and chastitie of bodie and minde but Iacobus de Voragine sayth Iac. de Vor. ser de Sanct. de celibrat Mis ser 1. De ritibus eccle Catho c. 9. ff 6. Lib. 2. de sacra part 4. Part. 4 q 26. That it signifieth the Helmet of Saluation because he must appoach to the Altar with hope and confidence Stephanus Durantus that thereby is vnderstood the custodie of a mans mouth Hugo de Sancto victorie and Alexander de Ales thinke it signifieth the vaile wherewith the perfidious Iewes did couer the face of Christ The Albe according to Michael the Suffragane because it is cleane and closed round about the Priest designeth the most entire conuersation of Christ amongst all The Albe Ibid. And in another place he sayth it admonisheth vs of the innocencie and puritie we receiue in Baptisme But Iacobus de Voragine Ibid. Vbi supra more like a souldior will haue it signifie Loricam iustitiae because that as the Albe couereth the Priest all ouer so doth Iustice with other vertues couer the soule Ibid. nu 9. Stephanus Durantus will haue it signifie the perseuerance of good workes Germanus will haue it signifie the brightnesse of the Godhead In Theor. rerum Ecclesiast and the shining conuersation of a Priest Againe it representeth the white garment wherewith Herode did mocke Christ Stephanus Eduensis Bishop sayth that it designeth the glorie of
opinion of all the holy Doctors oâ— the Church that this bread and wine was offered for a sacrifice to God and not for a refection to Abraham both this exposition and assertion is false For both Tertullian contra Iudaeos and also Epiphanius expound it of his bringing foorth of bread and wine to Abraham Hebr. 55. Haeres 55. Epiphanius saith Abraham was about eightie eight or ninetie yeares old when Melchisedech met him and brought forth bread and wine vnto him Lib. 1. cap. 11. So also doth Iosephus expound it Melchisedech milites Abraham hospitaliter habuit nihil illis ad victum deesse passus simul ipsum adhibuit mensae Melchisedech vsed hospitality to Abrahams souldiers and suffered them to want no victuals and did take Abraham to his table That this is the true sense appeareth by the Hebrew word which doth not properly signifie to offer and sacrifice but to bring forth and the force of truth maketh some of the Romane Church to confesse this to be true Caietan in Gen. 1.14 Cardinall Caietan vpon this place writeth thus There is nothing heere said of sacrifice or oblation but of bringing foorth which Iosephus saith was done to the refection of them which had gotten the victory And that which in the vnlgar edition is put after as a cause for he was the Priest of the most high God in the Hebrew is not set as a cause but as a clause separated from it Andrad defens fidei â—rident lib. 4. Andradius also doth herein forsake his friends and acknowledgeth this to be the true exposition his words be these We need not Kemnitius to striue about the word offering seeing that both in the best corrected Latine copies and also in the holy Fathers which apply this place vnto the holy Eucharist it is proferens brought forth and I in iudgement agree with them which say that Melchisedech refreshed Abrahams souldiers wearied and fainted with long fight By which it appeareth how vnprofitably this place is cited for a figure prouing the sacrifice of the Masse wherein Christs true substantiall body blood is offred in sacrifice as the Church of Rome teacheth vnder the forme of bread and wine 11 Very impertinent further is that argument Bellarmine maketh for the Masse The Paschall Lambe falsely pretended to be a figure of the Masse De sacrific mis lib. 5. cap. 2. taken from the Paschall Lambe which he saith is an expresse figure of the celebration of the Eucharist saying That the celebration of the Paschall Lambe was an immolation of the victime which was offered therefore the celebration of the Eucharist must bee also an immolation of the victime offered vnto God that the figure may answere the thing figured It is a strange thing that so great a scholler will so impertinently alleage such an argument for who knoweth not that the Paschall Lambe was offered also by such as were no Priests or if they were as himselfe suggesteth concerning this sacrifice there remained an ancient priuiledge Li. 1. vitae Mosis that all housholders should exercise the priesthoode as may be seene in Philo. Besides any man may see that the figure doth not answere the thing figured because the immolation of the Lambe was bloudy which is not found in the sacrifice of the masse as the Aduersaries confesse as also for that the Lambe was sacrificed by a multitude which agreeeth not with the masse which is offered but by one Priest at a time And further in regard that the paschall Lamb was not propitiatorie for sinnes as hee holdeth the masse to be but was only done in commemoration of the Israelites freedome from Egipt There is no man lastly that is so ignorant but knoweth that the Paschall Lamb was a figure of Christs bloudy sacrifice vpon the Crosse and therefore it can onely be gathered hence that our Lamb Christ Iesus was to be sacrificed of whom Saint Iohn the Baptist said Beholde the Lambe of God that taketh away the sinnes of the world Now that we should offer Christ so as the Aduersaries teach vnder accidents without substance of bread and wine doth no where appeare And albeit some of the Church call the Eucharist by the name of a Sacrament yet doth it not follow that the masse is therefore to bee approoued as is the same for it is a fallacious argument from a thing spoken but in some respect to conclude the same thing absolutely The Fathers called the Eucharist a Sacrifice but in some respect onely as first in that all sacred rites may be called by the common word of the olde Testament Sacrifices Quasi à faciendo sacra from doing holy and sacred actions Secondly in regarde that in the Supper there is a commemoration of that onely and true sacrifice of Christ they gaue that name to the action from the chiefest and most principal respect Thirdly in regard of diuers prayers powred foorth in the celebration of the Supper Heb. 5.7 Reuel 5.8 8.4 which are called Sacrifices in the Scriptures Fourthly because the spirituall sacrifices of our soules as Faith Hope and Charitie are exercised and stirred vppe by the vse of the Supper that they euâ—r vnderstoode it to bee such a Sacrifice as our Aduersaries teach the masse where but the formes of the Creatures without substance are adored and worshipped as GOD himselfe and GOD himselfe sacrificed and offered in substance to GOD they will neuer bee able to prooue or make manifest either by Scriptures or approoued Writers of Antiquitie howsoeuer they may with Cardinall Bellarmine make shew to doe it as hee laboureth to doe by the former things so impertinently misapplied as the meanest Scholer is able to discouer their insufficiencie 12 Now therefore curteous Reader hauing thus obserued the sacrifice of the masse to bee vnwarrantable in the holy Scriptures My resolution vpon the obsâ—ruation of al the pâ—emises concerning the Masse and not approoued by the auncient Fathers as iâ— is now taught in the Church of Rome I could no longer continue in league and friendshippe with that Church which pretends so many proofes for it and hath none at all For finding as it appeareth by all my precedent obseruations in this Chapter that it was neuer instituted by Christ that the pretended propitiation thereof derogateth from the Sacrifice Christ made vpon the Crosse that it is but a nouell doctrine in many things vnknowne to the Fathers of former Ages that most hatefull Idolatrie is committed therein that it containeth ceremonies verie ridiculous and vncertaine in their meaning not knowne to the Church of Rome it selfe and such as are neyther ancient nor Apostolicall that it is maintained and defended by false deuised and baâ—â—ard writings that it hath many foolish and false prerogatiues giuen it by the Aduersaries that it is established and confirmed by many lying signes and wonders the arguments of an adulterous generation that the Types and Figures of the olde Testament make no whit for it
sweet prouidence and mercie for those that liue in a most blinded and yet zealous ignorance of the errors they are in wrapped in by the slights of their false teachers seducing them who are much more industrious and laborious for the kingdome of Antichrist than the true professors of the Gospell are for the kingdome of Christ according to our Sauiours owne words Prudentiores sunt filij tenebrarū quam filij lucis in generatione sua The children of darknesse are more prudent in their generation than the children of light Against whom I will daily pray that those who stand as sentinels ouer the reformed Churches may both haue aud carefully practise our Sauiours words in another place as an holesome Autidote Estote prudentes sicut serpentes simplices sicut columbae Be ye prudent like serpents and simple like doues vsing serpentine prudence to defend their faith and soueraigne rulers as their heads though with hazard of their owne bodies and liues and not omitting such a sweet doue-like simplicity and mildnesse without gall of malice that their aduersaries may be ouercome by the obseruation of their wisdome and their Christian-like charitie towards them 3 But to returne whence I am digressed The Church of Rome by terrors more thē by proofes endeuors to plant the beliefe of seuen Sacraments I discouer the idlenesse of the Romish Anathema by the error and noueltie of the doctrine of seuen Sacraments for the desence wherof the Councell hath thundered it out for I can find no Scriptures making properly for seuen no nor any one ancient Father reckoning seuen onely and no fewer nor more as for Baptisme and the blessed Eucharist there is no doubt to be made for all the things which the Church of Rome requireth to a Sacrament properly taken do concurre therein Belarm lib. 1. de sacra Bapt. cap. 1. Hebr. 6. vers 4. Ephe. 5. vers 26. Iohn 3. vers 5. the externall right is expressed in Saint Paul calling it The lauer of water in the word of life The institution and commandement vnlesse a man be borne of water and the spirit he cannot come vnto the kingdom of God c. and in going teach ye al people baptising them in the name of the Father Mark vlt. v. 16. and of the Sonne and of the holy Ghost the promise of grace who beleeneth and is baptised shall be saued but who beleeueth not shall be damned So likewise in the Eucharist the externall rite is found to be bread and wine Mat. 26. vers 26 Ioh 6. vers 57. The institution and commandement at the last supper do this in remembrance of me The promise of grace he that eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood abideth in me and I in him Whereby it is apparent that of these two Sacraments the Scriptures shew al the things most plainly belonging vnto a Sacramēt properly taken as the Church of Rome vnderstandeth of Sacrament with all the things necessarily belonging thereunto and therefore that these two are Sacramnts is cleere in their vnderstanding which the Church of England according to all antiquitie doth admit but the other fiue receiued by the Church of Rome either in one effētiall thing or other belonging to a Sacrament properly taken are defectiue as either in the sensible signe or in the institution and commandement or in the promise of grace notwithstanding that all must concurre according to the Church of Rome to a true Sacrament Now therefore although I could particularly shew by the disabling of the other fiue that there are not seuen Sacraments as the Councell of Trent defineth yet because I will auoid prolixitie I will only proue it by shewing that penance is no such Sacrament 4 All Diuines of the Church of Rome do ioyntly agree that euery Sacrament consisteth of matter and forme Penance no Sacrament properly neither is auricular confession any essentiall part thereof Tho. Aquin. part 3. quaest 84. art 2. in corp S. Tho. part 3. vbi supra art 3. in corp the matter say they of this sacrament are cōtrition cōfession and satisfaction for the sinnes on the behalfe of the penitent the forme is the words of absolution pronounced by the Priest Thomas of Aquine their cheefe Doctor saith thus The nearest matter of this Sacrament are the acts of the penitent whose matter are sins which he repenteth which he confesseth and for which he satisfieth And in the next article he sheweth the forme saying It is cleare that this is the most conuenient forme of this Sacrament I do absolue thee With whom Viguerius also agreeth saying Ioannes Viguer Instit cap. 16. vers 1. The nearest matter of the Sacrament of Penance are the acts of the penitent contrition confession and satisfaction the matter of which acts are sinnes which the penitent repenteth which he confesseth and for which he satisfiesh In whose assertions I obserue two notable errors first that they count Penance a Sacrament which is onely a vertue disposing men to the Sacrement of the Eucharist according to that Probet seipsum homo sic de pane illo edat Let a man proue himselfe and so eat of that bread which prouing must be by repentāce And secondly that they make auricular confession consisting in a circumstantiall enumeration of sinnes in their numerall distinct kinds to a Priest an effentiall part of that Sacrament neither of which can bee proued in Scriptures I cannot but admire to see so great a Doctor as Thomas Aquinas was Tho. Aquin. part 3. de sacra poenit art 1. sed contra Act. 8. to make a most weake argument for proofe of this Sacrament saying that as Baptisme is adhebited for the purification of sinne so Penance Therefore Peter said to Simon do penance for this thy wickednesse but Baptisme is a Sacrament as is said before therefore Penance also for the like reason Heere is a stout reason and of great force certes especially when we consider that the Angelical doctor following the vulgar translation misalleageth the Scripture for in the Greeke set out by Arias Montanus the Greeke word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 signifieth not do penance Arias Montan. in 8. Act. Apost vers 22. but repent thou as the same Author though a Romanist translateth it Neither is it heere to be omitted how notoriously the Rhemists do depraue the same place of Scripture who in excuse of their following the vulgar translation adde a notable falsehood and vntruth saying In annot Act. 8. vers 22. That the Greeke 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 doth signifie as much is it not strange then that Arias Montanus I thinke as good a Grecian as any of them would haue swarued from their translation but their imposture in this place is most inexcusable shewing that they care not what they say so they may crosse the reformed Churches as appeareth when in the table before the new Testament printed anno 1600 wherin they charge the English editions of false translation
much in one of his Epistles to make mention or to giue salutation to his consort Philippians 4. whome hee therefore denieth himselfe to carrie about that hee may bee the more ready to preach the Gospel 1. epistle of Saint Paul to the Corinthians And againe in the eight Booke of his worke he saith They say that Saint Peter when hee sawe his wife led vnto martirdome he reioyced in the grace of Election and at her returne vnto her owne house and cryed out vnto her when shee was ledde and calling her by her name said O wife remember the Lord. Such were the marriages of Saintes so perfect was the affection of the Blessed Thus hee who liued about the yeare of our Lord God one hundred ninetie and seauen in the time of Commodus the Emperour By which Doctrines and Examples in the Apostles times it is very euident that Priests and Bishops had wiues 5 In the Canons of the Apostles it is decreed thus A Bishop or Priest shall not The marriage of Priests proued by ancient Councels Dist 28. canon Si quis vnder the colour of Religion cast away his owne wife But if he doe reiect her hee shall bee excommunicated but if hee shall perseuere hee shall bee depriued Which Canon is related in an other place The most renowned generall Councell also held at Nice in the time of Constantine the Emperour about the yeare of our Lord GOD three hundred and thirtie where were likewise assembled three hundred and eighteene whereof also mention is made in the Tripartite Historie and elsewhere In the which Caution was made with full consent of all the Fathers Not to prohibite Subdeacons Deacons Lib. 2. cap. 14. dist 31. can Nyâ—en Syaâ—d Priestes or Bishoppes from sleeping with their wiues lest by that meanes a yoake should bee imposed vppon them which might bee a cause of fornication In which bufinesse Paphnutius who being himselfe single and most famous for leading holinesse of life and power of doing myracles laboured and obtained verie much Againe as in succeeding Ages some at Rome would haue induced Priestes and Deacons vnto single life or to abstinence from their wiues and went about to make Lawes to this purpose so in the yeare of our Lord God sixe hundred seauentie and seauen the sixth generall Councell was gathered at Constantinople in the time of Constantine the fourth whereat there were present two hundred foure score and nine Bishoppes for which cause some will haue it of the same authoritie with the Euangelicall Bookes in which Councell some things concerning the marriage of Priestes were decreed making mention of them who at Rome laboured much in that matter the words of the Councell are recorded in the corpes of the Connon Lawe in these verie wordes Dist 31. can quoniam in Romam For as much as wee vnderstand it to be deliuered in the order of the Romane Canon that those who are ordained Deacons or Priests shall not accompanie with their wiues we following the ancient Canon of Apostolicall diligence and the constitutions of holy men will indeed haue legall mariages to be of force in no case dissoluing their marriages which their wiues nor depriuing them of familiaritie together in fit season Whosoeuer therefore shall bee found worthie to be ordained Deacon or Subdeacon or Priest such shall in no case be prohibited from ascending to such degree for cohabitation with his wife neither likewise shall they be constrained at the time of their ordination to professe chastitie And forthwith sentence is pronounced against those that shall presume againt this in these words If therefore any shall presume against the Apostles Canons to depriue any Priests or Deacons from the company and communion of their legall wife let him be deposed likewise the Priest or Deacon who for religions sake shall expell his wife let him be excommunicated and if he shall persist in this let him be deposed The same sixt Sinode decreed as appeareth in the Canon law That the Priest who liueth not in lawfull marriage Dist 28 Canon Presbiterum should abstaine from his office Now when I obserued thus in the Canon of the generall Councel mention to be made of the Canon of the Apostles which I haue before rehearsed and also the constitution of the Nicene Councell and with the generall consent of the Councell of Constantinople those to be condemned excommunicated and deposed that would defend the Romane Canon or compell any to keepe it I could no way satisfie my selfe how the mariage of Priests prohibited now in the present Church of Rome is not flat against these ancient generall Councels If Bellarmines assertion be true That a Councell is an assemblie of true Iudges De Concil lib. 1. cap. 18. lib 2. de Concil authorit cap. 1. whose decrees are necessarily to be followed As also againe if it be true That by the Catholike faith wee are to hold that generall Councels confirmed by the high Bishop cannot erre neither in faith nor manners As Bellarmine in another place affirmeth what excuse can the Church of Rome pretend to free her selfe from disobedience to the aforesaid Councels and dischrge her selfe from heresie in not beleeuing what the Councels confirmed by a high Bishop and by the Christian world acknowledged The cited ancient Councels alloweth Priests marriages the late Councell disalloweth them therefore the best conclusion that any man of iudgement can make hereupon is that the former are to be embraced and the latter to be reiected 6 I cannot but wonder to see how the Church of Rome swarueth from the marke of antiquitie in prohibiting or making a law to restraine Priests from the lawfull estate of wedlocke Proofes of antiquitie for the marriage of Priests I find that one Dionisius Bishop of the Corinthians who flourished in the time of Antonius Verus that is about the yeare of our Lord 164. as Eusebius relateth Euseb Eccles hist lib. 4 cap. 23. wrote an Epistle to the Gnosians in the which he warneth and entreateth Pynitus their Bishop not to lay heanie burdens vpon the shoulders of his disciples nor to intimate vnto his brethren the necessitie of enforced chastitie whereby the infirmitie of many shall be end angered Concerning the which Pynitus wrote backe vnto Dionisius embraced his good aduice and counsell and withall entreated him to send him whatsoeuer other spirituall food what strong and sound I haue noted likewise that Origen who succeeded Clement in the Schoole of Alâ—xandria Origen hom 25. in Matth. about the yeare two hundred as Saint Hierome witnesseth expounding th Gospell of Saint Matthew hath left these words toposteritie against the commanders of single life The Lord reprehendeth saith he such teachers who only doe not which they say but also cruelly and without mercie not according to the estimation of euery hearers strength do enioyne things aboue their power as namely who forbid to marrie and who compell from that which is expedient to immoderate
vncleannesse I haue read also that Gregorie Nazianzen Gregor Nazian Bishop for the funerall of his father who was a Bishop and of his Gorgonia that he made most learned sermons in which it is manifest to be seene with what holinesse the Bishops and Ministers of the Churches liued in the state of wedlocke I find further that Saint Iohn Chrysostome vpon those words of Esay I saw the Lord sitting Chrysost hom 4. speaketh most honorablie of the marriage of the Apostles and Apostolicall men Who also saith in another of Saint Philogonius that he was an aduocate In orat de S. Philogonio but afterward was made a Bishop and in time of his being Bishop had a lawfull wise and a daughter I obserue also that Saint Hierome seemeth to insinuate In 6. cap. Pauli ad Ephesios that till his time Bishops and Priests were married according to the Apostles meaning Let Bishops and Priests reade this saith he who bring vp their children in ecular learning and make them to reade Comedies and to sing the lasciuious writings of Iesters being bred vp perhaps with Ecclesiasticall reuenues And alittle after Heli the Priest himselfe was holy yet because he instructed not his children in all discipline and correction he fell downest it to the ground and so died Distinct 37. Canone legunt Which words are to be seene in the Canon law I find also Saint Ambrose to say that the integrity of the bodie is to be wished for by vs which of counsell I perswade Quaest 32. ca. 1. integritas and not out of power do command For virginitie alone is that which may be perswaded and may not be commanded it is a matter rather of wish then of precept Which words do not a little tâ—xe them that enact lawes to make men liue single liues neither are Saint Chrysostomes words vnlike vnto those of Saint Ambrose Hom. 10. in epist ad Iimoth who treating of the marriage of Priests speaketh most plainly saying It is lawfull for him that will honestly to embrace marriage for as riches doe difficultly lead into the kingdome of heauen yet many rich men haue often entered thither euen so marriages though they haue many difficulties in them yet they may be so vsed as not to be any impediment to perfection of life Who in another place speaketh more plainly vpon those words of Saint Paul Whosoeuer without fault is a man of one wife Chrysost hom 2. in epist ad Tit. saith thus The Apostle intendeth to stop her mouthes of Heretikes that condemne marriage shewing that thing to want fault yea to be soprecious that therewith also any bodie may be promoted vnto the holy seat of a Bishop I find further that Primasius a disciple of Saint Augustine as some hold where the Aostle prescribeth what kind of children Bishops children ought to be doth not obscurely handle this matter Primas super verba Apostoli when he saith He that hath not knowne how to instruct a few children how shall he gouerne so many children of God that is all the people Neither are Histories of antiquitie wanting to proue the marriages of Priests Eusebius hath left recorded that Polycrates Bishop of the Ephesians maketh mention of seuen of his predecessors Euseb eccles Hist lib. 5. c. 24. of whom he was borne who in order were Bishops and himselfe to haue been the eight Whose words also Saint Hierome reporteth who liued in the timne of Seuerus In lib. de scripto eccles Hist eccles lib. 6. cap. 42. The same Author likewise hath left recorded that Cheremon Bishop of Nilus a towne of Egyyt with his aged wife was banished for Christ which Author maketh mention also of diuers other married Bishops I haue found that Spiridion Bishop of Tremithunth a husband-man also in the Bishopricke of the Cyprians Hisotr Tripartit lib. 〈◊〉 cap. cap. 10. and a shepheard of sheepe had wife and children neither for that was he the lesse famous for Diuine matters I haue read also that Eupsychius of Caesaria in Capadocea Priest Histor tripartii lib. 5. cap. 14. when hee was but newly married at that time to haue ended his life with a glorious martyrdome Many others might be alleaged and this was the custome of the ancient Church in the East many out of their owne free will euen Bishops abstained Tripartit hist lib. 9. cap. 38. and many of them also in time of their Bishoprickes by their lawfull wiues had children Neither was it the custome in the East but also in the West Church Hilarie Bishop of Pictauia is well knowne and is reported by many to haue been married The words of Damasus are plaine who saith Exquadam Epist ad diuum Hieron Osâ—us Pope was the sonne of Steuen a Subdeacon Boniface Pope was the sonne of Iucundus Priest de titulo fasciolae Agapetus Pope the sonne of Gordian Priest Theodorus Pope the sonne of Theodorus Bishop of the citie of Hierusalem Siluerius Pope sonne of Hormista Bishop of Rome Deusdedit Pope son of Iucundus Priest Felix the third a Romane sonne of Felix Priest who was his father Gelasius an Africane was borne of his father Valerius Bishop and many other are found who haue gouerned the Apostolicall sea that were borne of Priests Thus much saith Damasus Pope who was Bishop of the Church of Rome about the yeare of our Lord 380. and a little after Gratianus ad canonem Cenomanensem addeth that they were borne in lawfull marriages which then were euery where free for Priests I omit to speake of Nicholas the first who would not trouble the Bulgarian Priests for marriage but suffered them quietly to liue in that estate Rescriptum eius ad Bulgaros dist 28. canone consulendum who liued about the yeare of our Lord 866. And so I ouer-passe many other Popes after his time who were sonnes to Bishops and Priests as might easily be proued out of Platina who writeth their liues By all which proofes both out of holy Fathers and ancient Historiographers I find the state of marriages iustifiable before God and man 7 Now when the law came in that debarred them of this priuiledge and honorable estate it is easily to be discouered The Prohibition of Priests marriages when it came into the Church of Rome to haue bin in the time of Siricius the Bishop of Rome 380. yeares after Christ before which time it was beleeued and practised that Priests might haue wiues as freely as other men and Siricius was the first that forbad it I find first that before his time Priests exercised their functions being married men Aduers haeres verb. Sacerdot haeres 4. asis acknowledged by Alphonsus who writeth that in the Primitiue Church it was obserued that he which was maried might be promoted to Priest-hood though it were not required of him that he should first be married he addeth that this eustome preuailed till the times of the Nycene Councell
And diuers other writers affirme Scot. 3. d. 37. Cost Enchir. pag. 51. that in the most ancient times of the Church and after the Apostles death they had their wiues And I obserue that hee was the first that forbad Priests to marrie Greg. à Valent. tom 4. d sp 9. q. 5. punct 5. §. 1. Dist 82. plurim Inuent lib. 5. cap. 4. Dist 84. cum in preterito gloss §. qui Sacrament Index expurg 381. uum 261. Naucler tom 2. generat 137. Jnuent lib. 5. cap. 4. Sigebert an 1074. Lambert pag. 201. 207. Auentine in Annal. lib. 5. Nauclâ—r vol. 2. ge 36. Baron an 174. Sigon reg Jtal. lib. 9. an 174. pag. 448. pag. 460. by the decree thereof extant in the Canon law as also by the confession of Polydor Virgil and the Glosse vpon the Canon law saith Syricius brought in the continencie of Priests and Deacons yea some affirme that of old before the time of Siricius Priests might contract marriage This Glosse Pius Quintus the late Pope hath commanded to be wiped out because it makes against the present doctrine of the Church of Rome but Nauclerus saith in effect as much that SyriÌ„cius commanded Deacons to be continent But although Pope Syricius began this matter yet as Polydor Virgil saith It could neuer be effected that their marriage should be taken away til Gregory the seuenth came to be Pope in the yeare 1074. Which thing when he attempted in Germany he was opposed against as one that brought in a new eustome neuer receiued before Auentine writeth that in those daies Priests had wiues openly as other men bad and begate children their wiues being called by aseemely name Presbyteresses And when the Pope forbad them marriage this to many Bishops and other learned and good men seemed a new doctrine and a pestilent heresie as euer troubled any Christian kingdom And he saith the Bishops of Italy Germanie and France met together and for this cause decreed that he had done against Christian pietie and deposed him for that among diuers other things he diuorced men and their wiues denying such as bad their lawful wiues to be Priests wheÌ„ yet in the meane time he admitted to the altars whore-mongers adulterers and incestuous persons Fast lib. 1. Mantuan saith that Hilarie a Fench Bishop was married and that in his time it was lawfull Sinesius the Bishop of Ptolomais writeth thus of himselfe Epist ad Enopt Niceph. lib. 14. cap. 55. The sacred hand of Theophilus hath giuen me a wife and hereupon I testifie vnto all men that I will neither forsake her nor yet as an adulterer keepe her company but I will pray God to send mee by her many and good children Athanasius reports that Bishops and Monkes liued married Epist ade Dracont Epist 321. Pius 2. apud Plaitn in vita and had children And Pius Secundus saith It is better for a Priest to marrie then to burne though hee haue vowed not to marrie And moreouer that there bee many reasons to forbid Priests marriage but more to allow it But no maruaile that this restraint was made by the Pope since the prohibition of marriages is a plaine marke of Antichrist who should bring in the contempt of women for after that the Prophet Daniel had said that Antichrist should persecute the holy teachers and the pious beleeuing people Daniel 11. and should exalt himselfe aboue all God hee addeth Hee shall know nothing of the God of his Fathers and hee shall know nothing of the loue of women and of euery God and that hee shall magnifie himselfe aboue all things Which version agreeth with the Hebrew truth and with the seuentie Interpretors and Aquila Therefore let not any man oppose that which is carried about and in which it is read Hee shall bee in the concupiscences of women Where Saint Hierome himselfe in his Comentaries vpon Daniel interpreteth this sentence thus That Antichrist shall counterfeit chastitie to deceiue many By all which it is manifest that this law restraining Priests from marrying is a noueltie brought into the Church by Popes by degrees and a great wrong vnto the state of marriage which I haue shewed to be honorable in all This I could exemplifie by the abuses come into the Church by this restraint both in former ages and in this present age wherein wee liue If this law had not been it is likely that Matthaeus Parisiensis would haue had no cause to leaue recorded vnto posteritie that a Cardinall did all the day in a Synode heere in England inueigh against the marriages of Priests Matth. Parisan Henric. primum who at night was taken in bed with a strumpet there are too many to bee found as carnall as this Cardinall If this law of the Pope had not restrained Priests from marrying occasion would neuer haue been giuen for a Gentleman in Wales this last yeare to haue written vnto Master Birkhead the Arch-priest complaining of a Iesuite who by the heate of the powder-treason was thought to be driuen into Ireland where he got his owne kinswoman with child neither would many the like abuses bee complained of in diuers if the wicked restraint of marriages which is in truth the very doctrine of Diuels had neuer been made and inuented Gentle Reader pardon mee if these obscaenities offend your eares I may as well relate truthes in iustification of true doctrine against the Church of Rome as that Church both by reports and printed bookes may disgorge multitudes of lies against the reformed Church of England your deare countrey I do not this of any delight I take to walke in the wayes of sinners bt onely to discouer the wickednesse of their doctrine by such their wicked fruits as iust punishments inflicted by Gods permission that they may see their errors and forsake their wicked wayes Now therefore since it appeared vnto me by these premises how the Church of Rome against the law of God against the practise of the purest ages to the scandall of the Christian world through Satans craft vnder pretence of chastitie restrained Priests from lawfull marriages I could not remaine in the communion of that Church lest by Gods permission in time I might also be partaker of her iust punishments 8 And as I was moued to abaÌ„don her by reason of this illusioÌ„ whereby the diuel maketh her his The Church of Rome alloweth of incestuous marriages so was I no lesse moued by the coÌ„sideration of her doctrine permitting such mariages to be lawful in such degrees as som of their own teach to be prohibited by the law of God nature as namely by suffering one brother to marrie his brothers wife when the other is deceased For so doth the Pope by dispencing in this case which notwithstanding is iustly to be reprooued as I proue out of Ioannes Viguerius the learned Bishop of Spaine who deliuereth his Doctrine thus It is a doubt Io. Viguer
by the secret vertue of the Stone after an inuisible manner adioyning the Rings together a goodlie entire Chaine was made of them Euen so dearely beloued Christian Reader I finde Christ Iesus to haue beene such a powerfull and attractiue Loadstone vnto my Soule by the precedent obseruations lincking the one vnto the other with such infallible truth that therewith euen as with a most strong chaine of his excessiue loue and charitie hee hath now at the length drawne mee to the knowledge of his true Faith rightly taught and professed in the Church of England 2 It is no other than a chaine of Charitie A briefe recapitulation of the premised obseruations by which hee hath drawne mee to write this Treatise for the manifestation of his truth to those that are ignorant thereof It was a chaine of his prouidence by ministring occasions of times persons and places concurring to my conuersion It is a chaine of truth that euery mans chiefe businesse in this life must bee to attaine vnto the end he is created vnto by God or else hee receiueth his soule in vaine It is a chaine reaching from heauen that a supernaturall and reuealed knowledge from God is necessarie to saluation The obseruation also of an absolute necessitie of a supernaturall Faith is a strong chaine to draw any man to search diligently after it The knowledge likewise of the right rule and golden mete-wand of true Faith consisting of GODS sacred Word is a most forcible chaine to drawe Christians vnto the right knowledge of GODS truth The true knowne visible Church of Christ teaching the true sense of Scriptures is a powerfull chaine to draw men vnto the right faith of CHRIST IESVS Conformitie of Doctrine with the ancient doctrine of the Primitiue Church being a proper marke of the true Church of God is likewise a most attractiue chaine drawing to the true knowledge of right Christianitie The wonders and supposed miracles which Christ fore-told the Pseudo-Christs and false Prophets should doe for the seducing of Gods Elect if it were possible are also a strong chaine to draw any man from the Church of Rome The great hypocrisie of false Teachers fore-spoken of in the holy Scriptures agreeing chiefly with the Church of Rome are a chaine of great strength and power to draw any man from that Church The fruits by which false Prophets are to bee knowne and discerned abounding in the Church of Rome are also a powerfull chaine to draw any man of true iudgement from the abhominiations of that Church The discouerie of the Sacrifice of the Masse to bee Idolatrous which is accompted by the Church of Rome the chiefest act of religion that can bee done to God is a most forcible chaine to draw any man to the knowledge of CHRIST IESVS once offered for vs procuring our Sanctification Is not the proofe of Transubstantiation also to bee a noueltie a potent chaine to draw any man from Rome to the Church of England where the Sacrament is freed from such disgrace Is not the Amputation also of the holy Eucharist a powerfull chaine to draw men from the Church of Rome that they may rightly according to Christs institution bee partakers of the Lords Supper else where Is not also the noueltie of the Popes Pardons and Indulgences which is annexed to Crosses Graines and Meddals a powerfull chaine to draw any man that is not ridiculously childish a stronge chaine to draw him from the Church of Rome If the false doctrine of seuen Sacraments be well discouered by any man bee can not want a strong chaine to draw him to acknowledgement of two true Sacraments instituted by Christ if the doctrine of the Virgin Maries conception in originall sinne bee doubtfull in the Church of Rome the truth of Scriptures shewing it certaine may serue for a strong chaine to draw any man from that doubtfulnesse If the pretended chastitie of the Romish Clergie doe make the Church of Rome seeme more pure and holy than any other the prohibition of lawfull marriage to Priests and the dispensation and permission of vnlawfull marriage to kindred may bee as a strong chaine to draw deceiued soules from the filth and impurities of her hypocriticall holinesse By these the mightie strength power of all those chaines hath the goodnesse of almightie God deliuered my long estraied soule out of her dangerous waies setled me in the happie societie of his true faithfull beleeuers teaching the true ancient Catholike and Apostolike faith Oh how truly may I now say with holy Dauid in humble acknowledgement of Gods singular mercies vnto my soule Maruailous are thy workes Psal 139.14 O Lord and that my soule knoweth right well 3. Now it is time To all Seminarie Priests O all yee Seminarie Priests in this Land or else where who labour still in the same blindnesse and errours wherein hitherto I haue beene my selfe inwrapped as in a darke cloude that out of that true charitie and zeale of your soules good and happinesse wherewith I haue cause to be affected towardes you I direct my speech a while vnto you and manifest the sincere candor of my heart and affections to pittie your case as I haue had cause to bee sorrie for it heretofore in my selfe and therefore I can not but admonish you of the perill you liue in both of body and soule for looking no better into the doctrines which you teach You pretend to bee the salt of the earth Math. 5. vers 13. and the light of the world therefore you haue cause to see well that your doctrine bee sound wherewith you season mens soules and that the example of your vertues and life bee not hypocriticall and superstitious if your salt bee infatuated with nouelties and corrupt doctrines all the world will trample vpon you and you are only fit to bee cast out vnto the dunghills if your liues giue no true light but bee a couered vnder the appearance only of vertues as vnder a bushell where there is no corne your poore followers will bee hunger starued and runne into darkenesse and neuer finde the true light of the world CHRIST IESVS Who illuminateth as Saint Iohn saith Ioh. 1. vers 9. euery man comming into this world If it bee true that CHRIST saith Hee that doeth and teacheth Math. 5.19 shall bee called great in the Kingdome of hâ—auen Vnlesse both these duties goe together without mixture of falshood and finne you can neither bee great in Heauen nor in Earth but certaine I am your paines will bee great in the deepedungeon of hell Examine well your owne consciences both for doctrine and conuersation build not vpon other mens bookes only but examine their doctrines by the infallible rule of Scriptures send your Disciples vnto Christ as Saint Iohn Baptist did not to the Popes who can and haue erred both in doctrine and manners say vnto your Children as Christ our Lord and Master said Search the Scriptures c. because
DOCTRINALL AND MORALL OBSERVATIONS CONCERNING RELIGION WHEREIN THE AVTHOR DECLARETH THE Reasons of his late vn-enforced departure from the Church of ROME and of his incorporation to the present Church of ENGLAND teaching maintaining and defending the true Christian Catholike and Apostolike Faith professed by the ancient Primitiue Church most conspicuous in the outward vertues and constant sufferings of many holy Bishops and other good Christians glorious in the crowne of Martyrdome By IOHN COPLEY Seminarie Priest LVKE 22.23 When thou art conuerted strengthen thy brethren IAMES 5.20 He which maketh a sinner to be conuerted from the error of his way shall saue his soule from death and couereth a multitude of sinnes LONDON Imprinted by W. S. for Richard Moore and are to be sold at his Shop in Fleet-street in Saint Dunstans Church-yard 1612. TO ALL SEMINARIE PRIESTS MONKES FRIERS IESVITES AND ALL LAY-PROFESSORS of the present Romane falsely pretended Catholike faith grace and true conuersion in Christ IESVS VVHereas now some monthes are ouer-passed since my conformitie to the Church of England wherof I haue hitherto beene silent withdrawing myselfe to further the contemplation of those inducements which lead mee hereunto my zeale of truth and knowledge of your great spiritual miseries who liue wrapped in a cloud of ignorance depriued of the most comfortable beames of true Christian faith working by the heate of charitie in mens soules enforceth me to dedicate these my doctrinall and morall obseruations vnto your selues as standing in most need of them My intention in dedicating them to you is no other then true compassion of your soules dangerous estate not seeing nor knowing your owne erroneous doctrines taught in the present Romane Church of which I dare say many of you are sincere zealous professors with onely regard to your soules health and the kingdome of heauen esteeming that aboue all things to bee the cheifest to bee sought for in this world is in truth it is and therefore your case the more worthie of Christian commiseration and true Apostolicall endeauours for your deliuerie out of your so perillous and lamentable a condition which according to the small portion of that talent that Almightie God hath vouchsafed to bestow vpon mee I haue endeuoured to shew vnto you by this Treatise desiring you curteously and charitably to accept in good part with no lesse humility and care of your owne soules good then I do present it vnto you with a sincere desire thereof in the most tender bowels of Christ Iesus Vouchsafe to reade it with deliberate iudgement examine well the spirit wherewith it is written weigh the substance and contents rather then the manner or circumstances of my writing the stile is but plaine and familiar you shall find no affectation of eloquence in it because my labours and paines taken herein haue been rather for the profit of your soules then for the recreation of your wits I know well that neither the planting of Saint Paul nor the watring of Apollo can redound to your profit vnlesse God giue encrease and prosper the successe and therefore leauing the encrease to God and desiring you most attentiuely to reade these my obseruations deliberately to ponder them and effectually to follow them I most kindly take my leaue of you with Saint Pauls charitable words Pax Dei quae exuperat omnem sensum custodiat corda vestra intelligentias vestras in Christo Iesu Philip. 4.7 The peace of God which passeth all vnderstanding keepe your hearts and intelligences in Christ Iesus Resting this 13. day of Iune Anno Domini 1612. A most zealous friend and louer of your soules IOHN COPLEY ¶ Aduertisements to the Reader ALbeit to my singular comfort Christian Reader I might in the Sunne-shine of mine owne happinesse haue enioyed to my selfe the great benefite of Gods fauour shewed mee in my conuersion from Romish nouelties to the ancient Catholike Faith taught in this Kingdome yet for that I had diuers reasons inuiting mee to the participation thereof vnto other mens knowledge that what was priuate to my selfe might be also a publique good vnto others I haue thought it expedient with the promulgation of it for thy better information concerning my selfe to propound vnto thee some particular Aduertisements whereby thou mayest the better know mee and my meaning who am otherwise perhappes vnknowne vnto thee and accordingly with moderation of iudgement void of impatient humour or partialitie censure my proceedings in the matters handled in this Treatise 2 First therefore I would haue thee take notice that some few more zealous and earnest than charitable or wise followers of the Church of Rome sticke not to obiect vnto mee That they cannot be perswaded that I am truly in iudgement vnderstanding a sincere Professor of the faith of England otherwise than for some priuate respect eyther of liberty or other contentment or preferment whereby you may well inferre that they haue no great opinion of any ignorance in me of their Doctrine nor of actual miscarriage in maners that should make me forsake their communion since they thinke I haue too much knowledge to be in heart of any other and yet can charge mee of no misdemeanour for mine owne part I must needes tell you that herein they are either very ignorant in their vnderstandings or malitiously affected in their willes ignorant of the true knowledge of Gods fauour in conuerting sinners and malitious to the Church of England whereunto I haue incorporated my selfe and therefore to disgrace it they are willing without either true vnderstanding or vertue to cast any sinister imputation they can vpon my person which I doubt not but by Gods assistance and the endeuors of patience and diligence I shall turne to their owne shame and to the further manifestation of the wicked doctrines and impieties of their Romish Church without any indignitie or disgrace to the Church to which I am now incorporated 3 Secondly I would further haue thee know that some few Priests of their Church hauing growne debauched in their liues and conuersations and after their forsaking communion with the Church of Rome for a cloake of liberty to their lewd inclinations haue proued most treacherous to those vnto whom before they professed friendship remaining in their owne consciences perswaded they did not well in discouering Priests and causing them to be apprehended and ransacking the houses of Recusants more for their own profits than for any desire of seruice to the state or zeale to the Church of England giuing ouer all exercise both of vertue or learning fit for Cleargy men Hereupon diuers of the Romaine Church haue made their aduantage for the iustification of their owne Religion and reproofe of theyr aduersaries faith insomuch that I heard a Iesuit of good reputation say that a great noble man of this realme being in conference with others of his rancke should say that he much wondred why such men as were vertuous in their cariages so long as they were
of Rome Fol. 171. Chap. 15. Containeth an obseruation of the Pardons and Indulgences which the Pope annexeth to Crosses Graines and Meddalls Fol. 180. Chap. 16. Containeth an obseruation about the number of seuen Sacraments admitted by the Church of Rome Fol. 189. Chap. 17. Containeth an obseruation about the doctrine of the Virgine Maries conception in originall sinne Fol. 206. Chap. 18. Containeth an obseruation of the honorable state of Marriage prohibited by the Church of Rome to Priests who by Gods law may lawfully liue in it and allowed to those who by Gods law can not liue together without Incest Fol. 214. Chap. 19. Containeth the Conclusion to the Reader with a recapitulation of all the precedent obseruations for the Readers profit Fol. 213. DOCTRINALL and Morall Obseruations concerning Religion CHAP. I. Containing the first obseruation shewing the reasons and occasions of this Treatise AMONGST all the things which draw men into admiration Great is the benefit of true conuersion because it manifesteth the power of God and which doe see me to happen contrarie vnto common course and order worthily may the conuersion of soules from the waies of sinne and iniquitie chalenge the first place and is to be esteemed as the greatest for this is the most excellent worke the Heauens doth affoord vs and the most wonderfull that the infinite power of God infinitely powerfull can performe This the prime Doctor of the Romane Church most clearely intimateth Tho. Aquin. 12. q. 113. saying Maximum opus Dei est iustificatio impij The iustification of a sinner is the greatest worke of God according to that of the Kingly Prophet Miserationes eius super omnia opera eius Psal 144. vers 9. his mercies are aboue all his workes yea and the Church of Rome to keepe fresh the memorie of this document prayeth to God yearely in these words Deus qui omnipetentiam tuam parcendo miserando maxime manifestas In Dom. 20. post Pent. O God that by pardon and mercie chiefely manifestest thy Almightie power Which veritie also S. Augustine confirmeth saying vpon those words of S. Iohn Greater workes than these shall he doe Ioh. 14. v. 12. August tract 72. in Ioh. post Med. tom 9. Maius opus est vt ex impio iustus fiat quam creare coelum terram it is a greater worke for a sinner to be made righteous than to create heauen and earth This though it seeme a paradox is most true for certainely albeit the creation of the world was a maruellous worke yet the iustification and conuersion of a sinner is much fuller of admiration God framed and moulded the world almost in a moment of time and brought foorth all creatures in a short time as it were into the field but to abolish the turpitude and foulenesse of onely one originall sinne he vsed the delay of fiue thousand yeares and to bring this worke to perfection his onely sonne Christ Iesus endured three and thirtie yeares exile from his heauenly Kingdome For the worke of creation God did but speake Psal 148. vers 5. Dixit facta sunt but for this other worke Christ was to suffer and die Oportebat Christum pati Luk. 24. vers 16. ita intrare in gloriam suam it was behoofefull for Christ to die and so to enter into his glorie therefore Saint Augustines sentence of true conuerts is to be noted Augustin in Sermon saying Conuersio ad bonum non homini sed Deo adscribenda the conuersion of a sinner vnto good is not to be ascribed vnto man but vnto God who of himselfe can doe all things by his power 2 Now verily as iustification and remission of sinnes is the greatest worke of God Great also because it manifesteth the glorie and wisdome of God manifesting his infinite power and mercie so neither is there any worke of his more forcible to set out his glorie and wisedome vnto the world than the same It is a glorie vnto the artificer to delineate most perfect colours of Emblemes vpon base yron and hard steele The skill also of the Physitian is praise-worthie when hee freeth one from danger that is poysoned and swolne by the biting of a Viper with a present Antidote so the glorie of God and his goodnesse chiefely shineth in the conuersion of sinners So it shined in Saint Paule the Apostle when hee being infected with the poyson of infidelitie and swolne therewith Spirans minarum caedis Actor 9. vers 1. breathing forth threatnings and slaughter against the Disciples of the Lord Christ appearing verie oportunely vnto him cured him and strengthened him in faith Hereby appeareth the frailtie of humane nature and the power of Gods grace which redoundeth much vnto the glorie of his Saints whilest calling vnto their remembrance their passed dangers they behold their happie securitie of present glorie euen as the Mariner after the danger of shipwracke reioyceth as a sicke person reioyceth after therecouerie of a perillous disease and as conquering souldiors triumph and glorie the more in their victories by how much their hazards and encounters were strong This Saint Augustine teacheth most elegantly saying Nimis exultant Sancti dum praeteriti periculi memores dicunt 4 Confess cap 3. dextra Domini fecit virtutem dextra Domini exaltauit me the Saints doe verie much reioyce when mindfull of passed danger they say the right hand of the Lord hath done his power the right hand of the Lord hath exalted me So did Saint Paule reioyce when of a persecutor he was made a vessell of election So also Saint Mathew when of a Customer he was made an Euangelist So Saint Marie Magdalene when from being a vessell of contumelie and disgrace shee was translated into a vessell of glorie So Saint Peter when after the denying of his Master he was made a constant pillar of truth by his personall perseuerance in faith obtained him by Christs prayer who said Ego rogani pro te Petre Luke 22.32 vt non deficiat fides tua I haue prayed for thee Peter that thy faith faile not 3 The obseruation hereof gentle Reader maketh mee truly to discouer An acknowledgement of the benefit of conuersion as the case standeth the obligation I am bound in to God for Almightie God of his infinite goodnesse and out of the vnexhausted riches of his mercie hauing blessed my soule with a true and vnfained conuersion from the superstitious idolatrous and hereticall religion of the Romane Church vnto the perfect knowledge and practise of the Religion established in this Realme touching that faith which is conformable to that which was taught by the Ancient Primitiue Apostolike and Catholike Church which is maintained and defended by his Maiestie with whom I may presume boldly to say maugre all the Church of Rome I will neuer be ashamed to render an account of my profession Praemonit to all Christian Monarchs and of that hope that
Christian Princes After this I fell by a meere chance vpon the booke of the now Lord of Canterburies written in confutation of some of Master Doctor Hilles quarterne of reasons Next met I with the Bishop of Lincolnes answere to Parsons with some others All which I perused diligently and with great attention in which writings although some doctrinall points much distasted my palate by reason of my setled affection to the Romane faith yet I found many points both doctrinall and morall verie remarkable and powerfull to moue strong doubtes had I not by the implicite faith of whatsoeuer the Romane Church teacheth folued them all and so consequently held them as matters of scandall and temptation the first of which ought not to moue a setled constancie nor the second to finde any entertainment but euen at the verie first occurrence to be reiected yet notwithstanding at the last reflecting vpon many former obseruations I conceiued that ground of implicite faith to be subiect to the daunger of errour and held it fit to examine verie diligently the groundes of the true Church especially for a Cleargie-man who is to yeelde a reason of his faith and to giue satisfaction vnto others and chiefely in such times as the question is to be discussed which is the true Church a man ought to heare to beleeue and to follow if hee will not be esteemed as a Heathen and Publicane Then began I to reflect more seriously vpon the former points and to grow very familiar with the aforesaid bookes and with much stay to examine the reasons and solutions of Cardinall Bellarmine to his aduersaries in the chiefest points of Doctrine now controuerted where finding manie friuolous arguments and idle solutions I grew into much greater care to discusse matters than euer before least whilest I thought to goe the right way to Heauen and to lead others thither wee went both blindfolded to hell 6 Next vnto this occasion happened another The powder-treason another occasion and that was the most vnmatched Pouder-treason as I thinke the most odious conspiracie that euer was inuented or intended by the braine of man the hatefull memorie whereof will proue euerlastingly to all posteritie a spot indelible not onely to the actors but also to all that shall maintaine approue and allow of the same wishing it had had the intended effect acknowledging no other faultinesse therein but the want of that successe which no honest or good Christian minde could euer endure This was so great a scandale to many that had they not beene otherwise confirmed in the faith of Rome they would forthwith haue abiured it and for my selfe in particular when I heard the names read in the proclamation of those who were the chiefe agents therein I stood amazed fearing that it had beene approued by the Pope vnder-hand because I thought if Garnet Gerralde and Greeneway were either agents or concealers thereof the prouidence of the Iesuites was such that they would neuer whatsoeuer they thought in their iudgements of the lawfulnesse thereof haue giuen consent thereunto without the approbation of higher authoritie and my conclusion in iudgement was that if euer I could be assured that the Pope allowed by any conniuencie whatsoeuer of the fact I should therein rather acknowledge him to be the Vicar of hell than the Vice-gerent of Christ And further I was much more amated when I heard that Garnet should acknowledge himselfe to haue heard of it in Sacramentall confession and yet to conceale it from the State and to denise no means or way to discouer the fact without opening himselfe or his penitent which the doctrine of his owne Church obliged him vnto Siluest verbo Confessio §. 3. num 2. prope finem Emanuel Sa Aphoris verbo Confessor S. Thom. addit q. 1. de sigill confes art 1. id primum circa finem colligitur a simili for the auoidance of so publike a harme at least in generall this made me very much to suspect that in his iudgement he approued it whatsoeuer he pretended to the contrarie For though he had made conscience to haue reuealed his penitent yet stood he bound in charitie and iustice to haue reuealed so much in generall by some way or other as sufficient notice might haue been giuen to auoid the publike harme and desolation that should haue ensued to the State thereby which no doubt he might haue done if hee had would by some meanes or other Besides another thing which bred a great maruaile in me was The Pope exalted him soon after to the dignity of Poenitentiarius in Rome that the Pope himselfe did neither chastise Greenway for the same considering the euidence giuen by his brother Garnet no nor so much as far as euer I could vnderstand as giue any publike intimation of dislike of that hatefull designement which he might haue done by either of his Breues to the comfort and satisfaction of his children here in England and chiefely to the State who for his silence therein haue iust cause to suspect that he either winked at it in secret before hand or at least after the successe thereof would haue ratified it for the most heroicall stratageme that euer Catholikes performed and haue placed him in the Calender of his famousest Martyrs as M. Wilson hath alreadie done of Garnet and Owldcorne in his English Martyrologe who as the head Iesuit hath reported fathereth vpon himselfe that most infamous libell called Pruritanus a booke so full of blasphemous application of Gods sacred word so vnrespectiue to his Maiestie so iniurious to the State and so enterlaced with lasciuious and beastly scurrilitie that it would shame any honest man to be esteemed the author thereof therefore the Iesuites doe deale politikely in ascribing it to a secular Priest to make the secular Clergie as odious to the State as themselues since it is well knowne and that not to a few that the first inuenter of the greatest part of that booke was a faire young Iesuit sometimes a student in the Vniuersitie of Louaine who sent his first inuentions thereof to Parsons and others at Rome who made themselues full merrie with them and well approued them insomuch that father Talbot the Master of the Nouices ingeniously confessed that the reading of some of them caused him much to be distracted in his prayers and it is to be thought that that Iesuit who may best chalenge the first inuention of that libelling art when he shall come to read his Breuiarie by the memorie of them he will offer vp a very vnsauorie incense in the sight of God at these words Et dixit omnis populus fiat fiat and will proue such a merrie mad petitioner as will make all the black guard of hell attending him to dance for ioy But to returne to the consideration of the treason when I arriued beyond the seas and heard some to tearme it but an inconsiderate act as though the substance of the designement were not faultie
some kind of guidance vnto the true Church In the serious contemplation of which point I thought that the most assured course I could take herein was to lay downe such a direction as is approued both by the Church of England and by the Church of Rome and truly to examine some principall points of doctrine in question betweene the English and Romane Church by this meanes of triall whereunto if I should find either the first agreeable or the second disagreeable I resolued that I might haue a strong inducement to conclude which was the true Church of Christ and which the false whose doctrine might be esteemed Christian and whose doctrine Antichristian 2 By which inducement I was the more earnestly moued to make triall then by any other It is approued by Fathers for that I found the ancient Fathers very frequent in giuing of this marke of antiquitie for Tertullian saith By the order it selfe Lib. de praescrip aduers Her that is made manifest to be of our Lord and true which is first deliuered and that externe and false which is sent in afterward And in another place writing against Marcion he saith Lib contra Marcion I affirme that my Gospell is true Marcion saith as much for his who shall determine this controuersie betwixt vs but the difference of time prescribing authoritie to that doctrine which shall be found more ancient and adiudging corruption to that which shall be conuinced to be the later Saint Gregorie Nazianzen vrgeth the Apolinaristes thus Greg. Naz. epist 2. ad Cledonium Hieron epist ad Pamach Ocean de errori bus Origenist Hieron contra Luciferianos If the faith began but thirtie yeares since whereas there be almost foure hundred years from the manifestation of Christ certainly both our Gospell and faith were vaine and void for this long time And Saint Hierome questioneth with the Origenists of his time after this manner Why goest thou about after foure hundred yeares to teach vs that which wee knew not before The Christian world was without this doctrine vntill this day And against the Luciferians he saith I will declare vnto thee my opinion briefly and plainly we must remaine in the Church which being founded by the Apostles hath endured to this day and all others euen in this that they were instituted after shew themselues to be Heretikes Vincent Lyrinens in cap. 26. 27. With which Fathers Vincentius Lyrinensis accordeth when explicating that of Saint Paul O Timothie keep that which hath bin left vnto thee He saith This depositum is that which hath been committed to thee not which hath been inuented by thee that which thou hast receiued not that which thou hast deuised a thing brought vnto thee not vttered by thee in which thou must not be an author but a keeper not an instructer but a follower not a leader but one that is directed Now therefore thus finding so many ancient Fathers making antiquitie a neere adiunct vnto Catholike and Orthodox truth and noueltie to be the vsuall badge of Herretikes I began with great diligence and care to examine two maine points of religion now controuerted and much disputed on as well by the most learned of the English as of the Romane Church viz. of the doctrine of iustification by faith alone and of the imperfection of our good workes that being according to knowledge grounded in religion my zeale therein might be the greater and my assurednesse of a sound ground cause me to stand the more strongly and to labour in others spiritual profit with the greater constancy and courage as since it hath succeeded through Gods especiall grace to the vnspeakable comfort of my soule affording me grace and abilitie of bodie to performe this so profitable a worke begun and ended by him whom I do most humblie desire to be the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of all my endeuours 3 Now as I proceeded on further by degrees Antiquitie a good way of triall to compare the doctrine of the Church of England and that of Rome concerning the two points aboue specified with the doctrine of the ancient Church by this meanes of antiquitie I found the doctrines of iustification by faith only and of the imperfection and demerit of good workes as they are taught in the present Church of England most deseruedly to claime the priuiledge of antiquitie as taught by many both Latine and Creeke Fathers Iustification by faith alone proued by Greeke Fathers Ses 6. Can. 9. Origen lib. 3. Rom. 3. notwithstanding that the Church of Rome accurseth al that hold the contrarie in expresse termes saying If any shall say that a wicked man may be iustified by faith alone c. let him be accursed Against which definitiue sentence of the Councell of Trent I find first of the Greeke Fathers Origen to be most cleare who vpon those words of Saint Paul to the Romans We therefore thinke that man is iustified by faith without the workes of the law writeth thus The Apostle in these words saith that iustification by faith alone sufficeth so that a man onely beseeuing is iustified although he performe no worke And if an example be required who was euer that without good workes was iustified by faith alone I think that thiefe may suffice who crucified with Christ cried vnto him on the crosse Lord Iesus remember me when thou shalt come into thy kingdome Neit her is there any good worke of his described in the Cospell But for this faith alone Iesus saith vnto him Amen I say vnto thee This day thou shalt be with me in Paradise This thiefe therefore is iust fied by faith without the workes of the law because the Lord did not aske what worke hee did first neither did he expect what worke hee had done when he belieued but being iustified by faith alone when he was to enter into Paradise he tooke him for his companion and it is related in the Gospell according to Saint Luke vnto the woman without any worke of the law and for faith alone hee said thy sinnes are forgiuen thee And againe Thy faith hath made thee safe goe in peace And in many places of the Gospell wee reade that our Sauiour vsed this speech to shew that the faith of the beleeuer is the cause of his saluation Hitherto Origen Neither is Saint Basil of other opinion who writeth thus The Apostle saith Basil cōcione dehumilit he that reioyceth let him reioyce in the Lord saying that Christ is made vnto vs from God Wisedome Iustice Sanctification and Redemption that as it is written he that is to reioyce let him reioyce in the Lord for this is perfect and entire reioycing in God when a man is not exalted for his owne righteousnesse but acknowledgeth true righteousnesse to bee wanting in him and to bee iustified by faith alone in Christ And Paul reioyceth in that he despiseth his owne righteousnes and in that by
Christ he seeketh that righteousnesse which is of God Thus much S. Basil whose doctrine agreeth most plainly with the doctrine of England in this point 4. I finde also S. Chrysostome to bee most cleare for the same doctrine of iustification by faith only saying vpon those wordes Other Fathers Chrysost Coment in Epist ad Rom. cap. 3. Gloriation is excluded by what law c. In this place he sheweth the power of God not only for keeping him but for iustifying him and for leading him vnto glorie standing in no neede of workes but requiring only faith Hom. de Fide Lege And in an other place No man without faith hath had life for the Theefe beleeued and was iustified by the most mercifull God here say not vnto me that time was wanting that hee might liue iustly and doe honest workes neither will I striue about this but only this one thing will I affirme that faith alone of it selfe saued him Againe also in an other place Hom. 3. in Epist ad Tit. hee saith If thou beleeuest why doest thou inferre other thinges as if faith alone sufficeth not to iustifie a man Hom. 7. Rom. 3. He saith further But what is the law of faith euen to be saued by grace Here the Apostle sheweth the goodnesse of God who not only saueth vs but also iustifieth and glorifieth vs vsing no workes hereunto but requiring faith only Againe Hesichius saith that God hauing commiseration of mankind when he saw it weakned to performe the workes of the law Hesich commeÌ„t sup Leuit. l. 1. c. 2 he would not haue man to be saued by workes but by grace but grace through mercie is apprehended by faith alone not by workes Theophilact vpon these wordes of Saint Paul Because by the law no man shall be iustified before God Theophil Commenâ—â—n cap. 3. ad Galath saith That hee sheweth that by the law all men are made execrable and subiect to malediction and that blessings are heaped vp by faith now hee clearly sheweth that faith it selfe or alone hath power to iustifie And againe saith elsewhere Theophilact 2. ad Thes 2. For faith alone he is to giue eternall good thinges Thus it appeareth how the doctrine of iustification by faith only was taught by the ancient Greeke Fathers 5. Proofes of Latine Fathers Now if we examine the Latin Fathers wee shall finde them as plaine and copious in this point as the other for Hilarie speaking of the Scribes saith Hilar. in Ma. h. Can. 8. It moueth the Scribes that sinne should be remitted by man for they only beheld man in Christ Iesus and that to be remitted by him which the law could not loosE For faith alone iustifieth The same teacheth Saint Ambrose vpon the wordes of Saint Paul Being iustified freely by his grace saith Ambros sup Paul ad Rom. 3 They are iustified freely because working nothing nor yeelding requital they are iustified by faith alone through the gift of God And againe vpon these wordes sup Rom. 4. Beleeuing in him that iustifieth the wicked HIs wordes are these He saith this because if by the workes of the law vnto the wicked beleeuer his faith is reputed to righteousnesse as to Abraham how therefore doe the Iewes thinke themselues to be iushfied by the iustification of Abraham since they see Abraham not by the workes of the law but by faith alone to be iustified therefore the law is not needfull when the wicked is iustified by faith alone with God And in an other place This is appointed by God that hee who beleeueth in Christ shall bee saued without workes De vocat Gent. Cap. 9. ad Rom. by faith alone and againe faith alone is appointed to saluation Primafins likewise sometimes an Auditor to S Augustine speaketh often of iustification by faith alone Sup illud ad Rom. 4. saying He iustifieth the wicked by faith alone not by the works which he had not And againe he saith Ad Rom. 5. Abraham before circumcision is iustified by credulitie aone And in an other place Thou liuest like a Gentill Ad Galath 2. not like a Iew. Thou knowest that hou hast had life through grace not by works but by faith alone Ad Galath 5. And againe Abraham beleeued God and it was reputed to him for righteousnesse so vnto you faith alone sufficieth to righteousnesse Which Author hath many other places to the same purpose Haymo sup Paul ad Gal. 3. Haymo who liued in the time of Ludouicus Pius the sonne of Charles the great saith The law was not fulfilled by faith but by worke but the Gospell is fulfilled more by faith then by workes because faith alone sauethl Sup. Paul ad Heb. 11. Againe in an other place saying If the Harlot that is an Infidell and an Idolatresse is saued by faith alone much more shall they be saued who haue not fallen into more grieuous crimes In Euâ—ng de Circumcil Christi Abacuc 2. Aug. l. 1. contra duas Epist Pelag cap. 21. So likewise elsewhere They shall be faued only by faith alone as it is written but the iust liueth by faith Saint Augustine also himselfe seemeth most plaine for this opinion saying Of what vertue soeuer thou shalt preach the Ancient iust men to haue been of nothing hath made them safe but faith And againe If any man after beleeuing shall forth-with depart out of this life L. 83. quaest q. 76 iustification of faith abideth with him without any precedent good workes because he hath not attained thereunto by merit but by grace 6. Which doctrine of these so Ancient Fathers Later writers euen the learnedst of the moderne Writers of the Church of Rome do approue and ioyntly allow of in their writings Thomas Aquinas their Angelicall Doctor writeth thus Rom. 3. Lect. 4. Gal. 3. Lect 4. Workes be not the cause why a man is iust before God but rather they are the execution and manifestation of his iustice for no man is iustified by works but by the habit of Faith infused yea iustification is done by faith onely Bonauent 4. d. 15. q. 1. nu 10. And Bonauenture the Franciscanes Seraphicall Doctor writeth thus For so much as man was not able to satisfie for so great offence therefore God gaue him a Mediatour who should satisfie for it whence it comes to passe that by only faith in his Passion all the fault is remitted and without the faith of him no man is iustified Saint Bernard also is most perspicuous in the deliuerie of the same doctrine saying Cant. ser 22. Whosoeuer is compunct for his sinnes hungreth and thirsteth after righteousnesse let him beleeue in thee that iustifiest a sinner and being iustified by faith onely hee shall haue peace from thee So that now it is apparant that the doctrine of iustification by faith onely taught in the Church of England is made good by the marke of
antiquitie and approued euen by some of the Romanists themselues against themselues Yea Vergerius a learned Bishop as my Lords Grace of Canterburie noteth but of Sledian intending to write against Luther in that argument Doctor Hils reasons vnmasked reas 8. nu 2. fol. 307. Sleid. lib. 21. was by trauersing of it caught himselfe And so by the discouerie first of one veritie at length grew to abandon altogether the Church of Rome as any whosoeuer shall read this Treatise may well doe I hope with satisfaction and comfort to his owne conscience 7 I further began also to make triall of the doctrine of the Church of Rome concerning good works by this marke of antiquitie which teacheth them to be so perfect About the imperfection of good workes that in some sort they are simply absolutely and perfectly iust and righteous further that they are merits that they iustifie a man and that they are not onely mereitorious for encrease of grace but also of eternall glorie which doctrine tendeth exceedingly to the engendring and nourishing of a Pharisaicall pride and presumption in good workes whereas the doctrine of the Church of England teaching imperfection to be euen in our best workes of the righteous that they are not merits that they doe not iustifie that they are not meritorious is a most holesome doctrine for planting of the true Publicanes humilitie relying wholly vpon Christs righteousnesse and the imputation thereof when he said Deus propitius esto mihi peecatori Lord be mercifull vnto me a sinner and so was pronounced more iustified than the Pharisie iustifying himselfe by his workes Luk. 18. vers 11. when he said I am not as other men are extortioners vniust adulterers or euen as this Publicane I fast twice a weeke I giue tythes of all that I possesse This obseruation I gathered by reading and diligently noting Bellarmines confused controuersies in the doctrine of iustification drawing the readers onely to a proud Pharisaicall presumption in their owne workes against whom I obserue many Fathers Our righteousnesse imputed first to account all our true righteousnesse to be Christs righteousnesse more than ours and ours onely by imputation and therefore our owne righteousnesse consequently very imperfect Saint Augustine hath in plaine tearmes thus Epist 106. ad Bonifac. The righteousnesse by which through faith we beleeue we are iustified that is wee are made righteous is the grace of God through Iesus Christ our Lord. In Enche ca. 41. And againe He is sinne and we righteousnesse not ours but Gods neither in vs but in him as he is sinne not his owne but ours nor in himselfe but in vs so therefore we are Gods righteousnesse in him as he is sinne in vs to wit Lib. 2. de Iacob vit beata by imputation S. Ambrose sayth As Iacob of himselfe deserued not the primogeniture who being hidden in his brothers apparrell and clad in his garment which yeelded forth the best odor did insinuate himselfe to his father that to his profit he might vnder another person receiue benediction so doe wee lye hidden vnder the precious puritie of Christ our first begotten brother that from the sight of God wee may giue testimonie of our iustice With the doctrine of which auncient Fathers holy Bernard agreeth as well as the Church of England Bernard Ser. 61. in Cantic Cant. saying I will remember thy iustice alone for it is mine to wit thou art made vnto me thy righteousnesse from God for how can I feare that one iustice may not suffice vs both It is not the short cloake which according to the Prophet cannot couer two thy iustice is iustice for euer and this large and eternall iustice shall couer both mee and thee together Whereby it is cleare that all our righteousnesse is none of our owne but Christs and therefore all our workes in respect of our selues are sinfull and imperfect 8 Besides the imperfection of our workes appeareth Works imperfect because they cause not saluation in that although they are necessarie for many respects yet are they not the efficient causes of saluation for Saint Ambrose sayth This is appointed by God Ambros in 1. ad Cor. 1. that he that beleeueth in Christ be saued without worke freely receiuing by faith alone remission of sinnes And Saint Augustine hath these wordes August in Psal 70. Thou art nothing of thy selfe call vpon God sinnes are thine mercies are Gods chastisement is due vnto thee and when the reward shall come he shall crowne his gifts not thy merits Saint Chrysostome also sayth Chrysost in cap. 3. ad Rom. Herein the power and might of God is shewed in that he saueth iustifieth and leadeth vnto glorie by faith alone without good workes Basil saith thus Basil in Ps 114. Euerlasting rest abideth vpon those that striue lawfully in this life not for the merits of their deedes but out of the most bountifull fauour of God in which they haue beleeued All which places doe argue against the perfection of workes for our greater humiliation and Gods greater glorie 9. Moreouer the learned Fathers doe further shew VVorkes imperfect because impure Hieron lib. 2. aduers Pelag. that the workes of the righteous are not simply and absolutely iust and perfect for Saint Hierome writeth thus If according to Iob the Moone doth not shine and the starres are not cleare in his sight how much more man who is rottennesse and the sonne of man a worme For euery mouth is stopped and euery cleane one is obnoxious vnto God because before him by the workes of the law all flesh shall not be iustified and there is no difference of persons for all haue sinned and are in neede of the glorie of God being iustified freely through his grace Saint Augustine speaking to Pelagius sayth thus Aug. li. de natur grat The Lord if he would might lift vp mortall men to Angelicall puritie and so cause that they might perfectly keepe the Law but hee neuer did nor euer will doe it Epist 29. Saint Hierome also speaketh as plaine to this purpose when he sayth The fullest charitie which cannot be encreased so long as man liueth here is not in any but so long as it can be augmented truly that which is lesse than it ought to be is of vice out of which vice it is Lib. de perfec iustit resp 18. Lib. 9. confes cap. 13. that no man doth good and sinneth not who further sayth It is sinne when either there is not charitie which ought to be or when it is lesse than it ought to be And Saint Augustine Woe also to the laudable life of men if without mercie thou doest discusse it Lib 9. Mor. c. 1. And Gregorie the Great in his Morals sayth The holy man because he seeth that all the merit of our vertue is vice if it be seuerely iudged by the inward arbitrer doth right well adioyne if hee will
striue with him he cannot answere him one for a thousand And againe Cap. 28. How much soeuer wee sweate in good workes we doe not apprehend true cleanenesse but we imitate it And in another place he sayth Lib. vlt. Mor. c. vlt. Our euils are pure euils and the good thinges which wee beleeue wee haue cannot bee pure good thinges With which auncient Writers verie well agreeth Saint Bernard Ser. 5. de verbis Isaiae saying If our righteousnesse be humble perhaps it is right but not pure vnlesse perhaps we beleeue our selues to be better than our fathers who said no lesse truely than humbly All our righteousnesse is like a filthie polluted cloth How is it pure iustice where sinne cannot yet be wanting By all which places I was enforced to conclude the acknowledgement of the imperfection of good workes with the Church of England to be much more agreeable vnto truth and more profitable for true Christian humiliation than an ouerprizing of our workes with the Church of Rome to puffe vp soules with vaine glorie and ostentation by the which manie are most lamentably let fall into the pit of Hell Tolluntur in altum vt lapsu grauiore ruant they are lifted vp on high that their fall may be the greater 10 Againe Imperfect because they cannot iustifie to demonstrate further the imperfection of our workes the auncient Fathers are most cleare teaching that they cannot iustifie a man in the sight of God Saint Ambrose sayth But that is auailefull vnto me Ambros de vit bon li. 1. cap. 6. that we are not iustified by workes of the Law I haue not therefore whereof to glorie in my workes I haue not whereof to boast my selfe and therefore I will glorie in Christ I will not glorie because I am iust but I will glorie because I am redeemed I will not glorie because I am void of sinne but because sinnes are remitted vnto me I will not glorie because I haue beene profitable but because Christ is the aduocate for me with the Father but because the bloud of Christ is powred out for me The same learned Doctor in another place sayth Vaunt not thy selfe for being styled the Sonne of God In Luc. cap. 14. grace is to be acknowledged nature not to be vnknowne neither mayest thou boast thy selfe for seruing well for doing what thou oughtest to doe the Sunne serueth the Moone obeyeth and the vessell of Gentiles chosen of God sayth I am not worthie to be called an Apostle And elsewhere shewing himselfe not to be guiltie of sinne he addeth but in this I am not iustified Saint Augustine further sayth Tract 82. in Ioannem This is glorie towards God wherewith not man but God is glorified if he be iustified not by workes but by faith And againe In Psal 30. You are saued by grace sayth the Apostle and this not of your selues but it is the gift of God not through workes as if you did well that you might be worthie to approach thereunto not through workes least perhaps he be extolled 11 Further Imperfect because not meritorious for proofe of the imperfection of our workes I finde the auncient Fathers to affoord me matter herein teaching them not to be meritorious for Origen was auncient and yet hee said Orig. ad Rom. li. 4. c. 4. I can hardly beleeue there is any worke that may require the reward of debt Saint Chrysostome is auncient and yet hee sayth Hom. 33. in Genes If any of our workes doe follow the free vocation of God they are a retribution of debt but grace beneficencie and greatnesse of bountie are Gods gifts therefore not meritorious Saint Hilarie also sayth In Psal 51. That not the workes of iustice themselues were sufficient vnto the merit of perfect blisse vnlesse the mercie of God also in this will of righteousnesse doe not repute the vices of humane changes and motions Lib. 1. aduers Pelag. Saint Hierome sayth Now therefore wee are iust when wee confesse our selues sinners and our righteousnesse is not in proper merit but by Gods councell Lib. 4 de Ciuit. Dei cap. 20. Saint Augustine sayth Without the merits of good workes the sinner is iustified by faith and that alone De grat lib. arbitr cap. 9. And againe The Saints doe attribute nothing vnto their merits they attribute all to mercie O Lord. And againe elsewhere Wee must vnderstand that God bringeth vs to eternall life not for our merits but for his owne mercie Lib. 1. de vocat Gent. Prosper further sayth Therefore in the Parable of those that laboured in the Vineyard the same reward is giuen to the Labourers whether they labour much or little that those who haue laboured with much sweate and haue not receiued more than the last may vnderstand that they haue receiued the reward of grace and not of workes Yea and Gregorie the great Super Psal 7. Paeniten Bishop of Rome sayth It is one thing for God to reward men according to their workes and another thing to giue the reward for the workes themselues when the Scripture sayth According to our workes the qualitie of our workes is vnderstood and that the reward shall be his whose the workes are for vnto that blessed life wherein wee liue with God can no labour be compared no worke likened seeing the Apostle sayth The sufferings of this life are not worthie of the glorie of the life to come Which proofes of auncient Writers shew most clearely good workes not to be so perfect as the Church of Rome makes them and therefore I may well say with Waldensis He is to be reputed the sounder Diuine Sacrament ti 1. c. 7. p. 30. and the better Catholike and more agreeable to the Scripture that simply denieth such merit confessing that simply no man merits the kingdome of Heauen but obtaines it by the grace and free will of God that giues it 12 From all which authorities of the auncient Fathers Later writers proue the same Bernard orat 1. omn. sanct diuers wayes shewing the imperfection of our workes Saint Bernard seemed no whit to swarue saying But what can all our righteousnesse be before God Shall it not according to the Prophet be reputed as a filthie polluted cloth and if he be straightly iudged all our righteousnesse shall be found vniust and hauing too little What therefore shall be of sinnes when iustice it selfe may not answere for it selfe Therefore deuoutly crying with the Prophet Enter not into iudgement with thy seruant O Lord with all humilitie let vs haue recourse vnto mercie whihch alone can saue our soules And in another place If any be deuout if he be solicitous Bernard ser 3. de annuno Mariae if he be feruent in spirit let him take heede he trust not to his merits that he relie not vpon his workes All which though they make strongly against the doctrine of the Church of
true Catholike Church and desiring not to shew my selfe altogether ingrate vnto Gods so great mercie I haue freely decreed to consecrate and offer vp my selfe wholly vnto his diuine seruice for attaining as much as in me lieth to the end of the said Colledge and I doe promise and confirme by this mine Oath vnto Almightie God that I am and shall bee euer most ready in minde by the assistance of his holy Grace to receiue in due time holy Orders and to returne into England there to gaine soules whensoeuer the Superiour of this Colledge shall thinke good by vertue of his office to command me thereunto For the taking of so vnlawfull an Oath in such my blindnesse against the lawfull power and authoritie of the Gouernours of this Realme with contempt of their Lawes to the contrarie as also for the practise of the contents therein specified vpon false supposition of gaining soules to God whilest I drew them from God from my heart I repent me crauing pardon of God and his Maiestie with diuers others whom I haue offended and grieuously prouoked their iust indignation against me acknowledging that I may truely say vnto God with the prodigall Sonne that wasted his substance in a farre Countrie I will goe to my Father and say vnto him Father I haue sinned against heauen and against thee Luke 15. v. 21. I am no more worthy to be called thy Sonne If thou curteous Reader art as I was glorifie the name of God in the view of thy errours which I hope by this Treatise sufficiently to lay open vnto thee turning to God who is mild and mercifull to all true penitent sinners purposing amendment and acknowledging their sinnes and if thou art otherwise let mee intreat thee for the loue of God to giue him thankes for mee and thou thy selfe to bee constant and firme in the Faith of the present Church of England which teacheth the true Christian Apostolike and Ancient faith in which through Gods grace we may be saued CHAP. IX Containeth an obseruation of the Wonders and supposed Miracles which as Christ hath fore-told the Pseudo-Christs and Prophets shall doe for the seducing of Gods Elect if it were possible AMongst the diuers markes which Cardinall Ballarmine brings to shew vs which is the true Church Miracles make more for the Church of England than for the Church of Rome and to which societie of Christian beleeuers were ought to ioyne our selues to bee true children of Christ hee vrgeth for his eleuenth Marke the glorie of Miracles in these wordes Miracles are necessarie to perswade men to a new faith Bellarm. de notis Eccles l. 4. c. 14. in Epitome or to an extraordinarie mission and are sufficient and efficacious to proue the same so that where true Miracles are found without doubt there is the true Faith Which Assertion when I considered deepely with due obseruation of all points of doctrine concerning the working of Miracles I found this Marke to make as much for the Faith of the present English Church for that it is the same which being new in the Apostles time was confirmed in the hearts of all beleeuers by the Miracles of the Apostles and holy Men of the Primitiue Church at the first planting of the Christian Faith and hereby I am put in minde that as Aristotle saith Aristoteles Prudentis est distinguere it is the part of a prudent man to distinguish betwixt times times betwixt doctrines faithfully compare the beleeuers of the first Ages euen of Rome it selfe with those of after-ages which as I indeuoured to performe in examining this marke of miracles I obserue that vnlesse it were done with great prudence infinite numbers may bee carried simply and ignorantly into grosse errors to the great impeachment of Gods glorie and miserable seduction of their owne soules and therefore to lay downe this obseruation I thought it good to vse extraordinary diligence that therewith all I might be the more assured of truth that the world may clearely see that this pretence of Miracles maketh nothing at all for the present faith of Rome but onely against it shewing the Professours thereof not to bee true Christians 2 For albeit it be a truh not to be denied al that do miracles doe not true miracles that all true miracles can onely be done by God yet doth it not follow that all that doe miracles doe true miracles and such as are done by him for to euery true miracle foure things are required as a learned Roman Teacher affirmeth First Foure thinges required to true miracles Io. de Combis in compend Theolog verit lib. 1. ca. 20. it must be of God Secondly it must be beyond nature Thirdly it must be euident Fourthly it must be fore the corroboration of Faith Therefore if any of these foure be wanting it may bee called a Maruell but not a Miracle Therefore it is also to bee knowne that the Diuell can doe miracles though not true miracles yet such miracles as to men may seeme true miracles for Thomas Aquinas saith and that very truly out of S. Augustine That miracles by art Magicke are made Aug. lib. 83. q. 79 Tom. 4. Part. 1. q. 14. q. 4. Sed contra which are altogether like vnto those miracles which are done by the seruants of God which he explicateth dogmatically after this manner If a miracle be taken properly the Diuels cannot doe miracles nor any other creature but onely God because a miracle properly is termed that which is beyond the order of anie nature created Yet sometimes in a large sense that is called a miracle which exceedeth the faculty and vnderstanding of man and so the diuells can doe miracles which men admire in that they exceede their power and knowledge For one man when he doth any thing tha is aboue the power and knowledge of an other man he leadeth the other into an admiration of his worke that in some sort he seemeth to do a miracle Yet it is to be vnderstood that albeit such workes of Diuells which seeme miracles vnto vs reâ—ch not vnot the true nature of miracles they are notwithstanding sometimes true things As when sire fell from heauen and with one blowe consumed the familie of Iob with all the heards of his cattell and a whirlewinde ouerthrew the house Aug. 20. de Ciuitae Dei c. 19. slew his children which were the workes of Sathan were not fantasmes as Augustine saith And therefore well doth Saint augustine say in an other place speaking of the lying miracles of Antichrist as he same Doctour noteth That the workes of Antichrist may bee called signes of lying Li. 83. q. 79. to 4. eyther because hee will deceiue mortall senses by phantasmes seeming to doe that which hee doth not or because that if they bee true Prodigies yet they drawe those that shall beleeue them to a lie Hence the same Doctour Saint Augustine saieth Aug. li. 83. q. 79. a
it absolutely necessary that God should continue that faith by miracles which was formerly planted by them but rest themselues contented with the former of the Primitiue Church lest otherwise they should be subiect to seduction whence I concluded to my selfe that vnlesse the Church of Rome could proue her selfe to be true Catholike and ancient Primitiue I ought not to be led by her pretended miracles in regard that Doctor Stapleton saith Heretikes and the forerunners of Antichrist may do true miracles by Gods permission for the triall of the good which neither my selfe nor any manelse ought to beleeue because Christ hath armed vs with a warning caueat against them saying Nolite eis credere 4 Which Pretence of miracles a signe of false teachers Matth. â—4 24 how true it is I appeale to the holy Scriptures themselues our Sauiours words are most plaine There shall arise false Christs and false Prophets shall shew great signes and wondes so that if it were possible they should deceiue the verie Elect behold I haue told you before but beleeue them not by which warning aduice is giuen to beware of them to discerne them and not to giue credit vnto their teaching notwithstanding all their miracles Neither is Saint Pauls prediction lesse significant of them who remembreth vs 2. Thess 2.9 That the comming of that sonne of perdition is by the working of Satan with all power and signes and lying wonders and in all deceiue ablenesse of vnrighteousnes among them that perish because they receiued not the loue of the truth Apocal cap. 13.13.14 that they might bee saued Saint Iohn also in his Reuelations speaking of the second beast saith He did great wonders so that he made fire to come downe from heauen on the earth in the fight of men and deceiued them that dwellon the earth by the signes which ae permitted to him to do in the sight of the beast Apocal. cap. 16.13 Afterwards we heare also againe that three vncleane spirits like frogs came out of the mouth of the Dragon and out of the mouth of the beast and out of the mouth of the false Prophet for they are the spirits of diuels working miracles And moreouer lastly we find in the same booke That the beast was taken and with him that false Prophet Apocal. cap. 19.20 that wrought miracles before him whereby he deceiued them that receiued the beasts marke Now what is to bee vnderstood by powers signes and wonders I will cite the words of Ioannes Vignerius Institut Christ cap. 9. §. 2. vers 3. Hebr. 2. Matth. 24.24 who saith That miracles in the sacred Scriptures are tearmed powers signes wonders and portentes for Hebrewes the second it is said God witnessing in signes and portents and diuers powers and Matthew the foure and twentieth they are called prodigies which differ thus in that because they exceed the facultie of nature they are termed powers but in that they are ordained to the manifestation of grace they are called signes and for their excellencie they are termed wonders and prodigies as it were shewing things far off So that putting all these places together I could not conclude otherwise then vnlesse I would beleeue these false Prophets vnlesse I were willing to be an Entertenido to the son of Perdition and bee deluded most notoriously by lying wonders vnlesse I would be a perpetuall consort vnto the frogs vamped forth of the Dragons mouth vnlesse I would bee wilfully deceiued as one that had receiued the beasts marke then to shake hands with the present Church of Rome boasting so much in her miraculous powers signes wonders and prodigies for in the reformed Churches I find no such illusions pretended nor the least danger thereof nor any where else but in the present Romane Church 5 By which obseruation Miracles not to be expected in the latter times I was the rather induced to this conclusion for that I finde diuers inclining to thinke it too much curiositie now that the faith is planted and after so long continuance to seeke it out by more miracles Therefore first I will set downe the Doctrine of an old Dominican Friar distinguishing the times of doing miracles whose words are these The Church hath a three-fold state viz. Iacob de Vorag de sanctis in die ascensio ser 6. The Primitiue the moderne and the last In the Primitiue state miracles were wrought often but now seldom and in the last state that is of Antichrist they shall be done most seldome In the Primitiue state they were done often because according to Saint Chrysostome the ancient miraracles haue admiration profit and necessitie Therefore then according to Saint Chrysostome miracles were done as well for admiration because men being then accustomed to their senses were therefore to be lifted vp as for profit because then many were infirme and oppressed of diuels and for necessitie because they were infidels and wrapped vp in errors But in the moderne state they are seldome done because necessitie requireth them not men being now beleeuers yet sometimes they are wrought because profit and vtilitie exalteth them for that sometimes men are found weake and to stand in need of them And why miracles are not done now so frequently as they were in the Primitiue Church there is a threefold reason one is for the strength of faith because now the Church is strengthened and established in faith This reason Bernard assigneth putting an example of the plant into which we power water till we see it fastened in the earth secondly for the profitable example of the world De ciuit Dei lib. 22. This reason Augustine assigneth saying whosoeuer requireth yet wonders that he may beleeue he is a great wonder himself who beleeueth not when the world beleeueth Thirdly for the greater merit of faith because according to Saint Gregory faith hath no merit where humane reason prouoketh it but in the end they shall bee wrought but seldome for three reasons that Isidorus teacheth either that the hand of the persecutors may become more bould or that the patience of the Saints may be the more proued or that the lightnes may be the more shewed of those which shall fall Who speaking heere of the miracles of Saints in these three states of time she weth they shall be scanty in the middle ages after Christ and very raw in the last ages which if it be true what can I do but suspect the pretended miracles of the Church of Rome which swarmeth with so many bookes replenished with their narrations in such strange and vnheard manner as there were neuer the like and therefore they easilie seeme to surmount all beliefe and I may more largely presse those words against those of the Church of Rome which this Authour pointeth at saying to all her followers out of Saint Augustine De ciuit Dei lib. 22. Why say they are not the miracles now done which you doe preach to haue beene done I might
say that before the world did beleeue they were necessrie to this end that the world might beleeue but whosoeuer doth enquire after wonders that hee may beleeue hee himselfe is a great wonderment who beleeueth not now the world doth beleeue By which words I obserue a necessitie why men should look for miracles in the Primitiue Church but none why wee should expect them now but rather why wee should feare to bee deceiued by beleeiuing false ones for true ones and therefore Saint Augustine giueth another stronger reason to hold him in the Church than the continuance of miracles saying Contra Epi. fundamenti The consent of people and nations doth holde me there doth hold mee an authoritie which was begunne with miracles nourished by hope encreased by charitie confirmed by antiquitie by which I obserue though hee shew the authoritie of that sacred doctrine confirmed in the beginning by miracles as a menes to hold him yet hee speaketh of no continuance of them but leaueth confirmation to the authoritie of sacred doctrine it selfe which must bee the strongest hold of the Churches claime De vera relig cap. 25. Saint AuguStine also in another place saith Since the Catholike Church is diffused through the whole world and grounded neither are these miraculous things permitted to endure vntill our times lest the mind should alwayes seeke visible things and by the custome of them man-kind should waxe cold at the new appearance whereof it was all on fire Mor. lib. 27.11 And Saint Gregorie saith most plainely What maruaile is it if the faith being propagated miracles be not oft done since euen the very Apostles in many which were alreadie faithfull did not doe them Neither is Isidorus any whit discordant from Saint Augustine aboue recited who seemeth to insinuate as much in these words Miracles are a signe Isidor lib. 1. de summo bono not necessarie for the faithfull who now haue beleeued but to the vnfaithfull that they may bee conuerted for Paul for the infidelitie of not beleeuers cureth the father of Publius by miracles from the infirmitie of an ague but sicke Timothie who was a faithfull not by prayer but medicinally that thou mayest know miracles to be done not for the vnfaithfull but for the faithfull So I find Didacus de la Vega not to swarue much from this doctrine Conc. quadrag feria 4. post primam dominicam quadrag Matth. 12. vers 39. who vpon these words Generatio male adultera signum quaerit signum non dabitur ei nisi signum Ionae Prophetae An euill and adulterous generation seeketh a signe but no signe shall be giuen vnto it saue the signe of the Prophet Ionas saith The Scribes and Pharisies approach vnto Christ to require signes and wonders from heauen by the which hee should shew himselfe the true Messias promised in the Law whome hee reprehendeth with sharpe wordes and confoundeth them calling them an euill and adulterous generation and their demaund required no milder wordes but was worthie of such an answere For the comming of the Sonne of God into the world was not so hidden but that it was preuented many ages before and announced by the heauenly Oracles of the Prophets Whereupon I obserued that if the Scribes and Pharsies were reprehended so seuerely for requiring signes from heauen because they had Christ foretold by the Prophets then could I not but assure my selfe that the followers of the Church of Rome are worthie of as great a reprehension euen of the same nature of adulterous generation that after the faith so long planted and begunne with miracles and confirmed by antiquitie boast so much on their owne miracles and strange wonders Doctor Stapleton vpon these words of Christ Iob. 4. Prompt mor. Dom. 20. post Pent. soco 5. Nisi signa prodigia viderit is not creditis Vnlesse you see signes and wonders you beleeue not hath these words worthie of note and obseruation The ruler is checked because that being brought vp amongst the Iewes and instructed in the Law hee would not beleeue by the authoritie of the Scriptures but by signes but expect the extreame daunger of his Sonne that hee might see a signe This was an incredultie almost common to all the Iewes which in another place Christ taxeth most sharpely for certaine of the Scribes and Pharisies comming vnto him and saying Master wee will see a signe of thee Matth. 12. answering hee said vnto them Matth. 16. a wicked and adulterous generation asketh a signe Which words againe hee answered at another time when the Sadduces empted him in like manner and calleth them a wicked and an adulterous generation which seeketh signes because they did euill in tempting God and such an euill was this that they shewed their soules not to bee the true spouses of God by faith but adulterous friends of transitorie things For euen as a wife which truely loueth her husband desireth not to see any extraordinarie signes of her husbands loue towards her as that her husband should as it were cast himselfe into the fire or water for his wiues sake but resteth contented with that true internall loue which hee carrieth her and the common externall signes of a husbands loue towards her So the faithfull soule which by faith and charitie is espoused vnto her God if shee bee such a one doth see so many signes in her selfe the loue of God so vehement and sincere so many embracings of Gods loue towards her so many and frequent sweetnesses from aboue so many daily graces fauours and benefits lastly that peace of her God which passeth all vnderstanding that to seeke other signes for confirmation of her faith in God or the charitie of God towards her she esteemeth it not onely idle but also most impious For as it is an argument of chast loue to cleaue only to God so is it the signe of an adulterous soule in slipperie things to seeke externall signes Further as the ancient Iewes were contented with the signes of their Elders done in the desert in the red sea on mount Sina Deut. 32. in the passage of Iordan according to that Interroga patres tuos dicent tibi Aske thy Fathers and they will tell thee So the Iewes when Christ teacheth and all Christians at this day must be cōtented with the old signes either typically done before Christs comming of which it was not fit the Iewes should be ignorant and chiefely the Scribes and Pharisies and the Princes of the people amongst which this Ruler seemeth to be one or performed by Christ himselfe which are sufficient for our faith Therefore all this curiositie and shew of incredulitie and fornication from God is worthily taxed by Christ either in this Ruler or in the standers by or in both whose hearts he saw By which Lobserued how worthie of reprehension of the Church of Rome is which for confirmation of her doctrine euen vntill his day standeth still vpon miracles as
esteemed of the Church of Rome as a Doctor of Paris who liued two hundred yeares since Hemang de stat eccles p. 53. spake of Friars saying They are worse than the Pharisies rauenous wolues in sheepes clothing who in wordes pretend the forsaking of the world and in deeds with all possible fraud deceit and lying hunt after it The like vnto these did Saint Iohn Baptist call Genimina viperarum the brood of Vipers Matth. 3. because inwardly they carried poyson howsoeuer outwardly they glistered in the vanity of virtues and perfect zeale And Iob seemes prettily to describe them saying Iob. 39. Penna struthionis similis est Herodii accipitris the hawke and storke surpasse other birdes in the speede of their wings vnto which the Struthio is like in fethers Herodius but not in flight because they can but moue their wings to flie yet neuer flie euen such doe I find to be the false prophets of the Church of Rome who by diuers externall actions seeme to haue their wings raised to flie yet with their heart and soule they cleaue to the earth they forsakenot the world tast only terrene things there are like fishes swimming in their vncleannes Wolues in their mallice Foxes in their craftines birdes in their vaineglorie yet doe they transfigure themselues into the Angells of Light dissembling mortification 2. Tim. 3. to deceiue the simple and vnder the pretence of pietie to take their prey whome the holy Apostle Saint Paul calleth Voluptatum amatores magis quam Dei habentes speciem quidem pietatis virtutem autem eius abnegantes louers of pleasures more than of GOD hauing the shew of pietie but denying the power thereof and therefore to bee auoyded and warinesse to be taken of them as Christ himselfe forewarned CHAP. XI Containeth an obseruation of the fruits by which false prophets are to be knowne and discerned BY the former obseruation of the false prophets hypocrisie A way for Papists to discouer the truth which Christ teacheth to be auoyded I haue in some sort beene induced to behold the false pretended catholike religion of the Church of Rome and to conceiue what a zealous detestation a man of vnderstanding ought to haue of that faith and religion which is taught by such hypocriticall teachers yet when I considered further more particularly the meanes which in the iudgement of Papists themselues our Sauiour teacheth euery man to vse for the discouerie of them much more haue I beheld the corruption of the Roman religion and beene moued to beartier repentance and greater commiseration of poore seduced Popists here in England who in a good sinceritie and erroneous assurance of their religion are ignorantly led by many of their teachers into a wonderfull blind obedience not onely to the temporall detriment of their states and fortunes and hazard of worldly meanes for their posterities but also which is worse to the great perrill of their soules euerlasting ruine and destruction for whose good also I haue thought good to giue them some meanes of redresse by explicating vnto them the meanes discouered by Christ wherewith they might helpe themselues as also the maner of my proceeding in the consideration of this point 2 In my scrutinie therefore and search into the truth of religion and discouerie of falshoode False prophets to be discouered by their fruits I conceiued nothing more important for the better successe in my businesse than to obserue out of the Scriptures some probable way and meanes allowed of by the Papists themselues by the which I might cleerely distinguish betwixt false and true teachers for that I perceiued that al pretend truth pretend the church pretend Christ pretend the saluation of soules pretend the knowledge of Scriptures yea and the falsest teachers carrie the outward appearance likewise of good shepheards And I found that Christ who forewarned vs to beware of the bad hath also giuen vs aduise to hearken vnto the good and withalll a good instruction euen in the iudgement of the Romanists how to discerne and distinguish the one from the other Matth. 7. when hee said By their fruits you shall know them doe men gather grapes of thornes or figges of thistles Euen so euery good tree yeeldeth good fruit and the euill tree yeeldeth euill fruits A good tree cannot yeelde euill fruites neyther can an euill tree yeelde good fruits Doctour Stapletons explication of Christs meaning euery tree that yeeldeth not good fruites shall be cut downe and shall be cast into the fire Therefore by their fruites you shall know them 3 For D. Stapleton a principall Romanist hath thus interpreted our Sauiours speech saying In this place the fruites by which heretickes must bee knowne are neyther some true things which they teach neyther are they alwayes the workes which they doe whether good or euill but they are partly the hereticall doctrines themselues which are false and impious which are proper to euery hereticke and of euery arch-heretike properly inuented partly also certayne ill workes proper to heretikes and growing foorth from the roote it selfe of heresie for such are theyr owne proper fruites as haue theyr owne Authors and Parents 4 Concerning the first Two wayes heretikes may be knowne by their doctrine Ibid. The faithfull people may two wayes knowe heretickes from theyr owne doctrines as by theyr proper fruites first by theyr doctrine generally receyued namely as if it be new and vnheard and otherwise than by the knowne rule of faith which anciently they receiued for so the Scripture exhorteth faithfull people when shee giueth warning to beware of heretickes saying If any shall euangelize vnto you otherwise than you haue receyued let him be accursed An other way by theyr false dostrine an hereticke is knowne as by his owne fruite when by the doctrine it selfe euill workes are engendred or when the doctrine it selfe leadeth men vnto wickednesse of life and manners as at this day very many doctrines of other herotickes doe 5 Concerning the latter the euill workes proper to heretikes and by which they may be knowne as by their owne proper fruits How here tikes may be known by their works are a certaine pride not vulgar but especiall against the present and all auncient Doctours of the Church Likewise an hatred not of this man or of that man but of the whole Church or truly of her superiors pertinacie anuy inobedience ambition couetousnesse and a singular kind of hypocrisie And further which vseth to issue out of these-spoile and destructions of Churches subuersion of kingdomes and common-wealths the dissolution of the whole people These fruits of Heretikes the Scripture teacheth and all antiquitie hath obserued So the Anostle there shall be men louing themselues hautie proud and hauing the shew of pietie 2. Tim. 3. but denying all the power thereof that is the Gospell in their mouth charity in their tongue hatred of the Church in their heart sacriledges in their deeds pride in
their breast Againe Rom. 16. not seruing the Lord but their belly by sweet speeches they seduce the hearts of innocents 2. Cor. 11. And againe such false Apostles are craftie worke-men transfiguring themselues into the Apostles of Christ. 1. Tim 4. So vnto Timothie certaine shall depart from the faith attending to the spirits of error and doctrines of diuels speaking a lie in hypocrisie 2. Pet. 2. Further Peter They shall make merchandize of you in couetousnesse with fained words And lastly Titus 1. Paul vnto Titus Teaching the things which behooue not for filthie lucres sake By these fruits wolues are knowne vnder the garments of sheepe and heretikes vnder the title of the Ministers of the Word De vtil credendi cap. 1. Therefore Augustine defineth an Heretike thus An Heretike is he that either begetteth or followeth false and new opinions for temporall commoditie and chiefely for glorie and dominion sake For euery Heretike forsaketh the vnitie and faith of the Catholike Church either for temporall commoditie or to get the praise of his name By all which we see these words of our Sauiour explicated not by any but such a one as in all things fauoureth the Romane church to point out the right way to iudge false teachers by all which the more I duely obserued the more did I find iust cause to forsake the Church of Rome and to abandon all longer communion therewith 6 For first concerning their doctrines The Bishops of Rome haue beene authors of many false doctrines Sess 24. Can. 3. I haue found the Bishops of the Church of Rome to haue been the authors of many erronious nouelties For Pius Quartus decreed at Trent that it should be lawfull for him to allow those degrees to marrie together which God in Leuiticus had forbidden and to forbid those which God had allowed this was ex Cathedra an hereticall decree who can excuse it but this was not his heresie alone for against true faith and beliefe many Popes haue taught the like marriages Summa Angelica verbo Papa nu 1. Martine the fifth allowed one to keep in marriage his owne sister Of late yeares another Pope allowed King Henrie the eighth to marrie his brothers wife in which case of affinitie Ioannes Viguerius teacheth that the Pope hath no lawful power to dispeÌ„ce And another Pope taught Emmanuel King of Portugale to marry two sisters By which dispensations and doctrine Osor de gest Eman. lib. 2. I perceiued both heresie to be taught by Popes and to be practised Celestine Pope ordained marriage to be void Hadrian quod lib. 6. pag. 34. when either of the parties fall into herefie Pope Steuen the sixth decreed in a Councell that such as were ordained Bishops by Pope Formosus his predecessour were not lawfully ordained Sigebert chron an 902. Sigon de Reg. Jtal. lib. 6. an 896. Baron an 897. nu 6. b de consecrat d. 4. à quodam 32.77 quod proposuisti Ibid. §. sed illud Ambr. Concil Senens apud Baron an 303 nu 89. Caranza in Marcel Tom. 2. an 302. nu 102. Athanas epist ad solitar fas tem an 353. Baron an 357. num 43.44 because Formosus was an euill man which tasteth flat Donatisme Pope Nicholas decreed that to Baptise onely in the name of Christ is good Baptisme contrarie to the decrees of Gregorie and Pelagius Pope Gregorie decreed that a man might take another wife in case his wife were so diseased that she would not yeeld him the debt of mariage the which saith Gratian is contrarie to the sacred Canons and to the doctrine of the Apostles and Euangelists Marcellinus committed idolatrie and offered sacrifice to Iupiter Saturne Hercules and the Pagan gods and was thereupon examined and condemned by a Councell of three hundred Bishoppes Which storie Baronius confesseth was from the beginning beleeued with a generall consent and kept in the ancient Martirologies and Breuiaries of the Romane Church Liberius who was Pope about the yeare three hundred and fiftie fell into Arianisme subscribing to the vniust condemnation of Athanasius whereupon Athanasius fell from his communitie and himselfe as an obstinate Heretike was deposed and cast out of the Church Honorius the first that was Pope in the yeare 626. was a Monotholite Heretike whose heresie was that Christ had but one will and so withall but one nature for the which the Church condemned him in three generall Councels In which matter Caius against Pighius saith Synod 6. act 4.12.13 Synod 7. act vlt. Synod 8. act 7. How can Pighius cleare him whom Psellus Tharasius Theodorus with his Councell at Hierusalem Lâ—â— liv 〈…〉 p. â—lt Epiphanius and Pope Adrian affirme to haue beene an Heretike And Dominicus Bannes deriding Pighius calleth it a iest that now after nine hundred yeares Pighius can find all those wickednesses to be forgers 22. Pag. 91. I haue read that in the yeare 1408. in the Councell of Pâ—sa consisting of a chousand Diuines and Lawyers they were faine to depose two Popes at once Gregorie the twelfth and Benet the thirteenth â—hcodor â—â—c meas de 〈…〉 sum hist 〈◊〉 3 〈…〉 cap ◠§ 3. 〈…〉 Atten. vbi supra cap. 6. § 2. Sess 11.12 the tenours of whose depriuation cals them Notorious Scismatikes obstinate maintainers of Seism Heretikes departed from the faith scandalizing the whole Church vnworthie the Papacie cut off from the Church 〈…〉 Benet continued Pope still for all this a second Councell holden at Constance deposed him againe and declared that he had no right to the Papacie commanding all men to esteeme him as an Heretike and Scismatike The same Councell deposed also another Pope for heresie namely Iohn the three and twentieth against whom it was prooued that he held and defended as his iudgement that there is no eternall life Bian pag. 1384. Sess 34. nor no immortalitie of the soule nor resurrection of the dead Not long after the Councell of Basil deposed Eugenius the fourth See AEn Silu. qâ—aest Concil Basil lib. 2. apud Fascir expetend pag. 20. inde Declaring him to be a rebell against the sacred Canons a notable disturber and scandalizer of the peace and vnitie of the Church a Simonist a periured wretch incorrigible a Scismatike an obstinate Heretike By which exampics of Popes teaching false doctrines against faith and notable heresies I obserued the Church of Rome to haue been cleerely deciphered hauing such false prophets and teachers as Christ speaketh of easie to be discerned by the fruits of their doctrines either taught or professed or both And so this way of iudging Heretikes by their doctrine makes exceedingly against the Romane Clergie especially when I reflect vpon all the nouelties taught and confirmed euen by Popes approuing them as concerning the prohibition of Priests marriages the tolleration of the Stewes and Brothel-houses in Rome and other places adoration of the Eucharist with the worship of Latria with
Roman teachers by the fruits of their liues to see whether by them also they can be found such as Christ speaks of to be auoyded Other fruits of the Roman Church and albeit I haue already in the former chapter alleadged much in declaration of their hypocrisie it is here not amisse to consider also somewhat of other their fruits And first to beginne with Ambition Bribery I find that Platina on Damasus 2. noteth that the custome grew that any ambitious fellow might inuade S. Peters seate and that of Boniface 8. the saying was Tâ—latin in vita Damas That he entred like a Fox raigned like a Lion and died like a Dogge Vita Bonis 8. I find also that Iohannes Saresburiensis obserued long agoe that It passed striuing for the Popedome they fought for it ambitious men entred into the holy place Pol. lib. 8. cap. 23 not without theyr Brothers blood I sinde further that Platina speaking of the comming of Siluester 3. to the Popedome saieth Vita Siluest 3. At that time it came to passe that he which most preuaild not in learning ning and holy life but in Aribery and Ambition euen he alone obtained the Papacie good men beeing oppressed and reiected I find also that Caesar Baronius intreating of the Popes that succeeded in the ninth age telleth how about the 908. Theodora a noble woman but a notable strumpet of great beauty and excellent wit by keeping company with Adelbert the Marquesse of Tuscia by whom also she had certaine daughters Anno 908. nu 6. got the monarchie of the Citty into her hands and prostituting her daughters vnto the Popes inuaders of the Apostolike Sea and to the Marquesses of Tuscia thereby the commaund of those strumpets so encreased that at theyr pleasure they remoued the Popes that were lawfully created and thrust violent and mischieuous men into their roome Anno 912. nu 8 I also find moreouer that the famous Ecclesiasticall Writer maketh great complaint for the miserable face of the church at that time saying How filthy was the face of the Roman Church then when most powerfull and withall most sordid whores bare all the sway at Rome at whose lust Seas were changed Bishoppes were giuen and that which is horrible and not to be vttered whose louers the false Popes were thrust into the seate of Peter which were not to be written in the Cathologue of the Roman Bishoppes but for the noting of such times For who may say they were lawfull Popes which were thus without right thrust in by such strumpets No where we find any mention of Clergy choosing or giuing consent afterward all Canons were put to silence the Pontificall decrees were choaked ancient traditions proscribed and the olde customes sacred rites and former vse in choosing the high Bishop vtterly extinguished thus had lust gotten euerie thing to it owne hand By whose complaint I obserued not onely the lasciuiousnesse of those Popes but also that there were no right Popes no continued succession of chiefe bishops which is one of the strongest grounds the teachers of Rome doe build vpon nor consequently no visible head of the Church vpon earth for that this abuse continued almost 200. yeares together discontinuance of time Sigon de reg Ital. an 1046. lib. 8. vnlawfulnes of entrance interrupting the succession which the Church of Rome most insolently braggeth of I finde diuers examples recorded by good Writers of such Apostaticall Popes as shew they were false teachers euen by the confession of such Writers as are highly esteemed in the Church of Rome Who knowes not that Benet the ninth was a child about ten yeeres olde Baron an 103. Baron an 955. num 2.3 Plat. Baron ann 908. nu 1. Baron an 912. num 7. Baron an 928. That Iohn the thirteenth was a mad lad eighteen yeares old at the most That Sergius the third entred violently casting out his predecessor Christopher imprisoning him with bands till hee draue him to turne Friar and so to end his dayes Iohn the eleuenth was created Pope by Theodora and violently intruded for his filthie loue Afterward her daughter Marozia by force of armes expelled him and caused him to be imprisoned where hee was smothered to death Baron an 928. num 2. Baron an 931. num 1. Leo the sixt succeeded him and hee also was imprisoned and died The next but one was Iohn the twelfth hee was bastard to Sergius by madame Marozia and being yet but a stripling was violently put into the Popedome by his mother and her husband Wido the Marquesse The next Pope but one was Stephen Baron an 940. num 1. chosen by the Romans without the Cardinals consent Iohn the thirteenth another boy was made Pope by the faction of Albericus his father Baron 9.55 num 4. when for his age hee was not yet capable of the order of a Deacon in the end his Bishops forsooke him Luitpr li. 6. c. 11 and one night as hee was in bed with a mans wife the diuell strucke him and he died About ten yeeres after Benet the sixt was imprisoned and murdred by Boniface that succeeded him who got the Popedome by violence Baron an 974. was againe himselfe as violently deposed Anno 275. nu 1 and Iohn the fifteenth put in his roome but hee returned againe and apprehending Iohn imprisoned and murdered him Anno 985. nu 1. Baronius saith of him Hee was a villaine and a thiefe the murderer of two Popes the inuader of Peters Chaire who had not so much as one haire of a Roman Bishop whether we consider his entrance or going forward but deserueth to be reckoned amongst famous theeues and ransakers of their Countrey such as were Sylla and Catiline all who might cast their cappes at this thiefe By all which fruits I was much diuerted from the church of Rome Yet other fruits as bad as the former Besides the great schismes that haue bin amongst the Popes are fruites by which they may well be knowne for false prophets wherein there haue been two or three Popes at once I find about the yeare 1044. Benet the ninth Baron an 1044. num 1.2.5 Naucl vol. 2. gener 35. Onup in Greg. 6. Theod. in Niem lib. 1. ca. 7. Siluester the 3. and Iohn were all Popes at once and made their abode in 3. seuerall places of the cittie diuiding amongst them the reuenews of the Patriarchies vntill Gregory the 6. hiring them with money to giue ouer himselfe was created the fourth Pope and was presently expelled againe and Clement ordained Againe about the yeare 1379. beganne the schisme betweene Vrban and Clement which ended not till seuenty yeeres after At the first there were two Popes togither the one in Italie the other in France Naucleer col 2. gener 46. Ioh. Moium de reb Hisp l. 18. c. 1 Naucl. gene 47. what time the most learned men aliue could not
Guic. Hist l. 1. buying the consent of the Cardinals that after smarted for it The King of Naples signified vnto the Queene his wife with teares when he heard of his election that there was a Pope created who would be the bane of Italie and of the whole Commonwealth the which was also the generall ceonceit of all men Guicciardine sayth He was a Serpent Lib. 6. that with his poysoned infidelitie horrible examples of crueltie luxurie and monstrous couetousnesse selling without distinction thinges holy and prophane had infected all the world His manners and customes were dishonest Lib. 1. little sinceritie in his administrations no shame in his face small truth in his wordes little faith in his heart and lesse religion in his opinions all his actions were desiled with vnsatiable couetousnesse immoderate ambition and barbarous crueltie He was not ashamed contrarie to the custome of former Popes who to caest some colour ouer their infamie were wont to call them their nephewes to call his sonnes his childen Lib. 3. and for such to expresse them to the world The bruit went that in the loue of his owne daughter Lucretia were concurrent not onely his two sonnes the Duke of Candie and the Cardinall of Valence but himselfe also that was her father who as soone as hee was chosen Pope tooke her from her husband and married her to the Lord of Pesere but not able to suffer her husband to be his corriuall hee dissolued that marriage also and tooke her to himselfe by vertue of Saint Peters keyes Lib. 6. Onuph It was among other graces his naturall custome to vse poysonings not onely to bee reuenged of his enemies but also to despoyle the wealthie Cardinals of their riches And this hee spared not to doe against his owne friends till at the last hauing a purpose at a bauquet to poyson diuers Cardinals and for that end appointed his Cup-bearer to giue attendance with the wine amde readie for the nonce who mistaking his bottle gaue the poysoned cup to him was thus himselfe dispatched by the iust iudgement of God that had purposed to murder his friends that he might be their heire 12 I omit many other particular fruits of diuers Popes which would make much more against the Church of Rome but these being ynough for the application to Dr. Stapletons doctrine concerning the discouerie of false Prophets vnto the Teachers of the Church of Rome I could not but iudge the teachers of that Church too passionate and partiall that knowing the most distastfull fruites thereof not onely in their Head the Pope but also in their Cardinals Bishops and euen in their religious Monasteries to haue been so bad as the like are not to be found in any of the resormed Churches will notwithstanding most vniustly charge the Ministers of Gods Word and Teachers of reformation to abound in such fruits insomuch that I could not but admire the impudencie of Master Doctor Stapleton speaking against the Teachers of the reformed Churches saying The Diuell seemeth to haue receiued power from God by his Ministers Bonif. Mor. Dom. 7. post Pent. loc 2. the Heretikes of our time to produce most barbarous and horrible fruits and to make huge slaughters in the Church and according to his pleasure and malice to vexe trouble and destroy the mysticall bodie of Christ as well in the whole worship and Sacraments of Religion as also in all the authoritie and power it hath vpon earth Whereas in truth mature iudgement of the premised fruits of the Church of Rome both concerning doctrine and manners will discouer his rash assertion to be vertified of himselfe and his owne Romane Church teaching many nouelties and abounding in all kind of wickednesse as men of learning and experience well know And therefore his enumeration of 74 wicked fruits in the Teachers of reformation may fitlier be applyed in part to the Church of Rome and in the meane time the reformed Churches hauing learned to forgiue not onely 74 calumniations and iniurious reproaches but euen 77 and that 77 times of their offending neighbours will not be so vncharitable as not to pardon them but also most earnestly out of true charitie pray for their conuersion as Christ did for the Iewes saying Ignosce eis Domine quia nesciunt quid faciunt Pardon them O Lord because they know not what they doe Hence courteous Reader since I follow but the Councell in the search of truth which Christ by the interpretation of the Romanists themselues giueth to all in iudging Teachers by their fruits and hereby being moued to an alienation from the Church of Rome I hope that in conscience euen in the sight of God and Man I am excusable for my incorporation to the Church of England since it is grounded vpon such a place of Scripture as Christ himselfe deliuereth and the Church of Rome alloweth as a direction by which men may discerne the truth of their Teachers Esteeme not therefore slight ly of this inducement but weigh it seriously as indeed it is a point of great importance to produce in the soules of Christians that true detestation and hatred of the Romane Apostasie as the enormities and foule deformities thereof varnisht ouer with lies and hipocrisies doe require CHAP. XIII Containing an obseruation about the Sacrifice of the Masse which is accompted by the Church of Rome the chiefest act of Religion which can be done to God AS that obiect which is most frequently presented to a mans eies The Sacrificie of the Masse grounded vpon mans inuention is also most frequent in his memorie and taketh the deepest impression euen so the Sacrifice of the Masse being an action which in the Papacie as a Priest I did daily performe with more serious preparation and intensiue affection than any thing else whatsoeuer because I held it the most pleasing action I could doe to the honour of God to the good of his Church and for the benefit of my selfe and others therefore amongst all the erroneous doctrines which I discouered in the Church of Rome the abuse thereof doth most often offer it selfe to my minde and with greatest impression laieth open vnto mee the foulenesse of my former heresies in that Church and toucheth my soule with the deepest stroke of repentance aboue all others especially when I consider the most detestable Idolatrie committed therein not only by my selfe but by the Assistants in adoring visible Elements for the Sauiour of the world and that with such a kinde of worship as is only due to God himselfe and in being too credulous to that erroneous doctrine of the Councell of Trent Sess 6. c. 2. can 3 that if any man shall say that the Sacrifice of the Masse is only a Sacrifice of praise and thankes-giuing or a bare commemoration of the Sacrifice performed vpon the Crosse and not a propitiatorie Sacrifice or that it doth not profit him alone that receiueth it and that it ought not to bee
offered for the liuing and the dead for their sinnes punishments satisfactions and other necessities let him bee accursed Which curse albeit it carrieth a terrour with it to such as are not enlightned so that they can discerne the erroneous doctrine for which it accurseth and that carrieth not rather in minde the feare of Gods maledication than any of man saying Cursed is hee that putteth his trust in man and taketh man for his defence and his heart goeth from the Lord as the followers of the Church of Rome doe who relie only vpon the Popes authoritie who may be as sinnefull a man as any other thinking themselues secure if his authoritie be their defence and the warrant of their beliefe yet could I not stand in dread of his curse when once I found this Sacrifice of the Masse as it is now taught by the Church of Rome not to haue sufficient warrant by Gods word nor by the ancient Church teaching any such doctrine concerning it as the present Church of Rome teacheth 2. The Masse was not instituted by Christ For first I obserued that this Sacrifice which the Church of Rome teacheth to bee a propitiatorie Sacrifice and such a one as may be offered for sinnes as well of the liuing as of the dead is not any thing agreeable to the institution of our LORD IESVS there is not so much as a word spoken by CHRIST of any offering or oblation to bee made but only commandement giuen to eate and drinke and to doe that in remembrance of him his wordes only importing the institution of a Sacrament and no Sacrifice Neither did hee so much as vtter a word that hee offered himselfe at the last Supper for Cornelius Musso a Bishop so famous for his learning Bib lioth Sanct. lib. 4. Suar. tom 3. d. 74 §. 2. as Sixtus Senensis writeth that hee was a Preacher at twelue yeares old and all Italie ranne after him did defend that Christ at his last Supper offered no Sacrifice at all whereupon I framed this argument Note this argument The Priest in the Commemoration of the last Supper is not to doe other thing in substance then what Christ did but Christ as Musso held offered to Sacrifice at all ergo the Priest in commemoration of Christs last Supper is not to offer vp any Sacrifice at all Behold then here it followeth by necessarie consequence vpon Mussoes Assertion that the Sacrifice of the Masse is not to bee offered at all It is cleare as Musso saith that hee offered not himselfe to his Father at his last Supper for then should hee not haue perfected his Sacrifice with one oblation made as the Apostle Saint Paule teacheth Hebr. 7.27 and 9.26.28 but with a double Oblation twice made namely once in his Supper and once vpon the Crosse which were most repugnant to the holy Scripture Againe the Apostle Saint Paul saith 1. Cor. 11. v. 23. sequent I haue receiued of the Lord that which I deliuered vnto you c. and so sheweth the whole manner of CHRISTS institution of the blessed Eucharist who made no mention at all of any Sacrifice which the Apostle considering he boasted that hee had shewed all the Councell of God would not haue omitted Act. 20.27 if the Supper had contayned any meaning of a propitatorie Sacrifice Moreouer Saint Paul writing to the Corinthians bids vs to shew the Lords death not by sacrificing Christ for to Sacrifice and to shew the Lords death are two distinct thinges and the shewing CHRISTS death by the Sacrament is sufficient for the application thereof to our soules for the remission of our sinnes Therefore I could not conceiue any such Sacrifice as the Masse propitiatorie for sins to be instituted by Christ which Sacrifice if it bee of such importance as the Church of Rome teacheth and so principall an act of religion doubtlesse there would haue beene some apparent touch thereof expresly giuen in the holy Scriptures and especially in that place where the Papists pretend it should be instituted Again The Sacrifice of the Masse disableth Christs sacrifice vpon the Crosse 1 Ioh. 22. I haue further obserued that to teach the doctrine of the propitiatorie Sacrifice of the Masse the perfect satisfaction made by Christs Sacrifice vpon the Crosse is made insufficient and inualid For hee being the propitation or reconciliation not only for our sinnes but also for the sinnes of the whole world for the demonstration of which effect vpon the Crosse he cried Ioh. 19.30 finished I can see no neede why a propitiatorie Sacrifice of the Masse should bee offered for sinnes so often since the reconciliation made by Christ is applied by the Sacrament Hebr. 7.27 Besides since Christ did it once when he offered vp himselfe and as S. Paul saith Not that he should offer imselfe often Hebr. 9.25 none being Priests according to the order of Melchisedech but Christ of whom the Scripture saith Hebr. 5.4.5 Tues Sacerdos in aeternū secundū ordinē Melchi it followeth that no other was to offer vp Christ as a propitiatorie Sacrifice for sins but himselfe Moreouer the Sacrifice of Christ hath no neede to bee often reiterated whereby the Priesthood of Christ is opposite to the Priesthood of the old Testament whose sacrifices ought to bee reiterated for Christ needed not daily Hebr. 7.27 as those high Priests to offer vp sacrifice for his owne sinnes and then for the peoples for that did he once when he offered vp himselfe And againe After hee had said This is the testament that I will make with them c. and their sinnes and iniquities will I remember no more Hebr. 10.16.17.18 Where remission of these thinges is there is no more offering for sinne And againe Christ by his owne bloud entred once into the holy place and obtained eternall redemption for vs not such a redemption as is to be reiterated euery day Hebr. 9.12 And againe Not that hee should offer him selfe often as the high Priest entred into the holy place euery yeare with other bloud for then must hee haue often suffered since the foundation of the world but now in the end of the world hath hee appeared once to put away sinne by the Sacrifice of him selfe And as it is appointed vnto men once to die and then commeth the iudgement So Christ was once offered to take away the sinnes of many Againe Hebr. 9.25.26 By the which Will wee are sanctified euen by the offering of the body of IESVS CHRIST once made And againe Hebr. 10.10 Euery Priest appeareth daily ministring and often times offered one manner of Sacrifice which can neuer take away sinnes but this Man after hee had offered one Sacrifice for sinnes sitteth for euer at the right hand of God Hebr. 10.11.12 c. for with one offering hee consecrated for euer them that are sanctified By which places it is cleare there needes no more reiteration
of CHRIST alreadie sacrificed who once hath wrought Redemption and Propitiation for sinne vvhich is to bee applied by the Sacrament 4. The sacrifice of the Masse a nouell doctrine Praeceptor Romae desacr Mis c. 1 dict 2. In can not but meruaile that the Sacrifice of the Masse can bee esteemed so highly as it is in the Church of Rome which is as they say and teach a Sacrifice that is perfected and consisteth of Christ as the thing offered and chiefly of three actions the Consecration the Oblation and Consumption Which saith the same Authour concerning the substance was instituted by Christ Ibid. dicto 1. concerning the action as it is now done by the Church For if wee looke well into it wee shall finde it but a nouell doctrine in all the essentiall parts thereof It beganne not all at once but by degrees for the Latine language came not in where the people vnderstood it till the time of Gregorie six hundred yeares after Christ Declarat ad Censar Theol. prouis as Erasmus saith the Church in former time vsing the Seruice in the Vulgar tongue The doctrine likewise of Transubstantiation nowe beleeued by the present Church of Rome Tom. 3. dist 5. sect 1. p. 628. to be therein is acknowledged by Scotus and Biel to be no elder than the Councell of Laternae for so Suares the Iesuite writeth of them The Sacrifice or oblation thought by some to be made therein in the iudgement of other learned Papists was not done by Christ For Azorius the Iesuit writeth Jnstit Moral lib. 10. cap. 8. That some Catholikes deny that Christ offered vp himselfe vnder the forme of Bread and Wine in his last Supper which being true indeede it followeth that the opinion of such a sacrifice is not founded vpon Christs deede or instituted by him but vpon some later inuention since him Whence it followeth that Ioannes Stephanus Durantus doth teach most vnsound doctrine De ritibus Eccl. â—â—ath cap. 3. n. 1. 2. when he saith That it is perspicuous by the testimonies of Christ himselfe of Paul the Apostle and of ancient Fathers that Christ instuuted the sacrifice of the Masse and was the Authour thereof who also after hee had cited the institution of the Sacrament Luke the 21. and 1. Cor. 11. vpon those wordes Doe yee this in remembrance of mee he concludeth That by those wordes Christ gaue a commandement of sacrificing vnto Priests A notorious shift of a learned Papist to proue the Masse for to doe signifieth to sacrifice But in very truth whosoeuer is not most stupid may out of the wordes of both places euince the contrarie and discerne what a grosse absurditie it is to inforce that because to doe sometimes doth signifie to Sacrifice therefore Christ commanded the Priests to Sacrifice for if it be true that there Christs commandement to doe this imported a command to Sacrifice where then is the Sacrament instituted which is a distinct thing from a Sacrifice Many such shifts as these are the Teachers of the Romane Church enforced to vnder-take for the maintenance of their Doctrine which if men would obserue with attention and iudgement they might with very great facilitie discouer the weake grounds of all their Arguments I finde that Thomas Aquinas seemed to bee of a contrarie opinion For disputing how Christ is sacrificed in the Eucharist hee answereth that hee is said to bee in two respects First because the ministration of the Sacrament is an Image Thomas Aquinas against the Masse representing the Passion of Christ which is his true immolation and Images vse to bee called by the names of those thinges whereof they are Images Secondly in respect of the effect of his Passion because by the Sacrament wee are made partakers of the fruit of his Passion And saith hee As concerning this second manner it is proper to this Sacrament that Christ is immolated or sacrificed therein These reasons argue that hee held no such kinde of Sacrifice as the present Church of Rome defendeth because the celebration of the Eucharist in his iudgement being but an Image of the true Sacrifice of Christ hee could not thinke it to bee a true sacrifice vni-vocally so called but only by externall relation And saying againe That Christ is sacrificed therein by reason wee are made partakers of the fruit of his Paession hee sheweth clearely hee knew no reall sacrifice because wee are made partakers of that euen in Baptisme also where no man imagins Christ to bee sacrificed 5. Idolatrie is coÌ„mitted in the sacrifice of the Masse But what shall I say of that most odious and horrible Idolatrie that is committed in the sacrifice of the Masse where Bread and Wine which are the creatures of God are worshipped with Latria as is the Sonne of God the which worship is onely due to God O yee heauens come and admire at this vnspeakable folly and blindnesse of men they stick not only to doe this abhominable fact but they persist also in teaching it I my selfe being a Student in the Colledge in Rome had this deliuered me from my Master in the Pulpit a learned Iesuit in manner following as a matter of faith who vpon this question Who is to be worshipped with the adoration of Latria De adorat ff 1. q. 1. in dictat Rom. saith Thirdly with the same worship of Latria the consecrated Hoast and Chalice is to be worshipped because vnder those most sacred formes Christ the Lord is adored who is really present according to his humanitie diuinitie which is defined in the Councell of Trent Sess 13. c. 5. can 6. lib. 2. deritib Eccles cap. 40. and Stephanus Durantus sheweth it most fully this doctrine as it is most vntrue so is it here affirmed by the Italian Reader with a manifest vntruth for I can not so much as finde the word Latria in all that Chapter of Stephanus Durantus An ItaliaÌ„ trick which I haue very carefully perused herein Durant c. 40. l. 2. num 3. who only affirmeth That it is probable that the Eucharist is lifted vp and shewed to the people for adorations sake and hee may as well be vnderstood of Dulia or Hyperdulia or of a lesse reuerence which is done in the ministration of any Sacrament not in worship of the thing present but in worship of God who is in heauen Yea and to shew that this kind of Latria-worship is held to bee a doctrine of Faith in answere to his third question Ibidem which is this Since the precept of adoring the Sacrament is a matter of Faith at what time doth it oblige the faithfull to performe it Hee answereth in soure cases First when the Sacrament in the Sacrifice of the Masse is eleuated those that are present are bound to adore it Secondly when it is carried to the sick Thirdly when the Hoâ—st is ministred to the Communicants the Communicants are not only bound to
for whereas before it is cited that he made Pope Sergius the ordainer of t is triple fraction Desancto Greg. Pap. ser 4. yet saith he in another place speaking of Greg. the great He ordained also that in the masse three parts should be made of the body of Christ to signifie that the mysticall body that is the faithful of Christ are diuided into 3. parts for that part which is put in the chalice hidden and put in the wine signifies that part which is in heauen which is hidden from all euills and is made drunk with the plenty of Gods house the other 2. parts signifie the 2. parts of the faithfull which areyet exposed to tribulations the one which in the world is exposed to much trouble the other which is in purgatory subiect to great tormēt Out of which Author by the way I obserue the great alteration made in the masse who saith that whereas the masse was first said confusedly he viz. Greg. adorned it beautifully appointed in to be sung in a threefold language to wit in the greeke as Kyrie-eleison in the hebrew as Amen and Alleluia in the latin as the rest By all which premises if I should adde herevnto the various meanings of the Priests turning one while his backe to the people another while his face Jbidem one while reading aloude as if he were chiding in an vnknowne tong otherwhile in silence as if he were asleep one while turning a half circle other while turning round the whole as if he were dancing Salingers round one while reading at the middle of the Altare then on the right end after hopping to the left like a nimble stage-plaier as I and others somtimes obserued in a quicke footed Iesuit not without smiling at such his antike gestures he did them with so ill a grace If I should adde all these the reading of thē would be too tedious yet by the former related the reader may iudge of the rest the true meaning whereof may be forged out of any priuate mans braine as he pleaseth as it appeares by the distracted senses of these already cited out of diuers Authors truely there is no man of a pious affectiō but may frame far more reuerēd ceremonies than any of these euen almost out of euery ordinary action How the Papists doe vse much to establish the doctrine of the Masse by the allegations of bastard fathers as for the antiquitie of the masses ceremonies most of them are but nouel in respect of the ancient and primitiue times of Gods church neither instituted by Christ or by any of the Apostles many of them ordained in imitation of the Roman heathenish ceremonies practised about the idolatrous worship of their false gods 7 It is strange notwithstanding very obseruable to note the frequent practise of Romish teachers in the citations of bastard Authors when by the ancient Fathers they go about to establish this doctrine of the masse in the mindes of those that are either too simple or ouer-credulous who are easie to be deceiued either by the good opinion they conceiue of them or by the long acquaintance familiar conuersation they haue long maintained but all is not gold that glisters the wolfe wil deceiue by he sheeps skin weeping Crocadils wil bite to death and sweet notes of singing Syrens drowne their hearers Euen so fares it spiritually with poore Romish Catholikes as they call thēselues when they lend their eares to the pretended antiquity the Priests will alleadge for their doctrine which especially is apparent in their proofs for the sacrifice of the masse Pag. 10. For M. Tho. Harding in his answer to M. Iewels challenge Pag. 320. as also M. Tho. Heskins in his Parliamēt do alleage Abdias bishop of Babilon who liued Ann. Dom. 44. vnder whose name there is a Book intituled The Stories of the Apostles which is iudged by Sixtus Senensis for a treatise fained vnder his name by cardinall Baro. is vtterly reiected yet M. Heskins saith For thy better confirmation gentle Reader I shal adde the testimony of Abdias Bish of Babylon Pag. 43. and a Disciple of the Apostles who writeth thus of the masse death of S. Mathew And when all had said Amen when all the Church had receiued the Masse To. 1. pag. 326. pag. 394. Abdias hist Apostol lib. 7. and the mysteries that were celebrated hee stayed himselfe that by the Altar where the body of Christ was by him consecrated there should his martirdome be solemnized These plaine words deuised and fathered vpon Abdias may iustly giue cause for men deceiued to looke about them what they beleeue not easily to beleeue all that either master Harding or master Heskins or others doe alleadge out of Antiquitie for many such counterfeit Writers are often all eadged because no better can bee found for the proofe of their false doctrine I finde likewise that Iodocus Coccius to establish the Masse citeth Clement a Bishoppe of Rome who liued in the yeare 80. as Author of the eight Bookes of Apostolicall Institutions To. 2. pag. 656. 868. To 1. pag. 117. and yet the Cardinall Baronius iudges them to be written in his name and Posseuinus the Iesuite seems to thinke it will be a hard matter to proue them to be either Apostolicall or lawfull or at the least written by Clement himselfe his words are these Turrianus hath not altogether amongst all proued or euicted those constitutions to the Apostolicall or lawfull Posseuin in Appar pag. 328. written by Clement himselfe And yet notwithstanding the Papists make no scruple to cite these bookes as most authenticall as heere Coccius doth So deale the Rhemists also to proue the sacrifice of the Masse alleaging Dionisius the Areopagit Pag. 204. who liued in the yeare 96. as Author of the celestial and ecclesiastical Hierarchy which book notwithstanding is reiected by Caietan that famous schoole-man among the Cardinals Cap. 3. as you shal find it written in Sixtus Senensis Pag. 61. So to proue the same doctrine Doctor Harding in his Reioynder against Iewels Replie of the Masse and also Cardinall Bellarmine alleage Arnobius who liued in the yeare three hundred Pag. 47. and pag 206. Tom. 3.955 as the Author of the Commentaries on all the Psalmes yet is it iudged by Sixtus Senensis by the incongruitie of the stile Pag. 262 et 201. innumberable soloecismes and barbarismes which are in it to be as farre different from his other writings as heauen is from earth and Posseuine saith of them Posseuin in Appar pag. 129. Neither are they approued by Sixtus Senensis nor by others So againe to establish the Masse Iodocus Coccius alleageth Damasus Pope of Rome Tom. 1.667 who liued in the yeare three hundred sixtie seuen as Author of the booke carrying this title of the liues of the Bishops of Rome commonly called Liber Pontificalis which booke Posseuine iudgeth to
and wine passe into the substance of the body and bloud of Christ yet so as the nature of bread and wine ceaseth not and they are turned into the diuine substance yet the bread and wine still remaine in the propertie of their nature If this be true that the nature of bread and wine ceaseth not and that the bread and wine still remaine in the propertie of their nature then can not transubstantiation stand For hereby Gelasius confuted Eutiches the Heretike holding that Christ had but one nature and that in regard of the vnion the humanitie was turned into the Deitie against which error he opposed the doctrine of the Eucharist shewing that as therein bread and wine after consecration were honoured with the name of his body and bloud and receiued grace to their nature to bee a holy Sacrament though still they remained in their former nature and propertie So the humanitie of Christ receiued grace by the hypostaticall vniting it to the God-head and yet still retained the former propertie to be humane flesh Therefore had Gelasius beliefe beene answerable to the present Church of Rome concerning Transubstantiation he not only could not thereby haue confuted Eutiches but Eutiches might by that very doctrine most probably haue confuted him Who might right well haue argued thus Thou Gelasius thinkest the Sacrament a resemblance of the incarnation of Christ and the vnion of his two natures but in the Sacrament the bread and wine after consecration remaine no more but are turned into the flesh and bloud of Christ and so there is but one substance After this manner may I likewise say in the Incarnation after the vnion the humanitie remaineth no more but is changed into the Diuinitie and the Nature is but one What could Gelasius haue answered to this Argument if hee had held the doctrine of Transubstantiation Hence it is euident both by his wordes and the scope of his disputation that he held it not Not vnlike to Gelasius is the doctrine of Theodoret Dial. immuta fol. 8. writing thus Our Sauiour in deliuering the Sacrament called his body bread and that which is in the cup he called his bloud he changed the names and gaue his body that name which belonged to the signe and to the signe that name which belonged to his body The reason why he thus changed the names was because he would haue such as partake the diuine Sacraments not to heede the nature of those thinges which are seene but for the change sake of the names to beleeue the change that is made by grace For he called it wheat and bread which by nature is his body and againe on the other side he called himselfe a Vine Thus honoring the simbols and signes which are seen with the name of his body bâ—oud not by changing their nature but by adding grace to nature And further the same Author in an other place reprehending the Eutichian heretike saith Dialog 2. Inconfusus You are caught in your owne net for the mysticall signes after consecration do not depart from their nature but they abide in their former substance form and figure and may be seen touched as before If they depart not from their nature if they abide in their former substance figure and forme if Christ changed not the natures but the names adding grace to nature how can the doctrine of transubstantiation in the iudgement of this writer stand free from the impeachment of an erroneous innouation 7. How moderne Authors of the Church of Rome shew the doctrine of transubstantiation to be nouell De verit corp sang p. 46. And so I find euen by the confession of the learnedst moderne Writers this doctrine is but nouell and of small antiquitie and hath not been beleeued as a matter of faith in the purest ages of the Primitiue Church for it is well knowne that before the Councell of Laterane no man was bound to beleeue Transubstantiation as themselues confesse Tonstal sayth It was free for all men till that time to follow their owne coniecture as concerning the manner of the Presence Scotus and Biel are reported by the later Schoolemen to haue been of minde That the opinion is very new and lately brought into the Church Soto 4. d 9. q. 2. art 2. 4. Suar. tom 3. d. 5.4 d. 10. q. 2. ad arg pro prima sect 1. and beleeued only vpon the authoritie of the Laterance Councell And Scotus himselfe saith We must say the Church in the Creede of the Laterane Councell vnder Innocent the third which begins with the words Firmiter credimus declared this sense concerning transubstantiation to belong to the verity of our faith Besides Scotus Bellarmine confesse Scot. d. 11. q. 3. Bellar. Euchar. lib. 3. cap. 23. Turrec tract 13. q. 49. There is no Scripture to conuince it vnlesse yee bring the Church of Romes exposition that is to say the Popes authoritie in whom they thinke the power of the vniuersall Church in determining matters of faith principally resides Now therefore if this doctrine bee no more ancient than the Councell of Laterane as it is cleare I oppose against the accurse of the Councell of Trent the malediction of blessed Saint Paul a better man than any in the Councell of Trent who pronounceth a direfull Anathema against any that shall teach other doctrine than what he taught how fearefull a state then doe all Popish Priests stand in that teach this noueltie of Transubstantiation diametrally contrarie to the places of S. Paul before cited 1. Cor. 10.16 1. Cor. 11.26 Vers 27. Vers 28. Euagrius 4. lib. Hist c. 35. Niceph. lib. 17. cap. 25. Hiesich l 2. super Leuit. cap. 8. Euseb lib. 7. c. 8. August cont lit Petil. lib. 9. c. 30. It is well knowne that it was an vsuall thing in former ages in diuers places to giue the residues of the Sacrament to little children as Euagrius and Nicephorus haue left recorded to posteritie Yea and in other places of the Christian world as Hesichius teacheth neither hath it beene thought much in former times to giue the bread of the Sacrament into the peoples handes and sometimes permitted them to carry it home which is a signe that they conceipted not then the doctrine of Transubstantiation which hath caused it since to be adored and haue made it a sinnefull act for Lay people to touch the Sacrament yea and haue brought it to such a fond esteeme that if a Flie or a Spider fall into the wine or any like thing which can not without vomit or danger of death be taken downe the Flie or Spider or what else must be taken out and washed as warily as may be in a Chalice and the Priest must take the ablution but the Flie or Spider must be burnt Ibidem eodem cap. Or if a sick man vomit vp the body of the Lord it must bee taken vp againe as diligently as may be and taken by a
Priest or by some cleane and discreet youth if the sicke man can not resume it himselfe 8. The inconueniences of approuing Transubstantiation Besides the inconueniences that follow of this doctrine of Transubstantiation are so many that no man almost out of common sense can admit it vnlesse bee will fondly suffer himselfe to bee carried away with such a generall implicite faith of the Church of Romes inerrabilitie whereby he may fall into as many heresies and dangers of seduction as a blinde man is in danger of falls if he will only walke by the guidance of an other as blinde as himselfe Hence it followeth that it must be beleeued that accidents are without a subiect whereas the nature of a Sacrament requireth no such matter like as when the wood is burned the colour of the wood should remaine alone without a subiect that Mice that knaw the consecrated Hoast doe knaw bare accidents alone and thta the glorified body of Christ are subiect to the grinding of teeth That no worke of God neither of Creation nor of Redemption is so great as the worke of consecration by the Priest by which transubstantiation is performed Whence it is come that the Romish Diuines hold that many miracles together are done in the Sacrament of the Eucharist whereof Ioannes de Combis reckoneth vp nine so fond and ridiculous that it is a wonder any man can beleeue them as first In Comp. Theol. verit lib. 6. c. 14. That the body of Christ is in as much quantitie there as it was vpon the Crosse and as it is now in heauen yet doth it not exceede the bounds of that forme with all the rest of like nature Hence to breede a beliefe of this doctrine the Romish writers tell vs that the Sacrament being lost in a Village of Komele in Germanie in a Pixe Caesar lib. 9. c. 7. it was discouered in a field by the Oxen that did worship it kneeling downe vpon the ground which neither by whips nor cries would not stir out of the place from worshipping their Creatour till it was taken away by the Parish Priest who fetcht it away with crosse candle and incense in great reuerence They tell also how a certaine woman going to the Communion reserued the Sacrament and put it into her hiue amongst her Bees as one had counsailed her wherevpon the pretie Bees were so religiously affected to their creatour that for the fit entertainment of so great a guest S. Anto. 3 p. sum tit 12. c. 8. ff 3. they built him a goodly Chappell in waxe with walls windowes dores caues and Altar to rest him vpon with a bell also and when the time was come that the honie was to be taken out the woman raised vp her hiue and beheld this fine miracle which caused her with great feare to go and confesse her fault to the Priest who with his Parishioners carried the Hoast with great reuerence to the Church They tell also for a great miracle concerning this doctrine S. Bonauent in vit 8. Francis Cath. Hist cap. 5 tit 13. part 4. how that S. Francis had a sheepe which ordinarily went to Church which at the time of Eleuation of the Lords body that the people might worship it bended downe his head fell vpon his knees shewing all other tokens of worship and adoration which much moued the assistance to greater deuotion They tell further Ioan. Mefreth in hort Reign ser de coena Domini that when a woman cast the Sacrament amongst Swine they kneeled downe to it and worshipped it how shee rosted it and it fell a bleeding how shee buried it in the earth and yet still the bloud flowed forth whereupon moued to compunction shee beleeued the true body of Christ to be in the Sacrament and did penance for her incredulitie all the rest of her life Many other the like incredible fables they haue left recorded to moue men to worship the bread and wine in the Sacrament with diuine honour due only to God and so to confirme this noueltie of Transubstantiation the which since there are no Scriptures to support it I can not beleeue it as also for that the obseruations of the reasons noted in this Chapter induce me to the contrarie beliefe Therefore deare Reader beware how you beleeue the Romish doctrine established with such lying signes and wonders reiecting both Scriptures and Fathers to the contrarie make not a corruptible creature your God and Maker giue honour and glorie vnto God only who by his infinite mercies requires it at thy handes and as I haue done renounce all societie in rites ceremonies and acts of religion with the Church of Rome that that of Dauid may be verified both of me thee Psal 1. v. 1. saving Blessed is the man that hath not walked in the councell of the vngodly nor stood in the way of sinners and hath not sit in the chaire of Pestilence which happinesse thou maiest enioy if thou followest not the vngodlie Councells of Laterane and Trent in this point of doctrine if thou continuest not in that Church and restest not thy selfe vpon that Pestilent chaire of Romes infectious Idolatries CHAP. XIIII Containeth an obseruation about the Sacrament ministred but vnder one kinde to Lay people in the Church of Rome I Haue read in a certaine Preacher that the Writers of naturall thinges haue left recorded The Sacramēt vnder one kind giueth not life vnto the soule Petrus Besseus Concep Theol. fer 2. maior Heb that there is a certaine hearbe to bee found vpon the Alpes hauing only two branches which is of such a strange naturall power and officacie that the beasts liuing vpon those mountaines if they chance to tast but of one of those branches forthwith they die but if they eate of both branches they take no hurt or dammage but are nourished thereby Euen so doe I obserue vpon the mountaines of holy Scripture the plant of the holy Eucharist hauing two branches of bread and wine by Christs institution of such nature and qualitie that if by faith his faithfull flock eate but of one branch and leaue the other they perish through heresie but if by faith they tast and feede of both branches that is both of bread and wine they feele much good they are strengthened in the life of their soule and are much nourished thereby according to that of Christ Ioan. 6. Nisi manducaueritis carnem filij hominis biberitis eius sanguinem non habebitis vit am in vobis Vnlesse you eate the flesh of the Sonne of man and drinke his bloud you shall not haue life in you Whereby I obserue the great danger the Church of Rome standeth in which will afford here sheepe in the Sacrament only one branch viz. the bread and bereaue them of the other branch viz. the wine and on the contrarie side the great happinesse of the Church of England which affordeth Christs faithfull flocke both branches
their mindes Afterward the Councell of Basil released the decree of Constance to some as to the Bohemians and the Councell of Trent confirmed it againe Ses 21. c. 2. Whereby it is apparant that the moderne Church of Rome hath swarued in this point of faith from which it beleeued formerly and since it began to be the seat of Antichrist The most ancient Liturgies in their owne forme shew Cyril Cath. mystag 5. Liturg. Marci pag. 62. Thom. p. 3. q. 80. art 12 q. 3. Hom. 16. in nu 1 that the people receiued the wine as well as the bread And Caietane sayth This custome endured long in the Church and that they had ministring cuppes for the nonce to serue the people with wine which none will denie Origen sayth plainegly Christian people were accustomed to drinke the bloud And S. Cyprian How doe we make them fit for the cup of Martyrdome Epist. 2. if first we doe not admit them by the right of communication in the Church to drinke the cup of the Lord The same Author or another as ancient Serm. de coena Dom. in another place sayth The Law doth prohibit the eating of bloud the Gospell commaundeth that it be drunke That the Chalice also was vsed in S. Ambrose his time himselfe sheweth Apud Theod. 5. Hist 15. In 2. Malach. speaking to Theodosius With what boldnesse wilt thou partake with thy mouth the cup of precious bloud S. Hierome sayth in expresse tearmes The Priestes which make the Eucharist and distribute the bloud of the Lord to the people And Paschasius sayth Super cap. 15. Drinke ye all of this as well the ministers as the other beleeuers Apud Gratian. can Comperimus de consecrat dist 2. Gelasius sayth We finde that some receiuing onely the portion of the sacred bodie abstaine from the cup of sacred bloud Who doubtlesse because I know not by what superstition they are taught to be obliged either let them receiue the entire Sacraments or let them be expelled from the entire Sacraments because the duision of one and the same mysterie cannot be without grat sacriledge All which places doe most liuely expresse the faith and practise of the ancient Church to haue beene otherwise than it is now in the present Church 6 Is it not a lamentable thing to see Obserue well this Councell Ses 13. that the Councell of Constance confesseth That Iesus Christ instituted and administred the Sacrament vnder both kinds and that in the Primitiue Church this Sacrament was receiued by the faithfull vnder both kinds And yet against Christs institution and the practise of the Primitiue Church the same Councell most blasphemously complaineth That in some parts of the world some rashly presume that Christian people ought to receiue the Sacraments vnder both kinds and thus censures it to be presumption and rashnesse to follow Christ Of the Fathers of that Councell with the Pope himselfe I may well say Concilium inierunt vt caperent Iesum in sermone Exod. 7. But as the Serpent of Moses deuoured the Serpents of the Sorcerers so Christ will ouercome the malice and craft of such wicked counsellors It is a folly for our aduersaries to say That when Christ said Doe this in remembrance of me he spake onely to Priests for then it would follow that the lay people may be debarred of both kinds and it is as impertinently obiected that the Apostles were Priests therefore Christs Precept Drinke ye all of this belongs to Priests onely for then the Primitiue Church did amisse and S. Paule the Apostle also who deliuered the Supper to the lay people without amputation of either kind in such manner as he had receiued it of the Lord. My conclusion vpon the precedent obseruation Now therefore vpon due consideration of all the premisses finding the Church of Rome to adulterate the word of God to ouerthrow the nature of the Sacrament to goe against the doctrine of the Primitiue Church and to checke most impudently Christs owne institution cursing them that beleeue as Christ teacheth and doe as he commaundeth in drinking as well of the Cup as in eating the Bread of the Sacrament without diuision or amputation I see no ground of faith to warrant the doctrine of the Church of Rome in this case and therefore it is to be feared vnlesse God shew her the greater mercie for all her maledictions and curses to the terror of poore simple Christians shee her selfe will one day inconsolably tast of the bitter cup of Gods wrath and indignation which vpon the suddaine will be poured vpon her to her vtter ruine and destruction and shee that hath so much afflicted and tormented others will find it true that Horrendum est incidere in manus Dei viuentis It is a horrible thing to fall into the hands of the liuing God CHAP. XV. Containing an obseruation of the Pardons and Indulgences which the Peope annexeth to Crosses Graines and Meddals I Haue obserued in reading the liues of Saints a storie worth the noting of Iohn the Bishop of Hierusalem Metaph. in vita S. Epiph. Laurent Surius 12. Maeij who hauing with his honors changed also his minde being surprised with extreame couetousnesse he grew to heape vp great store of treasures beyond all reason or measure which Saint Epiphanius vnderstanding endeuoured to draw him to some liberalitie towards the poore but he who preferred his gold before all other workes of charitie cared not for the poore Epiphanius seeing this obtained of him a certaine summe more by force than by loue which he distributed amongst the poore with great ioy Few daies after the Bishop redemanded againe his money with great importunitie vnto whom Epiphanius gaue good wordes promising to repay him soone after but the Bishop was not contented but vsed him with some violence vttering iniurious speeches against him calling him impostor and cosener Epiphanius nothing troubled spit in his face wherewith instantly strucken blind he fell to the ground whereupon at length he acknowledged his fault crauing pardon Then Epiphanius shewed him into what a gulfe of couetousnesse hee was plunged putting his hand vpon his head restored him his right eye againe who praying him to restore him also his left eye the holy man refused it to the end he should be alwaies warned by that marke euer after to vse more modestie and more carefully to auoid that plague of couetousnesse In this example courteous Reader you haue a liuely representation of the Bishop of Rome his insatiable auarice now that hee is come to such temporall greatnesse in this world and consequently of the spirituall blindnesse wherewith God hath strooken him for the same not suffering him to see the light of truth but to runne head-long into diuers inextricable heresies as a iust punishment for such his greedy desires for the nouelties which are now broched in the Church of Rome were not knowne till this hateful sinne of auarice tooke
ground of them in all rpobabilitie than that the Popes being desirous to enrich themselues with money haue deuised them for the emptying of mens purses throughout all Kingdomes subiected to his vsurping authority like Boniface the ninth of whom it is written That he sent into diuers Kingdomes his Treasurors with Pardons Theod. a mem de scismat lib. 1. ca. 68. pag. 20. who extoried thereby very great summes of money from the simple people that in some one Pronince they would get together aboue an hundred thousand florens and released all sinnes to them that confessed vnto them without anie penaunce Therefore as I said in the beginning anarice caused spirituall blindenesse in Popes and blindenesse as a punishment confirmeth them more and more in their errors 6 Is it not strange considering all reason to bee against this doctrine of Indulgences that the Church of Rome will by her comminations still curse those that embrace it not as the Councell or Trent doth all those That affirme them to bee vnprofitable Ses 25. decret de Indulgentijs or denie anie power to be in the Church to graunt them What shall not as I said before the bloud of Christ as well take away the temporall paine due vnto sinne as the eternall or is not his satisfaction infinite what neede then the superfluous satisfaction of Saints 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Did the auncient Church euer speake of other Pardons than of the Pardons of outward penances which ere enioyned for publique satisfaction of the Church Hath not Christ fatisfied for the whole world what neede then of the satisfactions of Saints what more than Indulgences instilleth a vaine securitie into the soules of men and ouerthroweth the foundations of all true contrition is not Gods forgiuesse and remission expressed with an Omne debitum dimisi tibi Matth. 18.32 I haue forgiuen thee all thy debt if euerie debt why not aso the debt of temporall paine if an exception can be shewed why is it not made manifest Now iudge beloued Reader whether heere bee not sufficient reason to make mee or anie other say farewell vnto the Romish Church that thus enthralleth soules prophaneth the bloud of Christ disableth the Sacraments and picketh mens purses by the deuised doctrine of her Ecclesiasticall Indulgences Deere Iesu pardon my former fault make mee see better heereafter let mee with true compunction for this errour say with the holy Prophet Dauid Erraui sicut ouis quae perijt quaere seruum tuum I haue gone astray like a lost sheepe seeke thy seruant O Lord Psalme 119. verse 176. CHAP. XVI Containing an obseruation about the number of seuen Sacraments admitted by the Church of Rome IN my trauels in the Low-countries I haue often smiled to see how the people in those parts Vaine is the terrors of Romish curses against the truth in a faire corne-field to driue away crowes and other birds from the corne will most artificially frame the reprefentation of a terribleman standing ouer the corne with a grimme countenance and with bow and arrowes drawne vp to the head to the great terror of all birds that none may approach as if forthwith he would hit all that came neare So likewise when I confider how the Church of Rome vseth the shew of terrors and comminations to keepe Christians from feeding vpon the wholesome truthes and verities growing in the spacious fields of Gods word I find much cause of laughter to see shee should thinke men endued with reasonable soules should haue so little sense as not to discouer her vaine scare-crowes of curses and excommunications which are only terrible in words and iust nothing in effect but counterfeit terrors without hurt or harme as for example she makes a great shew in words concerning the number of seuen Sacraments as if she would shoot euery one to the quicke that will be so venterous as to approach vnto the field of Scriptures to know the truth thereof her threatning shew is this Concil trid sess 7. desacra in genere Can. 1. If any shall say that all the sacraments of the new Law were not instituted by Iesus Christ our Lord or that there are more or fewer then seuen viz. Baptisme Confirmation Eucharist Penance Extreame-unction Order and Matrimonie or also any one of these seuen not to be truly and properly a Sacrament be hee accursed Heere is the definitiue sentence of the Church of Rome casting you out of her Synagogue if you gainesay her decree it is curiositie with her and great presumption to examine her doctrine you must not be so hold as to taste of the sweet and most pleasant fruits of Gods word the arrow is drawne vp to the head against you the terror of Anathema must put you to flight Christs doctrine must be no longer the little graine of mustard-seed growne vp aboue all hearbs for his faithfull birds to sit vpon the boughs therof this scar-crow Anathema must put all to flight 2 But those that are wise and iu siciall doe discouer the vanity of this frightful spectacle Those that are wise discouer the vanitie of them with the Berraeans they will examine the Popes doctrine by the Scriptures as they did Saint Pauls they will follow the directions of Doctor Stapleton who appointeth also a meane to trie the doctrine of false teachers by antiquitie euen for all the common sort of people They will as a great Doctor and Champion of the Popes said to me once find that it had been better that the Pope had left many of the doctrines of the Councell of Trent vndefined because so many new Anathemaes makes the world begin to suspect that the Popes labour more to subiect people vnto them by terrors then by truth as men doe children who to keepe them in awe will tell them of Hobgoblins and Robin-good-fellowes such like that wil fetch them away if they bee vnruly and leaue not their crying Which policie my selfe partly obseruing to be vsed by the Church of Rome euen in a moderne example of Paul the fifth his Breue against the oath of alleageance thinking only by the bare words declaratiue without any one reason alleaged for the vnlawfulnes in taking it other then his owne plaine assertion to strike such a terror both into his owne children and into the King and State as if none would dare to gain-say it but blessed be almightie God who hath so communicated the beames of his vnspeakable wisdome vnto him and his loyall subiects yea and vnto many of the Popes owne children who were long seduced by his pretended inerrable power that they dare not onely beleeue the contrarie but also openly auouch it to the world and ioyne foot to foot in defence thereof both with pen and sword if need be howsoeuer the Iesuites would thinke themselues aduantaged if both sides should come to this latter encounter but I trust God out of his mercie will dispose of milder courses more manife sting therein his
soules into hell fire 10 And in very truth Diuers Authors shew auricular confession not to be ancient Socr. li. 5. ca 19. Tripartit hist lib 9. 35. Sozom. li. 7. c. 16 Niceph. libr. 12. cap 28. Wald. tom 2 de saora ca 141. Dom à Sot 4. dest 8 q 1. Henriq sum pag 325. Andâ— Orthodox expl c. pag. 663. Bâ—ron tom 1. ann 56. nu 28. Homil 22. ad pop Antioch when I looke backeward vppon the beginning of Christianitie as by the Scriptures I finde no such doctrine of auricular Confession to Priests as a thing necessary to saluation so doe I finde it a nouell doctrine not agreeable to Antiquitie but to haue had beginning after the planting of Christianitie For Nectarius the Bishop of Constantinople Put it downe in his Church and all the Bishoppes of the East did the like in theirs This the learned est Writers of the Romaine Church know well enough and acknowledge rayling vpon Nectarius for so doing as Andradius and Baronius doe which is a signe that the refourmed Churches reiecting confession breake no commandement of God but follow the example of the primitiue church that refused it This seems to be most cleare by S. Chrysostome saying This is wonderfull in God that he not onely forgiueth vs our sinnes but neythâ—r doth he disclose them or make them knowne neyther enjorceth he vs to come foorth and teil them he requireth no more but that we speake to him alone and to him alone confesse our faults It is not likelie that these learned and holie Bishoppes would thus haue done and also taught if Auricular Confession with a numerall accompt of euerie particular sinne to a Priest had beene generally receyued as an essentiall part of pennance necessarie to saluation in theyr times I doe finde by diuerse that there is scarce anie kinde of thing which causeth more scandall vnto the Cleargie it selfe than this Doctrine of particular enumeration of sinnes For a certaine Writer saith Religious men themselues in no thing sinne so much as in dissembling confessions Alua. Pelag. de planot Eccles lib 2. art 28. p. 255. For scarce or seldome at all doe they confesse otherwise then in generall termes naming no great sinne What they say one day that they say the next as if euery day they sinned alike Yet this abuse is nothing to that the same Author addeth saying That it was an ordinarie practise for the Priests to commit execrable villanie with the Women at confession as if they were the Sonnes of Eli Art 127. pa. 111 rauishing wiues and deflouring maides in the Church Art 2. pag. 83. and committing Sodomie with yong men with other stuffe then this affirming That the Church was made a stewes I finde further that an other Romish Writer saith Art 2. 73. 83. Cornel. Agrippa de vanit c. 64. I could by many examples fresh in memorie shew how fit this confession is for bawderie for Priests Monkes and Nunnes haue this speciall prerogatiue that vnder pretence of religion they may goe vp and downe when and whither they will and vnder colour of confession talke with anie woman whom they oftentimes entertayne but homely closely they goe to the stewes rauish virgins and widdowes yea manie times which my selfe haue seene and knowne runne awaie with mens wiues and carrie them to their fellows and hereby whose soules they should gaine to God their bodies they sanctifie to the Diuell II. â—isconueniences ouerthrowing auricular confession Many other proofes might be alleaged of the inconueniences of auricular Confession as by opening such sinnes by women or yong men as the very hearing of them striketh impression in the Priests and many times engendreth such occasions of temptations to them as they haue no power to resist them besides euen to the penitents also some sinnes into which they may fall by humane infirmitie may bee of that nature that they can neuer haue the heart through bashfulnesse to confesse them and then follow vnperfect confessions and after continuall remorse and perplexities of minde which make their whole liues irkesome vnto them drawing them into the remedilesse gulfe of desperation especially when the sinnes are such in weake natures as the Apostle Saint Paul himselfe thought vnfit to bee named which are fitter to bee opened to GOD than to Men. Therefore no man can well thinke that auricular confession is a soueraigne medicine for sinne which often is an occasion of much sinne No doubt IESVS CHRIST and the Apostles were as carefull to preserue men from sinne as the Pope can be and yet they neuer prescribed this medicine For certes whosoeuer feareth not to commit sin in the presence of God that seeth all men will as little blush to confesse it after their manner to a Priest whom they may deceiue and hee that regardeth not the law of God will care as little for the Priests absolution the feare of God and awe of his truth being of more force to bridle our sinnefull nature than the pollicie of man so that to conclude obseruing this auricular confession not to be an essentiall part of Penance nor to haue any warrant in the word of God nor to bee ancient doctrine without beginning since Christ and his Aposses nor to bee agreeable to reason in respect of many inconueniences that ensue of it it followeth that Penance is not a Sacrament instituted by Christ and consequently that there are not seuen Sacraments instituted by him as the Church of Rome teacheth and therefore I could no longer bee frighted with the Excommunication of the Councell of Trent against those that should denie this doctrine like those qui trepidant timore vbi non est timor Who tremble for seare where there is no cause of feare 12. Strange sables deuised for the prâ—ose of auricular coniession I remember a notable fable worth the relating deuised to breede feare and terrour for want of totall confession into the eares of a Priest which is recorded in diuers Writers of the Church of Rome of which two one of them was Penitentiarius to the Pope a man of great learning and good life and the other to wit the yongest was a simple vnlearned man In mag Spec. exemplor dist 9. p. 531. Guil. Pip. tr 1. super Conc. c. 13. ex lib. qui dicitur Scala coeli It happened that these two trauailing abroade together were lodged at a certaine Castle where a great Ladie dwelt that had committed Adulterie nay Incest with one of her owne Kinne Who out of the shame shee had conceiued for hauing committed so enormous an offence remained for the space of eleuen yeares without going to confession to her Curate who entertaining this religious couple and obseruing them in their carriages to bee vertuous and grane and not to haue any acquaintance with her and considering that perhaps they might neuer come againe to her house shee thought shee might doe well to make her
Church in the same Kingdome was aduertised that the Dacians made preparations for the warres against him Whereupon he sent the Abbot Hersinus vnto them to know the truth of their designements The Abbot then being vpon his returne at sea was surprised with such a tempestuous storme that he and all his people were in danger of their liues if they had not sought for succour of the virgine Marie for as they inuoked her with all the deuotion they could behold there came from Heauen a venerable Personage apparrelled like a Bishop who after he had saluted the Abbot said vnto him Will you be deliuered from this danger he answered that he desired nothing more Know you then said the Personage that I am sent from the virgine Marie to aduertise you that you shall be deliuered from all danger if you will obey me Commaund said the Abbot all that you please and you shall be willingly obeyed Hereafter then said he you shall keepe a solemne Feast of the Conception of the virgine Marie and in preaching you shall declare that it is to be kept The abbot asking vpon what day it should bee kept and what Seruice the Church should say thereon he answered it should be kept the eight of December and for the Seruice they should take that of the Natiuitie putting the word Conception in lieu of Natiuitie Anno 1060. Then the Personage vanished away the storme ceased and the Abbot escaped with all his companie and afterward performed his promise Is not this a strong foundation to build an article of Faith vpon Let the circumstances be considered as that the Bishop that appeared comming from the virgine Marie vsed such great familiaritie with the Abbot as to salute him that he appeared in a storme when wicked spirits are busiest that he willed him to keepe a Feast of that act concerning the blessed Virgine which cannot be freed from sinne and iudge whether it be not time to flye to the Scriptures reuealed from God when such visions must serue as it is probably deuised by the diuell to delude men withall for the establishment of a new article of faith as diuers of the Romane Church hold this to be It may be this vision might be such a one as I haue sometimes heard of the like nature by a certaine Gentleman as acquaintance of mine who told mee that one appeared vnto him in the forme of a Bishop telling him he must be a Romane Catholike if he would be saued and that he should trauell ouer the seas escape many dangers acquainting him with future euents concerning the Earle of Essex and himselfe which he would not speake of Which vision some of his kindred gaue credit vnto and furthered him in his iourney And I haue heard since when his money was spent beyond the seas he returned home againe and finding himselfe deluded by his vision embraced againe his former religion and continueth in it to this day Some Romanists haue thought that this vision was but an inuention that thereby hee might finde a few golden peeces out of his friends the better to maintaine his trauailes The truth of his vision I leaue to his owne conscience but this I may truely say there is a great resemblance betwixt his and the Abbots and therefore in my iudgement if the Diuell played the Bishop in the one he might as well doe it in the other 5. Another apparition to the same effect Ibidem part 7. Dionys Cor. ser 2. Conc. Be. Mariae Polbert ibid. I haue noted another apparition recorded by diuers Writers of the Church of Rome tending to the same purpose viz to make good the doctrine of the Virgine Maries conception without originall sinne In the time of Charles King of Fraunce a certaine young man nephew to the King of Hungarie loued so much the Virgine Marie and was so addicted to her seruice that daily before he eate any thing he sayed her Houres who falling vpon a time into a great infirmitie and sicknesse vowed his chastitie vnto her if she would helpe to saue his life Forthwith the chamber was replenished with a great light and he was restored to his health Soone after his vncle died without issue which made the Lords of the Countrey to persuade him to enter into the estate of Marriage to the end the Kingdome may not be without heires offering him a faire Ladie which he married But after he had receiued the blessing he remembred that he had not yet that day read our Ladies office he retyred himselfe to say them the more deuoutly sending the Ladie Bride with the rest of the companie home to his house and when he said that Anthieme Pulchra es decora filia Hierusalem that is to say Thou art faire and gracious O daughter of Ierusalem suddainely the virgine Marie appeared vnto him with two Angels attending her and said vnto him If I am faire honest and gracious as thou sayest wherefore doest thou forsake mee for another am not I more beautifull than she O Ladie said he your beautie surpasseth all the beautie of the world thou art exalted aboue the Angels what is your pleasure that I should doe If you leaue said she your carnall espouse for the loue of me you shall haue me for wife in Heauen and if you will keepe a yearely solemne Feast euerie yeare vpon the eight day of December of my conception teaching others to keepe it you shall be crowned with me in the Kingdome of my Sonne When she had spoken these wordes shee vanished out of sight and the young man transpoeted himselfe out of the Citie and Kingdome into a Wildernesse where his comportement was so holy that since he was made Patriarch of Aquilâ—ia where hee preached and instituted the said Feast Collections vpon this storie Iudge now gentle Reader whether this be an apparition likely to come from Heauen when that which is commaunded here is so expressely against the word of God inuiting from that state of marriage which the Apostle calleth honourable vnto the seruice of that fained and deuised priuiledge of the Virgin Maries Conception without originall sinne which I haue already shewed to be expresly repugnant to the word of God and therefore diametrally against faith Besides the institution it selfe is so late that it appeareth to bee cockle sowed by the enuious man the Deuill not by Christ or his Apostles and therefore not to be receiued by those who know Antiquitie to bee the infallible marke of truth The due obseruation of all which premises considered in this Chapter was as forcible an inducement to leade my feete out of the dangerous waies of Romish nouelties as any other therefore curteous Reader let me intreate thee with me to call the Virgin Marie most blessed amongst women as truly shee was vpon earth and is so also in heauen in the glorie of her soule but thinke her not yet so blessed as in this point of her Conception to paralell her with Christ