and without disturbance taught the truth of all those Doctrines The truth was then in possession of the Pulpits of Divinity Schools and of Presses but what when this Man appeared the most Famous and Learned Protestant Divines at home and abroad opposed him and did write against him If any one hath a mind to know the shifts and tricks of that Party to strengthen themselves and undermine their opposers and to prevent the calling of a General Synod which was sued for as the best way effectually to maintain truth and oppose falsehood let him read the Acts of the Synod of Dort with the Preface to it where they had all the fair play that might reasonably be wished for But because about these matters in the eighth Century disputes did break out again as it appeared in the case of Gottescalk wherein Hinemarus of Rheims and Remigius Archbishop of Lyons with the Churches of his Diocese were highly engaged these last for and the other against Gottescalk which if any one desireth to be well informed of let him read the Honest and Excellent account of it given by that worthy and Eminent Prinate of Ireland James Vsher which I quoted before A thing much to be taken notice of in all these disputes and which is the chief Subject of this Chapter is this that Arminius and his Followers do hold the opinions of Pelagians and Semipelagians and that Calvin whom they make the head against their opinions and we hold the same with Austin Hilarius Prosper Fulgentius and other Orthodox Doctors of the Primitive Church we hitherto have sufficiently declared ours what remaineth is for me to shew what those Fathers of the Church did hold about these points but that shall be briefly because the trouble of proving it hath been saved me by others who make good out of the writings of those ancient Fathers the things now in question First As to Predestination (a) Justin Martyr dialog cum Triph. Sect. 2. God elected us and was made manifest to them that sought him not And do you think O man that we could ever have understood these things in the Scripture except we had received grace by the will of God of which grace ye Jews being destitute have understood none of them Another saith (b) Cyprian de Mort. num 2. there is no need of Money Industry and Man's Hand but it is the free and ready gift of God as freely as the Sun shineth the Fountain watereth the shower moisteneth so doth the heavenly spirit power it self into us The great asserter of Christ's Divinity speaks thus (a) Athanas cont Aâ—â—â—â—n 4. Pag. 175. The Apostle James hath taught of his own will begat he us with the word of truth Therefore of all the regenerate yea and of all that by creation were generated it is the will of God by the word of God that doth create and regenerate whatsoever pleaseth him Let us hear what saith another (b) Ambros in Psal 118. Serm. 10. Perseverance is not in him that willeth nor in him that runneth for it is not in the power of man but in God that sheweth mercy that thou shouldest be able to accomplish that which thou hast began Another saith (c) Hieron ad Ruff. lib. 1. Paul and those that are like him are not elected because they were holy and unspotted but they are elected and predestinated that afterwards in their lives in good works and vertues they may be unspotted and holy These Doctors attribute it to grace to the free gift of God to his own will and pleasure perseverance is not in the will or power of man but in Gods mercy neither were we elected for our Faith or Holiness but to be unspotted and holy all this is the sense of the fore-quoted Doctors which agreeth with what we said But because in Austin's days chiefly that Heresie sprung up and that he was the man who most laid it to heart and made it his main business to oppose it he hath written against it more clearly and most to the full of any Out of so many Treatises he hath written about it which are so well known we shall quote only one or two places (d) August de praedest grat cap. 13. Out of those to whom the severity of Justice adjudgeth punishment according to the unexpressible mercy of his secret dispensation he chose out vessels which he might fit unto honour both delivering some from wrath to come and leaving others to the sentence of Justice Enchirid. ad Laurent cap. 99. And in another place he hath mercy with goodness he hardeneth without injustice so that he that is freed may not boast of his merits neither he that is damned may complain of any thing but his merits for grace alone maketh a difference between the redeemed and the lost whom one common cause derived from the root had united together in one lump of destruction With this concurred another when he saith (e) Prosper ad except genu resp ad dub 9. Austin by a godly and constant doctrine hath abundantly proved that predestination was to be preached to the Church in which it is the preparation of grace and grace is to be preached in which is the effect of predestination and the fore-knowledge of God wherein he fore-knoweth before all ages on whom he would bestow his gifts Which preaching whosoever is against he is a most open defender of Pelagian Pride And in another place he saith from himself No Catholick doth deny the predestination of God The faith of predestination is established by many authorities of holy Scriptures yet unto it Ad capit Gall. cap. 1. it is not lawful to attribute any of the sins of men who came to their inclination to sin not by God's Creation but by their first Fathers transgression from the punishment whereof no man is free but only by the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ prepared and predestinated in the eternal counsel of God before the foundation of the world An excellent testimony about all these Doctrines by Austin asserted is given by Hormisda a Bishop of Rome to a Bishop of Africa who desired his advise about the Books of Faustus the Semipelagian in these words (a) Epist ad Possessor They know how not only the Roman and African Church and all the Sons of promise through all parts of the world do agree with this man's Austin Doctrine as in the whole Faith so in the confession of Grace But let us come to another (b) Fulgent de incar grat in fine God who made man by his predestination fore-appointed to whom he would give the gift of illumination to believe and the gift of perseverance to profit and persevere and the gift of glorification to reign who no otherwise performed indeed then he hath ordained in his unchangeable will The truth of which predestination by which the Apostle witnesseth that we are predestinated in Christ before the foundation
himself That design vanish't and my measures were broken and so I now leave only these few words of my respect for his Memory ERRATA PAg. 1. last line but one before and what r. wait for p. 15. in the Margin r. Deut. 28 p. 18. in the Marg. r. Psal 135 p. 19. l. 1. r. bow p. 25. l. 24. after which r. Sence p. 33. l. 7. r. that all p. 50. in the Margin r. Isaiah 12.40 p. 60. l. 5. before question add to p. 104. l. 14. r. Elijah p. 120. l. 7. before lookt add God p. 128. l. 37. for naturally r. wholly p. 135. in rhe Margin for John r. Joshua p. 142. l. 29. after but add be is p. 170. in the Margin for John r. Jonah p. 217. l. 32. r. 1615 p. 222. last l. for mistake r. mislike p. 231. for beg r. buy besides few mistakes in the Marginal Quotations CHAP. I. A Plea for Free-Grace against Free-Will SO much and by several hands hath already been said upon the points I now go about to handle that I must not pretend to bring many new lights to the matter Only what I propose to my self is as much as I can and the nature of the thing will give me leave to make it clear to a common Capacity that ordinary people may not as often they are be easily imposed upon by those who disguise and defame the Truth whither out of Ignorance or Malice or both let God and their Conscience be their Judge all they could they have done upon wrong suggestions to influence a prejudice not only against the things but the very names so that some are come to that length as to slight and leave off reading a Book if they see the word Predestination in it as if they were frighted with the name or there was some dangerous Poison under it but after this rate such must also leave off reading some places of Scripture wherein the word to Predestinate is several times contained I know how to write Truth upon the Mind and the Heart is the proper work of God's own Spirit specially those Truths that are contrary and cross to Man's natural Pride and Inclination Only I desire the Reader to remove all prejudices so quietly and patiently to peruse those few sheets and what God will do for him in the discovery of these truths which the Adversaries thereof have done what they could to confine and hide in Corners and if thereby he meets with satisfaction and advantage in the discoveries of it let him thankfully give God the Glory But this is certain how those errours which tend to destroy Grace and set up a strength in Nature began some years ago to be so propagated by a sort of Men who designed to meet with and be reconciled to the Church of Rome that they went about and too far prevailed in 't to corrupt the very Springs of Learning with keeping out of the Vniversities those that were for free Grace against free Will and bringing in only those whom they thought fit for their purpose wherefore 't is no wonder if so many Streams derived from thence have been infected with that Corruption infused into and influenced upon them and if the Disease is become Epidemical amongst that party wherein to profess such Opinions was a great qualification for Places and Preferments But every sound and Orthodox Christian must own that in matter of Salvation we cannot attribute too much to free Grace nor too little to Nature and to our own Strength which is the true State of the Dispute CHAP. II. Who Arminius was and what are his Opinions BUT before we proceed it will be necessary for a better information of the Reader to give some account of the Author and of his Opinions Arminius or James Van Hermin a Dutchman from whom they are called Arminians though they take the name of Remonstrants was not properly the Author but Reviver of old Errors with some kind of alteration 'T is commonly known in Holland whence we have this account of his Person how at first let it be spoken without any design to reflect he was a Tapster or Chamberlain in a Publick-house from whence by the care of some Guests who were pleased with his Wit he was sent to School and there maintained out of the publick Treasury of Amsterdam where he afterwards was admitted to be a Preacher whence after the Death of Learned Junius he was called to Leyden to be Divinity Professor in his place but upon condition that before his admittance he should have a Conference with Gomarus c. and in that Conference he should by an open Declaration of his Opinion clear himself of all suspicion of unsoundness in Doctrine and that he should promise if he had any singular Opinions he would not discover them to the disturbance of the Churches Which Conference was accordingly held before the Curators of the University and the Deputies of the Synod in which Arminius most expresly denyed and condemned the Opinions of Pelagius about Grace Free-Will Original Sin Perfection in this Life and Predestination adding that he approved all that Austin and other Fathers had written against Pelagius promising also to read nothing different from the received Doctrine hereupon he was admitted Professor and for some time taught the Doctrine of the Reformed Churches in the points of Christ's Satisfaction Justification by Faith Perseverance in Faith Certainty of Salvation and such other matters as afterwards he denyed this breach of his promifes was so notorious and he went so far on that to remedy this evil the calling a Synod was thought necessary which he by means of Friends and Credit which was considerable amongst great Men as Barnevelt who afterwards lost his Head Vtengobard of Grotius c. he did stop it as much as he could knowing he there should be called to answer for himself But seeing how for all his oppositions a Synod was like to be he fell Sick for Grief as generally believed and died October 19. 1609. He was so full of Envy against the reputation of the first Reformers that one of his chief designs ever was how to discredit their Persons and Labours which spirit of his in a high degree is transmitted to his Sectators For certainly no Papist can or doth express a greater Contempt Hatred and Malice against the Blessed Memory of those Eminent instruments of Reformation than most Arminians do After his Death his Party used the same means to prevent a Synod nay rather than not to do it they would have betaken themselves to their Arms had they not been prevented by the extraordinary care and diligence of Maurice Prince of Orange in Conformity to Orders from the States Before this they had so shuffled things that with their tricks they hindered it for some Years till the disease and danger of ruin not only in that Church but in the State also growing worse and worse And King James from hence pressing strongly the States General for
as others do we presently are by them branded with the name of precise and morose Puritans If they do well they attribute it to themselves to the right use they make of their free-will to their own will and inclination But if in us there be any thing better than in others we wholly as 't is most due attribute it to free-grace the glory of all we return to God and not to any will of ours for no good is done in or by us but what comes from God's free-grace to which specially in matter of Salvation we can never attribute too much nor too little to our own strength So that whilst their principles lead them to looseness and licentiousness ours or rather Gods in us lead us to holiness and vertuous practices and if thorough the corruption of our nature they do not as it should we confess it ought so to be Let them shew us their faith by their works for by the fruit we judge of the Tree Now bad actions and a vitiout life do naturally and necessarily flow from their principles and whilst as I said before (a) 2 Pet. 2.19 they promise others liberty they themselves are the servants of corruption Now if there be such an universal sufficient grace imparted to all men whereby they may be saved if they will why then from the Creation till now have not the effectual means of saving grace been imparted alike which if so then all or most had been saved which not being it must proceed from a want either of will or of power I cannot believe it is for want of a will for though people out of their own corruption be willing enough to procrastinate repentance and like Sampson be lulled a sleep in their Dalilah's bosom yet when they hear or see the Philistines (b) Judg. 16.19 the approaches of death dangerous sicknesses heavy afflictions and terrors of Conscience are coming upon them surely none are so prodigal of their own Souls or so desirous of damnation but would unfeignedly desire to be saved (a) Numb 23.1 let me die the death of the righteous and let my last end be like his was the desire of that wicked false Prophet Balaam And as Sampson would have drawn up together all his forces to have overcome his Enemies he found his strength was gone The Lord was departed from him So those sinners who were lulled a sleep with those pretty fancies of a power to repent believe and be saved when it comes to the push they find there is no such thing in them as they were made to believe In Sampson his strength was gone for once he had it but that free-will and power which Arminians do brag of no man ever had Therefore at last they must be convinced how in man is no such a power whereby to be saved when he will Now to sum up all in few words Horrible absurdities follow on the Arminian opinions some whereof they acknowledge and others are bound on their back by unavoidable consequences Namely that the fruit of Christ's death doth absolutely depend upon the accidental assent of man's free-will that notwithstanding his death it was possible and very contingent that all men had perished That no soul had been free from Hell by his Blood That God should never have had any Church at all That now by vertue of his death true grace is given to all That all Pagans as well under the Law as the Gospel who never heard of Scripture are truly reconciled to God by the death of his Son That all Infants even of Heathens who die before the years of discretion are saved by Christ That in no man is any original sin but every one when he is born is put in the state of Innocency That Baptism is not necessary for no sin is therein remitted because there is none then to be remitted CHAP. XV. How Arminianism is contrary to the Doctrine of the Church of England WIth a sort of men namely those that are zealous for the Religion of their Fathers and true Sons of the Church of England I make no doubt but that this will be a weighty and prevailing Argument which for their sake and information before I have done I hope by the grace of God to make good and thereby to shew the disingenuity and design of those who to impose upon several people have the face to affirm Arminianism to be the Doctrine of the Church of England which is so contrary to truth To understand this well it must be explained what is meant by the Doctrine of the Church 't is not the opinions of some corrupt Members of the Church whom that Mother disowns as spurious because fallen from her Principles and having set up Errors of their own which she never taught them though they would father them upon her she hath fed them with pure and sincere milk which their own ill constitution hath turned into Poyson But what we call the true Doctrine of the Church is that which was received believed and taught in the very beginning of the Reformation from errors and abuses of the Church of Rome and without alteration by her self lasted for above threescore years after till a party here combined to bring in erroneous innovations of their own In few words we call that the Doctrine of the Church of England which concerning these controverted points is contained in the 39 Articles in the Common Prayer Book the Book of Homilies and the Catechism of Edward the 6th These are the general publick and authentical Records and Evidences of the Faith and Doctrine of the Church of England and we shall not want the Testimony of the most Eminent and famous Doctors thereof to prove what we say So then we shall make it appear how Arminiamsm is contrary to all this I mean in every one of these we shall find Testimonies against it First of all to begin with the Articles of Faith We have the 17th about Predestination in these Words Predestination to life is the everlasting purpose of God whereby before the Foundation of the World was laid he hath constantly decreed by his Counsel secret to us to deliver from Curse and Damnation those whom he hath chosen in Christ and to bring them unto everlasting Salvation c. Let the whole be read with Attention and what we have asserted about that Point will be found therein to be contained as the eternity of God's Decree everlasting Purpose its immutability hath constantly decreed c. But because if I should point at every Word confirming what I am about proving out of this Article it would take up too much time To do it more effectually I shall make use of another Man's Pen I mean of Mr. Thomas Rogers a Man beyond exception in the Case who was a Chaplain to Archbishop Bancroft He hath written an Analysis upon all the 39 Articles which he doth dedicate to the Archbishop and the Book is licens'd and printed by Authority
which are beginning to bud forth amongst you We must not omit giving the King the due commendation he deserveth for the pains he took to write against Worstius After all this let Arminians for shame leave off the Plea that their Errors are the Doctrine of our Church which is as true and no more than when Papists do pretend their Religion to be the true Apostolical Faith even in those Articles that are so contrary to it but farther to shew how perswaded King James was of the mischief of those unsound opinions he was very active in suppressing them to prevent those evil consequences that might happen thereby and this not only at home but also abroad upon this account he did write to the States general and ordered his Ambassador there to be instant and to follow the business close and we may say the meeting of the general Synod of Dort is in a high degree due to the King 's earnest solicitations So to encourage and countenance it he sent thither Divines from hence whereof Dr. Field Bishop of Landaff was the chief Dr. Davenant afterwards Bishop of Salisbury Dr Hall was there at first but upon account of indisposition of health he came back Dr. Ward Dr. Goad and Balcanquall instead of Dr. Hall in all they were five who signed the Acts of the Synod of Condemnation of Arminianism We have more witnesses to bring in if we would but we want them not though they be men of note but what need bringing in particular men after the whole body have declared against our and the truths Adversaries We might bring in (a) Exposition on the Creed Dr. Babington Bishop of Worcester (b) Certainty of Salvation against Dr. Bishop Dr. Abbot Bishop of Salisbury (c) Answer to the Rhemish Testam on Rom. 8. Dr. Fulke (d) Of the Church lib. 1. cap. 3. and cap. 17. and in his Digres 41 and 43. Dr. Field (e) Reply to Fisher Dr. White (f) Descript Eccles Thes â— Dr. Reynolds though some may happen to except against him yet what he saith in the quoted place is approved by the fore-named Dean of Carlisle Dr. White Nay in this case we have for us (g) Discouse of Justification Hooker with some a man without exception all whose evidence is much to our purpose but to quote all their words it were too long after so many other Quotations yet they who have a mind and leisure may peruse them as quoted in the Margin So then during K. James's time Arminianism had nothing to do here and continued so in Charles Reign till Laud came into favour and was made Archbishop and yet at first those Errors were ill lookt upon for Mr. Richard Mountague in his Appeal having written for Arminianism his Book was answered by five or six of the most considerable men in the Nation all agreeing he had departed from the Doctrine of the Church he was thrice about it before the Parliament and his Book condemned as contrary to the Articles of the Church Under his Hand and Seal he renounced his Errors in a letter of his written to the Archbishop of Canterbury he thought he stood in need of a Pardon which King Charles gave him for all his writings and at last called in his Book as the great occasion of many unnecessary troubles After him Dr. Thomas Jackson came upon the Stage but for those Arminian Books of his was censured in Parliament and excepted against by the Convocation and in the following Parliaments Complaints even by some of the best Sons of the Church were made against those Innovations and Errors in Doctrine under the name and notion of Arminianism Yet under the favour of Bishop Laud and his Faction being encouraged with Protection and Preferments got much ground and corrupted many members of the Clergy who became rotten branches of a sound and wholesome tree yet for all the violent stream some had the courage and zeal to appear in writing against it though they smarted for it they charged Arminians of being favourers and maintainers of Popery of renouncing the Doctrine of the Church of England of being pestilent Hereticks Enemies of God and of his grace for the most part licentious proud vicious and bitter Enemies to the practical power of godliness whereof some turned Papists Innovators and disturbers of the Peace of both Church and State And any impartial Reader that will take the pains to read some of those Books may find the charge well proved Indeed the serious consideration of these things doth afford matter for sad thoughts and sufficient cause of grief to those who love the glory of God and the good of his Church after so much pains taken by the first instruments of our Reformation to remove abuses in Doctrine and bring things into the true Primitive Channel who left us Articles and other Works in writing according to the true Apostolical Doctrine contained in the word of God believed and professed by the Orthodox Primitive Church which these first Reformers sealed with their own Blood for they were Martyrs not only for refusing to joyn with the Church of Rome in her Idolatry but also for the testimony of the grace of God in Christ to exclude all humane help power strength abilities from working our Salvation by means of any dispositions free-will improvement of graces and merits of our own these things they laid down their lives for and to maintain that our whole Salvation comes from the free grace of God alone and from nothing at all of our own For to believe one is and may be saved by his own merits and workings or by those of another or even in part through grace and in part through our care and endeavours in the bottom 't is all one for thereby Salvation is divided between God and Man when God alone will be owned to be the sole Author and Finisher of it Well those directions for our Faith left by those eminent instruments of Reformation were (h) Dr Abbâ—◠〈…〉 in his Discourse De Perseverantia Saâ—ct in the Epistle dedicated to King Charles the 1st then Prince of Wales complaineth of some of our Divines that foll wing the by-paths of Arminius Dogmate etiam nunc destruunt articulos Religionis quos â—â—sus propria manu confirmerunt They destroy'd those very Articles of Religion which they had subscribed before subscribed by those who in and about the time I mentioned before embraced and promoted Arminianism and by those who now own it in as much as they could wresting the Sense of those thus doing what they could or can to poison the very Springs But let them do their worst the Truth and meaning of those Rules of our Faith is still the same but they are bad Children of a good Mother from whose Counsels and Directions they are degenerated and about things in Question apostatized So that in this respect they have cruelly divided rent and torn Mother-Church which if
alone can give it which in another place is confirmed (m) 2 Tim. 2.25 If God peradventure will give them that is men repentance And as repentance is meerly a gift of God so is saith if we must believe St. Paul (n) Ephes 2.8 For by grace ye are saved thorough saith and that not of our selves it is the gift of God Our salvation here is not attributed to free-will or any thing of our own The Apostle is not satisfied to say by grace ye are saved through Faith but he excludes himself and all and that not of our selves but that Faith which is the Instrument whereby Christ is received and applyed is a gift of God not of Nature or any Parts Abilities or Free-will in us And another Apostle comfirms it very much with a general rule he gives how not only the gift of Faith but (a) Jam. 1.17 every good gift and every perfect gift is from above and cometh down from the Father of lights We must not look for any grace to grow here below no such thing to be found upon Earth but what doth originally come from Heaven We must not seek for any in Man in any faculty of his Soul which is a bondslave of sin and naturally dead in sin till God hath been pleased to quicken it (b) 1 Pet. 1.9 The end of our faith saith an Apostle is our salvation And Jesus (c) Heb. 12.2 saith another is the Author and finisher of our faith Thus our whole Salvation comes from Christ alone exclusively to any man This work I thought fit to conclude with the several Proofs drawn out of Scripture to shew how our Salvation not only as to the general but also as to particulars in every part and degree thereof doth wholly and only depend upon God and in case there be any good in or done by us we must own God to be the Author of it through the immediate and effectual working of his holy Spirit to trust upon himself or in any thing in himself (d) 2 Kings 18 21. 'T is to trust upon the staff of a bruised reed on which if a man lean it will go into his hand and pierce it To seek for salvation and power to repent and believe within himself in his Mind in his Will in his Heart it is (e) Luk. 24.5 to seek the living amongst the dead By God's command we are (f) Rev. 18.4 come out of the Roman Babylon if we are God's people so that except we have a mind again to be partakers of her sins and so to receive of her Plagues we must return thither no more When God had brought his people out of Egypt by the mouth of Moses he gave this command (g) Deut. 17.16 Ye shall hence forth return no more that way This command is addressed to and concerns us for we know Rome is the great City (h) Rev. 17.8 which spiritually is called Egypt and Sodom too 'T is called Babylon by reason of her Idolatry Egypt upon the account of slavery and Sodom for her abominable wickedness thence God hath graciously brought us out why should we like some of the Children of Israel or Lot's Wife incline and desire to return thither we read as of the sin of the punishment of those that did so for their carcases fell in the wilderness and the Woman became a Pillar of Salt which we are commanded to remember Luk. 17.32 Now I say that the Arminian Errors do lead men back into the Church of Rome I hope I sufficiently demonstrated how in these matters of grace they joyn hands and agree together against us that when Arminianism began to settle here a design was carried on to meet with and be reconciled to that See If then we be not willing to return to it again we must avoid falling into the way that leadeth to it to escape the danger These points about grace are not indifferent and inconsiderable but of the highest nature and concernment that can be for our eternal Salvation doth wholly depend upon God's free-grace I mean our Election Vocation Faith Repentance Conversion Justification Sanctification and at last Glorification These are such fundamental truths as no Martyr can lay down his life upon a better account wherefore no man ought to be ashamed or afraid to own and suffer for if called to it But self-denyal is a hard thing to be obtained and self-love so deeply rooted in man's corrupt heart that they will not part with boastings they are pleased with the thoughts of their own worthiness and are fond of an imaginary power and abilities which they fansie to be in themselves instead of giving God the glory Yet O Lord to thee belong honour and righteousness Dan. 9.7 but to man nothing but shame and confusion of face FINIS