to CHRIST that they depend upon him as their only head c. then surely if there shall be any that shall not submit themselves to that Hierarchie reverently and with the greatest obedience that may be I confesse there is no Anathema of which they are not worthy Thus he in the treatise of the necessity of reforming the Church Do you heare your Doome from your owne Oracle Loe such and no other was that Hierarchie wherein you lately bore a part and which you have now condemned make account therefore of the merit and danger of Calvins just Anathema Interea tamen Ecclesiae authoritatem vel pastâ—rum Superintendentium quibus Ecclesiae râ—gendae provinâ—â—a mandata est sublatam nâ—lumus Fatemur ergo Episcopos sivâ— Pastores râ—vâ—renter auâ—iendos quaâ—enus pro suae functionis ratione verbum Dei docent Confess Fidei nomine Gall. Eccles Yet againe the same Authour in his Confession of Faith written in the name of all the French Churches speaking of the depraved estate of the Roman Church then in the fieri of Reforming plainly writes thus Interea tamen Yet in the meane time we would not have the Authority of the Church or of those Pastors or Superintendents to whom the charge of Governing the Church is committed taken away we confesse therefore that these Bishops or Pastors are reverently to be heard so farre forth as according to their function they teach the Word of God And yet more plainly Sanè si veri Episâ—opi essent aliquid iis in hac parte auth ritatis tribuerem non qua tum sibi postâ—lant sed quantum ad politiam Ecclesiae ritè ord nandam requiritur Calv. Instit l. 4. c. 10. Certainely saith hee speaking even of Popish Bishops if they were true Bishops I would yeeld them some authority in this Case not so much as themselves desire but so much as is required to the due ordering of the Policie or Government of the Church Lastly for it were easie to heap up this measure in an Epistle of his wherein the question is purposely discussed what is to be done if a Popish Bishop shall be converted to the reformed Religion he so determines it That it is fit such an one first renounce his Popish power of sacrificing and professe to abstaine from all the superstitions and foedities of the Romish Religion then that he must doe his utmost endeavour that all the Churches which belong to his Bishopricke may be purged from their Errours and Idolatrie and at last concludes that both his possessions and authority too should be left him By vertue whereof he must take order that the Ministers under him do duly preach Gods Word as himselfe also must doe Thus he wisely and moderately Not first of all stripping him of his Episcopall power and discharging all his Clergie of their respects and obedience to him and reducing him to the rank of the meanest Plebeian Presbyter as some hot heads would have done You heare how judicious and moderate Calvins opinion was then and had he been in your late pretended Assembly at Glasgow or this of Edinburgh what vote he would have given Had he had the casting voice your Coat had not been cast for him How happy were it for your Churches if all among you who so much honour his name would as readily submit to this his judgement Sure I am had it been so with you you had been as far from defying Episcopacie in holy professors as you are now from truth and peace § 3. The judgement of the German Reformers concerning the retaining of Episcopacie ANd that the French Reformers may not herein bee thought to goe alone take notice I beseech you what the Germane Divines of the Ausburgh-Confession have freely professed to this purpose Who taking Occasion to speake of Canonicall Ordination break forth into these words following Sed Episcopi c. But the Bishops say they do either force our Priests to disclaime and condemne this kind of Doctrine which we have here Confessed or by a certaine new and unheard of kind of Cruelty put the poore and innocent soules to death These causes are they which hinder our Priests from receiving their Bishops so as the crueltie of the Bishops is the Cause why that Canonicall Government or Policie Quam nos magnopere conservare cupiebamus which we earnestly desired to conserve is in some places now dissolved And not long after in the same Chapter Prorsus hic iterum c. And now here again we desire to testifie it to the world that we will willingly Conserve the Ecclesiasticall and Canonicall government if only the Bishops will cease to exercise Cruelty upon our Churches This our will shall excuse us before God and before all the world unto all posterity that it may not be justly imputed unto us that the Authority of Bishops is impayred amongst us when men shall heare and read that we earnestly deprecating the unjust cruelty of the Bishops could obtaine no equall measure at their hands Thus those learned Divines and Protestants of Germany wherein all the world sees the Apologist professeth for them that they greatly desired to conserve the government of Bishops that they were altogether unwillingly driven from it that it was utterly against their heart that it should have beene impaired or weakened That it was onely the personall crueltie and violence of the Romish Persecutors in a bloody opposition to the doctrine of the Gospell which was then excepted against To the same purpose is that Camer in vita Melancth which Camerarius reports concerning those two great Lights of Germany Melancthon and Luther That Philip Melancthon not only by the consent but the advice of * Who professeth also so much in the Smalcaldian Articles Art 10. Luther perswaded the Protestants of that time that if Bishops would grant free use of the true doctrine their ordinary power and administration over their severall Dioeceses should be restored unto them And the same Melancthon in an Epistle to Luther hath thus Melanct. Epist Luthero You do not believe in how great hatred I am both with the Noricians and I know not whom els for restoring to the Bishops their jurisdiction and in a most true censure in his history of the Augustan Confession Melanct. Camerario hist Confâ—s August per Chytraeum Hoc autem malè habet quosdam immoderatiores reddi jurisdictionem restitui politiam Ecclesiasticam This saith he troubles certaine immoderate men that jurisdiction is re-delivered to the Bishops Buc. de Regno Christi He that desires to see more testimonies of this kinde I refer him to the Survay of Discipl chap. 8. and their Ecclesiasticall policie restored As for Bucer he is noted and confessedly acknowledged for a favourer of Religious Episcopacie See now I beseech you how willing these first reformers were to maintaine and establish Episcopall government how desirous to restore it how troubled that they might not continue
Poza the braine-sick Professour of Divinity set up by the Iesuites at Madrill That it is free for any man besides and against the judgement of the holy Fathers and Doctors to make innovations in the doctrine of religion And for his warrant of contemning all ancient Fathers and Councels in respect of his owne Opinions borrowes the words in Ecclesiasticus Concil Constantinop Act. 5. Ecclesiast 25. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 cited by the Councell of Constantinople Beatus qui praedicat verbum inauditum Blessed is he that preaches the word never before heard of impiously and ignorantly marring the text mistaking the sense belying the Authour slandering the Councell the misprision being no lesse ridiculous than palpable For whereas the words are 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in auditum he turnes them both into one adjective inauditum and makes the sentence as monstrous as his owne stupidity Pope Hormisda in his Epistle to the Priests and Deacons of Syria turnes it right Qui praedicat verbum in aurem obedientis He that preaches a word to the obedient farre bee it from any sober and Orthodoxe Christian to entertaine so wild and wicked a thought he hath learned that the old way is the good way Ier. 6.16 and wil walk therin accordingly and in so doing finds rest to his soule he that preacheth this word is no lesse happy than hee that obediently heares it neither shall a man finde true rest to his soule in a new and untrodden by-way If therefore it shall be made to appeare that this government by lay-Presbyters is that which the ancient and succeeding Church of God never acknowledged untill this present age I shall not need to perswade any wise and ingenuous Christian if otherwise he have not lost the free liberty of his choice that he hath just cause to suspect it for a misgrounded novelty For such it is §. 22. The fifteenth ground That to depart from the judgment and practice of the universall Church of Christ ever since the Apostles times and to betake our selves to a new invention cannot but be besides the danger vehemently scandalous c. LAstly it must upon all this necessarily follow that to depart from the judgement and practice of the universall Church of Christ ever since the Apostles times and abandon that ancient forme wherein we were and are legally and peaceably infeoffed to betake our selves to a new one never till this age heard of in the whole Christian world it cannot but be extremely scandalous and savour too much of Schisme How ill doth it become the mouth of a Christian Divine which Parker hath let fall to this purpose Quod duo 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 posuerit Park Polit. Eccles l. 2. c. 5. Who dareth to challenge learned Casaubon for proposing two means of deciding the moderne controversies Scriptures and Antiquity what more easie triall can possibly be projected Who but a profest Novellist can dislike it 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 was the old and sure rule of that sacred Councell and it was Salomons charge Remove not the old land-marks Prov. ◠If therefore it shall be made to appeare that Episcopacie as it presupposeth an imparity of order and superiority of government hath been a sound stake pitched in the hedge of Gods Church ever since the Apostles times and that Parity and lay-Presbytery are but as new-sprung bryars and brambles lately woven into the new-plashed fence of the Church In a word thus if it be manifest that the government of Bishops in a meet and moderate imparity in which we assert it hath been peaceably continued in the Church ever since the Apostolicall Institution thereof and that the government of lay-Presbyters hath never beene so much as mentioned much lesse received in the Church untill this present age I shall need no farther argument to perswade all peaceable and well-minded Christians to adhere to that ancient forme of Administration which with so great authority is derived unto us from the first Founders of the Gospell and to leave the late supply of a lay-Presbyterie to those Churches who would and cannot have better The Second Part. §. 1. The termes and state of the Question setled and agreed upon THese are the grounds which if they prove as they cannot but do firm and unmoveable we can make no fear of the superstructure Let us therefore now addresse our selves to the particular points here confidenly undertaken by us and made good all those severall issues of defence which our holy cause is most willingly cast upon But before we descend to the scanning of the matter reason and order require that according to the old and sure rules of Logicians the terms be cleared and agreed upon otherwise we shall perhaps fight with shadows and beat the ayr It hath pleased the providence of GOD so to order it that as the Word it self the Church so the names of the Offices belonging to it in their severall comprehensions should be full of Senses and variety of use and acception and that in such manner that each of them runs one into other and oftentimes interchanges their Appellations A Prophet we know is a foreteller of future things an Evangelist in the naturall sence of the word is he that preaches the glad tidings of the Gospel an Apostle one of Christs twelve great Messengers to the world a Bishop 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 an Overseer of the Church a Presbyter some grave ancient Churchman a Deacon a servant or Minister in the Church yet all these in Scripture are so promiscuously used that a Preacher is more then once termed a Prophet 1 Cor. 14. Act 1.20 2 Ep. Iohn 1 Peter 5.1 1 Tim. 4.6 an Evangelist an Apostle an Apostle a Bishop an Apostle a Presbyter a Presbyter an Apostle as Romans 6.7 a Presbyter a Bishop and lastly an Evangelist and Bishop a Deacon or Minister for all these met in Timothy alone who being Bishop of Ephesus is with one breath charged to do the work of an Evangelist and to fulfill his 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or Ministery It could not be otherwise likely but from this community of names there would follow some confusion of apprehensions for since names were intended for distinction of things where names are the same how can the notions be distinguished But howsoever it pleased the Spirit of God in the first hatching of the Evangelicall Church to make use of these indistinct expressions yet all this while the Offices were severall known by their severall Characters and employments So as the function and work of an Apostle was one viz. To plant the Church and to ordain the Governours of it of a Bishop an other to wit To manage the Government of his designed Circuit and to ordain Presbyters and Deacons of a Presbyter another namely To assist the Bishop and to watch over his severall charge of a Deacon another besides his sacred services to order the stock of the Church and to take care of
Christians especially in the greater Cities so multiplied that they must needs be divided into many Congregations and those Congregations must necessarily have many Presbyters and those many Presbyters in the absence of the Apostles began to emulate each other and to make parties for their own advantage then as St. Ierome truly notes began the manifest and constant distinction betwixt the Office of Bishops and Presbyters to be both known and observed For now the Apostles by the direction of the Spirit of God found it requisite a d necessary for the avoyding of schisme and disorder that some eminent persons should every where be lifted up above the rest and ordained to succeed them in the ouer-seeing and ordering both the Church and their many Presbyters under them who by an eminence were called their Bishops Or as the word signifies Supervisors and Governours So as the Ministers 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Phil. 3.7 they 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 for as the Offices so the names of Bishop and Deacon were of Apostolicall foundation These Bishops therefore were the men whom they furnished with their own ordinary power as Church-governors for this purpose Now the offi◠es grew fully distinct even in the Apostles daies and under their own hands although sometimes the names after the former use were confounded All the question then shortly is whether the Apostles of Christ ordained Episcopacie thus stated and thus fixedly-qualified with Imparitie and Iurisdiction For if we take a Bishop for a parochiall Pastor and a Presbyter for a Lay-elder as too many misconstrue the terms it were no lesse then madnesse to doubt of this Superioritie but we take Episcopacie in the proper and fore-defined sence and Presbyterie according to the only true and ancient meaning of the Primitive Church viz for that which we call now Priesthood the other is a meerly new and uncouth devise neither came ever within the Ken of antiquitie As for the further subdivision of this quarrell whether Episcopacy must be accounted a distinct Order or but a severall degree in the same Order there is heer no need for the present to enter into the discussion of it Especially since I observe that the wiser sort of our opposites are indifferent to both so that whichsoever you take may be granted them to be but Iuris humani And I cannot but wonder at the toughnesse of those other opposites which stand so highly upon this difference to have it meerly but a degree In the mean while never considering that those among the Pontificiall Divines which in this point are the greatest Patrons of this their fancy go all upon the ground of the Masse according to which they regulate and conforme their opinions therein First making all Ecclesiasticall power to have reference to the body of Christ Bellarm. de sacram Ord n. l. 1. c. 9. as Bellarmine fully then every Priest being able with them to make his Maker what possible power can be imagined say they to be above that The Presbyter therefore consecrating as well as the Bishop the Order in their conceit upon this ground can be but one So then these doughty Champions among us do indeed but plead for Baal whiles they would be taken for the only pullers of him down But for our selves taking order in that sense in which our Oracle of learning Bishop Andrewes Winton Epist ad Molin 1. ci es it out of the School qua potestas est ad actum specialem there can be no reason to deny Episcopacy to be a distinct order since the greatest detractors from it have granted the power of Ordination of Priests Deacons and of Imposition of hands for Confirmation to Bishops only They are Chamiers owne words Camer de Oe cumen Pontif. l. 10. c. 5. Accipere Episcopum novam potestatem Jurisdictionem non iverim inficias I cannot denie that a Bishop as such receiveth a new power and jurisdiction Moreover in the Church of England every Bishop receives a new Ordination by way of Eminence commonly called his Consecration which cannot be a void-Act I trow and must needs give more then a degree and why should that great and ancient Councell define it to be no lesse than sacriledge to put down a Bishop into the place of a Presbyter if it were only an abatement of a degree but howsoever this be yet if it shall appear that there was by Apostolicall Ordination such a fixed imparity and constant Iurisdiction amongst those who were intrusted with the teaching and governing Gods people that is of Bishops above the other Clergie as I have spoken we have what we contend for which whiles I see doubted I cannot but wonder with what eies men read St. Paul in his Epistles to Timothy and Titus Surely in my understanding the Apostle speaks so home to the point that if he were now to give direction to an English Bishop how to demean himselfe in his place he could not speak more fully to the execution of this sacred Office For I demand what it is that is stood upon but these two particulars the especiall power of Ordination and power of the ruling and censuring of Presbyters and if these two be not clear in the charge of the Apostle to those two Bishops one of Crete the other of Ephesus I shall yield the cause and confesse to want my senses §. 5. The clear Testimonies of Scripture especially those out of the Epistles to Timothy and Titus urged NOw because this is the main point that is stood upon and some wayward opposites are ready to except at all proofs but Scripture I shall take leave briefly to scan those pregnant Testimonies which I finde in those two Apostolicall Epistles and first Timothy is charged 1 Tim. 1.3 to charge the preachers of Ephesus that they teach no other Doctrine than was prescribed That they do not give heed to Fables and Genealogies If Timothy were an equall Presbyter with the rest those Teachers were as good as he what then had he to do to charge Teachers Or what would those Teachers care for his charge How equally apt would they be to charge him to keep within his own compasse and to meddle with his own matters It is only for Superiors to charge and inferiors to obey Secondly this charge S. Paul commits to Timothy to oversee and controll the unmeet and unseasonable doctrines of the Ephesian false teachers 1 Tim. 1.12 according to the prophecies which went before of him and that in opposing himselfe to their erroneous opinions he might war a good warfare This controlment cannot be incident into an equality In this charge therefore both given and executed however it pleased our Tileno-mastix in a scurrilous manner to jeer us upon the like occasion with a profecto erit pessimus Dominus Episcopus Paulus that S. Paul was an ill Lord Bishop I may truly say that both St. Paul and Timothy his disciple doth as truly Lord it heer in their
and that in the Character of it it much resembles that to the Hebrews This noble monument that you may not doubt how it came so late to our hands was by Cyrill the late worthy Patriarch of Constantinople sent out of his Library of Alexandria whence he removed to our gracious Soveraign of Great Brittain for a precious Present as that which was by the hand of S. Tecla her self transcribed and placed at the end of the old and new Testament fairely by her written in the same Character A Present worth too much Gold And if any man do yet misdoubt his eyes may informe him by the view of it in so well his Majesties Library where it is kept and out of a desire of more publique good was lately set forth by the learned searcher of Antiquities Mr. Patrick Yong the worthy Keeper of his Majesties Library But if any man shall hope to elude this Testimony by taking advantage of the only mention of Presbyters and Deacons in the foregoing passages let him know this was onely according to the occasion of the writing of that Epistle and withall let him consider who wrote it Even Clement Bishop of Rome whether the first as some of the ancient or the third as others after Saint Peter a difference not hard to be reconciled and therefore how little danger there is of his favouring a parity in that sacred Administration §. 11. The pregnant and full testimonies of the holy Saint and Martyr Ignatius urged AFter him what better and more convincing authority can we appeal unto than that of holy Ignatius the famous Martyr of Christ whose memory is justly precious to the whole Church of God to this very present age that Miracle of Martyrs who called his fetters Christ's chains of Spirituall pearls who when he was to be throwne to the wilde beasts for the profession of Christ could boast 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. Hier. Catalog Script Eccles that he should set to the world as the Sunne that he might rise to God and when he heard the Lyons rooring I am said he Christ's Wheat Oh let me be ground with the teeth of wilde beasts that may be found pure bread for my God make much of these wilde beasts that they may become my Sepulcher that nothing my be left of my body c. I had rather dye for Christ then raigne over the whole world This blessded Saint in all those confessedly-genuine Epistles which he wrote Seaven in number still so beats upon this point as if religion depended upon it Reverence and Obedience to their Bishops This man lived in the dayes of the Apostles conversed with them and in likely-hood saw Christ in the flesh being martyred in the Eleventh yeere of Trajan according to Baronius and therefore throughly acquainted with the state of Gods Church in the Apostles time and his own and should in this name be more to us then a thousand witnesses Eevery word of his is worthy to carry our hearts along with him Heare then what he saith in his Epistle ad Trallianos Be subject to your Bishop Ignat. Epist ad Trall 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as to the Lord for he watcheth for your soules And streight Necessary it is that whatsoever ye doe ye should doe nothing without your Bishop But be ye subject also to your Priests as to the Apostles of Christ See what a distance here is whereas other of the Fathers compare the Bishops to the Apostles Presbyters to the 70 disciples this man advanceth his patterne higher requiring obedience to Bishops as to Christ to Presbyters as to the Apostles And what proportion is there betwixt the respects we owe to God and to man And a while after yet higher The Bishop saith he Ibid. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. bears the resemblance of God the Father of all things The Priests are as the bench of his Apostles c. And lest any man should construe these words to sound onely of a generality of reverent respects without yeelding of any power of command Soone after he speaks home for what other saith he is a Bishop then he that is superiour to all principality and power Pag. 9. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. and as far as a mans power may reach made an Imitator of the Christ of God And what is the Presbytery or Priest-hood but an holy company the the Counsellors and Assessors of the Bishop and what the Deacons but the Imitators of the Angelicall powers which give him pure and unblameable attendance What say ye now to this ye Patrons of Paritie in Church-government How do yee think your opinion consorts with this blessed Saint the holy partner of the Apostles Here ye have the three distinct Orders of Bishops Priests or Presbyters and Deacons Here you have a cleare and constant Superiority of Bishops above Priests with no lesse difference then betweene a Prince and his Councell-bord above Deacons no lesse then betweene a Prince and his attendants And this delivered according to the received judgement and practise of the Primitive Church The testimony is too pregnant to be eluded And yet wel-fare a friend in a corner Nico Vedelius because he sees the witnesse so cleare that he cannot be shifted off charge him with corruption and subordination pretending that sure these words are foysted in he knows not how into the Text we are yet beholding to him for asserting the truth and legitimation of these seven Epistles of our Martyr which Coke and Parker and Antitilenus being netled with their unavoydable evidences durst cry downe for bastardy whom I leave to be throughly Schooled by Chamier Rivitus Crit Secr. Vedel Apol. exercit Videlius By whom out of all antiquity they are sufficiently vindicated to the shame of the injurious accusers It is out of my way to follow this Chase but herein Videlius playes his part that those passages which he finds in these confessedly Authentique Epistles most convictive for our purpose He would faine challenge to be corrupted And why so Surely saith he these words of Principality and power ascribed to Bishops doe not savour of that golden age of the Apostles wherein Ignatius lived when Episcopacy was not Imperium potestas a rule and power but a service rather And why not both As if excellency of dignity could not consist with humility of Officiousnesse What else doth our Saviour imply in his charge he that is greatest amongst you let him be your servant their glory like as their Saviours Kingdome was not of this world Spirituall greatnesse may well agree with outward lowlinesse 1 Cor. 2.3 4. 1 Thess 1.5 St. Paul matcheth 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 weakenesse and power and even whiles he was Tent-making could speak of his 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 And why should this phrase be here seized upon suspition rather then in other passages of holy Ignatius where
Cyprian Cum Episcopo Presbyteri Sacerdotali honore conjuncti the Presbyters joyned with the Bishop in Priestly honour l. 3. ep 1. Cypr. l. 3. Ep. 1. What shall I need to urge how often in the ancient Councels they are stiled by the name of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Priests and how by those venerable Synods they have the offices and imployments of onely Priests and Clergimen put upon them our two learned Bishops D. Bilson and D. Downam have so cleered this point that my labour herein would be but superfluous I referre my reader to their unquestionable instances One thing let me adde not unworthy of observation I shall desire no other authour to confute this opinion of the Lay-presbyterie than Aerius himself the onely ancient enemy of Episcopacie what is a Bishop saith he other then a Presbyter c. there is but one order one honour of both Doth the Bishop impose hands so doth the Presbyter Doth the Bishop administer Baptisme so doth the Presbyter The Bishop dispenseth Gods service so doth the Presbyter c. Thus he Lo there is but one professed enemy to Bishops in all the history of the Church and he in the very act of his opposition to Episcopacie marres the fashion of the Lay-presbytery He could not in terminis directly oppose it indeed How should he oppose that wich never was But he attributes such acts and offices to a Presbyter as never any Laick durst usurpe such as never were never could be ascribed to any that was not consecrated to God by an holy ordination Had this man then but dreamed of a Lay-presbytery either to supply or affront Episcopacie it might have been some countenance at least to the age of this invention but now the device hath not so much patrocination pardon an harsh word as of an old Stigmatick yea it is quashed by the sole and onely Marprelate of the ancient Church §. 4. Ambrose's testimony urged for Lay-Elders fully answered YEt let me eat my word betimes while it is hot there is an holy and ancient Bishop they say that pleads for a Lay-presbytery and who should that be but the godly and renowned Archbishop and Metropolitan of Milaine St. Ambrose a man noted as for singular sanctimonie so for the height of his spirit and zeale of mantaining the right of his function and what will he say Amb. in 1. Tim. 5.1 Vnde synagoga posteà etiam Ecclesia seniores habuit c. Whereupon saith he both the synagogue and afterwards the Church also had certain Elders or ancient men without whose counsell nothing was done in the Church which by what negligence it is now out of use I know not except perhaps it were by the sloath of the teachers or rather by their pride for that they would seeme to be of some reckoning alone Here is all and now let me beseech my reader to rouze up himselfe a little and with some more than ordinary attention to listen to this evidence on which alone for any likely pretence of antiquity so a great cause wholly dependeth And first let him heare that this is no Ambrose but a counterfeit even by the confession of the greatest favourers of the Lay-presbyterie Park Polit. Eccl. who that they would thus easily turne off the chiefe if not the only countenance of their cause it is to me a wonder but they well saw if they had not done it it would have beene done for them Possevine thinks he finds Pelagianisme in this Commentarie upon the Epistles Bellar. Tom. 4. de Amiss grat c. 5. l. 4. de Iustif c. 8. both Whitakers and Bellarmine disclaime it for Ambrose's the later pitches it upon an hereticke even the same wich was the authour of the booke of the Questions of the Old and New testament Hilarie the Deacon and the former doth little other whiles he cites and seemes to allow the Censors of Lovaine to this purpose Maldon in Mat. 19. Maldonate casts it upon Remigius Lugdunensis who lived Anno 870. farre from any authentick antiquity and confidently saies no man that ever read Ambrose's Writings can think these to bee his It is then first no great matter what this witnesse saith but yet let us heare him Vnde synagoga saith hee Whereupon the Synagogue and after the Church also had Elders And whereupon was this spoken I beseech you Let my reader but take the fore going words with him and see if hee can forbeare to smile at the conceit The words run thus upon occasion of Saint Pauls charge Rebuke not an elder but intreat him as a father c. Propter honorificentiam aetatis majorem natu cum mansuetudine ad bonum opus provocandum c. For the honour of age the elder in yeares is by meeknesse to bee provoked to a good worke c. Nam apud omnes ubique gentes honorabilis est senectus For saith he amongst all nations every where old age 't is honourable And so inferres whereupon both the Synagogue and afterwards the Church had certaine elder or ancient men without whose counsell nothing was done in the Church Plainly the words are spoken of an elder in age not any Elder in office And so S. Pauls words import too for it follows the elder women as mothers I suppose no man will think S. Paul meant to ordain Eldresses in the Church Thus in the supposed Ambrose all runs upon this strane fort here is Honorificentia aetatis the honorificence of age majores natu honorabilis senectus no intimation of any office in the Church But you will say here is mention of the Elders that the Synagogue had True but not as Iudges but onely as aged persons whose experience might get them skill and gravity procure them reverence and such the Church had too and made use of their counsell and therefore it followes quorum sine consilio without whose counsell nothing was done in the Church he saith not without whose authority these then for ought this place implieth were not incorporated in any Consistory but for their prudence advised with upon occasion and what is this to a fixed bench of Lay-presbyters Or if there were such a settled Colledge of Presbyters in ancient use as Ignatius implies yet where are the Lay They were certaine ancient experienced Divines who upon all difficult occasions were ready to give their advice and aid to their Bishop how little the true Ambrose dreamed of any other let him be consulted in his noble humble and yet stout Epistile Am. l. 2. Epist 1◠3. to the Emperour Valentinian where that worthy patterne of Prelates well showes how ill it could be brooked that persons meerly laick or secular should have any hand in judging and ordering of matters spirituall Yea for this very pretended Ambrose how farre he was from thinking of a Lay-presbytery let himselfe speake who in the very same Chapter upon those words Let the Elders that rule well he counted worthy of
State and hazard of the Reformation it selfe or to the adjuring and blaspheming of an holy Order in the Church and dishonouring of Almighty God while they pretended to seeke his honour This was their Case but what is this to yours Your Church was happily gone out of Babylon your and our most gracious and religious Soveraigne sincerely professeth maintaineth incourageth the blessedly-reformed Religion his Bishops preach for it write for it and professe themselvs ready after the example of their predecessors to bleed for it Your and our late learned and pious Soveraign of blessed memory with the generall votes of a lawfull Assembly re-inforced that Order of Episcopacie which had been as I take it but about seventeene yeares discontinued And how can you now think of paralleling your condition with the forraigne But that you may not think that I speake at randome and upon blinde conjectures of the state of this difference heare I pray you Fregevill Politique Reform pag. 70. of the Translation into English what wise Fregivillaeus a deep head and one that was able to cut even betwixt the league the Church and the State saith concerning it The Ministers of the reformation saith he which planted it in France had respect unto their businesse and to the work they took in hand when they brought in this equalitie which Was to plant a Church and to begin after the manner of the Apostles when they planted a Church in Ierusalem As also they meant not to traverse the state of the Clergy or to submit it to their orders whensoever the Clergie or whole State of France should happen to admit the Reformation But their purpose tended onely to overthrow superstition and in the meane time to beare themselves according to their simple equality whereupon I infer that he that would take occasion of this equality brought into France to reverse the estate of the Episcopall Clergie among the reformed should greatly wrong the cause of those who there-under have reformed France and had never that intent Thus he Whereto adde That the same Authour professeth that it is not the degrees of the Clergie which the Reformers except against but the superstition In the meane time he judiciously professeth that the French Ministers have taken up this equality of government only provisionally reserving libertie to alter it according to occurrences To which purpose he projecteth to the French King the Creation of one supreme Bishop or Patriarch of France to whom the whole estate of the French Clergie might upon faire termes be subjected Doe you not now in all this which hath beene said see a sensible difference betwixt their Condition and yours Can you chuse but observe the blessing of Monarchicall reformation amongst us beyond that popular and tumultuary reformation amongst our neighbours Ours a Councell theirs an uproare Ours beginning from the head theirs from the feet Ours proceeding in a due order theirs with confusion Ours countenancing and incouraging the converted Governours of the Church theirs extremely over-awed with averse power or totally over-borne with foule sacriledge in a word ours comfortably yeelding what the true and happie condition of a Church required theirs hand-over-head taking what they could get for the present And what now Shall we instead of blessing God for our happinesse emulate the misery of those whom we doe at once respect and pitie Suppose the late Kings and Parliaments of France before these separate formes of administration were pitcht upon would have said You of the Reformed profession injoy your religion freely and if you thinke it more safe to live under Church-Governours of your owne let your Clergie recommued unto us such grave and worthy persons as may be fit for those places they shall forthwith be established over you with full authority and just maintenance would any of the learned Divines of those times have slighted the offer and have said by your leave Sir vve like it not vve have other projects in hand vve vvill set up a nevv government that vvill better befit our purposes certainly I should vvonder at the man that should entertaine such an impossible imagination of those vvise and godly learned professors vvho vvere by the iniquitie of the times in a manner forceably driven at least as they imagined upon this forme and necessarily put to this choice vvhether they vvould still submit to popery or no longer submit to Episcopall Administration vvhich there vvas only managed by Popish hands What need more vvords Themselves have as vve have already seen clearely decided it Go novv and take these men and times for your patternes vvho never meant to make themselves and their condition imitable presidents but rather the objects of our better vvishes It vvas a modest vvord of Beza That he never meant to prescribe the Ecclesiasticall policie of Geneva to other Churches for this vvere high presumption And vvill you be prescribing to your selves that vvhich he vvould not prescribe to you Will you create tha◠to be an universall Ordinance of God which he dare not warrant for any other than a Locall Constitution Neither is there a more sensible difference betweene the Authority and successe of a Monarchicall or popular Reformation than there is betweene the forms which are fit and expedient for large Churches living under the sway of a Monarch and those which particular Cities or territories may admit under a Democraticall or Aristocraticall government Hereupon saith the Reformed Politique discreetly I do inferre that in the state of a mighty and peaceable Church as that of England or as the Church of France or such like might be if God should call them to Reformation the state of the Clergie ought to be preserved For equality would be hurtfull to the State and in time breed confusion Thus he And indeed besides those holy and divine considerations whereof we shall treat in the sequell it stands with great reason that there should be a correspondence betwixt the Church and the State and a meet respect to the rules of both As therefore because in a free Citie or State we finde certaine Optimates who by successive Elections sway the government according to their municipall rules not without the assistance and consent of a greater number of Plebeian Burgesses and see perhaps this forme of Administration in those places succesfull it were a crime of strange braine-sick giddinesse to say nothing of the hainous morall transgression to cast off the yoke of just and hereditarie Monarchie and to affect this 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 many headed Soveraignty So were it no lesse unreasonable where a Nationall Church is happily setled in the orderly regiment of certain grave over-seers ruling under one acknowledged Soveraigne by wholesome and unquestionable Laws and by these Laws punishable if they over-lash or be defective in their charge in a fastidious discontentment to seeke to abandon this ancient forme and to betake themselves to a popular forme of Discipline borrowed from abroad which what were it
other than to snatch the reines out of the hands of a skilfull Coachman and either to lay them loose on the horses necks or to deliver them to the hands of some ignorant and unskilfull lackeyes that run along by them But of this point more elsewhere My zeal and my respects to the Churches abroad and my care and pitie of many seduced soules at home have drawne me on farther in this discourse than I meant For who can indure to see simple and well meaning Christians abused with the false colour of Conformity with other Churches when there is apparently more distance in the ground of their differences than in the places of their situation Be wise my deare Brethren and suffer not your selves to be cheated of the Truth by the mis-zealous suggestions of partiall-teachers Reserve your hearts free for the clearer light of Scripture and right reason which shall in this discourse offer to shine into your soules For you Sir fu frere confesse unlesse you can in truth deny it that you goe alone and that you have reason absolutely to quit all the hope of the Patrocination of other Churches which you might seeme to challenge from their example and practice For now that I have got you alone I shall be bold to take you to task and doe in the name of Almighty God vehemently urge and challenge you to maintaine if by any skill or pretence you may your owne act of the condemnation of Episcopacie and your penitent submission to a Presbyteriall government Wherein I doubt not but I shall convince you of an high and irreparable injury done by you to God his Ordinance and his Church § 6. The project and substance of the Treatise following FOr the full and satisfactorie performance vvhereof I shall only need to make good these tvvo maine points First That Episcopacie such as you have renounced even that vvhich implies a fixed superioritie over the rest of the Clergie and jurisdiction is not only an holy and lavvfull but a divine Institution and therefore cannot be abdicated vvithout a manifest violation of Gods Ordinance Secondly That the Presbyterian Government so constituted as you have novv submitted to it hovvever venditated under the glorious names of Christs Kingdome and Ordinance by those specious and glozing termes to bevvitch the ignorant multitude and to insnare their consciences hath no true footing either in Scripture or the practice of the Church in all ages from Christs time to the present That I may clearly evince these two maine points wherin indeed consists the life and soul of the whole cause I shall take leave to lay down certain just and necessary Postulata as the ground-workes of my ensuing proofs all which are so cleare and evident that I would fain suppose neither your selfe nor any ingenuous Christian can grudge to yeeld them But if any man will be so stiffe and close-fisted as to stick at any of them they shall be easily wrung out of his fingers by the force of Reason and manifest demonstration of Truth §. 7. The first ground or postulate That government whose foundation is laid by Christ and whose Fabrick is raised by the Apostles is of Divine Institution THe first whereof shall be this That government whose ground being laid by our Saviour himselfe vvas aftervvards raised by the hands of his Apostles cannot be denied to be of Divine Institution A Proposition so cleare that it were an injurie to goe about to prove it He cannot be a Christian who will not grant that as in Christ the Sonne of God the Deity dwelt bodily so in his servants also and agents under him the Apostles the Spirit of the same God dwelt so as all their actions were Gods by them Like as it is the same spring-water that is derived to us by the Conduit-pipes and the same Sun-beames which passe to us through our windowes Some things they did as men actions naturall civill morall these things were their own yet they even in them no doubt were assisted with an excellent measure of grace But those things which they did as Messengers from God so their names signifie these were not theirs but his that sent them An Ambassador dispatcheth his Domesticall affaires as a private man but when he treats or concludes matters of State in his Princes name his tongue is not his owne but his Masters Much more is it so in this case wherein besides the interest the agents are freed from errour The carefullest Ambassador may perhaps swerve from his message these which was one of the priviledges of the Apostles were through the guidance of Gods Spirit in the acts of their Function inerrable So then if the foundation were laid by Christ and the wals built up by his Apostles the Fabrick can be no lesse than divine §. 8. The second ground That the practice and recommendation of the Apostles is sufficient warrant for an Apostolicall Institution SEcondly It must also be granted That not onely the government which vvas directly commanded and enacted but that vvhich vvas practised and recommended by the Apostles to the Church is justly to be held for an Apostolicall Institution In eminent and authorized persons even examples are rules much more in so sacred Neither did the Spirit of God confine it selfe to vvords but expressed it selfe also in the holy actions of his inspired servants as Chrysostome therefore truly said That our Saviour did not only speak but vvork Parables So may vve say here that the Apostles did not only enact but even act lavves for his holy Church Licèt autem nullum extat praeceptum de manuum impositione c. Calv. l. 4. Instit C. 3.8.16 And this is learned Calvins determination about imposition of hands Although saith he there is no certaine precept concerning Imposition of Hands yet because vve see it vvas in perpetuall use vvith the Apostles their so accurate observation of it ought to be unto us instead of a command and therfore soone after he affirmes plainly That this Ceremony proceeded from the Holy Ghost himself And in the fore-going Chapter speaking of the distribution of Pastors to their severall charges he saith Nec humanum est inventum c. It is no humane device but the Institution of God himselfe For vve read that Paul and Barnabas ordained Presbyters in all the Churches of Lystra Antioch Iconium And that direction vvhich the great Apostle of the Gentiles gave to Timothy vvas as Calvin truly Mandati nomine in the name and nature of a command And vvhat els I beseech you vvould the rigid exacters of the over-severe and Judaicall observation of the Lords day as an Evangelicall Sabbath seem to plead for their vvarrant vvere they able to make it good any vvay but the guise and practice of the Apostles Precept certainly there is none either given or pretended Thus the bitter Tileno-mastix can say There was a double Discipline of the Apostles Docens and Vtens in the first they gave precepts to
the Church Paracles l. 1. c. 4 and her Governours in the second their practice prescribes her government although as he adds without booke not without the Churches owne consultation and consent which if it be granted makes the more for us who ever since we were a Church have consented to the Apostles practice and constantly used the same What do I stand upon this They are the words of Cartwright himselfe 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the example of the Apostles and generall practice of the Churches under their government draweth a necessitie §. 9. The third ground That the formes ordained by the Apostles were for universall and perpetuall use THirdly it is no lesse evident that the form which the Apostles set and ordained for the governing of the Church was not intended by them for that present time or place onely but for continuance and succession for ever For no man I suppose can be so weak Praecepta ipsa disciplinae omnibus in futurum Ecclesiis dictante Sp. Sancto tradiderunt Sco. Wy Paracles l. 1. c. 4 as to thinke that the rules of the Apostles were personall locall temporary as some Dials or Almanacks that are made for some speciall Meridians but as their office and charge so their rules were universall to the whole world as farre and as long as the world lasteth For what reason is there that Crete or Ephesus should be otherwise provided for than all the world besides Or what possibility to think that those first planters of the Gospell should leave all the rest of Christs Church as the Ostrich doth her eggs in the dust without any farther care The extent and duration of any rule will best be measured as by the intention of the Authour so by the nature and use of it S. Paul's intention is clearely expressed for a continuance untill the appearing of our Lord Iesus Christ 1 Tim. 6.14 As for the nature of the severall directions they carry perpetuity and universality of use in the face of them there being the same reason of their observation by all persons concerned and in all times and places why should not every Bishop be as unreproveable as a Cretian or an Ephesian Why should an accusation be received against an Elder upon more slender evidence in one place than another Why should there not bee the same courses taken for Ordination and Censure in all ages and Churches since the same things must of necessity bee done every where in all ages and Churches But why should I strive for a granted Truth For it is plaine that the Isle of Crete and Ephesus were but the patternes of other Churches and Timothie and Titus of other faithfull Overseers If therefore it shall appeare that Episcopacie so stated as we have expressed was in these persons and Churches ordered and setled by Apostolicall direction it must necessarily be yeelded to be of Apostolike and therefore Divine Institution §. 10. The fourth ground That the universall practice of the Church immediately succeeding the Apostolike times is a sure Commentary upon the practice of the Apostles and our best direction FOurthly I must challenge it for a no lesse undoubted Truth That the universall practice of the Church immediately succeeding the Apostles is the best Commentary upon the practice of the Apostles and withall that the universall practice of Gods Church in all ages and places is next unto Gods Word the best guide and direction for our carriages and formes of Administration The Copartners and immediate Successors of those blessed men could best tell what they next before them did for who can better tell a mans way or pace than he that followes him close at the heeles And if particular men or Churches may mistake yet that the whole Church of Christian men should at once mistake that which was in their eye it is farre more than utterly improbable A truth which it is a wonder any sober Christian should bogle at yet such there are to our griefe and to the shame of this late giddy age even the great guides of their faction Polit. Eccles l. 2. cap. 7. Falsum est c. Our mis-learned countriman Parker the second Ignis fatuus of our poore mis-led brethren and some Seconds of his stand peremptorily and highly upon the Deniall It is false saith he that the universall practice of the Church is sufficient to prove any thing to be of Apostolike Originall And jeeringly soone after Vniversa Ecclesiae praxis consensus patrum unica Hierarchicorum Helena est The universall practice of the Church and consent of Fathers saith he is the onely dearling of the abettors of the Hierarchy But the practice of the Church immediatly after the Apostles is no evidence Heare now I beseech you my deare brethren all ye who would pretend to any Christian ingenuity and consider whether you have not reason to distrust such a leader as would perswade you to slight and reject the testimony and practice of the whole Church of God upon earth from the first plantation of it to this present age and to cast your selves upon the private opinions of himselfe and some few other men of yesterday surely in very matter of doctrine this could be no other than deeply suspicious than foulely odious If no man before Luther and Calvin had excepted against those points wherein we differ from Rome I should have hated to follow them how much more must this needs hold in matter of fact Iudge what a shame it is to heare a Christian Divine carelesly shaking off all arguments drawne from Antiquity Continuance Perpetuall Succession in and from Apostolike Churches unanimous consent universall practice of the Church immediate practice of all the Churches succeeding the Apostles as either Popish or nothing And all these are acknowledged for our Grounds and are not Popish For me I professe I could not without blushing and astonishment read such stuffe as confounded in my selfe to see that any sonne of the Church should be not onely so rebelliously unnaturall to his holy mother as to broach so putrid a Doctrine to her utter disparagement but so contumelious also to the Spirit of God in his providence for the deare Spouse of his Saviour here upon earth Holy Jrenaeus Iren. l. 4. contr haeres I am sure was of another minde Agnitio vera saith he The true acknowledgement is the doctrine of the Apostles antiquus Ecclesiae status and the ancient state of the Church in the whole world by the Succession of Bishops to whom the Apostles delivered the Church which is in every place And then whiles we have both these the doctrine of the Apostles seconded by the ancient state of the Church who can out-face us What meanes then this wilfull and peevish stupidity Nihil pro Apostolico habendum Ibid. l. 2. c. 7. Nothing saith Parker is to be held for Apostolike but that which is found recorded in the writings of the Apostles Nothing Was all
the poor yet all these agreed in one Common Service which was the propagation of the Gospel and the sounding of Gods Church and soon after the very terms were contra-distinguished both by the substance of their charge and by the property of their Titles insomuch as blessed Ignatius that holy Martyr who lived many yeers within the times of the Apostles in every of his Epistles as we shall see in the sequel makes expresse mention of three distinct orders of Government Bishops Presbyters Deacons Now we take Episcopacie as it is thus punctually differenced in an eminence from the two inferior orders of Presbyter and Deacon so as to define it Episcopacie is no other than an holy order of Church-Governours appointed for the Administration of the Church Or more fully thus Episcopacie is an eminent order of sacred function appointed by the Holy Ghost in the Evangelicall Church for the governing and overseeing thereof and for that purpose besides the Administration of the Word and Sacraments indued with power of imposition of hands and perpetuity of Iurisdiction Wherein we finde that we shall meet with two sorts of Adversaries The one are furiously and impetuously fierce crying down Episcopacy for an unlawfull and Antichristian state not to be suffered in a truely Evangelicall Church having no words in their mouthes but the same which the cruell Edomites used concerning Ierusalem Downe with it down with it even to the ground And such are the frantick Separatists and Semi-separatists of our time and Nation who are only swayed with meer passion and wilfully blinded with unjust prejudice These are Reformers of the new Cut which if Calvin or Beza were alive to see they would spit at and wonder whence such an off-spring should come Men that defend and teach there is no higher Ecclesiasticall government in the world than that of a Parish that a Parochiall Minister though but of the blindest village in a Country is utterly independant and absolute a perfect Bishop within himselfe and hath no superiour in the Church upon earth and doth no lesse inveigh even against the over-ruling power of Classes Synods c. than of Bishops you are not perhaps of this straine for we conceive that our Northern neighbors desire and affect to conforme unto the Genevian or French discipline Honoratiss Do. Glanico Cancellario Scotiae respon ad sex quaestiones for which we find Beza's directions although both your act of a brenunciation and some speeches let fall in the assembly of Glasco and of the plea of Covenanters fetching Episcopacy within the compasse of things abjured might seem to intimate some danger of inclination this way our charity bids us hope the best which is that you hate the frenzeys of these our wilde Countrey-men abroad for whom no answer is indeed fit but darke lodgings and Ellebore The other is more milde and gentle and lesse unreasonable not disallowing Episcopacy in it selfe but holding it to be lawfull usefull ancient yet such as was by meer humane device upon wise and politick Considerations brought into the Church and so continued and therefore upon the like grounds alterable with both these we must have to do But since it is wind ill lost to talke reason to a mad-man it shall be more than sufficient to confute the former of them in giving satisfaction to the latter for if wee shall make it appeare that Episcopacy is not onely lawfull and ancient but of no lesse than divine institution those raving and black mouthes are fully stopped and those more easie and moderate opposites at once convinced But before we offer to deal blows on either side it is fit we should know how far we are friends and upon what points this quarrell stands It is yielded by the wiser fautors of Discipline that there is a certain Polity necessary for the retention of the Churches peace That this Polity requires that there must be severall Congregations or flocks of Christians and that every flock should have his own Shepherd That since those guides of Gods people are subject to error in Doctrine and exorbitance in manners which may need correction and reformation and many doubtfull cases may fall out which will need decision it is requisite there should be some further aid given by the counsell and assistance of other Pastors That those Pastors met together in Classes and Synodes are fit arbiters in differences and censurers of errors and disorders That in Synodes thus assembled there must be due order kept That order cannot be kept where there is an absolute equality of all persons convened That it is therefore necessary that there should be an head President or Governour of the assembly who shall marshall all the affairs of those meetings propound the Cases gather the voyces pronounce the Sentences and judgements but in the mean while he having but lent his tongue for the time to the use of the Assembly when the businesse is ended returnes to his own place without any personall inequality A lively image whereof we have in our lower house of Convocation the Clerks whereof are chosen by the Clergy of the severall Diocesses They all having equall power of voyces assemble together choose their Prolocutor He cals the house receives petitions or complaints proposes the businesses asks and gathers the suffrages dismisses the Sessions and the action once ended takes his former station forgetting his late superiority This is the thing challenged by the Patrons of Discipline who do not willingly heare of an upper house consisting of the Peeres of the Church whose grave authority gives life to the motions of that lower body They can be content there should be a prime Presbyter and that this Presbyter shall be called Bishop and that Bishop shall moderate for the time the publike affairs of the Church but without all innate and fixed superiority without all though never so moderate Iurisdiction Calvin in this case shall speak for all who writing of the state of the Clergie in the Primitive times hath thus Calv. Instit l. 4. c. 4. Quibus ergo docendi munus c. Those therefore which had the charge of teaching injoined unto them they named Presbyters These Presbyters out of their number in every city chose one to whom they especially gave the title of Bishop lest from equality as it commonly fals out discords should arise Neither was the Bishop so superiour to the rest in honour and dignity as that he had any rule over his Colleagues but the same office and part which the Consul had in the Senate to report of businesse to be done to ask the votes advising admonishing exhorting to go before the rest to rule the whole action by his authority and to execute that which by the common Councell was decreed The same office did the Bishop sustain in the assembly of the Presbyters Thus he and to the same purpose Beza in his Treatise of the degrees of the ministery Moulin Chamier others So as we easily see how
of power a Priority of Presidencie for the time not personall Beza yields him 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as he acknowledges Justine Martyr to call him President of the Presbytery imo ne perpetuum q. istud 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 munus esse necessario opportuisse but perhaps not perpetuall wherein I blesse my self to see how prejudice can blinde the eyes of the wise and learned for what Author in the whole world ever mentioned such a fashion of ambulatory Government in the Church And do not our Histories testifie that Polycarpus the Angel of Smyrna dyed Bishop there that Onesimus by Ignatius his testimony so continued Bishop of Ephesus James at Ierusalem and of these errors taxed by the holy Ghost were but for the time of a shifting Presidencie why should any one of the momentany guides of the Churches be charged so home with all the abuses of their Iurisdiction How easie had it been for him to shift the fault as hee did the chair for how could it concerne him more then the next men surely this conceit is more worthy of pity than Confutation No indifferent Reader can looke upon that Scripture and not confesse it a strained Construction Here then were certainly both Continuance and Iurisdiction Wherein Parker braves our learned Docter Field as relying meerely upon the proofs of humane authority but that worthy Divine had he insisted upon the point which hee but touched in the way could easily out of the very Text it self have evicted the Angels power and Iurisdiction for how plain is it that the Angell of Ephesus had taken the Examination of the counterfeit Apostles and found them lyers which if a meer Presbyter had undertaken to do to bee sure hee had been shaken off with scorn enough It is imputed to the Angell of the Church of Pergamus that however himself in his own person held constant to the Faith yet that there were those under his charge who held the doctrine of Balaam the beastly errours of the Nicolaitans lhey were of his Clergie that taught these wicked Doctrines And for this the Bishop is texed and menaced how should this be if he had not had a coe cive power to restraine and punish them And more plainly the Angell of the Church of Thyatyra notwithstanding all his good parts graces services is sharply taxed What is his fault Revel 2.26 That thou sufferest the woman Iezabel who calleth herself a prophetesse to teach and seduce my servants c. Were he but an Ordinary Presbiter unarmed with power how could he helpe it Or why should he be charged with what he could not redresse Let an ingenuous reader now judge whether these bee not more than probabilities of a Supereminent and Iurisdictive power in these speciall Angels of the Asian Churches Shortly then upon these clear passages of Saint Paul and Saint Iohn meeting with the grounds laid by our blessed Saviour I am for my part so confident of the Divine Institution of the Majority of Bishops above Presbiters that I dare boldly say there are weighty points of faith which have not so strong evidence in holy Scriptures Let me instance in that power which we that are Evangelicall Ministers have by the vertue of our sacred Ordes given to us alone for the Consecration and distribution of the holy Eucharist a point not more highly than justly stood upon by all Orthodox Divines yea Christians What warrant can we challenge for this right but our Saviours practise And with all that speech of his to his Disciples Luke 22.20 Do this in remembrance of me Now if this Hoc facite shall be taken as it is by some as not spoken of the Consecration or benediction but of the receit what warrant had the Apostles and all their holy successors in the Church of God ever since to enjoyne and appropriate this sacred worke to none but those that are Presbyters by Ordination The receiving of Infants to holy Baptisme is a matter of so high consequence that we justly Brand our Catabaptists with heresie for denying it yet Let me with good assurance say that the evidences for this truth come farre short of that which the Scriptures have afforded us for the superiority of some Church-governors over those who otherwise indeed in a sole respect of their ministeriall function are equall He therefore that would upon pretence of want of Scriptures quarrell at the divine Institution of Bishops having so evident and unavoydable Testimonies might with much better colour cavill at those blessed Ordinances of God which the whole Church hath thought her self bound upon sufficient reason to receive and reverence §. 8. The estate and order of Episcopacy deduced from the Apostles to the Primitive Bishops DId not the holy Scriptures yield unto these firme grounds whereon to build our Episcopacy in vain should we plead the Tradition and practise of the Church ever since for as much as we have to deal with those who are equally disaffected to the name of a Bishop and to Tradition and are so fore-stalled with their own prejudice that they are carried where Scripture is silent to an unjust jealousie against the universall practise of the whole Church of God upon earth But now when Christ and his Apostles give us the text well may the Apostolicall and universall Church yield us the Commentary And that let me boldly say is so clear for us that if our Opposites dare stand to this triall the day is ours their gultinesse therfore would fain decline this barre Tertull. de prescrip c. 24 25. Parker taking advantage from a word of Tertullian Nihil interest quando quid sit quod ab Apostolis non fuit It matters not when any thing is which was not under the Apostles that is Adulterine what ever it be that is not named by the Apostles inferres What then It matters not when the Episcopall Hierarchy began whether sooner or later Qi d igitur Nihil interest c. l. 2. c. 8. it is enough that it is Adulterine for that it is not named by the Apostles And contrarily it matters no whit at what time the reformed dis ipline was impayred whether in the very first Church or no or whether in the time immediatly succeeding Thus he And shall we take him at his word Where then did the Apostles name this mans Consistory Where his Lay-changable Presbytery Where his Discipline It is therefore Adulterine As also Where name they the peoples voyce in their Ministers Election where Classes or Synods Are all these adulterine For us we are not concerned in this Censure Our Episcopacy is both named and recommended and prescribed by the Apostles As for his discipline seeing it never came within the mention either of an Apostle or of any Christian for above fifteen hundred yeers since our Saviour left the world what can that be but grosly adulterine But to make up all Parker should have done well to have taken notice of the following words of
Tertullian Quod ab Apostolis non damnatur imo defenditur hoc erit judicium proprietatis That which is not condemned by the Apostles yea defended rather may well be judged for their own and then he would have found how strong this plea of Tertullian is against himselfe For where ever can he show Episcopacy condemned by the Apostle yea how clearly do we show it not allowed only but enjoyned finding therefore Episcopall imparity so countenanced by the written word we have good reason to call in all antiquity and the universall Church succeeding the Apostles as the voice of the Spouse to second her glorious husband Had there been any sensible gapp of time betwixt the dayes of the Apostles and the Ordination of Bishops in the Christian Church we might have had some reason to suspect this Institution to have been meerly humane but now since it shall appeare that this worke of erecting Episcopacy passed both under the eies and hands of those sacred Ambassadors of Christ who lived to see their Episcopall successors planted in the severall regions of the world what reason can any man pretend that this institution should be any other then Apostolicall had it been otherwise they lived to have Countermanded it How plain is that of St. Ambrose Paul saw Iames at Ierusalem because he was made Bishop of that place by the Apostles and to the same effect St. Austin contra Cresiâ—n 1. 2. St. Ierome the only Author amongst the ancients who is wont with any colour to be alleadged against the right of Episcopacy yet himself confesseth that Bishops began in Alexandria from Mark the Evangelist who died sixe yeers before St. Peter or St. Paul Thirty five yeers before St. James the Apostle Forty five yeers before Simon Cleophas who succeeded St. Iames in the Bishoprick of Ierusalem being the kinsman of our Saviour 〈◊〉 l. 3. c. 11. as Eusebius Brother to Joseph as Egesippus The same author can tell us that in the very times of the Apostles Ignatius was Bishop of Antioch indeed of Syria Sicut Smyrnaeorum ecclesia habens Policarpum ab Joanne conlocatum Tert. de praesc Policarpus of Smyrna Timothy of Ephesus Titus of Crete or Candia That Papias St. Iohns Auditor soon after was made Bishop of Hierapolis Quadratus a disciple of the Apostles Bishop of Athens after Publius his martyred predecessor And can we think these men were made Bishops without the knowledge and consent of the Apostles then living or with it without it we cannot say except we will disparage both the Apostles care and power And withall the holinesse of these their successors who were knowne to be Apostolicall men disciples of Christ Companions of the Apostles and lastly blessed Martyrs if with it we have our desire what shall I need to instance Our learned Bilson hath cleared this point beyond all contradiction In whom you may please to see out of Eusebius Egesippus Socrates Ierom Perpet goverm of the Ch. ch 13. Epiphanius others as exact a pedegree of all the holy Bishops of the Primitive Church succeeding each other in the foure Apostolicall Sees untill the time of the Nicene Councell as our Godwin or Mason can give us of our Bishops of England or a Speed or Stow of our English Kings There you shall finde from Iames the Lords brother who as Ierom himselfe expresly sate as Bishop in the Church of Ierusalem to Macarius who sate in the Nicene Councell 40. Bishops punctually named From St. Peter who governed the Church of Antioch and was succeeded by Evodius and he by Ignatius twenty seven In the See of Rome thirty seven In the See of Alexandria from Marke the Evangelist twenty three A Catalogue which cannot be questioned without too much injurious incredulity nor denied without an unreasonable boldnesse The same course was held in all other Churches neither may wee thinke these varied from the rest but rather as Prime Sees were patternes to the more obscure For the other saith Eusebius Euseb l. 3. c. 37. it is not possible by name to rehearse them all that were Pastours imployed in the first successions of the Church-government after the Apostles Neither indeed needeth it the wariest buyers by one handful judge of the whole sack and this truth is so cleer that the most judicious late Divines have not stuck to acknowledge so much as we have desired §. 9 The testimony and assent of Bucer and some famous French Divines BY the perpetuall observation of the Church even from the Apostles themselves saith Bucer we see it seemed good to the holy Ghost that among the Presbyters to whom the charge of the Church is specially committed one should have the singular Charge of the Churches and in that Charge and Care governed others for which cause the name of Bishops was attributed to these chiefe Governours of the Church Thus he in full accord with us And Chamier when he had first granted that statim post Apostolorum excessum immediately after the decease of the Apostles began the difference between a Bishop and Presbyter Cham. de membris Eccles milâ— t. l. 4. c. 1. straight as correcting himselfe addes Quid Res ipsa caepit tempore Apostolorum vel potius ab ipsis profecta est The thing it selfe began in the very time of the Apostles yea proceeded from them Thus hee although withall hee affirmes this difference not to have been Essentiall but Accidentall A distinction in this respect unproperly perhaps applied by him but otherwise Nulla est EsseÌ„tialis distinctio inter Episcopos Presbyteros respectu ministeriâ— idem enim utrisque est Apostoli tamen erant primarii a Christo ministri instituti qu bus non aliis Ecclesiae suae fundationem regimen commisit Spalat de Rep. Eccl. 1. 2. c. 3. Spalatensis justly both yelds and makes in a right and sure sense For certainly in the proper works of their ministeriall function in preaching and administring the Word and Sacraments they differ not or only differ in some accident but yet in those points which concerne Ordination and the administration of government then the difference is reall and palpable and that as we shall soon see not without a fixed Iurisdiction To the same purpose my reverend and ancient friend Moulin in one of his Epistles to the renowned Bishop of Winchester Molin Epi. ad Winton Ep. 3. Statim post c. Soon after the Apostles time saith he or rather in their owne time as the Ecclesiasticall story witnesseth It was constituted That in one Citie one Presbyter should have preeminence over his Colleagues who was called a Bishop Et hanc regiminis formam omnes ubique Ecclesiae receperunt and this form of government all Churches every where receive I do willingly take the word of these two famous professors of the French Church The one sayes Constitutum est It was constituted in the time of the Apostles the other that it proceeded from
holyes Our Martyr goes on In his Epistle to those of Smyrna he is Ignat ad Smyr 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. Pag 16 11 if it be possible more punctuall Follow your Bishop saith he as Christ did his Father and the Colledge of Priests as his Apostles reverence your Deacons as ministring according to the command of God Let no man without the Bishop do any of those things which appertains to the Church Let that Eucharist be held right and unquestionable which is done by the Bishop or by such an one as he shall allow Where the Bishop shall appear there let the multitude assemble as where Christ is there all the heavenly hoast stands by him c. It is not lawfull without the Bishop to baptize nor to offer c. And soon after 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. Honour God as the Author and Lord of all things and your Bishop as the chief Priest bearing the image of God of God I say as chief and of Christ as Priest c. Neither is there any thing greater in the Church than the Bishop who is consecrated to God for the salvation of the world neither is there any among the Princes like to the King who procures peace and equity to his subjects c. And anone Let all your things be done in decent order in Christ Let your Laicks be subject to the Deacons Pag. 48. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 â— the Deacons to the Priests or Presbyters the Presbyters to the Bishop the Bishop to Christ as he to his Father Could he speak plainer Lo saith Vedelius and our Scotus 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 this savours not of the age of Ignatius in whose time no such distinction as of the Clergie and Laity was on foot Weakly suggested Had they but read our Clement Clem. ad Corinth in his fore-recited Epistle to the Corinthians they had soon eaten this word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 saith he to the Priests their proper place is assigned The Laickes have their services 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 A Lay-man is bound to lay Ordinances But I may not so far hinder my way as to make excursions to meet with Cavills if any man be disposed to accept I am ready to give him full satisfaction in a meet season 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 In his Epistle to Polycarpus he requires that no man should so much as marry without the Bishops consent and soon after Pag. 208. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. Let all things saith he be done to the honour of God give regard to your Bishop as God to you 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. My soul for theirs who obey their Bishop Presbyters and Deacons In his Epistle to the Ephesians magnifying their Bishop Onesimus he charges them to give all respects to him and addes Ye ought to look upon your Bishop as upon God himself since he waits upon the Lord and serves him And towards the end Following the holy Ghost for your guide obeying your Bishop and the company of Presbyters with an intire heart c. What shall we think of all this was not St. Ignatius see'd to speak on the Bishops side Or how would these words have sounded in the late Assemblies of Glasco and Edinborough Are we more holy than he Is the truth the same it was or is the alteration on our part All these have been large and full Testimonies of the acknowledged superiority of Bishops and of the high respects that are and were ever due to these prime governours of the Church But if any man think these came not yet home to the point let him cast his eye back upon the first Epistle ad Trallianos and mark well what he saith where having reckoned up the three so oft mentioned Orders of Bishops Presbyters and Deacons he addes Without these Pag. 5. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 c. there is no elect Church without these no holy Congregation no assembly of Saints And I perswade my self that you also are of the same minde Lo here words which no Vedelius can carp at as interpolated imposing such a necessity of the being of these three severall Orders in Gods Church that it cannot be right without them I see and pity his shuffling Append. Notaâ—rum Crit. but would be glad to see a satisfactory answer from any hands Epist ad P Molin In the mean time I wish with learned Bishop Andrews those Churches where they are missing that happinesse which now to our grief and I hope theirs they are forced to want I have dwelt long with blessed Ignatius where could I be better That one Author is in stead of many why should I not boldly say if besides the divine Scriptures there were no other testimony but this one Saints it were abundantly enough to carry this Cause and I must wonder at any man who confessing Ignatius to have been so holy a Bishop so faithfull a Martyr so true a Saint can stick at a Truth so often so confidently so zealously recommended by him to the world For me let my soul go with his let his faith be mine and let me rather trust one Ignatius than ten thousand Cartwrights Parkers Ameses or any other their ignorant and Male-contented followers Tell me now my dear brethren tell me in good eanest Do you not think this Ignatius a likely man to build up the kingdome of Antichrist were not these shoulders fit for the supportation of that man of sin Away with these absurd and wicked fancies and if this charge of his were holy and Apostolicall wherein he requires us to honour our Bishops as the Lord himself whom they serve and represent what doom do you suppose would he have passed upon those who as such abhorre them and eject them as Devills I cannot without horrour think of either the act or the issue §. 12. The testimony of the Ancient Canons called the Apostles YEt perhaps if Ignatius went alone he might herein incurre some suspicion now all antiquity is with him never any ancient Author said otherwise We will begin with those Canons which are instyled 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of the holy and most venerable Apostles Surely if not theirs yet of some Apostolicall men near to their times worthy even for their age and authority to be reverenced of all Christians as the most credible witnesses of the state of those Primitive times In them besides the note of professed distance betwixt the Bishops and Presbyters proclaimed in every Chapter there are those which do imply a power and Iurisdiction as Can 15. Can. 15. If any Presbyter or Deacon 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or any of the number of Clerks leaving his division or Parish shall go to another 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and without the leave or allowance of his own Bishop abide in another Parish or charge we forbid him further to Minister especially if when his own Bishop calls him back he
to give some colour and God knowes but a colour of a lay-Presbytery Let the Elders that rule well 1 Tim. 5.17 saith St. Paul to Timothy be counted worthy of all honour especially they who labour in the word and doctrine A place which hath been so throughly sifted by all who have medled with this ill-raised controversie as that no humane wit can devise to add one scruple of a notion towards a farther discussion of it I dare confidently say there is scarce any one sentence of Scripture which hath undergone a more busie and curious agitation The issue is this that never any expositor for the space of fifteene hundred yeeres after Christ tooke these aeresbyters for any other then Priests or Ministers Of eleven or twelve severall expositions of the words each one is more faire and probable than this which is newly devised and obtruded upon the Church That the text is so farre from favouring these lay-Presbyters that we need no other argument against them For where was it ever heard of or how can it be that meere Laicks should be 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Bishops and Pastors have had that stile as in Scripture so in following antiquity that passage of Clemens Alexandrinus cited by Eusebius concerning Saint Iohn that he at Ephesus committed the charge of his young man to an old Bishop whom he cals 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 besides that of Iustin Martyr already cited and others shew it plainly And if as some our appellation of Priest come from 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as it well may how can a lay-man be so Or if from Prebstre as the more think let us have Lay-priests if Lay-presbyters And what better Commentary can we have of Saint Pauls 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 than himselfe gives of himselfe in his exhortation to the Elders or Pastors at Ephesus who interprets it by carefull attending to themselves and their flocks which even their owne authours are wont to appropriate to Pastors And what can that double honour be which the Apostle claimes for these Elders or Presbyters but respect and due maintenance To whom is this due but to those that serve at the Altar As for Lay-presbyters was it ever required that they should be maintained by the Church And what can those 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 be but those Priests which diligently and painfully toile in Gods harvest in the Word and Doctrine all the Elders therefore there intended are exercised in the Word and Doctrine but there are some that doe 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 labour more abundantly than the rest these must be respected and incouraged accordingly Neither is there any reason in the world to induce an indifferent man to think that this 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 should imiplie a severall and distinct office but rather a more intense and serious labour in the same office as might be showne in a thousand instances Whereas therefore this is the onely Scripture that in some fore-prised eares seemes to sound towards a Lay-presbytery I must needs professe for my part if there were no other text in all the Booke of God more pregnant for their disproofe I should thinke this alone a very sufficient warrant for their disclamation And I doe verily perswade my selfe that those men who upon such weake yea such no-grounds have taken upon them being meer Laicks to manage these holy affaires of God have an hard answer to make one day before the Tribunall of Almighty God for this their presumptuous usurpation Now then since this one litigious and unproving text is the onely place in the whole New Testament that can beare any pretence for the lay-Presbytery for as for their Dic Ecclesiae and their 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 they are so improbable and have been so oft and throughly charmed that they are not worth either urging or answer and on the contrary so many manifest and pregnant testimonies of Scriptures have been and may be produced within the Presbyters or Elders of the Church are by the Spirit of God onely meant for the spirituall guides of his people I hope every ingenuous Christian will easily resolve how much safer it is for him to follow the cleare light of many evident Scriptures than the doubtfull glimmering of one mistaken text §. 3. Lay-Eldership a meere stranger to antiquity which acknowledgeth no Presbyters but Divines ANd as the Scriptures of God never meant to give countenance to a lay-Presbytery so neither did subsequent antiquity I speak it upon good assurance there was never any clause in any Father Councell History that did so much as intimate any such office in the Church of God or the man that weilded it The fautors of it would gladly snatch at every sentence in old records where they meet with the name of a Presbyter as if there the bels chimed to their thought But certainely for fifteene hundred yeares no man ever dreamed of such a device If he did let us know the man I am sure our Apostolicall Clemens makes a contradistinction of Laicks and Presbyters Clem. Epâ—st ad Corinth supra Ignat. Ep. ad Magn. Do nothing without your Bishop â—eithâ—r Presbyter nor Deacon nor Laick And Ignatius the holy Martyr yet more punctually goes in these degrees 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 This difference is so familiar with that Saint as that we scarce misse it in any of his Epistles in so much as Vedelius himselfe finding in the Epistle of this Martyr to the Ephesians Ignat. Epist ad Ephes 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 translates it memorabile sacerdotum vestrorum collegium a Colledge of Presbyters such the Bishops of those first times had as we have still the Deane and Chapter to consult withall upon any occasion but those Presbyters were no other than professed Divines Neither were ever otherwise construed If we looke a little lower who can but turne over any two leaves of the first Tome of the Councels and not fall upon some passage that may settle his assurance this way Those ancient Canons which carry the name of the Apostles are exceedingly frequent in the distinction They speake of the Bishops or Presbyters offering on the Altar of God which no Lay-man might do They make an act against a Bishops or Presbyters rejection of his wife Can. Apost c. 3.4.5 under pretence of Religion which in a Lay-man was never questioned c 6 7. They forbid a Bishop Presbyter or Deacon to meddle with any secular cares or imploiments A Laick person had no reason to be so restrained shortlie for we might here easilie wearie our Reader the ninth of their Canons is punctuall which playnly reckons up the Bishop Can. â— Presbyter Deacon as 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 of the Priestly list and in the foureteenth if any Presbyter or Deacon 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or whosoever else of the Clergie Dionysius the mis-named Areopagite hath 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 for Bishops and Presbyters and the holy Martyr
government sadly complaining of Antichrist and that the light of life hath lien hid under the mask of Popery until this day of love and now he coms to erect his Seniores sanctae intelligentiae Elders of the holy understanding and his other rabble Beware therefore I advise you how you take up this challenge but upon better grounds disgrace not Gods Truth with the odious name of Antichristianisme honour not Antichrist with the claime and title of an holy Truth Confesse the device new and make your best of it But if any man will pretend this governmet hath beene in the world before though no footsteps remaine of it in any history or record he may as well tell me there hath beene of old a passage from the Teneriffe to the Moone though never any but a Gonzaga discovered it §. 8. A Recapitulation of the severall heads and a vehement exhortation to all Readers and first to our Northerne brethren NOw then I beseech and adjure you my deare brethren by that love you professe to beare to the Truth of God by that tender respect you beare to the peace of his Sion by your zeale to the Gospell of Christ by your maine care of your happy account one day before the Tribunall of the most righteous Iudge of the quick and dead lay every of these things seriously together and lay all to heart And if you finde that the government of Episcopacie established in the Church is the very same which upon the foundation of Christs Institution was erected by his inspired Apostles and ever since continued unto this day without interruption without alteration If you finde that not in this part of the Western Church alone into which the Church of Rome had diffused her errours but in all the Christian world farre and wide in Churches of as large extent as the Roman ever was and never in any submission to her no other forme of government was ever dreamed of from the beginning If you finde that all the Saints of God ever since the holy Martyrs and Confessors the Fathers and Doctors both of the Primitive and ensuing Church have not onely admitted but honoured and magnified this onely government as Apostolicall If all Synods and Councels that have been in the Church of God since the Apostles time have received and acknowledged none but this alone If you finde that no one man from the dayes of the Apostles till this age ever opened his mouth against it save onely one who was for this cause amongst others branded and discarded for an heretick If you finde that the ancient Episcopacie even from Mark Bishop of Alexandria Timothy Bishop of Ephesus and Titus of Câ—ete were altogether in substance the same with ours in the same altitude of fixed superiority in the same latitude of spirituall jurisdiction if you finde the Laicke Presbytery an utter stranger to the Scriptures of God a thing altogether unheard of in the ancient times yea in all the following ages of the Church If you finde that Invention full of indeterminable uncertainties If you finde the practice of it necessarily obnoxious to unavoydable imperfections and to grosse absurdities and impossibilities Lastly if you finde the device so new that the first authours and abettors of it are easily traced to their very forme as those that lived in the dayes of thousands yet living If you finde all these as you cannot choose but finde them and many weighty considerations moe being so clearly laid before you I beseech you suffer not your selves to be led by the nose with an vnjust prejudice or an over-weening opinion of some persons whom you thinke you have cause to honour but without all respects to flesh and blood weigh the cause it self impartially in the ballance of Gods Sanctuary and judge of it accordingly Vpon my soul except the holy Scripture Apostolicall acts the practice of the ancient Church of God the judgement of all sacred Synods of all the holy Fathers and Doctors of the Church all grounds of faith reason policie may faile us we are safe and our cause victorious Why then O why will you suffer your selves to be thus impetuously carried away with the false suggestions of some mis-zealous teachers who have as I charitably judge of some of them whatsoever grounds the rest might have over run the truth in a detestation of error and have utterly lost peace in an inconsiderate chace of a fained perfection For you my Northerne brethren for such you shall be when you have done your worst if there were any foul personal faults found in any of our Church-governours as there never wanted aspersions where an extermination is intended alas why should not your wisdome charity have taught you to distinguish betwixt the calling the crime were the person vicious yet the function is holy why should God his cause be stricken because man hath offended yet to this day no offence proved Your Church hath been anciently famous for an holy and memorable Prelacie and though it did more lately fall upon the division of Dioeceses D. Henr. Spelman ex Hectore Boetio Anno 840. so as every Bishop did in every place as opportunity offered executo Episcopall offices which kinde of Administration continued in your Church till the times of Malcolme the third yet this government over the whole Clergie was no lesse acknowledged than their sanctimony after the setling of those your Episcopall Sees it is worth your note and our wonder which your Hector Boetius writes Sacer Pontificatus Sancti Andreae tanta reverentia c. The Bishoprick of St. Andrewes was with so great reverence and innocence of life from the first institution of it in a long line of Episcopall succession continued to the very time wherein we wrote this That six and thirty and more of the Bishops of that See were accounted for Saints Good Lord How are either the times altered or we There may be differences of carriage and those that are Oxthodoxe in judgement may be faulty in demeanour But I grieve and feare to speak it There is now so little danger of a Calender that no holinesse of life could excuse the best Bishop from being ejected like an evill spirit out of the bosome of that Church Deus omen c. In the name of God what is it what can it be that is thus stood upon Is it the very name of Episcopacie which like that of Tarquin in Rome is condemned to a perpetuall disuse What hath the innocent word offended Your own Church after the Reformation could well be contented to admit of Superintendents and what difference is here as Zanchius well but that good Greek is turn'd into ill Latin 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Superintendens Their power by your owne allowance and enacting is the same with your Bishops Their Dioeceses accordingly divided their residence fixed viz. The Superintendent of Orkney his Dioecesse shall be the Isles of Orkney Catnesse and Strathnever his Residence
in the town of Kirkwall The Superintendent of Rosse his Dioecesse shall comprehend Rosse Sutherland Murray and the North Isles called the Skye and Lewes with their adjacents his residence shal be the Canonry of Rosse The Superintendent of Argile his Dioecesse shall be Argile Kintire Lorne the South Isles Argile and Boot with their adjacents his residence is at Argile The like of the Superintendent of Aberdene the Superintendent of Breckin the Superintendent of Fiffe the Superintendent of Edinburgh the Superintendent of Iedburgh the Superintendent of Glasgow the Superintendent of Dumfreys all of them bounded with their severall jurisdictions which who desires to know particularly may have recourse to the learned Discourse of D Lindsey then Bishop of Brechen concerning the proceedings of the Synod of Perth Where he shall also finde the particularities of the function and power of these Superintendents Amongst the rest these That they have power to plant and erect Churches to set order and appoint Ministers in their Countreys That after they have remained in their chiefe townes three or foure moneths they shall enter into their Visitation in which they shall not onely preach but examine the life diligence and behaviour of the Ministers as also they shall trie the estate of their Churches and manners of the people They must consider how the poore are provided and the youth instructed they must admonish where admonitions need and redresse such things as they are able to appease They must note such crimes as are hainous that by the censures of the Church the same may be corrected And now what main difference I beseech you can you finde betwixt the office of these Superintendents and the present Bishops How comes it then about that the wind is thus changed That those Church-governours which your owne reformers with full consent allowed and set downe an Order for their Election in your Constitutions before the Book of Psalms in Meeter should now be cashiered There and then M. Knox himselfe whose name you professe to honour by the publike authority of the Church conceives publike prayer for M. Iohn Spotteswood then admitted Superintendent of Lothian in these words O Lord send upon this our Brother unto whom we doe in thy name commit the chiefe charge of the Churches of the division of Lothian such a portion of thy holy Spirit as that c. And in the name of the Church blesseth his new Superintendent thus God that hath called thee to the office of a watchman over his people multiply the gifts of his grace in thee c. Now I beseech you how is this Superintendency lost That which was then both lawfull and usefull and confessed for no other then a calling from God is it now become sinfull and odious Are we become so much wiser and more zealous than our first reformers as there is distance betwixt a Superintendent and no Bishop But what is it the stroake the Bishops have in government and their seat in Parliament which is so great an eye-sore Let me put you in mind that your greatest patrons of your desired Discipline have strongly motioned an Ecclesiasticall Commission for the over-looking and over-ruling your Consistories and even when they would have Bishops excluded both out of those Comitiall Sessions Moved also to the Lords of the Counsell in Q Eliz. time by the humble Mot. and out of the Church yet have moved such was Beza's device long since for Scotland That in the place of Bishops there might be present in the Parliament-house some wise and grave Ministers of speciall gifts and learning sorted out of all the land to yeeld their Counsell according to Gods heavenly Law even as the Civill Iudges are ready to give their advice according to the temporall Law and for matters of greater difficulty What a world is this Grave and wise Ministers and yet no Bishops Doth our Episcopacie either abolish our Ministery or detract ought from wisdome and gravity Away with this absurd partiality But these must be to advise not to vote in any case beware of that where then is the third estate Beza's Counsell we see is yet alive but it comes not home to the purpose Welfare that bold Supplicator to Q. Elizabeth which moved that foure and twenty Doctors of Divinity to be called by such names as should please her Highnesse might be admitted into the Parliament House and have their voices there instead of the Bishops O impotent envie of poore humorists Doctors but no Bishops Any men any names but theirs the old word is Love creepes where it cannot goe How much are we beholden to these kinde friends who are so desirous to ease us of these unproper secularities Even ours at home can nibble at these as they think ill-placed honours and services yours goe alas too roundly to worke striking at the root of their Episcopacie not pruning off some superfluous twigs of priviledge rather than not strike home not caring whom they hit in the way would God I might not say even the Lords Anointed whom they verbally professe to honour at whose sacred Crowne and Scepter if any of the sons of Belial amongst you do secretly aime whiles they stalke under the pretence of opposition to Episcopacie the God of heaven find them out and powre upon them deserved confusion But for you alas Brethren what hopes can I conceive that these pre-judged papers can have any accesse to your eyes much lesse to your hearts my very Title is barre too much But if any of you will have so much patience as to admit these lines to your perusall I shall beseech him for Gods sake and for his own to be so farre indifferent also as not upon groundlesse suggestion to abandon Gods Truth and Ordinance and out of meere opinion of the worth of some late Authour to adore an Idoll made of the earings of the people and fashioned out with the graving toole of a supposed skilfull Aaron Shortly after these poore well-meant howsoever I doubt ineffectuall endeavours my prayers shall not be wanting for your comfortable peace loyall obedience perfect happinesse Oh that the God of heaven would open your eyes that you may see the truth and compare what you have done with what you should doe how soone would you finde cause to retract your own decrees and to re-establish that true Ordinance of the living God which you have beene mis-induced to abandon §. 9. An exhortary conclusion to our brethren at home ANd for you my dearely beloved Brethren at home For Christs sake for the Churches sake for your soules sake be exhorted to hold fast to this holy Institution of your blessed Saviour and his unerring Apostles and blesse God for Episcopacie Doe but cast your eyes a little back and see what noble instruments of Gods glory he hath beene pleased to raise up in this very Church of ours out of this sacred vocation What famous servants of God what strong Champions of Truth and renowned Antagonists of Rome and her superstitions what admirable Preachers what incomparable Writers yea what constant and undaunted Martyrs and Confessours men that gave their blood for the Gospell and imbraced their fagots flaming which many gregarie Professours held enough to carry cold and painlesse To the wonder and gratulation of all forraigne Churches and to the unparallelable glory of this Church and Nation I could fill this page with such a Catalogue of them who are now in their heaven that come for the present to my thoughts besides those Worthies yet living both here and in Ireland who would be unwilling from my pen tO blush at their owne just praises as might justly shame and silence any gaine-sayer After that a malicious Libeller hath spit out all his poyson against Episcopacie and raked together out of all histories all the insolencies and ill offices which have in former ages been done by professedly Popish Prelates which do almost as much concerne us as all the Treasons and Murders of formerly male-contented persons can concerne him faine would I have him shew me what Christian Church under heaven hath in so short a time yeelded so many glorious Lights of the Gospell so many able and prevalent adversaries of Schisme and Antichristianisme so many eminent Authours of learned workes which shall out-bid time it selfe let envie grinde her teeth and eat her heart the memory of these worthy Prelates shall be ever sweet and blessed Neither doubt I but that it will please God out of the same rod of Aaron still to raise such blossomes and fruit as shall win him glory to all eternity Go you on to honour these your reverend Pastors to hate all factious withdrawings from that government which comes the nearest of any Church upon earth to the Apostolicall And that I may draw to Conclusion for the farther Confirmation of your good Opinion of the Bishops of your Great Britaine heare what Iacobus Lectius Iacob Lectius Prascriptionum Theologicarum l. 2. Nota. 2. the learned Civilian of Geneva in his Theologicall Prescriptions dedicated to the Consuls and Senate of Geneva saith of them De Episcoporum autem vestorum vocatione c. As for the calling of your Bishops saith he speaking to his Popish adversaries others have accurately written thereof and we shortly say that they have a show of an Ordinary Ministery but not the thing it selfe and that those onely are to be held for true and legitimate which Paul describes to us in his Epistles to Timothy and Titus Cujusmodi olim in magno illo Britanniarum regno extitisse atque etiamnum superesse subindeque eligi Episcopos non diffitemur Such kind of Bishops as we doe not deny but yeeld to have been of old and to be still at this day successively elected in the great Kingdome of Britaine Thus he when Geneva it selfe pleades for us why should we be our owne adversaries Let me therefore confidently shut up all with that resolute word of that blessed Martyr and Saint Ignatius 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 Let all things be done to the honour of God Give respect to your Bishop as you would God should respect you My soule for theirs which obey their Bishop Presbyters Deacons God grant that my portion may be the same with theirs And let my soule have the same share with that blessed Martyr that said so Amen FINIS