3. This therefore is that which he opposeth namely that there was a Deviation in various degrees and falling of from the Original Institution Order and Rule of the Church until it issued in a fatal Apostasie This is that which on the present Occasion must be further spoken unto For if this be not true I confess there is an end of this contest and we must all acquiesce in the State Rule and Order that was in the Church of Rome before the Reformation But we may observe something yet farther in the Vindication and Confirmation of this Truth which I acknowledge to be the Foundation of all that we plead for in point of Church Reformation As 1. That the Reasons and Arguings of the Doctor in this Matter the Necessity of his Cause compelling him thereunto are the same with those of the Papists about the Apostacy of their Church in Faith Order and Worship wherewith they are charged namely when where how was this Alteration made who made opposition unto it and the like When these Enquiries are multiplyed by the Papists as unto the whole Causes between them and us he knows well enough how to give satisfactory Answers unto them and so might do in this particular unto himself also but I shall endeavour to ease him of that trouble at present Only I must say that it is fallen out somewhat unexpectedly that the Ruins of the principle Bulwark of the Papacy which hath been effectually demolished by the Writings of Protestants of all sorts should be endeavoured to be repaired by a Person justly made eminent by his Defence of the Protestant Religion against those of the Church of Rome 2. But it may be pleaded that although the Churches following the first Ages did insensibly degenerate from the Purity and simplicity of Gospel Faith and Worship yet they neither did nor could do so from an Adherence unto and abiding in their Original constitution or from the due Observation of Church Order Rule and Discipline least of all could this happen in the Case of Diocesan Episcopacy I Answer 1. That as unto the Original of any thing that looks like Diocesan Episcopacy or the Pastoral Relation of one Person of a distinct order from Presbiters unto many particular compleat Churches with Officers of their own with Power and Jurisdiction in them and over them unto the Abridgement of the exercise of that Right and Power unto their own Edification which every true Church is entrusted withal by Jesus Christ it is very uncertain and was introduced by insensible Degrees according unto the effectual working of the Mistery of Iniquity Some say that there were two distinct Orders namely those of Bishops and Presbyters instituted at first in all Churches planted by the Apostles But as the contrary may be evidently proved so a supposition of it would no way promote the cause of Diocesan Episcopacy until those who plead for it have demonstrated the State of the Churches wherein they were placed to be of the same nature with those now called Diocesan Wherefore this Hypothesis begins generally to be deserted as it seems to be by this Author Others suppose that immediately upon or at or after the Decease of the Apostles this new Order of Bishops was appointed to succeed the Apostles in the Government of the Churches that were then gathered or planted But how when or by whom by what Authority Apostolical and Divine or Ecclesiastical only and humane none can declare seeing there is not the least footstep of any such thing either in the Scripture or in the Records that remain of the primitive Churches Others think this new Order of Officers took its occasional Rise from the Practice of the Presbyters of the Church at Alexandria who chose out one among themselves constantly to preside in the Rule of the Church and in all matters of Order unto whom they ascribed some kind of Preheminence and Dignity peculiarly appropriating unto him the namâ— of Bishop And if this be true as unto matter of Fact I reckon it unto the Beginnings of those less harmful Deviations from their Original Constitution which I assigned unto Primitive Churches But many Additions must be made hereunto before it will help the Cause of Diocesan Episcopacy What other occasions hereof were given or taken what Advantages were made use of to promote this Alteration shall be touched upon afterwards 2. Why may not the Churches be supposed to have departed from their original Constitution Order and Rule as well as from their first Faith and Worship which they did gradually in many successive Ages until both were utterly corrupted The Causes Occasions and Temptations leading unto the former are to the full as pregnant as those leading unto the latter For 1. There was no vicious corrupt disposition of Mind that began more early to work in Church Officers nor did more grow and thrive in the Minds of many then Ambition with desire of Preheminence Dignity and Rule It is not to be supposed that Diotrephes was alone in his Desire of â—reheminence nor in the irregular actings of his unduly â—ssumed Authority However we have one signal Instance in him of the Deviation that was in the Church with him from the Rule of its Original Constitution For he prevailed so far therein as by his own single Episcopal Power to reject the Authority of the Apostles and to cast them out of the Church who complyed not with his humour How effectually the same Ambition wrought afterwards in many others possessing the same Place in their Churches with Diotrephes is sufficiently evident in all Ecclesiastical Histories It is far from being the only Instance of the Corruption of Church Order and Rule by the Influence of this Ambition yet it is one that is pregnant which is given us by Amâ—rose for saith he Ecclesia ut Synagoga Seniores habuâ—â— quorum sine consilio nihil agebatur in Ecclesia quod qua neglâ—gentia obsoleverit nescio nisi forte doctorum desidia aut magis superbia dum soli volunt aliquid videri In 1. ad Timoth. cap. 5. It seems there was some alteration in Church Rule and Order in his Time whose Beginning and Progress he could not well discover and trace but knew well enough that so it was then come to pass And if he who lived so near the Times wherein such Alterations were made could not yet discover their first Insinuation nor their subtle Progress it is unreasonable to exact a strict account of us in things of the same nature who live so many Ages after their first Introduction But this he judgeth that it was the Pride or Ambition of the Doctors of the Church which introduced that Alteration in its Order Whereas therefore we see in the Event that all Deviations from the Original Constitution of Churches all Alterations in their Rule and Order did issue in a compliance with the Ambition of Church Rulers as it did in the Papal Church and this Ambition was signally noted
are made Members of this Church by an Act of Parliament for their Naturalization and no otherwise 3. That we separate from this Church in things wherein we are obliged by the Authority of Christ to hold communion with it which neither is nor will ever be proved nor is it endeavoured so to be by any Instances in this Treatise 4. That to with-hold Communion from Parochial Assemblies in the Worship of God as unto things confessedly not of Divine Institution is Schisme that kind of Schisme which is condemned by the Antient Writers of the Church Upon these and the like suppositions it is no uneasie thing to make vehement Declamations against us and severe Reflections on us all is Schisme and Schismaticks and all of the same kind with what was written against by Cyprian and Austin and others a great many But the true state of the Controversie between him and us is this and no other namely Whether a Dissent in and Forbearance from the Communion of Churches in their state and kind not of Divine Institution or so far as they are not of Divine Institution and from Things in other Churches that have no such Divine Institution nor any Scriptural Authority to oblige us unto their Observance be to be esteemed Schisme in them who maintain and professedly avow Communion in Faith and Love with all the true Churches of Christ in the World This is the whole of what we are concerned in which where it is spoken unto it shall be considered But because there were in the Primitive Churches certain Persons who on Arbitrary Principles of their own consisting for the most part in gross and palpable Errors which they would have imposed on all others did separate from the Catholick Church that is all other Christians in the World and all the Churches of Christ condemning them as no Churches allowing not the Administration of Sacraments unto them nor Salvation unto their Members whom the Antient Church condemned with great severity and that justly as guilty of Schisme their Judgment their Words and Expressions are applyed unto us who are no way concerned in what they speak of or unto We are not therefore in the least terrified with what is alledged out of the Antients about Schisme no more then he is when the same Instances the same Authorities the same Quotations are made use of by the Papists against the Church of England as they are continually For as was said we know that we are no way concerned in them And suppose that all that the Dr. alledgeth against us be true and that we are in the wrong in all that is Charged on us yet I dare refer it to the Dr. himself to determine whether it be of the same nature with what was Charged on them who made Schismes in the Church of old I suppose I guess well enough what he will say to secure his Charge and it shall be considered where it is spoken But as was said the great and only Design of the Author of this Book is to prove all Non-conformists to be Schismaticks or guilty of the Sin of Schisme How he hath succeeded in this Attempt shall be afterwards considered And something I have spoken in the ensuing Discourse concerning the Nature of Schisme which will manifest how little we are concerned in this Charge But yet it may not be amiss in this place to mind both him and others of some of those Principles whereon we ground our Justification in this Matter that it may be known what they must further overthrow and what they must establish who shall persist in the Mannagement of this Charge that is indeed through want of Love in a design to heighten and perpetuate our Divisions And The first of these Principles is That there is a Rule prescribed by our Lord Jesus Christ unto all Churches and Believers in a due Attendance whereunto all the Vnity and Peace which he requireth amongst his Disciples do consist We acknowledge this to be our Fundamental Principle Nor can the Rhetorick or Arguments of any man affect our Consciences with a sense of the Guilt of Schism until one of these things be proved namely Either First That the Lord Christ hath given no such Rule as in the Observance whereof Peace and Unity may be preserved in his Church Or Secondly That we refuse a compliance with that Rule in some one Instance or other of what therein he hath himself appointed Unless one or the other be proved and that strictly and directly not pretended so to be by perpetual Diversions from the things in Question no vehement Assertions of any of us to be Schismaticks nor Aggravations of the Guilt of Schisme will signifie any thing in this Cause But that our Principle herein is according unto Truth we are fully perswaded There is a Rule of Christs giving which whosoever walk according unto Peace shall be on them and Mercy as on the whole Israel of God Gal. 6.16 And we desire no more no more is needful unto the Peace and Unity of the Church And this Rule whatever it be is of his giving and Appointment No Rule of Mens Invention or Imposition can by its Observance secure us of an Interest in that Peace and Mercy which is peculiar unto the Israel of God God forbid we should entertain any such Imagination We know well enough men may be through Conformists to such Rules unto whom as unto their present state and condition neither Peace nor Mercy do belong For there is no Peace to the Wicked He who hath directed and commanded the end of Church Unity and Peace hath also appointed the Meanes and Measures of them Nothing is more disagreeable unto Nothing more inconsistent with the Wisdom Care and Love of Christ unto his Church than an Imagination that whereas he strictly enjoynes Peace and Unity in his Church he hath not himself appointed the Rules Bounds and Measures of them but left it unto the Will and Discretion of Men. As if his Command unto his Disciples had been Keep Peace and Vnity in the Church by doing and observing whatever some men under a Pretence of being the Guides of the Church shall make necessary unto that End Whereas it is plainly otherwise namely that we should so keep the Peace and Unity of the Church by doing and observing all whatever that he commands us And besides we strictly require that some one Instance be given us of a Defect in the Rule given by Christ himself which must be supplyed by humane Additions to render it compleat for the End of Church Peace and Unity In vain have we desired in vain may we for ever expect any Instance of that kind This Principle we shall not be easily dispossessed of And whilst we are under the Protection of it we have a safe Retreat and shelter from the most vehement Accusations of Schisme for a Non-compliance with a Rule none of his different from his and in some things contrary unto his for the
Heaven as a Divine Institution But I have treated of this subject in other Discourses 2. The Name Pretence and presumed power of the Church or Churches have been made and used as the greatest Engine for the promoting and satisfying the Avarice Sensuality Ambition and cruelty of men that ever was in the world Never any thing was found out by men or Sathan himself so fitted suited and framed to fill and satisfie the lusts of multitudes of men as this of the Church hath been and yet continues to be For it is so ordered is of that make constitution and use that corrupt men need desire no more for the attainment of Wealth Honour Grandeur Pleasure all the ends of their Lusts spiritual or carnal but a share in the Government and power of the Church nor hath an interest therein been generally used unto any other ends All the Pride and Ambition all the flagitious lives in Luxury Sensuality Uncleanness Incests c. of Popes Cardinals Prelates and their Companions with their hatred unto and oppression of Good men arose from the advantage of their being reputed the Church To this very day the Church here and there as it is esteemed is the greatest means of keeping Christian Religion in its power and purity out of the world and a temptation to multitudes of men to prefer the Church before Religion and to be obstinate in their oppositions unto it These things being plain and evident unto wise men who had no share in the conspiracy nor the benefit of it how could they think that this Church-State was from Heaven and not of Men. 3. By the Church so esteemed and in pursuit of its Interests by its Authority and Power innumerable multitudes of Christians have been slain or murdered and the earth soked with their Blood Two Emperours of Germany alone fought above eighty battels for and against the pretended power and authority of the Church It hath laid whole Countreys desolate with fire and sword turning Cities into ashes and Villages into a wilderness by the destruction of their Inhabitants It was the Church which killed murthered and burnt innumerable holy Persons for no other reason in the world but because they would not submit their Souls Consciences and Practices unto her commands and be subject unto her in all things Nor was there any other Church conspicuously visible in all these parts of the world nor was it esteemed lawful once to think that this was not the true Church or that there was or could be any other For men to believe that this Church-State was from Heaven is for them to believe that cruelty bloodshed murther the destruction of mankind especially of the best the wisest and the most holy among them is the only way to Heaven 4. The secular worldly interest of multitudes lying in this presumptive Church and the state of it they preferred and exalted it above all that is called God and made the greatest Idol of it that ever was in the world For it was the faith and profession of it that its authority over the Souls and Consciences of men is above the Authority of the Scripture so that they have no Authority towards us unless it be given unto them by this Church and that we neither can nor need believe them to be the Word of God unless they inform us and command us so to do This usurpation of Divine Honour in putting itself and its Authority above that of the Scripture or Word of God discovers full well whence it was In like manner those who assumed it unto themselves to be the Church without any other Right Title or Pretence unto it have exalted one amongst them and with him themselves in their several capacities above all Emperors Kings and Princes Nations and People trampling on them at their pleasure Is this Church-State from Heaven Is it of Divine Institution Is it the heart and center of Christian Religion Is it that which all men must be subject to on pain of eternal damnation who that knows any thing of Christ or the Gospel can entertain such a thought without detestation and abhorrency 5. This Pretence of the Church is at this day one of the greatest causes of the Atheism that the world is filled withal Men find themselves they know not how to belong unto this or that Church they suppose that all the Religion that is required of them is no more but what this Church suggests unto them and abhorring through innumerable prejudices to enquire whether there be any other ministerial Church-State or no understanding at length the Church to be a political combination for the Wealth Power and Dignity of some persons they cast away all regard of Religion and become professed Atheists 6. Unto this very day the woful Divisions Distractions and end less Controversies that are among Christians with the dangerous Consequences and effects of them do all spring and arise from the Churches that are in the World Some are for the Church of Rome some for the Church of England some for the Greek Church and so of the rest which upon an acknowledgment of such a state of them as is usually allowed cannot but produce Wars and Tumults among Nations with the oppression of particular persons in all sorts of calamities In one place men are killed for not owning of one Church and in another for approving of it Amongst our selves prisons are filled and mens goods spoiled divisions multiplied and the whole Nation endangered in a severe attempt to cause all Christians to acknowledge that Church-State which is set up among us In brief these Churches in the great Instance of that of Rome have been and are the Scandal of Christian Religion and the greatest cause of most of the evils and villanies which the world hath been replenished withal And is it any wonder if men question whether they are from Heaven or of Men For my part I look upon it as one of the greatest mercies that God hath bestowed on any professed Christians in these latter Ages that he hath by the Light and knowledge of his Word disentangled the Souls and Consciences of any that do believe from all Respect and Trust unto such Churches discovering the vanity of their pretences and wickedness of their practices whereby they openly proclaim themselves to be of Men and not from Heaven Not that he hath led them off from a Church-State thereby but by the same word revealed that to them which is pure simple humble holy and so far from giving occasion unto any of the evils mentioned as that the admittance of it will put an immediate end unto them all Such shall we find the true and Gospel Church-State to be in the following Description of it He that comes out of the Confusion and Disorder of these humane and as unto some of them hellish Churches who is delivered from this mystery of iniquity in darkness and confusion policies and secular contrivances coming thereon to obtain a view of
any others that he was pleased to make use of therein For as he took it on himself as his own work to build his Church and that upon himself as its foundation so he employed his Apostles to act under him and from him in the carrying on that work unto perfection But what was done by them is esteemed to be done all by himself For 1 It was immediately from him that they received Revelations of what did belong unto this Church-State and what was to be prescribed therein They never did neither jointly nor severally once endeavour in their own Wisdom or from their own Invention or by their own Authority to add or put into this Church-State as of perpetual Use and belonging unto it as such either less or more any one thing greater or less whatever It is true they gave their Advice in sundry cases of present Emergencies in and about Church Affairs They gave direction for the due and orderly Practice of what was revealed unto them and exercised Authority both as unto the Ordination of Officers and the Rejection of obstinate sinners from the Society of all the Churches but to Invent Contrive Institute or Appoint any thing in the Church and its State which they had not by immediate Revelation from Christ they never attempted it nor went about it And unto this Rule of proceeding they were precisely obliged by the express words of their Commission Mat 28.19 20. This I say is so plainly included in the Tenor of their Commission and so evident from all that is divinely recorded of their Practice that it will admit of no sober Contradiction In what others think it meet to do in this kind we are not concerned 2 The Authority whereby they acted in the Institution of the Church in its Order whereon the Consciences of all Believers were obliged to submit thereunto and to comply with it in a way of Obedience was the Authority of Christ himself acted in them and by them They every where disclaim any such Power and Authority in themselves They pleaded that they were only Stewards and Ministers not Lords of the Faith or Obedience of the Church but helpers of its Joy yea the Servants of all the Churches for Christ's sake And hereon it follows that what is recorded of their Practice in their Institution ordering or disposing of any thing in the Church that was to be of an abiding continuance hath in it the obliging Power of the Authority of Christ himself Wherefore if the distinction that some make concerning the Apostles namely that they are to be considered as Apostles or as Church-Governours should be allowed as it is liable to just exceptions yet would no Advantage accrew thereby unto what is pretended from it For as what they did appointed and ordered in the Church for its constant observation as Apostles they did it by immediate Revelation from Christ and in his Name and Authority so what in distinction from hence as Church Governours they did or ordered they did it only by a due Application unto present occasions of what they had received by Revelation But as they were Apostles Christ sent them as his Father sent him and he was so sent of the Father as that he did stand and feed in the Strength of the Lord in the Majesty of the Name of the Lord his God Micah 5.4 So did they feed the Sheep of Christ in his Strength and in the Authority or Majesty of his Name 5. Christ therefore alone is the Author of the Gospel-Church-State And because this is the only Foundation of our Faith and Obedience as unto all that we are to believe do and practise by vertue of that Church-State or in Order thereunto the Scripture doth not only plainly affirm it but also declares the Grounds of it why it must be so and whence it is so as also wherein his doing of it doth consist 1. Three things amongst others are eminently necessary in and unto him who is to constitute this Church State with all that belongs thereunto And as the Scripture doth eminently and expresly ascribe them all unto Christ so no man nor all the men of the World can have any such Interest in them as to render them meet for this work or any part of it The first of these is Right and Title He who institutes this Church-State must have Right and Title to dispose of all men in all their Spiritual and Eternal Concernments as seemeth Good unto him For unto this Church-State namely as it is purely Evangelical no man is obliged by the Law of Nature nor hath any Creature power to dispose of him into a condition whereon all his Concernments Spiritual and Eternal shall depend This Right and Title to the Sovereign Disposal of Mankind or of his Church Christ hath alone and that upon a treble account 1 Of Donation from the Father He appointed him the Heir of all things Heb. 1.2 3. He gave him Power over all Flesh. Joh. 17.2 Especially he hath given unto him and put into his absolute disposal all those who are to be his Church ver 6. 2 By vertue of Purchase he hath by the price of his most precious Blood purchased them unto his own Power and Disposal He purchased his Church with his own Blood Act. 20.28 which the Apostle makes the Ground of that care which ought to be had of it And this is pleaded as a sufficient Reason why we should be wholly at his Disposal only and be free from any Imposition of men in things Spiritual 1 Cor. 7.23 Ye are bought with a Price be ye not the Servants of men The Purchase of this Right and Title was one great end of the principal Mediatory Acts of Christ. Rom. 14.9 10. For to this end c. 3 Of Conquest For all those who were thus to be disposed by him were both under the Power of his Enemies and were themselves Enemies unto him in their Minds He could not therefore have a Sovereign Right unto their Disposal but by a double Conquest namely first of their Enemies by his Power and then of themselves by his Word his Spirit and his Grace And this twofold Conquest of his is fully described in the Scripture Whereas therefore there is a Disposal of the Persons that are to belong unto this Church-State as unto their Souls Consciences and all the eternal Concernments of them by an indispensible Moral Obligation to a compliance therewithal until men can manifest that they have such a Right and Title over others and that either by the especial Grant and Donation of God the Father or a Purchase that they have made of them unto themselves or Conquest they are not to be esteemed to have either Right or Title to institute any thing that belongs unto this Church-State And it is in vain pretended as we shall see more afterwards that Christ indeed hath appointed this Church-State in general but that he hath appointed no particular Form of Churches or
and Priviledges by vertue of the Law of Christ. Unto this Church which is his Spouse doth the Lord Christ commit the Keys of his House by whom they are delivered into the hands of his Stewards so far as their Office requires that Trust. Now this which we shall afterwards more fully confirm is utterly inconsistent with the committing of all Church Power unto one Person by vertue of his Ordination by another Nothing that hath been spoken doth at all hinder or deny but that where Churches are rightly constituted they ought in their Offices Officers and Order to be preserved by a successive Ordination of Pastors and Rulers wherein those who actually preside in them have a particular Interest in the orderly communication of Church-Power unto them CHAP. IV. The Especial Nature of the Gospel Church-State appointed by Christ. THE Principal Enquiry which we have thus far prepared the way unto and whereon all that ensues unto it doth depend is concerning the especial Nature of that Church-State Rule and Order which the Lord Christ hath Instituted under the Gospel of what sort and kind it is And hereunto some things must be premised 1. I design not here to oppose nor any way to consider such Additions as men may have judged necessary to be added unto that Church-State which Christ hath appointed to render it in their apprehension more useful unto its ends than otherwise it would be Of this sort there are many things in the World and of a long season have been so But our present Business is to prove the Truth and not to disprove the conceits of other men And so far as our Cause is concerned herein it shall be done by it self so as not to interrupt us in the declaration of the Truth 2. Whereas there are great contests about Communion with Churches or Separation from them and mutual charges of Impositions and Schisms thereon they must be all regulated by this Enquiry namely what is that Church State which Christ hath prescribed Herein alone is Conscience concerned as unto all Duties of Ecclesiastical Communion Neither can a chaâ—ge of Schism be managed against any but on a supposition of Sin with respect unto that Church-State and Order which Christ hath appointed A Dissent from any thing else however pretended to be useful yea advantageous unto Church Ends must come under other prudential considerations All which shall be fully proved and vindicated from the exceptions of Dr. St. 3. There have been and are in the World several sorts of Churches of great Power and Reputation of several Forms and Kinds yet contributing Aid to each other in their respective stations As 1 The Papal Church which pretends it self to be Catholick or Universal comprehensive of all true Believers or Disciples of Christ united in their Subjection unto the Bishop of Rome 2 There were of old and the shadow of them is still remaining Churches called Patriarchal first 3 then 4 then 5 of them whereinto all other Churches and professed Christians in the Roman World were distributed as unto a Dependance on the Authority and Subjection to the Jurisdiction and Order of the Bishops of 5 principal Cities of the Empire who were thereon called Patriarks 3 Various Divisions under them of Archiepiscopal or Metropolitical Churches and under them of those that are now called Diocesan whose bounds and limits were fixed and altered according to the Variety of Occasions and Occurrences of things in the Nations of the World What hath been the Original of all these sorts of Churches how from Parochial Assemblies they grew up by the Degrees of their Descent now mentioned into the height and center of Papal Omnipotency hath been declared elsewhere sufficiently 4. Some there are who plead for a National Church-State arising from an Association of the Officers of particular Churches in several Degrees which they call Classical and Provincial until it extend it self unto the limits of an whole Nation that is one civil Body depending as such on its own supreme Ruler and Law I shall neither examine nor oppose this Opinion there hath been enough if not too much already disputed about it But 5. The visible Church-State which Christ hath instituted under the New Testament consists in an especial Society or Congregation of professed Believers joyned together according unto his Mind with their Officers Guides or Rulers whom he hath appointed which do or may meet together for the celebration of all the Ordinances of Divine Worship the professing and authoritatively proposing the Doctrine of the Gospel with the Exercise of the Discipline prescribed by himself unto their own mutual Edification with the Glory of Christ in the Preservation and Propagation of his Kingdom in the World The things observable in this Description and for the farther Declaration of it are 1 The Material cause of this Church or the Matter whereof it is composed which are visible Believers 2 The formal Cause of it which is their voluntary Coalescency into such a Society or Congregation according to the mind of Christ. 3 The End of it is presential local Communion in all the Ordinances and Institutions of Christ in Obedience unto him and their own Edification 4 In particular these ends are 1 The Preaching of the Word unto the Edification of the Church it self and the Conversion of others 2 Administration of the Sacraments or all the Mystical Appointments of Christ in the Church 3 The Preservation and Exercise of Evangelical Discipline 4 Visibly to profess their Subjection unto Christ in the World by the observation of his commands 5 The Bounds and Limits of this Church are taken from the number of the Members which ought not to be so Small as that they cannot observe and do all that Christ hath commanded in due Order nor yet so Great as not to meet together for the Ends of Institution of the Church before mentioned 6 That this Church in its compleat State consists of Pastors or a Pastor and Elders who are its Guides and Rulers and the Community of the Faithful under their Rule 7 That unto such a Church and every one of them belongs of Right all the Priviledges Promises and Power that Christ doth give and grant unto the Church in this World These and sundry other things of the like Nature shall be afterwards spoken unto in their Order according unto the Method intended in the present Discourse Two things I shall now proceed unto 1 To prove that Christ hath appointed this Church-State under the Gospel namely of a particular or single Congregation 2 That he hath appointed no other Church State that is inconsistent with this much less that is destructive of it 1. Christ appointed that Church-State which is meet and accommodated unto all the ends which he designed in his Institution of a Church But such alone is that Church Form and Order that we have proposed In Christs Institution of the Church it was none of his ends that some men might be thereby advanced to
not or is neglected It is therefore fond to suppose that our Saviour should prescribe this Rule for that season wherein there was no need of it and not for those times wherein the Church could not subsist in order without it 3ly The Church here directed unto is a Christian Church For 1. whereas it hath been proved it concerned the times to come afterwards there was in those times nothing that could pretend unto the name of the Church but a Christian Church only The Jewish Synagogues had an utter end put unto them so as that an Address unto any of them in this case was not only useless but unlawful And as unto Magistrates or Arbitrators to have them called the Church and that in such a sense as that after the Interposition of their Authority or Advice a man should be freed from the discharge of all Christian Duties such as are mutually required among the Disciples of Christ towards his Brother is a fond Imagination For 2 It is such a Church as can exercise Authority in the Name of Christ over his Disciples and such as in Conscience they should be bound to submit themselves unto For the Reason given of the Contempt of the Voice Judgment and Sentence of the Church in case of offence is their Power of spiritual binding and looâ—ing which is comitted by Christ thereunto and so he adds immediatley ver 18. Whatever ye shall bind on Earth shall be bound in Heaven and whatsoever ye shall loose in heaven shall be loosed on earth is the Priviledge of a Christian Church only 4thly It is a visible particular Congregation alone that is intended For 1. As unto the Church in other acceptations of that name either for the Catholicâ— invisible Church or for the whole Body of professed Believers thoroughout the world it is utterly impossible that this Dâ—ty should be observed towards it as is manifest unto all 2. We have proved that the first and most proper signification of the word is of a single congregation assembling together for its Duties and Enjoyments Where ever therefore the Church in general is mentioned without the Addition of any thing or circumstance that may lead unto another signification it must be interpreted of such a Particular Church or Congregation 3. The Persons intended offending and offended must belong unto the same society unto whom the Address is to be made or else the one party may justly decline the Judicatory applyed unto and so frustrate the Process And it must be such a Church as unto whom they are known in their Circumstances without which it is impossible that a right judgment in sundry cases can be made in point of Offence 4 It is a Church of an easie Address Go tell the Church which supposeth that free and immediate aâ—cess which all the Members of a Church have unto that whole Church whereof they are members Wherefore 5 It is said 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 tell the Church not a Church but the Church namely whereunto thou and thy Brother do belong 6 One end of this Direction is that the offending and the offended parties may continue together in the Communion of the same Church in Love without Dissimulation which thing belongs unto a particular Congregation 7 The meaning is not tell the Diocesan Bishop for whatever Church he may have under his Rule yet is not he himself a Church Nor is it 8 the Chancellours Court that our Saviour intended Be it what it will it is a disparagement unto all Churches to have that name applied thereunto Nor Lastly Is it a Presbytery or Association of the Elders of many particular Congregations that is intended For the Power claimed in such associated Presbyteries is with respect unto what is already in or before particular Congregations which they have not either Wisdom or Authority as is supposed finally to order and determine But this supposeth that the Address in the first place be made unto a particular Congregation which therefore is firstly and properly here intended All things are plain familiar and exposed to the common Understandings of all Believers whose minds are any way exercised about these things as indeed are all things that belong unto the Discipline of Christ. Arguments pretendedly deep and learned really obscure and perplexed with logical Notions and distinctions applied unto things thus plain and evident in themselves do serve only to involve and darken the Truth It is plain in the place 1 That there was a Church-State for Christians then designed by Christ which afterwards he would institute and settle 2 That all true Disciples were to join and unite themselves in some such Church as might be helpful unto their Love Order Peace and Edification 3 That among the members of these Churches Offences would or might arise which in themselves tend unto pernicious Events 4 That if these Offences could not be cured and taken away so as that Love without Dissimulation might be continued among all the Members of the Churches an Account of them at last was to be given unto that Church or Society whereunto the Parties concerned do belong as Members of it 5 That this Church should hear determine and give Judgment with advice in the cases so brought unto it for the taking away and removal of all Offences 6 That this Determination of the Church is to be rested in on the Penalty of a Deprivation of all the Priviledges of the Church 7 That these things are the Institution and Appointment of Christ himself whose Authority in them all is to be submitted unto and which alone can cast one that is a Professed Christian into the condition of an Heathen or a Publican These things in the Notion and Practice of them are plain easy and exposed to the Understanding of the meanest of the Disciples of Christ as it is meet that all things should be wherein their daily Practice is concerned But it is not easily to be expressed into what horrible Perplexities and Confusions they have been wrested in the Church of Rome nor how those who depart from the plain obvious sense of the words and love not the Practice they direct unto do lead themselves and others into ways and paths that have neither use nor end From the corrupt abuse of the holy Institution of our Lord Jesus Christ here intended so many Powers Faculties Courts Jurisdictions legal Processes with Litigious Vexatious oppressive Courses of Actions and Trials whose very names are uncouth horrid foreign unto Religion and unintelligible without Cunning in an artâ—ficial barbarous Science of the Canon Law have proceeded as are enough to fill a sober rational man with astonishment how it could ever enter into the minds of men to suppose that they can possibly have any Relation unto this Divine Institution Those who are not utterly blinded with Interest and Prejudice wholly ignorant of the Gospel and the mind of Christ therein as also Strangers from the Practice of the Duties which it requires will hardly
Example of the Primitive Churches that succeeded unto those which were planted by the Apostles themselves and so may well be judged to have walked in the same way and Order with them And that which we alledge is That in no approved Writers for the space of 200 years after Christ there is any mention made of any other Organical visibly professing Church but that only which is Parochial or Congregational A Church of any other Form State or Order Papal or Oecumenical Patriarchal Metropolitical Diocesan or Classical they know not Neither Name nor thing nor any of them appear in any of their Writings Before I proceed unto the Confirmation of this Assertion by particular Testimonies I shall premise some things which are needful unto the right understanding of what it is that I intend to prove by them As 1. All the Churches at first planted by the Apostles whether in the greatest Cities as Jerusalem Antioch Corinth Rome c. or those in the meanest Villages of Judea Galilee or Samaria were as unto their Church-State in Order Power Priviledge and Duty every way equal not Superior or Inferior not ruling over or subject unto one another No Institution of any Inequality between them no Instance of any Practice Supposing it no Direction for any compliance with it no one word of intimation of it can be produced from the Scripture nor is it consistent with the nature of the Gospel Church-State 2. In and among all these Churches there was one and the same spirit one Hope of their Calling one Lord one Faith one Baptism whence they were all obliged mutually to seek and endeavour the Good and Edification of each other To be helpful to one another in all things according unto that which any of them had received in the Lord. This they did by Prayer by Advice and Counsel by Messengers sent with Salutations Exhortations Consolations supplies for the Poor and on all the like occasions By these means and by the exercise of that mutual Love and Care which they were obliged unto they kept and preserved Vnity and Communion among themselves gave a common Testimony against any thing that in Doctrine or Practice deviated from the Rule and Discipline of Christ. This Order with Peace and Love thereon continued among them until Pride Ambition Desire of Rule and Preheminence in Diotrephes and a multitude of the same spirit with him began to open a door unto the entrance of the Mystery of Iniquity under pretence of a better Order than this which was of the appointment of Christ. 3. It must be acknowledged that notwithstanding this Equality among all Churches as unto their State and Power that there were great Differences between them some real and some in Reputation which not being rightly managed proved an Occasion of evil in and unto them all For Instance 1. Some were more eminent in spiritual Gifts than others As this was a Priviledge that might have been greatly improved unto the Honour of Christ and the Gospel yet we know how it was abused in the Church of Corinth and what Disorders followed thereon so weak and frail are the best of men so liable unto Temptation that all Preheminence is dangerous for them and often abused by them which I confess makes me not a little admire to see men so earnestly pleading for it so fearlesly assuming it unto themselves so fiercely contending that all Power and Rule in the Church belongs unto them alone But 2. Reputation was given unto some by the long abode of some of the Apostles in them Of this Advantage we find nothing in the Scripture But certain it is it was much pleaded and contended about among the Primitive Churches yea so far until by Degrees Disputes arose about the Places where this or that Apostle fixed his Seat which was looked on as a Preheminence for the present and a security for the future But yet we know how soon some of them degenerated from the Church Order and Discipline wherein they were instructed by the Apostles see Rev. chap. 2. and 3. 3. The Greatness Power Fame or Civil Authority of the Place or City where any Church was planted gave it an Advantage and Priviledge in Reputation above others And the Churches planted in such Cities were quickly more numerous in their Members than others were unless men strictly kept themselves unto the force of Primitive Institutions it was very hard for them to think and Judge that a a Church it may be in a small Village or Town in Galilee should be Equal with that at Hierusalem or at Antioch or afterwards at Rome itself The Generality of men easily suffered themselves to be persuaded that those Churches were advanced in State and Order far above the other obscure poor Congregations That there should be a Church at Rome the Head City of the world was a Matter of great Joy and Triumph unto many and the Advancement of it in Reputation they thought belonged unto the Honour of our Religion Howbeit there is not in the Scripture the least regard expressed unto any of these things of place number or possibility of outward splendor either in the Promises of the Presence of Christ in and with his Churches or in the Communication of Power Priviledges unto them Yet such an improvement did this foolish Imagination find that after those who presided in the Churches called in the principal Cities had tasted of the sweetness of the bait which lay in the Ascription of a Preheminence unto them they began openly to claim it unto themselves and to usurp Authority over other Churches Confirming their own Usurpation by Canons and Rules until a few of them in the Council of Nice began to divide the Christian world among themselves as if it had been been Conquered by them Hence proceeded those shameful contests that were among the greater Prelates about their Preheminency and hence arose that Pretence of the Bishops of Rome unto no less a Right of Rule and Dominion over all Christian Churches than the City had over all the Nations and Cities of the Empire which being carried on by all sorts of evil Artifices as by downright Forgeries shameless Intrusions of themselves impudent laying hold of all Advantages unto their own exaltation prevailed at length unto the utter ruine of all Church Order and worship There is no sober History of the rise and growth by several Degrees of any City Commonwealth or Empire that is filled with so many Instances of ambitious seeking of Preheminence as our Church stories are By this Imagination were the generality of the Prelates in those dayes induced to introduce and settle a Government in and among the Churches of Christ answering unto the Civil Government of the Roman Empire As the Civil Government was cast into National or Diocesan or Provincial in less or greater Divisions each of which had its Capital City the place of the Residence of the chief Civil Governour so they designed to frame an Image of
the Lord Christ hath ordained no Power nor Order in his Church no Office or Duty that should stand in need of the Civil Authority Sanction or force to preserve it or make it effectual unto its proper ends It is sufficient to discharge any thing of a pretence to be an appointment of Christ in his Church if it be not sufficient unto its own proper End without the help of the Civil Magistrate That Church-state which is either constituted by humane Authority or cannot consist without it is not from him That Ordinance which is in its own Nature divine or is pretended so to be so far as it is not effectual unto its end without the aid of Humane Authority is not of him he needs it not he will not borrow the assistance of Civil Authority to rule in and over the Consciences of men with respect unto their living to God and coming unto the enjoyment of himself The way of requiring the Sanction of Civil Authority unto Ecclesiastical Orders and Determinations began with the use of General Councils in the days of Constantine And when once it was engaged in and approved so far as that what was determined in the Synods either as to Doctrine or as unto the Rule of the Church should be confirmed by the Imperial Authority with penalties on all that should gainsay such Determinations It is deplorable to consider what mutual havock was made among Christians upon the various Sentiments of Synods and Emperours Yet this way pleased the Rulers of the Church so well and as they thought eased them of so much trouble that it was so far improved amongst them that at last they left no Power in or about Religion or Religious Persons unto the Civil Magistrate but what was to be exercised in the execution of the Decrees and Determinations of the Church It is necessary from this Institution of particular Churches that they have their Subsistence Continuation Order and the efficacy of all that they act and do as Churches from Christ himself For whereas all that they are and do is Heavenly Spiritual and not of this world that it reacheth nothing of all those things which are under the Power of the Magistrate that is the Lives and Bodies of Men and all Civil Interests appertaining to them and affect nothing but what no Power of all the Magistrates under Heaven can reach unto that is the Souls and Consciences of men no trouble can hence arise unto any Rulers of the world no Contests about what they ought and what they ought not to confirm which have caused great Disorders among many 3. In particular also There neither is nor can be in this Church-state the least pretence of Power or Authority to be acted towards or over the Persons of Kings or Rulers which should either impeach their Right or impede the exercise of their just Authority For as Christ hath granted no such Power unto the Church so it is impossible that any pretence of it should be seated in a particular Congregation especially being gathered on this Principle that there is no Church Power properly so called but what is so seated and that no Concurrence Agreement or Association of many Churches can adde a new greater or other Power or Authority unto them than what they had singly before And what Power can such Churches act towards Kings Potentates or Rulers of Nations Have they not the highest Security that it is uttterly impossible that ever their Authority or their persons in the exercise of it should be impeached hindered or receive any detriment from any thing that belongs to this Church-state These Principles I say are sufficient to secure Christian Religion and the State Order and Power of Churches instituted therein from all reflections of Inconsistency with Civil Government or of influencing men into Attempts of its Change or Ruine The summe is Let the outward frame and order of righteous Government be of what sort it will nothing inconsistent with it nothing entrenching on it nothing making opposition unto it is appointed by Jesus Christ or doth belong unto that Church-state which he hath ordained and established Two things only must be added unto these Principles that we may not seem so to distinguish the Civil State and the Church as to make them unconcerned in each other For 1. It is the unquestionable Duty of the Rulers and Governours of the World upon the Preaching of the Gospel to receive its Truth and so yield Obedience unto its Commands And whereas all Power and Offices are to be discharged for God whose Ministers all Rulers be they are bound in the discharge of their Office to countenance supply and protect the Profession and Professours of the Truth that is the Church according unto the degrees and measures which they shall judge necessary 2. It is the Duty of the Church materially considered that is of all those who are Members of it in any Kingdom or Commonwealth to be usefully subservient even as Christians unto that Rule which is over them as Men in all those ways and by all those means which the Laws Usages and Customs of the Countries whereof they are do direct and prescribe But these things are frequently spoken unto There are sundry other Considerations whereby it may be evinced not only that this Order and State of Gospel-Churches is not only consistent with every righteous Government in the world I mean that is so in its Constitution though as all other Forms it be capable of Male-Administration but the most useful and subservient unto its righteous Administrations being utterly uncapable of immixing itself as such in any of those occasions of the world or State-Affairs as may create the least difficulty or trouble unto Rulers With others it is not so It is known that the very Constitution of the Papal Church as it is stated in the Canons of it is inconsistent with the just Rights of Kings and Rulers and oft-times in the exercise of its Power destructive unto their Persons and Dominions And herein concurred the Prelatical Church-state of England whilst it continued in their Communion and held its dependance on the Roman Church For although they had all their Power originally from the Kings of this Realm as the Records and Laws of it do expressly affirm That the Church of England was founded in Episcopacy by the King and his Nobles yet they claimed such an addition of Power and Authority by vertue of their Office from the Papal Omnipotency as that they were Ringleaders in perplexing the Government of this Nation under the pretence of maintaining of what they called the Rights of the Church And hereunto they were inabled by the very Constitution of their Church-Order which gave them that Power Grandeur with Political Interest that were needful to effectuate their Designe And since they have been taken off from this foundation of contesting Kings and Princes on their own Ecclesiastical Authority and deprived of their dependance on the Power
at present will not be said concerning the New Covenant whereunto all Ordinances of Divine Worship are inseparably annexed Men might at a cheaper rate as unto the eternal interest of their own Souls provide another Covering for their sloth negligence unbelief and indulgence unto proud foolish imaginations whereby they render the Churches and Ordinances of the Gospel useless and ineffectual unto themselves thereby charging them with a decay and uselesness and so reflecting on the honour and faithfulness of Christ himself 2. They do not cease because there is at present or at least there is shortly to be expected such an effusion of the gifts and graces of the Spirit as to render all these external institutions needless and consequently useless This also is falsely pretended For 1. The greatest and most plentiful effusion of the Holy Spirit in his Gifts and Graces was in the days of the Apostles and of the first Churches planted by them nor is any thing beyond it or indeed equal unto it any more to be expected in this world But yet then was the Gospel Church-state erected and the use of all its Ordinances of Worship enjoyned 2. The Ministry of the Gospel which comprizeth all the Ordinances of Church-worship as its object and end is the Ministration of the Spirit and therefore no supplies or communication of him can render it useless 3. One of the principal ends for which the communication of the Spirit is promised unto the Church is to make and render all the Institutions of Christ effectual unto its edification 4. 1 Joh. 2.20 27. is usually pleaded as giving countenance unto this fond pretence But 1. The Vnction mentioned by the Apostle was then upon all Believers Yet 2. It is known that then they all walked in Church-Order and the sacred observation of all the Institutions of Christ. 3. If it takes away any thing it is the Preaching of the Word or all manner of Teaching and Instruction which is to overthrow the whole Scripture and to reduce Religion into Barbarism 4. Nothing is intended in these words but the different way of Teaching and degrees of Success between that under the Law and that now established in the Gospel by the plentiful effusion of the Spirit as hath been evidenced at large elsewhere Nor 3. Do they cease in their Administration for want either of Authority or Ability to dispense them which is pleaded unto the same end But neither is this pretence of any force it only begs the thing in Question The Authority of Office for the Administration of all other Ordinances is an Institution And to say that all Institutions cease because none have Authority to administer them is to say they must all cease because they are ceased 2. The Office of the Ministry for the continuation of the Church-state and Administration of all Ordinances of Worship unto the end of the world is sufficiently secured 1 By the Law constitution and appointment of our Lord Jesus Christ erecting that Office and giving warranty for its continuance to the consummation of all things Matth. 28.20 Ephes. 4.13 2. By his continuance according unto his promise to communicate Spiritual gifts unto men for the Ministerial Edification of the Church That this he doth so continue to do that it is the principal external Evidence of his abiding in the discharge of his Mediatory Office and of what nature these gifts are I have declared at large in a peculiar Discourse on that subject 3. On the duty of Believers or of the Church which is to choose call and solemnly set apart unto the Office of the Ministry such as the Lord Christ by his Spirit hath made meet for it according unto the rule of his Word If all these or any of them do fail I acknowledge that all Ministerial Authority and Ability for the dispensation of Gospel-Ordinances must fail also and consequently the state of the Church And those who plead for the continuation of a successive Ministry without respect unto these things without resolving both the Authority and Office of it unto them do but erect a dead Image or embrace a dead carcase instead of the living and life-giving Institutions of Christ. They take away the living Creature and set up a skin stuffed with straw But if these things do unalterably continue if the Law of Christ can neither be changed abrogated or disannulled if his dispensation of Spiritual gifts according unto his promise cannot be impeded if Believers through his grace will continue in obedience unto his commands it is not possible there should be an utter failure in this Office and Office-Power of this Ministry It may fail in this or that place in this or that Church when the Lord Christ will remove his Candlestick But it hath a living root whence it will spring again in other places and Churches whilst this world doth endure Neither 4. Do they cease because they have been all of them corrupted abused and defiled in the Apostacy which fell out among all the Churches in the latter Ages as it was fully foretold in the Scripture For 1. This supposition would make the whole Kingdom of Christ in the world to depend on the corrupt Lusts and wills of men which have got by any means the outward possession of the Administration of his Laws and Ordinances This is all one as if we should say that if a pack of wicked Judges should for a season pervert Justice Righteousness and Judgment that the being of the Kingdom is so overthrown thereby as that it can never be restored 2. It would make all the duties and all the priviledges of all true Believers to depend on the wills of wicked Apostates For if they may not make use of what they have abused they can never yield Obedience to the commands of Christ nor enjoy the priviledges which he hath annexed unto his Church and Worship 3. On this supposition all Reformation of an Apostatized Church is utterly impossible But it is our duty to heal even Babylon itself by a reduction of all things unto their first Institution if it would be healed Jerem. 51.9 and if not we are to forsake her and reform ourselves Rev. 18.4 There is nothing therefore in all these pretences that should in the least impeach the infallible continuation of the Evangelical Churches and Worship as to their right unto the end of the world And the Heads of those Arguments whereby the Truth is invincibly confirmed may be briefly touched on 1. There are express Testimonies of the Will of Christ and his promise for its accomplishment that the Church and all its Ordinances of Worship should be continued always unto the end of the world So as to the Church itself Matth. 16.18 Rev. 21.3 The Ministry Matth. 28.20 Ephes. 4.13 Baptism Matth. 28.18 19 20. The Lords Supper 1 Cor. 11.26 As for other Institutions Publick Prayer Preaching the Word the Lords day singing of Gods Prayses the exercise of Discipline with what belongs
Life it self An Opinion Ignominious unto Christian Religion however vapoured withal by young Men whose Wit flies above all serious Consideration of things and their Circumstances and countenanced by others from an influence of Interest who otherwise would not be imposed on by such an Anti-Evangelical Presumption I shall therefore at the utmost distance from Interest or Passion briefly consider the Case proposed and give an account of my Thoughts concerning it 1. One or two things are usually premised unto the consideration of this case as namely 1. That those who refrain from that Communion with the Church of England which we insist upon do yet agree therewith in all important Doctrines of Faith which is the Foundation the Life and Soul of Church Union and Communion This I freely grant but with this Limitation that this Agreement respects the Doctrine as declared at the first Reformation and explained in the Age next ensuing thereon If there be a change made in or of these Doctrines or any of them by any in or of the Church of England we profess our Disagreement from them and do declare that thereby the Foundation of our Communion with them is weakened and the principal bond of it loosened 2. That not only as Christians but as Reformed Protestants we do agree in the Renunciation of the Doctrines and Worship of the Church of Rome which are opposed by the common consent of all those who are usually so called Yet this must be added thereunto that if any in or of the Church of England should make an Accession unto any Parts of the Doctrine and Worship of the Roman Church not avowed or warranted by the consent of the Church in its first Reformation we are not we cannot be obliged unto Communion with them therein and by their so doing the Original Bond of our Communion is weakened if not dissolved 2. These things being premised we shall enquire in the first place what is the Rule of that Communion with the Church of England in its Parochial Assemblies which is required of us If this be pleaded to be a Rule of divine Prescription we acknowledge that great diligence and humility are required unto the consideration of it that we be not mistaken And if it prove to be according to the Mind of Christ that is of his Institution if we fail of a compliance with it we are guilty of Schisme But if the Rule prescribing limiting and exacting this Communion be not so much as pleaded to be of divine Institution whatever fault there may be in our dissent from it Schisme it is not For Ecclesiastical Schisme neither hath nor can have respect unto any thing but divine Institutions For if it hath it is in the Power of any sort of men to make Schismaticks of whom they please as practically and in pretence it is come to pass at this day in the World Now the Rule of the Communion required is the Law of the Land the Book of Canons with the Rubrick of the Common Prayer If according to the Prescriptions Directions and Commands given in them we do joyn our selves in Communion with Parochial Assemblies then are we judged conformable to the Church of England and not else By and according unto these are all enquiries made concerning Communion with the Church and if they are observed the return is Omnia bene Now this Rule hath no divine Warrant for its Institution no Example in the Primitive Churches especially considering what are the things which it obliges us unto nor can be made consistent with the Liberty wherewith Christ hath made his Disciples free A Dissent from this Rule is as far from Schisme as any man need desire it For nothing is so but what respects some Command or Institution of Christ which immediately affects the Conscience It is true the Lord Christ hath Commanded that Love Union Peace and Order whereof Schisme is a disturbance and whereunto it is opposite But they are that Love Union and Order which he hath appointed To suppose that he hath left it unto Men to invent and appoint a new kind of Union and Order which is done in the Rule we treat of which he never required and then to oblige his Disciples unto the Observation of it be it what it will so as that their dissent from it should be Criminal and that for this Reason that it is so appointed of men is no small mistake And if all that Love Union Peace and Order which the Lord Jesus hath enjoyned his Disciples may be punctually observed without any respect unto this Rule as a Rule of Church Communion to dissent from it whatever fault of another kind it may be is no more Schisme than it is Adultery And if on some mens Arbitrary Constitution of this Rule and the Dissent of others from it such Differences and Divisions ensue as seem to have the general Nature of Schisme the Evil of them belongs unto those alone by whom the Rule is framed If indeed some should frame such a Rule of Church Communion because they suppose they see Cause for it and would then leave it unto others to observe as they see Cause if it be not of Use it would not be liable unto much abuse But whereas our Lord Jesus Christ hath given one and the same Rule equally unto all his Disciples in these things namely that they should observe and do all that he hath commanded them for some of them on any pretence or Plea whatever as of their being the Church or the like arbitrarily to frame a Rule of their own as an Addition unto his obliging all others unto a strict Observance of it because they have so framed it is that which neither the Scripture nor Primitive Antiquity know any thing of I will not enquire what is that Power and Authority whereby this Rule is constituted and confirmed nor in whom it doth reside The Name of the Church is usually pretended and pleaded But before any can be concerned herein all that hath been pleaded for the true state and nature of Evangelical Churches must be overthrown which will not be done speedily Railings Revilings and Reproaches will not do it But until this is done it will be believed that every particular Congregation is indispensibly obliged in itself to observe and do all the Commands of Christ and is left at Liberty so to regulate the outward circumstances of its Worship and Order as is best for its own Edification whereof it self is the most competent Judge But as for a Church of another sort invested with Authority to make a Rule not only as unto the outward Circumstances of those Actions wherein Church Order and Worship do consist but as unto sundry Religious Rites and Observances which thereby are added unto it and impose the Observance of it on a great Multitude of other Congregations without their consent whether they judge the things enjoyned to be for their Edification or otherwise it is apparently not from
or Folly of men can invent When these Articles of the Church of England were composed neither Socinianisme nor Arminianisme which have now made such an inroad on some Protestant Churches were in the World either Name or Things Wherefore in their Confession no Testimony could be expresly given against them though I acknowledge it is evident from what is contained in the Articles of it and the approved Exposition they received for a long time in the Writings of the most eminent Persons of the Church that there is a virtual Condemnation of all those Errors included therein But in that state whereunto things are come amongst us some more express Testimony against them is necessary to render any Church the Ground and Pillar of Truth 2. Besides a distinction is found out and passeth currant among us that the Articles of this Confession are not Articles of Faith but of outward Agreement for Peace's sake among our selves which is an Invention to help on the ruin of Religion For Articles of Peace in Religion concerning Matters of Faith which he that subscribes doth it not because they are true or Articles of Faith are an Engine to accommodate Hypocrisie and nothing else But according unto this Supposition they are used at mens pleasure and turned which way they have a Mind to Wherefore 3. Notwithstanding this Standard of Truth Differences in important Doctrines wherein the Edification of the Souls of Men are highly concerned do abound among them who mannage the publick Profession of the Church I shall not urge this any farther by Instances in general it cannot modestly be denied Neither is this spoken to abridge Ministers of Churches of their due Liberty in their Mannagement of the Truths of the Gospel For such a Liberty is to be granted as 1. Ariseth from the distinct Gifts that men have received For unto every one is Grace given according to the Measure of the Gift of Christ Ephes. 4.7 As every Man hath received the Gift so minister the same one to another as Good stewards of the manifold Grace of Gad 1 Pet. 4.10 2. As followeth on that Spiritual Wisdom which Ministers receive in great variety for the Application of the Truths of the Gospel unto the Souls and Consciences of Men. Hereon great variety in publick Church-Administrations will ensue but all unto Edification 3. Such as consists in a different Exposition of particular places of Scripture whilst the Analogy of Faith is kept and preserved Rom. 12.6 4. Such as admits of different stated Apprehensions in and about such Doctrines as wherein the practise and comfort of Christians are not immediately nor greatly concerned Such a Liberty I say as the Dispensation of Spiritual Gifts and the different manner of their exercise as the unsearchable depths that are in the Scripture not to be fathomed at once by any Church or any sort of Persons whatever and our knowing the best of us but in part with the difference of mens Capacities and Understandings in and about things not absolutely necessary unto Edification must be allowed in Churches and their Ministry But I speak of that Variety of Doctrines which is of greater importance Such it is as will set men at liberty to make their own Choice in the use of means for their Edification And if such Novel Opinions about the Person Grace Satisfaction and Righteousness of Christ about the Work of the Holy Spirit of God in Regeneration or the Renovation of our Nature into the Image of God as abound in some Churches should at any time by the suffrage of the Major Part of them who by Law are entrusted with its conduct be declared as the sense of the Church it is and would be sufficient to absolve any man from an Obligation unto its Communion by vertue of its first Institution and Establishment 5. Evangelical Discipline is neither observed nor attainable in these Parochial Assemblies nor is there any Releif provided by any other means for that Defect This hath in general been spoken unto before but because it belongs in an especial manner unto the Argument now in hand I shall yet farther speak unto it For to declare my Mind freely I do not judge that any man can incur the Guilt of Schisme who refraines from the Communion of the Church wherein the Discipline of the Gospel is either wholly wanting or is perverted into Rule and Domination which hath no countenance given unto it in the Word of Truth And we may Observe 1. The Discipline of the Church is that alone for which any Rule or Authority is given unto it or exercised in it Authority is given unto the Ministers of the Church to dispense the Word and administer the Sacraments which I know not why some call the Key of Order But the only End why the Lord Christ hath given Authority or Rule or Power for it unto the Church or any in it it is for the Exercise of Discipline and no other Whatever Power Rule Dignity or Preheminence is assumed in the Churches not meerly for this End is Usurpation and Tyranny 2. The outward means appointed by Jesus Christ for the Preservation of his Churches in Order Peace and Purity consists in this Discipline He doth by his Word give Directions and Commands for this end and it is by Discipline alone that they are executed Wherefore without it the Church cannot live in its Health Purity and Vigor the Word and Sacraments are its Spiritual Food whereon its Life doth depend But without that Exercise and Medicinal Applications unto its Distempers which are made by Discipline it cannot live an healthy vigorous fruitful Life in the things of God 3. This Discipline is either private or publick 1. That which is private consists in the mutual watch that all the Members of the Church have over one another with Admonitions Exhortations and Reproofes as their Edification doth require The loss of this Part of the Discipline of Christ in most Churches hath lost us much of the Glory of Christian Profession 2. That which is publick in the Rulers of the Church with and by its own consent The Nature and Acts of it will be afterwards considered 4 There are three things considerable in this Discipline 1. The Power and Authority whereby it is exercised 2. The Manner of its Administration 3. The especial Object of it both as it is Susceptive of Members and Corrective Whereunto we may add its general End 1. The Authority of it is only a Power and Liberty to act and ministerially exercise the Authority of Christ himself As unto those by whom it is exercised it is in them an Act of Obedience unto the Command of Christ but with respect unto its Object the Authority of Christ is exerted in it That which is exercised on any other Warranty or Authority as none can exert the Authority of Christ but by vertue of his own Institutions whose Acts are not Acts of Obedience unto Christ whatever else it be it belongs not unto
by all the Governours of the Christian Church that the Jewish Christians should be left unto their own Liberty out of respect unto the Law of Moses and out of regard unto the Peace of the Christian Church which otherwise might have been extremely hazarded But 1. The Governours of the Christian Church which made the Determination insisted on were the Apostles themselves 2. There was no such Determination made that the Jews should be left unto their own Liberty in this Matter but there was only a Connivance at their Inclination to bear their old Yoke for a Season The Determination was onely on the other hand that no Imposition of it should be made on the Gentiles 3. The Determination it self was no Act of Church Government or Power but a doctrinal Declaration of the Mind of the Holy Ghost 4. It is well that Church Governours once judged that Impositions in things not necessary were to be forborn for the sake of the Peace of the Church Others I hope may in due time be of the same Mind 2. He says The false Apostles imposing on the Gentile Christians had two circumstances in it which extreamly alter their Case from that of our Dissenters For 1. They were none of their lawful Governours but went about as seducers drawing away the Disciples of the Apostles from them It seems then 1. That those who are lawful Governours or pretend themselves so to be may impose what they please without Controul as they did in the Papacy and the Councils of it But 2. Their Imposition was meerly doctrinal wherein there was no Pretence of any Act of Government or governing Power which made it less grievous then that which the Dissenters have suffered under Were things no otherwise imposed on us we should bear them more easily 2. Saith he They imposed the Jewish Rites as necessary to Salvation and not meerly as indifferent things And the Truth is so long as they judged them so to be they are more to be excused in their doctrinal Impositions of them then others are who by an Act of Government fortified with I know not how many Penalties do impose things which themselves esteem indifferent and those on whom they are imposed do judge to be unlawful Whereas he addes that he hath considered all things that are Material in Discourse which seem to take off the force of the Argument drawn from this Text I am not of his Mind nor I believe will any indifferent Person be so who shall compare what I wrote therein with his exceptions against it though I acknowledge it is no easie thing to discover wherein the force of the pretended Argument doth lye That we must walk according unto the same Rule in what we have attained that wherein we differ we must wait on God for Teaching and Instruction that the Apostles Elders and Brethren at Hierusalem determined from the Scriptures or the Mind of the Holy Ghost therein that the Jewish Ceremonies should not be imposed on the Gentile Churches and Beleivers and that thereon those Churches continued in Communion with each other who did and did not observe those Ceremonies are the only Principles which in Truth the Doctor hath to proceed upon To infer from these Principles and Propositions that there is a National Church of Divine Institution for what is not so hath no Church Power properly so called the nature of its Power being determined by the Authority of its Institution or Erection That this Church hath Power in its Governours and Rulers to invent new Orders Ceremonies and Rites of Worship new Canons for the Observation of sundry things in the Rule of the Church and Worship of God which have no Spring nor Cause but their own Invention and Prescription and is authorized to impose the Observation of them on all particular Churches and Believers who never gave their consent unto their Invention or Prescription and hereon to declare them all to be wicked Schismaticks who yield not full Obedience unto them in these things it requires a great deal of Art and Skil in the Mannagers of the Argument SECT II. PArt 2. Sect. 21. pag. 176. Our Author proceeds to renew his Charge of Schisme or sinful Separation against those who though they agree with us saith he in the substantials of Religion yet deny any Communion with our Church to be lawful But apprehending that the state of the Question here insinuated will not be admitted and that it would be difficult to find them out who deny any Communion with the Church of England to be lawful he addes that he doth not speak of any improper Acts of Communion which Dr. O. calls Communion in Faith and Love which they allow to the Church of England But why the Acts hereof are called improper Acts of Communion I know not Add unto Faith and Love the Administration of the same Sacraments with Common Advice in things of Common concernment and it is all the Communion that the true Churches of Christ have among themselves in the whole World Yea this Church Communion is such as that 1. Where it is not there is no Evangelical Communion at all whatever Acts of Worship or Church Order men may agree in the Practise of if the Foundation of that Agreement be not laid in a joint Communion in Faith and Love they are neither accepted with God nor profitable unto the Souls of men For 2. These are the things namely Faith and Love which enliven all joint Duties of Church Order and Worship are the Life and Soul of it and how they should be only improperly that which they alone make other things to be properly I cannot understand 3. Where there is no defect in these things namely in Faith and Love the Charge of Schisme on dissenting in things of lesser Moment is altogether unreasonable It is to be desired that an overweening of our Differences make us not overlook the things wherein we are agreed This is one of the greatest Evils that attend this Controversie Men are forced by their Interest to lay more weight on a few outward Rites and Ceremonies which the World and the Church might well have spared had they not come into the Minds of some Men none know how than upon the most important Graces and Duties of the Gospel Hence Communion in Faith and Love is scarce esteemed worth taking up in the streets in comparison of Vniformity in Rites and Ceremonies Let Men be as void of and remote from true Gospel Faith and Love as is imaginable yet if they comply quietly with and have a little Zeal for those outward things they are to be approved of as very orderly Members of the Church And whatever Evidences on the other hand any can or do give of their Communion in Faith and Love with all that are of that Communion yet if they cannot in Conscience comply in the Observance of those outward things mentioned they are to be judged Schismaticks and Breakers of the Churches Unity whereas no
claiming an Interest in Authority to give Laws to the Church This therefore is absolutely denyed by us namely that any men under what pretence or name soever have any Right or Authority to constitute any new Frame or Order of the Church to make any Laws of their own for its Rule or Government that should oblige the Disciples of Christ in point of Conscience unto their observation That there is nothing in this Assertion that should in the least impeach the Power of Mastrates with Reference unto the Outward Civil and Political Concerns of the Church or the publick Profession of Religion within their Territories nothing that should take off from thâ— just Authority of the lawful Guides of the Church in ordering appointing and commanding the Observation of all things in them according to the mind of Christ shall be afterwards declared In these things the Lord is our Judge the Lord is our Statute-maker the Lord is our King he will save us It is then but weakly pleaded that seeing the Magistrate can appoint or command nothing in Religion that God hath forbidden nor is there any need that he should Appoint or Command what God hath already Appointed and Commanded if so be he may not by Law command such things in the Church as before were neither Commanded nor Forbidden but Indifferent which are the proper field of his Ecclesiastical Legislative Power then hath he no Power nor Authority about Religion at all That is if he hath not the same and a Coordinate Power with God or Christ he hath none at all One of the best Arguments that can be used for the Power of the Magistrate in things Ecclesiastical is taken from the approved Example of the Good Kings under the Old Testament But they thought it honour enough unto them and their Duty to see and take care that the things which God had appointed and ordained should be diligently observed by all those concerned therein both Priests and People and to destroy what God had forbidden To appoint any thing of themselves to make that necessary in the Church and the Worship thereof which God had not made so they never esteemed it to be in their Power or to belong unto their Duty When they did any thing of that Nature and thereby made any Additions unto the outward Worship of God not before commanded they did it by immediate Revelation from God and so by Divine Authority 1 Chron. 28.19 And it is left as a brand on those that were wicked not only that they commanded and made Statutes for the Observation of what God had forbidden Mic. 6.16 but also that they commanded and appointed what God had not appointed 1 Kings 12.32 33. And it will be found at last to be Honour enough to the greatest Potentate under Heaven to take care that what Christ hath appointed in his Church and Worship be observed without claiming a Power like unto that of the most high to give Laws unto the Church for the Observation of things found out and invented by themselves or other men Of the same nature is the other part of their Plea against this Denial of a Legislative Power in men with respect unto the Constitution of the Evangelical Church-State or the ordaining of any thing to be observed in it that Christ hath not appointed For it is said that if this be allowed as all the Dignity Power and Honour of the Governours of the Church will be rejected or despised so all manner of Confusion and Disorder will be brought into the Church itself For how can it otherwise be when all Power of Law-making in the preservation of the Dignity of the Rulers and Order of the Church is taken away And therefore we see it was the Wisdom of the Church in former Ages tha all the principal Laws and Canons that they made in their Councils or otherwise were designed unto the Exaltation and Preservation of the Dignity of Church Rulers Wherefore take this Power away and you will bring in all Confusion into the Church Ans. 1. They do not in my Judgment sufficiently think of whom and of what they speak who plead after this manner For the substance of the Plea is That if the Church have its whole Frame Constitution Order Rule and Government from Christ alone though men should faithfully discharge their Duty in Doing and Observing all what he hath commanded there would be nothing in it but Disorder and Confusion Whether this becomes that Reverence which we ought to have of him or be suited unto that Faithfulness and Wisdom which is particularly ascribed unto him in the Constitution and Ordering of his Church is not hard to determine and the Untruth of it shall be afterwards demonstrated 2. As unto the Dignity and Honour of the Rulers of the Church the subject of so many Ecclesiastical Laws they are in the first place to be desired themselves to remember the Example of Christ himself in his Personal Ministry here on Earth Matth. 20.28 Even as the Son of man came not to be ministred unto but to minister and to give his Life a Ransom for many With the Rule prescribed by him thereon ver 25 26 27. But Jesus called them unto him and said ye know that the Princes of the Gentiles exercise Dominion over them and they that are great exercise Authority upon them But it shall not be so among you but whosoever shall be great among you let him be your Minister And whosoever will be chief among you let him be your servant With the Occasion of the Instruction given therein unto his Apostles ver 24. And when the Ten heard it they were moved with Indignation against the two Brethren As also the Injunction given them by the Apostle Peter on whom for their own Advantage some would fasten a Monarchy over the whole Church 1 Epist. 5.2 3. Feed the Flock of God which is among you taking the oversight thereof not by constraint but willingly not for filthy Lucre but of a ready Mind Neither as being Lords over God's Heritage but being Ensamples to the Flock And the blessed expressions of the Apostolical State by Paul 1 Cor. 4.1 Let a man so account of us as of the Ministers of Christ and Stewards of the Mysteries of God 2 Cor. 1.24 Not for that we have Dominion over your Faith but are helpers of your Joy 2 Cor. 4 5. For we preach not our selves but Christ Jesus the Lord and our selves your Servants for Jesus sake It may prepare their Minds for the right Mannagement of that Honour which is their due For 2 There is in and by the Constitution of Christ and his express Laws an Honour and Respect due unto those Church Guides which he hath appointed abiding in the Duties which he requireth If men had not been weary of Apostolical Simplicity and Humility if they could have contented themselves with the Honour and Dignity annexed unto their Office and Work by Christ himself they had never
Church and nothing else But it was the Will of God that there should be all those things in the Gospel Church-State also or else why do men contend about them And if this were the Will of God if they were not all revealed appointed prescribed legalized by Christ where is his Faithfulness in Answer to that Moses But no Instance can be given of any Defect in his Institutions that needs any supplement to be made by the best of men as unto the end of constituting a Church-State Order and Rule with rites of Worship in particular 4. How it is derogatory unto the Glory of the Scripture as unto its Perfection shall be elsewhere declared 8. There is no more required to give Authority obliging the Consciences of all that do believe unto any Institution or Observation of Duty or Acts of Rule in the Church but onely that it is made evident in the Scripture to be the Mind and Will of Christ. It is not necessary that every thing of this Nature should be given out unto us in form of a Law or precise Command in express words It is the Mind and Will of Christ that immediately affects the Consciences of Believers unto Obedience by what way or means soever the knowledge of it be communicated unto them in the Scripture either by express words or by just consequence from what is so expressed Wherefore 9. The Example and Practice of the Apostles in the Erection of Churches in the Appointment of Officers and Rulers in them in directions given for their Walking Order Administration of Censures and all other holy things are a sufficient Indication of the Mind and Will of Christ about them We do not say that in themselves they are Institutions and Appointments but they infallibly declare what is so or the Mind of Christ concerning those things Nor can this be questioned without a denial of their Infallibility Faithfulness and Divine Authority 10 The Assertion of some that the Apostles took their Pattern for the State and Rule of the Churches and as unto divers Rites of Worship from the Synagogues of the Jews their Institutions Orders and Rules not those appointed by Moses but such as themselves had found out and ordained is both temerarious and untrue In the pursuit of such bold Conjectures one of late hath affirmed that Moses took most of his Laws and Ceremonies from the Aegyptitians whereas it is much more likely that many of them were given on purpose to alienate the People by Prohibitions from any compliance with the Aegyptians or any other Nation whereof Maimonides in his Mene Nebuchim gives us sundry Instances This Assertion I say is rash and false For 1 As unto the Instances given for its confirmation who shall assure us that they were then in use and practice in the Synagogues when the Apostles gave Rules unto the Churches of the New Testament We have no Record of theirs not one word in all the world of what was their way and practice but what is at least 250 years younger and later than the writings of the New Testament and in the first of their writings as in them that follow we have innumerable things asserted to have been the Traditions and Practises of their Forefathers from the days of Moses which we know to be utterly false At that time when they undertook to compose a new Religion out of their pretended Traditions partly by the Revolt of many Apostates from Christianity unto them especially of the Eliâ—nites and Nazarenes and partly by their own Study and Observation coming to the knowledge of sundry things in the Gospel Churches their Order and Worship they took them in as their own undeniable Instances may be given hereof 2 Wherein there is a real coincidence between what was ordained by the Apostles and what was practised by the Jews it is in things which the light of Nature and the general Rules of the Scripture do direct unto And it is dishonourable unto the Apostles and the Spirit of Christ in them to think or say that in such things they took their Pattern from the Jews or made them their example Surely the Apostles took not the Pattern and Example for the Institution of Excommunication from the Druids among whom there was some things that did greatly resemble it so far as it hath its Foundation in the light of Nature CHAP. III. The Continuation of a Church-State and of Churches unto the end of the world what are the Causes of it and whereon it depends THAT there was a peculiar Church-State Instituted and appointed by Christ and his Apostles acting in his Name and Authority with the infallible guidance of his Spirit hath been declared But it may be yet farther enquired whether this Church-State be still continued by Divine Authority or whether it ceased not together with the Apostles by whom it was erected There was a Church-State under the Old Testament solemnly erected by God himself And although it was not to be absolutely perpetual or everlasting but was to continue onely unto the time of Reformation yet unto that time its continuation was secured in the Causes and means of it The Causes of the continuation of this Church-State unto its appointed period were two 1. The Promise of God unto Abraham that he would keep and preserve his Seed in Covenant with him until he should be the Heir of the World and the Father of many Nations in the coming of Christ whereunto this Church-State was subservient 2 The Law of God it self and the Institutions thereof which God appointed to be observed in all their Generations calling the Covenant the Statutes and Laws of it perpetual and everlasting that is never to cease to be abrogated or disannulled until by his own Soveraign Authority he would utterly change and take away that whole Church-State with all that belonged unto its Constitution and Preservation 2. The Means of its continuance were three 1 Carnal Generation and that on a twofold account For there were two Constituent Parts of that Church the Priests and the People the continuation of each of them depended on the priviledge of Carnal Generation For the Priests were to be all of the Family of Aaron and the People of the Seed of Abraham by the other Heads of Tribes which gave them both their foundation in and Right unto this Church-State And hereunto were annexed all the Laws concerning the Integrity Purity and Legitimacy of the Priests with the certainty of their Pedegree 2 Circumcision the want whereof was a bar against any advantage by the former Priviledge of Generation from those two Springs and hereby others also might be added unto the Church though never with a Capacity of the Priesthood 3 The Separation of the People from the rest of the World by innumerable Divine Ordinances making their Coalition with them impossible From these Causes and by these Means it was that the Church-State under the Old Testament was preserved unto its appointed season Neither
which having as they thought unduely enough failed in one or two Instances it became the Destruction of a Church state not only in the Churches where such Mistakes had happened as they surmized but unto all the Churches in the World that would hold Communion with them But in these things we have no concernment Other Notions of Schisme besides those insisted on we acknowledge not nor is any other advanced with the least Probality of Truth Nor are we to be moved with outcries about Schisme wherein without regard to Truth or Charity men contend for their own Interest Of those Notions of it which have been received by men sober and learned we decline a trial by none that only excepted that the Refusal of Obedience unto the Pope and Church of Rome is all that is Schisme in the World which indeed is none at all That which is now so fiercely pleaded by some concerning different Observations of external Modes Rites Customes some more or none at all to make men Schismaticks is at once to judge all the Primitive Churches to be Schismatical Their Differences Varieties and Diversities among them about these things cannot be enumerated and so without any disadvantage unto the Faith or breach of Love they continued to be untill all Church Order and Power was swallowed up in the Papal Tyranny ten thousand times more pernicious then ten thousand such Disputes For a Close unto this whole Discourse concerning the original nature and state of Gospel Churches I shall use that Liberty which Love of the Truth puts into my Possession Churches mentioned in the Scripture ordained and appointed by the Authority of Jesus Christ were nothing but a certain number of Men and Women Converted to God by the preaching of the Gospel with their baptized seed associating themselves in Obedience unto Christs Commands and by the Direction of his Apostles for the common Profession of the same Faith the Observance and Performance of all Divine Institutions of Religious Worship unto the Glory of God their own Edification and the Conversion of others These Believers thus associated in Societies knowing the Command and Appointment of Jesus Christ by his Apostles for that End did choose from among themselves such as were to be their Rulers in the Name and Authority of Christ according to the Law and Order of his institutions who in the Scripture are called on various Considerations Elders Bishops Pastors and the like names of Dignity Authority and Office who were to administer all the solemn Ordinances of the Church among them Unto this Office they were solemnly appointed ordained or set apart by the Apostles themselves with fasting Prayer and imposition of hands or by other ordinary Officers after their decease This was the way and method of the Call and setting apart of all Ordinary Officers in the Church both under the Old Testament and in the New It is founded in the Light of Nature In the first Institution of ordinary Church Rulers under the Law the People looked out and chose fit Persons whom Moses set apart to the Office Deut. 1.13 14 15. And in the Call of Deacons Acts 6. The Apostle uses the same Words or words of the same importance unto the Church as Moses did to the People Acts 6.31 asserting the Continuation of the same way and order in their Call And whereas he who was first to be called to Office under the New Testament after the Ascension of Christ fell under a double Consideration namely of an Officer in general and of an Apostle which office was extraordinary there was a threefold Act in his Call the People chose two one of which was to be an Officer Acts 1.23 Gods immediate Determination of one as he was to be an Apostle ver 24. and the obedient Consent of the People in compliance with that Determination ver 26. The Foundation of these Churches was generally in a small number of Believers But their Church state was not compleat until they were supplyed with all ordinary Officers as Bishops and Deacons The former were of of several sorts as shall be proved hereafter And of them there were many in every Church whose number was encreased as the Members of the Church were multiplied So God appointed in the Church of the Jews that every ten Families should have a peculiar Ruler of their own Choice Deut. 1.13 14 15 For there is no mention in the New Testament of any one single Bishop or Elder in any Church of any sort whatever either Absolutely or by way of Preheminence But as the Elders of each Church were many at least more thenone so there was a parity among them and an Equality in Order Power and Rule Nor can any Instance be given unto the Contrary Of these Churches one onely was originally planted in one City Town or Village This way was taken from Conveniency for Edification and not from any positive Institution and it may be otherwise where Conveniency and Opportunity do require it The Number in these Churches Multiplying dayly there was a necessity of the Multiplication of Bishops or Elders among them Hereon the Advantage of some one Person in Priority of Conversion or of Ordination in Age Gifts and Graces especially in Ability for Preaching the Gospel and administring the Holy Ordinances of the Church with the Necessity of preserving Order in the Society of the Elders themselves gave him peculiar Dignity Preheminence and Title He was soon after the Bishop without any disadvantage to the Church For in those Churches in some of them at least Evangelists continued for a long Season who had the Administration of Church Affairs in their hands And some there were who were of Note among the Apostles and eminently esteemed by them who had eminent yea Apostolical Gifts as to Preaching of the Word and Prayer which was the peculiar work of the Apostle These were the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 mentioned by Clemens Of the many other Elders who were associated in the Rule of the Church it may be not many had Gifts for the constant Preaching of the Word nor were called thereunto Hence Justin Martyr seemes to assign the constant publick Administration of Sacred Ordinances unto one President And this also promoted the constant presidency of one in whom the Apostolical Aid by Evangelists might be supplyed These Churches thus fixed and settled in one place each of them City Town or Village were each of them intrusted with all the Power and Priviledges which the Lord Christ hath granted unto or endued his Church withal This Power is called the power of the Keys or of binding and loosing which hath respect only unto the Consciences of Men as unto things Spiritual and Eternal being meerly Ministerial Every one of these Churches were bound by the Command of Christ to live in Peace and Vnity through the Exercise of Peculiar sincere and fervent Love among all their Members as also to walk in Peace and useful Communion with all othâ—â— Churches in the
and Interest of the Papal See having no bottom for or supportment of their Church state and Order but Regal Favour and mutable Laws there have on such Causes and Reasons which I shall not mention ensued such Emulations of the Nobility and Gentry and such contempts of the Commonâ—People as leave it questionable Whether their Adherence unto the Government be not more burdensome and dangerous unto it than were their antient Contests and Oppositions CHAP. VII No other Church-state of Divine Institution IT may be it will be generally granted I am sure it cannot be modestly denied that particular Churches or Congregations are of a Divine original Institution as also that the Primitive Churches continued long in that Form or Order But it will be farther pleaded that granting or supposing this Divine Institution of particular Churches yet there may be Churches of another Form and Order also as Diocesan or National that we are obliged to submit unto For although the Apostles appointed that there should be Bishops or Elders ordained 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 that is in every City and Town where Christian Religion was received and Clemens affirmeth that they did themselves constitute Bishops and Deacons 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 in the Regions or Villages and Cities yet there was another Form afterwards introduced Theodoret Bishop of Cyprus affirms that there were eight hundred Churches committed to his care Epist. 113. whereof many were in Towns and Cities having no Bishop of their own The whole Country of Scythia though there were in it many Cities Villages and Fortresses yet had but one Bishop whose Residence was at Tomis all other Churches being under him as Zozomen declares lib. 6. cap. 20. So it is at this day in divers Provinces belonging of old unto the Greek-Church as in Moldavia and Walachia where they have one whom they call the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Leader or Ruler that presides over all the Churches in the Nation And this Oâ—der of things that there should not be a Bishop in smaller Churches was first confirmed in the sixth Canon of the Council of Sardis in the Year 347. In Answer hereunto I shall do these two things First I shall shew that there is no Church Order State or Church-Form of Divine Institution that doth any way impede take away or overthrow the Liberty Power and Order of particular Congregations such as we have described Secondly I shall enquire into the causes of Churches of another State or Order as the Power of Magistrates and Rulers or their own choice and consent 1. There is no Form Order or Church state Divinely Instituted that should annul the Institution of particular Congregations or abridge them of their Liberties or deprive them of the Power committed unto them It is such a Church-state alone that we are now concerned to enquire after Whatever of that kinde either is or may be imagined that entrenches not on the State Liberty and Power of particular Congregations is not of our present Consideration Men may frame and order what they please and what advantage they make thereby shall not be envied unto them whilst they injure not any of the Institutions of Christ. But 1. These Churches as they are Churches are meet and able to attain the Ends of Churches To say they are Churches and yet have not in themselves Power to attain the ends of Churches is to speak contradictions or to grant and deny the same thing in the same breath For a Church is nothing but such a Society as hath Power Ability and Fitness to attain those ends for which Christ hath ordained Churches That which hath so is a Church and that which hath not so is none Men may if they please deny them to be Churches but then I know not where they will finde any that are so For instance suppose men should deny all the Parochial Churches in England to be such Churches as are intrusted with Church-Power and Administrations what Church in the first Instance could they require our Communion withal Will they say it is with the National or Diocesan Churches neither of these do or can as such administer Sacred Ordinances A man cannot Preach nor hear the Word but in a particular Assembly The Lord's Supper cannot be Administred but in a particular Congregation nor any presential local Communion of Believers among themselves like that described by the Apostle 1 Cor. chap. 12. and chap. 14. be otherwise attained No Communion is firstly and immediately required or can be required with Diocesan Churches as such Wherefore it is Parochial particular Churches that we are required to hold Communion with We say therefore these Parochial Churches are either really and truely so endued with Church-Power and Liberty or they are not If they are or are acknowledged so to be we have herein obtained what we plead for if they are not then are we required to joyn in Church Communion with those Societies that are not Churches and if we refrain so doing we are charged with Schism which is to turn Religion into Ridicule For 2. It is utterly forreign to the Scripture and a Monster unto Antiquity I mean that which is pure and regardable in this Cause that there should be Churches with a part half more or less of Church-Power and not the whole neither in Right nor Exercise or that there should be Church-Officers Elders Presbyters or Bishops that should have a partiary Power half or a third part or less of that which entirely belongeth unto the Office they hold Let one Testimony be given out of the Scripture or that Antiquity which we appeal unto unto this purpose and we shall cease our Plea But this is that which our Understandings are set on rack withal every day There is a National Church that is entrusted with Supreme Church-Power in the Nation whereof it is Here at the entrance we fall into a double disquietment For 1. we know not as yet what this National Church is here or in France nor of what Persons it doth consist 2. We know not whether this National Church have all the Power that Christ hath given unto the Church or that there is a Reserve for some Addition from beyond Sea if things were well accommodated Then that there are Diocesan Churches whose Original with the Causes and Occasions of their Bounds Limits Power and manner of Administrations I think God alone knows perfectly we do but guess for there is not one word mentioned of any of their concernments in the Scripture And we know that these Churches cannot be said to have all the Power that Christ hath entrusted his Church withal because there is another Church unto which they are in subjection and on which they do depend but it seems they have the next degree of Power unto that which is uppermost But whatever their Power be it is so administred by Chancellors Commissaries Officials in such ways and for such ends that I shall believe a dissent from them and it